Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Frankenstein (2025)
Transcript
- 0:00Good evening ladies and gentlemen and welcome
- 0:03to once upon a time at the Oscars Hello, everyone,
- 0:38and welcome to Once Upon a Time at the Oscars.
- 0:41The show that takes you through every Best Picture
- 0:43nominee from 1927 to today. I'm your host, Kyle.
- 0:45And I'm Ryan. And here we are with the third
- 0:47film of the 2026 Academy Year. Kind of a big
- 0:51deal, this movie. It is. Yeah, I mean, in general,
- 0:56but also for both of us. You know, we're both
- 0:58very big horror guys. And I think even beyond
- 1:01horror, we're both big Del Toro guys. Of course,
- 1:04speaking of Guillermo Del Toro, the director,
- 1:06storied career, absolutely huge legacy, pretty
- 1:11heavy hitter across the board. Huge fan of Haunted
- 1:14Mansion, as are we. This is true. This is true.
- 1:17What's your favorite Del Toro movie? Let's talk
- 1:19about that immediately. Right out the gate. Oh,
- 1:21my God. Honestly, it's tough because it feels
- 1:23kind of like... It kind of feels like when you're
- 1:26talking like Spielberg and you ask about Spielberg,
- 1:28everyone's like, well, I could tell you the cool
- 1:30answer or I could just tell you that it's Jurassic
- 1:32Park. So for me, I mean, there's so many others.
- 1:35It could be for Spielberg. But for me, I think
- 1:37it's that same situation with Pan's Labyrinth
- 1:39where it's like I could tell you. that I really
- 1:42like Kronos, or that I'm a huge... Even he produced
- 1:46The Orphanage. He didn't direct it, but I really
- 1:48like The Orphanage a lot. It's Pan's Labyrinth.
- 1:51I mean, we're just kind of dancing around that
- 1:52all day. I think that is the most accurate way
- 1:57he's been... Sorry, not accurate, but that really
- 2:00is the truest work of his. I think every theme
- 2:03that you see of his, and the tragedy, the beauty,
- 2:06and these creations, and these monstrosities...
- 2:09That is Pan's Labyrinth. And I think it's like
- 2:11placed into like a real world scenario. It's
- 2:14incredible. So it's that one for me. Is it the
- 2:17same for you? Yeah, yeah, absolutely. It's Pan's
- 2:19Labyrinth. I mean, Hellboy 2, the Golden Army
- 2:21or whatever it was, was pretty great. But no,
- 2:23Pan's Labyrinth all the way. Yeah, I think that's
- 2:25where he flourishes is when he gets to do something
- 2:28original. And I know that's based on a lot of
- 2:30different things. But I feel like that is very
- 2:33much his vision. Yeah. Like his recent works,
- 2:36Nightmare Alley and things, I like them. They're
- 2:40good. But I think he really thrives when he gets
- 2:42to just completely do his own thing. I'll swerve
- 2:46on you a little bit there. I think Nightmare
- 2:47Alley is my two. Oh, is it really? I really like
- 2:50Nightmare Alley. But see, to me, that's like...
- 2:52this is actually kind of a great segue to me
- 2:55nightmare alley is the way that guillermo can
- 2:58like kind of swerve a little bit from the lane
- 3:00he's been in and still like do movies that feel
- 3:03like guillermo del toro right there's not a creature
- 3:06in sight so to speak within nightmare alley but
- 3:10it still touches on like those horrors of humanity
- 3:12and like how we are like our own worst villain
- 3:14our worst enemy and also worth mentioning and
- 3:18we'll get there and like five years from now,
- 3:21but like the final end shot of Nightmare Alley
- 3:24is one of the more like haunting things I can
- 3:27remember. And I just remember being absolutely
- 3:28floored watching that movie with that final scene.
- 3:30Cause I also think it's some of Bradley Cooper's
- 3:32best work. Yeah. I mean, that's true. That's
- 3:34true for sure. Yeah. When will we talk about
- 3:37that? I feel like it's going to be like 10 years.
- 3:39It might be longer. Yeah. Yeah. Nine or 10 years.
- 3:42Yeah. Like eight. Yeah. Cause it's 2020 something,
- 3:46right? That's true. Yeah. You're right. Yikes.
- 3:47It was 2020. That's right. Yeah, so, yeah, like
- 3:51nine years or so. Yeesh. We're on our way. We're
- 3:54on our way. But anyway, let's get back to the
- 3:57movie we're talking about today. We actually
- 3:58haven't said it. No, we haven't. This is Frankenstein.
- 4:02Man, such a big deal. It's really the dragon
- 4:04he's been chasing for a long time, right? Yeah,
- 4:06it is. It is. I think I read as far as 2007 is
- 4:11when he first was like, I would love to do Frankenstein.
- 4:14That would be like my master project. That's
- 4:16a long time. That's like 20 years. Yeah. And
- 4:19now we got it. He has an interesting quote, too,
- 4:22that I didn't write to do word for word. But
- 4:24he was basically like, the pain of being an artist
- 4:27and a filmmaker is that when you find your dream
- 4:30project, once you make it, it's done. If it's
- 4:33a 10, it's a 10. If it's a 6 .5, that's what
- 4:36it is. But it's done and the dream is over. I
- 4:39think that's a really interesting quote when
- 4:42it comes to this movie in particular. Do you
- 4:44know if he said 6 .5 or is that the paraphrasing
- 4:47that you said? He definitely said 6 .5. That's
- 4:49such an interesting thing for him to do. And
- 4:52we'll get into that here in a moment. He wants
- 4:54decimals on Letterboxd. My king, my absolute
- 4:57king, bring back. And you know what? We're at
- 4:59decimals. Like we're at the 0 .5. Give us more.
- 5:01You're right. Give us more. Give us more variety
- 5:04than just the 0 .5. So Del Toro, I stand behind
- 5:06you, my king. So let's talk a little bit about
- 5:08Frankenstein. Before we get into our feelings
- 5:11on it and everything, nominations. Yeah, totally.
- 5:14Do you want to get into those? Yeah, let me throw
- 5:16this out real quick. This was directed by Guillermo
- 5:18del Toro, starred Oscar Isaac as Victor Frankenstein,
- 5:22Jacob Elordi as Frankenstein's monster or the
- 5:26creature, as they put it in this movie. But he
- 5:28is Frankenstein's monster. Correct. Christoph
- 5:30Waltz, Mia Goth was in this, and it also starred
- 5:33Felix Kemmerer, Charles Dance, David Bradley,
- 5:36and Lars Mikkelsen. Love seeing Lars Mikkelsen
- 5:39pop up here. Yeah. He's one of the first people
- 5:40on screen. I was like, I was the chimp. I was
- 5:42like hooting and hollering, like pointing. I
- 5:44was like, Lars Mikkelsen, no way. Yeah, so do
- 5:46you want me to run down the nominations list
- 5:47here? Yeah, let's do it. So nominated for nine
- 5:51total nominations. Supporting actor for Jacob
- 5:54Elordi, as you mentioned, is The Creature. Adapted
- 5:56screenplay from Guillermo del Toro. Cinematography.
- 6:00Original score. Costume design. Makeup and hair.
- 6:03Sorry, makeup and hairstyling. Makeup. Makeup
- 6:05and hairstyling. production design, and sound.
- 6:08With Frankenstein, Beauty and the Beast level,
- 6:11tale as old as time, right? This is something
- 6:13we've been talking about for, I mean, over a
- 6:16century now, right? With Mary Shelley. Yeah,
- 6:18the novel came out in 1818. Yeah. So, wow. Actually,
- 6:24isn't that crazy? Two centuries. Yeah. Wow, look
- 6:26at that. What are your thoughts? Let's remove
- 6:29ourselves from the movie real quick. Frankenstein
- 6:31in general, the story, what are your thoughts?
- 6:32So, fan? Yeah, this is one of the few times that
- 6:36I've read the source material. Oh, okay. Frankenstein,
- 6:39it's a great book. You know, hot take. Big fan.
- 6:42But as far as the movies and things go, Frankenstein,
- 6:49like the universal monster Frankenstein, is at
- 6:52least top two of my favorite original films.
- 6:56Boris Karloff's performance as Frankenstein is
- 6:58incredible. That movie is like the perfect blend
- 7:01of like horror. and sad drama, which I think
- 7:06Frankenstein is. Right. Absolutely. I haven't
- 7:09seen like the Hammer Horror and all of that,
- 7:12but I've seen the Kenneth Branagh Frankenstein.
- 7:15That's Kenneth Branagh, right? Yeah. With Robert
- 7:17De Niro. Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. Yes. Yeah.
- 7:19I've seen that. I've seen the weird Frankenstein
- 7:21and Van Helsing, and I enjoyed that rendition
- 7:23of him too. You've seen Young Frankenstein. This
- 7:26is true. Just a great monster. Probably like,
- 7:30I don't know, top three. monsters of all time
- 7:34i think that's fair and i know you know he's
- 7:36called the creature here because he's not really
- 7:38a monster but you know what i'm saying like he's
- 7:41so such a pop culture icon and this is a story
- 7:45that kind of transcends past the book and the
- 7:48movies and everybody knows frankenstein i love
- 7:51him i i think it's the same for me you know he's
- 7:53he's a staple and this is something we talked
- 7:55about with del toro this is his dragon that he's
- 7:58been chasing for so long And he finally got the
- 8:01opportunity to make his Frankenstein movie. Where
- 8:03I'll pivot a little bit there is, and I've told
- 8:07you this off pod, I think he's made his Frankenstein
- 8:09movie. I think he's made his Frankenstein movie
- 8:12a couple times. He always finds those themes
- 8:15that he really enjoys and puts that into his
- 8:18movie. So I think that's already prevalent. But
- 8:20he finally got to make his like true Frankenstein
- 8:22movie. And it's not a surprise to me that he's
- 8:25named Jacob Elordi's character the creature as
- 8:28opposed to like, you know, Frankenstein's monster.
- 8:30He's never referred to as Frankenstein's monster.
- 8:32He's referred to as the creature. And I think
- 8:34that's very intentional because del Toro has
- 8:36a sensibility to favor the science fiction or
- 8:41the horror or the monsters. Blaming humanity.
- 8:46Humanity is the fault and the issue with this.
- 8:48So he is the creation of Victor Frankenstein.
- 8:54He's the creation of Victor Frankenstein. And
- 8:57being the creation of that makes him a creature,
- 8:59right? He's from a creator. He's the creature.
- 9:03Let's go ahead and dive into our feelings on
- 9:06this movie. This should have been great. I think
- 9:08we can both agree on that. This should have been
- 9:10great. Absolutely. And I think you can argue
- 9:13that in a way it is great. It's this huge rolling
- 9:18epic. Visually, for the most part, it's gorgeous.
- 9:22The production design in this, the costume design,
- 9:26a lot of the visual effects are stunning. Not
- 9:29all of them, but a good bit of them. From a technical
- 9:32standpoint, this movie's fantastic. More often
- 9:36than not, it looks great. However, it's so weird
- 9:39because this... This story is over 200 years
- 9:42old now, you know, and I think you can kind of,
- 9:46when making a Frankenstein movie, again, like
- 9:48watching Van Helsing, that's not the story of
- 9:50Frankenstein. And that's just a small snippet,
- 9:53but you kind of just accept it. You're like,
- 9:55yeah, there's the creature, there's the monster.
- 9:57You should have a little bit of wiggle room in
- 9:59how you're telling this story, but this might
- 10:02just be heavy opinion based. Guillermo del Toro
- 10:06is the man I expected to take the novel and the
- 10:10story and do like a one to one version of that
- 10:14story. Right. Just 100 percent completely book
- 10:18accurate. And so much is changed in this movie
- 10:22and it just doesn't work for me. So you're right
- 10:26that it's not one to one. And I think where it's
- 10:28not one to one, there are moments that are like,
- 10:30OK, that's like straight from the novel. But
- 10:32the things that are changed. It's almost kind
- 10:35of like we should have expected this because
- 10:38the things that are changed are very del Toro.
- 10:40It's not like he sought out to make this perfect
- 10:43Frankenstein movie and it ended up being some
- 10:45monstrosity, so to speak. It's not terrible.
- 10:48It's not a bad movie by any means. It's just
- 10:51completely fine. And the reason why I think it's
- 10:54completely fine is that the changes that he made
- 10:57to it are so typical del Toro. any violence that
- 11:02the monster exudes or, you know, like in the
- 11:04novel, there's that whole side story with Frankenstein's
- 11:08monster and that little girl. And like the violence
- 11:11that occurs from that, like that is not present
- 11:14in the movie. In the movie, it is much more of
- 11:16a, like there's almost zero violence at the hand
- 11:20of the creature, right? Like it really is just
- 11:23like happening around him. So, I mean, the movie
- 11:26opens up with him. I mean, OK, well, OK, hold
- 11:29on now. That's true. But in terms of like, you
- 11:31know, that's when he's already been vilified.
- 11:32But like there's no point where like people turn
- 11:35against the monster and things happen. Well,
- 11:38I think there's no accidental violence caused
- 11:41by this monster. You're absolutely right. Yeah.
- 11:43And I think that's that's worse in a way, because
- 11:46now the monster does commit acts of violence,
- 11:49but by choice every time. And sure, a lot of
- 11:51it's in self -defense and things. But that. That
- 11:54kind of like childlike innocence of the creature
- 11:57and, you know, he's just killed this little girl,
- 12:00but it's not his fault because he doesn't know
- 12:01he's a child. That all goes away. And now you
- 12:06have this creature who in self -defense is like
- 12:09really wrecking havoc. And your sympathy is kind
- 12:13of messed with in a way. You're not reacting
- 12:17to this the way that I think all of the best
- 12:20interpretations of Frankenstein require you to
- 12:22react to. True. And again, it kind of bums me
- 12:26out. Let's start at the beginning here. So we're
- 12:30mostly introduced in the movie to Victor Frankenstein.
- 12:34That's going to be Oscar Isaac. What did you
- 12:36think about Oscar Isaac here? I thought he was
- 12:39solid. That's probably the best thing to say.
- 12:42Yeah. I think he was solid. Yeah. I don't think
- 12:44he's doing a bad performance here. I think he's
- 12:46just a little kooky. I think he's a little out
- 12:51there as, like, a scientist. And the performance
- 12:54that he's putting on and the performance that
- 12:56Jacob Elordi puts on as the creature are completely
- 12:59different movies. Yeah. Right? I think there's
- 13:01more of, like, almost like a B -movie side thing
- 13:03with Oscar Isaac, the way he's portraying Victor
- 13:05Frankenstein. And Jacob Elordi is like, you will
- 13:08sit down and see my magnificence. Like, it's
- 13:11a completely different thing. So I think that
- 13:13duality was, like, at odds to the majority of
- 13:16the movie. Victor is the story, right? Everything
- 13:20starts with Victor. And there's some scenes early
- 13:24on that I was like, we're seeing some cinematic
- 13:26masterpiece here. There's some classic del Toro
- 13:30stuff, too. Victor's father is this scientist,
- 13:33and he introduces him to the idea of anatomy
- 13:36and studying the body and everything, how it
- 13:38works. And he has this really, this is the most
- 13:41del Toro thing to me in the movie, he has this
- 13:43little doll. It's like a porcelain ceramic doll,
- 13:47and it's like the human body. Yeah, I think it's
- 13:50made of ivory. Ivory, thank you. So he can remove
- 13:53the cover of the ivory and see more of the anatomy
- 13:57and the organs of the human body. And so much
- 14:01of that just feels like, this is what you're
- 14:02here to do, dude. Make some gothic horror. This
- 14:05is great. There's a scene early on, too, where
- 14:07Victor is making his first presentation to a
- 14:10council. Of his discovery of how he can actually,
- 14:13like, reanimate a body. And the puppet that's
- 14:16used. And I love that it's a puppet, right? I'm
- 14:20sure there's some CG there, but it's a puppet.
- 14:22And he reanimates this puppet. And while he's
- 14:25doing this, Bill Hader has a great interview
- 14:27with Guillermo and Oscar where he's like, I loved
- 14:30this movie, but the moment where I was just so
- 14:32mad at Oscar Isaac was that scene. Because not
- 14:36only are you reciting the script that's so well
- 14:39done and you're performing it extremely well,
- 14:41you're bouncing a ball and you're tossing it
- 14:44in the air and catching it. He's like, actors
- 14:46don't understand how difficult it is to, like,
- 14:48recite a line like this and portray it well while,
- 14:50like, focusing on the ball. Because you're just
- 14:52too focused on, like, okay, am I going to catch
- 14:53it? How high is it? Is it going to land? So there's,
- 14:56like, acting choices that he's making that are
- 14:58so good in this. And that overall scene of, like,
- 15:01the reanimated corpse is beautiful. And, like,
- 15:04the score kind of, like, swells. There's, like,
- 15:05a harpsichord that starts playing to make it
- 15:07a little bit more, like, less period PC and more
- 15:10kind of, like, you know, out there sci -fi. Loved
- 15:13that. I thought that was really smart. I have
- 15:15one issue with that scene, and it's that I don't
- 15:17believe that the council reacted properly. Because
- 15:21even at that time period in the 1800s, even if
- 15:25I wasn't a fan of what this guy was doing and
- 15:26he reanimates a corpse, I would be on my head
- 15:29and be like, what just happened? And instead
- 15:32they're like, hey man, you can't do that here.
- 15:33Like, you gotta get out of here, man. It's like,
- 15:35no, pop off a little bit more for this guy. He
- 15:37just reanimated a corpse. It is funny. But that
- 15:40scene is incredible. Like, there are scenes in
- 15:42this movie that are very, very engaging. And
- 15:44I loved that early on. I think that's where things
- 15:47started waning for me. Yeah, like when he actually
- 15:49starts doing the Frankenstein stuff, that's when
- 15:52it starts waning. When he finds the funding.
- 15:54Like, when he actually becomes, yeah, when he
- 15:56becomes the creator. Yeah, you know, I think
- 15:59what happens is that scene is fantastic. Even
- 16:03before this, and then certainly after this, a
- 16:06lot of the themings are so heavy -handed to me,
- 16:09and it really frustrates me. They do the whole
- 16:13flashback to his show when he was a child and
- 16:15his father, Charles Dance. He's talking to him
- 16:17about the death of his mother, and Frankenstein
- 16:20literally says, I will conquer death. Like, just
- 16:24puts it right out there. There's no skirting
- 16:27around it. Later on in the movie, his brother
- 16:30looks him in the eye, and he says, No, Victor,
- 16:32you're the monster. Like there are so many moments
- 16:35that are so heavy handed. I'd open side in the
- 16:38theater when that happens. Yes, there's no subtlety
- 16:41to these themes. And even I watched the making
- 16:44of that's on Netflix. Yeah. Frankenstein, the
- 16:47anatomy lesson, which is a great resource if
- 16:50you're looking for like every single department
- 16:52and how much effort they put into this movie.
- 16:55But Del Toro talks a lot about like the color
- 16:57usage in this movie and how at the beginning
- 17:00it's all blacks and whites. Except for his mother,
- 17:03who is represented with red. I like that, but
- 17:06I think even that is too heavy -handed. It's
- 17:08just so blatant. Well, because you know who else
- 17:10was severely red in the movie? It was the Angel
- 17:13of Death. Yeah, yeah. The Angel of Death. And
- 17:16then Elizabeth, Mia Goth's character. Which portrayed
- 17:20by Mia Goth as well. What do you mean? Oh, did
- 17:22you catch that? Victor's mother. Oh, yeah, yeah.
- 17:25No, I saw that. Yeah. I mean, they removed her
- 17:27eyebrows, but otherwise it's Mia Goth. But yeah,
- 17:29Mia Goth, and again, another very heavy -handed
- 17:31theme, the love interest of Victor in this movie,
- 17:34Elizabeth. Yeah, and maybe the creature. And
- 17:37the creature, well, definitely the creature,
- 17:39is portrayed both by Mia Goth as well as his
- 17:42mother. So there's that whole, like, you know,
- 17:44well, now you're the Oedipus complex. Edible?
- 17:48Whatever. Oedipus, sure. Yeah. So there's a lot
- 17:51of heavy -handed themes in it, for sure. But
- 17:53the monster thing of just like, no, you're the
- 17:55monster. I think even the creature has an opportunity
- 17:57to say it towards the end of the movie. Yeah.
- 17:59So just a couple opportunities where it's like,
- 18:01oh, man. It's too much. You did not have to do
- 18:03all that. No. But it's important to note, you
- 18:07know, performance -wise, I mentioned that...
- 18:10Oscar Isaac is doing kind of a B -level performance
- 18:13here. I'd say 30 minutes on, I think he's really
- 18:17doing like leaning heavy into this B -level thing.
- 18:19Before that, I thought he was doing really well.
- 18:21I was really enjoying it. But mostly around the
- 18:24time that the creature actually kind of arrives,
- 18:27that's when you kind of like start realizing,
- 18:29oh, wait a minute. This movie could have been
- 18:31so much different because Jacob Elordi is doing
- 18:33something insane here. Can we make a little noise?
- 18:36Let's hear it for the boy with Jacob Elordi.
- 18:40Yeah, okay. So you feel the same way, though?
- 18:42No, yeah, he's great. The problem I have with
- 18:46Jacob Elordi, not even Jacob Elordi, I do not
- 18:49like the creature design in this movie. Oh, sure.
- 18:52And that detracts from his performance for me
- 18:54so much. I felt very similar to Robert Eggers'
- 18:59Nosferatu. Sure. Such a great movie. Could not
- 19:03get into the design of Count Orlok in that movie.
- 19:07Do you think... Because with Robert Eggers, he
- 19:11very much was, he said that the reason for the
- 19:14design of Nosferatu in that movie was to keep
- 19:17it true to the time period. Sure. He wanted to
- 19:19be as like, you know, like his lighting and sound
- 19:21and everything in those movies, he tries to make
- 19:23it as close to the time period as possible. I
- 19:24totally get it. Do we think that a similar thing
- 19:27happened here with Frankenstein? Because my initial
- 19:28thought is no. So what I had read is that the
- 19:32creature design was based on drawings done by
- 19:35Bernie Wrightson, who... He found like a later
- 19:40version of the Frankenstein novel and was like,
- 19:43I'm going to create or I'm going to draw exactly
- 19:47what the book is describing. So in a way, this
- 19:51is supposed to be like the most accurate representation
- 19:53of what Frankenstein's monster is supposed to
- 19:56look like. Right. However, I pulled up these
- 19:59drawings and like, yes, he has the long hair
- 20:01and he looks kind of pieced together. But in
- 20:04the film, he's just so clean. He's very purple.
- 20:08He's purple. He looks a lot like the master race
- 20:13in Prometheus. Oh my God. I don't remember what
- 20:15they're called. Yeah, for sure. The engineers.
- 20:17Yeah. And it's just really distracting to me.
- 20:21I think he looks best when he's fully covered
- 20:23up with a cloak or whatever. Yep. Specifically
- 20:28the scenes in Antarctica. Yes. But it just, it
- 20:31does not work for me and it pulls me out of his
- 20:34performance in a big way. And that's unfortunate
- 20:37because he's great. He really is great. Yeah.
- 20:39See, I didn't have as much of an issue with the
- 20:42physical appearance. I think for me, I always
- 20:45knew that Guillermo was going to do something
- 20:47a little different than just like the green creature
- 20:49with stitches all over. He's still very much
- 20:51stitched together. But for the most part, he
- 20:54looks like maybe he found one guy who had a lot
- 20:57of pieces torn apart and he just sewed them back
- 20:59together. It doesn't look a lot of like... What
- 21:02took the arm of this guy and the leg of this
- 21:04individual and pieced them together? It does
- 21:05look like, hey, I just found the perfect specimen
- 21:06and just pieced them back together. Jacob Elordi
- 21:09is otherworldly in this movie. He does such a
- 21:12great job of learning from the ground up. Maybe
- 21:16it's just like, sorry, I wasn't familiar with
- 21:17your game. But I know he's in Euphoria. Yeah.
- 21:20And he's doing euphoric work in Euphoria. I don't
- 21:23mean that in necessarily that sense. I more mean
- 21:25he's playing the part in it. But you think about
- 21:27the people you're surrounded with, Sidney Sweeney
- 21:28and the performances she's giving now in movies
- 21:30like The Housemaid, and you're just like, what
- 21:32are you doing on Euphoria, my guy? Like, yeah,
- 21:34Zendaya's in there as well. But like, he is cooking
- 21:37in this movie. And there's moments where like,
- 21:39you know, he has to be, to your point, like a
- 21:41child, like an infant almost, where he can't
- 21:43speak, or the only word he knows is Victor, much
- 21:45to the displeasure of Victor Frankenstein. I
- 21:48did think there's a really funny scene in this
- 21:50movie that is definitely intentional, where Victor
- 21:53is annoyed. that all the creature is saying is
- 21:56Victor. And to me, it just felt like heavy. Like
- 21:59I have a nine month old at home kind of thing
- 22:02where you're like, say mama. And they're like,
- 22:05dad, you're just stop. Say dad, say mama, please.
- 22:09There's a great scene in this where it just kind
- 22:11of feels like Victor's like begging, like, I
- 22:13just need you to learn one more word, buddy.
- 22:14Stop it. So that was pretty great. But he can
- 22:18play those parts. And, you know, if that's all
- 22:20he's doing, fine. But then you see him, like,
- 22:22really trying to, like, have a curiosity in the
- 22:24world and understand, like, why he is how he
- 22:27is. And learning from the older gentleman that
- 22:30he learns from and then, like, that family inevitably.
- 22:33There's so many, like, great scenes from Jacob
- 22:36Elordi specifically. And it feels like this is
- 22:38the most, like... it's funny we're saying this
- 22:40on the double feature day that you and I are
- 22:41having, a Shakespearean -type performance in
- 22:44what he's doing. So if there's a reason to watch
- 22:47Frankenstein, and again, it's not like it's an
- 22:49unwatchable movie, Jacob Elordi is it for me.
- 22:52I think that a lot of the del Toro that you see
- 22:54in this movie is very prevalent in all the other
- 22:56movies that he sees, but it's rare that he can
- 22:59get a kind of performance. It's also worth mentioning
- 23:01this is kind of the... This is the role that
- 23:04would be played by Del Toro's longtime partner,
- 23:07Doug Jones. Yeah. Right? Like, this would have
- 23:09been a perfect role for him, but there's so much
- 23:11more of a personality behind Frankenstein's creature
- 23:15than there is in, like, you know, the creature
- 23:18in Shape of Water or, you know, the Pan in Pan's
- 23:22Labyrinth. Fawn? Pan. Either way. There's a lot
- 23:26more like that. So it's interesting that you
- 23:28would have seen in this role, Doug Jones, and
- 23:31now you see Jacob Elordi, you're like, okay,
- 23:32what are we going to get from this? But it's
- 23:33actually probably the best decision that he made
- 23:35in this movie for me. Yeah. And you know, there
- 23:38was that in -between time as well, where Andrew
- 23:40Garfield was supposed to play the monster. I
- 23:42wonder how that would have gone. Yeah. I don't
- 23:45think it, I wonder, because I'm happy to be wrong,
- 23:47but I don't know if Andrew Garfield necessarily
- 23:49would have given the, I think Jacob Elordi is
- 23:51perfect because not a lot of people know Jacob
- 23:52Elordi. People know Jacob Elordi, but they're
- 23:54not like, oh, all I can see is Peter Parker,
- 23:57or all I can see is his character in Social Network.
- 24:00Right. Eduardo. I see so much of who you've been
- 24:03before, but with Jacob Elordi, he really is like
- 24:05a discovery almost in this movie, cinematically
- 24:08at least. Yeah. I mean, I know he was like Elvis,
- 24:10and he was in Salt Burn. Yeah, yeah. So it's
- 24:14not like his first movie ever, but it really
- 24:16is more of a newcomer thing. Yeah, no, I agree
- 24:18with that. He's also very tall. Andrew Garfield,
- 24:20I don't know if he has that on him. I think he's
- 24:21almost six foot. Andrew Garfield. Okay. And Elordi's,
- 24:24what, 6 '2", something like that? 6 '2", or 6
- 24:27'3", probably. I mean, based on this movie, 8
- 24:29feet? Like, he's just so much taller than everyone
- 24:32else. How tall are engineers from Prometheus?
- 24:34Yeah, I don't know. You are probably the better
- 24:38person to... You just stop there. Kind of, yeah.
- 24:42Just as a whole, just to, like, kind of hype
- 24:45up Jacob Elordi's performance in this, because
- 24:48I really was taken aback. out so much by the
- 24:51creature design and things and see that's the
- 24:53thing that's tough is like if he was the costume
- 24:55designer or like you know the makeup designer
- 24:57then i'd say hey it's it's on him completely
- 24:59yeah but like he can't control what it looks
- 25:01like in that movie so the performance he's giving
- 25:04in spite of like what anyone might think about
- 25:06his appearance is It is. And well worth the prize
- 25:09of admission for this movie. To keep things short
- 25:11and sweet, I don't know what happened with this.
- 25:14I think specifically it is a del Toro movie.
- 25:17It looks like a del Toro movie. One thing that
- 25:19I really like is that a lot of the production
- 25:21design here is very del Toro in the sense of,
- 25:24hey, if we're building this castle, I need every
- 25:27room in this castle to be real. We need to build
- 25:29this out. We need a giant little pendulum here.
- 25:33We need to build out this laboratory. And it
- 25:36looks great. He even like really pushed for the
- 25:39ship. There's a moment in the beginning of the
- 25:40movie and throughout the movie where there's
- 25:42a ship that's been, what's the word? Like stuck
- 25:45on the ice. Shipwrecked. Well, not shipwrecked,
- 25:48but. It's like beached, basically. Sure. Yeah.
- 25:50Thank you. Beached. So it's like beached in ice
- 25:53and they can't get out. And that's kind of the
- 25:55basis of the story of like how they hear about
- 25:57Victor's tale and the creature's tale, which
- 26:01are the two sections of this movie. So that ship
- 26:04is fully built out. And they actually built this
- 26:07ship in total. And I'm not going to be the one
- 26:09to tell you, like, well, the ship is actually
- 26:10a character in this movie. And, like, just like
- 26:13New York in other movies. It's not. But, like,
- 26:15it's just very cool that they built out this
- 26:17ship. There are some pretty heavy CGI scenes
- 26:20in this, specifically location -wise. Whenever
- 26:22there's, like, wide shots of locations, generally,
- 26:26CGI in the background. There's some wolves that
- 26:29get a bad beat in this movie in terms of the
- 26:31CGI. Yep. But otherwise... There's a lot of production
- 26:35that does scream Del Toro to me. I want to give
- 26:37a shout out to Tamara Deverell and Shane Veo.
- 26:41They were the two nominated for production design.
- 26:44They were both nominated for Nightmare Alley.
- 26:48So they've worked with Del Toro before, as most
- 26:50of the crew was, I've come to find out. But Shane
- 26:54Veo, who was responsible for the set decorations,
- 26:58won for Shape of Water. Oh, that makes sense.
- 27:02seasoned vets out here building ships. I mean,
- 27:05again, it looks very good. So much credit to
- 27:09them. A question that I have for you, did you
- 27:11feel, this is infamously a Netflix production,
- 27:15right? Netflix put this out, made it difficult
- 27:18to see in theaters. I was lucky enough to be
- 27:20able to see it in theaters. I know you caught
- 27:22it at home. Twice. Twice. So do you feel that
- 27:27there was any heavy Netflix feel to this movie?
- 27:31Did it feel like Netflix or in terms of like,
- 27:33you know, them reciting the script or not the
- 27:35script, them reciting the narrative a couple
- 27:38of times, just in case you're not looking at
- 27:39the screen, like the more nefarious things we've
- 27:42heard about Netflix. I don't know if anything
- 27:43like that existed. I think it's one of those
- 27:47rare exemptions they offer people where they're
- 27:52like, okay, it's Frankenstein. It's Del Toro.
- 27:54Like you do you. I would say there's one other
- 27:57exception that we'll talk about later. Train
- 27:59dreams. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Didn't feel a lot
- 28:02of, I'm grieving. Well, that's the thing. I think
- 28:06it's a little different when a movie gets picked
- 28:08up for distribution by - Sure. Yeah. This started
- 28:11a Netflix production. You're right. But no, it's
- 28:15so weird. Netflix productions have a look to
- 28:18them, but I don't know if that's Netflix's fault
- 28:22here or if it's just Del Toro. It does seem like
- 28:25an easy scapegoat, doesn't it? It does. When
- 28:28the movie's not great, I was like, damn you,
- 28:29Netflix. Yeah. Maybe it's not their fault, but
- 28:32that's just the easiest thing to do. There is
- 28:34something off about this movie, and I would love
- 28:36to be the podcast that sits here and tells you
- 28:38exactly what it is, but there's just something
- 28:40that stops this from being a great del Toro movie.
- 28:43And I don't know what it is. Maybe it's, for
- 28:45me, the biggest thing I can see is the vast difference
- 28:50between the acting performances of Oscar Isaac
- 28:53and Jacob Elordi in this. Not just Oscar Isaac.
- 28:57I don't think Mia Goth is very good in this.
- 28:59Christoph Waltz is doing a Christoph Waltz thing.
- 29:03He's fine. He's just fine, though. It just feels
- 29:06like, hey, I'm Christoph Waltz. His name's Harlander,
- 29:10the character. But the whole time I was just
- 29:12like, what's Christoph up to right now? Because
- 29:14he's just kind of playing Christoph. He's like,
- 29:16I have syphilis. Put my brain in this body. And
- 29:19then he's gone. And you're like, oh, okay. Okay,
- 29:21see ya. Yeah, I don't know. I wonder how much
- 29:25of it is the... the script itself, the screenplay.
- 29:28Because, again, there are such heavy -handed
- 29:30moments. True. You're the monster and all of
- 29:33that. I don't know that I love the romance in
- 29:35it. It's kind of just... It feels forced. It
- 29:37does feel forced. The other characters kind of
- 29:40feel hollow in a way that I don't think is a
- 29:43fault of their performances. They're just not
- 29:45written in a way that makes them, I don't know,
- 29:48interesting, which is so weird because... it's
- 29:51victor frankenstein like i know him yeah you
- 29:53know i should already be acclimated to that personality
- 29:56and and that character's motivations and things
- 30:00but it feels like they've presented me with a
- 30:03victor frankenstein that is just kind of empty
- 30:06and hollow yeah but i don't know how to identify
- 30:08what it is that's making that happen for me a
- 30:11perfect example is william uh victor's brother
- 30:14Like we're kind of told very early on that William
- 30:16was the favorite of his father. After his mother
- 30:19died, his mother died actually just before child
- 30:23or in childbirth. with william so uh her his
- 30:26father played by charles dance did favor william
- 30:29a bit more so losing his mother and watching
- 30:32his father reject him in favor of his brother
- 30:34did kind of drive him down this role of like
- 30:37madness so to speak but like more like he was
- 30:39just more driven to um really like bring life
- 30:42back to death i will conquer death i will conquer
- 30:44death there you go so we're we're told to kind
- 30:47of like hate william but william for the most
- 30:50part it's just like more a victim of circumstance
- 30:53Of like, I didn't choose for this to happen,
- 30:55man. Why are you mad at me? He's just hanging
- 30:56out. He's just hanging out. He's kind of a silly,
- 30:58goofy guy. You're right. There's a lot of, maybe
- 31:00that's what Elizabeth likes about him. I don't
- 31:02know. There's just a lot of like happenstance
- 31:05in this where it's kind of like it just happens
- 31:06this way. I also think that the first scene between
- 31:11Mia Goth and Jacob Elordi, when she discovers
- 31:14the creature in the sewers, just casually checking
- 31:17out the sewers of my brother -in -law's castle.
- 31:20Not a big deal. And she finds him. It's worth
- 31:24noting that there's like this romance that's
- 31:26like immediately between them, like a connection
- 31:28of sorts. This is while he can still only say
- 31:31the word Victor. She's very enamored by him.
- 31:33It's worth noting that within 30 seconds of meeting
- 31:36this creature, Mia Goth's character, Elizabeth,
- 31:39does allow his hand on her throat. And I was
- 31:42like, we're doing a little much here, guys. Like,
- 31:44this is just, it's very fast. It's very sudden.
- 31:47It feels rushed. So in a movie that's two hours
- 31:50and some change, closer to two hours and 30 minutes
- 31:53and it's not, it somehow feels rushed and dragged
- 31:57out at the same time. Yeah. I think putting it
- 31:59in parts wasn't a great idea. I think telling
- 32:01Victor's tale and then the creature's tale, majority
- 32:05of the movie is Victor's tale. And then creature's
- 32:07tale, by the end, you've already kind of made
- 32:09your decision about this movie, how you feel.
- 32:10Right, right. So... It's an odd duck. I don't
- 32:16know what to say. Because I would love to tell
- 32:18you, hey, this is awful. Don't see it. That's
- 32:20not the case. Or I'd love to tell you, hey, it's
- 32:22amazing. Go see it. That's not the case either.
- 32:24It really is somewhere between. And it makes
- 32:27sense why it's nominated nine times, right? Yeah.
- 32:30And again, I think watching that anatomy, the
- 32:34anatomy lesson, the Frankenstein documentary,
- 32:36that go look at all of the technical wonders
- 32:39that they did with this movie. And it's all valid.
- 32:42Yeah, it really is. It really is. And it's cool
- 32:44because this is a team, like I said, that Del
- 32:47Toro has worked with many times. And he mentions
- 32:51like, I forget if he uses the metaphor of being
- 32:54a painter or like a conductor, but those are
- 32:56like the two most common tropes of a filmmaker
- 32:59as a director. But yeah, he's like, you know,
- 33:02everybody came together and like it was all a
- 33:04compilation of everybody's master craftsmanship.
- 33:07And it's really true. It's just, it falls flat
- 33:11in the execution of the actual storytelling.
- 33:14True. It's so, I don't know what it is. And I
- 33:18want to find out what it is that I'm, like the
- 33:21scene you just brought up where Mia Goth goes
- 33:22down in the sewers. I remember watching it again
- 33:26last night, her and William show up to the castle
- 33:28and Victor's like, come on, come upstairs. I
- 33:31got something to show you. It's blah, I'm frantic.
- 33:33And they're like, where's Harlander? Where is
- 33:37he? And he's like. I don't know. Come upstairs.
- 33:39And then he like drags William upstairs. And
- 33:42then Mia Goth just wanders away. Yeah. She was
- 33:45like chains moving or something. Yeah. Yeah.
- 33:47And then, you know, she does her whole thing
- 33:50with the monster. But then it cuts to Victor
- 33:52upstairs with William and not Elizabeth. And
- 33:55I'm just like, aren't you a little worried, dude?
- 33:57Do you care? And because of that one decision,
- 34:00it felt like the screenplay said, Elizabeth has
- 34:03to go encounter the monster. Yes. Well, you know.
- 34:07What is Victor doing that he's so distracted
- 34:09and they're like, I don't know, he's upstairs
- 34:11talking. Yeah. That's not believable. No, it's
- 34:13not. And like, basically because both, or especially
- 34:17because both individuals are in love with Elizabeth.
- 34:21Yeah. Right? So like, why wouldn't they at some
- 34:23point be like, hey, where is the love of my life?
- 34:26Yes. And also, why are you saying the love of
- 34:28your life? Yes. That's the love of my life. You
- 34:30said something very interesting there, where
- 34:31you talked about Del Toro comparing himself to
- 34:34a painter or a conductor. Very good segue, because
- 34:37score is something that it's nominated for here.
- 34:39Yes. For his longtime contributor, or I guess
- 34:44partner, Alexander Desplat, but also written
- 34:47by Eldberg Hemsing. I listened to the score on
- 34:52the way here. I feel like in the movie, it's
- 34:54kind of easy to get like lost in this or not
- 34:57lost in the score, but kind of forget about the
- 34:58score a bit because there's a lot happening on
- 35:00screen and you're not paying attention much to
- 35:02the music behind it. That being said, I think
- 35:04it's mostly just kind of accompanying the scenes
- 35:07and not so much trying to stand out. There is
- 35:10one specific melody that's repeated a couple
- 35:14of times, especially in the beginning of the
- 35:16movie. And it's kind of considered like. uh victor's
- 35:19theme that's kind of played throughout and i
- 35:21think that's a little catchy it's not very memorable
- 35:24but just like it's a little like something a
- 35:26motif to kind of hang on for the rest of the
- 35:28movie and then i mentioned in that great scene
- 35:31with the the council that he's presenting in
- 35:34front of and there's like a harpsichord that
- 35:36kind of comes in right i thought that was really
- 35:38strong otherwise it really is just kind of like
- 35:41it's a good score there's nothing wrong with
- 35:43it uh but it does just kind of accompany the
- 35:46movie rather than stand out at any time which
- 35:48might be the perfect analogy for like everything
- 35:53in this movie yeah they're they're all good good
- 35:59is such a boring way to describe them but like
- 36:01they they are all well done but when they all
- 36:04come together to form this this painting this
- 36:08piece of music this composition they're all just
- 36:11kind of boring together like i i hate saying
- 36:13that you're right Yeah, I listen to the score
- 36:16as well, and it's just kind of like, it almost
- 36:19sounds like background music. I feel like if
- 36:21you listen to this on its own, you get bored
- 36:24really quick. And I know that it is supposed
- 36:27to be played while the movie is on, but it doesn't
- 36:31add anything inspiring to the movie itself. It's
- 36:35mostly classical. Honestly, it just sounds kind
- 36:37of like classical music play in the background.
- 36:39There's a scene where Victor and Elizabeth dance
- 36:41at a gathering that they're at. And the music
- 36:45really does pick up because I think the title
- 36:47on the soundtrack is Victor in Love. And it does
- 36:51pick up and it's very like bright and like, you
- 36:53know, fun. And that's kind of the peak from that
- 36:57in the harpsichord or kind of the peak for me.
- 36:58But it has to be because it's supposed to be
- 37:00like an uplifting dance and everything. Otherwise,
- 37:02it is just kind of part of the course. Gothic.
- 37:05a little classical, like mostly violin, a little
- 37:08sad. Yeah. But it just stands there. I think
- 37:11another great metaphor for what you're saying
- 37:12here of like, you know, hey, this is a perfect
- 37:14example of all of this, is that everything feels,
- 37:16and this is a little cute, so I apologize, stitched
- 37:19together. Like everything really is just kind
- 37:22of like we took this and this and this and put
- 37:23it together and hopefully you enjoy it. And it
- 37:25doesn't feel like del Toro's true vision. The
- 37:28only thing that feels like, well, this has del
- 37:30Toro written all over it other than the look,
- 37:32is that the classic theme. that man is the monster.
- 37:37Yeah. Right? And it's just a little too heavy
- 37:40-handed in the script. Agreed. And that's what's
- 37:42really baffling to me, is that this is written
- 37:44by del Toro, right? This isn't like he picked
- 37:46up someone else's script and made the movie.
- 37:48Like, it is written by del Toro. You know, it's
- 37:51funny, because you use the analogy again, of
- 37:54all these pieces, all these players in the composition,
- 37:58they're all solid, but the thing missing here
- 38:01is the composer. There was no director nomination
- 38:05for Del Toro in this. And I wonder if that's
- 38:08kind of the thing. Like this man who, I don't
- 38:12know about you, but hearing the talks of Del
- 38:14Toro's working on a Frankenstein movie for like
- 38:1620 years. My God. That's, I was so hyped for
- 38:20years and years and years. And maybe it was kind
- 38:24of his ball to drop a little bit. Which sucks.
- 38:28It does. Honestly, I do wonder too, and I'll
- 38:31be the first person to admit this. I wonder how
- 38:33much of my, not even disenjoyment of this, but
- 38:37like, you know, just like confusion of it stems
- 38:39from when they're like, hey, it's a Netflix production.
- 38:41I was like, really? Yeah. Are you sure? Like,
- 38:44that's the thing too. When he started talking
- 38:47about making this a film. It wasn't a Netflix
- 38:49thing. It wasn't until later that he signed his,
- 38:53I think it was a three picture deal with Netflix.
- 38:55He'd already done Pinocchio, which even Pinocchio,
- 38:58I think that's like just fine. Yep. He worked
- 39:01on the Cabinet of Curiosities, which was like,
- 39:03you know, Del Toro's Cabinet of Curiosities,
- 39:05but it was like a television series of sorts.
- 39:08Yeah. I really don't know what it is. If Netflix
- 39:12like sprinkles a little something on all of these
- 39:14productions that just. takes away some of the
- 39:17magic, some of the appeal of what del Toro is
- 39:20known for. I cannot put my finger on it, but
- 39:24I'm sad that it exists. I mean, you're 100 %
- 39:26correct, and I think a way to kind of cap this
- 39:28off and talk about that is we're negative on
- 39:31the movie, but it is worth mentioning again that
- 39:34I'm still very happy with these nominations overall,
- 39:36with the 10 movies, even defending F1. I fall
- 39:40on my sword with that one. But with Frankenstein,
- 39:42even though it's not fantastic, it is still like,
- 39:45Like, my dad. If my dad's like, hey, should I
- 39:48watch Frankenstein? Yeah, man. You should. You
- 39:50should check it out. Because he has absolutely
- 39:53no expectation of like, oh, Del Toro made a Frankenstein
- 39:55movie? Dope. Right. So I think he flew a little
- 39:58close to the sun with this one. I think you're
- 40:00right. Like, there's a lot of anticipation that
- 40:02he's going to make this movie. I think he's made
- 40:03movies that are better than this that were essentially
- 40:05his Frankenstein movie just without Frankenstein.
- 40:08So it's still... it's still fun. It's still enjoyable.
- 40:13I'm very happy that I got to see it in theaters.
- 40:15That's not something that a lot of people get
- 40:16to say. I know you know, that's the thing. It's
- 40:20hopefully it's going to play again. Uh, I may
- 40:22have mentioned this on the last pod. I think
- 40:24I mentioned off pod though. AMC. Loves doing
- 40:27these Best Picture showcases where, on the span
- 40:29of two days, they'll play the nominees. Previously,
- 40:32they have been unable to play Netflix productions.
- 40:34And it's worth mentioning that Frankenstein and
- 40:37Knives Out, well, Wake Up Deadman, Knives Out
- 40:41Mystery, Jake Kelly, all these movies that played
- 40:43in theaters did not play in AMC theaters because
- 40:45of that Netflix partnership. That has been waived.
- 40:48So now, this year, you can go to these Best Picture
- 40:51showcases and see Train Dreams and Frankenstein
- 40:53in AMC theaters. So there's still an opportunity
- 40:56for people to see this in theaters. And I hope
- 40:58that they do if they haven't seen it already.
- 41:00But I will say that that didn't fully change
- 41:01my opinion on this movie. In theaters, I was
- 41:04just more like, yeah, that was fine. But why
- 41:07didn't I like that more? Because I love Del Toro.
- 41:09And obviously, we all like the story of Frankenstein.
- 41:11Yeah. But something was just in the middle there.
- 41:14Still, it's heavy at the bottom for me. I think
- 41:17we talked about this early on. We talked about
- 41:18our predictions, but this is a movie that's going
- 41:21to be carried by its below -the -line nominations.
- 41:25Very much production design, makeup and hairstyling,
- 41:28costume design. These are things where I think
- 41:31it's going to have a pretty heavy hand in its
- 41:33chances to win. In things like sound, original
- 41:36score, cinematography, adapted screenplay, best
- 41:40picture, I'm not so sure. I will say I don't
- 41:42think he's going to win, but supporting actor
- 41:44Jacob Elordi, that is a very strong nomination
- 41:47for him. And I would not be shocked in any other
- 41:51year if he won for this performance. No, I agree
- 41:54with you. I don't think he's beating out Stellan
- 41:55Skarsgård for sentimental value. No. But he could.
- 41:58No, he could. Yeah, yeah. I think that's the
- 42:01one I'm probably most like, I see the big possibility
- 42:04here. As great as everything else was. Benicio,
- 42:08Sean Penn. Yeah, yeah. But like the technical
- 42:11nominations in this as well. Like, you know,
- 42:14sound. I don't know. You've got one battle after
- 42:17another. You've got Sinners. You've got F1. You
- 42:20know, the great room rooms. And everything else.
- 42:23The score, the costume design. Like, I think
- 42:26there are other films this year that kind of
- 42:28just have a one -up on just about every category
- 42:31here. And, you know, that's fine. I guess. You'll
- 42:36see these guys again. That's the thing. Like
- 42:37I've mentioned so many times, this crew, they
- 42:40are Del Toro's crew. They've all been, not all
- 42:43of them, but most of them have been nominated
- 42:45before. Dan Lawson, the cinematographer, was
- 42:49nominated for The Shape of Water, Nightmare Alley.
- 42:51He also did the John Wick movies. I think starting
- 42:55with the second one, Onward. Oh, great. One of
- 42:57my favorites. He's worked with Del Toro since
- 42:591997 when he did Mimic. which is such a long
- 43:03time to work with anybody. But the costume designer,
- 43:06Kate Hawley, Pacific Rim, Crimson Peak, like
- 43:10she's worked with them before. She also did the
- 43:11Hobbit films. Crimson Peak, another great one.
- 43:14Yeah. I used that as a double feature one time.
- 43:17I thought you meant this. I was like, did you
- 43:18just give it away? Yeah. Let me just throw it
- 43:20out there. But even Alexander Desplat, like he
- 43:24said, he was... The Shape of Water, he won for
- 43:26that. He won for the Grand Budapest Hotel. He's
- 43:28been nominated 12 times. So a very seasoned composer.
- 43:32This just wasn't it as a whole for me in every
- 43:35category. It was all just fine. Yeah. I mean,
- 43:39again, I think supporting actor is like way more
- 43:41than fine. Yeah. But everything else is just
- 43:43completely fine. And it makes sense that it was
- 43:45nominated. One more thing I want to say about
- 43:47Frankenstein before we wrap up here is I want
- 43:50to do a little coda. A little... little cute
- 43:53thing at the end here okay i want to talk about
- 43:55horror yeah horror has had an incredible uh year
- 44:00at the oscars here i wish i was more proud of
- 44:02the horror that we do have in something like
- 44:04frankenstein but i mean let's break it down frankenstein
- 44:08is nominated for best picture nine nominations
- 44:09overall yeah sinners is horror for sure nominated
- 44:15broke the record for nominations for oscars unreal
- 44:18that a horror movie is able to do that yes Weapons
- 44:21was nominated in, outside of Best Picture, probably
- 44:25the best thing they could have, which is Supporting
- 44:27Actress for Amy Madigan in the role of Anne Gladys.
- 44:30Absolutely. Unreal. Ugly Stepsister was nominated
- 44:34for Makeup and Hairstyling. Yeah. That's a Shudder
- 44:37production, or at least distributed by Shudder.
- 44:38That's what's so cool about that to me, because
- 44:41Makeup and Hairstyling is usually where you see
- 44:43the horror nominations pop up. Yeah. Substance,
- 44:46historically, last year. Yeah. But it's really
- 44:48exciting that Shudder now... Has entered the
- 44:51Academy Awards. So cool. I mean, Mubi, you're
- 44:54right. Mubi Entertainment was there previously
- 44:56with The Substance. So it's very cool to see
- 44:59horror prevalent here. It's not the first time
- 45:02we've seen horror, right? We've seen Get Out
- 45:04nominated for Best Picture before. Yeah. Silence
- 45:06of the Lambs before that. The Exorcist. The Exorcist.
- 45:09We've seen horror here before. What I'm happy
- 45:12about is the amount of horror that we're seeing.
- 45:15You know, the thing that's a bummer is like when...
- 45:18When we said, okay, Frankenstein got nominated.
- 45:20We can talk about horror at the Academy Awards.
- 45:22Like, this is a big deal. Up until I rewatched
- 45:25it last night, I was totally on board. But this
- 45:28is just not a horror movie. And that's what kind
- 45:31of bums me out. Like, the creation of this story
- 45:34by Mary Shelley is, everyone was like, I bet
- 45:38I can write a scary story and you can't, blah,
- 45:41blah, blah. And Mary Shelley was like, bet. And
- 45:43she wrote this iconic story about this monster.
- 45:48being brought back from the dead. And none of
- 45:51that horror exists in this movie. You could argue
- 45:53like the violence in it is, is horror and things.
- 45:57Maybe the, the scene in the cabin with the wolves
- 46:01and that older man, like that's some horror,
- 46:03but like that's about it. But even then I, I'd
- 46:06almost say that's like action. Like it's a tragedy,
- 46:08but it's not really a horror, you know? So it
- 46:11does bum me out that like this kind of outlet
- 46:14to be able to talk about horror at the Academy
- 46:16Awards, it, It's not really warranted through
- 46:19Frankenstein. Right. I think that it'll be much
- 46:22more exciting to talk about sinners. Sure. In
- 46:24the horror category. But this is just another
- 46:29reason for me to be like, Del Toro, come on,
- 46:32man. Like, make it. Make the Frankenstein movie
- 46:36that we know you, I don't know, I can't say that
- 46:39you can make. Because he did it. Yeah. He did
- 46:41it. And as he said, it's done. Yeah. That's it.
- 46:44It's over. And I just think maybe it was a 6
- 46:47.5 and not a 10. And that's why I love that he
- 46:50said 6 .5. Yes. Because that's kind of exactly
- 46:52what he did. Yeah. Do you want to move into ratings
- 46:56ourself? I think so. I'm pulling up my rating
- 46:58right now. But spoiler alert, I was not at a
- 47:016 .5. Okay. That sounds about right. Oh, let
- 47:04me ask you something. On Letterboxd, the review
- 47:06that you left, was that your most recent review
- 47:08or was that your first review? That was my first
- 47:09review. Okay. Do you think it's changed much?
- 47:11Good or bad? Since your second watch. I don't
- 47:14think it's changed much. Okay. But I don't remember
- 47:16what I said. I mean, I have it pulled up here,
- 47:18but... Let me pull it up. How do I pull this
- 47:22up? I do like your last line on your interview,
- 47:24or your review. Does it say, I want to prefer
- 47:27the audience? Oh, yeah, yeah. I brought up the,
- 47:30you're the monster, Victor. Yeah, for sure. I
- 47:33mean, you and I kind of stayed on the same level
- 47:35here in terms of our review. We are the same
- 47:38rating. Do you want to just announce that together?
- 47:40Yeah. We both had three stars. We did. We gave
- 47:42this three stars. I think that's completely fair.
- 47:45I think that's exactly in the middle. I mean,
- 47:47granted, 2 .5 would have been exactly in the
- 47:48middle. Right. But this, to me, it's still, like,
- 47:52there's del Toro sensibilities in there, the
- 47:53performance that Jacob Elordi has given. Like,
- 47:56there are good things in this movie. There's
- 47:59just also very, like, why don't I care more about
- 48:02this? Yes. Vibes throughout this movie. For me,
- 48:07I definitely blame Netflix. I think that's easier
- 48:10than, like, I've put Del Toro on too high of
- 48:13a pedestal, so I'm not like, Del Toro, you goofed
- 48:15on this one. I'm more like, Netflix, why did
- 48:17you let Del Toro goof on this one? That's your
- 48:19fault. And maybe that's not fair, but... When
- 48:22I saw this and I walked away, I was like, man,
- 48:23that just felt more Netflix than I thought I
- 48:25wanted it to, or than I did want it to. So three
- 48:28stars is fair for me. I know a lot of people
- 48:30who did really like this movie. Jordan, who was
- 48:33on the podcast in December to talk about All
- 48:36Quiet on the Western Front, huge horror guy,
- 48:39huge Universal Monsters guy, loves Frankenstein,
- 48:41and he loved this movie. So there are things
- 48:44that people do like about this movie that we
- 48:47didn't get, that didn't work for us. Again, mileage
- 48:52may vary, but I think it's very funny that you
- 48:54and I landed on the same rating for this. Yeah,
- 48:56yeah. It dropped two from last night. That makes
- 48:59sense. I had started at a three and a half. And
- 49:01after I rewatched it, I was like, no. I wonder,
- 49:04you know, I do think it's, I hope you get to
- 49:06see this in theaters at some point, whether it
- 49:07be this year or like in years to come. Yeah,
- 49:10maybe like 10 years from now. I don't think I
- 49:12could rewatch it again. And that's fair because
- 49:14especially just watching it a second time at
- 49:15home, like you're not. especially the death race
- 49:19that you're doing. Like, you're not inspired
- 49:20to make time to go see this. But I do wonder
- 49:23if your rating would change. If you see it in
- 49:26theaters, you're like, no, that is a three. Yeah,
- 49:28yeah, I don't know. If it was the visuals that
- 49:31really pulled me out of it, but it really is
- 49:32the story and the drive of the story. And, you
- 49:35know, that's the same whether you watch it in
- 49:36IMAX or you watch it on a iWatch. What are they
- 49:40called? iPic? No. What are the watches called?
- 49:43Apple Watch? Yeah. iWatch. I don't use an iWatch.
- 49:47That's what I do. iWatch. Exactly. But no, I
- 49:50hear you. Like, yes, the experience nine times
- 49:53out of ten is... more enjoyable in a theater.
- 49:57Yeah. And one thing I forgot to mention is when
- 49:59we talk about Del Toro visuals, there's a scene
- 50:02almost straight out of Crimson Peak or Hellboy
- 50:05with the Angel of Death. There's a nightmare
- 50:09or a dream that Victor has where the Angel of
- 50:12Death is reaching its hand out to him and it's
- 50:14engulfed in flames. And to me, I was just standing
- 50:17and applauding. And I was like, Del Toro, you
- 50:19did it again. It looks great. And it doesn't
- 50:22look too CGI. I loved it. Don't watch this at
- 50:26home, man. See, there you go. There's the difference
- 50:28watching it in the theater. I do want to rewatch
- 50:30it at home. Well, let me take that back. I think
- 50:33I will watch it at home. Yes. I don't know if
- 50:36I want to do that, but I'm interested to see
- 50:38where my rating changes. I would be interested
- 50:40too. We'll see. It's going to drop. Also, a big
- 50:42shout out to my Degrassi fans out there. Paige
- 50:44McElchuck does have a cameo in this movie. That
- 50:47doesn't mean a ton for a lot of other people,
- 50:48but she does appear in this movie and in theaters.
- 50:50This is how out of the movie I was by towards
- 50:52the end. This actress shows up on screen. She's
- 50:54the mother of the family in the cabin. Oh. And
- 50:57she shows up and I just stopped. I was like...
- 51:00Is that Paige Michaelchuck from Degrassi? And
- 51:02it is. And I told Taylor and she did not care
- 51:04about anything I was saying about Frankenstein.
- 51:06But when I mentioned that, she was like, I'm
- 51:07listening. Do I need to watch Frankenstein? Everybody's
- 51:10getting attacked by wolves and you're like, feel
- 51:12the rain on your skin. Yeah. You know, be the
- 51:15best that I can. Okay. So do you want to talk
- 51:18double features? I do. You know, I feel like
- 51:20I have gone first a lot of times in this. So
- 51:23I'd love for you to continue going first. I think
- 51:26I've gone first every episode so far this season.
- 51:28Maybe that's more what I'm thinking. It's your
- 51:30turn. I'm going to double feature this. I'm going
- 51:32to pair it with another adaptation of a classic
- 51:38monster, iconic monster. Okay. And I'm going
- 51:41to go with Francis Ford Coppola's Bram Stoker's
- 51:43Dracula. Great pick. I think that Coppola took
- 51:48another iconic horror novel and kind of looked
- 51:52past the... adaptations that had been made for
- 51:55the screen prior and really stuck true to the
- 51:58source material and did his own thing and made
- 52:00this really accurate gothic horror film while
- 52:03also kind of making things his own the the look
- 52:07of dracula in that movie is very unique yeah
- 52:10gary oldman looks weird as heck the old beehive
- 52:14head yes but he did it in a way that i i think
- 52:17del toro kind of missed So I think this is a
- 52:20good opportunity to watch Frankenstein and be
- 52:23like, okay, here's taking this classic story
- 52:26and kind of doing your own thing and maybe faltering
- 52:29a little bit. And then here's doing it in a way
- 52:31that just it hits. Yeah. That's what Bram Stoker's
- 52:35Dracula is to me. Interesting. Like it's a better
- 52:37blend of like the faithful and the chance that
- 52:40you took. Yes. Yeah, I think so. How it can be
- 52:43done right. I think so. Great pick. Thank you.
- 52:47That's a great comparison. I went with more of
- 52:51the idea of like a creator, the idea of like
- 52:55a creator and its creation. I think that a majority
- 52:58of Del Toro's Frankenstein. after Victor actually
- 53:02creates life and conquers death, that he spends
- 53:06the majority of the movie being kind of like,
- 53:08oh, geez. Oh, man. Oh, look what I did. Oh, no.
- 53:11And that's it. That's really him coming to terms
- 53:13with everything. I wanted to pair this with a
- 53:16movie with a creator who actually has a little
- 53:18bit more of a hand in the invention and the creation
- 53:21that he makes and sees more of the repercussions
- 53:24of this than maybe Victor does in Frankenstein.
- 53:28And so I paired it with the 1986 Cronenberg movie,
- 53:31The Fly. I think that this is a different version
- 53:36of how involved a creator can be in the process.
- 53:40I think that because Jacob Elordi has so much
- 53:43to work with in this movie, it really does, almost
- 53:45quite literally, even with the second part, the
- 53:48creature's tale, be about the creature more than
- 53:51it is Victor in this case. And I really like
- 53:53the idea of seeing a creator who actually...
- 53:56was more personally and physically affected by
- 54:01his creation. I also think that it kind of blends
- 54:04the horror better in The Fly than it does in
- 54:07Frankenstein, because you're right, it is more
- 54:08of a gothic horror, and then horror kind of has
- 54:10a parenthesis for Frankenstein. It's so prevalent
- 54:13in what Cronenberg does with The Fly in 1986.
- 54:16I like it. Jeff Goldblum, Geena Davis, obviously
- 54:19extremely gross, but that was what I was thinking.
- 54:22Big old stack of donuts. Yeah, big old stack
- 54:24of donuts. Great mirror scene. Yeah, that's a
- 54:27solid choice. I like it. I'm trying to redeem
- 54:30myself after Top Gun Maverick with that one.
- 54:32Oh, listen, that one made sense. That was peanut
- 54:34butter to jelly. I'm doing peanut butter and
- 54:36bananas now. Oh. Right? Yeah. I don't like peanut
- 54:39butter and banana. I'm sorry. Maybe I was doing
- 54:41peanut butter and banana. Now I'm doing peanut
- 54:43butter and jelly. I don't know. Yeah, now we're
- 54:45hitting it. Now we're hitting it. Now we're in
- 54:47the incrustables of podcasts. Hey, in the original
- 54:49story, Victor Frankenstein is in... Antarctica
- 54:55or the Arctic? Sure. Pursuing the monster to
- 54:58destroy it, isn't he? Correct. Yeah, they changed
- 55:01too much in this. I don't like it. Well, I don't
- 55:04like it. Take that up with Netflix and or Del
- 55:06Toro. I blame Del Toro. You blame Netflix, I
- 55:08blame Del Toro. There you go. We're both agreed
- 55:10on that. Anyway, that's going to do it for Frankenstein.
- 55:13An exciting promotion we've got going on right
- 55:16now. We have the Patreon account, of course.
- 55:20Recently, I've been doing my Oscar death race,
- 55:22and every Friday I post my recap of what I've
- 55:25watched that week leading up to the Oscars. If
- 55:29you're unfamiliar with the Oscar death race,
- 55:30I'm watching every movie nominated in every category
- 55:33at the Academy Awards. So there's 50 films. As
- 55:36of right now, which won't line up with the timeline,
- 55:39I'm 52 % done. So I watched 26 of the 50. So...
- 55:44You're going to knock on another one later tonight.
- 55:45Yeah. If you want to check that out, you can
- 55:48sign up at patreon .com slash O -U -T -A -O podcast.
- 55:52However, we also have the community discord.
- 55:55Normally that is available through a paid tier,
- 55:58but we are running a special all through February
- 56:01where if you follow the Patreon for free, doesn't
- 56:04cost you anything at all, you will get an invite
- 56:07to the discord. So if you want to talk this year's
- 56:10Oscars, if you want to just follow along and
- 56:12then like you're in. You know, it's not like
- 56:15once February is over, we're going to kick you
- 56:16out. You're in. You want to talk 1930s this year
- 56:20or 1940s next year, whatever. Give us a follow
- 56:23over on the Patreon account, and you will have
- 56:26essentially lifetime access to that Discord.
- 56:29Incredible. So long as you don't do anything
- 56:32goofy and weird, because then I'll kick you out.
- 56:36Am I going to get kicked out? Listen, I exclusively
- 56:38do goofy and weird things. We'll talk after the
- 56:42pod. Oh, no. Reprimanded again. But also, if
- 56:46you want to just shoot us an email about any
- 56:49of these movies, tell us why Frankenstein was
- 56:51an actual masterpiece and we're both big dummies.
- 56:55Happy to hear it. Yeah. Shoot us an email at
- 56:57outaopodcast at gmail .com. Or post in the Discord
- 57:02once you join from Patreon. Yeah, that's the
- 57:04way to do it. And what's the other thing? I never
- 57:07say rate and review. The podcast. You know what
- 57:11you should do, guys? You should rate and review
- 57:12the podcast. I agree. I agree. That helps a lot.
- 57:15Spotify, Apple Podcasts, wherever you listen.
- 57:18All the heavy hitters on YouTube. Yeah. We're
- 57:20actually doing pretty well on YouTube. Are we?
- 57:22Yeah. It's kind of fun. I've enjoyed that. The
- 57:24TikToks are doing very well, too. Yeah. By the
- 57:26way, huge credit, guys. Huge round of applause
- 57:28in the audience out there. The work that Kyle
- 57:31is doing on the videos on TikTok of the episode
- 57:35previews, masterful. So good. Oh, I just... The
- 57:40Begonia one's incredible. Dude, that one's so
- 57:43funny because I made that. It's such a simple
- 57:46little TikTok, but because I added the music
- 57:48that we're talking about, I'm just like... I
- 57:51do believe this is my masterpiece, but it's all
- 57:54because of, uh, Jerskin Fendrick's like, well,
- 57:57also I think like you, you found the perfect,
- 57:59like I come in with like the, to me, this means,
- 58:01and like, it was a perfect, like reintroduction
- 58:03from the music. It's like, man, he nailed this.
- 58:05So no, great work. Uh, unfortunately you have
- 58:07to keep that up for the rest of the season. Um,
- 58:09so good luck with that. Great. Thanks. Alexander
- 58:11to splat. Yeah. Thanks dude. Make a better score
- 58:14next time for editing purposes. Please. But I
- 58:17mean, I think that's going to do it for this
- 58:18episode. You have anything else you want to add?
- 58:20No, very excited to continue talking about these.
- 58:23And I think that Frankenstein and F1 are kind
- 58:25of the weird low points of this. And it just
- 58:28keeps getting better from here. I agree. So look
- 58:30forward to the next episode where we're going
- 58:32to be covering Chloe Zhao's Hamnet. I'm excited
- 58:36about that one. Very excited. That's going to
- 58:37do it for today's episode. As always. I'm your
- 58:41host, Kyle. And I never considered what would
- 58:43come after creation. And having reached the edge
- 58:46of the earth, there was no horizon left. Oh,
- 58:49that's deep. Yeah, right? Also, you're the monster.
- 58:52And we'll see you at the movies.