Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Understanding the Intractable Problem of Substance Abuse in the Legal Profession
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to introductions for understanding the
- 0:07intractable problem of substance abuse in the
- 0:10legal profession. My name is Dean Sirwin. I am
- 0:13the section chair for the wellness section here
- 0:16at the Beverly Hills Bar. I'm going to introduce
- 0:19our speaker, David Mann. David is a graduate
- 0:23of Ohio State University, which I won't hold
- 0:25against him being from Ann Arbor, and Stanford
- 0:27Law School. He served as deputy public defender
- 0:29in San Francisco. before becoming a solo criminal
- 0:33defense practitioner. After 12 years of practice,
- 0:37substance abuse related issues caused him to
- 0:39resign from the bar with disciplinary charges
- 0:41pending. Very honest of you there, David. Following
- 0:46a relentless battle with addiction, which included
- 0:48numerous hospitalizations and periods of living
- 0:51on the streets, he succeeded in getting clean
- 0:53and sober in 1998. Since then, he's worked among
- 0:57other things as a cab driver, private investigator,
- 0:59paralegal, and a drug and alcohol rehabilitation
- 1:01counselor. He presently serves as the Northern
- 1:04California consultant to The Other Bar, a statewide
- 1:07organization of recovering attorneys, judges,
- 1:09and law students. In this capacity, he spends
- 1:12his time providing outreach and education to
- 1:15the legal community and assisting attorneys as
- 1:17they struggle with substance abuse and related
- 1:19challenges that threaten their ability and or
- 1:22eligibility to practice law. So before we get
- 1:25started, I'd like to thank you, David. I'd like
- 1:27to congratulate you on your sobriety. And thank
- 1:31you for giving back and for being here with us
- 1:34today. With that, take it away, David. Thanks,
- 1:37Dean, for the introduction. Hi, everybody. So
- 1:41this is called the intractable problem of substance
- 1:44abuse in the legal profession, which is a new
- 1:47name I came up with just because. I think it's
- 1:50really accurate to describe the problem as intractable.
- 1:56I've been working exclusively in my sort of quasi
- 2:00-rehab capacity for over 15 years now with lawyers.
- 2:05And they're the most difficult population to
- 2:08work with. But they also are in a profession
- 2:13where there are structural components to the
- 2:17profession that make them more susceptible to
- 2:20counterintuitively to addiction than any other
- 2:23profession. And there's quite a bit of studies
- 2:26and statistics that validly document and back
- 2:31up that contention. And what I try to do, you
- 2:38know, this is a required unit, as was mentioned,
- 2:40and I try to make this topic worthwhile you know
- 2:44if you've been around for a while every three
- 2:46years you take this thing people get a little
- 2:49cynical and i'm in front of a live audience i
- 2:52can sort of see the the the grumpiness of the
- 2:56old timers and wonder why they have to take this
- 2:58thing again and again so i try to make it worthwhile
- 3:01i try to do that by addressing some of the things
- 3:04i think don't get addressed and uh My goal basically
- 3:08is to make you believe that this problem is as
- 3:12serious as it is, and then make you understand
- 3:15why that is, because it's not random. There are
- 3:19some, as I mentioned, there's some amazing things
- 3:21that go on with regard to the relationship between
- 3:24addiction and the legal profession. And my basic
- 3:29operating thesis, as you'll hear as it folds
- 3:32out, is that the addiction is a very strange
- 3:36peculiar and unique disease and the legal profession
- 3:40is kind of a strange and peculiar and unique
- 3:42profession and you could not have designed a
- 3:47profession more likely to succumb to addiction
- 3:51than the law and you couldn't have designed a
- 3:54disease more likely to afflict lawyers than addiction
- 3:58so You know, it remains counterintuitive that
- 4:02lawyers have this problem, but the statistics
- 4:04that are out there are amazing. I used to use
- 4:07a number that I was hoping was wrong and I hoped
- 4:12it was wrong because things had improved and
- 4:14it was too high. I find out a number of years
- 4:17ago with the now definitive and uniformly cited
- 4:22study that my number was wrong because it was
- 4:25too low and things have gotten worse. So if you're
- 4:29interested, if you Google Patrick Krill along
- 4:32with ABA Betty Ford Foundation, you'll find a
- 4:35study that has now become the go -to cited source
- 4:40for this number. And the number is 20 .5 % of
- 4:44attorneys are said to succumb to some form of
- 4:48addiction during the course of their career or
- 4:50their lives, which is almost twice the amount
- 4:53that's attributed to the general population,
- 4:55which is 11 percent. It's also one out of five
- 4:58lawyers. And we beat out every other profession.
- 5:02Dentists, I think, are second, which is interesting
- 5:06to me. They have access to prescription pads
- 5:09and all kinds of goodies. And I think dealing
- 5:12with difficult clients who hate lawyers is one
- 5:16thing, but being a dentist where everybody dreads
- 5:19going to see you and you're going to inflict
- 5:21pain on them might cause some discomfort that
- 5:25needs self -medication. Anyway, we're number
- 5:28one. We have these horrible numbers. For that
- 5:31reason alone, statistically, the state bar wants
- 5:33you to take this course. As you know, they're
- 5:38in charge of the well -being of the profession,
- 5:41they're in charge of the reputation of the profession,
- 5:45and they're in charge of protecting the public
- 5:46from bad actors in the profession. And this course
- 5:50presumably provides more knowledge about this
- 5:53problem. Knowledge is power. You know, for everybody
- 5:57who listens to this thing, one or two people
- 5:59realize that it may apply to them and then they
- 6:02take action and do something about it. It's one
- 6:06or two less people who are going to be dysfunctional
- 6:09and incompetent performing their jobs. And, you
- 6:13know, so we have this problem statistically.
- 6:17Reputation wise, you know, the legal profession
- 6:20is not. popular in the general public you know
- 6:24I don't know of any other profession that has
- 6:26its own genre of jokes right lawyer jokes and
- 6:29if you know a lawyer joke that has a punchline
- 6:32that's complimentary to the profession or to
- 6:34lawyers, I'd like to hear it, but most of them
- 6:36aren't. And one of the stereotypes is that of
- 6:40the drunken trial lawyer. And that actually goes
- 6:43back as far as Shakespearean times. There's a
- 6:45couple of plays that have a drunken barrister
- 6:48really on and off of the set through the whole
- 6:50show. So we don't want to reinforce that stereotype,
- 6:52but we also need to protect the public. And if
- 6:56you think about it. of professions that can have
- 6:59this disease, you want to juxtapose two extremes.
- 7:02One of them is the profession of being a barista
- 7:05at the Starbucks and the other one's being a
- 7:07lawyer. The barista becomes an alcoholic. There's
- 7:11going to be all of the health consequences, the
- 7:13family consequences, the financial consequences,
- 7:16maybe the legal consequences, but professionally,
- 7:19not too much. Screw up your latte, start stealing
- 7:23some money from the cash register, stop showing
- 7:25up to work. fired end of professional consequences
- 7:28but you know as a practicing attorney that you
- 7:32know the consequences of the work you do are
- 7:34very significant for your clients and if you're
- 7:37dysfunctional and making mistakes you know the
- 7:40concentric circles of societal and economic repercussions
- 7:44can be extreme. bad clause in a contract results
- 7:49in years of protracted litigate and expensive
- 7:51litigation. You make a mistake in somebody's
- 7:54trust in a state plan and families are litigating
- 7:57over the distribution of assets for years. You're
- 7:59a prosecutor and you don't do your job well and
- 8:02somebody who is legitimately dangerous and needs
- 8:04to be locked up for the protection of the rest
- 8:06of us goes free. You're a defense lawyer and
- 8:09you don't do your job right and somebody who
- 8:11by all rights should not have gone to prison
- 8:13goes to prison. So when we're not up to snuff
- 8:16because of drinking or drugging, it's a bad thing.
- 8:20And as proof of that, you all used to get the
- 8:24California Lawyer Magazine in your mailbox if
- 8:26you've been around a while. Now, I think it still
- 8:28comes out electronically online. But usually
- 8:32when I ask this question, I get some laughs and
- 8:35knowing smiles. And the question is, what is
- 8:36your guilty pleasure when you first get your
- 8:39California Lawyer Magazine? And what people do
- 8:42is page back to the discipline section. right
- 8:45and there's five pages of lawyers in trouble
- 8:48and it's like Jerry Springer for lawyers and
- 8:50you know they've commingled funds and they missed
- 8:53filing deadlines and they've abandoned clients
- 8:55and you look at this thing comes out every month
- 8:58there's 15 people in there and you wonder legitimately
- 9:02what is wrong with our profession so there's
- 9:04good news and bad news about that And the good
- 9:07news is in spite of that, there aren't that many
- 9:09dishonest, evil, incompetent lawyers in the state
- 9:12of California. The bad news is there's a lot
- 9:14of impaired lawyers because, and this is a number
- 9:17from the state bar discipline system, 70 % of
- 9:20the people who show up in that discipline section
- 9:22of that magazine turn out to have an underlying
- 9:25problem with alcohol, drugs. or things like anxiety
- 9:30and depression or a combination of. So we want
- 9:33to keep ourselves as healthy as possible. The
- 9:36idea is you take this course. It's going to remind
- 9:38you that the problem exists and hopefully encourage
- 9:42you to be mindful of how much of what you hear
- 9:46might apply to you. So. I'm not going to be speaking
- 9:50directly to how you can sit down and analyze
- 9:52yourself, but I'm going to be talking about what
- 9:55I consider to be the structural parts of this
- 9:57profession that cause people to have trouble.
- 9:59And I encourage you to think about those, think
- 10:02about whether they apply to you, and then think
- 10:04about what, if anything, you can do to minimize
- 10:07the effect that they have on you. Because there
- 10:09are... things that you can do. The problem, as
- 10:13I said, is kind of intractable because it's part
- 10:15of the culture. It's built into the profession.
- 10:18These problems are not going to go away, no matter
- 10:20how hard we try, because they're, as you will
- 10:23see, they're just built in. But you can certainly
- 10:27be aware of what's going on and try to protect
- 10:29yourself. I want to talk first a little bit about
- 10:33the other bar, because I'm under contract with
- 10:35the other bar. I'm there under the auspices of
- 10:38them. So we're a nonprofit. We've been around
- 10:40for 45 years. We're a 501c3. We survive on donations,
- 10:45which if you want to make one, we would appreciate
- 10:47it. You go to our website, otherbar .org. There's
- 10:50a PayPal function. But our mission is to help
- 10:54California lawyers who have problems with substance
- 10:56abuse, alcohol, or other problems. hoarding,
- 11:00gambling, there's a whole bunch of stuff. And
- 11:03to that end, we do things, not many, but in many
- 11:06cases, we're the only entity that does what we
- 11:09do. And it's my belief, based on 15 years of
- 11:14watching us have the effect we have on turning
- 11:17people's lives around and preventing disasters
- 11:19that were... good at what we do. So we have a
- 11:22website, Otherbar .org. I invite you to visit
- 11:24that. That has resources, referrals, and information
- 11:27about this whole topic. We publish and distribute
- 11:31these brochures. If we were live, I'd make sure
- 11:34you all had one of these that sort of synopsize
- 11:37what we're all about. They have our website.
- 11:40address on it but they also have our phone number
- 11:43it's an 800 number 24 -hour hotline it rings
- 11:46through to my cell phone and you can call anytime
- 11:49with a question about yourself a concern about
- 11:52yourself or a colleague. And what I do is completely
- 11:55confidential. It's free and it's voluntary. And
- 11:59I gather information from whoever calls and do
- 12:02my best to put them after the call is over in
- 12:05a better position to deal with what they're having
- 12:07to deal with than they were beforehand. And that
- 12:09might mean some advice. That might mean some
- 12:12instructions that might mean volunteering for
- 12:15me to participate in an intervention with them
- 12:18or their firm or their family. It might make
- 12:21a referral and resources to different types of
- 12:24programs that are available. And I do my best
- 12:27to treat them as a temporary client and as I
- 12:33used to have when I worked in treatment programs.
- 12:36take them from where they are to where they need
- 12:38to be and alleviate whatever the triage -like
- 12:42situation is that caused them to call. So that's
- 12:45what we do. The other thing, though, we do is
- 12:47provide these CLEs. And because it's a required
- 12:50unit, I do almost 50 of these a year. And I have
- 12:54a colleague in Southern California who also does
- 12:56about that many. And that gets us in front of
- 12:58them. Tens of thousands of lawyers and and the
- 13:01point is to enlighten you all a little bit about
- 13:03this problem Also though to make you realize
- 13:05that maybe you want to pick up the phone and
- 13:08give us a call And people do and when they do
- 13:12a lot of times it starts a process that solves.
- 13:15What was a building and likely to be terrible
- 13:19problem if it didn't get addressed. So that's
- 13:21the other bar. And that's why I'm here to talk
- 13:24to you. So this problem in the profession, it's
- 13:27counterintuitive. We don't think of lawyers as
- 13:29drug addicts and alcoholics typically. And I
- 13:34think it becomes easier to understand the problem
- 13:36with lawyers if you spend a little bit of time
- 13:38first just understanding the problem of the disease
- 13:42of addiction. Because It's a unique and powerful
- 13:46and perverse disease. And if you start describing
- 13:51it before you have gotten very far down your
- 13:54list of descriptors, you will have left every
- 13:57other disease behind. There's nothing else like
- 13:59it. And I submit you can do that same thing with
- 14:02the legal profession. You can leave everything
- 14:04else behind when you start describing some of
- 14:06its inherent features. So let's start with the
- 14:09disease of addiction. It is a disease according
- 14:11to the American Medical Association, which means
- 14:14that you have all the same rights if you have
- 14:16this disease as if you had any other disease,
- 14:19HIV, cancer, you name it. HIPAA applies the right
- 14:22to health insurance, the right to medical leave,
- 14:25the right to confidentiality. All of that applies
- 14:28to this disease. The problem is that people Even
- 14:32though it's a disease, think of it that way.
- 14:34It still has sort of a stigma to it and people
- 14:37consider it a moral failing. That tends to block
- 14:40people from getting the help they need. Nobody's
- 14:43too embarrassed to admit they have cancer, but
- 14:46people tend to be embarrassed to admit that they
- 14:49have a problem with drinking or other addictions.
- 14:53But here's this disease. It's a chronic progressive
- 14:55fatal brain disease. Chronic means there's no
- 14:58cure. You can put it in remission, but you still
- 15:00have it. You're responsible for some ongoing
- 15:02treatment to keep it in remission. If you don't,
- 15:04it can come out of remission. It's called a relapse.
- 15:07Other chronic diseases are diabetes, cancer.
- 15:11You manage your blood sugar levels, your insulin.
- 15:14You go to chemo. You get... radiation. And if
- 15:18you're lucky, you put it into remission, but
- 15:20you need to do some things to keep it there.
- 15:23Progressive means that it will get worse unless
- 15:26it's dealt with. And a lot of things we get aren't
- 15:28progressive. A cold, a flu, an infection, those
- 15:32start off and they follow a trajectory. You know,
- 15:35they get an upward trajectory, but they max out
- 15:38like a bell curve. And with the passage of time
- 15:40in the operation of an intact immune system,
- 15:42they go away. This disease does not do that.
- 15:45It starts off very slowly and but then once it
- 15:49picks up its upward trajectory, it will continue
- 15:52on that trajectory unless it is explicitly overtly
- 15:56dealt with. It has to be treated or it will not
- 16:00get better on its own. And then if it's not treated,
- 16:03it goes on to the last of the triumvirate I just
- 16:07mentioned of traits is fatal. It kills people.
- 16:10Heart attacks, strokes, accidents. Overdoses,
- 16:14cirrhosis of the liver, many ways this disease
- 16:17is fatal. And it's a brain disease. And what
- 16:20that means is once you have this disease, your
- 16:22brain is in scientifically measurable and observable
- 16:26ways different from a normal brain. And the basic
- 16:28thing that has happened is your reward system
- 16:31has gotten... turned on its head and your brain
- 16:34has been convinced that something that's not
- 16:36good for you, drinking or taking drugs, is good
- 16:39for you and has survival value and it tells you
- 16:43to compulsively pursue this behavior. The other
- 16:46main thing that happens with your brain is the
- 16:49relationship between your reptile brain, which
- 16:51is primitive, and your limbic brain, its survival,
- 16:55its appetites, its drives, and your prefrontal
- 16:59cortex or intellectual brain has changed. Typically
- 17:03as humans, what distinguishes us is our prefrontal
- 17:06cortex, the brain we use to make important decisions
- 17:09and write briefs, can overpower our limbic brain.
- 17:12It can keep the appetites in place. You know,
- 17:15we don't hit each other over the head and steal
- 17:16each other's food. You know, we don't act like
- 17:19animals. And what happens when you have this
- 17:21disease is your reptile brain starts to overpower
- 17:24your intellectual brain. And the reason that
- 17:27happens is it's driven by neurotransmitters that
- 17:30change how you feel. When you take a drug that
- 17:33makes you feel good, that is because that's a
- 17:37reward behavior, and it releases dopamine. And
- 17:41you're never supposed to be able to release as
- 17:44much dopamine as you can with a powerful drug.
- 17:47The dopamine we're supposed to feel comes from
- 17:50eating a good meal and doing other things that
- 17:53are good for us. And those things cause pleasure.
- 17:56That's the reward. so that we will eat because
- 17:59if we don't eat we will starve and survive. Sex
- 18:02is pleasurable because of our release of dopamine
- 18:04because as a species if we don't engage in that
- 18:07behavior we'll fail to reproduce and go extinct.
- 18:10You take a drug it feels good and your limbic
- 18:14brain thinks that it has survival value and it
- 18:17tells you like it says with food you should eat
- 18:19but when you take too much of a drug it has bad
- 18:23Side effects when you have this disease at first
- 18:26you try the substance and it usually works for
- 18:29you And then you repeat the behavior, but if
- 18:32you repeat it pretty soon You use more and more
- 18:35of it and that's because of habituation your
- 18:37body and your brain adjusts It doesn't work.
- 18:39So you need to take more and then you get to
- 18:42dependence as you take more and more Your body
- 18:45and your brain get to where they've adjusted
- 18:47so much that you can't do without it So you're
- 18:50taking a lot of this drug. It's not doing what
- 18:53you want it to do But it's doing a bunch of bad
- 18:56things and it's hard to quit because you get
- 18:59intense withdrawals if you try to quit and in
- 19:03a Complete final stage of addiction you have
- 19:07lost control You don't have the ability to quit
- 19:10anymore and that's even if you can recognize
- 19:13that you have this problem and know and decide
- 19:16that you have to quit but there's another characteristic
- 19:19of this disease that precludes that, and it's
- 19:22called denial. This is one of the few diseases
- 19:24that has a characteristic that tells you, because
- 19:27of your brain being changed, that you don't have
- 19:29it. People defend it, they deny it, and they're
- 19:32not lying. When you tell them they're an alcoholic
- 19:34and they say no, they're speaking their own truth.
- 19:38The problem is, and we say in recovery, you can't
- 19:41fix a broken brain with a broken brain. So your
- 19:44main survival tool to fix anything is your brain.
- 19:47But in this situation, your brain is severely
- 19:49compromised. It's telling you, you don't have
- 19:52this problem and you need help and you have to
- 19:55admit the problem before you can get that help,
- 19:58but you deny it. So there's perversely only two
- 20:01areas of human endeavor I know where the term
- 20:03denial, the word denial is a term of art and
- 20:06one is addiction psychology and the other one
- 20:08is the law. You know we deny the request for
- 20:10admissions we deny the allegations no self -respecting
- 20:13attorney admits anything right well you got to
- 20:15admit you're an alcoholic if you're going to
- 20:17get the help you need to solve the problem and
- 20:19you're not going to be able to solve it on your
- 20:21own the other thing is most people have gone
- 20:23through a period of whatever they're using where
- 20:25they used it successfully you know i drank for
- 20:2815 years and it wasn't a problem now i'm getting
- 20:31dui's and i'm getting in trouble at work and
- 20:33i you know i have to drink in the morning Why
- 20:36can't I just go back to where I was and do it
- 20:39the right way? You can't. But people try and
- 20:43try and they don't want to recognize that if
- 20:45the primary symptom is loss of control, then
- 20:49you can't regain the control. And therefore,
- 20:52the solution is total abstinence. And that's
- 20:55why alcoholics go to meetings and you need to
- 20:58stop completely. And it's hard for people to
- 20:59wrap their heads around that. So this is a really
- 21:02bad disease. You don't want to have it, right?
- 21:04So the next question is why does anybody have
- 21:06this disease? You know, why does anybody become
- 21:09an alcoholic or an addict if it's so terrible?
- 21:13You know, we all know drugs are bad. There's
- 21:15a war on drugs. Just say no to drugs. Don't become
- 21:18a drug addict. So that's the question is good.
- 21:21Why does that happen to people? But it's kind
- 21:23of based on a faulty premise, which is that people
- 21:25decide and choose to become drug addicts, which
- 21:28is absurd. Nobody decides to have a chronic progressive
- 21:33fatal brain disease. You know, that just doesn't
- 21:36happen. So the key to understanding this is to
- 21:39understand that there's another word for drugs
- 21:41and the word is medicine. And every addict and
- 21:45alcoholic I've worked with of the hundreds over
- 21:48the years I've been doing this describes their
- 21:51drug of choice, the thing that ended up trying
- 21:53their best to kill them and ruin their life is
- 21:55something they thought of as their medicine when
- 21:58they first found it and started using it. And
- 22:02it's usually true, you know, that it did help
- 22:06them. So people don't make a choice to become
- 22:09an addict. They make a smaller, benign, incremental,
- 22:13and sometimes rational choice to introduce a
- 22:16chemical to their brain and their body so they
- 22:19can change the way they feel or be the way they
- 22:22want to be. And I divide these chemicals into
- 22:25four categories, up, down, around, and off. Up
- 22:29is energy, stimulants. Down is relax, depressants.
- 22:35Around is change your reality, get a break from
- 22:38normal reality. That's things like, you know,
- 22:41hallucinogens and marijuana. And then off is
- 22:44go to sleep, Ambien, Linestra, things like that.
- 22:47So up, down, around, and off, those are the four
- 22:50directions we can go in life and with chemicals.
- 22:55And in each case, it's legitimate to need to
- 22:57do those things sometimes you need more energy
- 22:59you got to get that brief written sometimes you
- 23:01need to relax sometimes you need to escape sometimes
- 23:04you need to go to sleep and in each case there's
- 23:07a healthy way to do it if you need more energy
- 23:09take a two -hour nap jump in the shower refreshing
- 23:12cool shower go back to your desk finish writing
- 23:14your brief if you need to relax you know roll
- 23:17out the yoga mat assume the lotus position do
- 23:20some deep breathing meditate you can relax if
- 23:23you need to escape Go on a vacation, immerse
- 23:26yourself in a culture where they speak a different
- 23:29language, some faraway exotic place. Go into
- 23:31the jungle, the mountains, the ocean, and you
- 23:34can get a reality break. There's healthy ways
- 23:37to get to sleep. Taken together, they're called
- 23:39sleep hygiene. But in each case, doing those
- 23:43things the healthy way requires, in some combination,
- 23:47one or all of the following. Time, money, and
- 23:51discipline. It takes two hours to take a two
- 23:53hour nap. Meditation takes time and they call
- 23:56it a discipline. It takes time and money to go
- 23:59on vacation and so on. So if you're chronically
- 24:02short on time and or money and maybe a little
- 24:06bit deficient in the discipline department, these
- 24:09chemical shortcuts become very attractive because
- 24:12they will do whatever you want and need them
- 24:14to do like that. And they do it better than anything
- 24:18in nature. And that is sort of the pernicious
- 24:20evil thing about drugs. You know, the war on
- 24:24drugs has been going on for ever. And every year,
- 24:28the worst year is always last year. You know,
- 24:30the flavor of the month changes. There was crack
- 24:33in the 80s. It was crystal meth in the 90s. Now
- 24:36it's fentanyl. But, you know, the number of overdose
- 24:39deaths, the toll this takes on society, you can
- 24:43add up the amount of money we spend on legal
- 24:47problems, accidents, injuries, medical treatment,
- 24:51incarceration. divorce altogether it might be
- 24:55the most expensive problem we have as a society
- 24:58and we cannot get a handle on it and I don't
- 25:01see it happening anytime soon so another pet
- 25:04little theory of mine is that you know Einstein
- 25:07is supposed to have said with the advent of nuclear
- 25:09weapons that he thought in that regard our technology
- 25:13may have surpassed our humanity meaning as humans
- 25:16we had come up with something with our little
- 25:18brains that was so big and powerful that in the
- 25:22fullness of time, we might prove unable to control
- 25:25it, and it could destroy us. And that could still
- 25:27happen. I think that with the current state of
- 25:32technology and the availability of highly refined
- 25:34pills, powders, and potions that can instantly
- 25:36change the way we feel that our technology may
- 25:39have surpassed our humanity, that we're just
- 25:42not equipped intellectually, neurologically,
- 25:45biologically, sociologically, psychologically,
- 25:48to deal with the temptation and the consequences
- 25:52that are presented by the availability of all
- 25:54these chemicals. So and by the way, you know,
- 25:57the problem comes down to this. Any drug has
- 25:59its desired effects and its undesirable side
- 26:01effects. So one aspirin will cure your headache
- 26:03and a bottle could kill you. It's the same thing
- 26:06with all these drugs of abuse. A little bit is
- 26:08usually not that bad of a thing. But when you
- 26:10need more and more and you take more and more
- 26:12and eventually, you know, you're taking a devastating
- 26:15amount and you're getting more side effects than
- 26:17desired effects, that's when the problem happens.
- 26:20So that is how people become addicts. They start
- 26:23off with something that helps them and they're
- 26:25walking down the road of life and it's helping
- 26:28them. But then they start to lean on it and pretty
- 26:32soon they need it to walk down the road of life.
- 26:34And then pretty soon they can't do without it.
- 26:36But by that time, It's providing way less benefit
- 26:39than it is harm and they are stuck because they
- 26:43can't quit without a lot of help. So that is
- 26:45the bizarre and perverse and powerful way that
- 26:48people become addicts. People don't decide that
- 26:52they want this to happen to them. So that's how
- 26:55it happens to anybody. Now, why does it happen
- 26:56to lawyers so much? So I had to think about this
- 27:00because, you know, we are distinguished from
- 27:03other professions because we're number one. So
- 27:05what distinguishes us from other professions?
- 27:08And people will propose stress when I ask, what
- 27:12do you think the problem is with lawyers? Stress.
- 27:15And obviously, that's true. But there's a lot
- 27:18of other stressful professions. And yet, we're
- 27:20number one. So what is it about the legal profession
- 27:24that makes us number one? And working with hundreds
- 27:28of lawyers and paying attention to what goes
- 27:29on and analyzing what goes on in this profession
- 27:33and how it relates to addiction. I've come up
- 27:36with basically four broad categories of things
- 27:40that I think are the biggest factors that cause
- 27:42lawyers to have this problem. And the first one
- 27:45is our personalities. And there's been tons of
- 27:49studies done about the lawyer personality profile.
- 27:53Lawyers have been... experimented with more than
- 27:57lab rats. And there's a sort of a agreed upon
- 28:01consensus lawyer personality profile. And you
- 28:04can find this in any number of books. There's
- 28:07one that sort of started the ball rolling by
- 28:09a woman named Susan Dyckhoff that's called Lawyer
- 28:11Know Thyself. But I'm going to read you this
- 28:13personality profile of the lawyers. I've learned
- 28:16to give a disclaimer before I do this, because
- 28:18taken together, they sound kind of nasty. You
- 28:21wouldn't want to know this person. But note,
- 28:23and this is not inconsequential, that a lot of
- 28:26these, by themselves, actually can help us do
- 28:29some of the things we need to do as lawyers.
- 28:31But it turns out, when you put them all together,
- 28:33it creates a profile that might make you a good
- 28:35lawyer, but not necessarily a good spouse or
- 28:37a good friend or somebody who has a good relationship
- 28:40with themselves. So this may not be you, but
- 28:44you may know this person. The lawyer personality
- 28:47profile, controlling, ego -driven, high achieving,
- 28:51competitive, more comfortable with thoughts than
- 28:53feelings, more motivated by external than internal
- 28:58rewards, perfectionism, negative thinking. The
- 29:02trait that correlates highest with membership
- 29:05on the law review and high academic performance
- 29:08in law school is pessimism. It sounds weird,
- 29:12but think about it. What do we do? Bar exam.
- 29:15What is that? Issue spotting. What is that? You
- 29:18look for things that are going to go wrong. And
- 29:21that's what we do. What is a contract? It's two
- 29:24pages of what the parties are going to do and
- 29:2615 pages of what's going to happen if they don't
- 29:28do it. So it helps you be a good lawyer if you
- 29:32can spot those potential problems. It's our job
- 29:35to keep them from happening. So far, kind of
- 29:40not happy things here, right? So you're going
- 29:42to like this next one, above average intelligence.
- 29:45Most of us will cop to that one, right? Now we
- 29:49go down the rabbit hole again, self -centered,
- 29:51compulsive, grandiose, tended to be tense as
- 29:54opposed to relaxed. And finally, how we make
- 29:57our intrepid way through the enchanted forest
- 30:00of the legal profession. This is our lions and
- 30:02tigers and bears, argumentative, opinionated
- 30:05and judgmental. Oh my, right? Now those last
- 30:10three sound particularly harsh, but think about
- 30:12it. We go to court and write briefs to make our
- 30:14argument. We do it to try to get a favorable
- 30:18judgment. And it comes in the form of an opinion.
- 30:21What's your argument going to be? Did you read
- 30:22the opinion? Did we get the judgment? Bam. It's
- 30:25the trifecta of legal thought. The first one
- 30:28on the list, controlling, is first because it's
- 30:30the most important. But I've been asked, why
- 30:32is it even there? I just got done saying the
- 30:35addicts. symptom is loss of control. If you're
- 30:38a full -blown addict, you have lost control.
- 30:40But if you are the type of personality who succumbs
- 30:43to the temptation to put a chemical in your body
- 30:45to instantly change the way you feel, that's
- 30:48a pretty controlling personality trait. Not everybody's
- 30:50willing to do that. But figuratively speaking,
- 30:54when you do that, what you're trying to do is
- 30:55slap a dial on the side of your head that says
- 30:58up, down, around, off, now. So you take that
- 31:03all together, and what it basically tells me
- 31:06is that by personality, we are predisposed to
- 31:10be susceptible to addiction. And then the profession
- 31:14comes along and makes it worse. Three primary
- 31:17ways, I think. One is our compensation. Now,
- 31:21if you're on the partnership track, you're doing
- 31:23well, you've been a lawyer for a little while,
- 31:25you're making a lot of money. Hundreds of thousands
- 31:27of dollars. And that's nice. Nothing wrong with
- 31:30making a lot of money, right? Most people who
- 31:33make that kind of money, they do their job and
- 31:35they cash their paycheck. We do our job and we
- 31:39bill by the hour. And we bill, you know, back
- 31:42when I worked at big firms for a while, it was
- 31:45quarter hours. Now it's tenths of an hour, right?
- 31:48You know this. And it's six minute segments.
- 31:51And, you know, this is such a modest, I've been
- 31:54told this is a stupidly low hourly rate, but
- 31:57I haven't practiced for a while. So I use $500
- 31:59an hour because the math works easily. So you're
- 32:02billing at $500 an hour and six minute segments.
- 32:06You get to work in the morning. Six minutes,
- 32:09$50. Six minutes, $50. Six minutes, $50. How
- 32:17long do I have to do that before it becomes a
- 32:18little bit annoying? Probably already is, right?
- 32:22Yeah. All day, all week, all month, all year.
- 32:27better add up to 2 ,000 or something if you want
- 32:29to be on the partnership track. That's nuts,
- 32:33you know. You go to the bathroom and you think
- 32:35of a case while you're in there so you can build
- 32:37the time when you come out. I had a good idea
- 32:39in there, 50 bucks. But what this does is fundamentally
- 32:43change our relationship with time. I submit to
- 32:45you that most people don't run around thinking
- 32:47of their time in six -minute segments they have
- 32:49to justify. But we do, you know, and it spills
- 32:53over. Somebody tells you you gotta wait in line
- 32:56half an hour for a table at a restaurant. And
- 32:58some little part of you says, really? Are you
- 33:00gonna give me 250 bucks? That's what my time
- 33:02is worth. But it also affects you in ways that
- 33:05go straight to your wellness. You could go out,
- 33:08sit on the park bench, see the birds, watch people
- 33:11roller skate, eat your lunch out of a bag, and
- 33:14get some fresh air, look at the sky and go back
- 33:16to your desk. Or you could stay at that desk.
- 33:19and bill another hour. You could leave work early
- 33:22and go to your kid's soccer practice and kid
- 33:24would be happy, it'd be fun, or you could stay
- 33:27a little late at work and bill a couple hours.
- 33:30So that pressure is always there and it directly
- 33:32affects the attractiveness of shortcuts. I could
- 33:37meditate for an hour, but I need to bill this
- 33:40hour. I could take a two -hour nap, but I need
- 33:42to bill these two hours and so on. So when you
- 33:46don't have enough time, you look for a shortcut.
- 33:48The chemical shortcuts are there. Lawyers use
- 33:50them and that helps us get in trouble. The next
- 33:53thing that comes along is the adversarial system.
- 33:56Have you guys heard of this? The adversarial
- 33:58system. What a system. Equally qualified professionals
- 34:02going up against each other in a public forum
- 34:04and doing battle with great consequence and somebody
- 34:07wins and somebody loses. Sometimes the losers
- 34:09don't get paid. Damn, that's kind of intense.
- 34:14That's what we do. You know, you would like to
- 34:17think a bunch of professionals who go to school
- 34:20until they're 26 years old and then, you know,
- 34:23do a rite of passage and take the bar exam in
- 34:25order to get a state granted license to practice
- 34:27their profession would cooperate with each other
- 34:31in a collegial fashion towards a common goal.
- 34:34Architects do that. Engineers do that. Doctors
- 34:37do that. We fight it out. Somebody's trying to
- 34:40do something and we're trying to keep them from
- 34:42getting it done. Adversarial. What other profession
- 34:46is adversarial? I'm glad there's not adversarial
- 34:48medicine. How'd you like to go to the ER? There's
- 34:51three doctors on each side of your gurney. These
- 34:52three are trying to save you and these three
- 34:54are trying to kill you. You know, that wouldn't
- 34:56be good. But you know what profession does that?
- 34:59Sports, professional sports, the Super Bowl,
- 35:03competitive, high pressure, a winner and a loser.
- 35:07So you got the Super Bowl athlete, the football
- 35:10player, and you got the lawyer. and you got the
- 35:13game and the trial and you got the victory and
- 35:16you have the five million dollar verdict and
- 35:19in each case the lawyer and the football player
- 35:23are going to be motivated to do everything they
- 35:26can under nature to prepare for this hugely consequential
- 35:29event you know and the football player has his
- 35:33innate gifts and his training and and his strategy
- 35:37and the quality of his team and his opponents
- 35:39and the quality of their, you know, whatever
- 35:43they're able to bring to this. And the lawyer
- 35:45has his education, his intelligence, his training,
- 35:48his experience, the quality of his legal strategy,
- 35:51the quality of his team and the quality of the
- 35:53opponent. And in each case, they can both do
- 35:55everything under nature to prepare for this event.
- 35:58And then they're going to hit a wall. And the
- 36:01only thing left to do is get up in the morning
- 36:03and go to the kickoff or go pick the jury. and
- 36:06hope for the best. Well, with those kinds of
- 36:09consequences on the line, both of them, the football
- 36:13guy and the lawyer are going to try to figure
- 36:16out a way over, around or through that wall or
- 36:19a way to push it back a little bit. And if the
- 36:22wall is needing to get sleep or the wall is needing
- 36:25to have more energy or the wall is needing to
- 36:28relax for a while, there's a way to do it with
- 36:32drugs and alcohol. So The lawyers do it. They
- 36:36use drugs for performance enhancement. You take
- 36:39an Adderall to stay up late and prepare for your
- 36:41trial. Now you've been up almost all night. You
- 36:44need to get a little bit of sleep. You take an
- 36:46Ambien to get to sleep. Now you get up and you're
- 36:48a little bit foggy from that Ambien and you...
- 36:50pound some coffee and maybe take another Adderall
- 36:52to go to trial. Now you overdid the Adderall
- 36:55and you're a little nervous public speaking and
- 36:57you take a half a Valium to take the edge off.
- 37:00And I know these people who have done this thing
- 37:02and it's not that uncommon. And the football
- 37:06players take performance enhancing drugs as well.
- 37:09But the football players get tested so they get
- 37:12caught and then they have a choice. Figure it
- 37:15out, get better or your career is over. Lawyers
- 37:18don't get tested. So we don't get caught and
- 37:21it manifests after a long time only when it's
- 37:24really bad and far along and nobody can ignore
- 37:29it anymore. And because of that, it's had that
- 37:32much more time to develop and it's going to be
- 37:35that much harder to fix it, to cure it. So that
- 37:39we're in that position because of the adversarial
- 37:41system. And the final thing that affects lawyers
- 37:44is something that affects everybody, but it affects
- 37:46us more. in a unique way and that is cognitive
- 37:50dissonance which is means noise in the brain
- 37:53but it's discomfort in your brain when there's
- 37:55a conflict between your held values or when there's
- 37:58a conflict between a held value and your behavior
- 38:01which is not consistent with that value and I
- 38:05submit to you that that kind of discomfort that
- 38:08comes from inside your brain from the inside
- 38:11out is maybe one of the worst things to try to
- 38:13deal with so people are really motivated to try
- 38:15to make it go away, right? And everybody can
- 38:18have it, but lawyers can really have it. And
- 38:22the reason for that is advocacy. We represent
- 38:26our clients, and our clients are trying to get
- 38:28something done, and it's our job to help them
- 38:30do it. And whatever they're trying to do may
- 38:33only affect them, but it may affect the economy,
- 38:37the environment, or other people. We're told
- 38:40to ignore that. It's not us doing it, it's the
- 38:43client doing it. So you have client A with objective
- 38:46B. And let's say, you know, as happened to a
- 38:50friend of mine, he goes to work in the morning,
- 38:52gets called in. Kenny, we got an assignment for
- 38:56you. This is just the job for you. Meet client
- 38:58A. He's a real estate developer. He owns all
- 39:00this property that runs in and around these wetlands
- 39:02and, you know. marshes up in up near where you
- 39:07live as a matter of fact in quarter Madera and
- 39:09And he wants to pave the wetlands and build McMansions,
- 39:12but there's all these obstacles You know, nobody
- 39:14wants to let him do this help him get it done
- 39:16So my friend Kenny goes to quarter Madera City
- 39:19Council meetings religiously for a year and he
- 39:23lobbies and he gets zoning variances and he cuts
- 39:26deals and he proposes a public -private partnership
- 39:28and we'll put in some low -income housing and
- 39:32some infrastructure and sewers and streetlights
- 39:34and and he does nine iterations of an environmental
- 39:36impact statement till he gets one that says a
- 39:39certain salamander won't be too adversely affected
- 39:41and Finally, he gets the green light. You can
- 39:45do this and he goes to work calling the partners
- 39:48calling the client I got a big announcement Congratulations,
- 39:52you got the green light. You can go ahead pave
- 39:54the wetlands and build your McMansions Everybody's
- 39:58happy, you know, they shove a cigar in my friend's
- 40:00mouth and they give him a big fat bonus check.
- 40:03Then he drives home that night. And turns out
- 40:06he's a member of the Audubon Society in the Sierra
- 40:08Club, and he likes to go out birdwatching in
- 40:11these migratory bird flyovers that are now going
- 40:14to be paved and turned into McMansions. And he's
- 40:17sitting there with his cigar and his bonus check.
- 40:20Is he a man? Well, I'm good. I'm a good lawyer.
- 40:24I did that. I got that done. What did I do? I
- 40:29hurt the birds. I love the birds. I feel bad.
- 40:34I don't want to feel bad. How can I feel good?
- 40:38And then he spies his high -end bottle of scotch
- 40:40sitting over there on the counter, and I think
- 40:42I'll have a double scotch. And he has that double
- 40:45scotch, and now he doesn't feel quite so bad.
- 40:47I'll have another one. After that second double
- 40:50scotch, it's bird schmerz. I'm going to fire
- 40:52up the cigar, figure out what kind of new car
- 40:55I want to buy with my bonus check. So the thing
- 40:59about being told that we're advocates and the
- 41:01client's doing it and we're not doing it is that
- 41:05that can be very little relief. We're told if
- 41:09we follow the code of ethics and the law, that
- 41:12takes us out of the equation. But the code of
- 41:14ethics and the law are not morality, first of
- 41:17all. But they're not even aspirational. They
- 41:20don't represent ceilings. They represent floors
- 41:23under which we can't go without getting in trouble.
- 41:25So you can follow the code of ethics and the
- 41:28law. But if you play an instrumental part in
- 41:29making something happen that doesn't sit well
- 41:31with your personal values, it can be not a good
- 41:35feeling. And then you can want to seek relief
- 41:37for that feeling. And people do. So this cognitive
- 41:41dissonance thing is a real problem. Nobody wants
- 41:44to feel bad. People want to feel good. people
- 41:47of substance want to feel good because they're
- 41:49good people who do good things for good reasons.
- 41:53And this advocacy role can create a pretty substantial
- 41:57challenge to that. So that's the four main reasons
- 42:07that I have come up with that are unique to the
- 42:09profession that I think combined cause us to
- 42:13have the highest incidence of this problem of
- 42:15any profession. And hopefully, you've landed
- 42:18in a space in your career, in your professional
- 42:21niche, where you don't have to come across this
- 42:23that often. But I was a true believer in the
- 42:27type of law I did, and I still came across it
- 42:29once in a while. And it's not a good feeling
- 42:32to think that the very thing that you do for
- 42:35a profession, the place where you apply all your
- 42:37gifts and talents, is helping do things that
- 42:42you would rather not have happen. So that's why
- 42:48it happens to anybody, addiction, and that's
- 42:51why it tends to happen to lawyers. I'm going
- 42:53to talk about this last part of the case study,
- 42:56and I'm exhibit A. I use myself for this case
- 42:59study because I know things about this that I
- 43:02hope you never have to learn, and I know them
- 43:04because I went through it. And I think it's valuable
- 43:07for you to hear from the mouth of somebody who
- 43:11was a lawyer who was an addict has much in common
- 43:15with you and is willing to talk about this because
- 43:18I want to make it real and I want to make it
- 43:21real so you realize that it maybe could happen
- 43:24to somebody you know, maybe you because I didn't
- 43:28ever think it was going to happen to me and it
- 43:30did and nobody I knew thought it was ever going
- 43:32to happen to me. But I also want to impress you
- 43:34with how absolutely horrible it is to suffer
- 43:38from this disease. because I want to instill
- 43:41in you some respect and fear for it so you'll
- 43:43be motivated to try to make sure that you don't
- 43:47stand idly by while it happens to somebody you
- 43:50know and that you certainly don't let it creep
- 43:53up on yourself and find yourself in those shoes.
- 43:58So case study, exhibit A, me. Who am I? So for
- 44:04a while, you'll recognize this is sort of a legal
- 44:06term is called laying a foundation. And it might
- 44:08sound like I'm bragging at first, but I'm laying
- 44:10a foundation for the proposition that up to a
- 44:12point, I would have been considered was considered
- 44:15the least likely person to end up where I ended
- 44:17up. And I thought of myself as the least likely
- 44:20I felt I was immune to this thing. This is something
- 44:24that happens to somebody else. So I was the middle
- 44:27son of a middle -class family in the Midwest.
- 44:30I grew up in a suburb of Ohio. Totally normal
- 44:34life, middle -class lifestyle. You know, my mom
- 44:37was the president of the PTA. There was no abuse
- 44:40and no alcoholism in my family. You know, I mean,
- 44:44my dad sold all state insurance, you know, in
- 44:46the 60s and 70s. It can't get much more normal
- 44:49than that, right? And that meant I was in good
- 44:50hands, too. So, you know, no excuses. But...
- 44:56You know, I feel like I remember. I just have
- 44:59to interject. Thank you for that pun. Yeah. If
- 45:04there was a, you know, a hook that I could be
- 45:07hauled off stage, I think that would earn it
- 45:09every single time. But I can't resist. But I
- 45:15had a lot of those personality traits I mentioned,
- 45:17you know, from the start, and that's kind of
- 45:19what gets people into law school. I was competitive.
- 45:21I was ego driven. I was high achieving. I was
- 45:23smart. And the thing is, the first report card
- 45:26I got in the first grade had all A's on it. Now,
- 45:31when that happens, there's only one way to go,
- 45:34which is down. And I didn't ever want to get
- 45:37a B. You know, A's are beautiful. They're symmetrical.
- 45:40They look like little rockets. And they go shoot
- 45:42up in the air. You know, B's are lopsided and
- 45:45sideways. And no B's for me. Thank you very much.
- 45:49I have never had a B. That's my compulsiveness,
- 45:52my competitive, my ego -driven. So when you're
- 45:56that way, you know, you start to do anything
- 45:59to keep that going on. So I remember in high
- 46:02school, I got parts in the school play. I sang
- 46:07in the choir. I played on the football team.
- 46:10I was on the baseball team. Oh, as a... Boy Scout,
- 46:14I had to be an Eagle Scout. And when I got into
- 46:17student government, somebody had the gavel and
- 46:19I wanted that gavel and that was the president.
- 46:21So I had to become the president. And back then
- 46:24we had school crossing guards who were allowed
- 46:26to actually walk to school. It was amazing. You
- 46:28didn't have to wear a helmet or anything. And
- 46:30so they had these crossing guards and they had
- 46:32the safety patrol. And there was a guy who had
- 46:36the gold badge and that was the captain. And
- 46:38I wanted that gold badge, so I had to be the
- 46:40captain of the safety patrol. I graduated from
- 46:43high school at the top of my class of 700 people.
- 46:46And I go to Ohio State. And after four years
- 46:48there, out of the plus minus grading system,
- 46:50I graduate as the valedictorian of a class of
- 46:537 ,500 people. Four point average. An A minus
- 46:59would have destroyed the perfect symmetry of
- 47:00that four point. It would have been a 3 .9876
- 47:03or whatever. I couldn't let that happen. But
- 47:06I never got a single A minus in a program that
- 47:10had A minus grading system and the compulsion,
- 47:15you know. So, you know, I was the valedictorian
- 47:18and then I, you know. took the LSAT and destroyed
- 47:23it and then I got into a great law school and
- 47:25I moved to California and I go through law school
- 47:28and I work at some big firms and I get offers
- 47:30but I hate it and then I was fortunate enough
- 47:33to do an internship at the San Francisco Public
- 47:35Defender's office and I loved it. I knew that's
- 47:38what I wanted to do so I said no to the big money
- 47:41and the you know all that stuff and I took the
- 47:43job and I became a San Francisco Public Defender
- 47:46and I was good at it. I was passionate about
- 47:49it. I did dozens of jury trials. And then I left
- 47:52that office and spent another nine or 10 years
- 47:55as a solo practitioner after three or four years
- 47:57as a public defender. So that's my resume. That's
- 48:01my career. But that's only part of it. Here's
- 48:04the rest of it. I am, as I speak to you now,
- 48:07a recovering intravenous crystal methamphetamine
- 48:10addict. I'm a convicted felon. I'm a disbarred
- 48:13California attorney. I'm somebody who spent Six
- 48:16months of his life in a maximum security County
- 48:19jail Wearing an orange jumpsuit before orange
- 48:22was the new black. It was wasn't cool. It was
- 48:24just porn I've spent 11 months of my life in
- 48:28three separate residential rehab programs One
- 48:32with one of them court -ordered and ultimately
- 48:34ice. I have four felony convictions I don't know
- 48:37if I mentioned that and ultimately I spent 18
- 48:40months a year and a half of my life drug addicted
- 48:43homeless and destitute living on the streets
- 48:46of San Francisco. So there you go. How do you
- 48:51fit all of that in one life? You know, it's like
- 48:54schizophrenia. There's a one word explanation
- 48:57for it and the word is addiction. In my third
- 49:00year of college, I no longer could naturally
- 49:03keep up what it took to maintain these grades.
- 49:07I was taking, you know, graduate level econ courses
- 49:11which I had no business taking and and you know
- 49:14I had a final exam coming up at the end of finals
- 49:16week I was exhausted I had to get an A you know
- 49:19this is one of those econ courses that has like
- 49:21Greek symbols and and you know equations and
- 49:24calculus and all this stuff and and I was burnt
- 49:28out at the end of finals week I couldn't do the
- 49:30all -nighter I needed to do and some kid in the
- 49:32dorm gave me a pill here you go this is what
- 49:34you need well what is it it's a diet pill where'd
- 49:37you get it from my mom Her doctor prescribes
- 49:40them. I take them out of her medicine cabinet.
- 49:42Really? Well, what could go wrong? I take this
- 49:45pill. It's pure amphetamine. It keeps me up all
- 49:49night. I'm laser focused. I study for my exam.
- 49:53The next day, I aced the exam. I was a competitive
- 49:56runner back then. I do for my daily run. Personal
- 49:59best time. Did you guys know you can run fast
- 50:02on amphetamines? Yeah, which is good because
- 50:05eventually there's people chasing you all the
- 50:06time. And if you're a runner, you want to stay
- 50:11skinny. And I come from this German family where
- 50:14we know how to overeat. But it was a diet pill.
- 50:17So it suppressed my appetite. This was the perfect
- 50:21drug for me. And it wore off. And I felt fine.
- 50:25I went and saw that kid and told him, give me
- 50:27as many of these pills as you can. And for my
- 50:30last year of college, I probably never wrote
- 50:32a paper or took an exam when I wasn't under the
- 50:35influence of amphetamines. And I became mildly
- 50:37addictive. addicted to them and dependent on
- 50:40them. Then I moved to California for law school
- 50:42and I need these things and there aren't any
- 50:45pills in California. And so somebody helpfully
- 50:48in law school supplies me with some crystal meth.
- 50:52Here's what we have out here. It's a powder.
- 50:54Snort it. It'll do the same thing. I was never
- 50:57going to do street drugs. Every addict and alcoholic
- 51:00will end up doing everything they say they're
- 51:01never going to do. So now I'm on crystal meth
- 51:04in law school. And I go through my entire law
- 51:08school career using crystal meth. And there was
- 51:10a cohort of us in school who all were doing it.
- 51:12And I didn't have to go to a bad neighborhood
- 51:14to do it. I got it from another law student.
- 51:17And then I get out. I was under the influence
- 51:19of crystal meth. When I took the bar exam and
- 51:21passed, I was under the influence for my entire
- 51:24public defender career, for every trial I did,
- 51:27most of which I won, and for my entire career
- 51:31as a solo practitioner. I'm here to tell you
- 51:34right now that from my third year of college
- 51:37to the last day I practiced law, I was never
- 51:40not under the influence of amphetamines. And
- 51:44they worked pretty well most of the time for
- 51:46quite a while. But you know, you can only do
- 51:49a highly addictive drug for so long before you
- 51:52get addicted to it. And I was addicted to it
- 51:54and I could manage it. But then something happened.
- 51:58I said intravenous crystal meth, right? I had
- 52:01this girlfriend after 15 years of doing this
- 52:04drug who was a nurse and liked to do it as well
- 52:07but she knew a different way to do it which was
- 52:10by loading up a syringe full of it and giving
- 52:13me a shot of it and a professionally administered
- 52:16shot of crystal methamphetamine and that happened
- 52:20and I'll never forget it. It was the most amazing
- 52:24four or five hours of my life and nothing was
- 52:29ever the same. When it was over with, I looked
- 52:31at her and I said, I want to do this every day.
- 52:35And that's what I did, and that's what we did.
- 52:38And when you use more and more of a drug, you
- 52:41shoot it, you use a ton more than when you're
- 52:43snorting it, you get more of the bad side effects.
- 52:46In this case, the bad side effects are visible
- 52:48weight loss, malnutrition, bizarre behavior,
- 52:52delusional thinking, paranoia, irresponsibility,
- 52:56and all those things happen. And in a... Courthouse
- 53:00where I'd been known and respected for 12 or
- 53:0213 years people started to notice I was getting
- 53:04weird and I was representing all crystal meth
- 53:08dealers and the Narcotics people didn't like
- 53:13it They put out the word help us get this guy
- 53:15and we'll give you a license to deal drugs in
- 53:17San Francisco and to get out of jail free card
- 53:20A client of mine informed on me a warrant was
- 53:23obtained. My office was raided I was handcuffed
- 53:26to my chair for four hours while they searched
- 53:28my office. They found enough evidence to charge
- 53:30me with four felonies. And I was taken across
- 53:34the street, kept to my chain to my office chair
- 53:37for hours while the police waited for all the
- 53:41media to show up outside, the network affiliates
- 53:44with the vans and the cameras. I get hauled out
- 53:46my handcuffs doing the perp walk on the news
- 53:49on all stations over the weekend and the whole
- 53:51Bay Area. booked into the county jail, spend
- 53:54the night in jail, appear in the court the next
- 53:57morning for an arraignment in front of a judge
- 53:58at whose house I'd had dinner with whom I'd played
- 54:01golf, enter a plea, get out on bail, and then
- 54:04spend the next year trying to stay out of state
- 54:07prison. And the DA desperately wanted me to go
- 54:09to state prison. By that time, by the way, I
- 54:12had an intervention done by my family and friends.
- 54:14I'd been a 28 -day program. It didn't work. But
- 54:17I'd also burnt through my money, my family, and
- 54:19my friends. And I had no support network anymore
- 54:22except two of the best lawyers in town who were
- 54:25my friends and represented me for free. And after
- 54:29a year, we miraculously managed to get a plea
- 54:31that kept me out of state prison and involved
- 54:34pleading to all four felonies, resigning from
- 54:37the bar. $5 ,000 fine, three years probation,
- 54:42six months in jail, six months court ordered
- 54:45residential rehab, and three years state prison
- 54:48suspended. So I go through all this and after
- 54:52a year I step out of this rehab program and I
- 54:56have almost all my possessions are gone. I have
- 54:59no money, no job, no place to live, no car, no
- 55:04law license. and four felony convictions and
- 55:07I'm 39 years old standing on the street. What
- 55:11am I going to do? I mean, I literally don't have
- 55:15anywhere to go tonight to stay. And if I did,
- 55:18I don't know how I'm going to get there. I got
- 55:21to rebuild my life. I lost everything. How did
- 55:24I get everything? I got it with crystal meth.
- 55:29Therefore, I better go get some crystal meth
- 55:31so I can rebuild my life. Broken brain. It takes
- 55:36a long time to work your way out of this when
- 55:38it's as bad as that was with me. So that was
- 55:41my plan. I may not surprise you to know it didn't
- 55:44work. I found myself living in a repurposed U
- 55:48-Haul truck out on the edge of the San Francisco
- 55:51Bay in these abandoned railroad yards with all
- 55:53these other drug addicts. And I would walk around
- 55:56all day and scrounge through dumpsters. You figure
- 55:59out what places have the day old sandwiches in
- 56:03the dumpsters. And I was eating out of dumpsters.
- 56:05I ate at every soup kitchen in San Francisco.
- 56:08I can still give you a culinary review of all
- 56:10the different ones and which ones are best. And,
- 56:14you know, I wandered around. I had long hair.
- 56:17I had a base, backward baseball cap. I had a
- 56:19beard. I was pushing a beat up mountain bike,
- 56:22scrapping metal to turn into recycle to get money
- 56:25for drugs. And that was my life. And it just
- 56:28went on day after day after day. And nobody in
- 56:31the whole wide world knew where I was. I was
- 56:34invisible and suffering and not able to figure
- 56:39out how to get out of there. And it just went
- 56:42on and on. So, you know, I needed to get some
- 56:46insight. I needed... enlightenment I needed an
- 56:49epiphany and that happens when you hit your bottom
- 56:51and I apparently hadn't hit it yet so things
- 56:53were going to have to get worse and they did
- 56:55one day I go back to my truck and it was gone
- 56:57towed away for unpaid parking tickets so my shelter
- 57:01my truck had a cot and a Coleman stove in there
- 57:04was gone but it also had the few kernels of remaining
- 57:08possessions that I'd managed not to lose the
- 57:11things that you hope and assume that you're never
- 57:13going to lose in life you know for everything
- 57:15was online a family photograph album with historical
- 57:18photos of my whole extended family gone by law
- 57:22school diploma gone my undergraduate honors thesis
- 57:25and hard copy of it gone a little shoe box with
- 57:28my eagle scout badge in my boy scout merit badges
- 57:32in it gone. Growing up I had this beloved German
- 57:37grandfather, my grandpa Otto and I was his favorite
- 57:40grandkid and you live next door to us. And I
- 57:42hung out with him, and he taught me to grow things
- 57:44and build things and fix things. And right before
- 57:51he died, he gave me his hand -carved, wooden
- 57:54-handled German pocket knife to remember him
- 57:57by. Gone. And I'm standing on the street, sorry,
- 57:59Grandpa, I lost your knife. Winter's coming.
- 58:03I don't have a truck. It's going to be rainy
- 58:05and cold. What am I going to do? Huh. I could
- 58:08go to rehab. Now I've been to rehab twice. I
- 58:11could get off drugs and see if that helps. No,
- 58:15I lost my truck. I got to replace my truck. Therefore,
- 58:19I'm going to need some crystal meth so I can
- 58:21replace my truck. Good idea. I didn't work either.
- 58:26So now I spent another nine months. homeless
- 58:29for a total of a year and a half on the streets
- 58:31of San Francisco. But now I'm wandering around
- 58:34in the cold and the rain. I'm sleeping in cardboard
- 58:37boxes, bushes, under loading dock overhangs to
- 58:41try to stay dry. I'm learning how to steal loaves
- 58:44of bread that are on racks cooling behind bakeries
- 58:47and eat them, run around the corner like a character
- 58:49in a Charles Dickens novel and shove a whole
- 58:51loaf of bread in my mouth because I don't want
- 58:53to get caught. I'm on probation and I'll go to
- 58:55prison because I'm so hungry. I learned I got
- 59:00stabbed, I was beaten with a two by four, went
- 59:03to the hospital twice with overdoses. And I learned
- 59:06some things that they didn't teach me in law
- 59:08school. I learned what it's like to be so hungry,
- 59:10you steal a loaf of bread. I learned that if
- 59:14you're sufficiently exhausted, you can be cold
- 59:17and wet and shivering and you can still go to
- 59:19sleep. And when you've got some sleep and you're
- 59:21a little less exhausted, you wake up and you're
- 59:23still cold and shivering. But mainly I learned
- 59:26that it's not enough to want to die, you have
- 59:27to be able to kill yourself. And I didn't seem
- 59:29to have that in my skill set. So this is just
- 59:33going on and on and on. Complete incomprehensible
- 59:37demoralization. No idea what was going to happen,
- 59:41except I just wanted it all to be over and it
- 59:44wouldn't end. You know, I couldn't get an appointment
- 59:48with Dr. Kvorke. So just ground down like this
- 59:51and then here's what happened. You know, as will
- 59:53happen, something things conspired to bless me
- 59:57and save my life. So at a certain point, I had
- 1:00:00a tent and a sleeping bag, a little camp on the
- 1:00:03outside of town. And one day I walked three miles
- 1:00:06from my camp into this residential neighborhood
- 1:00:08called Petrero Hill and down in San Francisco,
- 1:00:11where a friend of mine lived from back in the
- 1:00:13old days when I was a human. And he would sometimes
- 1:00:16let me sleep on his couch, take a shower and
- 1:00:18give me something to eat. I got there and knocked
- 1:00:21on his door. He wasn't home. I waited. It got
- 1:00:24really late. He didn't come home. Now, you know,
- 1:00:26it's midnight and I'm three miles from my camp.
- 1:00:29I'm not going to walk that far back. I can sleep
- 1:00:32anywhere. I've slept anywhere. So I look around.
- 1:00:36I find this playground next to his house and
- 1:00:38it's got a sliding board with a sandbox under
- 1:00:41it and a little wooden structure around it. And
- 1:00:43I just decide to lay down. Jeans and a t -shirt.
- 1:00:47I weigh 130 pounds, July 24th, summer night in
- 1:00:50San Francisco. I lay down in this playground
- 1:00:52and go to sleep. And as I'm going to sleep, I
- 1:00:56state to myself, based on what I knew, something
- 1:00:59I hope you never have to learn, but I knew, it
- 1:01:02was when you're homeless, the best thing that
- 1:01:04ever happens is you go to sleep. Because when
- 1:01:06you sleep, you can dream. And when you dream,
- 1:01:09you can have a job, a life, a law license, a
- 1:01:12relationship, a place to live. You can be a human.
- 1:01:15but every time you have to wake up again and
- 1:01:18when you do it hits you like a ton of bricks
- 1:01:20oh my god i'm a homeless drug addict and then
- 1:01:23your hierarchy of needs kicks in am i hungry
- 1:01:25can i find a bathroom can i get some drugs are
- 1:01:27the police going to come and you have to deal
- 1:01:29for another day in san francisco where you can't
- 1:01:33sit still unless you have money and you don't
- 1:01:35have any So I also knew though I wasn't going
- 1:01:37to want to wake up but I knew I was in a playground
- 1:01:39and if I didn't get out of there there were going
- 1:01:41to be moms kids they'd probably call the police.
- 1:01:44Last thought get out of here in the morning don't
- 1:01:47stay get out. So it turns out the you know the
- 1:01:52night didn't go the way I wanted it to. The wind
- 1:01:56kicked up the fog rolled in and I walked I got
- 1:01:59up wet and shivering and cold and started walking
- 1:02:02around Trying to figure out a way to get warm.
- 1:02:06And I started screaming because I couldn't find
- 1:02:09anything. And I pulled up under a streetlight
- 1:02:11and just screamed the word, what, over and over
- 1:02:15again. And I was crying and just hysterical.
- 1:02:20And it was 3 AM in this quiet neighborhood. And
- 1:02:23I didn't get any thunder and lightning right
- 1:02:25then. I calmed down. I screamed so loud, I damaged
- 1:02:29my vocal cords. I couldn't speak for three weeks.
- 1:02:31I had to write notes to communicate. But I calmed
- 1:02:34down, I went back to my friend's house and that's
- 1:02:35when I pulled out this tarp from his truck, he
- 1:02:38was home then, and I went back to the sliding
- 1:02:40board, rolled up in this tarp, and that's when
- 1:02:42I got all toasty warm, like this little Speed
- 1:02:44Freak burrito, and then had that self -talk about
- 1:02:47how I was going to have to get out of there in
- 1:02:48the morning. What happened is, I can hear the
- 1:02:51birds singing, I can hear the kids playing, and
- 1:02:53I'm in my tarp, warm, and I'm not coming out.
- 1:02:57You're going to have to pull me out of here with
- 1:02:58a tractor. I want to be dead. The next best thing
- 1:03:01is at least to be unconscious in this warm tart.
- 1:03:04And eventually something started poking me in
- 1:03:06the side of the tarp and I tried to ignore it
- 1:03:08and it wouldn't go away and finally I had to
- 1:03:11deal with it and I stick my head on snark snarling
- 1:03:13out and I was looking up at the bright sky squinting
- 1:03:16in this little blonde girl you know her hair
- 1:03:19is silhouetted against the sun like a halo she
- 1:03:22was my saving angel and she had been poking me
- 1:03:24with a stick when my head popped out she threw
- 1:03:27the stick up in the air and jumped back and she
- 1:03:29screamed he's alive and her mom came to get her
- 1:03:32and she's pulling her daughter away she says
- 1:03:34You didn't touch anything, did you? You better
- 1:03:36come and wash your hands. So this was pre -COVID,
- 1:03:41I found that kind of insulting, right? Turns
- 1:03:44out there's three moms, about seven kids. They're
- 1:03:46on their regular outing to the playground. They've
- 1:03:48been taken off to these bleachers on the side.
- 1:03:50Can't go on the sliding board because the man's
- 1:03:52there. Now if you have kids, you know this makes
- 1:03:55the sliding board the most desirable piece of
- 1:03:57playground equipment there is. Can we go yet?
- 1:03:59Can we go yet? No, the man is there. I'm trying
- 1:04:02to get out of there, extricate myself from my
- 1:04:05tarp. I'm nasty and drug addicted and hateful
- 1:04:10and unpleased with this situation. So I get up,
- 1:04:15I put my backward baseball cap on and I'm dragging
- 1:04:18my sorry butt out of there. and as I'm doing
- 1:04:21that one of these moms decides to give the kids
- 1:04:23a lesson in life use me to do it and she points
- 1:04:27to me and she says to these kids and I heard
- 1:04:30her I don't know if I was intended to but god
- 1:04:32bless her she may have saved my life she says
- 1:04:34to the kids so who knows what we need to do so
- 1:04:36we never have to live like that man and I heard
- 1:04:41her say that and I'm not proud to tell you that
- 1:04:44my first reaction was it pissed me off You know,
- 1:04:46I wanted to turn on my heel and rip off my baseball
- 1:04:49cap and say, tell them not to go to law school.
- 1:04:52They'll be all right. But instead, you know,
- 1:04:55it hit me like a freight train in my sternum.
- 1:04:58Oh, my God, I need to figure out what I need
- 1:05:01to do so I don't have to live like this anymore
- 1:05:03because I'm not going to live like this too much
- 1:05:05longer. I'm going to die out here. And that day,
- 1:05:09I walked myself out to my third and final treatment
- 1:05:12program. It was. In the bad neighborhood of town,
- 1:05:15it was a county run program and no more swimming
- 1:05:17pool, no more volleyball. They took me for my
- 1:05:20food stamps and my G .A. check. And I stayed
- 1:05:23for four months when I did something I've never
- 1:05:25done before, which was listen to people and do
- 1:05:27what they told me to do, even though I didn't
- 1:05:29think they were as smart as I was because they
- 1:05:32knew something I didn't know, which is how to
- 1:05:34live without drugs. And I learned how to do that.
- 1:05:37And I'm here to talk about it. Many years later,
- 1:05:40I survived. Almost everybody I know who was out
- 1:05:44there with me is dead. You know, when your demographic
- 1:05:48is homeless, intravenous, drug addict, you don't
- 1:05:50usually last long. I don't know why I got chosen
- 1:05:53to survive. Not my job to answer that question,
- 1:05:56but I did have to figure out what I was going
- 1:05:58to do about it. I decided to take what I had
- 1:06:01learned and learn more. I did the treatment,
- 1:06:04the training and got... good at being a drug
- 1:06:06and alcohol treatment counselor. I worked in
- 1:06:08a bunch of programs. Ultimately, I completed
- 1:06:11the lawyer assistance program. They hired me.
- 1:06:13I worked for them for a year. And then for 15
- 1:06:16years, I've been working for the other bar. So
- 1:06:18this is my job to speak to you, to answer that
- 1:06:22phone, and to try to help other people so they
- 1:06:25don't have to go where I went. You can help me
- 1:06:28do my job in three ways. One, do not become somebody
- 1:06:32I have to help. Think of what you've heard here.
- 1:06:35Think of what might apply to you and watch out.
- 1:06:38It wasn't going to happen to me. It did. It can
- 1:06:42happen to you. Second thing is, if you see it
- 1:06:46in a client or a colleague, in somebody else,
- 1:06:49don't just watch and wait, hoping it'll get better.
- 1:06:52It won't. Remember, it's progressive. It needs
- 1:06:55to be addressed. Pick up the phone and call me
- 1:06:59at the other bar and you can remain anonymous.
- 1:07:01and say, I do family law in Beverly Hills. And
- 1:07:05a bunch of us know each other. And we know this
- 1:07:08one lawyer. She's a good lawyer. She's been around
- 1:07:10forever. But something's going on with her. She's
- 1:07:12lost weight. She's late. She's not doing well.
- 1:07:15We don't know what to do. I'll ask you a bunch
- 1:07:18of questions. I'll find out as much as I can
- 1:07:20find out. And you can remain anonymous. And I'll
- 1:07:23call that person and tell them, I worked for
- 1:07:25the other bar. We have a hotline. We have people
- 1:07:28who are concerned about you that called. and
- 1:07:32think that you maybe could use some help. I'm
- 1:07:34here to offer that help. It's voluntary, it's
- 1:07:36free, it's confidential. Can I help you? And
- 1:07:39you know, people hang up, they say F you, but
- 1:07:41sometimes their voice breaks or they start to
- 1:07:44cry and they say, oh my God, yeah, it's time.
- 1:07:47Please, what can you do to help me? And you know,
- 1:07:49even if they hang up, there's life before and
- 1:07:51after that phone call. But the least it does
- 1:07:53is plant a seed. You know, if I'm getting a call
- 1:07:56like that, maybe I need to give some thought
- 1:07:59to what I'm doing to myself. And the final way
- 1:08:02you can help me do my job is to help us stay
- 1:08:04in business. We survive on donations. We barely
- 1:08:08make our budget. I'm a contractor. We have no
- 1:08:11employees. We have no brick and mortar location.
- 1:08:13I drive my own car. I use my own phone. We barely
- 1:08:16make our budget every year. Everything helps.
- 1:08:19So, you know, if you want to make a tax deductible
- 1:08:21donation, you can go on OtherBar .org. There's
- 1:08:24a PayPal function there. If everybody who's watching
- 1:08:26this gave a little bit of money, it would It
- 1:08:29would help us survive for another month because
- 1:08:32if we go out of business, people are going to
- 1:08:34suffer, get disbarred and die who could have
- 1:08:36been saved because nobody else does what we do.
- 1:08:39And I would like us to be able to keep doing
- 1:08:41it and we can with your help. And that's all
- 1:08:44I have to say today. OK, thank you for having
- 1:08:47me, everybody. Have a great weekend.