Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Protecting Your IP with Manny Caixeiro, Rebecca Horton, Elizabeth Manno
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to nuts and bolts of protecting your
- 0:06IP. I'm Alapoli Castro, CLE advisor for the Beverly
- 0:10Hills Bar Association, and today I'm delighted
- 0:12to introduce our speakers, Elizabeth Mono, Manny
- 0:15Kysheru, and Rebecca Horton of Venable LLP. Elizabeth
- 0:20focuses on technology disputes including patent
- 0:22infringement, licensing, trade secrets, and other
- 0:25IP litigation. Elizabeth represents leading companies
- 0:28in technology fields including media streaming,
- 0:31software, semiconductors, GPS, wireless devices,
- 0:35Internet of Things, artificial intelligence,
- 0:37and medical software. She also counsels companies
- 0:41on creating, maintaining, and maximizing the
- 0:43benefits of their IP portfolios. With her holistic
- 0:46approach, Elizabeth provides a steady hand and
- 0:49sound advice at every phase of disputes. Manny
- 0:52represents industry leaders and cutting -edge
- 0:54companies in their most challenging litigation
- 0:56matters. Manny focuses on complex commercial
- 0:59and intellectual property disputes across a range
- 1:02of industries including software, medical devices,
- 1:05financial services, and entertainment. He has
- 1:08extensive experience litigating issues involving
- 1:10patent damages, valuations, and licensing on
- 1:13behalf of both plaintiffs and defendants. Rebecca
- 1:16helps clients protect their intellectual property
- 1:18and brands. Rebecca is a skilled litigator who
- 1:21advises clients on the protection and enforcement
- 1:23of their IP rights. She serves clients across
- 1:26a broad range of industries including technology,
- 1:29financial services, and consumer goods and retail.
- 1:31Rebecca handles high stakes litigation involving
- 1:34trademarks, copyright, patents, and trade secrets.
- 1:38Super Lawyers has repeatedly selected Rebecca
- 1:40as a rising star in the intellectual property
- 1:42space. She is also a frequent speaker at conferences
- 1:46and contributor to legal publications related
- 1:48to IP issues. We can't wait what they have to
- 1:50share with us today. Thank you so much for those
- 1:52introductions and thank you everyone for joining.
- 1:54We're really excited to speak to you today about
- 1:56the nuts and bolts of protecting your IP. So
- 1:59we have a presentation that we'll pull up. But
- 2:02over our years of practice, we've already, I
- 2:04think, come to appreciate just how important
- 2:06IP can be to a company's business strategy. So
- 2:10we're excited to talk to you today about that.
- 2:12And hopefully, you'll have the answer to this
- 2:14question about why you should care about IP by
- 2:16the end of it. But at a very high level, your
- 2:19clients and the companies you work for work very
- 2:22hard to come up with innovations, creative work,
- 2:25art, and branding. And so it's important to protect
- 2:28those things as part of your business strategy
- 2:30otherwise you are risking losing out on some
- 2:33of the value that you know your companies are
- 2:35creating. So next slide please. So we want to
- 2:38talk kind of about the different ways that you
- 2:40can protect your IP and then we're going to also
- 2:42talk a little bit about how you can maybe decide
- 2:44between which type of protection is important.
- 2:47So the first one if we can go to the next slide
- 2:49is patents. So you've probably heard of a patent
- 2:53before. They come up a lot. But basically, a
- 2:55patent gives you the right to exclude others
- 2:58from using or selling your invention for a limited
- 3:02period of years. It's usually about 20 years.
- 3:05And in exchange for that, you are going to publicly
- 3:08share your invention so that patents become public,
- 3:11anyone can access them, but you get the right
- 3:12to exclude anyone else from practicing that technology
- 3:16for that period of time. So that's sort of the
- 3:18trade -off there. And so there's pros and cons
- 3:21to that, but there's a lot of benefits. The benefit
- 3:24is you get to monopolize the market in a legal
- 3:26way. You can be the only company that is able
- 3:29to practice that technology. And patents are
- 3:32a licensing, a licensable item. You can sell
- 3:36that technology, allow others to use it if they
- 3:38pay you a fee. So it provides a revenue stream
- 3:41if you want to do that. And patents are, for
- 3:44that reason, part of a valuation of any company.
- 3:47So whether you're a startup or an established
- 3:48company, your patent portfolio is something that
- 3:51you're able to license. You can sell them, and
- 3:54it's a potential revenue stream. And it's also,
- 3:57because of that, an asset that you can leverage.
- 3:59It's something that you can set up. as collateral
- 4:01or used to gain more funding if you need it,
- 4:05that kind of thing. So it can be a benefit in
- 4:07that way. arsenal really for your company to
- 4:13have patents. There's plenty of companies out
- 4:14there that have a very big patent portfolio,
- 4:17but they're not licensing it or suing anyone
- 4:20of those patents and they're using it more as
- 4:22a defensive mechanism. So other companies are
- 4:24deterred from coming after them for patent infringement
- 4:27because of the large portfolios they have. So
- 4:29we could do a whole presentation on this, but
- 4:31there's lots of benefits and things that you
- 4:34can do with patents. So if we could go to the
- 4:36next slide. You may be thinking patents sound
- 4:39like something that only tech companies should
- 4:41worry about, but it's really almost every industry,
- 4:44every type of technology or company has some
- 4:48form of patents. And so since we're in Beverly
- 4:50Hills, we thought it was appropriate to mention
- 4:53some of the patents that have been at the center
- 4:55for Hollywood for a long time. So again, it's
- 4:58not just the tech companies. Things like the
- 5:01projection devices early on in Hollywood were
- 5:03very important and shaped the industry in a lot
- 5:06of ways. And there were patents on this. So that
- 5:09has been integral in that industry. And I think
- 5:12really you'd be hard pressed to find any industry
- 5:15of any kind that doesn't have some form of patents
- 5:19or technology that have been central to it. I
- 5:20mean, and most companies now, for example, have
- 5:22a website. So there's, everyone's using technology
- 5:25in some way. Next slide. These. And these are
- 5:31just some more examples of some of the patents
- 5:33we've seen in Hollywood. This is a very old 1930
- 5:36patent drawing that we're seeing here about an
- 5:40invention for measuring film. So again, it's
- 5:43not just tech companies that can have patents
- 5:45or come up against them. It's really pretty much
- 5:48any industry, including Hollywood. Next slide,
- 5:51please. So the other alternative of a way you
- 5:55can... protect inventions is a trade secret.
- 5:58And you do kind of have to decide between a patent
- 6:01and a trade secret. And we'll talk a little bit
- 6:02more later about how you might decide that. Because
- 6:05a trade secret, as the name suggests, is something
- 6:08that is kept secret. Whereas I mentioned earlier,
- 6:11a patent, you're going to have to disclose that
- 6:13information to the patent office and eventually
- 6:15the public. So you do kind of have to decide
- 6:17which path you want to take. But a trade secret
- 6:19can be any sort of information that derives independent
- 6:23economic value from not being and is the subject
- 6:27of efforts that are reasonable to maintain the
- 6:30secrecy. So what that means is this is not just
- 6:33any sort of confidential information. It really
- 6:35has to be something that you can prove, you know,
- 6:37drives economic value, actual dollars from not
- 6:40being known and that you have made efforts to
- 6:43keep it secret. Next slide, please. And so there
- 6:49has been kind of a, for a long time, a patch,
- 6:51sort of a patchwork of trade secret laws across
- 6:53different states. And then the state laws still
- 6:56exist, but the federal law has now come into
- 6:59play as of 2016, the Defense of Trade Secrets
- 7:01Act. And this is the definition of trade secrets
- 7:04from that. And so that's really sort of changed
- 7:07since then over those years, changed the face
- 7:10of trade secret litigation and how it's managed
- 7:14with that federal act. If you could go to the
- 7:16next slide, please. So a trade secret, again,
- 7:20it can cover a wide range of things just like
- 7:22patents, but I think actually even broader than
- 7:26patent protection, so that's another consideration.
- 7:29But of course, you often think of the formula
- 7:32for Coke or things like that. But it can also
- 7:34be the compilation of information. It can be
- 7:37a business plan. It could be your client or supplier
- 7:40list. We see a lot of litigation over client
- 7:43lists in different industries. So it's even broader
- 7:47than the type of protection you can get from
- 7:48a patent. And it doesn't have to be something
- 7:50necessarily novel the way that you would have
- 7:53to show in a patent case. So that's another difference.
- 7:56Next slide, please. So this is sort of the pros
- 8:02and cons of trade secrets and patents. As I mentioned,
- 8:05you sort of have to pick between one or the other
- 8:07what you want to do to cover your invention.
- 8:11We'll start with trade secrets. The pros of a
- 8:13trade secret is that you don't have to disclose
- 8:15it to anyone. With a patent, you're going to
- 8:17have to disclose it to the patent office and
- 8:19eventually the public. You don't have to do that
- 8:21with a trade secret. And you also don't have
- 8:24to be something that you are proving is the first
- 8:27time anyone has done it the way you have to with
- 8:29a patent. And there's no limit on time for trade
- 8:32secrets. You can keep them indefinitely as long
- 8:35as you're keeping them secret and meeting all
- 8:36the requirements of it. Whereas with a patent,
- 8:39you get a limited number of years that you have
- 8:41the patent protection. And trade secrets also
- 8:44don't have, I don't want to say no cost, but
- 8:47it's lower costs in that you don't have to pay
- 8:49filing fees to the patent and trademark office
- 8:52the way you do for patents or trademarks or other
- 8:55items. But there are internal costs because as
- 8:58we were discussing, you have to keep it secret
- 9:00and you have to put in time and effort and internal
- 9:03cost to do that. The downside of a trade secret
- 9:07is that process. You have to constantly monitor
- 9:10and ensure that you're not disclosing your trade
- 9:13secret, that you have the proper employee agreements
- 9:16and things in place. We'll talk a little bit
- 9:17more about that later. But there is work that
- 9:19you have to do on that. Whereas with a patent,
- 9:21you don't have to spend that effort to keep things
- 9:23secret. And a trade secret can't prevent reverse
- 9:26engineering. It only helps you if someone has,
- 9:29you know, it protects you if like an employee
- 9:31were to take your information to another company
- 9:33and that's how they do it. But if a completely
- 9:36separate company decides to reverse engineer
- 9:38your product, a trade secret isn't going to help
- 9:40you if they didn't get it from you. Whereas a
- 9:42patent, it doesn't matter where they got the
- 9:44information or how. I mean, it can matter in
- 9:47some ways, but it does. You don't have to prove
- 9:49that they got it from you, a patent. If someone's
- 9:51practicing it, whether or not they knew you were
- 9:53doing it, you're able to get them, you're able
- 9:56to protect your invention and get them to stop
- 9:59making your patented product. And trade secrets
- 10:02can just be a little bit difficult to prove at
- 10:04times. In trial, there's a lot of litigation
- 10:06over, you know, were you doing enough to keep
- 10:08it secret? What exactly is the secret? It can't
- 10:12just be, you know, all of your business plans.
- 10:14It can be a little bit challenging to prove in
- 10:17litigation as the plaintiff. And then you also
- 10:19have to show actual harm in a trade secret case.
- 10:22Your damages have to be tied to what you lost
- 10:24from the trade secret being taken. Whereas in
- 10:27a patent case, you don't necessarily have to
- 10:30prove lost profits or anything like that. In
- 10:32a patent case, you're entitled to a reasonable
- 10:35royalty just off the bat. So you don't have to
- 10:37show that you actually had actual losses from
- 10:40the infringement. Whereas in a trade secret case,
- 10:42you do. So then the pros and cons of a patent
- 10:45are, you know, basically the flip side of that.
- 10:49You know, you can exclude anyone, whether or
- 10:50not they get the information from you, but it's
- 10:52for a more limited period of time. You don't
- 10:55have to monitor disclosure and make sure you're
- 10:57keeping it secret. So that can make it a little
- 10:59easier sometimes to deal with vendors and other
- 11:03suppliers and even employees because you don't
- 11:05have to worry so much about a secrecy requirement.
- 11:09And like I mentioned, you're entitled to damages
- 11:11whether or not you've lost any of actual losses
- 11:15based on the infringement. But the downside is
- 11:18it's a limited time period. You are required
- 11:21to disclose it publicly. So people are eventually
- 11:23going to be able to use your invention for free.
- 11:26And you do have to prove novelty. It does have
- 11:29to be something that's truly novel for the first
- 11:31time. And it can be a little more expensive in
- 11:34that you have prosecution fees and regular maintenance
- 11:37fees. You're going to have to pay the patented
- 11:38trademark office. But again, the trade off is,
- 11:41you know, very high value ability to exclude
- 11:44anyone for a very long period of time, you know,
- 11:46within the jurisdiction of the United States.
- 11:49Uh, so if we can go to the next slide, I'm going
- 11:50to turn it over now to my partner, Manny, to
- 11:52kind of talk about, okay, so how do you decide,
- 11:55you know, which of these is right for you? Um,
- 11:58so I'll let you take it over Manny. Great. Thanks,
- 12:01Elizabeth. Appreciate it. And hi, everyone. Again,
- 12:04I'm Manny Caccero. I practice locally here in
- 12:07Century City. And, you know, I do a lot of litigation
- 12:10and in connection with that, also a lot of advising
- 12:12companies about how they make some of these decisions
- 12:16on a practical level about, you know, what is
- 12:19the best way to go about protecting their innovation?
- 12:22And what's the most most cost effective and budget
- 12:25friendly way to do that? So on the screen, you'll
- 12:29see a list of considerations that a company is
- 12:32going to want to think about. And I don't want
- 12:35to repeat some of the things that Elizabeth said,
- 12:37but I do want to call attention to a few factors
- 12:40that I've seen it in a practical world matter
- 12:44to companies. And the first really is budget
- 12:48because the process of obtaining a patent Involves
- 12:55upfront cost you're you're going to need a higher
- 12:58an attorney Usually getting a pack a patent is
- 13:03you know, protect protracted back and forth with
- 13:06the patent office And you're gonna have more
- 13:09upfront investment As opposed to you know, a
- 13:13trade secret doesn't really require Monetary
- 13:17investment to establish the IP you just need
- 13:21to have effective protocols in place to define
- 13:24and protect the secrecy of the trade secret,
- 13:27which we'll talk about how you would go about
- 13:29doing that. The next factor I often pay attention
- 13:36to is this question of do you want to enforce
- 13:38against competitors? In other words, are you
- 13:42establishing this IP in a defensive way? In which
- 13:47case, you know, trade secret can be a very effective
- 13:50way to protect your IP or from the outset is
- 13:54your view that you want to enforce your monopoly
- 13:58and you intend to go after people who may be
- 14:01practicing your invention. Well, in that situation,
- 14:06patents offer some significant advantages. We'll
- 14:10talk about this in a little bit, but perhaps
- 14:12the most significant advantage is that patent
- 14:15infringement occurs regardless of the infringer's
- 14:20intent. It's the mere practicing of the patented
- 14:24technology or method or use of the patented technology
- 14:27that establishes infringement, regardless of
- 14:30whether the other side even, you know, knows
- 14:32about your patent or when they were developing
- 14:34their product or ever meant to infringe your
- 14:36patent. As opposed to trade secrets, which really
- 14:39tend to have, you tend to be able to show that
- 14:42the defendant um, obtained access to your trade
- 14:46secret. And it was that access that led to the
- 14:50benefit the defendant is receiving as opposed
- 14:52to, for example, the defendant just innocently
- 14:55inventing something on their own and innocent
- 14:57invention, uh, can be patent infringement. It
- 15:01generally will not be a trade secret misappropriation.
- 15:05Um, and the other thing to think about, um, is
- 15:08international enforcement. Uh, you know, US patents
- 15:13only go as far as the US border. Trade secrets,
- 15:20depending on the state law and the jurisdiction,
- 15:22you can cover international misappropriation
- 15:27in some circumstances. I will say that one of
- 15:31the things that is becoming increasingly common
- 15:34in the world of patents is enforcement campaigns
- 15:37and portfolio development on an international
- 15:39level. So most sophisticated companies are not
- 15:43only obtaining U .S. patents, they're obtaining
- 15:46patents in other jurisdictions, including most
- 15:48notably the EU and Brazil. And so while a U .S.
- 15:54patent may not solve your patent problem from
- 15:57an international perspective, international analogs
- 16:01to a U .S. patent may. We go to the next slide,
- 16:04please. So let's talk about a patent portfolio
- 16:09for a minute, because one of the mistakes that
- 16:11I see companies commonly make is a philosophy
- 16:15that they want to obtain a patent on everything.
- 16:18And this is, as you might expect, needlessly
- 16:21expensive. And the result is a lot of patents
- 16:25that may not be protecting anything that the
- 16:28company is using and may not have any application
- 16:31of what's in the market at all. A much more cost
- 16:36effective and efficient approach is to have a
- 16:39patent harvesting strategy that focuses on both
- 16:42core products and the products that you anticipate
- 16:47are going to get traction in the market and the
- 16:50most important features of those products. Now,
- 16:54one of the reasons that this is important is
- 16:57to reduce the maintenance fees, reduce the prosecution
- 16:59fees. Now, the good news here is this, is that
- 17:03One of the features of a patent and one of the
- 17:06advantages of a patent over a trade secret is
- 17:09that there is a secondary market for patents.
- 17:11And one of the things that we spend a lot of
- 17:13time doing with clients who may have too many
- 17:17patents or patent in the wrong areas of their
- 17:21product line is you can work to sell those patents.
- 17:25They're marketable assets. Trade secrets are
- 17:28not because you would lose the secrecy in the
- 17:31process of doing that. That thing comes to another
- 17:35important thing to consider about patents is,
- 17:39on a transactional level, when you're acquiring
- 17:42a company, when you're selling a company, when
- 17:43you're considering an investment, when you're
- 17:45seeking financing, making sure that the valuation
- 17:49of a patent is accurate. And this is challenging.
- 17:53There is no bright line scientific black and
- 17:58white way to to put a valuation on a portfolio.
- 18:04It's inherently a subjective view. And here is
- 18:07where having done the work on the front end when
- 18:10you're establishing your portfolio, making sure
- 18:12that your patents are actually valuable, if you're
- 18:15the seller, if you're seeking the financing,
- 18:17that's going to be important. And equally important,
- 18:19if you're the buyer, not necessarily taking the
- 18:23seller's word for it and having an established
- 18:25way to really be able to do diligence that properly,
- 18:28because those can be key assets um, in a company.
- 18:31And the other thing is when a company doesn't
- 18:35work out and you know, you're, you're, you're
- 18:37winding up where there's bankruptcy often patents
- 18:41are the last valuable asset that a company may
- 18:45have. And it could be a way to ensure that you
- 18:49maximize and extract the last bits of value out
- 18:52of a failed company. We can go to the next slide,
- 18:55please. A trade secret portfolio is different.
- 19:01A patent portfolio, if you go to a sophisticated
- 19:03company, they can literally pull up a spreadsheet
- 19:05and show you their patent portfolio. Most companies
- 19:09rarely do that with trade secrets for a few good
- 19:12reasons. Well, one is not so much a good reason.
- 19:18It's a practical reason. They haven't done the
- 19:20work to identify all of their trade secrets.
- 19:23But the good reason is this is that sometimes
- 19:25it's hard to figure out what the trade secrets
- 19:27are. And it's only when the rubber meets the
- 19:31road and you're seeing a competitor start to
- 19:34use a trade suit. But do you realize that this
- 19:37was a trade secret to begin with? So. One of
- 19:41the struggles in, in relying on trade secret
- 19:44is you do need to be constantly monitoring, querying,
- 19:49auditing your people to make sure that you're
- 19:52identifying what the trade secrets are. Because
- 19:54as Elizabeth said. The key to enforcing a trade
- 19:58secret is showing that you took reasonable steps
- 20:00to protect the secrecy. And so if you haven't.
- 20:05Done that if you haven't even identified it much
- 20:07less. Have you put in the right protections to
- 20:10protect the secrecy? You may lose enforcement
- 20:13the trade secret to give you a war story on this
- 20:15a few years back I went to a client and we were
- 20:18having a discussion along these lines and we
- 20:21came to the question of you Well, what are your
- 20:23trade secrets and they said? You know the formula
- 20:26for product X said okay Well, what is the formula
- 20:29for product X and they pointed out to the hallway
- 20:31and there was literally on a placard with the
- 20:35formula for product X without any sort of disclaimer
- 20:39or confidentiality. And so I had to advise them
- 20:41that it may be challenging to enforce this as
- 20:45a trade secret, given that everybody who walked
- 20:48through your hallway has now seen this formula.
- 20:52So as I mentioned, while you may not have the
- 20:56upfront outside legal spend, on a trade secret
- 20:59portfolio as you'd have with a patent portfolio,
- 21:01it does require more internal diligence. And
- 21:05places where this manifests is in employment
- 21:08agreements. You're making sure that there's appropriate
- 21:11confidentiality and in jurisdictions where it's
- 21:13allowed, post -employment confidentiality and
- 21:16restrictive covenants. Make sure that there's
- 21:19training to the employees about how they should
- 21:21treat trade secrets, have a policy for it. And
- 21:25then your third party agreements, make sure That
- 21:28can be a variety of things, but if you're working
- 21:30with a co -manufacturer, if you're working with
- 21:31a service provider, this is one of the ways that
- 21:34often trade secrets lose their enforcement because
- 21:37a company gives access to a service provider
- 21:39to their trade secret, assuming... that they're
- 21:44not that the service provider is going to maintain
- 21:47the confidentiality, but there actually may not
- 21:49be that obligation, or at least not that specific
- 21:51heightened obligation as you would need for a
- 21:53trade secret. And you could lose a trade secret
- 21:56protection through a third party that way. And
- 22:00then, you know, IT systems and safeguards, this
- 22:02to me really goes to make sure they do not inadvertently
- 22:05losing trade secrets because you haven't set
- 22:07up the right technology to protect your about
- 22:11your internal emails, your slats, whatever you
- 22:13have from being discovered. If you go to the
- 22:17next slide, please. Yeah, I was just going to
- 22:19chime in too. I mean, in litigation, these things
- 22:21Manny is talking about is the primary issue litigated.
- 22:25Like, did you do enough? So if you're planning
- 22:27to enforce your trade secrets and rely on that
- 22:29instead of a patent, you really need to have
- 22:30a good plan for that to tell the jury what you
- 22:33did. Otherwise, you may risk losing and you don't
- 22:35have a trade secret, which is obviously devastating.
- 22:38And then also on that piece, I think when you're
- 22:41looking at third party agreements, it's a huge
- 22:43sort of umbrella of the variety. It could be
- 22:46end user agreements. It could be, you know, in
- 22:48the different types of agreements too, like NDAs
- 22:51when you're exploring opportunities and whatnot.
- 22:54So to Manny Elizabeth's point, it's a lot of,
- 22:56it might seem like a lot of work up front to
- 22:58sort of do a revamp, but then at the back end,
- 23:02right, Probably exponentially more thankful that
- 23:05those safeguards were in place because easier
- 23:07to do it preemptively than after the fact 100
- 23:12good good points Elizabeth and Rebecca So turning
- 23:17back for a minute to patents Okay, so you have
- 23:20your patent The next question that's often going
- 23:24to come up is well How do I know if somebody
- 23:26is infringing my patent and what does that require?
- 23:30So patent infringement occurs Once you've obtained
- 23:33your patent, whenever someone has made, used,
- 23:37sold, or imported something, that practices all
- 23:40of the elements of a claim of a patent. And I'm
- 23:42just going to break that down for one second.
- 23:45A patent is often a long document, but the most
- 23:48important part comes at the very end of a patent,
- 23:51where there are a list of numbered paragraphs
- 23:53that are called the claims. And the claims actually
- 23:56define what you have. your patent on. So most
- 23:59of the patent is just providing context and background
- 24:02for what's called the claims at the end. And
- 24:05the way you infringe a patent is if you go to
- 24:09one of the claims, let's say claim one, and claim
- 24:11one requires A, B, and C. If somebody out there
- 24:15is doing A and B and C, they infringe your patent
- 24:19regardless of whether they knew they were doing
- 24:21all those things. Importantly, if somebody is
- 24:25just doing A and C, They are not infringing your
- 24:27patent. And that often is the battleground on
- 24:30one of the main battlegrounds on patent infringement.
- 24:34Another major issue, which we're not going to
- 24:35get into too much detail today is whether your
- 24:39patent was ever truly valid such that it should
- 24:41have been granted and what that there are a number
- 24:44of ways to invalidate a patent, but the most
- 24:47common and. the way that that is fought is the
- 24:51idea that you were not the person, you being
- 24:54the person holding the patent, the defendant
- 24:56will say you were not the person who really invented
- 24:58this invention, that somebody before that either
- 25:03invented this exact invention or that this invention
- 25:07that you have a patent on was obvious to people
- 25:10who were in the field earlier. When assigning
- 25:18value to a patent, as I mentioned before, it's
- 25:22subjective, and in the end, the real value to
- 25:26any given patent is no more or no less than the
- 25:30amount of damages you can obtain against the
- 25:32world for people who are infringing the patent.
- 25:38Which is to say, patents don't automatically
- 25:41generate money on their own, they have to be
- 25:43enforced. Generally, the way to measure damages
- 25:48in a patent infringement case is a reasonable
- 25:51royalty. And this gets very complicated, but
- 25:54ultimately what you do is there's this hypothetical
- 25:56construct that both sides will get into that
- 26:00will argue what the parties would have agreed
- 26:04to as a reasonable royalty had they been willing
- 26:08to enter into a hypothetical negotiation at the
- 26:12time the infringement began. In some cases you
- 26:15receive, and actually pausing there, as you can
- 26:19imagine that is abstract, that's hypothetical,
- 26:22it's often thought out and you need good experienced
- 26:26experts, good experienced litigators who know
- 26:29how to navigate these issues because we've had
- 26:32cases where even if you're as a defendant, even
- 26:35if you're found to infringe, if you can win this
- 26:39royalty battle and show that the Um, the value
- 26:43of this patent was low. Well, I'd argue you won
- 26:46the litigation, right? Right. Paying a dollar
- 26:49for infringing is, is not a bad business outcome.
- 26:56Sorry. There's a recent case here in the central
- 26:59district of California where that exact thing
- 27:00happened. There was infringement, but a dollar
- 27:02was the damages. And obviously that's pretty
- 27:05much a win for the defendant. Exactly. Now there
- 27:08are circumstances where you can see more. In
- 27:11competitor cases, you can receive lost profits,
- 27:16which tends to be a higher measure of damages.
- 27:21And injunctions are possible, particularly in
- 27:25competitor cases. Now because of some case law
- 27:28that's developed from the Supreme Court over
- 27:29the last 20 years, injunctions are less frequent
- 27:33in the U .S. than in other jurisdictions. But
- 27:36there is a push to reestablishing junctions as
- 27:39a common remedy and notably in other countries,
- 27:45especially in Europe and especially in some South
- 27:47American countries, injunctions are very common.
- 27:50So that's why we're seeing on a global level
- 27:54companies look for international patents and
- 27:57some of the enforcement is shifting away from
- 27:59the US and to these other jurisdictions where
- 28:02Injunctions are more common. You also get interest.
- 28:07And one concept also to be aware of is that,
- 28:10as I mentioned, infringement doesn't have to
- 28:12be intentional for it to occur. But if it is
- 28:16intentional, if there is willful infringement,
- 28:19damages can be troubled at the discretion of
- 28:22the court. It's rare, but it's possible. Go to
- 28:26the next slide, please. One of the trends that
- 28:36we're seeing in the patent world is that, look,
- 28:39in general, like any other sophisticated commercial
- 28:41litigation, there's not a ton of trials in the
- 28:45patent world, but there are more than you might
- 28:49think, and they are increasing. And one of the
- 28:54key factors here is venue. If you talk to anybody
- 28:58who's engaged in patent litigation, probably
- 29:00the first thing they will talk to you about is
- 29:02the Eastern District of Texas and the Western
- 29:03District of Texas, which are two venues where,
- 29:09for a lot of reasons, they've established some
- 29:12very patentee -friendly rules, some patentee
- 29:16-friendly precedent, and perhaps most important
- 29:20for a lot of patentees, a very fast time to trial.
- 29:26and a philosophy that most issues should be tried
- 29:29rather than resolved on summary judgment or resolved
- 29:32by the court. If you find yourself facing a lawsuit
- 29:39in the Eastern District of Texas or the Western
- 29:41District of Texas, you need to recognize that.
- 29:44You need to recognize that if you don't have
- 29:47some really excellent legal defenses that can
- 29:52convince... maybe some judges who are not inclined
- 29:55to dismiss a patent cases that should be dismissed,
- 29:58that you may very well be on track for a trial
- 30:02in one of those jurisdictions. We go to the next
- 30:05slide, please. Now, one of the biggest misconceptions
- 30:09out there about patents is that they are enforced
- 30:15and litigated and the world of patents is a competitor's
- 30:19world. In other words, you know, the I opened
- 30:22an ice cream store and there's another ice cream
- 30:24store down the block. I should be able to enforce
- 30:27my patent on ice cream against my competitor
- 30:29down the block. And that's very fair. And that's
- 30:32very free market economy. It's what we all think
- 30:35of as, as sort of, you know, at the backbone
- 30:38of the way we think of economy and property rights
- 30:40in the United States. The reality of patent litigation
- 30:44in today's world is very different. As you can
- 30:47see here, 88 % of high technology patent litigation
- 30:53involves a patent plaintiff that is a non -practicing
- 30:58entity, sometimes known as an MPE, and derogatorily
- 31:02referred to as a patent troll. Now, there are
- 31:05lots of varieties of MPEs, and I don't think
- 31:07it's fair to call all of them patent trolls,
- 31:09but the general common denominator here is you're
- 31:11talking about companies that aren't competing
- 31:13in the industry. They exist to monetize, license,
- 31:19enforce, patents. And that is what most patent
- 31:24litigation is. And look, that could take one
- 31:28flavor of that is, you know, a company that's
- 31:30got a few patents, they know they're no good,
- 31:31but they know that if they go and threaten the
- 31:35world, they can extract small settlements from
- 31:37a lot of different people. And that's a business
- 31:39model. And that's what people traditionally think
- 31:41of as trolling. But at the other extreme, and
- 31:44especially over the last 10 or 15 years, You
- 31:48see very sophisticated non -practicing entities
- 31:51working with litigation finance companies to
- 31:55establish large portfolios of thousands of patents,
- 31:59and they are not out to get quick -hit settlements.
- 32:05They are out to make big money at trial. So circling
- 32:09back to something I said earlier though, if you
- 32:11are getting patents, these MPEs also need to
- 32:15buy patents from somewhere. And it's another
- 32:17reason why having a good, thoughtful approach
- 32:20to getting patents can help you make money and
- 32:22help your company because even if you're not
- 32:24using it, you can monetize in a number of ways.
- 32:28If we can go to the next slide, please. Again,
- 32:31patent litigation realities, simple point here.
- 32:34Most of these cases do settle, but in certain
- 32:38jurisdictions that's less common. We go to the
- 32:40next slide. Now trade secret litigation is a
- 32:46little bit of a different beast. You don't see
- 32:49this Texas issue. You see much more enforcement
- 32:53in Los Angeles, in Chicago, in New York. Often
- 32:57trade secret disputes are, in my experience,
- 33:00they're rarely just brought as a pure trade secret
- 33:02dispute. Usually there's some other business
- 33:05or employment dispute. that the trade secret
- 33:11dispute is wrapped into, right? Like, you know,
- 33:14your employee left, stole your secrets. You're
- 33:17enforcing a restrictive covenant against them,
- 33:19but also a trade secret case. Or, you know, you're
- 33:22bringing an unfair competition case against a
- 33:25competitor. And along with that, you're making
- 33:27trade secret claims. So they tend to be less
- 33:30standalone and more part of complex disputes
- 33:34between companies. And that's one of the reasons
- 33:36why if your goal is to enforce from the beginning,
- 33:39Patents are kind of an easier way to do that
- 33:41because a patent dispute has less less stuff
- 33:45around it. And trade secrets tend to have a lot
- 33:47more issues. We go to the next slide, please.
- 33:52OK, what would a CLE in 2025 be if we didn't
- 33:55talk at least briefly about AI and just a few
- 33:58concepts here to hit on? One is that you can
- 34:04get patents on technical innovations. that lead
- 34:08to AI models and AI techniques. For instance,
- 34:14one thing I was looking into yesterday was deep
- 34:16faking. There are patents on getting deep fakes
- 34:18or patents on detecting deep fakes. However,
- 34:23some of the rules that currently exist is that
- 34:26an inventor of a patent cannot be AI. It has
- 34:28to be a natural person. And an invention is maybe
- 34:33patentable. It's made with the assistance of
- 34:35AI. But the natural person has to significantly
- 34:38contribute to that invention. Another note here
- 34:41is that in general, the output of AI is not going
- 34:46to be patentable. However, it may in a closed
- 34:49system be a trade secret. So that's another thing
- 34:53to consider. We go to the next slide. Here, I'm
- 34:58not going to get into a lot of detail, but Suffice
- 35:01it to say that we are seeing a little bit of
- 35:04a sea change in the Trump administration when
- 35:06it comes around innovation and protecting innovation.
- 35:09We are seeing a lot of people in the Trump administration,
- 35:12including the Secretary of Commerce, with an
- 35:15extensive history of licensing and enforcing
- 35:18IP and a philosophy that supports that. We're
- 35:22seeing a rollback on some of the procedures and
- 35:26substantive defenses that defendants have used
- 35:29recently to defend against patent infringement.
- 35:33And, um, and we're seeing notably, uh, the next
- 35:37less bull point here. There is a real push to
- 35:39restore, um, injunctions as a, as a significant
- 35:43remedy for patent infringement in the United
- 35:45States. One of the rationales, which you can
- 35:48debate on this is, well, if we're not doing that,
- 35:53other countries are clearly using injunctions
- 35:56to protect their IP, and are we falling behind
- 35:59other countries when we don't do that? There
- 36:02is a lot of back and forth. You can go on this.
- 36:05Suffice it to say, as a result of these changes
- 36:09in momentum, it is a better time than it has
- 36:13ever been to obtain, develop, monetize your patent
- 36:17portfolio, because you're seeing a lot of the
- 36:19barriers and obstacles that previously existed
- 36:22come down. And conversely, It's a precarious
- 36:28time if you are in an industry where you're likely
- 36:30to be sued for patent infringement because a
- 36:32lot of the defenses that have become standard
- 36:35playbook are being questioned. So with that,
- 36:41I'm going to hand this off to my friend Rebecca
- 36:44to talk a little bit about some other IP concepts.
- 36:48Thanks, Al. If we can go to the next slide. All
- 36:51right, copyright is another IP asset that you
- 36:54can have. A copyrightable work is an original
- 36:58work of authorship that is fixed in a tangible
- 37:00medium of expression. Some parts of that might
- 37:04make sense. The fixation piece sometimes can
- 37:07cause some questions that if we take, for example,
- 37:09a song, it can be considered fixed if it's recorded
- 37:14when it's recorded or when the composition is
- 37:16written down. A common question then is, what
- 37:21is not a copyright? Sometimes it's easier to
- 37:23figure out what is not a copyright than what
- 37:25is. And so the Copyright Office is pretty clear
- 37:28on that. You can't copyright an idea, a procedure,
- 37:32process, methods. This by no means is a exhaustive
- 37:36list. But with the caveat that although, for
- 37:39example, an idea might not be predictable, the
- 37:42expression of idea may be. But I think as you
- 37:45saw from the earlier part of this presentation
- 37:48on patents, for example, although something might
- 37:51not be copyrightable, there might be something
- 37:53like another form of protection available, like
- 37:56patent protection. All right, next slide. All
- 38:02right, copyrights too have played a central role
- 38:05in Hollywood. We see Thomas Edison again back
- 38:08in the early 1900s when he was doing adaptations
- 38:11and duplications of theatrical works. You know,
- 38:15in the early 1900s, we also saw theft of vaudeville
- 38:18material, which led to, not surprisingly, law
- 38:20firms trying to capitalize monetize on that and
- 38:24advertising their services to help protect authors
- 38:29against that theft. You'll see on this slide
- 38:32one such example of that advertisement and indicating
- 38:37that a copyright will protect you from pirates.
- 38:40And so then throughout the 1900s, you see sort
- 38:44of evolution. We have the Copyright Act from
- 38:471909. But the one that you're probably most familiar
- 38:49with is the one that was passed in 1976. And
- 38:53that often is the foundation of a lot of the
- 38:57copyright infringement claims and actions and
- 38:59cases that you hear from today. And in the 90s
- 39:02then, with this sort of rise of the digital age,
- 39:05there was also a rise in piracy. And then we
- 39:07saw in the late 90s the passage of the Digital
- 39:10Millennium Copyright Act, otherwise known as
- 39:13the DMCA. And I'll talk a little bit more about
- 39:16sort of the nuances of protections that are provided
- 39:20under the DMCA. Next slide. Alright, there are
- 39:25a variety of copyrights available in the entertainment
- 39:28space. Once again, not an exhaustive list. Illustrative,
- 39:34for sure. But one thing that can be interesting
- 39:36about this is that a work might have multiple
- 39:40types of copyrights that are applicable. So back
- 39:42to that example of a song, the recording, the
- 39:46song itself is typically copyrightable, as is
- 39:50the musical composition. And we've seen a lot
- 39:54of things come up in the daily news. Everything
- 39:56extends beyond the industry press into sort of
- 39:59the daily news about big artists either re -recording
- 40:03their music so that they can own it or buying
- 40:06back their records and the composition so as
- 40:09to be able to own it. Next slide. All right,
- 40:15practical tips when it comes to registering Copyright
- 40:18Works. A question that we get, and it's an understandable
- 40:22question, is in copyright, Protection attaches
- 40:26upon fixation of the copyrightable work. So write
- 40:29that example of once it's written down or it's
- 40:32recorded. So then it naturally begs the question,
- 40:35why register? Why go through that process? Well,
- 40:38there's a number of advantages that come with
- 40:40it. First of all, it can serve as proof of ownership
- 40:42that you are the author of that copyright. It
- 40:45also provides you the ability to enforce. those
- 40:48copyright acts. You are not able to bring a copyright
- 40:51infringement action unless you have a registered
- 40:53copyright. And also longevity. So for a lot of
- 40:58copyrights, it affords once that copyright has
- 41:01been registered, it affords protection for the
- 41:04life of the author plus 70 years. And then as
- 41:07Manny and Elizabeth previously talked about,
- 41:09it also can serve as a valuable asset that can
- 41:11be leveraged. In addition to sort of help with
- 41:15a sort of broader, more international IP portfolio
- 41:18building as well. Disadvantages, sure, there's
- 41:21some administrative requirements like the cost
- 41:24and renewing the copyright. And one thing that
- 41:27can cause, you know, it's a little bit more nuanced
- 41:30is the requirement that you provide a copy of
- 41:33that copyright, of the work you're seeking to
- 41:35copyright, and then that is maintained by the
- 41:38U .S. Library of Congress. And so for things
- 41:41like, for example, software code, that sometimes
- 41:44requires you to submit a certain amount of pages.
- 41:46And then if there are trade secrets provided
- 41:49in the pages you're submitting, then it sort
- 41:54of adjusts how many pages have to be provided
- 41:56to satisfy that requirement. All right, next
- 41:59slide, please. Copyright infringement and defenses.
- 42:05You know, so essentially very similar in the
- 42:08sense of patent infringement. When someone violates
- 42:10one of the exclusive rights of a copyright owner,
- 42:13you can bring an infringement claim or they might
- 42:14be liable for infringement. It has a certain
- 42:17amount of elements that you have to possibly
- 42:20allege at the beginning of the case or prove
- 42:21at the end. Common issues that come up in common
- 42:25copyright infringement cases can be whether or
- 42:28not the alleged infringer had permission to um
- 42:31you know use that work so for example if there
- 42:34was a license right was were they just operating
- 42:37within the scope of their license or were they
- 42:39exceeding it and then also whether or not the
- 42:41infringing work is substantially similar to the
- 42:44copyrighted work there's also theories of secondary
- 42:47liability that you see in copyright as well,
- 42:50so not the primary party infringing, but somehow
- 42:53involved in the process. And then there's also
- 42:56criminal infringement under the statute as well,
- 42:59as is the DMCA, which provides some additional
- 43:02remedies for things like, for example, it provides
- 43:06the process for notice and takedown when someone's
- 43:09infringing your copyright as addition to addressing
- 43:13issues where people circumvent security protocols
- 43:15to get access to copyrighted work. or are somehow
- 43:19altering your copyright management information
- 43:21of your work. Rebecca, we got a question in the
- 43:26chat from someone. Do you need to register a
- 43:28copyright to bring an action in the US or just
- 43:31register to get additional damages? You need
- 43:35to register a copyright to bring a case in the
- 43:38US. And then it also then opens up the opportunity
- 43:42for, obviously, the damages associated with it.
- 43:46There are common defenses as well, and Manny
- 43:51and Elizabeth talked about these as well, but
- 43:53there is the fair use defense, which I think
- 43:56we are all hearing a lot about. And in the most
- 44:01basic summary of it, it's whether or not the
- 44:05use of the alleged infringer was actually fair.
- 44:08courts, and so effectively they didn't have to
- 44:11ask permission or provide money in order to use
- 44:14the copyrighted work. And courts look at a variety
- 44:17of factors for that in terms of the purpose and
- 44:20character of the work, of the infringing work,
- 44:25the kind of original work, was it sort of more
- 44:27factual or creative, the amount and substantiality
- 44:30of the copying, and then the harm in the marketplace
- 44:33or the potential harm for the copyright owner.
- 44:38And we'll talk a little bit more about recent
- 44:40developments in that space in a few slides. Next
- 44:43slide, please. Available remedies for copyright
- 44:48infringement. Once again, these are some of the
- 44:51ones that we saw in the patent space and actually
- 44:54we'll also see in the trademark space too. Another
- 44:57interesting remedy that can be available for
- 45:00copyrighted works, for example, pirated copyrighted
- 45:03works, is impoundment and destruction of those
- 45:06pirated works. All right, next slide, please.
- 45:11Copyright litigation and reality trends that
- 45:14we're seeing. Not similar to other forms of IP
- 45:18litigation and also just generally litigation,
- 45:20most cases settle, but they can be time consuming
- 45:22and costly. So for example, there is this, these
- 45:28metrics, these median times were pulled from
- 45:30copyright cases since 2009 that have since resolved
- 45:34and the sort of average time it takes to get
- 45:36to each stage. So for example, it could take
- 45:39at least 796 days to get to trial. So it's definitely
- 45:43not a short dispute by any means. There are alternative
- 45:47routes to bring your copyright claims, for example,
- 45:50before the Copyright Claims Board. There are
- 45:53some distinctions here, though. For example,
- 45:56there's limited jurisdiction over the types of
- 45:58claims that you can bring before the Claims Board,
- 46:01in addition to there being a cap on damages and
- 46:04oftentimes no injunctive relief unless the parties
- 46:06were to agree to it in settlement. All right,
- 46:09next slide, please. Rebecca, we've got another,
- 46:12if I can jump in with another question, someone
- 46:14asks, how do you prevent or combat a false copyright
- 46:17strike? So I guess in someone's claiming copyright
- 46:20that they don't really have, do you have any
- 46:23recommendations on that? I mean, I, well, I guess
- 46:29if they're claiming it in the beginning, right,
- 46:31the pre -litigation stage, right, then you ask
- 46:34them to show evidence of copyright ownership
- 46:37right and that could be something like there
- 46:39could be a registration right but then they're
- 46:41not the owner or the sufficiency of the license
- 46:43if there was sort of an or assignment of the
- 46:45copyright um so i mean if there's something as
- 46:49basic as you know this is not something you don't
- 46:51have a copyright registration for it um or evidence
- 46:55of its you know it being you're the first to
- 46:57sort of create that expression, right? And then
- 47:02sort of evidence of it being fixed, right? When
- 47:05was it recorded, right? When was it written down?
- 47:07That sort of thing. If you get into litigation,
- 47:10right, then it's gonna be an issue that oftentimes
- 47:12could come up in the context of the beginning
- 47:15stages of litigation. So the motion to dismiss
- 47:17stage, and that would be oftentimes an argument
- 47:19made, is that you're not even the owner of the
- 47:23copyrighted work, or you don't have standing
- 47:26to bring it. All right, judicial and regulatory
- 47:29developments. As Manny said, what would be a
- 47:32CLE unless we talk about AI? And I could spend
- 47:36an hour and longer talking about developments
- 47:40in the copyright infringement and AI space. So
- 47:43currently, there are in excess of 40 cases alleging
- 47:48copyright or involving copyright infringement
- 47:50and AI tools. And we've reached, some of those
- 47:54cases have reached a dispositive point. So a
- 47:56couple of weeks ago, we got two decisions out
- 47:58of the Northern District of California, finding
- 48:01in favor of fair use, but they reached those
- 48:05decisions slightly differently in terms of how
- 48:08they find that the doctrine applies to AI tools,
- 48:11in addition to certain fact patterns that might
- 48:13have a different outcome, which is very interesting.
- 48:16And then we'll see, I think we anticipate in
- 48:19the next, before the close of the year, some
- 48:21additional dispositive rulings coming down and
- 48:24not surprisingly likely appealed, so we're going
- 48:27to see that working its way up. There are also
- 48:31a lot of regulatory developments as well. The
- 48:33Copyright Office has been busy. They have issued
- 48:36three reports covering various areas of major
- 48:40issues at the intersection of copyright and AI.
- 48:44One of their reports was about digital replicas
- 48:47of people's images and likeness. So Manny had
- 48:50talked earlier about that term deepfake. And
- 48:54so we're seeing, so the first report covered
- 48:57that. There was a report about the copyrightability
- 49:00of AI -generated works. Similar sort of what
- 49:04we're looking at, we see in kind of in the patent
- 49:06space as well. Works completely generated by
- 49:09AI are not copyrightable, but works that are
- 49:13generated with the assistance of AI maybe depending
- 49:16on the scope and extent in which the AI tool
- 49:18was used to generate that work. And then also
- 49:23we saw a report on the use of copyrighted works
- 49:26in the development of generative AI tools. These
- 49:29reports are very lengthy, but they are interesting
- 49:31in the sense that the Copyright Office solicited
- 49:34public comment in drafting these reports and
- 49:38includes a summary of some of those public comments,
- 49:41both from industry leaders and participants to
- 49:43academics, the general public. And then the Copyright
- 49:46Office also, in those reports, indicated some
- 49:49of where it stood on potential issues as well.
- 49:54But we're not quite sure whether or not those
- 49:57positions on those issues are, you know, set
- 50:00in stone because there has been some changes
- 50:03in the Copyright Office. As we all know, with
- 50:06this administration, there have been a lot of
- 50:08employment shake -ups, and that has also impacted
- 50:11the Copyright Office as well. Currently, there
- 50:14is no register of copyrights. The register of
- 50:17copyrights is the person that signs the copyright
- 50:21registration. And so as a result, copyright registrations
- 50:25are currently going out without a signature.
- 50:29And there is a discussion currently as to whether
- 50:32the validity of an open discussion is the validity
- 50:35of those copyright registrations that we're seeing
- 50:39sort of ongoing right now. I recently checked
- 50:41the Copyright Office website though, and they're
- 50:44very aware of that public. discourse because
- 50:47there's a lot of, I think it's in their facts
- 50:49section and Q &A, but there's a lot of sort of
- 50:52response saying that these copyright registrations
- 50:56are still valid even absent the signature. In
- 51:00Congress as well, there's a number of acts currently
- 51:03going through involving copyrights and AI both
- 51:07directly on in terms of disclosure of of creation,
- 51:15alteration of data sets that use copyrighted
- 51:19work and then in addition to a number of acts
- 51:23involving deepfakes as well. I'm not going to
- 51:26go through each one, but there's a number of
- 51:28things happening currently and it's changing
- 51:31in real time. All right, next slide. Protecting
- 51:37your brand. All right, so this is another...
- 51:40area IP assets, another way of another form of
- 51:47IP protection that's a trademark. A trademark
- 51:50is a source indicator that identifies and distinguishes
- 51:53the source of goods or services of one party
- 51:56or the brand from those of the other in the marketplace.
- 51:59Depending on how you define it, it can be word
- 52:04marks, it can be It can be sort of there are
- 52:07things like word marks. There are design marks.
- 52:10You hear terms like house marks, service marks,
- 52:12that sort of thing. A word mark would be, as
- 52:16you can imagine, a word itself, whereas a design
- 52:18mark might be, for example, a logo. So a brand
- 52:21name and the design elements around it. What
- 52:24are the benefits of trademark protection and
- 52:28trademark registration? It is a form of protection
- 52:31for the brand identity. The rights can last indefinitely.
- 52:35Once again, it can be an asset to leverage as
- 52:38well. And there's actually common law rights
- 52:41that are associated with a trademark in addition
- 52:43to rights that are associated with a federal
- 52:47registration as well. And then we were able to
- 52:50find this image of Venable's trademark certificate
- 52:55there, which amazingly likely passed our conflicts
- 53:00check. All right, next slide. Trademarks have
- 53:05also played a central role in Hollywood as well.
- 53:08I won't go through sort of each of the steps
- 53:09and certainly this is not an exhaustive list
- 53:12of the timeline, but essentially as you can imagine
- 53:14as theatrical works and movies and films became
- 53:18incredibly increasingly more available and to
- 53:23the pop. to the public and then monetize, for
- 53:26example, with merchandising and whatnot, that
- 53:29you can see that then there became an increased
- 53:31need to protect the brand associated with these
- 53:34characters, films, TV, and music as well. And
- 53:37you saw a focus on seeking formal protection,
- 53:42federal protection for those marks. In addition
- 53:44to in the 80s, you started seeing more leveraging
- 53:48of trademark law, not only by sort of companies
- 53:50and corporations, but by individuals as well,
- 53:54and also extending into areas like protecting
- 53:57a likeness or a catchphrase. And we'll talk a
- 54:00little bit more about protecting the image and
- 54:03likeness as a brand protection strategy in a
- 54:05second. Next slide. Trademarks in entertainment
- 54:10and retail, there are a number of them. Once
- 54:12again, we talked about some of the traditional.
- 54:16trademarks, like a word, a phrase, a symbol,
- 54:19a design, that sort of thing. There are a number
- 54:21of non -traditional trademarks, though, for scent,
- 54:24sound, color, motion, and once again, sort of
- 54:27the... crux of it is whether or not it serves
- 54:31as a source identifier. So if you think about,
- 54:33for example, the opening credits of a movie,
- 54:36right, you'll see credits for a studio, a production
- 54:38company, and you might see an animation that
- 54:41you associate with a certain brand or a sound,
- 54:45right, and some companies have sought and obtained
- 54:48trademarks for that animation and that sound.
- 54:51Next slide, please. Practical tips for registering
- 54:57trademarks and some considerations, right? Previously
- 55:01I mentioned there's common law, right? So you
- 55:02don't have to register a trademark to have trademark
- 55:04protection. So then that begs the question, why
- 55:07seek federal registration for a mark? Or you
- 55:10can also seek state, you can register trademarks
- 55:14on the state level as well. A federal registration
- 55:17affords nationwide rights, and then it also can
- 55:21serve as a presumption of ownership and validity
- 55:24of the mark. There are additional types of legal
- 55:28claims that can be brought. And then also some
- 55:31of the additional things that we talked about
- 55:32earlier with other types of IP. It can be a valuable
- 55:35asset. It can assist in foreign registrations.
- 55:39Disadvantages, there's some administrative requirements
- 55:41as there is for any formal filing of IP. One
- 55:45aspect of it is a trademark application can be
- 55:48time consuming. I think the USPTO currently estimates
- 55:51that it takes on average 12 to 18 months to receive
- 55:54a trademark registration. Next slide, please.
- 55:59All right, so as I promised, under that umbrella
- 56:02of brand protection, there's trademarks. And
- 56:05another area is the right of publicity. And that
- 56:08is the right of an individual to control the
- 56:10economic use and exploitation of their identity.
- 56:13It varies by state, but they define identity
- 56:16as an individual's name, image, and likeness.
- 56:19So this is another form of protection. Sometimes
- 56:21you see it in state law, considered or framed
- 56:25as a right of publicity. In other areas, it's
- 56:27a right of privacy. And this has some relationships
- 56:30to other IP. There is no registration system
- 56:33in place. It is primarily governed by state law.
- 56:36And there's some overlap. It can overlap with
- 56:39trademark protection as well. And I'm not a graphic
- 56:42designer, but the design on the side was intended
- 56:44to be those college pennants, those felt flags.
- 56:49I realized that that should never be my primary
- 56:52job as a graphic designer. But I think, Manny,
- 56:55you had some... Some insight as well in terms
- 56:59of What we're seeing sort of in the name image
- 57:02and likeness space and and and how that's sort
- 57:04of relating to deep fakes as well Manny you're
- 57:10on you Yeah, I would say just for the interest
- 57:12of time that this issue of deep fakes and and
- 57:16I am naming image like this it's There's a trademark
- 57:20angle to it. There's an obvious copyright angle
- 57:22to to the extent, you know you're using a registered
- 57:26name and image and likeness. And there's a lot
- 57:28of action on the patent side too. I saw recently
- 57:31there are companies getting patents on both methods
- 57:35to create deepfakes and methods to detect deepfakes.
- 57:41And one of the really interesting things on it
- 57:44from a patent perspective will be how enforceable
- 57:47any of that is because you know, One concept
- 57:52in patent law is that if something's abstract,
- 57:54if you could do it on your own, just using a
- 57:58computer to do it doesn't make it patentable.
- 58:00And a lot of these deepfake patents and deepfake
- 58:03detection patents, I think, are going to raise
- 58:05interesting questions about, are they enforceable
- 58:08at all? Thanks, May. All right, next slide. I
- 58:17won't go through every step, but once again,
- 58:18there are certain elements to establishing or
- 58:21proving trademark infringement. Oftentimes, the
- 58:24common and big issue is whether or not there's
- 58:27actual or likelihood of confusion by consumers
- 58:30between the source of goods and services. But
- 58:34unlike with copyright, you can bring a trademark
- 58:37infringement claim based off of unregistered
- 58:40marks or federally registered marks or a combination
- 58:43of both. Let's go to the next slide. The remedies
- 58:50as well, on a high level categorically, there's
- 58:53some similarities to the other remedies available
- 58:56in other forms of IP. This is sort of a slide.
- 59:00This chart is depicting trademark awards that
- 59:05have happened in cases since 2009. It obviously
- 59:10does not capture settlement agreements because
- 59:14oftentimes any sort of monetary money exchange
- 59:16in the course of those is confidential. But it's
- 59:19interesting, too, that you see, for example,
- 59:21statutory damages are more than actual damages
- 59:26or infringer profits. And then there are statutory
- 59:30damages available in addition to for things,
- 59:32issues like counterfeited marks or improper domain
- 59:36name registration. And there's the potential
- 59:39for troubling of damages like that we heard Manny
- 59:43talk about as it relates to patent damages. And
- 59:46we've seen awards anywhere from, they stand out,
- 59:50but anywhere from 50 million up into the 100
- 59:53million for trademark infringement cases. All
- 59:57right, next slide, please. All right, judicial
- 1:00:01and regulatory developments. Once again, we cannot
- 1:00:03escape AI, nor do we want to. There are certain
- 1:00:07AI infringement cases or AI cases that also involve
- 1:00:11trademark infringement as well. There's copyright
- 1:00:13infringement claims, but there's also trademark
- 1:00:14infringement claims. One of those cases, for
- 1:00:18example, is Getty Images. It's actually appending
- 1:00:20in both the US and the UK. And that case actually
- 1:00:26has already gone to trial and they're waiting
- 1:00:28on a decision. So that will be definitely interesting
- 1:00:31to see how that comes out. And these other cases
- 1:00:35are at their earlier stage, but they involve,
- 1:00:38for example, an AI generated image based off
- 1:00:43of, alleged to have been based off of a film
- 1:00:45and that it was used in a promotional event.
- 1:00:48And there's allegations that that creates a false
- 1:00:51impression of endorsement by the film company
- 1:00:56of the company that's using or running that.
- 1:00:59promotional event and then there's also a case
- 1:01:03advanced local media that involves a number of
- 1:01:06claims but it's sort of it's premised on output
- 1:01:10from an AI tool and that some of the output is
- 1:01:14falsely attributing incorrect content to certain
- 1:01:18news and magazine publishers as well. See a lot
- 1:01:21of sort of developments in the trademark a lot
- 1:01:23of discussion in the trademark space also as
- 1:01:26sort of as it applies to social media. in terms
- 1:01:29of whether or not you can get trademark protection
- 1:01:33for domain names. Also we see, and there are
- 1:01:36some domain names that do have trademarks, or
- 1:01:39companies that own domain names that have trademarks
- 1:01:41on those domains. We also see it in... And there
- 1:01:43are some trademarks for hashtags and social media
- 1:01:46handles. A lot of times the question really comes
- 1:01:49down to whether or not that, for example, hashtag
- 1:01:52or social media handle is being used as a brand
- 1:01:54or source identifier versus, for example, in
- 1:01:57the context of hashtags, it's just an organizational
- 1:02:00or search tool that you're seeing. And then we're
- 1:02:06also seeing it in the counterfeit and third party
- 1:02:08retail site. So there have been some recent decision
- 1:02:12in the southern district of New York involving
- 1:02:15a third party retail site and the marketing and
- 1:02:18selling of goods on that site and the use of
- 1:02:21the brand and whether or not that was authorized
- 1:02:24or endorsed. And so that's sort of causing a
- 1:02:27lot of discussions for the companies that do
- 1:02:30are involved in third party retail. And then
- 1:02:33as we previously talked about, Manny talked about
- 1:02:34as well, name, image, and likeness. It's something
- 1:02:37that you're hearing a lot in the daily news in
- 1:02:41addition to industry news with, for example,
- 1:02:43college athletes now being able to monetize their
- 1:02:45name, image, and likeness. And then also as it
- 1:02:48relates to all the legislation currently underway
- 1:02:50or in process as it relates to deep fakes. All
- 1:02:55right, I'm going to now, I've been talking for
- 1:02:56a while, so I'm going to turn it over to Manny
- 1:02:58Elizabeth to close us out. Yeah, so we're short
- 1:03:01on time so I guess I think I just our takeaway
- 1:03:03for all of you would be You know that that you
- 1:03:06should be strategic about it IP there should
- 1:03:08be some that's part of your business plan Just
- 1:03:10like you know any other part of a business plan
- 1:03:12if we can go to the next slide We've provided
- 1:03:15in the material some links to some additional
- 1:03:17information if you want to learn more about any
- 1:03:20of these concepts. And we all love to talk about
- 1:03:22it. So our contact information is in there too.
- 1:03:24So feel free to reach out. And we did have a
- 1:03:27few questions in the chat. We can hang around
- 1:03:29and answer those if people want to hear them.
- 1:03:31But we understand that you all have very busy
- 1:03:33days too. So thank you all for joining. We appreciate
- 1:03:36the opportunities to present. And we'll chat
- 1:03:39about some questions. But I understand if people
- 1:03:41need to hop off as well. So thank you. So one
- 1:03:46of the questions we got was, you know, how would
- 1:03:48anyone know if AI was used in patent development,
- 1:03:50which is a great question, because as we mentioned,
- 1:03:53AI can't be an inventor. When you apply for a
- 1:03:56patent, there's all kinds of disclosures you
- 1:03:57have to make, and there's a duty of candor. So
- 1:03:59you're going to have to identify an inventor
- 1:04:01that's going to have to be a human being, and
- 1:04:04they're going to have to sign declarations and
- 1:04:05things like that. And then if you get into litigation,
- 1:04:08there is absolutely a lot of discovery and depositions
- 1:04:13and things about what we call conception. and
- 1:04:15reduction to practice. So whoever owns a patent
- 1:04:17is going to have to explain exactly how they
- 1:04:19conceived and came up with the invention. So
- 1:04:22that would be the time where, you know, if you're
- 1:04:24facing patent infringement and you think that
- 1:04:25this was created by AI, you would absolutely
- 1:04:27get to probe that and sort of demonstrate how
- 1:04:30or discover that AI was involved. So, I mean,
- 1:04:35it would not be a good idea to lie to the patent
- 1:04:36office. I suppose it's possible, but that would
- 1:04:39certainly come out. Okay, another question we
- 1:04:42got was, are there any special issues on these
- 1:04:45for nonprofits that you've seen in your practice?
- 1:04:48From my view, you know, nonprofits can hold patents.
- 1:04:51A big thing that comes to mind to me is for universities.
- 1:04:54A lot of universities obviously have a lot of
- 1:04:55inventions and technology that they patent. And
- 1:04:58so really, it's the same rules as for anything
- 1:05:00else. But I don't know, Rebecca and Manny, if
- 1:05:02you have any thoughts on any distinctions or
- 1:05:04things to be aware of in that space. No, it's
- 1:05:07the same in trademark and copyright as well.
- 1:05:09Pursuing it and then also protecting it, I think
- 1:05:12a lot, especially like, for example, in the trademark
- 1:05:14space, right, the goodwill that can be associated
- 1:05:16with a nonprofit, it can then be very important
- 1:05:19to protect that because that's, you know, the
- 1:05:21reputation and the general sort of perception
- 1:05:23of your company, of your nonprofit, right, is
- 1:05:26critical and important as well. So we definitely
- 1:05:29see a number of nonprofits trademarking either
- 1:05:32their sort of over their house mark or, you know,
- 1:05:34their goods and services. what they're doing.
- 1:05:37And Elizabeth, where my mind went on that was
- 1:05:40from the defense side, just being a nonprofit
- 1:05:43is not going to insulate you from potentially
- 1:05:46infringing. And so where my mind went on that
- 1:05:50as the issue will become indemnification is if
- 1:05:53you're a nonprofit, I think you're going to want
- 1:05:55to make sure that, you know, to the extent you're
- 1:05:58using software services. from other companies
- 1:06:02that you've thought through your indemnification
- 1:06:05provisions and don't find yourself on the hook
- 1:06:08for essentially somebody else's infringement.
- 1:06:11That's a great point, because I definitely, in
- 1:06:13the trademark context, I've seen nonprofits be
- 1:06:15targeted, too. So you do need to be very cautious
- 1:06:17when you're coming up with your branding and
- 1:06:19things like that, especially for newer nonprofits.
- 1:06:23OK, copyright question. Do any states still have
- 1:06:25common law copyright protection for works that
- 1:06:27are It's in a tangible medium of expression.
- 1:06:30For example, a stand -up comic who runs through
- 1:06:33his routine at a comedy club but has not recorded
- 1:06:35it or written down. There's no common law protection
- 1:06:39for copyrights. It's a federal IP right. So unfortunately,
- 1:06:44no, but there might be... there might be creative.
- 1:06:50So for example, like, right, once it's sort of
- 1:06:52fixed, I guess the protection is there. But I
- 1:06:55guess what I mean is more so that you can't sort
- 1:06:57of enforce that if somebody were to sort of take
- 1:06:59that. And then sort of as a general matter, right,
- 1:07:02there is not the common law, right. So we're
- 1:07:04just looking on the federal level. I think that
- 1:07:07would really come down to what is fixation. I
- 1:07:12think I would have to Like and that issue you're
- 1:07:16looking there's access to it, but it's not recorded
- 1:07:19written down I think that would get into the
- 1:07:21nuances of what is considered fixation right
- 1:07:24and I think you know, specific to the scenario
- 1:07:31and the context, right? So that would be something
- 1:07:33that you'd want to sort of discuss about exactly
- 1:07:35sort of what happened, right, to figure out if
- 1:07:37you can, if there's some sort of flexibility
- 1:07:40there in that fixation outside of the sort of
- 1:07:42traditional norms of it being sort of recorded
- 1:07:44or written down. And then this is a follow -up
- 1:07:49question on the The false strike issue we talked
- 1:07:53about you know i think that i think the question
- 1:07:56is anymore like if your work is being removed
- 1:07:58from a platform. I guess based on a claim of
- 1:08:01copyright infringement, but you think that's
- 1:08:03incorrect You know, is there any any way that
- 1:08:05you can? You can do something about that if you
- 1:08:08don't believe it's copyright infringement And
- 1:08:10I think the answer maybe you have to go through
- 1:08:11whatever takedown process, which is probably
- 1:08:13not a helpful one But if you have any tips on
- 1:08:15that Rebecca, yeah, I think well, there's sort
- 1:08:17of yeah There's the formal process right if you
- 1:08:20were sort of end up in court, but that a lot
- 1:08:22of platforms have You know policies in place
- 1:08:26for counter notifications, for example. So it
- 1:08:29was essentially combating the takedown notice
- 1:08:33that was submitted and then also the ability
- 1:08:36to contact directly the claimant to ask them
- 1:08:39to retract the claim. A lot of this is efforts
- 1:08:42to either formally with the platform itself or
- 1:08:45also directly with the claimant to avoid the
- 1:08:49dispute that's going on or resolve the dispute.
- 1:08:54platforms do have an expiration, right? So I
- 1:08:56guess you could wait out that expiration, but
- 1:08:58oftentimes that can be understandably not of
- 1:09:01interest. So those are some of the alternative
- 1:09:05routes that are available outside of the sort
- 1:09:07of formal context of litigation. All right, and
- 1:09:11last question. And I think this is also for you,
- 1:09:14Rebecca. Is there a process that you recommend
- 1:09:15to transfer a copyright from one entity to another
- 1:09:18in addition to any recordation of the transfer?
- 1:09:22a robust written agreement in place. So obviously
- 1:09:26I think as this person noted that it does need
- 1:09:32to be recorded with. It doesn't have to be but
- 1:09:37it should be recorded with the copyright office
- 1:09:38But I think also relatedly is that sort of underlying
- 1:09:42that is a written agreement Which outlines the
- 1:09:46sort of the transfer of the ownership the specific?
- 1:09:49Rights that are being assigned over being transferred
- 1:09:52over any sort of additional aspects to that agreement
- 1:09:55if there's sort of an exchange of money that
- 1:09:57sort of thing That's going to be something where
- 1:10:00you're going to want to underlying written agreement
- 1:10:02as well Yeah, so that's all the questions we
- 1:10:06had. Thank you for those are great questions
- 1:10:08So again, we appreciate everyone joining today
- 1:10:11Happy to chat further take a look at the materials
- 1:10:14and we hope you all will now answer the question
- 1:10:17of why IP should matter Thanks, everyone. Thanks