Latest / Surrounded / Israeli vs Palestinian: Can They Agree? | Surrounded Follow-up (ft. Rudy Rochman and Dr. Ahmed Soboh)
Transcript
- 0:00Judaism is not a religion.
- 0:01I know a lot of us have been constantly saying that,
- 0:04but all the claims about the Holy Land and the temple,
- 0:07it's all religious.
- 0:09It's,
- 0:09it's historical.
- 0:10That's where we came from.
- 0:11How can someone become an ethnic?
- 0:13People convert,
- 0:14there are Native American nations that have a way for.
- 0:17To actually become Native American.
- 0:18It's actually almost identical to converting to Judaism.
- 0:22It's up to the indigenous population to choose
- 0:24how one becomes a member of their society.
- 0:26And I wouldn't see any of you guys going to Native Americans and
- 0:29telling them you don't have an ability for someone to join your nation.
- 0:32It's only when it comes to the Jewish people that we're being challenged.
- 0:35I'm here with Doctor Ahmed and
- 0:37Rudy Rockman.
- 0:39You,
- 0:39uh,
- 0:39both were in Surrounded.
- 0:41You haven't seen the episode yet,
- 0:43so you both are kind of coming into this a little bit blind,
- 0:46but thank you both for being in the
- 0:47original video and welcome to the follow-up podcast.
- 0:51Thank you for having us.
- 0:53I really want to see if
- 0:55we play back certain moments from the episode,
- 0:57if we can find even the smallest kernels of agreement.
- 1:01This is a huge
- 1:02conflict,
- 1:03a huge historic,
- 1:05you know,
- 1:05issue.
- 1:06It's very complex.
- 1:07Um,
- 1:08it,
- 1:08it ranges over a very long time period.
- 1:11But if we kind of zoom in to the most human level,
- 1:15maybe there are just these
- 1:16Um,
- 1:17these small semantic tweaks,
- 1:19maybe there are just these acknowledgments of each other's humanity
- 1:22that can,
- 1:23you know,
- 1:23uh,
- 1:23open up space for there to be agreement and kind of
- 1:27possibilities of visualizing a future.
- 1:29So that,
- 1:30I know it's,
- 1:31it's a hope,
- 1:32and,
- 1:33you know,
- 1:33there's
- 1:34reasons to believe that that's not possible,
- 1:37but that's what I want to try and do.
- 1:38So I'm going to pull up the first clip,
- 1:40and then
- 1:41I'll invite you both to jump in from there.
- 1:44Doctor,
- 1:44you did something that's very important that I think that we can
- 1:47transcend the conversation is by understanding
- 1:49what we're saying rather than terms.
- 1:50The reason why I'm saying that anti-Zionism is
- 1:52anti-Semitism is that because I'm giving a very specific
- 1:55definition of Zionism,
- 1:56which is the official definition
- 1:58and the definition that historically was and currently is
- 2:00that the Jewish people that's not what we mean
- 2:02exactly.
- 2:02This is why we need to have a conversation of what do you truly mean?
- 2:05When I say I'm a Zionist,
- 2:06I'm not talking about suffering of Palestinians.
- 2:08I want Palestinians to be.
- 2:09Able to return.
- 2:10I want Palestinians to be able to live.
- 2:11No,
- 2:11no,
- 2:12my actions are actually working to that.
- 2:14I work with Palestinian leaders in Gaza and in
- 2:16the West Bank to actually change the situation.
- 2:18My actions Palestinians for what's happening with us.
- 2:20I'm not blaming Palestinians for what's happening to us.
- 2:22I actually blamed the US government for their foreign aid.
- 2:25I blame the British for what they did into our country,
- 2:27and I would like to see us being able to transcend.
- 2:28But what you are doing is so important
- 2:30because everyone who's listening can realize we
- 2:32need to understand what we're actually saying.
- 2:34If you're condemning the suffering of Palestinians,
- 2:36that is not being anti-Zionist.
- 2:37And for if you're miscommunicating that,
- 2:40and Israelis are hearing you saying,
- 2:41I'm an anti-Zionist,
- 2:42let's ask you what you truly mean by that.
- 2:44Dr.
- 2:45Ahmed,
- 2:46what do you mean
- 2:47when you say anti-Zionism?
- 2:49For Palestinians,
- 2:50we've
- 2:51been suffering for the past 75 years,
- 2:53and even more than that since the
- 2:56establishment of this ideology called Zionism.
- 2:59And um
- 3:01Even,
- 3:01even if we take the definition that Rudy's taken,
- 3:04is that this means the right of Jewish people to live in the land of Palestine.
- 3:10On what expense is the question?
- 3:12On what expense are they allowed to come from Europe and other parts of the world
- 3:16and settle in Palestine?
- 3:19History showed us that was a very
- 3:22Very bloody
- 3:23process
- 3:24and a lot of people were killed
- 3:26and until now
- 3:28to support the ideology of Zionism for us
- 3:31Palestinians and for all those who are supporting
- 3:35the Palestinian cause,
- 3:37anti-Zionism means
- 3:38anti-ethnic cleansing,
- 3:40anti-genocide,
- 3:41anti-stealing homes,
- 3:43confiscating lands,
- 3:45which is happening as we are talking right now,
- 3:48as we are speaking right now,
- 3:49this is.
- 3:50Happening not only in Gaza,
- 3:52in the West Bank as well.
- 3:53So this ideology that's called Zionism
- 3:56for us,
- 3:57it's a bloody ideology that killed so many people,
- 4:01that massacred so many people.
- 4:03It used all kinds of tactics.
- 4:04It used terrorism.
- 4:06It used uh political uh blackmailing just for the sake
- 4:11of,
- 4:11uh,
- 4:11of,
- 4:12of this goal
- 4:13that might sound nice and and benign,
- 4:17but it is,
- 4:18it is coming on a very,
- 4:19very high price on the expense of people's lives and properties.
- 4:23OK,
- 4:24Rudy,
- 4:24let's,
- 4:24let's
- 4:25pull you in and,
- 4:26and hear your response to that,
- 4:27and I'll,
- 4:28I'll see if,
- 4:29if I can find any,
- 4:30any points to elaborate on.
- 4:33Well,
- 4:33if I were to do the same thing,
- 4:35I would basically make the argument that because
- 4:37there has been terrorism from the Palestinian side,
- 4:40and a lot of negative things that have come from the Palestinian population,
- 4:43which doesn't represent all,
- 4:44then that means that the very Palestinian identity and the movement
- 4:47of the Palestinian people means it's associated to something negative.
- 4:50That's what Ahmed just did.
- 4:52And what I'm saying is that
- 4:53the movement of Zionism was the movement to seek to
- 4:56have self-determination for the Jewish people on their ancestral homeland
- 5:00called
- 5:00Israel slash Judea.
- 5:01Historically,
- 5:02it was Israel slash Judea before it was renamed to Palestine.
- 5:05Same way Ahmed is from Bethlehem,
- 5:07the house of bread in Hebrew.
- 5:09This was the name of the territory.
- 5:10These were Hebrew cities,
- 5:12Hebrew towns,
- 5:12Hebrew civilization,
- 5:14and Hebrew name.
- 5:15Now,
- 5:15when someone is saying that they're an anti-Zionist,
- 5:17they're anti the idea of Zionism.
- 5:19And Zionism,
- 5:20if it is the right for the Jewish people to self-determine
- 5:22on their ancestral homeland,
- 5:23then someone that's an anti-Zionist is against that very idea.
- 5:26That being said,
- 5:27I don't think that that's what Ahmed and many people are saying.
- 5:30I do believe that when they're
- 5:31saying they're against the suffering of Palestinians
- 5:33and associating that to anti-Z Zionism,
- 5:35what they're doing is misdefining anti-Zionism
- 5:37and misdefining Zionism.
- 5:38Now,
- 5:39there were a lot of words that were thrown out,
- 5:40genocide,
- 5:41which is clearly not happening in the land.
- 5:43Have there been a lot of people dying,
- 5:45innocent people dying?
- 5:46On both sides,
- 5:47absolutely.
- 5:47If we want to go to the specifics of the individuals,
- 5:49we can.
- 5:50If we've gotten into the policies and the
- 5:51criticisms of the different things that were done,
- 5:53we can,
- 5:54but to constantly be throwing these blanket statements,
- 5:57these trigger words to demonize a population
- 6:00is not going to help us get anywhere.
- 6:01When I'm criticizing Palestinians,
- 6:03I'm criticizing Palestinian individuals,
- 6:05I'm criticizing Hamas.
- 6:06I'm not saying all Palestinians.
- 6:08But when Ahmed and a lot of people are criticizing Israel,
- 6:11they're not criticizing
- 6:12specific politicians.
- 6:13Our policies.
- 6:14They're criticizing all of Zionism and the very idea that I have
- 6:17a right to this line and calling it a cute idea,
- 6:19but it has to be associated to something negative,
- 6:21because a lot of people suffer from this inability
- 6:24to be able to see the humanity on the other side,
- 6:26and they just connect all of their experiences and
- 6:28suffering to the very identity of the others,
- 6:30which is what keeps us trapped in this conflict.
- 6:32Let's not confuse
- 6:34Jews
- 6:35and Zionists.
- 6:36For us,
- 6:37we have completely,
- 6:38we,
- 6:38we don't look at them as the same at all.
- 6:41Yeah,
- 6:41what's the distinction?
- 6:42We have no doubt
- 6:44that Jewish people have the right
- 6:46to visit,
- 6:47live in the Holy Land.
- 6:48That's no problem.
- 6:49That's been the case actually
- 6:51when the European Jews were fleeing the European persecution and the Holocaust.
- 6:56The Palestinians opened the doors for them,
- 6:58opened their homes for them,
- 6:59and say,
- 6:59Sure,
- 7:00come over.
- 7:00This is the land that we can live together.
- 7:02You have connection to it because you follow Abraham,
- 7:05you follow Isaac,
- 7:05you follow Moses.
- 7:07You have connection with that.
- 7:08We have no problem with that,
- 7:09both Christians and Muslims,
- 7:10Palestinians.
- 7:11The problem is not with Jewish have the right to
- 7:14exist or live or settle in the land of Palestine.
- 7:17The problem is with the ideology that's
- 7:20political ideology that's even not even religious,
- 7:23secular ideology
- 7:24that used all kinds of tactics until nowadays to kick Palestinians out.
- 7:30Rudy brought up that.
- 7:32You're,
- 7:32you're kind of taking on Zionism in this broad way,
- 7:34maybe an overly general way,
- 7:37but he's curious and specific
- 7:39criticisms you have of
- 7:41the government itself.
- 7:42If you could narrow your focus,
- 7:45what are some of those most specific criticisms that
- 7:48there is a problem in the Israeli society.
- 7:51There's a very problematic,
- 7:53uh,
- 7:54I don't want to call it sickness,
- 7:55but there's a problem in this.
- 7:57Society,
- 7:58there are Israelis who are in thousands chanting Death to Arabs.
- 8:02There are little young Israeli girls signing on the rockets that are fired to Gaza,
- 8:08their names as a as a as a gift or as a
- 8:12this is sickening.
- 8:13This is sickening to see people,
- 8:15average people in the Israeli society,
- 8:17and again we're not talking about Judaism,
- 8:19we're talking about
- 8:20people in the Israeli society.
- 8:22All this hatred
- 8:24that's coming out,
- 8:26we believe it's coming out from the Zionist ideology.
- 8:29Now,
- 8:30we don't have to fight over terminology.
- 8:32We don't have to argue over what's the name.
- 8:35All what we care about is what's happening,
- 8:37the real actions that's happening on the ground.
- 8:40So we're talking about religious extremism.
- 8:42Is that another way I could,
- 8:45I would not say religious extremism,
- 8:47it's political extremism.
- 8:49It's as many people.
- 8:50Netanyahu himself is a secular person.
- 8:52He's not religious.
- 8:54There's so many people in the Israeli government who are promoting
- 8:58ethnic cleansing and genocide according to the definition of
- 9:01many of the international organizations with what's happening.
- 9:04They are not religious at all.
- 9:06I believe
- 9:07if a if a Jewish person follows their religion properly,
- 9:10they won't not be that extreme.
- 9:12They would not be
- 9:13that hateful.
- 9:15You have so many
- 9:16rabbis,
- 9:17so many
- 9:19right wing or orthodox Jews
- 9:21who are against what the Israeli government is doing.
- 9:24So it's not about religion whatsoever.
- 9:26We have to clearly say that it's not about
- 9:29the Jewish religion at all.
- 9:31So no one said that all Jews are Zionists and all Zionists are Jews.
- 9:35Jews are descendants of this ancient civilization's people,
- 9:38and Zionists believe in the idea
- 9:41that Jews should have a right to self-determine on their ancestral homeland.
- 9:43You could be a Jew and against the idea,
- 9:45and you could be a non-Jew and for that idea.
- 9:46So no one said they're both.
- 9:47Also,
- 9:48European Jews are Jews that had an experience in Europe,
- 9:50not that originate in Europe,
- 9:51and he is right.
- 9:52There were some Palestinians who welcomed Jews,
- 9:54just as there are Jews who welcome Palestinians as I am,
- 9:57and no one is trying to deny that.
- 9:59Now,
- 9:59when it comes to there are problems in Israeli society,
- 10:01I mean,
- 10:01I don't know a society without problems.
- 10:03And there are problems also within the Palestinian society,
- 10:06but you won't hear me saying Palestinian identity is the problem,
- 10:09or that the problem is called the Palestinian identity.
- 10:12But every single time that we're having a conversation,
- 10:14instead of pinpointing those specific problems within the Israeli society,
- 10:17we're always equating them and attaching them to the name of the Israeli people,
- 10:21the Israeli state,
- 10:22or to Zionism.
- 10:24I mean,
- 10:24there are minorities.
- 10:25who chant the death of Jews.
- 10:26And I have videos where I debate those people,
- 10:29expose their voices,
- 10:30call them out for the things the majority
- 10:31of Israeli society would reject those ideas.
- 10:34But yet this minority that is super loud and
- 10:36constantly used in the media and Al Jazeera because
- 10:38they love to show the Jews that are bad
- 10:39to make this impression to people on the outside
- 10:42that the Jews are all bad,
- 10:43the majority of the Israeli people reject that.
- 10:45and Ahmed knows that because he lived in this land.
- 10:47He grew up in this land,
- 10:48and I'm sure he's met some Israelis that are bad,
- 10:51but many.
- 10:51Israelis that are good.
- 10:52And yes,
- 10:53there are some politicians that are promoting ideas of ethnic cleansing.
- 10:56I would say that the transfer ideas of transferring Palestinians out of a certain
- 11:00land is an idea of ethnic cleansing that's not being done in action.
- 11:03But there are no Israeli politicians that I know of that are promoting
- 11:06the ideas of genocide that are saying all Palestinians need to be killed,
- 11:10which is what genocide is,
- 11:11the intent
- 11:12killing of a population.
- 11:13And thankfully,
- 11:14that's not happening,
- 11:15and I hope that will never happen on either side.
- 11:18So,
- 11:18let me,
- 11:19let me rewind a little bit.
- 11:20I mean,
- 11:20I,
- 11:21I hear good faith coming from both of you.
- 11:23Neither one of you
- 11:25want to paint with a broad brush,
- 11:27um,
- 11:28by religion and say all people of this religion are,
- 11:31um,
- 11:32hateful.
- 11:33And,
- 11:33you know,
- 11:34there's some disagreement about what Zionism means.
- 11:36I think we,
- 11:36we might just have to kind of park that there.
- 11:39But
- 11:41Something,
- 11:41Rudy,
- 11:41that uh
- 11:42I heard from Ahmed was this idea of a sickness.
- 11:46Now,
- 11:47as an American,
- 11:48I can kind of empathize with that because
- 11:51internally we discussed this,
- 11:52you know,
- 11:52like a cultural sickness,
- 11:54we have a very divisive culture.
- 11:56So like I,
- 11:57you,
- 11:57you will find me being very critical of American culture.
- 12:01Does any of,
- 12:01of kind of how what he described
- 12:04going on
- 12:05as kind of a political radicalism.
- 12:07Does that,
- 12:08and I know you've kind of acknowledged that,
- 12:10but,
- 12:10but does that resonate with you?
- 12:11Can you elaborate on that a little more?
- 12:14It absolutely resonates.
- 12:16Yeah,
- 12:16and this is why it's important to separate it from
- 12:18the term Zionism and from the idea of Zionism,
- 12:21because there are many people like me
- 12:22who believe the Jews have a right to self-determine on their
- 12:24ancestral homeland and are against the violence of Palestinians and are
- 12:27for the idea of having them returned to the land and
- 12:30seeing them as a fellow native population of this land.
- 12:33So,
- 12:33is there hate?
- 12:34Yes,
- 12:34and I would say that
- 12:35the biggest win Hamas had
- 12:37is not the amount of Jews that they killed,
- 12:39it's the amount of Jews that they turned to be like Hamas and to be hateful,
- 12:43and that has been growing.
- 12:44Since October 7th,
- 12:45of course,
- 12:45due to trauma,
- 12:46but we need to now focus our energy to be able to change it.
- 12:49Are there Palestinians who completely hate all Jews or hate all Israelis?
- 12:53Yes,
- 12:53we can go to trauma is where that source is from,
- 12:55and this is the symptom.
- 12:57But
- 12:57if we don't cure the source of where this is coming from,
- 12:59we're going to continue this loop of violence.
- 13:01And the way to cure the source is to understand that
- 13:04both of our identities are legitimate.
- 13:06Both of the names that we use,
- 13:07like Palestinian,
- 13:08a lot of Jews and Israelis tried to demonize the name Palestinian.
- 13:11I reject that.
- 13:12Why are we demonizing and rejecting the name Zionist or Israel?
- 13:15We have to be able to understand that the certain names that we're
- 13:18using to describe ourselves are describing our humanity and our right to exist,
- 13:22not the negativity that exists.
- 13:24And we can
- 13:24specifically talk about that negativity and heal where the source is coming from,
- 13:28which is the suffering that exists and the inability to have full access
- 13:31to this land for both of us from the river to the sea.
- 13:33And if we focus on those points to be able to move us forward,
- 13:36we could give our children
- 13:38a better future than the one we inherited.
- 13:40As much as you try to make it as a chicken and egg situation or a vicious cycle that
- 13:46that we don't know who started it,
- 13:48we all know who started it.
- 13:49We all know it all started
- 13:51when the the
- 13:52the
- 13:53the militias
- 13:55and the European
- 13:56Zionists came and massacred so many Palestinians,
- 14:00took their homes,
- 14:01took their villages.
- 14:02We all know that's when it started.
- 14:04Before that,
- 14:04Jews,
- 14:05Muslims,
- 14:05Christians were living peacefully in Palestine.
- 14:08Jews have the ability to go and access
- 14:10all their places of worship,
- 14:11all the holy and sacred spots.
- 14:14There are so many
- 14:16documented
- 14:17stories about
- 14:19Palestinians and Jews
- 14:21babysitting their own children,
- 14:23neighbors living with each other,
- 14:25eating the same food,
- 14:27having the same culture.
- 14:28It all started
- 14:30when
- 14:31few people in Europe decided that let's create this ideological Zionism and
- 14:35let's go and establish a national homeland for Jews at any expense.
- 14:40That is the problem
- 14:42that
- 14:43It's,
- 14:43it's,
- 14:43it's,
- 14:44it doesn't matter how they were going to establish it.
- 14:46Let's just establish it.
- 14:47If it means we're going to kill people,
- 14:49let's do it.
- 14:49If it means we're going to bomb homes,
- 14:51let's do it.
- 14:51And that's what history proves.
- 14:53It's not,
- 14:54I'm not just making stuff up.
- 14:55This is exactly what happened.
- 14:57You hear it from Israelis.
- 14:59You hear it from,
- 15:00from
- 15:01older Israeli soldiers who participated in these massacres.
- 15:04Look it up.
- 15:05You'll find it.
- 15:06It's all over.
- 15:07I hear what you're saying,
- 15:08but I,
- 15:08I'm
- 15:09I want to be cautious about
- 15:11looking towards the past too much
- 15:14because just from my experience as an outsider
- 15:17from this conflict.
- 15:19I,
- 15:19I,
- 15:19I've,
- 15:20it's very hard to get to a point of consensus on.
- 15:24How to right the wrongs of the past and what the rights and wrongs of the past
- 15:28are.
- 15:30Something
- 15:30that
- 15:31we were kind of focusing on from Rudy was this idea of like,
- 15:34what,
- 15:34who are the bad actors
- 15:36on his side.
- 15:37And
- 15:38uh,
- 15:38you know,
- 15:39I think that question kind of
- 15:40came towards you,
- 15:41but
- 15:42instead of looking at the,
- 15:44the past.
- 15:45You know,
- 15:45let's,
- 15:46let's kind of think about the present,
- 15:47and this actually came up in your guys' debate.
- 15:49So
- 15:49Doctor Ahmed,
- 15:50I want you to respond,
- 15:51but let's do,
- 15:52uh,
- 15:52let's watch,
- 15:53um,
- 15:54how you guys discussed this
- 15:55in a clip,
- 15:56and then
- 15:57I'll throw it back to you.
- 15:58See,
- 15:58the difference in this conversation is that there are bad actors on both sides.
- 16:01I'm identifying the individual bad actors on the Israeli side,
- 16:04identifying the bad actors on the Palestinian side and saying,
- 16:07do not attach these bad actors to all Palestinians.
- 16:09What you're doing is identifying the bad actors here and saying.
- 16:12All Israelis and refusing to I didn't say all.
- 16:14I said majority.
- 16:15They came on the borders of Gaza.
- 16:17That's horrible and they're cheering the things that you see death to Arabs,
- 16:20right and left,
- 16:21a minority of the population,
- 16:22minority.
- 16:23It's a great minority and minor,
- 16:25it should be.
- 16:26It should be 0.
- 16:28Is it a democratic state?
- 16:29Yes.
- 16:29So why would a minority be able to control the actions of the government?
- 16:33Great question.
- 16:34This is the majority of a parliamentary system government where you
- 16:37have all these different parties and in order to have power,
- 16:40you need to have over 60 seats out of 120 seats in order to have the majority.
- 16:43You don't have a 60s party seat.
- 16:45You have a 20,
- 16:46you have a 5,
- 16:46you have a 2,
- 16:47and the majority is very small.
- 16:48So then a party with 2 seats that is a minority has the ability to take out to.
- 16:53It's unfortunate.
- 16:53That's the reality of the political system.
- 16:55That's why we got to change it that all I'm not to speak for Netanyahu.
- 16:58There's plenty of criticism that I have of Netanyahu.
- 17:01Doctor Ahmed,
- 17:01do you feel like there's a presence of bad actors coming from your end as well though?
- 17:07Absolutely.
- 17:08I'm a doctor myself,
- 17:10I don't just put a band-aid on every disease that I see.
- 17:12I like to look for the root cause of it.
- 17:14I like to look at what caused
- 17:17such
- 17:17uh such a bad act from somebody.
- 17:21Uh,
- 17:22you're trying to say,
- 17:23let's not talk about history.
- 17:24Rudy's going 3000 years old
- 17:26story and connecting it to what's happening right now.
- 17:29I would love to exclude history completely out of this discussion.
- 17:32I would love it.
- 17:33And let's sit down and let's talk about,
- 17:36you know,
- 17:36what,
- 17:37these are the human rights of the people.
- 17:39There's an apartheid,
- 17:41whether we like it or not,
- 17:41there is an apartheid.
- 17:43There are people who are living on the one
- 17:44side of the wall in a very luxurious lifestyle,
- 17:47abundance of water,
- 17:48all kinds of life needs are available for them,
- 17:52and you just step one side on the other side of the wall,
- 17:55and you have a completely different world,
- 17:57completely.
- 17:58Different life circumstances.
- 17:59So yes,
- 18:00if you want to delete history,
- 18:02let's take it out of the formula.
- 18:03Let's let's not talk about the rights of anyone in that land.
- 18:06Let's talk about what's happening right now.
- 18:08Let's create a democracy.
- 18:10Let's create equal rights,
- 18:12citizenship for everyone,
- 18:13and let's allow anybody who had a house or had a property,
- 18:17a deed or a property
- 18:19in the land to come back and take it and use it.
- 18:22So we cannot
- 18:23say we don't want to talk about history while
- 18:25the whole discussion is about 3000 year old claim.
- 18:29I hear your,
- 18:30your
- 18:31point about the asymmetry of power.
- 18:33Even if we don't think about this in a historical sense,
- 18:36I think we all would agree that that kind of is true right now.
- 18:39Um,
- 18:40Israel's just a much more powerful military presence,
- 18:43uh,
- 18:44literally a nuclear power.
- 18:46But
- 18:47the,
- 18:47the conversation often goes towards Hamas.
- 18:49Do you
- 18:50consider Hamas a bad actor?
- 18:53So Hamas is a natural outcome of the
- 18:58many years and decades of oppression,
- 19:00even if you put a group of secular people or religious fanatics or anybody
- 19:04in the shoes of the Palestinian.
- 19:07I mean,
- 19:07what do you expect from a child,
- 19:09a 5 year old child,
- 19:11sitting down in his house,
- 19:12sleeping at 3 a.m. in the morning,
- 19:14and a group of soldiers just walk in and start,
- 19:16start humiliating his father.
- 19:18harassing his mother
- 19:20and then capturing
- 19:22his brother to prison and he doesn't hear about his brother for
- 19:25another 1015 years.
- 19:27What do you expect from that kid to do when he becomes an older
- 19:30man?
- 19:30What do you expect from people who were
- 19:33who lost all their family members
- 19:35simply
- 19:36because
- 19:38a letter came 5 minutes before they bombed their homes.
- 19:40And everyone died.
- 19:41So
- 19:42you have to understand this is a natural outcome,
- 19:45a resistance movement for the oppression and the occupation
- 19:49that was taking place.
- 19:50Do I agree with all the actions and the tactics of Hamas?
- 19:54Absolutely not.
- 19:55Nobody agrees with anybody,
- 19:56but
- 19:57to say that they are the only bad actor and they are just evil,
- 20:01they just happen.
- 20:02Hamas did not start until 1986.
- 20:05Israeli oppression and aggression started since 1948,
- 20:09so
- 20:09you have to understand where that's coming from.
- 20:12Trust me,
- 20:13if there is no oppression,
- 20:14if there is no aggression from the Israeli side,
- 20:17we would not have seen a movement like Hamas.
- 20:19We would not have seen
- 20:21people who are willing to blow themselves up in a bus
- 20:25because of
- 20:26just simply because they want to do that.
- 20:29So we have to understand
- 20:30where did that come from and where did it start.
- 20:32You know,
- 20:33Ahmed,
- 20:33I see you as my,
- 20:34as my family member,
- 20:35as my cousin.
- 20:36I know Palestinians are rooted to this land,
- 20:38and many of them descend from the Jewish people,
- 20:40and although they're not Jewish today,
- 20:42they're still descendants of the same people.
- 20:44We come from this land and our futures are tied together.
- 20:46Uh,
- 20:47I know that you're a dentist and you're a doctor and you're probably a good doctor,
- 20:49but,
- 20:50you know,
- 20:50I say this with the utmost respect.
- 20:52I think there are a lot of people who still suffer
- 20:54from a reality where there's a good guy and there's a bad guy,
- 20:56and I think you suffer from that too.
- 20:58And there are many Jews and Israelis who suffer from this as well.
- 21:01This is not the way that we can be able to transcend.
- 21:03If you see all Israelis as bad and all Palestinians as good,
- 21:06then there's no way for us to move forward.
- 21:08There are many different Israelis and many different Palestinians that are bad,
- 21:12and there are many that are good,
- 21:13and there are many that are,
- 21:13that are good on both sides.
- 21:15Now,
- 21:15where did this start?
- 21:16Did this,
- 21:16I never said this started from the Palestinians.
- 21:18You'll never hear me say
- 21:19that the source of all issues is from the Palestinians.
- 21:22I actually sourced the British.
- 21:23When the British came,
- 21:24what they did is they divide and conquered all civilizations,
- 21:27whether we look at India and Pakistan,
- 21:29we look at Afghanistan,
- 21:30we look at,
- 21:31uh,
- 21:32Nigeria with the Hausa Fulani,
- 21:34Yoruba,
- 21:34and the Igbos,
- 21:35and they did the same thing between the Israelis and the Palestinians.
- 21:38What did they do to the Israelis that made us feel
- 21:40like the Palestinians in the Arab world were against us?
- 21:42They
- 21:43Hajmin al-Husseini as the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem,
- 21:45a Palestinian who as an individual was very hateful towards the Jews,
- 21:49had met with Hitler several times and wanted Hitler to
- 21:51come and finish off the Jews in the land.
- 21:53They,
- 21:54the British that were against Hitler,
- 21:55appointed Hajamin Hosseini as the representation
- 21:58of the Palestinians.
- 21:59So when we heard the spokesperson
- 22:01say things and say horrible things about Jews,
- 22:03we interpreted that as that was the Palestinian position.
- 22:06Now,
- 22:06what did they do for the Palestinian to
- 22:08experience Zionism and Israel and the Jewish?
- 22:11People as European colonialism.
- 22:13They wrote the Balfour Declaration.
- 22:15Now,
- 22:15keep in mind that they wrote the Balfour Declaration
- 22:17before they even had access to the land.
- 22:18They wrote it when the Ottomans were still in control.
- 22:21So why would they even plan to create something
- 22:23that they didn't even have the land over?
- 22:25Furthermore,
- 22:25when they did have control of the land,
- 22:27the Jews were being killed by the Nazis.
- 22:29Wouldn't it be your intention,
- 22:30since you wrote it clearly to allow the Jews to leave
- 22:32from Europe and to come and build their Jewish state?
- 22:34Yet every ship of Jews that was fleeing Europe,
- 22:37fleeing Nazi persecution,
- 22:38was sent.
- 22:39Back to Europe and not allowed.
- 22:41And even after the Holocaust with the white papers,
- 22:43Jews were not allowed to come into this land.
- 22:45So in reality,
- 22:46the British did not want to allow for the creation of a Jewish state.
- 22:48What they wanted was for the idea of Zionism to be
- 22:51experienced by the Arab world as an extension of European colonialism.
- 22:54And this is where we start with the problem,
- 22:56where I and my population starts to experience
- 22:59your population as the source of our problem
- 23:01and vice versa.
- 23:02Now,
- 23:02you brought up villages that were displaced.
- 23:04Were there many villages that were displaced in 1948?
- 23:07Absolutely,
- 23:08but only in the context of war.
- 23:09If it wasn't a war,
- 23:10then villages weren't displaced.
- 23:11And the only villages that were displaced were
- 23:13villages that were complicit in attacking Jews.
- 23:16Was every single individual there attacking Jews?
- 23:18Absolutely not.
- 23:19Should they all have been kicked out?
- 23:20No,
- 23:20but we need to provide a little bit more of context when things are being said.
- 23:24Now,
- 23:24in terms of asymmetry,
- 23:25it's a fact
- 23:26that
- 23:27Israel has more power,
- 23:28which is why Israel has more of a responsibility to fix the situation.
- 23:31I'm constantly talking about that we need to
- 23:33take the actions to give freedom of speech.
- 23:35To invest in education,
- 23:37and infrastructure and job opportunities,
- 23:38and to change the conditions
- 23:40that is causing people to hate Israel.
- 23:42And then once those conditions are shifted,
- 23:44we can start having conversations of integration and the right of
- 23:48return and for us to be able to live here together.
- 23:50Now,
- 23:50when
- 23:51Ahmed was asked
- 23:52if Hamas is a bad actor,
- 23:53he said yes very quickly and then focused almost 99% of the time on justifying Hamas.
- 23:59When I was asked about extremist
- 24:01Arabs,
- 24:02or sorry,
- 24:02when I was asked about.
- 24:03Extremist Israelis,
- 24:04I spent the majority of the time condemning them,
- 24:07saying why they're bad,
- 24:08and a minority of the time giving the context.
- 24:10And the context is important because
- 24:12people aren't born just hateful.
- 24:13Palestinians aren't born just hating Jews for no reason.
- 24:16There is a context,
- 24:17but there is also a manipulation
- 24:19of the media,
- 24:19of the Palestinian Authority,
- 24:21previously of the Palestinian Liberation Organization,
- 24:23and of Hamas today,
- 24:24and of this anti-normalization policy that we
- 24:27can't even communicate between one another,
- 24:28that is causing the Palestinian population to come to conclusion.
- 24:31Conclusions that all Israelis are bad.
- 24:33And although that might not be the source where this is all starting from,
- 24:36it is still a problem that has to be addressed the same way
- 24:39that the hate that exists on the Israeli side has to be addressed.
- 24:41But you know what?
- 24:42When an Israeli like me says that Palestinians are my family,
- 24:45and we should live together,
- 24:46nothing happens to me.
- 24:47When a Palestinian says something that they should live with Israelis,
- 24:50all of a sudden they disappear,
- 24:51whether in the West Bank or Judea and Samarra and in Gaza.
- 24:55And when I've made videos with Palestinians,
- 24:57I have to blur their faces and change their voices.
- 24:59Now one last.
- 25:00Ahmed said that there were many stories of Jews living
- 25:03with Palestinians.
- 25:04They were living good in the past,
- 25:06and my intention of this conversation and all of the work that I do
- 25:09is to recreate that,
- 25:10to create a future we could actually be able to
- 25:12live together and not see each other as our enemies,
- 25:14but as the family that we are right in front of one another.
- 25:17I'm also in agreement that
- 25:19the British policies over the early 19th century caused so
- 25:23much divisions around the world and caused so much problems.
- 25:25Even when they left the United States,
- 25:26they left behind them.
- 25:28The seeds of the civil war.
- 25:30So yes,
- 25:31I agree
- 25:32that whatever they left,
- 25:34they created a problem,
- 25:36but we cannot keep blaming that on the British.
- 25:39The British are not the ones who
- 25:41put the guns in the hands of the Israeli soldiers in Yassin.
- 25:45The British are not the ones who put all the young men and young boys,
- 25:49even though it had nothing to do with any war,
- 25:51and executed them in front of their mothers and daughters
- 25:54and their sisters,
- 25:55and let the women run to the other village
- 25:58to
- 25:59run,
- 25:59make everyone run away.
- 26:01The British did not kill 70,000.
- 26:04Finally,
- 26:04Israel agrees that the 70,000 people were killed in Gaza.
- 26:08So
- 26:09we cannot keep blaming them on the actions right now.
- 26:13I cannot blame the British for any Palestinians' actions right now.
- 26:17I can say
- 26:18their policies were bad back in the early 19th century,
- 26:21but
- 26:21right now we're adults,
- 26:23we're grown-ups.
- 26:24We have,
- 26:24we have,
- 26:25we have to take responsibility for our actions.
- 26:29You cannot expect from a Palestinian to have exactly the
- 26:33same because of that asymmetry that we're talking about.
- 26:36You cannot expect
- 26:37that as a Palestinian
- 26:39I have to
- 26:40act exactly
- 26:41like as an Israeli.
- 26:42I cannot do that.
- 26:44Israel is the bully.
- 26:45You cannot expect a kid in the school who's been beaten up
- 26:48by all these bullies and expect them,
- 26:50hey,
- 26:51you have to
- 26:52act in the same manner.
- 26:53No,
- 26:53you go to the one with the stick,
- 26:55you go with the one with the weapons,
- 26:56you know,
- 26:56go with the one to the one with the,
- 26:58with the
- 26:59aircrafts and bombs and telling them,
- 27:00hey,
- 27:01you should stop.
- 27:02You should not do this.
- 27:03Let's sit down and talk.
- 27:04That's exactly how civilized nations work and talk.
- 27:09What about what Rudy said though about,
- 27:11you know,
- 27:11Rudy made the point that
- 27:13There are Palestinians who can't.
- 27:16You know,
- 27:16out of fear for their lives,
- 27:18feel like they can't say that they should live peacefully with the Jews.
- 27:21No,
- 27:21no,
- 27:21it's not true.
- 27:22There's so many Palestinians are saying they want to live peacefully.
- 27:24Even the president of the Palestinian Authority is saying
- 27:26that the government in Ramallah is saying that.
- 27:28What
- 27:31the people who might lose their lives are the traitors,
- 27:33the ones who are helping the Israeli
- 27:35army to assassinate and kill Palestinian people.
- 27:38These are the people who are losing their lives.
- 27:40Now in the West,
- 27:41it's completely the opposite.
- 27:43If a Jewish person
- 27:45or an Israeli person stands up for the rights of the Palestinians.
- 27:48They get canceled.
- 27:49They don't get invited to anything.
- 27:51They lose financially.
- 27:53They lose jobs.
- 27:54But find me a Palestinian who came to the states or came to
- 27:58the West and start talking bad about Palestine and start supporting Israel.
- 28:01Look how supportive they get.
- 28:03They get all the talk shows.
- 28:04They get all the invitations to all these synagogues and these churches.
- 28:08There's several examples
- 28:10of those Palestinians who come and they were very supported
- 28:14by many of the Westerners because they speak against Palestine.
- 28:18On the other hand,
- 28:18Israelis or Jews who speak against the atrocities of the Israeli government,
- 28:22they already
- 28:23right away they don't get the same treatment.
- 28:25They lose big time.
- 28:27Dr.
- 28:27Ahmed,
- 28:27I hear what you're saying.
- 28:29Something as an outsider,
- 28:30somebody who consumes a lot of Western media.
- 28:34I,
- 28:34I think it would be very difficult
- 28:36for the Palestinian cause to gain.
- 28:41As broad of a support
- 28:42as I think is necessary for the kind of change that I think we all are hoping for
- 28:47without
- 28:48a more
- 28:50um
- 28:51surgical
- 28:52criticism of Hamas.
- 28:54Your,
- 28:54your characterization of the Palestinian people as kind of the bullied,
- 28:58uh,
- 28:58people,
- 28:59I think that resonates,
- 29:01but it also does kind of generalize.
- 29:03And I hear so much focus on
- 29:07Hamas and Hamas using the Palestinians as human shields.
- 29:10And
- 29:11I'm sure we can go into the validity or the
- 29:14Um,
- 29:15invalidity of those claims,
- 29:17but I guess my larger point is,
- 29:19it seems hard from my perspective
- 29:22to brush past Hamas
- 29:24and,
- 29:25and sort of what they represent
- 29:27as kind of
- 29:28an elected governing body,
- 29:30um,
- 29:31and a,
- 29:31and a kind of a political movement in their own way.
- 29:34Uh,
- 29:35that,
- 29:35that just seems like something that
- 29:37I,
- 29:37I,
- 29:38I don't see,
- 29:38um.
- 29:40The world,
- 29:41uh,
- 29:42moving past.
- 29:42Do you,
- 29:43do you,
- 29:43does that resonate with you?
- 29:45I don't
- 29:48agree
- 29:48because at some point Nelson Mandela was
- 29:52called the biggest terrorist in South Africa
- 29:54and he was banned from every Western outlet.
- 29:57Later on,
- 29:58he was celebrated and he was
- 30:00asked to talk to.
- 30:02Taliban was also brushed as the most terrorist group
- 30:06in Afghanistan,
- 30:07and now the United States is sitting down
- 30:09with them and having negotiations with them.
- 30:11These political conflicts,
- 30:13they always change.
- 30:15Um,
- 30:16as much as,
- 30:17as it's important for Palestinians to gain,
- 30:21uh,
- 30:22sympathy on the support of the Western media.
- 30:26As much as Palestinians lost hope in that,
- 30:29and they see,
- 30:31you know what,
- 30:32even when people speak against Palestine,
- 30:35the freedom of speech was completely out of the window
- 30:38in America.
- 30:39Professors,
- 30:40students
- 30:41lost their jobs and lost their education simply because they spoke.
- 30:44They didn't do anything else but spoke against a genocide.
- 30:48So,
- 30:49There is not much hope
- 30:51from Palestinians and Palestinian supporters in Western media to,
- 30:55to
- 30:56be the savior of the Palestinians,
- 30:58unfortunately.
- 31:00Uh,
- 31:00me as an American Palestinians,
- 31:02I never,
- 31:02I never lose that hope.
- 31:04I'll try my best
- 31:05to explain and express and talk about it.
- 31:08Uh,
- 31:09but the problem is that they always put this,
- 31:11uh,
- 31:14Hanger.
- 31:15Do you condemn Hamas?
- 31:16Do you,
- 31:17do you condemn
- 31:18what Hamas is doing as if it's the gate to any discussion?
- 31:22I refuse to accept that narrative.
- 31:24I refuse to accept
- 31:26that I have to have a permission
- 31:29and talk about and give a judgment about a group simply so you can hear me.
- 31:34I think we'll keep trying,
- 31:35if that's,
- 31:36if,
- 31:36if we,
- 31:37if we keep trying to express our story and our narrative
- 31:41without any conditions and contingencies,
- 31:43we'll keep,
- 31:44we'll keep doing it.
- 31:46Hm,
- 31:46Rudy,
- 31:47let's,
- 31:47before we move on to the next clip,
- 31:49I know you want to get in here one more time.
- 31:53Yeah,
- 31:54so I'm going to try to go again because there are many things discussed.
- 31:56I only sourced the British,
- 31:58uh,
- 31:58to source where the hate started,
- 32:00not what's still affecting us,
- 32:01and we've been victims
- 32:02till this day of what started then but is continuing.
- 32:05And I would say
- 32:06that there are countries like America
- 32:08who are profiting from war and investing a lot of weapons to make sure war continues,
- 32:13Iran and Qatar that are also profiting from this conflict,
- 32:16and those would be modern countries that are profiting from our division.
- 32:19Uh,
- 32:19you mentioned Deli Yassin wasn't in war.
- 32:21Deliassin was in 19.
- 32:2248,
- 32:23uh,
- 32:23and I'm sorry for all my Palestinian cousins who suffered,
- 32:26not just in the Yin,
- 32:27but in other places,
- 32:28and I hope that we can find resolution.
- 32:29But again,
- 32:30all of these conflicts,
- 32:31whether it's Gazans dying,
- 32:32this is all during war and conflict,
- 32:34not just random situations of people attacking one another.
- 32:37Uh,
- 32:37in terms of Abu Mazen,
- 32:39uh,
- 32:39wanting to support,
- 32:40uh,
- 32:40living in peace with the,
- 32:42with the Jewish people,
- 32:43I mean,
- 32:43he supports families
- 32:45of
- 32:46Palestinian terrorists and pays them monthly salaries for having killed Jews.
- 32:49So
- 32:50I don't believe that he wants to do that now.
- 32:51You said that Palestinians can openly speak about
- 32:54wanting to live with Israelis.
- 32:55I mean,
- 32:56I have many Palestinian friends
- 32:58who were normalizing and were hiding their identity,
- 33:00but somehow their identity was found out and they disappeared for weeks.
- 33:03And after disappearing,
- 33:04they told me that they were caught by the Palestinian Authority or tortured.
- 33:07This happened also in Gaza and by Hamas for even doing a Zoom call with Israelis.
- 33:12So Palestinians absolutely do not have freedom of speech and don't have the right.
- 33:15Now calling Israelis as the bully is again putting this good guy bad guy narrative,
- 33:20and we're not going to be able to get.
- 33:21Out of that,
- 33:21if we're always seeing all Palestinians as bad or all Israelis as bad.
- 33:25Again,
- 33:25let's specify which Israeli is bad,
- 33:27and let's specify which Palestinian is bad.
- 33:30But that doesn't mean that's all.
- 33:31Now you said that if an Israeli speaks about Palestinian rights and Palestinian
- 33:35identity and speaks on behalf of the Palestinians and cares about them,
- 33:38that they would get canceled.
- 33:40Well,
- 33:40I'm saying it right now,
- 33:41and I say it all the time,
- 33:42and I don't get canceled.
- 33:43I'm actually seen as one of the leading voices
- 33:46of young Jewish activists online,
- 33:48and no one is canceling me for speaking about Palestinians.
- 33:50So that's not true.
- 33:51Last thing about asymmetry,
- 33:52you know,
- 33:53just because one has the power doesn't mean that they're bad.
- 33:56You know,
- 33:56when King David was young,
- 33:57he was weak against Goliath,
- 33:59but eventually he becomes a powerful king,
- 34:01and he's the same King David.
- 34:02So just because Israel today has power doesn't mean that we're bad.
- 34:05But with that power
- 34:06comes the responsibility to fix the situation.
- 34:08If Palestinians were in power,
- 34:10I'd expect them to be the leader of the change.
- 34:12We are currently in power and we have to change the conditions.
- 34:14That is something I'm putting on Israel's responsibility to do
- 34:17in order for us to be able to transcend.
- 34:20We agree on that point.
- 34:22Oh,
- 34:23wonderful.
- 34:24Um,
- 34:26So we're,
- 34:26we're just a little bit past halfway.
- 34:28I wanna,
- 34:29uh,
- 34:30my opinion is not terribly important.
- 34:31I'm not a
- 34:32very educated person on this issue.
- 34:35Uh,
- 34:35but I,
- 34:35I do have,
- 34:36I think,
- 34:36a good sense of,
- 34:37of like uh,
- 34:38an outsider's perspective.
- 34:40And so,
- 34:40yeah,
- 34:40Doctor Ahmed,
- 34:41I think
- 34:41if I were to put a pin in anything,
- 34:44it,
- 34:44it really is,
- 34:46how can the Palestinian
- 34:48cause
- 34:49be self-critical and also advocate for itself.
- 34:53That to me feels like an important question
- 34:55in winning the hearts and minds of broader
- 34:58public as,
- 34:59as you responded to.
- 35:00But that's sort of like the pin of kind of
- 35:03what I feel like is a really important question when we look at the Palestinian side.
- 35:06I wanna
- 35:07show you guys a clip because in your debate,
- 35:10Rudy,
- 35:10you kind of brought up this idea of
- 35:13Welcoming the Palestinians into Israel and,
- 35:15and kind of what if we were to.
- 35:18Visualize what a one-state.
- 35:20Society might look like.
- 35:22And so,
- 35:23we're gonna hear what you said and then
- 35:26kind of
- 35:26discuss it.
- 35:28Do you believe that there should be one civilization?
- 35:30The reason I don't use one state is because the current political
- 35:33system that we have with the Knesset is completely corrupt and horrible,
- 35:35and we have to create something new that is
- 35:37a republic that people have a right to defend,
- 35:39but something new.
- 35:39Do you believe in one civilization for both of our people?
- 35:42If it's equal rights,
- 35:43if it's fair,
- 35:44if it's just,
- 35:45yes.
- 35:45So let's there's no apartheid,
- 35:46well,
- 35:47if,
- 35:47if Palestinians and Jews agree to have a one-state solution,
- 35:50it will be.
- 35:50It won't be a Jewish state.
- 35:51It will be a Jewish state.
- 35:52So that's,
- 35:53you're asking what I'm looking at.
- 35:54My,
- 35:54my vision for it,
- 35:55it cannot be a Jewish state.
- 35:56Why not?
- 35:56What is a Jewish state that's a problem for you?
- 35:58Because it's not a democratic state.
- 35:59If it's,
- 35:59it's it's,
- 36:00but it could be both.
- 36:01It could be both,
- 36:01right?
- 36:02What do you mean?
- 36:03Why would it not be a democratic secular?
- 36:05Sure,
- 36:05but you could have also a culture of a country,
- 36:08a Chinese state,
- 36:09a Japanese state is going to be Japanese by its culture,
- 36:11but a Jewish state will have rights.
- 36:13For Jewish people more than the rights of others believe that's what happened.
- 36:16That's what happened to Palestinians who live under the
- 36:18Israeli rule and those who are living in Israel,
- 36:20they don't have to serve in the army.
- 36:22They don't have to do a lot of things that they have you talking to them?
- 36:24Have you spoken to any of those people,
- 36:26Palestinians who live as Israeli citizens who don't have to serve
- 36:28in the army and don't have to or 3rd class citizens.
- 36:30They're not 2nd or 3rd class.
- 36:31They are equal citizens.
- 36:33First off,
- 36:34I want to commend.
- 36:36You,
- 36:36Doctor Ahmed,
- 36:36for,
- 36:37for
- 36:37entertaining that thought experiment,
- 36:39cause I do think that's a big concession.
- 36:41What if we were to entertain this idea of a one-state solution?
- 36:44What could it look like?
- 36:45I think that,
- 36:46that's a generous,
- 36:47uh,
- 36:47participation
- 36:49because that,
- 36:49that's something that uh you don't hear often.
- 36:51But
- 36:53Uh
- 36:54what is your
- 36:55pushback?
- 36:56I want you to elaborate a little bit on the
- 36:57pushback that you were trying to articulate in that clip,
- 37:00and then Rudy,
- 37:00you can respond to,
- 37:01to what he says.
- 37:04So I,
- 37:05I believe that,
- 37:07and me and many Palestinians believe
- 37:10that there's a possibility of having a one-state solution,
- 37:13a democratic state
- 37:15that's not religious,
- 37:17not Islamic,
- 37:17not Christian,
- 37:18not Jewish.
- 37:20Where everybody,
- 37:21regardless of their faith,
- 37:22they have equal rights,
- 37:24where everybody,
- 37:25regardless of their faith,
- 37:25they have access to their holy sites,
- 37:27where everybody can practice their faith and their identity freely
- 37:32without having to feel
- 37:34that they're subjugated and they have to be second class citizens.
- 37:37That's,
- 37:38that's an idea that many,
- 37:40many,
- 37:40many Palestinians have no problem with it.
- 37:43The problem is that we feel that Israelis are not genuinely desiring this.
- 37:49They want to always keep the Palestinians as the working class,
- 37:53the labor class,
- 37:56the subjects who are
- 37:58forced to.
- 37:59Stand in lines for hours and hours on checkpoints,
- 38:02um,
- 38:03who are
- 38:04simply do not have the same right as the Jewish citizens.
- 38:08So that is the problem that we're having
- 38:11in in trying to believe that that that people like Rudy and and I,
- 38:15and I'm honestly.
- 38:17Rudy's saying good things,
- 38:18and I hope and I pray
- 38:20they are genuine.
- 38:21The problem is that it's hard to believe.
- 38:24It's hard to believe
- 38:25that there are enough Israelis who are willing
- 38:28to accept this.
- 38:31Well,
- 38:31I mean,
- 38:31I would,
- 38:32I would say,
- 38:32uh,
- 38:32I would vouch for Rudy in that.
- 38:34I,
- 38:34I sense that he's being very genuine,
- 38:36but,
- 38:37you know,
- 38:38it's,
- 38:38it's,
- 38:38this is difficult
- 38:40to,
- 38:40to,
- 38:40uh,
- 38:41to thread the needle on both ends.
- 38:43But Rudy,
- 38:44when,
- 38:44when you hear Doctor Ahmed's concerns about
- 38:48The Palestinians
- 38:49having a second class status in this
- 38:52future we're imagining.
- 38:55How,
- 38:56what do you think?
- 38:57Well,
- 38:58first of all,
- 38:58I use one civilization instead of one state because
- 39:01I think already the political framework that we have in
- 39:03Israel proper today is something that doesn't work and saying
- 39:06one state kind of implies the extension of that.
- 39:08And I think we need to build something that is a republic that does
- 39:11have equal rights for each person that
- 39:12we do have representation in our governments,
- 39:14but something that is built completely
- 39:16different and not a parliamentary style system
- 39:18that doesn't work.
- 39:19I would say one major issue in conversations like this
- 39:22is we always are seeing Judaism as a religion.
- 39:25And Judaism is not a religion.
- 39:26A religion is a belief system in a god,
- 39:28deity book or prophet.
- 39:29So if one does not believe in the god deity book or prophet,
- 39:32let's say a Christian that rejects Jesus is not a Christian,
- 39:34a Muslim that rejects Muhammad is not a Muslim,
- 39:36a Buddhist that rejects Buddha and their philosophies is not a Buddhist,
- 39:39and a Jew that rejects Hashem and Torah is still a Jew.
- 39:42So we're not a wandering ideology that one is a part of it,
- 39:44if you believe in it or not.
- 39:46We are the descendant of an ancient civilization called Judea,
- 39:48and Judaism is the portable suitcase of that civilization.
- 39:52We are a people,
- 39:52we are family,
- 39:53we are a nation,
- 39:54we are a civilization and not a religion.
- 39:56So when I'm saying a Jewish state,
- 39:58it is to recreate that civilization.
- 40:00But in that civilization,
- 40:01you also had
- 40:02many non-Jews
- 40:03who had equal rights under King David,
- 40:05under Malach Daud,
- 40:06like many people in Islamic studies learned
- 40:08that King David had a civilization which gave equal rights to everyone.
- 40:12Now,
- 40:12Israeli Arabs are not second-class citizens.
- 40:14They're equal citizens like everyone else,
- 40:16and Palestinians in the West Bank are not second-class citizens.
- 40:18Because
- 40:19they're not citizens,
- 40:20and they don't have rights into Israel.
- 40:21And that's something that's wrong.
- 40:22But I also don't have rights into the
- 40:24Palestinian Authority areas and into the Gazan areas.
- 40:26So it's not one person has more rights than the other,
- 40:28it's limitation of movement
- 40:30and inequality that exists on both sides.
- 40:32Now,
- 40:33in order to be able to find a solution,
- 40:35we have to understand the non-negotiables for both sides.
- 40:37Now,
- 40:37it's important for the Israeli audience and people
- 40:39who are pro-Israel and Zionists to hear.
- 40:41Palestinians will not let go of the right of return
- 40:44and freedom from the river to the sea.
- 40:45This is something that is non-negotiable on their end,
- 40:48and we have to learn it and understand it.
- 40:49And you know why I respect it?
- 40:51Because I believe the same thing.
- 40:52I believe that I will never let go of the idea.
- 40:54I mean,
- 40:55for 2000 years,
- 40:55we didn't let go of this idea that we should have the right of return.
- 40:58And I understand where it's coming from the Palestinians,
- 41:00because we are family,
- 41:01and it's coming from the same place.
- 41:03Now,
- 41:03the non-negotiables for the Israeli side is full economic,
- 41:06political,
- 41:06and military control over Israel.
- 41:08Israel is the capital and the 3rd temple is built.
- 41:11Those are non-negotiables on both side.
- 41:12Sides.
- 41:13Now,
- 41:13you're gonna ask yourself,
- 41:14how are we going to go from where we are today,
- 41:15point A to point G?
- 41:17Well,
- 41:17there's B C D E F to get to G.
- 41:20And in order to be able to get there,
- 41:21we have to understand that first of all,
- 41:22we have to address with the demographic issue and the cultural issue.
- 41:26The demographic issue can be addressed if we understand that today's 1616
- 41:30million Jews around the world are the descendants of 2.5 tribes.
- 41:33There's 9.5 tribes of Israel that have yet to
- 41:35be reunited and returned to the Jewish people.
- 41:38Today,
- 41:38their population.
- 41:39Is 500 million,
- 41:4120% still identifies Israelites.
- 41:43Half of them want to make aliyah.
- 41:44We're talking about 20 to 50 million people that
- 41:46would be returning to the land of Israel.
- 41:48Once that population returns,
- 41:49the idea of Palestinians returning does not threat Jewish demographics and
- 41:53does not remove the fact that it's a Jewish state.
- 41:55The next thing for culture,
- 41:57if we as Jews want to be able to see Palestinian culture change,
- 42:00we have to change the conditions of Palestinians living.
- 42:03We have to be much harsher against terrorism.
- 42:05We'll completely remove.
- 42:06Hamas completely remove Hezbollah,
- 42:08completely remove the Palestinian Authority,
- 42:10but be much softer and so much caring
- 42:13of Palestinian individuals who are being mistreated,
- 42:16who are suffering,
- 42:17and provide them education,
- 42:18infrastructure,
- 42:19job opportunities,
- 42:20roads,
- 42:20equal resources.
- 42:21And once Palestinians experience Israel as caring for their lives,
- 42:25not as
- 42:26putting them to the side,
- 42:27then the conditions can change for us to be able to shift the culture
- 42:30and be able to see each other as one living in the civilization.
- 42:35So,
- 42:36question,
- 42:36if you're,
- 42:38you're,
- 42:38you're completely OK with the return of all Palestinians to their homeland.
- 42:43But that's contingent that the 20 million
- 42:47Jewish from around the world will come back.
- 42:49Let's say if those 20 million,
- 42:51they don't want to come back.
- 42:51They're happy where they are.
- 42:52They're happy in America.
- 42:54They're happy in Argentina,
- 42:56and saying,
- 42:57I don't want to go back to the Middle East.
- 42:58It's too much.
- 43:00So are you going to tell those Palestinians who are still
- 43:02willing to come back from the refugee camps in Lebanon,
- 43:05Syria,
- 43:05and Jordan?
- 43:06And Egypt,
- 43:07that they,
- 43:08they're not allowed to come unless
- 43:10those
- 43:11Jewish around the world are willing to come.
- 43:13Is that,
- 43:13is that what your point,
- 43:14to keep,
- 43:14to keep
- 43:15the,
- 43:15the,
- 43:16the,
- 43:16the demographic
- 43:18structure that you were
- 43:19hoping to keep?
- 43:21Ahmed,
- 43:21don't get me wrong,
- 43:22I'm not a referee.
- 43:23I'm not in the middle.
- 43:24I'm on the side of Israel,
- 43:25and I'm telling you what the non-negotiables are for the Israeli side.
- 43:28And as someone on the Israeli side,
- 43:30I understand what the non-negotiables are on your side.
- 43:33And in order to be able to get there,
- 43:35we have to create a reality that can work for both.
- 43:37I'm telling you that there are 9.5 tribes of Israel,
- 43:39as you know,
- 43:40there are 12 tribes.
- 43:40This is not something new
- 43:41that exists out there,
- 43:43and they are,
- 43:45you're saying that,
- 43:46so no,
- 43:47right?
- 43:47The answer is no.
- 43:48The,
- 43:48the,
- 43:48the answer is that if I could actually.
- 43:51If I could actually jump in here because again,
- 43:53I see.
- 43:54Really good
- 43:55faith coming from both of you,
- 43:57and I think this is a very interesting.
- 44:00Point that we're in,
- 44:01in the conversation.
- 44:02Rudy,
- 44:03something that you said that I admittedly get kind of stuck on,
- 44:07Doctor Ahmed might feel the same way is
- 44:09when you said
- 44:11You don't see
- 44:13Judaism as a religion,
- 44:14and you kind of described it as as several things afterwards,
- 44:17including kind of a nation and,
- 44:19and a people.
- 44:20But I,
- 44:21as again,
- 44:22as an outsider,
- 44:23I,
- 44:23I think the tricky thing is Judaism
- 44:25is a religion.
- 44:26Like there are
- 44:27many,
- 44:28many people who see it that way,
- 44:29who practice it.
- 44:30And,
- 44:31but it is also,
- 44:32you know,
- 44:33kind of been seen as an ethnicity because there's a,
- 44:35a,
- 44:36uh,
- 44:37uh,
- 44:37you can trace the lineage back.
- 44:38So it,
- 44:39it exists as many things and it's also now,
- 44:42I mean,
- 44:42the Star of David is on the flag.
- 44:44So I think
- 44:45this is a source of
- 44:47Of confusion,
- 44:48and I think
- 44:49where wires get crossed is.
- 44:52It means so many things to so many different people.
- 44:55So what you're describing to us is,
- 44:57is kind of a political
- 44:59project,
- 44:59not that different to maybe like the United States,
- 45:01like let's build a great republic,
- 45:03and that's admirable.
- 45:05But then as you go deeper into it,
- 45:07it
- 45:08can also sound like a religious project,
- 45:10which
- 45:11I think
- 45:12invites a lot of pushback because
- 45:15that just raises concerns.
- 45:17Do,
- 45:17do you hear kind of what I'm
- 45:19Yeah,
- 45:20so let me,
- 45:20let me address it just to address Ahmed on,
- 45:22on his question because I wasn't able to,
- 45:24to respond.
- 45:25Um,
- 45:25the same way
- 45:26you would want to see the right of return,
- 45:28but you would not accept a reality with the right of return
- 45:30that doesn't also come with freedom from the river to the sea.
- 45:32I cannot accept anything that you're asking if
- 45:34it doesn't fulfill the non-negotiables on my side.
- 45:37What I do believe is that we can be able to get there together.
- 45:39The non-negotiables on my side are non-negotiable,
- 45:41the same way they're non-negotiable for yours,
- 45:43but I'm proposing a path that we can both have what we need
- 45:46now.
- 45:47Judaism is not a religion.
- 45:49I know a lot of us have been constantly saying that,
- 45:51but the moment that that started in history of us referring to Judaism as a religion
- 45:55is in the time of Napoleon.
- 45:56Napoleon was one of the first individuals in European history
- 45:59to give Jews equal rights.
- 46:00Until then,
- 46:01we were constantly persecuted and even shortly after.
- 46:03Napoleon,
- 46:03we went right back to persecution,
- 46:05and he would the one word be that you would,
- 46:07you would choose a civilization,
- 46:09because a religion is only a belief system for any people,
- 46:11and Judaism is not only a belief system and it isn't for any people,
- 46:14it is for one people.
- 46:15We are a civilization
- 46:18and we have a do you believe in God?
- 46:19Yes,
- 46:19we have,
- 46:20but do you believe that God has a specific purpose for you?
- 46:23I believe a Jew Shem created this world and
- 46:25has a specific purpose for every single person.
- 46:27But let me tell you this,
- 46:28you're not being intellectually honest if you don't acknowledge that
- 46:32that is,
- 46:33that is like the core of what
- 46:35all human beings see as a religion.
- 46:37Let me tell you,
- 46:38they're indigenous civilizations sorry to push back,
- 46:40but that's just,
- 46:41this is the weakness I feel like on
- 46:43your side is that that feels intellectually dishonest.
- 46:46Would you say that Aboriginals,
- 46:47Maoris,
- 46:47and indigenous Native American.
- 46:48Americans are religions,
- 46:50yet they have spiritualities,
- 46:52but they're not religions.
- 46:53So a native population can have a spirituality.
- 46:56Maybe the Western modern nations don't,
- 46:58but ancient indigenous peoples absolutely have spirituality
- 47:01at the core of their civilization.
- 47:02And even if an individual does not believe in that spirituality,
- 47:05they still are part of the people.
- 47:06You're looking at spirituality through the framework of Western societies,
- 47:10and it doesn't work through Western societies because we're not part of the West.
- 47:14No,
- 47:14this is what I'm trying to point out,
- 47:15claims,
- 47:16but all the claims about the holy land and the temple is all religious.
- 47:21It's,
- 47:22it's historical.
- 47:22That's where we came from.
- 47:24It's actually history.
- 47:25Where did it come from?
- 47:26It's all religious.
- 47:27It's all all history.
- 47:29You dig in the land,
- 47:29you find our history.
- 47:30That's not ethnicity.
- 47:32How can someone become an ethnic
- 47:34people.
- 47:35Well,
- 47:35there are Native American nations that have a
- 47:38way for one to actually become Native American.
- 47:40It's actually almost identical
- 47:41to converting to Judaism.
- 47:43It's up to the indigenous population to choose
- 47:45how one becomes a member of their society,
- 47:47and I wouldn't see any of you guys going to Native Americans and
- 47:50telling them you don't have an ability for someone to join your nation.
- 47:53It's only when it comes to the Jewish people that we're being challenged.
- 47:56But Rudy,
- 47:56Rudy,
- 47:57I,
- 47:57I hear,
- 47:58I,
- 47:58I mean,
- 47:59thank you for allowing me to push back.
- 48:00And again,
- 48:01I'm not,
- 48:02I don't have the utmost confidence that I'm right,
- 48:04but I,
- 48:04I have a really strong hunch here that this is,
- 48:07uh,
- 48:07this is a problem or,
- 48:09or a,
- 48:09a point that similar to what I said about Hamas on the other side,
- 48:13is like something that needs to be more closely examined
- 48:16by the Palestinian side if they want to see their
- 48:18goals achieved.
- 48:19I feel like this is,
- 48:20this is quite confusing because
- 48:23Indigenous peoples don't
- 48:24possess nuclear weapons.
- 48:26There's no nation state that we can think of today that accurately represents.
- 48:31But
- 48:32I'm,
- 48:32can they
- 48:33possibly,
- 48:34but I,
- 48:34I guess,
- 48:34but let,
- 48:36but let's think about the now.
- 48:37And so as an American,
- 48:39there's,
- 48:39this is a,
- 48:40a point of major contention in American politics is
- 48:43are we or are we not a Christian nation?
- 48:46And I believe it's Thomas Jefferson's,
- 48:48you know,
- 48:48he's famously quoted for the separation of church and state,
- 48:51and many Americans hold that very dear and there's a
- 48:54A vocal,
- 48:55uh,
- 48:56political movement in the United States that wants
- 48:58the United States to be seen as a Christian
- 49:00nation.
- 49:00Now,
- 49:01that's a very divisive
- 49:03point of contention.
- 49:04And so what I'm saying is,
- 49:06It
- 49:07to kind of brush past what the average person,
- 49:10what the normal person sees as a religion and say,
- 49:13we're not a religion,
- 49:15we're a civilization,
- 49:16but there are elements
- 49:18of our culture that are very much religious,
- 49:20like belief in a specific God
- 49:23and um a culture centered around those practices and,
- 49:26and,
- 49:26and those faith-based.
- 49:28Uh,
- 49:29you know,
- 49:30touch points.
- 49:31I,
- 49:32I don't think you're going to get the support or,
- 49:33or even just the understanding of,
- 49:35of a lot of people by,
- 49:37by trying to kind of merge all those things into one thing.
- 49:40Well,
- 49:40is,
- 49:41isn't spirituality different than religion because there are many indigenous
- 49:44civilizations that have spirituality at the core of their identity,
- 49:48like Native Americans who believe in a wolf deity and a
- 49:51barefoot deity and all kinds of very interesting deities.
- 49:54And if an individual Native American doesn't believe in that,
- 49:57they're still Native American and they're not calling their
- 49:59identity a religion.
- 50:01It's only applied to the Jewish people,
- 50:02and that's because the Jews have been mistakenly
- 50:04communicating to the world that we're a religion.
- 50:07In our mind,
- 50:07what we're saying.
- 50:08Is this is our spirituality,
- 50:09but what the world is hearing is that this is a
- 50:11wandering ideology that is not based on being a people.
- 50:13Look at Iran today.
- 50:14Is it not a Persian country?
- 50:16Of course,
- 50:16it's a Persian country.
- 50:17Are there non-Persians that are living as Iranians?
- 50:20Yes.
- 50:20Is it still a Persian country?
- 50:21Yes.
- 50:22Is being Persian a religion?
- 50:23No.
- 50:23Is it connected to spiritualities historically?
- 50:26Yes.
- 50:26So you're looking at it through the Western framework
- 50:29that to be spiritual,
- 50:30you must be a part of a religion,
- 50:31and that doesn't work for ancient civilizations like the Mayans,
- 50:34like the Aztecs and others.
- 50:36But I can't think of any
- 50:38example that would line up with what you're saying where it's
- 50:41like we've been incorrectly referring to ourselves as a religion and
- 50:45we see ourselves as
- 50:47a civilization and I believe millions and millions of Jews would disagree with you,
- 50:51and they,
- 50:52uh,
- 50:53they,
- 50:53even those who are living
- 50:56under the Israeli government.
- 50:58And they,
- 50:58they still,
- 50:59they would disagree with you.
- 51:00And there are many more Jews that would agree with me than disagree with me,
- 51:03especially when they hear the explanation of what it means to be a religion,
- 51:07not what we mean,
- 51:08but what the world means and what the world defines it.
- 51:09I want to bring this back to the discussion,
- 51:13regardless if you count yourself as an ethnicity
- 51:15or a religious or a spirituality nation,
- 51:18you'll have bombs and F-15s and F-16s who are killing people,
- 51:22bombing homes in Gaza for years,
- 51:25and,
- 51:26and you still do that.
- 51:27And,
- 51:28and they're still doing that,
- 51:29and you're still using all your money and your power
- 51:32to influence American politics.
- 51:34I mean,
- 51:35John asked a very good question.
- 51:37It's like,
- 51:37what can we do as,
- 51:39as,
- 51:39as Americans,
- 51:40as,
- 51:40as Westerners?
- 51:41And what you're doing right now,
- 51:42John,
- 51:43is amazing.
- 51:43The fact that you're able to have this
- 51:46discussion,
- 51:46this dialogue without the fear of.
- 51:48Someone's pulling out from advertising in your show without
- 51:51the fear of someone
- 51:53pushing you to say no,
- 51:54you cannot air this episode.
- 51:56This is,
- 51:57this is highly respectful and highly
- 52:01appreciated
- 52:02from many people like John who are now going out and pushing the envelope and saying,
- 52:07let's hear what Palestinians have to say.
- 52:09We've been screaming out by ourselves in the corners for the past
- 52:142030,
- 52:1440 years,
- 52:15and no one wants to listen to us,
- 52:17CNN
- 52:18anchors and hosts who've been
- 52:20kicked out because simply
- 52:22they acknowledge that there's a suffering of the Palestinians in one of.
- 52:25Episodes and one of their talks,
- 52:27many,
- 52:28many other politicians lost their but.
- 52:30So,
- 52:31so the fact that we are now
- 52:33hearing the Palestinian voices is highly appreciated,
- 52:37John,
- 52:38and that is something.
- 52:39So
- 52:39good,
- 52:40good discussion,
- 52:40good talk.
- 52:42I don't know if it's going to make a difference whether
- 52:44you believe Judaism is a religion or spirituality or ethnicity.
- 52:48Uh,
- 52:48on,
- 52:48on what's happening on the ground,
- 52:50it does have effect on what's happening historically
- 52:53because all your claims is religious claims.
- 52:56No historic claims.
- 52:57Say,
- 52:57uh,
- 52:58it's not a religion,
- 52:58so.
- 52:59So I,
- 53:00I,
- 53:01these are things that
- 53:03Ahmed,
- 53:03what is the name of your city?
- 53:05It's Bethlehem.
- 53:06That's history.
- 53:07That is Hebrew.
- 53:08We come from this land.
- 53:09That's not a spirituality or a biblical verse.
- 53:12That is actual history.
- 53:14No problem.
- 53:14It's historically,
- 53:16no,
- 53:16but I say history and you keep trying to make it about religion.
- 53:18It's not a religious argument.
- 53:20Many of the descendants of the Hebrews who named Bethlehem,
- 53:23they still live there.
- 53:24They didn't go to Europe.
- 53:25Yes,
- 53:25I agree with that.
- 53:26I agree with that.
- 53:27Why are we bringing Europeans to have more claim?
- 53:30They're not Europeans.
- 53:31They were displaced in Europe the same way Palestinians that
- 53:33are displaced elsewhere are not part of those other societies.
- 53:36They're not Europeans.
- 53:37Stop trying to delegitimize our identity because some of us,
- 53:40not all of us,
- 53:41not even most Israelis,
- 53:42the minority of Israelis had an experience external in Europe.
- 53:45We come from the same land that you come from.
- 53:47We are the same family.
- 53:48If we tested our blood,
- 53:49we would have the same DNA,
- 53:51but this is not a religious argument.
- 53:53Historical argument and the majority of media,
- 53:54by the way,
- 53:55is against Israel on social media and on national news.
- 53:59This is new.
- 54:00This is the action.
- 54:01This is the results of the actions of the Israeli government.
- 54:03This is new.
- 54:04This is just for the past two years.
- 54:06This is the rise of anti-Semitism and people using
- 54:08your cause only when it fits their agenda.
- 54:10When Palestinians are being killed by Hamas.
- 54:12Let me put it when Palestinians unraveling any other context,
- 54:14they don't care about anti-Semitism.
- 54:16It's all about anti-war,
- 54:17man.
- 54:18How many people spoke about Palestinians.
- 54:19Dying in the Syrian civil war in Black September,
- 54:22suffering under the Palestinian Authority,
- 54:23being killed once Israel left by Hamas.
- 54:25Who spoke about those Palestinians?
- 54:27Nobody.
- 54:29I think they said they care about my cousins,
- 54:29guys.
- 54:30I want to when they could use them Holocaust museums all around the world.
- 54:34Americans have been shoved in their throats to learn about the Holocaust.
- 54:38They've been,
- 54:39they've been forced to learn about the Holocaust.
- 54:41No,
- 54:42but that comes with consequences that when the people who have
- 54:47Presented themselves as the victims.
- 54:49Now they're causing the problem.
- 54:50People are gonna act,
- 54:52but that has nothing to do with now
- 54:54Doctor Ahmed and Rudy.
- 54:55I,
- 54:55I wanna,
- 54:55because we're coming up,
- 54:56uh,
- 54:57we're actually on time,
- 54:57so I,
- 54:58I wanna give Rudy,
- 54:59I wanna give you both the opportunity to say one last thing,
- 55:02but let's,
- 55:02let's.
- 55:03Here,
- 55:05I don't mean,
- 55:05I want to make sure that you both know that
- 55:09I see you all as independent voices.
- 55:11You know,
- 55:11Rudy is speaking for himself.
- 55:13Rudy is a content creator who says very unique things in his content,
- 55:17and he's,
- 55:17I believe that he's speaking from his independent voice.
- 55:20I don't believe he is controlled by
- 55:23some larger agenda,
- 55:24and I admire him for that,
- 55:25and that's why Jubilee was interested in engaging with him and
- 55:28why we're here.
- 55:29And Doctor Ahmed,
- 55:30I believe you are someone who's very uniquely willing to entertain,
- 55:34um,
- 55:36With constructive
- 55:38conversations
- 55:39about what the future could be like in a unique way.
- 55:42But if
- 55:42my goal here was to kind of like,
- 55:44and,
- 55:44and I did think we uncovered some unique things,
- 55:47but I also wanted to communicate where as an outsider,
- 55:50I felt there were weak points in,
- 55:52in,
- 55:52in how I was receiving the messages from both of you.
- 55:55And so I wanted,
- 55:56I,
- 55:57I hope that you can kind of take that away where it's like as an outsider,
- 55:59I've not fallen,
- 56:01you lost me there like.
- 56:03Or you're losing people like me there.
- 56:05And so Hamas was an example,
- 56:06but then this kind of,
- 56:08this,
- 56:08this um
- 56:10lack of clarity around what Judaism means to
- 56:14people,
- 56:15but,
- 56:15and I know Rudy what it means to you,
- 56:16but what I think,
- 56:18what other people associate it with,
- 56:19that was something I wanted to,
- 56:21to point out
- 56:22and I didn't mean to,
- 56:23to come across as,
- 56:24as like
- 56:25Leaning more one way or the other.
- 56:28But I,
- 56:28I appreciate you both for participating in this.
- 56:31And I want to give you each kind of a,
- 56:34an opportunity to just what would your closing thought
- 56:36be in as constructive of a way as possible,
- 56:38like your hope for where this can lead to.
- 56:43Rudy,
- 56:43why don't you start us off?
- 56:45Sure,
- 56:46uh,
- 56:46John,
- 56:46I didn't take offense.
- 56:47You know,
- 56:47we can have uh passionate conversations
- 56:50and know that our,
- 56:50our hearts are in a good place.
- 56:52I'm not going to bring any critiques because,
- 56:54you know,
- 56:54this is closing statement to talk about the future
- 56:57and on positivity.
- 56:58Critique Jubilee,
- 56:59please,
- 56:59uh,
- 57:00I invite that I'm,
- 57:00I'm,
- 57:01I'm talking actually about,
- 57:02about the the Palestinian side because if then I burn critiques,
- 57:05I won't be able to respond after.
- 57:06So
- 57:07I'll focus solely on,
- 57:08uh,
- 57:08the positive outlook.
- 57:10And I think every Israeli and Jew listening.
- 57:12And every Palestinian and Arab listening has to understand
- 57:15there is no future where either of us disappear.
- 57:17There's not a future where we're all going to be killed on one side or the other.
- 57:20There's not going to be a future where we're all
- 57:21going to be displaced on one side or the other,
- 57:23and the status quo is clearly impossible and making us all suffer.
- 57:26And it's not about competition of who's suffering more.
- 57:28It's about a reality that we are all suffering.
- 57:31Israel has the power to be able to make the change.
- 57:33That doesn't mean that Palestinians have no power to be able to do anything at all,
- 57:37but we need to understand.
- 57:38that there is no future without each other,
- 57:39and the conversation should be focused on what are the non-negotiables and
- 57:43how can we take the steps to be able to get there
- 57:45and never vilifying
- 57:47and seeing the other person's identity
- 57:49and history as the source of our problem.
- 57:52If we see it that way,
- 57:53then the conversation goes left and south and bad right away,
- 57:56but we need to be able to understand that
- 57:58each other's identity are not linked to our suffering,
- 58:00and we both have a place to stay here forever.
- 58:02Inshallahbazatahem.
- 58:05I,
- 58:05I don't think I disagree much
- 58:08on
- 58:08many of the points that you mentioned.
- 58:10Um,
- 58:10Honestly,
- 58:11um,
- 58:12when we met the first time in the,
- 58:14in the,
- 58:15in the surrounded episode,
- 58:17uh,
- 58:17in my mind,
- 58:19you have to understand,
- 58:20sitting down in front of an Israeli soldier,
- 58:23the only thought that comes to my mind that,
- 58:25you know what,
- 58:25this could be the one who's going to kill me one day.
- 58:28That's that,
- 58:28that comes to my mind when I'm when I'm in the West Bank or when I'm in Bethlehem.
- 58:33Um,
- 58:34so,
- 58:34uh,
- 58:35the fact that you are
- 58:37speaking
- 58:38that way and coming from
- 58:41the side that you are
- 58:43clearly and openly pro-Israel,
- 58:46but yet willing to sit down
- 58:48and see Palestinians coming back
- 58:51to their lands,
- 58:52I hope and I pray more people will start thinking that way.
- 58:56I don't want sellouts.
- 58:57I don't want to sit down with sellouts who are.
- 59:00Who are
- 59:02anti their own people.
- 59:03No,
- 59:03I respect people who are promoting the causes of their own
- 59:07community and their own nation,
- 59:09but I have more respect for people who do it in a fair way,
- 59:12in a,
- 59:13in a just way.
- 59:14So I'm hoping
- 59:15that
- 59:16you will,
- 59:17your voice will get
- 59:18louder in your own community,
- 59:21and I'm hoping more people will join your movement,
- 59:24and I'm hoping more people will listen to what you're saying.
- 59:27And I'm hoping one day
- 59:29the government will start acting in a similar way
- 59:33regardless,
- 59:34and I'm hoping,
- 59:35as John said,
- 59:36this is a genuine
- 59:37claim.
- 59:39I'm hoping more people will be
- 59:42speaking in that same language
- 59:45on both sides.
- 59:48I don't know what the future is hiding for us.
- 59:50I don't know where we're going to be in 10 years from now.
- 59:54We're hoping that
- 59:55We will see that civilization
- 59:59prosper
- 1:00:00where every single person under it having complete equal
- 1:00:04freedoms and rights,
- 1:00:05regardless of their ethnicity,
- 1:00:07regardless of their faith,
- 1:00:08regardless of their religion.
- 1:00:10And people who are
- 1:00:11living as refugees will be back in their homes,
- 1:00:14or they'll be compensated,
- 1:00:16and I'm hoping
- 1:00:18that we won't see more kids getting killed
- 1:00:21on either side.
- 1:00:25Well,
- 1:00:25thank you
- 1:00:26both so much.
- 1:00:27Uh,
- 1:00:28it really is a privilege just to,
- 1:00:30to be in this position,
- 1:00:31even though I feel very unqualified.
- 1:00:33And,
- 1:00:34um,
- 1:00:34I thank you for sharing your evening and your morning on opposite ends of the world.
- 1:00:38Um,
- 1:00:39and I wish you,
- 1:00:40you
- 1:00:40both
- 1:00:41great rest of your day and,
- 1:00:42and,
- 1:00:42and safety and health.
- 1:00:44For more follow-up episodes of Surrounded,
- 1:00:46be sure to like,
- 1:00:47subscribe,
- 1:00:47leave us a positive review,
- 1:00:49follow us wherever you get your podcasts.
- 1:00:51If you're watching the video version,
- 1:00:53subscribe to Tubilee.
- 1:00:54Uh,
- 1:00:55if you want to see video episodes of Surrounded,
- 1:00:57subscribe to Jubilee's YouTube channel.
- 1:01:00Um,
- 1:01:00thanks for supporting us.
- 1:01:01Thanks for listening.
- 1:01:02Remember,
- 1:01:03you could be wrong,
- 1:01:04so could I.
- 1:01:05Keep your mind open until next time.