Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Always Says They Are Too Busy
Transcript
- Lucas: You ask someone to take on a new project and they say, 'I'd love to, but I'm just swamped right now.' And that's it — conversation over. You walk away feeling like you can't push, they walk away feeling justified. But the work still needs to get done. Luna: Right, and the tricky part is — sometimes they genuinely are swamped. But other times, 'too busy' becomes a reflex. A shield. Lucas: Exactly. And as a manager, your job isn't to accept that at face value or to argue with it. It's to get curious. I want to talk about a specific tool I've used and seen work really well. I call it the Busyness Audit. Luna: Okay, I'm listening. Because my first reaction is — that sounds like a lot of tracking. Isn't there a risk the employee feels like you don't trust them? Lucas: Totally fair pushback. And if you frame it as 'I need to check up on how you spend your time,' yeah, that'll backfire. But I've found that if you frame it as coaching — 'help me understand your workload so we can protect your time better' — most people are actually relieved. Luna: Protect their time. I like that reframe. So how does the audit work in practice? Lucas: You ask the employee to keep a simple log for one week. Not a minute-by-minute timesheet — just, at the end of each day, list the major tasks they worked on and roughly how long each one took. Then you sit down together and map every single task against two questions: Does this move a team priority forward? And does this need to be done by you specifically? Luna: So you're basically sorting their work into buckets. High-value, low-value, unique to them, could be done by someone else. Lucas: Exactly. And the results are often surprising. I worked with a product manager at a mid-size SaaS company — let's call her Priya. She managed a senior engineer who constantly said he was too busy for any new feature work. She asked him to do the audit. Turns out he was spending forty percent of his week in internal status meetings that no one had actually asked him to attend. He was attending out of habit. Luna: Forty percent — that's two full days a week. So the audit wasn't about him being lazy. It was about him being stuck in a pattern. Lucas: Exactly. And once they saw it on paper, they could act. They cut him out of five recurring meetings. His calendar freed up instantly. And Priya didn't have to say 'you're not that busy' — the data did the talking. Luna: That's the key, I think. It moves the conversation from subjective — 'you're too busy' versus 'no I'm not' — to objective. Here's the log, here's where the time goes. Lucas: Right. And once the data is on the table, you can have a real conversation about prioritization. Maybe some of those low-value tasks can be deferred. Maybe some can be automated. Maybe the employee is doing work that actually belongs to someone else. Luna: And what about the cases where the audit shows the person genuinely is overloaded? That happens too. Lucas: Then you have an even more valuable conversation. Now you're not guessing — you know. And you can go to your boss or the team and say, 'We need to reprioritize or bring in help, and here's the evidence.' The audit helps the employee, but it also helps you advocate for them. Luna: Okay, so the Busyness Audit is a tool for clarity. But I want to push on something else. What about the employee who isn't actually busy, but has learned that saying 'I'm too busy' is the easiest way to avoid work they don't want to do? Lucas: That's the performative busyness problem, and it's real. In some cultures, being busy is a status signal. If you look overloaded, you look important. The audit exposes that too — because if the log shows ten hours of tasks in a forty-hour week, the conversation shifts from 'you're too busy' to 'what are you doing with the other thirty hours?' Luna: And that's a harder conversation. But at least you're having it based on something concrete, not just a feeling. Lucas: Exactly. And I'd add one more thing: when you introduce the audit, don't single out one person. Frame it as something you're doing with the whole team. 'I want to make sure we're all spending time on what matters most, so let's do a time check-in for a week.' That normalizes it and reduces the defensive response. Luna: That's smart. It becomes a team practice, not a performance review. And honestly, a lot of managers could benefit from doing the audit themselves first. Lucas: Absolutely. I've done it on myself. It's humbling. You realize how much time goes to stuff that isn't your real job. Luna: Speaking of real jobs — Lucas, I know we avoid ads on this show, and we've kept it that way because of listeners who've supported us. If today's episode helped you think about a conversation you need to have, or gave you a tool to try, that's the kind of thing that makes a difference. If it was worth a coffee to you, you can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: And we mean that — it's the smallest possible ask. Even a few bucks helps us keep the show ad-free and focused on practical stuff like this. So thank you to anyone who's already chipped in. Luna: Alright, let's get back to the audit. One thing I want to add: after you've done the audit and reprioritized, what's the follow-up? How do you keep the conversation from just happening once? Lucas: Great question. I recommend a lighter version — a weekly five-minute check-in where you ask two questions: 'What was your most important task this week?' and 'What was the biggest time-waster?' That keeps the habit alive without the heavy logging. Over time, the employee starts self-correcting. Luna: So the goal isn't to monitor them forever. It's to teach them to monitor themselves. Lucas: Exactly. The Busyness Audit is a training wheel. Once they can see their own patterns, they don't need you to point it out. And that's the whole point of management — building self-sufficient team members. Luna: And for the manager listening who's thinking, 'I don't have time to do an audit with every single person' — you don't have to. Pick the one or two people where the 'too busy' reflex is a pattern. That's where it'll have the most impact. Lucas: Good point. And to close with a thought: next time someone tells you they're too busy, resist the urge to get frustrated. Instead, get curious. Say, 'Help me understand what's on your plate. Let's look at it together.' That small shift changes everything. Luna: From accusation to collaboration. I like it. Thanks, Lucas. Lucas: Thanks, Luna. See everyone next week.