Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 78
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder True crime cases five four, three, two, one one one
- 0:21one. Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you
- 0:31are all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get
- 0:34started. The price of jealousy was murder the case of Kelly Cochrane. This
- 0:47case is an unsurprising yet startling example of what can happen when a love triangle
- 0:51goes wrong. Two individuals involved in an illicit affair suffered tragic and undeserved fates
- 0:58in the worst possible scenario imaginable. You won't believe what happened, but be
- 1:03warned the story ahead is shocking and disturbing. This case ended up in murder,
- 1:11not once, but twice. If you found out your significant other was
- 1:17cheating on you, how far would they have to go for them to find
- 1:19themselves back in your good graces? Would you want to be allowed to cheat
- 1:23yourself? Maybe they'd have to buy you that expensive piece of jewelry you've had
- 1:29your eye on, or a new set of wheels. For some, it
- 1:33would be impossible to forgive the indiscretion. What if the price of forgiveness was
- 1:38something you never thought you were capable of. Would you be able to go
- 1:42through with it. Kelly and Jason cochrane had been a couple since they attended
- 1:48high school together in Merrillville, Indiana. Even then, they thought they were
- 1:53meant to be together, so once Kelly graduated from high school in two thousand
- 1:57and two, the couple tied the night. For the first ten years of
- 2:01their marriage, things were pretty good for the two of them. Jason worked
- 2:06servicing swimming pools, earning himself a decent living to go along with his wife's
- 2:09paycheck. Unfortunately, a back issue forced him out of the job market,
- 2:15leaving Kelly as the primary breadwinner of their family. No matter how hard she
- 2:21worked, their debts continued to pile up to the point they left their hometown
- 2:24for the city of Caspian, Michigan. The new location also offered the benefit
- 2:30of legal marijuana that they hoped would help in relieving the debilitating pain Jason suffered
- 2:35from. After the move, Kelly began working in a factory that manufactured parts
- 2:40for naval vessels. While there, she met another employee named Christopher Reagan.
- 2:46Despite a twenty year difference in age and both of them being involved with someone
- 2:51else, the two became close and eventually things turned intimate. The relationship would
- 2:58not, however, remain a secret. When Jason found out about his wife's
- 3:02infidelity, he was heartbroken. He was not one to allow Kelly to continue
- 3:07to see Reagan and remain quiet about it. When he confronted her about the
- 3:12transgression, she expressed remorse for her shortcomings, but that wasn't enough for Jason
- 3:16to feel Kelly had properly learned her lesson. Jason asked his wife a very
- 3:22simple question, how are you going to make this right? Her answer was
- 3:27simple. Kelly told her husband of thirteen years she would allow him to kill
- 3:31Reagan. The plan to do so went as follows. She would invite Christopher
- 3:38over to their house with the promise of sex, where Jason would be lying
- 3:42in wait to take out the thing that had come between the two of them.
- 3:46The ploy worked to perfection. On the night of October fourteenth, twenty
- 3:51fourteen, Christopher and Kelly were engaged in their love making when Jason, who
- 3:57was at the time hiding in the shadows of the room, came out out
- 4:00armed with a rifle and shot Reagan at point blank range, even before Reagan's
- 4:04blood hadn't yet fully drained from his body. Kelly was already handing her husband
- 4:10a buzzsaw for him to cut apart the body to dispose of it. Neighbors
- 4:14even reported hearing the shot and then the sound of power tools that night.
- 4:18In regards to the issue of Reagan's car that he'd driven to their house to
- 4:21meet up with Kelly, they'd abandon it on the outskirts of town. It
- 4:28would be ten days before Christopher's girlfriend at the time would report him missing.
- 4:31By this point, most of what was left of his body had already been
- 4:35taken to and dumped in the woods. After the report was made, police
- 4:40found his vehicle where it had been left by the Cochranes. There was one
- 4:45piece of evidence the couple had failed to get rid of or even notice when
- 4:47they'd taken his car. Reagan had left a post it note with directions to
- 4:53their house inside. When investigators paid the two a visit, Kelly gave off
- 4:59a calm and comfortable demeanor. Jason, however, appeared nervous. The two
- 5:04were separated and questioned. Kelly admitted to the affair with Reagan, but claimed
- 5:10her and Jason had an open marriage. When they spoke to Jason he gave
- 5:14the distinct impression that he was very upset about Kelly's behavior. There were definite
- 5:19inconsistencies with the statements, but other than suspicion, there wasn't any evidence foreign
- 5:25arrest, and the trail leading to the whereabouts of Christopher Reagan went cold when
- 5:30the FBI conducted a search of their home in March twenty fifteen, Kelly and
- 5:34Jason were starting to feel like the news was tightening around their necks. To
- 5:40put some distance between themselves and Reagan's murder, they moved to Hobart, Indiana.
- 5:46It was here, only fifteen months after the move, that Kelly would
- 5:48strike again. This time, the victim was Jason himself. When paramedics were
- 5:55called to their home, they found Jason unresponsive after an apparent win overdose.
- 6:00Meanwhile, Kelly was purposefully trying to disrupt any attempts they made to revive her
- 6:05husband. His funeral was held a few days later, and Kelly did her
- 6:11best to play the part of a grieving widow. Those that were in attendance
- 6:15didn't know that while this was going on, she was preparing to skip town
- 6:19to Kentucky, funding this move by selling many of their possessions online. At
- 6:25this point, the medical examiner had taken a look at Jason's body and determined
- 6:30the actual cause of death to be asphyxiation, not an overdose. This prompted
- 6:35a warrant to be issued for Kelly's arrest on multiple charges, the greatest of
- 6:40which was the murder of her husband. Despite her attempts to avoid capture,
- 6:46Kelly made the foolish mistake of keeping in contact with investigators. She told them
- 6:50that she was somewhere on the west coast of the United States, but police
- 6:55tracked her phone to the town of Wingo, Kentucky, where the Marshal Service
- 6:59would arrest her on April twenty ninth. During her trial, a number of
- 7:03facts came out about the two murders, The first of which was Kelly had
- 7:08attempted to kill Jason by intentionally giving him what she believed to be a lethal
- 7:13amount of heroin, but to be sure her husband didn't recover, she smothered
- 7:16him as well. At first, Kelly had considered killing Jason instead of Reagan
- 7:23because she was convinced Christopher was the only good thing in her life. It
- 7:27was when Christopher rejected her offer of a serious relationship, Kelly hatched the plan
- 7:31to have her husband kill him. One of the most shocking and gruesome revelations
- 7:36the couple's friends and family had to accept was that they had likely been served
- 7:42pieces of Reagan's body that had been barbecued shortly after his death. Kelly cochrane
- 7:48was sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder of Christopher Reagan, and she earned
- 7:54an additional sixty five years behind bars for murdering her husband. Only later,
- 7:59while in carcerrated, did she boast of other killings that could bring her body
- 8:03count as high as nine, leading some to believe her to be a serial killer.