Latest / Decrypted: The UK Cyber Briefing / GCHQ cannot say how many removable drives it has lost
Transcript
- 0:03Good morning, and welcome to Decrypted.
- 0:05I'm Belinder. It's Sunday, the first of November, twenty twenty-six, and this is the morning edition.
- 0:12G C H Q cannot say how many removable drives it has lost.
- 0:17G C H Q cannot say how many of its U S B sticks, hard drives and discs it has lost.
- 0:25That's the finding in the Investigatory Powers Commissioner's annual report, laid before Parliament this week
- 0:30. It's less about spies than about stocktaking.
- 0:34And if your organisation has a drawer of old media, you should read it as a mirror.
- 0:38So, what did the commissioner actually find?
- 0:42The Investigatory Powers Commissioner's Office oversees how UK agencies use surveillance powers.
- 0:48It says G C H Q has now scoped the problem.
- 0:52The maximum number of removable devices it can't immediately locate is, in the report's words, "a very signif
- 0:59icant number". G C H Q currently estimates that to be "in the thousands".
- 1:04The report lists U S B sticks, external hard drives, compact discs and memory cards.
- 1:10It says some may hold data obtained under the Investigatory Powers Act.
- 1:15The office also reported on this in 2024.
- 1:18It says it is "very concerned" and "disappointed with the time it has taken G C H Q to investigate".
- 1:25Nothing in the report alleges that any device reached an adversary.
- 1:28The Record reported that a G C H Q spokesperson declined to say whether the agency knows of any unauthorised
- 1:35access. G C H Q says its management system for removable media "was previously not sufficiently robust to effe
- 1:42ctively track the items that were registered for use".
- 1:45Why is that so hard to size up?
- 1:49Picture a library whose catalogue lists every book, but whose borrowers never sign anything out.
- 1:54You can count the shelves.
- 1:56You can't tell a lost book from a misfiled one.
- 1:59The thousands are items G C H Q can't immediately account for.
- 2:03They're not confirmed losses.
- 2:05The report says how many are truly lost will only be confirmed when the tracing work finishes.
- 2:11You can't judge a breach you can't size.
- 2:15It's also invisible to defenders.
- 2:17A lost stick writes no log, trips no alert and fills no dashboard.
- 2:22The only control is a record kept when the device is issued, which is exactly where G C H Q admits its system
- 2:28was weak. So what's the Secure by Design lesson here?
- 2:33Removable media is a data path, and a data path needs an owner from the day it's created.
- 2:39Four decisions would have changed this story.
- 2:41Encrypt by default, so a lost stick is an inconvenience rather than an incident.
- 2:47Issue media through a register that records who has it and when it comes back, with expiry dates.
- 2:52Offer a managed transfer route, so staff aren't reaching for a stick to get work done.
- 2:58And use a tool that reports where media sits.
- 3:01G C H Q has commissioned one for use in 2026.
- 3:05The cost is cultural. The report says removable media is "an essential component" of some G C H Q processes.
- 3:13People will keep using what the system makes easiest.
- 3:16So, what should you do this week?
- 3:19Ask your I T lead three questions.
- 3:22How many removable devices have we issued?
- 3:24How many are encrypted? And how would we know if one went missing?
- 3:28If the answers are guesses, you have the same gap.
- 3:31As always, this is opinion, not advice.
- 3:36That was Decrypted, with me, Belinder.
- 3:40The written version and every source are linked in the show notes.
- 3:44Thanks for listening. Stay patched, and stay sceptical.