Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / How to Use Experts Effectively in Mediation with Robert S. Mann and John D. Hanover
Transcript
- 0:02My name is Jeff Kravitz. I am the co -chair of
- 0:06the ADR section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:11And today we're going to be talking about using
- 0:13experts at mediation with two folks who know
- 0:17it well. First is John Hanover. He's a mediator
- 0:20and an arbitrator with ADR Services, Inc. He
- 0:24brings over 37 years of experience in construction
- 0:27litigation and dispute resolution. John is known
- 0:31for his pragmatic solutions -oriented approach,
- 0:34and he has represented clients in complex construction
- 0:38disputes across trials, arbitrations, and mediation,
- 0:42and previously held leadership roles at a major
- 0:44law firm as general counsel for an international
- 0:47engineering project management and construction
- 0:51services firm. He's going to be joined by Bob
- 0:54Mann, my former colleague. He too is a mediator
- 0:58and arbitrator. with ADR, and he's known as one
- 1:02of California's top dispute resolution professionals
- 1:04with deep expertise in real estate, business,
- 1:08and construction matters. He is a former trial
- 1:11lawyer with over 70 verdicts, an extensive project
- 1:15management experience, bringing a unique blend
- 1:18of technical knowledge and practical insight
- 1:21to even the most complex and contentious disputes.
- 1:25So gentlemen, I've been looking forward to this.
- 1:28Let's roll. You've got the floor. Okay. Thank
- 1:31you, Jeff. It's so good to see you. Welcome everybody
- 1:34to our webinar on how to use experts effectively
- 1:37in mediation. Thanks to all of you for joining
- 1:40us today, even though we can't see you. This
- 1:43webinar came about because a lawyer in a case
- 1:46about a month ago called me a couple of days
- 1:48before the mediation and he said, do you think
- 1:50I should bring my expert to the mediation? And
- 1:53I thought to myself, I don't think this person
- 1:57has much of a plan or much of a goal. I thought
- 2:01about it. I wrote an article about that whole
- 2:04concept for the Daily Journal. The Beverly Hills
- 2:07Bar Association saw it, called me and said, would
- 2:10I do a webinar? I said, absolutely. Here we are.
- 2:14Our presentation today is in the context of a
- 2:18construction dispute because so many of those
- 2:21disputes are expert -driven. And as my colleague
- 2:25John Hanover will explain, our focus today is
- 2:28on using the experts effectively. And we're trying
- 2:31to frame this discussion in two ways. The first
- 2:34is as goal driven, as John will explain. It's
- 2:38goal driven. Set a goal and work that goal. And
- 2:41the second is, in addition to that goal, we're
- 2:45trying to give you practical information that
- 2:48you can use in a practical way to do better at
- 2:50your next mediation. So let's start with our
- 2:53four -step plan. So John, let's talk about our
- 2:57four -step plan. We'll do Bob. So thank you and
- 3:00good afternoon to everybody. I'm John and it's
- 3:03my pleasure to be here with my friend and my
- 3:05colleague Bob Mann to talk about the use of experts
- 3:08in mediation. And Bob's right, when Bob got that
- 3:12question and he invited me to join him in this
- 3:14mediation, we started thinking about how best
- 3:17to use experts in mediation. And we didn't really
- 3:21want to talk about it in the sense of nuts and
- 3:24bolts or a mechanical system necessarily. for
- 3:28using experts. We really wanted to think about
- 3:30it strategically, and that took us ultimately
- 3:34to the four -step plan that's on your screen
- 3:36now that Bob and I devised. And it all starts
- 3:41with, number one, setting the right goal. And
- 3:44that is the strategic element of putting together
- 3:49something that's going to get you to step four,
- 3:53achieving the right result, as long as you retain
- 3:56the right expert and you prepare the right way.
- 4:00So following these concrete steps, we thought
- 4:03That really is the ultimate success roadmap for
- 4:09getting to a result that you have planned for
- 4:14and hope to execute at the mediation. With that
- 4:19four -step plan, Bob, the first is obviously
- 4:22setting the right goal. Next slide, please. Let's
- 4:30think about what typical goals are in mediation.
- 4:33We can start with maybe the easiest, unproductive
- 4:36goals. What are unproductive goals? Going through
- 4:41the motions, checking off a box, some court -ordered
- 4:44mediation where you've got to report back to
- 4:45the judge, okay, we had a mediation. If that's
- 4:49your goal, then you can probably skip the rest
- 4:52of the webinar because it's not really going
- 4:54to be expert -driven. What we want to talk about
- 4:57are more productive goals. such as, what do we
- 5:01really want to accomplish? What's the goal? Is
- 5:04it to develop information? Is it to exchange
- 5:07information? Is it to confirm information? Is
- 5:10it to narrow the issues? The next one, very,
- 5:13very important, is it to influence a future conversation
- 5:17that will lead to a resolution? Or is the goal
- 5:20to achieve a resolution? That's kind of the end
- 5:22game goal of all of these things. So let's think
- 5:25about how we use the experts effectively to accomplish
- 5:31these goals. So let's say your first goal in
- 5:35a mediation process is we want to develop information.
- 5:40So how do we use that expert effectively to do
- 5:42that? I think that the first step for you as
- 5:45the lawyer is to meet with the expert, sit down,
- 5:49explain, that's my goal. We need to develop information
- 5:54in this case. We're lacking information and then
- 5:57map out a strategy to achieve it. For example,
- 6:03if that's your strategy, you don't want to simply
- 6:06say to yourself, well, I need a construction
- 6:09expert or a delay expert or a damages expert
- 6:13or professional care standards expert. This is
- 6:19very, very specific. How does that expert effectively
- 6:24develop information? The answer is by asking
- 6:28questions. Which subcontractor did this work?
- 6:32Are there plans? Are there permits? Are there
- 6:35subcontracts or just purchase orders? Is there
- 6:37insurance? What is the big picture of this project?
- 6:41Did the owner run out of money? Is this a project
- 6:44that failed because the plans were no good? Were
- 6:47there unforeseen site conditions? The task of
- 6:51obtaining and developing information has to be
- 6:53both big picture and granular at the same time.
- 6:57What if you want to exchange information as a
- 7:00part of educating the parties about the case?
- 7:04There's two concerns about effectively exchanging
- 7:08information. The first is timing. The second
- 7:11is transparency. There's no secrets in these
- 7:15cases. The sooner you publish information, the
- 7:18better. This is a recurring theme that we're
- 7:21going to be talking about today. Transparency
- 7:24means publishing the essential documents in these
- 7:29cases, defect lists, cost of repair estimates,
- 7:32testing reports, reports of consultants. How
- 7:35do you confirm information? If everybody is trying
- 7:42to get on the same page about the basic facts,
- 7:46an effective expert goes about that by confirming
- 7:50information. Here's an example. Perhaps there
- 7:54is some lack of clarity about the scope of work.
- 7:59Maybe there's a stucco problem in the case, and
- 8:02the expert needs to confirm. What's being recommended
- 8:05here? You want to take all the stucco off this
- 8:07building, a portion of the stucco off this building.
- 8:10Do you want to, for example, remove all the windows
- 8:13that were tested or every single window in the
- 8:16building? So this is confirming information.
- 8:21So your experts got to be focused on that. The
- 8:25last thing, almost the last thing in this line,
- 8:28narrowing the issues. After you develop the facts,
- 8:33an effective expert narrows the issue. Construction
- 8:37cases and a lot of other cases sometimes start
- 8:40like this, then they get really big, and at the
- 8:43end, you have to bring them back to this. You
- 8:45have to make them smaller again. We think that
- 8:48the most effective way to narrow issues is expert
- 8:51to expert meetings, preferably without the lawyers.
- 8:58Those meetings you might think about as a sort
- 9:01of a friendly deposition. What if you want to
- 9:06influence a future conversation, which is a very
- 9:09important goal in this process? If that's your
- 9:12goal, the effective expert focuses on two things.
- 9:18If you represent the plaintiff, that expert has
- 9:22to focus on raising expectations on the defense
- 9:26side. If that person is representing the defense
- 9:29side, that focus has to be on lowering expectations
- 9:34on the plaintiff side. Here's the most important
- 9:37point about that. An effective expert raises
- 9:41or lowers expectations by saying things like,
- 9:44This is why that can't be done, or this is why
- 9:50we have to do this in this certain way, as opposed
- 9:53to saying things like, we're just not going to
- 9:56do it that way, because that's not helpful. This
- 9:59is why we're going to do it this way. The last
- 10:03issue, reaching a resolution. This is all homework.
- 10:08And then at the end, this gets you to reaching
- 10:11a resolution. So let's look at our next slide.
- 10:23So this is about how to choose the right expert.
- 10:28So how do you choose the right expert? Well,
- 10:31these are the qualities, but remember, all of
- 10:34these qualities relate to your goal. So let's
- 10:37look at these in order. A good expert is articulate
- 10:40because To be effective, an expert has to tell
- 10:45a story. They have to be able to communicate
- 10:48complex ideas in an understandable fashion. Experts
- 10:52who wander through presentations and digress,
- 10:56maybe tell war stories, are typically not effective.
- 11:00An effective expert is a consensus builder. This
- 11:05is a key aspect to this in my view of the world.
- 11:09I usually use a firefighter metaphor. An effective
- 11:14expert brings a fire extinguisher to a mediation.
- 11:19An ineffective expert brings a gallon of gasoline
- 11:22to pour on the fire and just makes the fire bigger.
- 11:26Experts have to be flexible. Oftentimes opinions
- 11:30and focus has to change over time as the facts
- 11:33change. Economic realities can change opinions
- 11:37and focus. For example, a lack of insurance from
- 11:40a key party requires you to shift your focus
- 11:43to other parties. An effective expert is nimble
- 11:47and flexible. Let's think about persuasiveness
- 11:52for a minute. There's a big difference between
- 11:55knowing something and persuading someone else
- 11:59to see it the same way that you see it. Really,
- 12:03it's a combination of art and science. It's a
- 12:08merger of technical mastery with storytelling.
- 12:12But persuasiveness is very, very important. Sometimes
- 12:17the most effective thing an expert can do is
- 12:19simply say nothing. Sometimes silence is the
- 12:23best thing in a mediation. While people are saying
- 12:25things, it's better to just be quiet and listen.
- 12:30This can be very, very persuasive in a kind of
- 12:33an ironically silent way. and it's part of being
- 12:37effective. Here's the last thing to say about
- 12:40this particular part of the slide. You might
- 12:43ask yourself, well, okay, I need somebody who's
- 12:46articulate and persuasive and builds consensus
- 12:49and is flexible, but what if I haven't used this
- 12:52person before? How do I find out if they have
- 12:54these qualities? I recommend you sit down with
- 12:58the expert that you're thinking of hiring and
- 13:00you say to him, this is what this case is about.
- 13:04This is my goal. I want to persuade somebody
- 13:07about this. How would you do it? Tell me how
- 13:11you would approach it and listen to what that
- 13:14expert says. Are they articulate? Are they persuasive?
- 13:17Do they have a mastery of the technical aspects
- 13:19of the case? Can they tell a good story? I think
- 13:22that will help you. Let's have our next slide.
- 13:27Do you want to comment? No, no, let's go to the
- 13:30next slide and I'm going to comment on what the
- 13:33bad expert looks like because the good expert
- 13:36that you've described is one who understands
- 13:39the goal after you've set the goal and you've
- 13:42strategically planned how you're going to conduct
- 13:44the mediation. And if you find an expert who
- 13:48you qualify as a good expert, you're in great
- 13:51shape. But if you go to mediation and you happen
- 13:55to have a bad expert, which I've seen many times,
- 13:59you're going to end up with someone who can't
- 14:01do what you need to do to advance those strategic
- 14:03goals. And the first point that you made, Bob,
- 14:07was you really need somebody who can crystallize
- 14:10that knowledge. But I've seen experts who are
- 14:13so deep in the are so interested in their own
- 14:18kind of curiosity about details of the case that
- 14:22they're unable to crystallize that knowledge
- 14:24and communicate what should be a concept that's
- 14:28very persuasive. I kind of think about it as
- 14:33a jigsaw puzzle. Oftentimes I'll see experts
- 14:35who are very good at identifying the edges of
- 14:39the piece and can describe the piece very well
- 14:43but cannot take that piece and put it into the
- 14:46overall puzzle so that you end up with a picture.
- 14:49The bad expert just isn't capable of doing that.
- 14:52The second trait I've seen as a bad expert is
- 14:56someone who's not authentic, who doesn't come
- 14:59across as authentic. And that's part of the conversation
- 15:02you just described, Bob. At the same time, you're
- 15:05listening to how that person would tell the story,
- 15:08you're judging, you're identifying the characteristics
- 15:11that are going to make that expert either effective
- 15:15or ineffective in mediation. And if the expert
- 15:19really doesn't have the subject matter expertise,
- 15:22hasn't done the homework, feels uncomfortable
- 15:26in that setting, isn't in sync with counsel,
- 15:29they're going to come across as inauthentic and
- 15:32that's not going to be helpful in the mediation.
- 15:36In terms of the flexibility and being able to
- 15:39really change course or to monitor the proceedings
- 15:45and then use the best techniques and the best
- 15:49information they have, I think about that. I
- 15:52guess I have a lot of analogies, but I think
- 15:54about that in terms of golf, not that I'm a great
- 15:58golfer or even would ascribe to a golf method.
- 16:06That right, but even with that frustration I'll
- 16:10use the analogy of a bag of golf clubs because
- 16:12there are 14 clubs Ranging from a putter to a
- 16:17driver one to hit the ball a very short distance
- 16:19the other obviously they hit the ball a very
- 16:21long distance and everything in between and if
- 16:24a bad expert only has one club in my mind, a
- 16:29bad expert only has one speed, only has one tone,
- 16:35one level of aggression, one focus, cannot pivot
- 16:40when necessary during the mediation, and comes
- 16:43frankly in a confrontational way looking for
- 16:46a fight, which at the mediation, that's really
- 16:49not the, shouldn't be the goal of anyone who's
- 16:53coming there to achieve one of the results. that
- 16:57Bob identified and we've talked about in terms
- 16:59of setting the goal. So most appropriate, I think,
- 17:03is the expert who can read the room. And if you
- 17:06have someone who can't and makes inappropriate
- 17:09remarks at the wrong time or uses analogies or
- 17:13facts that really don't support the goal that
- 17:16you've identified, you're going to end up with
- 17:19a very ineffective and unproductive expert. Now,
- 17:22it could be worse. You can end up with the ugly
- 17:26expert. Bob's going to describe that. We're going
- 17:29to talk about a few situations that really derail
- 17:32a mediation as opposed to just aren't supportive
- 17:35of the goals that you've identified. Next slide,
- 17:38please. Thank you, John. Well, you got to love
- 17:43this slide. Before we say anything about it.
- 17:49I just love this line. But the great part is
- 17:52somebody loves this animal, which is even better.
- 17:56So let's think about this for a second. Bad reputation.
- 18:01There are experts out there who have bad reputations.
- 18:04How do you find out? Ask around. Ask other lawyers.
- 18:07Ask other experts. What do you think about this
- 18:09person? Do they have a good reputation? Have
- 18:11you dealt with this person? You can find out
- 18:14a lot of stuff. Has this expert ever gone on
- 18:17the record with contrary positions? I'll tell
- 18:21you a very, very short, very short war story,
- 18:24if you will. Many years ago, my former partner
- 18:27and I tried a big case against a stock brokerage
- 18:29company who looted an account. In the middle
- 18:33of preparing for the trial, I found an appellate
- 18:36case where they had referenced the expert. Except
- 18:39in that case, he had testified, he was the defense
- 18:41expert in our case, but he testified for the
- 18:44plaintiff in that case. I called the lawyer.
- 18:47He had the trial transcripts and he sent me a
- 18:49copy of them and I read the transcripts and lo
- 18:52and behold, the 20 things that he said in our
- 18:55case, he said this and the other case, he said
- 18:58that at the trial. I read the transcript for
- 19:03two hours. That's all I did. I never asked him
- 19:05a single question. I read the transcript for
- 19:07two hours. It destroyed him. It was my finest
- 19:13moment in 48 years as a lawyer. Very shortly
- 19:17thereafter, they settled the case for $11 million.
- 19:20So it's a good idea. Have you ever testified
- 19:22in a deposition or in trial before? Ugly experts
- 19:28transformed themselves from experts to advocate.
- 19:32I think effective experts need to stay in their
- 19:35expert lane. There are honestly few things more
- 19:39disruptive than an expert who takes on the mantle
- 19:43of lawyer, judge, jury, expert, all these things.
- 19:46An expert is there to offer expertise. They can
- 19:50advocate for that position within their expertise,
- 19:53but it's not a good idea to have them start looking
- 19:57and acting like lawyers. Experts who inflame
- 20:01clients. Last week I was in a mediation and the
- 20:09expert had a lot of really, really, really bad
- 20:12photographs, meaning alarming photographs. Every
- 20:16time I went into the plaintiff room, in that
- 20:19case, during a full day mediation, the expert
- 20:22had the photographs on the screen. I thought
- 20:25to myself, I can almost see the client's blood
- 20:29pressure going up, looking at these photographs.
- 20:33It was very, very counterproductive. You have
- 20:37got to be very, very careful. You can advocate
- 20:39and talk about things, but it's a bad idea to
- 20:42inflame the clients. Similarly, experts who create
- 20:47unrealistic expectations impede resolution. I've
- 20:51heard experts say things like, well, they're
- 20:54never going to talk their way out of this one,
- 20:57or there's absolutely no excuse for this defect,
- 21:00or they say to a client, don't worry, you're
- 21:03going to get everything you are asking for. Well,
- 21:07not only is it inappropriate, it's counterproductive
- 21:10to a resolution. Lastly, alienating others. Remember,
- 21:18consensus building is really, really important.
- 21:22Somebody who alienates other people and aggravates
- 21:24them, sometimes even the mediator, it's destructive.
- 21:28I've had experts call names. He's an idiot. I've
- 21:34had them in meetings. Let me tell you something.
- 21:36I'm right, you're wrong. That is not helpful.
- 21:40That is not helpful. It's not effective, and
- 21:42it's counterproductive. Last thing is a quick
- 21:47note on using repair contractors as experts.
- 21:52And I'm going to put this under the heading of
- 21:54the ugly. I don't think it's effective. Here's
- 21:58why. A repair contractor has a built -in conflict
- 22:01because the more repair work that person does,
- 22:04the more money he makes. So he has to justify
- 22:08every dollar of repairs. I think that using a
- 22:11repair contractor as a percipient witness to
- 22:14talk about what he or she encountered is fine,
- 22:17but you're probably better served by retaining
- 22:19another expert to talk about the why, the what,
- 22:23and the how much. Here's the very, very last
- 22:27thing on this, really ugly. A long time ago,
- 22:31I represented the developer of the Shutters Hotel
- 22:34in Santa Monica in a very long arbitration. After
- 22:38many years of fighting around, we finally got
- 22:41the contractor to produce what we knew was an
- 22:44agreement between the contractor and the lead
- 22:47expert, who was the project manager on the project.
- 22:51Well, guess what? Lo and behold, the agreement
- 22:55said that this witness, who was their lead witness
- 22:58in the arbitration, had a contingent interest
- 23:01in the outcome of the arbitration. I can tell
- 23:05you the arbitrators never believed another word
- 23:09that guy said. That was the end. So you want
- 23:13to be careful. It seems very obvious that was
- 23:16a multimillion dollar case. Everybody was astounded.
- 23:23So these things happen. Let's look at our next
- 23:26slide. Thanks, Bob. So, yes, those are great
- 23:33examples of the ugly. Even the trial examples,
- 23:38I think, are appropriate examples for the mediation
- 23:41because the same thing happens. You can have
- 23:44the same expert who's going to lose all credibility
- 23:47in a mediation and suddenly become very ineffective
- 23:50or a bad expert in terms of trying to move the
- 23:54case towards one of those goals, whether it's
- 23:56information exchange or influencing the other
- 23:58party or achieving a resolution. So what does
- 24:02a good expert do? You know, what is, how are
- 24:05you going to be, how the party's going to be
- 24:08best served by a good expert who is there to
- 24:11build consensus, who is collaborative, who isn't
- 24:15trying to inflame his client, et cetera, her
- 24:17client. What the good expert is going to do is
- 24:20to weave a story based on the potential liability
- 24:24of the parties and whether plaintiff or defense,
- 24:28typically at least in a construction case, that
- 24:30extra is going to be dealing with the liability
- 24:34questions here on a breach of contract or strict
- 24:37liability negligence, etc. So if you're starting
- 24:42from the idea of asking the expert to assist
- 24:47you in the mediation by achieving one of your
- 24:50goals, you have to tie that goal to these theories
- 24:53of liability as well. So if it's a breach of
- 24:56contract case and you want to have the expert
- 25:00talk about the scope of the work, for instance,
- 25:03in the contract and how that scope might have
- 25:06been breached, you need to do it in the way that's
- 25:09going to elicit or further the goal that you
- 25:12have. If it's the goal of exchanging information,
- 25:16then And again, you're going to identify what
- 25:19the contractual requirements are, but then have
- 25:21the expert ask questions and ask questions about
- 25:25what that scope was, how it may have been changed
- 25:28by the architect, what the discussions were on
- 25:31change order requests, et cetera. Same thing
- 25:34for strict liability. If you've got a strict
- 25:37liability case, and for instance, you're dealing
- 25:39with SB 800 and a right to repair, You're going
- 25:44to weave that into one of your other goals so
- 25:47that the expert can tell that story effectively.
- 25:51And an expert who can do that is going to be
- 25:53worth his or her weight in gold and mediation,
- 25:56because that's ultimately what is going to be
- 25:59persuasive. Same thing for negligence and standard
- 26:02of care, which I kind of equate the same. Tying
- 26:06that to one of the goals will lead the expert
- 26:09to talking about what a person in the locale
- 26:16who has that experience would have done in either
- 26:20executing the work or repairing the work if that's
- 26:23going to be the key issue. But you're going to
- 26:26need that expert to be able to describe exactly
- 26:30what should have been done and how it was not
- 26:34done in that particular case. That may relate
- 26:37to a code violation. There's an example Bob and
- 26:40I talked about where You know, there's a particular
- 26:46element, a weep screed perhaps that needs to
- 26:48be installed on a particular building. There's
- 26:51a code that specifically, a building code that
- 26:54specifically addresses how that's going to be
- 26:58installed. And if that isn't done correctly than
- 27:01that, that tells you what story the expert needs
- 27:04to tell. And so being able to put those together,
- 27:08being able to identify with the theory of liability,
- 27:12what that story is going. to be is going to be
- 27:15the most effective. Next slide, please. This
- 27:22is a continuation of this concept of the expert
- 27:25telling a story. The umbrella over these more
- 27:32or less granular things, the umbrella is to correlate
- 27:37the story with the expert's preparation. In other
- 27:41words, it's back to our central theme. What's
- 27:45the goal? The goal dictates the expert's focus
- 27:48and preparation. So for example, let's say, and
- 27:54these are, we're going to spend some time on
- 27:56this slide because these are very common tropes
- 27:59in construction disputes. So let's say, look
- 28:02at the second one, betterments and improvements.
- 28:05I'll give you a great example of this. Last week,
- 28:08in the same case where the plaintiff's expert
- 28:10was showing all the alarming photographs, all
- 28:13the defense lawyers sent me briefs in that case
- 28:16and they all said the same thing. This case is
- 28:19about betterments and improvements because it
- 28:21was a money spent case, meaning the plaintiff
- 28:25had already spent the money to have the house
- 28:28repaired. All of that money had spent, all the
- 28:30repairs had been made. So how do you defend a
- 28:33case like that? Well, you argue betterment and
- 28:36improvements. Everybody said this is a betterment
- 28:38and improvements case. What does the effective
- 28:41expert need to do in a case like that? Need to
- 28:45focus on a close analysis of where are the betterments
- 28:50and improvements. You have to take the original
- 28:54plans, the repair plans. do overlays, put them
- 28:58on top of each other, use color coding to show
- 29:01the changes and the betterments, photographs.
- 29:03There were some very effective photographs showing
- 29:05the before and the after about how they transformed
- 29:09this house from a nice house into a Taj Mahal.
- 29:16The point is, it's back to the question of focus.
- 29:23If it's an estimated cost of repair case, The
- 29:27analysis has to focus on scope and method because
- 29:31scope times method equals cost. So an effective
- 29:35expert will have a detailed analysis of scope
- 29:38and a reasoned explanation for method, emphasis
- 29:41on reasoned. An effective cost of repair presentation,
- 29:47unfortunately, because it's time consuming, but
- 29:49by definition, it has to be granular, sometimes
- 29:53painfully granular. But the important thing to
- 29:56understand is, when an expert comes in and he
- 29:59does some 30 ,000 foot analysis, it's usually
- 30:02unpersuasive and ineffective. If it's a delay
- 30:06and disruption case, for example, it's not usually
- 30:11effective for an expert to show up and say something
- 30:14like, well, I stuck my thumb in the air and I
- 30:17concluded there's 235 days of delay and it's
- 30:21all attributable to the owner. Well, that's usually
- 30:24not going to be very persuasive, especially because
- 30:28most people in construction cases know there's
- 30:31usually plenty of blame to go around, and that
- 30:34kind of assertion is not going to carry the day.
- 30:40So this is a very important point. Delay analysis,
- 30:45generally, more generically speaking, is a very,
- 30:48very specialized field. There's only a few qualified
- 30:51experts who do this work. That's not usually
- 30:55the problem. It's not the problem of finding
- 30:58somebody. There are good experts out there. The
- 31:00problem is, it's expensive. A delay analysis
- 31:04is very, very, very expensive. Oftentimes, people
- 31:08don't want to spend the money to do a deep dive,
- 31:11and the expert is forced to come into a mediation
- 31:14with a rather superficial analysis of the situation.
- 31:20it's not going to be very effective. That's an
- 31:25example of how an expert who might in a different
- 31:30setting be extremely effective becomes ineffective
- 31:34because somebody has put that expert on a leash.
- 31:40One other thing about this. I have found that
- 31:44it's particularly effective and very persuasive.
- 31:48when a qualified expert comes in and says, here's
- 31:52a signed contract. I signed this contract. I
- 31:57will do this work. Very, very, very effective.
- 32:02I remember one case where a contractor came in
- 32:04and said, here's a signed contract. I'll do the
- 32:07work. I was skeptical that he could do the work
- 32:09for that amount of money. And I asked him about
- 32:11it. And he said, I'll do the work and I'll make
- 32:14money. And I'll tell you why. I've done over
- 32:175 ,000 houses that have the same problem. That's
- 32:21an effective use of an expert. Here's the last
- 32:25thing on economic loss, which is one of our bullet
- 32:29points on this slide. Economic loss, form of
- 32:33lost rents, lost profits, others strictly economic
- 32:36damages. These kind of damages require special
- 32:40expertise. The key to having an effective expert
- 32:45is to have your economic loss expert work closely
- 32:48with your construction expert because your economic
- 32:53loss claim is almost always time driven. So your
- 32:57expert needs to be able to convincingly and persuasively
- 33:01say, this is why we're going to have six months
- 33:04of lost rent because it's going to take six months
- 33:07to fix this building. So they have to work closely.
- 33:11So John, maybe you can pick up some of the things
- 33:14on the right hand column. Let me talk about those
- 33:17on the right hand and let me emphasize, Bob,
- 33:20that I think Damages in a mediation is somewhat
- 33:24under, people are under prepared for that discussion
- 33:27of damages. I think people spend a lot of time
- 33:30on liability. They discover the facts. They've
- 33:33naturally spent a lot of time in the in a litigation
- 33:36leading up to the mediation, trying to discover
- 33:39the facts and damages really need to need to
- 33:43have the focus and the attention that they deserve
- 33:46because that's going to be what ultimately might
- 33:50result in achieving that resolution of the case.
- 33:55I do recommend that those experts be the most
- 33:59prepared and the most able to address each of
- 34:02the things, Bob, that you've identified, each
- 34:05of the elements of damages that you've identified
- 34:08in column one. Sort of granular but very important.
- 34:15See these two line items that talk about defense
- 34:17cost of repair on defense scope and cost of repair
- 34:21on plaintiff scope. Very often defense experts
- 34:24come to a mediation and they have a good defense
- 34:26cost of repair but it's only on the defense scope
- 34:29and the plaintiff says well that's not helpful
- 34:32because you're rejecting our scope. I think an
- 34:37effective expert will have a defense cost to
- 34:39repair on both the defense scope and the plaintiff
- 34:42scope. And I agree, John's focus on damages is
- 34:46highly important, highly important. Remember
- 34:49all the buckets, liability, damages, and intangibles.
- 34:55Right, and that's part of that expert who can
- 34:58really be flexible, who can really see the case
- 35:00from all sides, who can recognize the gray in
- 35:04their cost of repair and say, that might not
- 35:07be the only way to... to fix the problem, and
- 35:10I'm going to draw from the plaintiff's experts
- 35:13and that cost of repair as well. Now, some of
- 35:17these damages, so looking at the right side,
- 35:20the additional living expenses ties to exactly
- 35:24what that cost of repair is, or I'm sorry, what
- 35:27that repair methodology is and the time that
- 35:30it's going to take. But in addition, you're going
- 35:33to have to have an expert who can really say
- 35:36what the market conditions are, how those additional
- 35:39living expenses are going to be incurred, what
- 35:42the actual pack up and the pack back is going
- 35:47to add to that expense so that you can factor
- 35:50that into the overall damage calculations in
- 35:53a construction case. Same thing for loss of use,
- 35:56but that loss of use could be even more complicated.
- 35:59I've had cases where you might have a mixed -use
- 36:02building, where you have retail establishments
- 36:05in a commercial building, you have apartments
- 36:08or condos and so the sales might be delayed.
- 36:11You have interest rate fluctuations. And even
- 36:15I had a case where we were discussing a football
- 36:18stadium that was being delayed in construction,
- 36:22the Levi Stadium in San Francisco. The problem
- 36:25there is, of course, if you're going to miss
- 36:27a season in the NFL, you're going to have a lot
- 36:30of loss of use. And so trying to factor that
- 36:33into the calculation of what those damages are
- 36:37takes a highly specialized expert and someone
- 36:40who can opine about all the particulars in a
- 36:45sports arena that might be lost ticket sales
- 36:48from popcorn sales. And so doing that is really
- 36:52critical. The resultant damage. Yes. The greatest
- 36:58statement I've ever heard. If you miss it, you
- 37:01might have some loss of use. Yes, I think so.
- 37:06Like a billion dollars worth maybe. Yeah, exactly.
- 37:10You are going to have a serious problem on your
- 37:13hand that's caused by a construction delay. Resultant
- 37:18damage. I think that comes into play for a variety
- 37:24of reasons. One is typically that's the trigger
- 37:28for insurance coverage on a commercial general
- 37:31liability policy. So any expert who's going to
- 37:34be testifying in a construction mediation or
- 37:38offering an opinion in a construction mediation
- 37:41is going to need to be mindful of how to determine
- 37:45resultant damage and what might be covered and
- 37:48what might not. be covered. And Bob and I have
- 37:51talked about that. Bob's example, which I'm going
- 37:53to steal right now, is to have the three stooges
- 37:57as the painting contractor that you've hired
- 38:00to do work. And you have Mo walking in with a
- 38:04can of pink paint for this residential single
- 38:08-family residence. It's going to be painted,
- 38:11slips, spills the pink paint, and Then Curly
- 38:15trips over, slides in the pink paint, has a ladder
- 38:18in his hand, turns and breaks a window, and that's
- 38:22going to be your resultant damage from the work
- 38:26of the contractor who had that negligent act
- 38:31in spilling the paint. The other point there
- 38:34is if the paint's pink and the contract calls
- 38:37for a white paint job, that's not something that's
- 38:41going to be covered by insurance. That's something
- 38:44that's going to be a breach of contract and the
- 38:47scope not being followed. So you may have damages
- 38:50for that, but you're not going to be triggering
- 38:53insurance coverage on that. Whereas breaking
- 38:56the window, which was the work of another sub,
- 38:59would be generally covered by that policy. You
- 39:03know, the other areas that you're going to get
- 39:06into and your expert's going to need to be able
- 39:09to opine about are the water damage, which in
- 39:12my mind is always the easiest to explain and
- 39:15the most understandable in terms of insurance
- 39:18coverage and defective work. No matter where
- 39:21the water comes in, if it's from a roof or it's
- 39:24a window or it's bubbling up from the foundation
- 39:29and it's leaching into the floors, that water
- 39:32is going to cause resulting damage either to
- 39:35drywall or to other roofing materials or even
- 39:39to furniture or furnishings if the water is flooding
- 39:44the house. Water damage is a great example where
- 39:48an expert can be very descriptive, can use photos,
- 39:53can use videos of that damage. is going to immediately
- 39:58get the attention of the other parties and be
- 40:00something that the mediator can work with in
- 40:05order to trigger insurance coverage and start
- 40:08talking about a potential resolution. Rip and
- 40:12tear is another area of damages that's frequently
- 40:17debated, at least in construction mediation,
- 40:20because some items that need to be repaired might
- 40:24already be covered with work that was completed
- 40:28correctly, but is going to have to be damaged
- 40:31in order to get to the defective work. So an
- 40:36example is an HVAC system that's not functioning
- 40:41properly. It's already been installed in the
- 40:45ceiling. The ceiling has been installed. Or you
- 40:49have other duct work that's running down walls
- 40:51or through spaces between the ceiling and the
- 40:56roof. And you're going to have to get at that,
- 40:59which might be a very expensive. exercise of
- 41:05going through materials that have been completed.
- 41:08There's a lot of case law of that, whether that's
- 41:11going to be covered or not, but your expert is
- 41:14going to need to be able to describe that work
- 41:17in a way that makes it very apparent that there's
- 41:21no other way to make that repair, but to destroy
- 41:25other work and work of other subcontractors because
- 41:29that's going to trigger the coverage. Tangibles
- 41:34is also a somewhat debated topic, but many of
- 41:39these that we've already talked about in terms
- 41:40of economic loss, loss of use, even loss of reputation
- 41:46for a business that may be delayed in their opening
- 41:50are intangibles that can add to the value of
- 41:55a settlement and are something that an expert
- 41:58is going to need to be prepared to tell that
- 42:01story about. So let's let's continue Bob on the
- 42:05next slide on finding the drama of how to tell
- 42:11that story because that ultimately is going to
- 42:14be what the expert is going to need to do and
- 42:18can. dramatically shift the results of the mediation
- 42:23by using the right photo, by using a model, a
- 42:27video, really using that smoking gun. I think
- 42:30the best story I have about that is an expert
- 42:34who had been retained in an EPHIS case. That
- 42:39is a case that dealt with an exterior siding,
- 42:43a cladding on a building that was designed for
- 42:47a very low moisture environment. And it was supposed
- 42:53to be not watertight, but certainly to maintain
- 42:56a low moisture quantity in a substrate that was
- 43:01primarily made out of wood and wood chips and
- 43:04resins that was to hold that material together.
- 43:08Well, it turned out in that particular case that
- 43:12the moisture content was very high and the construction
- 43:16was not done correctly and water was getting
- 43:18in from the roof. It was getting up from the
- 43:21weep screen in the bottom. And so mushrooms began
- 43:24to grow out of the sides of the buildings and
- 43:28into the apartments because it was an apartment
- 43:31building with nearly 1 ,000 units. And so the
- 43:36expert who worked closely with the plaintiffs'
- 43:41council, had been able to use something also
- 43:45that's often overlooked, which were interrogatories,
- 43:49to find out what cases that manufacturer of the
- 43:52substrate had been in. And one of those cases
- 43:56happened to relate to a boat manufacturer. Now,
- 44:00you may have thought when you're looking at those
- 44:02materials, it's going to be irrelevant, it might
- 44:04not be helpful. Turned out that the expert in
- 44:07looking at those materials found one dusty box
- 44:10that contained probably 600 letters from people
- 44:14who had bought the boats and that substrate had
- 44:18been used to make seat backings or on the floor
- 44:22of boats. and the letters one after another said
- 44:26essentially this material should only be used
- 44:30for mushroom farming. And the expert was able
- 44:34to present that in combination with the pictures
- 44:38of mushrooms that were nearly the size of a cantaloupe
- 44:42growing into apartment buildings. And that was
- 44:46the drama that caused that case to settle almost
- 44:50immediately. And I know Bob, you have another
- 44:52example on water intrusion that we'd like to
- 44:56share. I'll give you two, really quickly, two
- 45:00or three other examples. I was arbitrating a
- 45:03case down in Orange County involving a school.
- 45:07On the last day of the arbitration, which lasted
- 45:10for weeks, I never have understood fully why
- 45:12it didn't happen on the first day, they water
- 45:15tested the building. When they water tested the
- 45:17building, everything was painted white in this
- 45:20building, they used blue dye in the water. They
- 45:24showed a video. The whole building turned blue.
- 45:28I mean, no exaggeration. The entire building
- 45:31turned blue. When that happened in the arbitration,
- 45:34it got very, very quiet in the room. Nobody said
- 45:38anything for about five minutes. And then all
- 45:40the lawyers said to me, we're going to go outside
- 45:43and talk for a few minutes. And about an hour
- 45:45later, they came back and said, we think we've
- 45:47settled the case. I'll give you two other quick
- 45:49examples. I had a landslide where a building
- 45:53fell down the side of the hill. My expert, who's
- 45:58very, very smart, said, I think I remember seeing
- 46:02this. And he tracked down footage from a news
- 46:06crew, a television news crew, and there was a
- 46:09video of the building sliding down the hill.
- 46:13It was incredibly dramatic. The last one was.
- 46:18It was mediation involving the landscape contractor.
- 46:23The house was featured on one of these reality
- 46:27TV shows. The landscape contractor on the air
- 46:32was saying things like, I've got everything totally
- 46:35under control, it's under budget, it's all great,
- 46:37it's all wonderful. The expert said, I wonder
- 46:40if there are outtakes. He went to the producer.
- 46:45and found the outtakes. And in the outtakes,
- 46:48the contractor was saying things like, I am so
- 46:51over my head in this project. I have no idea
- 46:54what I'm doing. The budget is completely out
- 46:57of control. We're never going to meet the schedule.
- 47:00They put together a highlight reel, and they
- 47:02showed it at the mediation. End of case. End
- 47:08of case. Resolution achieved. Goal achieved.
- 47:12Absolutely. Let's go on to our third, which is
- 47:19the prepare the right way, Bob. So let's talk
- 47:22about that. Okay, so here we're coming full circle
- 47:25to our basic premise, which is establish your
- 47:29goal, create a plan to work that goal, and then
- 47:33implement that plan. So it's kind of an annoying
- 47:38expression, frankly, but the annoying expression
- 47:42is plan your work and work your plan. I don't
- 47:46know why it sounds annoying, it does to me. Implementing
- 47:49the plan in this context means, first of all,
- 47:52explaining the goal to your expert. I don't say
- 47:56to the expert, give me a defect list, give me
- 47:58a cost of repair. Instead, you might say, look,
- 48:02this case is all about finding insurance coverage.
- 48:05I want you to concentrate as much as possible
- 48:08on resultant property damage. That's going to
- 48:11be the essence of this case. Or, for example,
- 48:14in a delay case, very common in delay cases,
- 48:19especially in public contract work, there are
- 48:22these very onerous provisions in the contract.
- 48:26If the contractor has a delay claim, the contractor
- 48:30has got to jump through all these hoops to document
- 48:33the delay claim, and it's got to be done right
- 48:35away. If it's not done, it's waived, and all
- 48:38this terrible contract language. If that's the
- 48:41case and you're representing, for example, the
- 48:43public entity, you're going to say to your expert,
- 48:46I want you to focus on the contract language.
- 48:49I want you to present this in the way of this
- 48:53is what the contract requires and this is what
- 48:56they didn't do. It's a concept of being very,
- 49:06very careful. at the outset to have a strategy
- 49:10and then implement that strategy. Let's take
- 49:15a look at our next slide. And yes, with that
- 49:21strategy and the preparation, you go back to
- 49:24what are you asking that expert to do at mediation?
- 49:28If the expert's being asked to develop information,
- 49:32then the expert is going to ask questions, not
- 49:34tell. So the expert is going to really get at
- 49:37the why and where did that happen? How did that
- 49:41happen? Who did what? trying to really identify
- 49:46the details that are going to be necessary for
- 49:49the opinions to actually make sense and for that
- 49:52education to follow. Same thing with the exchange
- 49:56of information. I think the key there is going
- 49:59to be transparent and timely, something you mentioned
- 50:03before, Bob. But in order for it to be effective
- 50:05in a mediation, that expert is going to have
- 50:09to be transparent about what he or she knows.
- 50:12Because otherwise, there will be nothing for
- 50:15the opposing experts to comment on or to share
- 50:18information. And one of those methods that we're
- 50:20going to talk about in a minute that the mediator
- 50:23may use to really get at the dispute and to try
- 50:27to formulate some resolution of that dispute.
- 50:33Timely means, unless those experts have made
- 50:36that information available before the mediation,
- 50:40it's not going to be helpful. at the mediation.
- 50:43It's like being at trial and not being able to
- 50:45lay your hands on an exhibit within seconds.
- 50:48You might stand there for a long time and thinking
- 50:51you have the best piece of evidence ever, but
- 50:54if you can't get it in your hands and present
- 50:57it to the jury or to the judge in a timely fashion,
- 51:01it's going to lose all impact. the experts needs
- 51:06to be able to exchange that information in advance
- 51:10so that the parties and the experts can talk
- 51:13about it during the mediation. If that hasn't
- 51:16happened, it's going to be as if those great
- 51:19documents, that great report doesn't exist because
- 51:24it will be passed over in the context of the
- 51:27mediation. If the goal is to confirm the information,
- 51:31then the expert just needs to be prepared so
- 51:34that the expert can ask the specific questions
- 51:37that are necessary to confirm the information,
- 51:40to learn the information from the other side.
- 51:43And that's going to be the best preparation.
- 51:46It's not easy, it's not fast, and it's not cheap,
- 51:49but it's necessary if the expert's going to be
- 51:53effective at mediation. Next slide, please. We're
- 52:00going to talk about timing in the slide after
- 52:04this one, but a lot of this is so much about
- 52:07influencing the future conversation, and that
- 52:10conversation is the resolution day, the money
- 52:13day, and the mediation. I like to think about
- 52:17it using the following analogy because some of
- 52:21you out there in the ether may know me from prior
- 52:24mediations and know I'm a car guy. So I like
- 52:27to use the car painting analogy. If you are painting
- 52:31a custom car, the preparation for doing that
- 52:36is ridiculous. It's hundreds and hundreds of
- 52:41hours of sanding and cleaning and sanding and
- 52:43doing this. The actual painting after you've
- 52:47spent three or four hundred hours in the preparation,
- 52:50it's about two hours. That's all it is. It's
- 52:52the same thing in the mediation. That one day
- 52:56in mediation, that's painting the car. Everything
- 52:59else is sanding, cleaning, doing the body work,
- 53:02all of that stuff. So all of that preparation
- 53:05is intended to lead to a conversation to mediation
- 53:09to resolve the case. It's almost always lowering
- 53:14and raising expectation. Lowering expectations
- 53:18on the plaintiff's side and raising them on the
- 53:20defense side. Part of it's mastering the details
- 53:24and part of it's telling a great story. If the
- 53:27great story is, this plaintiff has suffered,
- 53:31to use John's case, I love the mushroom case.
- 53:35These people are living in apartments where there's
- 53:38mushrooms growing. Look at these photographs.
- 53:40This is no way to live. If that's the story,
- 53:44tell that story. Have your expert tell that story.
- 53:47If the great story is, These defects are egregious.
- 53:51Look, here's a video of water pouring through
- 53:54a ceiling when it's raining. I've seen those
- 53:58videos, by the way. They're very effective. If
- 54:00the great story is, for every $100 that the plaintiff
- 54:05spent to repair this house, they spent $95 making
- 54:09it better and $5 making repairs, tell that story.
- 54:14That's your great story. This is where your expert
- 54:17can be effective. Figure out what story do we
- 54:21want to tell and let the expert tell that story.
- 54:26Let's look at our TF slide. And I think going
- 54:30to the next slide, yes, there is that TF day
- 54:33and that TF process is incredibly important.
- 54:36And in most complex construction cases, you're
- 54:39going to need a tee -up day. So let's describe
- 54:42Bob generally going through the tee -up slides
- 54:46quickly, because I do want to talk about the
- 54:48last slide in terms of the mediation techniques
- 54:51and how the experts might be asked to participate
- 54:55in the mediation. So I'm going to let you run
- 54:57through those really quickly, and then I'll talk
- 54:59about slide 17. Great. So tee -up is all about
- 55:05timing. Insurance carriers, where's the money?
- 55:09Insurance money. Most of the time you're dealing
- 55:11with insurance money. Insurance carriers live
- 55:15in a very bureaucratic world. They live and buy
- 55:18by rules, regulations, reports, multiple layers
- 55:21of authority. As a result, if you're going to
- 55:24succeed and get that money, you have to play
- 55:26by their rules. And their rules are mostly about
- 55:30timing. So what do you have to do? What does
- 55:32your effective expert have to do? Your effective
- 55:35expert has to develop this information in a timely
- 55:39way. They can't just dog it. They've got to be
- 55:42on the spot, and they've got to develop this
- 55:44information. They have to publish it clearly,
- 55:47convincingly, and timely. A defense lawyer needs
- 55:51to evaluate it and review it and write a report.
- 55:54The expert needs, the defense expert needs to
- 55:57evaluate it, review it, oftentimes write a report.
- 56:01The adjuster needs to think about it. Maybe go
- 56:04to higher levels of authority to get more authority
- 56:07or set reserves in the case. Here's the best
- 56:11way to think about it. It's simple. Sooner is
- 56:14always better. Always. If you're going to have
- 56:18a T -update, these documents have to be sent
- 56:21out at least 60 to 90 days before that T -update.
- 56:25Otherwise, you're not going to be on the golf
- 56:27course. You're going to be someplace else. So
- 56:30an effective expert produces the reports in a
- 56:34timely fashion, critically important. So we have
- 56:37a few minutes left. John, you want to jump to
- 56:40the next slide? Sure. I think let's jump to,
- 56:45I don't know if we're going to jump all the way
- 56:47to 17 or there was more that you wanted to talk
- 56:50about, Bob, on the tea update at this point.
- 56:53I think we pretty much covered it. It's mostly
- 56:55about time and knowing what people need to see.
- 56:58I agree. So let's talk about how the experts
- 57:02likely to be used, which is slide 17 at the mediation,
- 57:06because I think if you're preparing that expert
- 57:09and you're looking at those goals, you need to
- 57:13take into account how the expert will participate
- 57:16in the mediation so that you can achieve that
- 57:19result. These are the ways typically that an
- 57:22expert might be used, either having a presentation,
- 57:25a joint expert session with or without counselor
- 57:28with or without the mediation, I mean the mediator.
- 57:32having neutral experts, on -call experts, and
- 57:35even the situation which I've had when the experts
- 57:39really are the ugly experts that aren't being
- 57:42helpful in the mediation, being asked not to
- 57:46participate or not to come back for day two,
- 57:49if that's the money day, or not being participatory
- 57:52in some other way. But I think depending on what
- 57:55your goal is, the experts need to be prepared
- 57:59for participating in any one are all of these
- 58:02ways because the mediator is hopefully going
- 58:06to be flexible and use each of these in a way
- 58:09to further that goal, which also gets to the
- 58:13point of it's helpful if the mediator knows the
- 58:16goal. And so communicating and being transparent
- 58:20with the mediator so that the mediator can use
- 58:23the tools available to achieve that goal is very,
- 58:27very important. And I don't know if you wanted
- 58:31to comment on any of these presentations, Bob,
- 58:33but I think just my key point is the experts
- 58:37need to be... prepared to do any one of these.
- 58:41I think an expert presentation can be persuasive,
- 58:45detailed, and dramatic, but you have to read
- 58:49the room and know how long you have and what
- 58:51the next step is and what the purpose is. The
- 58:54joint expert sessions I've seen go completely
- 58:57off the rails, where it devolves into a shouting
- 59:01match between experts, which isn't helpful. as
- 59:05opposed to a collaborative effort where your
- 59:07expert and the other expert can say, yes, I agree
- 59:11on those items. Yes, that is the way to repair
- 59:14that. I think that cost is appropriate. Let's
- 59:17move on. Neutral experts may be used to bring
- 59:21additional information in that your expert would
- 59:24have to consider. And then the last is, maybe
- 59:28it's not necessary for the experts to be there
- 59:30at the mediation, but be on call. And I know,
- 59:34Bob, you've had situations where that can be
- 59:36effective or be ineffective. Yes, I think these
- 59:40are all very great points that John has made.
- 59:44If you're going to have your expert standing
- 59:45by, make sure the expert's in the office and
- 59:48not in his car. That usually doesn't work out
- 59:51too well. But the last point I would make about
- 59:53this is All of this, everything on this slide,
- 59:57it's all about timing. If you're having a presentation
- 1:00:00on what's supposed to be a money day, guess what?
- 1:00:02It's not going to be a money day. If you're having
- 1:00:05a joint session on a money day, it's not going
- 1:00:08to be a money day. And under the heading, John
- 1:00:10made an excellent point about sharing information
- 1:00:12with the mediator. I always ask the lawyers,
- 1:00:16is this a money day or is this a T -update? What
- 1:00:19are we trying to accomplish? I like to set the
- 1:00:22goal too. not just the lawyers and the experts,
- 1:00:25but the mediator too. I think it's very helpful
- 1:00:27because it's a collaborative effort. Well, let's
- 1:00:31see. My computer says it's 1 .30. We may have
- 1:00:36questions. I have a question. My question is,
- 1:00:40how old is my photograph? I'm not sure, but it's
- 1:00:46not recent. I'm not sure. I might know, but I'm
- 1:00:51not going to comment, and we'll see if anybody
- 1:00:53emails in. I don't know if there's a prize for
- 1:00:56guessing that, Bob, but it's somewhere between
- 1:00:59a week and six months. I can't really say. I
- 1:01:03totally agree. Not more than that. I wanted to
- 1:01:05thank everybody for joining us today. John, thank
- 1:01:08you for working with me on this. It was, I think,
- 1:01:10an excellent presentation. At least I hope everybody
- 1:01:13thinks so. So thank you for taking the time to
- 1:01:16join us. And thank you, Bob, and thank you to
- 1:01:19the Beverly Hills Bar Association for giving
- 1:01:21us the opportunity to present. And yes, I hope
- 1:01:25we've shared some things that will be helpful
- 1:01:27going forward. I know if there are questions,
- 1:01:29you can submit those questions. Bob and I will
- 1:01:32be happy to answer any questions that you may
- 1:01:34have. I know we didn't have time for questions
- 1:01:37given the amount of information we had, but we'll
- 1:01:39be happy to respond to any questions that are
- 1:01:42submitted by anyone who is here now or watches
- 1:01:46the presentation. at a later time. So thank you
- 1:01:49all. Thank you. It doesn't appear like we actually
- 1:01:54have questions at this moment. So I'd like to
- 1:01:58say thank you both, John and Robert, for assisting
- 1:02:00us today with today's program. If anyone in the
- 1:02:04audience today does have any questions, please
- 1:02:06feel free to direct them over to the emails provided
- 1:02:09in this slide. Thank you and have a lovely afternoon.
- 1:02:14Thank you.