Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Charlie Munger Hates EBITDA and Warren Buffett Don't Care P/E?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. You know, we usually find
- 0:03ourselves tackling a single stock or maybe a big tech trend,
- 0:06but today we're doing something a little different.
- 0:09We're kind of opening up a file on a whole worldview.
- 0:12We've got this amazing stack of Q&A sessions and letters from,
- 0:15well, two of the sharpest minds in finance, Warren Buffett and
- 0:19the late, great Charlie Munger. It's always a good day when we
- 0:22get to spend some time with the oracles.
- 0:23And what I really love about these sources we have today is
- 0:25that it's not the usual stuff. You know, it's not value
- 0:28investing 101. We're not talking about buying
- 0:30coke back in 88. We're looking at these really
- 0:33candid moments where they just tear down what they see as the
- 0:38the nonsense of modern Wall Street.
- 0:39Nonsense is a good word for it. Reading through all this I got
- 0:41the feeling they see modern finances just completely
- 0:44detached from reality. Like they're not just investors
- 0:46anymore, they're sort of the last sane people in the room.
- 0:49That's a perfect way to put it, yeah.
- 0:50They are absolutely obsessed with economic reality of versus,
- 0:54let's call it accounting reality.
- 0:56They're looking for the truth in the numbers, not just what's
- 0:58technically allowed. OK, so before we dive into
- 1:01Charlie Munger's his Absolute war on Eva Da, we should
- 1:06probably set the stage. We need to look at the tools we
- 1:08have for just understanding the market's context right now,
- 1:11because even the best philosophy needs some data.
- 1:13Right context is everything. You have to know the temperature
- 1:16of the room before you decide what to wear.
- 1:18Exactly. And Speaking of market
- 1:20temperature, we actually have a tool to share that helps you
- 1:22keep a finger on that pulse to track total market temperature.
- 1:26Welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett indicator from
- 1:30Apple App Store Apple Store eBay a fee.
- 1:34It's a stored eBay pittor and Yoshuki A sustaining you
- 1:37dibitor, you buffet indicator ebi evituri Yukuchi cookie.
- 1:43OK, let's get into it. The great deception.
- 1:46I genuinely laughed out loud reading Monger's comments on
- 1:49ebitor. For anyone listening who just
- 1:51sees that acronym everywhere, can you remind us what it
- 1:53actually stands for? Sure.
- 1:54So EBITDA is earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation
- 1:58and amortization and Wall Street loves it.
- 2:01They pitch it as the sort of proxy for cash flow.
- 2:04The argument goes that it gives you a cleaner look at a company
- 2:07score operations. Which, on the surface, sounds
- 2:11kind of reasonable. I mean, if I'm comparing two
- 2:13companies, I want to strip out the noise.
- 2:15But Munger doesn't just dislike it, he calls the people who use
- 2:18it disgusting. Why such a strong reaction?
- 2:22Because he says it strips away a real cost.
- 2:24A very, very real cost. The deed appreciation monger
- 2:28absolutely hates this because if you own a bunch of trucks they
- 2:30wear out, you have to replace them.
- 2:31To pretend that isn't a cost is, in his mind, just lying about
- 2:34your profits. He used that analogy that I
- 2:36thought was just perfect, the one about the easing broker
- 2:39trying to rent out an office. Yes, the broker with A1000
- 2:42square foot suite who tells the client, hey, let's just call it
- 2:442000 square feet, Munger says. That's not honorable behavior,
- 2:48but it's exactly what companies do with EBITDA to make their
- 2:51valuation multiples look cheaper.
- 2:52So it's just marketing disguised as math.
- 2:54That's it. And he goes further.
- 2:56He calls it horror squared that business schools are teaching
- 2:59this stuff now. He says, you know, it's one
- 3:01thing for a bunch of thieves to invent a term to sell stocks,
- 3:04but it's another when universities start legitimizing
- 3:06it. He even has this concept he
- 3:08calls reverse float to explain why depreciation is so bad.
- 3:12OK. We talk about float all the time
- 3:14with insurers. You know you get the money 1st,
- 3:16pay claims later. So what's reverse float?
- 3:19Reverse float is the nightmare. It's when you spend the money
- 3:21first. You buy all the heavy machinery,
- 3:24the factories, and you only record the expense slowly
- 3:27overtime, Munger says. That's the absolute worst kind
- 3:31of expense because the cash is already gone.
- 3:33You are poorer, but your books don't show it yet.
- 3:35Right. So the cash left your bank
- 3:36account on day one, but the income statement just trickles
- 3:39out this tiny charge every year and EBITDA just pretends the
- 3:42cash is still there. Exactly.
- 3:44And if you ignore the cash leaving the building, you're not
- 3:47analyzing a business, you're participating in a fantasy.
- 3:49So if we're supposed to throw out EBITDA, what do we look at?
- 3:53I know there are other big formulas like the state PE ratio
- 3:56or the Buffett indicator itself. Are those the Holy Grail?
- 4:00You'd think so, right? Especially with Buffett's name
- 4:02on one of them. But in these sources, he really
- 4:04pushes back on that idea of a Magic formula.
- 4:07He says while they're not unimportant, sometimes they can
- 4:10be totally unimportant. Totally unimportant.
- 4:12That sounds like a contradiction from a guy who loves numbers.
- 4:15Well, his point is that you can't just plug numbers into a
- 4:17spreadsheet and get an answer. Valuation isn't static because
- 4:20the whole environment changes and.
- 4:22The one variable that changes everything is.
- 4:24Interest rates he calls them the financial equivalent of gravity.
- 4:29The 30 year bond tells you what the world is willing to accept
- 4:32for zero risk money. If rates are super high, stocks
- 4:35have to be dirt cheap. If rates are zero, well, much
- 4:38higher valuations can make sense.
- 4:40So a PE of 15 isn't inherently good or bad.
- 4:43Right, it's all relative. Buffett's point is that looking
- 4:46for one single formula is a trap.
- 4:48You have to understand the gravity of the moment.
- 4:50You know that idea of understanding the whole
- 4:52environment, It actually connects perfectly to the life
- 4:55advice they gave. They talk about how to really
- 4:57learn business, and it's not by studying the winners.
- 5:00This is one of my favorite takeaways from our whole deep
- 5:02dive today. Their advice is if you really
- 5:05want to be a great investor, you shouldn't just study success,
- 5:08you should go run a terrible business.
- 5:10A terrible business. A lousy 1, Buffett says.
- 5:12You learn so much more from struggling with a bad business
- 5:15for a couple of years than you do from coasting in a good one.
- 5:19Why is that? I mean, shouldn't you learn from
- 5:21the best? If I want to learn tennis, I
- 5:24watch Federer. I don't go down to the local
- 5:26park. But in business, a great
- 5:28economic engine can cover up for a ton of mistakes.
- 5:31If you're running a monopoly, you can be a pretty mediocre
- 5:34manager and still look like a genius.
- 5:36But in a bad business, Buffett says, you learn that IQ does not
- 5:39solve the problem. You can work 100 hours a week,
- 5:42but if the underlying economics are broken, you will fail.
- 5:45That's a very humbling lesson. It forces you to separate your
- 5:48ego from the outcome. It does, and both of them admit
- 5:51that a huge part of their own education came from businesses
- 5:54that were just awful. You know, textile mills,
- 5:57department stores. It taught them the difference
- 6:00between a great manager and just a great business that anyone
- 6:03could run. It reminds me of that Buffett
- 6:05quote when a management with a reputation for brilliance
- 6:09tackles a business with a reputation for bad economics.
- 6:12It is the reputation of the business that remains intact.
- 6:15Exactly. And that flows right into their
- 6:17career advice. Munger is so clear.
- 6:20Don't wait. Right.
- 6:21You said if there's something you really want to do, don't
- 6:23wait until you're 93. Which is pretty funny coming
- 6:25from him. But the point is real, and
- 6:28Buffett adds to it. He says the ideal job is the one
- 6:30you take if you didn't need a job.
- 6:32That's a high bar to clear. It is, but it's about finding
- 6:34that alignment and they connect this to a mental model
- 6:37inversion. Oh, I love Monger's inversion.
- 6:40All I want to know is where I'm going to die, so I'll never go
- 6:42there. That's the one.
- 6:43He's joking, but he's also deadly serious.
- 6:46He's talking about reverse engineering your life.
- 6:49Kierkegaard said life is lived forwards but understood
- 6:52backwards. Monger is saying try to simulate
- 6:55that understanding. Now look at your life from the
- 6:57perspective of your 90 year old self.
- 7:00What will you regret? Figure that out and just head in
- 7:02the other direction. It's.
- 7:03Such a powerful idea. Instead of trying to be
- 7:05brilliant, just try to consistently not be stupid.
- 7:08That's it in a nutshell. OK, let's pivot to a case study
- 7:12that came up. A company called McLean MLANA.
- 7:16Shareholder asked about it because it brings in a huge
- 7:18amount of revenue for Berkshire, something like $45 billion, but
- 7:22it gets almost zero attention compared to GEICO or See's
- 7:25Candies. Yeah, McClain is a fascinating
- 7:271. It's a wholesale distributor.
- 7:28Basically, if you walk into a 711 or a Walmart and buy a
- 7:31snack, there's a good chance McClain put it on that shelf.
- 7:33So they're the logistics guys for convenience stores.
- 7:35Exactly. And the reason nobody talks
- 7:37about it is the margins, they are razor thin.
- 7:40We're talking about a business with maybe a 6% gross margin and
- 7:43a 1% pre tax margin. Wait. 1% So for every $100.00 of
- 7:49stuff they sell, they only keep $1.00 before tax.
- 7:52Yep. Why in the world would Berkshire
- 7:54own that? That sounds exactly like the
- 7:56lousy business we were just talking about.
- 7:57It sounds like a trap, doesn't it?
- 7:59But this is where the deep dive gets fun.
- 8:01It works because of one word turnover.
- 8:04Speed. Incredible speed, Buffett says.
- 8:07Their sales are something like 30 times their receivables and
- 8:10their payables. They move inventory so fast that
- 8:13the capital is never tied up. So it's about velocity, not
- 8:16margin. It's all about velocity.
- 8:18I mean, think about it. You could have a 50% margin on a
- 8:21diamond ring, but if you only sell one every two years, your
- 8:23capital is dead. But if you make 1% on a candy
- 8:26bar and you sell that inventory 30 * a year, your actual return
- 8:29on capital is 30%. A high volume, high speed game.
- 8:32The ultimate volume game. But there's another part of this
- 8:35story that's maybe even more important.
- 8:37And that's how Berkshire bought it.
- 8:39The deal story This part was incredible.
- 8:42So how does a deal this big normally go down?
- 8:45Normally it's months and months. Teams of lawyers, bankers, due
- 8:49diligence, financing contingencies.
- 8:52It's a huge process. McClain was owned by Walmart.
- 8:56Walmart wanted to sell it. So they went to Buffett because
- 8:58he has the cash. They went to him because they
- 9:00knew he could act. The Walmart CFO flies to Omaha.
- 9:04They talk for a bit. The CFO goes into another room,
- 9:07calls the CEO, comes back out and says you have a deal.
- 9:10Just like that, no audit teams crawling all over the place.
- 9:13Just like that, a handshake. It was a cash deal, no financing
- 9:17nonsense. Buffett said Walmart told him
- 9:19they'd never closed a deal that fast in their entire history.
- 9:22And this wasn't a one off thing for him, right?
- 9:24The force also mentioned that Northern Natural Gas deal.
- 9:27Another perfect example. The seller was in deep financial
- 9:31trouble. They need cash by Monday
- 9:32morning. This was over a weekend a.
- 9:34Weekend. You can't even get a mortgage
- 9:35approved in a weekend. Exactly.
- 9:37But Buffett looked at it, knew the deal made sense, but there
- 9:39was a regulatory hurdle. So he just wrote them a letter.
- 9:42He said basically, here's the money now, if the regulator's
- 9:45block it later, we'll undo it. But here's the cash you need by
- 9:47Monday. Wow, so he took on the risk.
- 9:49He gave them the money before the deal was even technically
- 9:52cleared. He did because he knew the
- 9:54business and he knew they were desperate.
- 9:56This is the real Buffett mode that you can't find on a balance
- 9:59sheet sheet. Almost no one else on earth can
- 10:02write a multi billion dollar check over a weekend with no
- 10:06board meeting. That really is the power of
- 10:08reputation. It is being known as quick,
- 10:11simple and certain. That brings deals to their
- 10:15doorstep that no one else even gets to see.
- 10:18You might get a slightly lower price from Berkshire but you
- 10:21know the check is going to clear on Monday.
- 10:23That's incredible. It all connects back, doesn't
- 10:25it? Trust and reputation are real
- 10:27assets. They compound just like money.
- 10:28Absolutely. Speed is just a function of
- 10:30trust. So before we wrap, we have to
- 10:32touch on the legacy questions. They ask them very bluntly, what
- 10:36do you want people to say at your funeral?
- 10:37And this is where their personalities just really come
- 10:39through. Buffett, you know, classic
- 10:40Buffett. He deflects with a joke.
- 10:42He says. I want them to say that's the
- 10:45oldest looking corpse I ever saw.
- 10:47Which is pretty good goal honestly means you won the game.
- 10:50It does. Monger, on the other hand, gets
- 10:52a little more sentimental, but he kind of covers it with that
- 10:54gruff exterior. He just says he wants to be
- 10:57remembered as a teacher. A teacher.
- 10:59Yeah, he says he uses wise assery.
- 11:01That was his word to make the lesson stick.
- 11:04He knows he can be blunt, but it's all in service of the
- 11:06teaching. And he even ended with that joke
- 11:08about Wilt Chamberlain's tombstone.
- 11:10He did quoted the epitaph that's supposedly on his grave.
- 11:14At last I sleep alone. Classic Monger always leaves you
- 11:18with a smirk and something to think about.
- 11:20Exactly. OK.
- 11:21So let's try to bring this all together.
- 11:22We have the great deception of EBITDA.
- 11:25Don't trust metrics that hide real costs.
- 11:27We've got the advice to go run a bad business, to really learn
- 11:30how things work. And the lesson from McClain?
- 11:33Speed and reputation are massive competitive advantages.
- 11:37Being able to act when everyone else is stuck in meetings is a
- 11:39superpower. And then the big one, I think,
- 11:42reverse engineer your life. Don't wait until you're 90 to
- 11:45figure out what really matters. You know, if you tie it all
- 11:48together, it's really about honesty, honest accounting,
- 11:51honest self-assessment, and doing business honestly to build
- 11:55trust. If you strip away the nonsense
- 11:57and just focus on the underlying reality, you're probably going
- 11:59to end up in a pretty good place.
- 12:01And that kind of leaves the final question for you, the
- 12:04listener. If you were to apply that monger
- 12:06inversion model, if you look back at your own investment
- 12:09strategy or even your career from the age of 90, which of
- 12:12today's painful expenses or struggles would you realize were
- 12:16actually just valuable investments in your education?
- 12:18That is a thought to chew on. Maybe that terrible business
- 12:21you're in right now is actually your master class.
- 12:23It very well could be all right. Before we go, we have to do the
- 12:26housekeeping. The important stuff.
- 12:28Disclaimer Full Deep Value Research reports can be found in
- 12:31the description links. All analysis is based on
- 12:34publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 12:37differing interpretations. The content is for educational
- 12:40purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 12:44Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 12:46decisions. And if you enjoyed this deep
- 12:48dive if. You want to listen to our full
- 12:50deep dive about this topic or access more advanced contents?
- 12:53Welcome to join Deep Value Club membership or subscribe us on
- 12:56Deep Values dot AI. Don't forget to like this video.
- 13:00Much appreciated. Thanks for listening.
- 13:02We'll see you on the next deep dive.