Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 159 author Ruby Blondell
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening, you've Forgotten Hollywood with doug Hess here on jail Jbdia. Hello
- 0:24everyone, and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcast and memories of Yesteryear.
- 0:28My name is doug Hess and if you're tuning in and Forgotten Hollywood for the
- 0:31first time. But what I do on this podcast is take you on a
- 0:34journey back in time. We share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may
- 0:38or may not know about. And in this episode, we have a very
- 0:40special guest with us today and it's Ruby Blundell, who is the author of
- 0:46the book Helen of Troy in Hollywood. Ruby, welcome to Forgotten Hollywood.
- 0:51Thank you very much. I'm happy to be here. No, it's our
- 0:53pleasure and thank you for coming on and spend it a few minutes to talk
- 0:57about your book, Helen of Troy in Hollywood. In the first question I
- 1:00just tried to kind of kick off to you, is to tell the audience
- 1:04a little bit about what this book is about and how the book came about.
- 1:10Well, the book was originally prompted by the movie Troy, which is
- 1:14not exactly Forgotten Hollywood because the representation of Helen in that movie may be so
- 1:21mad I really did not care for it, and so I started. I
- 1:26wrote My first article was about Diane Krueger in that film, and it was
- 1:32really pretty mean eyed article because I hated the representation. But I started getting
- 1:37into Helen and Greek sources more through that, and I ended up my plan
- 1:42was to do a book that was Helen in Greek myth and in film,
- 1:46okay, but I got through so much material on the first topic that I
- 1:52did a whole book on Helen and Greek myth which is just called Helen of
- 1:55Troy. And so then I moved the movie part into a second book and
- 2:01that's what this is. Helen of Troy and Hollywood. Oh excellent. Actually,
- 2:06you know, I know you were kidding there about the movie Troy and
- 2:08not being really forgotten Hollywood, but some people would actually prefer it was forgotten
- 2:15because there's some controversy with that film. So I'll just leave it at that,
- 2:19right, fair enough, we can certainly talk about it, but fair
- 2:23enough. Yeah, So you know, when reading your book, so Helen
- 2:28of Troy has really been depicted not only on the big screen the silver screen,
- 2:31but also in television as well. And really there's a lot more portrayal
- 2:38of her in film in TV than maybe what one would realize. Yes,
- 2:44a lot of people have said to me, well, what are you what
- 2:46is it about? You know, I've never heard of herking in film except
- 2:50for the infamous Troy, of course. And it's true that some of these
- 2:53things really are forgotten, including some of them deserve to be forgotten, some
- 3:00of them less. So there's an epic from the nineteen fifties called Helen of
- 3:05Troy, directed by none other than Robert Wise, which is it's truly terrible.
- 3:09I mean, I find that there are a lot of interesting things to
- 3:14say about it, but it's not a great movie, even by the standards
- 3:16of that genre. But one of my favorite Helens. I have two favorites.
- 3:23One is a silent movie Helen and the other one is Helen in a
- 3:27Star Trek episode. But the silent movie one is probably going to be of
- 3:31the greatest interest to you in your audience, I would guess, because it
- 3:35really is forgotten Hollywood. The movie has been lost, that's only. It's
- 3:39called The Private Life of Helen of Troy, and it was an early film
- 3:44directed by Alexander Corda, who then became famous in the talkies, So it
- 3:51was one of the last silent films made because it's twenty seven, the same
- 3:53year that sound came in, and it was based on a best selling novel
- 3:59at the time. And like I said, it's been lost, but about
- 4:03twenty minutes remain and a lot of publicity materials, a lot of reviews,
- 4:11a lot of extraneous materials, so you can more or less reconstruct it pretty
- 4:15well. Yeah, what do you think Hellman of Troy has been such a
- 4:20quote unquote quote unquote hot topic and keep showing up over and over again,
- 4:27whether it's on television or on the big screen. Well, I'd like to
- 4:34claim that she, in some ways is a representative figure of cinema. She's
- 4:44the embodiment of female beauty, and as we all know, in early Hollywood,
- 4:47especially the beauty of female stars, is an obsession. The first chapter
- 4:54of the book is giving background and looking at various issues like how do you
- 4:58present beauty on screen and the role of beauty and early Hollywood and realism,
- 5:04and they were absolutely obsessed with beauty and beauty contests. And they were also
- 5:11obsessed with classical antiquity, especially ancient Greece. So for me, Helen brings
- 5:17those two things together. She's the archetype of ultimate beauty. She's also the
- 5:23embodiment of somebody's idea about ancient Greek beauty. And in early Hollywood, they
- 5:29were very keen to appropriate antiquity for themselves, to show that the movies were
- 5:33culture. That you have all this contempt for Hollywood, which people still have
- 5:40today, especially from the East Coast, and so the discourse around the movies
- 5:48in Hollywood leans very heavily on classical antiquity and likening the stars to ancient gods
- 5:55and goddesses, statues, especially, all that kind of thing. So I
- 6:00think that in that sense, Helen represents the movie for me. Gotcha in
- 6:06terms of no, you had mentioned earlier that and we're not going to pick
- 6:11all one particular film, but you said the way she was portrayed in the
- 6:16early two thousand and Troy, and then there were some others that were not
- 6:19very pleasing in your eyes of Troy. What do you think that is?
- 6:24Do you think that they were trying to purposely mischaracterize her or was it just
- 6:30a pure lack of knowledge? What do you portray to that? I think
- 6:36it's almost opposite My two least favorites other two epics Okay Troy and the nineteen
- 6:44fifties Helen Troy. And I think because these were high presstee genres which cost
- 6:47a lot of money, the filmmakers were very nervous and very conservative. And
- 6:56for the one in the fifties too, there's a huge amount of influence of
- 7:00censorship. Helena Troy is in her essence a transgressive woman, and yet Robert
- 7:09Wise was trying to make her the heroine of his epic, and I've read
- 7:14the correspondence with the MPAA and it's kind of sad really, but just it's
- 7:21like, no, you're showing too much of her breast, you know,
- 7:24And it's really hard to show Helena Troy is the essence of like sexiness and
- 7:30desirability and also a female transgression, and to show that in the nineteen fifties
- 7:32context is really difficult, right, So I think for different reasons, but
- 7:38in both cases, because of the high stakes of the epic genre, those
- 7:42two films are the least successful. Whereas I love the Silent Movie and I
- 7:46also love television in general because the stakes are lower and so they're willing to
- 7:50take more risks and do different things. Just as an example of that,
- 7:56Helen is normally blonde, super blonde Wiser's epic, they took an Italian actor
- 8:03and they bleached her hair and lightened her skin anyway, But in television you
- 8:09get there are two darkhead Helends, both of whom were played by interracial actors.
- 8:15So you are willing to take a chance and do something different. Yeah?
- 8:18Interesting? In your research? Did what surprised you? Did anything in
- 8:24particular surprise you when you were writing this book and doing your research. Well,
- 8:30I started from a position of zero knowledge about film and Hollywood. Okay,
- 8:33so a lot of things surprised me as I went along the cult of
- 8:41beauty in Hollywood, I didn't realize how much that was wrapped up in ancient
- 8:46Greek themes. There is great article by Ruth Waterbury for Photoplay called Olympus Moves
- 8:52to Hollywood, and it shows it's about how allegedly the movie stars embody the
- 9:03appearance right down to the specific vital statistics of the ancient gods. And the
- 9:11usual model for this for women is the venus de Milo. So all these
- 9:16movie stars were compared to the venus de Milo, and a whole bunch of
- 9:20them would have publicity photos of themselves with the Venus de Milo or a list
- 9:26of the so called vital statistics, which is crazy because the Venus de Milu
- 9:28is a huge marble statue. You know, she doesn't have vital So the
- 9:35degree of obsession with that, and also in the in the discourse of beauty
- 9:41surrounding Hollywood, like there's one article which talks about how allegedly hundreds of young
- 9:46women at Wellesley College have the same vital statistics as the Venus de Milo,
- 9:52which is you know, it's insane. But they were in this kind of,
- 9:56if you want to call it, beauty contest between American and Greek beauty.
- 10:01So they wanted to claim that the modern American girl, as they usually
- 10:05call her, is the modern is the reincarnation of the ancient Greek beauty.
- 10:09But they also sometimes want to say that actually she's better. You know,
- 10:13the Venus demula is a bit overweight. So I could go on and on
- 10:18about that. There's so much fascinating material about the subject of beauty in that
- 10:22period. Sure, sure, well into some degree do you think that carries
- 10:26on today with Hollywood? The obsession with beauty definitely sure, it's a little
- 10:35different. You don't advertise films by giving people's vital statistics anymore, which they
- 10:41used to right, Right. The thing that interests me that persists, and
- 10:48this goes all the way back to ancient Greece, is this tension that we
- 10:50have between ideas of beauty as objective and subjective. We have the cliche beauty
- 10:56as in the eye the beholder, right, and just about everybody would agree
- 11:00with that, sure, but we don't behave as if beauty is in the
- 11:03eye of the beholder. We have beauty contests. I mean, I fauty
- 11:07isn't the beholder? What's the point of a beauty contest? Like, how
- 11:11are you going to judge anybody? So you see these conflicting views, and
- 11:15it creates issues around representing Helen because she's by definition the most beautiful woman in
- 11:22the world. So you're gonna say it's either beholder, then it really shouldn't
- 11:28matter what she looks like, you know, it's almost anybody can play the
- 11:31part. Yeah, exactly. Theoretically, you know, if the audience really
- 11:37believes it's now they beholder, they should be like, well, oh well,
- 11:39I guess you know, Paris like her yeah, but that's not what
- 11:43happens. What happens is they try to make somebody look like what they think
- 11:48is like a cultural icon of beauty, and then the audience reacts accordingly,
- 11:52and the audience will say she's not beautifully enough, right, And they're already
- 11:58cast judgment when they say that. They're not just saying, well, she's
- 12:01not to my taste, They're saying she is not she does not have the
- 12:05beauty of Helen right. Well. The other thing I think Hollywood does,
- 12:13and we can debate whether this is on purpose or not, but a lot
- 12:16of individuals do not probably even truly understand Helen of Troy period, the ancient
- 12:24Greek aspect, and so a lot of times they are looking to film and
- 12:28culture to set the idea of what history, for lack of a better word,
- 12:33really is, and I think Hollywood really takes advantage of that freedom to
- 12:43help direct and shape what others believe is a realistic view of whether it's Helen
- 12:50or Troy or I mean, I saw the new trailer for Napoleon that's coming
- 12:56out, and Hollywood takes is creative licensing to be able to play loose with
- 13:05the rules, and I think a lot of times folks take that as a
- 13:09gospel. Yes, and they're completely entitled to do it however they want,
- 13:16absolutely, and especially when it comes to Greek myth, because this is what
- 13:20my first Helen book was about. There are multiple versions, all kinds of
- 13:24different ways of approaching it, and Hollywood is completely entitled to whatever they want
- 13:28with it. But the other side of that kind is that why do they
- 13:33make movies about antiquity because they think people will want to go see them,
- 13:37and people want to go see them partly because they have this cultural cachet.
- 13:41Everybody's read these stories at school. They think they know the story and they
- 13:45want to go see their idea. So you do end up and for some
- 13:48of the films I talk about I did talk about this issue, you end
- 13:52up with this tension between on the one hand, the writer or the director
- 13:56is trying to do something different, and on the other hand, the audience
- 14:00is saying you're wrong, that's wrong, you know, because of what they
- 14:03read in school, or because of their own personal preference for a certain version.
- 14:07And it's a real catch twenty two for the filmmakers, I think,
- 14:11right, and then everybody kind of gets beat up in the process because everybody
- 14:16thinks they are the right version or the right story. I'll leave that way.
- 14:24I'll just give you one example, another one that I really like.
- 14:28It's it's a mini series called Helen of Troy from two thousand and three,
- 14:31and it was on television and I interview the writer for it, and she
- 14:37had wanted to do a feminist version, and it actually I think it is
- 14:39a feminist version. But I also a lot of the book. I look
- 14:43at reviews and reactions and online reactions, and people were furious with it because
- 14:50it wasn't quote unquote the Iliad. And she didn't even pretend it was the
- 14:54Illiot, you know. She used different sources and she was trying to tell
- 14:56the story a new and different way. But people have this idea of what
- 15:00they think it should be, and very very very hostile, very unfortunately.
- 15:05I think it's in some ways a really interesting rendition. Yes, And I'm
- 15:09sitting here as you say that, a lot of people, not everybody,
- 15:13but a lot of people, like you said, have have read that in
- 15:16school. That was required in the English Crisses growing up, And so I
- 15:20guess in one way, you kind of want to past society on the back
- 15:24that people actually remember and listened there. But when it comes to Hollywood,
- 15:30then they almost scorn Hollywood for being taking any liberty to create be creative in
- 15:39the process. And I don't know, I just find that kind of an
- 15:43oxymoron that we want Hollywood to be creative and then when they when they do,
- 15:48we scold them for it. Right absolutely, And you know, maybe
- 15:52I'm a hypocrite here because this whole project started with me hating as representation a
- 15:56pale of try um. But that wasn't just because I was like, it's
- 16:03not accurate or it's not my idea of beauty I had. I had my
- 16:08reasons. My own image of Helen was different, and I didn't take issue
- 16:15with it. Um. So it's not it's not that you're not allowed to
- 16:18be critical, but the framework that you adopt when you go into a critique.
- 16:23Yeah, and if you think that, if you think that you know
- 16:26the iliad and this, I won't even get into it. But there's some
- 16:30stuff in the book about about people's really kind of slightly daft reactions, yes,
- 16:37yeah, yeah, And you know, and I think to your point
- 16:41that if you took a hundred people and said pick your ideal Helen or Troy,
- 16:45we'd probably have a hundred different versions of who that would be, and
- 16:49who would be that lead character, etcetera, etcetera. And to go back
- 16:55to what we kind of circle back to talk about. To each of us
- 16:57we would be correct, but the other time I would tell the other one
- 17:03just how terrible they were. But yes and yeah, at the same time,
- 17:07going back to what we said before, you have this obsession with absolute
- 17:11standards of beauty that has not gone away. There are always like computer programs
- 17:15now that will tell you how beautiful you are and tell you what to do
- 17:18about it, and guess what, you have to be white, and you
- 17:22know, you have to have certain very predictable features all and you can't wait
- 17:27over this much. The list goes on and on, and I think that's
- 17:32really a terrible thing for society, especially for young female women, because you
- 17:37keep hearing stories about how that really affects especially the younger women. Probably you
- 17:45want to be wrong here, affects everybody, but I really think it really
- 17:51hits hard to the younger generation. Yeah, absolutely, yeah, Because Helen
- 17:56of Troy was considered to be a model for women herself, often in a
- 18:02really bad way. Again, some of my favorite material is the early stuff
- 18:06and the stuff about how she was a bad example and she caused all kinds
- 18:08of bad things to happen. So how are you? And you know,
- 18:11Hollywood was very, very nervous about putting bad role models on the screen,
- 18:17so you have trying to how do you justify or defend putting this quote unquote
- 18:25bad woman in your movie. And it's interesting because this really started from the
- 18:32beginning of Hollywood. But antiquity one reason they had several reasons for being obsessed
- 18:37with it, one of which we discussed before. But another reason was because
- 18:40it was culturally respectable. You could do kind of slightly shocking or scandalous things
- 18:47and you could say, well, it's a lot hard it's all culture,
- 18:49you know, we need to know this The Private Life of Helen of Troy.
- 18:53I looked into a lot of the reception of it my audiences, and
- 19:00I found one where in a city in Portland, the police department didn't want
- 19:07to show the film because it was scandalous, but the movie theater owner defended
- 19:11it on the grounds that it was a classic and every child should know it,
- 19:15so you can use the classics. I mean Cecil B. De mill
- 19:18is as famous example of this, using classical themes that you can show all
- 19:22kinds of scandalous behavior. Yes, and to a degree, I think Hollywood
- 19:30today actually kind of thrives on that to a degree to help with publicity and
- 19:37what's you're saying, pressus press, there's not such thing as bad press kind
- 19:41of helped generate more excitement and more enthusiasm for the for the film. And
- 19:47if somebody tells you, oh, you can't go see it, that makes
- 19:51people want to go see it right right? Right or wrong? Good or
- 19:55bad? Yeah? Yeah, Well, Ruby, thank you so much.
- 19:59I know we're get close here on time here, but I want to thank
- 20:03you for coming on and spending some time with this today. I do believe
- 20:07you have a special offer if somebody would like to go out and purchase this
- 20:10book. It's by Princeton Press. Is that correct? That's your publisher?
- 20:17I do indeed, Yes, it's Princeton University Press. And it's thirty percent
- 20:21off if you put in the code P three two five. P three two
- 20:29five is the code for thirty percent discount code off. Yeah, and just
- 20:33for our listeners, that's good only at the Princeton Press. I imagined,
- 20:41so yeah, it must be. It must be on that website. Technically
- 20:44the book isn't even out yet, but yeah, but you can pre order
- 20:47it and make sure that you go out and get a copy of Ruby's book,
- 20:52Helen of Troy in Hollywood. You're not going to be disappointed. And
- 20:56Ruby, thank you again for coming on and sharing a few minutes with us.
- 21:00And we really appreciate you coming on and telling us a little bit of
- 21:03Helena Troy. Thank you so much, it was really fun. Well,
- 21:07thank you so much, and thank you for listening to this episode of Forgotten
- 21:11Hollywood. Just search for Dougcaster or Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find me
- 21:15on Twitter, Instagram at hesteg fourteen. If you listen to this podcast on
- 21:18iTunes or another podcast service, please subscribe or rate and review this episode.
- 21:22Tune in next time for the latest episode of Forgotten Hollywood. Thank you for
- 21:26listening and we will see