Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Issues Tips on Starting an Exam Efficiently - What You Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: All right.
- 0:02Hey everyone.
- 0:03This is Mark Tranquil with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:06I am joined today by three of my team members, Todd, Steven Dennis,
- 0:11gentlemen, how you doing today?
- 0:14Bauer: Doing well.
- 0:14Doing good.
- 0:15Treichel: All right, let's, uh, in case there's, you know, some new listeners
- 0:19that have stumbled across the, the Wonders that are the With Flying Colors
- 0:23podcast that haven't heard you before.
- 0:26Uh, let's give you, give your elevator pitch of your background at, at
- 0:30N-C-N-C-O-A and or credit unions.
- 0:32And let's start with, uh, let's start with Steve this time.
- 0:37Farrar: All right.
- 0:38I sum up my career at NCOA and with credit unions really into three separate parts.
- 0:43Now, the, the, the first part was just as a, as an examiner and a
- 0:48problem case officer, which I did for probably a little over, uh, 10 years.
- 0:53And in that worked when the, on the west coast and most of that
- 0:57was as a problem case officer.
- 0:58And in that, uh, dealt with a lot of resolution of credit
- 1:02unions through mergers, assisted mergers and conservatorships.
- 1:06And all of those types of things.
- 1:08Then, uh, I followed Mark to the central office and worked remotely in the
- 1:14office of examination and insurance and risk management for, uh, you know, at
- 1:18least another more than 10 years there.
- 1:21And that I really enjoyed that job 'cause got involved in so many of the
- 1:25kinda national issues affecting NCOA.
- 1:29And, and, uh, my duties were, were, were, were really great 'cause, uh, one
- 1:33of my calculations was dealing with how much should the NCA reserve for credit
- 1:37union potential failures and losses.
- 1:40I got involved in the corporate resolution and then towards the end
- 1:44of my career I spent a lot of time on the, uh, risk-based capital regulation,
- 1:48but really diverse topics and, and, and a lot of interesting people and
- 1:52within the industry to work with.
- 1:54Then, uh, post-retirement, I've spent a stint as, uh, working in a conservatorship
- 1:59as a, as a CFO, and then we, we started with Mark, and then we've been able to.
- 2:04You know, continue to take what we learned in all those years at NCA and
- 2:08help credit unions mainly with the, their communications with the examiners.
- 2:13Treichel: It does come about down to communications a lot.
- 2:15It seems just like life.
- 2:17Uh, hey, Todd, you're up next.
- 2:18Okay,
- 2:19Miller: well I spent 34 years with NCUA.
- 2:22It's kind of interesting.
- 2:23The first six, seven years.
- 2:25Um, I was actually a parallel path with Steve as an examiner and a PCO.
- 2:30We worked for the same se initially, we worked for the same director of
- 2:34special actions and then we kind of detoured Steve moved on to other things.
- 2:39I stayed in the examiner's core a little bit longer than him when I had children.
- 2:44Um, so the first 10 years I was basically an examiner problem case officer.
- 2:49The next 10 years of my career, I spent it as a regional capital market
- 2:52specialist in the western region.
- 2:54Kind of one of the more complex regions.
- 2:56During that I kind of got involved in some of the corporate stuff too.
- 3:00Steve and I, I think we wrote one of the first reports for Mr.
- 3:03Fri about how much risk those corporates poses to the agency.
- 3:07And then you drug me into Westcorp for my last year.
- 3:10I call it my last year.
- 3:11'cause I wasn't allowed to talk to anyone.
- 3:13I spent a whole year at Westcorp working for you when you were the agent for
- 3:16the conservator and then the last 11 years of my career, I was a director of
- 3:21special actions in the western region.
- 3:23Supervising problem case officers.
- 3:26Um, regional capital market specialists.
- 3:28Some regional lending specialists unfortunately closed more than a few
- 3:33credit unions at that last recession.
- 3:36Also I was involved in a couple conservatorships that were returned
- 3:40to the members, so those are kind of highlights of the career.
- 3:43It's always nice when you can conserve a credit union, give it back to
- 3:45the members, and know that those credit unions are still there today.
- 3:49I think I retired for maybe two, three months When you came
- 3:52through Billings and said, Hey.
- 3:54Wanna do something in your spare time.
- 3:56And so I've been helping you ever since.
- 3:57That was in 2021, so we're coming up on four years of that mark.
- 4:02Treichel: That's crazy.
- 4:02Yeah.
- 4:03And Steve and I have been at it almost five.
- 4:05And, uh, it's, uh, it, I tell you what time flies, guys.
- 4:10And Dennis.
- 4:11Dennis, the newest Yeah.
- 4:12Newest team member to, to our group.
- 4:14But I've actually known you just a touch longer than, uh, Todd and Steve.
- 4:18Gotta good.
- 4:19Provide your background.
- 4:20Uh, if, if you could,
- 4:21Bauer: yeah.
- 4:21Yeah.
- 4:21I'm, I'm the newbie to Mark Mark's group here, but I've known Mark
- 4:24for probably about 38 years.
- 4:26I, that's the timeframe of my career with credit unions.
- 4:30Um, my first six years were actually with NCUA as an examiner
- 4:35and a problem case officer.
- 4:36Very similar.
- 4:37To, uh, Steve and Todd.
- 4:39Um, but after six years I decided I wanted to go on the other side.
- 4:44So I jumped ship from NCUA and worked for Ideal Credit Union.
- 4:49Back then, it was Postal Credit Union in, um, St.
- 4:52Paul, Minnesota.
- 4:53I've worked for them for 32 years.
- 4:55I just recently retired about a year ago and in, I think in January I stayed in
- 5:02contact with Mark throughout the years.
- 5:04Good friends as well.
- 5:06Um, and he asked me to jump on a call here and there.
- 5:09And so that, that's where I, I got connected with Mark's group here.
- 5:13My, my 32 years at the credit union, uh, we were approximately about a
- 5:17hundred million in assets basically.
- 5:19Then through our organic growth for the next 32 years, we
- 5:22worked our way up to about a 1.1
- 5:24billion, um, retired there as the, um, uh, chief financial officer.
- 5:28Had a great career, was.
- 5:30It was fun.
- 5:31I loved my job throughout the, throughout my 38 or 32 years.
- 5:35So, worked in various aspects of the credit union.
- 5:38Started as a VP of operations, but basically grew as the CFO
- 5:42through that period of time.
- 5:43Had risk management report to me, obviously finance, accounting and it, so,
- 5:48a bunch of different areas that reported into me throughout that timeframe.
- 5:51Treichel: Yeah, we've all, we've all been blessed of, of almost
- 5:54having 40 years of working in credit unions one way or another.
- 5:57And, uh, it was luck that, uh, that brought me to it, and
- 6:02probably some of you as well.
- 6:03But, uh, it's really enjoyable now to.
- 6:06To be able to look at what we used to do and what's happening
- 6:09at NCA, et cetera, et cetera.
- 6:11And in that regard, you know, there's not a lot with only one board member
- 6:14and with the Trump administration saying, you know, we don't want new
- 6:17regulations and we don't want, uh, new guidance and things like that.
- 6:21There, there's not as much coming out from NCA at this time, but they did come
- 6:26out with, uh, via their nsu a express.
- 6:28And by the way, if you don't subscribe to NSU a Express, you can sign up
- 6:31an NNC a's website and they'll.
- 6:33They'll alert you when new things come out.
- 6:36Some of it's mundane, like this person was prohibited.
- 6:39Uh, some of it's, uh, meaty when they come out with a new letter or a new regulation.
- 6:43And what they did recently was they came out with, uh, a reference
- 6:48to a, a new webpage called Tips on starting an exam efficiently.
- 6:54And it was interesting because, you know, we have had some conversations
- 6:59with some credit unions recently.
- 7:01Where there seemed to be a lack of efficiency.
- 7:04And Steve, you mentioned communication and how important that is.
- 7:08Uh, but we've seen some signs that showed us that things might
- 7:11not have been working optimally.
- 7:13And it appears that some feedback has gotten to NCA through, um,
- 7:17through the reporting back system.
- 7:19The post exam exam survey.
- 7:21Yes.
- 7:21Thank you.
- 7:21The post exam survey, if you will, that things could be done better.
- 7:25So there is this page out there, tips on starting an exam efficiently that we
- 7:29thought it'd be good to chat with that.
- 7:31You know, there we, there's how we used to do it.
- 7:33There's how they're saying it needs to be done now or recently.
- 7:37There's the things we've seen client-wise and Dennis from, from
- 7:40where you sit, there's things you probably did to prepare for an exam.
- 7:44But let, I'm just gonna throw it out there.
- 7:46Who wants to take first bite on this, uh, apple of how to start an exam efficiently?
- 7:53Farrar: Let's go ahead and start with you because you, you have, uh,
- 7:56experience on both sides a little bit and know a little bit more
- 7:59about merit than, than, than I would
- 8:02Miller: Well,
- 8:02I got some training on merit.
- 8:04I retired right before they implemented it.
- 8:07It's somewhat interesting.
- 8:09You know, I think a lot of what's coming out of this, it's because of COVID, NCUA
- 8:13is moving more and more offsite, what we're seeing with our clients, and they've
- 8:18expressed it to us that, you know, the, the pre-exam requests for electronic
- 8:22documents are growing ever larger.
- 8:25And in the past, you know, there's been some guidance laid out to examiners
- 8:30and EICs, but things have done.
- 8:33Very informally in some respect.
- 8:36Their exams have always had a standardized exam request, but
- 8:40you've always had specialists.
- 8:41I know even when I was a capital market specialist, you know, my list was a
- 8:45little different than other specialists.
- 8:46Sometimes I almost always sent them to the EIC would, sometimes the EIC
- 8:51would say, Hey, go ahead, send it right to this person at the credit union.
- 8:54So there was different.
- 8:56Protocols being followed by different people, even though it
- 9:00was always the EICs responsibility.
- 9:04And you know, we heard it from our clients.
- 9:06They refer to it in this letter that, you know,
- 9:14Treichel: got some feedback coming from D Dennis.
- 9:18I think your dog might be, uh, chewing up, uh, something.
- 9:23Bauer: Yeah, you scratch.
- 9:24Sorry about that.
- 9:25I'll put it myself
- 9:26Treichel: on mute for a second.
- 9:27We're okay.
- 9:27Very good.
- 9:28Uh, Todd, go ahead.
- 9:29I'm sorry.
- 9:30Miller: Now I gotta get back to my train of thought.
- 9:31So anyways, a lot of credits are starting to complaint.
- 9:34Hey, they're getting duplicate requests.
- 9:36Um, like I said, the specialists all have separate different little
- 9:39flavors for what they wanna ask for.
- 9:42Sometimes those are going directly to the credit union, not through the EIC.
- 9:46NCUA has got three different ways where examiners can, or
- 9:52credit unions can provide their information to the examiners.
- 9:55They can do it through the merit survey, um, they can do it through
- 9:59NCUA secure transfer portal.
- 10:02They can do it through their own.
- 10:03Facility or secure file transfer portal.
- 10:06And you know, it's pretty clear this letter makes it clear to you that it's
- 10:11so credit union's choice on how they do that, you know, so two of these tools are
- 10:14NCOs, credit Union can use their own tool.
- 10:18It's interesting when you go through the.
- 10:21Their national supervision policy manual.
- 10:24You know, some of the things that the card union have to provide CTR sars,
- 10:29things with personal information.
- 10:31They're not supposed to send those through merit.
- 10:33They're actually supposed to use the secure file transfer portal.
- 10:36Or their own.
- 10:38So you've got some differing standards for different types of data, but it's
- 10:42always the credit union's choice.
- 10:44And I think you read through, and we just had a client go through this,
- 10:47if you use NCUA secure file transfer portal, um, and we have clients that
- 10:52like to do it 'cause they can see what's been downloaded by the examiners.
- 10:56And this probably came out in their exam survey.
- 10:59We've seen this where clients, they've provided thousands of
- 11:02documents and the examiners don't even download and look at all of 'em.
- 11:05Treichel: And Yeah.
- 11:06And then they, and then they say, Hey, you didn't give us this.
- 11:08And it's like, no, you've had it for a month.
- 11:10Miller: Yeah, I'm, I'm gonna defend NCA on that one a little bit in just a second.
- 11:15But you have to, if you're a credit union, you know, read through your
- 11:18choices, read the instructions.
- 11:20Um, we just had a client.
- 11:22That, did things through the secure transfer file portal and
- 11:26the examiners couldn't see it.
- 11:28That can only happen one way, and it's pretty clear in NCOs instructions how
- 11:32that can happen and what you shouldn't do, and maybe our client did it.
- 11:36I'm gonna defend the examiners and maybe asking for documents they can't always get
- 11:41to or don't always get to a little bit.
- 11:44NCUA, they recently, in February, they changed their exam schedule.
- 11:49They made that public.
- 11:51What they didn't make public is they changed their NSPM two
- 11:55for code threes, fours, fives.
- 11:57Those guys are no longer under 90 days.
- 12:00They're under one contact between exams.
- 12:04For three, four fives, that's brand new.
- 12:06And they put that in the NSPM and they didn't really make that public.
- 12:10And I didn't notice it till I was looking at the NSPM as part of this letter.
- 12:14So when I was a problem case officer, and when I was a director of special actions,
- 12:21you know, you'd lay out, you'd have these three, four contacts for credit unions.
- 12:24You have this many resources for this contact.
- 12:27It wasn't uncommon for us to ask for extra things and if we had time to
- 12:32look through those and roll those steps over to the next contact.
- 12:36So we would do that occasionally, you know, if resources are available,
- 12:40we could look at more stuff.
- 12:41So sometimes we would ask for more stuff, then we knew we could get through with
- 12:46the idea that, hey, if the exam goes smoothly, we can look at more stuff.
- 12:50It's less to look at next time we come.
- 12:53So there is the MCUA side of that.
- 12:56Now with our clients, I don't think that's happening in all cases.
- 13:00I think they're just going overboard because everything is offsite nowadays.
- 13:04You're not on site.
- 13:06There is a fourth way for, examiners to get stuff from the credit unions,
- 13:10and that's to use the credit unions VPN, that requires extra step
- 13:15through NCUA's help desk or one stop, I guess what they call it now.
- 13:20I don't think NCUA really just encourages that.
- 13:24I've done it personally in times when we're like going through an entire
- 13:28commercial loan portfolio to price it for.
- 13:32A p and a action or something of that nature.
- 13:34There's a whole bunch of rules the examiners have to follow.
- 13:37If they get on the credit union's, VPN, they have to get off of ncua,
- 13:42and I don't think that happens very often, that fourth way.
- 13:46Most of it, it's the secure transfer portal, or it's the merit surveys are,
- 13:51it's the credit unions portal and, it doesn't talk about this in the letter, but
- 13:57I do know with a lot of state contacts, a lot of the states have portals and
- 14:02NCUA will use the state's portals for documents when the state is in charge.
- 14:06So there is a.
- 14:07A couple other ways not mentioned in this document.
- 14:11It, it's just interesting nowadays with the PII, how they have to
- 14:14formalize all this, before there was ever even a formal process.
- 14:19Steve, you and I, we were getting documents from credit unions
- 14:21electronically way back in the 1990s.
- 14:24Before NCA even envisioned it formally, so it's been going on for a long time.
- 14:29I just think now as NCA, we see this with our clients.
- 14:33There's more and more stuff offsite, so those electronic lists are getting
- 14:37longer and longer and obviously there's issues in the process along the way
- 14:43that's happened more than once, or this letter would not have been issued.
- 14:49Treichel: Exactly right.
- 14:50Steve, Dennis anything you want to add to what, anything you'd
- 14:55like to add or respond to?
- 14:56I've got a couple things that Yeah.
- 14:58That, that Todd triggered that I'll mention, but I'm
- 15:00gonna let you guys chat first.
- 15:02Bauer: Yeah.
- 15:02This, yeah.
- 15:03So I, um, fresh off of working at the credit union, so
- 15:07this is still pretty fresh.
- 15:08Um, as far as an exam process, we use, um, NCOA secure file transfer,
- 15:13um, for uploading our documents.
- 15:16Well, we're right, and it's a it becomes a little bit of a challenge for
- 15:20credit unions to manage the process.
- 15:23Today we dedicated one individual sort of as our contact, our VP
- 15:29of risk management to handle, um, basically working with the EI.
- 15:36From NCA.
- 15:37Um, but where it gets to be a challenge is just the pure number of
- 15:40examiners that are involved today, particularly with all the specialists.
- 15:44So I think on the last exam we had, we had like 16 or 17 different exams.
- 15:49We're a state charter credit union, so that might be added to the, the total, but
- 15:53that's a lot of different individuals to.
- 15:57Be able to manage.
- 15:58So you gotta have a pretty solid process in place in order to try to make it
- 16:02as efficient as you possibly can.
- 16:04Um, so our approach was to have a single point of contact on our end, and that's
- 16:10where everything, everything went through.
- 16:12So any request went to that, our VP of risk, and then from
- 16:16there, um, she distributed those requests out to the subject matter
- 16:21experts at the credit union.
- 16:23And that, that seemed to work pretty good.
- 16:25Um, where it gets really challenging is right.
- 16:28The we, NCA provides the list up front, generally about four weeks.
- 16:33We'd like to have it earlier if possible, but Right.
- 16:36It just allows us to spread out that workload.
- 16:38'cause the, usually the initial list, there's like a hundred
- 16:42over a hundred different types of requests that they're asking for.
- 16:45So it takes time.
- 16:46So we, you know, our credit union folks might be going through another.
- 16:49Like our year end audit or there's other things obviously going on.
- 16:53So the more right upfront that EIC can scope out that exam
- 16:57and provide that information as to what they need, the better.
- 17:00Right.
- 17:01That just gives us more time to, to formulate and put that all together.
- 17:05But then where it gets to be a challenge.
- 17:07So for example, I think the last exam, I think there were well over
- 17:10a hundred pre-exam items, but then during the exam, like that two week
- 17:14period that there wa that we have.
- 17:17An exam, then there was probably another 60 or 70 items that were requested.
- 17:22And again, during that process, we always ask those examiners to
- 17:25go through at one point of contact and then we we distribute it out.
- 17:30So that's where it gets to be a challenge.
- 17:31And then a lot of times, I think it was mentioned that the the examiner said,
- 17:36well, I, we don't have that, but it's, so then we're wondering, are you actually
- 17:40looking at what we uploaded to the.
- 17:42To the portal.
- 17:44But generally that, that didn't happen that often.
- 17:47It was just the, that two week period where all of a sudden you thought you
- 17:49provided most of the information, but then during the exam, then all of a sudden you
- 17:53get this big request list that is, and that may be coming from, you know, 13 or
- 17:5714 different examiners at the same time.
- 18:00Treichel: Um, and they could, they could, and they could ask for something similar.
- 18:04Uh, and then it, like, you get this version of what they asked for this
- 18:07version and, and all of them deal with loan trial balances, but one
- 18:10of 'em might have one different.
- 18:12So then you've got someone who's gotta track all that down and say, did we give
- 18:15you exactly exactly what you wanted?
- 18:17Or did we give it to you three times?
- 18:18Because you added one element and
- 18:20Bauer: Yep.
- 18:20Or policies, right?
- 18:21Everybody puts their policies together a little bit differently
- 18:23from credit union to credit union.
- 18:25And, you know, we provided them all of our policies and
- 18:28they're asking for that policy.
- 18:29Well, we've already provided that it's, you know, it's in this, in this area.
- 18:32But overall, you know, our experience has been, has been, been generally good.
- 18:36It's just, yeah, that two week period of time, our VP of risk, I mean, that's
- 18:40pretty much her, her full-time job during that period of time is, is just dealing
- 18:44with you know, the exam, the examiners.
- 18:47Establishing meetings, right?
- 18:48There's meetings that need to happen.
- 18:49So we had this individual make sure everything was coordinated.
- 18:53There wasn't any duplicate going on, so we just had one person I think that works the
- 18:57best on for us anyway, worked the best.
- 18:59That one person sort of quarterback that process for us.
- 19:03Treichel: You know, we've had Steve, I'll let you comment uh,
- 19:06on everything that's been said.
- 19:11Farrar: Uh, mine.
- 19:12I just had one more thing I was looking at then.
- 19:14The, the, on the NSPM of the section on notify credit, union
- 19:18of exam contact it, it talks about that at least four week notice.
- 19:23And I and Dennis, you're pointing out how important that is.
- 19:26The other thing they have on, in the paragraph on that exam staff.
- 19:30I do not need credit union approval to schedule an exam, but whenever possible,
- 19:35the NOA should reach agreement to minimize disruption to the credit union
- 19:39and to ensure critical staff members are available while examiners are on site.
- 19:44And I, I think the exam, it seems like the scheduling is, is not
- 19:49as flexible as it used to be.
- 19:51And we're, we do hit that in that, when they're scheduling exam during
- 19:56some of the holidays, like the recently, one on the 4th of July.
- 20:00Certainly you, it could have critical staff members that have long planned
- 20:05vacations during that, that period way before there were no ancy way.
- 20:10And I think that's something that might come up and the credit union just needs
- 20:13to be, you know, upfront in that with, uh, here's staff that we, that's had
- 20:18long-term thing and they're critical.
- 20:20They won't be here.
- 20:21You know.
- 20:22Okay.
- 20:22Let's, let's make arrangements to do what we can for that.
- 20:25I'll ask for Todd and Dennis.
- 20:27Any, you guys, any other statements on that?
- 20:31Bauer: Yeah, I think that's important.
- 20:33You know, I was, I was talking to our VP of risk.
- 20:35She, we have our, usually our, we have our year end audit and our WE NSU exam.
- 20:41Yeah.
- 20:41We normally had it at the same time, year end.
- 20:43It's sort of always sort of coordinated.
- 20:46She doesn't take any vacation from January to the end of March.
- 20:49She just blocks off her calendar knowing that, yep, we're gonna
- 20:52have a year end exam and we're gonna have a year end audit.
- 20:56But I think that is hopefully flexibility on the part of NCOA that yeah, if
- 21:00there are some key people that are gonna be gone during that time that
- 21:03can work with, uh, NSU a to try to reschedule so that that critical
- 21:07person can be part of that examination.
- 21:11Treichel: A couple general thoughts tied to all the different
- 21:13things that, that, that hope.
- 21:15I, I wrote some things down, hopefully, so I didn't forget where my train
- 21:19of thought was at, but I had, we had a client recently that had three
- 21:22different EICs announced within a one month period and two different
- 21:27exam dates, and it went from.
- 21:29It was originally charted out as X and it actually was three dates, and
- 21:33then it was pushed back, and then it was moved up before it was ever done.
- 21:36So as you're trying to figure out how your people are gonna be there, but
- 21:40NCA and in NCA staff defense, there's a lot of chaos because you've got
- 21:44people who have left from the buyout.
- 21:45You've got people who are going to be leaving because of the buyout,
- 21:48and you have the mayhem that causes to any form of scheduling.
- 21:52So they're in chaos, which makes having that gatekeeper.
- 21:57In total control that much more important because more than ever, the good
- 22:02communication is falling on the hands of the credit union to be communicative or
- 22:08over communicative because NCUA again, has resource challenges that, that are
- 22:13driving a lot of, some of the things probably driving why this thing had to
- 22:17be reissued as a webpage, if you will.
- 22:20And Todd, something you said, uh.
- 22:23Perked up my ears about about 120 days contacts.
- 22:27Uh, how they seem to have slipped that into the NSP.
- 22:32They made it public without making it public.
- 22:34Makes me wanna go and scour.
- 22:36You know what else has been changed, but that reminds me of a quote, uh, that I
- 22:40used a lot when I was at NCUA, which is before you take down a fence, you should
- 22:45understand why that fence was put up.
- 22:48And the fence was put up to have 30, 90 day contacts for Code Fives,
- 22:52120 day contacts for Code Fours, 180 day contacts for code threes.
- 22:58You know, we talked about how we've all been involved in
- 23:00credit Union for 40 years.
- 23:01Well, either around that time we started or before that time.
- 23:05Uh, NC a's staffed up so that they could do follow ups, uh, on credit
- 23:12unions that were having more challenges.
- 23:14And the reason links back to what Steve was talking about, how, you
- 23:17know, being involved in how you determine how solvent the insurance
- 23:21fund is and what the losses are.
- 23:23It won't happen today and it won't happen tomorrow, but if code
- 23:27fives and code fours only need one contact instead of three or four.
- 23:31Because they're wanting to comply with their own internal policies.
- 23:36And oh, by the way, and I, we halman two Januarys ago said, Hey, we need to
- 23:41do better in, in complying with our own policies on code threes and code fours.
- 23:47Then they watered that down so that they could comply.
- 23:49And I've talked here a lot about how that's the equivalent of airlines adding
- 23:53a half hour to their flight times to show, wow, look, it we're 95% on time now.
- 23:58So they took that and now they're saying you only have to have one
- 24:02contact for a code four, which goes to the chaos that they're under.
- 24:07Uh, meaning it becomes that much more important for the credit union to be
- 24:11humming on all cylinders because quite frankly, NCUA has all these challenges.
- 24:16Any, anything you'd like to add to that nuance, uh, of this discussion?
- 24:22Miller: A couple things.
- 24:23I think, you know, in the case of like, you know, your VP of risk
- 24:27management, Dennis, you know, who's in charge of putting things together.
- 24:30I think at this point in time, you know, whoever that person is at the credit
- 24:34union, when they start uploading things, they probably need to be over-communicated
- 24:39of, like you said before the A exam even starts, before they even get everything
- 24:43all uploaded, you know, send an email off to that EIC, Hey, can you see this stuff?
- 24:47Are you getting this stuff?
- 24:49'Cause we recently had one where the union uploaded everything and, you
- 24:53know, the, the examiner said, Hey, you uploaded it to a file we can't see.
- 24:58So it sat there for three, couple weeks, and the examiners couldn't access it.
- 25:02They never checked until the first day of the exam.
- 25:04And you know, then you got a person staying up till four in the morning
- 25:08trying to get caught back up.
- 25:09So be a little over communicative if you're the one responsible.
- 25:14Send that message to the examiners.
- 25:16Are you getting things?
- 25:18It's somewhat interesting.
- 25:19You know, they did away with those follow up contacts in the late nineties,
- 25:23early two thousands per a year.
- 25:25They left it up to supervisors and regions and as they were short on.
- 25:29Staff, those follow ups didn't happen and ended up costing the insurance fund money.
- 25:35And you can kind of see that maybe happening again this time around.
- 25:40Because out of those 20% of people that left NCOA, a lot of them were there.
- 25:45Most experienced people too.
- 25:46The people that were probably best able to manage, uh.
- 25:50A flexible schedule and had the most experience in, in reading those risk
- 25:54reports and understanding warning signs.
- 25:57So it will be interesting to see how this plays out over time.
- 26:03Treichel: It will it won't end well.
- 26:05And then they'll go through a hiring increase because there'll be a change
- 26:09in administrations, there'll be losses and the IG will do reports and Congress
- 26:14will look at them and Treasury will say, you need to do X, Y, and z.
- 26:17That's the one thing is you always know there'll be change.
- 26:20The pendulum will swing, it's swinging in this direction right now.
- 26:23It will swing back and there will, at some juncture, there'll
- 26:26be losses where they'll go, wow.
- 26:28We went in here.
- 26:28We normally would've gone in here three times.
- 26:30We went in here once we went there for 40 hours and we didn't catch the problem.
- 26:35Uh, um.
- 26:36Yeah.
- 26:36So, uh, you know, the history will repeat itself here for sure.
- 26:40Miller: Well, with the offsite exams too, everything is siloed.
- 26:43You know, a lot of times, you know, I remember when we do exams on site,
- 26:47people will be talking, I might be a capital markets over here.
- 26:50And, you know, you get someone else in the room, it's like, you know, you
- 26:53realize that's a problem and you know, now they're not having those little joint
- 26:57communications or you're not having those discussions in the room so that experience
- 27:02doesn't transfer when you've got.
- 27:04Everyone working offsite.
- 27:06So I think that will be somewhat interesting.
- 27:09I often wonder, you know, the industry doesn't know it, and we don't see
- 27:12this, but each year when NCA issues their supervision priorities, they
- 27:16issue that minimum exam scope document.
- 27:18That's never been public.
- 27:20I haven't seen one since I retired.
- 27:22But you know, they're reducing these timeframes, they're reducing the need
- 27:26for follow-ups, and it just makes you wonder, okay, what in that minimum
- 27:30exam scope document has changed too.
- 27:34Farrar: Yeah.
- 27:34Oh yeah, go ahead Todd.
- 27:36Bauer: You, you were mentioning, you know, offsite and then there's,
- 27:40now there seems to be specialists.
- 27:43So like back in the day when I was an exam, there weren't specialists.
- 27:46We were all generalists.
- 27:47So it seems like when you're introducing that offsite um, that offsite
- 27:53exam and then all the specialists, that's just, that just complicates.
- 27:59The communication process for the credit union, because all of a
- 28:02sudden you might have a individual that's working on multiple things.
- 28:06I can sort of, you know, see Yep, all this information's here.
- 28:09Then you got the specialist working on one area and another.
- 28:13And it might be, there might be some crossover, but then they're
- 28:15asking for the same thing.
- 28:17So it just seems, it, it seems that, and I understand why there are specialists,
- 28:21but that seems to have, have maybe created a little bit more work on the
- 28:26part of the credit union to make sure.
- 28:28Then, right.
- 28:28You're providing information to two people rather than one or whatever.
- 28:32So that's what I have observed over the years.
- 28:35Well,
- 28:36Miller: maybe Mark will cut this out.
- 28:37I'll just kind of throw my little 2 cents, you know.
- 28:41So you started out with, I'm
- 28:43Treichel: not gonna cut it out.
- 28:43I'm gonna lean in,
- 28:45Miller: start it out with, you know, the.
- 28:47Information security people.
- 28:49Then you had capital market specialists.
- 28:52There was a couple in the region.
- 28:53At one time, you had like one regional lending specialist in each region.
- 28:57Now I don't know how many regional lending specialists are.
- 29:01You can't keep track of 'em.
- 29:02There's so many of 'em.
- 29:02Um.
- 29:04And then you've got, now I think BSA people and compliance specialists too.
- 29:09I can't even keep track of all of them.
- 29:11It's very difficult for EICs to monitor all these specialists.
- 29:15'cause all the specialists are higher grades than the EICs.
- 29:18Most of the time.
- 29:19And I'll be honest, some of these specialists, they're
- 29:22like little primadonnas.
- 29:23They don't like to follow instructions.
- 29:25They all want to do things their own way.
- 29:27It creates a huge challenge for the EICs to manage all of that.
- 29:32And you know, I don't know.
- 29:34I suspect with the 20% of the staff that left NCUA, a lot of
- 29:37them probably were specialists.
- 29:40And maybe they will rebalance this because I think they just got to the
- 29:43point where there was too many, especially lending specialist you know, you
- 29:47should expect a principal examiner to.
- 29:50Do most of it, especially the loan reviews.
- 29:54Um, but yeah, the number of specialists creates challenges.
- 29:57It's hard for EICs and ESS to manage them because, like I
- 30:00said, they are higher pay grades.
- 30:03EICs are expected to listen to 'em, other than when the specialists get
- 30:07carried away than the EICs are not supposed to listen to 'em, you know, and
- 30:10it creates lots of back and forth with the specialist supervisors and the ses.
- 30:15It's just a dynamic that is somewhat interesting in and hard to manage.
- 30:19And like I said, there's a lot of 'em out there and in my experience,
- 30:24a lot of those specialists.
- 30:26Are somewhat prima don is they want to do things their way and some of
- 30:30them can be somewhat difficult to guide and direct and it's a real
- 30:34challenge for EIC CS a grade 12 having to reign in a grade 14 specialist
- 30:40who wants to do things their way.
- 30:43Treichel: And it can be a grade 14 that says this should be in a document
- 30:46resolution, or this should be an examiner finding, and then they move on to the
- 30:49next exam and the examiner in charge.
- 30:52In theory isn't as, as educated or no, isn't a specialist,
- 30:58isn't the higher graded.
- 30:58And you can get into the, to the whole dynamics of what
- 31:02will be in that final report.
- 31:03And then obviously it goes to the supervisory examiner who can
- 31:06be that first level of arbiter.
- 31:08Uh, so there, there are, there the.
- 31:12The specialist system creates opportunities, and if left unchecked,
- 31:16it can create some challenges.
- 31:18And then if you think about Todd, you touched on, you know, maybe they're
- 31:21gonna kinda rethink what's going on, and I do believe they're in a, in
- 31:25a big mode of, of reinventing NCUA.
- 31:29I I've heard that from good sources.
- 31:32I've heard that.
- 31:33They're not necessarily as inclusive as you might think they should
- 31:37be on how they're doing that.
- 31:39So I'm curious to see you know, what does come out relative to that?
- 31:44And I'm thinking about you know, originally having come from
- 31:48Minnesota the Minnesota Twins are in a, in a rough season right now.
- 31:52Uh, and I, you know, we're recording a podcast.
- 31:55I listen to sports podcast.
- 31:57And there the twins at the deadline traded 10 of their 26 major league players.
- 32:04They traded their five best relief pitchers.
- 32:07They traded their starting shortstop by eating part of his contract.
- 32:11And so they've got 38% new staff.
- 32:15Coming up from their AA club, who we know some of 'em are, and by the way, they
- 32:21traded all these guys, but only one of the people they got was ready to come to
- 32:25the major leagues theoretically right now.
- 32:27So they're taking nine guys from the minor leagues, moving
- 32:29them up to the big leagues.
- 32:31One of those guys was named player of the, of the week last week.
- 32:35Another guy's 31 years old.
- 32:37He's he can play all the infield positions.
- 32:39He hit his first home run.
- 32:41Two days ago, and it's creating these opportunities for these folks
- 32:46from the lower levels to come up.
- 32:48And that's what's gonna happen at NCUA.
- 32:50You know, there's a lot of talent leaving.
- 32:53They're gonna have some hiccups in the road because there's gonna be some
- 32:56corporate knowledge that was left, but they were also married to some
- 32:59old ways of doing things, because that's how we've always done it.
- 33:02So that, you know, it's gonna be kind of two steps forward, one
- 33:05step back, in my opinion, at NCA.
- 33:07But there will be, you know, stars and superstars and new leaders from every
- 33:12level of NCUA people who, who may have only been there a couple years, who are
- 33:17now being tasked with doing more things.
- 33:19And they're gonna grow, they're gonna make mistakes.
- 33:21You need to have the freedom to make some mistakes.
- 33:23But when that pendulum does swing, maybe they'll get, uh, a little bit
- 33:27better control under some things.
- 33:30And maybe that will be a little bit better control under the specialist.
- 33:33But something good will come out of all this chaos.
- 33:35It always does.
- 33:37There'll be some losses that will come out of this, this, uh, newly
- 33:40revealed change to their exam cycle.
- 33:43But yeah.
- 33:43Interesting times for sure.
- 33:45Miller: You, Steve, myself, we were hired as a rebuilding thing,
- 33:50uh, right after NCA lost a third of their staff under Callahan.
- 33:54So, exactly, exactly.
- 33:56I mean, and you get a chance, I mean.
- 33:59It like Steve and I just months outta training, we were in charge
- 34:03of code four credit unions.
- 34:04They don't let you know.
- 34:05People do that for three or four years now, you know, and we did it right away.
- 34:10You learn a lot when you're forced to and some of that will go on again at NCUA.
- 34:16Like I said, it will be interesting, you know, NSU A
- 34:19doesn't release regional org charts.
- 34:21It'd be nice to see one before all the retirements and then see
- 34:25like next one on January one, you know where all the people are.
- 34:29It would be interesting thing to compare.
- 34:31None of that stuff is ever public, so we won't get a chance to do it,
- 34:34or it's historically never been public, but it would certainly
- 34:38be interesting to see how they.
- 34:40Play out this reorganization because they lost a lot of executives and supervisor.
- 34:45Oh, well, some regions lost a lot of supervisors, some regions didn't.
- 34:49You know, so it's different in each region too, the way the impact is.
- 34:53And you know, the NSPM was set up, so all the regions are run uniformly.
- 34:58And now the way they have to triage this, it's gonna have to be some
- 35:02slight variations amongst the regions, you know, unless they make people
- 35:05move around, because the people that left are different in each region.
- 35:10Treichel: No, it's, you know, and you're reminding me and Dennis you'll might
- 35:13have some thoughts to, to this when we started when I came on and I got
- 35:18outta training, I think I had four or five months on, we had a new SE group.
- 35:22Dennis had been on three, four months more than me, and he was the second in,
- 35:28in seniority in our group of 10 examiners.
- 35:31I was third, and then there were a bunch, you know, so.
- 35:34It was one guy, Leon Hendrick, who had been forced to move under the
- 35:38Callahan administration from Denver to DC and he said, no, I'll take a
- 35:43principal examiner job in South Dakota.
- 35:46Uh, he trained Dennis and he essentially was the trainer and the leader of all
- 35:50of us young folks coming up, dealing with code fours and code fives far
- 35:54sooner than the policies allowed.
- 35:56And, uh, we learned a lot.
- 35:58We learned a lot quick.
- 35:59It was like, uh, drinking from a fire hose at times.
- 36:01But that's what's happening right now at NCA with these changes.
- 36:04It'll be happening this year.
- 36:05It'll be happening next year.
- 36:07And they'll, um, they'll come away stronger in some ways, but there
- 36:12will be some hiccups, which gets back to it's incumbent upon the
- 36:15credit unions to communicate well with NCOA while they're in this,
- 36:18um, being reborn like the Phoenix.
- 36:22Bauer: So I got a question from you guys' perspective from
- 36:25at the starting of the exam.
- 36:27So there's the EIC and you mentioned generally the EIC is probably gonna
- 36:30be, what, a, I don't know, 11 or a 12?
- 36:34Yep.
- 36:3512 and then, right.
- 36:37So then you've got specialists that are fourteens, grade fourteens.
- 36:40Do they do they coordinate before they exam anything or do does the
- 36:45examiner in charge simply send out the can list of, here's the.
- 36:49Here's the a hundred items that we normally request.
- 36:52It's not necessarily fine tuned.
- 36:54Um, and then when the specialists show up, they then request their own information.
- 36:58Is that generally how it.
- 37:00The specialists
- 37:00Miller: are supposed to send it to their s or to the examiners ahead of time.
- 37:04So here's kind of how it worked in our region.
- 37:07You know, the, the ESS would go out to the specialist supervisors.
- 37:11It's like, okay, I need a capital market specialist.
- 37:13I need a couple lending specialists.
- 37:15Those used to be called DSAs.
- 37:17I think now they're creating new specialist supervisors
- 37:20and different titles.
- 37:21They would make that assignment.
- 37:23In the Western region.
- 37:25Each of the specialists, they had a request list that they created.
- 37:30So like the capital market specialist had a uniform one.
- 37:32It was in our regional instructions, so the EIC could just pull that out,
- 37:36ask the capital market specialist.
- 37:38Anything you need to add to this one?
- 37:40Same with the regional lending specialists.
- 37:42I think the information securities officers, they may, they had a
- 37:45couple different ones, but that's incumbent on the specialists to get
- 37:49that list to, um, that EIC well ahead of time, depending on the region.
- 37:55Some of these specialists, their schedules were filled out.
- 37:586, 7, 9 months, a whole year in advance.
- 38:01As a supervisor, I typically only kept it at three months.
- 38:04'cause I wanted spaces if problem cases came up and I didn't wanna
- 38:08have to go to an SE and say, oh, you lost your specialist.
- 38:11I'd just rather delay for two or three months before I'd assigned them one.
- 38:15So there is little differences on how supervisors handle it, but in all cases,
- 38:20the EIC should have the specialist request list long before they send
- 38:24their thing to you and they should be.
- 38:27Putting that in.
- 38:29Bauer: I just don't, yeah, I don't think that's, I don't think that's happening.
- 38:31'cause I just looked at my the VP of risk sent me the most recent exam
- 38:36information she provided, and I just looked at the request list and so
- 38:40I was looking Okay, what kind of it information did they request upfront?
- 38:43There was only one item and had to do with the disaster recovery.
- 38:47So I'm assuming that there was a specialist that, that and then that
- 38:50those requests came in after they showed up during the exam, so, right.
- 38:54So that.
- 38:55So that in and of itself creates a lot of inefficiency for, for the
- 38:59crediting because there's a lot of information it is gonna provide.
- 39:03And if you don't know, it's probably can be predictable
- 39:05as to what's gonna be asked.
- 39:06But it'd be great that a little bit more coordination upfront with that
- 39:11EIC and the specialist to try to get as much of that information in advance of
- 39:15the exam as possible rather than just.
- 39:17All of a sudden they show up and we need this, and this.
- 39:20So then that, that, and then that, right.
- 39:22That creates, that, those 70, 80 other items that I was talking about that
- 39:26just fills up that two week period.
- 39:28And that's all, you know, that's all that's going on.
- 39:31Is communication.
- 39:31Then between the subject matter expert are quarterback in charge,
- 39:36our, our individual, our VP of risk, and then the potential examiner.
- 39:40So
- 39:41Miller: information security one is, is somewhat different.
- 39:44They have.
- 39:46They have different exam scopes, they use a different exam cycle,
- 39:49so it's a two or three year cycle.
- 39:51So the information securities officers, their requests are gonna change from
- 39:55year to year because they have a cycle of different scopes that they follow.
- 39:59And then what you find with them, even more so than the regional
- 40:03lending specialists, is there's a wide variation in their skill sets
- 40:07of the information securities office.
- 40:09So some of 'em have a.
- 40:11Really deep background in payment systems.
- 40:13So they tend to wait, you know, that information security towards payment
- 40:18systems where others are, you know, got a deeper background within their network
- 40:23security and things of that nature.
- 40:25And that flavors their request list a little bit and they
- 40:28play to their strengths.
- 40:30And then, like I said, they do have.
- 40:33Rotating exam or they used to have a rotating exam scope for
- 40:38the information specialists.
- 40:39So this year you get this form filled out.
- 40:43This year it's this exam scope, a different kind of scope that they use.
- 40:47So, you know, there's more variability with the information
- 40:51systems officers than there others.
- 40:53And then of course the compliance exams change, but those are
- 40:56usually telegraphed with the.
- 40:58Supervision priorities.
- 40:59As I usually tell the whole industry, this is where our focus on compliance is
- 41:03gonna be, but even then, the examiners have a little bit of flexibility
- 41:07to follow up on prior issues.
- 41:09Yeah, the lending stuff, there's not really a lot of reason for those lendings
- 41:14specialists request list to be varied from year to year the way they are.
- 41:19And certainly with the.
- 41:21Regional capital market specialists.
- 41:24Those shouldn't change very much.
- 41:25Like I said, in the Western region, we had a standard one that all the capital market
- 41:29specialists use the same request list.
- 41:32Um, the states really wanted that.
- 41:34The state supervisors, they get frustrated when NCUA specialists
- 41:39provide different lists, though in our region, in the western region with a
- 41:42lot of the states, we had agreed upon specialist lists that were given to
- 41:46the state supervisors ahead of time.
- 41:48So if the state supervisors know we're getting capital market
- 41:51specialists, we have this list.
- 41:52If they're getting a regional lending specialist, we have this list.
- 41:55But I don't know how other regions and other supervisors handle that.
- 41:59I assume they had similar things, but don't hold me to it.
- 42:03And I retired in 2021, so I don't really know if that same stuff
- 42:07is going on today in 20 20, 25.
- 42:10Treichel: Very good.
- 42:11Very good.
- 42:11Well, guys, any last thoughts on this, uh, topic before we wrap for the day?
- 42:18Bauer: There's so much here.
- 42:19I just have one other thing I thought I Go for it.
- 42:22Yeah, so there is a, right there the survey questions in that they
- 42:25were provided in this document here.
- 42:28And I'm just curious again how this really plays out.
- 42:30'cause I don't, I never really saw this play out.
- 42:33And the question was, examiners reviewed the annual audit, internal
- 42:36audit function, and the supervisory committee activities and indicated.
- 42:41I would assume to the credit union, the extent to which they
- 42:44relied on these in arriving at any exam or nation conclusions.
- 42:49So I ne I mean, I, I know that went, I know that's being probably done, but
- 42:53I never heard that being communicated back to me as the credit union.
- 42:59I'm just curious, is that actually being done or, or not out there?
- 43:04It should be.
- 43:05I think it would be great if that actually was being done.
- 43:07Um, I'm just curious if it is.
- 43:10Miller: It depends what's in that minimum scope document.
- 43:12You know, at the state of the time when I retired, examiners
- 43:15were required to go look at those supervisory committee internal
- 43:20work papers from your external CPA.
- 43:22Um, they had a catchall.
- 43:23If I, I've looked at this CPA's work, you know, the last five times.
- 43:28Okay, I can skip it here and there.
- 43:31But in theory, they were supposed to look at that and have that
- 43:34conversation with their, you know, supervisory committee chair.
- 43:38Generally.
- 43:39Okay.
- 43:39Would they say you did a good job with that external audit or not?
- 43:43No.
- 43:43Usually it would just be an exception type thing where they
- 43:45might say something to use A CFO if they found exceptions with that.
- 43:50Yeah, yeah.
- 43:51They were supposed to be looking at 'em all along for years.
- 43:54Bauer: Yep.
- 43:54But I, it'd be interesting too, you know, other internal audit functions or
- 43:58risk assessments that credit unions do.
- 43:59I mean, we, we had a huge amount of internal audit work that we did.
- 44:03A lot of risk assessments.
- 44:05A lot of them dealt with you know, cybersecurity and security.
- 44:08I mean, I was curious how much, uh, examiner might rely on some of that
- 44:12information or review that information to maybe, maybe better scope or
- 44:17scope up or scope down the exam.
- 44:19The exam process.
- 44:21Miller: I think it's a time resource thing.
- 44:23Dennis, like I said before, NCA, we'd ask for things and you know, even my staff,
- 44:27we'd ask for a little bit more 'cause it's like, what are we gonna dig into?
- 44:31You know, some credit unions, you might go to the internal audit.
- 44:34Go through minutes, look at reports they had, have a five minute conversation with
- 44:38them on their scoping other places, and I did this with newer people that when
- 44:42I was training people, I'd make them dig deeper into that whole internal audit and
- 44:47risk management process just for learning.
- 44:50And sharpening their own saws, what is going on here?
- 44:53But it becomes a time and resource thing.
- 44:55And now here with NCUA losing 20% of their staff, you might have the
- 45:00initial reaction, they should spend more time with internal audit.
- 45:04I think the reality is, is they're gonna spend less time
- 45:06with internal audit because you know you need to get that loan.
- 45:10What's going on with credit risk?
- 45:12What's going on with interest rate risk and liquidity risk?
- 45:15I mean, credit risk is always gonna be their biggest one.
- 45:18They can't really leave that unattended.
- 45:20That causes most of the losses to the fund.
- 45:24Fraud creeps in there from time to time.
- 45:26But in general, most of the credit unions that NCUA suffers a loss on.
- 45:31It's because of credit risk, you know, and high credit risk.
- 45:34It creates liquidity risk problems.
- 45:37So while you might think, Dennis, it's like examiners could be more efficient if
- 45:41they spent more time with internal audit.
- 45:43I think with the shortages and staff, the reality is, is they're gonna
- 45:47spend less time with internal audit.
- 45:52Treichel: That's an, yeah, that's a, that whole topic is quite interesting.
- 45:55And, and you know, the, the check a checklist type
- 45:59approach encourages compliance.
- 46:01'cause if the question's here, and I have to say it, I have, I,
- 46:03theoretically I have to do it.
- 46:05And if I have to have that conversation part of why that's in there is to
- 46:09raise the bar internally at NCA.
- 46:11Going back to what Todd said about.
- 46:13There was a focus on making sure that they did look at it, and internally
- 46:17you build that and then you ask in the survey that it is being done, and then
- 46:22they can kind of measure over time.
- 46:23In 20 21, 90 9% of people said, yes, it was done.
- 46:28Then it goes to 98, 96, 94.
- 46:31They can kind of see internally there's a trend that maybe that's an issue,
- 46:34hopefully that there could be some.
- 46:38Some of that behind all this, but it's a point well taken that, that's
- 46:42a great resource for NCA to rely on.
- 46:45But will they be able to now with everything that's going on,
- 46:48Bauer: but, but now with the survey, there'll be a little bit
- 46:51more visibility onto whether or not those questions or if that's
- 46:54actually communicated to the credit.
- 46:56Either they are or they aren't.
- 46:58I think the examiner then needs to state that upfront at some point during the
- 47:02exam that it wasn't done or it was done.
- 47:04Yeah,
- 47:05Miller: I don't know.
- 47:05This is, you know, NCA, they sent the surveys out to third parties.
- 47:10You know, they used to come internally into the office.
- 47:13I'd be on details, man.
- 47:14I'd pick up our regions box and go through those surveys myself, 'cause they were
- 47:18in a room, this is where they went.
- 47:20Someone compiled them once every.
- 47:22Three months or six months and sent the results out to the regions, but
- 47:26it was actual NCUA people were looking at 'em, you know, now they've hired
- 47:30a third party to collate that, and will you get the same flavor and
- 47:35will they learn the same amount?
- 47:37Looking through those surveys.
- 47:39I mean, I'd learned a lot.
- 47:40I'd be on detail in e and I and I'd pick up, like I said, I'd pick up the stack
- 47:43of our regions that hadn't been compiled yet, and I'd flip through them and
- 47:46I'd look at the questions and comments and you know, you're losing that now
- 47:50that they're moving that whole survey process to an external third party.
- 47:55You know, it might be more independent, but you know, if you're not seeing the
- 48:00actual documents, will you learn as much?
- 48:02And I.
- 48:03Don't know the answer to that question.
- 48:05I suppose it depends on the quality of that third party.
- 48:09Um, but I mean, NCA, not a couple frauds that way.
- 48:13We fired a couple examiners that were making up exam reports.
- 48:16I, I know one
- 48:17Treichel: of 'em be referring exam
- 48:18Miller: survey and it's like, wait, we didn't have any
- 48:20Treichel: exam.
- 48:21I, I wasn't new examiner training with one of those guys back in 1986.
- 48:26And you just, you just reminded me of the conspiracy theory.
- 48:30That the NBA had that when the New York Knicks won the lottery and got to pick
- 48:36Patrick Ewing, that it was an inside job because they wanted the New York
- 48:41team to be good, and then they decided to go external and have, a CPA firm CP
- 48:46along with all the, the bouncing balls.
- 48:48So, it's external which create, which makes it more independent, but it
- 48:52creates, it creates other issues.
- 48:54Okay?
- 48:55So I got to do an NBA lottery draft reference, uh, Minnesota twins
- 49:00trading 38% of , their team members to create new opportunities for
- 49:05the youth in the twins farm system.
- 49:08Bauer: Yeah,
- 49:08Treichel: this is my favorite podcast in a while, guys.
- 49:12Bauer: They did it to save money so they could sell the twins.
- 49:15Heck, I thought we have this one
- 49:17Miller: done in 20 minutes and
- 49:18Treichel: here we're, I thought so too.
- 49:19A whole hour.
- 49:20I thought so De and, and Dennis, I don't know if you saw it, but the poll
- 49:23ads have decided they're not selling.
- 49:25That came out today.
- 49:27Bauer: Oh, did, oh, no, that's not good.
- 49:29Oh, no.
- 49:31Treichel: Oh no.
- 49:32Exactly.
- 49:33Exactly.
- 49:34But hey, well, let's, you know, we got the Vikings, we got hope
- 49:37with a new, a new quarterback.
- 49:38All is good in, uh, in Minnesota.
- 49:40Uh, sports, the POLADs are keeping the team, uh, they got young guys playing
- 49:45and the Vikings are gonna go 17 and oh,
- 49:48Bauer: that's what we say every year.
- 49:49Every year?
- 49:50Treichel: Yeah, every year.
- 49:51We're the sealers fan who lives in Minnesota.
- 49:53All right.
- 49:54What else guys?
- 49:55Anything else?
- 49:57Miller: Here's a blast from the past.
- 49:59My notes are on these.
- 50:00Remember the old NI guess I can't get It shows the old NCA route slips.
- 50:04I love those.
- 50:06I still have a couple paths of 'em and I still use 'em.
- 50:10Yep.
- 50:10For scrap paper and notes, my note for this is on an NCA Ralph slip number 1502.
- 50:18Revise.
- 50:20March, 1987.
- 50:23Treichel: You don't have any of the Golden Rod exam overviews left, do you?
- 50:27No,
- 50:27Miller: I do not.
- 50:28I only did like two exams on those when I started.
- 50:33You started
- 50:34Treichel: afterwards then.
- 50:34I didn't know what Golden Rod was until I came to work at NCUA.
- 50:39I realized it was a color.
- 50:41All right, guys.
- 50:41You still
- 50:42Miller: did time reports with those When I started.
- 50:44And you mailed them out, remember?
- 50:46Treichel: Oh yeah.
- 50:47Yep.
- 50:48Yeah, you had to make sure stuff added up then.
- 50:50'cause it wasn't a formula in a spreadsheet.
- 50:54All right guys.
- 50:55Thank you for your time.
- 50:56Listeners.
- 50:56I wanna thank you for listening and or watching as always.
- 51:00Appreciate that.
- 51:01, This Mark Trekel signing off with flying colors.