Latest / The Morning Rundown / A Weak Jobs Number, a Failed Execution Fallout, and Cornell's Prosecutor Shake-Up
Transcript
- 0:14[Maya] Okay, I'm on my second coffee, and it's still not enough for
- 0:17[Maya] this news cycle.
- 0:18[David] Mine's tea.
- 0:19[David] Very disciplined.
- 0:20[David] It's gonna need a backup.
- 0:21[Maya] Wait, really?
- 0:22[Maya] Tea?
- 0:23[Maya] On a Friday like this?
- 0:24[David] Hey, I'm a calm person, Maya.
- 0:26[Maya] Sure you are, Mr.
- 0:27[Maya] Calm.
- 0:28[Maya] Anyway, this is the Morning Rundown.
- 0:30[Maya] I'm Maya, that's David, and we've got a rough one.
- 0:33[David] Three stories this morning.
- 0:35[David] First, a jobs number that surprised a lot of people.
- 0:37[Maya] Then the fallout in Tennessee after that execution went wrong.
- 0:41[David] And a Cornell case where one omitted statement changes the whole picture.
- 0:46[Maya] Ugh.
- 0:46[Maya] Institutions not doing the basic job, basically.
- 0:50[David] Ha, fair.
- 0:51[David] But the number comes first, since everybody was waiting on it this
- 0:54[David] morning.
- 0:54[Maya] Right.
- 0:55[Maya] Let's start there.
- 0:56[David] And we'll keep it measured on the two heavier ones.
- 0:58[David] No guessing past what's actually been reported.
- 1:00[Maya] Good rule.
- 1:01[Maya] Okay, here we go.
- 1:02[Maya] The jobs number right now.
- 1:05[Maya] Okay, twenty-nine thousand.
- 1:06[Maya] That's the September payroll number, and the Bureau of Labor Statistics itself
- 1:11[Maya] calls that little changed.
- 1:12[David] Which is government speak for we looked, and nothing much happened.
- 1:16[Maya] Right?
- 1:17[Maya] Nobody writes a headline about little changed.
- 1:19[David] True, but for a lot of households, that phrase matters.
- 1:23[David] Little changed means the job market isn't collapsing, and it also isn't
- 1:26[David] giving anyone much of a tailwind.
- 1:28[Maya] So not a crisis headline, not a good news headline, just a
- 1:32[Maya] shrug with a number attached.
- 1:34[David] The unemployment rate sits at four point two percent, and that's been
- 1:37[David] boxed in between four point one and four point three since March.
- 1:41[David] So the BLS says the rate has barely moved for months.
- 1:45[Maya] So it's steady, but it's not hiring.
- 1:47[David] That's the tension in one sentence.
- 1:49[David] A steady rate and a small hiring number can look odd side
- 1:52[David] by side, so it's worth slowing down on.
- 1:54[Maya] And one month of data doesn't make a trend, so I'm not
- 1:57[Maya] going to pretend it does.
- 1:59[David] Mm.
- 2:00[David] Now, the expectation was way higher.
- 2:02[David] CNBC reported a Dow Jones consensus of eighty-four thousand.
- 2:06[Maya] Wait, really?
- 2:07[Maya] So the economists were off by more than fifty thousand jobs?
- 2:11[David] Roughly.
- 2:12[David] Picture a restaurant planning for eighty-four diners and seating twenty-nine.
- 2:16[David] You notice.
- 2:17[Maya] You notice, and the cook's already prepped.
- 2:19[David] Here's the part that cuts against the doom story, though.
- 2:22[David] CNBC says unemployment ticked up largely because more people entered the labor
- 2:26[David] force.
- 2:27[Maya] Meaning they're looking for work, not getting laid off.
- 2:30[David] Right.
- 2:31[David] And the broader underemployment measure actually fell to seven point six percent.
- 2:35[Maya] Huh.
- 2:36[Maya] That's a better sign than the headline.
- 2:38[David] It is, and it's why I'd read past the top line.
- 2:41[David] A rate can rise for a bad reason or a less bad
- 2:43[David] reason, and here CNBC points to more people looking for work.
- 2:47[Maya] Right.
- 2:48[Maya] So the headline says weak, and the details say people are still
- 2:51[Maya] trying to get in the door.
- 2:53[David] It is.
- 2:54[David] But I keep coming back to it.
- 2:55[David] People are coming off the sidelines, they want jobs, and employers are
- 2:59[David] shrugging.
- 3:00[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 3:01[Maya] That's the question.
- 3:02[Maya] A growing labor force and nobody hiring them.
- 3:05[David] And I'd be careful not to overclaim.
- 3:07[David] One month is one month.
- 3:08[David] But if workers are showing up and businesses aren't taking them on,
- 3:12[David] it's fair to ask whether something about the business climate is making
- 3:15[David] employers hesitate.
- 3:16[Maya] Costs, rules, uncertainty.
- 3:18[Maya] Pick your flavor.
- 3:19[David] Pick one, sure, but I can't prove which from this report.
- 3:22[David] It just raises the flag.
- 3:24[Maya] So what would you want to see next to know if it's
- 3:27[Maya] a blip or something stickier?
- 3:29[David] More months of data, honestly.
- 3:31[David] If hiring stays soft while people keep coming into the labor force,
- 3:34[David] the question gets louder.
- 3:35[David] If it bounces back, we shrug and move on.
- 3:38[Maya] Fair.
- 3:39[Maya] What about healthcare?
- 3:40[Maya] That's usually the steady one.
- 3:42[David] Healthcare added seventeen thousand.
- 3:44[David] The BLS release has the average monthly gain over the prior twelve
- 3:47[David] months at forty-five thousand.
- 3:49[Maya] So even the reliable engine is running at well under half speed.
- 3:53[David] Seventeen thousand against forty-five thousand.
- 3:56[David] That's the sector detail I'd keep an eye on because healthcare came
- 3:59[David] in lower than its own recent average.
- 4:01[Maya] Which fits with the overall number being soft, though I can't tell
- 4:04[Maya] you from here what's driving it.
- 4:06[David] Yeah, which makes the market reaction weird.
- 4:09[Maya] Oh, this is the funny part.
- 4:11[Maya] Stocks went up.
- 4:12[David] They did.
- 4:13[David] CNBC says markets rose because traders now see the Fed likely holding
- 4:17[David] at its October meeting.
- 4:19[Maya] Bad news is good news.
- 4:20[Maya] Ugh, Wall Street's whole personality.
- 4:23[David] Hey, I'm not sure it's a personality.
- 4:25[David] It's more like a hope that a weak number keeps borrowing costs
- 4:27[David] from rising.
- 4:29[Maya] Still wild, though.
- 4:30[Maya] Fewer jobs and everybody's cheering.
- 4:32[David] Cheering for a hold, not for the jobs.
- 4:35[Maya] And a Hold isn't guaranteed, right?
- 4:37[Maya] Traders just see it as Likely.
- 4:39[David] Right.
- 4:39[David] Likely, not certain.
- 4:41[David] October is the meeting, and we'll see what the Fed actually does.
- 4:43[Maya] Okay.
- 4:44[Maya] That's a distinction I'll happily take for now, Honestly.
- 4:47[Maya] All right, shifting gears because the next one is a Different kind
- 4:50[Maya] of failure.
- 4:51[David] Now to a story where the process itself is the problem: Tennessee.
- 4:56[Maya] Okay, Tennessee.
- 4:57[Maya] And I want to keep this one plain because the facts are
- 5:00[Maya] heavy enough.
- 5:01[David] Agreed.
- 5:02[David] Wednesday night, Christa Pike was supposed to be executed.
- 5:05[David] She survived two doses of pentobarbital.
- 5:08[Maya] Two doses, and the US Supreme Court had cleared it earlier that
- 5:12[Maya] same day.
- 5:13[David] So every legal hurdle was done.
- 5:15[David] The court said go, the state went, and the procedure itself didn't
- 5:19[David] work.
- 5:19[Maya] And that's what stands out to me.
- 5:21[Maya] The legal side was settled, so the open question is entirely about
- 5:25[Maya] what happened in that room.
- 5:27[David] Which is why the focus has moved from the courtroom to the
- 5:29[David] process itself.
- 5:30[Maya] CBS News has the next piece.
- 5:32[Maya] Governor Bill Lee canceled the state's remaining scheduled execution this year.
- 5:36[David] And he also ordered a third-party review on top of that.
- 5:40[Maya] Right.
- 5:40[Maya] Outside eyes, not the Department looking at itself.
- 5:43[David] Which matters because the Tennessee Department of Corrections says it followed its
- 5:47[David] protocol.
- 5:48[Maya] Wait, so it followed the protocol and she's still alive?
- 5:52[David] That's the claim, and I'll be honest, I don't know what to
- 5:55[David] do with it yet.
- 5:56[David] Either the protocol was followed and the protocol is the problem, or
- 5:59[David] something happened that the protocol didn't catch.
- 6:01[Maya] Hmm.
- 6:02[Maya] Those are two very different failures.
- 6:05[David] Very.
- 6:05[David] One is a policy question for the legislature.
- 6:08[David] The other is a competence question for the people in that room.
- 6:11[Maya] And they lead different places.
- 6:13[Maya] One means lawmakers have to look at the rules.
- 6:15[Maya] The other means looking at how the rules were carried out.
- 6:19[David] Right.
- 6:19[David] And a review from outside the Department of Correction at least has a chance
- 6:22[David] of telling those apart.
- 6:23[David] I'd just add that we don't know yet what it will be
- 6:25[David] allowed to cover.
- 6:26[Maya] Okay, now the part that's contested.
- 6:29[Maya] NBC News carried a Thursday update from her lawyers.
- 6:32[Maya] They say she's alive but in critical condition, and her prognosis is
- 6:35[Maya] unclear.
- 6:36[David] Unclear.
- 6:37[David] So nobody's promising anything.
- 6:39[Maya] Nobody.
- 6:40[Maya] And one of those lawyers, Randall Spivey, told NBC he counted at
- 6:44[Maya] least seven needles in her left arm.
- 6:46[David] Seven?
- 6:47[Maya] At least seven.
- 6:49[Maya] And he said one of them looked bent.
- 6:51[David] Okay.
- 6:51[David] I wanna be careful because that's attorney testimony.
- 6:54[David] It's not an official finding.
- 6:56[Maya] Totally.
- 6:56[Maya] It's what one side's lawyer says he saw.
- 6:59[Maya] It raises questions about how the procedure was carried out and why
- 7:02[Maya] it failed, but it doesn't answer them.
- 7:04[David] And all we have from the department is that it followed its
- 7:06[David] protocol.
- 7:07[Maya] So two accounts that don't obviously match and no official finding to
- 7:11[Maya] sort it out.
- 7:12[David] And that's why the review matters more than any one account.
- 7:14[David] You have the state saying protocol was followed.
- 7:17[David] You have the lawyers describing something that sounds nothing like a clean
- 7:20[David] process.
- 7:21[Maya] Somebody has to reconcile those.
- 7:23[David] Somebody independent, ideally.
- 7:25[David] Whatever you think about the death penalty, and people land everywhere on
- 7:28[David] it, a state that carries one out owes the public a basic
- 7:31[David] level of competence.
- 7:32[Maya] I mean, come on.
- 7:33[Maya] If the government is going to do the most serious thing it
- 7:35[Maya] can do to a person, it should be able to do it
- 7:38[Maya] right.
- 7:39[David] Right.
- 7:39[David] Supporters of capital punishment should want that answer more than anyone.
- 7:43[David] If you believe in the penalty, you don't want it run sloppily.
- 7:46[Maya] And NPR reports this failed attempt has reignited furious debate about the
- 7:50[Maya] death penalty across the US.
- 7:52[David] Which was predictable.
- 7:53[David] Everyones gonna read their own view into it.
- 7:55[Maya] And that's fine.
- 7:56[Maya] That's what a democracy does with something like this.
- 7:59[Maya] But the review is the part that can produce facts instead of
- 8:02[Maya] opinions.
- 8:03[David] Right.
- 8:03[David] And what it covers matters.
- 8:05[David] We don't have its scope yet, so I'd hold off on assuming
- 8:07[David] it will answer every question people have.
- 8:10[Maya] Sure.
- 8:10[Maya] But the narrower question is the one with a deadline.
- 8:13[Maya] The state says it followed its rules, so what does the review
- 8:16[Maya] find?
- 8:16[David] And I'm not gonna predict that.
- 8:18[David] We'll see what comes out and whether it's public.
- 8:20[Maya] Fair.
- 8:21[Maya] Speaking of which, there's another case where someone is saying the system
- 8:24[Maya] failed, and this one is moving fast.
- 8:27[David] Cornell, yeah.
- 8:28[David] That one has a twist.
- 8:29[Maya] Okay, Cornell.
- 8:31[Maya] And I wanna be careful here because this one involves allegations, and
- 8:34[Maya] nobody has been convicted of anything.
- 8:37[David] Agreed.
- 8:37[David] So the facts we have are about the process, not about guilt.
- 8:40[Maya] Right.
- 8:41[Maya] Governor Kathy Hochul appointed Attorney General Letitia James as special prosecutor by
- 8:46[Maya] executive order.
- 8:47[David] By executive order.
- 8:48[David] So she didn't ask the county nicely.
- 8:51[Maya] No.
- 8:52[Maya] She did it at a Friday news conference.
- 8:54[Maya] Hochul cited serious questions about the Cornell police investigation and about the
- 8:58[Maya] Tompkins County DA's decision not to prosecute.
- 9:02[David] Hmm, that's two separate things she's questioning, the police work and then
- 9:05[David] the DA's call.
- 9:07[Maya] Yep.
- 9:07[Maya] And The Guardian reports Hochul says she no longer trusts the local
- 9:10[Maya] DA's ability to handle the case.
- 9:13[David] That's a governor saying out loud that a county prosecutor can't be
- 9:16[David] relied on.
- 9:17[David] That's rare.
- 9:18[Maya] Very.
- 9:19[Maya] Now, here's the part that turns this whole story.
- 9:22[David] Go.
- 9:22[Maya] The ABC7 reported that per The Times, the woman told campus police
- 9:27[Maya] she was raped, and that statement was left out of the report
- 9:31[Maya] given to the DA.
- 9:32[David] Wait, left out from the report the prosecutor used to decide?
- 9:36[Maya] That's what ABC7 is relaying, and I wanna flag it's secondhand.
- 9:41[Maya] ABC7 is passing along The Times.
- 9:43[Maya] I'm not saying I've seen the report.
- 9:45[David] Fair, but if it holds up, think about what that means.
- 9:48[Maya] Go on.
- 9:49[David] A DA can only weigh what lands on the desk.
- 9:52[David] If the most basic statement, "I was raped," never makes it into
- 9:55[David] the paperwork, the decision not to prosecute was made on a partial
- 9:58[David] file.
- 9:59[Maya] Right.
- 10:00[Maya] And we don't know yet who left it out or why.
- 10:03[David] Totally.
- 10:04[David] That's what an investigation is for.
- 10:05[David] Nobody should pretend to know that today.
- 10:08[Maya] Hochul went pretty far in her language, though.
- 10:10[Maya] She said the accuser was failed by those obligated to protect her.
- 10:15[David] That's a strong line, though I'd note she's the one who appointed
- 10:18[David] the investigator, so that's a statement from the person starting the process.
- 10:22[Maya] Sure, but James has a piece of this, too.
- 10:24[Maya] She said her office will also review how Cornell handled the allegations.
- 10:28[David] So the scope isn't just the DA, it's the university.
- 10:31[Maya] Campus police, the DA, and the school's own handling.
- 10:35[Maya] Three layers.
- 10:37[David] Which makes you wonder who else was in the chain.
- 10:39[Maya] Maybe.
- 10:39[Maya] We'll see what James finds.
- 10:41[Maya] The Guardian says the case has restarted a national conversation about sexual
- 10:45[Maya] assault on college campuses.
- 10:47[David] And that conversation's been going a long time.
- 10:50[David] Parents hand over tuition and assume somebody's keeping students safe and keeping
- 10:54[David] records straight.
- 10:55[Maya] You'd hope that's the baseline.
- 10:57[David] Can I flag one thing about how we're talking about this?
- 11:00[David] There are really three different pieces in play, and they're easy to
- 11:03[David] blur together.
- 11:04[Maya] Walk me through it.
- 11:05[David] First, what campus police gathered and wrote up.
- 11:08[David] Second, what got passed along to the DA.
- 11:11[David] Third, the DA's call not to prosecute.
- 11:14[David] Hochul cited questions about the first and the third.
- 11:17[Maya] And the omitted statement sits right in the middle between the first
- 11:20[Maya] and the second.
- 11:21[David] If the reporting holds, yes, it's the hinge.
- 11:23[David] But again, that's an if.
- 11:25[David] We're relaying a relay here.
- 11:27[Maya] Right.
- 11:28[Maya] And why does that matter to someone who's never set foot on
- 11:30[Maya] a campus?
- 11:32[David] Because a decision not to prosecute is only as good as what
- 11:35[David] it was based on.
- 11:36[David] If it was made on a full file, that's a judgment call
- 11:38[David] people can disagree with.
- 11:40[David] If it was made on a partial file, that's a different kind
- 11:42[David] of problem, and it's one that a fresh set of eyes can
- 11:45[David] look at.
- 11:45[Maya] Which seems to be the whole idea of bringing in someone from
- 11:48[Maya] outside the county.
- 11:49[David] That's how I read it.
- 11:51[David] Hochul said she no longer trusts the local DA's ability to handle
- 11:54[David] the case, so she handed it to the Attorney General.
- 11:56[David] What James can do beyond what's been said at the news conference,
- 12:00[David] I don't know, and I'm not going to guess.
- 12:02[Maya] And it all rests on allegations.
- 12:04[Maya] Nobody's been convicted, no guilt has been assigned, and an investigation is
- 12:08[Maya] supposed to test every account properly.
- 12:11[David] Which cuts both ways.
- 12:12[David] A careful process protects the woman, and it protects anyone who's been
- 12:15[David] accused.
- 12:16[David] That's why the process matters more than the headline.
- 12:19[Maya] Totally.
- 12:20[Maya] And it's why I'd rather be slow and accurate than fast and
- 12:23[Maya] loud on this one.
- 12:24[David] For now, the thing to watch is what James' office turns up
- 12:27[David] on the police work, the DA's decision, and how Cornell handled it.
- 12:31[Maya] And whether the public gets to see it.
- 12:33[Maya] All right, let's close out the show.
- 12:35[Maya] Okay, so one line each.
- 12:37[Maya] A jobs number that came in way under what Wall Street expected.
- 12:41[David] A Tennessee execution that went sideways with a review now promised.
- 12:45[Maya] And Cornell, where a prosecutor got swapped because of what may not
- 12:48[Maya] have made it into a file.
- 12:50[David] Different stories, same uncomfortable question about who was supposed to be minding
- 12:54[David] the shop.
- 12:55[Maya] Right?
- 12:56[Maya] So what should people keep an eye on?
- 12:58[David] The Fed's October meeting.
- 13:00[David] That's where the soft jobs picture meets an actual decision, and I'd
- 13:04[David] rather watch what they do than what anyone says about it beforehand.
- 13:08[Maya] Totally.
- 13:08[Maya] Honestly, I'm just hoping next week is quieter.
- 13:11[Maya] I'll need more than coffee for that.
- 13:14[David] Noted.
- 13:14[David] Bring backup tea.
- 13:16[Maya] Thanks for listening, everybody, and that's The Rundown.