Latest / Decrypted: The UK Cyber Briefing / Ofcom's age-check shortlist: the question is what gets kept
Transcript
- 0:03Good morning, and welcome to Decrypted.
- 0:05I'm Belinder. It's Friday, the thirtieth of October, twenty twenty-six, and this is the morning edition.
- 0:12Ofcom's age-check shortlist: the question is what gets kept.
- 0:18On Thursday, Ofcom narrowed down the ways social media firms may check that a user is 16.
- 0:25That's ahead of the government's under-16 ban.
- 0:27Four methods survive. None of them is foolish on its own.
- 0:31The Secure by Design question is what each one leaves behind once the check is over.
- 0:36Ofcom's published material doesn't yet answer that.
- 0:39So, what did Ofcom actually shortlist?
- 0:43Its rapid assessment found four methods currently capable of being highly effective at 16.
- 0:49Matching a photo identity document to a live image of the user.
- 0:53A bank-based check, using the bank's own age record with the user's consent.
- 0:57A reusable digital identity.
- 1:00And facial age estimation.
- 1:02Estimation has a margin of error of a few years at 16.
- 1:06So Ofcom suggests a Challenge 25 style approach.
- 1:09Estimate first, then verify properly anyone close to the line.
- 1:14The government says its first regulations will arrive before the end of 2026, with the ban in force next yea
- 1:20r. Now, who might get left out?
- 1:24Ofcom estimates that 94% of people aged 16 and over hold a passport or driving licence.
- 1:31It also estimates that around 150,000 sixteen and seventeen year olds have neither.
- 1:36That figure leans on a survey of 8,459 pupils, which Ofcom itself calls non-representative.
- 1:44Free proof-of-age cards are one route in.
- 1:46And as The Register reports, Ofcom accepts that the risk of circumvention cannot be entirely eliminated.
- 1:54Then there's the design question.
- 1:56Think of a good age check as a bouncer.
- 1:58They glance at your licence and say yes or no.
- 2:01A poor one photocopies it, files it and keeps the copy.
- 2:05Ofcom says age checks at 16 will involve processing personal data.
- 2:09It concludes they can be delivered in a way that protects privacy and complies with data protection law.
- 2:15It will keep working with the Information Commission.
- 2:18But the pages I read give no retention periods.
- 2:21Photo matching means passports and live face images passing through third-party providers.
- 2:26That's why Big Brother Watch calls the plan a national I D system by the back door.
- 2:32The security point is simpler.
- 2:34A provider holding large stores of passport images is a target.
- 2:38And the safest copy is the one that doesn't exist.
- 2:41So what would Secure by Design ask for?
- 2:44First, a yes or no, nothing more.
- 2:47The platform should receive "over 16", not the document or the face.
- 2:52Second, deletion as the default.
- 2:55Evidence is discarded once the result is issued, with the rule written down and audited.
- 3:00Third, no single point of failure.
- 3:03Ofcom's separate app store report says a layered approach avoids exactly that.
- 3:08It found app stores rely on self-declared age, and are not currently regulated under the Online Safety Act.
- 3:14And what does this mean for you?
- 3:16If you run a service with young users, or supply one, the age check will probably be bought in.
- 3:22So put deletion, sub-contractors and breach notification in the contract before launch.
- 3:28And don't build your own store of identity images.
- 3:31As always, this is opinion, not advice.
- 3:35That was Decrypted, with me, Belinder.
- 3:39The written version and every source are linked in the show notes.
- 3:43Thanks for listening. Stay patched, and stay sceptical.