Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Reducing Embodied Carbon: Engineering Insights from Nate Maniktala
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:16Welcome to Engineering Influence, a podcast from the American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:20And today I'm very pleased to be joined by Nate Magtala.
- 0:24He is a principal with Branch Pattern. And today we're going to be focusing
- 0:27on the issue of embodied carbon in industrial real estate, commercial real estate.
- 0:34This is an issue which is of growing concern. I think it's of growing awareness
- 0:39of the engineering community. Of course, the developing community,
- 0:42the community of developers out there are looking at developing commercial real estate.
- 0:46And Branch Pattern has a new report out on the impact of embodied carbon.
- 0:51And Nate, really do appreciate taking time to join us on the program.
- 0:56Well, I'm thrilled to be here. Part of ACEC. I love the organization.
- 1:00I'm really excited to have this conversation. Well, we're excited to have it
- 1:03as well. You know, for those out there who may not be directly familiar with
- 1:07Branch Pattern, if you could tell us kind of what you do and how you fit in
- 1:11the AEC space, that would be great.
- 1:14Yeah, that'd be wonderful. So Branch Pattern, we've been around since 1991,
- 1:18and we are a consulting and engineering firm that's dedicated towards sustainability.
- 1:26Our origin story is that we were founded by a high-performance MEP engineer
- 1:31and really dedicated to creating energy-efficient buildings.
- 1:35He was very passionate about it and so got involved in a lot of projects that
- 1:39were part of the AIA Committee on the Environment types of boards.
- 1:43Sustainable design was his passion.
- 1:46We decided that one of the things we wanted to do is to have a greater impact.
- 1:50And so we expanded our services to go beyond MEP design.
- 1:56And today we're a building science and sustainability engineering firm that
- 2:01encompasses all aspects of building science.
- 2:03So we have architects, we have registered architects, we have mechanical engineers,
- 2:07civils, the whole gamut.
- 2:08And we provide consulting services in collaboration with a lot of AEC firms
- 2:15to take buildings to make them optimized for human experience and environmental stewardship.
- 2:21It really shows, you know, the diversification of the industry.
- 2:25I think that that ability to be both on the engineering side and on the consulting
- 2:30side, on the science side shows,
- 2:33you know, what a good engineering firm can be as a trusted advisor in multiple
- 2:37ways to clients and not just clients, but actually, you know,
- 2:42beyond that, the general public on issues that are important,
- 2:48like sustainability. Yeah.
- 2:50So what really prompted the branch pattern to embark on this study?
- 2:55I understand this is the second version of the study.
- 2:59What kind of sparked the idea to put this together?
- 3:02Well, we saw, so one of our large sectors that we serve is the industrial real estate sector.
- 3:08And we're really fortunate to work with some of the largest developers and owners
- 3:13in the industrial real estate in the world. And we are their green building
- 3:17consultants, sustainability partners across their entire portfolio.
- 3:21And so we see hundreds and hundreds, about 600 industrial buildings a year, our firm touches.
- 3:28And that is throughout North America, South America, and Europe. up.
- 3:32We were also noticed that a lot of the research and the information around embodied
- 3:39carbon tended to be centered on other sectors, the non-industrial sectors, right?
- 3:43The Carbon Leadership Forum, a wonderful organization that we fully support
- 3:46and participate in, established some benchmarks.
- 3:50But in 2023, when we were reviewing the benchmark, they had two industrial buildings
- 3:55in the entire benchmark.
- 3:57And we thought to ourselves, you know, one of our core values is advocacy.
- 4:03We help lead the industry forward and lead a movement so that our clients and
- 4:09the entire sector understood, you know, how they should approach embodied carbon
- 4:13and what is a good baseline to be using.
- 4:16And if you measure that baseline, then we can start to track improvement.
- 4:21You know, for those out there who may not be directly involved with the industry,
- 4:25you know, we try to get this out to a wide audience. I think That they're,
- 4:28you know, people assume immediately, well, they understand kind of the baseline
- 4:32idea of operational carbon, right? A building is.
- 4:36You know, stuff's going on in a building 24-7, right?
- 4:39There are furnaces, there are energy generations, there are,
- 4:42you know, you are emitting something from a building.
- 4:45How does that differ from embodied carbon?
- 4:49Yeah. So embodied carbon is largely upfront, right?
- 4:53While operational carbon emissions
- 4:55happen over the course of a building's lifetime and decrease over time,
- 5:00you know, as electricity providers incorporate more renewable energy,
- 5:03as well as carbon capture and storage,
- 5:06the emission profile of a building, as we anticipate,
- 5:09is going to change dramatically in the future here,
- 5:12where the embodied carbon emissions, that is the emissions associated with the
- 5:20materials and the construction and the manufacturing of all those materials
- 5:24during the entire life cycle.
- 5:26So that includes extraction of raw materials, the manufacturing,
- 5:30the transportation, installation, maintenance, and then disposal of building materials.
- 5:35The eventual deconstruction and demolition and waste processing at the end of
- 5:40a building's lifetime can also contribute to a lot of that embodied carbon emission.
- 5:45And so the decisions we make today are permanent, whereas a lot of the operational
- 5:52decisions we make can be improved over time.
- 5:56Yeah, and that's the challenge, right? That's really the challenge when it comes down to engineering.
- 6:01It's a question of, you know, you do have the opportunity over time,
- 6:06hopefully, that operational emissions are going to be lowered or controlled.
- 6:09You have regulations that are coming in about net zero, things of that nature that can be changed.
- 6:14But then the question really becomes up front, what is the embodied carbon total
- 6:23on this structure that you're designing? Yeah.
- 6:26And I add the time value of decision-making is important too,
- 6:30because if we want to hit some of our climate goals,
- 6:34these emissions are happening largely in these first year or three years of
- 6:39the building construction process.
- 6:41And so we can say that we made a building 60% more energy efficient,
- 6:47but we're going to see those returns over 30 years.
- 6:51If we reduce embodied carbon by 60%, we're going to see the vast majority of
- 6:55those reductions in these initial years.
- 6:57And when we looked at industrial real estate, in 2022, 716 million square feet
- 7:04of industrial construction started in the United States.
- 7:08Over the last five years, it's averaging about, that was the peak,
- 7:12it's averaging about 475 million square feet of industrial construction starts each year.
- 7:17That's 20 to 25% of all construction in the United States.
- 7:21So it's a very big opportunity that I think if we attack it, we can make a big impact.
- 7:28Yeah, absolutely. And then you have layered onto that the post-COVID effect
- 7:33of a lot of buildings not really being torn down and rebuilt,
- 7:37but you're having a lot of buildings retrofitted.
- 7:39That's happening a lot in Washington, D.C. A lot of office space is going to
- 7:42be becoming condos, right? You have a lot of firms that are looking at how do we...
- 7:47How do we deal with renovating and rehabbing the space to be for a completely different use?
- 7:54You know, how does that fit into the whole mixture with embodied carbon instead
- 7:59of just, you know, rebuilding or tearing down, but actually retrofitting?
- 8:03Yeah. You know, I really enjoyed listening to your past, well,
- 8:07I think in mid-December, you had a podcast on this topic with Kelly Roberts
- 8:10from Walter P. Moore, and she did a wonderful job.
- 8:12And I like one of the things that she said, and I've heard a lot of other people
- 8:16say is the greenest building is the one that's already built.
- 8:18And there's what that really means is that you can avoid the manufacturing of
- 8:24new materials. You can avoid the emissions associated with demolition and all of that waste.
- 8:30However, the way that we typically approach this, especially in the industrial
- 8:35sector, is we look at it from a cost benefit standpoint.
- 8:39And so an industrial developer might say, gosh, this is a class B industrial
- 8:43building that I've acquired. I need to make it a class A in order for me to
- 8:48be competitive in the market.
- 8:50I could just tear this thing down. Maybe it's mostly a metal building and ship
- 8:55it off and build new 40-foot clear concrete building.
- 9:01And it's going to make the most business sense.
- 9:04And that's largely how most of these developments go.
- 9:08But because we are creating more of a focus on embodied carbon and having a
- 9:13better understanding of the impact of tearing that building down and just building up new,
- 9:19we can leverage this data to justify different decisions, right?
- 9:24Like with new data, we can make new decisions.
- 9:27And we are seeing because of embodied carbon, there is a story to tell that
- 9:32justifies adaptive reuse of some of these industrial buildings, right?
- 9:37And so maybe it was a non-industrial building that we're converting into a multi-story
- 9:41industrial building in an urban area for that that last mile.
- 9:45Maybe it's a metal building that rather than just tearing it down,
- 9:50we're figuring out ways to reuse a lot of it and maybe just upgrading corners
- 9:54and elements of it, raising the roof instead of just demoing and building new.
- 9:59And we work with those clients, with our clients and all the design teams to
- 10:04help quantify how much carbon would be saved by doing that.
- 10:09Yeah, I think that's really important. I mean, quantifying that amount,
- 10:13because as you said, you know, those decisions are based on a cost benefit analysis.
- 10:18But away from, you know, the ledger, you have to take into account,
- 10:23of course, you know, if you're a public company, then you have investors,
- 10:26you have competing interests that are beyond just profit loss.
- 10:32ESG, of course, in the past couple of years has become an increasingly significant,
- 10:37important consideration exactly how a company might be able to position itself
- 10:42in the marketplace for future project development based off of their environmental
- 10:46sustainability scores and such.
- 10:48How do you help quantify that? And in your experience,
- 10:52how those more softer social impacts help drive the debate on development with embodied carbon?
- 11:04Yeah, it really starts with trying to figure out a way to get it on the ledger.
- 11:08How can pollution be on the ledger?
- 11:11And when a company decides to commit to being a socially responsible company,
- 11:18where they're going to be accountable for the pollution that they create, right?
- 11:24And even if governments aren't requiring them to although some governments especially the eu,
- 11:31it are requiring them to and so a lot of our companies are global and so they're
- 11:35kind of reading the tea leaves and they're seeing okay well if we have to do
- 11:39it in europe we should just try to figure out a way to do it across our entire
- 11:42organization and it's the right thing it's the right thing to do and it's going
- 11:47to increase investor confidence and a lot of other
- 11:50factors so how do you put it on the ledger well if you if you commit to being
- 11:56carbon neutral or or offsetting all of the carbon all of the emissions that
- 12:01you you're responsible for.
- 12:04The offsetting of that's going to have a cost and so what is the cost of carbon
- 12:08what is that internal cost of carbon going to be for your organization and so
- 12:13we have these discussions with the ESG leaders and sustainability leaders and
- 12:18executives at companies to be like, what do you think you're established?
- 12:21What is your established metric here? Because then we can put it on the books
- 12:24and you can say, when we reduce this many metric tons, it saved us the internal
- 12:30cost of offsetting that carbon that we've, that we've assigned.
- 12:34Right. And so there's some trading of dollars that, that helps it be more of
- 12:39a business decision rather than just philosophical one. Mm-hmm.
- 12:42And that's really what it comes down to is driving the business decision and
- 12:47showing that there is an actual tangible benefit for being able to quantify
- 12:52and actually put on the ledger, you know, these numbers.
- 12:58How are, you know…,
- 13:01You look at the regulatory scheme out there, California, of course,
- 13:05being a leading state in this.
- 13:07Washington, D.C. is aggressive on net zero energy and then also being as carbon neutral as possible.
- 13:17California is, by clean legislation, you have the GRESB internationally.
- 13:24How are all these regulatory schemes impacting the industry domestically?
- 13:29And what's been the industry response?
- 13:32Yeah, that's a great question. You know, there are these different influences
- 13:36that drive change and innovation, right, in general.
- 13:40And I think it starts with innovators. You know, if you think about the innovation
- 13:44adoption curve, you start with these innovators.
- 13:46Those innovators didn't need policy.
- 13:49You know, they were motivated by a competitive spirit to try to be better and
- 13:55stay ahead, you know, of what's next. And so that's where we start our engagement
- 14:00is working with those innovators.
- 14:02And then it kind of goes into these early adopters. And these early adopters
- 14:07tend to look at the innovators and say, okay, there's an opportunity here.
- 14:10There's an opportunity for us to find a better way of building buildings.
- 14:15We're interested in learning from those innovators, seeing what's working,
- 14:19what's not, continuing to experiment.
- 14:21There's some risk associated with innovation, even for the early adopters, right?
- 14:26And but they're willing they're willing to do that and they
- 14:29they find investors that are
- 14:32also have an appetite for that risk have that appetite have that appetite for
- 14:36risk and so that's where we are with embodied carbon we are in that we're in
- 14:40that chasm that lies between early adopters and the early majority and i think
- 14:46we're right we're like in the middle of trying to cross that chasm policy helps that chasm.
- 14:52Policy helps drive us towards this early majority.
- 14:55And it's typically, it doesn't go across the entire policy landscape.
- 14:59It starts in these kind of emerging policy markets like New York or California or Europe.
- 15:07And so they have, the importance of policy is to create, to get us closer to the majority, right?
- 15:17By the time it gets to California, it's been in Europe for a long time.
- 15:21And before it's been in Europe, it's been with those innovators and those early adopters.
- 15:26So, you know, some of our clients that we collaborated with us on this report,
- 15:30like Prologis and Brookfield, they've been investing in embodied carbon for,
- 15:36you know, almost a decade.
- 15:38They have invested in collaborations with MIT and doing research because they
- 15:45truly are trying to position themselves
- 15:48to be ahead of the curve and to continue the lead from the front.
- 15:54And so for them, these policies are relatively inconsequential because they've been there.
- 16:01But what the policies tend to do, which is beneficial, is it brings that majority to the table.
- 16:06And it's important when it comes to Embodied Carbon Chef because you can have
- 16:13all the aspirations of an owner and a designer to create a low-carbon building,
- 16:18but it really takes broad support from the product manufacturing industry as well.
- 16:24And the product in the manufacturing industry needs to have demand in order
- 16:30for them to justify the investments that they need to do that.
- 16:34And so these policies help create some demand.
- 16:36We saw the same thing in a lot of other innovation, whether that's the solar
- 16:41panel or the LED light bulb, right? And so we've seen these innovation cycles
- 16:47occur in our industry over and over and over again.
- 16:51And we're just currently in
- 16:52the middle of the embodied of the lower carbon material innovation cycle.
- 16:56You know, to that point, demand happens once there's enough education in the
- 17:01marketplace where you have an informed consumer or an informed individual who's
- 17:07making decisions about material specifications.
- 17:10You think there is that knowledge gap? I mean, what is the knowledge gap right
- 17:13now between the engineering and construction industries when it comes to body carbon?
- 17:18Because we do have, you know, low carbon concrete. We do have mass timber.
- 17:23We have material options that have an impact on reducing that up front.
- 17:30Carbon, you know, sink. Where do you see this knowledge gap right now and what
- 17:35has to happen to close it?
- 17:37Yeah, well, that's a big part of what we try to do every day.
- 17:41One of the benefits of, you know, our business being in the consulting side
- 17:44is that we are free to help other designers and constructors in the AE industry.
- 17:51We don't see ourselves as competitive. We see ourselves as complementary.
- 17:55And so one of our hopes is that more designers and contractors will use us to help educate them.
- 18:05And this means a lot of times we just come in as part of our advocacy to do
- 18:11education and workshops.
- 18:13And other times they'll actually hire us to look at their specifications and
- 18:16do some analysis and make some recommendations and changes to how they could
- 18:20do a better job of writing their specifications for low-carbon targets.
- 18:25For example, rather than just specifying a slab thickness, make it a performance-based
- 18:31slab specification where you're putting PSI requirements and you allow for innovation to happen.
- 18:37Those types of little things we can help with the industry.
- 18:41We've made a lot of progress in the last five years. We've been really focused
- 18:44on educating the industry for five years.
- 18:47It's been great to see partners like our carbon leadership forum grow in membership.
- 18:54And product manufacturers are innovating. You know, another thing that is important
- 19:00when you're going through this innovation is understanding and evaluating because
- 19:04not every product is going to be successful, right?
- 19:08There may be performance requirements. There may be some misinformation out
- 19:13there about the performance from an emission standpoint of products.
- 19:16And so you have to be careful.
- 19:18Even well-intending suppliers, they get caught up in the marketing.
- 19:22And maybe they didn't do the analysis to the rigor of ISO or EN standards.
- 19:27And so as a specifier or as an owner, you are excited about a product that says
- 19:34they can reduce your embodied carbon emissions by 20%.
- 19:37Can we look under the hood and can we do some of that analysis?
- 19:41And so that's another area that we work in.
- 19:44And we found great success because product manufacturers are well-intending
- 19:49for the most part. And they want to get the information right.
- 19:53And I think we're in a good spot. And I think that actually the next frontier
- 19:58that we're currently working in is, you know, embodied carbon information around
- 20:02concrete and steel has been maturing rapidly over the last five years, especially.
- 20:07But there are a lot of other product types that it's still very,
- 20:11very early, specifically MEP equipment.
- 20:14So it's like, what are the embodied carbons for these air handlers and even
- 20:18solar panels, which are a carbon reduction goal with those?
- 20:26What's the embodied carbon of a solar panel?
- 20:30So those are areas that we're excited that we're doing a lot of research.
- 20:35And we've partnered with some very large companies that have helped fund some
- 20:38research for us to look at the embodied carbon of MEP systems.
- 20:42Do you think that there's one alternative material that is leading the world?
- 20:47You know, across others. I mean, you know, we talked mass timber with Walter P. Moore.
- 20:52We'll be going down to Texas to take a look at their Anderson Ball classroom
- 20:56project that they have huge mass timber education building in Texas as part
- 21:01of our engineering and public works road show soon. I mean, that's going to be a good example.
- 21:06It stands out because it's wooden buildings. You know, seeing more of those is always nice.
- 21:12But, you know, in your research, Is there one that's leading the charge?
- 21:17It's a great question. We wish there were some sexy answers for embodied carbon,
- 21:23but the reality is a lot like energy efficiency.
- 21:26It takes a lot of little things to reduce embodied carbon.
- 21:31The mass timber construction is really exciting for us.
- 21:36We're very strong advocates for mass timber because not only is there an embodied
- 21:40carbon benefit, which there is, But there's a biophilic component to mass timber.
- 21:48Biophilia is the phenomena that we love nature as a human species.
- 21:53We are connected to nature.
- 21:55We're biologically predisposed to like natural materials. And so...
- 22:02When we have a mass timber building, yes, we'll enjoy it more.
- 22:06People like mass timber buildings, but we'll also protect it.
- 22:10And that's the embodied carbon story.
- 22:12We tend not to want to just demolish mass timber buildings.
- 22:16I mean, how many of these buildings that exist in cities today do we have that
- 22:21are loft style with exposed wood beams?
- 22:23And, you know, these buildings could have been torn down for concrete and steel
- 22:27structures, but, you know, just culturally, we tend to see concrete and steel
- 22:31as this material that we don't protect like we do natural wood finish.
- 22:37So, well, it would be nice if we could marry, you know,
- 22:40some, some of the environmental sustainability positives to the,
- 22:44to just general aesthetics and go back to they, I saw, I saw images of,
- 22:50and this is kind of a non sequitur, but you know.
- 22:53They're, the commanders are potentially looking at a new stadium and then the
- 22:56architect, one of an architecture firm just out of nowhere created drawings
- 23:01where they weren't, they weren't solicited, but it was a mass timber stadium.
- 23:04Yeah and it was a just to
- 23:07look at it was amazing because
- 23:10you're immediately like you said you're immediately drawn to it because you're
- 23:13looking at an entire football stadium that is wood and immediately you're like
- 23:21yes please build that because aesthetically it's going to be so amazing yeah
- 23:26hopefully you know that that takes off and and you have that that that combined benefit it.
- 23:33I do have to ask because, you know, when you talk about mass timber,
- 23:36you got to talk about policy.
- 23:37When you talk about policy, you got to look at what's going on in the world.
- 23:40We have potential for terrorists from Canada.
- 23:42Well, guess what? That's where we get a lot of lumber.
- 23:45How, I mean, right now, you know, are you, how, how is branch pattern looking
- 23:51at, I guess, the current situation in Washington, the potential change.
- 23:57ESG, environmental issues have been on the forefront for the past decade or so.
- 24:01You have this huge polar shift in Washington, too early to tell what's going to happen.
- 24:06But, you know, are you game planning? Are you looking ahead at how change might
- 24:12impact either regulation or potential commercial interest in body carbon?
- 24:21Yeah, that's a big challenge, right? If only we could predict the future and
- 24:26had control over, you know, what people thought or did. I'll see you next time.
- 24:31You know, we do analysis. So, you know, as a leader of a business,
- 24:36our responsibility to guide a business towards success.
- 24:39And one of the analysis tools that we use in business is called a PESTLE analysis.
- 24:45I don't know if you've ever heard of a PESTLE analysis, but it stands for political,
- 24:49environmental, social, technological, legal, and economic.
- 24:54And you try to look and you do this environmental assessment to say,
- 24:59what are these factors that are outside of our control that could affect my business's success?
- 25:08And so we did that last year in anticipation of potential political changes
- 25:15in the United States. So we ran a scenario in which Harris won and a scenario
- 25:19in which Trump won, and we tried to look at what those things were.
- 25:24It's challenging to know. One of the things that I feel anecdotally is interesting
- 25:30is that in this case, we've been through a Trump presidency.
- 25:35So it's a little bit easier to have a reference point than if it was a new individual,
- 25:40right? What happened during Trump's last presidency is that sustainability grew in importance.
- 25:46There was significant advancement in the movement to build greener and better buildings.
- 25:53There was economic growth. And so, you know, the environmental components of it,
- 25:59what I anticipate, if I were to guess, is that the private sector,
- 26:05you need to take more leadership over the next four years to fill the void,
- 26:10which is a great conservative principle, right?
- 26:13Maybe good ideas win and let the market work.
- 26:18And I have a lot of confidence in the market.
- 26:21I really do. I think that ultimately sustainability is a good idea.
- 26:28We just talked about how we hope that they build a building out of wood.
- 26:32Why? Because we think it'll be a cool, better building that people will enjoy
- 26:35more and we will protect for more generations, which that's a sustainable outlook, right?
- 26:40We know that there are many people who lead investment in real estate that do
- 26:47see climate risk as a real business concern and a global concern.
- 26:53And so you mentioned GRESB earlier, G-R-E-S-B, that's the global real estate
- 27:00sustainability benchmark.
- 27:02That is purely a tool for private investors to evaluate the sustainability of
- 27:08real estate investments.
- 27:10And so the number of people that have been participating in that benchmark,
- 27:15it's a voluntary disclosure program for real estate companies to disclose the
- 27:20sustainability performance of a real estate portfolio.
- 27:26And so that investors can use that as one tool when evaluating where they want
- 27:31to invest in different funds.
- 27:34That grew so grew significantly
- 27:37under donald trump's last administration not
- 27:40because of anything he did but because sustainability is creating
- 27:44enough value on its own so you know i we we're we're staying the course because
- 27:50we believe it's the right thing to do and i think we're also pretty well positioned
- 27:54that we we don't do things we're not code driven organization we try to be beyond that.
- 28:01And we try to find people who are in that innovator, early adopter stage that
- 28:07are really interested in outcomes.
- 28:09Yeah. I think it's technology and sustainability merge.
- 28:13And as the two kind of pushes it along, there's a greater interest on the private
- 28:19sector to be that's the differentiator.
- 28:22And I think you're right.
- 28:25I think that the market is going to push this forward.
- 28:28But, you know, the important thing is with firms like yours and, you know.
- 28:35The firms throughout ACEC is it's a great opportunity to educate policymakers
- 28:41on these topics to bring it up to them.
- 28:44And because I know there are very few members of Congress who are engineers.
- 28:49There are even fewer who understand. I think there's, you know,
- 28:52Bruce Westerman, who is an engineer and also a professional forester and is
- 28:57a huge proponent of mass timber, but he's like one of hundreds who don't get it.
- 29:02So it's up to us to educate those people in power on the importance of this
- 29:08from an environmental standpoint, but then also to.
- 29:13Push the industry and push clients to take the risk to, to, to,
- 29:19to embrace these things.
- 29:21Yeah. It's a, it's a great report and it's a, it's a great conversation, Nate.
- 29:25I, you know, I'd love to have you back on the show for those who want to get
- 29:29a hand of, you know, get a hold of this report, where should they go and where
- 29:33should they go to learn more about Branch Pattern?
- 29:35Yeah, absolutely. So our website is branchpattern.com and you can go on our website.
- 29:41We've got this report. We also have a lot of other research that we've posted
- 29:45in our perspectives and our thought leadership.
- 29:47There's a knowledge library there and you can download a copy of this full report.
- 29:53It does a really good job of providing if anybody in the industrial sector kind of where to focus.
- 29:59And so, yeah, hopefully it's beneficial and definitely on there,
- 30:02there's also all of our contact information and advocacy is a key principle for us.
- 30:07And so, you know, we really look forward to engaging with the industry to help
- 30:11solve these problems, because I don't think it's a political problem.
- 30:14I think it's a problem that the people, we're all in power to control.
- 30:19The power isn't with politicians, the power is with us, right?
- 30:22And so if we can drive the industry forward, we can make the change we want.
- 30:27That's a great way to close the conversation, Nate.
- 30:32Nate Manitoli is a principal with Branch Pattern.
- 30:35Check them out, branchpattern.com. get a hold of the report,
- 30:38take a look at it. It's a really good report. The website's great, too.
- 30:40You've got a lot of great resources on the website as well that you can really dig into and learn more.
- 30:47So I do appreciate you coming on the show, and I look forward to extending the
- 30:51conversation in the future. Absolutely. Thanks for having me.
- 30:54Fantastic. And again, this has been Engineering Ethics Podcast from the American
- 30:58Council of Engineering Companies, and we will see you next time.
- 31:03Music.