Latest / B2B SaaS Talks with Fexingo: Enterprise Software, Sales Cycles, and Procurement / Why SaaS Vendors Are Abandoning The Land And Expand Model
Transcript
- Lucas: The land and expand model was supposed to be the holy grail of SaaS growth for the last decade. You get in with a small pilot, prove value, and then watch the wallet grow organically quarter after quarter. Luna: It worked until every vendor started asking for more money at the exact same time the buyer’s budget went rigid. It feels like we hit a wall in mid twenty twenty six. Lucas: Exactly. Look at the latest procurement surveys from November. Buyers aren’t rejecting expansion outright; they are capping it. They want predictability. They want to know that if they pay five hundred thousand dollars this year, they won’t wake up to a two hundred thousand dollar surprise invoice next quarter. Luna: So vendors are stuck between keeping their existing customers happy and trying to squeeze more out of them without triggering churn. That tension must be killing close rates. Lucas: It is killing efficiency. I spoke with a head of sales at a mid market CRM provider who told me his team’s expansion revenue dropped by eighteen percent year over year simply because procurement started requiring separate approvals for any add on above ten percent. Luna: That approval threshold sounds arbitrary but it changes everything about how you structure your quarterly business reviews. You can’t just pitch features anymore; you have to pitch budget justification. Lucas: Right, and here is the twist. Vendors are starting to abandon the land and expand playbook entirely. They are moving toward usage based pricing not because it is fairer, but because it shifts the risk back to the buyer. Luna: If the buyer pays only for what they use, the vendor doesn’t have to defend a massive annual commitment. But does that actually help the vendor’s bottom line? Lucas: It helps with cash flow stability. When you have a large upfront contract, you carry the risk that the customer stops using it halfway through the year. With usage based, you get paid as they engage. It aligns incentives better than a flat fee ever did. Luna: But isn’t usage based pricing harder to forecast? Investors hate uncertainty when they are looking at your revenue multiples. Lucas: They do hate it, which is why some vendors are hybridizing. They keep a base license for core access and charge per unit for advanced modules. It gives them a floor and a ceiling. It is less volatile than pure consumption. Luna: I see. So it is not about abandoning the old model completely, just adding guardrails. Does this mean customer success teams are getting more work? Lucas: Massively more work. In a land and expand world, you could send an email once a quarter reminding them to upgrade. Now you have to monitor actual usage patterns. If usage dips, you lose revenue immediately. You cannot wait for renewal season to find out. Luna: That requires a whole new layer of data analytics. Most legacy SaaS companies are still running on spreadsheets for this kind of granular tracking. Lucas: They are. And that operational lag is where the real vulnerability lies. Vendors who haven’t built the infrastructure to track usage in real time are watching their expansion margins compress while competitors who have are capturing share. Luna: It reminds me of how cloud providers charged for compute hours versus reserved instances. The flexibility came with a premium price tag. Lucas: Precisely. The premium is the incentive for the buyer to stay predictable. But right now, buyers don’t want predictable premiums. They want variable costs that match their volatility. It is a clash of philosophies. Luna: If I were running a sales org, I would be terrified of losing the land and expand lever. It was our primary driver for valuation multiples. Lucas: Valuation multiples are shifting too. The market is rewarding predictability over aggressive expansion promises. If your guidance relies on a fifty percent expansion rate that no longer exists, your stock gets punished faster than if you just grew steadily. Luna: So transparency becomes the new currency. Admitting that growth will slow down because the market is maturing might actually be healthier than pretending it won't. Lucas: Absolutely. And that brings us to a point that matters for everyone listening who supports independent business analysis. If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, consider supporting the show directly. Luna: Listener support is what keeps us ad-free and allows us to dig into these structural shifts without corporate interference. You can find us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — that's F. E. X. I. N. G. O. Lucas: Every contribution helps us keep producing deep dives like this one. Thanks for helping us stay independent. Luna: Back to the data. Do you think smaller startups can survive this shift without changing their pricing strategy entirely? Lucas: Smaller startups have an advantage here because they are agile. They can launch with usage based pricing from day one. They don’t have the baggage of legacy contracts to unwind. Luna: But they also lack the brand trust to convince an enterprise to switch to variable costs. Big companies love fixed costs because it makes their job easier during budget cuts. Lucas: That is true. Enterprise procurement loves predictability. But startups are finding that if they offer a transparent usage dashboard, buyers feel safer. They know exactly what they are paying for at any given moment. Luna: Transparency reduces friction. It sounds simple, but most vendors hide their pricing behind custom quotes. Removing that mystery changes the entire dynamic. Lucas: It does. And it forces the vendor to be efficient. If you charge per user, you have to make sure every user is active. You can’t just sell seats to dormant accounts and call it a day. Luna: So the product itself has to improve to justify the cost. There is nowhere to hide behind marketing spend anymore. Lucas: Exactly. Marketing can open the door, but product usage keeps it open. This is why customer success is becoming the most critical department in SaaS companies right now. Luna: I always thought sales was the king. But if revenue depends on daily engagement, customer success is definitely the queen. Lucas: Or maybe the engine. Sales brings them in, but customer success ensures they actually drive the car. If the car breaks down, you stop getting paid. Luna: That is a brutal way to put it, but accurate. What happens to vendors who refuse to adapt and stick to the old licensing model? Lucas: They face a slow bleed. Their churn increases because buyers cancel when they don’t need the full suite. Their expansion stagnates. Eventually, they become acquisition targets rather than standalone winners. Luna: So adaptation isn’t optional anymore. It is existential. The market has moved past the growth-at-all-costs phase. Lucas: We are in the efficiency phase now. Every dollar spent has to generate a clear return. The land and expand model was great for scale, but it wasn’t built for sustainability in a tight economy. Luna: Do you see a reversal coming? Will buyers eventually demand more predictable contracts again as things stabilize? Lucas: Maybe in three years. But for now, the trend is clear. Flexibility is winning. Vendors who embrace it will define the next decade of enterprise software. Luna: Interesting. I wonder if this shift will force vendors to build better integrations so users can plug in exactly what they need. Lucas: Highly likely. Modular architecture is going to replace monolithic suites. Buyers want Lego blocks, not pre-fabricated houses. Luna: That changes the competitive landscape entirely. It lowers barriers to entry for niche players who can solve one specific problem really well. Lucas: It does. And it raises the bar for incumbents who have to maintain legacy code alongside new modular offerings. Complexity becomes their enemy. Luna: Complexity kills speed. In a market that demands transparency and agility, heavy platforms are going to struggle to pivot. Lucas: Agreed. The question is whether they can dismantle their own complexity before the market leaves them behind. Luna: Some will. Others will just keep hoping the next quarter brings back the easy growth days. Lucas: Those are the ones we should watch. Their struggles will tell us a lot about where the industry is heading next. Luna: Let’s see who adapts first and who falls behind. That should be a fascinating year ahead.