Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / Why Your Brain Turns Colleagues Into Enemies
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that moment when a project goes sideways and everyone in your department just nods knowingly — 'oh, that's the IT team for you' — even though you've never actually talked to the person who built the thing that broke? Luna: Oh, all the time. And it's always the same few people in IT who get blamed, but you can't actually name one of them. Lucas: Right. That's not just laziness or office cynicism. That's a specific mental shortcut called the out-group homogeneity effect. It's the reason we see our own team as a collection of distinct personalities — but everyone outside it as kind of interchangeable. Luna: So we're the colorful cast of characters and they're just the faceless 'them.' That explains a lot about my Monday mornings. Lucas: Exactly. And it's been studied for decades. The classic experiments go back to the 1970s — researchers found that people in one group could easily distinguish faces within their own group, but had a much harder time telling apart faces from another group. It's not racism per se, it's just how our brains are wired to process in-groups versus out-groups. Luna: So this is actually a perceptual thing, not just a personality flaw. Lucas: Yeah. They called it 'they are all alike, but we are diverse.' And it shows up in all sorts of office settings. The marketing team thinks sales is just a bunch of pushy extroverts. The engineers think HR doesn't understand what they actually do. The remote folks think the in-office people are getting all the inside scoops, and the in-office folks think remote workers are just slacking off at home. Luna: And each side genuinely believes the other is homogeneous. Like, you've met one remote worker, you've met them all. Lucas: Right. And the problem is, this bias fuels real conflict. It makes us more likely to blame the other group when something goes wrong, less likely to give them the benefit of the doubt, and more likely to rally behind our own side even when they're wrong. Luna: So what's the actual harm in the day-to-day? I mean, a little team spirit is good, right? Lucas: It's good until it turns into a blame game. Here's a concrete example I came across recently. In a mid-sized software company, the marketing team was constantly complaining about the IT team. Every time a campaign dashboard glitched, they'd say 'IT dropped the ball again.' But when they finally sat down to troubleshoot, it turned out the issue was almost always a typo in the marketing brief — not a system problem. Luna: Ouch. So they were blaming IT for their own mistake because IT was the easy target. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the out-group homogeneity effect in action. The marketing team didn't see IT as a bunch of individuals with different skill sets and workloads. They just saw a monolithic 'IT' that was always messing things up. And that perception made it easier to lay blame, and harder to actually solve the problem. Luna: So how do you spot this bias in your own office? I feel like we all have a tendency to do this without realizing. Lucas: A simple test is to ask yourself: if I had to describe my own team, I could probably name three things each person is good at and one quirk that drives me crazy. But if I had to describe the team across the hall, I'd probably give you a vague list of stereotypes. That asymmetry is the tell. Luna: That's a great way to put it. I'm already getting a little uncomfortable thinking about how I describe the data team. Lucas: And it's not just about blame. It affects collaboration too. When you think the other group is all the same, you're less likely to reach out to them for help or feedback. Why bother? You already know what they're going to say. Luna: Right, you assume you know, but you're actually just projecting your stereotype onto them. Lucas: Yeah. And this is where I think we should pause for a second, because if there's one thing that helps us keep making these episodes ad-free, it's the people who listen and get something out of them. A couple of dollars a month — you know, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — genuinely makes a difference in whether we can keep doing this. Luna: Yeah, it really does. And it's not about perks or anything — it's just that listener support is what keeps this thing running without ads. Lucas: So if you've ever found yourself nodding along to one of these conversations and thinking 'that's exactly what happens in my office' — that's the kind of moment that makes this worth doing. And a small contribution helps us keep going. We'll get back to the psychology, but that's something that weighs on us. Luna: Alright, so we've talked about what the bias is and how to spot it. But is there a way to actually break it? Like, does knowing about it even help? Lucas: It does help, but you have to be intentional. The research suggests a few practical moves. One of the most effective is what psychologists call 'de-individuating' the out-group. That means making a conscious effort to see the individuals behind the label. Luna: So instead of 'the IT team,' it's 'Priya who handles the servers and Marcus who's really good at debugging.' Lucas: Exactly. And you can do this in a really systematic way. Next time you're in a cross-functional meeting, try to learn one specific fact about each person from the other team. Not just their job title — something personal, like they're training for a marathon or they have a dog named after a movie character. Luna: That humanizes them, but is that enough to actually change your perception? Lucas: It's a start, but the deeper fix is to change the way your team interacts with the other group on a regular basis. When you have more opportunities for real collaboration — not just email chains, but actual joint problem-solving — the boundaries start to blur. Luna: So it's about creating shared experiences, not just shared Slack channels. Lucas: Right. And there's a study from a few years ago that looked at software teams and found that when developers and quality assurance folks sat together — literally in the same physical space — the number of bugs they caught and fixed went up, and the number of blame-games went down. They started to see each other as collaborators instead of adversaries. Luna: What about when you can't sit together, like in a remote or hybrid setup? That's where we're living these days. Lucas: That's a good question. The research on virtual teams suggests that the out-group homogeneity effect actually gets stronger when you don't have informal interactions. You don't hear the background chatter, you don't see their coffee mug, so they become even more of a faceless blob. Luna: So we're more prone to stereotyping our remote colleagues than our in-office ones? Lucas: Potentially, yes. But there's a fix. A lot of companies now do 'virtual coffees' — pairing up people from different departments for a casual fifteen-minute video chat. It's not about work, just about getting to know each other. And that kind of thing can chip away at the homogeneity effect, because you start to see the person as an individual, not just a role. Luna: That makes sense. But what about when you're the one being stereotyped? Like, you're on the receiving end of this bias. How do you handle that? Lucas: That's a great point. If you feel like your team is being lumped together unfairly, the best move is to make yourself and your teammates more visible as individuals. Share your progress, your quirks, your wins — not in a braggy way, but just to remind people that you're not interchangeable. Luna: So it's like managing your personal brand, but at the group level. Lucas: Kind of. And it can be as simple as making sure your name is on things, bringing up a personal hobby in a meeting, or volunteering to present your team's work. The more they see you as a three-dimensional person, the harder it is for them to put you in a box. Luna: I like that. It makes me think of a friend who works in finance and she complains that the marketing team thinks everyone in finance is a boring spreadsheet jockey. But she's also never spoken to anyone in marketing beyond a few emails. Lucas: Right. And that's the cycle, isn't it? She's doing the same thing to them — assuming they're all fluff and no substance. It's a two-way street. Luna: So how do you break that cycle when you're stuck in the middle of it? Lucas: One practical trick is to challenge your own assumptions when you catch yourself saying 'they always' or 'they never.' Just pause and think of one counterexample. It sounds simple, but it rewires your brain a little. And if you can't think of one, that's a sign you need to learn more about that group. Luna: So it's a kind of cognitive intervention. Lucas: Exactly. And another move is to cross-pollinate. If you're on a project, ask for someone from the other team to join your stand-up or your planning session. Just having them there, hearing their perspective, can break down the 'us vs. them' barrier. Luna: That's a good tangible step. But what if your organization is really siloed, and you don't have that kind of flexibility? Lucas: Then you start small. Maybe you just have a one-on-one coffee with someone from the other department — no agenda. It's amazing how much that can shift your perception. Because once you know someone as a person, it's hard to think of them as part of a faceless mob. Luna: That's reassuring. It's not about some grand restructure — it's about individual connections. Lucas: Yeah, and that's the underlying lesson. The out-group homogeneity effect is a mental shortcut that we all fall into, but it's also one that we can consciously override. It just takes a little effort and a genuine curiosity about the people behind the labels. Luna: So next time I catch myself saying 'Oh, that's just engineering,' I'll try to think of one engineer who doesn't fit that description. Lucas: And that's the kind of move that makes your whole office a little less frustrating to navigate. Because once you see the individuals, the politics get a whole lot easier to understand.