Latest / Automotive State of The Union / The Public Votes on Automotive (and it ain't pretty), A Constitution For Sale, Who Should Automotive Be Watching
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Thursday, November 18th, we're back in our respective locations, Syracuse, Nashville. And I woke up this morning and realized the Constitution is for sale.
- 0:14Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. They consider once know me- Paul, I'm just glad to be back in this, in my chair, 'cause it bounces more.
- 0:24I know, you got... [laughs] The bounce was weird in- [laughs]... those hotel chairs, I gotta say. I gotta agree with you. Like, they just, they just didn't have the swagger that we're used to.
- 0:32They- [laughs] How was your trip home, good? Oh, easy trip. Yeah, the, the, the plane flights were great. I got to, got to spend some time with family yesterday and, uh, so that, that was wonderful.
- 0:43Um, I, I'm, I'm gearing up. For, for those that don't know, I'm, I'm, uh, I'm running a marathon this weekend. Yeah, he is. So I'm trying to figure out what my sleep pattern and, and, uh, what my- [laughs]...
- 0:53what my last couple miles on my feet are. And so it's, uh, coming off of, uh, coming off of a trip to Florida, it's gonna be an interesting, uh, rest of the week. But- Yeah, you- I'm, I'm excited. It's good. Yes, yes.
- 1:03How was your... How were your travels? Travels were good. You know, we were rolling heavy, all, all, the whole Daily family, so there's six of us making our way through the airport. And little guy did super good.
- 1:12He slept on the longer flight, so good timing. Ah, perfect. [laughs] We're happy. We're happy. We're good.
- 1:18This morning, uh, I don't know if you heard, we'll, we'll come back to this tomorrow, but there is a crypto, it's called a DAO, decentralized autonomous organization, where, um, every, a bunch of crypto enthusiasts are getting together, getting their funds together to bid on a copy of the Constitution at Sotheby's tonight at 6:30.
- 1:38That's... It's a crazy thing. But for real, look it up real quick. Look it up. Say Constitution DAO and you'll see all about it. We'll come back to it tomorrow to see- We'll recap it once- Yeah, we'll recap it...
- 1:48once everything goes down. Yeah, we will. But we'll just put that out there. But, uh, got some other interesting news this morning when it comes to, uh, stocks of the publicly traded auto groups, Kyle. Dang. Yeah, wow.
- 2:01So, uh, so a- our good buddy Ryan Everson, uh, shared with me a link and, and so shout out to auto genius Ri- Ryan Everson- Woo-hoo...
- 2:08for sharing this idea, uh, or this, this market report from MarketWatch that, um, essentially says because of the projection of Morgan Stanley, and, a- a- and, and we'll get into the projection in just a second, all of the publicly traded auto groups yesterday took a steep dive, even after closing high on Tuesday.
- 2:34So just the, the volatility of the market, e- especially in auto, driven by a single mover in the market saying, "Uh, we're a little bit concerned about the, the, the ability of franchise auto retail to succeed."
- 2:52And, and the real key on that was not because of inventory, it wasn't because of chip shortages, it wasn't because of EV even. It was because of consumer experience. Dang.
- 3:04K- what an interesting thing from a financial perspective, from a, from Morgan Stanley, who's f- uh, totally financial, that would typically look at things like dollars and cents, Ts and I, uh, d- you know, dotting I's, crossing Ts, you know, supply and demand.
- 3:18And they said, "No, no, no, it's not any of those things. It's actually the inability of franchise retail and the OEMs to come together to create a positive consumer experience."
- 3:26Ah, you mean it's not just a frou-frou feelgood thing? It's actually got massive seismic financial implications? No way. Even the art kids have an impact on math kids? Even the art kids. [laughs] Even the art kids.
- 3:41[laughs] Uh, if, if you're new to this story, um, you know, we, we talk about kind of siphoning from Gary Vaynerchuk's vernacular of math kids and art kids in marketing.
- 3:50And the math kids are the ones that, you know, watch the data. The art kids are one, are the ones that watch the, the humanity in the, the substance of the content, you know, the, the feelgoods.
- 4:00And, uh, you put those two together and you get, you know, you get really great marketing and branding. So, um, if you're new, we're trying to make this podcast really accessible to all layers of the dealership.
- 4:09So if you're, if... You know, sometimes we're gonna try to slow down for a second to just make sure everyone's on the same page.
- 4:14So when we're talking about the public auto groups, we're talking about the auto groups that are publicly traded on the stock exchange, that have a large holding of dealerships all across the country.
- 4:22So think Penske, Sonic, AutoNation, Group One, and, um, did I miss any of the big ones? Um, I'm gonna get- Lithia. Lithia. [laughs] I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Um, yeah, Lithia for sure. So, [swallows]
- 4:35and, and they trade on the stock exchange. These companies have gone public.
- 4:38So, um, from a Morgan Stan- like Morgan Stanley analyst major markets, they are the leading indicator that people tend to look at and talk about. And yesterday, a Morgan Stanley, Stanley analyst said, "You know what?
- 4:51They're gonna have trouble keeping up." And then, you know, probably 10% of the, on average, of the market cap just went away. Yeah.
- 4:59So consumer sentiment, if you think about it, I, I said to Kyle, "You know, if you take a step out of the industry for a second," right?
- 5:05You know, Kyle and I, um, Automotive State of the Union, m- incredible advocates of the retail auto industry, the franchise model, believing that is the best way that consumers can be delivered a car, and serviced, and cared about, and have their community supported, right?
- 5:20That's the very best way. We believe that with all our hearts. If you're not us, and you step out, you take an objective look at it,
- 5:26you can easily see that with everyone obsessed about consumer experience, that like, oh, it's really hard for Ford or GM or Honda to manage the expectations of the consumer all the way through the process because, let's ho- let's be honest, you do get a very different experience between dealerships,
- 5:45right? Yeah. We, y- you know, we look at, like e- especially me coming from the f- from the retail environment, you know, there's a lot of conversation about kind of what some of these even OEM programs are meant to do,
- 5:59right? It's not, it, it...
- 6:01Y- yes, are they, i- is there a do- desire to kind of streamline, you know, create brand efficiency and, and even more, you know, have, have a data, a, have a data layer that, that actually like is feeding back and forth?
- 6:15Yes. But-There's a lot of it in the conversation is it's not... These programs are not meant for the top 10% of dealers. The, the, the OEMs know that those, that those can survive without regulations and mandates.
- 6:29It's really this issue that the bottom 25%, that drawing them up is the, is the, like, gap in consumer experience, and maybe even, like, m- more like the bottom 75%. Yeah. I, I was gonna- Right?...
- 6:42I was gonna say, likely. Yeah, more like the bottom 75%. So when we look at the OEMs going, "Oh my goodness, our brand is resting on the laurels of
- 6:53the bottom 75% of consumer experience for our brand", that's a scary proposition for an OEM. Right. So- Right? And that's what Morgan Stanley is pointing to. Yeah, and if you're an OE- OEM, you're like, "Well,
- 7:06we need to fix that." Right? And we see all the opportunity... Right when things are in transition, there's a lot of opportunity. So EVs, opportunity for the OEM to take more control. Mm. Right?
- 7:17Because it's, it's not as... You know, it's easy to pit two sides against each other in, like, good and evil, but business is a contact sport, right? Everyone's role in business is to keep playing, right?
- 7:31Dave Meltzer: "The first rule of business is- Is stay in business"... stay in business", right? [laughs] So everyone's trying to abide by the first rule of business, and it's moves and countermoves, right?
- 7:41It can feel personal, but it's not personal. I mean, it's personal... [laughs] It is personal, actually. Yeah. If you really care about what you do, it is personal.
- 7:47And we talked earlier this week about, you know, trying to think of the humanity in both sides.
- 7:53If you're an OEM and you're listening, realize that the dealers are, are a bunch of good humans, right, that want the best for their family and their community.
- 8:01And if you're a dealer, look at the OEMs and saying, like, hey, your manufacturer rep, the inventory guy, right, the brand, the marketers, the, the co-op people, right, they're other humans trying to abide by the first rule of business.
- 8:12Yes. Right? So it's gonna be this constant dance to figure out how we can work together and win, right? Or keep winning, or keep staying in business.
- 8:22And I believe that, you know, it is the, the mandate, like, it's our flag in the ground that
- 8:30franchise auto dealers need to do everything they can to show OEMs that they are savvy retailers, that they deliver an amazing customer experience, and that they are the very, very best means to deliver the best customer experience.
- 8:44'Cause once... If they can do that, then it's fine. [laughs] Yeah. Right? It's fine. You know, we, we keep having these conversations with, uh, with, uh, marketing teams or marketers. Yep.
- 8:55And, and we say things like, "You need to market yourself to your owner, to your company", all that type of stuff. It's like there's some level of, like, you're not...
- 9:05You know, the, the marketer is not just taking whatever is, is in the store and telling the story externally. Yep. Right? It's also telling the story internally- Absolutely...
- 9:14backwards, the brand story internally to employees. But then there's an element that that marketing team actually has to sell themselves, sell, sell their value and, and what they do to the ownership. All day. Right?
- 9:27Now we're taking it a step further and saying, oh, wait, the marketers, uh, whether that be the dealer principal or the owner, is actually selling the, uh, you know, their philosophy up to the OEM. Absolutely. Right?
- 9:41I mean, think about the role of the franchise dealer in, in shifting the perception.
- 9:48We, we keep saying this, shifting the culture and perception of auto- franchise automotive retail, but it's so much more broad than just, like, your clients. Uh, it's... It can't start there.
- 10:01It has to start with yourself. [laughs] Yes. And, and so if you're listening, know that you have a role in that. Obviously, if you're a dealer principal, you have a role.
- 10:11A general manager, right, if you're a high-level leader, you know you have a role, right?
- 10:15But if you're not that high-level leader, understand that you have a role, and hopefully this will spur you to realize that that big, big problem that we just laid out, that big challenge that laid out, includes you to be part of the solution.
- 10:29We- Yeah. Th- so, so, uh, uh, I, I call them advocates, right? And, and, uh, when I was at Nelson, I would always encourage every single employee to be an advocate where they're at, right?
- 10:41And so it doesn't matter if you're a dealer principal or a salesperson or the newest hire at a dealership, your role as an advocate for the sustainability of your company or your brand in your community with the people that you're c- uh, you know, that you come across, uh, uh, is so vital to the success of all of this, right?
- 11:03Because people vote with their perception. All day. Right? And whether the vote is political or financial or, you know, where they're putting, where they're putting their money- Reviews. Right. Yeah. Whatever.
- 11:13I mean, yesterday people voted with their perceptions on these major publics. Absolutely. There was, there was an in- inciting event where this analyst, you know, weighed in. Adam- He, he...
- 11:26No, it's- Adam Jones- Okay, okay... is his name. [laughs] Voting machine, weighing machine. Watch this, right? Yeah. We just came off third quarter, uh, uh, investor calls, right?
- 11:37Where all of these publics posted record quarters, which means there was a weighing machine aspect over the last few days- Me-... to their portfolios. Yeah. Meaning that- Right?...
- 11:48people were buying stock, and it was going up based on the performance- Performance... the revenue generated. Right. But then, all of the sudden, a future outlook from an individual
- 12:00turned their portfolio, their stock portfolio, into a voting machine, meaning people were, were voting with where they were putting their money on based on their future perception of the ability for the stock to perform.
- 12:13Yeah. That's a great point. You know, yesterday at, um, the AAAS event in Palm Beach, Brian Pash's event, uh, shout out to Brian Pash and the whole PCG team, who did an amazing job- Yeah... pulling off- Amazing job...
- 12:24a very, very difficult-Uh, to pull off event. They did it. Um, everyone went home full of knowledge and inspiration. So, uh, that was great.
- 12:33And so at lunchtime, though, uh, Kyle and I were sitting and having a conversation with Alex Vetter, CEO of Cars.com, and we were talking about who do we watch for the indicators.
- 12:43Like, who does the auto industry watch for indicators of where things might be going? And the punchline of that conversation was, like, everyone else watches auto as the indicator. Oh, yeah.
- 12:55Which means [laughs], which makes it really, really hard, right? Which means we're the, the crash test dummies. Right. Like, we're gonna hit the wall- I was saying, like-...
- 13:02and then they're gonna be like, "Oh, what happened to them?" [laughs] I said to Alex, I said, "You know, what I know is that all of the people in real estate that I know, they, they look at what- Yeah...
- 13:12real estate will follow three to four months behind whatever auto does." Yep. So they are constantly asking me, "How's traffic in the store?" Yep.
- 13:19"How's things feelings, uh, uh, how are things feeling in the automotive industry?" You know, and so who do we look at? I know. Well, I mean,
- 13:28you, you look at some of the other news coming out from, from manufacturers and, um, you know, just looking at what's happening with supply and chips and with, what, uh, who was it that said that by November 1st they are not gonna have any idle plants?
- 13:41I think it was GM. They won't have a single idle plant- Yeah... due to the chip shortage. Um, I think it was Honda said they are going to have no idled plants, like, because of any chip supply shortage.
- 13:53So it's like things are really opening up. When we talked to some people, um, also like, you know, asked Brian Cramer, um, Toyota of Naples, like, "Hey, how's it looking?" He goes, "Everything's looking really good."
- 14:04Yeah. Right? Like, by March we're gonna be... The, the gates are open. We're gonna have inventory again. Yeah. We're gonna have inventory. Rolling. And, and, but interestingly enough,
- 14:16same, similar conversation with Alex Vetter. He said everything's gonna, you know, because of inventory coming back, everything's gonna roll for 30 to 60 days.
- 14:26But then, but then there's gonna be this, like, pulling of the rug out because supply will be back in a greater, in, in greater excess than demand, and those caught without having made the changes and the shifts necessary will be caught.
- 14:41It's like, it's like going to dinner with me when there's pizza and wings involved, right? [laughs] I keep ordering it. That's, that's almost a good segue moment, because essentially- It's a great segue...
- 14:50if, if you do, you'll notice one thing, that as people eat, I keep ordering pizza, and pizza and wings come out, and ev- eventually the demand is satisfied and we have a lot of extra pizza we have to figure out what to do with, 'cause we can't bring it home 'cause we're at an event in a hotel.
- 15:04[laughs] Things that actually happened this week. Yes. [laughs] And so that is going to be a predictor [laughs] of what is to come if we don't pay attention and watch ourselves.
- 15:13Thanks for spending some time with us here today. We're gonna be back tomorrow morning. So, uh, subscribe, share this email with your friends, and if you feel so inclined, leave your boys a review.
- 15:22Everywhere I go, the people really wanna know, who I is and who I be. They stop and stare when they see me. If I said it once, no need to repeat. Run up on me, watch you fall to your knees.
- 15:31Tip my hat when it's time for the kill. Ain't no beast when you're really real