Latest / Consumerpedia / 85 - Too Much: How We're Encouraged to Buy, Buy, Buy
Transcript
- 0:01Americans are drowning in stuff. Clothing, electronics, toys and
- 0:06games, collectibles, appliances. We have closets and drawers
- 0:10filled with stuff. Some of us have so much stuff we
- 0:13need to rent storage units to hold it.
- 0:15Why? Why are so many people consumed
- 0:18by consumption? I'm her Weisbaum, the consumer
- 0:21man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:24Welcome to consumerpedia@checkbook.org.
- 0:27We're the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:31trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:34advertising or take money from any business we recommend, you
- 0:37can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:40objective. Now here's the host of Consumer
- 0:43Pedia America's consumer expert, the Consumer man Herb Y Spom.
- 0:49Amazon, Timu, eBay Shine, Facebook Marketplace It's never
- 0:53been easier to shop until you drop.
- 0:56By one estimate, 20 million Americans are compulsive
- 0:59shoppers. About 2 1/2% of us meet the
- 1:02diagnostic criteria for a hoarding disorder.
- 1:05The urge to buy, buy, buy, and keep, keep, keep fueled a new
- 1:09book, American Bulk Essays on Excess.
- 1:13In this collection of deeply personal stories, Emily Mester
- 1:16explores her father's obsession with shopping and her own
- 1:19tendency to overbuy. Plus, she shares the tricks she
- 1:22used as a salesperson to close the deal.
- 1:25Emily, it is so nice to meet you.
- 1:26Thanks for being with us. Thank you for.
- 1:28Having Me So your book American Bulk is a collection of essays
- 1:31and you share some really personal stories about you and
- 1:33your family and friends. Much of it has to do with buying
- 1:36and selling, what motivates us? How stores and salespeople can
- 1:40manipulate us. What made you decide to write
- 1:42this book? I wanted to write an essay just
- 1:45about Costco, and I knew it had played a significant role in my
- 1:49life. You know, I grew up going there
- 1:50every Sunday, but I didn't really have a theory about what
- 1:52it meant in a broader sense or what it meant to my family.
- 1:55And I knew my family. I knew all these sort of
- 1:57disparate facts about my family. I was like, all right, we've got
- 2:00some hoarding in there. We've definitely got some buying
- 2:02and overconsumption, but I didn't have a coherent thesis
- 2:05about it. So I went with a friend to
- 2:07Costco and I sort of walked around.
- 2:09He'd never been. And I walked around and I, you
- 2:11know, just pointed things out and was like, isn't it
- 2:13interesting that you can't buy just like a jar of oregano?
- 2:16And oh, did you know that that vodka, the bottle is ugly, but
- 2:19it's actually allegedly Grey Goose?
- 2:21And then as I wrote the essay, I think I realized it was pretty
- 2:25difficult to write an essay about Costco without writing an
- 2:28essay about my family's own. Pecadilla was about buying and
- 2:32then from there I got the title of the book, American Bulk, and
- 2:35then I came up with a bunch of essays that would go with it.
- 2:38Then in in writing it, I sort of realized how deeply consumption
- 2:41defines, I mean really everyone's lives, but
- 2:43particularly my family's life. We're going to talk more about
- 2:46Costco in a minute, but let's start off with your shopping
- 2:49experiences as a kid, you say your mom was frugal, but you
- 2:52called your dad obsessed with acquiring stuff.
- 2:55You write quote. Every Sunday we do this, we go
- 2:57to our favorite stores. The trick to get something is to
- 2:59ask dad when his card is full and he's close to the registers.
- 3:02When he seems happy and light, my mom will say I don't need it
- 3:05so I don't ask her, but dad will say sure and she'll sign.
- 3:08I'll add it to his pile. The piles and carts become piles
- 3:11and bags. When we bring all the bags into
- 3:12the house, they'll sit there for days, sometimes weeks.
- 3:15So it sounds like the motivation for spending money was simply to
- 3:18buy stuff for your father. Yeah, I guess so.
- 3:20It's for him and for me, it seems to be this kind of
- 3:24ancient, deep kind of reptilian impulse.
- 3:27Because he was doing this. I think even in college he was
- 3:30apparent, you know, he didn't have any money, but he was, you
- 3:32know, going into credit card debt, buying like ridiculous as
- 3:35seen on TV, things like a pizza oven and like an egg tastic,
- 3:39that kind of thing. I think, as I say in the essay,
- 3:41it's sort of the shape his money takes.
- 3:43It's like a physical evidence of his prosperity.
- 3:46And I think, yeah, some people, they want a couple sort of
- 3:49shining big tokens to their wealth.
- 3:51They want like, want a fancy car and fancy watches.
- 3:53But I feel like he just wants lots and lots of kind of regular
- 3:56person stuff. I found it interesting that he
- 3:58wouldn't want to look at the stuff when he got at home, but
- 4:00he kept it in bags and on the kitchen.
- 4:02To me, that's the joy. It's not the spending the money,
- 4:05it's getting at home and plugging the thing in or using
- 4:07it or whatever. Spoken like someone who is not
- 4:09addicted to shopping. Yeah, I know you would think
- 4:11that the utility of the joy of The thing is lies in owning it,
- 4:15but no, I totally see where my dad's psychology comes from
- 4:18because I have it too. You know, I order things online
- 4:20and the best moment is when you slice open the box and you open
- 4:24it up. It's like that Christmas morning
- 4:26feeling. And, you know, Christmas morning
- 4:27too. The excitement of Christmas
- 4:28morning mean, yes, it's owning the stuff later, but it's
- 4:31getting the stuff. That's so it's the like the
- 4:34dopamine hit of receiving. So in that chapter wholesale,
- 4:37which is mostly focused on shopping at Costco, you said
- 4:40this was something your family did every week, one of the few
- 4:43things you all did together. Yeah, we weren't like a big
- 4:47sitcom together in this family. I remember once I suggested that
- 4:50we do a family game night. So I think I saw some sort of
- 4:52PSA about how it brings families together.
- 4:55And they were like, who do you think we are?
- 4:57Shopping was basically our primary mode of togetherness
- 5:00because it gives you. Yeah, it's like a third thing
- 5:02kind of look at shopping. Addiction is the same thing.
- 5:05It's just like a an outlet to place living.
- 5:08You don't really know where else to put it.
- 5:09And in that chapter, you call your dad a compulsive shopper
- 5:12and describe to him walking up and down the aisles of Costco
- 5:15not with a list of things he needs, but with the wide eyes of
- 5:18a child in a toy store, you wrote.
- 5:20He fills the cart with cereal and bagels, yes, but also with
- 5:23wrench sets, hole punchers, colorful plastic drinking
- 5:25tumblers, Kirkland brand khaki pants over and over.
- 5:28And despite my mother's protests, and while my dad might
- 5:30not spend like the average Costco shopper, his neurosis are
- 5:34it's collective beating heart. It's true that Costco gets you
- 5:36more for your money, but it seems like the discount is only
- 5:39a secondary pleasure. It's not the money part that
- 5:42inspires A cult like devotion, it's the more.
- 5:45Spend time in any Costco and you'll feel it too.
- 5:47The joy of Costco does not lie in thrift.
- 5:49It lies in bulk. Yeah, You know, obviously Costco
- 5:53is a great deal. That's why people go.
- 5:55If it wasn't, they wouldn't go. But I think there is a joy that
- 5:59people don't fully reckon with that is just seeing all that
- 6:02stuff and having all that stuff available to you and having
- 6:05permission to buy that stuff because it's such a great deal.
- 6:08There is something just like viscerally pleasurable about
- 6:10like a big pallet of toilet paper.
- 6:13And when you can get it for a good deal, it's it's kind of all
- 6:16the sweeter. And some people have chafed at
- 6:17this analysis. They're kind of like, no, no,
- 6:19no, I just go to Costco for the deals.
- 6:20That's really all. And it's like, yes, but isn't a
- 6:22little bit of it just the plenitude how much stuff there
- 6:25is available to you? I've heard it described as a
- 6:28treasure hunt because in fact, they actually do move things
- 6:30around, so you have to look for them and go past other things
- 6:33that you may not know was there. I mean, they're pretty smart at
- 6:35how they get you to buy stuff. Yeah, because if you compare it,
- 6:38you know, you go into the grocery store, most people don't
- 6:40walk in being like, oh, what's new at the grocery store?
- 6:42What will I find her on this aisle?
- 6:43They're going for stuff they need.
- 6:44But with Costco, I think most people, yeah, they sort of
- 6:47wander around and they're like, oh, what did they add?
- 6:49What clothing did they add? And there's even, you know,
- 6:51entire Instagram accounts and YouTube channels.
- 6:54The whole thing is they just list all the new things Costco
- 6:57has. And often I follow some that
- 6:59even though I don't even go to Costco that much anymore, I'm
- 7:02like, Oh my God, Costco has that.
- 7:04Like, wow, Costco has this brand of deer foam slippers that's so
- 7:08exciting. It's like a treasure hunt.
- 7:10What will be brought into the fold of the deal?
- 7:12I remember when I was first married we went there and my
- 7:15wife came home with like a size of mayonnaise that would last
- 7:18the entire neighborhood a year. I mean if you have a big family
- 7:21one thing, but at least like with salad dressing and stuff,
- 7:24they figured out how to give you 6 little bottles as opposed to 1
- 7:27gigantic bottle that will take care of your whole zip code.
- 7:29The tubs of mayonnaise, I always looked at those and it was just
- 7:32like, I mean, interested in whoever this is for.
- 7:34Well, at one point in your life, you worked as a salesperson, and
- 7:36your job was to get customers to spend more.
- 7:39Up next, we're going to talk to Emily about the tricks she was
- 7:41taught to boost sales. I'm her wife's mom, the consumer
- 7:44man. And this is Consumer Pedia
- 7:46powered by checkbook.org. From tech gadgets to financial
- 7:51tips, travel hacks to health trends, Consumer Pedia provides
- 7:55expert insights and practical advice to help you save time and
- 7:59money, avoid the scams, and stay healthy.
- 8:02With dozens of episodes to choose from, Consumerpedia is
- 8:05your guide to making informed decisions.
- 8:07Just go to consumerpedia.org and search by episode, title or
- 8:11topic, such as home, travel, auto finance, consumer
- 8:15protection or technology checkbooks.
- 8:17Consumerpedia podcast consumerpedia.org.
- 8:21Listen and learn and share with your friends.
- 8:26Our guest is Emily Mester, author of the new book American
- 8:28Bulk Essays on Excess. So, Emily, when you graduated
- 8:32college, you were an English major.
- 8:33You went to work at an Ulta cosmetic store in South
- 8:36Carolina, and now you were the one trying to get people to buy
- 8:39and spend more money. Yeah, it was really exhilarating
- 8:42for a while to be on the other side because I, you know, I'd
- 8:44been a consumer for so long and never a seller.
- 8:47And I found myself, you know, they didn't give me much formal
- 8:49training on how to sell because I was mostly just a cashier.
- 8:51But I found myself employing a lot of the psychological tricks
- 8:54I sort of inwardly did when I bought stuff.
- 8:56And primary among them was like confirming the validity of
- 9:00someone's desire. Like as they were purchasing it,
- 9:02as I was bringing it up, I would be like, this is a must have.
- 9:05We can't seem to keep this in stock.
- 9:07You have you have chosen well that I would find myself doing
- 9:10that as a consumer. I would watch like YouTube
- 9:12videos of products I already owned to just sort of like, it's
- 9:16kind of like looking in the mirror to just sort of take
- 9:18stock of what I was doing and what I had and that I was making
- 9:22a good decision. And I found it worked on people.
- 9:24Yeah. They really wanted to have their
- 9:26purchase kind of validated by me.
- 9:28But that works. Yeah, yeah.
- 9:30I feel like the key to being a good salesman is to convince
- 9:32someone that like not that they want it, but that they are
- 9:35incomplete without it because it is already part of them.
- 9:38So in this chapter, you talk about the store's loyalty
- 9:40program. Customers needed to earn 100
- 9:42points before they earned a discount, and you, as the clerk,
- 9:46saw the guest point balance displayed on the register.
- 9:48But you were taught not to share this information with them
- 9:51before they swiped their card to pay for the item you had just
- 9:53rung up. Yeah, I mean, that one, they
- 9:55just said the points balance is what gets them in the store.
- 9:58And if they're in the store anyway, you don't need to give
- 10:00it to them unless they ask. And one time I was being
- 10:02beneficent, I guess, and I saw this woman had a really big
- 10:04points balance, and I redeemed it without asking her.
- 10:07I thought I was being so, so nice.
- 10:09And she actually didn't want me to.
- 10:10She was saving up, you know, she was sort of like sitting on it
- 10:13like a, like a treasure horde. What I was supposed to do
- 10:16instead was print out the receipt and then lay it smooth,
- 10:19smooth it on the counter and circle their point balance with
- 10:21the heart and be like, wow, you have, you know, 700 points.
- 10:25That is $10 offer the next time you come in because it's always
- 10:28about getting them in the next time.
- 10:30Because if you told them you have enough points to do
- 10:32something now, they might use them and not make the purchase.
- 10:34And the goal was to get them to make a purchase, right?
- 10:36Yeah, We also had these coupons that I think Alta still has.
- 10:39It's really ubiquitous. It's in every Ulta catalog, and
- 10:42it's something like $3.50 off. And people would come in and try
- 10:45to use it every single day. And I had to be like, there's
- 10:47actually a bunch of restrictions on this coupon.
- 10:49You can only use it on the drugstore stuff, can't use it on
- 10:52the fancy stuff, which is what everybody wanted to use it on.
- 10:54I mean, I couldn't outright be like, yeah, they got, but I
- 10:57started to be like, I know, I'm sorry.
- 10:59I've been I've been had by that coupon too.
- 11:01You say with your neon highlighter you drew a wonky
- 11:04heart on the receipt before they look.
- 11:06Did that work? Was that the closer?
- 11:07Sort of. It was such a trippy little
- 11:09behavior. So you described floating to the
- 11:11ceiling when you got someone to buy a trinket or apply for an
- 11:14ill advised Ulta credit card. That's really how it felt.
- 11:17Yeah, there was this kind of like narcotic rush in convincing
- 11:22someone to buy something that was like, I got someone to part
- 11:25with their heart, earned money just by my powers of persuasion.
- 11:29Because so rarely do you have that concrete of a piece of
- 11:33evidence that you can, you have sort of that power of persuasion
- 11:36over someone. Usually it's a lot softer.
- 11:38It's like, oh, this person agreed to some quest I had or,
- 11:42you know, I I did this or that, but it's, it's literally like,
- 11:44wow, no, that person bought that thing because I convinced them
- 11:47to buy it. It's like being an orator or
- 11:49something. You wrote.
- 11:50I sold things I didn't own. I sold things I didn't like.
- 11:53I sold things to people who were already buying them.
- 11:55It felt right somehow, to compliment the customers
- 11:57impulses to confirm them. It felt like the store's final
- 12:01act of magic to transform want into need.
- 12:03Did you ever during this time period feel guilty, or was this
- 12:06just the game? They're the customer, you're the
- 12:08salesperson. Your job is to sell them as much
- 12:10as you can. Yeah, I sometimes felt guilty or
- 12:12more just like slimy because I was just being so fake, like
- 12:16this kind of mask of cheaper consumerism that I had felt so
- 12:20strange. I mean, even like the voice I'm
- 12:21using now is my real voice. But the voice I used at Alto was
- 12:24like, hey there, I'll have the next guest.
- 12:26It was just completely alien. And I would feel, yeah, I was
- 12:29like, why am I lying to this person?
- 12:30I don't even need to do that. I don't need to tell this person
- 12:32that I have the thing they have. I remember one time this girl,
- 12:35she was just sort of the sort of a slightly awkward, kind of
- 12:38lanky teenager. And for some reason, I looked at
- 12:40her and was like, are you a model?
- 12:42And she was like, no, I'm not. And I was like, oh, my God, I
- 12:44thought you were a model. It was weird.
- 12:45It felt good to compliment someone, to make them feel good.
- 12:48But then I was like, what? I was like, what I just did is
- 12:50called a compliment. But because I did it within this
- 12:52like consumer space, it felt like something something else.
- 12:56So shopping malls aren't what they used to be, but they still
- 12:58attract crowds, especially on weekends and around holidays.
- 13:01And in one of your essays you share the story of taking a
- 13:03friend to the mall and what an emotional experience was for you
- 13:07and how everything you thought was pre plotted out to be there
- 13:10for a specific reason to make that purchase.
- 13:12Yeah. And that feeling is the name I
- 13:14learned the father of the American shopping mall, Victor
- 13:17Gruen, called it the Gruen Transfer.
- 13:18And it's that feeling of bamboozlement you get when you
- 13:20walk into a mall. And it's maybe similar to the
- 13:22feeling you get walking in a Costco where you're full of kind
- 13:25of opportunity and what's it's going to be around the next
- 13:27corner. For me, it started to kind of
- 13:29calcify into this feeling. I started calling mall sad.
- 13:32And it's a feeling I'm still, I'm still sort of parsing what
- 13:35mall sadness is and why I get it.
- 13:36Because the neat answer is that, oh, I start to get sad because
- 13:39consumerism is this, you know, hollow activity.
- 13:41And like, I'm being dogged by the emptiness of it.
- 13:44But I think that's part of it. But yeah, it's just this, I
- 13:47don't know, this artificiality. And I'm sort of looking around
- 13:50at everybody else and I'm like, what is going on?
- 13:52What are we doing? Like the chirpiness of the ad
- 13:54copy, and like the careful arrangement, the displays and
- 13:57all of the smells. And yeah, it's this weird,
- 13:59depressing sensory overload. I love the sentence you said.
- 14:02Each store's particular arrangement of sound and light
- 14:04and temperature and scent had been calibrated with military
- 14:08grade precision to coax my eyes to a shelf, my feet to a
- 14:11register, my fingers into my wallet.
- 14:13I began to feel like I was in a terrarium.
- 14:15Yeah, it did feel like that. And I think part of it is, I
- 14:18mean, even just the fact that malls are indoor, there is
- 14:21something kind of hermetically sealed about them.
- 14:24Yeah. It's almost like being in a room
- 14:25where there's not a plan and then you add a plant and you
- 14:27realize how much the kind of reptilian part of you wanted
- 14:30there to be a plant there so that you can like, I don't know,
- 14:33connect with signs of life. Maybe it's that.
- 14:36Yeah, maybe. Yeah.
- 14:37The buoyancy and the weapons grade cheerfulness of the
- 14:40displays felt at odds with just kind of the mundane experience I
- 14:44was having. It's like, it's like how being
- 14:45at a, you know, an amusement park or Disney World can be kind
- 14:48of dazzling and very quickly get, I don't know, overwhelming
- 14:51and depressing. With online shopping, the malls
- 14:53are always open. You can shop anytime, anywhere
- 14:56at site strategically designed to get you to buy it.
- 14:58Now, that's straight ahead. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 15:01man, and you're listening to Consumer Pedia powered by
- 15:04checkbook.org. Consumer Pedia.
- 15:07Fast Facts According to the website Statista, Amazon net
- 15:12revenue last year was $638 billion.
- 15:16Amazon faces tough competition from Chinese shopping apps such
- 15:20as Timu and Shine, which are now widely used by American shoppers
- 15:24looking for affordable options. Statista says Timu was the most
- 15:28downloaded shopping app in the US last year.
- 15:30And by the way, shopping on smartphones is now the most
- 15:33popular way to purchase items online in the US.
- 15:39Emily, I think you'd agree that online shopping has supercharged
- 15:42the compulsion to shop, right? Yeah, I mean, I saw it first
- 15:45just happened. And my dad, he has always been a
- 15:47shopper. And we would go in the weekends
- 15:49to Costco. We would go to, I don't know,
- 15:51REI, we would go to the service merchandise, just go to all
- 15:54these stores. But you know, there are limits
- 15:56with in person shopping. You can only fit so much in your
- 15:58car. You know, he was busy working
- 16:00during the week. You can only buy so much.
- 16:02But once Amazon went online, he was pretty early to that.
- 16:06And I remember his eye is like lighting up.
- 16:08And it was, yeah, like being in Costco all the time.
- 16:11It's like, again, that like, dopamine hit is constant.
- 16:13The joy of it is kind of doubled in that you get to, like, have
- 16:16that rush when you hit buy, and you get to have that rush when
- 16:19it arrives on your doorstep. It's like you're buying yourself
- 16:21a mini Christmas with every purchase.
- 16:23And your dad also didn't have your mother there to say don't
- 16:26buy that when you're buying something late at night or in a
- 16:28room while by yourself. Yeah.
- 16:29It's kind of like how, you know, people will often recommend if
- 16:31you're overspending, to try to do your purchases in cash.
- 16:34And I feel like along the same lines, I've noticed that in
- 16:36person, even when I've imposed limits on my am I buying?
- 16:39I never really have to do it in person because in person when
- 16:42I'm faced with the physical reality of what I'm buying, I'm
- 16:44actually a pretty thoughtful shopper.
- 16:46And I think it's, yeah, it's similar.
- 16:48Like online is so abstract and in the air that I think it
- 16:50encourages you to just sort of lose touch with reality.
- 16:53A little bit. I recently watched a new Netflix
- 16:55documentary called Buy Now the Shopping Conspiracy and it
- 16:59explored the horrible environmental consequences of
- 17:01overconsumption and how brands and retailers manipulate us to
- 17:04buy things that we really don't need.
- 17:06It featured a former Amazon executive, Mar and Costa, who
- 17:09explains some of the many tricks that Amazon uses to get you to
- 17:12buy more, She said everything you see on each page is tested
- 17:16and tested and tested and designed to get you to buy now.
- 17:19I mean, it's really a science. We were constantly developing
- 17:23new ways to get you to buy, influencing your behavior in
- 17:28subtle ways that you'd never even realize.
- 17:32We could have, you know, a certain sentence that says free
- 17:37shipping. If you purchase $25 or more.
- 17:40In one case, you make the $25 orange.
- 17:44In another one, you make it green.
- 17:46And you can have nine different things that you're testing
- 17:49against each other. And there's enough traffic to
- 17:52the site that you could get statistically relevant data on
- 17:56which version of that sentence makes the most money.
- 18:01Every pixel on that page was tested and optimized and
- 18:07optimized and optimized. Yeah, it's really weapons grade
- 18:11over there. I've talked to people who work
- 18:13on kind of the algorithms of like, for example, those lost
- 18:16cart, those abandoned cart emails you get where you're
- 18:18like, how do you even know I was there?
- 18:20And it's like this like Siren being like, I saw you looking
- 18:23like, do you want to come back? It is insane what they can track
- 18:27and how they can use it to get you to buy.
- 18:29In the book, you spoke about your first office job with a
- 18:31good salary and how you shopped quote with a vigor that startled
- 18:35even you. You're right, if I was awake and
- 18:37not on the clock, I was on my phone, and if I was on my phone,
- 18:39I was building a cart. And then you started downloading
- 18:41all the apps Sephora, eBay, Target, CVS, Nordstrom, Gap,
- 18:45even Papa John's and McDonald's. You're right, if I'd find some
- 18:49place to sit or sprawl and open each one up like a portal to a
- 18:52new world. My body still but for a few
- 18:54fingers, which manipulated the screen with a tender and knowing
- 18:57finesse of a Carpenter or a brain surgeon.
- 19:00With only my thumb, I could open up the new arrivals and resort
- 19:03them by price, low to high. I could add three different
- 19:05things to my cart and then flip among them.
- 19:07Reading the reviews of each collectively shopping aid up the
- 19:10bulk of my waking life. Yikes.
- 19:13Yeah, it's pretty crazy. I've especially noticed that
- 19:15with trying to get you to get the app versus the web version.
- 19:17I don't know if you've noticed, but websites are getting worse
- 19:20and worse, particularly shopping websites.
- 19:22And I think it's because if they can get you on that app, I feel
- 19:24like it turns your cognition into something a little bit more
- 19:27animal and more muscle memory ish.
- 19:29Like there is some, so I don't know if whenever I use the web
- 19:33version of a, you know, I have to use my mouse to click around
- 19:36and I have to, there's like a separation.
- 19:37And I think in that separation I can think a little bit more.
- 19:40But an app is just like, if you think you are addicted to an
- 19:43app, move its location on your home screen and watch how many
- 19:46times your little animal thumb goes to click that app in its
- 19:50old location. It's sobering.
- 19:52And I'll tell you, everybody wants you to download the app
- 19:55now. I mean, they know it works.
- 19:56There's no question about that. Oh yeah, no, they just make it
- 19:58so crappy to go on the web version that you're like, all
- 20:00right. That's what got me to get the
- 20:02I'm like, do I need the Papa John's app?
- 20:03No, but it is undeniably A smoother user experience.
- 20:06So what do you think about people who decide not to buy
- 20:09anything but essentials for a period of time?
- 20:11Have you ever tried a no buy year?
- 20:13Oh yeah, I'm in one right now and I've tried them before and
- 20:15failed, but I'm in one right now.
- 20:17It is an addiction both in how hard it was to break initially
- 20:22and how, you know, I'm like 3 months in now.
- 20:25I'm not saying I'm totally cured.
- 20:26I'm sure I would have completely relapsed back into the Super
- 20:29overconsumption, but I don't want things as much like I
- 20:32really, you know, can want something.
- 20:34And now that I've experienced the feeling of wanting something
- 20:36so bad and then one week later revisiting that want and being
- 20:40like this does nothing, I would really, really recommend it.
- 20:43I've tried to get my dad to do 1 forever.
- 20:44I'm just like just, I'm like just for a day, just for a week.
- 20:47Just try not to buy anything just to see how it feels, just
- 20:51to, I think give yourself a sense of how addicted you could
- 20:53be because I think shopping, you know, compared to a lot of
- 20:56addictions, it's, it can feel relatively benign.
- 20:58It's, you know, it's kind of almost charming.
- 21:00It's like I'm a shopaholic and I think it can make people forget
- 21:04just how much of their brain it takes up.
- 21:06And I think once it starts taking up a lot of your brain, I
- 21:08found myself I would look forward to shopping during
- 21:11interactions with other people or I would sort of filter
- 21:14experiences through shopping. Like I'd be like, wow, I'm
- 21:16having such a nice time at the park and everyone is dressed
- 21:19really well. I wonder where I can find these
- 21:20things online later Or I'm having such a nice time at the
- 21:23park. What if I got a really good park
- 21:25blanket so that the next time I'm here, I can really, you
- 21:27know, splash out. That's when I realized I needed
- 21:29to like, pause and assess. I've heard the tip if you want
- 21:33to buy something online, put it in your basket, leave it there
- 21:35for a week and come back and chances are you might not need
- 21:38it. That's a good way to slow things
- 21:39down. Absolutely.
- 21:40Yeah, it's, it's still surprises me how much what feels like a
- 21:45huge need in that moment, which is a need that is partly, you
- 21:48know, manufactured by these companies, how much that
- 21:50evaporates after a week or two or three.
- 21:52And if you still want it after three weeks, then it's probably
- 21:55a legitimate. It's not, it's not a chemical
- 21:57animal need. It's a need that you have
- 21:58thought about or, or want. It can just be a lot.
- 22:00So, based on what you discovered about yourself in shopping when
- 22:03you wrote this book, are you any better now at separating your
- 22:06wants from your needs? It sounds like you are.
- 22:08Yeah, I think I am. And I, you know, I don't want to
- 22:10speak too soon and pretend that I'm cured of it.
- 22:12But I do think I'm better able to sort of say, OK, just because
- 22:18some sort of receptor in my brain is activated by this
- 22:20thing, just because I like it or I can see a place for it in my
- 22:24life, does not mean that I need it.
- 22:27You know, it is fine to just want something and not need it.
- 22:29I have plenty. You know, it's, yeah, I feel
- 22:31like I don't subscribe to the like, you have to need it or it
- 22:33has to spark joy, but I feel like it has to.
- 22:36I think pausing what I buy has had me take stock of what I
- 22:40actually use, where there are gaps where I actually could use
- 22:44maybe like a different belt or a better blender or something, and
- 22:48where I'm just kind of fruitlessly optimizing because
- 22:50I'm flexing the muscle of buying stuff.
- 22:53When you started to write the book, were you concerned about
- 22:55the environment, that kind of thing, or were you basically
- 22:58concerned about people just spending too much money and get
- 23:00addicted to shopping? Yeah, no, I think the
- 23:02environmental stuff, it took an interesting form as I was
- 23:05writing the book and performing writing the book.
- 23:07You know, usually I would accumulate, I would, I would
- 23:08order all this stuff, I'd return a bunch of it.
- 23:10I'd box half of it back up and, you know, I'd flatten all the
- 23:13boxes and, you know, I'd do whatever, do the whole little
- 23:15routine. It took hours at first.
- 23:17At least I would feel sort of cleansed by it.
- 23:19You know, that feeling you drop something off at Goodwill and
- 23:22you're like, like it's I'm free. But it started to become that
- 23:25anytime I would get rid of something, whether it was taken
- 23:27to Goodwill, return it or throw it away or anything, it didn't
- 23:30really feel like it left. I think I just imagined it
- 23:32joining this large pile. And I've started to think of
- 23:35everything that way. I was just like, oh, this
- 23:37doesn't leave. It leaves me, but it doesn't
- 23:40leave the Earth. And it's hard, you know?
- 23:42Yeah. It's hard to balance this kind
- 23:44of abstract, gigantic concept of your environmental impact with
- 23:48the day-to-day. Just like, I don't know, this,
- 23:51I'm drinking out of a plastic bottle.
- 23:53It's easy to sort of feel like abstaining from it doesn't do
- 23:55anything, so why bother? But I have started to try and
- 23:58like, you know, reduce waste. But absolutely.
- 24:00Yeah. I think that just that feeling
- 24:01of like nothing is ever truly jettisoned for me started to
- 24:04really take hold. And it was very strange.
- 24:06And sobering. Emily Mester is author of the
- 24:08new book American Bulk Essays on Excess.
- 24:12If you want to make a purchase, you can buy it on Amazon.
- 24:14Emily, thank you so much for spending time with us today.
- 24:16It was a fascinating conversation.
- 24:18Nice to meet you. Yeah, thanks for having me.
- 24:20Well, that's it for this edition of Consumer Pedia.
- 24:23We hope you'll rate the episode and follow us on Apple Podcast,
- 24:26Spotify, or wherever you listen to your podcasts.
- 24:29Remember, we release new episodes every other Thursday.
- 24:33Another way you can support this show is to follow us on Consumer
- 24:36Pedia on Facebook and Instagram and at my Consumer Pedia on X,
- 24:40formerly Twitter. I'm Herb Weisbaum.
- 24:42Thank you for listening. Consumer Pedia is a public
- 24:46service of checkbook.org. We're a unique nonprofit that
- 24:49helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 24:51You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 24:54and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 24:58unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 25:01seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 25:04Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Minneapolis, Saint Paul,
- 25:08Seattle, San Francisco and Washington DC.
- 25:11To get your free 30 day subscription, go to
- 25:13checkbook.org/consumer Pedia Consumer Pedia.
- 25:18Empowering consumers to save money and make smarter choices.