Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Depositions Are Trial with Sach D. Oliver
Transcript
- 0:02Satch Oliver is a distinguished trial lawyer,
- 0:05focused on catastrophic trucking accidents, and
- 0:08is the CEO of the Oliver Law Firm, and is renowned
- 0:11for his expertise in the courtroom. With over
- 0:1520 years of trial work, he stands as one of the
- 0:18top trial lawyers in the United States. His commitment
- 0:21extends beyond depositions and trials, as demonstrated
- 0:26by his work as a passionate live auctioneer where
- 0:35he has raised millions of dollars for nonprofit
- 0:37organizations showcasing his dedication to making
- 0:40a positive impact. His inaugural publication,
- 0:44Depositions Are Trial, published by the AAJ,
- 0:47the American Association for Justice, just hit
- 0:50the shelves where he shares his expertise, results,
- 0:54and battle scars across the country. And now
- 0:57let's get started. Bill, thank you very much,
- 1:02honored. humbled to be with you here today and
- 1:05I look forward to visiting with you for the next
- 1:07hour or so. We're going to talk about depositions
- 1:11and our philosophy and methodology. Depositions
- 1:15are the trial and this is something we've written
- 1:18a book about. It's a methodology that we have
- 1:21been applying for probably 15 years now and it
- 1:25works extremely well. We're going to walk through
- 1:27some of that today. I do welcome questions. They've
- 1:31told me those need to be at the end. of the session
- 1:33today. And I look forward to hearing any questions
- 1:37that you have. So basically, I'm asking you to
- 1:41open up your mind to a new way of thinking that
- 1:45your next deposition is not a discovery deposition
- 1:50per se, like maybe you were taught in law school
- 1:52like I was. It's not a deposition to just find
- 1:56out the who, what, where, or why. But in today's
- 2:00modern trial litigation culture, your next deposition,
- 2:04it is the trial. And with today's post pandemic
- 2:11jury situation, we're seeing 50 % of witnesses
- 2:18in almost every trial that are by video. And
- 2:21some more than that depends on what jurisdiction
- 2:23we're in, of course. We travel all over the country
- 2:26and try cases everywhere. So we have to adapt
- 2:30to the different local rules and jurisdictions
- 2:32and judges. But still yet, our last case in Oregon,
- 2:38our last case in California, and our last case
- 2:40in Arkansas, those are all three extremes, jurisdictional.
- 2:4350 % of the witnesses were by video. Before the
- 2:49pandemic, our philosophy depositions are the
- 2:52trial. It was a philosophy. Now it's literal
- 2:56because of the pandemic. And so most likely the
- 3:01video, 50 % of the video depositions that you
- 3:04take, it's going to be what's shown to the jury.
- 3:08So what are you going to do with it? Because
- 3:10if it's not trial preparation testimony, it'll
- 3:13fall short and it'll be lacking, or at least
- 3:16it will be compared to ours. And so I ask you
- 3:19to open up your mind to a new way of thinking.
- 3:25And it's really simple. It's no longer a conference
- 3:28room in today's litigation environment. Now,
- 3:31keep in mind, we specialize in 18 weather cases.
- 3:35That's what we do. We do handle the occasional
- 3:37construction case, whether that's a construction
- 3:40zone or construction failure at a facility or
- 3:43nuclear plant. But most of our cases are 18 wither
- 3:48cases. We exclusively represent the plaintiffs.
- 3:51And to give some context, we have currently 18
- 3:54cases across the country. And they are significant
- 3:57and large cases. So I want you to have that context.
- 4:01So we see the conference room as the courtroom.
- 4:06It's not the conference room. And so we're going
- 4:09to put the amount of preparation necessary to
- 4:15get organized from our strategy, through our
- 4:21visual aids, through our exhibits, through our
- 4:24cadence, through our questions, to be ready for
- 4:28trial. We see the world when it comes to depositions
- 4:32as a series of deposition video clips. That's
- 4:39how I see it. We have to collect the truth. put
- 4:43an exhibit or visual aid with it so that it's
- 4:45all really enjoyable by the judge and the jury.
- 4:48And then we have to play these video clips in
- 4:5015, 30, 60, 90 second video clips to our jury
- 4:54trial. Well, that means all of the work has got
- 4:57to be done before the deposition takes place.
- 5:00And that's our philosophy. So here's an example.
- 5:04Here's a tractor trailer case in Ohio and it's.
- 5:08R &L carriers, the corporate representative.
- 5:11This is a deposition. This deposition was taken
- 5:14at a very, very nice defense firm, a tall, tall,
- 5:17high in the building, a skyscraper deal. And
- 5:21I just show you this to give you an example that
- 5:24we're going to get there way early to set up.
- 5:29And our organization, there's nothing fancy about
- 5:32it, but let's see if this video will play. If
- 5:35not, I may have to ask. Ready for the deposition
- 5:38today of corporate representative of R &O Carriers.
- 5:43I've already met him this morning. Pleasant man
- 5:45to sit right here. Deposition outline. Computer
- 5:50for videos that we're going to play. Binder 1
- 5:53with exhibits ready for trial. Clipboard just
- 5:56like we're going to do at trial. An actual calendar.
- 5:59Trucking calendar where you fill in dates. Previous
- 6:02depositions provided by great friends in the
- 6:04trucking industry. Rulers. and of course every
- 6:08exhibit visually for trial binders one through
- 6:13seven organized and ready to go so in this particular
- 6:23setup which we can see a pattern of in our depositions
- 6:27the it's pretty simple but if we have the witness
- 6:30wherever the witness is placed in this situation
- 6:32they're on the end of this long table and the
- 6:34videographer eventually will be at the far end
- 6:37of the table. We have our deposition outline,
- 6:40every question typed out, and those questions
- 6:42are sequenced. We'll talk about the sequence
- 6:45of that in just a moment. And the questions are
- 6:48sequenced in order with our exhibits and our
- 6:51visual aids that are in the binders that you
- 6:54see. And in this case, there was 136 exhibits
- 6:57and visual aids in those seven binders. And so
- 7:01they are all in precise order so that we have
- 7:05rhythm and we have flow and we are organized.
- 7:08And of course we have our toys with us like drawing,
- 7:11rulers, coloring pens, sharpies, so the witnesses
- 7:14can draw exhibits and visual aids as it as it
- 7:17occurs. We also have our laptop set up, not for
- 7:20us. My goodness, not for us. The laptop is for
- 7:25the witness to show the witness blow ups, visual
- 7:29aids, exhibits, dash cam footage. crash recreation.
- 7:33We have a policy in our office that We do not
- 7:38use our laptops during the deposition. We don't
- 7:40type on our laptops during the deposition. It's
- 7:43about the most insulting thing you could do to
- 7:45the witness, either your client or the adversary,
- 7:49is to be over there typing, working on something
- 7:51else, or much less is what I've seen so often,
- 7:53someone reading the news with a sports page.
- 7:56Because let me just tell you this and just be
- 7:58honest and blunt. Whenever I'm deposing a vice
- 8:01president corporate representative, Usually they're
- 8:04a highly paid executive, highly functioning,
- 8:06high capacity individual, and we're focused and
- 8:09we're attuned and we're in line. We're active
- 8:11listening and we're rolling through this. When
- 8:14I see that there's three defense lawyers, in
- 8:16my case sitting on the other side, every one
- 8:18of them have their laptop in front of them, and
- 8:20you just can't help but pick up that you know
- 8:23they're reading the news or the sports page.
- 8:25I say hallelujah glory to the good Lord because
- 8:29the witness also picks up on it. He's offended
- 8:32by it and he tunes in more to me as well. And
- 8:34so I always call it telltale signs. I always
- 8:37have a telltale sign that's one of them where
- 8:40we're going to annihilate the other side. Whenever
- 8:43they're checking the sports while their corporate
- 8:45representative is being deposed by our team members.
- 8:48So you just go through there and you see these
- 8:50things and you can see also. I've removed most
- 8:54of the chairs from my side of the table. That's
- 8:57so I can move freely about the courtroom. We're
- 8:59going to stand up. I'll show you some examples
- 9:02of that shortly. We'll stand up during the deposition
- 9:05and move freely about the courtroom, approach
- 9:07the witness, show exhibits. And I don't have
- 9:11them here, but we often will have our big boards,
- 9:14three by four foam boards with blowups with us
- 9:18at the deposition as well. One reason our depositions
- 9:27have been successful in our methodology of depositions
- 9:30are the trial are successful is that we consider
- 9:32the deposition process to be a journey with the
- 9:36jury. We have done the jury research, test, test,
- 9:41and test again, way before we took the depositions
- 9:46in the case. We're generally gonna do a case
- 9:49acceptance focus group. before we've accepted
- 9:53the case or right at the beginning of the case,
- 9:56and it's going to do general issue spotting and
- 9:59what we know about the case at that preliminary
- 10:01stage. Then we're going to conduct the rounds
- 10:05of investigation and discovery, collect evidence,
- 10:10manfactors, dirt, et cetera, and then we'll test
- 10:13it again. A lot of times about a midway through
- 10:17the deposition process, we'll do another focus
- 10:20group test. then once we've collected all the
- 10:23evidence and done the full investigation, taken
- 10:26the depositions, we'll do a full -blown mock
- 10:28trial, or I call it jury simulation, where we
- 10:32will, most recently we've been, the last five
- 10:34years I've been hiring outside defense counsel
- 10:37to actually prepare the defense, and I try to
- 10:40get someone with an equal or more experience.
- 10:43So if If my defense lawyer has 35 years of experience
- 10:47in the tractor trailer defense industry, I'm
- 10:50going to try to find a defense lawyer with 35
- 10:53years experience in the tractor trailer industry
- 10:54to do it or 15 years or 20 as well so that we
- 10:58can adequately test the case truly because you're
- 11:02about to find out we're going to find out our
- 11:03vulnerabilities from the very beginning all the
- 11:06way through the case and be ready for it at deposition.
- 11:09And that's because we want to know what our side's
- 11:13landmines are. before the deposition takes place.
- 11:18That level of intellect and testing and strategy
- 11:21will give you the upper hand during the deposition,
- 11:24just like it does at trial. That's why they're
- 11:27one in the same anymore. I've got a great example
- 11:34here why focus groups are so important. I had
- 11:37a tractor trailer case. where the truck driver
- 11:40was watching pornography. And obviously, I thought
- 11:44that was a huge mad factor. So we tested it before
- 11:47any deposition started on a focus group. We did
- 11:51go look at these visual aids we created, even
- 11:55the morning porno o 'clock focus group and all
- 11:58that kind of stuff. And the focus group came
- 12:02back and said, I was committing character assassination.
- 12:11And matter of fact, it was an extremely conservative
- 12:13venue. And in my mind, this is why focus groups
- 12:17are so important is I'm generally wrong. In my
- 12:20mind, that conservative Bible belt venue, the
- 12:26porno clock visual aid would have driven damages,
- 12:29right? Driven punitive damages, driven culpability,
- 12:32driven everything. However, I was wrong. We found
- 12:36out that the jury focus group jury believed I
- 12:39was committing character assassination. And so
- 12:43we realized that we needed to change and alter
- 12:46how we approach that. So we literally converted
- 12:49after this focus group. They ripped my head off.
- 12:53That we converted it to watching something didn't
- 12:55mention the word porn didn't say what they were
- 12:58watching and took away all those X's and whatnot.
- 13:01We simply said the driver. is watching something.
- 13:05It absolutely, then we tested the case again
- 13:08and it achieved what we wanted. We're telling
- 13:11the truth. Now the jury was very upset that the
- 13:14truck driver did not have any backlash blow at
- 13:16us for character assassination whatsoever. And
- 13:20quite honestly, it got better because as we tested
- 13:22it, the jurors' imaginations about what they
- 13:25were watching, they plugged in what they perceived
- 13:29to be the worst case scenario. So in that particular
- 13:33case, the defense filed a huge motion in Lemony
- 13:36to exclude pornography. And we negotiated an
- 13:40exchange where we didn't want them to do something.
- 13:44In exchange, we would not say pornography. And
- 13:47of course, they gladly agreed to it because they
- 13:49had not done their own focus group research and
- 13:52knew that we weren't even going to do it anyway.
- 13:57Mad Factor testing. We want to know the sequencing
- 14:00of the mad factor evidence, what upsets the jury
- 14:03the most, before our deposition. Why is that?
- 14:07Remember I talked about sequencing. We want to
- 14:10sequence our deposition outline as the same as
- 14:14our mad factors. So if we have a case where the
- 14:17truck driver is a convicted felon within three
- 14:20years of hire, he was on his cell phone and he
- 14:25tested positive for methamphetamines. and he's
- 14:28speeding into a construction zone. Four mad factors,
- 14:31see? Now, every time I plug it into my head as
- 14:34to what the number one mad factor is, I always
- 14:37enjoy testing it. My office likes to kind of
- 14:39take bets even, because I'm always wrong. I want
- 14:44to hear what the focus group has to say is, of
- 14:46those four, what's the most upsetting piece of
- 14:49evidence to the jury? And you know what we find?
- 14:53It's almost always unanimous. That's crazy. The
- 14:58number one mad factor is almost always unanimous.
- 15:02And that's if I've got 12 people, 72 people,
- 15:05or our last jury simulation, we brought in 144
- 15:08people in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and the number
- 15:11one mad factor, it was not quite unanimous. Over
- 15:14130 people had the same exact mad factor. That's
- 15:18kind of crazy. And so that's how important it
- 15:21is to know. And of course we use this sequencing
- 15:24throughout the rest of our trial preparation,
- 15:26but we're talking about depositions on our trial
- 15:28today. Focus groups, jury simulations, and then
- 15:32of course dress rehearsals. Your dress rehearsal
- 15:37for a trial, which we do standard two weeks before
- 15:39the trial starts, we have all of the witnesses
- 15:42by video clip, even the witnesses. that are going
- 15:46to testify live at trial, we still have their
- 15:49video clips. Our dress rehearsals are the closest
- 15:52thing that you can get to the real trial because
- 15:56of our depositions, our trial methodology. It
- 15:59works very well. And of course, If we're doing
- 16:04focus groups and we're standing in front of people,
- 16:07we're testing it out, we're then applying it
- 16:10with the depositions of our trial methodology,
- 16:12then we're doing jury simulations where we're
- 16:14testing the case adversarially, and then we're
- 16:17doing dress rehearsals, you're ready for trial.
- 16:20I mean, this methodology works so well and it
- 16:22flows. But I will tell you that our cases and
- 16:27our depositions, our trial methodology is so
- 16:31visual aid heavy, that visual aids must become
- 16:36the culture of the case. I've seen so many, and
- 16:40I used to do it this way, you know, 20 years
- 16:43ago, I used to make up a visual aid at the last
- 16:46second, or if the case didn't settle a mediation,
- 16:50oh my gosh, we've got to create our visual aids
- 16:51for trial. I will suggest to you that's the old
- 16:55way of doing it. that the way to do it now is
- 16:59we want those visual aids done way before the
- 17:02deposition, and we're using those visual aids
- 17:05in the depositions with the witnesses. Now, that
- 17:09is a work in progress. Most of our visual aids
- 17:13are spot on. They work very well. But if you're
- 17:18using them with witnesses, if it's the truck
- 17:21driver, safety personnel, engineer, mechanic,
- 17:26executive, corporate representative, and they
- 17:28don't like something about a visual aid, I'm
- 17:30gonna hand them the Sharpie to let them fix it.
- 17:33And so, and I love that organic part of the deposition,
- 17:38our trial, just like we're in front of the jury,
- 17:40and they use their Sharpie to fix it, we capture
- 17:43it all on video, and then we use the visual aid
- 17:46that's corrected with a Sharpie by that witness,
- 17:49either by video or in front of the jury live.
- 17:56If you want to consider making visual aids the
- 17:59culture of your case, then you want to bring
- 18:03them into the pleadings. Our pleadings have visual
- 18:09aids built into the complaint package, built
- 18:13into the trial briefs, built into motions. filed,
- 18:18built into motions for summary judgments filed,
- 18:21or responses, in our case generally, to partial
- 18:24motions for summary judgment. So that from the
- 18:27very beginning, every one of the case, opposing
- 18:31counsel, the judge and their staff, insurance
- 18:35committees reviewing it, of course our clients
- 18:39as well, everybody is gradually becoming accustomed
- 18:44to using and seeing and touching and being a
- 18:48part of our visual aids. We also, when we send
- 18:53letters, just routine letters in the case, let's
- 18:56say one of our cases, let's say the average turnaround
- 18:59of one of our cases is 18 months to two years.
- 19:04And how many letters do we send to opposing counsel
- 19:07or the court in that time period? 30? 50? 75?
- 19:14Well, we're gonna put the visual aid that assist
- 19:17in whatever the content of the letter into the
- 19:19letter. So even our letters have got this culture
- 19:23rolling through it. And of course, scheduling
- 19:27hearings by Zoom or in person, we're gonna show
- 19:30visual aids, all of our depositions, motion and
- 19:33discovery hearings. Of course, the mediation
- 19:35is going to have a tremendous amount. of visual
- 19:40aids. We have a mediation next week, a two -day
- 19:42mediation in Fort Worth, Texas, and 60 days before
- 19:48the mediation, we send an entire full cards up
- 19:51deposition video clips presentation with all
- 19:53of our visual aids for trial to the insurance
- 19:56tower just so they've got all our visual aids.
- 19:58No secrets there because we used every one of
- 20:00those visual aids in the 13 depositions of the
- 20:03case. Of course, pretrial hearings and trial.
- 20:08So if you're using these visual aids like this,
- 20:11if you start doing it gradually, if you've never
- 20:13done this before, just get started. That's what
- 20:18I would say. Just start. Use one visual aid.
- 20:22Use three. The next thing I hear a lot is, oh
- 20:25my gosh, Satch, you've got 20 cases. I've got
- 20:28150 cases. Well, don't try to do all this on
- 20:32150 cases. You can start on three cases. So pick
- 20:37what you believe or perceive to be either your
- 20:41favorite or your best, whatever you want to go
- 20:43about doing, three cases and start this process
- 20:48of using visual aids. I will tell you what invented
- 20:52this idea is failure because as you probably
- 20:57know, the rules in your great state, rules in
- 21:01my great state, anywhere I go, visual aids can
- 21:05be created in front of the jury. You can draw
- 21:08right there in front of the jury. Visual aids
- 21:10that are used for demonstrative aid purposes
- 21:13to assist the jury can be created by the rules
- 21:15at the last second, the night before. However,
- 21:19I have found judge after judge after judge who
- 21:24have just taken a position that If you haven't
- 21:28shown it to the other side in a timely manner,
- 21:31the presumption is they're not going to let me
- 21:34use it. And I had two or three trials in a row
- 21:37as a young buck where that happened to me, and
- 21:40I said never again. These are great, creative
- 21:43visual aids. They deliver the point. They tell
- 21:45the truth. The jury deserves to know about them.
- 21:48And all I had to do was use them throughout the
- 21:51case, give them to the other side often and early,
- 21:55show them to the judge at the hearings, and I
- 21:57could have used them. It was a simple decision
- 22:00for us. And so while it started out many years
- 22:03ago through failure, it has become something
- 22:06that plaintiff's lawyers are adopting across
- 22:08the country. And I just love to get the feedback.
- 22:11Lawyers are sending me videos of their visual
- 22:14aids and how they're using them. And it's fantastic.
- 22:17I'm thankful that it's working for so many people.
- 22:22Visual aids are a creative process. I just got
- 22:25asked to speak at the Chicago Big Truck Auto
- 22:27for the National Trial Lawyers Association on
- 22:30visual aids, because our visual aids are so effective.
- 22:33And I told them what I'll tell you. Visual aids
- 22:36have got to tell the story. And the more of an
- 22:39emotional story that they tell, the better. The
- 22:42next thing everybody's like, oh, man, why do
- 22:44your visual aids work? It's because we only want
- 22:47the truth on there. I hear lawyers say, oh, man,
- 22:50I got to come up with a trick. I got a problem
- 22:52with my case. I got to come up with a trick visual
- 22:54aid. If you're trying to trick somebody with
- 22:57a visual aid, I call that a defense verdict or
- 23:00a low verdict. And so let's not try to trick
- 23:03anybody. The reason why our visual aids work
- 23:05so well is that they're the absolute truth and
- 23:08they tell a story and I hope they're emotional,
- 23:11but they're creative and we get them out and
- 23:13show them often. We want our visual story to
- 23:17tell the five senses somehow. Get those five
- 23:22senses out there. Now you got to be creative
- 23:25to do this in depositions. You got to You know,
- 23:30obviously, sight's easy. They're going to see
- 23:32all kinds of stuff. Touch, we're going to pass
- 23:34things around to the jury. Fishing poles of the
- 23:37decedent, teddy bears of the decedent, favorite
- 23:40artwork of the injured. You know, whatever that
- 23:42is, we're passing it around. Exhibits, of course,
- 23:45we're going to pass around. So we can do touch.
- 23:48We can do hearing. Now, smell, we have to get
- 23:51creative. But how do we do that? Well, you got
- 23:54to think it through. But it's like our book,
- 23:58Depositions, Our Trial, I wanted it to serve
- 24:00as the five senses, the book itself. So I reached
- 24:04out to Nestle, had them duplicate our little
- 24:06cover of our book and create a Hershey's bar
- 24:09so that when you buy the book you get a Hershey's
- 24:12bar so it has the taste. And then of course we
- 24:14wanted to smell like leather so we inserted leather
- 24:18senses into the book. And then when you open
- 24:22the cover of the book, just like you see those
- 24:23hallmark cards to tell you something, when you
- 24:26open the cover of our book it makes the sound
- 24:30of a horse nag. And so our book even covers the
- 24:33five senses. Now you gotta be creative to think
- 24:35that through, just like in your trials. So screeching
- 24:39sounds, if we have a case where the tires are
- 24:42screeching, that's a sound that we can duplicate
- 24:44often. If we're trying to do different sounds
- 24:49like that, now what about smell? Well, I will
- 24:55tell you the most effective smells situation
- 24:58is a burning case. We had clients that got burned
- 25:01up and so the witnesses and the clients were
- 25:06talking about the smell of a burning body and
- 25:09you take cowhide of some sort and you can burn
- 25:13it and have it described and that's what our
- 25:16clients went through as their body was being
- 25:19burned. That's an example. Taste. you have the
- 25:23taste thing such as, well, burning is a great
- 25:26one because if you've ever represented a burn
- 25:28client, they talk about the black licorice taste
- 25:31in their mouth that comes back to them at all
- 25:33times. And so we're gonna pass out black licorice
- 25:36to the jury. We're gonna ask the judge and the
- 25:39jury if they'd be able to take a bite of it to
- 25:41experience even in a minor way and know what
- 25:44it's like to get this feel, even if nobody takes
- 25:49a bite. which they don't take a bite and judges
- 25:52don't want me to let them. The black licorice
- 25:55is used as a visual aid and everybody has taken
- 25:58a bite of black licorice and so you know that
- 26:00taste. So I'm telling you our visual aids, we're
- 26:02getting creative, but we want them to be the
- 26:05five senses. Let's see, where are we gonna take
- 26:10our deposition? Here's the first responder of
- 26:12a client that's cut out after a tractor trailer
- 26:14case in a construction zone. The cutters that
- 26:18you said were like giant scissors. Just like
- 26:42a giant crab claw basically. that was the one
- 26:48you said you tried using that and it wasn't working
- 26:50because it was twisting it too much it was torquing
- 26:52that pedal into okay and so that's a great example
- 26:59we're we're doing the first responders who have
- 27:01to use the jaws and the hydraulics and the solzols
- 27:04to cut our client out and so Instead of doing
- 27:07that in a lawyer's conference room or even the
- 27:09firehouse had a conference room, we did the deposition
- 27:12in the garage in the fire truck. And so he demonstrated
- 27:15the tools and got them out. He actually cut some
- 27:18metal that was like what was used to cut out
- 27:24our client from the RV. And so we use that as
- 27:29an example. Now, in that particular case, why
- 27:31do you do all that? Well, one, We wanted to have
- 27:33it on video clip. You know, I've had bad luck
- 27:36getting judges to let me bring fire trucks into
- 27:39the courthouse or even big huge jaws of life.
- 27:43You know, they tell me, go get your evidence
- 27:44some other way. This judge was a wonderful judge
- 27:48and she ordered it to come into the courtroom.
- 27:51And so hallelujah, we had the best of both worlds.
- 27:54I get to tell you that story and we got to bring
- 27:57in the real stuff in the courtroom, but we didn't
- 27:59have that video clip. in case something as a
- 28:02backup plan went wrong. Okay, depositions, your
- 28:07toys, these video clips are trial. Get your toys
- 28:11ready. Almost every one of our cases, I'm sure
- 28:14there's some exceptions, but it's been a long
- 28:16time. Almost every one of our cases, we can find
- 28:22toys on the internet that duplicate or are substantially
- 28:26similar to our fact pattern. right? We buy those
- 28:29toys, we recreate scenes all the time, and it
- 28:35is very effective with juries. Matter of fact,
- 28:41we have tested toys recreations versus crash
- 28:50reconstruction fancy digital expensive recreations,
- 28:53and they're both wonderful, and we use them both.
- 28:56They're great. But an eyewitness, using the toys,
- 29:01the jurors and our focus group testings on the
- 29:03testing we have done, preferred that method of
- 29:07evidence over the engineer talking through the
- 29:09crash reconstruction digital animation. And so
- 29:12I'll just give you some examples. You'll see
- 29:14that it's so simple. Here we're deposing a construction
- 29:18site superintendent. You can see the toy setup.
- 29:21All right. What's the next warning sign? One
- 29:26lane road or be prepared to stop. Either or.
- 29:30I've got a one lane road. Would you put it out
- 29:32there? Is there a cone by it? Yes. All right,
- 29:37what's the next warning sign? Is there a red
- 29:42orange cone by it? Yes. And is this how you set
- 29:47it up on the day of the wreck, July 12, 2017?
- 29:49Yes, sir. And were you following the law that
- 29:53required a 1 ,500 feet advance notice of a highway
- 29:55work zone? Yes. Nothing fancy other than that.
- 30:00We're setting it up. And so jurors, witnesses.
- 30:04can just set it up and feel it and see it. And
- 30:07here in this situation, we were able to set that
- 30:09up with the jury as well. And so we kind of had
- 30:13a debate on, do we hot glue everything together
- 30:15so that we can save time in front of the jury,
- 30:17or do we let the witness set it up again and
- 30:19give them a picture of what they'd done previously?
- 30:22This case resolved, and so we didn't have to
- 30:24go through that debate at trial. OK, repeat after
- 30:31me, or I like to better say positive repetition.
- 30:34We're going to utilize our depositions to conduct
- 30:38positive repetition. For those of you who've
- 30:41tried a lot of cases, you know that repetition
- 30:43is important. We all know that. However, I would
- 30:47hear, I'd go to a seminar like this and I'd hear
- 30:50a great trial lawyer stand up and say, you got
- 30:53to tell the jury. Repetition, repetition, you
- 30:56tell them again, you tell them what you told
- 30:58them, and then you tell them what you conclude,
- 31:00you know, whatever. Positive repetition. Then
- 31:02I'd stand up and hear another great trial lawyer
- 31:04that I really admired say, no, juries, they get
- 31:08upset with you with too much repetition, or they're
- 31:11smarter than you think you should say at one
- 31:13time. And I was very confused for a long time
- 31:16until I realized they're probably both right.
- 31:19And so that's where I started implying, applying
- 31:22positive repetition. Positive repetition is where
- 31:26we may show or share the same type of thing through
- 31:31different modes, through different visual aids,
- 31:35through different witnesses. But we don't say
- 31:39the exact same thing or show the exact same thing
- 31:43over and over and over. That becomes what I call
- 31:46despicable repetition. And you guys all know
- 31:49what I'm talking about. You guys know it. You
- 31:52have felt despicable repetition, every one of
- 31:55us in our lives, unfortunately, probably often.
- 31:59And so I hope I don't do it today. What we want
- 32:03to do is we want jurors to want to feel and see
- 32:07and hear what the evidence is. And because it's
- 32:11coming from in a different picture or a different
- 32:14drawing or a different animation, or a different
- 32:17witness, it's received in a positive repetition.
- 32:21Man, what are some examples of that? Exhibit
- 32:2329C. Is it your understanding that from the download
- 32:32from Martin's tractor that Martin's driver maintains
- 32:35a speed of around 65 miles per hour until eight
- 32:40seconds before impact? That's what the exhibits
- 32:51appear to show, yes. Nothing fancy about that.
- 32:54We're taking very boring information, speed from
- 32:58a download, and creating an exhibit and a visual
- 33:01aid. What I want to show you here is that while
- 33:03we're talking about positive repetition, but
- 33:05this is the actual visual aid that's simply prepared
- 33:08ahead of time, marked with an exhibit, and used
- 33:10with a corporate representative. This was a video
- 33:13clip for trial. It's all done. And so, but here's
- 33:17the positive repetition. Here's another version
- 33:19of the same thing. So an engineer, obviously
- 33:55crash reconstruction is walking us through this,
- 33:58but it's a different analysis, but it's the same
- 34:01same data from a different approach. And so there's
- 34:14an example of positive repetition. Here's another
- 34:16way. So in 29 F. Martin's driver. would have
- 34:23been violating the speed limit plus violating
- 34:26the recommended speed for that curve, true? Mr.
- 34:30Gaynor would have been violating those, yes.
- 34:32While driving Martin's tractor trailer, true?
- 34:35Yes. As a Martin employee, true? Yes, he was
- 34:41an employee at that time. Nothing fancy about
- 34:46this. I hope you're receiving these visual aids
- 34:48and saying that's simple. That's what we really
- 34:50want to accomplished here today and there's nothing
- 34:54fancy about the visual aid other than it was
- 34:56done and used in the deposition and now the video
- 35:00clip is completely prepared for trial and so
- 35:04you've seen three different versions of essentially
- 35:06similar evidence but in a positive way different
- 35:09visual aids and different witnesses positive
- 35:12repetition here's another example of positive
- 35:15repetition so on exhibit 25a martin's driver
- 35:19keith gainer In the state of Arkansas versus
- 35:21Keith Gaynor guilty plea, pages eight and nine,
- 35:24lines 24 through one, Keith Gaynor says, so I
- 35:29was intoxicated and I was taking a turn too fast,
- 35:32I flipped my semi and it crushed a car and killed
- 35:36somebody. Do you see that? I see that. And are
- 35:39those the facts as you understand them? Yes.
- 35:52So really not worried about the content here.
- 35:55What I'm worried about is the teaching philosophy
- 35:58in that this is positive repetition on one slide
- 36:03that is set up ahead of time because of our preparation
- 36:06to get the truck driver and the corporate representative
- 36:09on the same testimony in the same 30 seconds.
- 36:12So that's I call it double positive repetition.
- 36:15And so we just have to do this once. Also, when
- 36:17we do something like this, We don't do it again
- 36:20with the truck driver. I'm not going to show
- 36:22that same thing. If we cover this testimony with
- 36:24a corporate rep, and I'm talking about a trial,
- 36:27not in deposition. We may cover it in deposition.
- 36:30But at trial, we're not going to then again use
- 36:35this exact same testimony with the driver. The
- 36:37jury's already received it. And so we're worried
- 36:40about exhibit 55. to despicable repetition, which
- 36:47is what we don't want to do. I talked about standing
- 36:52up. If you remember about 45 minutes ago, I talked
- 36:56to you about why we move the chairs away from
- 37:00our side of the conference room table in the
- 37:03depositions, our trial courtroom. And that's
- 37:06so that I can stand up or you can stand up and
- 37:09take the deposition. I would never suggest to
- 37:12you that you stand up the entire time at all
- 37:15unless your back's hurting. But what I do do
- 37:19is I just get up and go get an exhibit. I go
- 37:22get up and get a visual aid. And then we walk
- 37:25to the witness. And what I found is that for
- 37:29the same reasons that we usually stand up for
- 37:31direct or cross examinations or opening and closing
- 37:35statements at trial, they work the same way in
- 37:39the deposition. It also breaks things up. I don't
- 37:42know how many of you have to take depositions
- 37:44that are hours long, but I have found that just
- 37:48everybody bogs down at four hours. And so standing
- 37:52up literally kind of wakes everybody up. It changes
- 37:54things and it changes the angles and it works
- 37:57very well. And there's absolutely no rule against
- 38:00it. Once again, I'll tell you the story what
- 38:04created this. is I was young and taking great
- 38:10depositions. Things were going well for us. And
- 38:13the fence bar in our little tiny state had kind
- 38:16of been talking about our deposition strategy.
- 38:20And so I generally have a way that I set up the
- 38:24deposition and the way that I handle exhibits
- 38:27and visual aids. And so I got to this, this is
- 38:31gonna be 15, 20 years ago. I got to take down
- 38:34to the defense firm where they wanted me to take
- 38:36their corporate representatives deposition. I
- 38:39go up the elevator and I walk into the conference
- 38:42room and on my side of the table are stacks and
- 38:48stacks of bankers boxes where I usually sit and
- 38:54they're all down through there and there's a
- 38:56chair at the far end of the table that's for
- 38:59me and then The defense firm had it was clearly
- 39:04law clerks and secretaries taking up all the
- 39:07other chairs. So when I walk in, there's one
- 39:09chair available for me. Of course, at first,
- 39:11I was very upset by that. And so I had to go
- 39:14out in the hallway. And at first, I was angry,
- 39:17but probably a little bit came out of that. And
- 39:18I thought, oh, my goodness, you know what? I'll
- 39:20just have a little fun with this. And so I stood
- 39:23up and took that entire deposition from the back
- 39:26of the room. And I did it because I was kind
- 39:29of forced to in this circumstance. It was a phenomenal
- 39:34deposition. And it was just like when I was in
- 39:37the courtroom and I was walking up, approaching
- 39:40the witness, taking exhibits up there, backing
- 39:42away, body positioning, body language. I was
- 39:45going back and forth, walking around, handing
- 39:47stuff to the defense counsel, walking up to the
- 39:49witness, getting in different spots. And I had
- 39:52so much fun that day because the defense lawyer
- 39:55did the dirty deed to us. And I left there and
- 39:59on my three -hour drive home that day, I was
- 40:00like, godly, I need to stand up for depositions
- 40:03more often. Shortcuts challenging or negatively
- 40:07impacting nuclear industrial radiological safety
- 40:11are not tolerated. Do you agree with that? Yes.
- 40:21So if there's a shortcut... that negatively impacts
- 40:25nuclear, industrial, or radiological safety,
- 40:29supervisory personnel at energy should not take
- 40:33that shortcut. True? I agree. That would be an
- 40:37intolerable behavior. True? The expectation.
- 40:46Nothing fancy about that other than we're standing
- 40:48up and you're seeing us use the boards. That's
- 40:50the only point of that slide. I also want to
- 40:54visit with you about cadence, because we've heard
- 40:58about cadence in the courtroom forever. I've
- 41:02heard some of the best trial lawyers I've ever
- 41:04heard speak just unbelievable talk about cadence,
- 41:08even in a direct exam, but you mostly hear it
- 41:11taught in a cross examination in the well of
- 41:13the courtroom. And I believe in all of that wholeheartedly.
- 41:17And so I... I've heard it taught and we were
- 41:21trying to do it and trying to learn how to do
- 41:23that in the courtroom and all is wonderful. But
- 41:27how do I get cadence? How do I get rhythm? That's
- 41:32what I was trying to figure out. Well, as Phil
- 41:35mentioned when he introduced me, I've been trained
- 41:37as a live auctioneer. So I went to auctioneering
- 41:40school, I think in 2009. and had a great time.
- 41:44It was just a great experience. It expanded my
- 41:47mind. It taught me new things, things I've never
- 41:48been exposed to. But at auctioneering school,
- 41:52you have to learn about cadence and rhythm. And
- 41:55you have to do it with something that's kind
- 41:57of boring, numbers. And so here's how they taught
- 42:00us at auctioneering school cadence and rhythm.
- 42:04They taught us to take our favorite song, every
- 42:07student there pick their song. and go sing the
- 42:12chorus line. So I picked I've Been Everywhere
- 42:16Man by Johnny Cash. You guys hopefully heard
- 42:18the song. If you hadn't, shame on you. Let me
- 42:21know. I'll send it to you. And you guys, they
- 42:25know it. It's, you know, I've Been Everywhere
- 42:26Man, right? And so you have to sing it. I've
- 42:29been everywhere, man. I've been everywhere, man.
- 42:32So then once you get that chorus down, then they
- 42:35have you plug in The cadence of the chorus line
- 42:39with numbers. I've been everywhere, man. I've
- 42:42been everywhere, man. $5 bid now $10. $10 bid
- 42:46now $15. $15 bid now $20. And the next thing
- 42:50you know, you've got cadence with numbers. And
- 42:54then you can speed that up, of course, or slow
- 42:56it down. Well, after we practice that every day
- 42:59for like 14 days in a row, everybody there, even
- 43:04folks who said they could not dance and had no
- 43:06rhythm, They had cadence. They had rhythm. It
- 43:10can be taught. And I'm driving back from Dallas,
- 43:13Texas, and it hit me. I had so much fun with
- 43:17this cadence and rhythm process. I was like,
- 43:20oh my gosh, I can do this in my next deposition.
- 43:23I can practice cadence and rhythm by getting
- 43:25my questions short, more concise, and I can get
- 43:29to rolling just like I've heard great trial lawyers
- 43:32from across the country teach in the courtroom.
- 43:35We'll start doing it. and depositions. And we
- 43:38started practicing it, and it works very well.
- 43:41You have to be organized. You have to have your
- 43:44questions succinct and as short as possible.
- 43:46But as you guys know, for the same reason it
- 43:48works in the courtroom, it works very well in
- 43:51depositions. Because what I wanted is just roll
- 43:53the video clip, roll down with that cadence and
- 43:58rhythm. And if you need help with cadence and
- 44:00rhythm, you should buy some Johnny Cash music
- 44:03and listen to a Billy Graham sermon. because
- 44:06these two gentlemen are some of the best ever
- 44:09in history with cadence and rhythm. Actually,
- 44:13we do depositions, our trial workshops, and I
- 44:16have people pick their favorite songs. We then
- 44:19write out three questions, three to 10 questions,
- 44:22but I'll usually start them out with three questions
- 44:24on one of their cases, and then we take their
- 44:27chorus rhythm and have them do it with their
- 44:29three questions. It doesn't take people very
- 44:31long. In less than an hour, we'll have trial
- 44:34lawyers of every age using a little cadence and
- 44:40rhythm. Uphill language. I like to conclude here
- 44:47in my last few minutes with uphill language,
- 44:51because there's language that I hear us use on
- 44:56both sides of the aisle. all the time that are
- 45:00just creating more obstacles for ourselves. Such
- 45:05as the most common is, you would agree with me.
- 45:11I hear lawyers use this, you would agree with
- 45:13me. You would agree with me. Well, I don't know
- 45:16what kind of depositions you're taking, but most
- 45:19of the time, the person I'm deposing or the people
- 45:23or the entities I'm deposing, we filed a lawsuit
- 45:26against them. Or if you're on the other side
- 45:29of an aisle, that person perceives and believes
- 45:32you hurt them. And so if you're an adversarial
- 45:36attorney to the witness and you say, you'd agree
- 45:39with me, you start the witness out before they
- 45:43even hear the question, no, I don't. And what
- 45:47we want to do is we want to open up the window
- 45:50for the truth. That's our only goal here. Our
- 45:53methodologies work very well if your goal is
- 45:55to collect the truth. And what I have found is
- 45:5980 % of the witnesses that I depose, by the way,
- 46:04this is bar stool science, 80 % of the witnesses
- 46:08that I depose are good people, truth telling
- 46:12individuals who want to tell the truth. They're
- 46:17good at their jobs, they're good husbands, they're
- 46:18good spouses, they're good parents, everything.
- 46:21And it's only the pressure of litigation that
- 46:25puts them in a situation where it's not that
- 46:29they don't want to tell the truth, they're just
- 46:30under pressure. Whatever that source of pressure
- 46:32is, I don't know. But what I found is that 80
- 46:37% want to tell the truth. And on those 80%, our
- 46:41methodologies work well to simply open the window
- 46:44to let the truth come out. That's all we want.
- 46:48Now, 10 % of witnesses, they're going to tell
- 46:52the truth no matter what you and I do. Hallelujah
- 46:54for those witnesses, right? Those are short depositions,
- 46:58and it feels great. Your mind didn't have to
- 46:59work as hard that day. The other 10 % of witnesses
- 47:04are going to outright lie no matter what you
- 47:08and I do. And you don't have to worry about those
- 47:10people because they're all going straight to
- 47:11hell. And what I've found with witnesses that
- 47:15are willing to outright lie, when those witnesses
- 47:20or entities get in front of a jury, the jury
- 47:23rings them up. So that's why I say our methodology
- 47:27works 100 % of the time. The 80%, they just need
- 47:31a little help to open the truth window. The 10
- 47:33% are going to tell the truth no matter what
- 47:34you do. And the other 10 % are going to lie,
- 47:37play those lies in front of the jury and it'll
- 47:39be the highest verdict you've ever received.
- 47:41Or if you're on the other side of the aisle,
- 47:43for me, it'll be a defense verdict if the plaintiff
- 47:46lies. We want to avoid, or try to avoid, me and
- 47:53my in our questioning. Because if you're making
- 47:56this deposition about you, things aren't going
- 47:59to go good. That's all there is to it. The word
- 48:03correct is difficult. So I don't know. I'm not
- 48:08a big fan of the word correct at the end of our
- 48:12questions. So da da da da da correct, da da da
- 48:15da da correct. It's not just horribly wrong.
- 48:19But what I'll find is you've got to really make
- 48:21sure that your question, your load is what I
- 48:24call it. The load of the question is perfect
- 48:27or the word correct can be a little confusing
- 48:30to the witness. All, every and never. When I
- 48:37was young, I put those three words in every single
- 48:40question, every single always never question.
- 48:43And I was running into all these roadblocks with
- 48:46witnesses just constantly. roadblock roadblock
- 48:50oh my gosh what's the problem there's something
- 48:53simple it's like well the word all every never
- 48:57and what i found is just take them out the question
- 49:01is just as good and just as strong and you don't
- 49:03have to put in those types of words they're just
- 49:07going to create obstacles here's an example it's
- 49:11a very simple example but do you agree with me
- 49:17tractor trailer should have safe brakes on each
- 49:19axle. Instead, tractor trailer should have safe
- 49:24brakes on each axle. And I'm doing that with
- 49:27inflection, which we practice, or tractor trailer
- 49:30should have safe brakes on each axle. True? And
- 49:34of course, that's assuming a hostile witness
- 49:35and cross -examination for a leading question.
- 49:39It's my understanding, once again, I hear this
- 49:42all the time. Matter of fact, I've seen this
- 49:44taught. It's my understanding that, insert, what
- 49:48I've seen happen with witnesses, adversarial
- 49:51witnesses, when you say it's my understanding,
- 49:53wait a minute. And so what we've said is, so
- 49:58it's clear for the jury. So it's clear for the
- 50:00jury, Great White Logistics hires drivers with
- 50:02no felony convictions within three years of hire.
- 50:05True? And so there are things like this that
- 50:09create an easier path to the truth. and simply
- 50:12removes you or me from the process. Now open
- 50:18it up, whatever questions you have, worst case
- 50:20scenario, I don't know the answer, but I'll do
- 50:23the best I can to honestly answer it. Thank you
- 50:26very much. Well, great. Yeah. So we do have some
- 50:30questions. The first one is in regards to your
- 50:35mock jury section. They were asking, do you worry
- 50:38about defense's discovery of your mock jury materials?
- 50:41It's very possible. It is possible. And I've
- 50:45been worried about that before. I've had it happen
- 50:47before where defense found out and they did a
- 50:50implant, a planted a defense, a juror, a spy
- 50:54in our mock trial event. And so it is very possible.
- 51:01I think that that's part of the risks. We tried
- 51:03to do a background check on our jurors and they
- 51:07got to sign their life away. of course, and confidentiality
- 51:10and agree that that's not happened ahead of time.
- 51:13So we do do things to try to prevent that. It
- 51:16is possible, though. All right. And let's see.
- 51:22This question is in regards to the first example
- 51:26you're using with the truck drivers with the
- 51:28character assassination. They wanted to know
- 51:30if you were using animations too in that particular
- 51:33deposition. Animations too? I don't know. I don't
- 51:41understand the question. I guess they're just
- 51:45curious if you're also using animations in your
- 51:47depositions. This was in regards to the one with
- 51:51the video that you were talking about that you
- 51:53didn't want to end up using. Yes, we use animations
- 51:59in most of our depositions of some sort. It depends
- 52:01on every case is different, but we generally
- 52:04do show some sort of animation. I call it recreation
- 52:07animation. We've tested that. That's like a cartoon,
- 52:10and it's not real. A recreation is real. And
- 52:13so we're going to use a recreation of some sort
- 52:16generally on almost every case, not every deposition,
- 52:20but strategically with witnesses. And then the
- 52:26next question is, they would like you to repeat
- 52:28what the mad factor is. I guess they're also
- 52:32curious as to what is almost always unanimously
- 52:35chosen among jurors. Was there a specific one,
- 52:38or was it all the ones that you mentioned? That
- 52:41was a specific case example that I gave you.
- 52:45What I meant by is in every individual case that
- 52:49you test, let's say you've got five mad factors,
- 52:53pieces of evidence that upset the jury. What
- 52:56I'm telling you is that most of the time, the
- 52:59piece of evidence, the number one mad factor
- 53:01that upsets the jury the most is unanimous amongst
- 53:04your focus group members. So you and I would
- 53:07have to get together and talk about and list
- 53:10out and brainstorm what are the mad factors and
- 53:12then test it. And we'd find that the jurors are
- 53:15like, every one of them is, that makes us the
- 53:17most upset. Great. And another question is, if
- 53:23you have a large stack of business records, do
- 53:26you have any more tips on making those interesting
- 53:28or more interesting when you must present them?
- 53:31Absolutely. When you have boring information,
- 53:35that's why visual aids are even more important.
- 53:37And so we're going to do summary. versions of
- 53:41it, but let's just say you've got 1 ,000 pages,
- 53:44right? Surely, I'm praying you don't have to
- 53:47go through 1 ,000 pages there. But of the 1 ,000
- 53:49pages, let's say you have to go through 150 of
- 53:52them in a deposition, and that's realistic sometimes.
- 53:55In that situation, we are going to have a visual
- 53:58aid created for those 150 boring business records,
- 54:02visual aids of it, blowups, or if there's anything
- 54:05we can at all creatively attached to it as a
- 54:09photograph or an animation or a red flag, and
- 54:13then we're going to hand the original document
- 54:15to the witness, and then we're going to hand
- 54:18them, let's say the original document is exhibit
- 54:21one, then exhibit 1A is the visual aid of that
- 54:27document, and then we're going to repeat that
- 54:30so that it's simple, it works, and it is how
- 54:34we make something very boring. a little bit more
- 54:38digestible or tolerable in how we go about it.
- 54:42The next thing I would tell you to do is how
- 54:46do you take those business documents and turn
- 54:49it into a story? That's what you really want
- 54:53to try to do. So boring thousand documents. Well,
- 54:57what's the three minute or less story of those
- 55:00documents? Then storyboard it. You can pile up
- 55:05these documents, but let me tell you the story
- 55:07of these documents, ladies and gentlemen, or
- 55:10let's get that story out through a series of
- 55:12questions from a witness and let a witness tell
- 55:14the story of these documents. And then if possible,
- 55:18usually in most cases, there's some photograph
- 55:21or drawing that we could, as the person tells
- 55:24the story of the documents, then those photographs
- 55:29or drawings pop up across the top as you tell
- 55:33the story. Now, every case would be different.
- 55:36There might be cases that are just so boring
- 55:40that you couldn't even do any of that. But most
- 55:43of the time what we find, almost all of our cases,
- 55:46there's a way to take that big pile of documents
- 55:48and tell a story and create visuals for them.
- 55:52And then the next question is, what is the best
- 55:57way to gather a mock jury pool? You know, I don't
- 56:01think there's a best way. There's so many ways
- 56:03to do it. I have done I was much younger I would
- 56:07go into gas stations and sit down at the little
- 56:10cafe area and start talking to him about the
- 56:11case So that can how we got started. I have gone
- 56:15to local churches Give them a thousand bucks
- 56:17if 20 people would stay after church and hear
- 56:20about this case Now of course, we're more sophisticated
- 56:24and we hire headhunters now and we give them
- 56:27demographics because we're gonna find out the
- 56:30demographics of our venue and we are going to
- 56:33duplicate as close as possible the demographics
- 56:36of our venue. And so we are head hunters now
- 56:40for our focus groups and jury simulations to
- 56:42get that accomplished. I just don't want people
- 56:44to get, if you're not doing it now, don't worry
- 56:47about it so much as. Put an ad in the newspaper,
- 56:52put an ad on Craigslist, put an ad on YouTube,
- 56:54put an ad out there that you're gonna pay a hundred
- 56:57bucks for a morning on a Saturday for two hours.
- 57:01You'll have people sign up. Now you have to vet
- 57:03them, of course. But you can also, and inexpensive
- 57:07is just calling a simple staffing agency and
- 57:10asking for six men, six women, or whatever you
- 57:15want to do. And so those are some ways of doing
- 57:18it if you're Wanting to get started, don't worry
- 57:22about it too much. Just round up a group of people
- 57:24and get started. If you're already doing it and
- 57:26you're ready to go more sophisticated, then I
- 57:29encourage you to set up a call with myself and
- 57:31Philip Miller, who's our jury consultant across
- 57:33the country, who we've done so many of these
- 57:35and gotten crazy results. And so he's the best
- 57:38I've ever seen at doing it. Philip Miller out
- 57:41of Nashville, Tennessee. And there are others
- 57:43who are awesome at it as well. He's just one
- 57:46of my closest friends and he and I have been
- 57:47doing it since 2000. 12 of the other. All right.
- 57:53And let's see. So what apps or media do you use
- 58:00for deposition visuals, PowerPoints, still photos,
- 58:04videos? All of the above. We're using everything.
- 58:11I mean, that's it. We're using everything. And
- 58:13I'm constantly challenging my team to be more
- 58:15creative and try new stuff. So when we do try
- 58:19new stuff, like new visuals or new animations,
- 58:22we don't do the entire deposition that way. Like
- 58:25we'll stick to what we know, which is primarily
- 58:27PowerPoint, quite frankly, videos, pictures.
- 58:31But if they've got a new idea, then we'll bring
- 58:34in three new ideas, not 100, into the next deposition,
- 58:39test it out. I'm also a big believer in what
- 58:43they call paper, Sharpies, glue, crayons, butcher
- 58:49pans, hobby lobby, two -by -fours. If you've
- 58:54seen our trials, we have a two -by -four timeline
- 58:57where we put a two -by -four in front of the
- 58:59jury, put dowel rods in it for our chronological
- 59:01timeline. And so we're big believers in all of
- 59:05those things. And of course, I love playing with
- 59:06toys. Well, great. I think that about wraps up
- 59:11Q &A. Mr. Oliver, thank you so much for your
- 59:15time today. The presentation was fantastic. And
- 59:18I hope our attendees enjoy the rest of their
- 59:20afternoon. Thank you so much. Thank you all.
- 59:22Bye bye.