Latest / The Learning Corner by Precursor / Episode #28: Fund 1 Over Performance Math, Media and Content Runs VC, Fund Manager Patience
Transcript
- 0:00For any content piece I could find on the Internet, I could easily find another VC who
- 0:04would say it's dead wrong.
- 0:05I tell people, think of these things as inputs that should shape your thinking.
- 0:08They should never tell you what to do or how to do it.
- 0:11It's the week of April 14.
- 0:13Welcome to the Learning Corner, a Precursor Ventures podcast.
- 0:21Welcome to the Learning Corner by Precursor.
- 0:23I'm Mia Farnam, and I'm joined by our GP and managing partner, Charles Hudson, where we'll
- 0:28be talking through the articles and Goodreads that caught our team's attention over the past
- 0:33week.
- 0:34Our first topic is Steve Kim's LinkedIn post, which explores the theory around fund ones and
- 0:39how they often produce some of the best performing venture funds.
- 0:42The core argument is rooted not in the experience or hustle of the fund manager,
- 0:46although that obviously helps, but more so in the math.
- 0:49So fund ones statistically have fatter tails, meaning they're more likely to deliver either
- 0:54outlier returns or dramatic underperformance due to the compounding effects of skill and
- 1:00chance.
- 1:01As a result, exceptional fund one managers can generate returns that outperform their more
- 1:05established peers before regression to the mean kicks in with subsequent funds.
- 1:10So the root of this fund one success is based in compounding effects of skill and chance.
- 1:16So when I was thinking about this after reading it, my question was, is it possible for
- 1:21experienced fund managers to quote, unquote, replicate skill and chance in later funds to
- 1:26create this type of repeated outsized return from your perspective?
- 1:29I always like reading Steve's work.
- 1:31They're very analytical over there at Veritas, so it's helpful when you're a fund one manager
- 1:35to get things like this published.
- 1:36And so I think the answer to your question, Mia, is yes.
- 1:39And I think it's for a couple of reasons.
- 1:41When I think about what you have on your plate as a fund one manager, there is something
- 1:45special.
- 1:46Usually, if you raised your fund, you had some thesis on the world.
- 1:50And if you outperform, usually that thesis on the world was true in that moment.
- 1:54So if you're a specialist fund manager, maybe there was some inflection point in the category
- 1:58that you are focused on that allows you to get into all of these really interesting companies.
- 2:02Maybe it was a founder archetype where I think about, you know, the early days of Felisys when
- 2:06Aiden was really focused on the ex Googler network.
- 2:09Sometimes you have these moment in time, kinda like arbitrage opportunities that you see that
- 2:13other people don't see that can give you outperformance.
- 2:15The other thing on a practical basis is you're not as busy with the other stuff in this
- 2:19business.
- 2:20You don't have a legacy portfolio of companies to support.
- 2:23You don't have a larger staff of people to manage.
- 2:26The job is simpler, and in some ways, it's cleaner and purer.
- 2:29And I think you can recreate this outperformance if you have another one of
- 2:33these, like, big insights on a market shift, which is why I think so much of VC writing is
- 2:39focused on trying to figure out, is x trend the next big paradigm shift?
- 2:43Because if it is, it creates the situation where you can have dramatic outperformance.
- 2:47Like, you know, if you were early on the Internet, if you were early on mobile, in some
- 2:50ways, you were early on crypto, it's unclear to me that being early on AI other than sort of
- 2:55some of the foundation models will end up being a great investment strategy, but we'll find out
- 2:58soon.
- 2:58So I think if you can recreate that beginner's mind and find one of these big technology
- 3:03shifts and actually have the freedom and time to actually invest and take advantage of it,
- 3:08then, yes, you can replicate the performance.
- 3:10But that's a lot of conditional statements.
- 3:12It's fascinating.
- 3:13It also assumes that you're identifying the arbitrage opportunity way before everyone else
- 3:17is, and to your point, have access to and can make those investments quickly.
- 3:22But to your point, working in an earlier stage fund that has not as much infrastructure to
- 3:26create barriers to make quick decisions probably is a is a massive way to kind of a
- 3:30whole leg up.
- 3:31I mean, the other thing I've been thinking about a lot lately is historically, capital has
- 3:35been a business where general partners invest in their immediate network and that proximity
- 3:41is a good signal for quality.
- 3:43And the older you get, the fewer of your friends start companies.
- 3:46Yeah.
- 3:46The ones who are successful retire.
- 3:48The ones who are unsuccessful kinda give up on entrepreneurship, and you get further and
- 3:52further removed from where company creation is happening.
- 3:56And I wonder if part of this is also the age at which most people tend to start their first
- 4:00funds is usually when their friends are in their prime entrepreneurs.
- 4:04So if you think, like, most fund managers I meet are somewhere between very late twenties
- 4:08to mid thirties.
- 4:09Yeah.
- 4:09And oftentimes, that's a period of time where a lot of people in your network are either
- 4:12starting companies or actively involved in managerial roles at meaningful companies.
- 4:17And as you get older, your network gets further removed from company creation.
- 4:20It's been my experience.
- 4:21You have to work much harder to stay close to the metal.
- 4:24Yeah.
- 4:24It leans into another question, which is the dark side of fund one performance is that they
- 4:28drastically underperform, as we mentioned earlier.
- 4:31Taking into account some of the insights from Steve's post, I was wondering if we wanted to
- 4:35zoom out on any specific trends that could lead to that outcome.
- 4:38I was trailing down on some of the messages that were responses to his post, and a lot of
- 4:42them were saying, like, the great ends of this take into account that folks have smaller
- 4:46funds, writing until correctly valued companies and able to move pretty swiftly.
- 4:51So I guess the opposite of that would probably create the inverse scenario of the dark side of
- 4:55fund one outcomes being a little bit more underperforming.
- 4:57Well, I think we've talked about this.
- 4:59Like, the opposite of fortune is misfortune.
- 5:00I talked to an LP this week who told me, like, it's really hard to escape a bad vintage year.
- 5:05And he's like, the only way to escape it is to not play.
- 5:07And so it's very possible, I think, about the COVID era.
- 5:10It's possible that there were good fund one managers who simply chose a really bad market
- 5:15environment in which to do their first fund.
- 5:17Those first funds will underperform, and it's unclear to me whether some of those folks will
- 5:20get a second shot.
- 5:21And we might not actually know if they're any good because of the vintage year effect of when
- 5:26they started.
- 5:26And so it can cut both ways.
- 5:28Like, starting at the wrong time can really set you up for underperformance.
- 5:31I mean, it reminds me of the post that we talked to.
- 5:33Forgot who wrote it, but it's not like, oh, I'm gonna start picking lower valued companies now.
- 5:38You can't just start sacrificing on that just because you're like, this is how I'll continue
- 5:42to win and maintain performance.
- 5:43There's so much macro that you have no control over, which to those fund managers' defense
- 5:48that will ultimately result in if the fund's gonna have another go at it, and a lot of that
- 5:52was completely out of their control.
- 5:53One of the biggest pieces of advice I got when I got started was from other experienced GPs
- 5:57who were just like, make sure your first fund is awesome.
- 6:00If your first fund is awesome, it will buy you a lot of time to figure things out.
- 6:03And I think the same goes I know other venture firms who feel the same way about new GPs.
- 6:07Make sure that their first one or two deals that they work on are awesome Yeah.
- 6:11So that they get the reputational flywheel of being associated with a good company, and so
- 6:15more good companies seek them out.
- 6:16And if you can manufacture or create circumstances where that happens, it sets
- 6:20everybody up for success.
- 6:22Well, it's a good dovetail into our next topic, which is from Paul Smolera's blog, VC Content
- 6:27Club, titled the next great VC firm will be built like a media company from day one, and it
- 6:33outlines why content strategy will become table stakes for emerging funds.
- 6:37He argues that attention, not access, will become the ultimate currency and venture,
- 6:41winning the hearts and minds of founders starting with building belief and narrative
- 6:45power at scale.
- 6:46So the most successful firms will treat content creation like editorial strategy, building
- 6:51repeatable formats and founder for storytelling and multichannel evergreen assets that extend
- 6:57the firm's influence far beyond traditional sourcing.
- 7:00And it's funny.
- 7:01Aliyah, who's on our team, she commented to me that this piece reminds her of the recent New
- 7:05York Times piece, what is venture capital now anyway, where it compared the new and old
- 7:09guards of venture capital and what models are sustaining momentum over time.
- 7:13Media and content were one of the key features in that piece that differentiated the more
- 7:17cottage industry versions of venture capital from what we see today.
- 7:21So my questions are, one, how much do you agree with this type of narrative?
- 7:26And then two, how can you strike a comfortable balance of continuing to put founders at the
- 7:31center while also living in this reality of building a more public brand for your venture
- 7:36fund in parallel?
- 7:37I think it is important to acknowledge that there are some established brands who simply
- 7:42don't need to do this stuff.
- 7:44Like, they don't.
- 7:45They're brands that are well known to and by founders.
- 7:47But I'd argue, you know, I've been in venture twenty plus years.
- 7:50Even your Sequoia and Kleiner work harder to be top of mind with founders than they I'm not
- 7:56saying they didn't work hard before.
- 7:57I think there's a more of a recognition that there's more competition in the business.
- 8:00And so if you just think about it and say, remove the word venture capital.
- 8:04If you're in a business where competition is increasing and the underlying product money is
- 8:09a relative commodity, what if it's like toothpaste?
- 8:12Most of the energy and activity doesn't go into r and d and making new toothpaste.
- 8:16No no offense to anyone who listens to this podcast who makes toothpaste.
- 8:18But a significant amount of the energy goes into marketing the features and benefits of
- 8:23your toothpaste, such that when the consumer goes to Target or their favorite store and sees
- 8:27the wall of toothpaste boxes, they pick yours.
- 8:30And I think in many ways, wooden venture was more of a cottage.
- 8:33You know, the the post talks about like the whisper, the old whisper.
- 8:36It was easy.
- 8:36Founders just talked to other founders.
- 8:38There were relatively few firms you could go to.
- 8:40It was really important that founders said good things about you.
- 8:43But we've dramatically increased the top of funnel of entrepreneurship, and not everybody
- 8:47knows every firm.
- 8:48And so if you're a brand new firm and you're trying to break in, I always tell people, you
- 8:52should assume that the really good founders are getting advice about whose money they should
- 8:56take.
- 8:56They're getting that advice from other founders.
- 8:58They're getting that advice.
- 8:59How do you insert yourself into that conversation?
- 9:01And content is one way you can do it.
- 9:03And I think twenty minute VC and Tomas Timgas are, like, two really different polar examples.
- 9:08You know, Harry makes a ton of podcasts and is really active, and I think that has been
- 9:12unquestionably important for his brand even based on the most recent fund announcement that
- 9:17they had.
- 9:18And Tomas just kind of cranks out data informed posts on a regular basis and has been doing
- 9:23that for a really long time.
- 9:24And those are, like, content strategies that appeal to different audiences.
- 9:28I also think there's another consumer for VC content that isn't the focus of this article,
- 9:33and it's limited partners.
- 9:34I think limited partners also wanna invest in funds that are brands.
- 9:38And I think increasingly, we're moving to a world where individual GPs are mini brands, and
- 9:44founders choose mini brands over firms.
- 9:46I think it's been heading this way for a long time.
- 9:48You know, some of this media is weirdly parasocial.
- 9:51I've talked to founders and, like, you don't actually know that person.
- 9:53You've just read a bunch of their articles and consumed a bunch of their Instagram stories.
- 9:57You actually don't have a bidirectional relationship with this person.
- 10:00You're a fan, which is great.
- 10:01Like, you're fan.
- 10:02Wonderful.
- 10:02But I do think in most ways, I think it's a net positive for our industry that you can use
- 10:08content to launch a new firm.
- 10:10I think that I could name others beyond homebrew, and I think what Sarah's done with
- 10:13conviction Yeah.
- 10:14She's, I think, done a really good job of putting a stamp out there.
- 10:17So the the two things I tell founders is or VC fund founders, people who are starting to own
- 10:21funds, find a content format that you enjoy.
- 10:24Because producing content in a format you don't enjoy will feel like work, and you will
- 10:28inevitably quit doing it because at some point, there'll be something more important to do.
- 10:32And second, make sure the content you're creating is attracting the kind of founders
- 10:35that you wanna attract.
- 10:37So if you wanna be a s h you know what poster on x and be snarky, be prepared to attract the
- 10:43founders who respond to that stuff.
- 10:45Yeah.
- 10:45If that's not who you wanna be, don't do that.
- 10:47People are like, well, I should I wanna write.
- 10:49I wanna blog more.
- 10:49I'm like, do you enjoy writing?
- 10:51They're like, no.
- 10:51I'm like, well, then you should pick a different medium because you're not gonna do
- 10:53it.
- 10:53I can tell who's writing with AI.
- 10:56It's very obvious, everyone, as a PSA.
- 11:00Some of it is very bad, and I the better I know the person I actually did tell somebody.
- 11:04I was like, you need a new ghostwriter, and he's offended.
- 11:07And I was like, no.
- 11:08Your ghostwriter does not sound at all like you.
- 11:11I'm stuck on your toothpaste example.
- 11:13It's funny, and I'm thinking about myself in the founder's shoes.
- 11:16I go into the supermarket.
- 11:17I go select my toothpaste and the wall of toothpaste.
- 11:19They all say that they basically do all these amazing things that are unique and different
- 11:22and going to help and improve my health.
- 11:24I assume they all do the same thing, and I think that's my question about this comparison.
- 11:28At the end, I'm just looking for toothpaste.
- 11:30I just need it to survive.
- 11:31I've never had the outcome though of a toothpaste drastically being the reason why I'm
- 11:36going to the dentist and having cavities.
- 11:38So my question to you is, how much is that live in venture where it was marketed as such and it
- 11:43actually does the inverse of what you wanted to creates a negative impact for the trajectory of
- 11:48your company?
- 11:49I think I've seen people with content create expectations for founders of what, you know,
- 11:53the money I'll call the money plus bundle.
- 11:55You're gonna get money plus something else, money plus advice, money plus platform
- 11:58services, money plus this operator network.
- 12:01I've certainly seen some toothpaste that purports to cure cavities.
- 12:04And so people buy it, and they're like, oh, I still have cavities.
- 12:07And I'm like, you know what?
- 12:08Their go to market support team can't help you if you don't have product market fit.
- 12:11It's not a failure of their platform team.
- 12:13It's a failure of your company to find product market fit.
- 12:15And I have seen people who've been like, wow.
- 12:17I was promised the moon and the stars, and I I didn't get it.
- 12:20I do think, for me, the toothpaste analogy stands because every now and then in
- 12:24toothpaste, you get something like whitening or you get brightening or you get natural
- 12:28toothpaste.
- 12:29You you get these, like, different flavors.
- 12:31And all those different flavors are designed to appeal to people with different preference
- 12:35functions.
- 12:35Yeah.
- 12:36And so some people want Crest and Colgate because you can get it everywhere and it's very
- 12:40reliable.
- 12:40Other people like Tom's.
- 12:42Other people want whatever the new Instagram influencer, social media toothpaste is.
- 12:46I think about a lot of the people that I'd meet.
- 12:49And it's funny when I talk to founders, they'll bring up like a Nicole Wischoff.
- 12:52They'll bring up people who have what I would describe as, like, pretty strong points of view
- 12:56online.
- 12:56And I think it creates in the mind of founders a point of view about that investor in a way
- 13:01that if you're just kinda doing your job and quiet, people might not know you and might not.
- 13:04By the way, there are also people in this business who are wildly successful who produce
- 13:07no content
- 13:08Right.
- 13:09Who do none of this stuff to, who are emerging managers.
- 13:11And those people, I find, tend to be embedded in networks where content consumption of that
- 13:15type doesn't matter.
- 13:16And they've created something a little bit more proprietary, not to overuse the word, but for
- 13:20their deal flow.
- 13:21My one last question here, and again, putting myself in the shoes of a founder, Paul's claims
- 13:25that the most successful firms will think like a newsroom about your entire platform, and I
- 13:30can certainly see this executed well.
- 13:31And so he mentioned Hunter.
- 13:33I think Stephanie and Artemis does a good job.
- 13:35Olivia at Forum has been starting to put out content of her own.
- 13:37But like real life newsrooms, it's easy to start launching really biased content in favor
- 13:43of your own fun, strategy, beliefs, and venture at large.
- 13:46And I think from a founder standpoint, it does create a very noisy LinkedIn.
- 13:51I just chatted with one of my other friends who's a founder, and she said, I can't even go
- 13:54to LinkedIn.
- 13:55I just feel like I'm so overwhelmed by self promotional content.
- 13:58So founders are just perhaps a bit overwhelmed by content and just fall numb to old
- 14:03narratives.
- 14:04So I'd love to hear what you think about this and kind of how to guide founders in the
- 14:08direction of how do you find people who are putting out the content that you like and also
- 14:11being open minded about what that means.
- 14:14I think you should never take something you read and immediately go implement it at your
- 14:18company.
- 14:18I don't care who wrote it.
- 14:19After the Toby AI internal memo, a few people were like, we're doing this at my company.
- 14:23I'm like, why?
- 14:24You have 50 people.
- 14:25Why?
- 14:25Like, are you sure this is the right answer?
- 14:27So I don't care who wrote it.
- 14:28Don't blindly take someone's content piece.
- 14:30Second, I often encourage founders, think about the lens through which this person views the
- 14:34world.
- 14:34And with that lens, why is what they're writing true?
- 14:37And do you look at the world through the same lens?
- 14:39And I think for any content piece I could find on the Internet, I could easily find another VC
- 14:44who would say it's dead wrong.
- 14:45Why it's great to be a solo founder?
- 14:46Why you should never start a company alone?
- 14:48Why you should raise the most money possible?
- 14:50And so I tell people, think of these things as inputs that should shape your thinking.
- 14:54They should never tell you what to do or how to do it.
- 14:56You know, not everybody can watch two hours of content from one point of view and two hours of
- 15:01content from the opposite point of view.
- 15:03For some people, that's like very enriching.
- 15:04They're like, oh, I have a more complete picture.
- 15:06For other people, it's overwhelming.
- 15:07It's too much to process.
- 15:08So just be honest about who you are.
- 15:10I was listening to this great, I almost put it in the channel this weekend.
- 15:13There's a really good capital allocators interview with Howard Marks.
- 15:17It's an older interview that Mhmm.
- 15:18It's a previous interview, but she's talking about private credit.
- 15:21And and talking about when he writes memos, he's like, I write memos when I have something
- 15:25to say that I feel like others haven't said.
- 15:27And I was like, that's kind of like my writing process too, which yields about one article a
- 15:31month, maybe.
- 15:31In some months, it yields nothing.
- 15:32And so I think if you're like, hey, we're gonna post on LinkedIn every day, you will become
- 15:37like cable news.
- 15:37Hey, we're on for twenty four hours, so whatever we have to write about something
- 15:41today.
- 15:41What's the something?
- 15:42And so I've never wanted to be beholden to a content calendar where, hey, it's Tuesday.
- 15:47You gotta publish something.
- 15:49And so I do think some people have taken the content thing too far.
- 15:52I talked to somebody who's been in the venture services ecosystem for thirty years, and we
- 15:56were talking about Josh Koppelman at First Round.
- 15:58And he's like, the thing that they got right is almost every piece of content they publish has
- 16:03the founder as the core audience and has something valuable for founders to read.
- 16:07It's very rarely about first round is awesome.
- 16:09Like, round review is like, these are good articles, and these are situations you are
- 16:13likely to encounter as a founder.
- 16:14And here are some it's kind of a mini MBA.
- 16:16Here are some frameworks to think about when you encounter this situation.
- 16:19And I think, ironically, that's kind of the best way to get known is for creating things of
- 16:23value, not by being self promotional.
- 16:25Totally agree.
- 16:26I would say, like, on LinkedIn, I try to diversify what things I engage with because I
- 16:31know, similar to any other social media platform, it will create things that it thinks
- 16:35that I like, and then all of my content will look very similar, and it'll all be saying the
- 16:39same things.
- 16:40And the one thing I will say is I echo, just find a form of content that you like to create,
- 16:44but also that you're good at creating.
- 16:46I personally, hence why we're doing a podcast.
- 16:48I'm very long winded as pertains to writing, so I would never be launching venture reflections
- 16:53like Charles would.
- 16:55It's just not my medium.
- 16:56Our final topic is a recent LinkedIn post written by Jenny Fielding, who's the cofounder
- 17:00and managing partner at Everywhere Ventures, which reflects on the long feedback cycles of
- 17:05early stage venture.
- 17:06She recounts how it took five and a half years of investing with no liquidity and plenty of
- 17:10second guessing before a surprise acquisition by a Fortune 500 company returned her fund
- 17:15several times over.
- 17:16So despite the success, she finds herself doubting her firm's momentum only to be
- 17:20reassured by moments like recent week where five portfolio founders received term sheets
- 17:25from top funds.
- 17:26So she highlights the importance of patience to remain calm throughout the roller coaster of an
- 17:30early stage VC.
- 17:31I'm sure Jenny's sentiments ring true for a lot of early stage venture funds and managers that
- 17:36we've talked at length here about the importance of patience in a market like the one
- 17:40we're in, but also honestly always in venture.
- 17:44Just wanted to get closing thoughts on that one from you.
- 17:47That one definitely made the rounds in my PC manager WhatsApps.
- 17:51Like, the amount of public commentary in that article is maybe a tenth of the private
- 17:54commentary I've seen.
- 17:55Yeah.
- 17:55And I think if anybody other than Jenny wrote it, I'd be like, this is maybe a humble brag.
- 17:59But it's really honest because I know Jenny, and that sounds like her.
- 18:02I think for a lot of people, including myself, that's what 2023 and the first half of twenty
- 18:08twenty four felt like because we went from an era where I think a lot of LPs who invested in
- 18:13pre seed and seed stage funds were like, yes, we wanna see performance, but we also
- 18:16understand this is a long game and the performance won't show up overnight.
- 18:20And it felt like LPs were gonna give you the time for things to mature.
- 18:24And then between interest rates going up, public markets being volatile, LPs just needing
- 18:29liquidity, Suddenly, a lot of pre seed and seed managers, there was this very pointed question,
- 18:34like, where's my money?
- 18:34Yeah.
- 18:35Where's the DPI?
- 18:36And I think for a lot of us, I won't speak for everyone else, for me, it did cause moments of
- 18:40doubt where I was just like, wow.
- 18:41It has been a while.
- 18:42We haven't returned as much money as I'd like.
- 18:44What if collectively we're not as good at this job as we thought?
- 18:47And then, you know, you get a secondary here or there.
- 18:49You get some markups and you feel better.
- 18:51But I think this is the hardest emotional roller coaster part about being a VC.
- 18:55I told one of our LPs over the weekend, you know, I talk to a hundred to a 20 portfolio
- 19:00companies a month.
- 19:01Maybe 5% of them are just on fire doing great.
- 19:04The rest of them are somewhere between completely struggling and, like, chugging
- 19:08along.
- 19:08And the weight of doing that month after month, sometimes it's hard to just continually look at
- 19:12a big portfolio and a large basket of companies and say, like, where are the winners?
- 19:16And, you know, we have a few companies in our portfolio that emerged in the last two years,
- 19:20and that's a ten year old fund.
- 19:22And I assume the same will happen in funds two, three, four, and now fund five.
- 19:25We will have late breaking winners, and we will also have companies that we were really excited
- 19:29about for the first seven years that will falter.
- 19:31And so I think there was very little patience in our business, both on the part of LPs and
- 19:36GPs in the last two years.
- 19:37I think everybody wanted to to know, like, am I okay?
- 19:40Yeah.
- 19:40And it feels like slowly but surely we're going back to a new equilibrium, which will be more
- 19:45patient than that time, but probably not as patient as days past.
- 19:48Well, we are all out of time for today.
- 19:50Thank you, Charles, for stopping by the Learning Corner, and thank you to all our
- 19:52listeners for popping by.
- 19:54Please like and subscribe, and we will see you all next week.
- 19:57Thanks.