Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Electric City Cars: A Five-Year Reliability Roadmap
Transcript
- 0:10What if the best automotive investment you could have made
- 0:12back in 2020 wasn't some rare sports car, but a tiny plastic
- 0:18electric hatchback? Yeah, I mean, it sounds crazy
- 0:21when you put it like that. Right.
- 0:24But today we are taking a deep dive into the real world reports
- 0:27and market data on European electric city cars from 2020.
- 0:32We want to see if these early compact EVs are actually
- 0:36surviving the test of time. And you know, we really want to
- 0:38uncover what their second hand market actually looks like today
- 0:41for you, the buyer. Exactly.
- 0:43So to figure out their used value, we first have to look at
- 0:46their physical survival. Like, if you treat automotive
- 0:49tech like an aging smartphone, you'd probably assume a
- 0:51three-year old EV battery is basically on life support right
- 0:54now. Oh yeah, absolutely.
- 0:56But the market data tells a completely different story,
- 0:58which is honestly quite reassuring it.
- 1:01Kind of defies basic battery logic though.
- 1:03I mean, my phone loses what, 20% of its capacity in two years?
- 1:06Right, exactly. So how are these 2020 models
- 1:09showing a battery state of health sitting comfortably
- 1:12between 92 and 95%? And that's with an average of
- 1:1655,000 to 65,000 kilometers on the clock.
- 1:19Well, it's mostly the car's thermal management system
- 1:22buffering the cells. Unlike a phone that you, you
- 1:25know, drain to zero and charge to 100 every single day, the car
- 1:29locks away a buffer. Oh could protect the chemistry.
- 1:31Yeah, that buffering is exactly why the degradation curve
- 1:34flatlines. So the initial capacity drop
- 1:37happens in those first two years and then it just stabilizes.
- 1:40Wow, so a car that rolled off the lot with a 200 kilometer
- 1:43range is still what, confidently delivering 185 to 190 kilometers
- 1:48today? Precisely, which means if the
- 1:50most expensive component, the traction battery, isn't dying,
- 1:53the day-to-day owner experience must be pretty painless.
- 1:56Is that what's driving the crazy loyalty in this specific market?
- 1:58It's a massive factor, Yeah. Surveys show models like the
- 2:02Mini Cooper SE and the VWE UP are hitting 95 to 98%
- 2:07reliability and satisfaction rating.
- 2:09That's huge. It really is.
- 2:10And a big part of that comes down to how aggressive City
- 2:14Region preserves the hardware. We are seeing owners hit 60,000
- 2:18kilometers with completely untouched original brake pads.
- 2:22Which is brilliant from a maintenance perspective, but
- 2:25there's a hilarious irony here that the data pointed out.
- 2:28Oh. The 12 Volt battery thing.
- 2:29Yes you have this massive high tech traction battery surviving
- 2:34perfectly, yet the biggest complaint on the forums is the
- 2:38cheap old school 12 Volt accessory battery just dying all
- 2:43the time. Yeah, the car is sitting on this
- 2:44huge reserve of power, but it fails to trickle charge its own
- 2:49accessory battery when parked for too long.
- 2:51It's such a funny oversight. It's a glaring design oversight
- 2:54for sure, but it grounds the discussion well because these
- 2:57cars are definitely not invincible.
- 2:59They have distinct physical limits.
- 3:01Right, like the winter driving penalty.
- 3:02Exactly. If you run the cabin heater in
- 3:04winter, especially in models without a heat pump, you're
- 3:07looking at a 25 to 30% drop in range.
- 3:10And their highway performance is inherently compromised too.
- 3:13Yeah, because without a multi speed gearbox the single
- 3:16electric motor is forced to spin at wildly inefficient RPMS at
- 3:20high speeds. Add in the terrible aerodynamics
- 3:23of a boxy City car, yeah, and your efficiency just completely
- 3:26tanks the second you hit 130 kilometers per hour.
- 3:29They're strictly city creatures, but because they're 200 to 250
- 3:34kilometer range perfectly matches that urban ecosystem,
- 3:37we're seeing a remarkably strong secondhand market.
- 3:40It's so completely different from the massive premium EV SU
- 3:43VS from 2020. Those are plummeting in value
- 3:46right now. The tech evolved way too fast to
- 3:49justify their original price tags.
- 3:51While city EVs, on the other hand, are holding their ground
- 3:53as the ideal second car. The economics on the VWE UP and
- 3:57this go to Citigo are actually staggering when you look at the
- 4:00depreciation curves. Wait, give me the numbers again.
- 4:02Back in 2020 people were buying these for around 12,000 to
- 4:06€14,000 right, thanks to heavy government incentives.
- 4:09Right. And today, even with 50,000
- 4:12kilometers on the clock, they're reselling for 11,000 to €13,500.
- 4:18That's insane. The initial owners practically
- 4:20drove for free for years. They really did, though buyers
- 4:24navigating this market do need to be careful with models like
- 4:27the Renault Zoe. Yeah, where the pricing
- 4:29structure can be incredibly deceptive.
- 4:31Exactly the battery lease trap. Right, you'll see a used Zoe
- 4:35listed for what looks like an absolute steal around €8500, but
- 4:39that's because the battery is leased.
- 4:41Yeah, you're stuck paying a recurring monthly fee to the
- 4:44manufacturer just to keep the car functional.
- 4:46And if you want the model where the battery is fully owned, the
- 4:49real market value sits much higher, between 12,000 and
- 4:53€14,500. You absolutely have to read the
- 4:57fine print. The total cost of ownership
- 4:59completely changes depending on that single contract detail.
- 5:03Well, thank you so much for joining us on this deep dive
- 5:05today. Yeah.
- 5:06Thanks for tuning in everyone. We hope you are walking away
- 5:09with some fresh insights into how the EV market is maturing.
- 5:13It definitely forces us to rethink our assumptions about
- 5:15tech degradation. Absolutely.
- 5:17It changes the whole perspective on longevity.
- 5:19It really. Does.
- 5:20Which leaves us with a final thought to consider for you.
- 5:22Yeah, if small EVs with modest batteries hold their value
- 5:27better than massive premium SUVs simply because they perfectly
- 5:30fit their urban environment well, are we culturally
- 5:32overvaluing maximum range? Right, like next time you look
- 5:36at your aging smartphone, maybe ask yourself, does it actually
- 5:38need a bigger battery or just a better habitat?