Latest / The Vegan Report / Veterinarians Are Not The Villains. With Dr. Heath, Dr. Zamzow & Dr. Gianni | Ep. 48
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to The Vegan Report. My name is Ryan and two months ago in Austin, Texas, the American
- 0:08Veterinary Medical Association held a convention where its house delegates voted to codify
- 0:16ventilation shutdown mass killings as part of its new principles of veterinary medical
- 0:23ethics. By doing so, they basically gave their blessings to Big Ag for killing hundreds of
- 0:32pigs or poultry at once by shutting off air supply and driving up temperatures to cook
- 0:39them alive to leave them agonizing for hours before dying from suffocation or organ failure.
- 0:48This, for the representation of the veterinary profession, was deemed not only tolerable
- 0:56but ethical. How can people who have been trained to heal animals come to vote for this
- 1:06abominable practice? What is up with veterinarians? To get some answers, I talked to three amazing
- 1:15vegan veterinarians, Dr. Crystal Heath, Dr. Niki Gianni, and Dr. Aaron Zamso, and a big
- 1:24thank you to Aaron, who was the one who came up with this idea of a group conversation.
- 1:31They convinced me to suspend my judgment of veterinarians and instead try to understand
- 1:38why the veterinary profession is the way it is and how veterinarians could become the
- 1:45key powerful allies the animal rights movement needs.
- 1:51My first question for you is what makes you different from other veterinarians? What differentiates
- 1:59you from the veterinarians we know? Those who treat and care for our dogs and cats or
- 2:07who visit our local farms? Let's start with Crystal.
- 2:16I would say with anybody, if I lived their life and had their experiences, I would do
- 2:25exactly as they're doing and say that I would be acting different or saying things different.
- 2:31I would say I'm somehow better than them or worse than me. That's just not true. We're
- 2:36all, I for one, am very fortunate. I've given my life experiences and who I've met in my
- 2:43life and how I grew up. It gave me a certain perspective on life and I think it made me
- 2:53see things for what they are and saw how veterinarians are often in our training were normalized
- 3:03to violence against animals and were conditioned into the system. My certain personality traits,
- 3:11I'm just one who's willing to not go along with the flow. I never felt like I needed
- 3:18to be popular or needed to fit in or any of that. That allowed me to take a step back
- 3:26and look at the whole problem and see what our profession was doing to animals.
- 3:32I think that is what led me down this path to speaking out about the abuses of animals
- 3:40in our society and how veterinarians have become complacent in that and what we can
- 3:45do to help inform and educate and empower veterinarians to see this for themselves too.
- 3:53Hopefully I can be that person in other veterinarians' life that I benefited from growing up so that
- 4:01we can educate more veterinarians and help them wake them up to what our profession has
- 4:06been complacent in.
- 4:07Thank you, Crystal. What about you, Erin?
- 4:11Yeah, I definitely agree with Crystal that it's a life experiences, interpersonal relationships,
- 4:22things that you encounter along your journey all shape your perspective. I didn't start
- 4:28out in veterinary medicine thinking that I would be an animal activist per se. I think
- 4:35to a degree every person who goes into veterinary medicine, they're going in it because they
- 4:41really want to help better the lives and well-being of animals. From that standpoint, a lot of
- 4:48us start from a very similar place.
- 4:55I've also never been a huge rule follower from that standpoint, just always questioning
- 5:01things. But I had an experience in veterinary school. I was fortunate enough to have a classmate
- 5:14I became very close to, we became very good friends that was more aware of the issues,
- 5:23both with animal farming and things like the terminal surgeries that we were going to be
- 5:30asked to do, how we were taught surgery and different procedures, emergency procedures.
- 5:36I really have that person to thank for encouraging that awakening. I would say a lot of it started
- 5:44even my freshman year of veterinary school just learning how animals were raised in production.
- 5:53That sparked a lot of curiosity, a lot of frustration, sadness, outrage. It really shifted
- 6:01my perspective. I would say it was a turning point in my life. Also because I had a relationship
- 6:13with someone that I trusted and that I cared about, that helped to shift that. There were
- 6:25times when I didn't feel very brave going through veterinary school, challenging the
- 6:30status quo and having that person in your corner for me, for my personality, really
- 6:36helped. It's just taken off from there. I would say also, and I can say this as someone
- 6:45who went to veterinary school in the 1980s and a lot of things have changed since then,
- 6:49a lot of perspective that are much more mainstream were not so much back then, that I can speak
- 6:55from experience from things that I have done that I would not do at this stage and that
- 7:01I wish I hadn't done, even in pre-veterinary school and life. It comes from that personal
- 7:11reflection and growth and evaluation as you go through life of, hmm, wow, why did I do
- 7:20that? I think it's really important not to put anyone who is passionate about a
- 7:31certain area or is active in trying to change things in a certain area on some kind of a
- 7:37moral pedestal because it is all about our journeys and we need to be able to have these
- 7:42conversations and be real. I think that's a big criticism of veganism to begin with.
- 7:51That's why I said, well, it's not like it's cruelty-free because you're killing bugs and
- 7:59you're killing rodents in those fields and all that and that's true. There's no such
- 8:05thing as a cruelty-free lifestyle. I think that's important. Different life experiences
- 8:15and just the machinations of the brain and the mind and the direction that feels like
- 8:26is where I need to go. Thank you, Erin. I hear a lot of humility in both of your answers.
- 8:35What about you, Nikki? Hopefully I can be as eloquent as these two. I think I came from
- 8:42a slightly different perspective in terms of veterinary school as I was already well
- 8:47into my activism and veganism and had to cover it a little bit, if you will, to get into
- 8:54vet school. I wasn't sure how deep of a dive they would do into their applicants. Although
- 9:00I can tell you that one question that I was asked at the interview, and I don't think
- 9:04this is a secret, it's available on Google and any sources for those prepping for interviews,
- 9:10but was what was the difference between animal rights and animal welfare? They're at least
- 9:17curious where you stand on that. It's not to say you wouldn't get in if you said maybe
- 9:22you were leaning animal rights, but I think the conservative nature of vet schools prefers
- 9:28if you perhaps lean animal welfare as of at least when I was interviewing 10 years ago.
- 9:37When I was a kid, well, when I was real young, my family was like every other American family
- 9:45going to circuses and we bought our puppies all from the pet store and just a nice little
- 9:52Italian family that made meat in every food that we ate, meat in the salad, meat in the
- 9:58dessert practically. My kind of changing point was with Lolita the orca. I don't know if
- 10:08you can see behind me, but I have a giant wall of Lolita the orca from Miami Seaquarium,
- 10:15pictures and posters from throughout the years. To keep it brief, my mom was planning a trip
- 10:21to SeaWorld because it seemed like that's where you take kids in the 90s and kids love
- 10:27whales and it's just like the two other doctors have mentioned already. I think people who
- 10:34want to go to SeaWorld or they want to become a veterinarian, they want to do those things
- 10:39because they love animals. It's not that they want to go there to support any kind of oppression
- 10:44or be a bad guy. We were looking into this trip to SeaWorld and even in the 90s, my mom
- 10:53was able to find very much pre-Blackfish and pre-the-cove days. There wasn't a lot of resources
- 11:01online about captivity for orcas and how detrimental it was, but she found some sources that said,
- 11:07oh, okay, maybe going to SeaWorld isn't the most ethical trip we could take. We went whale
- 11:13watching in Seattle instead. That was beautiful and I think that changed the course of my life
- 11:20because she told me about Lolita, one particular orca who is suffering for 50 plus years in a
- 11:28very, very tiny cramped concrete bland, boring enclosure who unfortunately passed away last
- 11:36year in the same enclosure. That got the spark going for me. While we certainly did not go
- 11:45vegan right away, my mom and I became passionate about whales and captivity and then it transformed
- 11:53into like, okay, maybe we should protest the circus when they come to town. Maybe we should
- 11:58get our dogs from the shelter. Then lastly, because food is closest to your heart and usually most
- 12:04personal and when you're a child living under your parents' roof, it is difficult to go vegan or
- 12:11vegetarian. But then eventually we did go vegan in 2007 and then I went to vet school in 2015.
- 12:19I was pretty well on my journey, but everybody's at a different part of their journey as these other
- 12:26two have very eloquently said. Hopefully that covers it.
- 12:29Thank you, Nikki. It's fascinating how the three of you have had such different experiences of
- 12:40getting to where you are now in your reflection and in your advocacy work. Erin, you wanted to
- 12:46intervene. It was interesting that you made the comment about the veterinary school interview.
- 12:52Nikki, I was just talking to a pre-veterinary student yesterday that's been shadowing me on
- 12:57some things. It's really neat to see this person doing a lot of different kinds of shadowing and
- 13:10getting these experiences, but also being very open to learning about the issues in veterinary
- 13:17medicine that we're grappling with and the animal rights, animal welfare. She asked me about that
- 13:26question. She's like, I'm just not sure. How do you see that? I said, I think the way I could put it
- 13:31most succinctly is that animals have rights to welfare. If we look at the five freedoms and how
- 13:43the welfare is really defined, they have rights to that. Also, how can you say a living being does
- 13:54not have some inherent rights? If there's any pre-veterinary students out there, I don't know
- 14:04if that would be helpful or if they would get press for more information, but I feel like it's
- 14:09such a common sense thing. It's like they have rights to welfare, and we have the obligation to
- 14:15provide that and ensure those rights. I don't know if that would be helpful or not.
- 14:23Well, I think we're getting to the heart of the problem, which is vet school. I feel like this is
- 14:31the conditioning you were talking about, Crystal, of other vets and that force for shaping
- 14:42the normal standard view of what are animals and how they should be treated.
- 14:50I think it's all coming from the schools. Crystal, I start with you. What do you have to say about
- 14:59the schools? Are they broken? Are vet schools broken? What are they teaching to most vets out there?
- 15:10Well, this is just the inherent problem with medical culture in general, and we've seen this
- 15:14with the human medical profession as well. Carl Elliott just wrote a really brilliant book called
- 15:20The Occasional Human Sacrifice, and it's all about the atrocities that happened in human experimentation.
- 15:27He talks about, of course, Tuskegee is the most famous story, the Tuskegee Syphilis Study,
- 15:34where doctors allowed Black people with syphilis to not be treated, even though there was a known
- 15:42treatment for syphilis for 40 years. This study was stopped in the 1970s, and it wasn't until
- 15:49the 90s that we really started to address the issue. Alison Coppola wrote this brilliant essay
- 15:58about this in the British Medical Journal, about how medical culture conditions us
- 16:03to be susceptible to committing mass atrocities. It's the hierarchy. It's our desire to get ahead
- 16:11and be successful. It's the use of euphemisms in our training, and it's the normalization to pain.
- 16:19We have to see patients who are in pain, and we have to often inflict pain upon them in order to
- 16:25help heal them or in experimentation in order to increase our medical knowledge.
- 16:34That becomes really problematic. Then there's the additional problem of when you have an institution
- 16:40that is very prestigious, everybody thinks that and has the cause of doing good. Everybody has
- 16:50the idea that our cause is good, this institution is very prestigious, has a high barrier to entry,
- 16:58it's very hard to get into, so all of our decisions that we make must also be good.
- 17:03It's often these institutions that are very prestigious and have this high, this moral good
- 17:13aim that are often the last to realize that they have committed atrocities, that they have been
- 17:19complacent in causing harm. That's just the inherent problem with the whole structure.
- 17:26But there is hope, because Stanley Milgram's studies really pointed this out. This famous
- 17:32shock studies where a student was asked to repeatedly shock somebody until they died,
- 17:39and they would do this because we have this inherent desire to do what is expected of us.
- 17:46It's our default, we do what is expected, especially by an authority figure. But when there
- 17:51was another authority figure who voiced concerns about what was going on, that tipped the scales
- 17:57for students to obey their conscience. I think that's what we are doing, and that's what we're
- 18:02trying to do, is be that authority figure that is voicing concerns, saying, hey, this is a problem.
- 18:11That will, even if it's just one voice, will tip the scales to allowing and enabling others to
- 18:18listen to their conscience. We just want to encourage everybody, if you're in that room and
- 18:23you're feeling pressured to stay silent and not say anything as something bad is happening,
- 18:30speak up and be that voice to tip the scales to allow others to listen to their conscience.
- 18:36Thank you, Crystal. Nikki, does this point resonate with you?
- 18:40Yeah, I think the prestigiousness of the universities, especially, or I guess I shouldn't
- 18:47say especially, but when you think of veterinary medicine, I guess a lot of folks probably aren't
- 18:51aware, but I think at this point, there's maybe 30 vet schools in the United States and maybe
- 18:58three to five in Canada. They are very difficult to get into. There's this air of, okay, well,
- 19:08hey, they can do no wrong because this is where all the vets have to go. There's no alternative
- 19:15school, basically, but I think the schools have made a minute bit of progress in that hopefully,
- 19:23Crystal would probably know better on this statistics, but hopefully we're seeing less
- 19:27terminal surgeries. That was not something that we had to do in vet school, at least.
- 19:33A terminal surgery would be, for instance, like a dog spay where then the animal is euthanized on
- 19:40the table and doesn't wake up afterwards. At my vet school training, we adopted the animals out
- 19:49to a shelter afterwards, though I'm sure there are still significant trainings where maybe they're
- 19:57doing something a little bit more intense like removing a kidney or something like that where
- 20:01they probably do euthanize on the table. I think that is a good example of what we're seeing.
- 20:09I think that is still obviously very problematic and hopefully we're moving a little bit further
- 20:15away from that. I think a lot of the times with these vet schools, it's like, well, this is how
- 20:23we've always done things. Although the medical schools, you could say the same thing. Maybe their
- 20:29grandpa was a doctor, their dad was a doctor, they're a doctor, and this is just how we do
- 20:35things. Medicine itself has advanced, but maybe some of the ethics are a little bit more gray area.
- 20:42CB Thank you, Nikki. Erin?
- 20:44EW Yeah, I wanted to speak to the point about
- 20:50it was really hard for me to speak out initially and I'm glad I had that friend. I had friends and
- 21:02family and people when I was in veterinary school being, don't rock the boat, get out, you can do
- 21:08so much good once you have that degree. At that time, I was threatened with being like, goodbye,
- 21:17you can't stay here if you're going to do that. It took a bit of doing to get our program through,
- 21:26get through with our little semblance of our conscience and soul intact, but that was back
- 21:32in the 1980s. But I think a lot of people don't, it is really, really hard to speak out against the
- 21:42tide for some people and some personalities. But I think even encouraging, just questioning,
- 21:51just having that reflective conversation where people have to explain why this is okay.
- 22:00And then if you have some data or you have some information, well, I actually know veterinarians
- 22:05who trained and didn't do these terminal surgeries or have successful practices and they don't do
- 22:13declives or ear cropping. So it's questioning. And we have these ethics classes in vet school
- 22:29and I remember it was Bernard Rollins that came to do ours. And I feel like we had all these
- 22:39conversations and then everybody just sort of like, okay, that's great. You know, and didn't apply it.
- 22:50So when we as either, you know, in veterinary school, out of veterinary school, experienced
- 22:57veterinarians of whatever, wherever we are in our, in our circles, can question and speak out. It does,
- 23:07it sparks thought. And especially if you can have a nice, I was with a couple of veterinarians
- 23:14yesterday, equine veterinarians, and this pre-vet student was kind of shadowing and working with us.
- 23:23And I brought up about the ventilation shutdown and the changing of the ethics committee and
- 23:34wording and all that. These two vets had no idea and they were in complete agreement, complete
- 23:40agreement. And they're like, you know, one of them is mixed animals, these farm animals, small
- 23:45animals, you know, horses, all about one another one's exclusively equine and they both completely
- 23:52agreed that like, what, what's going on here? You know, why would, why would we not condemn this as
- 24:00an organization? Why don't, why aren't we doing more to ensure? And of course, we talked about the
- 24:05corporate influence and the, you know, money that drives so much of our, our unethical practices.
- 24:15So questioning and building relationships with people just as in their vet and a human being
- 24:21without putting that initially forward, you know, finding your commonalities first, you know,
- 24:29your commonalities first, I think can be very helpful. Thank you, Erin. Crystal, you wanted to
- 24:37react to Erin's point. Yeah, I'll just say like, as far as questioning, it's really hard to question
- 24:44when you're a vet student, because they have answers to all of these common questions, like,
- 24:49oh, you know, there are successful practices that don't be caught. Well, then they'll say, well,
- 24:54then, you know, are people euthanizing their cats because they're scratching them or scratching
- 25:00their furniture? You know, they have rationalizations for this. And we have, you know,
- 25:07it's a long conversation because, you know, yeah, there are studies now that show that when in areas
- 25:14that cat decline is, is banned, they, they don't actually have increased euthanasia rates, but
- 25:22students might not have all of this data in front of them. So they don't know how to retort to that.
- 25:28And it's, it's hard when you have a professor who has the platform, and you question them, and then
- 25:35they respond back, you can often look foolish or, you know, just give them another platform to
- 25:41legitimize and further entrench their belief system to 138 members of the class. So it is very,
- 25:48it is very, very challenging to do this. So I will just say that. And as far as
- 25:55the corporate influence in our veterinary schools, you have to remember, like, a lot of veterinary
- 26:00schools are these land grant universities. That was the, the purpose of these universities was
- 26:07to expand agriculture back in the 1800s. And corporations fed a lot of money into these
- 26:14universities and their purpose was to increase the productivity of American agriculture.
- 26:22And the animal rights movement sort of kept away from the veterinary profession for all of these
- 26:27years and didn't engage with them. And I think that was a huge detriment to the animal rights
- 26:35movement for not getting more veterinarians on board. They easily, and especially the, the violence
- 26:43with which some animal rights activists engaged with veterinarians. There's all these stories of
- 26:52veterinarians being bullied and harassed and getting death threats from animal rights activists,
- 26:58which I don't think a true animal rights activist would threaten the life of another human being,
- 27:04because humans are animals, so it doesn't make sense. But there are, you know, people who are
- 27:10unstable out there who do that sort of thing. But then all animal rights activists were painted with
- 27:15this broad brush and no veterinarians had a good experience with animal rights activists. I remember
- 27:22first getting involved into the animal rights movement and getting a lot of hostility from
- 27:28animal rights activists who are like, what's wrong with your profession? And like questioning,
- 27:33spaying and neutering and things like that. And I, just because of who I am and me feeling totally
- 27:39comfortable not fitting in, but knowing that their goals are good and I could help shape this movement
- 27:46to better work for animals instead of work against animals, I felt like, oh, here's a problem we need
- 27:53to address within the animal rights movement. And a lot of people are, are, are animal rights activists,
- 27:58not because they love animals, but they, because, and especially, unfortunately men realized, oh,
- 28:05this is a group of women who are very empathetic. And now I have this argument where I can be morally
- 28:12superior to other people. I'm going to, you know, get involved with this movement, get access to all
- 28:18of these women and become like a thought leader in this movement in order to gain some sense of power
- 28:24in society, which is very problematic, which is something else that we need to address in the
- 28:28animal rights movement. But yeah, I'll just add that. And now I think it's time for animal rights
- 28:34activists to engage empathetically with the veterinary profession and together we can really
- 28:40move things forward. Yeah. And so to continue off that, I actually found a little photo from
- 28:49when I was in vet school, we had a day of, you know, ethics based talks, like Dr. Aaron had
- 28:56mentioned as well. And, you know, a day devoted to ethics, as opposed to your four years of education
- 29:03in vet school and like your four years of pre-vet and all the other years of training you have.
- 29:08But nonetheless, for this day of ethics, we had a computerized vote where you could vote from a
- 29:15clicker device from your desk. And it was anonymous, but the professor asked, which of the
- 29:22following is the greatest concern to animal welfare? And this was in 2016. And the options
- 29:28were obesity in pet dogs, dehorning cattle without anti-inflammatories, castrating piglets without
- 29:36local anesthetic, keeping free ranging carnivores in zoological collections, or another issue.
- 29:43And the overwhelming response was 53% of students voted obesity in pet dogs as the number one animal
- 29:53welfare issue in 2016. And, you know, it's hard to say because 11% voted that another issue was the
- 30:02most important. I think that was probably me and a few of my friends, you know, and the second most
- 30:09common option, neither of the two farmed animal related options was of course, free ranging
- 30:16carnivores in zoological collections as another issue. Dehorning cattle without anti-inflammatories
- 30:24got 5% of the vote and castrating piglets without local anesthetic got 11% of the vote. So, I mean,
- 30:32you know, fairly concerning numbers. I think a lot of it is just very institutionalized for us by
- 30:41even that point. So that was two years into my vet school experience. You know, a lot of folks had
- 30:47been shadowing at farms, or maybe they grew up again at their mom or dad's vet clinic. And these
- 30:53were kind of the ways that they had seen things done. And yeah, I mean, I think dogs being obese
- 30:59is a concern that I see every day at work. But I don't think it's probably like the number one
- 31:05animal welfare issue in the entire country. Thank you, Nikki. You all raised so many good points I
- 31:12want to get back to. But first of all, I want to ask you, do you think there is a difference,
- 31:19like a fundamental difference between veterinarians who work for the big ag industry,
- 31:27and the rest of veterinarians? Erin, you were talking about, you know, those veterinarians
- 31:35friends who reacted quite with shock on the decision related to ventilation shut down.
- 31:47And I was thinking, you know, is this push to treat animals the way we treat objects?
- 31:56Is it more coming from, you know, vets who are working in the big ag industry? Are they the ones
- 32:03you know, carrying that ideology and that perspective? And the rest of veterinarians
- 32:12are more sympathetic to your views, but feel, I guess, overwhelmed by this majority or powerful
- 32:24minority, you tell me, of farm vets? I'm not sure I can adequately answer that, because I feel like
- 32:37every, everybody is, has the capacity to, to shift their perspective, and, you know, know better,
- 32:49and, you know, know better, do better, and, and that sort of thing. I actually do consult with,
- 32:57so at the Sanctuary, we have three cattle, we had four, now we have three Jersey cattle that came
- 33:02from Farm Sanctuary, California. And I consult with cattle, veterinarians and large animal vets,
- 33:12so veterinarians in the industry frequently. And there are some that have been, like I was on a
- 33:22cattle vet, you know, discussion group, and that was like, why would you have cows in Sanctuary,
- 33:28you know, that kind of thing. But I would say, for the most part, you know, I say,
- 33:32I explain myself and say, these are, think of them as pets. Think of them as how you would treat a pet
- 33:39horse or, or something. So I qualify that. And, but I, I'm, I consult with a very prominent cattle
- 33:53veterinarian that does, I believe she's at Oklahoma, that does a lot of education. She has
- 33:59large animal continuing education service. And she's fantastic. She completely understands my
- 34:06perspective. So I'm probably not answering your question at all. I don't, it's, it's an industry.
- 34:16It's, it's a system. And so yeah, there are going to be differences in, in perspectives, but I don't
- 34:26think because you work in the animal agricultural industry, that you're immune to seeing animals as
- 34:37individuals and, and caring for them. I think most people just see it as an inevitability, maybe,
- 34:47or, or see that we may need to increase welfare in farming and are against like corporate animal ag.
- 35:00So I'm not, I'm not, it's not probably not really
- 35:05answering your question, but I see it as a, as like a system problem. And I don't see veterinarians
- 35:12as, as being the drivers of that system. I see capitalism and the commodification of animals
- 35:20as a business model, as drivers of that system. Thank you, Erin. If that helps at all. Well,
- 35:28Crystal, you wanted to react? Yeah. So I've read a lot of the internal emails of veterinarians who
- 35:38legitimize ventilation shutdown. So I think I have unique insight into their thought processes
- 35:44going, leading up to this. And there's a lot of things that they, they, there's a set of beliefs
- 35:49that they have been led to believe. And one of their main concerns was, oh, these producers
- 35:58are not able to put food on their tables. Like if this were to happen, this work would threaten food
- 36:05security if, you know, they aren't able to get bailouts for the loss of their animals. And also
- 36:13they believe that demand for meat is rising because of consumer demand, because people want to eat
- 36:22meat. And because when people, when a nation gains the enough wealth to eat meat, people naturally do
- 36:32when they can afford to. They believe that it's a consumer driven thing. It's, it's inherent in
- 36:38humanity to want to eat meat when they can afford it. And we know that's not true. We know now from
- 36:45economics, it's the industry when the industry is trying to upsell basically cheap grain into a more
- 36:53valuable commodity. And Cargill has a lot to do with it. Cargill, one of the biggest agribusiness
- 36:58companies in the world has 21 billionaires. They are, and the industry is working very hard to
- 37:05increase demand for meat. So it's the industry driving demand. It's not people driving demand
- 37:12for meat. But they view it as, you know, it's just something inherent in human nature that
- 37:17people want meat. We have to feed 10 billion people. And the only way to do it is to legitimize the
- 37:23intensification of animal agriculture. And in this system, you have to sort of diminish and
- 37:29deprioritize the well-being of animals in this system and prioritize the well-being of people.
- 37:36And they view it as you have to trade off. Humans are more important than animals is something they
- 37:44view. They don't view, you know, the one health model that I view as if we hurt other people,
- 37:51view as if we hurt other animals, we're hurting ourselves. They kind of only see the short term.
- 37:57It's a choice between human welfare or animal welfare. And we're choosing human welfare.
- 38:03So that's the set of beliefs that their culture is teaching that has allowed this to happen.
- 38:11And I hope to tell more about this into the profession and hopefully show them that there's
- 38:17another way to look at this. And we have to make some producers not so reliant on
- 38:25slaughter-based protein production, you know, and have to be complacent in this system.
- 38:31I hope that makes sense because it's very complicated.
- 38:35Thank you, Crystal. Nikki, did you want to add something to Crystal and Erin's answers?
- 38:42I don't really know that I have that much to add. I guess I'll just reiterate that, yeah,
- 38:49I don't think the veterinarians are necessarily the part of the system that is broken or at least
- 38:55the most broken. It's really just this constant drive and demand. And I guess you could probably
- 39:01say that throughout any animal industry, you know, not just the food industry slash factory farming
- 39:08slash, you know, farming in general, animal experimentation, you know, the mass breeding
- 39:15of animals for the pet industry, you know, things like that. It's tough because at the end of the
- 39:21day, you know, any facility, generally speaking, that has animals being used for human use,
- 39:29whether that's a circus or an animal testing laboratory, I mean, they employ veterinarians
- 39:36at those places. And it's the dichotomy of certainly we need someone there who's going to
- 39:42be an advocate for the animals and treat their health as long as these industries exist. You
- 39:49know, I want the elephants in the circus to get good veterinary care. It's just tough when perhaps
- 39:55the provider is very entrenched in the industry themselves and, you know, maybe can't see past
- 40:03the elephants living a different life or the pig a different life or something like that, you know,
- 40:07because it's just, it's how they how they do it. And what they're expected to do in their role is
- 40:13just give medical advice and maybe not extrapolate on the welfare. Thank you, Nikki. You all talked
- 40:20about the hardship and the level of difficulty to speak up. And that pressure that pressure to
- 40:28conform to the standard view in the veterinarian profession. What's the price tag that comes with
- 40:37speaking up for animal rights? Nikki, would you like to start? I think a lot of it is probably
- 40:44just how your peers view you, you know, job availability. I think if you're going to be a
- 40:54I think if you're going to be a squeaky wheel and known as such, especially early on, you know,
- 41:00jobs may say, Oh, I don't know if we want like a rabble rouser here working for us. I would say
- 41:06small animal clinics are probably less concerned about that. I'm fortunate to work at a small animal
- 41:14general practice where we, you know, we're the Illinois representatives for the paw project.
- 41:20So anti-declying, we have quite a few vegan veterinarians on staff. I think it's a pretty
- 41:27ethical clinic and they were not at all opposed to my animal rights inclinations when I was hired.
- 41:35But I think for a lot of folks, that would be something they would consider maybe not bringing
- 41:40up at interviews. And it would be great to see if we could change the thought process surrounding
- 41:47that so that people could be a little bit more free with their thoughts, you know, Oh, hey,
- 41:51I'm applying to work at this pig farming operation. And I do lean a little bit more animal welfare or
- 42:00I am vegan. But I am, I have the animals best interest in mind or something like that. I have
- 42:06no idea if that would even be possible. I think it probably just wouldn't fly honestly, but that
- 42:10would be, that would be a nice change. Thank you, Nikki. Erin? Yeah, I think I can mostly speak to
- 42:20my experience in veterinary school, which was just opting out of, which wasn't an option,
- 42:29refusing to participate in like the terminal cardiology lab and being threatened. And a lot
- 42:39of actually students in the class wanted to opt out of that. And a few others did refuse to do it.
- 42:45And the professor threatened to reduce our grade, which I don't even know is like legal or I,
- 42:53at that time, I was just like, go ahead, whatever, you know, I'm not killing the dog.
- 42:57And then during we learned surgery, our junior year, and my two, my good friend classmate,
- 43:11and then one student in the year behind us created a, we just said, we're not doing this,
- 43:20we have to figure something else out. And that was a really long drawn out process. We got a lot of
- 43:24pushback from the other students in the class. We did create an alternative track for ourselves
- 43:31to get through. We ended up graduating late. We did not walk with our class. We didn't get our
- 43:37White Coat ceremony with them. We created our own small private graduation several months later. So
- 43:43our graduation was actually delayed. We had to do a lot of work to get that, the training that
- 43:53you know, to check all the boxes before we graduated and a lot of extra time. We had
- 44:01classmates that wanted a special designation on our diploma that we were not trained in surgery,
- 44:07which is, you know, is ridiculous because I think in both my friends and mine, in our externships,
- 44:15we were like doing surgery. And, you know, it's like my first, I didn't have to practice a
- 44:23splenectomy. My first splenectomy, you know, it's like, you learn your skills and you go forward,
- 44:31right? And you have a mentor there or, you know, I mean, back in the day, we literally had our
- 44:37surgery book open on the counter, you know. And that's true with human medicine too.
- 44:44You know, you don't do every procedure. There's always going to be a first time. You learn your
- 44:50good basic skills and hemostasis and keeping your patients stable and all that. And you don't need
- 44:56to kill anything to do that. But that was the pushback that we got. And it was very traumatizing
- 45:05for me at the time because I was not a go along with everything person. I didn't really feel like
- 45:11I fit in anywhere. And so it was, you know, and we had friends that were like, hey, yeah, yeah,
- 45:18we support you, but we're not going there. Or we want to do that, but no, you're risking too much.
- 45:26You know, I mean, we were told to go somewhere else. We were told, you know, so it was actually
- 45:32kind of had to go to getting some outside support that talked to the veterinary school. And then they
- 45:41kind of had a change of heart, but it was stressful. It was stressful. I don't even know if any of my
- 45:48classmates even think about that now. It's not like I'm, you know, good friends with a lot of them,
- 45:53but yeah, I'd be interested to talk to them now, like, you know, if they're going to be able to
- 46:00do that, I'd be interested to talk to them now. Like, how do you feel now about that? Like you
- 46:06still think, you know, have you changed your tune? So if people need to see it can be done and then
- 46:16see that we go on to be, you know, successful in what we're doing and not compromising our education
- 46:23and our conscience. Thank you, Erin. I did have pushback in practice as well. Like I would refuse
- 46:31to do convenience euthanasia and things like that. And yeah, but you know, not now.
- 46:43Thank you, Erin. Crystal, I know you're a special case of that.
- 46:47Yeah, I mean, I've, so I personally think like, the biggest price anybody could pay is feeling
- 46:54like they can't say what they think. But throughout history, like women have had to shut their mouths
- 47:01in order to just survive because you're going to get killed if you say what you actually think or
- 47:06you're not like we couldn't even get a credit card until the 1970s. You couldn't open a business
- 47:10bank account on our own until the 80s. So women throughout history have been like, you know,
- 47:17balancing this like I need to survive versus say what I actually think. But when even before vet
- 47:26school, I knew I could always make money. You know, I always just, I had started businesses in the
- 47:34past. I and but especially like after I paid off my $200,000 in student loan debt, it became really
- 47:41easy to say what's on my mind. And I also developed like a certain position in the veterinary
- 47:48profession where people knew I was very good at my job and I love surgery. And I knew I could always
- 47:54get hired even if I was obnoxiously saying what I think, because I was very good. And I could,
- 48:01you know, make a practice a lot of money. So it's just like, you know, I was very secure in the fact
- 48:09that I'd always be hired. And if I couldn't be hired, I'd start my own business. So I would be
- 48:13fine. The only thing, you know, if I ever become sick or unhealthy, like, you know, and I become
- 48:21unwell, like, oh, it's a little bit of a problem. But I'll figure it out. Like I just always had
- 48:26that mindset. So I have, you know, when you be gain a little financial security becomes a very
- 48:32easy to say what's on your mind. But I, you know, I have suffered consequences because of that
- 48:37been kicked out of the humane ending symposium banned from the legislative fly in not allowed
- 48:44to join the American Association of swine veterinarians not allowed to join the American
- 48:48Association of bovine practitioners. So that, you know, I was very, very, very happy with that.
- 48:54So that does that decrease my effectiveness. I know a lot of veterinarians out there who are
- 49:00like, we're going to message a certain way so that we can stay in the room and like actually have
- 49:07a position of authority. But I'm like, well, I'm happy to be on the outside, sort of expanding
- 49:13that overturn window for you guys so you can walk through it. But I know I cannot. I am not somebody
- 49:23who's going to stick to a script and be like, I'm going to temper or tone police what I'm saying.
- 49:32I just I rather have the freedom to say what I actually think. But of course, there are more
- 49:37effective ways to say things. And you always have to like think, oh, is there a better way to say
- 49:43this that's still in line with what I actually think, which is I think that we need to end the
- 49:48exploitation of animals, ultimately. But I do think we should improve welfare while animals exist in
- 49:54animal agriculture, but we should ultimately seek to end exploitation as soon as possible.
- 50:01And I never want to be like, no, I'm not for abolition, just so that people, you know,
- 50:09accept what I say. I'm like, you should all be on board with, you know, ending some of these most
- 50:16horrific practices. But ultimately, I see a feature where we don't have to slaughter animals for
- 50:21protein production. So yeah, I mean, I will just say that, that I think the biggest price anybody
- 50:29could pay is feeling like they can't say what they actually think. But I also understand that
- 50:35having that perspective, you have to have a certain level of privilege in society in order
- 50:40to have that perspective too. Thank you, Crystal. Erin? Yeah, I think,
- 50:48I think that's true. Not feeling like you can speak out or speak to your, speak your conscience
- 50:54is very, it's a really awful feeling. And to feel like you're in a situation where you're
- 51:01compromising your ethics to, you know, earn a living or what, I think there's probably a lot
- 51:07of veterinarians that are in that position. And I think, I guess maybe, I don't know, it's my age or
- 51:17having had unsuccessful, you know, oh, I wish I would have done it this way, type conversations,
- 51:25but I'm just at a place where it's like, it's a, you know, I'm going to speak my mind, I can say,
- 51:33this is, this is what I think. I realize you may not think that way. And, and so I, I just
- 51:42say what I think. And I'm very, I'm very honest about it, even in whether I'm very fortunate
- 51:48that I get to work at a sanctuary as, as part of my job, part of my veterinary practice,
- 51:55that is pretty much in agreement with all of that. But I do other work and I, I don't hold back
- 52:07on, on saying what I think, whether it's, you know, docking tails or cropping ears or decline or,
- 52:15you know, I mean, I do relief work at one practice, sometimes I'm like, I will not see farm animals
- 52:22in this area because of, you know, I'm just, I'm not going to have that relationship with an animal
- 52:30that's going to, you know, that is a commodity basically. And so it's like, hey, you think this
- 52:41way, I think this way, I'm not going to shut up about it, but I'm also not going to expect that,
- 52:47that you're necessarily going to change your mind. If you change your mind, that's great. But I think
- 52:51even just saying how you feel in a conversational way, and I hope more people feel empowered to do
- 52:59that, you know, that it doesn't always have to be this big confrontation. It doesn't have to be this,
- 53:04you know, your, your opinion versus my opinion or your take versus my take. This is, this is
- 53:09unapologetically how I feel. And, you know, have a nice day. Thank you, Erin. I think that with
- 53:22my line of questions, we have identified the problem and brought up many of the nuances of
- 53:30that problem. But did I miss something? Is there a layer, an additional layer to this problematic
- 53:40situation that I have forgotten to ask about? Yes, Nikki.
- 53:47I'll just add one quick thing, which I think Crystal pretty well brought up at the beginning.
- 53:53But, you know, just overall for veterinarians to be cognizant of others' wellbeing,
- 54:03because this is such a stressful profession. And I'm not sure if any of your listeners are aware of
- 54:09some of the very high suicide rates in veterinary professionals. And so, you know, while I see a
- 54:17fair amount of unfortunate bullying of, you know, maybe you could say like, not to generalize, but
- 54:25like agricultural vets who are bullying, maybe animal rights or animal welfare leaning veterinarians,
- 54:31or even veterinarians who work in industries that support animal exploitation, generally speaking.
- 54:37So, you know, vets who work at theme parks with animals and things like that, kind of talking
- 54:42poorly, even in a public space, like the internet, about some of their colleagues more akin to us
- 54:51vets here who have different feelings on it. You know, I think it's a rough profession already,
- 54:57and we just have to be aware not to make it too much rougher for each other. And so, you know,
- 55:05even for myself, just being cognizant sometimes that, yeah, I mean, for some of these folks who
- 55:12are, for whatever reason, indoctrinated or feel forced to work in some of these positions,
- 55:20you know, we don't want to bully them. We want to extend the olive branch across the aisle.
- 55:25I think Crystal's organization, Our Honor, is really good at doing that. We don't really want
- 55:31to make it like us versus them. It's really how we could all work together as veterinary
- 55:36professionals to make a difference for animals without sacrificing someone's mental health,
- 55:42hopefully too much in the meantime.
- 55:46Thank you, Nikki. Crystal, you wanted to add something?
- 55:49Yeah. And I will just add, like, we do criticize the AVMA and the pork board a lot, but we do
- 55:56criticize the AVMA and the pork board a lot, but we don't call them names. We just state the facts
- 56:04about what they did and how problematic this is and who their stakeholders are and all of this.
- 56:11We don't call people names. And I've seen this problem in the animal rights movement of some
- 56:18people being like, I will never be friends with somebody who eats meat. And that's really a foolish
- 56:25perspective, I think, because imagine if, like, I personally want to see a future where we have
- 56:32access to public transportation and we have walkable cities and we don't have to rely on cars.
- 56:37But I am not going to be like, if somebody drives a car to work, they're not allowed to support our
- 56:44car-free future or our campaign to increase access to public transportation because then they're
- 56:49hypocrites. And it's like we have to realize that we live in a world where the industry has realized
- 56:55that they cannot rely on the whims of consumer choice to dictate people's food choices. It is
- 57:02not a consumer choice issue. They have instilled habits into us. And there are only, and the idea
- 57:09that we have to pit people who are able to free themselves from eating slaughter-based protein
- 57:16versus those who are not able to for whatever reason is really foolish. And I also see a lot of
- 57:24vegans and animal rights activists refuse to engage in the industry, refuse to become USDA
- 57:30inspectors, refuse to work in lab animal medicine or anything like that. And I think they need to
- 57:36work there. And there's a lot of animal rights activists who refuse to go to zoos because they
- 57:42don't want to buy a ticket. When it's like, go and film it and show the world what it is through your
- 57:49eyes. That's what we need. And simply having this purity mindset of like, no, just abstaining is
- 57:58good enough. Not in this culture. We're all implicated. You are paying for slaughter-based
- 58:03protein production. You are paying the companies for ventilation shutdown, whether you buy their
- 58:09products or not with your taxpayer dollars. Jenny Oaks Turkey Store got $105 million of our money,
- 58:15whether you're vegan or not. We're all paying for this. So we're all implicated and we all have to
- 58:20engage with it. And this purity mindset is not beneficial and it's doing nothing to help the
- 58:27animals. So yeah, go vegan. But if you can't, like I'm still your friend because I understand
- 58:33that a lot goes into it. It's not just a consumer choice issue. Anyway.
- 58:39Thank you, Crystal. I think this is a great segue to the next topic, which is the solution.
- 58:48We talked about the problem in depth. Now I want to talk about for the remaining time about the
- 58:54solutions out there. And I'm a bit of an outsider. I became vegan out of compassion. And then I found
- 59:02myself doing this podcast and then discovering this whole world of animal rights. And with
- 59:09all its struggles and I have to say I did find, like you said before, Crystal, then there is a
- 59:19lack of critical thinking among animal rights activists. And this surprised me because when I
- 59:30heard people talk about vegans or veganism as being a religion, I always heard it like a criticism,
- 59:41like a way to just not consider veganism. But now I'm realizing more and more that
- 59:50there is a kind of orthodoxy among vegans and animal rights activists, which feels like a religion
- 1:00:00in a way, feels a bit dogmatic. And so my first question, I guess, is how can we create a bridge
- 1:00:10between the animal rights world and veterinarians, the world of veterinarians?
- 1:00:17And one of my criticisms I have for animal rights activism is how it does not invest in impactful
- 1:00:27actions, not always. And one of the most impactful actions we can make is to turn more and more
- 1:00:38veterinarians into advocates or just into vegans. And I don't know why we're not putting more time
- 1:00:49and energy in doing that because veterinarians are such powerful allies to have. So I'll let you
- 1:01:01answer that. Who wants to start?
- 1:01:03I can go first. I mean, I think, yeah, Pareto principle, 80% of outcomes come from 20% of your
- 1:01:10efforts. The salespeople understand this and the animal agriculture industry understands this.
- 1:01:16They understood how important it was to get veterinarians to lend legitimacy to their
- 1:01:22practices. So they invested a lot of time and money into the veterinary profession. And I think the
- 1:01:27animal rights movement needs to do the same thing. Like I want to see a bridge between the animal
- 1:01:31rights movement and the animal rights movement. And I think that's a very important thing.
- 1:01:37Like I want to see why aren't there animal rights activists outside of every veterinary
- 1:01:43conference or having a table at every veterinary conference engaging politely with the veterinary
- 1:01:49profession the same way the pork board does. The pork board doesn't engage with the veterinary
- 1:01:54profession saying, you need to support animal agriculture or else you're hurting the future
- 1:02:00if you don't have which Extremism side. Like they do support questioned exhaustive
- 1:02:07ORE the family person. And in some areas they address it even through basic Shanahan
- 1:02:16supporting them and offering them jobs in animal rights movement,
- 1:02:22being open and engaging.
- 1:02:24But I also, as far as the animal rights movement and veganism being a religion,
- 1:02:29yeah, that's a problem.
- 1:02:31The foundations of the vegetarian society back in the 1800s was church-based,
- 1:02:38which is the only understanding that a lot of things had.
- 1:02:41But there were a lot of people like Anna Besant,
- 1:02:46who was the inspiration for Gandhi, was very anti-religion.
- 1:02:51So there was that too.
- 1:02:53But I think there are a lot of people,
- 1:02:56a lot of leaders in the animal rights movement who played on
- 1:03:00the emotions of a lot of people in the movement and fostered a lot of anger.
- 1:03:07Their videos and the way that they go about getting a lot of social media clicks is by
- 1:03:13inciting anger and getting passion about this and wielding that anger against people.
- 1:03:21We have to just stay away from all of that.
- 1:03:26This shame-based activism is very harmful.
- 1:03:30The antidote to shame is empathy.
- 1:03:33I think that's our strength and that's what we should be extending to everybody,
- 1:03:38in fostering that empathy for those who we view as part of the problem.
- 1:03:45They are cult members.
- 1:03:46We need to extract them from that cult where
- 1:03:49they're asked to betray their conscience and harm animals.
- 1:03:52When we know empathy for other animals is
- 1:03:55a evolved trait that humans and other animals evolved hundreds of thousands of years ago.
- 1:04:00That's our nature. So we just need to get people to go back to our nature.
- 1:04:04Fostering empathy is the key to all of this.
- 1:04:07Thank you, Crystal. Erin?
- 1:04:09I think that covered what I was going to say.
- 1:04:12I just think we so often we other and we dehumanize.
- 1:04:17People that we see as not aligning with our thought processes or goals or things like that.
- 1:04:26We are all human beings and we need to remember that and honor that.
- 1:04:33Even if you feel like someone's completely sold their soul or they're being malicious.
- 1:04:41We need to look at how these things develop,
- 1:04:48how these processes develop and these systems develop and understand it's not just about animals.
- 1:04:58It's about exploitation and commodification in general.
- 1:05:03There's that interplay of the economic system.
- 1:05:08It's like we can't just put the band-aids on it without understanding the underlying drivers.
- 1:05:18Looking at the entire system of what capitalism does to all beings.
- 1:05:28And how it indoctrinates us all into thinking there are no other alternatives.
- 1:05:35And so in just trying to create a better world for all animals, for human beings, for the planet.
- 1:05:45I think it's really important that we stop vilifying and dehumanizing people.
- 1:05:54And we just stick to facts.
- 1:06:00I don't think you have to go into it being fake and being nice when you're upset about something.
- 1:06:09You can do things in it with integrity and honesty and transparency.
- 1:06:16I think that's the way I see it.
- 1:06:22And I know that more radical activism does get results.
- 1:06:27I just don't know if it's really going in the direction that we really need to get to pretty quickly for a number of reasons.
- 1:06:37For social justice, for human rights, for the planet, for the animals.
- 1:06:42We need to be very careful about our praxis and very focused on it.
- 1:06:48Thank you Erin. Nikki?
- 1:06:50Yeah, I think that was a very beautiful sentiment, Erin. I agree.
- 1:06:55I think ultimately considering all these factors, I kind of call it the PETA principle,
- 1:07:02which would be getting more of us in the room with them.
- 1:07:08PETA has stock holdings in a number of animal ag companies.
- 1:07:13And I think they have stock holdings at SeaWorld and things like that so that they can be a part of the shareholders meetings.
- 1:07:19And just be maybe one voice of dissent in the room.
- 1:07:23It kind of brings me back to an advertisement that I saw in a magazine, I don't know, probably like 20 years ago.
- 1:07:32I would say it was probably from the pork board, but I can't recall exactly.
- 1:07:37But it said in the big white letters, big bold letters, who will you believe?
- 1:07:42The vegans or the vets?
- 1:07:44And it was basically just meant to kind of pit people against each other in terms of like,
- 1:07:51well, veterinarians know all the facts about pork production and they are the ones I should believe, not these hippie crazy vegans.
- 1:07:59But I saw that and thought, well, I guess I should become a vet now because I'm already a vegan
- 1:08:05and I need people to see more legitimacy in my claims that I know are right.
- 1:08:11And they just kind of look at you like, hey, you're a kid standing outside Macy's with a sign that says ban fur.
- 1:08:18Like, what do you know? And so to come at it from a veterinary perspective is so powerful.
- 1:08:25If we could get if we could inspire more vegans or animal activists, more vegetarians to go to vet school,
- 1:08:33I'm sure this podcast was not an overarchingly positive view on it all.
- 1:08:39I mean, I think that school is like four of the most grueling years of my life in terms of studies academically.
- 1:08:47But, you know, if we could get more of us in those rooms, for instance, in my class of 120 veterinary students, I was the only vegan.
- 1:08:57I mean, there are maybe 10 to 15 vegetarians, which is great.
- 1:09:00But in our vet school throughout the four years of classes, I want to say there were four or five vegans
- 1:09:07and 450 vet students. And I think if we could increase those numbers, that would just get more conversations flowing.
- 1:09:16You know, certainly I think a lot of people are vegan for health or maybe other reasons than animal based.
- 1:09:25But nonetheless, you know, every lunch lecture that we had in school where, you know,
- 1:09:30say the university provides you with a lunch and you go learn about, I don't know, a new flea and tick preventative or something.
- 1:09:37The options were, you know, you could get chicken, beef, pork or vegetarian, maybe.
- 1:09:43And there was not a vegan option. So I would be the one who would just send them an email and be like, hey, actually, I'm vegan.
- 1:09:50I want to go to this talk. Can you get me a lunch?
- 1:09:52And usually it was like, oh, no. And, you know, just trying to bridge that gap and also, you know,
- 1:10:05to just be open to conversing, which these two have said really nicely throughout this whole talk today.
- 1:10:11I think it's just a lot of openness and being willing to talk to people.
- 1:10:16You know, if I'm out with my friends and they order a cheeseburger and like, I'm not going to smack it out of their hands.
- 1:10:22That said, if somebody posts like a Facebook picture of something particularly egregious,
- 1:10:27like a fellow veterinarian riding an elephant at a circus, then I do sometimes make a little comment on that.
- 1:10:35But, you know, just knowing how to converse in a way that's going to make people receptive.
- 1:10:42I find it a compliment when occasionally people will say to me, you know, oh, you're not like other vegans.
- 1:10:49In other words, you're not like annoying. But I think I am a little bit annoying sometimes.
- 1:10:55You know, I'm very proud to be an activist. I run protests. I've run probably hundreds of protests.
- 1:11:02So, you know, loud and proud activist. But I am glad that people don't see me as someone who's so combative that they can't be open with me.
- 1:11:09You know, we all started somewhere.
- 1:11:15And ultimately, you know, I think if we can extend any offering of peace to them and meet them where they're at,
- 1:11:24you know, if they're wearing leather shoes, it's OK, you can still come to my house.
- 1:11:28You know, if they bought their dog from a pet store, you know, I usually just say, well, now that you know better, do better.
- 1:11:34So I think there's plenty of opportunity for progress.
- 1:11:39And if you're a vegan animal activist listening to this and maybe you already have a degree in biology, well, consider applying to vet school.
- 1:11:48Thank you, Nikki. Erin, you wanted to react?
- 1:11:51I think one of the excuse me, one of the more powerful ways that that we can help with the ripple effect one on one is just by,
- 1:12:02you know, simply being being good kind of people, you know, having our sense of humor,
- 1:12:10building relationships and friendships and and having not being our activism doesn't always have to be our leading thing going into something.
- 1:12:20Right. So it's like then people find out like, oh, oh, you're oh, you're, you know, an animal rights activist and you're vegan.
- 1:12:31And because they already have this relationship with me as, you know, the vet that really cares about their dog or cat.
- 1:12:38And I've actually found like it's not on a one on one level.
- 1:12:43It can be a pretty, pretty powerful because then you don't have to earn that respect.
- 1:12:49You have that respect. And then. That it's just seen in such a better light.
- 1:12:54So like, Nikki, people saying like, oh, you know, I'm glad you're not one of those vegans, but you're you know, you're Nikki first.
- 1:13:03And, you know, you're fun and you're and you have a sense of humor and you can talk about a lot of things and you care about people and and that.
- 1:13:11And and I think that helps dispel this idea of the angry activist and the, you know, the one that's throwing, you know, blood on you and shaming you.
- 1:13:23And I just I hope so, at least, you know, I think it's always really for me, it's like when I when I see vegan influencers speak out and use their platform
- 1:13:38and their voice to to speak out about the oppressive economic systems we have or the, you know, military actions of the United States and and things like that.
- 1:13:51It's man, man, my respect level just is like way up because I'm like, oh, yeah, you're really you get in the whole picture here.
- 1:14:00You see, you know, how how awful these systems are and you're using your voice and your platform to say something.
- 1:14:10And that it makes a huge influence. And and they they get, you know, kick back to I mean, anybody speaking out on, you know, current really, really bad things going on.
- 1:14:25It's. Yeah, they get kicked back to, but they get gain a lot of respect and a lot of people's eyes for not being that single focus or just realizing that that that that compassion and that moral compass doesn't.
- 1:14:44It's not limited to nonhuman animals.
- 1:14:48Thank you, Aaron. I want to quickly end on this question. I was reminded during this conversation of Colin, who was a guest for I think the second episode of this show.
- 1:15:06And he told me the story of how he wanted to become a vet and he was doing this internship and during that time he was asked to shot a cow.
- 1:15:21And that experience just made him completely turn his back to the vet profession and become vegan.
- 1:15:31And so quickly, I would love if every one of you could give maybe a few words of encouragement for the Collins of this word and also for other vegans out there who are in a hostile environment,
- 1:15:52but doing their share of, I guess, activism or being this beacon of hope and light in this dark and hostile environment, whatever that environment might be.
- 1:16:11You know, we haven't touched. I know that everyone of you is in the US.
- 1:16:15And when you were talking about how you could say whatever you want, you know, I was thinking of you have freedom of speech.
- 1:16:25And that's something that many maybe listeners from other countries do not have in their state, in their nation.
- 1:16:37So what would be your words of encouragement for the people out there struggling in a hostile environment?
- 1:16:45And let's start with Crystal.
- 1:16:49Yeah. And what did you say in the beginning? He was asked to what a cat.
- 1:16:53So there was a cow who.
- 1:16:56Yeah. And I think she just laid on the floor and she did not want to just rise back up and walk. And they tried everything.
- 1:17:09And so they had to euthanize the cow and the euthanizing the cow meant shutting the cow in the head.
- 1:17:18So, yeah. Wow. Yeah. I mean, it's I've never had to do that in my career. And I know a lot of people are like, well, I don't want to euthanize animals.
- 1:17:31And you know, I rarely euthanize animals now. I mean, I used to work in a shelter where I had to.
- 1:17:37But I know many vets who don't want to. And so they don't like you can make your career whatever you want it to be.
- 1:17:44And people are also, you know, tell me, oh, I heard you have to do terminal surgeries.
- 1:17:51What school should I go to where I won't have to do that?
- 1:17:54I'm like, aren't you a vegan? Are you an activist?
- 1:17:57Like, don't you want you should want to change the curriculum so that it's not by you abstaining from participating in terminal surgeries or going to school that doesn't do it anyway.
- 1:18:09You're making no difference at all. You will make a difference by going to Iowa State or North Carolina State,
- 1:18:15some of the worst schools and causing a fuss and a ruckus and changing the curriculum.
- 1:18:21And there are attorneys who want to help you.
- 1:18:23I know the most famous, the person who's done the most impactful work on this,
- 1:18:29Gary Francione, back in the day, would represent that students who were conscientious objectors and who wanted to change the curriculum.
- 1:18:37And he really made a lot of difference in schools and one of the reasons why a lot of schools have moved away from it.
- 1:18:44But I am publishing a paper very shortly, which will show that most schools still do terminal surgeries.
- 1:18:51And there's been a lot of silence over the past 20 years about this.
- 1:18:56I feel like the students in the 90s made the most difference.
- 1:19:00And then it was like after the 90s, the 2000s to 2020, it was pretty silent.
- 1:19:05And there was not a lot of activism in this area. And now is the time.
- 1:19:11I know a lot of animal rights attorneys who would want to help students.
- 1:19:17So get involved and find support in the animal rights community and like, let's collaborate and work together
- 1:19:25and invite me or other veterinarians to your school for a lunch talk or like,
- 1:19:31let's figure out how we can table outside of these schools and do outreach to these students and make a difference.
- 1:19:41So, yeah, that would be my advice. You have a whole lot of support in all of us here.
- 1:19:49Thank you, Crystal. Nikki?
- 1:19:53I guess my summary would be for those who are probably the majority of your listeners who are vegans, but not veterinarians,
- 1:20:03just knowing that veterinarians are an extremely high demand, not a day goes by where I don't get some kind of LinkedIn email
- 1:20:11that's touting a significant sign on bonus because they are just they need to hire DVMs.
- 1:20:21They need to hire veterinarians. And so, you know, I think if you are on the fence about going to vet school,
- 1:20:27obviously consider it more than just this podcast. But, you know, just knowing that there are great opportunities to work in animal shelters.
- 1:20:35You know, you can work in general practice and maybe volunteer at a sanctuary if you're as fortunate as Dr.
- 1:20:41Aaron, you know, maybe you'll actually be able to be employed there as well or perhaps volunteering in wildlife rehab or conservation medicine.
- 1:20:49You know, just because you don't want to do euthanasia or you don't want to do surgeries.
- 1:20:55I have many colleagues who don't do certain X, Y and Z. And, you know, I think you can draw the line at your comfort level.
- 1:21:03And, you know, then I think for the probably like 0.01 percent of listeners who are vegan veterinarians,
- 1:21:11who are not actively being interviewed on this podcast, but are listening to it,
- 1:21:16I think just using our platform as veterinarians to, you know, teach kindness to everyone in your day to day, of course,
- 1:21:24but especially focusing on, you know, teaching kindness to children, to teenagers.
- 1:21:29You know, if you can have people shadow you at work and just talk to them about empathy, you know, you don't have to like say, go vegan child.
- 1:21:38But, you know, if you could volunteer at like an animal shelter or having a camp.
- 1:21:43I know in Chicago, a lot of our bigger, well-funded animal shelters have kids camps over the summer where they do a lot of work on,
- 1:21:51hey, let's do enrichment for the animals who are here and let's teach kindness.
- 1:21:57And I think that's just such a great way to go about it, you know, starting them off from a kind perspective whenever we can,
- 1:22:05growing kids who love animals for, you know, more so than just like, oh, I love dolphins.
- 1:22:12I want to swim with dolphins, you know, oh, I love dolphins.
- 1:22:15I want to free the dolphins, you know.
- 1:22:18Thank you, Nikki. And finally, Erin.
- 1:22:25Well, first of all, for those people, realize that they're not alone.
- 1:22:28And that's one of the main purposes of this organization that Crystal started, our honor is so that there is an outreach.
- 1:22:41There is support.
- 1:22:44So, you know, connect with this organization, with our honor, with Crystal and those of us that are involved in that so that we can give that support.
- 1:22:58And you realize that you're not alone, someone to talk to and strategies for carrying on.
- 1:23:07I'm it's unfortunate that it's unfortunate that Colin shied away from veterinary medicine because of that experience.
- 1:23:17It's sometimes in, especially with large animals, people always think that euthanasia is, you know, it means good death.
- 1:23:30Right. And that's what we always strive for.
- 1:23:33But when you're dealing with an animal that weighs over a thousand pounds, quite often, you know, you do your very best to make things as peaceful and comfortable as possible.
- 1:23:47But as someone who's euthanized, you know, many horses and and some ruminants and cattle, you it's actually.
- 1:24:02If done right, a gunshot is actually very, very quick and humane death.
- 1:24:09It feels very violent.
- 1:24:13But you got to remember, you know, pushing a lethal drug into veins and, you know, the whole process of euthanasia, while we try to make it very peaceful, we're still ending a life.
- 1:24:27So it's unfortunate that that that's what turned them away from from being veterinarian, because, you know, I've learned to carry a firearm.
- 1:24:39When when I do that, when I go out on those, it just is something that they don't want to use it.
- 1:24:45But if I do, you will actually end up reducing suffering at some points if you need to.
- 1:24:52But, yeah, if you're feeling in that dark place and you want to go into veterinary medicine, there are organizations and people here for you now.
- 1:25:01So please reach out. Thank you so much, Sharon.
- 1:25:07So, again, thank you, everyone, for having taken the time to answer my questions and have this conversation, group conversation.
- 1:25:19I love initiatives like this one, which are new, kind of new.
- 1:25:25I don't think I come across other group conversations of vegan veterinarians.
- 1:25:32And I love, you know, just testing those boundaries of animal advocacy with this podcast,
- 1:25:44because why have a podcast if not for those beautiful conversations?
- 1:25:51So, again, thank you so much, everyone.
- 1:25:53Thank you, everyone, for listening.
- 1:25:55I kindly invite you to share this podcast with the vegans, you know, let's encourage more people to take action.
- 1:26:03Again, thank you so much for caring.
- 1:26:05And I will see you next Tuesday for a new episode.
- 1:26:35Thank you.
- 1:27:05Thank you.