Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Protecting Minors in the Influencer Economy: The Child Content Creator Rights Act and Coogan Law Update
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, I am David Schraga, the Secretary of the
- 0:05Beverly Hills Bar Association's entertainment
- 0:07law section, and welcome to today's program titled,
- 0:11Protecting Minors in the Influencer Economy,
- 0:13the Child Content Creator Rights Act, and a Coogan
- 0:16Law Update. Before starting our program, the
- 0:19entertainment law section wanted to acknowledge
- 0:21the support of our sponsor, Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:24Company. For five decades, Lawyers Mutual Insurance
- 0:27Company has been the only California -based company
- 0:29to continuously provide lawyers throughout the
- 0:31state with professional liability insurance coverage.
- 0:35Their experience and expertise are complemented
- 0:37by the fact that LMIC is directed by a group
- 0:40of dedicated lawyers themselves. They offer special
- 0:43rates with competitive premiums for a wide range
- 0:45of areas of practice, including entertainment
- 0:48law. You can learn more about them at LawyersMutual
- 0:51.com. And now I am delighted to introduce today's
- 0:55program moderator, Libby Morehouse. Libby Morehouse
- 0:58is an associate in the Los Angeles office of
- 1:00Gordon Reese Scully Mansukani, LLP, and a member
- 1:03of the employment practice. She represents clients
- 1:06in a variety of employment and pre -litigation.
- 1:09claims for wrongful termination, discrimination,
- 1:12harassment, and retaliation, as well as FIHA
- 1:15claims. Libby graduated in the top of her class
- 1:18at LMU Loyola Law School and was a member of
- 1:21the St. Thomas More Honor Society. During her
- 1:23time in law school, Libby served as a senior
- 1:26production editor for the Loyola of Los Angeles
- 1:29Entertainment Law Review. Libby also published
- 1:32her note on the need for legislative protection
- 1:34of minor children in social media during her
- 1:37time at Loyola. Libby, the floor is yours. Hi,
- 1:41everyone. David, thank you for the introduction.
- 1:44I'm excited for our panel today. We are joined
- 1:47by two amazing panelists, Uduak and Tyler Cho.
- 1:51Uduak is a fashion and entertainment lawyer,
- 1:54a former fashion model, and the founder of Fashionet
- 1:56Law. Fashion and Law, a boutique law firm serving
- 2:00clients from the fashion, music, film, and digital
- 2:03media industries. Widely regarded as a pioneer
- 2:06in U .S. fashion law, she launched the first
- 2:09fashion law seminars at San Francisco Fashion
- 2:12Week in 2005 and developed the first West Coast
- 2:16modeling law curriculum. She also created and
- 2:20taught the first fashion law course at California
- 2:22State University Sacramento. Her work includes
- 2:26advising on intellectual property, music, and
- 2:29media licensing, talent agreements, modeling
- 2:32contracts, and brand sponsorships. She also handles
- 2:36cross -border deals, particularly between the
- 2:38US and Africa, with a focus on the Afrobeats
- 2:41music industry. We're also joined by Tyler, who
- 2:45is the founder and CEO of Tyler Chow Law for
- 2:48Creators and Creator Arc, a legal and strategic
- 2:52advisory firm representing some of YouTube's
- 2:55biggest stars. Known as the creator's attorney,
- 2:58she also serves as a fractional CEO and business
- 3:02architect for digital talent building platform
- 3:05native media companies. She helps creators go
- 3:08from six figure brand deals to seven and eight
- 3:10figure businesses through intellectual property
- 3:13protection, digital product strategy, and consumer
- 3:16brand developments. Her clients have launched
- 3:18ventures inspired by breakout, creator -led brands
- 3:22like Feastables, Prime Hydration, Chamberlain
- 3:25Coffee, and Skims. Before launching her firm,
- 3:28Tyler spent nearly two decades as an entertainment
- 3:31attorney in Hollywood, holding senior roles at
- 3:34Disney, Skydance, Buzzfeed, and top firms, including
- 3:37Loeb & Loeb and Hogan -Lavelle's. She served
- 3:41as lead counsel on 18 feature films, including
- 3:44Saving Mr. Banks, Cinderella, and Gemini Man.
- 3:48A graduate of UC Berkeley, Tyler is based in
- 3:50Los Angeles and is on a mission to ensure creators
- 3:53don't just get brand deals, they build empires.
- 3:57Today's panel is to discuss recent developments
- 4:00in the Coogan Law and additional laws to protect
- 4:03children in social media, and we are very excited
- 4:06to discuss. Uduak? Thank you so much, Libby,
- 4:10for the introduction. Hi, everyone. Happy New
- 4:12Year. I hope your year has been off to a good
- 4:15start. And Libby, very, very impressive with
- 4:18your accomplishments. Congratulations. Keep it
- 4:20up. I know we have a lot of law students, too.
- 4:23actively participate. So here's where I want
- 4:25to start the conversation. I think often when
- 4:28I'm approached, particularly within the industry
- 4:30from practitioners as well as law students or
- 4:33recent grads, they always want to know how to
- 4:35get into the industry or if you are how you can
- 4:37apply it. So for our purposes, I want to share
- 4:40my background and that sort of take it into what
- 4:43we're discussing today. So let's start with when
- 4:46I entered into the fashion industry at 14 years
- 4:49old. I entered the fashion industry and although
- 4:52I was here in California, which has the Coogan
- 4:55law, there was no trust account and no court
- 4:58oversight with respect to the fashion modeling
- 5:02activities I was engaged in. So what that meant
- 5:06in practical terms were no protected earnings
- 5:08whatsoever, again, no court oversight, no clear
- 5:12consent framework, and no clarity around ownership.
- 5:15And I find it interesting that I was working
- 5:18in a regulated state, which we'll get more into
- 5:20in terms of child performer law in California,
- 5:24yet I was effectively unprotected. So it's interesting.
- 5:29I obtained a work permit. I signed with a modeling
- 5:32agency with a contract. And nevertheless, none
- 5:36of the modeling agencies ever signed with spoke
- 5:38about even minorized trust accounts, among other
- 5:42things. That was just silent. And unfortunately,
- 5:45that actually continues till today. Unless you're
- 5:47negotiating the bigger deals, you will find that
- 5:51within the industry, you do have agencies that
- 5:53are missing that part that's important where
- 5:55minors are concerned. Alright, so... Quick background
- 5:59on the modeling side of things. Let's move to
- 6:02the creator side. So I've always had two trajectories
- 6:06because I graduated from college with a degree
- 6:09in communications. And I've always felt that
- 6:12as a lawyer, I shouldn't be stuck with just only
- 6:14practicing law. And more importantly, the area
- 6:16of law I was going into necessarily requires
- 6:19me to understand the business of fashion and
- 6:22entertainment. So I wasn't going to just hang
- 6:24my communications degree. So I've always straddled
- 6:27the fence. of being a lawyer as well as a journalist.
- 6:30At some point, I got frustrated in my capacity
- 6:33as a journalist because the stories that were
- 6:35being covered about Africa, as many of you know,
- 6:38were very stereotypical stories that were just
- 6:40so behind. I felt that that was crucial. asked
- 6:43you my identity number one as a woman of African
- 6:46heritage and secondly also as a lawyer and how
- 6:49I show up with representing my clients. I wanted
- 6:52to change that narrative. Additionally, there
- 6:54were no stories at all about fashion law. So
- 6:58I wanted to also change that narrative. And here
- 7:00you go. I get into the creator economy that's
- 7:03back in 2006. I start blogging first and then
- 7:07from blogging subsequently on the music side
- 7:10as well as the fashion side evolved. into vlogs
- 7:13and ultimately podcasts. And between that time,
- 7:16what happened, and we get here a little bit more,
- 7:21we get into some of the legal issues that we
- 7:23are dealing with, with the new laws that have
- 7:25been implemented. Within that time, I had to
- 7:27navigate. platform and monetization shift. It
- 7:30used to be you were blogging all day, every day.
- 7:32And before you knew it, it became this whole
- 7:35business and structure had to be a part of it.
- 7:39And as you continue to grow with millions of
- 7:42millions of views, lots of followers, hundreds
- 7:45and thousands of followers, brands started to
- 7:48approach big brands and not only big brands,
- 7:51a lot of that also translated into perks, international
- 7:54travels, national travels and all kinds of access.
- 7:57that one would not necessarily have had. So as
- 8:00a content creator, I had to navigate all that,
- 8:04build brand partnerships with those brands approaching,
- 8:07shifted into the sponsored content, whole dynamics,
- 8:11and ultimately evolved from posting content to
- 8:14truly running a business. And as you can see,
- 8:16I'm showing you a sample of some of the businesses
- 8:18I ran, one of which was a magazine, because the
- 8:20blog... evolved into podcasting, vlogging, and
- 8:24a full -fledged magazine. And Ladybill magazine
- 8:26featured some of the top celebrities, among others,
- 8:30both on a national and international level. So
- 8:34what did I observe back then? First things first,
- 8:39we were, as content creators, we're building
- 8:42careers before the law even knew what to do or
- 8:45what to call us. And what were the key observations
- 8:48I observed and parallel with my experience in
- 8:52the modeling industry? Number one, no standardized
- 8:54contracts. I had the legal experience, so I was
- 8:57creating those contracts from scratch, for the
- 8:59most part. There was a lot of IP ownership confusion,
- 9:03brands trying to figure it out, trademarks, copyright,
- 9:06who owns what, control over the talent, what
- 9:09can you create, what are the scope, among other
- 9:12things, what are the liabilities that one may
- 9:14or may not incur. Because again, I had the legal
- 9:17background, I was making shots protecting my
- 9:20businesses, but for the most part, most content
- 9:22creators were oblivious to it and brands as well
- 9:24didn't really know how to treat content creators.
- 9:27There was also parents that were, you know, switching
- 9:30on their cameras and essentially acting as managers
- 9:33with complete zero oversight. all day, every
- 9:36day, vlogging their kids, every moment of it,
- 9:40from when they're born to what they're eating,
- 9:42when they're sleeping, among other things, really,
- 9:45really nuanced private situations that were coming
- 9:48into that context. And what was interesting was,
- 9:52I also observed just in the capacity of the modeling
- 9:55industry, same parallel in the creator economy,
- 9:58you had children that were generating revenue.
- 10:01without any kind of guaranteed access to earnings.
- 10:04Parents were the ones getting those earnings.
- 10:08So two industries, we transition to just comparing
- 10:11two industries. same legal issues across two
- 10:15economic systems. So from entering the industry,
- 10:19the fashion entertainment industry as a minor
- 10:21and I would go on ultimately to be involved in
- 10:23music and film and fashion and arts, all combining
- 10:27over and over again, the intersection of all
- 10:29of those arts. To becoming a creator and later
- 10:32legal counsel, I've lived both sides of the system
- 10:35and I've seen how the same legal system dynamics
- 10:38continue to persist. The minors will create the
- 10:41value, the adults can talk. contracts and revenue
- 10:44and there's no real protection and if you want
- 10:47real protection that really depends on statutory
- 10:49intervention not necessarily the intent especially
- 10:53of the adults involved. Enter Coogan and why
- 10:57Coogan exists and I already told you that California
- 11:00had those measures already but they weren't necessarily
- 11:04implemented or enforced particularly certainly
- 11:06in the fashion industry. What's the big deal
- 11:09about Coogan? A lot of you probably have heard
- 11:10about Jackie Coogan, who was the film industry's
- 11:13first child superstar and earned millions. He
- 11:17becomes an adult and discovers that his parents,
- 11:21specifically his mother and stepfather, had squandered
- 11:23all his earnings, leaving him broke. He sues,
- 11:27and ultimately the outcome is that the parents
- 11:29legally controlled his earnings. Certainly, it
- 11:33was very, very disruptive if you go back and
- 11:35look at the history, etc. The legislature felt
- 11:38like we wanted to do something about it to protect.
- 11:41child performance. So as a result, years later,
- 11:45California leads the way in enacting what we
- 11:47now know as the Coogan law. So what's the underlying
- 11:51principle there? Absent a statute, minors have
- 11:54no guaranteed property interest in their labor.
- 11:58The Coogan law or Coogan accounts are now required
- 12:01in several jurisdictions, not just California.
- 12:03So you have New York, Illinois, Louisiana, and
- 12:06New Mexico among the key jurisdictions that now
- 12:09require that. So let's get into what we are now
- 12:12talking about. First, we're going to look at
- 12:15what the Coogan law is all about, and then we'll
- 12:17look at the different updates. California Family
- 12:21Code, Section 6750 to 6753 for all my family
- 12:25lawyers who are on this call with us. So you
- 12:29should be aware of this as well. I know sometimes
- 12:31we think a teammate law doesn't necessarily intersect
- 12:33as much with family law, but it certainly does.
- 12:36So when a minor provides artistic or creative
- 12:39services, a portion of their gross earnings must
- 12:43be preserved in a block trust account, a Cougan
- 12:45account. And for all you lawyers watching this
- 12:47with the state bar updates that you probably
- 12:51all received with respect to how to handle client
- 12:54trust accounts even if you've not delved in this
- 12:56area of the law the concept should be familiar
- 12:59to you in terms of just making sure you have
- 13:02a preserve a blog trust account so what are the
- 13:04key requirements you're getting 15 percent of
- 13:07gross earnings that must be set aside entertainment
- 13:09lawyers you know we're always negotiating dealing
- 13:11with is it net or is it gross so 15 percent of
- 13:14growth gross earnings must be set aside Funds
- 13:18are the child's property, not the parents. And
- 13:22it applies regardless of the parental intent
- 13:25or the family agreement. So what Coogan has always
- 13:28regulated is money. We're not going to get into
- 13:31the details of your morality or your fame or
- 13:33working conditions with respect to your children.
- 13:35But what we are going to say, looking at it from
- 13:38the Coogan law perspective is, look, there's
- 13:41got to be accountability for the money that that
- 13:43child earns. So let's go into the update. What's
- 13:47happening with the Kugunlan update? What's changed?
- 13:51And what has changed is not necessarily the status
- 13:53text overall, but how it's understood and applied.
- 13:56That's where you have Family Code Section 675
- 13:59to come into play. Artistic and creative services
- 14:04are no longer limited to studios or traditional
- 14:07media. and gross earnings include digital monetization
- 14:11such as your sponsored social media posts which
- 14:13i was talking about most of you should be familiar
- 14:15with that if you get on instagram and you see
- 14:18maybe a celebrity or influencer and they have
- 14:21a product that they're they're advertising you'll
- 14:23see at the bottom of that hashtag you know sponsored
- 14:26ad etc per ftc requirements so sponsored social
- 14:31media posts your brand deals your platform -based
- 14:34revenue ads subscription affiliate income so
- 14:37it's now expanded where it's no longer limited
- 14:40to the studios or traditional media so what does
- 14:44that mean in plain english that means the medium
- 14:46does not control the function is what controls.
- 14:50All right, let's transition and look at why the
- 14:54Kogan update that we have now has a little more
- 14:57teeth. Number one, statutory mandate. Its enforceable
- 15:01trust obligation remains the same. And secondly,
- 15:04it's not platform dependent. And there's no exemption.
- 15:07If you're creating this content, put in it on
- 15:09YouTube, TikTok, Instagram. And the overall rule
- 15:13is digital does not equal informal and does not
- 15:16equal any sort of exemption that you get for
- 15:19purpose of your YouTube, TikTok, and Instagram.
- 15:22All right, let's transition to yet another statute
- 15:25we're looking at or a recent law that's passed,
- 15:29and that's the Child Content Creator Rights Act,
- 15:32Senate Bill 764, which expands Coogan's protections.
- 15:37I think it's always important to look at what
- 15:39a statute does and what it doesn't to make sure
- 15:41there's clarity and no confusion. So what does
- 15:44this law do? It recognizes minors in monetized
- 15:47online content. And it also imposes trust, compensation,
- 15:52record -keeping, and enforcement duties, even
- 15:54in informal influencer context. So if you're
- 15:58just, hey, I'm just doing this for fun and just
- 16:01putting on YouTube, no big deal, this requirement
- 16:04still applies. It also reinforces, very important
- 16:06key here, that parents are fiduciaries. They're
- 16:10not owners of those earnings. And that's obviously
- 16:12very important for that child that's put in so
- 16:15much. labor, if you will, and has nothing to
- 16:18show for it like the Jackie Coogan case that
- 16:21we discussed. So what it does not do, it does
- 16:25not replace the Coogan trust requirements. You
- 16:27still have to comply with that. And it doesn't
- 16:30create identical enforcement mechanisms as well.
- 16:34And so essentially, it's expanding the definition
- 16:37of covered performance to include minors in paid
- 16:40online content contracts and also extends overall
- 16:45the classic Kugen protections to digital labor.
- 16:49All right, so let's look at the next statute
- 16:52to talk about. That's AB 1880. That also expands
- 16:56Kugen protections and this also clarifies how
- 17:00earnings must be calculated and allocated when
- 17:03you have a content that is family -run and revenue
- 17:05that's pooled or indirect. It supports enforcement
- 17:08where digital income was previously obscured
- 17:12or mischaracterized. What this book bills have
- 17:15just discussed do not do is Again, they do not
- 17:18replace the Coogan law. Be very, pay attention
- 17:21to those nuances, especially when you're reviewing
- 17:23or talking with your client or negotiating those
- 17:25deals or drafting it. They do not reduce trust
- 17:28account obligations and they do not excuse compliance
- 17:31because income is new or platform based. So let's
- 17:36look at the visuals of side by side what all
- 17:39of this laws look like. Cougan, so issue who's
- 17:43covered. Cougan law, minor performing artistic
- 17:46or creative services, AB 1880. The minor as digital
- 17:50content creator under contract, SB 764, minors
- 17:53featured in monetized online content. Is contract
- 17:56required? Cougan law, absolutely. AB 1880, absolutely.
- 18:01Senate Bill 764, no. The core rule, Coogan Law,
- 18:0415 % of your gross earnings in Coogan Trust account.
- 18:09AB 1880 has the same 15 % rule that applies to
- 18:12digital earnings. And with respect to Senate
- 18:16Bill 764, your child must be compensated and
- 18:19earnings preserved. Who sets it up? Now, it's
- 18:22always important. I talked about my own experience
- 18:25when I started. With respect to Cuban law, again,
- 18:28looking at the fashion modeling industry, for
- 18:30example, the employer is responsible for making
- 18:33sure that's set up. And if there's no employer,
- 18:36the parent will set that up as well. So AB 1880,
- 18:44similar to Coogan law with respect to who must
- 18:47set up the trust account. And then the Senate
- 18:49Bill 764, parent or the adult content creator.
- 18:53And then what's Coogan law, what's new, the baseline
- 18:56financial protection we already talked about.
- 18:58AB 1880, with respect to that, it closes a digital
- 19:01loophole in Coogan. And then Senate Bill 764
- 19:04imposes that record keeping on child enforcement
- 19:07rights. Does it replace Coogan? A cross board.
- 19:10No, it doesn't replace Coogan. And on the Coogan
- 19:13Law side, that's not applicable since we're talking
- 19:15about Coogan Law. And then what it really governs,
- 19:18Coogan Law, you're looking at where the money
- 19:20goes, AB 1880, the digital earnings and its relationship
- 19:26to Coogan earnings. And then Senate Bill 764,
- 19:30accountability when parents control revenue.
- 19:32So what are your key takeaways as practitioners
- 19:35or law students or recent, you know, grads looking
- 19:39into this? Number one, if you're advising parents.
- 19:43Understand that advising parents is distinct
- 19:45from advising brands, two different things, right?
- 19:48So properly allocate for that from your intake
- 19:51process all the way to run and keep the main
- 19:53thing, the main thing on the lines clean. Number
- 19:55two, that trust accounts are non -negotiable.
- 19:58We already know how much reverence we have to
- 20:01have a trust account. It's no different when
- 20:03we're talking about the Coogan account here.
- 20:06Also, digital monetization triggers real liability.
- 20:10and contracts must reflect both statutes. Let
- 20:14me get to the conclusion side of things and then
- 20:18I will turn it over to my colleague who will
- 20:20get into a little more of the legal issues that
- 20:23may arise there. First things first, what would
- 20:27have changed for me as a minor? if we had the
- 20:30enforcement on the Coogan side, right? I might
- 20:33be sitting pretty rich now if the earnings were
- 20:37allocated or more information provided to me,
- 20:40certainly on the enforcement side of things.
- 20:44Also, secondly, With respect to the protections
- 20:47that matter most in practice, as I said, both
- 20:50actually matter. Obviously, you got to tailor
- 20:53it to the facts of your case and what's going
- 20:54on in terms of how you deal with the draft advisory
- 20:57role. But both protections matter. And then with
- 21:01respect to the gaps that the law must still arise,
- 21:04before I turn it over to Tyler, just a few things
- 21:06I just want to highlight on the litigation side
- 21:09of things. I know she's going to talk a lot on
- 21:11the deal -making side, and we'll come back and
- 21:12talk about deal -making and litigation. things
- 21:15that jump at me is on a national level we know
- 21:18that's huge controversy over parental rights
- 21:21and this to me raises the question of great we
- 21:25want to protect children but are we doing too
- 21:28much is the state is the government encroaching
- 21:30on parental rights and how do you balance that
- 21:32from a constitutional standpoint secondly if
- 21:35you are dealing with LLCs for example a lot of
- 21:39this content creators I know at some point I
- 21:41converted into an LLC. I know a lot of content
- 21:44creators generally move forward with LLCs or
- 21:47trust and family entities as a whole. How do
- 21:51you deal with that or navigate that for purposes
- 21:53of the rules that have been set up? Another final
- 21:56part that I will talk about is from a litigation
- 21:58standpoint, statute of limitations. What's the
- 22:01timing and scope of the child's right of action,
- 22:04right? So when What's the cut of time to file
- 22:09or not file? What are the discovery rules? Are
- 22:11we tolling the statute during the minority age?
- 22:15When does the clock truly start running on a
- 22:18child's claim? So those are some issues that
- 22:21jump at me. And on that note, I'm going to turn
- 22:23it over to Tyler. She's going to address influencer
- 22:26flight issues, the state versus federal gap,
- 22:29brand deal risk, and why platforms are exempt,
- 22:33and finally, conclude also with attribution uncertainty
- 22:36before. we get to the Q &A. So over to you, Tyler.
- 22:40Before we hand it over, I had a quick question
- 22:42in the chat that I was hoping you could address.
- 22:44Sure. We talked a lot about the need for the
- 22:48trust account. So someone is wondering if there's
- 22:51specific type of trust account or if a Roth IRA
- 22:54for a minor is sufficient to comply with the
- 22:58laws. Oh, that's a very good question. Generally,
- 23:01you have the blog cooking account, but I think
- 23:03you would. most likely seek the advisory of also
- 23:08your financial advisors when working in tangent
- 23:11with that when you start talking about the Roth
- 23:13IRA accounts. So I would say you should also
- 23:16have a financial advisor there. I did for a brief
- 23:19minute work at Merrill Lynch, but I'm not certified
- 23:22to necessarily give the full scope of that discussion
- 23:26without getting more into the facts of that particular
- 23:29situation and pairing it up with financial counsel
- 23:32as well, working in tangent with them. Thank
- 23:37you. Tyler, on to you. Thank you so much, Yudhak.
- 23:40That was amazing. Quick kind of, how do I shift
- 23:46the slides? I actually, I'm so sorry. Am I able
- 23:49to do that from my end? Because am I able to
- 23:54just shift to the next slide? I don't know who's
- 23:56controlling it. Let me, sorry, Susan, just tell
- 23:59Susan to advance and she'll advance it for you.
- 24:02Okay, perfect. Perfect. Well, thank you so much
- 24:05for that. I mean, that covered a lot of the things,
- 24:08you know, that I was going to cover, but I think
- 24:11I would love to get into sort of the deal making
- 24:14side and because I represent some very big creators.
- 24:19family channels, as well as some management agencies
- 24:23who manage very, very big family channels. I
- 24:26think it would be good to kind of talk about
- 24:28how this is really playing out in real time and
- 24:31in real life. If we could go to the next slide,
- 24:35please, Susan, I'm so sorry to ask you to do
- 24:37it. So, you know. I think, so I worked in Hollywood
- 24:46for 20 years. So I worked with the Coogan Law.
- 24:49You know, we had to go to as a studio when I
- 24:52was at Disney and we were doing Saving Mr. Banks.
- 24:54When we had minors, we would have to go to the
- 24:57court, right, to petition and for them to approve
- 25:00the actor to work in the film. And so the onus
- 25:04was really on the employer here who is the studio.
- 25:09And now, because we're talking about creators,
- 25:14the onus is on the parents, right, to be able
- 25:18to keep records and make sure that they're setting
- 25:21up the trust accounts for their children. Now,
- 25:25I will say that the biggest issue that we have
- 25:31is in terms of... calculation, right? So the
- 25:36Senate SB 764 states that you have to figure
- 25:43out if a child appears in 30 % of the video,
- 25:48then you have to set aside 65 % of the revenue
- 25:53that's attributable to the child's likeness.
- 25:57Uduak, I see you have your hand up. Did you want
- 25:59to say something? Oh, no, that's probably a mistake.
- 26:04My apologies. Oh, OK. No worries. No worries.
- 26:08So, you know, this is the biggest issue because
- 26:10as an attorney, when my clients come to me and
- 26:13say, well, how do I calculate 30 percent? Because
- 26:16if we have a 10 minute video and the child is
- 26:20in the background for, you know, two minutes,
- 26:24like how do we is it? And this is the biggest
- 26:27headache that we have right now in trying to
- 26:30determine, well, What is the proper calculation?
- 26:34And so what I say to my clients is Veer on the
- 26:38side of being more inclusive right because we
- 26:42are seeing a lot of these creators who Are on
- 26:48these family vlogging channels We think they're
- 26:51fine. We think they're happy and The second they
- 26:55turn 18 we're seeing these stories of creators
- 26:58turning around and suing their parents because
- 27:01what they're saying is, I didn't want to do that.
- 27:04I didn't want my life to be played out on Instagram
- 27:08or on YouTube or on TikTok. And I didn't have
- 27:11a say in that. So we're seeing a lot of these
- 27:14creators suing their parents. And so if you're
- 27:17going to be a parent who is in charge of a vlogging
- 27:20channel, make sure that you are setting up those
- 27:23trust accounts. Make sure you calculate, you
- 27:27know, towards being more inclusive. Like if you're
- 27:30not sure, I would say you know the kind of there
- 27:33because there's no bright line rule I would say
- 27:36if your child is in most severe videos and They
- 27:41are the star, let's say. And you can tell, right?
- 27:44If you have videos that don't perform as well
- 27:46because your kids aren't in it, then your child
- 27:49is the star of your channel. And that's what
- 27:52I hear more than anything else, right? Is that
- 27:55the videos with the children always perform better.
- 27:58The ones with the parents, maybe not as much.
- 28:00And so I would say if you want to be really compliant,
- 28:06put 65 % of that revenue aside for your children
- 28:08and a trust for them. Um, if we, Susan, can we
- 28:12go to the next slide, please? Thank you. So this
- 28:17is, you know, it was sort of broken down already.
- 28:20This is defining what the two laws are. I mean,
- 28:24I don't think we need to go through it again,
- 28:25because we did such a good job kind of explaining
- 28:29the differences between the two and how they've
- 28:32been updated. If we can go to the next slide,
- 28:34please. Thank you. Now the one thing I do want
- 28:40to highlight for the attorneys, you know, because
- 28:44we're all a California practitioners is this
- 28:48is specific to California and so Is it over protective?
- 28:56I don't think so, right? You hear the story of
- 28:59Udoch as a child model and then of Jackie Coogan.
- 29:03I think, you know, as a parent myself, I think
- 29:05having these laws really protects the children,
- 29:09the child actor, the child creator. But one of
- 29:15the questions I get a lot from my clients who
- 29:17are based in California or who are in other states
- 29:20who are looking to potentially move to California
- 29:22is, well, what if we leave California? Will that
- 29:27make us accept from these rules? And I would
- 29:32say potentially. Right. Like if you don't live
- 29:35in California and the content isn't being made
- 29:38in California. Maybe. But if you have brand deals
- 29:43with brands who are located in California, then
- 29:47maybe that brand deal, you know, that kind of
- 29:51jurisdiction would the locus would be in California.
- 29:56So I don't know that it's true. Like you hear
- 30:01about this is kind of almost like an urban myth.
- 30:06You know, our a lot of creators exiting California
- 30:10because they don't want to be bound by these
- 30:13laws. I will tell you. The reasons why creators
- 30:16are exiting California is not because of this,
- 30:19it's because of the taxes. Most of my clients
- 30:22who are big creators live in either Texas or
- 30:25Florida or Nevada because they have the best
- 30:28income tax laws. That's the reason why they're
- 30:32typically in other states. I haven't heard a
- 30:34lot of creators saying, well, I'm trying to escape
- 30:37these two laws and that's why we're moving away
- 30:40from California. If we could go to the next slide,
- 30:44please. Thanks, Susan. So these are the controversies
- 30:49that we're talking about here. We've talked about
- 30:52the attribution uncertainty. It's very hard to
- 30:55calculate. What does it mean if it's 30 %? How
- 30:59do you calculate 30 %? So I am advising my creator
- 31:04clients to over allocate and to be very meticulous.
- 31:09Is this happening in real life? Much less than
- 31:13I would like it to because it's you know, if
- 31:16you're doing shorts Like I have clients who put
- 31:18out five shorts a day, you know being able to
- 31:22track that is very hard now I will say as long
- 31:25as these videos stay on the platforms then the
- 31:30children could potentially have a way to go back
- 31:34and check the records. If you don't want to be
- 31:37sued by your child one day and saying that you
- 31:40did not properly protect my assets, you broke
- 31:43your fiduciary duties to me, I would say be meticulous
- 31:47and be really... over inclusive of the revenue
- 31:53and what they're entitled to then to be under
- 31:57allocating. Let's talk about brands, right? So
- 32:04the brands themselves, I'm hearing a lot of brands
- 32:09saying that they're sort of terrified of accidentally
- 32:13violating child labor laws. So under uh ab 1880
- 32:19brands and agencies now have to verify right
- 32:22that they have a kugen trust account before paying
- 32:25a minor creator that this is just like if it's
- 32:27just a minor creator like outside the context
- 32:29of a family so what i'm the friction that i'm
- 32:33seeing is that a lot of brands are now walking
- 32:35away from these sort of family -styled ugc content
- 32:39because the compliance right of having to Pay
- 32:45for a trust or verified that they have a trust
- 32:47for let's say a $500 gift to campaign isn't even
- 32:52worth the legal exposure for them. So I'm seeing
- 32:55the brands kind of backing away from family style
- 32:59vlogging channels in that way. You know the vlog
- 33:04definition, you know, the law is really broad.
- 33:07It covers sort of any monetized online content.
- 33:11Like I would like to say this isn't just YouTube.
- 33:14It's also tick -tock. It's Instagram and it's
- 33:16even monetized lives now I want to touch upon
- 33:21the fact that it's interesting that the onus
- 33:24is being put on the parents and sometimes even
- 33:27the brand But not on the platforms, right? So
- 33:30none of the platforms are being held responsible
- 33:33YouTube Tick -tock Instagram. I mean YouTube
- 33:36takes 30 or 40 percent cut right from every video
- 33:40but they're not being held responsible in helping
- 33:44make sure that whether these kids who have, you
- 33:48know, they're part of family channels are actually
- 33:52being protected, whether or not the parents have
- 33:55trust. The way, you know, in Hollywood, the studios...
- 33:59are responsible for that. So I think there's
- 34:02a gap there that's very ripe for some new laws
- 34:05to be written. And I've been hearing talks that
- 34:08this is something that might come down the pipeline
- 34:12in the near future is holding these platforms
- 34:15accountable because they're making billions of
- 34:17dollars a year off of a lot of young creators.
- 34:21And why are they not being held to a higher standard
- 34:25the way they do in Hollywood? And there is a
- 34:32gap between the states, right? There's probably
- 34:33a handful of states that are passing these types
- 34:38of laws protecting creators, but there are no
- 34:42federal laws protecting creators. I think there's
- 34:45some talk of this happening in the Capitol, whether
- 34:48or not those laws will be made. I think there
- 34:51have been some attempts to submitting these laws
- 34:55for consideration, but I haven't seen a lot of
- 35:00movement there yet as to whether or not that
- 35:03will happen. But I think with time, it will.
- 35:06I mean, you ask any five -year -old what they
- 35:10would like to do. And I think their dream job
- 35:13these days is to be a YouTuber, right? It used
- 35:15to be an astronaut or a doctor or a lawyer, but
- 35:18now it's to be a creator. I represent big YouTubers.
- 35:23I'm currently selling one of my clients YouTube
- 35:26channel for a hundred million dollars. I just
- 35:29got back from speaking in Dubai at the one billion
- 35:32follower summit where all the private equity
- 35:35money is coming into the space because they want
- 35:37to buy creator channels. They want to be by IP
- 35:40libraries. All the streamers and studios want
- 35:44access to their content. And so I think we're
- 35:47going to see more and more movement on these
- 35:51laws. hopefully to protect more creators and
- 35:55more children, there's a current Senate bill
- 35:58being passed to protect the mental health of
- 36:01creators, right? And I think, I don't know how
- 36:05many of you in the audience are creators. I would
- 36:07say if you're not a YouTuber to definitely think
- 36:10about it, if you're gonna create generational
- 36:12wealth, like that is actually one of the biggest
- 36:15paths is creating a YouTube channel. I put YouTube
- 36:18channels into trust for my clients' children.
- 36:22because it's worth more than real estate these
- 36:24days. Mr. Beast is worth $5 billion right now,
- 36:29which is bigger than some Fortune 500 company.
- 36:32So this is no longer just the creator economy,
- 36:35this is just the economy these days. So I think
- 36:41our job as attorneys is to help creators monetize,
- 36:47right? But in addition, our job needs to help
- 36:50them. It needs to be helping them survive their
- 36:53own success to some degree. And these laws are
- 36:57controversial because they treat the family business
- 37:01as just the business, stripping away sort of
- 37:04the domestic shield that parents have been using
- 37:07to avoid labor regulations for a decade. So I'm
- 37:11glad that these laws have been passed. I wish
- 37:15that they were happening in more states than
- 37:18just the ones we've listed. But I think There
- 37:23are a lot of parents making a lot of money off
- 37:27of their kids. You look at Jordan Matters, who
- 37:29is one of the biggest YouTubers on the platform.
- 37:33His daughter, Silas, has just launched her own
- 37:37skincare brand, and that's probably going to
- 37:39make $10 million. And he started out as a photographer,
- 37:45and then he started featuring his... kids in
- 37:48his channel and his views just exploded into
- 37:51the billions because people do want to see videos
- 37:55with children in it but i think we need to do
- 37:58the right thing and protect these children to
- 38:00make sure that they're not being exploited and
- 38:02that things you don't hear stories like what
- 38:06happened to udak when she was a child model um
- 38:10so You know, that's sort of my presentation.
- 38:14I mean, we did such a great job going through
- 38:17the laws. I mean, Libby, if we want to open it
- 38:20up, you know, maybe we want to kind of circle
- 38:22back. I don't know if you have anything else
- 38:24to add, but we could also take questions from
- 38:26the audience if there are any questions, too.
- 38:30You covered it very well. So we look forward
- 38:33to answering as many questions as we can get
- 38:35in. I have a question off the jump. Tyler, you're
- 38:41talking about the brand side of the potential
- 38:45risks with these gifted campaigns under AB 1880.
- 38:51Is there any sort of requirement under the law
- 38:55as it stands now if it's purely a gifted item
- 38:58or experience or PR for a portion of that value
- 39:02if they're not actually receiving a check or
- 39:06direct deposit to save a portion of that value
- 39:09into a trust account? Yeah. No, I mean, gifts
- 39:13is sort of this, you know, this is how things
- 39:15are kind of slipping through the cracks because
- 39:18gifts is it's just, you know, what what parents
- 39:20are saying is, well, if it's a food item, it's
- 39:23something that that is a benefits entire family.
- 39:26Right. Like how do we equate that into an amount?
- 39:29I think that's sort of the most difficult part
- 39:32of this is how do we actually calculate how much
- 39:36something is worth? I have heard that most of
- 39:39the time the gifts are not being calculated in
- 39:41that way. Now look, if you're getting a MacBook
- 39:43or a treadmill or something that is substantial,
- 39:48I would tell my clients, you should put that
- 39:51in the record and say, well, we received a MacBook
- 39:54that was worth $2 ,000. We all used it. But it's
- 39:59harder then for the parents to say, well, am
- 40:01I supposed to then go take 65 % of the value
- 40:04of the laptop and put it into the account? I
- 40:07think that's a really hard detail to enforce.
- 40:11yeah I'll chime in that would be very hard but
- 40:13I think for best practices because my concern
- 40:17is that The way the law is written, when I think
- 40:21I put on the litigation hat, it could really
- 40:23create a lot of strife with parents and children
- 40:26down the line. So I think for parents, number
- 40:28one, you have to come to the table treating this
- 40:31as a business, if in fact you are monetizing
- 40:34and doing the things that the statute calls for
- 40:36you to do instead of setting the trust accounts,
- 40:39monetizing content of your children. So first,
- 40:42I think from an advisory standpoint, have parents
- 40:45come to the table understanding that this is
- 40:47a business, number one. Number two, what that
- 40:50entails is you go back to that record keeping
- 40:53aspect of it, itemize everything, just get into
- 40:56the habit of just doing that. Because then you
- 40:58keep a nice paper trail, any of the issues, you
- 41:02can always back it up and say, hey, yes, it was
- 41:04a gift. here's what it was, here's the value,
- 41:07here's what I did with it. While, you know, we
- 41:10still catch up, the law still catches up. I mean,
- 41:12over 20 years later, we're now getting to the
- 41:15law aspect of it and still figuring out what
- 41:17it means. And I think a lot of those key nuances
- 41:20will have to be litigated. But in the meantime,
- 41:23just basic accounting and proper documentation
- 41:26would help a lot of parents and counsel advising
- 41:30parents as well. It always seems like the law
- 41:33is slow to catch up when technology moves so
- 41:36quickly these days. And you're saying the same
- 41:38thing with AI now that the law is having to scramble
- 41:41to catch up. But when we're talking about this
- 41:45record keeping, especially with SB 764 and the
- 41:49onus really being on the parents, if you could
- 41:54wave a magic pen and amend the legislation, how
- 41:59would you recommend any oversight or enforcement
- 42:03other than strictly just taking your parents
- 42:06to court, which I'm sure could be a really difficult
- 42:08thing for a minor or a freshly 18 year old to
- 42:13suddenly be suing their parents? Do you have
- 42:15any recommendations for what that would look
- 42:17like? I think it would be, hopefully, if the
- 42:22parent is smart enough to get counsel right off
- 42:25the bat, I think it would be our roles as lawyers
- 42:27to then... guide and I mean we already do it
- 42:31at least I think a lot of my colleagues do it
- 42:34on the entertainment and fashion side where you're
- 42:36saying even though family is involved we're going
- 42:39to keep things very clean the conflict of interest
- 42:43paperwork you've got a sign among other things
- 42:45in the engagement agreement so I think if we
- 42:47follow those principles we actually play a more
- 42:50substantial role in guiding the parents if they're
- 42:52willing to listen and to present it in a way
- 42:55where they don't think that you're thinking are
- 42:58trying to exploit their children because the
- 43:00statute presumes that right off the jump. The
- 43:03other thing that is of concern also, I understand
- 43:07the protection with respect to children, but
- 43:12as a content creator, the immense amount of work
- 43:16it takes to create content and at some point
- 43:20just farming it out, hiring independent contractors
- 43:23to handle all of that. I almost don't see the
- 43:27statute recognizing the role of parents and the
- 43:30amount of work and resources and investment that
- 43:32they put into that. It's sort of like, oh, you're
- 43:35doing this. So if there's a way to balance that
- 43:39where we're not pitting the kids against the
- 43:42parents and then we as council are coming in
- 43:44and making sure we sort of provide that guidance,
- 43:47I think that would really make a big difference.
- 43:53Well to jump off of that point, I mean I think
- 43:56The example I gave with Jordan matter and his
- 43:59daughter was you know, he really when when Silas
- 44:03turned 16 really invited her to be a co -owner
- 44:08in the business right to be a decision -maker
- 44:10with him and She was the one who kind of pushed
- 44:14her skincare line. She was the one who was in
- 44:16charge So I think the more that we can empower
- 44:20our kids to feel like they have a say in this
- 44:22the less likely we'll deal with that lawsuit
- 44:25at 18 because I think when you take away a child's
- 44:30say in their power, that's when we sort of get
- 44:32those lawsuits. I think when parents are inviting
- 44:36their kids to not be just, you know, free labor,
- 44:40like to be a partner in their business, that's
- 44:43when I'm seeing a lot of success for these. family
- 44:46channels, a lot of these family channels end
- 44:49up having the kids, you know, when they kind
- 44:50of turn 13, 14 and spinning off and having their
- 44:53own channel. I mean, Silas has her own channel.
- 44:56And I have a lot of clients, you know, I have
- 44:59Jenny Hoyas, who was 17 when I met her. She's
- 45:01now 20. And so these kids are being guided by
- 45:05their parents, but sort of, you know, with the
- 45:09thought that here, I'm going to support you until
- 45:11you can do this on your own. And I have seen
- 45:14it being a lot, that's a much more beautiful
- 45:20end conclusion than the kids who are being told,
- 45:25well, you have to make three videos a day, even
- 45:27if you don't want to do it, or I'm gonna take
- 45:30away your sports because you need to be making
- 45:32content. That's when I'm hearing those stories
- 45:34of parents being sued. And let me add just one
- 45:37final thing. I think we, as practitioners, we
- 45:40probably have context too, especially if you're
- 45:42not in the family law area and you're looking
- 45:44at the best interest of the child. We have context
- 45:47on the sports side and I know I'm sure there
- 45:49are many people who played sports, right? You
- 45:51have that overactive parent that really wants
- 45:54the child to be involved in everything and now
- 45:56that we have name image likeness deals, among
- 45:59other things, it can be really overreaching.
- 46:01So if parents also have the internal check. I
- 46:05know sometimes we don't get into the psychological
- 46:07part for parents. Your time may come in further
- 46:12in the future. You might be a 30, 40 year old
- 46:15that decides you want to still go into the NFL
- 46:17or whatever. But at this point, it's your child's
- 46:20reality. understand and respect boundary lines
- 46:23and don't try to fill a void, if you will, of
- 46:26whatever you never accomplished through that
- 46:28child. I think that goes a long way. Mutual respect,
- 46:31even though you're the parent, you still also
- 46:34should have an inclination to understand the
- 46:37importance of respecting your children as well.
- 46:39So I think that that's helpful in addition to
- 46:42what Tyler has just said. Definitely. I think
- 46:46in the law, we have a tendency to always see
- 46:48the worst case scenario or see these horror stories
- 46:52of, you know, these parents taking advantage
- 46:55of their children for the content, for the views,
- 46:57for the money. But I was so right with that with
- 47:01Jordan matters. There are so many other instances
- 47:03where they really are setting them up and the
- 47:06law is now catching up to provide that framework
- 47:08of support to continue to encourage that. briefly
- 47:13mentioned independent contractors, which leads
- 47:15perfectly into a question that we have about
- 47:18the difference in the way that minors are treated
- 47:21in music and by the labels compared to film side
- 47:25under Coogan. And so someone's asking if you
- 47:29could speak to the designation of employee versus
- 47:32independent contractors when it comes to minors
- 47:35and if a minor could potentially qualify as an
- 47:38independent contractor under the Borrello test.
- 47:42for purposes of labor code 2780. That's an interesting
- 47:47question. Well, first things first, from a fashion
- 47:50standpoint, usually when you have the contracts,
- 47:55you will have you know, the the labor code compliance,
- 47:59right? So there's the the general contract and
- 48:01then there's yet another contract that is a standard
- 48:04form from the in compliance with the labor code.
- 48:08But whether miners can be independent contractors,
- 48:11I think theoretically you can say yes, but practically
- 48:14that doesn't. I don't see how that happens because
- 48:17you have to look at that control test. Are the
- 48:20miners the one writing the script? Are they the
- 48:23ones directing how the camera is going to go?
- 48:25Are they the ones in charge of the work hours
- 48:28and the time off, among other things? So if you
- 48:30look at the standard test of what constitutes
- 48:32an independent contractor, I don't think that
- 48:34that would fall in line. And so necessarily,
- 48:37I think that would fail with respect to miners
- 48:39being categorized that way. However, if you have,
- 48:42for example, I've been following, I show speed.
- 48:45who is a content creator and what he's done across
- 48:48the US, then Asia, and now in Africa. It's just
- 48:52mind blowing. And the story goes that his mom
- 48:55was so resistant to him being a content creator,
- 48:59I think, when he was a minor. And now he's just,
- 49:02it's over 48 million people. while he livestreams,
- 49:07incredible. So if you look at that from that
- 49:09standpoint, mom wasn't involved, dad wasn't involved,
- 49:13although dad encouraged, but he is controlling.
- 49:15every aspect of his production and streaming.
- 49:18So arguably, and he's signing the deals himself,
- 49:21from what I understand, negotiating those deals,
- 49:23even though he has representatives. So I think
- 49:25one could make a strong case in that very rare
- 49:28exceptional situation that that minor, if he
- 49:31was a minor doing all those things that he would
- 49:33qualify for an independent contractor status.
- 49:39So let me add a little more to that. I actually
- 49:42know, you know, speed is with CA and I share
- 49:45a lot of clients with CA. And in terms of there's,
- 49:51I know there's a question in the chat about contracts
- 49:53and miners creating content when they're underage
- 49:56and how does, how do, They actually get permission
- 50:00to be on the platforms. How do they enter into
- 50:02brand deals? And they do have to have permission,
- 50:06right? Like they cannot be making content on
- 50:09these platforms without their parents giving
- 50:11permission. They certainly can't enter into representation
- 50:15agreements or brand deal agreements without their
- 50:17parents, you know, verifying and also signing
- 50:21as a sort of co -signer to those deals. So I
- 50:25do want to flag that Uh. The platforms are being
- 50:30very careful, right? They've gone in a lot of
- 50:33trouble because they have underage creators that
- 50:36they're making money from. So now, you know,
- 50:39they're being extra careful with bootstrapping
- 50:43and making sure that the parents have given permission.
- 50:46Because I've also heard of a lot of kids getting
- 50:49kicked off of these platforms because they lie
- 50:51about their birth year, you know, so that they
- 50:54can be 18. You know, Snapchat's been very strict
- 50:56about that. And so... I think more and more,
- 51:00I mean, like platforms and brands are very careful
- 51:04about it and the parents are involved. And I
- 51:07think, you know, the example of speed, I think
- 51:10speed is of age now, but I think when he was
- 51:12starting out, he wasn't of age. And you look
- 51:15at Jimmy, right? Mr. Beast, he started his YouTube
- 51:18channel when he was 12 or 13. His mom actually
- 51:21didn't want him to do it. He had to make his
- 51:24videos in secret She said he had to go to college,
- 51:27you know, and he he just was like I hate college
- 51:30I hate education and he did all that in secret
- 51:34I think the rules maybe back then 10 years ago
- 51:37were a little less strict and he could make content.
- 51:41I think the platforms weren't checking as closely
- 51:44as they are now. So I think now for these kids
- 51:48to be making content, they do need to get parent
- 51:50approval and the platforms check. They make the
- 51:54parents sign. I think they have to send the parents
- 51:57driver's license. So I think there's a lot more
- 52:00oversight now making sure that the kids that
- 52:03the platforms are making money off of are actually
- 52:06of age or have permission from their parents.
- 52:09Yeah, and let me chime in on that. Number one,
- 52:11you do need the work permit. I mentioned that
- 52:13when I was 14, I had to get a work permit. My
- 52:16situation was actually even unique because at
- 52:1714, I was a junior in high school. It didn't
- 52:20stop. needing a work permit. And then not only
- 52:23do you need that work permit side of things,
- 52:27always remember to not forget the basic contract
- 52:30laws that we operate on, right? As a matter of
- 52:32law, does a minor have a capacity to negotiate
- 52:35a contract? And we know that if we don't have
- 52:38the parent involved, then it's void as a matter
- 52:41of law in general. There might be exceptions
- 52:44to the rule. So don't forget when in doubt, or
- 52:47if you don't have a colleague to really quickly
- 52:48reference and call right away, that when in doubt,
- 52:52default to those general contract principles
- 52:54that we're all aware of. Our basic contract law
- 52:59always so applies. Similarly, someone out. a
- 53:04lot of people post casually on social media for
- 53:08their whole life, some for a period of time before
- 53:11they get monetized. So does the law touch on
- 53:15any requirement to save money after the fact
- 53:19if videos or content was posted of the child
- 53:23as a minor that later gets monetized once they've
- 53:25reached the age of majority? Or have we not kind
- 53:29of looked retroactively? I'll kick it off. And
- 53:32then Tyler, if you want to. Well, if they become
- 53:35an age of majority and then decide to monetize,
- 53:39turn on their YouTube monetization or any other
- 53:41thing. Or become eligible after the fact. They're
- 53:45adults. So I would argue that that's then completely
- 53:48on them because that would be a protective parent
- 53:52that's not monetizing that content. So I don't
- 53:54see where the issue would be. I guess it's not
- 53:59spelled out currently in the statute. And I think
- 54:02I just saw or saw something about case laws.
- 54:06The laws have just been enacted. So obviously,
- 54:08we're going to need time to figure that out in
- 54:10terms of case laws. But I'm just thinking on
- 54:15the right of publicity side of things. name image
- 54:18likeness i don't see how that analysis would
- 54:21would apply i mean parents were not the goal
- 54:24is to protect you almost from your parents exploiting
- 54:27you they haven't they switched up all monetization
- 54:29you now adults go and be blessed and do whatever
- 54:32you want to do and make your own bank so i don't
- 54:35i don't really see the issue there but you never
- 54:37know they're always nuances obviously over to
- 54:39you well i'm wondering i'm wondering if the question
- 54:42is more swords towards you know is is the is
- 54:47the child potentially saying, well, you should
- 54:50have turned on the monetization and why didn't
- 54:52you, right? Like, so look, by the way, there
- 54:55are people who don't know that they're supposed
- 54:57to turn on their monetization, right? Because
- 54:58when they hit, you know, It used to be 4 ,000
- 55:01subscribers, 10 ,000 watch hours. Like you're
- 55:03supposed to turn on your monetization. I actually
- 55:06have clients who were really big and say, they
- 55:09said, oh, I didn't turn it on right away because
- 55:11I didn't know I was monetized. So, you know,
- 55:14are there those parents who are not very savvy
- 55:16who didn't turn it on? And is the child potentially
- 55:18saying, well, you lost me a certain amount of
- 55:20money because you didn't turn on the monetization.
- 55:22I wonder if that's the question. But yes, I agree
- 55:25with you, Doc. If the parents were veering on
- 55:28like not wanting to. to exploit them and making
- 55:31money off of them and letting the child decide
- 55:33when they turn 18 if they want to turn on monetization,
- 55:36I would say good on the parent, right? So I wonder
- 55:39what part of that argument they're trying to
- 55:43make. And then I know we're coming up on the
- 55:45last few minutes. At the very end, Susan, if
- 55:48you could just kind of flash both of our end
- 55:51slides, because I know mine didn't come up. If
- 55:52people want to reach out and connect, that would
- 55:54be great. for both. Yeah. And let me that's such
- 55:57an interesting point about what you raise, Tyler,
- 56:01because it brings all the family law practitioners
- 56:03on the calling to play, right? Because assuming
- 56:06I don't do family law, but my former business
- 56:09partner who happens to be my sister does family
- 56:12law and that's her whole thing so I'm a little
- 56:15savvy with a few few aspects of it and I'm thinking
- 56:18of divorce proceedings for example one parent
- 56:21wants best interest of the child absolutely do
- 56:24not turn monetization on the other parent says
- 56:26no best interest of the child turn it on, and
- 56:30which one prevails when the child becomes an
- 56:34adult and says, hey, you should have turned on
- 56:36monetization. So that should be very interesting.
- 56:40But yeah, interesting question that you raised
- 56:42that we will see how family courts generally
- 56:45handle it in the future. And I think I had an
- 56:49even different interpretation of that question,
- 56:52more so asking if they've been posting just casually
- 56:57or trying to build a business as a minor and
- 57:00haven't been eligible for monetization, say,
- 57:03then they turn 18 and they become eligible on
- 57:08TikTok or YouTube. And suddenly those videos
- 57:11from when they were a minor start earning them
- 57:14money. I think that might have been where the
- 57:17question was coming from, if that would start
- 57:19counting towards the monetization that needs
- 57:22to be protected. I would assume the answer is
- 57:25the same, that they're then earning that money
- 57:26as an adult. Well, I wonder if there's, you know,
- 57:31then, I mean, are the parents going to to to
- 57:34say that they're entitled to some percentage
- 57:36of that? I guess that would be the argument that
- 57:39people would be making. But for the child, you
- 57:41know, if that's sort of their channel and now
- 57:44they're 18, they're monetized, like they would
- 57:45be making that money. And I want to pick up the
- 57:49point that you just made about, you know. two
- 57:51parents like I have clients who have family channels
- 57:55where it's it's the dad who's in the video with
- 57:58the kids and the mom is not and the mom actually
- 58:01doesn't want the kids to be you know in the video
- 58:04and the kids are almost too young you know I
- 58:06have a client who's like the kids are seven and
- 58:08nine and they just love you know doing fun stuff
- 58:11with their their their dad and the dad is just
- 58:13recording he used to be a Hollywood producer
- 58:15so that is also happening in real life, right?
- 58:20Where the families disagree as to whether or
- 58:23not the kids should be in the videos or not.
- 58:26And I think, you know, seeing that play out in
- 58:28real life is interesting because how do the parents
- 58:33decide whether, because the kids can't really,
- 58:36like, they're caught in the middle and they don't,
- 58:38you know. They don't know if they should or should
- 58:41not, but I'm seeing, I'm just seeing it play
- 58:44out. There's no answer here, but I'm seeing it
- 58:46play out in some family vlogging channels where
- 58:49maybe they start out and it's fun, but then it
- 58:52just becomes too much or their kids are getting
- 58:54recognized and they don't like that type of,
- 58:57you know, there's no privacy left for their families.
- 59:01So I don't know about you. I can take one or
- 59:03two more questions. What about you, Tyler? Yeah,
- 59:05I'm OK for a couple more minutes if we have any
- 59:07more questions. Just a few more questions before
- 59:09we wrap it up. Yeah, we talked about the fact
- 59:12that the platforms currently are escaping any
- 59:16sort of liability, unlike the studios in Hollywood
- 59:18under the traditional Coogan law. How do you
- 59:22see moving forward, or how would you propose
- 59:24that liability should come into play? Should
- 59:27they ensure a trust? is set up for the children
- 59:31before monetization happens? What does that liability
- 59:34look like to you? That's a great question. What
- 59:39comes to mind is one could argue that platforms
- 59:43are already having to deal with a lot of compliance
- 59:47issues with respect to their age. that a minor
- 59:51even gets on, like at least in California, the
- 59:5413 -year -old caught off for you to even be able
- 59:56to use their platform and have consent. Not only
- 59:59that, how their images are used. We know there
- 1:00:02have been class action litigation against Metta
- 1:00:05or Facebook, among others, in the past. YouTube,
- 1:00:08among others. So one could argue that there are
- 1:00:12already guardrails that are sort of limiting,
- 1:00:17especially platforms as opposed to studios etc
- 1:00:22but i think what we'll just have to see how that
- 1:00:26plays out because i think there's an argument
- 1:00:28that could be made that they're already doing
- 1:00:29a lot more than studios we're doing and so to
- 1:00:33add this arguably would be would be hard for
- 1:00:38them to regulate parents and could really get
- 1:00:43in the way also of them maybe encroaching on
- 1:00:46how parents should be raising their kids or the
- 1:00:49monetization aspect. It's very, very dicey. What
- 1:00:53do you think, Tyler? I actually agree with you.
- 1:00:58I mean, I think um these laws being so new and
- 1:01:02and because we don't have case law yet it's just
- 1:01:04it's hard for us it's just like ai right it's
- 1:01:06like a lot of people ask me like you know how
- 1:01:08would this be be dealt with with ai i mean i
- 1:01:12spoke at the ai mit ai summit they wanted me
- 1:01:15to talk about whether or not the llm's training
- 1:01:19was And I said, well, we're just going to have
- 1:01:22to wait for the Supreme Court to decide, right?
- 1:01:24And so some of these, like some of these questions
- 1:01:26that we have, great questions, we'll see play
- 1:01:29out in the next few years in court as more kids
- 1:01:32sue their parents, you know, maybe as, you know,
- 1:01:35could there be a class action, you know, where
- 1:01:38the platforms are being held responsible? I don't
- 1:01:40know, right? So I think we'll get more answers
- 1:01:42in the next few years with these laws, with AI,
- 1:01:46and we just have to ask practitioners. way for
- 1:01:50the courts to decide. I think one way we can
- 1:01:54help from a practitioner standpoint is let's
- 1:01:56be proactive. Let's sort of like the way ultimately
- 1:01:59the fashion industry had to do with models, skinny
- 1:02:01models and appropriate size and minors on the
- 1:02:06runway, et cetera. We can have industry certainly
- 1:02:09create those standards, but we can create those
- 1:02:11model standards of what it should look like,
- 1:02:14especially for our clients that have major influence,
- 1:02:17and then they can implement that as sort of like
- 1:02:19an industry custom and practice. So that's one
- 1:02:22way to look at it, because we really don't want
- 1:02:25kids suing parents left and right, ultimately.
- 1:02:29And we shouldn't have to wait for that long also
- 1:02:31to figure out this when it's real time negotiating
- 1:02:34those deals and trying to you know, do what we
- 1:02:37can for true monetization and a future of a child
- 1:02:41and at least have the parents also. Everybody
- 1:02:43just benefits in a good way. We love the deals.
- 1:02:46We don't like the fights, even though we know
- 1:02:47we ultimately have to help prevent the fights
- 1:02:50or fight if necessary. I agree with that. I mean,
- 1:02:55I think I always teach my junior attorneys, you
- 1:02:58know, what we do is maybe 10 or 20 percent the
- 1:03:01law and the rest of its human behavior. It's
- 1:03:03guiding our clients in the right way. I mean,
- 1:03:06that example I gave to you of the two parents,
- 1:03:08I told the parents. Point blank, you two have
- 1:03:12to talk and figure out what is the best for your
- 1:03:15family. Like, do not put your kids in the middle.
- 1:03:18Do not, you know, make them choose because they're
- 1:03:21kids. They can't decide. So we have to sort of
- 1:03:23sometimes step in and be... the therapist or
- 1:03:27the coach and help them think about, well, how
- 1:03:29could this play out in real life? Do you want
- 1:03:31your kids to sue you one day? Because they don't
- 1:03:33even think about that, right? They don't even
- 1:03:34realize that's a possibility. So it's our job
- 1:03:37to sort of tell them, look down the road for
- 1:03:39them and say, like, do you want this? And a lot
- 1:03:41of them say, no, I don't want my kids to sue
- 1:03:43me. You know, most parents want the best for
- 1:03:46their kids. So what a great conversation. Thank
- 1:03:49you so much both. Absolutely. Thank you both.
- 1:03:53Yeah. Okay, thank you. So Libby will close it
- 1:03:57out. Or is Susan close it out? Alright, this
- 1:04:02concludes today's presentation. Thank you so
- 1:04:04much Libby, Tyler and Uduak for a fantastic presentation.
- 1:04:08I hope everyone here has a lovely afternoon and
- 1:04:10thank you to our audience. Thank you everyone.
- 1:04:13Have a good one. Cheers.