Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / Why Post-IPO Firms Buy Back Shares Before Lockup Expiry
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about what companies do after they go public — secondary offerings, employee stock purchase plans, insider selling windows. But there's one move that feels almost contradictory: buying back your own stock right when the lockup expires. Luna: That's the moment when all those employees and early investors can finally sell, right? So why would a company step in and buy? Lucas: Exactly. The lockup expiry is typically seen as a flood of supply — shares hitting the market, downward pressure. But some companies use that exact window to repurchase shares, and it can be a really smart signal. Luna: Let's get concrete. Who's done this recently? Lucas: Take Rivian, for example. They've been public since late 2021, and they've had a choppy ride. But in the last year or so, they've been more active with buybacks, especially around their lockup expiries. Their stock is up over three percent in the past five days, stable compared to some others. It's not a home run, but it shows a certain commitment. Luna: And it's not just the small players. Even mega-caps do this. I remember Microsoft buying back shares after their lockups years ago. Lucas: Right, but the angle here is the post ipo context. A buyback announcement right before lockup expiry sends a message: 'We believe in our stock, and we're willing to put our money where our mouth is.' Luna: But isn't that risky? You're basically saying the market is undervaluing you. Lucas: It is a risk, but it's a calculated one. If the company has strong cash flow and a clear growth path, buying back at a temporary dip can be accretive to earnings per share. And it can boost employee morale — they see the company supporting the stock they hold options on. Luna: Speaking of employees, what's the practical effect on their equity? They're sitting on options that might be under water if the stock tanks after lockup. Lucas: That's the thing. A buyback can help stabilize the stock, so employees feel like their compensation isn't just a lottery ticket. It's a retention tool as much as a financial one. Luna: But you have to have the cash. Not every post ipo company has that luxury. Lucas: Right, and that's where it gets interesting. You see companies like Meta — they're down over eight percent in the last five days — but they have massive cash reserves, so they can afford to do buybacks even in a downturn. Smaller companies might not have that flexibility. Luna: So it's almost a signal of financial health. If you can buy back, you're telling the market, 'We have cash to spare.' Lucas: Exactly. And it's not just about the money; it's about the message. Think about it from an investor's perspective: if a company is confident enough to buy its own shares, that's a stronger vote of confidence than any analyst upgrade. Luna: But there's a flip side. What if the buyback fails to support the price? You've spent cash and the stock still drops. Lucas: That can happen, and it's embarrassing. But the company can argue that they took a long-term view. And sometimes, the buyback is just part of a broader capital return strategy, alongside dividends or debt reduction. Luna: I guess it's all about the context. Let me ask you this: how does this interact with insider selling? If insiders are selling, why would the company buy? Lucas: That's the key tension. A buyback during lockup expiry can be seen as offsetting the insider selling. It's a way to say, 'Yes, some insiders are taking profits, but we're here to support the stock.' Luna: It's almost like a PR move. Lucas: It is, but it's also a real economic decision. If the stock is undervalued, buying back is a good use of cash. And it can be more tax-efficient for shareholders than dividends, because you're not triggering immediate income. Luna: So for a post ipo company, when is the right time to announce a buyback? Right before lockup, or after? Lucas: It's usually announced a few weeks before, so the market has time to digest it. The board authorizes a certain amount, like fifty million dollars, and then the company can buy in the open market. It's a flexible tool. Luna: And this is where it ties back to our earlier talk about secondary offerings. Some companies do a secondary to raise cash, then use that to buy back? That seems overly complicated. Lucas: It can look that way, but sometimes it's about optimizing the capital structure. You might issue new shares to fund growth, but if you have excess cash, you buy back to offset dilution. It's a balancing act. Luna: So, in a way, it's about managing the optics as much as the actual numbers. Lucas: Right. And that's why we love covering this stuff — it's a mix of finance and psychology. The market reacts to signals, and buybacks are one of the loudest signals a company can send. Luna: Before we dive into the mechanics, I just want to say — if you're getting value from these conversations, a couple of dollars a month genuinely keeps us going. You can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It makes a real difference. Lucas: Yeah, it really does. We're ad-free, and that's thanks to listeners like you. Anyway, back to buybacks — one thing I want to clarify is the difference between a buyback and a tender offer. Luna: Right, a tender offer is when they specifically ask shareholders to sell at a certain price, right? Lucas: Exactly. An open-market buyback is more gradual. A tender offer is a one-time thing, often at a premium. Some post ipo companies use a tender offer right after lockup to give employees a liquidity event without flooding the market. Luna: That's smart. It's like a controlled sale. Lucas: And it works well when the company wants to support the price but doesn't want to be buying every day for months. It's a targeted approach. Luna: So what's the downside of a buyback? There has to be one. Lucas: The biggest criticism is that companies sometimes buy back at the top, wasting cash. If the stock is overvalued, you're destroying shareholder value. That's why the timing matters so much. Luna: And in a volatile market like right now, how do you know if it's a good time? Lucas: You don't always know. That's the gamble. But if you have a long-term view, you can ride out the noise. A company that's confident in its fundamentals can use a dip as an opportunity. Luna: So, in the end, it's a tool, not a magic bullet. Lucas: Exactly. It's one of many tools in the capital allocation toolbox. And when used judiciously, it can be a powerful way to signal confidence and reward stakeholders. Luna: I think the takeaway is that buybacks are not just about the math; they're about the story. Lucas: That's the perfect way to put it. In the world of post ipo companies, managing the narrative is half the battle.