Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 11)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. This is chapter eleven, not twenty nine on our
- 0:05deep dive on the Duggers and ancillary topics. So let's get to it.
- 0:10What do you say, burtle, Let's do it. My name is doctor
- 0:13Kirk Honda. I'm a therapist and professor. This is the Psychology and Seattle
- 0:17Podcast. My name is If you've ever eaten triangular potatoes, you have me
- 0:22to think so. In the last chapter, in the patron section, if
- 0:27you didn't hear it, we went over three incidents that happened in twenty fifteen.
- 0:33We went over the timeline from twenty fifteen until today. We talked about
- 0:37how the police reports were published in Touch magazine, which alerted everyone about what
- 0:44Josh had done when he was younger to his younger siblings. We talked about
- 0:49how in twenty fifteen, so that was a big scandal. Then later that
- 0:52year he was found to be on Ashley Madison website because I was hacked into,
- 0:58and he admitted he cheated and that he had a pornography addiction. And
- 1:00then it was alleged by Danny Cadillon, who is an exact answer, that
- 1:06he had violently sexually assaulted her and in that moment when I was reminded of
- 1:14that incident, that allegation, it really, even though it's in my notes,
- 1:21I'd forgotten about it because my notes are several pages long. I it
- 1:26really pushed my perspective of the possible hypotheses that are likely into a zone that
- 1:34Josh is a monster, and there's a lot of indications of that even when
- 1:42he was a teenager. And I've I felt ashamed of myself because you know,
- 1:48throughout this whole series and chapters and deep ties, I have been providing
- 1:55a perspective of like, well, we don't really know. It could be
- 1:57this could he could be a monster, but there's other possibilities. But there's
- 2:01something about the allegation of the sexual assault with Danny Cadillon that we discussed in
- 2:07the last chapter and the patron zone that really just brought all the different details
- 2:15together that point in the direction that he is a monster that should be locked
- 2:19up until it is very sure, or at least monitored and supervised until it
- 2:23is very sure that he is safe to the public and his own children.
- 2:29So then I felt ashamed. I felt bad because in the previous chapters,
- 2:34I was, you know, providing all these caveats. I'm like, Oh,
- 2:37we don't know. There's allegations, you know, it could be this
- 2:38way to go, and it still could be. We just don't know.
- 2:40But I feel I worry that people listening would be like, I can't believe
- 2:47that Kirk is having this like gray zone perspective. There's there's no there's a
- 2:53lot of reasons to believe this is not a gray zone kind of a thing.
- 2:57And so I just want to apologize if if I hurt anybody or bothered
- 3:01anybody in that way. Any thoughts on that, Burt, Yeah, Like
- 3:05I said in the last one, I think it's complex because number one,
- 3:08there's a lot a lot of stuff to this topic, a lot of facts
- 3:13and whatnot. It is true that both of us had because we both had
- 3:16read and seeing that that fact that that accusation, and we hadn't made it
- 3:22prominent enough. That's likely in our heads and therefore, yeah, I could
- 3:27see how that happened. That's at the same time you mentioned that a lot
- 3:32of what you were doing was to help give contexts about how when a family
- 3:38goes through something like this, it doesn't immediately mean the parents are monsters and
- 3:40everyone's a monster, and that was I think pretty important. It actually helped
- 3:45me understand a little bit more from that perspective that parents sometimes will not report
- 3:50and that doesn't mean that they're all monsters, right right. Also, I
- 3:53do think that it is responsible podcasting to not state that everything we hear and
- 4:00read is always a fact and we know incontrovertibly not to be the case,
- 4:03and that we are convinced of one. It's useful to give some caveats and
- 4:08to give some doubt at the same time. Yeah, I agree. I
- 4:11think that there are a lot of indications and that's a big one, that
- 4:15that accusation that the guy's not safe for society. Yeah, And to be
- 4:20clear, it's not as if the allegations of sexually abusing his younger siblings is
- 4:28somehow lesser. That also is a major red flag. And by monster,
- 4:32I mean that someone has a lack of empathy or seriously impaired empathy such that
- 4:39they cannot be trusted to take actions that don't harm other people. Also potentially
- 4:45a sadistic personality trait that is motivating him to actually wake up in the morning
- 4:50to say I can't wait to harm other people sexually, which is possible,
- 4:56quite possible. Given So I'm not saying that this sexual assault on Danny Cadillan
- 5:01is somehow like this huge, It's just the culmination somehow when I read that
- 5:06in my notes and as I'm talking about it's just all came together like,
- 5:10oh wait, it's it's really hard to avoid the strong possibility that Josh's and
- 5:16it might have always been what I'm you know, colloquially calling a monster.
- 5:23There's a difference between, hey, there was a confused, traumatized fourteen year
- 5:26old who did some horrible things to their siblings and the rest of their life.
- 5:30They they they always it was a tormentum, they went through a lot
- 5:33of treatment. I was gonna say, that's one thing. It's still it
- 5:36was. What happened is still horribles. It's a different thing to say,
- 5:41like, there's this person who did these things then continue to do horrible things,
- 5:44including raping violently to the point of nearly killing them, Like that is
- 5:49different. There's it's different, right exactly, Yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 5:54And I think in my head I was leaning towards that first one, and
- 6:00that he was sublimating through pornography and child porn and infidelity okay, you know,
- 6:06not great, but not necessarily on the level of harm and sadism.
- 6:12That that is a sexual assault on someone who was willing to have sex with
- 6:17him. It was consenting to have sex with him originally, and then he
- 6:20used that as a platform to enact his sadistic urges apparently. So it's uh,
- 6:30it's it's pretty awful. And I, you know, I understand why
- 6:32people were interested in the story because if if you know, if that's likely,
- 6:38then all the things surrounding this story, from the parents to the cult,
- 6:43to society to TLC. It's like, how does do things like this
- 6:50happen? You know, similar to the Bill Cosby story or the Harvey Weinstein
- 6:56story, where you have multiple people over decade aids, similar to Josh Dugger
- 7:01who knew or suspected, and many victims who would come forward of Harvey White
- 7:08Seen and Bill Cosby, and no one believes them or their statute of limitations,
- 7:13or the press doesn't pay attention, or the fans just want to ignore
- 7:16it. And it just points to our societal backwardness and corruption that victims of
- 7:28some of the most horrific crimes are just ignored, oppressed, blamed, not
- 7:33given justice, made to feel I mean, imagine how unsafe you would feel
- 7:40as a victim of a crime like this, and you see examples like this,
- 7:45or you're one of the victims of one of these individuals and they just
- 7:48continue to get away with it. And of course you understand that Harvey wit
- 7:53Seen, Josh Dugger, and Bill Cosby are not the only ones that are
- 7:57capable of this the ones. There's plenty of other capable of this, and
- 8:00you don't know who those people aren't necessarily because certainly Bill Cosby, no one
- 8:03would have suspected that he would have done anything like that, at least I
- 8:07never would have. And you would never want to leave your house because society
- 8:15just lets it happen. Institutions let it happen. Co workers let it happen.
- 8:20Friends let it happen, the press lets it happen. Fans let it
- 8:22happen. So it's you know, it's it's not just these three individuals.
- 8:26It's so much more than that that is really depressing and demoralizing and needs to
- 8:33fucking change. I mean, so the Me Too movement was an important step,
- 8:39but we have so so much farther to go, and that's not and
- 8:43we're talking about like mainstream progressive America. We're not even talking about what needs
- 8:48to happen within Evangelical Christians or IBLP, you know, these kinds of large
- 8:54scale Christian religious cults in our United States and that, and that's not even
- 8:58talking about when needs to happen on the world, because it's not like if
- 9:01someone lives in Saudi Arabia that we don't care about their feelings. You know.
- 9:07So this is a world epidemic or a world crisis that is continually happening,
- 9:13and we're just apparently helpless. What am I trying to say? We're
- 9:20I feel helpless? Yeah, okay, so let's talk about IBLP. So
- 9:26IBLP stands for Institute of Basic Life Principles. It was, yeah, Basic
- 9:33Life Principles. You know. The impression I got about the basicness of it
- 9:37is that the founders, Bill Authored and other people, they really wanted to
- 9:43make it simple and digestible. And I and from the little bit that I've
- 9:48seen in documentary and other places, I think they succeeded that. The delivery
- 9:54and the materials and the slides and the lectures are so basic, they're so
- 10:01simple, they're not high minded. They're very easy to digest, They're easy
- 10:05to remember. There's little phrases and and there's an aspect about them, not
- 10:11all of it, but there's an aspect about them that sound right, you
- 10:15know. It sounds like they've got to ring a truth to them. And
- 10:18I think you were saying that you would get creeped out by Bill Gothard.
- 10:22Well, what I was saying about Bill, I was saying that I got
- 10:26creeped out by the wife. The wife. But Bill Gothard reminded me of
- 10:33experiences I had when in high school when I would go to some of the
- 10:37groups that were, you know, led by one of these charismatic people,
- 10:41and it just had all that same And of course that's what he is.
- 10:43It's just I was like, yeah, I mean I've seen I've seen these
- 10:46folks. But to me, I can absolutely see why people were drawn to
- 10:52him. He has a very specific it's sort of like it's sort of like
- 10:56a mister Rogers. And I hate to make that connection, but you know,
- 11:01if you didn't know anything about him, he seems like a nice person.
- 11:05Yeah, a very wholesome, approachable He doesn't come across as particularly arrogant.
- 11:13And his lectures, and you know, it makes sense that he'd be
- 11:16giving advice on how to raise people since he raised so many kids of his
- 11:18own, right, Yeah, yeah, so uh. Instud of Basic Life
- 11:24Principles found in nineteen sixty one. It rose to power in the sixties and
- 11:28seventies, and a lot of people were talking about the factors as to why
- 11:31it would have risen the power. And for those who don't know, IBLP
- 11:37was the way I would describe it. I don't even know if this isn't
- 11:41necessarily accurate, but it was essentially a right wing Christian organization that was set
- 11:48up to assist churches. It wasn't its own church really, and it would
- 11:56have a lot of teachings and materials that you know, eventually they developed their
- 12:00own home school system, and so they made all our money from the lectures
- 12:05and the trainings and the outreach activities that they did. They weren't it's not
- 12:11like the Mormon Church where it's just like, you know, a church and
- 12:16that spreads through different you know, locations and this kind of thing. They're
- 12:20more of like this this organizing body that organized and influenced a lot of churches
- 12:28in the Midwest, is in Arkansas, and you know, the sort of
- 12:31middle zone of the United States and so roast to power. In the seventies,
- 12:35sixties and in the seventies, Americans were very scared and demoralized for a
- 12:41variety of legitimate reasons. Vietnam War, assassinations of various beloved politicians and activists,
- 12:52the decline of our economy, the oil crisis. There was a lot
- 13:00of domestic terrorism in the seventies. I mean, you know about about about
- 13:05Charlie Manson, but he was but one of thousands of small groups of people
- 13:15who were murdering and terrorizing and bombing and committing crimes and and you know,
- 13:20involved in crime waves and mass killings. There was a lot of that stuff.
- 13:24You know, we don't typically talk about that for some reason, but
- 13:28it's a major part of our of our history in the United States, and
- 13:31the seventies were you know, it's a pretty bleak time. Crime was on
- 13:33the rise, and you know, it was scary to a lot of people,
- 13:37and so there were a lot of people who were looking for some kind
- 13:43of answer, some kind of safety net, and there were a lot of
- 13:48people that stepped into this place. A lot of chrismatic leaders and maybe some
- 13:52helpful things. You know, you could argue that Sesame Street and and mister
- 13:56Rogers might have risen to power during this time as well, and they were
- 14:00forced were good. Bill Gothard was one of these individuals that rose to power
- 14:05because of this. And he would do this lecture series, the Basic Life
- 14:09Principles thing, and he would tell parents in these churches how to protect their
- 14:16kids from all these new bad things. I mean, that's not what he
- 14:18would say directly, but that's basically the message. Sex, drugs, rock
- 14:22and roll, that kind of stuff. And he would give these really simple
- 14:24advice tips. And there were these programs that they would create that did think
- 14:31you know, like kids Activities program and girls how to they can learn how
- 14:35to be women one day, you know, and and homeschooling this and outreach
- 14:41that, you know, all these all these programs that they were creating,
- 14:43how to be a good partner in a marriage. And then they had their
- 14:48heyday in the nineties and two thousands. That's when things really were at their
- 14:52peak for them. And then throughout the twenty tens they were experiencing a downfall
- 14:58due to conscious verses about sexual misconduct, and you could argue that the Dugger
- 15:05scandals didn't help, you know, because they were highly associated with that.
- 15:09So I thought we would talk about the belief system. But before that,
- 15:15let's take a break. What do you say, bro, let's do it
- 15:20all right, we're back from the break. So just going over my notes
- 15:24here about the belief system, and I can't completely summarize everything. I just
- 15:28have some things that are highlighted that are I think important to point out that
- 15:33relate to the Dugger's story and Josh Dugger and the oppression of women, that
- 15:37sort of thing. So it's hard to know the difference between IBLP and Bill
- 15:43Gothard's belief system since Bill was the chrismatic leader. You know, I think
- 15:46we associate Bill, you know IBLP, Oh, it's Bill Gothard. But
- 15:50you know, IBLP was a large organization with a lot of different charismatic leaders
- 15:54and lecturers. Bill Gothard just was the most famous and chris matic and well
- 16:00known. So when I talk about the beliefs of Bill author to IBLP from
- 16:06my distance perspective, it's all kind of one ball of wax. But there
- 16:08might be some differences. But anyway, so the other thing that should be
- 16:11pointed out is that this what I'm calling a cult, which you know,
- 16:15we might get into the specifics regarding evaluating cults later, but the beliefs of
- 16:19IBLP cult and Bill Gothard are not unique to IBLP and Bill Gothard. Many
- 16:29contemporary Christians absolutely believe in most, if not all, or even more,
- 16:34what we might call extreme ideas about gender and oppressed groups, and how to
- 16:44raise children and what the secular world is up to. You know, there's
- 16:48it's all. If you weren't in IBOP or didn't even know who Bill Gothard
- 16:52was, but you you were raised in an evangelical church, a lot of
- 16:56this will sound very familiar to you. Is a thing, you know,
- 16:59it's a lot of it's pretty mainstream, but you could argue that some of
- 17:03it was a little bit more extreme. Okay, So first I want to
- 17:07talk about gender and authority. So in my notes, I tried to have
- 17:12those different sections in my notes, you know, gender and authority, but
- 17:17given the way that they are, you can't separate, You can't discuss those
- 17:21two things separate. Yeah, so what was your take on gender and authority
- 17:26within this cult? So on the one hand, there's the standard. I
- 17:30think it's really common for most, for most Christian belief systems to have a
- 17:38paternalistic approach to it. Certainly the Catholic Church is a great example, where
- 17:45you know, the pope's a man, the priests are all men. They
- 17:48can't even get married because I don't know, women will distract them. But
- 17:52no, really it was because of Land's land reasons. But honestly it was
- 17:56just like men, it's a man's show and women are there. You're like,
- 18:00oh, I guess, Virgin Mary. That's cool and all. And
- 18:03that's true in a lot of those variants. That's not all Christian groups and
- 18:10things like that, but especially not nowadays. But it's certainly a historical truth
- 18:14and so that part's not that unusual. Where it's it goes a little further
- 18:18as well, is that they start saying this pattern of like who is in
- 18:23charge of whose lives? So it's not just that, well, you know,
- 18:30we need to all be subservant to God, and here's the belief system
- 18:33and stuff like that, and maybe it's right for the man to be the
- 18:37worker and the wife to stay home. It's not that it's that. Oh,
- 18:40Actually, the line of succession goes like this, it's God, then
- 18:44like Bill Gothor, than the man of the house, then the woman,
- 18:48and and it's a very strict system they call it. You know, being
- 18:52under the umbrella. You will not only not do well, you will be
- 18:56damned if you fall out of that system. And I was thinking about this
- 19:03and I just finally became galvanized in my mind that yeah, you have God,
- 19:08you have Bill Gothard. And officially Bill Gothard wasn't in the hierarchy,
- 19:12but the way that he was talked about and treated and maybe the way he
- 19:17saw himself was that of a prophet, a modern prophet. They weren't explicit
- 19:22about that, but you know, some of the people in the documentary talking
- 19:26about how they thought of him as a walking prophet, as a walking person
- 19:30who's connected to God. So you know, you got God, Bill Gothard.
- 19:33Then you have the dad of the household, the husband, and then
- 19:37you have the wife. That you know, seems to say that there's equidistance
- 19:41between each of those steps, but the woman, the wife is far brow,
- 19:47particularly because when it's one thing, if you're you know, if you're
- 19:52the dad, you're the husband. Bill Gothard doesn't live with you, and
- 19:56God is you know, there a certain way, but uh, in the
- 20:02home, the day to day operations, someone needs to make decisions, right,
- 20:07And uh, God and Bill Gothard aren't necessarily they're telling you what to
- 20:11do. So you got so you got dad and husband and and the mom
- 20:18said she's subservient to him. You know, the dad doesn't have to deal
- 20:21with Bill, author and God, but the mom has to deal with Dad
- 20:23all the time, right, And and the only people sort of under the
- 20:29mom are the kids, right And so uh, everyone in the in the
- 20:33church sees it that way. Everyone in the household sees that way. Extended
- 20:37family. You know, every every time you look at the woman, you're
- 20:40thinking, well, but the man, you know, the man is the
- 20:42boss over her in all ways. Whereas when you look at the man,
- 20:45you're not like, well, I better check in with Bill or God.
- 20:48You know, it's it's a very different dynamic and and uh would be and
- 20:55it is. You know, it's just extremely sexist and awful. Yeah,
- 20:57it's one thing for a family to choose to say, hey, you know,
- 21:03in this situation, I want you to take take the lead, like
- 21:07you're a better driver than I. Am or you're better with the cooking,
- 21:11or you're you're a little better with the parenting. So I'm gonna I think
- 21:15you know, you're better at evaluating it, you know, you do those
- 21:18kind of trade offs in a relationship. Or you're better with paying the bills
- 21:22on time, so you know, you take care of that checking account,
- 21:26you know, if it's a choice, But when it's forced and implemented and
- 21:30brainwashed into the women since they're born, then it, you know, results
- 21:37in people that are being absolutely harmed throughout their life. Let me just imagine
- 21:41what that would feel like. Well, and it's it's very common nowadays,
- 21:44Like you hear it from politicians, congress ladies saying, hey, uh,
- 21:52the wife needs to listen to the man. The man is in charge.
- 21:56You know, It's it's a common notion. Yeah, And I think what
- 22:00they did that was more than normal because you know, I certainly had heard
- 22:04those sides of the religious argument of like, you know, the wife really
- 22:08needs to be at home taking care of the kids, the man's in charge,
- 22:11but they crystallized that into near law, right right, Like I remember
- 22:18hearing growing up in my Christian church. That was in my memory and I've
- 22:23talked to my parents about this as well. It was very liberal and non
- 22:27oppressive from our memories and non political. But I do remember there were conversations
- 22:37about how the man is the spiritual leader of the house, but what does
- 22:41that mean? And I remember that being discussed because from my memory as a
- 22:48ten year old listening to the sermon or the discussions that it was sure.
- 22:52I mean, it says that in the Bible, and that makes sense to
- 22:55us because we live in a sexy society. But that doesn't mean that a
- 23:00husband can just do whatever he wants to and control his his wife. It
- 23:07just means that it was sort of like a figurehead or you have the title.
- 23:12But in reality, we understand that women aren't under men, and so
- 23:18therefore women have power, you know, that maybe they don't have the title
- 23:23as being the spiritual leaders. It seemed like there, you know, there's
- 23:26sort of a dancing around. Yeah, it's like, well, we're following
- 23:30the Bible's words, but we're adjusting it, or this is like is this
- 23:36one? It just follows it, you know, and there's some insidious aspect
- 23:40about it, which is, hey, as long as you're under the umbrella
- 23:44and the chain of command, You're fine, but there's this implication which means,
- 23:48unless I mean, unless some weird thing happened, assume that the chain
- 23:55of command is unbroken. Therefore you gotta do what you're told. Right,
- 24:00So let's talk about the umbrella, which I find to be in line with
- 24:03that basic packaging. Right. It's the metaphor and the visual is so easy
- 24:10to comprehend it. It's not complicated to yeah, well, let's protect you
- 24:14and fear, so it's not just like umbrella structure. It's and the members
- 24:21who would be interviewed would talk about this, not only in documentary, about
- 24:23podcasts that I listen to where they would talk about how and a lot of
- 24:27evangelicals and a lot of religious culture like this, where they talk about how
- 24:33if you step out of line, very very bad things are going to happen
- 24:36to you and the people you love. And there's this constant message of danger
- 24:42and fear and threat from the devil to the liberals, to the trans people
- 24:51in the bathrooms, to temptation to pornography, which is why you can't start
- 24:56questioning the authority because that leads to the problem. Right, So the solution
- 25:03is that you follow the authority. Structure, and if you do that,
- 25:11then you're fine. And if you are part of the umbrella, like you're
- 25:15the dad and the family, you are ultimately responsible for protecting everyone, which
- 25:21requires you not to just protect them, but to keep them in line.
- 25:26It connects all these elements that sound you know, if you hear it discussed
- 25:32from Bill Gothard, it doesn't sound nefarious, but it is nefarius because the
- 25:37end outcome is that you have all the women and girls completely without any agency
- 25:45at all. They have to do everything they're told, but it's told to
- 25:47them that it's only like that because you're in constant danger and that's the best
- 25:52in their best interest. Yeah, but it doesn't remind me of do you
- 25:55remember in South Park the episode with the underwear elms where they collect the underwear
- 25:59and then they have a plan. What's your plan? Well? Step one
- 26:03collect under under pans, Okay, step three profit. This is like step
- 26:10one. We have this system that's going to keep you safe as long as
- 26:14you stay under it. Step three. It kept you safe. And if
- 26:17someone raises their hands, like, well, what if the person above me
- 26:21isn't Step one? Yeah, check a man, Step three, everything's great.
- 26:26For example, what if older brother is what I'm under him? Check
- 26:32a man, I'm under him. What if he is a monster and is
- 26:37routinely raping me? You know, by definition, those things don't happen in
- 26:41this system because you're protected, right or he stepped out from underneath the umbrella,
- 26:47or you know, like it's all it all comes back to authority,
- 26:49like they would word it that way. Probably if someone at the top of
- 26:52the umbrella, like maybe let's say ripe if below Jesus, what if they're
- 26:56doing something wrong? Oh no, wait, that can't happen like Bill happen.
- 27:00Yeah, yeah, I think I'm realizing the genius of it because like
- 27:06with the Duggers, and it was probably framed this way that when it was
- 27:10discovered that Josh had raped his younger siblings, you know, maybe there would
- 27:15be a sort of a outside chance that they would blame the younger girls and
- 27:19say that, well, it's because you weren't doing your chores that day or
- 27:22something, or you let him, or you dress a certain way. You
- 27:26know, maybe, but they would probably look at Josh and say, well,
- 27:32because you allowed sexuality into your mind, that's you moving out from underneath
- 27:37the umbrella of your parents and of God, and that's what led to you
- 27:42being tempted to do these things. And so the genius of it is in
- 27:47terms of cult control and sustainability, is that the answer isn't to treat you
- 27:52or to look at the system. It's like, you just have to go
- 27:55under authority. You have to do everything that you're told and not think for
- 28:00yourself. Every everything is answered with that solution authority, authority, authority,
- 28:06because you're always in danger. And the overall effect, like a pyramid scheme,
- 28:11is Bill Gothard becomes massively powerful so that he can do his sexual assaults
- 28:18on girls anyway. So so yeah, authority and fear is a major part
- 28:25of this cult and others like this. By the way, of course,
- 28:29as we've been talking about, ben have one hundred percent authority over women.
- 28:32So Ephesians five is I think what they will point to and it says wives
- 28:38submit yourself to your own husbands as you do to the Lord, as the
- 28:44church submits to Christ. So also wives should should submit to their husbands in
- 28:49everything. End of quote. So, of course, sexism wasn't invented by
- 28:55Americans. It's been around for a long time and it was alive and well,
- 29:00back then when these human beings were writing about things, you know,
- 29:04these were religious folks back in the day, saying religious things that were influenced
- 29:11by their culture. And there you have it. You know. But because
- 29:15it's in the Bible, it's the word of God, and thus you're supposed
- 29:18to follow it to the t which is which again, it's just that presumption
- 29:23of like it. It's assuming well, nothing's going to go wrong, but
- 29:29knowing full well, the same book that contains that is filled with things going
- 29:33wrong everywhere by the same men, right, And you know, I want
- 29:41to point out that the Christians that I know in Seattle, when they read
- 29:45this passage, they're like, well, you know the Bible, you don't
- 29:48say it literally. You know, it's an interpretation of God's word. And
- 29:55back then, for whatever reason, that made sense to them, but it
- 29:57doesn't make sense to us. Now. We are positive that the Lord God
- 30:02Jesus Christ does not want us to do that, because there's no point in
- 30:06that. Why would women below below men? Doesn't make any sense anyway.
- 30:10Another idea is not only are they an authority, but they're superior. They're
- 30:15not just told that they have authority, They have authority because they're adherently superior
- 30:21men. Boys, males, fathers have absolute power. So then in the
- 30:25documentary it goes into spanking. We haven't told Oh my gosh, we haven't
- 30:30talking about this yet. So what do you know about IBLP and spanking?
- 30:34Well, most of what I know is what I saw in that video that
- 30:37was shown in the in the but it was shown in the documentary, right
- 30:41yeah, yeah, yeah, with the older dude calling for a volunteer.
- 30:47I want to I want to show you how to spank properly. Any boys
- 30:49in the audience, I get spank? I mean, how on the nose
- 30:53can you get? And then this little boy comes up and he's like,
- 30:56oh, like, I'm not sure what the hell is going on, and
- 31:00he proceeds to spank him and then oh again, no, it's worse than
- 31:03that. He role plays. Okay, pretend I'm your father and you've done
- 31:07something wrong and I need to punish, So I'm gonna spank you because I
- 31:10love you, So I spank you. And then when he's done, he's
- 31:12like, well, wait, so don't pay the lead the way that he
- 31:18doesn't. Oh yeah, I know. So he sits down and he gets
- 31:23the boy who looks like, I don't know, eight ten, he's a
- 31:26little and puts him over his lap and then you know, without doing it
- 31:33hard, sort of pantomimes, but he's grabbing that ass. But he yeah,
- 31:37he's making contact sufficiently with this boy's behind. And I'm not saying anything,
- 31:44but I am saying and the audience is last. It's so cute.
- 31:51This is yeah, And then when he's done, it's like, well,
- 31:55what do you think? And like the boy doesn't thank him properly or doesn't
- 32:00say he doesn't seem happy enough or something. He's like, oh, maybe
- 32:02I need to spank you again. I mean, it's so like if you
- 32:07are doing this in a parody movie, you'd almost feel like, wow,
- 32:12that's a little too much. Absolutely, if you were making a parody movie
- 32:15about and this again, this is a large if you if this was like
- 32:20thirty weirdos in Arkansas, then okay, Like I can picture Leslie Nielsen,
- 32:25yeah, doing this as a joke bit an airplane or something. But this
- 32:30is millions of people in the Midwest and the mid South of the United States,
- 32:37and they all contend. And the guy giving the lecture is a famous
- 32:42fellow who is known to be like the guru of spanking and parenting, and
- 32:47so in the video, it's it's extremely disturbing and creepy, like it is
- 32:55the definite Like if if you want to put in the dictionary, what does
- 33:00creepy mean? Just show this video. On the other hand, it's hard
- 33:05to you know. So the implication that I think you were making it.
- 33:07I think in my mind that I was imagining is that he's a sexual predator
- 33:13and is just looking for an excuse to fondle children on stage. And the
- 33:17way he goes about it is just so he's got to hug him afterwards.
- 33:22Remember, yeah, you gotta give me a hug. I'm your dad,
- 33:23remember right well that and you didn't put enough into that hug. You gotta
- 33:28do it again, That's what he says. Now I'd have to spank you
- 33:30again. It's creepy, hands down, I don't I can't imagine anyone not
- 33:34considering it to be a creepy depiction of I don't even know what I'm watching,
- 33:38honestly, So, girls and wives, mothers are all forbidden from having
- 33:45financial independence explicitly. It's not like it's subtly designed that way. It's baked
- 33:52into their rules that might even get as specific as women don't have their own
- 33:55checking account, or that if they do have a job, it has to
- 33:59be it can never interfere with them constantly being pregnant and taking care of household
- 34:04chores. Of the fact that there's so many because you have fifteen kids,
- 34:07so you know, there's there's a lot of explicit rules. You know,
- 34:12in other pockets of society, it just plays out subtly in this cult.
- 34:16It's it's explicit, right, Like imagine imagine a girl growing up in that
- 34:22cult and you ask the usual question, Hey, what do you want to
- 34:27do when you grow up? Think of how limiting. Yeah, it was
- 34:30already limiting for most of history for a woman to be asked that question,
- 34:34but think in that context, like how much more limiting? But make America
- 34:37greater. In Burnley, boys are are to be workers. College is discouraged,
- 34:44and any kind of intellectual enterprise or job is very much discouraged. So
- 34:50in these cults when they talk about, you know, boys are discouraged from
- 34:53certain jobs or college educated, that really underplays the all incomp seeing nature of
- 35:00the mind control that begins from an early age and not just from the parents,
- 35:06but the whole hierarchical structure. You know, the parents might be enacting
- 35:09parenting styles that they wouldn't have ever done naturally. And so it's this sort
- 35:15of pyramid scheme. And I used that because you know, usually the cults,
- 35:20the koreshes, the you know, the other ones. It's like the
- 35:22max amount of people you could have is fifty people, because it's not sustainable
- 35:27after a certain point. Yeah, the chrismatic leader can only talk to so
- 35:30many people. Yet you need that because the beliefs are a little too on
- 35:35the fringe or whatever. Right, yeah, right, So with this though,
- 35:39given yeah, yeah, given how organized they were and how they were
- 35:45ready victims in all these evangelical, right leaning churches to begin with, they
- 35:52could top down through a pyramid, you know, not pyramid, but a
- 35:54pyramidal hierarchical structure spread the notions that led to this cult that involved millions of
- 36:04people and abused millions and millions of kids. It's really quite astonishing. And
- 36:08by design, are going to produce a lot more of those kids. That's
- 36:13that's built in, right, Like, we got to produce a lot of
- 36:15kids, and in doctrine and all of them they got that makes our systems
- 36:20so much more powerful. Right, you need to have you need to be
- 36:23pregnant constantly, and you need the primary mission for all those kids is to
- 36:28be part of the quiver, the arrow that goes to Washington, DC or
- 36:30on the internet and convinces other people or change this policy to make it easier
- 36:36or you know, more appealing or something. Okay, So another belief So
- 36:38that's gender and authority, which we can go into more detail, but let's
- 36:45move on. Another major category of belief system is just bigotry. They wouldn't
- 36:49call it that, but you know, because this focus on queer people and
- 36:54trans people and gay people, it just doesn't make any logical sense, you
- 36:59know, and less you don't understand cults because that the power structure makes sense
- 37:02to the sustainability of a cult. Right, it's logical. But bigotry,
- 37:07like you would think you wouldn't want that because you'd want to control everyone and
- 37:13queer people will be discouraged. So what are you doing? Well? And
- 37:15this is widespread that you know, this sort of bigotry is not just you
- 37:21know, in this this sort of cult, This is a cult ish phenomenon
- 37:25that exists throughout our society, and it has to do with in group outgroup.
- 37:30The Nazis were like this with the Jewish people, you know, and
- 37:34other groups of people around the world. When you are wanting to establish power
- 37:39and control, there are a few elements that will work on the masses.
- 37:45One is as you have to inject fear, and sometimes they're already terrified to
- 37:49begin with, which we've already established that they were. In nineteen thirties Germany,
- 37:53there was a tremendous amount of fear about about war and about economy and
- 37:59chaos in politics. So you you have a terrified group of people, and
- 38:05then you stand up and say, I'm going to be strong and I have
- 38:07all the solutions, and I have no doubt that I can fix everything.
- 38:13You know, you just have. Because the more anxious you get as as
- 38:15a human being and as a group, the more we will believe a strong,
- 38:22seeming, convincing, narcissistic leader. The less scared we are, the
- 38:28more we look at an arcissistic leader and say you're narcissistic. Yeah, there's
- 38:32something wrong with you, But in a pinch, will take a narcissistic because
- 38:37it feels safer to us, So that that's another element, but fear has
- 38:43to be and then you have to emphasize the fear, maybe amplify it.
- 38:45Right, then you have target target. You need a scapegoat, you need
- 38:51someone to target. And it'll always slot into culture. Jewish people in Europe
- 38:57and around the world, but particularly you know, for just talking about Europe
- 39:00had been scapegoated for centuries. Yeah, so that cultural tradition and real easy,
- 39:10you know, and it could have been anyone else. The cultural zeitgeist
- 39:16was that the Jewish people were much more galvanizing to the mainstream German person than
- 39:23other groups. In the United States right now, it's queer people, it's
- 39:29the extreme left, right, the extreme left, which includes the queer people,
- 39:31but particularly queer people, because the fear of and the misconceptions are all
- 39:38baked into our society that have been brainwashed into us for generations about about sexual
- 39:45shame and immorality. You know, I put it in quotes and in misconceptions
- 39:51about what trans gay, bisexual people are capable of. You know, they're
- 39:57they're crazed, their compulsive off there. You know, they want to indoctrinate
- 40:02or convince or assault people. Yeah. I just think it's part because like
- 40:07we can't undercount like the whole thing there against right now is woke, and
- 40:10woke includes a lot of folks, including right black folks and other minorities.
- 40:15Well, you could argue now it's the woke scare tactics, but back then,
- 40:21in the seventies and eights and nice, it's it's, it's it's gay
- 40:24people and trans people, probably back then mainly gay people because trans rights hadn't
- 40:30been spearheaded as much by that, and probably sexual liberated was associated with that,
- 40:36like and there was a sense of like, well, I mean,
- 40:37if you're if you're not standard heterosexual, you're also a deviant sexual right,
- 40:45and and expanding it not just from that, but just people having sex outside
- 40:51of marriage, which was at least popularity wise in terms of outspoken, was
- 40:55a feature of the seventies moving forward, you know, and of course HIV
- 41:00was slided right into their beliefses. So so when you're trying to establish control
- 41:05and system, you either unconsciously will through trial and error, learn this is
- 41:12what's going to work, or you literally make a plan to enact those kinds
- 41:15of things because you've learned from previous cults and high control people, including the
- 41:20third Reich. And so you you have to have an outgroup. You have
- 41:24to have the people that are going to attack you. And since the culture
- 41:30provided it on a silver platter, career people were uh you know those people
- 41:34and continue to be in our society. So that's another elements. You got
- 41:37authority in power, you got bigotry outgroup in group, and you also have
- 41:42procreation. Is that good godly women should be constantly pregnant. They don't say
- 41:47that exactly, but but but yeah, when you hold up Michelle Dugger as
- 41:53like the paragon of femininity in your society and there's another woman who's maybe does
- 42:00a little bit more family planning and has only seven kids by the time she's
- 42:07forty five, and you put Michelle higher on the praise list, you know,
- 42:12it's it's clear, and you associate praise with going to heaven and avoiding
- 42:19writing hell. And let's not forget that the family that only had the seven
- 42:22children, you gotta wonder, does that mean they had sex a few times
- 42:27without giving birth? What's going on over here? Right? It's a little
- 42:30suspicious, And there's fear within the cult that because you have injected so much
- 42:37fear into everyone and you're all terrified of all these things that you've identified as
- 42:44threats that are constantly going to get you. Then any sign that someone is
- 42:50not right down the middle cult behavior and adherence is a risk that they're moving
- 42:58away, or they they're infult trading or something, and that'll spread like a
- 43:01cancer. Right, and so in these cults there, that's another element of
- 43:05conformity. You have to conform because the power structure perceives, or picks up
- 43:10or knows that their power is based on lies, and they understand or they
- 43:16into it that it won't take long if your members manage to be influenced by
- 43:23rational people on the outside, that you would lose all of your power and
- 43:29all of your money, and all of your fame and all your fun.
- 43:32And so you even if you're in the middle tier or the lord tier,
- 43:37you know, even if you're just a dad, you would perceive another family
- 43:43of seven kids. It's like, well, if they're going to move away,
- 43:45what if they influence my wife and then I lose control of you know,
- 43:50it's and then what does that mean? What does that mean about me?
- 43:53Does that mean I'm going to hell? Because it's my job to be
- 43:57the umbrella all that kind of stuff. Okay, so good, Godly men
- 44:01should get their wife constantly pregnant. That's another part of it. Children are
- 44:06the focus of life, which sounds really good, right. You know,
- 44:08there are a lot of the Bill Gotham speeches that we saw where it feels
- 44:13good. It's like, yeah, children are our future. Children are wonderful,
- 44:16and children are pure and beautiful, and it's so great being a parent,
- 44:21you know, it's adult kind of feels basic and good. It's the
- 44:25stuff that comes along with right. Yeah. Like, and this is I
- 44:30think also a key feature in a lot of cults, right, that there
- 44:35is some surface level presentation that seems appealing to the casual listen listener. Right,
- 44:43It's hard for a cult to take root when it's like, hey,
- 44:45Hi, nice to meet you. So are you interested in coming to our
- 44:49meeting on Friday. We're going to be discussing about how purple potatoes are really
- 44:53demons from the other planets, and they're all they're like, whoa, you
- 44:58lost me at purple potatoes. Instead of it's like, hey, are you
- 45:00interested coming on Friday? We're talking about how to be better people and how
- 45:04to improve the world. Oh, I don't know that sounds interesting. When
- 45:07I was in my thirties, I had met someone and it was a new
- 45:13friend of mine and he well, actually no, he didn't bring me to
- 45:19scientology, but he did talk about it a lot, and he was really
- 45:22into it, and the things that he talked about really changed my point of
- 45:25view about scientology. He talked about how it was a lot of self help
- 45:29and a lot of science, you know, grounded things that not over the
- 45:32top Thetan's you know, it's all this. He was just like a low
- 45:37level congregant of this church, right, and at that low level it's all
- 45:43very saint, you know, sort of like with Nexium, right with Rainierie,
- 45:46there were things on the ground level that, especially in the beginning,
- 45:50that is very helpful and powerful and normal and seems palatable. The further you
- 45:54go up in the in the pyramid, you have literally branding women, you
- 46:00know, as sex slaves. So with this they start with children are great,
- 46:05and what's so wrong about that? But then you know, and you
- 46:08know, like don't you want to like we don't get this that many years
- 46:13on this earth, Like don't you want to enjoy your time with your family
- 46:15and your children? Shouldn't you be there for them, so you have quality
- 46:20time with your twenty five children, right, And I don't know, but
- 46:27tell me if you picked up on this subtle message that, if you put
- 46:30everything together, that they're saying, it's your job to outbreed the secular heathens
- 46:37and that's your godly duty. Did you pick up on that? Well,
- 46:40So again, it's not presented like that on the surface, but of course
- 46:45that definitely, definitely because on the surface it's really about like, uh,
- 46:51this is what we're put on earth for. It's like to give birth and
- 46:53to enjoy this. And remember you're not you're not supposed to be having sex
- 46:58for fun, Like, let's be clear about this, right, Like it's
- 47:00for procreation. And then if you climb a little deeper, it's like,
- 47:06well, and by the way, we need more of us because we need
- 47:08to we are right. Everyone else is wrong. We need more of us
- 47:12to take over and blah blah. Yeah. Yeah, but that's not the
- 47:15first thing that they hit you with. And they are taking over, you
- 47:17know, they're you know, whatever they you want to identify. So before
- 47:23we go on, let's take a break. But the rest of this episode
- 47:27is is going to be for patrons of the podcast. So if you want
- 47:29to listen to us continue talking about this, and you're you want to support
- 47:35what we're doing here, become a patron of the podcast. Otherwise, please
- 47:37take care of yourself because you deserve it