Latest / The Emily Rassam Show / Wharton MBA Explains the S&P 500 in Plain English | Tom Bernard on The Emily Rassam Show
Transcript
- Emily Rassam: Hello and welcome to the Emily Rassam show. Today I am joined by Tom Bernard, the author of The Index of America how the SP 500 works and why you should invest in it. Today we're going to talk about finance, Tom's background, and his inspiration for writing the book. I'm confident we're going to learn a lot of financial tips. and some parenting ones toward the end. Welcome, Tom. Tom Bernard - Index of America: I am Lee. Thanks so much for having me. Emily Rassam: I would like to get us started by talking a little bit about your background. I understand you're from Central California originally and now you're based in Northern California and have been working in the financial sector for many years. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yes, that that's true. So I was born and raised in California. grew up in the Central Valley, Fresno, California, and came up to college at Berkeley and have been in the Bay Area since. that was in the the late nineties. So it so it's been a little bit. And I've I really got in interested in in personal finance during college when like like many, my parents got divorced and that kind of threw a wrench in the the financial mechanisms of college funding and how things were gonna work, et cetera. So I I had to take control of my finances and really start to understand them at a pretty, pretty young age in a very meaningful way. And that led to many different experiences, some good, some bad. But over the years, I've really ri been able to to use those experiences and refine my approach to investing and ultimately was able to come up with a pretty, pretty simple one with with the S P 500. since then gone on, had a career in finance. I've been able to teach at the City College of San Francisco, some personal finance courses. I've been I'm married, I have a couple kids, my youngest is heading off to college. And so while they were growing up, I was able to provide some financial guidance and education to them through like l our summer reading projects. Every summer we'd pick a book and read it and talk about it in the in the finance space. So that ultimately led to to writing my own book after having clipped so many articles and having little discussions about the S P five hundred and how it works and why it's a good investment with them and and others and finally said, you know what, I'm gonna sit down and put it all into one spot and the index of America is what what the result was. Emily Rassam: That makes sense. So I understand we're going to start off our story talking about your grandparents and how they influenced you in finance and what your inspiration for writing your book list. I know your introduction starts off talking about your grandparents, which is so nice. And Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Emily Rassam: for a little background for those who do not know, in I wanna say nineteen twenty three was the official start of what was not quite the S P five hundred. I think there were around two hundred companies back then, was founded. And then you have the crash in nineteen twenty nine, which his grandparents lived through. And then the proper S P five hundred was in fifty seven? Fifty seven? Okay. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Fifties. Fifty seven, yeah. Yeah, yeah, you got it. Emily Rassam: so Tom is going to kick us off here and tell us about his grandparents' story and his inspiration for his book. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yeah. Absolutely. So my grandparents as as you mentioned were lived th lived through the Great Depression. And my grandfather was born in nineteen eighteen, my grandmother in nineteen twenty two. and so in on the East Coast and so they they lived through it and had some really, really hard times. My grandfather I don't even think he finished eighth grade. my grandmother might have finished high school, but I'm I'm not even sure. And then they were you know, they were they were veterans, can participated in the war and really just grew up very I'll say hard scrabble. He was he was a factory worker at the Okanite. They literally built the transatlantic cable, you know, kind of weaving together all those those thick cables. It was you know, it was their generation, so they had seven children, right? So he finished eighth grade, was a factory worker, was able to, you know, married and was able to raise seven kids in the east coast, and they ultimately transitioned out to California. when when some of the the daughters moved out here. So lot of the sons stayed on the East Coast in New Jersey and the the daughters moved out to California and the grandparents came out here. And so I grew up with them with them since I was you know a little little boy. And as I was in college I I I mentioned I started to learn more about financing and as they got or finances in general and as they got as they got older, like like many elderly folks, they started to re you know, start to realize that they were gonna run out of money. You know, they they had saved and they had a small pension, but they were gonna run out of money and so the their seven children asked me to sit down with them and talk to them about finances. w which I did and I was happy to do that and explain to them what I knew, my understanding at the time. Keep in mind I was, you know, twenty, nineteen, twenty years old. And I mean we we sat around their their kitchen table for hours and hours and, you know, we laughed and we cried and it was so incredibly emotional to hear about the stories specifically from my grandfather, about his rem just remembering the Great Depression and remembering going down the big streets with the fancy houses and the mansions that were empty and like literally having to walk in there and rip out walls so that they had firewood in the winter and, you know, walking down the street and picking up coal kind of behind the c th the truck that that was carrying it down the road so that they had once again heating. So they were they were it was the Great Depression and they were they had hard times. and all he all he remembers about why it was caused was the stock market crash. The stock market crash. And so that very emotional memory pretty much said, you know, convinced him t that he would never invest in the stock market because I mean, he saw literally people jump out of windows in, you know, downtown New York and stuff like that because of the of the crash. And so they never invested in stocks. They'd always put their money in C Ds in a bank and they would roll them over every year or a few years. And after that discussion, we we agreed that, you know, they were at the time they were in their seventies. They ultimately lived to their mid nineties, but they lived they were in their seventies at the time and it didn't make sense for them to invest in the stock market because the concern was that at any any downturn they would sell. Right. And so the idea is if you're gonna invest, you you know, it goes up and it goes down. And while over time it goes up, and you know, and when you look at l long periods of time, 10, 20, 30 years, you know, I don't think there's ever been a 30 year period where it hasn't gone up. But there's, you know, they were very clear that they did not have the stomach. to invest in the market and to hold during the downturns. Even if it was in a very reputable index like you know total stock market or the SP 500, they just said, you know, no, it's it's too risky. And their perception of the risk and their tolerance to withstand that volatility was was effectively non-existent. And so we agreed that the best course for them was to continue to do what they had been doing for decades and decades that worked was to invest in in their CDs, which they did. And so we had to come up with alt other mechanisms. Like I mentioned, they had seven kids, the kids pulled together and it all worked out. They ended up having to sell sell some property, but I mean they ended up having a very nice kind of an end of life and it and finances weren't as big of an issue as we might have thought twenty years before when I sat down and had that conversation. Now could they have been better? Yeah, the stock market did great over those twenty over those twenty years. But but still they had had a very fulfilling kind of end end of their life and And everyone can look back and and and smile about it 'cause it was like I said, it w it they lived really good lives and and it ended well for them. Emily Rassam: That's wonderful. so I'm gonna pretend with you now that we're sitting and talking to your grandparents and I'm gonna ask you a few questions to Tom Bernard - Index of America: Okay. Emily Rassam: describe some of the terminology you just used before we start talking about what is the S P five hundred. So can you give us a basic description for those who don't quite grasp what is a stock? Tom Bernard - Index of America: Okay. So when you look around and and I like to use businesses, a business that you might be familiar with. think about a company, maybe you know McDonald's or you know, a television like Walt Disney, okay, you're in Orlando and so so Disney World. that's a business. And so that business is was started by you know Walt Disney and w and ultimately when Walt Disney decided that he wanted to do something, whether it's an animation studio or build Built his theme parks, he needed to get some money. And so there's really two ways to get money. You can go to a bank or or borrow it from people, and it could be a formal institution like a bank or or you know individuals, but the other and he has to pay it back, or the the individual has to pay it back with interest over time. But the other way is it is to effectively raise money and share some of the risk of that endeavor by selling equity or selling a portion or a percentage of that business. And Let's just say, for example, we wanted to start Disney World and might it might have needed, let's just say, a thousand dollars at the time. Well, we might have been said, well, listen, I will sell ten or twenty percent of Disney World to someone that's willing to give me the thousand dollars to build it. And that thousand dollars could have been on a contract and and is you know figured out that way, but for publicly traded companies, though though that equity portion is represented through stock shares. And so what happens is there's a very formal process that is highly, highly regulated by the Securities Exchange Commission, where a company that wants to issue stock or sell some of their equity to the public must go through a very formal process called an initial public offering. And then the shares that they that that get priced that determine how much money the company's going to raise and how much the people are going to have to pay in exchange for their equity get. goes through a roadshow and it gets priced and then ultimately they get sold and the the individual that that trades their money for the stock can hold on to it for as long as they want or they can sell it the the next day to to someone else that might be willing to pay more or pay less and every day the stock market is open and the prices the price for Walt Disney is reflected. I think it's updated now like literally every second it goes up, it goes down. and at any given point in time someone can sell it. And as long as someone is on the other side willing to buy it. And that is trading the stock. And so the stocks that we're talking about, when we say stocks as opposed to bonds, stocks is equity and bonds is debt. So think about it personally like a loan, right, would be bonds. And then to the extent that you were going to sell a percentage of something that you owned, that would be equity. Emily Rassam: Okay, thank you for that description. It was really really good. I thought that that was a good step towards then describing what is the SP 500 for those who don't know. Tom Bernard - Index of America: okay. So the S P stands for Standard and Poor's and that's just a company that creates indexes. And so the specific the Standard and Poor's 500 index has a very long history. we'll just take a step back and the you know Standard and Poor's was really over combined the combination of two companies. One was called Standard Statistics and the other one was called Poor's Publishing. And so these were standard statistics was around since the early 1900s, as you mentioned. they had indexes going back to you know 1923, and they might have only at the time had they had a couple different ones. One was a daily index where they just calculated the price of 90 stocks, and then they had a weekly index that had a little bit more, around 220 at the time. And those In the forties, the two companies combined. So standard statistics and poor's publishing combined com to come to form the standard and poorers. Now at the time, both of those companies had indexes, separate indexes that track different things. And what they realized during the merger was that it was a great opportunity for them to establish or a new baseline for the new company for the standard and poorers. And so what they did was that they took so in the in the early 40s, it was like forty-one, forty-two, forty-three. That was the height of a very productive time for the American economy because of the war. And so they measured the value of stocks every week for about three years. Right. And they used that value to establish a baseline for the value of stocks in the US. And that baseline number that they used was 10. So they they did this math every week for three years. So, whatever that is, 156 data points, right? And they came up with this baseline number of 10. And that baseline number is the number that is used for the SP 500 to this day. And so, because they were trying to measure the growth of the economic output of the United States, and so as represented by the stock market. And so if you think about the economic output of the US as measured by the value of stocks in the early 40s, that value is 10. And then I think today. The SP 500 closed at around 7,750. So from the early 40s to 2026, that's the type of growth that we're talking about in terms of the economic multiple and the value creation of the US economy as represented by the stock market from the 40s to 2026 and as captured by the S P 500. So SP is standard and poor. 500 is just the number of stock. Companies that are that are in this index. And there are some very specific rules for the SP 500 in order to be eligible to be in it. The first one is a value hurdle. And so the SP 500 is known as a large cap index because the value to get to the value a company must have in order to even be considered eligible. And not every company that meets this value hurdle is automatically admitted, but just even be like in the room you have to have a value of at least 22.7 billion dollars as as of the most recent valuation hurdle and they review it every quarter and sometimes they increase it so you know five years ago it might have been 15 billion as an example and so they increase that value hurdle to be considered the other thing is they've changed these requirements over ye over the years but currently a company must be considered a US company and it hasn't always been that case the case, but now it's currently must be a US company. And they they look at that a couple different ways. One, just where's the formal headquarters of the company, but also where's most of the business activity, where are most of the assets held, et cetera. And that is that determination is actually made by the index committee. That is a group of individuals that that have oversight effectively of the index and the rules. And we'll talk a little bit about how those rules are made in in a minute, but So the other interesting part is so there's an index committee, there's a there's a minimum value hurdle that we talked about. There's also a a seasoning requirement. So a company must have been public for at least 12 months. So something like SpaceX can't be in the SP 500 for at least 12 months because it has to be has to be open on the markets for 12 months. But in addition to being on the market for 12 months, it also has to be net profitable. So as they look at each quarter. For the last four quarters, the total, if you were to add them up, has to be positive. So you can lose money in Q one, lose money in Q two, lose money in Q three, but if you make so much money in Q four that it is kind of wipes out all those losses from the first three quarters, you are then eligible to be admitted. So they call that a quality filter. not ever not every company meets it, and it takes many companies, some of the largest in the in the world now. It took them many years, so I think Tesla took them many years to get in. Amazon it took them many years to be eligible to get in. Because once a company goes public, keep in mind the companies go public because they are looking to raise money, right? Equity money, and they typically aren't creating a lot of their own free free cash flow. So they're looking to r to the public markets. so that's a high level summary of how it works, but but in addition to those those rules. the index committee itself is comprised of individuals that are highly experienced. They they are not they're supposed to be independent in the sense that they're not they don't have commercial responsibilities for the company. And they go through a process where they if they are going to consider any changes, they document what those proposed changes are and they have a 30-day kind of listening tour if you will where they publish here are our proposed changes and they get feedback from the from the markets. So the S P 500 is the considered to be the highest quality index in the world and the the amount of products or derivatives that are traded is much much greater than the actual value of the stock. So if you were to look at the this the value of the underlying companies in the SP 500 at the end of twenty twenty five it was I think around sixty sixty trillion dollars but there are hundreds of trillions of dollars of products that are based on the S P five hundred so it is one of those one of the most significant indexes in terms of the the the ability to move financial markets around the world. It set it sets prices for you know insurance contracts and and other mechanisms that have nothing to do with the actual individual companies, right? They're they're but it's used as a proxy for the the prosperity of the American economy, the resilience of the American economy, et cetera. And so based on that, the it the importance and the significance of the S<unk>P 500 is much, much greater than merely the value of the companies that that comprise it. Emily Rassam: makes sense. So one of the things I wanted to specify to the audience listening is that there is a vetting process, which Tom is saying, to become part of the S P five hundred. and so it makes it a little more appealing. to investors because there are more rigorous standards in addition to just being able to have or be listed on the stock exchange. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yeah. There's one one other that I that I failed to mention but but I'd like to, and that is Emily Rassam: Sure. Tom Bernard - Index of America: the sector representation. So the there's something called the global industry classification system. It came it was created in the in the mid 90s and the purpose was to make sure that there was representation of the sectors of the economy in roughly market weighted fashion. So that if technology makes up thirty percent Then the SP 500 is roughly 30%. If transportation makes up 10%, transportation is roughly 10%. So that's the that's the overall goal. Now each individual company within that sector still has these hurdles that they must overcome. But now it's broken up among these 11 different sectors. And the reason that's important is because it's you might have one sector, and for many years now it's been the information. technology sector that has pretty much dominated the index and you hear all the time the Mag 7 and these you know seven or ten companies that really dominate it. If you didn't have this attempt to represent the values by the market, the market weighted values, it would be very easy to skew even heavier to technology because companies in other sectors that might not be as valuable would just be omitted because the most valuable companies might be you know, the sector weights might be much much greater. And there are other indexes where it's the entire the entire market, like the total stock market index, but then there are some like the the Russell 1000 where it's just the 1000 most valuable companies, right? And so the the percentages the of the sectors that are that are represented by something like by an index like that might be different than the market weighting of a total market index or the SP 500. And this is important because while Currently and for the last several decades, information technology has been the sector of choice and has really done outperformed the other sectors. You never know what's going to be next. And so owning the largest companies in the healthcare sector or the financial sector can really benefit you should that turn. And so let's say in 2027, it's not information technology, it's finance that that really leads the leads the market. Well, if you own the SP 500. You own the largest financial companies. You own the largest healthcare companies. Even if they're much, even though they might be much smaller than the technology companies or oil and gas, something like that, because they're really the they strive to have the largest and really what they call blue chip or the the highest quality companies in each representative sector. Emily Rassam: Yes, thank you for s saying that. And in Tom's terms, he's saying that this is a way to diversify your portfolio without having to study each individual company yourself and then purchase them individually. So it makes a diversified portfolio for you. And how has the SP five hundred performed given a comparison with the rest of the stock market in general, trend wise. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Trendwise, so the when it was created back in the fifties, the objective of the the committee was to have a measurable benchmark that could represent about 80 or 90 percent of the total stock market. And so as it the the date that I'll continue to use is the end of 2025. That's just because when I measured all the numbers, the US stock market was valued at about sixty-seven trillion dollars and the SP five hundred was about sixty trillion. trillion of that. The total world, when you look at the as the the way the SP company, index company tracks it was about 110 trillion. So the S P 500, those 500 companies were 60 of that 110. And there was about 13,000 companies that made up that 110. So that other 12,500 was 50. 50 million versus the 60 million or 60 trillion, sorry. And so that's So in terms of how does it repres how does it compare? For the US it's almost exactly the same. When you look at the total US stock market, it is almost the same. In fact, depending on what period of time you look at, it fares a little bit better, right? when you look at things like international stocks, or the the performance over time in terms of the percentage changes. And so there are periods of time when I think just more recent most recently. last few years, the international stocks outperformed US stocks. I think w you know the US stocks might have been up something like fifteen percent, but international stocks were up thirty or thirty-five percent one one year. And that happens over time, but when you look at the total value of the of the economies, the US the value represented by the US economy is much, much greater than any other individual comp country or even region. Right. So when you look at the US as opposed to all of Europe or all of you know all of Asia, for example, on the publicly traded front, it is much, much greater. In fact, it's much greater than the rest of the world for publicly traded companies. Right. When you look at a total there's an index fund called Vanguard Total World Index, and the US represents a more than sixty percent of the total value of of that and the SP five hundred represents vast majority of that sixty percent. So while the while the percentages the the performance can change over time, in general, the when you look at the the last hundred years or so, we'll talk talk a little bit about a study that was done by Henrik Bessenbender. He's a professor in finance out at ASU and he studied the last hundred years of US stock performance and he sudden something, I think it was something like ninety six thousand stocks or You know, and took took them all the way from the their creation or the time they went public to the time that they went bankrupt or merged or ultimately ended. And he compared them to 30-day US treasuries, and he found that most stocks, the majority of stocks, over the course of their life, don't even beat short-term treasuries. Okay, so the majority of stocks don't even beat the sh the the the comparison benchmark of short-term treasuries. And then when you look, you dig a little bit deeper. It was of all the value that was created. I think he he said something like 90 trillion dollars in value was created over that time. That cr that incremental value was created by less than four percent of the companies. So a very small number of companies is actually creating all of the value that is realized by by stock investors in N US stocks. And the reason that's important is because It just goes to show how incredibly difficult it is. So keep in mind, this is over a hundred years, right? And tens of thousands of stocks and picking four out of one hundred to actually capture the value in order to to to match just the market returns. And clearly if you would pick those four percent you'd you would way outperform the market. But that's really hard to do. And there is the the person that started Vanguard and started the first S P five hundred index fund guy named Jack Bogle, he had a great saying. He said, you know, don't look for the needle, just buy the haystack. And so by picking an index like the S P five hundred, you're not trying to find those four percent of companies. You you can be confident that it when you buy the index, they're in there. You don't know which ones, but they're in there. And over time it's changed. So right now we have, you know, the Mag Seven, but back in the nineties there was the nifty fifty, right? And then there was during the dot com boom there was a a whole, you know, there was some more like twenty-five-thirty stocks that were really leading the charge and they change over time. And when you look at this the 500 stocks that are in there today, only a handful have been there for more than like 30 or 40 years. So they change all the time. Stocks are getting added and getting removed. And as an investor, you don't have to worry about it. As long as you own the index, you know that there is a group of professionals that are making those decisions following the the weights that are laid or the the methodology that's laid out in terms of the hurdle and the sectors and all that stuff so that you as you mentioned they can have a diversified stock portfolio that is basically overseen by somebody else. So I like to call it a stealth it it is a stealth active fund, right? While it's a considered a passive index fund, really there's an index committee that is making buy and sell decisions every ninety days and they are adding and taking away and kind of, if you will, pruning your garden. to make sure that it's always looking good so you don't have to worry about it. Emily Rassam: Yes. so taking this information you have taught us, when we would say pretend that your grandparents were alive today and they went through two thousand eight, two thousand nine, and the crazy craziness that ensued afterwards. you know, 'cause we I like to think of kind of three different big things that have happened in the past hundred-ish years, starting with the stock market crash, and then the 70s, that tumultuous time, and then 2008, 2009, those are always mentioned. and may now maybe COVID, but we'll skip that one for now. what Tom Bernard - Index of America: Okay. Emily Rassam: would you say to your grandparents if they experienced two thousand eight, two thousand nine and you wanted them to invest somehow. a in regard to the stock market or real estate or etcetera. Tom Bernard - Index of America: That's a gr like Yeah. So so that that's a great question. And and ultimately these are very so you know personal finance first and foremost is personal. So there's no right answer that applies to everybody. and understanding your circumstances and your tolerance for risk is really important and everybody changes over time. So as I mentioned, I've got a couple kids and my youngest is heading off to college. It was you know, my risk tolerance is much different now than it might have been when they were very young, three or four, for example, right? And so Emily Rassam: Right. Tom Bernard - Index of America: it's just keep in mind that your circumstances change over time, your tolerance for risk changes over time, but it is very much a behavioral it it's a it's a behavioral game, if you will, in the sense that you know and it's easy for me to tell you the stocks go up and go down over time, but living through it when it's you know, you you've you've assigned something that's incredibly valuable to you to some portion of your portfolio. Maybe it's you know paying for kids for college or sending someone off to a great vacation for an anniversary or whatever it is, right? And how valuable or how significant it is if you might not be able to do that. Right? If that somehow while it looked like we were on track, things were going well, but now all of a sudden there's been a 10 or 15 or 20% decline. Now now it's at risk. But If you sell now, you can lock it in and and even if I, you know, work a little bit more, save a little bit more, then maybe I can get it back. So there's very much an emotional aspect to it. And and I like to say you shouldn't invest any money that you're not willing to lose. Right? And that's Emily Rassam: Right. Tom Bernard - Index of America: that is a problem a lot of people have is they invest money that they're not willing to lose. And so if you if you follow that, you're investing money that you're willing to lose, then sitting through the volatile periods shouldn't be a problem. But it's one thing to think I'm willing to lose it and then it's another thing to actually lose it and change your mind. Right. And Emily Rassam: Yes. Tom Bernard - Index of America: I I I have come to this realization the hard way. I've thought that my risk tolerance was extreme only to you know see the see the dot-com boom boom and then the bust or see the great financial crisis and and sell out maybe not all of my positions but sell out enough to make sure that okay, I'm fine. Like okay, I know I have this money in the bank and it's and it's okay now. So that anything else that happens, I'm I'm okay because when things go wrong, they usually go really wrong. Things for example, yes, the economy goes down, the stock market goes down, and then you lose your job. Right? Like I mean when when things go wrong, they go really, really wrong, but people only assume maybe one thing goes wrong. And so that's so they don't really have have a good appreciation. And I'm speaking once again from personal experience of what my you know your risk tolerance really is when it comes down to it. and so I strongly urge people to be more conservative than they than they think they should be. And what I mean by that is even if you start somewhere really simple, like just investing, you know, every dollar you you earn that you're going to quote unquote save or invest, put half in the stock market and put half in a money market fund. And so then you know exactly that half of your money is a hundred percent safe. And as the stock market goes up, that the the percentage that is represented by the stocks will continue to grow much greater than the 50% that you initially put in. And you'll have a real-time benchmark of, okay, well, if I hadn't, then you know, as long as it's always greater than the the cash that I put in my money market fund, kind of your own test, the the way I mentioned Henrik or Hank Bessenbender did the test against the short-term treasuries, you can effectively do that yourself by just putting half in short-term treasuries and half in the S P five hundred and over time, the SP five hundred will greatly outperform it. when I was writing the book, one of the analysts, Howard Silverblatt for the S P five hundred, he worked there for fifty years and he he retired just in early twenty twenty-six and when he signed off he basically said over his working career of forty-nine years, the S P five hundred had returned greater than twelve percent on average in terms of total return once you reinvest the dividends, greater than twelve percent over that fifty year period. And that covers everything, right? We're talking the 70s, we're talking the eight the crash in the eighties, we're talking the dot com boom and the bust and the great financial crisis and all all of that, COVID, etc. Still 12%. So the the the key really to be successful is to stay the course and and not get scared out of the market. But it is much easier said than done. And so you have to have a a conservative take a conservative approach because behavior ultimately at the end of the day, it's your behavior that is going to determine your returns. Emily Rassam: Yes, I have asked quite a few people who invest a lot about the market on days when it's way down and they say I don't care. I'm in it for the long term and it's different when it's like, you know, a large chunk of your nest egg, so to speak, versus someone who does it and they try to keep emotions out of it and they watch the numbers over the long term. I think we forget how much of investing is emotionally emotional attachment sometimes. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yeah. Well it's it's it's very real. You work hard for your money, right? And and to see money that you worked very hard for seemingly disappear, that's emotional, without a doubt, right? Emily Rassam: Yes, yes. and so what first of all I want to ask you one more question for someone who may not have done a lot of investing yet. What is a dividend? Since you mentioned the term. I it's like a nice one to talk Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yeah. Emily Rassam: about. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yeah, no, absolutely. So we talked about how companies get money, right? And they can get it from issuing equity or or borrowing money through through debt and issuing bonds. But then the question is: so company does all these things because they want to start they want to start Disney World. And now a bunch of people show up and they're paying their money and they're buying their cotton candy and they're going on the rides. And now Walt is sitting with a stack of cash, right? He has all this cash. What is Walt gonna do with all this cash? Right? Well, some of it he's gonna keep, and that's called retained earnings. So Walt Disney is retaining the earnings. Then but there might be somebody says, you know what, I don't need all this cash. I've got I've got all my working capital, I've got the cash that I need. so I'm gonna give some of it back. And there's really now two ways to give it back. One is the form of a dividend, and that is cash that is paid out to shareholders of record on the dividend date, and that's kind of technical stuff, but if you own some stock on the dividend date, you're gonna get a dividend. And they change that dividend, but historically the dividends go up in value over time. So if if a company issues a dividend and let's just say it's 10 cents a share, generally they try and increase it a little bit ever every few years or so, but they know that people are relying on that income. And so they try very very hard not to make it go down. Right. And so Emily Rassam: Right. Tom Bernard - Index of America: so companies manage that very closely. Now because of that and because of the The consequences of reducing a dividend, many companies now have another approach to returning funds to shareholders that is more variable, and that is in the form of share buybacks. And so the other way to return value is to say, well, if we have a hundred shares outstanding, I'm gonna use some of my money to buy back 10 or 20 shares, and the people that own the that didn't sell that own the remaining 80 shares. Now those shares should be worth more, right? Because the value of the company hasn't changed, but instead of being divided by 100, it's now divided by 80. And so you've gotten effectively money back that way that you are in control of when you realize that, because you can sell you can sell that share or hold on to that share. It's totally up to you. But if you choose, if you need the money, you can sell it the share, or if you don't, you can hold on to it. whereas the dividend, it is not up to you. You you get cash. Now you can always choose to buy more shares with the cash, but There's no question about was that distributed? It absolutely was distributed. And the the reason this is important is because there's a tax consequence associated with that. Whereas with a share buyback, there's not a tax consequence to you as the individual investor. And now the companies themselves, through share buybacks, are the largest buyer of stocks on any given year. And it has been this way for many years now. The companies themselves, through share buybacks, are the largest buyers of stocks. And they buy a much higher dollar value worth of stocks than they than they issue in dividends. So it used to be if you if you were to look back, you know, the percentage, it was something like three or four or five percent of dividends. And now the dividend, I think, for the SP five hundred is down to one percent in change. But it's not that that that the cash being returned has gone down. It's that Now there is a a mechanism to return it that is not a dividend through the share buyback. And so they're actually returning more money to shareholders than they've ever returned, but it's just now being done in these two different ways. One is dividend and the other is the share buyback. Emily Rassam: Now that you mentioned it, since we're we we have talked about taxable events now and this is one of your areas of expertise, why would we then want to reinvest our dividend versus taking it out tax wise? Tom Bernard - Index of America: That gr great question. And so the the reinvested dividend I believe is not taxable. so there there's a bunch of different rules. So many people hold investments in 401k accounts and IRA accounts, and so those are generally non-taxable. And there's some taxable accounts, but the the dividends are are that are reinvested are treated differently than the dividends that are that are distributed to to the individuals. But it's I think the rules the rules have changed. So my understanding isn't is it might not be perfectly up to date, but the the cleanest way for a company to issue the to return capital is in the form of the share buyback. So then there's no question that there's no tax events. But reinvesting dividend is is important because when the as I mentioned that that twelve percent return, that is the what's called a total return. And that total return assumes that you reinvest all the dividends because if you were to take as distributions the dividends and spend them, go out and have a nice dinner or whatever, and not reinvest them, your your the realized return would be less over time. And that tends to be about two percent. So depending on who you talk to, you might hear things like, the the stock market returns ten percent and that's typically a price That is the price return when you just look at the pure numbers of the index. it's seven thousand seven hundred and fifty versus ten as an example. But then when you factor in reinvesting dividends and now that you're actually getting more shares, that total return is going to be higher over time because of that reinvestment. Emily Rassam: Thank you. what are some other taxable events that we would want to keep in mind if we have a stock portfolio? that you can think of unless it's Tom Bernard - Index of America: goodness. So yeah. Emily Rassam: not something you want to talk about, but that's just a question I thought of that seemed relevant. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Sure. So so I think the well, especially for retirees, there so there's the tax when you sell something, there's capital gains, and there can be short term or long term capital gains, and that's depending on on how long you've owned the stock. Presumably you you want to sell stock that you've owned the for a long term, at least twelve months, and that'll be long term. But then there are those rules and the actual amount of that capital gains tax changes depending on how much income you are generating in any given year. So it's possible that your capital gains tax rate could be zero if you fall below certain thresh income thresholds or some nominal amount, I think 15% and then 20% at at higher levels. But many people can effectively manage their their taxes by selling appreciated shares in years when they have very low income so that they are so that while they are realizing capital gains, the tax rate that is being applied to those capital gains is very low. Emily Rassam: Yes, Tom is reminding us, business owners, why it's important to have a tra tax strategy every year and take advantage when you have less income in one of those years. 'cause it can make a large difference in how much asset you retain. Tom Bernard - Index of America: Yeah. So it I mean I I like to say that you know most people have a business partner whether they realize it or not, and that business partner is the federal government, right? Or the the government, whether it could be s federal or state. Emily Rassam: Yes. Tom Bernard - Index of America: And you if you don't think you have the feder the the government as a partner, just wait until you try and get your money and a a large chunk of it goes away. So it's you'll realize it pretty quickly. And so the the the more you can think about it in advance and minimize it, the better off you are. And so there are one of the things that's been really beneficial for for many individuals has been the Roth accounts and the ability to convert convert pre-tax money to to you know Roth conversions during during low income years has been beneficial for many retirees and something that if you haven't explored that and you're in that period where you've retired but you're not hitting required minimum distributions, it's something absolutely worth exploring because there could be some real advantages to you. Emily Rassam: Yes. I'm just asking a lot of queer clarifying questions because I know Tom Bernard - Index of America: Sure. Emily Rassam: not everyone is very well versed in investing terminology. so what was your major inspiration for writing your book on the S P five hundred? Tom Bernard - Index of America: So as I mentioned, I got into it b you know when I was when I was younger, but one of the things that that my wife had asked me to do was to make sure that I taught our kids about finances. And so when they were younger during summer break, we'd we'd or I'd pick a I'd pick a book. And we'd sit down and have a reading kind of a you know, a book club over the summer where we would read read the book and every week we'd sit down and discuss a chapter and understand what the the lessons were, what the ramifications were of some of those things. And my my favorite book that I recommend to to everyone when they're trying to educate kids is The Richest Man in Babylon. I think it's a a great, great starting book for for folks and and the stories in it are are something that th that kids can understand and and grasp and and you know, kinda take with them. So I think it's a great, great place to start. and over time as we had those conversations, I would clip articles or I would see something that was interesting and I would put it in a little binder and you know After many years of this I had a pretty thick binder and that that became the b those articles became the basis for the book and ultimately had to do a lot of editing and cutting it down but to try to make it just just the important parts, but that was that was the basis for it originally. Emily Rassam: how do you feel like you have done now that your kids are older with teaching them finance? Are you feeling good? You're feeling confident? Tom Bernard - Index of America: So I feel so I have two kids, my son's twenty, my daughter's eighteen. They both have jobs, they're both heading off to college and and getting an education and they also both have have invested some of their money in the S P five hundred and I feel feel good about that and I understand the importance of compounding and compound growth and that their their biggest asset really is time and so getting started early is is fantastic and I r I highly encourage it. everyone to you know, every teenager should go out, get a summer job and put some of your money away in a Roth. You know, five hundred dollars, a thousand dollars, a thousand dollars at fifteen years old, which you can do through a custodial account. Vanguard has them, Fidelity has them, your parents can help you out, makes makes such a big difference. And you know, you can now look online and see them be like, well look what's gonna happen. Like when I'm sixty five, it's You know, a hundred and seventy thousand, whatever the dollar amount is, and just getting so excited. They're like, and I don't have to do anything else. Right. And I'm like, that's the way compounding works, right? Your money Emily Rassam: Right. Yes, yes. Tom Bernard - Index of America: is working for you. You've earned it and now you let it do the work. Emily Rassam: I love that. I think that's really awesome that you have taught your kids so much about finance. I think it's an important skill set that a lot of us don't learn until we absolutely have to, because of something happening. and While we're on this topic, your favorite book, what is your best piece of advice that you have ever given or received? Tom Bernard - Index of America: Okay, so I I really like this book by Victor Frankel called Man's Search for Meaning. He was a prisoner in the concentration camps and kind of his his his learnings from that experience. So I think that's a really significant book and and made a big impact on my life. And then in terms of the you know, the things to kinda think of at like every day is a gift. Right. And you just have to embrace it. Every day is a gift. Tomorrow is never promised. So, you know, be be kinder than you think you should be and appreciate that every day, you know, that we have is a gift. Emily Rassam: I love that. Where can we find your book if we want to purchase it? Tom Bernard - Index of America: So my book is available for sale on Amazon as well as I've got a website, indexofamerica dot com, which will take you directly there. But it's also other bookstores, Barnes and Noble, Target, Walmart, wherever books are sold. But it's it's typically available via online purchase. It's not it's not stocked on the shelves of many bookstores, but a few. Yeah. Emily Rassam: Right. since we're on the topic of your book, was it self-published or did you have a publisher I didn't look at on your page? Tom Bernard - Index of America: No great. It was it was self published and in fact I just recently completed Emily Rassam: Awesome. Tom Bernard - Index of America: the audio book, which is now on Spotify, and I'm trying hard to get it back up onto Audible, but it's available on Spotify and so if you are not inclined to read the book, you can certainly listen to it. Emily Rassam: Did you record it yourself? Tom Bernard - Index of America: I did, I did. That was a really fun experience. Emily Rassam: That's awesome. I am in the process of doing that for a book I wrote too. And I didn't know you had to copyright the audio portion, so now I'm, you know, back in the game. Yes? Tom Bernard - Index of America: Going through that process. Okay. Yeah, th so as I was explaining to folks, every author writes the book, right? But when you self publish it, you now are also a publisher and you're doing the publisher's job too that you might not have Emily Rassam: Yes. Tom Bernard - Index of America: appre fully appreciated before. So if I ever go about it again, I'm I I am reconsidering self publishing versus going the the publisher route, for sure. Emily Rassam: Right, right. It is a task. It is a task. but a learning experience nonetheless. Well, I would like to sincerely thank you for joining me today. I know I have learned a lot about the S P five hundred, and I hope my listeners have too. And I wish you all the best in your journey. Tom Bernard - Index of America: But Thanks so much, Emily. This has been a lot of fun. I really appreciate the opportunity. Emily Rassam: Yes, and I do have a big compliment that I would like to give you. I appreciate how articulate you were with the explanations and telling us a story to go with it. I think that helps a lot in understanding. Tom Bernard - Index of America: my pleasure and and hopefully people can pick up the book or check it out at the their library and l learn a little bit more. Emily Rassam: I will have the link below for those of you who are going to look in the comments or the description. So it will be available. Thank you so much, Tom. Tom Bernard - Index of America: All right, thanks a lot, Emily.