Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The Market Edge: Inside the Housing Market with Mollie Carmichael
Transcript
- 0:04Hello, and welcome to the Market Edge, a podcast series created by Market Intelligence
- 0:09Committee members at ACEC National, featuring industry experts who address the
- 0:14most pressing issues to members today, with a focus on market trends.
- 0:18This series is also brought to you by the Engineering Influence Podcast at the
- 0:22American Council of Engineering Companies.
- 0:24My name is Diana Olaire, and I will be your host today. In today's conversation,
- 0:28we'll break down the forces reshaping the residential market,
- 0:31from regional performance and buyer sentiment to affordability,
- 0:36generational shifts, and the involving balance between new and resale homes.
- 0:40This will be a must-listen for engineering and development professionals navigating
- 0:44what comes next in housing. So please join me in welcoming Molly Carmichael.
- 0:50Hello. Thanks for having me, Diana.
- 0:53Absolutely. So Molly is a principal of Master Plan and Product Insights for
- 0:58Zonda Homes. And she's going to tell us a little bit more about that.
- 1:00But she's nationally recognized as a real estate strategist with more than 35
- 1:05years of experience advising many of the country's most sophisticated home builders.
- 1:10Master plan, community developers, building product manufacturers,
- 1:14financial institutions and land planners and architectural firms.
- 1:18So, Molly, so great to have you.
- 1:20Could you share a little more about your background for those that don't know
- 1:24you and more about Zonda Homes and what you all do?
- 1:28Sure, you bet. So I've been doing this for almost 40 years.
- 1:31I work with builders, developers, investors, building product manufacturers,
- 1:35as you mentioned, really helping them to figure out the real estate space.
- 1:38So anything that has to do with doing a real estate decision,
- 1:42that's what our company does.
- 1:43So we have Builder Media, we have an advisory team, and we have all things data,
- 1:49as it relates to every part of the real estate industry.
- 1:52We also do a lot of outlooks and forecast. So Allie Wolfs, our chief economist, you'll hear a lot.
- 1:58She's literally advising the White House and all kinds of different forces out there.
- 2:02And a lot of the work that I do is advising about the markets down at the ground level.
- 2:07So whether you're talking about an MSA or you're talking about a region or you're
- 2:11talking nationally, I'm looking at all things as it relates to what's performing,
- 2:16what's not performing, and then how do we devise the best strategy to be, frankly,
- 2:21profitable, successful, and provide something, you know, that's going to be
- 2:25here for generations and generations to enjoy in the future.
- 2:30Well, so glad to have you. You know, things have really changed since we spoke last time.
- 2:36We're full swing into the spring housing market where a lot of sales are taking place.
- 2:41And then Iran happened, gas prices are up, interest rates are climbing.
- 2:46And so I'm interested if your outlook has changed.
- 2:49Can you tell us more your thoughts on the macroeconomic environment of the housing
- 2:54market as a whole and what the biggest forces are that are shaping the market right now.
- 2:59Sure, you bet. So I think everybody came into the January selling season.
- 3:04And as many of you know, who know the real estate industry, it's after Super
- 3:08Bowl that you look for sort of is the market going to perform.
- 3:11And I think people were pretty bullish that we would see a stronger.
- 3:16You know, first of the year, and it's really been tough.
- 3:20The challenges for consumers is it's about their own consumer confidence,
- 3:25and that's really what's shaken up today.
- 3:27So when you look at the overall market, what hasn't changed, right?
- 3:33From gas prices to the economy, the stock markets bouncing up and down,
- 3:37you know, prices, unfortunately, when you go out to a lot of these different
- 3:41sales offices, incentives don't match, all of those things.
- 3:45So it's, It's, am I getting the right price? Is it a good time to buy?
- 3:49And really what's making people buy, for those that do buy, it's, I have to buy.
- 3:54So it's a life stage or a life change event.
- 3:58They want to cash out equity because they do think the market could change or
- 4:03there's concern for that.
- 4:05Or I would tell you, kind of the cream on the top is, if a builder does something
- 4:11so unique and so different that they haven't seen and they don't think they'll
- 4:15have that opportunity again because it's a unique niche in the market, then that's,
- 4:21the third one. All right. So I know that you have coast-to-coast experience
- 4:25and also with Zonda Homes access to national data.
- 4:29So what regions, you know, I think our member firms will be really interested
- 4:33in this, are, do you think performing the best or the worst when it comes to
- 4:37driving those differences? Where, where's the work happening?
- 4:41You know, it's, it's really interesting because you're right.
- 4:44So we look at all the markets across the country.
- 4:46The East Coast seems to be performing better than the West Coast, for example.
- 4:51And part of that has to do with affordability. Part of that has to do with some
- 4:55of the job growth and some of those things.
- 4:57Across the board, though, job growth is pretty anemic.
- 5:01So that's not the primary driver.
- 5:04I would say the affordability factor is a big piece of it. And then the supply piece of it.
- 5:08The West Coast, you have higher prices. We have negative migration in California.
- 5:15We have some of the category is, you know, whether it's Phoenix or Las Vegas,
- 5:19there were different factors driving on the West Coast.
- 5:21And then markets like Florida, with this huge shift of consumers,
- 5:26you know, turning 62 years of age and older, we're seeing, you know, that migration to move.
- 5:33And again, either cash out or retire. So Texas.
- 5:38It's somewhere in between. Texas tends to trend a little bit differently than
- 5:41the rest of the market. It really depends on which market.
- 5:44We could go into the very specifics there. As you know, Austin tends to be the
- 5:48better one of all four of the markets from a higher price point perspective,
- 5:52but because it is a higher price point, absorptions are slower, right?
- 5:56Houston, harder to make money. So again, I could get into the weeds from,
- 6:01you know, Maine all the way down to the other side of the US, California.
- 6:06So however much detail you want, I'm happy to touch on it.
- 6:09But Midwest, interestingly enough, has made a little bit of a comeback.
- 6:13It's never a roaring comeback.
- 6:16But like markets like Ohio, where there's all these data centers and,
- 6:20you know, it's super affordable.
- 6:23It's the second most affordable state in the country to buy a home.
- 6:26So there's some interesting things going on there. But because of that,
- 6:30there's a lot of like multifamily and single family racing to get there.
- 6:34And so it's interesting to watch right now.
- 6:36But you did touch on, I think, some key pieces, which is interest rates,
- 6:40gas prices, confidence in the market.
- 6:43All those things have to be intact for people to feel good about making a move.
- 6:48So you have quite a few things in there that I want to unpack.
- 6:51First, I think what came up the most is affordability.
- 6:54So I'm going to go ahead and go straight there. It really seems to be a defining
- 6:58issue in the housing market at this moment.
- 7:01The White House's main moves on this very issue from trying to prevent large
- 7:05institutional investors from buying single-family homes.
- 7:08We've been watching that with a lot of our members to reducing regulatory barriers,
- 7:13including permitting reform is the next big one, and even providing incentives
- 7:17for single-family developments in these opportunity zones.
- 7:20So what solutions or innovations do you think could actually the needle?
- 7:26And where are builders struggling to close there?
- 7:30Well, there's a lot to unpack in that question you just asked.
- 7:33So when we look at sort of some of the reform they're looking at,
- 7:39for example, on the single family for rent, so there's a lot of debate on that.
- 7:43That could be an hour discussion, quite frankly, but I'll hit the highlights.
- 7:47I think from a government perspective and a policy perspective,
- 7:52I think there's confusion on that specific category.
- 7:55And I think taking investors out of the market on single family homes for rent,
- 8:00that they're buying them and taking them off, that there's this thought that
- 8:04investors are really driving up the market.
- 8:06In some cases, they are on single homes one off. Right.
- 8:10But the bill for rent market, for example, where you're building these little
- 8:14neighborhoods of 50 to 100 homes and it's a whole community.
- 8:19For Build for Rent. There was actually a study done between Bannie and Freddie
- 8:23on for rent, and they found that people that rented homes, they actually wanted
- 8:28to live with people that rented homes.
- 8:31They didn't want to live in a single family, all ownership and be the one guy
- 8:35that is renting on the street, right?
- 8:37So what's been really interesting about the Build for Rent class that has been,
- 8:41it's somewhat new to do these like neighborhoods of lower density,
- 8:44horizontal, single-family front has really addressed affordability.
- 8:48And I think that gets missed. It provides a small lot, small home without someone
- 8:55above me and my own private backyard in a neighborhood of people that feel like
- 9:00they have a community that they're bonding with.
- 9:02If I have a dog or I've got little kids, they're cute little neighborhoods.
- 9:07And I think that's where policymakers are getting it wrong. I think that's one
- 9:11of the key areas to address affordability, for example.
- 9:14I also think some of the models, if done right, with the right design,
- 9:18I don't know why they don't design them as for sale in neighborhoods.
- 9:21And I know part of the policy or discussion is they can only hold them for so
- 9:25many years and then they want them to sell them. I think there's a market for that.
- 9:30But I also think there's going to still be a very, we can look at the numbers
- 9:35and we've done a lot of demand analysis in this specific category where there's
- 9:41plenty of demand on the resale side too.
- 9:44I think the opportunity is in both category, in the new home market for sale,
- 9:49and in the for rent market too, to address affordability. Last but not least.
- 9:54I just presented on this five minutes ago. You know, the core size that consumers
- 9:58want is 1,500 to 2,500 square feet.
- 10:00And the number of people that will accept a size smaller than that is huge.
- 10:04The average size home before 1960 was actually under 1,200 square feet,
- 10:10and it went twice the household size, right? I think actually that number was 1950.
- 10:14And so the reality is we've gotten a little lazy with space.
- 10:19The average size home today is 22 to 2400 square feet, and our household size has cut in half.
- 10:24So we've made bigger houses for fewer people and really to smart size and with attract.
- 10:32I mean, think of all the great cute cottage neighborhoods that we all love so
- 10:35much that are like 900 to 1500 square feet. They're beautiful.
- 10:40We just have to get better at functional spaces. when you go to areas like,
- 10:46well, I won't mention countries, but other countries that are making 400 and
- 10:50600 square foot homes function really well.
- 10:53It's just about getting smart with space.
- 10:55It's interesting. I've seen the same data come out from the U.S.
- 10:58Census showing that the average home size is in fact shrinking.
- 11:03And so it does sound like there are, you know, efforts being made for just that
- 11:08and the homes are becoming smaller.
- 11:10I want to shift a little more into asset class specific.
- 11:14Can you tell me more about how those different asset classes like single family
- 11:20or active adult multifamily, still the for sale and bill to rent,
- 11:24how are they performing relative to each other?
- 11:27Is one doing better than the other? And what signals are you most closely watching?
- 11:31You bet. So the multifamily market, as you might imagine, just with rates going
- 11:37up, cap rates going up and the investment, it feels a little frozen, frankly.
- 11:42It's really, it seems to be non-existent unless it's unique locations, very specific niches.
- 11:51Again, student, housing, staff, you know, depending on what category it is,
- 11:56I would say the multifamily market is a little frozen right now.
- 12:00And again, it's very interest rate and investment driven.
- 12:02The build for rent market is totally tied up in policy right now.
- 12:07Everybody is just we have a big conference that actually is happening this month
- 12:12in Phoenix on build for rent.
- 12:14And we have all the experts across the country coming in to talk about sort
- 12:17of what's happening and where. And I would tell you, the biggest discussion
- 12:20on all the calls I've had with these different experts is policy, policy, policy.
- 12:25Is anyone going to address policy? And the challenge is we don't have answers.
- 12:28So that market's tied up and frozen.
- 12:32And wrongly so when you're looking at affordability. It really is a solution for affordability.
- 12:37The single family market and the attached for sale market, the single family
- 12:44is the most active in all of its space for sale.
- 12:49And the attached market is getting tied up in insurance policies,
- 12:53depending on which part of the country. So Florida, it's flood insurance.
- 12:56California, it's fire insurance. Colorado, it's fire insurance.
- 13:00So there's all these insurance things that are really causing,
- 13:04and litigation, causing the attachment market to really struggle.
- 13:09And so single-family detached at all densities, I mean, we're trying to make
- 13:13single-family detached work at 21 of the acre as an example.
- 13:17So everything you can to get fee simple or single-family detached, that's where it's at.
- 13:22And it is the preferred product type too.
- 13:25If consumers can get it, that's what they'll do. But again, you can see the
- 13:29need for multifamily, single-family for rent, and attached and detached for
- 13:34sale across all markets worldwide.
- 13:37U.S. Do you have any data on senior living or this active adult communities?
- 13:42Because we've really seen this, you know, demographic shift and now the old,
- 13:49the fastest growing population is our oldest, 85 and up.
- 13:52And now you've got all the boomers who are going to be 65 and above in the next couple of years.
- 13:56That's going to really shift a lot of opportunity and demand that way.
- 14:00Do you have any data on that?
- 14:02I do. We actually, so as you know, probably for several years and going through
- 14:07to 2030, 10,000 boomers turn 62 a year.
- 14:11Like it's crazy when you look at the numbers that are happening.
- 14:14So yeah, so huge numbers are actually going towards retirement.
- 14:18Average age for retirement is 62 to 67, largely predicated on retirement. We all know that too.
- 14:24Average that will actually purchase into an active adult or age targeted or
- 14:28multi-generational. They're moving from their existing home.
- 14:31Your biggest competition is the home they live in, right? The home they built 30 years of memories.
- 14:35So how do I get that consumer to actually move?
- 14:37So today, I just referred on this to 22% actually want to live in an age-restricted community.
- 14:4419% want to live in an age-targeted community, right?
- 14:48And so the really interesting part of that is about, you know,
- 14:52when you look at those numbers together, 41% want to live in a community without children.
- 14:5959% want to live in a multi-generational community.
- 15:02But I will tell you, working for companies like Adele Web, when the customer
- 15:07who says, I would never live in age-restricted, comes out to an age-restricted
- 15:11neighborhood and sees baseball, rock climbing.
- 15:16Art classes, all the social stuff happening, they're like, hey,
- 15:20this is like Disneyland for adults. This is pretty great.
- 15:22So we start to see that movement really shift.
- 15:26If they've done their jobs right, And they've built these great communities,
- 15:28which so many of them do. So.
- 15:31I think the riveting thing is the percentage of people that want to live in
- 15:34a childless neighborhood.
- 15:35And then when you look at the supply, depending on the market,
- 15:38it's certainly not there.
- 15:39I also think that there is this idea that active adults only want to retire
- 15:45in Florida. It's just not the case.
- 15:48And so getting that dispersed correctly is also super important.
- 15:52And then getting the right amenities.
- 15:54The last part of this, which is essential, is we're seeing a much more ethnically
- 15:58diverse older population, particularly when you look at Gen X and younger,
- 16:03and you will see age-restricted is far more preferred for a Caucasian buyer
- 16:10versus all other cultures.
- 16:13And the reason is they're more likely to not have their children live with them,
- 16:17nor do they even want their children to live with them.
- 16:19And I'm not saying all Caucasians, but it does tend to be a more Caucasian buyer
- 16:24for an age-restricted community.
- 16:26So I do suspect we're going to see more strategy towards targeted.
- 16:30So Pulte's looking at that. Taylor Morrison's looking at that.
- 16:33Some of the other builders are already positioning for more targeted.
- 16:37And not more as it relates to mix, but they're more in their strategy, right?
- 16:41Because we will begin to see that 65-year-old that says, no,
- 16:47I want my grandkids to live with me if I want them to.
- 16:49We're going to see more multi-generational living. We have about 18% of people
- 16:54shopping for a home today that are already in a multi-generational home,
- 16:57whether it's 22-plus-year-old children or their grandparents.
- 17:01So, and look at the cost of taking care of the elderly today. It's insane.
- 17:06So we started talking about boomers. So I want to continue on that path.
- 17:10You actually told me about this, and I find this extremely interesting.
- 17:14You know, we're entering this period of a massive generational wealth transfer
- 17:18transfer from the boomers to their children.
- 17:21How do you expect that transfer to reshape demand?
- 17:24How will it impact product types? Will those change?
- 17:28Will planners do community plans differently in the decade ahead?
- 17:31What can you share with us about that? Yeah. Well, it's staggering right now
- 17:35when you look at already the wealth that is transferring.
- 17:38And there are specific numbers on that. I don't have those exact numbers,
- 17:42but it's billions of dollars that actually will transfer.
- 17:47And the reality is it has to transfer or the poor Gen Y population where the
- 17:53average age, as you know, reported by the National Association of Realtors is
- 17:5840 for a first-time buyer.
- 18:00And so we're starting to see some of that transfer of wealth actually happen
- 18:05to help that poor family that wants to move in California and just can't have a down payment.
- 18:12And so that transfer of wealth isn't happening just when people are passing.
- 18:17That transfer of wealth is happening during their lifetime as well to help their
- 18:21kids move and afford a home today.
- 18:23It's buying a home if you don't live in Ohio, in other parts of the country,
- 18:28even in Texas, you know, to find a home under $450,000 in Austin's a challenge.
- 18:35You know, different parts of Florida, a challenge.
- 18:38Colorado, unheard of. Seattle, really tough.
- 18:42So, Virginia, you know, parts of Loudoun County and, you know,
- 18:45depending on which parts you're looking at on the East Coast, still very, very tough.
- 18:49All right, I've got time for one more question. So I'm going to cut or blend two together.
- 18:54The question is about current home buyer sentiment. So are people feeling optimistic, cautious?
- 19:00And then how do you see or how does Zonda Homes see that transition in the next five to 10 years?
- 19:05Is it still a rose-colored glasses outlook or is it doom and gloom?
- 19:10So that's another one. I have recent stats on that.
- 19:13So the optimism to buy a home today is the lowest it's been in decades.
- 19:19So it's actually a very low percentage. And if you look at the Gallup polls
- 19:24and our poll, they're actually pretty darn similar.
- 19:27So it is the lowest it's been in a couple of decades.
- 19:31So let's hope it's going to get better, right? So and the things that will make
- 19:35it get better, we know it, interest rates, right?
- 19:39Gas prices will have to come down. We're going to have to be more creative about
- 19:43affordable and affordable solutions. So we need policy to support that.
- 19:46We need design to support that. We need the builders to show up and build it.
- 19:51So absolutely, I do think the market has to get better.
- 19:55The one thing I like about a challenging market, and I hate to say there's parts
- 19:59of it that I do like, but there are, is when the market is at its toughest,
- 20:03and I always look to New York in 1977 when I went bankrupt, it had to transform. It had to invent.
- 20:09It had to come up with innovation to survive, and it did. And look at it now, right?
- 20:14And so it's kind of the same thing right now in the market we're in.
- 20:17It's we're going to all have to be better for it.
- 20:19And I think, of course, it will get better because we're, you know,
- 20:23we're smart and we're going to have to move through it.
- 20:27Well, that is about all the time we have for today. Thank you for your positive
- 20:31outlook in a turbulent time.
- 20:33Molly, thank you so much for joining. Thank you to our listeners for tuning
- 20:37in to another episode of the Market Edge podcast.
- 20:40I'm Diana Olaire. See you next time. Thanks for having me.