Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 284. Hear Me Out: How Understanding Accents—Ours & Others—Improves Communication
Transcript
- 0:02Matt Abrahams: How you sound and what you say is critical to communication success.
- 0:08Let's put an accent on accents.
- 0:11My name's Matt Abrahams and I teach Strategic Communication at
- 0:14Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:16Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:20Today I look forward to speaking once again with my friend Valerie Fridland.
- 0:23Valerie is a professor of sociolinguistics at the University of Nevada in Reno.
- 0:28She's an expert on the relationship between language and society.
- 0:32Valerie is the author of Like, Literally, Dude, arguing for the good in bad
- 0:37English, and recently she released her new book called Why We Talk Funny:
- 0:41The Real Story Behind Our Accents.
- 0:44Well, welcome back Valerie.
- 0:46I am thrilled to be joined with you again and to continue the conversations
- 0:50you and I have had many times over the last time since you visited.
- 0:53Thanks for being here.
- 0:54Valerie Fridland: Oh, absolutely.
- 0:55It's always a pleasure to talk with you, Matt.
- 0:57Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 0:58Shall we get started?
- 0:59Valerie Fridland: Let's do it.
- 1:00Matt Abrahams: You have taught me so many things about how language works,
- 1:04but none has fundamentally changed my view than what you've talked
- 1:07about in terms of filled pauses.
- 1:10It changed the way I think about it, I teach it, what I try to do in my own work.
- 1:15For those of you who haven't heard Valerie's complete description of this
- 1:18checkout episode 91, would you mind just giving us a quick summary of what filled
- 1:22pauses are and what they actually do for us as communicators and as listeners?
- 1:27Valerie Fridland: Sure, absolutely.
- 1:29Well filled pauses are things we all use on occasion.
- 1:32We all recognize because they're the uhs and ums that populate our
- 1:37pauses, and every language has them.
- 1:39So it's something we find the world over.
- 1:42They're not all exactly the same form, but roughly.
- 1:45But what we find is that um and uh tend to occur when we're
- 1:48doing more complex things.
- 1:50So whenever we are having more complex sentence structures, so we're putting
- 1:54a lot of embeddings, a lot of different sort of extra parts in our sentences and
- 1:59and's, or or's, and relative clauses, we find that uh and um tend to occur
- 2:04before those points of more complexity.
- 2:07We also find when we're coming up with hard words, big words, unfamiliar words,
- 2:12we tend to uh or um more in front of them.
- 2:15But I think the most fascinating thing is not just why we do them as speakers,
- 2:19because we're signaling harder work cognitively, but it's actually what they
- 2:22do for a listener that's incredible.
- 2:25And not only do they signal to a listener like, hey, I'm doing
- 2:29something really complex here.
- 2:30It's gonna take me a minute.
- 2:31So they're kind of just giving you a heads up that we're taking a moment.
- 2:35The reason we wanna do that is because if I pause silently,
- 2:39you might think I'm done.
- 2:40But if I uh or um it's signaling to you I'm not done.
- 2:43I'm just pausing for a sec. But the really, really fascinating part
- 2:47is that they actually really help with memory on the listener side.
- 2:52So when we run experiments and we have people say uh before a content word,
- 2:56before some sort of word that we're interested in people remembering, and
- 3:00then we run the same experiment where we don't have people uh before that word,
- 3:04we find that the recall for the word with uh in front of it is better than
- 3:08in the cases where they didn't have uh.
- 3:09Which tells us that they're actually doing some pretty important work.
- 3:13So if you want people to remember what you say, a little uh won't hurt you.
- 3:17But I wouldn't overpopulate because we also don't like them.
- 3:21So just be aware of that facet as well.
- 3:24Matt Abrahams: It's fascinating to me that these filler words exist
- 3:27across different languages and that they actually serve a purpose.
- 3:30They signal that we're working hard.
- 3:32They highlight that what we're about to say is something
- 3:34you should pay attention to.
- 3:35And it turns out people actually do pay more attention and they actually
- 3:38remember that information more.
- 3:40So the old adage, get rid of all the filled pauses, is not actually accurate.
- 3:45It's okay to have them and they in fact help us.
- 3:48It's when you have a lot of them that it gets distracting.
- 3:51And I would argue that my theory is the reason when somebody uses so
- 3:55many of these filled pauses annoys us is we're actually trained to
- 3:58expect something of value to follow.
- 4:00If all that follows an um is another um that actually is frustrating.
- 4:04Valerie Fridland: Partially, I think that's true.
- 4:06I also think it's that the natural tendency is that we're going to um
- 4:09and uh more often in high stakes context because it's things we're
- 4:13not as used to saying, and it's not anxiety or stress, there's actually
- 4:17not that much evidence that really increases our rate of um-ing and uh-ing.
- 4:20When we go in front of the executive leadership and we're talking about
- 4:24something very important that we've done, we're probably going to be
- 4:28using higher level vocabulary, things we're not quite as familiar with.
- 4:32So I think when we're hearing presentations or speeches and people
- 4:36do a lot of um-ing and uh-ing, that is something that annoys us
- 4:39because we have an expectation that they're very well prepared and they
- 4:42know what they're going to say.
- 4:43So things that signal they don't disturb us.
- 4:46Matt Abrahams: I think you're exactly right.
- 4:48I'd like to turn our attention now to your second book, which is all about accents.
- 4:53You write that we all have accents.
- 4:56Why do we so easily notice accents in others but not ourselves?
- 5:00Valerie Fridland: I think the greatest myth that we operate under every
- 5:03day is that we don't have an accent.
- 5:06You know, we don't notice our accents because everybody around
- 5:10us generally talks like we do.
- 5:12So if you are moving to a new place, that's really when you're first realizing,
- 5:17oh my gosh, I'm the one that sounds funny.
- 5:19Because when you are the one that is the dominant speaker in an
- 5:23area, most people are sounding like you, so you don't hear it.
- 5:27You're used to it.
- 5:28Particularly when we're children, we grow up in an area, we kind of
- 5:31adjust or normalize to whatever we hear most often around us.
- 5:35Which can also be, not just the accents that's sort of prevalent in your area,
- 5:39but say you're born to a non-native speaker and you grew up as a native
- 5:43speaker in the US for example, you won't hear your parents' accents because
- 5:48you have normalized them as children.
- 5:50So we don't hear the accents around us because we're so familiar with them.
- 5:54We also are very heightened to notice difference.
- 5:57So when people come into our communities and they're not dressing like we are,
- 6:01they're not looking like we are, and really strongly not sounding like we
- 6:05are, we notice that and that's where the sort of the salience of accent comes in.
- 6:11Matt Abrahams: I do wanna talk about culture because accents
- 6:13and cultures go together.
- 6:15When communicating across cultures we often focus on learning the right
- 6:19vocabulary, the grammar, but you highlight the rhythm and intonation, like English
- 6:25as a stress timed language versus Spanish or Mandarin being a syllable
- 6:30timed, and I'd like for you to explain those, are huge hurdles for people.
- 6:34How do these, what are called prosodic differences, affect how well speakers are
- 6:40understood and evaluated by somebody in the native language they're now speaking?
- 6:46Valerie Fridland: Absolutely.
- 6:47When we're learning a language, we work a lot on sounds, but we really tend to
- 6:52ignore some really important areas that make a big impact on how comprehensible
- 6:59you are and how intelligible you are as a speaker, which is an area that linguists
- 7:02called prosodic features or prosody.
- 7:05And those include things like word stress and sentence stress.
- 7:09So what's highlighted by a speaker in a language.
- 7:12Tone, which can be like with Mandarin, tone on a single word can actually
- 7:17change the meaning of that word, something English doesn't have, which
- 7:20is obviously something really hard for English speakers when they're learning
- 7:23Mandarin, or intonation patterns, which as an English speaker, I often
- 7:28go down in my tone at the end of a sentence to signal I'm done talking.
- 7:33Conversely, when I have a question, I often ask that question with a
- 7:37rising intonation because that's signaling that I'm asking a question.
- 7:41So that's a sentence level pattern.
- 7:44So those are different types of prosodic features, and they're very difficult
- 7:50to learn when you come in from a language with one system prosodically
- 7:54and you're learning a language with a different system prosodically.
- 7:57So for example, as I mentioned a minute ago, an English speaker
- 8:01trying to learn a tonal language.
- 8:03Our intonation patterns where we go up at the end or down at the
- 8:06end, make it really hard when we're trying to get tones on a word.
- 8:10The opposite is when we have different sort of structures to our language
- 8:15inherently, and that's where we get to the stress versus syllable timing,
- 8:19where our fundamental way that we stress syllables in our language
- 8:24is different than another one.
- 8:25So let's break that down.
- 8:27Stress timing is a language like English, Russian, Arabic, German, and this is
- 8:33where particular words or syllables that you're speaking get more stress than
- 8:39others, depending on what the speaker wants to highlight in that language.
- 8:43So certain syllables are louder and longer, and then the other syllables in
- 8:47between actually get smushed together they had to be said more rapidly to
- 8:52fit into a sort of certain timing unit between those stress syllables.
- 8:57So in that language you have a rhythm that's sort of like dum dum dum.
- 9:02So you have the short syllables that are really jam packed and that's why
- 9:06you get things like vowel reduction.
- 9:08So when I say the instead of the in English or a instead of a, it's because
- 9:13I'm actually having to squish them between stress syllables interval.
- 9:17In a syllable timed language, which is something like Spanish or Chinese or
- 9:23French or Portuguese, every syllable has equal stress, so it's more like, bum
- 9:28bum, bum, bum bum, bum bum of a rhythm.
- 9:32Now this seems very complex and how would I ever figure out how to switch over?
- 9:37Well that's exactly the problem.
- 9:38We don't get practice in that.
- 9:39And this completely impacts how well you're understood.
- 9:43It may not seem like that big a deal 'cause it just is rhythmic, but it's
- 9:46a huge deal because think of a word as someone who might have a syllable
- 9:49time language, like it'd elephant.
- 9:52If you didn't know we were talking about giant things with big ears and
- 9:56trunks, you might have no idea what I said because it's elephant for a
- 10:00native English speaker, because I'm stressing that first syllable and
- 10:03then jamming the others really quick.
- 10:05But if I have a syllable time language, I'm going to stress each
- 10:08syllable equally and I'll have no a vowel because that's only happens
- 10:12when I remove stress from a syllable.
- 10:14So what happens, you can actually get words that are completely unintelligible
- 10:17because you're saying the stress wrong because you used a syllable time
- 10:21pattern on a stress time language.
- 10:23So these are things that are really rarely discussed in language classes.
- 10:27There are often problems that people encounter and they don't know why
- 10:30they're having problems being understood.
- 10:32And in fact, research suggests that non-native stress patterns like
- 10:36this can infect intelligibility as much as not being able to
- 10:39pronounce the sounds correctly.
- 10:41Now there's no easy magic fix, but the solution is really practice.
- 10:45And a lot of that is generally shadowing native speakers.
- 10:48It doesn't have to be interactive, but you could even record a TV show
- 10:52and repeat exactly in the intonation pattern of that television show, and
- 10:56eventually you'll start getting that rhythm down so there's no easy solution.
- 11:01Matt Abrahams: So what I'm hearing you say, which is super important, for
- 11:03people who are trying to learn a second language, yes, vocabulary and grammar
- 11:07are important, but what's as important and perhaps even more in some cases for
- 11:11intelligibility, it is understanding the rhythm, the stress patterns.
- 11:16And as with everything communication related, it's one thing to
- 11:19understand it intellectually.
- 11:20It's another thing to do it, and that's really a way to help yourself.
- 11:24I appreciate you identifying that.
- 11:26I wanna switch the sides of the equation.
- 11:28We often think of the burden of successful communication as being
- 11:32on the speaker, the non-native speaker producing the information.
- 11:36What role does the listener play in this communicative dynamic?
- 11:40And how can we train our ears and minds to be better able to adapt to
- 11:45understanding unfamiliar accents?
- 11:47Valerie Fridland: We often really put a lot of the burden on a non-native speaker.
- 11:52Anytime we're having a conversation, we have this expectation that
- 11:55the speaker, it's their job to make it intelligible to us.
- 11:58It's their job to make their speech understood.
- 12:02There are so many different problems with that equation, but
- 12:05let's unpack it a little bit in terms of why that's not the case.
- 12:09First of all, communication's a partnership.
- 12:11Just like a marriage, you can't have a marriage when one side is doing all the
- 12:15work and you can't have a conversation where one side's doing all the work.
- 12:18If you've ever had a conversation where it's only one sided, it's not a good
- 12:22conversation and you probably aren't gonna keep talking to that person.
- 12:25So if we wanna make communication successful, we have to go into it
- 12:29with this understanding that it's not just their job as a speaker,
- 12:33it's my job as a listener to make this productive and successful.
- 12:37There are a couple things at play.
- 12:39One is as a listener, I don't realize sometimes that they're
- 12:43not just speaking with an accent, I'm hearing with an accent.
- 12:47And we really put this belief system around accent on speakers alone, but we
- 12:53don't listen without a bias that is shaped by our own language and accent experience.
- 13:00And this affects us in a number of ways.
- 13:02One thing is it makes it harder to understand what sounds they might be
- 13:05saying because we have an expectation about what they're supposed to sound like,
- 13:09and maybe they're not sounding that way.
- 13:11But two, we also have a role the brain plays in making people
- 13:16better or worse understood.
- 13:18So simply by being accustomed to hearing a certain kind of speech
- 13:22and having expectations going into a conversation about what
- 13:26we think someone will sound like.
- 13:28So say they look like they'll speak with an American accent.
- 13:31But then it turns out they start speaking with a French accent, that actually
- 13:35causes cognitive disruption for us.
- 13:37And I don't mean that in a negative way.
- 13:39I simply mean there's an effect on the brain of this additional processing
- 13:44burden that hearing something unexpected or unfamiliar places on us.
- 13:49So there's a bunch of different aspects in terms of why we're hearing with an accent.
- 13:54You know, I think the long story short of that is to recognize
- 13:58that part of the reason we're not understanding has nothing to do with
- 14:02them and everything to do with us.
- 14:04And there's often a power dynamic that puts whoever is dominant in
- 14:08that sort of social or institutional setting in a position where they
- 14:12feel that it's the other person's job to make sure that they're coming
- 14:16across clearly and intelligibly, but that's an impossible task when you
- 14:21are not willing to meet them halfway.
- 14:23So as listeners and speakers, we need to both accept our roles and our jobs and
- 14:29our faults in speaking and listening to contribute to getting to a place where
- 14:34we can better understand each other.
- 14:36One simple option for that as a listener is if we know to expect
- 14:42something unexpected that knowledge alone decreases the processing burden.
- 14:46So simply being more open in our expectations actually mitigates
- 14:50this effect on our brain.
- 14:52But also the more accents we hear around us, the diversity in our institutions,
- 14:57diversity in our friend group, the less unfamiliar accent sound to us, the
- 15:03better jobs our brains do more generally.
- 15:05So those are easy things to do.
- 15:07Be more friends with more people, be more open in your expectations.
- 15:11So I think there's really a two-sided view we can take on communication, and that's,
- 15:16it's a partnership, not a one-sided event.
- 15:19Matt Abrahams: Amen.
- 15:20Communication takes two, right?
- 15:22And we often focus on the producing of the information, but the receiving
- 15:25of it is critically important.
- 15:27The idea about processing fluency and cognitive load are really important,
- 15:32and it's not just with accents.
- 15:34It's when you're talking about technical content, you're doing the same thing.
- 15:37You're increasing cognitive load and processing.
- 15:39So some of the same advice holds true.
- 15:42If you're a listener, have an open mind.
- 15:44I like this idea of exposing yourself to diverse accents and ideas, that helps
- 15:48reduce the processing fluency and burden.
- 15:51I've often thought about speaking accents.
- 15:53I've never thought about listening accents, and that's a really
- 15:56insightful way of thinking about this.
- 15:59Valerie, I knew this was gonna be fantastic.
- 16:01You know that when we end, I always ask three questions.
- 16:05One I make up just for you, and two, have been consistent across all the episodes.
- 16:09Are you up for answering these questions?
- 16:10Valerie Fridland: Let do it.
- 16:11I love it.
- 16:11Yes.
- 16:12Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 16:13If you could give just one bit of advice to somebody who's speaking
- 16:16the language that's not their own and has an accent, what would that be?
- 16:20Valerie Fridland: The biggest advice I can tell you is that not
- 16:23to put so much pressure on yourself to sound like a native speaker.
- 16:27We have this weird ideal of what it means to learn another language, what it means
- 16:32to be fluent in that language, what it means to be successful in that language,
- 16:37and it's an unrealistic goal and it causes all sorts of problems for native
- 16:42speakers and non-native speakers alike.
- 16:44As I'm entering this new journey of a language, what my goal
- 16:48should be is being successful at having communicative partnerships.
- 16:53That's really what we wanna do.
- 16:55It shouldn't be, I wanna sound like I don't have an accent.
- 16:59What we need to do is embrace accents because they're beautiful and they tell
- 17:02us our history, and they also tell us where we come from in our identities, and
- 17:06we should never wanna get rid of that.
- 17:08Instead, focus on what helps me be more easily understood and more
- 17:13confident as a speaker because that is what will make you successful.
- 17:18You can communicate very well with an accent.
- 17:20We just need to start believing that more as a speaker with a non-native variety.
- 17:25Matt Abrahams: So it's really about mindset.
- 17:27It's realize that you can be a very effective communicator even
- 17:30though you're speaking a language that's not your own and you might
- 17:32have an accent for those listening.
- 17:34The goal is not to sound like a native speaker.
- 17:36The goal is to be successful in the communication and
- 17:39that focus shift can help.
- 17:41The advice I always give people is when you introduce yourself,
- 17:44don't start with your name.
- 17:46As you alluded to, we're very good at digesting accents, but when something
- 17:51important is said right at the beginning our brain is still adjusting to,
- 17:54oh, that's how that person sounds.
- 17:56So I often encourage people who have accents to start by saying something
- 18:00else first before their name.
- 18:01Maybe I'm really excited to be here, or I'm somebody who's very
- 18:04passionate about this, and then say your name so that people have started
- 18:08to adjust and adapt to your accent.
- 18:10So hopefully those two bits of advice can help people.
- 18:14Question number two, who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 18:18Valerie Fridland: I would say that one person I really admire as a communicator
- 18:21in the same sort of space as me, the science communication, is Adam Grant.
- 18:26He does a remarkable job of communicating really technical research-based
- 18:32information in a way that's both relevant and very accessible to
- 18:37everyday speakers, and so I enjoy that.
- 18:40Matt Abrahams: Question number three, what are the first three ingredients that go
- 18:44into a successful communication recipe?
- 18:47Valerie Fridland: I don't think it's gonna surprise you that I start with
- 18:49listening because we talked so much about that, and I think we often just worry
- 18:53when we go into a conversation about speaking, what we really should worry
- 18:56about is listening, for so many reasons.
- 18:59One is, that makes us better as a communicator, right?
- 19:02Because we're genuinely paying attention.
- 19:05It helps shape how we respond and a lot of times when we spend too much time
- 19:09worrying, and I think non-native speakers sometimes do this, about what we're
- 19:12going to say, we actually miss really important nuanced points where we can make
- 19:17connections because of what they said.
- 19:20The other is self-awareness, and this is different than
- 19:23worrying about how I'm sounding.
- 19:25This is about understanding that my own background brings me to every
- 19:29conversation with preconceived notions of how things should go
- 19:32and what people should sound like.
- 19:34And as we talked about, this influences the way that we process things.
- 19:38So just being aware of that really can reshape our interactions with people.
- 19:43And then the third is smile.
- 19:45Be friendly, be open.
- 19:47I think sometimes we're so set on presenting ourselves a certain
- 19:51way or being a certain way in a context, professionally particularly,
- 19:56where we forget that just being friendly and kind and open can
- 20:00actually open a lot of doors for us.
- 20:02It can be the best nurturing sort of piece of the puzzle for a good
- 20:08conversation, is when someone feels like you really wanna genuinely have a
- 20:11good conversation with them, that you're happy to be there talking with them.
- 20:15I think that makes them more interested in conversing with you as well.
- 20:19Matt Abrahams: That last part is so important.
- 20:20It's really about connection and regardless of if you have
- 20:23an accent or not, you connect.
- 20:25I like your point on listening as well.
- 20:27Thank you for connecting with us and for sharing your insights on the value
- 20:32and importance of accents and really reflecting on ways that if we have an
- 20:35accent that we can address it, as well as those of us who are communicating
- 20:39with people who have accents.
- 20:41As always, Valerie, I learned so much from you.
- 20:43I appreciate your energy, your insights, and your time today.
- 20:46Thank you.
- 20:47Valerie Fridland: Always a good conversation with you, Matt.
- 20:49Thanks.
- 20:51Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 20:53Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 20:55To learn more from Valerie, please listen to episode 91.
- 20:58This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abraham.
- 21:03Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 21:05With special thanks to the Podium Podcast Company.
- 21:08Please be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 21:11Find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 21:14Also, follow us on LinkedIn, TikTok, and Instagram, and check out fastersmarter.io
- 21:20for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.
- 21:24Please consider joining our Think Fast Talk Smart Learning Community
- 21:27at fastersmarter.io/learning.
- 21:29You'll find video lessons, learning quests, discussion boards, my AI
- 21:33coach, and book club opportunities.
- 21:36Again, that's fastersmarter.io/learning to become part of our Think Fast
- 21:41Talk Smart Learning Community.