Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Arbitration: Consumer Arbitration
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to today's program, The Nuts and Bolts
- 0:05of Arbitration, Consumer Arbitration. I'm Alla
- 0:09Poli Castro, Director of Education and Professional
- 0:11Development at Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:14And today I'm delighted to introduce our speakers,
- 0:17Adam Schoenick and Delton Henderson. Delton is
- 0:20an accomplished attorney, arbitrator, and mediator
- 0:23licensed in California and New York with more
- 0:26than 20 years of experience advising clients
- 0:29across business, entertainment, and nonprofit
- 0:31sectors. He serves on the national roster of
- 0:34American Arbitration Association and FINRA. Adam
- 0:38is Vice President of Business Development and
- 0:40Outreach at the American Arbitration Association,
- 0:43where he oversees the organization's consumer
- 0:46case administration teams across the eastern
- 0:48United States. With nearly 16 years of experience
- 0:51at AAA, he has held multiple leadership roles
- 0:55focused on operations, business development,
- 0:57and client engagement. We can't wait to hear
- 0:59what they have to share with us today, so I'm
- 1:01going to turn it over to them. Thank you so much.
- 1:06Again, my name is Adam Schoneck from American
- 1:09Arbitration Association. And we're here today
- 1:13to talk about the nuts and bolts of consumer
- 1:16arbitration. So I'm going to go ahead and share
- 1:19my slides. All right. So we'll talk about what
- 1:30is the AAA, just some basic background information.
- 1:34We'll talk about the stages of the consumer arbitration
- 1:37process, AI best practices, and then we'll talk
- 1:42a little bit about our consumer arbitration data
- 1:45that we publish. What is the AAA? We're a 501c3
- 1:52not -for -profit organization. Our headquarters
- 1:56are in New York, but we have footprint across
- 2:00the US with a number of offices, dozens, I believe,
- 2:07and locations abroad as well. We were founded
- 2:12in 1926. So just one year after the Federal Arbitration
- 2:16Act and we are coming up on our centennial celebration.
- 2:21So look out for that starting next year. And
- 2:25we are the largest provider of arbitration services
- 2:29in the world. When it comes to consumer cases,
- 2:35we are by far the largest provider of consumer
- 2:39services in the world based on our number of
- 2:45cases that we see. When you talk about consumer
- 2:54arbitration, it's very important to talk about
- 2:59fairness and transparency as well because the
- 3:02consumers are not electing arbitration. The businesses
- 3:07are electing arbitration for them in these contracts.
- 3:11And so because the consumer, by our definition,
- 3:15didn't... have any negotiating power or say,
- 3:18you know, any say in how these contracts were
- 3:21written, these contracts have to meet a minimum
- 3:25due process standard. And that's embodied in
- 3:29the consumer due process protocol, which was
- 3:32developed in the late 90s by AAA in conjunction
- 3:39with advocates for businesses and consumers and
- 3:42consumer interest groups to make sure that Any
- 3:46contract for consumer arbitration we receive
- 3:49must meet those standards contained in the protocol.
- 3:54And if they don't, then we won't administer the
- 3:58case. Now, we will ask the business to waive
- 4:02that provision or provisions of the contract
- 4:05that do not comply with the protocol. But if
- 4:11they don't do that, then we will decline the
- 4:14case. Paired with that is our consumer clause
- 4:19registry. So in our rules, we ask that if a business
- 4:22is going to name us in their agreement, they
- 4:25first send us a copy of the contract, probably
- 4:30terms of service or standard purchase agreements,
- 4:35that sort of thing that consumers would sign,
- 4:40subscription agreements, that sort of thing.
- 4:43They have to send it to us first to make sure
- 4:45that it does comply with our consumer due process
- 4:48protocol. If it doesn't, we will not register
- 4:52it and we will ask for changes in the agreement
- 4:55or a waiver of the provisions before we'll go
- 4:59ahead and register that on the clause registry.
- 5:03The registry is open to the public and it's part
- 5:08of our mission to be transparent and to educate
- 5:12everyone involved in consumer arbitration about
- 5:16types of clauses and that sort of thing that
- 5:19are out there. I mentioned our consumer arbitration
- 5:23rules. These are a special rule set just for
- 5:28consumer arbitration cases. We just updated these
- 5:33rules this year, so they're brand new. That's
- 5:37a whole separate topic we could talk about, but
- 5:41the process that we're going to talk about today
- 5:46follows the consumer arbitration rules process.
- 5:51These were designed with the protocol in mind,
- 5:55of course, to maintain the fairness standards
- 6:00of the protocol in consumer arbitration. stages
- 6:07of the process. First, the case is filed. Cases
- 6:13can be filed on our website, ADR .org. There's
- 6:18a big red file a case button in the top that
- 6:21a party can go to and it'll take them through
- 6:24the steps of the filing process. That's the simplest
- 6:28way to file. Parties can also file by email or
- 6:33mail. with email being the increasingly more
- 6:38popular choice there, as you can imagine. There's
- 6:42a couple things that a filing party, we call
- 6:44the filing party the claimant that they need
- 6:48to file. So one is the demand for arbitration.
- 6:52We have forms on the website. We have one specific
- 6:56for consumer that they can use. Or they can just
- 7:00provide a written statement that has all the
- 7:03information we're requesting from the demand,
- 7:06which is basically a brief description of the
- 7:09dispute, how much is involved, the names and
- 7:13addresses, contact info for the parties and their
- 7:16representatives, and some other administrative
- 7:20data that we need to get the case going. The
- 7:23other thing we need with the filing is a copy
- 7:26of the contract. that names the American Arbitration
- 7:30Association. So before we can administer a case,
- 7:34the contract has to name us or the parties have
- 7:39to agree to bring their dispute to us. So we
- 7:44need that with the filing as well to make sure
- 7:46we have jurisdiction to handle the case. Once
- 7:51those things are filed with us, the claimant
- 7:53needs to serve the other party, who we call the
- 7:57respondent in the case. And that will start the
- 8:02ball rolling. If there are any deficiencies in
- 8:06the filing, we will reach out to the parties
- 8:09to say, hey, we need X, Y, or Z. But otherwise,
- 8:13we'll move on from that stage to the initiation
- 8:17stage. which is where we request the answer.
- 8:20But I want to turn to Dalton for a minute to
- 8:24talk about some best practices for the filing
- 8:29and case stage. Okay. Well, thank you very much,
- 8:34Adam. Again, my name is Dalton Henderson. I am
- 8:36and have been serving as a consumer arbitrator
- 8:40for the AAA for six years. I think maybe going
- 8:44seven years. One of the highlights, I think,
- 8:49of being a part of such an organization and program
- 8:54is this document that Adam referenced, the consumer
- 9:01due process protocol. For me, it's not just a
- 9:05set of requirements that you kind of check off.
- 9:09It's an important, it's a statement of values.
- 9:12The protocol says in effect that the arbitrator
- 9:15should be or arbitration should be accessible
- 9:18to the party despite. cost or their preparedness
- 9:26and familiarity with the process and attempts
- 9:29to strike a balance between that unique distinct
- 9:35space that consumer arbitration occupies in the
- 9:39ADR field. So again, when I'm presented with
- 9:44a case, the initial documents, the demand for
- 9:48arbitration and the answer. What I'm looking
- 9:51for as an arbitrator is sort of clear. not sort,
- 9:58but a clear and concise statement, description
- 10:01of the dispute. It doesn't have to follow the
- 10:07traditional pleading formalities, and oftentimes
- 10:11it will not if you're dealing with a circumstance
- 10:16where the claimant is unrepresented. But it should
- 10:21provide enough detail to allow me to understand
- 10:26and appreciate what is being asked and what support
- 10:32is available to get us to the resolution of the
- 10:39dispute at hand. In terms of things that I would
- 10:44recommend not doing, you know, when preparing
- 10:48either a demand or a response to a demand is
- 10:53being overly sensational. I know that sometimes
- 10:58in a litigation context or maybe as a result
- 11:03of one's proclivity towards creative writing,
- 11:09the attorneys will do a lot of things, gymnastics
- 11:16of a sort, in terms of language. That typically
- 11:20is less helpful in the initial stage of the process.
- 11:26Because again, my goal is to be able to understand
- 11:30and appreciate why the parties are there. And
- 11:34if I have to leap through these additional adjectives
- 11:38and adverbs, get at the essence or the substance
- 11:42of the claims and potential defenses, then it
- 11:46just makes the process a bit more, a little less
- 11:49efficient. Other recommendations or things that
- 11:54I would suggest avoiding is not preparing before
- 12:03you submit your documents. I've had instances
- 12:08where, for example, it's a two -tiered conflict.
- 12:13There is a contract on top of a contract, each
- 12:17with a separate arbitration provision. As a result
- 12:22of this case being presented for arbitration,
- 12:27we must consider the context of both of these
- 12:31agreements. One may state of preference a governance
- 12:37law of, you know, state of California and the
- 12:40other may make the governing law some other state.
- 12:47This is obviously a presents a preliminary issue
- 12:50that has to be resolved. If council or if the
- 12:53parties are aware of this in the beginning, this
- 12:56is something that we could certainly address
- 12:59sooner rather than later, you know, maybe even
- 13:02in advance of scheduling our preliminary hearing.
- 13:07So I would, you know, caution you to check the
- 13:12agreements or documents, you know, before, you
- 13:15know, for things like jurisdiction and, you know,
- 13:18if there are any conditions that are required,
- 13:20you know, before this process could be engaged,
- 13:26certainly do that. Thank you, Delton. And so
- 13:33we mentioned the answer. That comes after all
- 13:39the filing requirements have been met. And we'll
- 13:42request that from the respondent. Typically,
- 13:46under the consumer rules, the respondent has
- 13:4914 days to provide their answer after the demand
- 13:53was filed. We don't adhere to formal pleading
- 13:57requirements in the rules. So these do not have
- 14:01to be that formal. We recognize 14 days is part
- 14:09of the expedited nature of arbitration in allowing
- 14:15for shortage statements to move the process along.
- 14:21Once the answer is filed, or if no answer is
- 14:26filed, we take it as a general denial, but we
- 14:30will then go ahead and appoint the arbitrator
- 14:34to the case. So the arbitrator is like Delton,
- 14:38the person who decides the case, and they will...
- 14:46govern the case and how it moves, which stages
- 14:49you go through and the schedule of the case and
- 14:52whatnot. So they will really manage the case
- 14:56along with the AAA after their appointment. In
- 15:01a consumer case, arbitrators are appointed by
- 15:05the AAA. We have a specialized panel of consumer
- 15:12arbitrators, more than 1 ,700 or so across the
- 15:17country who hear these cases and who are experienced
- 15:23in hearing these cases. We'll explore the data
- 15:27a little bit later, but we have about 8 ,500
- 15:31cases a year or more. So that gives you an idea
- 15:36of how many cases we get versus how many arbitrators
- 15:44we have. So we will appoint an arbitrator and
- 15:49part of this is for efficiency sake, but part
- 15:53of this is also to maintain fairness in the process.
- 15:58We know that the business will tend to see more
- 16:03cases than an individual consumer and therefore
- 16:07a business if provided with the list process,
- 16:12would be able to have additional information
- 16:16about the arbitrators from their prior cases
- 16:19that the consumer might not have. And so we decided,
- 16:25okay, we will just go ahead and appoint the arbitrator
- 16:28so there's no influence on how that arbitrator
- 16:33is selected. If there is an issue, a party can
- 16:39object to the arbitrator. And by issue, I mean,
- 16:43the arbitrator has to make copious disclosures
- 16:48when appointed by the AAA, including information
- 16:52about past cases and whether they've worked with
- 16:57one of the attorneys. representing one of the
- 17:00parties or have been involved with either of
- 17:04the parties before along with a host of other
- 17:07information. So there is that disclosure period
- 17:13where the parties can review those disclosures
- 17:16and go ahead and make any objection to the arbitrator
- 17:19based on that information. The AAA then decides
- 17:24whether to keep the arbitrator or remove them.
- 17:29And that decision is final. We go from there.
- 17:33And so once the arbitrator is appointed, we'll
- 17:37go ahead and schedule the preliminary hearing.
- 17:40So this is where the parties and the arbitrator
- 17:44get together and talk about the schedule for
- 17:49the case. What kind of discovery is needed? When
- 17:53should motions be submitted? Is this going to
- 17:57be a desk or a live hearing? Any requirements
- 18:04for the award that the arbitrator needs to know
- 18:08about? As Delton mentioned earlier, any issues
- 18:14like governing law or other things that are going
- 18:18to be sticking points for the case? It's usually
- 18:24an hour or less. And the result of the preliminary
- 18:28hearing is a scheduling order, which is issued
- 18:33to the parties. And again, that sets out the
- 18:37scheduling of the case. So, Delton, when you
- 18:41are running a preliminary hearing, what do you
- 18:45tell parties that they should do or not do? Well,
- 18:51thank you for that. I chuckled a bit there when
- 18:54you mentioned the length of time that a preliminary
- 18:58hearing traditionally should take, because I
- 19:01was of the mind and certainly the practice to
- 19:06try to keep it to 30 minutes. That works too.
- 19:11It doesn't usually work out that way. What really
- 19:17helps in preparing for and then managing the
- 19:23preliminary hearing stage of the process is the
- 19:27party's preparation for this stage. It is perhaps
- 19:33one of the most important procedural moments
- 19:37in the case. This is when we're... going to explore
- 19:42the extent of discovery that may be desired or
- 19:50requested by the participants. We will discuss
- 19:53the type of hearing that will be used for the
- 20:03process. a host of other sort of preliminary
- 20:08issues would be addressed during this process.
- 20:14So I think one of the keys in terms of determining
- 20:17time and being inclined more towards efficiency
- 20:24and economy is the request of parties to prepare
- 20:30in advance. I think that would be the only overwhelming
- 20:35a tip that I could offer at this stage of the
- 20:39process. I typically approach the preliminary
- 20:43hearing with five objectives. I wrote them out
- 20:47so that I could remember to articulate each of
- 20:51them for you. The first would involve making
- 20:55sure that the participants understand this process.
- 21:00As we mentioned, my background in commercial
- 21:05mediation, I learned that you recognize when
- 21:09parties, regardless of their resources or sophistication,
- 21:13might not fully understand what the process is
- 21:17and what options are available to them. Consumer
- 21:21arbitration presents a very similar dynamic.
- 21:25The parties are unfamiliar with arbitration procedures,
- 21:29may feel uncertain about certain requests or
- 21:32or apprehensive in providing information that
- 21:36is essential for getting the process going. So
- 21:41I start there. And secondly, I try to help them
- 21:46help me understand what the key issues are, if
- 21:51that hasn't already been established in the preceding
- 21:57submissions, the demand and the answer. The third
- 22:02focus would be to discover the discovery protocol.
- 22:07This is something that we'll discuss maybe a
- 22:09little bit in greater detail later, but that's
- 22:13important. And a realistic schedule. you know,
- 22:18how much time is really going to be required?
- 22:23How many, you know, witnesses, if any? Will there
- 22:27be expert, you know, testimony or reports submitted?
- 22:30All of these things would, you know, if we're
- 22:37prepared, you know, we would, you know, address
- 22:40and try to plan them out accordingly. And then
- 22:45finally, The fifth thing is to address any threshold
- 22:51issues, dispositive motions for whatever they
- 22:56stand for. So that's my general approach to the
- 23:01preliminary hearing and tips that I would offer
- 23:04to practitioners or participants in the process.
- 23:11Thank you. One of the things we've mentioned
- 23:18a couple times is whether there's going to be
- 23:20a desk or a live hearing. So a desk hearing by
- 23:25default under the consumer rules, anything under
- 23:28$25 ,000 will be a desk hearing. And this is
- 23:32where each party submits their position via brief
- 23:38and the arbitrator reviews the brief and issues
- 23:41an award. So This is generally for smaller cases,
- 23:48again, under 25 ,000 in the consumer rules. And
- 23:56there's no live evidentiary hearing at that point.
- 24:00So it's just on the documents. We do have live
- 24:06hearings. If a party requests one and the arbitrator
- 24:10finds that a live hearing is necessary, even
- 24:12for a case Under 25 ,000, we will then have a
- 24:18live hearing. The default is virtual, although
- 24:21the arbitrator can decide, no, we're going to
- 24:24do this in person. And a live hearing, again,
- 24:28could be virtual. It could be telephonic. It
- 24:31could be hybrid, where some of the participants
- 24:35are in person and some are not. Or it can be
- 24:39in person. The in -person hearings since COVID
- 24:45are less and less these days. It's somewhere
- 24:49around 80 % of cases have a virtual hearing if
- 24:55they have a hearing. So that gives you an idea
- 24:57of, that was even before the rule change that
- 25:02made the default all virtual hearings. So obviously,
- 25:09Live hearing is going to be a longer process.
- 25:13There's additional administrative fees that are
- 25:16associated with having a live hearing for us
- 25:19to set it up and whatnot. And, Delta, what are
- 25:23your thoughts on when each of these might be
- 25:28useful parties? Well, so the desk. Arbitration,
- 25:35which, as you described, includes a decision
- 25:38based on the documents only, I think tends to
- 25:43be most appropriate where credibility is not
- 25:49an issue, or the necessity for expert testimony
- 25:55and demonstration is not necessary. Clearly,
- 26:01if it's a contract -based claim and it can be
- 26:08sufficiently presented in documents, I find that
- 26:14the desk arbitration is more helpful. We'll get
- 26:19to, I think, this topic a little bit later as
- 26:22well, but certainly with the onset and the availability
- 26:28of artificial intelligence now, it can provide,
- 26:33you know, an assist, you know, in that area as
- 26:36well to make the process even more useful, perhaps,
- 26:42you know, keep it in mind that the goal of the
- 26:46first primary goal is to provide the parties
- 26:51with a fair process that achieves economy and
- 26:57efficiency. Certainly, the AI tools might be
- 27:02useful in a desk arbitration context. Live hearings
- 27:07are certainly more appropriate when live testimony
- 27:14and, like I said, I think demonstrations and
- 27:18credibility is an issue. And I find that those
- 27:26are less and less, as you mentioned, live because
- 27:36of the... the ease of being able to present a
- 27:39case, you know, through the virtual platform
- 27:43or more importantly, is the cost, you know, of
- 27:48having, you know, to secure, you know, facility
- 27:51and have witnesses show up and the like, it's
- 27:56more, you know, probably less common, you know,
- 28:01that we're doing live arbitrations anymore. or
- 28:08we're doing them live, but we're not doing them
- 28:10in person, but virtually if they're live. Got
- 28:16it. Yeah, we found it's much more convenient
- 28:19for parties to do the virtual hearings rather
- 28:23than having to take off work and go travel somewhere
- 28:27to be at the in -person hearing. Desk arbitrations
- 28:36have some expedited deadlines. So the award is
- 28:43due within 14 days from when the parties submit
- 28:46everything versus in a live hearing where the
- 28:51award is due 30 days after everything is submitted
- 28:56just to make the process a little more streamlined.
- 29:03death cases. We'll move on to motion practice.
- 29:12So one of the misconceptions that a new practitioner
- 29:20might bring into arbitration is to treat it just
- 29:25like court motion practice. We have some stricter
- 29:32guidelines in the rules as far as when motions
- 29:36can be can be filed, including dispositive motions,
- 29:41because the idea is really to get to the hearing
- 29:47and have the issues heard expeditiously, get
- 29:52an expeditious award, so you're already briefing
- 29:57a lot of the same issues that might be in the
- 29:59dispositive motion for the hearing, the arbitrator
- 30:02may decide to hear that issue at the hearing
- 30:05in order to save time and make it more efficient.
- 30:11And under the new consumer rules for considering
- 30:14a dispositive motion, the arbitrator has to consider
- 30:18the cost of briefing that motion. Delton, what
- 30:24are your thoughts? If parties are going to submit
- 30:27motions, how do you like to receive them? How
- 30:33should they be written? What are your best practices
- 30:37there? Well, since we are in arbitration, not
- 30:42in court, and I'm not a judge, but an arbitrator,
- 30:47I personally prefer clarity over formality. And
- 30:53I wouldn't be more inclined to entertain a motion
- 30:58if it's short, focused, and grounded in contractual
- 31:07language, which is very different, I think, than
- 31:10what a motion would. look like or what it might
- 31:15contain if it were being presented to a judge
- 31:19in the federal courts. Here in arbitration, the
- 31:23underlining relationship filter is the contract
- 31:28to the extent that one exists and or the assumption
- 31:36of the existence of a contract through practice.
- 31:42So that would be extremely important to me when
- 31:47reviewing a motion request. And I know that we've
- 31:57had some offline discussions about this. And
- 32:01I think that with the traditional comparison
- 32:09of arbitration and litigation and the fact that
- 32:13many who come to arbitration have a litigation
- 32:16background, the expectation is that the council
- 32:22will have that level of expectation or opportunity.
- 32:30So I like Well, I don't like to do this, but
- 32:32I have to do it. In the beginning, I typically
- 32:36remind them that emotions are not a matter of
- 32:40right. You have to convince the panel that they
- 32:45would help streamline the process and get us
- 32:49to that end goal. in a way that is, um, uh, economical
- 32:54and efficient. Uh, and I probably would say those
- 32:57words, you know, many, many, many times. Um,
- 33:00but I, I think those are, you know, important,
- 33:02uh, goals to have. And so, um, that, that's kind
- 33:07of how I would, you know, respond to a motion
- 33:10request and. Okay. Um, obviously motions often,
- 33:18uh, relate to evidence and discovery. So we'll
- 33:23talk about that stage next. Obviously these can
- 33:27be intertwined depending on how your scheduling
- 33:31order is written. But in the evidence discovery
- 33:36stage, so the idea with arbitration is that it's
- 33:42not full discovery like you would get in court.
- 33:46But an important distinction with consumer arbitration
- 33:49is that it still has to be a fair process. And
- 33:55so the arbitrator has broad authority to require
- 34:01the discovery that is appropriate for the case,
- 34:05keeping in mind the efficiency of arbitration.
- 34:09Where that falls on the continuum, it's not commercial
- 34:14arbitration, which is very little, if any, discovery.
- 34:18But it's not anywhere near a full discovery that
- 34:25you might see in litigation, unless, of course,
- 34:29for some reason that was really required in the
- 34:32arbitrator's discretion for a full hearing. We
- 34:39arbitrators are allowed to order depositions
- 34:43Take place interrogatory. So the full range of
- 34:49Discovery tools is generally available in consumer
- 34:53arbitration. Just the volume of them would likely
- 34:57be less Delta what are your thoughts on best
- 35:03practices in this stage of the process? So here
- 35:08I would rely on the concept of proportionality.
- 35:16Consumer arbitration cases typically involve
- 35:20dollar amounts that are modest. in no way to
- 35:30say that all of these, the cases that I handle
- 35:33are small cases, but I think a large number of
- 35:40these disputes can range somewhere between hundreds
- 35:45of thousands, maybe tens of thousands of dollars.
- 35:52There are categories of cases that I handle that
- 35:57will be millions. And obviously, in those cases,
- 36:03you should expect a more robust discovery process.
- 36:11So proportionality, I think, is really key, keeping
- 36:15in mind that it shouldn't cost more to put on
- 36:22the case than what the case itself is worth.
- 36:30I don't know if that's... Sure. The rules do
- 36:36call for exchanging documents early, so there
- 36:40is some bit of asking the parties to work together,
- 36:45so there hopefully aren't any discovery issues,
- 36:48but at least the... exhibits that they intend
- 36:52to rely on and any witnesses that they intend
- 36:55to bring to the hearing have to be disclosed
- 37:00as well. And so if you are going to have a live
- 37:04hearing, we used to say that consumer arbitrations
- 37:10generally don't exceed one day of hearing. We
- 37:15don't say quite that anymore because there were
- 37:18There are some that do need more than one day
- 37:21of hearing, but generally it's going to be a
- 37:24half a day of hearing or less for a consumer
- 37:28arbitration. Delton maybe can correct me if I'm
- 37:31wrong on that as far as the timing of the hearing.
- 37:37But there's no... It's not, you don't have to
- 37:43call the arbitrator, your honor. And it's not
- 37:47necessarily a set procedure, although we'll generally
- 37:51follow typical court procedures. You know, there
- 37:57may be an opening statement from each side. There
- 38:00may be a closing statement from each side, depending
- 38:03on the case. But generally, This is not a long
- 38:12process. People may testify by video. They may
- 38:18testify by affidavit instead in order to streamline
- 38:23the hearing process. We can use videotaped depositions
- 38:30as witness testimony if the parties are okay
- 38:36with that and agree or the arbitrator orders
- 38:39it. So it can be very flexible. Like I said earlier,
- 38:45it can be hybrid. So the arbitrator really has
- 38:51authority to fashion that hearing in a way that
- 38:55suits the case. Dalton, what are your thoughts
- 38:59as far as best practices for hearings? Yeah,
- 39:06I think what is really quite unique in the consumer
- 39:12arbitration cases that I have facilitated is
- 39:17that It's largely a panel made of one, just me
- 39:21doing everything. And unlike in a courtroom where
- 39:26a judge may have bailiffs to take care of the
- 39:29room and a clerk to hand evidence and to manage
- 39:33all the process, it's one person doing all of
- 39:37this. So I do typically insist on a formality
- 39:42of sorts. And it can be conscute. that can screen
- 39:48as rigorous, but I like to say firm but flexible.
- 39:55Okay. But typically, you know, what's important
- 39:59for me, you know, in that context is, and this,
- 40:04of course, would vary because if I'm on a panel,
- 40:07which happens more frequently in my commercial
- 40:11arbitration cases than it does in the consumers.
- 40:14Or now, for example, I'm on a panel for an appeal
- 40:18for a consumer case. Then the division of labor
- 40:23can make the process a little bit more flexible
- 40:28and accommodating to what the needs are of the
- 40:33parties. So back to the mainframe experience
- 40:38that I'm usually the only person handling all
- 40:42of this. It is an active management process.
- 40:46There is the introduction or admission of evidence.
- 40:50There is the objections to that evidence. We
- 40:55typically follow the rule that evidence is admissible
- 41:00in the procedure process. so long as it's reasonable
- 41:05and material. And as all the lawyers in this
- 41:10webinar will appreciate, those terms aren't so
- 41:15easily defined. So many varying degrees of of
- 41:22interpretation of what that means. So you can
- 41:25end up spending an awful lot of time, you know,
- 41:28just deciding what what you're going to and what
- 41:32you're not going to allow to be presented. So
- 41:36I definitely try to. structure that part of the
- 41:41live hearing in a way that makes it more manageable
- 41:46and maybe even less stressful for people. Presentation
- 41:53of evidence through testimony or through other
- 41:59forms, that I think you're right. tends to be
- 42:05less rigorous, less formal, less more personal.
- 42:16Maybe not quite personally, I wouldn't go that
- 42:19far to say that. That's what I would say about
- 42:24the live hearing process. There wasn't something
- 42:29else I wanted to add, but it stayed in my mind.
- 42:32Maybe I'll come back to you later. Sure. After
- 42:39your hearing, the arbitrator may ask for post
- 42:46-hearing briefs. They may not. Sometimes it depends
- 42:50on the case, sometimes it depends on the arbitrator,
- 42:53whether they like post hearing briefs or not.
- 42:56But at some point, the arbitrator will decide
- 43:00that they have all the information they need
- 43:05to close the hearing. And so once the hearings
- 43:08are closed, that's a formal process. for the
- 43:13AAA, there's no more evidence or anything else
- 43:16that gets submitted to the arbitrator, nothing
- 43:18else for their consideration, because this is
- 43:22the time when the award clock starts to run.
- 43:29Some arbitrators will, especially in consumer
- 43:33cases that have attorney's fees, if the consumer
- 43:38wins the case, they may bifurcate the award and
- 43:43they may decide to do an interim award that decides
- 43:47liability. And then if the consumer wins or the
- 43:54attorney's fee provision is triggered, then take
- 43:58briefing from the parties on the issue like attorney's
- 44:02fees and decide that issue separately. And the
- 44:06thought there is that arbitrators can save the
- 44:11party's time and money in not briefing that before
- 44:15liability is decided. Because obviously, if it
- 44:19goes the other way, then there's no need. for
- 44:22the attorney's fee award in those cases. So we
- 44:25see that a lot in consumer cases that there may
- 44:29be an interim award deciding liability and then
- 44:33a final award is what we call it that decides
- 44:37the attorney's fees. But if there's not an interim
- 44:41award, then everything is just in the final award
- 44:45itself. The default under our rules is that The
- 44:51award has to contain the brief reasons for the
- 44:58award, which means it's not full findings of
- 45:03fact and conclusions of law, like you might see
- 45:06in an employment arbitration case, but it is
- 45:09not as simple as so -and -so wins or so -and
- 45:14-so loses. It has to contain the reasons why
- 45:18the award was decided. the way that it was. Part
- 45:23of this is awards are published, as I think I
- 45:26mentioned earlier. And another part of this is
- 45:30that in consumer arbitration, you really want
- 45:34to know the reasons why so that the consumer
- 45:37can understand that it was a fair process, that
- 45:41it was deliberately thought out. And even if
- 45:47they didn't win the case, that they can at least
- 45:49see why they did not win the case. As I mentioned
- 45:54earlier, if you had a desk arbitration, the deadline
- 46:00for that award is 14 days from when the hearing
- 46:03is closed. Otherwise, it's a 30 -day deadline
- 46:07from when the hearing was closed. And Delton,
- 46:13I actually want to ask you about the scope of
- 46:15award and maybe some things that an arbitrator
- 46:20should keep in mind as far as the authority that
- 46:28they bring to the table as the arbitrator. Well,
- 46:34for those who are less familiar with arbitration
- 46:38awards, I would just posit that unlike a judges
- 46:44ruling, which could be appealed for any number
- 46:48of reasons, the arbitrator's final award can
- 46:52only be challenged on a limited grant. If it's,
- 46:57you know, being administered under the FAA, the
- 47:05Federal Arbitration Act, then, you know, there
- 47:07I think are a list of 10 conditions or circumstances
- 47:12that would permit, you know, one to... a right
- 47:17to have a review of the award. And California
- 47:22Arbitration Act has a very similar. For me, I
- 47:27think that the most important aspect of the award
- 47:34writing is that it's to think of it more as something
- 47:38more than a legal analysis. Because what I want
- 47:46to achieve is an understanding by the parties
- 47:53of what they need to hear about how I reached
- 47:58the decision I reached and why. And so obviously
- 48:05I tend to write longer awards and I don't know
- 48:15why, but that's what I do. And the reason for
- 48:20doing so is just that I want them to understand
- 48:25the process, that a decision was not just reached
- 48:30out of a vacuum, but a real thought was given
- 48:35to all of the evidence that had been presented.
- 48:40Weight was accorded to every component that was
- 48:45available to me as the panel to consider as it
- 48:53relates to the issue. So I tend to take a little
- 48:57bit more time in drafting those than I think
- 49:05is customary. In more complex cases, I mean,
- 49:10obviously, within the context of consumer arbitration,
- 49:16it's not really fair to say that there are, you
- 49:19know, complex and non -complex cases because
- 49:21these are cases that involve people with, you
- 49:25know, lived experience that they are trying to
- 49:29address through a process that has been imposed
- 49:33upon them in many instances. And therefore, you
- 49:39want to, again, Error in the side of, you know,
- 49:44building or establishing a balance, you know,
- 49:48the equity component of it, you know, the decision
- 49:51making process is something that's very important
- 49:54to me. And I didn't make. A couple of things,
- 50:04so I didn't make a note for myself that in terms
- 50:08of what I. would like to accomplish in drafting
- 50:14an award. And I'll share that with you if you
- 50:17don't mind. I initially would begin with what
- 50:21I called a concise statement of the dispute and
- 50:26the relief that the parties were. seeking and
- 50:31whatever relevant factors that I was able to
- 50:35extract as undisputed facts versus those that
- 50:39were in fact disputed, materially disputed, and
- 50:46then lay out what that legal standard is. It's
- 50:50very similar to what we might have done as law
- 50:54students and creating briefs. I'm adding, I think,
- 51:01what I would call a human element to it, not
- 51:06to the extent that it's shifting my... uh position
- 51:12as a neutral but to the extent that it's providing
- 51:15you know some support you know that would make
- 51:19the the audience the the recipient of that information
- 51:22and communication you know more receptive to
- 51:25accept uh to accept it even if it's uh not in
- 51:28in their favor and oftentimes that's you know
- 51:31the case the people who are you know who don't
- 51:34win or get what they want are at least happy
- 51:39with the way that you reach your decision. So
- 51:42I'm aware of that, you know, as much as I'm aware
- 51:46of the very narrow, you know, circumstances in
- 51:52which an award can be overturned. And of course,
- 51:55you wouldn't want your award overturned. So that's...
- 52:01something to keep in mind. I wanted to achieve
- 52:06a sense of clarity as well, you know, conciseness,
- 52:10brevity. I had a professor in law school who
- 52:14always preached brevity. And it's like, what
- 52:19does that mean? We're writing legal documents.
- 52:25And the more words, the better, right? It's usually
- 52:28not the case, and especially when drafting an
- 52:32award. So that's usually the approach that I
- 52:38would take. Calculated, methodical, progress
- 52:47towards the end result. Thank you, Delton. And
- 52:55that was a nice covering of the post award. And
- 53:01these are final and binding decisions subject
- 53:06to very limited circumstances for appeals, modification,
- 53:11or vacator. It's interesting. You mentioned you're
- 53:15serving on a consumer appeals case. Appeals are
- 53:19not common in arbitration. They only occur when
- 53:23the party's agreement calls for an appeal. But
- 53:26the consumer space seems to be the most popular
- 53:30space for those kind of appeals provisions and
- 53:34contracts. So just an interesting tidbit there.
- 53:38But I want to talk shift gears. move away from
- 53:42talking about the stages of the case to talk
- 53:44about AI use in arbitration. The AAA is using
- 53:50AI for a lot of different things. We partnered
- 53:56with Clearbrief to offer that services to arbitrators,
- 54:00and that allows them to make timelines based
- 54:04on the submissions, check citations, and generally
- 54:09perform their document review function much quicker
- 54:15and better. We've published a number of AI case
- 54:22preparation books. So a party can go to this
- 54:27AI book and it was written by human authors,
- 54:33but we took AI then you can ask questions about
- 54:36the book and it'll give you answers based on
- 54:38the book. We have rules chat bots, excuse me,
- 54:43for each of our rule sets as well, including
- 54:46the consumer rules and a chat bot that helps
- 54:49parties get through the filing process. Our online
- 54:54portal has AI document summarization. We use
- 55:00AI in our arbitrator searches so we can get the
- 55:04most expert arbitrator for your case. And we
- 55:09tried a number of different things, some of which
- 55:13didn't work. For example, we tried an AI scheduling
- 55:16order tool where the AI would take the transcript
- 55:20of the preliminary hearing and spit out a scheduling
- 55:24order that was okay, but needed more work than
- 55:28was really saved in that process. And Delton,
- 55:35what are your thoughts on AI uses and best practices?
- 55:42I'm a strong proponent for use of AI as a tool.
- 55:47And I now include a provision in my scheduling
- 55:52orders that basically invite the parties to incorporate
- 55:58it as a tool in the process. During law school,
- 56:05I had a nickname, I guess, that my fellow classmates
- 56:11had given to me. It was data. I could remember
- 56:16the page numbers that certain cases were on.
- 56:20And if there was a holding or a ruling stated
- 56:24specifically, I could tell you which paragraph
- 56:26from that page it was. I don't know why, but
- 56:29that was sort of how my brain operates. And so
- 56:35it can be overwhelming when you're trying to
- 56:40cipher through so much information. And having
- 56:46a tool like, you know, I won't say any brands,
- 56:51but I mean having access to tools that would,
- 56:54you know, help. you know, streamline that process,
- 56:59you know, of sifting through the information
- 57:02and creating, you know, charts, you know, it's
- 57:07extremely, you know, important. I have, for example,
- 57:11a recent arbitration, which again, I think stands
- 57:16as an exception. This was five days, full days
- 57:20of testimony. Each side had four or five experts.
- 57:28And it was extremely detailed, very technical
- 57:35issue. And at the end of it, I had learned so
- 57:43much more about this particular operation. But
- 57:50at the same time, I was, you know, I was not
- 57:53an engineer. So, you know, it was it was helpful
- 57:58to be able to have, you know, the tools like
- 58:01clear brief, which the AAA provides complimentary
- 58:05to its arbitrators to put my data into this,
- 58:11you know, program, and then tell it, you know,
- 58:14to, you know, organize it. for me so that I could
- 58:19find things more easily. And in this case, I
- 58:23also requested for the AI to create hyperlinks
- 58:29to each of the cases and statutes that were cited
- 58:33within the documents that I was reviewing. So
- 58:36because this is a closed universe, it's only
- 58:38the information that I'm feeding it, I wasn't
- 58:40as concerned with some of the challenges that
- 58:44people are having with generative AI. So these
- 58:49hyperlinks would enable me to read the document
- 58:53and have, you know, let's say the case, you know,
- 58:56in a separate panel and be able to go back and
- 59:00forwards between the case and the brief, you
- 59:02know, at the same time. And it would even do,
- 59:05you know, citation checks and offer... you know,
- 59:10history of that case, and it just was, you know,
- 59:14quite robust. It could never have, would have
- 59:17never have been able to imagine handling all
- 59:22of that information by myself, you know, for,
- 59:27and meeting a 30 -day deadline to draft an award.
- 59:31I mean, so that... I'm a strong proponent of
- 59:35the use of AI, to get back to your question,
- 59:39when it's used appropriately and ethically. I
- 59:41think ethically is important as well. Thank you.
- 59:46We only have a minute left, but I did want to
- 59:49show some data about our consumer arbitration
- 59:52caseload. So this is for 2024. in early 2026
- 1:00:00will come out with our 2025 numbers. But we had
- 1:00:04about 8 ,500 -ish consumer cases filed last year.
- 1:00:10That was down a little bit from 2023, where we
- 1:00:14had about 10 ,000. Most of those cases were in
- 1:00:17California, about 3 ,000 of those. Texas was
- 1:00:21the next state with over 700. Most of those cases
- 1:00:26settled, 55 % settled. About 13 % were awarded.
- 1:00:34So that gives you an idea of the breakdown between
- 1:00:38how these cases get disposed of. And we saw the
- 1:00:44most cases in financial services. So that includes
- 1:00:47consumers against banks, consumers against crypto
- 1:00:50exchanges. crypto exchanges really drove a lot
- 1:00:55of these cases last year. I think it's important
- 1:00:59to highlight that these cases were resolved by
- 1:01:03award in a median of eight and a half months.
- 1:01:06The settled cases obviously may have resolved
- 1:01:09a lot quicker than that. consumers didn't pay
- 1:01:13fees in more than half of these cases. So we
- 1:01:17either waived fees or the business was responsible
- 1:01:21for the contract in more than half of the cases
- 1:01:25we received last year. I think that's the end
- 1:01:31of the program, but I'm happy to share my email
- 1:01:35address if anyone has other questions. It is
- 1:01:40SeanakA at ADR .org. And mine is Delton, D -E
- 1:01:49-L -T -O -N at LawOfficeDRH .com. And thank you
- 1:01:57all for attending. Thank you. This concludes
- 1:02:00today's presentation. Thank you so much, Adam
- 1:02:02and Delton, for your time and sharing your education.
- 1:02:06educating our members today and thank you so
- 1:02:08much to our members for attending. Have a great
- 1:02:10day everybody.