Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Disaster Divorce: Navigating Property Division After Catastrophe with Hon. Dianna Gould-Saltman, Craig Lipsey
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everybody, and welcome to today's CLE
- 0:06presentation. We are happy to have you joining
- 0:10us. Today's presentation is called Mediating
- 0:14a Divorce After a Natural Disaster. I'm April
- 0:18Zanis, co -chair of the Beverly Hills Bar Association's
- 0:21Family Law Section, and I'm delighted to introduce
- 0:24today's speakers, the Honorable Diana Gold -Saltman
- 0:27and Craig Lipsy, who is just as honorable. We
- 0:31would like to thank our section sponsor, White,
- 0:33Zuckerman, Warsawski, Luna and Hunt, for their
- 0:36continued support in helping us bring essential
- 0:39programming to all of our members. In the next
- 0:42few months, we hope you will join us for CLEs
- 0:44on business valuations, prenuptial agreements,
- 0:48parenting plan coordinators, as well as for State
- 0:51of Department II, which is scheduled for November
- 0:545th, 2025. The Honorable Diana Gold -Saltman
- 0:58is a highly respected family law attorney, former
- 1:01Los Angeles Superior Court Judge, and current
- 1:05mediator, arbitrator, and judge pro tem with
- 1:08signature resolution. With four decades of experience,
- 1:12including 14 years on the bench handling complex
- 1:15family law matters, she brings a deep expertise
- 1:18and insight to her work. A recognized leader
- 1:21in the field, Judge Gould -Saltman is a judicial
- 1:24fellow of both the American and International
- 1:26Academies of Family Law, and the recipient of
- 1:30numerous prestigious awards for her service and
- 1:32contributions to family law. Craig Lipsy is president
- 1:36and chief appraiser of Lipsy Appraisal Service,
- 1:40where he has specialized in residential real
- 1:42estate appraisal for over 40 years. He frequently
- 1:45serves as an expert witness in dissolution and
- 1:48litigation matters and has authored appraisal
- 1:51reports accepted by the IRS. Mr. Lipsy is a certified
- 1:55residential real estate appraiser in California
- 1:57and a trusted valuation professional for banks,
- 2:00attorneys, and fiduciaries alike. If you have
- 2:04any questions during today's program, go ahead
- 2:06and place them in the Q &A section down below,
- 2:09and our panelists will do their best to answer
- 2:12them along the way or at the end of the program.
- 2:15And with that, let's get started. Judge Goldsaltman.
- 2:18Thank you so much, April. If I can have the next
- 2:22slide, please. So welcome. How do we get here
- 2:29talking about this? Well, here's a clue right
- 2:32here. I wrote an article a few months ago that
- 2:35appeared in the Daily Journal regarding the divorce
- 2:37process when the LA fires broke out in the Palisades
- 2:41and Eaton Canyon, as well as other places around
- 2:44Southern California. We all knew people who were
- 2:48impacted, who lost their homes or were unable
- 2:52to return to homes that were partially damaged.
- 2:56At the time, I had several pending cases that
- 2:59I was mediating that were impacted by the fires.
- 3:04That brought me to the point where I wondered
- 3:08how we approach the issue of valuing property
- 3:13that is still there to value or even that which
- 3:16is not still there to value. Next slide please.
- 3:22And I think we have to start by taking a look
- 3:25at what we do in the usual course of business
- 3:28before or when there's not a catastrophe and
- 3:32Evidence Code Section 813 informs us that the
- 3:37value of property, not exclusive to real property,
- 3:40but this is what we're talking about today, can
- 3:44be shown only by the opinion of somebody who
- 3:47is qualified to express an opinion, such as Mr.
- 3:50Lipsy, or the owner or spouse of the owner, if
- 3:54the spouse is not also an owner, of the property
- 3:57or property interest being valued. Next slide,
- 4:00please. If it is an expert, we go to section
- 4:08800 of the evidence code. Next slide please.
- 4:14If the witness is testifying as an expert, then
- 4:17his or her testimony in the form of an opinion
- 4:21is limited to opinions that are, next slide.
- 4:29sufficiently beyond common experience that the
- 4:32opinion of an expert would assist the trier of
- 4:35facts. So the question is whether it would be
- 4:38of assistance, not whether it is essential, but
- 4:41the criteria is that it has to be beyond common
- 4:44experience. And next slide, please. And it has
- 4:49to be of a type that is reasonably relied on
- 4:53by experts in this field in forming an opinion,
- 4:57even if the underlying facts are not something
- 5:00that would be admissible. Next slide, please.
- 5:06So, Craig, how do we usually value property?
- 5:13How we normally value property, residential property,
- 5:17is through a market approach, which involves
- 5:21comparing a subject property to comparable sales
- 5:25in the neighborhood based on, as you know, of
- 5:31course, location, location, location is the number
- 5:35one criteria. But particularly with a lot of
- 5:39the properties that I appraised, they're unique
- 5:42properties. And again, this is where experience,
- 5:46I think, comes into play and knowing the areas
- 5:50that you're appraising, but when you're appraising
- 5:53a unique property, you've got to maybe go outside
- 5:58your normal boundaries for other characteristics
- 6:00that are similar things that are value drivers
- 6:07of properties. Of course, location. You've got
- 6:10the site. You've got a view, amenities under
- 6:15normal circumstances. These are not equivalent,
- 6:20but we're looking for properties with characteristics
- 6:23that are most similar. My main goal is to bracket
- 6:30a particular subject property based on, again,
- 6:34on the market data, on actual sales. I'm looking
- 6:38at what's on the market, what may be in contract.
- 6:42You want to stay as current as possible, but
- 6:45that's not always possible. I'm doing an appraisal
- 6:47right now. It's a unique property on a golf course.
- 6:52And the last sales that are on the golf course
- 6:55are a year and a half, two years old, which is
- 6:59not ideal, but they're characteristically the
- 7:02most similar. So I think they're very relevant.
- 7:09What we're going to be discussing today becomes
- 7:12a little bit more involved because and now we're
- 7:14going outside the norms of how we would normally
- 7:16value property because there's a lot of other
- 7:20considerations that we now got to look at. All
- 7:23right, can we have the next slide please? So
- 7:26when we're talking about a disaster, what are
- 7:29some of the unique aspects of valuation? I mean
- 7:33it may be similar to when you are valuing property
- 7:38that is a unique property apart from a disaster,
- 7:42wouldn't it be? Yes. Now, I mean, we're talking
- 7:47about the disasters that are affecting Los Angeles
- 7:51area have been the fires. The most recent fires
- 7:58were the most extensive in my lifetime, certainly.
- 8:02But there's been a lot of fires in Southern California.
- 8:06And so. from the one standpoint is there's always
- 8:10an immediate effect. This one is greater on a
- 8:14much larger scale than any of the previous fires,
- 8:17and we'll go back to the Bel Air fire in the
- 8:1960s and Mandeville Canyon burning down, and several
- 8:24fires in Malibu, and they've never been on this
- 8:29scale. So, in vowing properties, you were less
- 8:35affected. I mean, you were affected by the disaster,
- 8:38but there were still a majority of properties
- 8:40that were standing. Now you go to the palisades
- 8:43and in some neighborhoods you've got virtually
- 8:45no properties that are standing. And so it's
- 8:48a whole, it's a whole different analysis that's
- 8:53complicated. And I've been doing a lot of appraisals
- 8:58for people in particular in the palisades. I
- 9:01can't really speak so much about Altadena in
- 9:04that area because I really haven't done any appraisals,
- 9:06but I've done a bunch in the Palisades. A majority
- 9:11of them are casualty losses. People want to know
- 9:14what their property is worth before the fire
- 9:17and after the fire. To date, all the properties
- 9:21that I've appraised are vacant lots, so it's
- 9:24a little bit easier. Now we're talking about
- 9:26a house that survived, and now you've got a couple
- 9:32things. You've got to Uh, what neighborhood is
- 9:36that in? So Palisades in particular and Malibu,
- 9:40they have very defined neighborhoods in the Palisades.
- 9:43There's 15 different neighborhoods. So it's not
- 9:46necessarily like for like, but for example, I
- 9:50am appraising three homes in the Riviera section
- 9:53of Palisades. The Riviera suffered very little
- 9:57damage, not none, but 20 homes or less out of
- 10:01that entire neighborhood versus the alphabet
- 10:05streets where there's 5 % standing or something.
- 10:12What I've been trying to do and doing appraisals,
- 10:15I've only appraised one house that survived.
- 10:20It was in the Riviera, so I thought the effect
- 10:22was based on the market data as well, because
- 10:26there were some sales in the Riviera. of improved
- 10:30properties that survived. There have been no
- 10:34sales of homes that survived in the alphabet
- 10:37streets that I'm aware of. There was just one
- 10:42sale recently in an area near Palisades High
- 10:45School that sold. And one of the things I'm looking
- 10:49at is to see the properties that have actually
- 10:53sold, were they listed pre -fire? And if so,
- 10:56and were they taken off? because of the fire
- 10:59and then relisted and at what price point? Because
- 11:03intuitively you would think there is a significant
- 11:06loss in value. Initially, in the first month
- 11:12or two of land sales, the decline was anywhere
- 11:18from about 15 % to 30%. And when you say initially,
- 11:22would you? Like when the first set of sales,
- 11:26now we're There were no properties that sold
- 11:29until March in the Palisades. There were no sales
- 11:33in January or February at all. So in March, when
- 11:37some lands, the first land sales came through,
- 11:42based on the pre -fire land set value of those
- 11:48properties, looked like the decline, the diminution
- 11:52of value, if you will, was about 15 % to 30%.
- 11:56Part of that would be depending on location and
- 12:01what's around you. But there were properties
- 12:03that sold. As we were moving forward, now we're
- 12:07about four or five months worth of data. There's
- 12:12a lot more inventory. There's a lot more choices.
- 12:18how people are looking at things also is different
- 12:21because some people wanted to fast track. I mean,
- 12:24there's properties already being rebuilt, which
- 12:26I'm honestly shocked at that there's construction
- 12:30while there's a lot of lots that have not been
- 12:33cleared to date. So they did fast track that.
- 12:37So there's different people. Each owner is different.
- 12:41and what they want to do. I can just say from
- 12:43the standpoint of properties that have sold,
- 12:46survived in a fire damage, it looks like the
- 12:50discount is every bit as much as the vacant lots.
- 12:53So one of the things that you said initially
- 12:56is that when you're valuing properties apart
- 13:00from a disaster situation, location is a key
- 13:05aspect of the value. And one of the things when
- 13:09I think of the word location is what is its proximity
- 13:14to things people need, schools, shopping, does
- 13:19it have a view, that sort of thing. How does
- 13:22the effect on the neighborhood overall affect
- 13:29the value of the property? So for example, If
- 13:33the school's not there and isn't going to be
- 13:36there for some period of time, is the location
- 13:40still a big factor if you have children of school
- 13:44age? Well, again, going back to like using the
- 13:51Palisades Riviera specifically versus the next
- 13:55most upscale neighborhood of the Palisades is
- 13:57the Huntington Palisades. the Riviera suffered
- 14:00much less damage than the Huntington. Both of
- 14:04those neighborhoods, I mean, everybody who lives
- 14:05in the Palisades, it's a small community, but
- 14:08people who live in the Riviera don't utilize
- 14:11the civic center, the Palisades village, like
- 14:14the people live in the Alphabet streets or around
- 14:16the high school or the Huntington, because those
- 14:18are all within walking distance. So the Riviera
- 14:20already benefits, besides the fact that it's
- 14:23got the best properties, but it benefits because
- 14:29It's right next to Brentwood and Santa Monica.
- 14:31You can get out of there easily. And you can
- 14:36go into Brentwood and dine in the Palisades.
- 14:39Further in, you're more dependent on that community.
- 14:43And so those neighborhoods, I think, again, are
- 14:46more adversely affected than the Riviera or even
- 14:50the Rustic Canyon area south of Sunset, which
- 14:54you can still get in and out of. I mean now you
- 14:59can go anywhere, but while there was the lockdown
- 15:01on the street, getting into the community, you
- 15:06could still get out of there. And so again, the
- 15:10neighborhoods that are around in Palisades is
- 15:13a small community, so the people that are living
- 15:16close to the village I think are much more adversely
- 15:20affected. You also got a there's a whole nother
- 15:26thing is just really the the character of the
- 15:28neighborhoods and like the scale of the home
- 15:31so that Rivera's got much larger scale properties
- 15:34than not then The alphabet streets or some of
- 15:39the so you got a little bit also different buyer
- 15:42pool in a sense Well, I guess that's the question.
- 15:45We we had a particular neighborhood before the
- 15:50fires there were larger homes in one neighborhood,
- 15:53there were smaller homes in another neighborhood.
- 15:56In many cases there are no homes at all in those
- 16:01neighborhoods or a lot of them are gone. Does
- 16:05the old vision of what used to be a neighborhood
- 16:08matter now that we're valuing vacant land? That's
- 16:15an interesting question. I mean I think it does
- 16:18in a sense because You're buying vacant land,
- 16:21but you're also kind of projecting down the line
- 16:23what what you what you think the neighborhood
- 16:26when it comes back, what it will be. And I think
- 16:33the like the neighborhoods that are were further
- 16:37away, like in the highlands. That was its own
- 16:42community of it in and of itself and. I think,
- 16:50you know, people are very are very tied to their
- 16:53neighborhoods. I do think I think most people
- 16:57have a positive envision of what's going to be
- 17:01in the future. Obviously, there's some disillusionment,
- 17:04but the fact that you just. I think people want,
- 17:11you're never gonna get like normal. I don't know
- 17:14what that means. It's a new normal. So it's a
- 17:16new neighborhood. I think people will be kind
- 17:18of excited to see what the Palisades looks like
- 17:23in a few years. We have the next slide, please.
- 17:29So when we're looking at properties, let's say
- 17:32properties more in the Malibu area in this case,
- 17:36and the property, has survived. How, if in any
- 17:43way, have the disasters affected those properties?
- 17:49We've had a few isolated. I'm going to kind of
- 17:52focus in this case because the Malibu part that
- 17:56got burned, you lost a lot of beachfront homes,
- 18:02starting from Topanga to Carbon Beach, and then
- 18:09it stopped. But you also lost a lot of properties
- 18:12up in the hills, the Big Rock area, Carbon Mesa,
- 18:17a lot of those neighborhoods are gone. But interestingly
- 18:21enough, and there have been some land sales on
- 18:23La Costa Beach, and there was one to date on
- 18:26Carbon Beach, and they've all sold for four and
- 18:32a half to nine million dollars. and pre -fire,
- 18:35you couldn't buy on that beach for, a teardown
- 18:39would have been six or $7 million. So you can
- 18:42see, but there's a little bit of difference because
- 18:47beachfront Malibu homes, there's a real scarcity
- 18:51to start with. So buying, I can see why people
- 18:57want to be there. I think there's parts, the
- 19:02old section where the homes were, like kind of
- 19:05bootlegged and built on weird foundations in
- 19:08the Big Rock, Dog Beach, Topanga area. I don't
- 19:13know if this is true. I've heard maybe they'll
- 19:16be taken over by M &O Domain, but a lot of those
- 19:19homes will never be rebuilt. But La Casa Beach
- 19:22is going to get rebuilt. Carbon Beach is getting
- 19:25rebuilt. The homes that were lost. But there
- 19:28has been actually there has been one sale on
- 19:31Carbon Beach. that survived. And I haven't really
- 19:36tracked it too greatly, but I know it sold a
- 19:39lot less than it would have if the neighborhood
- 19:43was intact. And you think that's because of the
- 19:48damage that was done by this fire? Yes. Yes.
- 19:52Now, the other thing with Malibu is that you
- 19:55couldn't get to Malibu. Half of Malibu, or not
- 19:59half, but from Santa Monica, you had no access,
- 20:05so there was no market. Nobody could show a property.
- 20:08No one was going to be looking at a property.
- 20:10Same in the Palisades. But I thought in reality,
- 20:17there might be some bump up in Malibu, because
- 20:20Malibu, again, is a very tight -knit community,
- 20:23so people who lived in Malibu want to stay in
- 20:26Malibu, and particularly the full -timers, the
- 20:30people who It's their second, third, fourth home.
- 20:33Not so much, but a lot of people live in Malibu
- 20:36full time and they're not the celebrities and
- 20:39the ultra wealthy. And there's I think there's
- 20:48demand, but it didn't. I thought homes that were
- 20:51moving condition would be kind of bought up.
- 20:54And I think the lack of accessibility. hampered
- 21:00Malibu for longer than even the Palisades in
- 21:03a way. So from a judicial perspective, we're
- 21:08asked to do three things with real property.
- 21:11We're asked certainly to determine what the value
- 21:14of the property is, and we use experts or we
- 21:18use other things to give us the evidence that
- 21:22will allow us to do that. But we're also looking
- 21:25at characterization, whether it's community,
- 21:28separate. some of both, as well as allocation.
- 21:32And I think it's worth addressing that for a
- 21:34second. So when I'm deciding who's ultimately
- 21:39going to get a property, because we're talking
- 21:41about this in the context of a dissolution, some
- 21:45of the things that will affect my determination.
- 21:48if both parties want the property. If neither
- 21:51of them do and it's just going to be sold, that's
- 21:53a much easier decision. But if both of them do
- 21:56and I have to weigh the factors that are to be
- 21:59considered, I'm looking at, are there special
- 22:03aspects of the location? of the property that
- 22:09make it more likely that it is more useful or
- 22:12more valuable or should be allocated to one party
- 22:15or another. And if there's been a disaster, I'm
- 22:18looking at whether those factors changed. So,
- 22:21for example, if I have a stay at home parent
- 22:24with small children who are attending a nearby
- 22:27school and the school is no longer there and
- 22:31isn't anticipated to be rebuilt for a significant
- 22:34period of time, does allocating the house to
- 22:37the stay -at -home parent continue to make sense?
- 22:41On the other hand, I'm also looking at things
- 22:43like proximity to work of the parties if it's
- 22:48close for one and not close for the other. In
- 22:52one case I had, the parties were looking to...
- 22:56have a buyout of the property, but after the
- 23:00fires and their property stood and was not damaged,
- 23:05they were considering whether or not the property
- 23:09could be leased out and become an income producing
- 23:11property, which then affects the need for spousal
- 23:15support in many cases. I'm also looking at, in
- 23:20this case, on a maybe short -term, maybe long
- 23:24-term basis, the psychological impact on the
- 23:26parties or the children of any potential allocation
- 23:31or sale, assuming the property is sellable. And
- 23:36one other aspect of that is, is it insurable?
- 23:40Has insurance played a factor or the ability
- 23:42to reinsure played a factor in the valuing of
- 23:47the properties, Craig? Well, no doubt has impacted
- 23:52the market and how people are going to project
- 23:57going forward. Can they even get insurance? I
- 24:05mean, it's doubly difficult now. I will say insurance
- 24:09has been somewhat of an impediment over the last
- 24:14several years in the LA area, particularly properties
- 24:17north of Sunset, whether they're in the Palisades
- 24:20or Beverly Hills or Bel Air or Hollywood Hills.
- 24:28Insurance became, I mean, it's become prohibitive
- 24:32in some cases. I know that it's affected deals.
- 24:43quantifying it is a little bit difficult. One
- 24:48way you could do it would be if a property went
- 24:53into escrow at a certain price, the deal fell
- 24:57through. The reason was because the buyer couldn't
- 25:01get insurance or it was too expensive and backed
- 25:04out. Property comes back on the market and it
- 25:08sells. And if it sells at a discount, You're
- 25:13going to want to maybe ask the broker, how did
- 25:15that impact it? But there's a likelihood that
- 25:18insurance, first you got property insurance,
- 25:21now you got the fire factor, which is a psychological
- 25:25thing too. Again, it's hard to quantify. I think
- 25:31things like this just make me not be as bullish
- 25:34on a value depending on a particular area. going
- 25:42back to the Palisades, some of the neighborhoods
- 25:43that have really lost quite a few homes. Yeah,
- 25:50I think a lot of those were south of Sunset and
- 25:54they probably weren't impacted by what was north
- 25:58in terms of the insurance. Yeah, I'm on a Zoom.
- 26:02I'm on a Zoom. Oh, you can lock. Sorry. Yeah.
- 26:04Thank you. Excuse me. Sorry. but now those properties
- 26:09are gonna have to have fire insurance, and I'm
- 26:11sure it's gonna be very prohibited, and that's
- 26:13gonna be part of who's gonna come back. I mean,
- 26:17I think it's something that is gonna be part
- 26:21of your whole puzzle. And it is a puzzle. I mean,
- 26:25honestly, when I look at what factors not to
- 26:31consider, of course, putting on my judgy hat,
- 26:35I'm going to consider any relevant factor that
- 26:41is not speculative, but it sounds like there's
- 26:44a lot of aspects of what we're talking about
- 26:47here that are considerably speculative. I think
- 26:51they are. An appraiser likes to rely on data.
- 26:57We like to have something that we can grab a
- 27:00hold of and analyze it. And whether we're right
- 27:03or wrong, at least we have something we can hold
- 27:06our hat to. Appraising a property in the Palisades
- 27:11right now is extremely difficult because, as
- 27:13I mentioned at the beginning, you want to use
- 27:16current data. I just appraised the property out
- 27:19there. I had no choice. I did have two sales
- 27:23from post -fire. So I could kind of look at those
- 27:28on their surface and see Then this is projecting
- 27:34backward, but was their sales price at this point
- 27:38in time affected? Did it appear it was less the
- 27:42same as it would have been under the assumption
- 27:47it had sold on January 1st, let's say. Now we're
- 27:59projecting because there's Again, you can't price
- 28:03trend anything because there's no sales. So this
- 28:09is why I'm looking at land and how a lot has
- 28:12been affected and then trying to translate it
- 28:14back to a house because there's not enough data
- 28:17to trend the improved properties that survived.
- 28:22Do we ever look at disasters elsewhere to analogize
- 28:27that? So for example, the Paradise Fire up in
- 28:31Northern California and what happened there,
- 28:34do we ever look at that and see how over time
- 28:37it affected the sales there to see if we can
- 28:42reasonably project what is likely to happen here?
- 28:45I mean, I have done some internet searches and
- 28:51tried to glean some information. The thing is,
- 28:59is that particularly if you look at Paradise,
- 29:02it's a very remote location. It's a whole different
- 29:05market. It's a whole different price point. And
- 29:10you can probably be rest assured that most people
- 29:13were under -insured there, will be my guess.
- 29:18And I don't know that market from the standpoint
- 29:22that I could say, okay, these properties are
- 29:25selling for 600 ,000. Now they're selling for
- 29:27400 ,000 or what have you. I know some things
- 29:30anecdotally. You could, I mean, that's part of
- 29:36the research. You got to crunch the numbers really.
- 29:40And it's a lot of research and relying on other
- 29:43parties. Locally here, I can do that more on
- 29:47my own and kind of trend. to the extent that
- 29:50I've got data. But I want to give you an idea
- 29:59of how the land values have been affected. Let's
- 30:04concentrate for a moment on the alphabet streets.
- 30:08I don't know if every... doubt everybody knows
- 30:10where the alphabet streets but it's in the center
- 30:13of the palisades it's a very large well -defined
- 30:16neighborhood it was really originally like a
- 30:18starter neighborhood for the palisades it's right
- 30:21next to the shopping area and the caruso center
- 30:24that was redeveloped so became a very desirable
- 30:28area pre -fire and there were there's three different
- 30:34types of lots in there it's very consistent there's
- 30:39certain width, although most of the lots are
- 30:42the same depth. And the least expensive pre -fire,
- 30:48you couldn't buy anything for under $2 million,
- 30:51$2 .5 million for the smallest lot as a teardown.
- 30:56And now post -fire, there have been a handful
- 31:01of sales of the small lots at like $1 .7, $1
- 31:04.8, up to $2 million. So that's, you know, 20
- 31:10to 30 percent. Bump, you know, diminution. But
- 31:17there have been any houses that have sold in
- 31:19that neighborhood to say, what's the effect on
- 31:21the house? Because. You know, you got, of course,
- 31:26besides the insurance and the coverage and what's
- 31:29it going to cost to repair, some people won't
- 31:31even want to go back into even if it's standing
- 31:34house, they're going to think from a. you know
- 31:37health at health standpoint they're not even
- 31:39going to go back in there quality of life would
- 31:42you move into a house where everybody's building
- 31:44around you or going to be building over the next
- 31:47however many years but people are going back
- 31:51for sure but is there is there any cumulative
- 31:57effect so you're you're focused on on the west
- 31:59side for for houses on the west side that have
- 32:05gone through multiple disasters. Went through
- 32:07the 94 earthquake and withstood it. Went through
- 32:09the Woolsey fire and withstood it. And have now
- 32:12gone through this fire and withstood it. Does
- 32:16that make them more valuable or less valuable?
- 32:19Because the probability is you can only roll
- 32:23the dice so many times. I think at the end of
- 32:28the day, the desirability of the location, what
- 32:32Southern California is, their weather, particularly
- 32:35in the case of the Palisades, the proximity to
- 32:38the beach and the beautiful weather. And in Altadena,
- 32:42you've got a beautiful area also in the mountains.
- 32:45It's a little bit hotter, but you know, people...
- 32:50It's Southern California. I mean, it was mostly
- 32:52we got a housing crisis. We need houses. We need
- 32:54houses. So all of this is getting rebuilt. And
- 32:59so I think that's a positive aspect to it because
- 33:04of the need for housing. I wouldn't say it's
- 33:07going to be affordable. I'm curious to see where
- 33:09the price points come down the line and what
- 33:12these areas look like. Super hard to project
- 33:15now. Again, just to kind of go back in doing
- 33:22appraisal specifically and using data from 2024
- 33:25pre -fire and then projecting what would be those
- 33:28sales prices of those properties today. Or the
- 33:33first thing I want to do is appraise a property
- 33:36assuming just looking at the data. And then you
- 33:38got to now consider your location, the community
- 33:44services. I mean, there's some things that you
- 33:48have to consider that I don't have to consider.
- 33:51But again, like you were saying with families,
- 33:54people from the Palisades are everywhere now.
- 33:58They're in Orange County. And some of those people
- 34:02probably won't relocate because they'll get immersed
- 34:06into their new community. But at the end of the
- 34:13day, I do foresee an eventual good, good result.
- 34:18I mean, it's coming from a disaster, but you
- 34:21can only move forward. So. So can we have the
- 34:24next slide, please? So we've got properties that
- 34:30have been damaged, but not destroyed. They can't
- 34:34be lived in now, but they aren't a complete tear
- 34:38down. What do we do with those? What are the
- 34:42factors that you're considering when you're valuing
- 34:45those? You know, of course, got to consider what's
- 34:51the extent of the damage. And is it financially
- 34:57feasible or, you know, is the damage to the point
- 35:04where it doesn't make sense? I mean, this is
- 35:09one home we're looking at the slide, looking
- 35:12at a large scale of every house had a tree falling
- 35:14in it and damaging it. But I think that's one
- 35:21of the things is, and again, for me, valuing
- 35:25a property, what somebody is getting in terms
- 35:27of the insurance, it doesn't really affect the
- 35:29property value that's to them themselves. But
- 35:32the property is on the open market is not going
- 35:35to be influenced by how much insurance you got.
- 35:40Maybe it's gonna affect what you might sell it
- 35:42for and price it for. So in essence, yes, it
- 35:46does come into play, but I largely would really
- 35:52look at, again, you're looking at a house that
- 35:58survived in the... alphabet streets is going
- 36:03to be surrounded by 95 % of the neighborhood
- 36:06is going to be a construction site over the next
- 36:09several years. What's the quality of life that
- 36:12you're going to have? Do you really want to stay
- 36:15in that house? How much does that mean to you?
- 36:20And I think a lot of it is, of course, your house,
- 36:24the house itself, but it's going to be the neighborhood.
- 36:27How much would Do you want to come back to that
- 36:30neighborhood? That's not going to be the same
- 36:34that it was, but you're tied to it. That that
- 36:38seems to be what I'm hearing with regard to people
- 36:41returning to Altadena area, that it was a much.
- 36:45a very close -knit community. There had been
- 36:49longevity there. People had passed down their
- 36:52houses from generations. Many of them didn't
- 36:55have mortgages. They'd long ago been paid off,
- 36:58and multiple generations had received the houses.
- 37:01And while they may have had insurance, they didn't
- 37:05have insurance that one might have if one had
- 37:09a mortgage and one's bank required a certain
- 37:11amount of insurance for that property. And so
- 37:16the time necessary to repair it in addition to
- 37:20the funds necessary to repair the properties
- 37:23seems to me to be a significant factor when there
- 37:28is property that's been damaged. Is there any
- 37:33effect that you've heard with regard to people
- 37:36being reticent to return to the neighborhood
- 37:40based on the environmental safety of where they
- 37:46would be returning? Yes, I have. Smaller percentage,
- 37:55I can't tell you how many people, but I've definitely
- 37:58heard people who I had a client whose mother's
- 38:03house survived. And the woman's 90 years old,
- 38:08I believe. And the daughter doesn't want her
- 38:11to go back. And her number one reason was the
- 38:15environmental aspect of it. She didn't think
- 38:18it was safe for her mother. And in general, she
- 38:25didn't. And let's face it, I mean, It's really
- 38:31kind of unknown. I don't know what kind of studies
- 38:34they've done. They cleared that land pretty quick.
- 38:38We're making a lot of assumptions, but in the
- 38:42Palisades, they're not rebuilding the whole infrastructure.
- 38:46They're not putting everything underground. There's
- 38:50still going to be above ground utility poles.
- 38:54Why? Why is that? Is that state of the art? I
- 38:59don't know the answer to that. I mean, I'm surprised,
- 39:02but I'm telling you, there's power poles and
- 39:05they're not going to tear them all down because
- 39:06if they were going to, they would have done it
- 39:09already before somebody already started rebuilding.
- 39:13So I don't know. I'm very surprised. And that's
- 39:16why this rebuild process began a lot quicker
- 39:21than I thought it would take a year. And I really
- 39:23thought they were going to like rebuild. the
- 39:25infrastructure of the Palisades and I mean maybe
- 39:28isolated areas but if you drive through there
- 39:31they're not taking down those poles and they're
- 39:34being used and they're doing a lot of work to
- 39:37the pipes on Sunset Boulevard. I'm sure they're
- 39:40doing some other electrical considerations but
- 39:43I think those things are going to still be there
- 39:46and so you know I think that you know can have
- 39:50an adverse effect on some people coming back
- 39:53also because We saw it happen. Can I have the
- 39:58next slide, please? So let's talk about the vacant
- 40:04land that you're now being asked to look at.
- 40:08How do you assess when the entire neighborhood
- 40:12is gone? Right after Hurricane Katrina, I did
- 40:17a tour of the Ninth Ward of New Orleans to see
- 40:21what was left. And what struck me was Really
- 40:25interesting, it looked like this. There was nothing
- 40:29for miles except where the water had taken the
- 40:34remains of houses in the Ninth Ward, but very
- 40:37nearby was a set of tract homes. And the tract
- 40:41homes were, you know, stucco and wood and looked
- 40:44much more like, you know, Orange County or the
- 40:47San Fernando Valley circa 1968, but they were
- 40:51vacant. There was nobody for miles and miles
- 40:54in these tract homes, which were still standing.
- 40:56And you could see a water level that was above
- 40:59the first floor. They were just no longer habitable,
- 41:02except for the occasional FEMA trailer in a front
- 41:06yard. How do you even begin to assess something
- 41:11like that? You know, it's interesting because
- 41:15going back to that my client and now I'm thinking
- 41:18her mom lived out in this area Sunset Mesa, which
- 41:21is technically Malibu. It's really right next
- 41:26to the Palisades. And I said because she does
- 41:31her mom hasn't gone back. And I said, are people
- 41:35living there? And she said, yes. And I like I
- 41:39remember when I first got in the Palisades and
- 41:42like Nobody was living there. I don't know a
- 41:47lot, but definitely people are living in the
- 41:51midst of all this disaster. If they didn't suffer
- 41:56damage aside from smoke, people have reoccupied
- 41:59their homes because the alternative is so difficult.
- 42:08In a sense, I'm a little surprised because Again,
- 42:12you think if 80, 90 % of the surrounding terrain
- 42:17is a vacant lot and you're still intact, but
- 42:24there are hardy folks who will just hunker down
- 42:29and they'll live with it. But I think, particularly
- 42:36older people, and Cal State's had a lot of older...
- 42:40residents. So I think a lot of those people will
- 42:44definitely think twice about it from an environmental
- 42:48aspect. And if you're old and it's going to take
- 42:54you, depending on how quickly you can rebuild
- 42:57and how quickly you can get permitted and they're
- 43:03trying to expedite permitting and make it easier.
- 43:08But I mean, it's been six months, but it's still
- 43:13such a shocking event to happen, I think. First
- 43:16of all, it takes a long time for a lot of people
- 43:18just to even figure out, what am I doing? And
- 43:23some people are just getting into temporary housing
- 43:26and leasing for a few months, and now it's six
- 43:29months, and they may have to reconsider where
- 43:32they're gonna up and move. One of the things
- 43:37in this is, a little off track, but one of the
- 43:42aspects of this fire they did was it positively
- 43:45influenced some surrounding neighborhoods because
- 43:48people couldn't live in the palisades but didn't
- 43:51go far. It's really been an interesting study
- 43:55in a particular area of Santa Monica where this
- 43:58is a neighborhood that was positively affected
- 44:00by the fires because people wanted move -in ready.
- 44:07turnkey. Nobody's buying a fixer right now because
- 44:10they're building a new home. They got to rebuild
- 44:13the house. So they're looking for something they
- 44:15can move into and whatever their time frame was,
- 44:18whether it was one to three years, three to five
- 44:20years, what have you. So some real premiums were
- 44:23being paid. Seems to have softened a little bit
- 44:27in that aspect, but you know, not to be... morbid,
- 44:36but, you know, I mean, that did positively influence
- 44:39Santa Monica, in particular, and isolated parts
- 44:44of other communities, whether it was chevied
- 44:46hills or Venice or Mar Vista. And are these for
- 44:52purchases or for rental? A little of both. I
- 44:55mean, I know people that purchase homes. And
- 44:57again, part of it is the I think. because of
- 45:02the community aspect of Palisades and going to
- 45:04the schools. And so they wanted to go somewhere
- 45:07that was local, where they had a good school
- 45:10that was somewhat known to them, just in general.
- 45:17I mean, I had a client who lost success in the
- 45:18Palisades and went and bought a house, a new
- 45:22house in Mar Vista, like a month after it happened.
- 45:26He was one of the first people I was involved
- 45:28with that got in. I thought he was paying a little
- 45:33premium, but after him, there were so many more
- 45:36that came that it looked like he got a fair deal.
- 45:40I have to imagine that there were not a ton of
- 45:45architects and contractors and builders sitting
- 45:48around waiting for the phone to ring prior to
- 45:51this fire. Are there enough people to... Rebuild
- 45:57within the time frame that people are looking
- 45:59at you said you've already seen some people have
- 46:02already started reconstruction I Mean that's
- 46:07gonna that's a big concern and that is a big
- 46:09question. Are there enough? Architects are there
- 46:13enough builders or the what about the materials
- 46:16every of all of a sudden a thousand homes are
- 46:18being built the price of concrete and that's
- 46:21going to affect also someone whose house survived
- 46:23and the cost to fix it up or somebody who just
- 46:26wants to do a remodel and they're competing with
- 46:30a scarcity of materials and or labor. Interesting
- 46:35thing about the Palisades, I know a couple of
- 46:39guys I just read this article, they are land
- 46:42use, they're a land use company and they have
- 46:48reached out to like 40 architects and noted architects
- 46:53from Marmo Radzner, Michael Kovac, who are designing
- 46:59homes in various motifs, from a Cape Cod to a
- 47:06mid -century. But they're harking back. They're
- 47:08calling it case study 2 .0. So they're referencing
- 47:13those 40s and 50s case study homes. in the mid
- 47:17-century aspect, which I think is great. But
- 47:22what it will allow them to do is they will kind
- 47:26of be approved plans so that if you say, I want
- 47:30number 28, you can fast track as opposed to trying
- 47:35to hire an architect and start from scratch.
- 47:39You got to leg up. A lot of people, when they're
- 47:43buying new houses, they want a formula. So I'm
- 47:46presuming that these will be designed with a
- 47:49formula of the central, what appeals to the palisades.
- 47:52But I don't think we'll see a lot of English
- 47:55style houses. But I think we're going to see
- 47:58some modern interpretations. But I think the
- 48:01effort is great because it will hopefully fast
- 48:04track for some people. Who knows what the city,
- 48:07you know, they're trying to do some things. One
- 48:10of the things I feel All of us, it's a new, we're
- 48:14not making it up on the fly, but we're all learning
- 48:16as we go along and things change. From an appraisal
- 48:21standpoint, again, have more data, which makes
- 48:26a little bit, not easier, but at least gives
- 48:30you more of a guidance. Again, we're in a post
- 48:34-fire environment. That's the valuation we're
- 48:38talking about now. for family law. You're not
- 48:43doing a casualty loss and you want to know what
- 48:45it was worth January 6th or January 1st. We're
- 48:51looking at what's it worth on July 24th, taking
- 48:55into consideration everything we know. I have
- 48:58the next slide, please. Craig, you said we're
- 49:03in a post -fire environment. Are we not also
- 49:07in a pre -fire environment? And is that not something
- 49:11that we've got to consider? Yes, we are. I guess
- 49:17we always are. I think people are going to...
- 49:24Yes, we are. And that will kind of tie to the
- 49:28insurance aspect and the fire aspect. And again,
- 49:32people will consider... There's definitely people
- 49:35who are not going back. They're not going in
- 49:38the hills. And I'm sure we all know people who
- 49:42aren't going back. But the areas that will take
- 49:48longer, though, are going to be the further up
- 49:51into the Palisades, the more remote neighborhoods.
- 49:56I think they are going to take a lot longer to
- 49:59recover from a community standpoint. Yeah, I
- 50:07mean, it's like living anywhere. I mean, every
- 50:13part of this country has got something they got
- 50:15to consider. I think we're going to see fires.
- 50:20Hopefully, we're never seeing anything on the
- 50:22scale of what we saw and experienced this year.
- 50:30because it's so fresh in the mind of people and
- 50:33so fresh in our experience, I do think people
- 50:39will have an avoidance. And that will be a future
- 50:43fire will come into play, a future, not thinking
- 50:47of flood, but we got fire. And I'm not even sure,
- 50:51you know, it's not the earthquake, but now fire
- 50:55is a big thing. So. Well, it seems to me that
- 50:59certainly in the Palisades, there were, I knew
- 51:02a number of people who were close to what would
- 51:05have been their retirement. They paid off their
- 51:09mortgage. They were not anticipating having to.
- 51:13work another 20 years to have a new mortgage
- 51:16to have to pay off. And I would imagine in Altadena,
- 51:20the same thing. People who had long ago not had
- 51:23to worry about a mortgage, but could live a life
- 51:26without having that factored in. Can they even
- 51:32get a mortgage? Or do they even want to? You
- 51:39know, it's interesting. I got to look and see
- 51:40what what kind of financing has gone down in
- 51:44the Palisades on these, I mean, there's only
- 51:46been less than 20 houses that have sold, I think
- 51:53throughout the entire Palisades, subsequent to
- 51:56the fire. I would venture to say a majority of
- 52:00them are all cash deals. I don't know. I'd have
- 52:03to look and see what kind of financing they got.
- 52:07Altadena, the price point isn't as great as it
- 52:10was in the palisades, but to your point that
- 52:14people that weren't getting a mortgage and it
- 52:18was a legacy area and they have properties that
- 52:21were handed down to them and if they're not insured
- 52:24and they got to take out a loan to rebuild, they
- 52:28may not do it. Right. Even the ones who are insured.
- 52:31So far I have not encountered anybody who'd said,
- 52:35I was over -insured. I could buy my old house
- 52:37twice over for the money I'm getting from the
- 52:40insurance company. Mostly, either they're going
- 52:42to have to come up with a difference or they're
- 52:45going to have to come up with a whole thing.
- 52:49It's been interesting in finding out, I know
- 52:52some people who got a $3 or $4 million payment.
- 52:59within weeks of the fire. And then there's other
- 53:02people who are, I'm sure, still struggling. Such
- 53:12a complicated thing. And a lot of this, that
- 53:15comes into your personality and how aggressive
- 53:18you are, and you fight for yourself on everything.
- 53:22Nobody's going to give you anything. I'm fortunate
- 53:26that I didn't have to deal with this insurance
- 53:28aspect because people are, you know, if you got
- 53:32it, at least you could decide what your next
- 53:34step is. And I'm sure, you know, people who are
- 53:38still in limbo, and I'm sure that's a lot of
- 53:41people. And what I do think when you're talking
- 53:47about like some of the older residents who are
- 53:49near retirement and they don't, they're going
- 53:52to become renters. and they're going to sell
- 53:54their lot and they're just going to say, you
- 53:56know, I'm not going to dump it. I mean, if you
- 54:00lived in that house for 60 years somewhere in
- 54:03the palaces and you paid 40 grand for it and
- 54:06you're selling it for a million eight. I mean,
- 54:09it's not what it was, but you're more compelled
- 54:17than holding out to get that extra hundred thousand
- 54:19or two hundred thousand. You need your money
- 54:22now to live. So that's driving some of the sales.
- 54:29I mean, I have a client who's selling his lot.
- 54:34Right after the fire also, he went and bought
- 54:36a house in Santa Monica Canyon. He still wanted
- 54:40to stay close, but he knew he wasn't. And his
- 54:43intention initially when he bought his house
- 54:46in 2023 and he lived in the Palisades was to...
- 54:52He was an older guy. I mean he was probably in
- 54:55the 70s and he I'm not far off, but I'm just
- 55:00But he Was planning to like do a major remodel
- 55:09on his house in Palisades until it burned and
- 55:12now he's got his lot for sale and He overpriced
- 55:17it to begin with but within like three weeks
- 55:19he reduced it a million dollars See, and you
- 55:22raise an issue, this I think brings up the issue,
- 55:26but you've mentioned it a few times, and I think
- 55:28I have as well, is I don't think we can overstate
- 55:33the psychological impact of having gone through
- 55:37a fire, whether Eaton Canyon or the Palisades
- 55:41or elsewhere. I think it's quite different if.
- 55:44If your house burns down and your house is the
- 55:47only house that burned down, you have neighbors,
- 55:50you have friends, you have family who are there
- 55:52to support you. But when everybody's house burned
- 55:56down, you just don't have, and they don't have,
- 56:00the emotional capital to share, to help lift
- 56:05you back up because they're struggling in exactly
- 56:09the same way. And you mentioned, and I think
- 56:12it's worth noting again, that people are in the
- 56:17most difficult time to make a major financial
- 56:20decision and a life decision, even if they aren't
- 56:23in the middle of a divorce. But if they're in
- 56:27the middle of a divorce, when this happens, and
- 56:32we're still asking them to make important life
- 56:35decisions or compelling them to do so. I think
- 56:41it probably is worth mentioning that if you're
- 56:47a judge or if you're a mediator or if you're
- 56:50a lawyer that you should you should give people
- 56:53a little bit of grace that this is a disaster
- 56:57and people react differently and unpredictably
- 57:02and you can't tell people when they've grieved
- 57:07long enough for the life that they had. I recognize
- 57:12that. At the same time, I recognize that resolution
- 57:17is what will allow the family to move forward.
- 57:22And as a judge, if I have my judge hat on, I
- 57:27have an ethical obligation to resolve disputes
- 57:31expeditiously. And so I think we're in a situation
- 57:36now with a disaster where we have to balance
- 57:40those two interests. We have to give people enough
- 57:43time and patience and grace to be able to get
- 57:48to where they need to get to to move forward.
- 57:50But we also can't let that linger in such a way
- 57:54that we're ignoring our legal obligation to expeditiously
- 57:59resolve disputes. so that the parties can move
- 58:03on. So I'm suggesting that it's important to
- 58:08be sensitive to not only your own client, but
- 58:14to opposing counsel, opposing party, what they
- 58:18may be going through and taking that into consideration
- 58:21when we're negotiating these resolutions. And
- 58:27from Craig's perspective, determining value It's
- 58:32much more mechanical, it's much more mathematical,
- 58:35although I think it is now more art or as much
- 58:39art as science because we're in the great unknown.
- 58:44But I think now putting on my mediator hat. We
- 58:47have a little bit more of an opportunity when
- 58:49I'm mediating cases to be a little more creative
- 58:53about how we do this and what factors we take
- 58:56into consideration in determining a value or
- 58:59determining a disposition of a property. Can
- 59:04I add something? I wish you would. I was going
- 59:08to say appraisal is more of an art than a science.
- 59:11To begin with, it really is. And particularly
- 59:14in L .A., because there's so many factors. You
- 59:18know, when you do a bank appraisal and you have
- 59:20a form, you got to fill in the boxes and you
- 59:23got to account for every single difference and
- 59:26say a fireplace is worth X and a garage space
- 59:29is worth Y. And you have to do it for a bank.
- 59:33I do it internally. I don't. But those are opinions.
- 59:38They're based on you know, trying to pair sales,
- 59:42but there's so many factors in residential valuation.
- 59:46And one of the most important beyond the location
- 59:49and the size of the house and the number of bedrooms
- 59:52and the view and all that is there's an emotional
- 59:56component. And as an example, there was a property
- 1:00:04that sold post fire in Shevet Hills. The property
- 1:00:08was listed for $2 ,995 ,000 and sold for $6 million.
- 1:00:17And it sold to somebody who lost their house
- 1:00:21in the Palisades and this house looked like their
- 1:00:23house. There's no way, except to these people,
- 1:00:27was that property a $6 million property? I don't
- 1:00:32know what it was, but maybe it was $3 million.
- 1:00:34Maybe it was three and a half, but it wasn't
- 1:00:36six. And that's an emotional component. But that's
- 1:00:41an extreme, but in all residential, someone walks
- 1:00:46in and asks, there's something that moves them
- 1:00:50above and beyond, how many bedrooms? It's the
- 1:00:53feel of it. And that's different for everybody.
- 1:00:58And honestly, like, I try and quantify everything,
- 1:01:01but I also really try and step outside and say,
- 1:01:04okay, I know it's got X, Y, and Z, but what's
- 1:01:07the overall appeal? And, you know, you try and
- 1:01:10be as objective as possible and say, okay, it's
- 1:01:15not what I like, but let's say of a hundred people,
- 1:01:19what would appeal to these people, you know,
- 1:01:23more than the most, you know, because you got
- 1:01:25to look at the greater as opposed to. the property
- 1:01:29appraised were 10 people out of 100 it might
- 1:01:32appeal to. But that emotional thing is really,
- 1:01:39it's like when you appraise a unique property,
- 1:01:42a significant architect, a Neutra, Frank Lloyd
- 1:01:46Wright, these are like pieces of art. We all
- 1:01:51know art sells by no norms. there's an emotional
- 1:01:55aspect. Some people are collectors of real estate.
- 1:02:01But even when you get into just like, I don't
- 1:02:05want to say cookie cutter, but even let's say
- 1:02:07you're in the valley and you're in any given
- 1:02:09neighborhood, there's still an emotional thing.
- 1:02:12And maybe it's the neighborhood. You're emotionally
- 1:02:14attached to that neighborhood or you really like
- 1:02:16that school. I mean, there's so many factors,
- 1:02:18but, and that's why I like to stick with the
- 1:02:21location. as much as they can because then those
- 1:02:24locational factors are all similar when you're
- 1:02:28if you're gathering your comps from the same
- 1:02:29neighborhood where the schools are the same where
- 1:02:31everyone would probably use the same shopping
- 1:02:33when the freeway access is the same what have
- 1:02:36you um so those right can we have the next slide
- 1:02:40please we just want to say thank you thank you
- 1:02:44for joining us today thank you craig it was a
- 1:02:47wonderful conversation i hope we get to do it
- 1:02:49again Yeah, I really appreciate it. Hopefully,
- 1:02:51I didn't go off track too much. I know I tend
- 1:02:53to ramble a little bit stream of consciousness,
- 1:02:57but I appreciate the opportunity to be a part
- 1:03:00of this.