Latest / Kentucky Tonight / 2026 Kentucky General Assembly Session Wrap Up
Transcript
- 0:05Kentucky. Tonight, I'm Renee
- 0:06Shaw and we thank you so much
- 0:07for being with us tonight. The
- 0:092026 Kentucky General
- 0:10Assembly's 60 day session is
- 0:12coming to a close tomorrow and
- 0:14Wednesday. Lawmakers will
- 0:15consider overriding bills
- 0:17vetoed by Governor Andy Beshear.
- 0:19He's already vetoed 30 bills,
- 0:21with four already having been
- 0:24overridden. Tonight. We'll talk
- 0:25about lawmakers actions on the
- 0:26two year state budget,
- 0:28education policy, gambling. And
- 0:30what about measures on housing?
- 0:32And will there be an
- 0:33impeachment trial for a
- 0:35Lexington judge in the coming
- 0:36days to discuss all this? We
- 0:38have an hour Lexington studio
- 0:40for legislative leaders, state
- 0:43Senator Robert Stivers, a
- 0:44Republican from Manchester and
- 0:46Kentucky Senate president,
- 0:47state Senator Gerald Neal, a
- 0:49Democrat from Louisville and
- 0:51Kentucky, Senate minority floor
- 0:52leader state Representative
- 0:54David Osborne, a Republican
- 0:56from Prospect and Kentucky
- 0:57House Speaker and state
- 1:00Representative Joshua Watkins,
- 1:00a Democrat from Louisville and
- 1:02Kentucky House minority whip.
- 1:04We certainly want to hear from
- 1:05you tonight. You can send us
- 1:06your questions and comments by
- 1:08X, formerly known as Twitter,
- 1:09at Pub Affairs KET. You can
- 1:11send an email to KY Tonight at
- 1:14ket.org or use the web
- 1:16form@ket.org. Johnny Nash KY
- 1:18Tonight. Or you can simply give
- 1:19us a call at one (800) 494-7605.
- 1:23Well, welcome gentlemen. Thank
- 1:24you for being here. Almost to
- 1:26the finish line. Maybe, maybe,
- 1:28maybe we're going to start
- 1:30right there, Mr. President. So
- 1:32over the weekend, you said in a
- 1:34news interview with Bill Bryant
- 1:35that there is a 5050 chance of
- 1:37a Senate impeachment trial
- 1:38involving Fayette Circuit Judge
- 1:39Julie Goodman. And just to
- 1:40remind folks and we have talked
- 1:42about it, the Kentucky House
- 1:43Impeachment Committee found
- 1:44that she abused her judicial
- 1:46discretion and authority over
- 1:47six cases, cases in which she
- 1:49presided. You all had a meeting,
- 1:51I think, the Senate and the
- 1:52House today to talk about where
- 1:54you are, where are you, and
- 1:56will there be an impeachment
- 1:58trial that happens starting
- 1:59maybe the 16th?
- 2:00>> Well, first of all. People
- 2:04need to understand the process.
- 2:05People want to know why this is
- 2:08in effect right now. Well, it's
- 2:09what the Constitution says
- 2:11should happen for all
- 2:13individuals who hold these
- 2:15types of positions. The ability
- 2:18to impeach lies with the
- 2:21legislature.
- 2:22>> And the Kentucky Supreme
- 2:23Court said as much, right?
- 2:24>> They did. And and it is
- 2:26within their own articles where
- 2:28they are defined that the right
- 2:31of impeachment is inviolate and
- 2:34stays with the General Assembly.
- 2:35>> And violet means protected.
- 2:38>> It is protected. So our
- 2:40right to do the impeachment
- 2:42process is protected by the
- 2:45Constitution. And it doesn't
- 2:47matter what else is in the
- 2:49Constitution. We set the rules,
- 2:50we set the process, and then we
- 2:53determine whether it rises to
- 2:54the level of an impeachable
- 2:56offense. There were petitions
- 2:58filed against four individuals,
- 3:00at least four, I think. But
- 3:03there was also a resolution
- 3:04which the Supreme Court got
- 3:06wrong. They thought that this
- 3:07was a Kelly antimony resolution
- 3:11or impeachment. It's actually a
- 3:13resolution filed by a House
- 3:15member in the House. So when
- 3:17the Supreme Court opinion came
- 3:19down, I believe it was
- 3:20blatantly wrong in several
- 3:23positions. One, they enjoined
- 3:25the General Assembly, which the
- 3:26Senate nor I were ever joined
- 3:28in any litigation. So when I
- 3:30said that statement with Bill
- 3:33Bryant of the day, we hadn't
- 3:34been able to go through
- 3:35everything. But we are not in
- 3:39any way going to preclude
- 3:42ourselves from starting
- 3:43sometime after the 15th.
- 3:47>> Okay. So does that mean the
- 3:48session adjourns?
- 3:50>> It adjourns. If we go
- 3:52forward, it adjourns only to
- 3:54the aspect that we cannot
- 3:57consider any more legislation.
- 3:59But the Senate can stay in
- 4:01session as long as it takes to
- 4:04do an impeachment.
- 4:05>> But the House would be
- 4:06adjourned.
- 4:07>> They would.
- 4:08>> We had no choice but to
- 4:09adjourn on midnight April 15th.
- 4:14That said, our prosecutorial
- 4:17committee that will prosecute
- 4:18the impeachment right will
- 4:20remain and prosecute. And I
- 4:21will tell you that they they
- 4:23are fully prepared to to remain
- 4:25in prosecute the impeachment.
- 4:27>> So last week, there was a
- 4:28press release sent out from the
- 4:30Senate majority's office that
- 4:31mentioned several dates, and it
- 4:33would start on the 16th and
- 4:3517th. And then the judge
- 4:36Goodman could make her defense
- 4:37some days after. And then by
- 4:39April 24th, there seemed to be
- 4:41almost a conclusion that could
- 4:42be rendered at that time. Are
- 4:44you still sticking to that
- 4:45schedule.
- 4:45>> At this time? We are, but we
- 4:47also know because of work that
- 4:50we've been doing on the budget
- 4:52and other things, to conclude
- 4:55the session, we may have to
- 4:57delay that a few days.
- 4:58>> And you can decide. That's
- 5:01right. And is there a time
- 5:03limit by which you have to
- 5:04determine that you need to be
- 5:05back in session? I mean, is
- 5:07this open ended.
- 5:08>> It I think 115 years ago,
- 5:12the last impeachment trial in
- 5:15the Senate lasted a little over
- 5:1730 days.
- 5:19>> Okay. And it can start as
- 5:20late as June, July, August.
- 5:22>> We we can stay in session
- 5:25for this sole and singular
- 5:27purpose.
- 5:28>> Is there still pay during
- 5:29that time?
- 5:30>> It is. And we have
- 5:31calculated it.
- 5:32>> How much is it?
- 5:33>> Around $30,000 a day.
- 5:37>> Okay, so let me ask this.
- 5:38>> We knew you would ask that
- 5:40type question.
- 5:41>> You know me, sir. Okay. What
- 5:42do you think? Louder Neal.
- 5:44>> Well, I have to see how the
- 5:46process plays out because we'll
- 5:48be sitting as a jury with
- 5:50respect to that. So it just
- 5:53depends on procedurally what
- 5:54happens. And we have to see how
- 5:56it unfolds.
- 5:57>> Representative Watkins, you
- 5:58have said many times on the
- 5:59House floor that you're new to
- 6:01a lot of this, and you had
- 6:02remarked about these
- 6:03proceedings when they were
- 6:04happening in the House. What's
- 6:06your final takeaway here?
- 6:08>> I think this is a solemn
- 6:10occasion. I believe that
- 6:11everyone takes seriously. If I
- 6:12can just echo the note from the
- 6:15last impeachment trial being
- 6:17115 years ago, that that lets
- 6:19you know how rare I think these
- 6:21occasions are being in the
- 6:23House. I think our voice that
- 6:25there were some differences of
- 6:26opinion in terms of what I
- 6:27believe rises to the level of
- 6:29of an impeachment, but the
- 6:31Constitution is the
- 6:32Constitution. So I just like
- 6:33many other Kentuckians, are
- 6:34going to watch the process play
- 6:36out and then hope, from my
- 6:39personal perspective, I hope
- 6:40that there is a a resolution
- 6:42that allows for all of the
- 6:46unanswered questions to be
- 6:47answered, and hopefully we
- 6:49don't have to revisit such an
- 6:50occasion in the near future.
- 6:52>> Right? So given people may
- 6:53be confused because they
- 6:55learned last week about the
- 6:56Kentucky Supreme Court ruling
- 6:57that said this should be halted,
- 7:01essentially these proceedings.
- 7:02So a trial does not necessarily
- 7:05indicate that she is guilty.
- 7:07That just means you're working
- 7:09to find out whether or not she
- 7:12needs to be impeached.
- 7:14>> What what the process is
- 7:15basically is like the House
- 7:17does a preliminary hearing or
- 7:19what some people may consider
- 7:20the equivalent of a grand jury.
- 7:23They make a potential charge,
- 7:25deliver us articles of
- 7:28impeachment. And I've said this
- 7:29to Senator Neal and everybody
- 7:30in the chamber, stay away from
- 7:33press stories, newspaper
- 7:35stories, because we are just
- 7:37that. We are a jury. I do not
- 7:39know what their proof is.
- 7:41>> And you haven't seen their.
- 7:42>> I haven't seen it, haven't
- 7:44heard it. We stayed away from
- 7:45it. So we will start that
- 7:48process. The only thing I know
- 7:49about it is what I've read in
- 7:52those articles that were
- 7:53delivered. And the court's
- 7:55ruling, which I think was
- 7:58intriguing to say the least.
- 8:01>> Because they say that one,
- 8:02that the impeachment petition
- 8:03was invalid, that she hadn't
- 8:04committed any impeachable
- 8:06offenses and that she was not
- 8:08afforded Judge Goodman due
- 8:10process. Mr. speaker, do you
- 8:12have any comment on this
- 8:13process and where we are now?
- 8:15>> You know, I am I'm a
- 8:17non-attorney, so I get to to be
- 8:20poorly informed on these on
- 8:21these issues. But I will tell
- 8:24you that we are confident that
- 8:26we're on sound and, quite
- 8:28frankly, unambiguous
- 8:29constitutional footing in this
- 8:31issue. As I said, our
- 8:34prosecutorial committee is
- 8:36standing ready to prosecute
- 8:38this. They believe in the the
- 8:40issue that they have raised as
- 8:44President, Stivers said, you
- 8:46know, the the issue of the
- 8:48petition has been mooted
- 8:51because it was a resolution
- 8:52that was filed, which is what
- 8:54we acted on. So again, to to
- 8:58Representative Watkins point,
- 9:01there is nobody that seeks that
- 9:02sees any any Lee in this in any
- 9:05way, shape or form. This is a
- 9:07very solemn occasion, and I
- 9:08think every single member of
- 9:11the. The body felt that the day
- 9:14that we voted to to adopt the
- 9:17resolution, you could see
- 9:19people that were on both sides
- 9:20of it that were torn, that were
- 9:23were solemn about the fact that
- 9:25we had reached this level. You
- 9:27know, there's lots of lots of
- 9:30discussion about whether this
- 9:31will become, you know, a more
- 9:33common tool that will be used
- 9:35as political fodder. And I
- 9:38think that if for those that
- 9:40are watching closely to the the
- 9:43demeanor of the people on the
- 9:44floor that day, the way the
- 9:46committee conducted themselves,
- 9:47the way the Chamber conducted
- 9:49themselves, I think absolutely
- 9:51they understood the gravity of
- 9:55of the situation. And I think
- 9:57if anything proved quite the
- 9:59opposite, that nobody wants to
- 10:00go through this for any purpose,
- 10:04particularly a political
- 10:05purpose again.
- 10:06>> And the legal remedies that
- 10:08would be here that are
- 10:10forwarded to the jury who votes
- 10:13to perhaps to convict. I don't
- 10:15know if vote is the right word.
- 10:16>> It will be.
- 10:17>> A vote. It will be a vote.
- 10:19Right. There are two options,
- 10:20right? Three, three. What are
- 10:22they.
- 10:22>> To find? No impeachment. And
- 10:25I want to say this to my
- 10:28colleagues. I have stated I
- 10:29start as a no. They have to
- 10:31convince me to be a yes because
- 10:33this is we're setting aside an
- 10:37election where potentially
- 10:39setting aside a person's
- 10:41qualifications to hold elected
- 10:43office. So one is no
- 10:45impeachment. Two is an
- 10:46impeachment, which is removal
- 10:47from office or impeachment with
- 10:50removal from office and banning
- 10:52the individual from ever
- 10:54holding an Office of Public
- 10:56Trust.
- 10:57>> So and I'm pardon me if this
- 11:00is in the weeds. So you talk
- 11:01about a resolution. It was
- 11:03House resolution 124 that
- 11:04contained six articles of
- 11:06impeachment. Do you vote on
- 11:09just the resolution or the
- 11:11individual articles? Does that
- 11:13make sense?
- 11:13>> Yes it does. And what we're
- 11:15going to do is what we did and
- 11:17has been done in the past, and
- 11:18we're mirroring what we have
- 11:20seen done at the federal level,
- 11:21which has been upheld by the
- 11:23federal courts as
- 11:24constitutional. There will be
- 11:25an impeachment hearing
- 11:27committee that is chaired by
- 11:29Brandon Storm. They will hear
- 11:31this, and then they're going to
- 11:32come back with a recommendation.
- 11:33And that was the schedule with
- 11:35recommendations. And there can
- 11:36be a minority report and a
- 11:38majority report, and we can
- 11:40vote it in total or
- 11:43individually, depending on. And
- 11:45it may be they come back with a
- 11:47recommendation of one, two,
- 11:49three, 4 or 5 or some
- 11:51combination thereof or a
- 11:54recommendation. No impeachment
- 11:54at all. Right. And we've been
- 11:56very clear, we don't know. We
- 11:58you know, it's we don't know
- 12:00what the outcome will be.
- 12:01>> So if the outcome is options
- 12:03two and three to to remove from
- 12:08office and to ban from future,
- 12:10is that appealable to the
- 12:12Kentucky Supreme Court.
- 12:13>> In my opinion, no.
- 12:15>> Is there a different opinion
- 12:16about that?
- 12:17>> Oh, there's probably a
- 12:18different opinion.
- 12:19>> Lawyer leader Neal.
- 12:22>> Well, I'm not going to speak
- 12:24for the court, but I think
- 12:26there are some separations of
- 12:28in terms of the function of the
- 12:30legislature versus what the
- 12:32judiciary does. So I haven't
- 12:34researched that particular
- 12:35point. But if it's ruled that
- 12:37they have separate
- 12:38responsibilities
- 12:39constitutionally, then it could
- 12:40end up being that way.
- 12:42>> And Renee, if if it is
- 12:44appealable to the court about a
- 12:47member of the court and this is
- 12:49what the Constitution was
- 12:51framed on, is a series of
- 12:53checks and balances. Why did
- 12:55our initial framers of our
- 12:58Constitution give us that power?
- 13:00And in the 19, I think, 74 or
- 13:0476 Judicial Reform Act, it
- 13:07remained in there in that act
- 13:10which established the Supreme
- 13:12Court at the time, which is
- 13:14questionable because it was
- 13:16done by ballot initiative, not
- 13:17by full text, which this
- 13:20Supreme Court has ruled
- 13:22unconstitutional. You know,
- 13:24that that is it was retained in
- 13:26that that that right, that
- 13:29obligation, that constitutional
- 13:31duty remains with the
- 13:33legislature inviolate.
- 13:35>> Okay, so final question,
- 13:36because I could go on this the
- 13:38whole hour, the Judicial
- 13:40Conduct Committee or commission,
- 13:42what's the role here with them?
- 13:44And are you seeking information
- 13:47from that said commission?
- 13:49>> Just found out about that
- 13:50the other day in the opinion
- 13:52was the first time we
- 13:54questioned, you know, why has
- 13:56the JCC not acted? And it's
- 14:00kind of interesting. We
- 14:03understand there may be two
- 14:04petitions. They have the
- 14:06ability to sanction, remove,
- 14:09suspend, but they've not acted.
- 14:12And what was very curious to me,
- 14:15and I don't know what prompted
- 14:18it, but I have suspicions that
- 14:21after this came out of the
- 14:23house, numerous attorneys
- 14:25started reaching out saying,
- 14:26well, we want to talk about
- 14:28more with this judge. Don't
- 14:30know what they want to talk
- 14:31about, but they want to talk
- 14:33about more. And what we heard
- 14:36was we were afraid to file
- 14:38petitions in front of the JCC,
- 14:40because then we had to go back
- 14:41before this judge. And that
- 14:43made it very tough.
- 14:45>> Yeah. Any other comment on
- 14:46this before we move on? Just a
- 14:48quick follow up. Yeah, sure.
- 14:49>> On the JCC issue, Renee, at
- 14:52several points during the
- 14:55initial testimony that was
- 14:58taken and documentation that
- 14:59was sought in the House
- 15:01impeachment by the House
- 15:02Impeachment Committee, the
- 15:04Judicial Conduct Commission was
- 15:05asked on a number of occasions
- 15:07if in fact, there was anything
- 15:08pending before the Judicial
- 15:09Conduct Commission. They
- 15:11refused to answer. And so we
- 15:14had to operate under the
- 15:17assumption that there wasn't
- 15:19because we had nothing to the
- 15:20contrary to prove otherwise.
- 15:22>> Yeah. My only comment is
- 15:24that, you know, as been stated,
- 15:25I'm not privy to any of this
- 15:28information. We're in a
- 15:31position in the Senate. People
- 15:32like me waiting to see what
- 15:34comes to us. And what happens
- 15:35on another level happens on
- 15:37another level. If we're going
- 15:39to sit and we'll sit as a jury
- 15:41and hear the evidence at that
- 15:43time and make a decision.
- 15:44>> And this would all happen in
- 15:46a committee hearing room, right
- 15:47in Frankfurt, right.
- 15:49>> Open to the.
- 15:50>> Public, open to the public.
- 15:51And KET would would cover that.
- 15:54Okay. I just want to last
- 15:56question, I promise on this. I
- 15:57think.
- 15:58>> You said that two questions.
- 15:59>> I said that two questions
- 16:00ago, but I just want to make
- 16:02sure I understand I'm a little
- 16:03slow. This this session would
- 16:06not be terminated and you would
- 16:08remain in session. Could you
- 16:10not signee die as regular
- 16:13knowing that perhaps you need a
- 16:15month or two and then you be
- 16:17able, as Senate president, to
- 16:18call into special session for
- 16:19the sole purpose of the
- 16:20impeachment trial.
- 16:21>> I.
- 16:21>> Cannot you cannot.
- 16:22>> I can only extend session.
- 16:25>> Okay. All right. So this is
- 16:26good. We've had a good civics
- 16:28lesson here. I think.
- 16:29>> We had a really good
- 16:30constitutional amendment a
- 16:31couple years ago. That's right.
- 16:33Allowed us to do that.
- 16:34>> Okay, Mr. Speaker, I'm going
- 16:35to let you pick up on that. And
- 16:37wasn't that filed again this
- 16:38year? Was that filed again this
- 16:40year?
- 16:40>> It was filed again.
- 16:41>> This year. So. So let's tell
- 16:43viewers what you're talking
- 16:44about here.
- 16:45>> Basically with just allow
- 16:46for allow us to as the way the
- 16:48sessions are structured right
- 16:49now, we have hard drop dead
- 16:50dates March 30th and April 15th,
- 16:53by which we have to adjourn our
- 16:56session sine die. And and in
- 16:59some iteration, those
- 17:01constitutional amendments would
- 17:02have allowed for us to hit a
- 17:04pause button bank days and say,
- 17:07okay, we need to pause right
- 17:08now, ignore the April 15th date
- 17:12because we need more
- 17:13information, we need more time
- 17:14to do something and then
- 17:16reconvene beyond that.
- 17:19Unfortunately, those that that
- 17:20amendment was defeated, but I
- 17:22still think it makes for better
- 17:24government to do it. And and
- 17:26we're going to continue to
- 17:27pursue it eventually.
- 17:28>> Yeah. What do you think of
- 17:29that idea this side of the
- 17:31table?
- 17:31>> I think it works fine just
- 17:33the way it is.
- 17:34>> You Watkins.
- 17:35>> You know, I think that any
- 17:38opportunity to provide more
- 17:39clarity on processes and gives
- 17:41us more time to do so is just
- 17:43better for the people of the
- 17:44Commonwealth. I do want to go
- 17:46back really quickly if I can,
- 17:47because I was a new member. I'd
- 17:49say that not far removed from
- 17:51being a lay person. And so I
- 17:52got to participate in these
- 17:54impeachment proceedings. And
- 17:55one of the things that that
- 17:56still gives me pause and I
- 17:57still think gives a lot of
- 17:59people pause is just this, this
- 18:00understanding of what a
- 18:02misdemeanor in office really
- 18:02means. And so when I hear
- 18:04misdemeanor, I think of
- 18:05something that is criminal. And
- 18:07but upon going through these
- 18:09processes, I found out that
- 18:10that is not necessarily the
- 18:12case. There could be terms like
- 18:15misfeasance and malfeasance.
- 18:16Those are very subjective terms
- 18:18as to what a person
- 18:20individually thinks. Here's why
- 18:21I think that.
- 18:21>> Is, are those things rise to
- 18:23the level of a crime, though.
- 18:25>> If they. That's my question.
- 18:26Do they rise to the level of a
- 18:28crime? And here's why I think
- 18:30any other administrative
- 18:31process before impeachment is
- 18:32really important. And I think
- 18:34they're bringing up the
- 18:35Judicial Conduct Commission is
- 18:37exactly that. I wanted to see
- 18:39some sort of evidence that
- 18:40there were complaints or
- 18:41something given beforehand, and
- 18:42I give pause to hearing the
- 18:44fact that a judge doesn't
- 18:45necessarily want to complain
- 18:47about another judge. It sounds
- 18:49like to me, at risk of having
- 18:52some sort of retribution. And
- 18:53if that is the case about our
- 18:55legal system, then I think that
- 18:57is levying a sort of warning to
- 19:00the entire structural integrity
- 19:01of our institutions that I
- 19:03think is a nightmare for what
- 19:05democracy is. But at the
- 19:07baseline level, if I, as a
- 19:09person who participated, still
- 19:11finds myself confused, and I'm
- 19:12not a constitutional scholar
- 19:14and don't have the benefit of
- 19:15being a lawyer like my
- 19:16colleagues, I think there that
- 19:18most people will probably share
- 19:20that that didn't go to law
- 19:21school.
- 19:21>> Yeah, I think we can agree
- 19:23on that. Okay, so let's talk
- 19:25about some of the governor
- 19:27issued vetoes today, or maybe
- 19:30he had done this previously.
- 19:31House Bill 505 01503504. These
- 19:34are the budget bills and. 757
- 19:36the revenue bill. There were
- 19:37line item vetoes to those
- 19:39measures. I know you may not
- 19:41have had a chance to pore over
- 19:43all of those. Your initial
- 19:46reaction?
- 19:47>> Well, I haven't seen any of
- 19:49them. I heard that there was
- 19:51vetoes coming down. So where my
- 19:54initial premise on the
- 19:56impeachment is, I start as a no
- 19:58on this. I start as a yes that
- 20:00we will override. And
- 20:01somebody's going to have to
- 20:02convince me that it's no. But I
- 20:05can't comment because I've not
- 20:06seen those. As I understand,
- 20:08they were just handed down.
- 20:09They were our.
- 20:11>> Absolutely. At 647, I
- 20:12checked and that's when I saw
- 20:14them. So, Mr. Speaker, your
- 20:16thoughts.
- 20:16>> Yeah, I think I was told
- 20:18that there were 35 of them
- 20:20altogether. Have not had a
- 20:22chance. I looked at the bill
- 20:23numbers, but as far as the line
- 20:26items and the budget bills have
- 20:27not had a chance to look at any
- 20:29of those. I agree with with
- 20:30Robert, I think that our our
- 20:32bargaining position will be to
- 20:34override those, barring some,
- 20:37you know, new information that
- 20:39we haven't had before. And as I
- 20:41continue to say, the only thing
- 20:42more satisfying than passing a
- 20:44good bill once is to pass it
- 20:45twice. So I would expect that
- 20:48we will be active beginning
- 20:50tomorrow.
- 20:50>> Okay. Leader Neal.
- 20:52>> Again, I haven't seen any of
- 20:54those, but I expect to carry
- 20:57the torch to uphold the
- 20:59governor's vetoes.
- 21:01>> Before I let you respond,
- 21:03whip Watkins on 757, which was
- 21:05the revenue measure, the
- 21:08governor in his veto, he points
- 21:10out about the historic
- 21:13properties idea of putting an
- 21:16object or art of Senator Mitch
- 21:18McConnell in the Capitol
- 21:19Rotunda, in which we knew he
- 21:21had objected to that. And he
- 21:22mentions a couple of others who
- 21:24he feels should have also been
- 21:27elevated to have a place in the
- 21:29state capitol. Department of
- 21:30Corrections Commissioner Cookie
- 21:32Cruz and the late J. Michael
- 21:34Brown, who was the first black
- 21:36Kentuckian to serve as
- 21:37secretary of the governor's
- 21:38executive cabinet. Any thoughts
- 21:39that you have on that, and
- 21:43particularly the statue of
- 21:44Mitch McConnell, which I'll
- 21:45have. Also, the Speaker and Mr.
- 21:46President, respond to.
- 21:47>> I tend to defer to the
- 21:49governor and his perspectives
- 21:51about his veto power and such.
- 21:52I think this is probably the
- 21:54greatest expanded lesson of
- 21:55schoolhouse Rock that I've ever
- 21:57been a part of, but
- 21:58specifically to the statutes. I
- 21:59think that there are noteworthy
- 22:02Kentuckians that should be
- 22:03reflected in our rotunda. And I
- 22:06think as as someone who has
- 22:08roots in Kentucky, I want to
- 22:10see people who I feel like have
- 22:12have shaped the Commonwealth's
- 22:14history as well as the history
- 22:16of the country. I think you'd
- 22:18be hard pressed to say that
- 22:19Mitch McConnell did not do that.
- 22:21I also would be hard pressed to
- 22:24say hearing names like Cookie
- 22:25Cruz and J. Michael Brown. I
- 22:27think that they deserve that
- 22:29sort of elevated reach as well.
- 22:31And I would wonder if anyone
- 22:34disagrees with that. I'd wonder
- 22:35what that explanation is.
- 22:37>> Do you want to comment
- 22:37before I go too?
- 22:38>> I think it should go through
- 22:40some type of process and we
- 22:42need to look at that. I mean,
- 22:43we just removed someone from
- 22:45the rotunda because he thought
- 22:46it was not worthy of that spot.
- 22:49And the situation now is that
- 22:51what else has been precluded
- 22:53from our historical view in
- 22:55terms of that? For instance,
- 22:56people of color that have
- 22:58contributed greatly to the
- 22:59Commonwealth of Kentucky and
- 23:01certainly others and the names,
- 23:02of course, are J. Michael Brown
- 23:04and and Cookie Cruz and others
- 23:07are certainly would rise to
- 23:08that level.
- 23:09>> Mr. president.
- 23:11>> As to the placement of
- 23:14Senator McConnell. Well, I've
- 23:16said this when I introduced a
- 23:19resolution, and it goes almost
- 23:21to what the representative has
- 23:23said, that this individual has
- 23:27been in office for 40 years,
- 23:30has impacted this state, has
- 23:33impacted this nation and has
- 23:36impacted this world as no other
- 23:39Kentuckian has done. Maybe ever,
- 23:45except for possibly two people,
- 23:48one being Lincoln and Henry
- 23:50Clay. I don't know if that is
- 23:55the criteria, how you argue
- 23:57that any other person has been
- 24:00around for a little less than
- 24:0441 years, 40 years that has
- 24:08been on every national news
- 24:10story has been considered the
- 24:12most prominent Republican when
- 24:15in the in the nation, which
- 24:16makes him the most prominent
- 24:18Republican in the world. When
- 24:20there was an individual, be it
- 24:23Clinton, Obama, or, or or any
- 24:26other Democrat elected official
- 24:28to the presidency, this was the
- 24:32opposition to that individual.
- 24:34And so I find it hard to argue
- 24:38with that rationale.
- 24:40>> Mr. speaker.
- 24:40>> I would agree. I think that
- 24:43clearly leader McConnell is the
- 24:46most certainly the most
- 24:48consequential Kentucky
- 24:50political figure of my lifetime.
- 24:52And I would submit to you in
- 24:53the history of the Commonwealth.
- 24:55And also, I think in the
- 24:57history of this country, he
- 24:58will he will be recorded in the
- 25:00history books as being one of
- 25:02the most significant figures in
- 25:03American political history.
- 25:05That doesn't mean that you have
- 25:06to like him. You know, when
- 25:09when if you read the history
- 25:11books, you know, Henry Clay was
- 25:14less than admired person at
- 25:17many times in his his political
- 25:19career was a very controversial
- 25:21figure, as was Alben Barkley.
- 25:25Alvin Barkley was was an
- 25:27absolute partizan. That that
- 25:30was was controversial at times.
- 25:33I don't think that we have to
- 25:34say that we are broadly
- 25:36accepting these as, as as
- 25:38well-liked people. But their
- 25:40their political significance
- 25:42that have have molded the shape
- 25:44of this Commonwealth in this
- 25:46country. I will point out, just
- 25:48as an aside, that this governor
- 25:49does seem to have an uncanny
- 25:52inability to understand that a
- 25:54revenue bill is not subject to
- 25:56a line item veto. The court's
- 25:57been very clear over that for
- 25:59years, and multiple
- 26:03circumstances. You can you can
- 26:04line item veto, an
- 26:06appropriation bill. A revenue
- 26:07bill is not an appropriation
- 26:09bill, so we will likely
- 26:11override it anyway. But but he
- 26:13really does not have the
- 26:15authority to override or to
- 26:16line item veto a revenue bill.
- 26:18>> Yeah. Final thought.
- 26:19>> We'll stand up for the to
- 26:20uphold the governor's veto.
- 26:22>> So before we kind of dive
- 26:23into some other measures, I do
- 26:25just want to get an overall
- 26:27temperature of how you feel
- 26:28about this session and about
- 26:29the major accomplishments aside
- 26:31from the budget and the revenue
- 26:33and one time money, what stands
- 26:36out? I'll start with you, Mr.
- 26:37Speaker.
- 26:38>> You know, I.
- 26:39>> Know that you just you
- 26:40prefaced that by saying, aside
- 26:41from the budget, but I think in
- 26:43budget session, you have to you
- 26:45have to start there because
- 26:46when you start there, you
- 26:47finish there it is. It is the
- 26:49thing that drives everything
- 26:50else that we do during the
- 26:53budget session. And, and quite
- 26:55frankly, I think it's the most
- 26:56significant policy document
- 26:58that we will pass. So
- 27:00everything else pales. And I'm
- 27:02proud of the budget document
- 27:03that we passed. I'm proud of
- 27:05the one that we we produced and,
- 27:07and massaged through the
- 27:09process and changed and
- 27:10ultimately passed the last
- 27:13night of session. It is a
- 27:15really thoughtful, good
- 27:18document. And I think it it
- 27:21does exactly what we set out to
- 27:24do, and that is to address the
- 27:25needs of the Commonwealth and
- 27:27to to, to fund the needs as
- 27:29opposed to once we continue to
- 27:31to try to be as fiscally
- 27:33responsible as we possibly can
- 27:35to utilize taxpayer dollars in
- 27:38the very most effective and
- 27:40efficient way. And I think we
- 27:41did that, and I'm proud of that.
- 27:43>> Louder Neal. You know, I
- 27:44guess it's always in the eyes
- 27:46of the beholder. There are
- 27:48great things in that bill.
- 27:50There's no question I voted for
- 27:53the budget bills. And some
- 27:55people think that you take one
- 27:57item in there and you take a
- 27:59position that, well, I'm
- 28:00against the whole budget bill,
- 28:01but there it runs the
- 28:03Commonwealth and it has all
- 28:04kinds of things that are very
- 28:05important. On the other hand,
- 28:06that doesn't mean that you
- 28:08really buy into everything
- 28:09because there are things even
- 28:12philosophically, conceptually
- 28:13and practically that you don't
- 28:14agree with in the budget bill,
- 28:16and you have to acknowledge
- 28:18that it exists. And I think
- 28:20everybody makes takes that into
- 28:22consideration. You know, my my
- 28:25concern is, is not that that's
- 28:26the process. We make judgments.
- 28:29The majority is going to
- 28:30whatever they ultimately agree
- 28:32on, they're going to do. But I
- 28:34think it's very important to
- 28:36understand also that there are
- 28:39opportunities that we lose when
- 28:40we take certain types of
- 28:42strategies that limit our
- 28:43ability to deal with broader
- 28:46considerations. For instance,
- 28:47we're being impacted by the
- 28:48federal government in terms of
- 28:50decisions being made on that
- 28:52level. That has puts pressure
- 28:54on us. It transfers of the
- 28:57requirement, or let's say, the
- 28:58the ability for us to address
- 29:00our local needs. The changes up
- 29:02there affect us. It affected us
- 29:03this time. That means we made
- 29:05judgments here as to what we
- 29:07were going to allocate, where
- 29:09we were going to step up. We
- 29:11undertook some restrictive
- 29:12behavior in terms of people who
- 29:15qualified for certain, let's
- 29:16say, in the Medicaid realm and
- 29:18some of the other realms, which
- 29:20is really calculated. And
- 29:22everybody knows this. Some
- 29:24people are going to fall off of
- 29:25that because of the structures
- 29:26we set up that militate against
- 29:28them going through the
- 29:30processes. So all these things
- 29:32affect other policies that we
- 29:33undertake, and we put a series
- 29:35of them into place. And that
- 29:36means someone is not going to
- 29:38get a benefit that's in need.
- 29:39So when we talk about needs, I
- 29:42say again, it's always in the
- 29:43eyes of the beholder. And I
- 29:45think that's important. Another
- 29:46thing, two things, in fact. One
- 29:49is that we have this overall
- 29:50policy, which I was very glad
- 29:52to see. The Senate took a
- 29:53pretty strong position, and I
- 29:56perhaps the House as well, of
- 29:58not rushing past that next
- 30:00level in terms of rushing to
- 30:02zero in terms of income tax. I
- 30:04thought that was a wise
- 30:05decision that was made this
- 30:07session. I'm very concerned
- 30:09about that. You know, I hope
- 30:10I'm wrong that nothing gets
- 30:13shifted in terms of sales tax
- 30:14and other kinds of burdens on
- 30:16our citizenry going down the
- 30:18road, but I thought that was a
- 30:19good decision this time, and
- 30:22maybe that's where we ought to
- 30:23stop, I might argue, but I
- 30:25think that's important. But the
- 30:27last thing I want to make is
- 30:28this, is that when we assume
- 30:32the burden that the federal
- 30:33government shifts on us, you
- 30:34know, I think that's we have an
- 30:37obligation and responsibility
- 30:38to step up for those who are in
- 30:39a weaker position that need to
- 30:41be supported in that particular
- 30:43regard. And to the extent we
- 30:45don't, it raises considerable
- 30:47concern. For me. We got 30% of
- 30:49our people on Medicaid in the
- 30:52state of Kentucky is my
- 30:54understanding, and that's not
- 30:55talking about the other areas
- 30:56of needs. We're not a very
- 30:58prosperous state, although
- 31:00we've seen some sunshine over
- 31:02the last few cycles. I don't
- 31:05think that's going to sustain
- 31:06itself. I hope I'm wrong, but
- 31:08history tells me that we're
- 31:10going to have some highs and
- 31:12we're going to have some lows,
- 31:13and we'll see where that goes.
- 31:15But that's those are the
- 31:16concerns I have.
- 31:17>> But I think I'm probably
- 31:20most excited about the feedback
- 31:22and participation of everyday
- 31:26Kentuckians, whether they came
- 31:27to the Capitol. They called,
- 31:29they emailed about several
- 31:31several items as it relates to
- 31:32the budget. I was very happy to
- 31:34see that as it related to state
- 31:37employee health plans, that we
- 31:39made some adjustments there.
- 31:41And I think the feedback from a
- 31:42lot of people encouraged that.
- 31:45I think that there are some
- 31:48things that we are going to
- 31:49agree upon in the housing space.
- 31:51I think I'm.
- 31:52>> Going to get to that in just
- 31:54a moment.
- 31:54>> I know we are. So my ears
- 31:56are sort of raised for that.
- 31:58But I do want to echo some of
- 32:00the senator's concerns as it
- 32:02relates to the budget. And I
- 32:03think this is the normal part
- 32:05of the discourse. As someone
- 32:07who saw a budget for the first
- 32:09time, I will say that I was
- 32:11very appreciative of my
- 32:13colleagues on the House side,
- 32:16particularly Chairman Petrie
- 32:17and several others, who
- 32:19answered every question that I
- 32:20did have. And I had a lot of
- 32:23them because a lot of people do.
- 32:24I'm concerned about Medicaid.
- 32:26I'm just I'm quite frankly,
- 32:28concerned about affordability.
- 32:29I mean, gas is gas is $5 in
- 32:32some places. And and I know
- 32:34everyday people are concerned
- 32:35about how they're going to eat
- 32:37and whether or not they can go
- 32:39to the doctor, whether or not
- 32:40they'll have a roof over their
- 32:42head. And so I think when you
- 32:43pass a budget and I know the
- 32:45majority and the minority think
- 32:46about this as we make any
- 32:48decisions, it's how is it going
- 32:49to impact the people that we
- 32:51represent? And could we do a
- 32:52little bit more to make
- 32:54people's lives better? I am
- 32:55hopeful that we continue to
- 32:58drive this affordability issue
- 32:59home more and more as as we
- 33:02continue to talk.
- 33:02>> Yeah. Mr. president, I'll
- 33:04give you the last word on on
- 33:06budget and well, I.
- 33:07>> Think we do a really good
- 33:08job, Renee, on the budget,
- 33:10unlike Republican and Democrat
- 33:12states throughout the United
- 33:13States, we haven't had to go
- 33:15back in and cut programs
- 33:17because a lot of people
- 33:18extended using one time dollars
- 33:19to do recurring programs. As to
- 33:22Medicaid, we have placed in a
- 33:25segregated account $300 million
- 33:27to deal with any type of
- 33:29shortfall, which will have a
- 33:30major federal match to it. So
- 33:33we do a really good job at
- 33:34managing that. And for the loss
- 33:37of income where we have been
- 33:39reducing it. If you look, you
- 33:42think that you would have a
- 33:43corresponding drop in that
- 33:46section of our tax code. It's
- 33:48actually not that it's not
- 33:49dropping that fast because
- 33:50we're expanding our base and
- 33:52creating more jobs here. You've
- 33:54heard the governor say, hey,
- 33:55look, I've cut more ribbons.
- 33:57Well, that's right, because
- 33:58we've created the dynamic for
- 34:00him to cut more ribbons. So
- 34:03with that, I'm going to say
- 34:05dealing with the the budget
- 34:09bill, which has to be I agree
- 34:11with the speaker. It has to be
- 34:12our primary focus. But I think
- 34:14something we did in this
- 34:15session may have more impact
- 34:17that people need to understand.
- 34:19And that's being able to take a
- 34:22tax credit to put into a school
- 34:26system. So if Renee owes $1,700
- 34:30to the federal government, you
- 34:32can take that $1,700 and you
- 34:36can put it with what's called
- 34:37an Sgo, a nonprofit, which will
- 34:40funnel it back to Shawnee High
- 34:43School.
- 34:44>> It can be a public or
- 34:45private.
- 34:46>> Public or private school. I
- 34:47sat down with my superintendent
- 34:49and said, Manchester Elementary
- 34:5120 teachers there. They take
- 34:53that $1,700 tax credit, put it
- 34:56into a an NGO, and they're
- 34:59putting over $35,000 back into
- 35:03that school, just among the
- 35:06teachers themselves. And what
- 35:07do they do with it? They said,
- 35:09well, this is for rich kids. No,
- 35:11it has to be for 300% of
- 35:13poverty or lower that you're
- 35:14working with these children. I
- 35:16think that may be the most
- 35:18significant thing. Other than
- 35:19the budget that we did this
- 35:21year.
- 35:21>> Democrat Tina Bojanowski in
- 35:23the House had made the case
- 35:25similarly that this could help
- 35:26public schools. And, Mr.
- 35:27Speaker, we know this was your
- 35:29bill.
- 35:29>> She she actually,
- 35:31representative Bujnowski made a
- 35:32very passionate speech on that
- 35:35on the floor because she is
- 35:36very passionate about special
- 35:38needs programs.
- 35:39>> And and she is an educator.
- 35:41>> And she is an educator. And
- 35:42she saw very quickly how this
- 35:44could benefit some of those
- 35:46unique situations that, that we
- 35:48don't have the ability to do
- 35:49one off funding for right now.
- 35:51And, you know, I think one of
- 35:53the, one of the first people to
- 35:55embrace this was, was
- 35:57representative Fugate Chris
- 35:59Fugate down in Perry County,
- 36:01because he represents the
- 36:02poorest counties in Kentucky.
- 36:04And, and he, he was able to to
- 36:06say he lit up when he thought
- 36:09about the ability to bring
- 36:10outside money into those
- 36:12districts that are that are so
- 36:15impoverished. So I think the
- 36:17opportunity is. Robert said the
- 36:19opportunity is is incredible.
- 36:21And I think that it's
- 36:24unfortunate that it has. It's
- 36:29tried to delve into some
- 36:32political past fights that that
- 36:35really aren't appropriate here.
- 36:37>> The constitutional amendment
- 36:38of 2024, that 2 to 1 people did
- 36:42reject Wright over school
- 36:43choice. Yes. And this is not
- 36:44that is what you're saying.
- 36:46>> And I think to you know, I
- 36:48know that, you know, it's a
- 36:49better political narrative to
- 36:50say that it is. But as, as, as
- 36:53many people on both sides of
- 36:54the aisle pointed out that this
- 36:57this is not that. And this is
- 36:58an opportunity for everybody.
- 37:00There are some people that were
- 37:01concerned legitimately so about
- 37:04maybe some of the ambiguous
- 37:06language that is still pending
- 37:09at the at the federal level.
- 37:10But I think the opportunity
- 37:12that this gives for every
- 37:13school in Kentucky and every
- 37:14kid in Kentucky is, is, is
- 37:17pretty special.
- 37:18>> This is House Bill one, and
- 37:20we've talked about that before.
- 37:21And I think Senator Thomas,
- 37:22your colleague, has also talked
- 37:24about how he did not approve of
- 37:25that because it's still money
- 37:27that would be taken away from
- 37:28public schools, even if it's
- 37:29coming at the federal level.
- 37:31>> Exactly. And, you know, I
- 37:32can't say if money handled
- 37:34properly by those or or some
- 37:37construct is used in a way that
- 37:38helps people, is not beneficial
- 37:40to people who receive that. I
- 37:42think the point is, though,
- 37:44that if you take money from a
- 37:47public piece to fund a private
- 37:50piece, then you still doing
- 37:51something. I think the argument
- 37:52could be made as they make on
- 37:55the ground, that you're taking
- 37:56money from a public school to,
- 37:59let's say, fund charter schools.
- 38:02I know it's a different context.
- 38:04I know it's a different dynamic.
- 38:06I know it doesn't have to come
- 38:07out that way myself. A lot of
- 38:10people are just public school
- 38:12or just charter school. I'm not
- 38:14against charter schools, quite
- 38:16frankly. I'm just against
- 38:17public monies going to charter
- 38:19schools. If we haven't fully
- 38:21funded our public schools,
- 38:22that's my concern and that's
- 38:23always a concern. And when you
- 38:25do something like this, I could
- 38:27see where someone could take
- 38:28that position, but it's been
- 38:30passed. I think it's something
- 38:31that you got to take advantage
- 38:33of. You got to be aggressive
- 38:34about it. If you can bring the
- 38:37benefits to those who need it
- 38:38and fill gaps and so forth. I
- 38:40see no shame in that.
- 38:42>> Okay. I do want to get to
- 38:43housing, okay? Because I want
- 38:44to get to housing and gambling
- 38:46if we can, in the next 17
- 38:48minutes. So Senate Bill nine
- 38:50when last we left off, I think
- 38:52combined eight different pieces
- 38:53of legislation that started off
- 38:54as Robbie, Mills, Bill that
- 38:56would allow local governments
- 38:57to designate special building
- 38:59zones that could help finance
- 39:00and lower barriers to
- 39:02construction. So but it has a
- 39:03lot of other things in it now,
- 39:04right. What can you say about
- 39:07this, president Stivers.
- 39:09>> In the last days of the
- 39:12session that concluded to go
- 39:14into veto recess, we made a
- 39:18conscientious decision to make
- 39:20sure bills got readings. So
- 39:22they still be dealt with in
- 39:24this this last two days. So
- 39:27that bill is out there. But it
- 39:29had so much on it at that point
- 39:31in time when we were trying to
- 39:33finish the three branch budgets
- 39:35plus the transportation budget,
- 39:36plus what we call the six year
- 39:38road plan, plus the revenue
- 39:39bill that funds the government,
- 39:41that we decided to say we're
- 39:42going to wait and try to deal
- 39:44with that in the in the period
- 39:46of the recess, we had
- 39:47discussions on it. Today, we're
- 39:49going to discuss it a little
- 39:51bit tomorrow. But with all the
- 39:54additional, you know, jokingly
- 39:57we say we have we have a host
- 40:00in parasites that jumped onto
- 40:01it. We're going to have to look
- 40:04at those a little bit before we
- 40:06make a final decision. What
- 40:07we're going to.
- 40:08>> Do are you talking I don't
- 40:10know which one is which, but
- 40:11the Airbnb provision, short
- 40:12term rentals seem to be
- 40:13something that's getting a lot
- 40:15of discussion. I don't know if
- 40:16that's the host of The parasite.
- 40:18>> And that's such a tough
- 40:19decision. And I don't know
- 40:20where the speaker is on this.
- 40:22You know, it's been the Airbnb
- 40:23industry has been kind of the
- 40:25backbone of, of, of the housing
- 40:27component of our bourbon trail.
- 40:30If you start looking around and
- 40:31it has such positive impacts,
- 40:34otherwise other places, it
- 40:36hasn't been that positive. It's
- 40:38driven up some housing prices
- 40:40and has creating housing
- 40:42shortage in my hometown. We
- 40:45don't have a really good hotel,
- 40:46but the best thing we've got
- 40:48are some really nice Airbnbs.
- 40:49So how we deal with the issue
- 40:51and the collection of the taxes
- 40:53and what it does to the demand
- 40:55on housing, it's pretty tough
- 40:57to try to sift through all that.
- 40:59Plus, then you have individual
- 41:01property owners rights to do
- 41:03with whatever they want to do
- 41:04with their house. So it's not
- 41:05an easy issue.
- 41:06>> Yeah. Mr. Speaker.
- 41:08>> I think that that is kind of
- 41:09the core issue of the entire
- 41:11housing bill. And it did, you
- 41:13know, from from day one, it was
- 41:15kind of assumed that we were
- 41:16going to take this approach
- 41:18with it, allow each of the
- 41:20individual bills to be filed,
- 41:21take public input on them. Some
- 41:24of them went through committee.
- 41:25Some of them just got general
- 41:27public input through the task
- 41:29force that we had working in
- 41:30the interim. Find out where the
- 41:32the pressure points were, find
- 41:33out where we could get
- 41:35agreement. But at every, at
- 41:36every turn, you know,
- 41:37recognizing that we needed to
- 41:39do everything we could to tear
- 41:40down barriers to housing and
- 41:43affordable housing, protect
- 41:45property rights, understanding
- 41:47that that is the core of the
- 41:51foundation of this country's
- 41:52protection of property rights.
- 41:54But but also do as much as we
- 41:56can while respecting local
- 41:57control to eliminate a lot of
- 41:58the bureaucracy that we get
- 42:01wrapped up in, in the
- 42:03development of housing,
- 42:05particularly affordable housing.
- 42:06I think this bill does that. It
- 42:09is a lot there's a lot in that
- 42:11bill, and it's a lot to absorb.
- 42:15I, I would suspect that there
- 42:16will be changes before the
- 42:18final product is is passed. I
- 42:23do think we will pass something.
- 42:24I think it will be meaningful
- 42:26and I think it will will
- 42:28definitely move the bar. On the
- 42:30availability and affordability
- 42:31of housing in Kentucky.
- 42:32>> We know that House Democrats
- 42:33had a Homnibus 2.0. Was that
- 42:36the name of it? So are any of
- 42:38the ideas that you all had
- 42:40presented part of what we now
- 42:41know as Senate Bill nine.
- 42:43>> There are some ideas and
- 42:44Senate Bill nine that we agree
- 42:46with, and I served on the
- 42:47housing Task Force this summer,
- 42:50and we heard the Residential
- 42:51infrastructure fund, for
- 42:52example, as as an idea that we
- 42:54agree upon. And there were some
- 42:57adjustments, I think, to the
- 42:59Affordable Housing Trust fund,
- 43:00some allocations there that I
- 43:02think we agree upon. But if I
- 43:03could just kind of dovetail, I
- 43:05didn't get to get in on the
- 43:07education piece, but I'll say
- 43:08this as well. There are some
- 43:09things that we asked for, and
- 43:11there are some things that
- 43:12people have asked for that are
- 43:14not in there. And I would say
- 43:15that that on education, I would
- 43:17say that as as well as housing.
- 43:19So it really comes down to the
- 43:22affordability argument again.
- 43:23And one of the things that I
- 43:24hope that we tackle is some
- 43:27affordability requirements. If
- 43:28we are granting the ability for
- 43:30developers and builders to use
- 43:32public dollars to build housing,
- 43:34I want to make sure that it's
- 43:36affordable. And when you say
- 43:37that word affordable, the first
- 43:39question that comes to mind and
- 43:40in the mind of a lot of
- 43:42Kentuckians is affordable for
- 43:43who. And so we actually have
- 43:44data to figure that out. Is it
- 43:46going to be for our lowest
- 43:48income earners? Is it going to
- 43:49be workforce driven? I think
- 43:51those are some of the things
- 43:52that we want to see. But as a
- 43:54housing professional, both in
- 43:56the private sector and public
- 43:57sector, one of the things that
- 43:58I want to encourage my
- 43:59colleagues on the right to do
- 44:01and co-chair Mills has heard me
- 44:02say this a thousand times, so
- 44:04I'm going to say it 1001, just
- 44:06to to reiterate the point, I
- 44:07think we need to spend a bit
- 44:09more money on the creation of
- 44:10housing supply. There is some
- 44:12regulatory benefit to Senate
- 44:15Bill nine, and I think that is
- 44:16the case. We could do more
- 44:18there. Mixed use zoning,
- 44:20allowing local governments to
- 44:21come up with their the laws
- 44:23that make sense for them. We
- 44:25could limit corporate ownership
- 44:26for for homes and such, and
- 44:28also do something to help our
- 44:29renters. We have a lot of
- 44:31people who will never own a
- 44:32home. I'm a millennial. The
- 44:33average age of a first time
- 44:35home buyer is 40 years old, and
- 44:37that means that a lot of people
- 44:39my age are younger, are renting,
- 44:41and we haven't done a lot, in
- 44:42my opinion, to specifically
- 44:44address that. So it's a yes.
- 44:47And for me, if I have to say
- 44:49pretty please, I could do that
- 44:51too, but I would definitely
- 44:52want to see a bit more
- 44:53allocated to the Affordable
- 44:54Housing Trust fund and some
- 44:56evolving functions that will
- 44:57make sure that pays for itself
- 44:58over time.
- 44:59>> Let me let me raise another
- 45:00question, another issue here
- 45:01too as well. I served on the
- 45:03housing task force as well, and
- 45:05it was quite an education. But
- 45:06one of the things that was
- 45:08clear is that we have a crisis
- 45:09going on, particularly in urban
- 45:11areas, but also in the rural
- 45:12areas as well, but in the
- 45:14process, interacting with other
- 45:15people and getting closer to
- 45:16the ground in terms of what was
- 45:18happening in communities.
- 45:19There's also an issue as to
- 45:21does someone's utilization of
- 45:24this break up the continuity of
- 45:25the community itself? How much
- 45:28input should people have into
- 45:29this process in terms of how
- 45:31their community is going to be
- 45:33going to look? For instance,
- 45:34these people invest a ton of
- 45:36money in certain neighborhoods,
- 45:38etc. that now are going to be
- 45:41visited upon a loosened up
- 45:44circumstance that allows people
- 45:45to build things that may not be
- 45:47congruent with their
- 45:48communities. I think that is a
- 45:50consideration. I'll just say I
- 45:51don't know what the resolution
- 45:52is, other than they should have
- 45:54more voice in that in this
- 45:56process, and I hope that that
- 45:57evolves going forward as well.
- 45:59>> But procedurally, we should
- 46:00point out that whatever you
- 46:01pass is not veto proof.
- 46:03>> True. That is correct.
- 46:04>> So will that encourage more
- 46:08caution and what you think the
- 46:09governor may not veto in the
- 46:11final product?
- 46:12>> No. We're going to go ahead
- 46:13and try to get a final product.
- 46:16But let me say this about I
- 46:19think and we've dealt with so
- 46:20many numbers and we have to
- 46:22look at the speaker. I think we
- 46:24put $10 million each year in
- 46:25the Affordable Housing Trust
- 46:26fund, but that's only one
- 46:28Senate Bill nine is another
- 46:30discussion point. Senator
- 46:33Carter Heron worked on a
- 46:35brownfield bill that we passed
- 46:37that would open up a large
- 46:39portion of the TRACK of land
- 46:41for housing development. There
- 46:43are more than just these bills,
- 46:44like the Fourth and Oak Project,
- 46:47and we put money behind the
- 46:49Fourth and Oak project. You
- 46:50know, there's several places
- 46:52like that throughout Eastern
- 46:54Kentucky, Western Kentucky, in
- 46:55our urban areas that beyond
- 46:57what you see in the Affordable
- 46:59Housing Trust fund, we
- 47:00specifically set them out and
- 47:02funded to do things in those
- 47:03areas.
- 47:04>> And let me raise a point on
- 47:05that one, the brownfield bill.
- 47:07That was a very significant
- 47:08bill, not just for that project
- 47:10that opened up what could
- 47:11happen in brownfields that you
- 47:12find in different places in
- 47:14urban areas. And I think I was
- 47:17excited to see that happen.
- 47:18That was that was a good one.
- 47:20>> So I want to get in this
- 47:22question before we talk about
- 47:23House Bill 904. And that might
- 47:24be the end of our program. This
- 47:26from Martin Rivers in Lexington.
- 47:27He says, quote, the Kentucky
- 47:29legislature seems annoyed with
- 47:30transparency with JCPS and CPS.
- 47:33This is Jefferson and Fayette
- 47:34counties and their budget
- 47:36process. Why would citizens not
- 47:37be annoyed by the same thing in
- 47:39the Kentucky legislative budget
- 47:40process? So many of these bills
- 47:41had last minute subs or even
- 47:43last minute updates. Why should
- 47:45citizens trust legislators in
- 47:46the majority party and the
- 47:48process they use?
- 47:50>> I'll answer that real quick.
- 47:52First of all, we're time
- 47:54limited. We are by constitution
- 47:57at midnight on the 15th. Done.
- 47:59We only have so many working
- 48:02days by constitution, so some
- 48:04of it is set to us or put in
- 48:07place by the Constitution
- 48:09itself. We're not like a
- 48:11continuing ongoing organization
- 48:14like the JCPS or FCPs. They
- 48:18have annual long periods of
- 48:20time. The other part of that is
- 48:24when we get into the budget
- 48:27process, you're hearing budget
- 48:31committees throughout the
- 48:33session and before the session
- 48:35and in the interim talk about
- 48:37what we just talked about
- 48:39housing, housing, construction,
- 48:41you know, brownfield
- 48:42legislation, very open, very
- 48:45transparent. But at a certain
- 48:46point in time, you've got to
- 48:47get a written document.
- 48:49>> Mr. speaker.
- 48:50>> I think the fact of the
- 48:51matter remains that, you know,
- 48:52we do continue to to build in
- 48:56firewalls, fail safes into our
- 49:00budget process, whether it be
- 49:01from the Medicaid standpoint,
- 49:03whether it be our budget
- 49:04reserve trust fund, to make
- 49:05sure that we don't have the
- 49:07kind of problems that, quite
- 49:09frankly, JCPS and CPS have
- 49:12encountered, we make sure that
- 49:14we we haven't. So I'm not
- 49:16necessarily irritated by by a
- 49:19lack of transparency. I'm
- 49:21irritated by the fact that they
- 49:22are hundreds of millions of
- 49:23dollars short on their budget
- 49:24and don't have an answer for it.
- 49:26>> Well, I have to say, I think
- 49:28transparency is important. And
- 49:30democracy. We have an
- 49:32obligation to create as much
- 49:34transparency as we can. It gets
- 49:36messy when people disagree at a
- 49:39table, but that's part of this
- 49:40democratic process, and I don't
- 49:42think we're afraid of that. I
- 49:43think it's kind of we're in
- 49:44kind of a unique situation now
- 49:46because of the construction.
- 49:47And we're not in the capital
- 49:49piece now, but we should strive,
- 49:50I think, to create as much
- 49:54transparency as possible.
- 49:56>> Okay, before I get.
- 49:57>> To that last point, I'll be
- 49:59quick.
- 49:59>> Sure, sure.
- 50:00>> I would like to encourage
- 50:01everybody to, to pay attention
- 50:03to the interim as, as Robert
- 50:07said, you know, particularly
- 50:08Chairman Petrie has done an
- 50:10incredible job of, of having
- 50:12very regimented A&R committee
- 50:16hearings, budget review,
- 50:17subcommittee hearings,
- 50:18literally, he will start in
- 50:20June and end of this year,
- 50:23starting working on the next
- 50:25budget. It's it's easy not to
- 50:28pay attention to those things,
- 50:29but I think you have to kind of
- 50:31pay attention to those things
- 50:32to, to see the, the picture
- 50:34evolve into what we make into
- 50:36the final product.
- 50:38>> Before we get to gambling.
- 50:40So, you know, make people wait
- 50:42a little bit. Data centers. So
- 50:43at the beginning of the session,
- 50:45you know, we heard a lot about
- 50:47housing education and data
- 50:49centers. And where are we on
- 50:50that? Josh Bray had a Bill 593
- 50:54that dealt with the use of
- 50:56these facilities and them
- 50:57paying for their power or
- 50:59having some kind of agreement
- 51:00on how they, they would pay for
- 51:02that power, not pass it on to
- 51:04ratepayers, because they do
- 51:05consume a lot of energy. Where
- 51:07is that?
- 51:08>> It is in the Senate.
- 51:10>> And what's it doing in the
- 51:12Senate.
- 51:13>> Appears to be resting.
- 51:14>> Resting comfortably, you
- 51:15know, and.
- 51:16>> Josh did a really good job
- 51:18at this. And I've been involved.
- 51:19And I want to admit that Josh
- 51:22did a really good job. And I
- 51:23think Josh took a perspective.
- 51:25And I'm going to say this won't
- 51:27compliment the PSC. Josh took
- 51:30the perspective of a more rural
- 51:31look at this and dealing with a
- 51:34draft piece of legislation that
- 51:36dealt with more of a rural
- 51:37electric co-op, which is
- 51:39totally different than an
- 51:40investor owned. So we're trying
- 51:42to balance that out. But if you
- 51:45think what the PSC, the Public
- 51:46Service Commission that sits
- 51:47this, they looked at both the
- 51:50investor owns and the co-ops,
- 51:52and they formulated a plan to
- 51:55where the residential and
- 51:57commercial consumer would not
- 51:59bear the costs of a data center.
- 52:04And that's they call them
- 52:05tariffs. Some people say full
- 52:07cost allocation because it's
- 52:10not just the generation of
- 52:13electricity and actually the
- 52:15generation, if you got a large
- 52:17base load, consumer will
- 52:20stabilize the prices. That's
- 52:21what's happened in Eastern.
- 52:22Kentucky we lost a lot of
- 52:24population, a lot, a lot, a lot,
- 52:26a lot, a lot of industry that
- 52:28that stabilized the rates,
- 52:31right?
- 52:31>> You know, so the rates are
- 52:32higher for those who are left.
- 52:34>> Because you're basing it on
- 52:36a premise that we develop
- 52:38infrastructure with 40,000
- 52:40people. Now we've lost 10,000
- 52:41of them. So that 30,000 are are
- 52:44sitting there paying for that
- 52:45increased payment of of paying
- 52:47for the infrastructure. You
- 52:49don't want that passed on. That
- 52:50infrastructure shouldn't be
- 52:51passed on to the consumer when
- 52:53a data center comes in. But the
- 52:55PSC actually created two models,
- 52:58one for investor owns, one for
- 53:00co-ops that I think worked. But
- 53:02we need and it's probably going
- 53:03to take more work. And as we
- 53:05get through this, the process
- 53:07dictates that we focused on the
- 53:09budget, to sit down with Josh
- 53:11over the interim and come back,
- 53:12because we want to make sure,
- 53:14even though I think the PSC did
- 53:16a really good job, we still
- 53:18need to put some guardrails in
- 53:20place.
- 53:21>> Okay. Gambling House Bill
- 53:23904. We know that the governor
- 53:24did veto that bill, and this
- 53:26was about the major omnibus
- 53:30gambling bill that did a lot of
- 53:32things. So, Mr. Speaker, this
- 53:34is going to get overridden
- 53:35pretty easily.
- 53:36>> I would expect. So, yes, you
- 53:39know this it's a really good
- 53:40bill. It is a comprehensive
- 53:42bill, one that that I think
- 53:45kind of protects all the
- 53:46interests of gambling that
- 53:48involved the gambling industry.
- 53:51It it protects the charities
- 53:54that that are operating in an
- 53:57ethical manner. In Kentucky. It
- 54:00it, it absolutely identifies
- 54:03the, the firewalls that that
- 54:06the racing corporation is able
- 54:08to, to establish, to make sure
- 54:10that, that there aren't
- 54:11co-mingling of funds, that, you
- 54:13know, all those consumer
- 54:14protections that, that we'd
- 54:15like to see. And it gives the,
- 54:20the racetracks the ability to,
- 54:22to do certain things that they
- 54:24haven't been able to do in the
- 54:25past as far as exploring the
- 54:27expanding of their, their,
- 54:28their wagering mix. Raises the
- 54:34gambling or the age for sports
- 54:35betting from 18 to 21. That was
- 54:39important to many people. And
- 54:40the Chamber provides for the
- 54:44the licensure and regulation
- 54:46and taxation of fantasy sports,
- 54:48which is something that's been
- 54:49happening in Kentucky for a
- 54:50long period of time. And
- 54:53without without proper
- 54:55supervision and oversight. The
- 54:57one thing that's kind of
- 54:58completely thrown everybody a
- 54:59little bit for a loop across
- 55:00the country in the gambling
- 55:02space, is the evolution of
- 55:04these prediction markets that
- 55:06are, quite frankly, they're
- 55:09operating in a completely
- 55:12unregulated, untaxed
- 55:14environment, in a very
- 55:15predatory manner. That's going
- 55:19to continue to be a moving
- 55:21target because they're
- 55:22regulated federally. They are
- 55:24in no other gambling product is
- 55:26every other gambling product is
- 55:28is state regulated. So we tried
- 55:31to put some some guardrails
- 55:32around what they were and
- 55:33weren't able to do. Again,
- 55:35that's going to be a moving
- 55:36target. That's going to be
- 55:37decided in federal court before
- 55:39it's all over with. But we
- 55:40tried.
- 55:40>> But the Derby is still going
- 55:42to air on NBC, right?
- 55:43>> That is not going to be a
- 55:45problem. The Derby is still
- 55:47going to air on NBC. The. The
- 55:48Breeders Cup will still still
- 55:50be able to air. That is. That
- 55:51is not an issue.
- 55:52>> All right, all right. We'll
- 55:54have to leave it there. More to
- 55:56come tomorrow or the next day.
- 55:57And of course you can keep
- 55:59abreast on it because 630
- 56:00eastern each weeknight, we will
- 56:01have all of it laid out for you
- 56:03for the next few days. And if
- 56:05there is an impeachment trial,
- 56:06KET will be covering that as
- 56:08well next week. Next Monday
- 56:09night, candidates for the U.S.
- 56:10Senate in Kentucky. So you
- 56:11don't want to miss out on that.
- 56:13And then Bill Brian, of course,
- 56:15is here with the team of
- 56:16working journalists to discuss
- 56:17all the news of the week on
- 56:19common on Kentucky Friday at
- 56:20eight Eastern seven central
- 56:21right here on KET. I'm Renee
- 56:23Shaw, thanks for being with us
- 56:24and have a good week.