Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Lenwood Brooks of Performance Trust on NCUA's Board of One & More
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: All right.
- 0:01Hey, everyone.
- 0:02This is Mark Trakel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:05I'm excited today to be here with Lenwood Brooks of performant- Performance Trust.
- 0:09Lenwood, how you doing today?
- 0:11Lenwood Brooks: Mark, I'm doing great.
- 0:13It's great to be with you.
- 0:14I'm honored to be a second-time guest on the program.
- 0:17I guess that means the ratings were good enough last time.
- 0:19Mark Treichel: Yeah, that's right.
- 0:20Yeah, you got- ⦠the people liked your last episode, and I, you've had a
- 0:23couple more stops along the train track since we last chatted, so this could
- 0:27be fun catching up and a lot going on,
- 0:29Lenwood Brooks: but in all serious, Mark I was at a Performance Trust seminar
- 0:33a couple weeks ago, and I was sitting at a table with credit union leaders.
- 0:37And there were four of us at the table, and at that table, three
- 0:40of us were regular listeners of this program, so congratulations
- 0:44on building With Flying Colors.
- 0:45I think it is an incredibly educational and informative podcast.
- 0:49And I know from last time I was on the program, Mark, I heard from so many
- 0:54friends in the credit union space, but I also heard from so many friends
- 0:57at our former agency, the National- Yeah ⦠Credit Union Administration.
- 1:00So your reach here is far and deep into the credit union community, and
- 1:04I'm honored to be back with you today.
- 1:06Mark Treichel: I appreciate that.
- 1:07It's funny, I can tell when NCUAâ¦
- 1:09I can tell when I issue an episode that NCUA likes, 'cause the volume kicks
- 1:13up a little bit- ⦠and I can tell they're spreading it around the building.
- 1:15So I suspect that this is gonna be one of those.
- 1:18So hey with that, so you're at Performance Trust now.
- 1:21You were at the Federal Home Loan Bank of Dallas, I believe, before that.
- 1:25And then, of course, we met at, when you were the chief of staff for
- 1:27Rodney Hood Chairman Hood at NCUA.
- 1:30And then before that Capitol Hill, right?
- 1:32You were on Capitol Hill and as, as we're talking, I think John Cruz just was either
- 1:39confirmed or is about to get confirmed.
- 1:42So walk me through how that all works and anything relative
- 1:44to that you think we should
- 1:45Lenwood Brooks: chat about.
- 1:46Bear with me, Mark.
- 1:47Some of this process can be arcane, but that is the nature of the United
- 1:51States Senate, and things have changed a lot, so we'll get into that.
- 1:55John had his hearing.
- 1:56I thought he did very well.
- 1:58You could tell he was very well prepared.
- 2:00The way these things work, Mark, ever since I've been following this, I've never
- 2:03seen an NCUA nominee be by themselves.
- 2:06They're usually paired.
- 2:07So in, in Mr.
- 2:08Cruz's case, he was paired with someone from HUD, Housing and Urban Development,
- 2:13and someone at the White House.
- 2:14And the reason that's relevant, Mark, of course, if you have someone on
- 2:18the White House on your panel, most of the questions probably are gonna
- 2:22be directed to them, and when you're a nominee that can be a good thing.
- 2:25It limits gotcha questions and so forth, and that's exactly what happened in Mr.
- 2:30Cruz case.
- 2:30But that being said, the few questions he did get ans- asked,
- 2:35I thought he was incredibly skilled in how he answered them.
- 2:39It came across to me that he was well-prepared and intelligent.
- 2:41And I know, Mark, 'cause I've sat on both sides of the diocese as a staffer.
- 2:45I worked for Senator Wicker on his service on the Senate Bank Committee.
- 2:49I worked for Rodney Hood at the NCUA, and I've seen what it's like.
- 2:52And I just want to reiterate this.
- 2:55You can't understand how much work goes into these hearings on an agency side.
- 2:59It is absolutely enormous.
- 3:01I remember when Cal Hauptman was going through the process.
- 3:05His binder was, probably over 10 inches, and it's a lot, and it's a ton of work.
- 3:11But I just wanna commend NCUA, and I wanna commend Mr.
- 3:15Cruz because youâ¦
- 3:16It was obvious as someone who's watched a lot of these hearings
- 3:19that a lot of work went in to the hearing, and he was well-prepared.
- 3:23So after that hearing takes place, Mark what then happens is they
- 3:28do questions for the record.
- 3:29So that gives every senator on the Senate Bank Committee an opportunity to ask
- 3:34questions to the nominee in writing.
- 3:36That process can take a week or so, so you have that play out.
- 3:40And then the committee will gather back in and will vote them out of committee either
- 3:46on a voice basis or vote one at a time as a member of the Senate Bank Committee.
- 3:51So at this point in time, Mark, John has favorably reported out of the
- 3:57Senate Bank Committee, and what's next for him is Senate floor action.
- 4:00And I know I've been talking a while, but I'll wrap up here soon.
- 4:03But here's where we go from here, Mark.
- 4:05The Senate continually changes their cloture rules, okay, i- in practice.
- 4:11And what that means for John is that at this point his
- 4:15nomination can move in block.
- 4:16So up until recently, these cloture motions had to move one at a time.
- 4:22And I went back and looked, Mark.
- 4:24For Mr.
- 4:25Hauptman, it took something like four or five months-
- 4:28Mark Treichel: Really?
- 4:28⦠Lenwood Brooks: from the time when he was reported out of committee
- 4:30to when the Senate confirmed him.
- 4:32And what this is gonna practically mean for Mr.
- 4:34Cruz is I think there is a very high probability the Senate will confirm him
- 4:40before their August summer recess, so very soon, and it will probably be in block
- 4:46with whether it's 50 or 100 nominees.
- 4:49Most nominees can move in block.
- 4:51Now, cabinet nominees, I believe, are different.
- 4:54Judicial nominees are different.
- 4:55They still move one at a time.
- 4:56But this will matter to John because he doesn't have to wait
- 5:00four or five months to serve.
- 5:02I think it is very probable that he gets confirmed very soon, and he'll
- 5:07be able to hit the ground running, but it will still be an NCUA board of one.
- 5:12Mark Treichel: That's interesting.
- 5:13W- one thing you said too is when you go to the table with other folks like
- 5:17from the White House, it reminds me of the, you're getting chased by a bear.
- 5:20I don't have to be fast, I just have to be faster than you, right?
- 5:23So they're gonna put all the questions on the White House which which makes
- 5:27it a little bit more relaxing than the people from the White House
- 5:30having to get, get pressed on that.
- 5:31But that, that's all fascinating.
- 5:33The, the ⦠It's nice to see the efficiencies of them
- 5:35grouping them like that.
- 5:37And as I'm thinking about it, i- if it happens before the end of August, that,
- 5:41that's good for Houtman, 'cause he can go on to what he wants to go on to.
- 5:45And what you're saying, if, it
- 5:46What I'm interpreting there is it'll be a baton pass, right?
- 5:50Though both of them aren't gonna be there at the same time most likely.
- 5:53Lenwood Brooks: That's exactly right, Mark.
- 5:54In the Senate we'll be moving that nominee soon, and Kyle will move on to his next
- 5:59opportunity, which I'm excited for him.
- 6:01It sounds like a great opportunity.
- 6:03Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 6:03Yeah.
- 6:03A- absolutely.
- 6:04And then Cruz getting in there, say, end of August, beginning of September
- 6:08it's like, that ⦠As when you're at NCUA, the budget s- you get past
- 6:12July, st- August there's no board meeting in August a- and the staff is
- 6:17working on the budget, and then you got the bu- public budget briefing or
- 6:20hearing, whatever you wanna call it, and then you got the budget coming up.
- 6:23So he's gonna be, It's good he's a young man.
- 6:25He's gonna need a lot of that energy to have lots of meetings to get up to speed.
- 6:29So in that vein, what's it like to be a political appointee coming into an agency?
- 6:35You'veâ¦
- 6:35So you've got the career staff who've been there, when you guys came in,
- 6:38I'd been at NCUA for 30 years, right?
- 6:40And there's these, these armies of career staff that have been there,
- 6:43and then you're coming in new.
- 6:45You get briefed.
- 6:46You got these great briefing books and that kind of puts all this
- 6:49energy and ideas in your head.
- 6:50But what's it like coming in a political appointee amongst- Mark,
- 6:53Lenwood Brooks: I'll tell you it's a humbling process.
- 6:56I don't think you can quite understand what's it like until you go through
- 7:01it, and especially being the chairman or in the chairman's office.
- 7:05The schedule is intense.
- 7:07It is relentless.
- 7:09You haveâ¦
- 7:10Your days are jam-packed.
- 7:12On behalf of the agency, you're managing HR matters.
- 7:15You're having to do general management.
- 7:16Every credit union wants your time.
- 7:18Every staff member wants your time.
- 7:19You've got interagency meetings with your other federal partners.
- 7:22You have FSOC meetings.
- 7:24The list goes on and on.
- 7:26So it's hard to have a schedule that intense and also get brought
- 7:32up to speed, but I know Mr.
- 7:33Cruz is gonna put in the work and be successful.
- 7:36But I'll be candid, Mark.
- 7:38A lot of political appointees, and I think you can probably speak to
- 7:41this yourself, come in with some skepticism of the career staff.
- 7:45Mark Treichel: Yes.
- 7:45Lenwood Brooks: You hear things.
- 7:47You have preconceptions, and you have to get there and have your own experience
- 7:52to realize your preconceptions are wrong.
- 7:55I remember early on into my tenure, Mark, there was something that
- 7:59I really wanted to do and career staff pushed back on me hard, and
- 8:04i- in this case, I listened, Mark.
- 8:06And you have to recognize the political.
- 8:09The greatest strength of the wonderful career staff at the NCUA
- 8:13is their institutional knowledge.
- 8:15When you were there as executive director, you were the highest ranking
- 8:18career public servant, but your institutional knowledge was enormous.
- 8:23But I think the value political appointees have is they tend to
- 8:27look at things in a different light.
- 8:29I think their risk appetite is probably a bit more than the, the general
- 8:33counsel's office would like sometimes.
- 8:36But I think, someone like you, Mark, you had this incredible institutional
- 8:40knowledge, but at the same time, at that point, that was your only job.
- 8:44So I think for the career who've only b- been there 30 years, you can be myopic.
- 8:49You might be entrenched into the way things.
- 8:52So I think that's one thing I really want to highlight.
- 8:56But I'll say this too.
- 8:57Here's what I learned going in as a new political.
- 9:00Career staff will test you, and they should.
- 9:04They want to see is a new chairman, for example- Are you gonna be setting the
- 9:09agenda or are we gonna set it for you?
- 9:11And I think though, in these tests, Mark, I think the career staff deeply
- 9:17respect the institution of NCUA-
- 9:20Mark Treichel: Absolutely
- 9:20Lenwood Brooks: and the NCUA board.
- 9:22And by default, because of that, they're going to respect you.
- 9:26But I think the NCUA staff are looking to see how competent you are
- 9:30at your job, and do you earn their respect 'cause you are competent.
- 9:34And I know Mr.
- 9:36Cruz is gonna be incredibly competent in this job.
- 9:38But I bring this up, Mark, because my time in NCUA serving as Rodney Hood's
- 9:43chief of staff- When the staff know you're competent and they know your
- 9:47intention, they know that you're not there worried about your next job.
- 9:52They know you're not there worried about politics.
- 9:54But when they really know that you love the agency and the people
- 9:58in it, and you have the good intentions, what happens, Mark?
- 10:02Career staff become a force multiplier.
- 10:05They'll get on board and start rowing your direction as hard as possible, and
- 10:10I think working for Rodney Hood, it might have taken some time, but we got there,
- 10:14Mark, and we got a lot of good done.
- 10:16And you cannot get anything done as a chairman unless you
- 10:22have the career staff with you.
- 10:24They'll take your direction, but you want their buy-in and belief
- 10:27that you really care about them.
- 10:29'Cause there's a lot of great and talented people at NCUA, and one of my biggest
- 10:34regrets, Mark, it took me longer than I wanted for me to realize that on my own.
- 10:40NCUA is filled with talented public servants, many of whom could have
- 10:45very successful private sector jobs, and they're doing great work.
- 10:49And I'm excited to see what Mr.
- 10:51Cruz and the wonderful career staff at NCUA are gonna be able to accomplish.
- 10:55Mark Treichel: Yeah, me too, and it's always, the wisdom of crowds.
- 10:57You bring someone new in with a different idea, and you're right.
- 11:00I was at NCUA 30, almost 34 years, and other than a cup of tea, doing a couple
- 11:05things, before that that's what I did.
- 11:07And so staff, the it, ske- staff is skeptical of the board coming in,
- 11:13the board's skeptical of staff and then you usually meet in the middle.
- 11:17And the worst thing NCUA career staff can do is say, "We've
- 11:20always done it this way," right?
- 11:22Or, "Yeah, the last chairman asked us that question, and here's the legal opinion."
- 11:26'Cause as you learned, you can, I don't wanna say push the
- 11:29envelope, law evolves, right?
- 11:31And what the Federal Credit Union Act and what the regulations mean and h- you
- 11:35pushed it this far, but can you tweak the regulation in a way that provides
- 11:39a new service, kinda like in CUSOs and things I know that you did, when you
- 11:43were there to tweak some things that are still consistent with the act, but make
- 11:46the regulation a little bit better for credit unions to serve their purpose.
- 11:51Lenwood Brooks: There's a saying at NCUA, Mark.
- 11:53You never said it to me, but I know it circulated among staff, and that
- 11:56saying is, politicals come and go But we're here for life, and I think that
- 12:02does get back to what we were talking about the institutional knowledge.
- 12:04But at the end of the day, the reason the politicals come and go, Mark, is
- 12:08because the power they wield is enormous.
- 12:11Mark Treichel: Yes.
- 12:12Lenwood Brooks: If you did have that job for decades, i- in some
- 12:16ways you would be too powerful.
- 12:18So I think there's a lot of wisdom in how this was all designed by,
- 12:22our founders and how the Federal Credit Union Act has played out.
- 12:25But again the careers are critical to getting anything done at the agency.
- 12:30You're not gonna be able to get anything done if a chairman staff
- 12:34of, what is it, six or so at the max?
- 12:36Yeah.
- 12:36You need to buy in careers, and they're the ones that, again,
- 12:40they outlive administrations.
- 12:42Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 12:43But said.
- 12:43Let's pivot a little bit.
- 12:45So last month you joined Performance Trust.
- 12:47So tell me a little bit about what Performance Trust does.
- 12:51I know a little bit of it, but and my listeners mightâ¦
- 12:53You might even have some of my listeners who are clients, butâ¦
- 12:56And then what it is you'll be doing in your new role.
- 12:59Lenwood Brooks: Thank you for that, Mark.
- 13:00You're right, I did just join last month, so I'm relatively new.
- 13:04But to answer your question, Performance Trust is the largest
- 13:08independent investment bank focused exclusively on community depositories,
- 13:14so including credit unions, Mark.
- 13:16So for over 30 years, we've been working with our clients to help them
- 13:21raise the floor, to help them achieve results they wouldn't otherwise achieve.
- 13:25And I think, Mark, I was drawn to Performance Trust for many reasons,
- 13:29but one of the biggest reasons, to be frank, was the founding story.
- 13:33The group was founded by two gentlemen, one named Rich Berg.
- 13:37Rich is a fascinating gentleman.
- 13:39We might should have him on this show at some time, but he started
- 13:42out, Mark, as a math teacher.
- 13:44He's one of the best teachers I've ever been around, and he
- 13:46just commands a classroom and you just love to learn from him.
- 13:50If you go to our trading desk in Chicago, Mark, it's actually set up
- 13:54like a lecture hall in college, and that gets into, I think a core value of
- 13:59Performance Trust, which is education.
- 14:01But the other founder was a gentleman named Phil Newsome, Mark, and he was,
- 14:06like you, a former federal regulator.
- 14:08And what they saw out of Wall Street, they didn't like.
- 14:11They saw, over 30 years ago, community depository institutions taking on poor
- 14:18risk rewards on their balance sheet from Wall Street, buying products
- 14:22they probably had no business buying.
- 14:25But Mark, they just didn't complain about the problem, they did
- 14:28something about it, and that's how Performance Trust was founded.
- 14:33And we're focused on principles, process, and framework.
- 14:38And, that's hard to say when it's just words, Mark, but I think later
- 14:41on the podcast we'll get into more specifics on what we actually do.
- 14:45But, I came to PT because I saw a unique opportunity to turn insights into action.
- 14:52And you asked about what I'll specifically be doing, Mark.
- 14:55I'll be doing working alongside my colleagues, what they've been doing
- 14:59for many decades, and again, that is raising the floor, helping our
- 15:03clients achieve better results.
- 15:05And of course, Mark, with my background, I spent 18 years in DC, primarily in the
- 15:10regulatory realm and public policy realm, I'll continue to be involved, and when
- 15:15it makes sense, will be advocating for common sense reforms in the industry.
- 15:21So I'll still be involved in that regard.
- 15:24Mark Treichel: Very good.
- 15:25Yeah, that's the thing is you, the journey you take gives you this
- 15:28wisdom as you get old like me and you get a little bit older, right?
- 15:31And you can share that with Performance Trust, so I'm excited to see-
- 15:34Lenwood Brooks: I think the gray hair came in for me, Mark, when I
- 15:37was working alongside you at NCUA.
- 15:39Those, those long days get to you and the no sleep get to you.
- 15:42Yeah,
- 15:43Mark Treichel: that's right.
- 15:43That's right.
- 15:44The glory days.
- 15:45Yeah.
- 15:45Yeah, a lot of fun.
- 15:47That was a lot of fun.
- 15:47That's ⦠i'm excited for you and what you're gonna do
- 15:49there at Performance Trust.
- 15:50They're lucky to have added you to the team.
- 15:53Now I'm gonna pivot back to, so Cruz is getting added to the NCUA team.
- 15:57And y- I don't think ⦠I don't know if it came up today or not but he
- 16:01was asked earlier about the legality, the issue of a, a one-member board
- 16:06and perhaps the pending litigation.
- 16:08And he basically, I think, said, "Hey, I'm not a lawyer.
- 16:11That's for the, the Supreme Court and you all to figure out.
- 16:13And I'll, we'll, I'll ⦠I- if you put me on the board, I'll, a- and you
- 16:17put, whoever you put with me, I'll work with them," or something like that.
- 16:20But so he didn't go into the specifics of that.
- 16:22Any thoughts on that, him taking that approach and/or, that whole
- 16:26arena on the lawsuits and stuff?
- 16:29Lenwood Brooks: Mark, I wouldn't want to answer that question either.
- 16:31This is not a hypothetical.
- 16:32It is a, a real world example happening right now, and we're not
- 16:38gonna be able to answer that question today here on a podcast, Mark.
- 16:41It will ultimately be decided by the courts.
- 16:44And the question is this, if you look at the NCUA statute what
- 16:49happens when you have a board of one?
- 16:51Does a majority of ⦠Does one constitute a quorum?
- 16:55You can have very smart thinkers and lawyers on both sides of
- 16:59that argue, argue that issue.
- 17:01But I do think- There is a gray cloud hanging above the agency
- 17:06as long as they operate as one.
- 17:08I think they know that, and I think confirming John is a step in the
- 17:12right direction, but it's only a step.
- 17:14Until the board is at least two members, there will be a gray cloud unless the
- 17:20courts adjudicate it one way or the other, and that's where we stand right now, Mark.
- 17:24It's not a position I think that they'd like to be in, but it is a
- 17:28position they're in, and I think the courts will decide that question.
- 17:34And who knows what they'll decide.
- 17:36Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 17:36Very well said.
- 17:37And you know I like rock and roll, I like going to live concerts, and
- 17:40I'm a Van Morrison fan, and there's a Van Morrison line to a song.
- 17:44It's "What's the sound of one hand clapping?"
- 17:46And whether it's legal or not, whether they find out that a vo- board of
- 17:51one can vote, it's the CFPB has an administrator of one, and it's one person.
- 17:55You lose that wisdom of crowds.
- 17:56So I'm excited for whenever the dust settles there being a full board
- 18:02because you get that dialogue, right?
- 18:03Just like you get the dialogue between staff and a political, you get the
- 18:08dialogue within the sunshine rules of the three politicals on a board, and
- 18:13I think it gets to a better solution.
- 18:16Lenwood Brooks: I agree with you.
- 18:17I know we'll be going into this a bit later, but I like a three-member board.
- 18:22I- it's not too large and it allows individual board members to
- 18:25have their own responsibilities.
- 18:27I'll tell you this, 'cause Mark, you told me when we moved from chairman to board
- 18:31member too, like how different it would be, and you really don't understand how
- 18:35different it is until you go through it.
- 18:37Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 18:38Lenwood Brooks: It's so different.
- 18:39And I bring that up because I think when you're an NCUA board member,
- 18:43it's easier to get onboarded.
- 18:44I think when you're an NCUA board member, it's easy to take on personal projects,
- 18:48it's easier to dive deep into issues, and it's really more of what you make of it.
- 18:52But the chairman's office, again, to get back to what we were talking
- 18:54to a bit earlier, it is nonstop.
- 18:58Mark Treichel: Yeah.
- 18:58Heavy is the head of he who wears the crown, right?
- 19:00Somebody famous said that back in the day.
- 19:03So last time I went back and I was looking at what we talked about last time.
- 19:07And one of those things was the, the trend at NCUA board
- 19:10members is that congressional staff become NCUA board members.
- 19:13It's not someone who comes from having run a credit union or
- 19:16working at a trade association.
- 19:18W- what's your take on having predicted that's where it had been, and Cruz
- 19:23kind of fits, fits that, that approach.
- 19:25What's your thoughts relative to, how- Well- ⦠all that's gonna play out?
- 19:30Lenwood Brooks: You look at the last three board members, I believe.
- 19:33Cal Hauptman, who worked for a member on the Senate Bank Committee.
- 19:38Tanya Souka, who I believe, Mark, she was on the Senate Bank Committee staff.
- 19:41But if not, she worked for a member on that committee.
- 19:44And then Mr.
- 19:45Cruz, who was on the Senate Bank and Committee staff with Mr.
- 19:48Toomey, I believe.
- 19:49So look, I predicted it back when we last spoke over two years
- 19:53ago, this trend would continue.
- 19:54I have been right.
- 19:56Look, it is a political job by definition being on the NCUA board.
- 20:00And I said last time, Mark, people or policy, one of the reasons I think,
- 20:05Folks from Senate Banking Committee get this job is they know where
- 20:08they're gonna come down on policy.
- 20:09It's gonna be no wait and see.
- 20:11Now having said that, it being a political job by definition, I do
- 20:15think, the statute allows up to one board member to be a credit union.
- 20:19I do think, Mark, credit unions would be well-served having that voice, but I just
- 20:25wanna reiterate for your listeners, being a CEO of a credit union is a unique skill
- 20:29set, and you have a lot of perspective and value you can bring to the NCUA.
- 20:34But it is a political job, and I do think a lot of credit unions, it would
- 20:38be a learning curve if you're a credit union CEO to realize when you get to
- 20:41the NCUA, it is a political job, and you have to manage in a political way.
- 20:47And by that, it's not gonna be necessarily like you're a CEO of a credit union
- 20:50and you've got, everyone's gonna listen to you just because you're a CEO.
- 20:54There's a lot more dynamics at play and political fire.
- 20:57Maybe you can hit on that, Mark.
- 20:59Mark Treichel: You're right.
- 21:00Just how government works, right?
- 21:01The the, the- The request that you get in, having to write having to deal with
- 21:07the IG, the IG making recommendations and then those going up to Congress, right?
- 21:13In a semi-annual report.
- 21:15And and then all of a sudden a bill gets dropped and banks are getting
- 21:19something and credit unions aren't getting something, and you gotta get
- 21:22the wheels going with the contacts and understanding how government works to make
- 21:28sure credit unions don't get left aside.
- 21:30And of course, the trades do that, but NCUA, not being a cheerleader,
- 21:33but making sure that credit unions don't get hurt in that environment.
- 21:38And so if you've gotâ¦
- 21:39Th- tho- to me, those are just some examples.
- 21:41If you understand how government works, how Washington, DC works that can
- 21:45add a value to those types of things.
- 21:48You might understand as a CEO of a credit union wanting to be on
- 21:52an NCUA board how this reg could be tweaked in this way to help.
- 21:57But if you're the chair and you're in that position and you're trying to get
- 22:01Washington, DC to listen, you don't necessarily have those skill sets
- 22:05because you were a good communicator at your credit union with your board.
- 22:10Lenwood Brooks: It's just a different skill set.
- 22:11But that being said, I think someone who comes to the NCUA who's been
- 22:17on the other side of the exam table adds enormous value- Oh,
- 22:21absolutely ⦠to their perspective.
- 22:21Yeah, absolutely.
- 22:22Mark Treichel: With like- Yeah.
- 22:22A- and, and- ⦠a
- 22:24Lenwood Brooks: political appointee might not have if you've only been in
- 22:26the political realm your whole career.
- 22:28Mark Treichel: Yeah, that's exactly right.
- 22:29It gets to that wisdom of crowds.
- 22:30That's why, in the perfect world you would haveâ¦
- 22:32That's probably, you think about it, they said you can have one from the
- 22:36credit union side, which to me implies that you should probably try and have
- 22:40one from the credit union side, but you shouldn't have all three from that
- 22:44because then you're again, you've limited the scope of the knowledge of the group
- 22:48that's in charge of, leading the agency.
- 22:51Lenwood Brooks: Exactly right
- 22:53Mark Treichel: So let's pivot again back to a little bit of performance trust.
- 22:56When I was, when we were at NCUA together, we talked a lot about
- 22:59balance sheet and interest rate risk, and interest rate risk and liquidity.
- 23:03And then after I left that was rates shot up and credit unions
- 23:08were underwater in their portfolios, and it created some challenges.
- 23:12And from what I understand, we didn't get into it on the front
- 23:14end here, but Performance Trust probably does a little bit of that
- 23:17for credit unions, I'm guessing.
- 23:18Any- anything with that in that vein that you can share?
- 23:21Lenwood Brooks: Again Mark, to get back to what we were talking
- 23:23about earlier, we're the largest independent investment bank focused
- 23:26exclusively on community depositories.
- 23:28But to answer your question, I think, it's best to go back in time, Mark, and
- 23:33let's look at the crisis in March of 2023.
- 23:36And the cease to that crisis at the time, that liquidity event were
- 23:39really planted years earlier, right?
- 23:42With the influx of cash following COVID and-
- 23:45Mark Treichel: Yep
- 23:45⦠Lenwood Brooks: some institutions, Mark, took that cash and they
- 23:48invested in par mortgages at the low and tights as they like to say.
- 23:53And I think many of those institutions were chasing yield and duration.
- 23:58And it doesn't give you a complete picture when you're just chasing
- 24:02yield and then looking at duration.
- 24:04There's a lot of variables at play, and I think that's what
- 24:07Performance Trust really does, Mark.
- 24:09Not just on selling bonds, but in the entire suite of running a credit union
- 24:13or a bank, to look at the entire balance sheet and plug it into a model where
- 24:18you can see things plotted out and you can see things over time and over
- 24:23different interest rate scenarios, Mark.
- 24:25And I actually heard secondhand from a credit union client just yesterday that
- 24:30working with Performance Trust is likeâ¦
- 24:33Before, it was like looking at things in single dimension in black and white.
- 24:38But since he's been working with us, he's seen it in color, in 3D.
- 24:42And you're surprised, Mark, and I just went with to one of these classes myself.
- 24:46I told you we were founded with the principle of education.
- 24:49I sat through one of these classes myself, and I was surprised how often when you
- 24:54just look at duration and yield and you're just picking things, when you actually
- 24:58look at the analytics and plot it out, how your intuition can be wrong, right?
- 25:02And I think The reality here is we have no idea where interest rates are gonna go.
- 25:06If you look at the experts, Mark, they're usually wrong, and that's where
- 25:10our real sweet spot is looking at an entire balance sheet over different
- 25:14interest rate scenarios, a pretty wide v- variation, and over time.
- 25:18And when institutions have that knowledge, Mark, they're able to more
- 25:23effectively make strategic decisions.
- 25:25So again, you were asking me earlier what brought me to Performance Trust.
- 25:29One of the reasons is there's a lot of really smart, good people there,
- 25:33and our mission every day is to help credit unions and community banks.
- 25:38And Mark, the thing that makes me excited is when a credit union can improve its
- 25:43net worth, it allows them to better live out the credit union mission.
- 25:47It allows them to make lives better for their members, make lives better for
- 25:51their communities, and that's why we exist, and we're excited to be partners
- 25:56with credit unions and work together to help them live out their mission.
- 26:00Mark Treichel: No, it's that's exciting.
- 26:01Hey, I'll tell you that yesterday I was on the phone with a client,
- 26:03and we were talking about a couple- couple of unique new programs
- 26:08that, that they're contemplating.
- 26:11And I was giving my thoughts on different things on how NCUA might respond to them.
- 26:15But they also mentioned Performance Trust was helping
- 26:17them on a couple of these items.
- 26:19So I gave themâ¦
- 26:20they got a heads-up that I was interviewing you, and that they
- 26:23should be watching for this episode.
- 26:25But it was just, it was cool to hear that that these unique things they were looking
- 26:29to do Performance Trust was helping them do it, which means, again when you try
- 26:33something new on the horizon, it's good to have good experts in your corner to
- 26:37make sure that you mitigate those risks.
- 26:39And so but speaking of risks whatâ¦
- 26:41So what keeps you up at night?
- 26:42Is there anything on the balance sheets?
- 26:44I know you're just getting into the Performance Trust side of things, but,
- 26:48Lenwood Brooks: I still read the NCUA data, Mark, like you do.
- 26:51Yes.
- 26:52And fortunately, Mark, I, I sleep well most nights.
- 26:55But to answer your question though seriously I think, credit
- 26:58quality is something we still need to be keeping an eye on.
- 27:01Delinquencies, still keep an eye on.
- 27:03It looks like, some of that's plateaued, but I still think it's something to watch.
- 27:08I think commercial lending obviously is an issue.
- 27:11I think it's something NCUA is going to be looking at closely.
- 27:15But as you well know, Mark, unless you're a low-income designated credit
- 27:18union, that is capped out at 12.25%.
- 27:22So by the way NCUA's structured, the Federal Credit Union Act's
- 27:25structured, that risk is contained by, by that structure in the law.
- 27:30But when I look at the industry, Mark, the, the thing that I think is the biggest
- 27:34challenge for credit unions is credit unions that are able to continue to grow
- 27:38their membership and those who aren't, and I think that is a big challenge.
- 27:43I think some of the credit unions that haven't leaned in heavily into a digital
- 27:47platform, I think, those probably will continue to merge away unless
- 27:51there's special factors at play, Mark.
- 27:54But I think the credit union movement is well-served having an ecosystem
- 28:00where your really tiny credit union, a basement of a church, and some of
- 28:04the large largest of our institutions serving the market, I think that
- 28:08benefits the credit union ecosystem.
- 28:11And I think the industry has a lot going for it.
- 28:15Profitability has improved.
- 28:17The industry should be feeling good, but we should be cautiously optimistic, Mark.
- 28:21What keeps you at, up at night, my friend?
- 28:24Mark Treichel: There, there are a lot of merger discussions, which
- 28:26is just the natural progression.
- 28:28What keeps me up at night I think you hit, delinquency.
- 28:32Delinquency and loan losses is what kills credit unions and what hurts
- 28:35the insurance fund ultimately.
- 28:37Outside of, big frauds like the one they've got going on, which
- 28:40kinda they're gonna take a lump on with the insurance fund.
- 28:43But even that big fraud, that's not gonna trigger, a premium.
- 28:46I would have to say, and it's outside of my area of expertise
- 28:50is the cyber side of it, right?
- 28:52And the fraud side of it.
- 28:53Yeah.
- 28:53And the losses in that arena Iâ¦
- 28:55When I talk to my clients, I know those things are it's a
- 28:58lot of what they lose sleep of.
- 29:00I know it was a lot of what an NCUA board would lose sleep of
- 29:02relative to NCUA or or a, a credit union and, there was the, theâ¦
- 29:08There, there have been re- some recent stories of some, some hacks and different
- 29:11things and that's just, and it doesn't ma- for credit unions, they can, you
- 29:16can double their budget and they can figure out a way how to prevent fraud
- 29:19and how to do better cybersecurity.
- 29:21There's always more different tools, and it just that pressure of guarding that
- 29:26wall and then also the cost related to it when you're trying to build your capital
- 29:31and you're trying to serve your members.
- 29:33These, these CEOs and credit union warriors out there trying to
- 29:38fulfill the needs of their members, they've got a lot to worry about.
- 29:41And that's why it's good to have, be able to outsource some of the
- 29:44decisions and leverage using groups like Performance Trust and other consulting
- 29:48options in different areas out there.
- 29:50But that, that's kinda my take on that.
- 29:52Lenwood Brooks: No, I agree with you.
- 29:53I did mention fraud, but you're exactly right.
- 29:56It is continuing to evolve rapidly and you talk to some credit unions, fraud is the
- 30:02biggest loss they've seen in years, Mark.
- 30:04So it is something that is very concerning, and you do have actors,
- 30:08foreign state actors, and you really have to be on your A-game.
- 30:11Mark Treichel: That's right.
- 30:12That's right.
- 30:13Yep, and it's not cheap to be on your A-game.
- 30:14Oh, sure.
- 30:14So that, the pressure to that, right?
- 30:17I was a regulator for 33 years, and now I've been doing consulting
- 30:22for six years, and you've beenâ¦
- 30:24so you worked on the Hill, you worked as a regulator at NCUA, you worked at
- 30:28a federal, the Federal Home Loan Bank, quasi, quasi-regulator, if you will.
- 30:33That's kinda how I view that.
- 30:35And now you're in the pri- private advisory and Performance Trust.
- 30:38Taking all of those angles a- and the concept of the NCUA examination
- 30:44w- how have those different parts of your journey changed how you've looked
- 30:48at what the NCUA exam is all about?
- 30:52Lenwood Brooks: Mark, I, I think about that question I think about
- 30:55something you told me maybe several months into my job at the NCUA.
- 31:00And I remember, I don't know if you remember telling me this, but you
- 31:03told me Linwood A yell, a whisper from you comes off as a yell to staff.
- 31:11And that's not good for me when I have a loud voice anyway-
- 31:14and a deep voice.
- 31:15But, I did listen to you, Mark, and when I think about your question,
- 31:20it's a lot different sitting on the other side of the exam table.
- 31:24The examiners in NCUA are great.
- 31:26They carry out a core function, but I don't think they appreciate how
- 31:30something they say in passing can set off a fire drill in the C-suite-
- 31:36Mark Treichel: Yeah
- 31:36Lenwood Brooks: of a credit union and take weeks to resolve.
- 31:39I think, Mark a, a lot of the examiners could benefit from
- 31:43the same advice you gave me.
- 31:46A whisper to a credit union is gonna come across as a yell.
- 31:51I think that's something the agency could think about going forward.
- 31:55But I think the NCUA does a great job overall, Mark.
- 31:58I think they don't try to regulate by press release and enforcement
- 32:02actions to embarrass credit unions.
- 32:04I think they do it when necessary.
- 32:06But I think NCUA's not a partner, but they are a fair regulator, and I think
- 32:12it's okay to want the institutions that you regulate to succeed.
- 32:17I think it's okay to have people that work at an agency that really believe intensely
- 32:23about the mission of credit unions, and I think the credit union community is
- 32:27well-served by having regulators who can be tough and fair when necessary, but
- 32:33really want institutions to succeed, to serve the member owners, to serve those
- 32:38of modest means as defined in the act.
- 32:41And, I'm excited for the future, Mark, to see where the future takes us, 'cause
- 32:44I think it's bright for NCUA and I think it's bright for credit unions-
- 32:48Yeah ⦠even in this challenging environment with so many changes.
- 32:51Mark Treichel: Yeah, I agree with you there.
- 32:52We're gonna get a new board, they're gonna, they're gonna tweak things,
- 32:55they're gonna come up with ideas.
- 32:57And while NCUA, I talk a lot about NCUA losing 25, 30% of their staff and
- 33:01losing a lot of good people, but there's a ton of good people still at NCUA.
- 33:06'Cause just because 30% left, there's still 70%, and, people
- 33:10can rise to the occasion and a- are rising to the occasion.
- 33:14I'm seeing it in my discussion with, credit unions.
- 33:16Yeah, it's a good time to be a credit union, good time to be at NCUA.
- 33:18Yeah, a lot of exciting things there.
- 33:21And we talked a little bit about the ins- the board, right?
- 33:23And having one board member and getting back to three.
- 33:27When do you ⦠I- if you had to guess, if you, if I said, what's your crystal ball?
- 33:31When are we gonna have three board members and how's that gonna play out?
- 33:35What's it gonna look like?
- 33:38Lenwood Brooks: Conventional wisdom, Mark, would tell you it's soon,
- 33:41and that certainly could happen.
- 33:42But I think with Todd and Tonya's c- case working through the
- 33:47process, it could take longer, six months to a year, I'm not sure.
- 33:50Court, courts tend to move cl- move slowly.
- 33:52Look, Mark, I think in the last session, the Supreme Court, I
- 33:58believe it's wrapped up th- and they're taking their summer break.
- 34:01But I think if it was just the FTC case, the Slaughter case, and to back up for
- 34:06your listeners, that was a case that dealt with the firing of a Democrat
- 34:11appointee at the Federal Trade Commission.
- 34:13And the court ruled that the president can fire people at
- 34:17independent agencies at will.
- 34:19And of course, the NCUA is an independent agency.
- 34:21But I think, Mark, the same vein, the reason why I think Todd's case
- 34:26and Tonya's case could still be working through the process is because
- 34:30of the Cook case And, the court's reasoning there was interesting,
- 34:36but they basically set a different standard for the Federal Reserve.
- 34:40And no, the NCUA's not the Federal Reserve, but they
- 34:43both are financial regulators.
- 34:44The Federal Reserve regulating bank holding companies, NCUA
- 34:48regulating credit unions.
- 34:49They both have a liquidity function, Mark.
- 34:51The discount one- Sure ⦠with the Fed, the CLF at the Central
- 34:56Liquidity Facility at the NCUA.
- 34:58So I think because of that, we'll see how it plays out.
- 35:02I think the president can certainly appoint someone at any time, but I
- 35:06think there's a lot more confidence in someone accepting that appointment when
- 35:10that matter's been fully adjudicated.
- 35:13A lot of people think it'll be soon.
- 35:15I think it ⦠That certainly could happen, but I think it
- 35:18could take six months or longer.
- 35:20We just don't know.
- 35:21And the reason that's relevant, Mark, too, is, a six-year term if they stand with
- 35:28the logic in the FTC case, the six-year term no longer really applies in practice.
- 35:32It means you'll be tied to a presidential administration
- 35:36and that's gonna change things.
- 35:38Now, some p- people say, is it good or bad?
- 35:41I'm not gonna get into that, but I'll say it's a different thing, right?
- 35:44I think credit unions should be prepared for the NCUA to
- 35:48run a lot more like the OCC.
- 35:50And that, yes, you'll still have two to three members, but I think you should
- 35:54prepare for these really drastic swings in between administrations where, fair
- 36:00lending will be a top priority, and then it will go the other side and vice versa.
- 36:04And I think that can be exhausting.
- 36:07That probably could make the state charter more valuable for some credit unions.
- 36:12But I think, Mark, the industry is well-served by having a strong dual
- 36:16charter system, and I don't wanna see the federal charter disadvantaged at all.
- 36:20But again, to get back to an earlier point- It's gonna be
- 36:24a different thing for NCUA.
- 36:25We don't know exactly sure yet, but i- it's not gonna look like
- 36:29the NCUA was when you were there, and that is gonna change things.
- 36:33I remember being in meetings with staffers like you and w- looking at
- 36:38regulations tied to six-year terms and the like, and it's gonna change things.
- 36:43It's gonna be a different thing for the agency and, credit unions will be fine,
- 36:46it's just gonna be a lot different.
- 36:49Mark Treichel: Yeah, it's funny.
- 36:50You think, ⦠I'm gonna, I'm gonna connect the dots to
- 36:53how we got to where we're at.
- 36:54But it used to be that six-year term, the, someone comes in, a year is gone on
- 36:59the term, they get five years, and then under the Biden administration, Harper
- 37:03was actually ⦠b- Biden changed a, a, a legal opinion or whoever the, the,
- 37:09whoever the powers that be that worked for Biden that would've made such an opinion,
- 37:12the attorney general or what have you.
- 37:14S- so Todd basically got 11 years, right?
- 37:17So it went from people typically had five years, they come and they go,
- 37:21to Todd having two terms because he didn't have a full term, which was
- 37:25never what the interpretation was since Roosevelt a- approved the act.
- 37:29But it's it was a change that happened and then, instead of it
- 37:34being 11 years, i- it didn't shoot back down to six, it shot back down
- 37:38to the terms don't mean anything.
- 37:39So we've in the last six, seven years went from this to ⦠The podcast people can't
- 37:45understand this, but went from six years to 11 years and 11 months and 28 days down
- 37:51to, okay, it's just tied to the president.
- 37:52So what-
- 37:53Lenwood Brooks: And that's a great point ⦠you're
- 37:54Mark Treichel: right, what does that mean, right?
- 37:54It's different.
- 37:55Lenwood Brooks: That's a great point, Mark, too, in the light of the current
- 37:58situation at NCUA because as the Trump administration's term continues to
- 38:03tick on, if it takes another year or so to adjudicate the matter involving
- 38:09Harper and Insooka, you could be then looking to have a nominee whose
- 38:12term could be as short as one year.
- 38:14And, it takes a while to effectuate change at NCUA and, it takes at least a year.
- 38:19I mean-
- 38:20Mark Treichel: Yeah
- 38:20⦠Lenwood Brooks: you remember, Mark, some of those rulemakings we want to work on.
- 38:23I was just- blown away at the amount of work that goes into rule making,
- 38:28and you just don't turn on a dime.
- 38:30You have to really think through things and put it out for public comment, and
- 38:33all this and that, and i- it takes a while to effectuate change through rule making.
- 38:38It's not like turning a light switch on and off.
- 38:40Mark Treichel: Sure.
- 38:40That's a fact.
- 38:41That's a fact, so very good.
- 38:43This, Lenwood, this has been a lot of fun.
- 38:44A- any questions that I didn't ask you that you wanna highlight
- 38:48here before we wrap for the day?
- 38:50Lenwood Brooks: Thank you again, Mark, for allowing me to be on your podcast, and
- 38:53I just want to thank all the listeners.
- 38:56And for the people in the credit union movement, you're doing
- 38:59great work, you really are.
- 39:00You're making a difference in your members' lives and in your community,
- 39:04and I would just encourage everyone out there, I think as long as the
- 39:08credit union movement stays tethered to its mission, really about people
- 39:13helping people and about thinking of the founding of this whole movement, I
- 39:16think the future's very bright, Mark.
- 39:18When I talk to people 20 or 30 years younger than me,
- 39:21they love things like RAI.
- 39:23What's RAI?
- 39:24It's a co-op.
- 39:25And I think credit unions should lean in to being a financial co-op.
- 39:30The future is bright and exciting, and I'm so glad to be on the ride with you all.
- 39:36Mark Treichel: That's a good place to wrap, and if someone wants to
- 39:39listens to this and they wanna chat with you what's the best way
- 39:42for someone to reach you, Lenwood?
- 39:44Lenwood Brooks: My email is lbrooks@performancetrust.com,
- 39:48and my cellphone number, 202-374-5222,
- 39:53and that's for calls only.
- 39:55Mark Treichel: For calls only, got it.
- 39:56All right.
- 39:57We're,
- 39:57Lenwood Brooks: we're in a strictly regulated environment, Mark,
- 39:59Mark Treichel: understood.
- 40:00Yeah.
- 40:00That's if you ⦠I get that.
- 40:03I get that.
- 40:04All right, Lenwood, this has been fun.
- 40:05I wanna thank you for your time.
- 40:07Listeners, watchers, as always, I appreciate you listening or watching.
- 40:11I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 40:13This is Mark Trakel signing off with flying colors.