Latest / The Vegan Report / Vietnam: Beyond the Dog & Cat Meat Trade. With Catherine Besch | Reupload
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning Vietnam!
- 0:04Hello everyone, this is Ryan and you are listening to the Vegan Report.
- 0:08Last August I posted an episode featuring Catherine Besh, the founder of Vietnam Animal
- 0:13Aid and Rescue.
- 0:15And what is Vietnam Animal Aid and Rescue?
- 0:17Well, it's an animal sanctuary in the middle of a country, Vietnam, where the dog and cat
- 0:22meat trade is thriving, where most veterinarians have close to no veterinary knowledge, where
- 0:28you have one of the highest rates of antibiotic resistance in the world due to the overuse
- 0:34of antimicrobial drugs on farm animals.
- 0:38It is basically an animal rights hellscape.
- 0:41Which makes the work of Vietnam Animal Aid and Rescue crazy hard, but also essential.
- 0:48I am re-uploading the episode now because this wonderful organization urgently needs
- 0:54your support.
- 0:55They are in the red and I want to do my very best to keep their doors open as lives are
- 1:02at stake.
- 1:03I truly hope that this conversation inspires you to also take action and become a friend
- 1:10of Vietnam Animal Aid and Rescue.
- 1:13You can make a donation now by following the link in the description below.
- 1:17Let's dive right in.
- 1:21My first question for you is what circumstances led you to live in Vietnam?
- 1:27Yeah, it's sort of a strange story.
- 1:31This was all totally unintended experience to run an animal rescue in Vietnam.
- 1:37Basically Vietnam is something I've always grown up with though.
- 1:40My dad was a Marine officer in Vietnam who was shot in 1966.
- 1:46And he was then, he and my mother came back in the CIA in 1971 to 73.
- 1:52So I'm actually a legacy in Vietnam.
- 1:56This is the country I've known about since I was born.
- 2:00My dad used his time in the CIA, my mom in the US embassy, they use it as a shopping
- 2:06trip essentially because the government has to bring home all your household goods.
- 2:11And so my house was surrounded by Vietnamese furniture, Vietnamese art, Vietnamese ceramics,
- 2:17Vietnamese everything.
- 2:19And so like I was the four year old who could find Vietnam on a map and it's just always
- 2:24been like that.
- 2:25And so my parents are quite older, quite a bit as parents, quite a bit older.
- 2:31And so they, I kind of, they were getting older and I had left Mongolia the year before.
- 2:38It was horribly cold.
- 2:39If you're wondering, it's the coldest capital city in the world, Ulaanbaatar.
- 2:43And I was like, you know what, I need some sunshine.
- 2:45And this is a time in my parents' life where I want them to see what had happened to the
- 2:49country they loved so much.
- 2:51I brought, and I wanted to kind of bring that experience to them before they died.
- 2:56We're not real close as a family, but I thought this was something that would bring that to
- 3:01us.
- 3:02And I mean, it didn't really work exactly, but I, but I came and I fell in love with
- 3:07the place.
- 3:09I planned to stay only six months.
- 3:11I was doing my master's degree in disaster management online.
- 3:14And so I could kind of be anywhere in the world and I really wanted to follow international
- 3:17disasters.
- 3:18But Vietnam to me didn't like, it wasn't volcanoes and earthquakes, but we have seasonal flooding.
- 3:25And so I kind of took that as I, okay, well, this is my disaster to write about.
- 3:30I got typhoons and flooding.
- 3:33I'm kind of looking at how that, how that works in the developing world and, and how
- 3:38global south and, and, and that's just kind of what kept me here initially was that I
- 3:46was able to, to kind of sustain myself with my master's degree and some freelance writing
- 3:51while I was here.
- 3:52And then poof, I ended up with an animal rescue for the past decade and I never left.
- 3:58Yeah.
- 3:59Oops.
- 4:00Well, for someone who doesn't know much about Vietnam, how would you describe the place?
- 4:07Gorgeous.
- 4:08This is gorgeous.
- 4:10It's, it's a really beautiful and extremely green country.
- 4:17And the food is as a vegan is in my opinion, the best in the world.
- 4:21I haven't been to some countries that are known for their vegan food like Ethiopia as
- 4:26well.
- 4:27But, but I can guarantee you that we have, we have our, you know, we're pretty damn good
- 4:33here.
- 4:34So eating is definitely not a problem.
- 4:37I would say Vietnam is full of extremely friendly people.
- 4:40They call Thailand the land of smiles, which I think is crap.
- 4:45I don't think anybody smiles there.
- 4:47You come to Vietnam and you can see that they're just like a really friendly, outgoing sort
- 4:52of people.
- 4:54I think it's just warm.
- 4:56They're generally just really warm.
- 4:59I don't know.
- 5:00It's kind of, it's diverse.
- 5:03It's a very diverse country and people don't really give it that much credit for being
- 5:07so.
- 5:08I mean, we have four climate zones in the country.
- 5:10So that alone should show you that there is quite a bit of diversity.
- 5:15You know, like the North, it's typhoon season, for example, you know, and we won't get ours
- 5:20until October.
- 5:21And like, you know, it just kind of varies throughout the year.
- 5:26So, so yeah, I think the diversity, the mountains, everything are just really different, but
- 5:30it is very beautiful country and it never, I never stopped being surprised.
- 5:36You know, I think there's always more to discover just getting on my motorbike and driving into
- 5:41the mountains.
- 5:42And I always feel a sense of wonder here.
- 5:48There's no escape from that.
- 5:50One of my very best friend, her boyfriend is Vietnamese and she recently visited Vietnam
- 5:57and she showed me some of the pictures of the place.
- 5:59And I was like, I need to visit this place.
- 6:02It's so it's, you know, there are beaches, there are the foods, like you said, looks
- 6:08so yummy.
- 6:09We don't suffer for food.
- 6:10I can tell you that.
- 6:11Yeah.
- 6:12I mean, like, I don't want to paint a perfect picture though.
- 6:15Okay.
- 6:16Let me, let me, let me wipe the shine off what I just said real fast.
- 6:20Okay.
- 6:21It is a single party state with not an independent judiciary.
- 6:26It is highly oppressive to its own citizens.
- 6:32It is heavily censored.
- 6:34There are a lot of things.
- 6:35If you are a Vietnamese citizen, you are not living a great life in all cases.
- 6:41I mean, they are considered one of the happiest people in the world though, which is interesting.
- 6:46But as far as like having any, any, any ability to be part of the democratic process, that's
- 6:54not really a thing.
- 6:56It's very rare to be, to have anybody involved in the political situation here.
- 7:01That's not like already a suit.
- 7:04I call them suits, you know, the people, the people in suits, you know.
- 7:08So it's not particularly egalitarian in a lot of ways.
- 7:11I think women, you know, domestic violence is prevalent.
- 7:14I think animal abuse obviously is something that's a problem or I wouldn't be doing this.
- 7:21I think there's a lot of things that are negative about the traffic can be horrible.
- 7:25The honking is annoying.
- 7:27The karaoke makes me want to kill myself.
- 7:29There, you know, like I love to hate Vietnam and I hate to love it.
- 7:36It is my home in every possible sense.
- 7:39But, but it's not, it's not all shiny and pretty.
- 7:42I'm not going to, I'm not going to lie about that.
- 7:45I live a parallel existence as a foreigner in many ways because we're kind of to, to
- 7:51Vietnam, we're a bit of like walking ATMs being that we have a lot of cash to input
- 7:57as foreigners into the system.
- 7:59I have a, I have a fully foreign owned business license.
- 8:03So there, there's a lot of things that give me privileges that I wouldn't have otherwise
- 8:09if I were actually from here.
- 8:11So I don't, I, it's important to recognize the bad with the good.
- 8:17Yes.
- 8:18Well, you know, I had the view of a tourist, basically someone who was, you know, planning
- 8:26my vacation and thinking about Vietnam.
- 8:29But you know, even when I travel and I have traveled in many places around the world,
- 8:38I have every time witnessed a lot of displays of animal cruelty, you know, exotic, exotic
- 8:47animals on leashes in South America.
- 8:51I visited Greece.
- 8:52I was shocked by the number of dogs just in Athens, you know, their capital city welcoming
- 8:58you every time you went on a stroll.
- 9:02And yeah, Turkey and, and the cat situation there, you know, I was thinking about my time
- 9:10in Turkey and with the number of cats outside, I wonder how are the birds doing there?
- 9:19You know, they must be, no.
- 9:21Yeah.
- 9:22Yeah.
- 9:23And I mean, I'd say the same for Greece.
- 9:24I mean, those are probably, Italy is the same population, a high population of domestic
- 9:29cats.
- 9:30People are not sterilizing them.
- 9:32I mean, there are a lot of organizations in Greece at least because they've got a lot
- 9:36more help because they're in that part of Europe.
- 9:39But, and they have a lot of tourists and they have, you know, still in spite of all of Greece's
- 9:44economic problems, they still have a lot of people that are, that are putting money into
- 9:48those projects, including one of our staff, our director of operations.
- 9:52She lives in Greece and she does TNRs, Trap, Neuter, Release of cats.
- 9:57And so she's trying to help with getting that population down, but it's an endless cycle
- 10:03and there's not a lot.
- 10:04I mean, it's just so much work to keep that population down.
- 10:08And I believe those initiatives are the exception and not the rule.
- 10:12Yes, absolutely.
- 10:13Cause there's still so many people, I was out trapping with her.
- 10:16I love cat trapping.
- 10:17I used to do it in Alabama.
- 10:19And when I was living there and it is, it's frustrating because a lot of people think that
- 10:25it's unnatural to sterilize animals.
- 10:27They still have that very traditional and conservative mindset that it's just like,
- 10:31we shouldn't sterilize animals because we are taking away their natural right to give
- 10:35birth.
- 10:36And we try to explain to them when they were trying to prevent suffering and whatever.
- 10:39And this happened, this just happened, I guess in the past couple of weeks here as well,
- 10:44trying to sterilize a dog.
- 10:46And the guy was like, no, we just want her to have puppies again and again and again.
- 10:49And I give the puppies to my friend.
- 10:51And so we weren't allowed to free sterilization.
- 10:54We weren't allowed to do it.
- 10:55He's not interested in the wellbeing of the animal.
- 10:57He's interested in making sure that he is capitalizing upon another's reproductive system,
- 11:03just like you would in say the dairy industry or any other industry, breeding horses, for
- 11:09example, or breeding dogs.
- 11:11It doesn't really matter.
- 11:12It's all kind of part of the same vein of exploitation.
- 11:17Every time I witnessed those displays of cruelty toward animals or just, you know, bad, just
- 11:24neglect of the animal population.
- 11:27When we're talking about, like you said, cats or dogs, I was, what frustrated me the most
- 11:34was the feeling of being powerless.
- 11:37You know, it's not my country.
- 11:39I don't understand this country.
- 11:41I don't know how to help those animals.
- 11:46And even if I had, you know, the will to do so, I can't, you know, I'm going to leave
- 11:53in a few days.
- 11:54I mean, this is an impossible situation.
- 11:56So I just have to close my eyes, to look away, to just be in denial of what's happening.
- 12:02It's really hard.
- 12:03I live in a tourist town.
- 12:04It's the same thing.
- 12:05We get all these messages from people saying, I found this kitten on the side of the road.
- 12:09I'm leaving tomorrow.
- 12:11What can you take the kitten?
- 12:12No.
- 12:13Well, I mean, we can't because you're one of nine this week that have sent me that message.
- 12:20And I know you feel powerless and helpless and whatever, but like I don't own an island
- 12:25to put all these cats on.
- 12:27Let's get this straight.
- 12:28There is just no place for them to go.
- 12:29And you have to get used to the idea that you can't help everybody.
- 12:33And I think that's one of the worst parts of being a compassionate and empathetic person
- 12:37is being able to close your eyes and say, I understand the big picture.
- 12:41I'm doing everything I can on a daily basis, particularly as vegans to eliminate my part
- 12:49in exploitation, torture and murder.
- 12:53And that's bigger than what everybody else around here is doing.
- 12:58So you can't help every single individual.
- 13:02There's not the resources or the homes or the space or the veterinarians.
- 13:07And it just isn't like that.
- 13:09I mean, I can say that after 10 years running a rescue, but ultimately it is what led me
- 13:15to run a rescue.
- 13:17This idea of like, I'm not going to stand for this.
- 13:20I won't stand for this.
- 13:22I will do something.
- 13:24I am somebody who can do something.
- 13:26Well, I want to ask you about that because you did something and I want to know how did
- 13:35it start?
- 13:36How did the feelings of wanting to do something translated into actions?
- 13:43Coffee.
- 13:44Yeah, coffee.
- 13:45It's extremely strong here.
- 13:46This stuff's like jet fuel.
- 13:47Yeah, no, I mean, it really is.
- 13:52If you just go to your local Asian market, pick up some Vietnamese coffee and you won't
- 13:59even have to ask that question.
- 14:01This stuff is like, it's like, I don't know.
- 14:04It's stronger than your average cocaine.
- 14:07Yeah.
- 14:08It really messes with your idea of like, it makes you feel like a superhero.
- 14:13You know, it's a little bit like, yeah, it makes you feel like you can fly a little bit.
- 14:17And start an animal rescue.
- 14:19And like for that, I deeply regret that.
- 14:22But no, I mean, like at the time, you know, I'd been here six months, I guess I'd been
- 14:28here a year before, almost a year before I started the organization.
- 14:32I lived in one city for six months and then I came to Hoi An for six months and I had
- 14:36met some people.
- 14:37I met another girl who was willing to start a rescue with me.
- 14:40I was like, we've got to do something.
- 14:41She had like four cats at the time and people kept giving me animals.
- 14:46So I ended up with all these animals and I'm just like, because I'm just somebody who's
- 14:49always taking care of animals.
- 14:50I used to work with horses for, you know, 20 years and then now I've got this whole
- 14:57thing going on.
- 14:58This is just what I do.
- 14:59I'm just the person that people give animals to.
- 15:01I've always been like that, even when I was just a little kid.
- 15:06And so I kind of had this moment, there was this dog, Blair, who's still with us now and
- 15:12she was on the side of the road and she was mostly bald and she just was laying there.
- 15:19And I have this picture of her that I'll never forget.
- 15:21And she was terrified.
- 15:23And I just was like, you know what?
- 15:25No, no, not today.
- 15:28I'm done.
- 15:29I'm done.
- 15:30I'm done looking at this stuff and driving by.
- 15:31I can't do this anymore.
- 15:33And so the reason I started the organization was like, I realized that I couldn't afford
- 15:38a vet bill like that.
- 15:41This was going to be out of control and we needed to have some sort of public funding
- 15:45for this.
- 15:46So I took her to the vet.
- 15:50She was there for like a week, paid the vet bill.
- 15:53And then within the next couple of weeks, we put the organization on Facebook and we
- 16:00kind of got started.
- 16:01And then we had a fundraising party and got some money and just kind of it went from there.
- 16:06I had no idea how far it would go.
- 16:09I had no clue that it would end up just being we would be bombarded with animals over the
- 16:16next couple of years, particularly because we were the only people in the area doing
- 16:21anything.
- 16:22Central Vietnam, there was one foreign owned rescue in Saigon, but there was still none
- 16:30in Hanoi and there was none in central Vietnam.
- 16:34And we were just like, we were it.
- 16:38And so and so we just ended up being bombarded with animals.
- 16:42Most of them were dying anyway, and the vets were absolute garbage.
- 16:46And so they couldn't help us much.
- 16:48I luckily had worked with vets by working with horses.
- 16:51You know, working with horses is not the same saving kittens, by the way.
- 16:55I mean, the principles are kind of the same, but you essentially have to become a pharmacist
- 17:00slash drug lord.
- 17:02You've got to be able to you've got to be able to and we can get all of our we can get
- 17:06everything over the counter here.
- 17:07You don't have to have a prescription for anything so we can get our antibiotics.
- 17:10And as long as you've got a formulary for your dosages and can Google it.
- 17:16Basically I was a Google vet because there's a lot of things that the veterinarian knew
- 17:21nothing about.
- 17:22Nothing.
- 17:23No, it wasn't that he knew nothing.
- 17:25It's that he made up shit.
- 17:28And that made it much, much worse.
- 17:29So it was it was horrendous.
- 17:33So within the first year, I was like, we've got to start our own vet project because it
- 17:38was just so bad.
- 17:39Well, let's start first about the state of animal welfare in Vietnam.
- 17:44You know, the reason why you felt like you needed to create your organization.
- 17:49So you talked about the care, you know, the health care of animals.
- 17:54Why are the vets in Vietnam not skilled to deal with the current situation or were with
- 18:02anything that has to do with, you know, giving health care to animals?
- 18:07I mean, the connection we can't ever eliminate that connection between the public health
- 18:13care system and the veterinary industry.
- 18:15Right.
- 18:16People like to divorce the two and they think they're completely separate.
- 18:18And I think that's just ridiculous.
- 18:20We're doing that to our own detriment.
- 18:22So we're like 98th in the world and public health care.
- 18:26It's not a good place to be.
- 18:27It's not a great ranking.
- 18:30Just the general health care of the humans in this country is pretty bad.
- 18:35So when we talk about like being able to have animals get decent health care, you're starting
- 18:41from a horrible system that simply like they just don't understand pharmacology.
- 18:48They just don't.
- 18:49I mean, we have the second highest antibiotic resistance in the world.
- 18:52It's not, I mean, they'll give antibiotics out like TikToks.
- 18:55Wow.
- 18:56I mean, like, well, explain that for people, for people who don't know what it is.
- 19:02Great.
- 19:03So antibiotic resistance is basically you're, you know, there's all these bacteria that
- 19:08are becoming used to all the antibiotics that we're giving, giving them.
- 19:13And so they evolve.
- 19:15They evolve to be resistant to them.
- 19:18And if you keep giving antibiotics for all these bacteria, what happens is that you're
- 19:23just going to end up with antibiotic resistance.
- 19:25And that becomes a huge problem for hospitals and for people and for animals and the entire
- 19:31ecosystem for that matter.
- 19:33It's not limited to just humans and doggies and kitties.
- 19:36It goes far beyond that, particularly when we're talking about farmed animals and going
- 19:40into the food system and all of that.
- 19:42I mean, you know, that means if you hurt yourself and it's infected, we can't cure that normal.
- 19:52You know, normal treatment will not have any effects because the bacteria is causing the
- 19:56infection are resistant to any kind of drugs we have out there.
- 20:01It is absolutely, it's absolutely apocalyptic.
- 20:04You know, people aren't realizing that.
- 20:06And I mean, predominantly the over antibiotic use is in the animal agriculture industries.
- 20:12So I mean, we do it with people here too, but the animals and they're all getting it
- 20:17way more than the people are even.
- 20:19And of course that just creates this massive antibiotic resistant like playground in farms
- 20:28and things like that.
- 20:29So, but it's the only way people know how to cure anything because the conditions are
- 20:33all really dirty.
- 20:34So basic sanitation is just something they don't understand.
- 20:37When we had our vet clinic and eventually what happened was we had to open our own vet
- 20:41clinic.
- 20:42It was just a matter of like time.
- 20:44I mean, I saw a vet give a cesarean section without any anesthesia and I was like, you
- 20:49know what?
- 20:50I'm actually done with this crap.
- 20:51I'm not going back there.
- 20:52This is really fucked up.
- 20:53Pardon my French.
- 20:54So, so I, so I, I, we went kind of all in on the veterinary project and we hired a veterinary
- 21:03intern who had never learned how to wash your hands, who had never seen the inside of an
- 21:09animal dead or alive, who had been in veterinary school for five years, mind you, had only
- 21:17five years, never seen the inside of an animal dead or alive, never did any anatomy work,
- 21:22never did anything like that, never watched a surgery.
- 21:24She'd never seen a cat neutered.
- 21:26Did you ever, did you ever ask her what she did during those five years?
- 21:31Oh yeah.
- 21:32I mean, it was predominantly things like, like studying chemistry and microbiology.
- 21:36It was kind of like, like in the U S we have like, you have to get a science degree and
- 21:40then you go to vet school.
- 21:41It was kind of like all those little things, but just books that, you know, like the veterinary
- 21:48books and that were in their veterinary library, which was tiny, it was like smaller than my
- 21:53tiny house.
- 21:55They were all from like decades and decades and decades ago.
- 21:58And only one was, I remember looking through her library.
- 22:01There was one that was on canine surgery in English, of course, where nobody spoke any
- 22:06English, which is hilarious.
- 22:08And the book was written in 1955.
- 22:10That was their most recent book on canine surgery, 1955.
- 22:15I don't know about you, but we, I think, I think we can imagine that there's a lot that
- 22:20has changed since 1955 and canine surgery.
- 22:25So, so that was, that was a telltale of like a really poor education system.
- 22:32I've heard now that the better edu, the better universities are doing things like they have
- 22:36to be able to do a sterilization before they leave the university.
- 22:39But frankly, nobody's learning proper sedation protocols at all.
- 22:44They're just not getting it.
- 22:47Their understanding of basic animal anatomy and biology is piss poor, to say the least.
- 22:53But their practical skills, they don't have any animal handling skills.
- 22:57They fundamentally don't believe that pain management is something that should be discussed.
- 23:02And it's not because they're bad people, predominantly the people going into veterinary medicine
- 23:08or those that are, that are going to work in the animal agriculture industry.
- 23:12So they're going to be either paper pushers in the animal health department that are putting
- 23:15their stamp at slaughterhouses or they're working in the pharmaceutical industry, which
- 23:23is basically just making antibiotics to keep farmed animals alive until we murder them.
- 23:29So you're not really learning like basic care.
- 23:32So it's not even just cats and dogs.
- 23:33I mean, you have to look quite holistically at the veterinary industry and where it's
- 23:37failures are.
- 23:39But I think in the beginning, I didn't really understand how bad that was.
- 23:45I knew practically how they were failing, but I mean, they fundamentally didn't, you
- 23:49know, my vet here did not understand the difference between a steroid and an antibiotic in its
- 23:54function and, and, and applications.
- 23:56And it just, that's a big deal.
- 23:59You know, I'm astonished.
- 24:03I'm really big because you know, I have a cat and she's old and I don't know what I
- 24:09would do if I did not have, you know, her vet and yeah.
- 24:15And thinking about, you know, the whole animal industry, they rely a lot on vets.
- 24:23And so you have a whole, you know, the frontline, the, the, the frontline information is wrong.
- 24:31Yes.
- 24:32So what do you do?
- 24:33And not only that, you have to put it in perspective of how Vietnamese culture works in terms of
- 24:37hierarchy.
- 24:38So they're very much like, there's a lot of deference towards people of a higher rank,
- 24:44right?
- 24:45And so their ranking is like, okay, well, you have a doctor, doctor's degree.
- 24:48So you are the word of God and I'm not going to question you.
- 24:52Doctors, veterinarians here won't even tell you what medication they're giving your animals.
- 24:56They'll be like, oh, they have a liver infection and they get, and I'm giving him an injection.
- 25:01Injection of what?
- 25:02Right.
- 25:03So they just won't tell you that because that would make them lose face and they don't want
- 25:06to give away the information so that you'll just go to another vet and tell them what
- 25:10they, what they've done.
- 25:12So it is very like, it's really sick in that way.
- 25:15And that's true in a lot of parts of the global South in terms of the, and the public health
- 25:20system is exactly the same.
- 25:22They won't tell you what they're giving you.
- 25:24They won't give you information.
- 25:25They're just like, I am, I am the doctor.
- 25:28This is the word of God.
- 25:30And this is what's going, this is what it comes out of my mouth.
- 25:34And so it must be right.
- 25:35Do not make me lose face by asking any questions or by questioning my ability to provide you
- 25:41with great care.
- 25:43So if nobody's asking you questions and if they do ask questions, they'll just make something
- 25:47up if they don't know the answer, which is most of the time.
- 25:50So those pet owners, those people that really want to help their animals are not able to
- 25:55help their animals because the veterinarians aren't, aren't capable of providing just that
- 26:00basic care.
- 26:01And their, their information is, is so like, it's, it's the last word.
- 26:06Right.
- 26:07So, so there's, it's kind of a give and take sort of situation that just won't improve
- 26:12until the veterinary industry itself improves.
- 26:14And people are like, you should rescue animals and you should give, you know, help more animals
- 26:18with who, with who specifically, with what vets did you intend for me to rescue all these
- 26:23animals?
- 26:24Because the first few years or two years before we opened the vet clinic was all about just
- 26:29like having all these animals that we were watching die from things that were, that could
- 26:34have been treated because we simply didn't have the veterinarians that knew how to deal
- 26:38with it, could diagnose or talk to us even about what was going on.
- 26:44You know, we had hardly any diagnostics and if you don't have diagnostics, you don't have
- 26:48treatment.
- 26:49Okay.
- 26:50Like it begins with like, you have a blood machine.
- 26:52Well, do you know how much a blood machine costs?
- 26:55No, you don't have a blood machine, but could you do a blood smear?
- 27:00Could you look at it under the microscope and give us some answers?
- 27:03Well, they don't know what they're looking at.
- 27:04They weren't taught that.
- 27:05Right.
- 27:06So you're not going to get it.
- 27:07You're going to get sort of a vague, oh, they got a liver infection.
- 27:10Really?
- 27:11Are you sure about that?
- 27:12How do you know?
- 27:13Can you tell me why you said that?
- 27:15You know, I'm going to give them an injection of B12.
- 27:17Well, B12 doesn't solve everything.
- 27:20We have a B12 atropine ampicillin and say, you know, like saline, essentially.
- 27:24Those are these things that they just throw at every single animal and they're like, surprise,
- 27:30animals dead, you know, and we just, it's kind of like a situation you expect at some
- 27:36point to not have your problem solved when you go to the vet.
- 27:39So animal, people bring their animals to a vet knowing that it's probably like the last
- 27:45minutes of their life.
- 27:46So when the animal dies because of veterinary malpractice, it's not really surprising.
- 27:53Their interaction with the healthcare system as humans and with animals is just so negative
- 27:59that there's not like, they don't really expect miracles to happen at a veterinarian, you
- 28:04know, just like they wouldn't expect miracles to happen when their grandma's dying or to
- 28:08get any real help.
- 28:10You know, I was born in North Africa and the culture there is, you know, when I talk with
- 28:16family who still lives there and I tell them about my cat and how I bring her to the vet
- 28:24and the treatment I purchased, you know, for her, they feel like it's a joke because it's
- 28:33just a cat.
- 28:34Why are you spending your money on a cat?
- 28:37Right.
- 28:38Absolutely.
- 28:39I mean, there are people here that I've met that didn't know that a vet was a job.
- 28:42They didn't know that was a thing.
- 28:45So if we're saying like, you know, like the media attention of course is focused on that
- 28:51Asians are cruel to animals.
- 28:54I think we're missing a whole lot of that picture.
- 28:58This whole idea that there's this like savage anti-animal thing is just such a raging line
- 29:04of bullshit.
- 29:06It sells well.
- 29:07It sells well to dumb white people.
- 29:09But I mean, the marketing is excellent.
- 29:13But it's just a lie.
- 29:15It's just like they lack access.
- 29:17It's not like I ran a vet clinic that had predominantly Vietnamese staff, Vietnamese
- 29:21clients for almost three years.
- 29:24I guarantee you, nobody walked into that clinic thinking, I just don't care about this animal.
- 29:30We were constantly busy, you know, this idea that they don't care about animals or cruel
- 29:35to animals or whatever all the time just doesn't make any sense.
- 29:39I don't think there is a, it's just, it's just stupid.
- 29:42I mean, they're humans, humans and animals have had a close relationship for a pretty
- 29:47long time.
- 29:48Well, you know, I mean, before getting into the cultural differences, and I want to get
- 29:54to that because it's such an interesting discussion.
- 29:58I want you to continue your description of the state of animal welfare in Vietnam.
- 30:05We talked about the healthcare and how it is completely broken, to say the least.
- 30:11What about, and we touched on that, the stray population, you know, stray cats and dogs.
- 30:17Would you say that the country is in a state of crisis in terms of the number of...
- 30:23No, no.
- 30:24Do you know why?
- 30:26The dog meat trade, the dog meat trade and the cat meat trade.
- 30:29Yeah, people don't really want to acknowledge what this is.
- 30:32People are all boohooing about the dog and cat meat trade and they forget that that's
- 30:36our population control.
- 30:37The vast majority of animals in this country are called roaming-owned dogs.
- 30:42So we don't have a stray population.
- 30:44If we do, it's tiny.
- 30:47It's tiny, you know, and pretty much every dog and cat has a place it goes to get food
- 30:53and shelter from the rain and whatever.
- 30:57Are they taken care of there?
- 30:59Not necessarily, but it's not like a whole bunch of animals roaming.
- 31:04It's not like Cambodia.
- 31:05It's not like Laos.
- 31:06It's not like Thailand.
- 31:07It's not like, you know, it's not like a lot of other countries that have a large stray
- 31:11population where animals just literally exist without a person's direct care.
- 31:17That's not how it is.
- 31:19So we don't have a population control program in the sense that like the reason the animals
- 31:29still aren't lasting more than a year usually is disease, dog theft, animals being sold
- 31:36into the meat trade from people who own them.
- 31:40So it's not, so they have like a medical problem that the people aren't able to fix or whatever
- 31:44or the animal gets old or the animal bit a kid or something like that.
- 31:48They're going to sell it to the dog meat guy.
- 31:50So that's always going to happen.
- 31:51So that's behavioral medical issues that goes into the dog meat trade as well.
- 31:56The cat meat as well.
- 31:58Cat meat is quite a bit smaller, but cats are harder to catch to be fair.
- 32:03Dogs are always, cats are a little shifty, you know?
- 32:06But I would say, you know, people aren't looking at the fact that like if you get rid of the
- 32:11dog meat trade, you have to replace that with a functional population management system.
- 32:17And what's going to happen in Vietnam is that they're going to use culling.
- 32:21If there is no sterilization program that is widespread, the Vietnamese government no
- 32:26doubt in my mind will cull the animals with strychnine, will shoot them, whatever, which
- 32:32is what other countries like Myanmar have done and Cambodia.
- 32:36They just blanket kill them.
- 32:39You know, Egypt, I mean, there's a lot of countries that cull them like that, right?
- 32:43Because they're dealing with, you know, zoonotic diseases, particularly rabies.
- 32:48And if a kid gets bitten and gets rabies and dies, I guarantee you that entire population
- 32:53of that region is going to be culled.
- 32:56You know?
- 32:57So these are all things that like we have to consider.
- 33:00Plus there's a lot of infectious disease they get because animals aren't being vaccinated.
- 33:06So vaccination and sterilization have to come together, right?
- 33:09If we're going to improve the population or the lives of the population of the existing
- 33:15animals and prevent more from being born that are going to be born into a horrible life,
- 33:19we have to have sterilization and vaccination.
- 33:23Preventative care is the only care here, right?
- 33:25Otherwise it's going to be culling and it's the dog meat trade.
- 33:28That's how we manage the population.
- 33:29Because stray populations, man, that's how you have a lot of problems with human interaction.
- 33:35That's how you have the bites and that's how you have the zoonotic transfers.
- 33:40And we just, I want that to be understood very, very clearly about the dog meat trade.
- 33:47That it is our population management system.
- 33:50And if you erase it, if you ban it, which I don't believe is going to happen in a country
- 33:54with such weak rule of law to begin with, but if you ban it and it actually works, then
- 33:59you're going to have a whole lot of strays and it's going to be a different problem.
- 34:03But they're going to die one way or another.
- 34:05It's just, you have to choose which way it happens.
- 34:07Well, this is a strange economical activity because if there is a dog meat trade, why
- 34:15is there no dog farms?
- 34:18Why are they going after stray dogs?
- 34:22It's not really stray.
- 34:23I mean, they'll come and they'll steal them or people will sell them or whatever.
- 34:27They'll pick them up.
- 34:29So dog theft is a really big problem for sure.
- 34:32But I mean, to be clear, there's about, we estimate around 5 million dogs killed for
- 34:39meat every year.
- 34:41And predominantly that happens in the North, but it's really like in every village, the
- 34:45dog catcher I just saw yesterday, same guy I've seen for the past 10 years.
- 34:48They do the same job.
- 34:49They just drive around slowly in the middle of the day and they can pick up animals that
- 34:53people don't want anymore and they can get, you know.
- 34:56And they're called dog catchers.
- 34:57This is the dog catcher.
- 34:59Yeah.
- 35:00And they'll take it to a restaurant and whatever.
- 35:05Or they'll put them on a truck to Hanoi, something like that.
- 35:08I mean, the North eats a lot more dog meat than the rest of the country, but still, so
- 35:135 million dogs are killed every year, but let's compare that to the numbers in animal
- 35:17agriculture.
- 35:18So 551 million chickens are killed every year.
- 35:21That's a factor of 105 more, right?
- 35:24Yeah.
- 35:25Multiplier, 105.
- 35:27That's not a small amount.
- 35:2844 million pigs are killed.
- 35:30So if we're looking at the, if you look at the whole picture, dogs are actually like
- 35:340.7% of the animals killed in this country, not including sea life.
- 35:41It's a tiny, tiny amount.
- 35:44And people just absolutely lose their mind.
- 35:46Five million is a lot.
- 35:48And if I think about, you know, like you said, if there was no dog meat trade, we would have
- 35:54five million dogs in the streets.
- 35:57What?
- 35:58Yeah.
- 35:59Five million doesn't stay five million for very long, does it?
- 36:02You know what they're doing in the streets.
- 36:04They're shagging.
- 36:05Yeah.
- 36:06It's not just, they're not just hanging out, not making babies.
- 36:09That five million is going to be 25 million within a year.
- 36:12Right?
- 36:13So like you want, and what are they going to do with that 25 million?
- 36:16I guarantee you're going to find a way worse way than the dog meat trade to kill them.
- 36:21Guarantee it a hundred percent.
- 36:22That's the way the Vietnamese government works.
- 36:24So that's their version of, you know, protecting the public health.
- 36:30So yeah, I mean, it is, I mean, five million is a lot.
- 36:33We are a country of 97, 98 million people.
- 36:36It's a very large, densely populated country.
- 36:39So if you kind of put it into perspective, I think people, people still are thinking
- 36:42this is a tiny little country, you know?
- 36:45I mean, it's really not.
- 36:47And it's very densely populated as well.
- 36:50So it's Asia.
- 36:51It's Asia.
- 36:52It's Asia.
- 36:53I mean, but we're so much more densely populated.
- 36:55Like Laos has like 6 million people in it and there are neighbors.
- 36:59It's super weird.
- 37:00Nobody lives in Laos.
- 37:01I don't know why I've never been to Laos, but there doesn't seem to have people in it.
- 37:04It's a strange exception to the Asian Union.
- 37:06It's a weird exception to Asia.
- 37:08So weird.
- 37:09So I can't wait to go because maybe it's actually quiet because Vietnam is not.
- 37:14So yeah, I mean, I think people need to put it into the larger perspective of how many
- 37:18animals that is by comparison.
- 37:20Am I saying the dog meat trade is a good thing?
- 37:22And I think this is where it gets confusing.
- 37:24No, I am firmly against the dog meat trade.
- 37:26I have stopped dog catchers myself.
- 37:29I have taken animals from the dog meat trade.
- 37:32I have been to the restaurants.
- 37:34I have been, I've done all of this stuff.
- 37:35I see how they're killed.
- 37:37I see all of this.
- 37:39The dog catchers in my neighborhood every single day.
- 37:42I don't have to wonder about the dog meat trade.
- 37:44This is a real part of my daily life.
- 37:46I'm not some, you know, talking head in Los Angeles or London that's like, oh, boo hoo,
- 37:52the dog meat trade.
- 37:53Yeah.
- 37:54Okay.
- 37:55Well, you were on vacation here at the freaking Hilton for two weeks.
- 37:57You don't know diddly dick about, sorry, about the dog meat trade, but it's really true.
- 38:03It's just like all the people that cry about it are also non-vegans anyway.
- 38:08You can't talk about the dog meat trade if you got bacon grease dripping down your chin.
- 38:12I'm sorry.
- 38:13Like, I'm just not buying it.
- 38:15Well, if I wasn't on a trip in Vietnam and I saw, you know, a scooter with a dog in a
- 38:25cage and I would look at that, I would think, oh, that's, what is that?
- 38:30And then that's it.
- 38:32The idea of those are going to a restaurant and people are going to eat them would not
- 38:38even register in my mind because I have this cultural bias of, oh, but dogs are not for
- 38:44food.
- 38:46Dogs are, you know, our best friends.
- 38:48So yeah, I think there is also this bias of, you know, you don't really notice until you
- 38:55notice until.
- 38:56Until you notice.
- 38:57And it is, it is revolting for the first couple of years of the organization.
- 39:01We talked about dog meat endlessly.
- 39:03I mean, it was, it was something, even though I was vegan, I would, but I mean, I was vegan.
- 39:08So it kind of like, I feel like vegans are allowed to talk about a little more.
- 39:11If you're not vegan, you're talking about the dog meat trade.
- 39:13I need you to shut up.
- 39:15Like, it's just, I have no patience for that.
- 39:19But, but I would say, I would say in the first couple of years, it is something that you
- 39:23see and it, and it, and it shakes you to your core.
- 39:27You know, I remember even just in November, I was in Cancun, which is a big city, one
- 39:31of the biggest cities in the South.
- 39:34And there was a whole bunch of dogs just packed like there, there's no way they could have
- 39:39put any more in this time in this small cage that they put on the back of a motorbike.
- 39:45And it really is, even after all these years, it makes you sick.
- 39:50Even though I have seen, so I've seen one dog truck on the highway where all the animals
- 39:55were stuffed in cages and they were going north.
- 39:57And in that time, in 10 years of watching, of this organization and looking at animals
- 40:05in horrible situations, I've seen one dog meat truck, I've seen lots of dog catchers.
- 40:10But in that time, I've seen thousands upon thousands upon thousands of chicken trucks,
- 40:17duck trucks, goat trucks, cow trucks, pig trucks, all of these animals that are being
- 40:22slaughtered in such larger numbers than the dogs.
- 40:27And yet the only thing people focus on when we talk about Vietnam and when we talk about
- 40:32animal cruelty and animal welfare in general is the dogs.
- 40:35And the thing is, I'll admit, you see them more.
- 40:40You just see them more.
- 40:42Dogs are such an integral part of human life in every part of the world.
- 40:48Where can you go in the world where there's not somebody with dogs?
- 40:52They're a big part of our lives.
- 40:53So we focus on that and I get it.
- 40:55They are wonderful.
- 40:56I love my dogs.
- 40:58I love dogs.
- 40:59I love animals, you know, but but ultimately their suffering is an extension, not an exception.
- 41:09It's an extension of the existing industries of animal exploitation that exist all over
- 41:14the damn planet, everywhere and every country.
- 41:18And in fact, the Vietnamese eat one third of the meat that an American does.
- 41:24One third, that is a that is a fraction of what Americans are producing in dead bodies.
- 41:32So Americans eat three times as many dead bodies of animals that suffered and died for
- 41:38no good reason than the Vietnamese.
- 41:40Right.
- 41:41And I mean, that varies throughout the country, of course, depending on poverty levels and
- 41:45whatever.
- 41:46But still, yeah, let's get into that.
- 41:48It was the best friend I mentioned the food she showed me, you know, it looked really
- 41:54good, but it was also packed with meat.
- 42:00There was meat everywhere, animal products everywhere.
- 42:03And I was really.
- 42:05Is that different from Canada?
- 42:06No, no, no.
- 42:07Go to a restaurant.
- 42:08If I mean, I come back from Alabama and I'm like, where's all that?
- 42:13How am I supposed to eat here?
- 42:14True.
- 42:15You know, like I come down, I go to Alabama and be like, I can't even go to a restaurant
- 42:19because they put butter on every damn thing.
- 42:21They put butter and cheese on steamed vegetables.
- 42:24I just want some steamed vegetables.
- 42:25Throw me a salad that doesn't have cheese and egg in it or chicken on top of it.
- 42:29You know what I mean?
- 42:30Like I would say I would say it's much worse in other countries than Vietnam.
- 42:34There is a lot of cheese in Western, you know, cooking.
- 42:38But you know, I saw a lot of meat, just lots of meat.
- 42:44But they're little pieces.
- 42:45Yeah.
- 42:46OK, because you have to eat them with chopsticks.
- 42:49Right.
- 42:50So it may look like a lot of meat, but fundamentally, if we're talking about weight, it's actually
- 42:56a tiny amount of meat by comparison to others because we don't use knives here.
- 43:01So here, I mean, in the in the West, you have big chunks of meat that you cut with a fork
- 43:07and knife.
- 43:08Right here.
- 43:09We have to be able to get these little pieces out with chopsticks.
- 43:12That's right.
- 43:13So just like the actual volume is significantly smaller.
- 43:18Is it in a lot of dishes?
- 43:19Yes.
- 43:20But here's the thing about vegan food, because we are a Buddhist country in which the Buddhists
- 43:24here, this type of Buddhism is where they are vegan twice a month, full moon and half
- 43:31moon.
- 43:32Some people are vegan only for two days.
- 43:34Some people are vegan for four days.
- 43:36Some people are vegan for 10 days.
- 43:37And some people are vegan all the time.
- 43:39Right.
- 43:40And as a result of that, that is all over the country.
- 43:44Those all of those things that you saw that were meat, they replicate in vegan food.
- 43:50Right.
- 43:51So every single dish is made into a vegan version of that to be fed to people on full
- 43:58and half moon.
- 43:59Which are called, I think, upasatha days.
- 44:03But yeah, that's that's where the surprise came from.
- 44:07The fact that I was not expecting that from Vietnam, because in my mind, Vietnam is a
- 44:13Buddhist country.
- 44:14So why are they eating so much meat?
- 44:18Why are they exploiting animals so much?
- 44:22Because you look at China and there's this big vegetarian movement in China.
- 44:30And you look at India, same thing.
- 44:33And you can see the influences of Buddhism and Hinduism and such.
- 44:38So I was expecting the same from Vietnam.
- 44:41But no, not exactly.
- 44:43I think there's a lot of I mean, as they get richer.
- 44:46And this is true around the world.
- 44:50As as countries get richer, they are also increasing the amount of dead bodies in their
- 44:56food.
- 44:57That is that's just the standard graph.
- 44:59You know, like it just goes up together.
- 45:02So Vietnam is becoming wealthier and they don't have like a vegan movement in that regard.
- 45:08They don't the Buddhists don't really I mean, they're all you know, all the pagodas are
- 45:13all vegan, you know, all of that.
- 45:15But like, ultimately, they're not like spreading the word of veganism on its own.
- 45:19It's about compassion and whatever.
- 45:23But ultimately, that doesn't mean that they're not raising animals.
- 45:26It doesn't mean, you know, they're not like it hasn't or their family members or whatever.
- 45:31They're not it's just a very different version of like the vegan movement from like the UK,
- 45:37for example, you know.
- 45:39But but I don't see it at all in Thailand, frankly.
- 45:43You know, I don't I mean, I mean, as far as vegan food in Thailand, I mean, I'd give a
- 45:47big thumbs down to that.
- 45:49I mean, like, you know, of course, like in Bangkok and stuff, it's fine.
- 45:52And there are lots of places throughout the country.
- 45:54But it's not at all like in Vietnam, where you can get vegan food any place you go.
- 46:00You know, there's always a a chai place.
- 46:02Chai.
- 46:03Chai.
- 46:04Yeah.
- 46:05How do you explain that disconnect that, you know, twice a month they eat vegan for they
- 46:11get it.
- 46:12Yeah.
- 46:13Yeah.
- 46:14Because then all of a sudden, nothing.
- 46:15I don't get it.
- 46:16I don't get it.
- 46:17I don't get it.
- 46:18It makes me endlessly angry.
- 46:19I am constantly pissed off at foodists for being like, I mean, I live in a constant state
- 46:25of like, what are you missing here?
- 46:29Because they get it.
- 46:30It's like full and half.
- 46:31And their food is great.
- 46:32And they're eating the same stuff and like all these great dishes and this beautiful,
- 46:37you know, the why don't you do it all the time?
- 46:40Exactly.
- 46:41You have the cultural basis, the religious basis, and you have great vegan food, great
- 46:46vegan options.
- 46:47So why is there no, you know, support?
- 46:50I think a lot of it is nutrition.
- 46:53A lot of people have this idea and are brought up with the idea of just like Americans that
- 46:57you need meat to survive, that meat makes you strong and without it you are weak.
- 47:02Right.
- 47:03So I think a lot of it is nutrition based.
- 47:06And that's just wrong information.
- 47:08The same wrong information I was given as a child, you know.
- 47:12So we go back to the broken healthcare system.
- 47:15Oh, absolutely.
- 47:16Absolutely.
- 47:17And they're like, you know, it's just trying to feed people meat in order to be healthier.
- 47:22And when in reality it's quite the opposite, but it just doesn't make any sense.
- 47:27I get it.
- 47:28I mean, it makes me really, it makes me really angry.
- 47:32I get pretty pissed off at Buddhists.
- 47:34Yeah.
- 47:35So how do Vietnamese people perceive your sanctuary?
- 47:39That's complicated because I live, you know, I live in a tourist town, right?
- 47:44It's a UNESCO World Heritage Site.
- 47:46So it's an old city that was built by the Chinese and Japanese in the 15th century.
- 47:53And so we have this beautiful old town.
- 47:55And so we have a large influx of foreign influence, right?
- 48:00So it's not like I'm some weirdo for doing this, but in the beginning it's taken a long
- 48:04time for them to accept it.
- 48:07But they're still like, I'm still about three kilometers from the center, which is like
- 48:12countryside here, which I think is really funny.
- 48:16And so there's still a lot of people, the people that live here may have gotten wealthier
- 48:21from work in town, but their education hasn't changed and their experience with the world
- 48:27hasn't really changed that much.
- 48:28So I think people think it's ridiculous what we do, you know, but in general, but then
- 48:35there's a lot of people that really support it as well.
- 48:40You know, I mean, there's a lot of people, a lot of Vietnamese just love doggies and
- 48:43kitties, which is standard around the world.
- 48:47But the idea of being a vegan organization and being specifically like anti-speciesist
- 48:52is something that is really, really brand spanking new to this country.
- 48:58And we are the only farm sanctuary in the country.
- 49:02We're the only anti-speciesist organization.
- 49:04We're the only vegan rescue.
- 49:06So that makes us, from being an animal rescue, which they only kind of get anyway, to being
- 49:11a farm sanctuary is a big leap, you know, and to be like somebody who loves dogs and
- 49:18doesn't eat pigs.
- 49:19Like that's like, why would you do that?
- 49:22You know, like, but that's true in every country.
- 49:24I don't feel like that.
- 49:26We get that same problem.
- 49:27And whether I'm in France or in, you know, Costa Rica, they're like, so wait, you love
- 49:33dogs and you don't eat other animals?
- 49:37Are you sure that's normal?
- 49:39Are you okay?
- 49:40Yeah, no.
- 49:41I mean, really.
- 49:42So we are freaks in a lot of ways, not just to the local people.
- 49:47What?
- 49:48Well, honestly, Kat, it's good that you're here.
- 49:53It's good that you're in Vietnam.
- 49:55Yeah.
- 49:56So let's talk about this.
- 49:57Let's talk about your sanctuary.
- 49:59Who are the residents there?
- 50:01And what are your current projects?
- 50:03Right.
- 50:04So, I mean, currently we're trying really hard to get our veterinary project restarted,
- 50:08but we've been trying for like four to five years at this point.
- 50:11It's very difficult to get the money for it because people here are veterinary and they
- 50:14just don't think that it's worthy of any funding, especially because we're a vegan vet clinic
- 50:21and an anti-speciesist project, which ruffles a few feathers.
- 50:25I'm not going to lie.
- 50:27I was built to ruffle feathers.
- 50:29That's kind of what my whole life purpose is.
- 50:32But anyway, it's difficult to get funding for.
- 50:34So we have a sanctuary where the only, like I said, the only farm sanctuary in the country,
- 50:39as far as we know, there is another one.
- 50:41Nobody's been able to find it for us.
- 50:44But we, so we've got two pig residents that are eight and 12.
- 50:50Basically the oldest of their breed in the entire country.
- 50:53We've got four chickens who are lovely.
- 50:55They came to us just this spring.
- 50:57Come on, we've got nine kittens, which is so many.
- 51:01I can hear the one screaming behind me.
- 51:03There's four in the room just behind me.
- 51:06I fed you, be quiet.
- 51:09I wanted them to be quiet during this podcast anyway.
- 51:13So and then we've got another five that were just sterilized yesterday and we've got, I
- 51:18think 15 other cats.
- 51:20And then we've got, we're really reducing our number of dogs.
- 51:23We're really working hard to reduce the number of animals as much as possible because we
- 51:28need to put all of our funds into the veterinary project, which will ideally be a mobile veterinary
- 51:33clinic.
- 51:34So reaching the people that don't have access to veterinary care and providing vaccinations
- 51:38and sterilization.
- 51:39So ongoing preventative care in the rural regions in central Vietnam.
- 51:45And also being able to train Vietnamese veterinarians that are fresh out of graduate or fresh out
- 51:50of school.
- 51:51So we get them before they've learned anything really stupid.
- 51:54And then we train them up so that they're being trained by our international veterinary
- 51:58staff.
- 51:59So this is a big project we wanted to get started in January, 2024.
- 52:04But yeah, at the moment we have something called Kittenmas, which is getting rid of
- 52:10all the kittens, getting them all re-homed by Christmas.
- 52:13We want all those babies to have homes by Christmas because people don't realize that
- 52:19every single animal is a real drain on our ability to do preventative work.
- 52:24Not only on our time, but also on our financial resources and physical space.
- 52:30So we really want to get all those babies out as quickly as possible to safe and loving
- 52:35lifelong homes, which is far harder than you'd ever imagine it to be here.
- 52:40So we can also export, we have, I guess, three animals going in September to Paris and then
- 52:48they'll go to the UK.
- 52:49So we do international exports as well.
- 52:51Also if you want to adopt animals, we definitely can do the rabies titer test and microchip
- 52:56them and get them sent over within 90 days.
- 52:59Yeah, so we're able to get some animals out, but it's just a matter of like, that is a
- 53:05hugely expensive process that is so, so inefficient in terms of like the number of animals in
- 53:13need here.
- 53:14The biggest problem is that it takes so much.
- 53:17I mean, like I'm happy they all have homes.
- 53:19I'm really happy that I've been able to provide that.
- 53:21I just did three last month to the UK and Paris and I'm super happy about that.
- 53:27They deserve lifelong loving homes, but it took so much money and so much time and effort
- 53:33to get them on those planes and then to get them transported.
- 53:36And I had to rent a car to drive across the UK to bring them to Wales in the middle of
- 53:40nowhere.
- 53:41I mean, like it was some serious work.
- 53:43I'm super happy they're there, but like we have to be a lot more efficient if we're going
- 53:47to address the problem that exists, right?
- 53:50Like I said, 5 million dogs are killed for dog meat every year.
- 53:53If we could sterilize a thousand a year, you know, like we're making a huge dent on it,
- 53:58but we can't do that.
- 54:00If I'm, if my time and all of my staff time is spent just trying to maintain the sanctuary,
- 54:08trying to just keep our heads above water in terms of funding our overhead, which has
- 54:14just been really hard.
- 54:17And, and trying to move forward with a project that's actually going to do the amount of
- 54:22work that we need to do for the number of animals that are actually in need.
- 54:26My job is to go out of business, right?
- 54:28And it's to, I, I, my whole job is to have no more animals to rescue, right?
- 54:35How am I supposed to do that?
- 54:36If I'm focused on, on getting a puppy to Paris, you know, how am I supposed to focus on that?
- 54:41If all of our time is taking animals and rehabbing them and paying vet bills and then putting
- 54:46them on airplanes to someplace else because local adoptions are so rare.
- 54:50And you're not actively looking for them.
- 54:54I mean, sometimes people come and just dump them at your front door.
- 54:59Yeah.
- 55:00Yeah.
- 55:01Most of them are being dumped on us.
- 55:04You know, one of the poodle that went to, to Wales, she was locked in a, she was zipper
- 55:10tied in a beer crate and left at the end of our driveway.
- 55:14The four kittens that we just got right here, they were dumped on, at the, at the shelter
- 55:20and the other four, they were also dumped.
- 55:23We had to bottle feed them every three hours when we got them.
- 55:25That wasn't fun.
- 55:27That takes all of my energy and sanity to do.
- 55:30So, so yeah, I mean, like most of them, I mean, there are some that we find for sure.
- 55:36There are some that were like, basically most of our animals that came to us came from major
- 55:41medical cases.
- 55:42So they were animals that were like in a, like actively dying and we intervened, you
- 55:48know, but unfortunately people, people get quite excited about that on the day that they're
- 55:52rescued and don't understand that the vast majority of them are going to end up not being
- 55:56adoptable or having very major difficulties being adopted, particularly when it comes
- 56:01to cats and that we're going to have them for the next 15 years, but paying those expenses
- 56:06for like the existing residents in a sanctuary is unbelievably difficult.
- 56:11People do not want to, they want, they're happy to be like, Oh, I'm going to help you
- 56:14pay this vet bill for this animal you got today.
- 56:17Okay.
- 56:18Well, what about the next 15 years?
- 56:20What are you going to do about that animal then?
- 56:22So ongoing expenses tend to be very difficult for all rescues around the world.
- 56:28People it's just not, it's not sexy.
- 56:32Overhead isn't sexy.
- 56:34Paying vet bills for a nine year old cat that never got adopted when we got him as a kitten.
- 56:39Not sexy.
- 56:40So, um, so unfortunately just the entire business model of sanctuary and shelter and rescue
- 56:47here does not function because locally it's so difficult to get adoptions.
- 56:51It's not, we're not in California.
- 56:53We're in Vietnam.
- 56:54Most people here, like I said, have owned roaming dogs.
- 56:57So the animals are not safe.
- 56:58We do not adopt to anybody that lets their animals roam around.
- 57:01So everybody that has a dog will have to have it safe indoors and in a protected garden,
- 57:08which 99% of people here don't have.
- 57:11Um, otherwise that animal is going to get stolen and killed, or it's going to end up
- 57:15getting an infectious disease.
- 57:16It's going to end up being in a traffic accident.
- 57:19So we don't adopt to people like that, which eliminates the entire local population for
- 57:24that matter.
- 57:25Same with cats, cats.
- 57:26We only will adopt to indoor homes, but it's a very hot country.
- 57:31Everybody has their windows open.
- 57:32Everybody has doors open all the time.
- 57:34So we can only adopt to people living in apartments and those apartment buildings have to have
- 57:38to allow cats.
- 57:39So that is just in general, like our ability to take animals is hampered by the fact that
- 57:46they got to go somewhere.
- 57:48You, you can't just take them.
- 57:50It doesn't, it actually doesn't work like that.
- 57:52The math doesn't work out, you know, because the amount of animals that need to be taken,
- 57:57we simply just don't have the capacity to just keep adding more and keep adding more
- 58:03and keep adding more while we're ignoring the preventative work that prevents those
- 58:07more from coming.
- 58:08Right.
- 58:09So that balance has to rebalance.
- 58:12It's way off at the moment.
- 58:14Well, local shelters here, you know, North America have a hard time finding homes for
- 58:20their residents.
- 58:21So you're in Vietnam, you're not in a friendly environment for, you know, animal welfare
- 58:29and you have to do the same job.
- 58:30It's 10 times harder.
- 58:32So truly you have all of my admiration.
- 58:35No, but you're, you're doing some miracles here and it's sad to see how, you know, even
- 58:46on, on the international scene, you know, sometimes it feels like Westerners and people
- 58:52in richer countries have like, have more values and medias in, you know, everyone pays more
- 59:01attention to what happens in the West, even if it's something minor, but then there's
- 59:06a catastrophe and it's taking the lives of, I don't know how many people in a poor country
- 59:12and nobody pays attention, but that, that same dynamic applies to animals.
- 59:19There are also animals in Vietnam and in other parts of the world who are suffering and you
- 59:26know, we're so focused on animals here, which is understandable, but what about the rest
- 59:33of the world?
- 59:34So it's in your community and you're paying attention to the ones there.
- 59:37Well, imagine that you live in a country in which nobody pays attention to that.
- 59:42And the people here don't pay attention to it.
- 59:44And the only people that pay for us to do this work live like 7,000 miles away.
- 59:49You also have to consider that our funding is not coming predominantly from the poor
- 59:53residents of the country that we live in and a community that does not understand or care
- 59:58about the work that we do.
- 1:00:00Right.
- 1:00:01So they don't, they don't get what's going on predominantly and they don't want to participate
- 1:00:05in it in terms of philanthropy.
- 1:00:08So, so not only are we ignored by people abroad because the only thing that people think about
- 1:00:13here is the dog meat trade or the Vietnam war, but we also just don't have access to
- 1:00:19the funds to keep going in terms of like rescue and rehabilitation, rehoming, you know, we
- 1:00:25just don't, I mean, it's very difficult to get people to connect to Vietnam.
- 1:00:30Most people couldn't find us on a map.
- 1:00:32So we're really in a major disadvantage.
- 1:00:35And then you add to it, the fact that we are an anti-speciesist vegan organization, which
- 1:00:39pisses everybody off, you know, like we are outspoken and absolutely will not stop talking
- 1:00:48about abolitionism.
- 1:00:50And I guarantee you that does not make us any friends.
- 1:00:53So you take a giant pool of people that otherwise would support us even amongst the local population,
- 1:00:58because we're helping animals in general.
- 1:01:00And a lot of the Buddhists find that to be valuable.
- 1:01:03But then you then you're like, oh, but we're vegan.
- 1:01:06And they're like, oh, I don't know.
- 1:01:08That's really confrontational for me.
- 1:01:10Yeah.
- 1:01:11Why?
- 1:01:12Because you kill animals.
- 1:01:13Yeah.
- 1:01:14Yeah, you do.
- 1:01:15So we actually don't kill anybody and I'm not going to judge you and be mean to you,
- 1:01:19but I'm not going to lie about it.
- 1:01:21You know, my son is a pig.
- 1:01:24My real son is a pig.
- 1:01:25I know that sounds insane, but he is my son.
- 1:01:29And I love him more than anything in the world.
- 1:01:31And if you think he's edible, you don't support our work and you don't love animals.
- 1:01:36If that gets you all hurt because of the because of the fact that it confronts you, you need
- 1:01:40to look at yourself, not at me as being somebody judgmental or whatever.
- 1:01:45You need to step back and be like, am I harming animals?
- 1:01:48Yeah, we rescue animals from you if you're not vegan.
- 1:01:54That's a hard thing for people to take in.
- 1:01:58We rescue animals from non-vegans.
- 1:02:02That you are.
- 1:02:05You are a sanctuary.
- 1:02:06What are you protecting your residents from?
- 1:02:09It's the local population.
- 1:02:11The people are around.
- 1:02:1398% of the human population.
- 1:02:16Right.
- 1:02:17So like, it's insane that we're like, we're really having to defend ourselves against
- 1:02:21people that think my son is edible, you know, and our chickens belong on a Caesar salad.
- 1:02:27Yeah, because they couldn't figure out that like plants have protein.
- 1:02:30I don't know, like stop talking to the marathon runner Iron Man triathlete who doesn't think
- 1:02:37that you need to murder an animal.
- 1:02:39You know, like, I'm sorry, we're not in the same boat.
- 1:02:42So like, we do, we are confrontational on that degree.
- 1:02:46But it's like, in that regard, I think, but that's just kind of who I am as a person.
- 1:02:51And I'm never going to stop being that.
- 1:02:52I mean, I was kind of a virulent meat eater before I was a vegan as well.
- 1:02:57I hated vegans.
- 1:02:59I told people I wanted to put them on an island in Napalm.
- 1:03:03Like I just was super anti-vegan.
- 1:03:05Yeah, I was a fox hunter and I worked for the National Turkey Federation in Washington,
- 1:03:10DC.
- 1:03:11I mean, I worked for the farmers lobby.
- 1:03:13I mean, like people change.
- 1:03:14I get it.
- 1:03:15And I'm just, but people don't change unless you talk about it.
- 1:03:18So vegans that run animal rescues that don't talk about veganism, they really upset me
- 1:03:23the most because the animals don't need silent vegans.
- 1:03:26They need people who are willing to stand up for all species.
- 1:03:29And it's not going to be the ones that are doggy, loving pig eating animal rescuers.
- 1:03:35It's not going to be them.
- 1:03:37It has to be us.
- 1:03:38And we just have to stand up and I guarantee you're going to lose a lot of money doing
- 1:03:42it.
- 1:03:43But ultimately we've got what?
- 1:03:442.8 trillion animals that are unnecessarily killed every year.
- 1:03:48And I'm pretty sure if they had to choose between somebody who is just going to keep
- 1:03:52their donors happy and somebody who is going to stand up for them, they would take somebody
- 1:03:56standing up for them and taking a hit.
- 1:03:58You know, we work for animals.
- 1:04:00I don't work for the public.
- 1:04:03And at least you want to support someone who is wholeheartedly in the fight.
- 1:04:09You know, someone who looks at your sanctuary knows that you're here for the good reasons,
- 1:04:16you know, and you're not going to, you know, this is not something about you.
- 1:04:22This is not your really, you know, you believe in your cause and you're doing your
- 1:04:27If I were greedy, this would be a horrible place to be.
- 1:04:30This would be the worst possible job.
- 1:04:34People are like, Oh, you do it for the money.
- 1:04:37Really?
- 1:04:38Show me the money.
- 1:04:39Show me.
- 1:04:40I would love to see that.
- 1:04:41Well, at least people should appreciate it.
- 1:04:44Did I just forget my pin code to my ATM?
- 1:04:46Is that where the money is?
- 1:04:48Oh, no, no, no, no.
- 1:04:50We don't get anything out of this.
- 1:04:51I guarantee you.
- 1:04:52There is no joy in this work.
- 1:04:55It is all about the animals and we do the best we can.
- 1:04:58I mean, it kills us all the time, but you know, like I said, people should at least
- 1:05:03appreciate, you know, your feelings, your sincerity in what you're doing at the very
- 1:05:09least, you know, they know that you're not bullshitting here.
- 1:05:15So if listeners want to support your sanctuary, what should they do?
- 1:05:24We definitely use the funds, but more than funds, I would say, you know, like donating
- 1:05:29is great, but so is helping us get animals adopted so that we can move on to the to the
- 1:05:36veterinary program.
- 1:05:37I would say being able to share our work is really nice and to be able to say, Hey, there
- 1:05:42is a morally consistent animal rescue in Vietnam who loves and does not kill animals.
- 1:05:49We should support them.
- 1:05:51I would say also, you know, you can always do fundraising for us, which would be really
- 1:05:56great things like running a race because I'm a big runner or I was until my foot fell apart.
- 1:06:02But I really love it when people do athletic events and they fundraise for us in that way,
- 1:06:07because that's really good for us for not only for the funds, but for marketing in general,
- 1:06:12getting the word out about us.
- 1:06:14We are in kind of a dark space in the sense of we have very small reach for the organization
- 1:06:21and and getting just getting the word out is really, really helpful so that we have
- 1:06:26a wider reach for our work.
- 1:06:29And that gives us availability of more resources to do the work that we need to do and to get
- 1:06:35more animals adopted and to be able to to get more staff to be able to get more more
- 1:06:42to get the veterinary project rolling again and have just a wider reach to be able to
- 1:06:47do that is invaluable.
- 1:06:49And the idea of, you know, fundraising for your organization, you know, make it fun,
- 1:06:54make it something, you know, it doesn't have to be like a whole sporting event.
- 1:06:59It can be just a garage.
- 1:07:03But it can be just a garage sale.
- 1:07:05You know, it can be.
- 1:07:06Yeah, exactly.
- 1:07:07It can be going door to door or having a or a table at the entrance of your supermarket,
- 1:07:13something like that.
- 1:07:14And, you know, talking with people, you know, gather with friends and do a game night and
- 1:07:20for for your sanctuary.
- 1:07:22So yeah, it can take so many forms.
- 1:07:25And to end this conversation, Kat, did you want to add something?
- 1:07:30Yeah, I mean, there's just one thing that I think people people forget is compassion
- 1:07:35fatigue is a big subject for me.
- 1:07:37And I think people I want people to be a lot more compassionate to people that work in
- 1:07:41this field because we go through and see a lot of things that we can't necessarily always
- 1:07:49share and we shouldn't have to share.
- 1:07:52And it can be very dark and isolating.
- 1:07:54This is an unbelievably isolating job.
- 1:07:57Even when we weren't, you know, being I think I think being where we are and being a vegan
- 1:08:04organization and all of that makes it very isolating.
- 1:08:07But I think even if you're in California, it can be very isolating if you run a farm
- 1:08:10sanctuary or veterinary project or whatever, particularly as vegans.
- 1:08:15And we see such horrible things.
- 1:08:17And I want people to just really understand where people are coming from and to not be.
- 1:08:21So I need the peanut gallery to shut up.
- 1:08:24I would say I would say to acknowledge that people that work in this field need days off.
- 1:08:32Not all of us can be volunteers.
- 1:08:33To be a volunteer is a financial luxury that the vast majority of us that are professional
- 1:08:38caretakers don't have.
- 1:08:41I don't have a partner.
- 1:08:42I don't have family money.
- 1:08:43I don't have, you know, like a big credit card limit.
- 1:08:46You know, like we I can't be a volunteer.
- 1:08:49I do take a very small salary.
- 1:08:52We have a hard time even justifying that we pay our staff.
- 1:08:57And I think that's insane.
- 1:08:59Not everybody's in the same situation in every part of the world.
- 1:09:02And we have to be really mindful of that.
- 1:09:04But just in general, like understand that this is a really traumatic job.
- 1:09:08And when you send people pictures of the dog meat trade or whatever, you're constantly
- 1:09:12re like we see plenty of horrors.
- 1:09:15Like we don't have any any lack of that in our in our brains.
- 1:09:20And it's very, very stressful.
- 1:09:22And we also have to say no to a lot of animals.
- 1:09:25And that that sticks with us our entire lives.
- 1:09:28I mean, I I remember every time I said no to an animal because I know that certain
- 1:09:33death and people get very, very, very pushy online with rescues.
- 1:09:38And it's just like you have to take this animal or I'm going to put him to sleep or this person's
- 1:09:41going to get it and whatever.
- 1:09:42And sometimes people don't understand the lack of resources.
- 1:09:46Sometimes we just don't have quarantine space.
- 1:09:48Sometimes we just don't have the staff or we don't have the money.
- 1:09:50We don't have the vets.
- 1:09:51We can't help.
- 1:09:52And we have to acknowledge and accept that we can't save everybody.
- 1:09:56And I think as long as everybody has that sort of understanding of the individual humans
- 1:10:01that do this work that I do, we can all be a lot more compassionate towards them and
- 1:10:07ensure that they do have real breaks, that they do have a living wage, that they do have,
- 1:10:13you know, adequate staff to make sure that they don't burn out burnout.
- 1:10:17I mean, in the United States, the average person working in animal welfare and any sort
- 1:10:22of rescue is five and a half years.
- 1:10:23I've done double that in Vietnam.
- 1:10:25I assure you it has taken its toll.
- 1:10:27Right.
- 1:10:28So I think people need to really understand that this is a burnout job and to be kind
- 1:10:33to the people and not just be like, oh, you're an angel and whatever.
- 1:10:38But then the moment we want to take a vacation, you're like, I can't believe you're taking
- 1:10:41a vacation.
- 1:10:42Yeah.
- 1:10:43Well, yeah, I'm going to museum today.
- 1:10:46What are you going to do about it?
- 1:10:48Let me add to what you said, you know, you want the nonprofits, the causes that you are
- 1:10:57supporting to be run by professionals that are well paid and that who have the same,
- 1:11:06you know, standards of employment that you have because you want the best people behind
- 1:11:11your cause.
- 1:11:13You don't want like anybody coming in and just doing whatever.
- 1:11:19This is not how things get done.
- 1:11:21You need professionals and you need professional conditions.
- 1:11:25And that's something very counterintuitive.
- 1:11:29And it comes from, you know, this Christian background of, you know, you're not a non.
- 1:11:35Yeah, you're not a non doing the God's work or something like that.
- 1:11:41No, we're being professional.
- 1:11:43No, we're people that have student loans.
- 1:11:45Yeah, we're humans that have health insurance.
- 1:11:50We have to we have to drive something.
- 1:11:52We have to have friends.
- 1:11:54We have to we have to participate in the world like everybody else or our job suffers.
- 1:11:58And I know that more than anybody, because for most of this 10 years, I didn't have any
- 1:12:01of that.
- 1:12:02And, you know, for the first three years, I didn't take a salary at all because I was
- 1:12:06doing my master's and I had a small income from student loans.
- 1:12:09And then I started my Ph.D. and so which I had to quit because I didn't have time for.
- 1:12:15But ultimately, yeah, I got nearly 200 grand in student loan debt.
- 1:12:18I mean, it's not like I'm in deep trouble.
- 1:12:21I'm in deep trouble for being in this job.
- 1:12:24But I live far away.
- 1:12:25Come and get me, America.
- 1:12:26You know, like I paid it.
- 1:12:29Don't tempt them.
- 1:12:31Don't tell them I'm here.
- 1:12:34But but but in general, I mean, I think that we need to professionalize the nonprofit world
- 1:12:38in the sense that like people aren't going to do good if they can't live a normal life
- 1:12:42while doing good.
- 1:12:43We can make so much more money in the private sector.
- 1:12:46If I if I just ran a vegan business, I would be rolling in it with the amount of effort
- 1:12:50and cash in that I put into it.
- 1:12:53But instead, I'm working in a nonprofit and I get nothing and people think I deserve nothing.
- 1:13:00And that is very frustrating.
- 1:13:02And also, I want people to think about what you are against, you know, the the animal
- 1:13:09industry, but also the big problems that you're going against.
- 1:13:13You know, it's a David versus Goliath situation.
- 1:13:18I try to get through a day without punching anyone.
- 1:13:21That's my that's actually like if I get to the end of day and I'm like, you didn't scream
- 1:13:25at anybody.
- 1:13:26You didn't pull a knife on anyone.
- 1:13:28Nobody got kicked in the face.
- 1:13:30You're doing great, cat.
- 1:13:32Keep it up.
- 1:13:33Well, you know, that's my job here.
- 1:13:35Well, you need all my job here.
- 1:13:37All the possible, you know, best resources behind you.
- 1:13:42You need everything in your arsenal to go against that big giant.
- 1:13:46So so let's stop this conversation here.
- 1:13:51And I would like to express truly how I respect what you do and I admire what you do.
- 1:13:59And I think you're so strong for doing what you're doing.
- 1:14:03And having taken the time to answer my questions and to explain to listeners what is happening
- 1:14:11there and share your insight and experience.
- 1:14:15You know, this has been a valuable 10 years.
- 1:14:19I learned a lot.
- 1:14:20Yeah, exactly.
- 1:14:21You're an expert now on this topic.
- 1:14:23And definitely your your voice on that is truly precious.
- 1:14:28So thank you very much, Kat.
- 1:14:31Thank you for letting me voice that.
- 1:14:32I think it's not it's not often I get to express like the things that have happened
- 1:14:38here and discuss kind of the realities on the ground.
- 1:14:40So I appreciate it.
- 1:14:42Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:14:44I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans, you know, let's encourage
- 1:14:49more people to take action.
- 1:14:51Again, thank you so much for caring.
- 1:14:54And I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.