Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 206. Crafting Narratives That Motivate: What’s Your Strategy Story?
Transcript
- 0:03The glue for ideation, imagination, and even strategy, is communication.
- 0:11My name is Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:17Welcome to Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:22Today I'm excited to speak with Martin Reeves.
- 0:25Martin is chairman of the BCG Henderson Institute, which is a think tank dedicated to exploring and developing valuable new insights from business, technology, economics, and science.
- 0:36Martin has written many books.
- 0:38One of my favorites is The Imagination Machine, and he's also written a new book along with Bob Goodson called, like The Button That Changed the World.
- 0:48Welcome Martin.
- 0:49I look forward to our conversation.
- 0:51Yeah, likewise.
- 0:52Thanks for having me, Matt.
- 0:54Excellent.
- 0:54Let's get started.
- 0:55Okay.
- 0:56Sure.
- 0:57The very first article my students read in my GSB Strategic Communication Class is your article called Your Strategy Needs a Story.
- 1:06Your article emphasizes the power of narrative in strategy.
- 1:10How can leaders craft compelling strategic stories that not only inform, but also inspire and mobilize their organizations?
- 1:19There's a lot here.
- 1:20It, sounds improbable, right?
- 1:21Strategy seems to be a very serious affair.
- 1:24Very analytical affair and, and stories, it sounds like fiction.
- 1:28It sounds like something frivolous.
- 1:30But actually a strategy is a story, if you think about it.
- 1:32A, strategy starts with a reality, the present, and it's about a fiction which is causing a different state of affairs, competitive advantage, favorable outcomes.
- 1:42So it's a special type of story.
- 1:43It's a story which is initially fictional that's converted to a reality.
- 1:47And I think the important thing about the story is not just informing, which generally strategy does a very bad job at.
- 1:53There's this famous statistic that only twenty-seven, that twenty-eight percent of managers actually know any of the top priorities of their company's strategy.
- 2:03So informing is a bar, but an even bigger one is inciting action 'cause you want people to actually be motivated to, to execute the strategy.
- 2:12So how do you do that?
- 2:14I think you, you think about the details of the strategy, but then you think about how to tell it in a way which is actually informative and inspiring.
- 2:22And I think a lot of the elements are actually elements that are present in any story.
- 2:26You need to start with a past, how did you get here?
- 2:29A present, your future aspiration.
- 2:32You need some sort of obstacles to overcome to reach your journey.
- 2:36You need some sort of hero, the company, you need some sort of path as to, and philosophy as to how are you gonna achieve that, that result.
- 2:44And I think a very good way to think about this is the, the strategy formulation process, which is obviously a, a little bit aristocratic sometimes.
- 2:53It's, uh, only the strategists or the highly analytical types and the corporate center that deal with the strategy.
- 2:59But you think about the process of strategy formulation, an inclusive process, whereby a group of people that are charged eventually with executing the strategy, come up with the strategy, has the additional benefit that the process of formation of the strategy can be motivating and informative in itself.
- 3:17And I think critical there is using the right sequence of questions in that process.
- 3:23To have some degree of control and ability to shape the process, but a lot of openness too.
- 3:28So there's a lot of discovery, a lot of listening, a lot of, uh, creativity.
- 3:33I think these two topics of story and strategy are intertwined.
- 3:38And that's exactly why we use this article to kick up our class on strategic communication is to highlight how important both components are.
- 3:46A strategy that doesn't have a clear articulate story is just shelfware, and a story that isn't informed by strategy isn't really going to help be motivational.
- 3:57And I really like the piece that you'd mentioned, but also the article really talks about, which is the power of using questions to help not only determine your story, but to engage others in that story so they're more likely to follow along.
- 4:11So questions really to me, seem to be a core essence of that.
- 4:14It's a great technology in a way because questions can interrogate, they can elicit information.
- 4:21They can be purposeful, but be modest about the state of knowledge or ignorance, so they can be part of an inquiry.
- 4:29They're a shared social process, and also they can shape a process.
- 4:34I'm asking, asking the right question in the right order elicits a certain response and a certain momentum, so it's a lot better than simply letting anyone do everything they want and alternatively telling.
- 4:46So it's a very sophisticated technology.
- 4:48Hard, hard to use.
- 4:49A bit like listening, very important, but hard for people.
- 4:53The ability to ask good questions at the appropriate time towards a specific goal is challenging, but can be very fruitful, as you said.
- 5:01I like labeling it a technology.
- 5:04I really enjoyed your book, The Imagination Machine, and in that book you discuss how companies can systematically harness imagination.
- 5:13What strategies can we use to encourage and elicit imaginative thinking in our teams?
- 5:20For some reason, imagination is seen as being some sort of magical property that's only endowed to a few gifted individuals like Steve Jobs.
- 5:29And it comes to them in special moments where they see clarity and they see the future.
- 5:33But, and we have the idea that you couldn't possibly manage this sort of very frisky capability and process.
- 5:38But that's rather strange in a way because we don't say in the HR department of companies, oh my god, the affairs of people are intrinsically unpredictable.
- 5:45We couldn't possibly manage that.
- 5:47Let's give up, let's just leave it to a few talented individuals using their intuition.
- 5:52So the idea of the The Imagination Machine was to lay out how we could, obviously not with total predictability, but to some extent, shape this process of imagination.
- 6:01I think we, we tend to think of imagination as just the ideation step, the first step in the process.
- 6:05But actually it's the whole process from spark to reality.
- 6:09'Cause if you think about it, a company is an imagination machine.
- 6:12It takes an idea and it turns it into a reality.
- 6:14So it's a very special sort of machine.
- 6:16And the six steps or strategies, to answer your question, one of them is embracing anomalies, being curious.
- 6:22We know that the brain science says that imagination is driven by surprise.
- 6:26When we see something that doesn't fit the pattern of our existing mental model, we update our mental model.
- 6:32So if you don't expose yourself to that surprise, that anomaly, if you're just entirely introverted looking only inside the company, then that doesn't work.
- 6:40So that's the first step.
- 6:41And the second one is looking differently at assumptions.
- 6:45Often what we think of as a fact is just an assumption.
- 6:48It's just a mental model.
- 6:49So for example, we are in the pharmaceutical business.
- 6:52You could look at your business that way, but actually it's an assumption.
- 6:55And the boundaries of the pharmaceutical business are open to dispute and reinvention.
- 6:59So I think it's about having alternative mental models and understanding the difference between an assumption and a fact.
- 7:05The third step is, is colliding things with reality because, uh, most new business models fail, but when they fail they generate anomalous, they generate sparks, which further fuel the imagination process.
- 7:17And so a highly rational affair where you don't do anything when there's a possibility that's a mistake, and you don't do anything until you've done all of your analysis, it's too reliant on the power of rationality.
- 7:28And reality is smarter.
- 7:29It has more surprises in store for us.
- 7:31So collide your idea with reality as soon as possible, and there's a whole discipline of experimentation and so on.
- 7:37The fourth one is quite hard for companies, which is to make sure that ideas spread within a company.
- 7:43Silos, functions, special language, tribal jealousy, jargon.
- 7:47There's all sorts of ways which stop ideas, even good ideas spreading within a company.
- 7:53So my favorite example here is the Japanese company Recruit, which I talk about a lot in the book that actually has a, a culture of celebrating the spread of, of ideas.
- 8:02And the idea is that the most fun part of being a member of the company, and everyone's obligation is not just to run the business, but to have ideas about how to evolve the business.
- 8:11And they have vast festivals of ideas where anyone can participate, anyone can propose a new idea.
- 8:16So that's a culture which makes ideas spread.
- 8:20And fifth may sound like the opposite of imagination, which is actually codifying ideas start off as being very soft, very ambiguous, and to work predictably, to be industrialized they need playbooks.
- 8:32And often working out which of the thousand ideas are the essential details that need to be communicated to everybody is, there is a subtle exercise.
- 8:40So I have this idea I call evolvable scripts, which is, it's like a script for an actor.
- 8:44It's the things, the essential elements that you need to replicate in order to replicate the effect of an idea.
- 8:50And then the last one is just to repeat the cycle, which means staying humble, essentially being ready to disrupt yourself, no matter how great your previous business model was constantly being paranoid and humble and open to reinvention.
- 9:03And all of those things, of course, are about how leaders exemplify and communicate those ideas.
- 9:09All of these have to do with communication and modeling leadership behaviors.
- 9:14I really appreciate again, how you share the importance of communication in the process of imagination and creativity, just like you did with the notion of strategy.
- 9:24As you were mentioning these things, our listeners know that I love alliteration and, and things that can be easier to remember.
- 9:31So I tracked your six steps to helping organizations and individuals to be more creative and leverage The Imagination Machine as start with curiosity about what's going on around you.
- 9:44Challenge the assumptions that exist.
- 9:46Collide with the reality to generate more sparks.
- 9:50And then I took a little liberty here, but this notion of contaminate, in other words, spread the information around.
- 9:57Codify as step five so that you actually can make these repeatable, and then finally continue the effort.
- 10:04And so I came up with six Cs, which in my mind will help cement those ideas.
- 10:09And all of us can supercharge our organizations, our teams with imagination by following those six steps.
- 10:16And I appreciate not only sharing the six steps, but saying how important communication, the seventh C in there really is for making that happen.
- 10:25Absolutely.
- 10:26A key concept, right, I think is inspiration because to believe in the fiction of the better company or the better invention, it requires another C, confidence, and, and that requires not just, again, information, it requires inspiration, it requires some sort of emotional energy and belief and confidence in the possibility of a better future.
- 10:46So I guess we could say that final ingredient is the catalyst that is inspiration.
- 10:51In your work on imagination, you've highlighted the importance of reframing.
- 10:56How can communicators use reframing as a technique to help organizations see new opportunities or solve complex problems?
- 11:04My business, the consulting business, is to a first approximation it's problem solving.
- 11:08And there's a lot of complexity in the process of solving a problem.
- 11:12There's a lot of analysis to be done and data to be gathered, but the first question is always, what is the question?
- 11:18Because obviously doing all of these technical operations on the wrong question would be a waste of time, and that's where framing and reframing come ins.
- 11:25You know, throughout my career, I've just accidentally, probably just by dint of my personality, focused on that framing step.
- 11:32When everybody thinks that the question is clear, let's go reduce cost by fourteen percent and I think it's important to say, how do we know that's the right question?
- 11:39Could we just pause a little and explore other ways of framing the question?
- 11:42Why do we think that's the right question?
- 11:44So asking the word why repeatedly is one way of getting a reframing, asking what's an assumption and what's a fact?
- 11:50Analogies can be very useful in this respect.
- 11:52If we say, what is this?
- 11:53It opens up the possibility of seeing things differently.
- 11:56Boundaries is important.
- 11:58If we say, well, okay, we're a pharmaceutical company, but look, to have more broadly, we're actually a health company.
- 12:03And looked at even more broadly, we're a wellbeing company.
- 12:05So often broadening the boundaries of a problem permits us to see it differently.
- 12:10I often use constraints.
- 12:11I add a constraint and say, how do we think about that if we, for instance, couldn't use that particular buzzword.
- 12:18Or I remove a constraint, if I say, if there were no economic constraints on this, what would be the ideal way of doing this?
- 12:23And it reframes by removing or making assumptions variable.
- 12:27What it all boils down to, I think, is having multiple mental models, the ability to see things in different ways, and seeing that there are really two types of choice, at least two types of choice.
- 12:36One of them is choices within a given mental model within this particular construct.
- 12:40We are a pharmaceutical company.
- 12:41How do we make this better or that better?
- 12:43But then the bigger question of are we really a pharmaceutical company?
- 12:47What do we mean by that?
- 12:49This notion of reframing as you use it is really shaking up how we see reality.
- 12:53It's what's our mental model for this particular endeavor that we're working on.
- 12:58In the class I teach, we do a mini case where we take an auto company and walk through how reframing it is not about selling cars and trucks, but it's really about selling mobility and movement of people.
- 13:12And when you do that, it opens things up tremendously.
- 13:15So this idea of framing and reframing to uncover possible inspirations for creative solutions, and I see how these all relate, can really help.
- 13:26I'd like to turn our attention to your new book, Like: The Button That Changed the World.
- 13:31In the book you provide a history of the like button and discuss the consequences of it.
- 13:37What sparked your interest in the button?
- 13:40In a way, the story of the book is related to the content of the book, so I was getting to know somebody, I often try to make myself familiar with new people, new ideas, and I was getting to know somebody in a coffee shop who was a CEO of a tech company, and he was an avid hoarder.
- 13:54He was moving.
- 13:55So I said to him, you must be coming across all sorts of things in your cardboard boxes.
- 13:59And he said, yes.
- 14:00And he pulled out a notebook and it flipped open at a page where there was a sketch of a thumbs up symbol.
- 14:06And I looked at the date on it and it far predated Facebook's use of the like button.
- 14:11So I said, I said, Bob, you're telling me you invented the like button?
- 14:14And he said, no, of course not, maybe.
- 14:17And so this thirty minute conversation turned into a whole day conversation where we said, who did invent the like button?
- 14:22And what we found is that this incredible detective story of did this person invent it, did this company invent it, turned into a sort of quest and it unfolded in front of us.
- 14:31And it was a really interesting detective story.
- 14:34So we thought we must share this with the reader and we must write a book about this.
- 14:38And so this expanded because of course you can ask the question, who invented the like button?
- 14:43You can ask why the thumbs up?
- 14:44You can ask what were the consequences of the like button?
- 14:47You can ask what's next?
- 14:48And so we put all of that into a book.
- 14:51Can you share the impact of that like button in terms of what happens in our brains and in our bodies?
- 14:58Liking, it turns out the digital liking, which was invented.
- 15:02It's a piece of code in JavaScript, which signals to somebody like a reviewer that you like their review, that was invented, but it actually triggers something called the nucleus accumbens in the brain to release dopamine.
- 15:14And liking online is the same impact as liking in reality, and it involves the same brain chemistry and the same brain centers as being liked.
- 15:23So liking and being liked turns out it's the same thing.
- 15:27That's the same thing as pleasurable activities like sex.
- 15:30It's the same thing as drug addiction.
- 15:32It's the same thing which triggers teenage mental health and self-esteem problems with online addiction and so on.
- 15:39So it really has an enormous impact on the way that we, we communicate.
- 15:43This idea that a simple act of liking, and as you said, liking means not just revealing a preference, but being like something, has really impacted everything.
- 15:55And business leaders, working professionals need to think about it.
- 15:59And it's influencing how we communicate and what we communicate because we now have insight and information we didn't before.
- 16:06I think in good ways and ways we should watch out for.
- 16:09It obviously compresses the attention span as we're in an age of, if Aristotle was in the world of polished long form rhetoric, we're now playing ping pong with Tweets and likes, and that's useful actually.
- 16:20But I think it's also useful not to become the airline pilot that can't fly the computer controlled plane anymore.
- 16:26I think it's useful to maintain balance in our communication skills.
- 16:29So I personally try to communicate fractally.
- 16:31When I think about something I want to write, I think about the white paper that's a bit long for most people to read.
- 16:37I think about the HBR article that is nice and punchy that probably a lot more people will read.
- 16:42I also think about the LinkedIn post and I think about the Tweets at the same time.
- 16:45And I regard them all as legitimate and complimentary forms of communication.
- 16:50And I think that's important.
- 16:51And that notion of the fractal, I think is a really interesting analogy for how to look at that.
- 16:56So Martin, before we end, I like to ask three questions of my guests.
- 16:59One I create just for you and the others are similar across all my guests.
- 17:03Are you ready for that?
- 17:04Sure.
- 17:05So in your role as the head of BCGs Henderson Institute, you spend a lot of time thinking about the future.
- 17:12Is there a particular trend or idea that has you excited for what's coming that you can share with us?
- 17:20The reason this question is difficult for me to answer is I'm naturally interested in everything, but if I were to focus just on one of them, I would say that in a short space of time, everything in business has become intensely political.
- 17:33Or to put it another way we used to think about the company as a sort of an economic island where we could think about the company just as its customers, its investors, its products, and its financials, not about the social and political context, which we assumed was basically a constant and benevolent.
- 17:48We can't do that anymore.
- 17:49So that creates ideas about strategists for context, including politics and strategy.
- 17:55Which is something business is trying to figure out, and I'm trying to figure it out.
- 17:58So I'm very excited about that.
- 18:00Political strategy, geopolitical strategy, strategies of context, things like that.
- 18:05So I'm writing a lot about that and thinking a lot about that.
- 18:07Context is critical.
- 18:09In the study of communication we have long known that context is absolutely essential to consider and thinking about its implications for business more broadly, I think, is exciting.
- 18:18And, and I'm glad people like you are doing that, and I look forward to learning from you as you explore further.
- 18:24Let's move to question two.
- 18:26Who is a communicator that you admire and why?
- 18:30I do admire Aristotle simply because he wrote so much with so much clarity about communication in rhetoric.
- 18:37He wrote about ethos and pathos and logos, and the thirteen fallacies of communication.
- 18:42It's hard to add anything to that.
- 18:44And I think in business, we're often also in the business of communication, so we have to give presentations, we have to communicate things to people.
- 18:52And is dead relevant stuff.
- 18:54Am I appealing to ethos, pathos or logos?
- 18:56And am I deploying any of the fallacies and am I deploying them effectively?
- 19:00Very important stuff.
- 19:01So he's one favorite let's say, communication theorist.
- 19:05You have quoted many times today, Aristotle, and certainly a foundational figure in effective communication.
- 19:11Logos being facts and statistics, pathos being emotion and ethos, being credibility, and how those all come together, very important for communication today, I would argue perhaps critically important.
- 19:24My third and final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 19:33I think I would start with listening.
- 19:34What do we say when we listen?
- 19:36Nothing.
- 19:37I think communication is often confused with outputting information.
- 19:41I think inputting information is important too.
- 19:43I'm not a particularly good listener, but I'm a student of listening.
- 19:47So I think deep listening, really understanding your audience is very important.
- 19:51I think landing your point is important, so listening and landing your point.
- 19:56So to think about what is the person is trying to solve for, that you're talking to, and how do they process information and what appears to excite them and, and making choices about how you communicate.
- 20:08So I don't just communicate your messages and the way that you always communicate them using your favorite language and devices, but tailor it to the situation so that your points actually land.
- 20:19And that's often about less, right?
- 20:20That's often about saying of the hundred things you could have said and choose this one.
- 20:25And then I think in case we get too serious in the pursuit of listening and landing, I think levity plays a great role too.
- 20:31I think the emotional plane of communication, I think humor.
- 20:35I think the sizzle of a story, I think these sort of lighter elements are part of the communication process and can greatly enhance it.
- 20:43So I think about those three things a lot, listening, landing, and levity.
- 20:47You know, from earlier, I love alliteration, not unnoticed, that the person who wrote a book called Like, came up with three characteristics based on the letter L. Listening, landing, really making sure it's relevant to the people you're talking to, levity, bringing some humor, and you actually had a bonus in there, which is say less.
- 21:05We tend to say more than we need to.
- 21:08Martin, this has been a fantastic conversation.
- 21:10We covered a wide range of topics from the role of communication and story and strategy to how we can use inspiration to blend inspiration and imagination, and then ultimately talked about the like economy and what the like button has meant for us in the past, what it means now and where it's taking us.
- 21:29Thank you so much for your time and best of luck on the book.
- 21:32Thanks very much.
- 21:32It was a fun conversation, Matt.
- 21:34Fun to be here.
- 21:37Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 21:42To learn more about strategy and communication, please listen to episode 71 with Jesper Sorensen.
- 21:48This episode was produced by Ryan Campos and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 21:52Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 21:54With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 21:57Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 22:00Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 22:03Also, follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram and check out FasterSmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.
- 22:12Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes, AMAs, Ask Matt Anything and much more at FasterSmarter.io/premium.