Latest / The So What? / US China South Africa Quo Vadis 2
Transcript
- 0:04Hello, and welcome to the So What podcast, in
- 0:08which political economic analyst J .P. Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of
- 0:13South Africans. You can find a written version
- 0:16of this content on J .P.'s website, jplandman
- 0:19.co .za. I am Ruda Landman, and I am your host.
- 0:25Hello, and as always, a very warm welcome to
- 0:28the So What podcast. This one accompanies JP's
- 0:33newsletter in September 2026, and the title is
- 0:37South Africa, U .S. Quo Vadis 2. Why did you
- 0:42return to this? You wrote about it in March.
- 0:45Indeed, I did. I returned to it because in the
- 0:48last two or three weeks, what we've seen is the
- 0:50American government. announcing visa restrictions
- 0:54on South Africans. No details yet, so we don't
- 0:57know what restrictions applicable to whom, but
- 0:59the statement was made. And that was followed
- 1:01up by the local U .S. ambassador in South Africa
- 1:04making all kinds of belligerent and threatening
- 1:07remarks. Most undiplomatic, I thought. Most undiplomatic,
- 1:11but the man is not a professional diplomat, so
- 1:13you must probably expect that. And I thought
- 1:16it's a good time to go back to the topic six
- 1:19months after I wrote the first note. Are there
- 1:22any projects of turning this around? You say
- 1:25it has gone from rigid to frigid. Is there any
- 1:30way out of this, especially perhaps now that
- 1:33Rolf Mayer has been appointed and received a
- 1:36very warm welcome when he arrived in Washington?
- 1:39Yeah, it was a very good appointment. The Americans
- 1:41were keen to receive him. You're asking if there's
- 1:44any chance of turning it around. I don't think
- 1:46so. The conclusion I made in March was that there's
- 1:50a deadlock. on a policy level between South Africa
- 1:52and the US. The US is demanding five specific
- 1:55things. They are totally and completely unreasonable.
- 1:59And the South African government is not going
- 2:01to respond to those five. They're not going to
- 2:03yield to those five. Now, if the one guy demands
- 2:06and the other guy refuses, then there's a deadlock.
- 2:09And when there's a deadlock, the relationship
- 2:11will deteriorate. And I think the recent developments
- 2:14with the visa announcements and the ambassador's
- 2:17reaction. absolutely reinforce those conclusions
- 2:20in March. And as you say, I think we went from
- 2:23rigid to frigid, and that's where we are. Can
- 2:25it change, is what you're asking? Basically,
- 2:28Ruda, I see three scenarios. The first one is
- 2:30as is. There's no later. The Americans want the
- 2:34five things. The Africans won't give the five
- 2:36things. So the deadlock persists, and so the
- 2:39relationship will probably deteriorate further.
- 2:42In fact, just this past weekend, the Minister
- 2:46of Foreign Affairs, Ronald Lamola, who is in
- 2:49Washington, in New York, at the UN General Assembly
- 2:52meetings, have warned South Africa to prepare
- 2:55for a worst -case scenario. And I think that's
- 2:58a realistic assessment. But there is a second
- 3:01possible scenario, and that scenario is critical
- 3:04minerals. The Americans are very keen on access
- 3:09to critical minerals. In fact, we know that about
- 3:1260 % of products that we export to the U .S.
- 3:16were exempted by Trump himself from Trump tariffs.
- 3:20So clearly America wants those minerals. That
- 3:26is where we are. And what has now happened is
- 3:29that some rare earth projects are being developed
- 3:32in South Africa. And this need that the Americans
- 3:35have for critical minerals and rare earths specifically
- 3:38can be a joker in the pack. There was quite an
- 3:41important meeting in May in Johannesburg where
- 3:45Ambassador Boesel himself was present. Yeah,
- 3:48he was there as well as South African deputy
- 3:51cabinet ministers and some 25 officials from
- 3:55both countries as well as various business people.
- 3:58And the meeting in May was specifically to talk
- 4:00about rare earths and critical minerals. So it
- 4:02is a critical issue for the U .S. and parties
- 4:04are talking about it. Now, I can't see the South
- 4:09African government just agreeing to that, to
- 4:11a critical minerals deal. The U .S. will have
- 4:13to give something. And so what is possible is
- 4:16that they walk away from at least some of the
- 4:19five demands in exchange for access to South
- 4:22African minerals. That's why I call it the Joker
- 4:24in the pack scenario. There's a problem with
- 4:27that scenario, and that is that South Africa
- 4:29has already signed agreements with the European
- 4:32Union on access by the Europeans to South African
- 4:36critical minerals and rare earth metals. Now,
- 4:41what do you do now? The European Union has been
- 4:43an old, steadfast, loyal, and consistent supporter
- 4:47of South Africa. Do you now kick them in the
- 4:50face and give the minerals to the US? That seems
- 4:53to me to be unlikely. So how you divvy up, how
- 4:57South Africa divvy up the critical mineral scape
- 5:00between the US and the EU, it will be an interesting
- 5:03thing to watch. It will be difficult, and we
- 5:05must see how that plays out. But that is a possible
- 5:07joker in the pack. Because critical minerals,
- 5:10by definition, are rare and scarce. Oh, absolutely.
- 5:14And the Americans are very keen to have them.
- 5:17So, yeah. So we don't have enough for everyone.
- 5:20No, indeed. Indeed. What is happening beyond
- 5:24politics? I think that that's a very interesting
- 5:27thing. Rolf Mayer, the ambassador in the US,
- 5:29and Alistair Reuters, the investment envoy for
- 5:33the president, have coined the term a relationship
- 5:36beyond politics. And I think that's a good description.
- 5:39On a political level, there's belligerence and
- 5:42arrogance and threats, which we've seen. On a
- 5:46commercial and tourism level, things are going
- 5:48on. Since I wrote the last note in March, six
- 5:52months ago, some five American companies have
- 5:55announced investments in South Africa to the
- 5:58tune of about 13 billion rand. Some more companies
- 6:01have actually invested more money buying out
- 6:04South African companies, buying out shares in
- 6:06South African companies. So these are not new
- 6:09investments. They're buying into existing companies,
- 6:12but that's also quite a few billion. The most
- 6:15noticeable one was... Alcoa, the American aluminium
- 6:19company, buying the worldwide assets of South32.
- 6:23And that includes two smelters here in South
- 6:27Africa, one at Bayside and one at Richards Bay.
- 6:30So that's a transaction of several billion US
- 6:34dollars. Interestingly enough, Alcoa did not
- 6:37buy the smelter in Mozambique. That was excluded
- 6:39from the deal. But the two South African plants...
- 6:43So there's a lot of investment taking place.
- 6:45So BE requirements don't seem to deter that?
- 6:50Absolutely not. I think one can make two conclusions
- 6:52from the ongoing investment. The one is that
- 6:55BE is not an obstacle for the Americans, and
- 6:57we can talk about why. And secondly, the narrative
- 7:00of Afrikaner genocide is clearly not keeping
- 7:03people out. It may excite the politicians, but
- 7:06it has no impact on business people. Just on
- 7:09why BE is not really an issue, foreign companies,
- 7:12not just American companies, all multinationals
- 7:15have got an option in South African law to buy
- 7:19their BE points, partly by investing in what
- 7:23is called equity -equivalent investment programs,
- 7:26or EAPs. So instead of giving up some of your
- 7:29equity, 20 % or 30 % or whatever, you make additional
- 7:33expenditure on programs that has a socioeconomic
- 7:37impact. Now, one of the most noticeable ones
- 7:40is Amazon. Amazon has signed a multi -year agreement
- 7:43and they're investing a lot of money in buying
- 7:47nearly 2 million tons of carbon dioxide emission
- 7:52credits. So that follows a speck boom project
- 7:57in the Eastern Cape. So what happens, people
- 7:59in the Eastern Cape landowners plant speck boom.
- 8:02The speck boom absorbs carbon from the atmosphere.
- 8:06And Amazon buys those carbon credits, and that
- 8:09gives an extra income to the farmers. So that
- 8:13project has already created some 1 ,600 jobs
- 8:16in one of South Africa's poorest provinces. And
- 8:19it is helping to re -establish natural vegetation.
- 8:23The speck boom is a natural plant in the Eastern
- 8:26Cape, which has been decimated over the years.
- 8:29So equity equivalent investments like that enable
- 8:32companies to acquire a better BEE rating. So
- 8:36there are many ways to skin a cat, and clearly
- 8:39the multinational companies are using that. Might
- 8:42that also be part of a different future for BEE?
- 8:47Because I think BEE in the South African conversation
- 8:50is contested, and not only among... wealthy whites,
- 8:57to put it that way. No, indeed. It is, and I
- 9:00think one of the pities of this whole US -South
- 9:03African blow -up is that instead of going to
- 9:06Washington and lobbying there, what people should
- 9:09do is here in South Africa participate in a program,
- 9:12or a process rather, which was opened in January
- 9:15this year, January 2006, when the Minister of
- 9:18Trade and Industry said he's doing a review of
- 9:21all the regulations and practices. Now, that
- 9:24doesn't mean that it will disappear. Absolutely
- 9:26not. But it does mean that you can find ways
- 9:29to deal with the more egregious manifestations
- 9:32of that policy. And that is happening. And yes,
- 9:36I think this equity equivalent investments could
- 9:39very well find big attraction in the future here,
- 9:43also for local companies. What's happening with
- 9:46American tourism? Well, it's quite interesting.
- 9:49If we are such a bad place, where such terrible
- 9:51things are happening. Absolutely, and people
- 9:53are suffering genocide. Well, in May and June,
- 9:55we had each month more than 40 ,000 American
- 9:59tourists arriving here in South Africa. That's
- 10:02more than 1 ,000 a day. I didn't realize we can
- 10:04accommodate that many. So the tourists are coming.
- 10:08And at the moment, tourists from America are
- 10:11not the biggest number of tourists. Our biggest
- 10:13number of tourists comes from Africa. But the
- 10:16Americans are the biggest spenders. Probably
- 10:18no surprise there. So the biggest money comes
- 10:21from there, and that's carrying on. So companies
- 10:23are investing and tourists are coming. And that,
- 10:26I think, gives tangible expression to Mayer and
- 10:30Reuters' philosophy or their formulation of a
- 10:35relationship beyond politics. I think many South
- 10:40Africans need to internalize the fact that the
- 10:45U .S. is not the world. What's happening in our
- 10:48trade relations with other countries? Yeah, it's
- 10:51very fascinating. We now have the final trade
- 10:54figures on agricultural exports from South Africa
- 10:58for 2025. And the numbers are very revealing.
- 11:01In the first half of 2025, now remember Trump
- 11:04came in in January and he issued his executive
- 11:07orders on South Africa in February. In April,
- 11:10he had his Liberation Day tariffs. In the first
- 11:13half of 2025, agricultural exports to the US
- 11:16declined by 3%. In the third quarter, it declined
- 11:20by 11%. In the fourth quarter, it declined by
- 11:24a whopping 39%. Now, remember, the final tariffs
- 11:28came in in August after Trump made U -turns and
- 11:31exemptions and so on. So there was a huge decline
- 11:34in agricultural exports. So a real impact. A
- 11:37real impact. But overall, agricultural exports
- 11:40from South Africa were 10 % up in 2025. So in
- 11:45spite of the U .S. decline, to the rest of the
- 11:49world, there was an increase. So the farmers
- 11:51found different markets. The farmers found different
- 11:53markets, where did they find them? Africa, Europe,
- 11:56and in the BRICS countries. And that shows you
- 11:59what can be done. The farmers are really showing
- 12:01the way, and not for the first time, I might
- 12:04add. And as recently as on 8 September, the agricultural
- 12:08minister signed an agreement with China. for
- 12:12access for South African cherries into the Chinese
- 12:16market. So the farmers are carrying on and the
- 12:19trade keeps on expanding. And you make special
- 12:24reference to our relationship with China and
- 12:27interactions with China. Yes, also in August
- 12:31this year, a month ago, there was a South Africa
- 12:34-China energy investment summit for a week. in
- 12:38China, with South African companies going there,
- 12:40meeting with Chinese companies and so on. And
- 12:43a number of agreements were signed at that summit,
- 12:45one of them on radioactive waste disposal. Six
- 12:49companies, Chinese companies, committed to manufacturing
- 12:51products here for our transmission line build
- 12:56-out that ESCOM must do. SASL signed an agreement
- 13:01to develop aviation fuel. And at that summit,
- 13:06it was decided that South Africa and China will
- 13:09develop a formal official energy investment program
- 13:12or agreement. So, you know, relations with China
- 13:16are expanding in fields where South Africa needs
- 13:21their products. In summary, so what? Yeah, I
- 13:26think the biggest so what is, if you look at...
- 13:30what is happening in the U .S. on a political
- 13:32level versus the real level, trade, investment,
- 13:36and tourism, then the first of what is the old
- 13:39Arab proverb comes to mind, the dogs bark, but
- 13:44the caravan moves on. I think that is the first
- 13:46conclusion. The second conclusion is that relationships
- 13:49with the U .S. probably will not improve as long
- 13:54as the deadlock between the two countries persists.
- 13:56I think that is fairly clear. The deadlock was
- 13:59there in March and the relationship has deteriorated
- 14:02to September. The third conclusion is that critical
- 14:05minerals could be a joker in the pack. It could
- 14:08give us a different kind of scenario. The most
- 14:11likely outcome, I think, is that things will
- 14:15carry on as now. Politics will get worse. The
- 14:18rhetoric will get worse. The belligerence will
- 14:20get worse. The threats will get worse and more.
- 14:23And real life will carry on with more investment,
- 14:26with more tourists. And we will keep on diversifying
- 14:29away from America to the rest of the world. The
- 14:31world is very, very big. And lastly, I think
- 14:34the Americans should take note that China is
- 14:38treating South Africa substantially different
- 14:40from the way America is treating us. You know,
- 14:43we don't have to be in an abusive relationship.
- 14:46You don't have to keep on going back to the guy
- 14:49who's abusing you. You can develop other relationships.
- 14:52And I think that's coming out clearly. Thank
- 14:56you very much. Thank you.