Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Amazon Q3 2025 Financial Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Deep Dive. So today we've got this really
- 0:03extensive financial research report in front of us.
- 0:06Focus is Amazon.com. Right.
- 0:08And with a company like Amazon, you can't just glance at the
- 0:11headlines. It's too complex.
- 0:13Exactly. So our mission today is to kind
- 0:16of breakdown this giant look under the hood at its
- 0:19operations, see how the recent numbers stack up, Q2 2025
- 0:23specifically. And then the really interesting
- 0:25part. Yeah, the tough part, we're
- 0:27going to run it through that rigorous, almost unforgiving
- 0:30test, the Buffett style checklist.
- 0:32Seeing if this, you know, quintessential growth machine
- 0:35actually meets strict value criteria, it's a fascinating
- 0:38clash. It really is, but before we get
- 0:40into any numbers, the necessary disclaimer.
- 0:42Absolutely. As the report itself emphasizes,
- 0:45everything we discuss here is purely for educational,
- 0:48informational purposes. Think of it as translating
- 0:50financial data. It's definitely not investment
- 0:53advice. Not at all.
- 0:54You absolutely need to do your own homework, your own due
- 0:56diligence before making any decisions.
- 0:58OK. Understood.
- 1:00Crystal clear. All right, let's jump into that
- 1:03Q2 2025 scorecard then. This covers the three months
- 1:06ending June 30th. OK, top line.
- 1:08First net sales came in at $167.7 billion.
- 1:13Wow. Yeah.
- 1:15And that's up 13% from the year before if you strip out the
- 1:17currency fluctuations. 13% growth on that kind of base
- 1:20number, it's still pretty staggering.
- 1:22Isn't it really is? And where did that growth come
- 1:24from? Was it balanced?
- 1:25It was surprisingly balanced, actually.
- 1:27North America sales, they climbed 11%.
- 1:29That's up to 96.4 billion, $1,000,000 OK international
- 1:33sales, which can sometimes be a bit up and down.
- 1:35They also grew up 10% to $45.8 billion, so solid across the
- 1:40board there and. Then the the big engine room,
- 1:42Yeah. AWS, right?
- 1:44AWS It grew 11%, reaching $25.5 billion.
- 1:48Now 11%. That feels like a bit of a
- 1:50slowdown from the crazy growth rates AWS used to post.
- 1:53It is, relatively speaking, it's not that, you know, 3040% jumps
- 1:57we saw years ago, but 11% growth on a $25 billion quarterly run
- 2:01rate is still immense. And critically, it's a profit
- 2:04engine. OK.
- 2:06So that connects to the operating income figure.
- 2:08Directly operating income jumped nicely.
- 2:11It hit $19.2 billion for the quarter.
- 2:14That's up significantly from $14.7 billion the same time last
- 2:18year. And the driver for that big
- 2:19jump? The report points straight to
- 2:22AWS profitability. Get this AWS operating profit
- 2:26increased by 35%. 35% So even if revenue growth is just 11%, the
- 2:32profit contribution is soaring. Precisely that cloud segment is
- 2:36doing the really heavy lifting for the company's bottom line.
- 2:39Yeah, it makes sense. And what about cash flow?
- 2:41Always a key metric. Yeah, looking at the trailing 12
- 2:44months, so the full year leading up to June 30th, operating cash
- 2:48flow hit a new record $97 billion.
- 2:51Almost $100 billion in cash generated from operations in a
- 2:54year. That's hard to wrap your head
- 2:56around. It just speaks to the sheer
- 2:57velocity of the business machine they've built money cycling
- 3:00through at incredible speed. OK, so let's unpack that machine
- 3:03a bit. You don't generate that kind of
- 3:05cash without a serious competitive advantage.
- 3:07A Moat, right? What does the report say defines
- 3:10Amazon's Moat now? Well.
- 3:11It's not just one thing, it's multi layered really.
- 3:13First, just sheer scale. Their size is intimidating and
- 3:17tied to that is their massive logistics and fulfillment
- 3:21network. The delivery vans, The
- 3:22warehouses. Exactly.
- 3:24Building that out globally, nobody else has truly replicated
- 3:27it. Second, you got the marketplace
- 3:29itself. It's 2 sided.
- 3:31Meaning sellers attract buyers, buyers attract sellers.
- 3:34Right, a virtuous cycle. And 3rd, maybe the stickiest
- 3:37part is customer loyalty, mostly driven by Prime.
- 3:41The report mentions over 200 million subscribers globally.
- 3:45200 million paying members, that's a huge built in customer
- 3:48base. Creates high switching costs I
- 3:50guess. Definitely.
- 3:51It's an ecosystem designed to keep you in.
- 3:53So to understand the machine better, let's look at the parts.
- 3:56The report breaks down the 2023 sales.
- 3:58How diversified is it really? It's interesting the biggest
- 4:01piece is still online stores direct sales.
- 4:04Those run $232 billion in 2023. Still primarily A retailer then.
- 4:08But by revenue, yes. But look deeper.
- 4:11Third party seller services, the fees they charge other sellers
- 4:13to use their platform, that was about $140 billion.
- 4:16Yeah, hugely profitable segment. Right.
- 4:18They don't take the inventory risk there.
- 4:20Exactly. Then AWS, the profit engine we
- 4:22talked about that was around $90 billion, about 16% of total
- 4:26sales in 23. OK. 16% significant, but maybe
- 4:30less than some people think is a share of revenue.
- 4:32Correct, but share of profit is much.
- 4:35And here's the one to watch advertising.
- 4:37Ah, ads on the site and app. Yeah, it's growing incredibly
- 4:40fast, hit about $47 billion in 2023, roughly 8% of total sales
- 4:45and climbing. They're monetizing all that
- 4:47website traffic very effectively.
- 4:49Earning eyeballs into ad dollars?
- 4:51Okay, sounds great, but cost must be enormous too.
- 4:54Where does the money go? Oh, absolutely immense.
- 4:56The single biggest line item is cost of goods sold.
- 4:59Or call GS basically what they paid for the stuff they sold
- 5:02directly. That was nearly $305 billion in
- 5:062023. OK.
- 5:07That's the inventory cost. What's next?
- 5:09Next up are the cost of running that giant logistics machine.
- 5:12Fulfillment costs were about $90.6 billion.
- 5:14Packing. Shipping warehouses.
- 5:16All that and then technology and infrastructure supporting AWS,
- 5:20their websites, internal tech. That was another big one, $85.6
- 5:23billion. Those 3 lines dwarf everything
- 5:26else I imagine by far. Now you mentioned the
- 5:29fulfillment costs, but there's this amazing nugget in the
- 5:33report about their efficiency. It really highlights their
- 5:35operational skill. Yes, this is quite remarkable.
- 5:38It's a small number with huge implications.
- 5:42In 2023, Amazon actually reduced its average cost to serve per
- 5:47unit by 45 cents compared to the year before.
- 5:50Wait, 40-5 cents? That sounds.
- 5:52Tiny. It sounds tiny, right?
- 5:54But think about this scale. They ship billions and billions
- 5:56of packages, maybe upwards of 8 billion units a year globally.
- 6:00OK, multiply $0.45 by 8 billion. Exactly.
- 6:03You're talking billions of dollars saved, pure efficiency
- 6:06gain flowing straight to the bottom line.
- 6:08It shows incredible execution, optimizing their network,
- 6:12regionalizing inventory. It's as good as finding new
- 6:15revenue. Operational mastery, OK, but
- 6:17that sheer scale, that dominance, it also makes them a
- 6:19target, doesn't it? What risks does the report?
- 6:22Flag 2 Main categories Regulatory and competitive On
- 6:25the regulatory side, the spotlight is intense antitrust.
- 6:29Yeah, that seems like a constant headline.
- 6:31It is. The report specifically calls
- 6:33out the USFTC lawsuit that was filed back in September 2023,
- 6:38and there are ongoing investigations in the EU too.
- 6:41The core issue being. Well, when you own the giant
- 6:43marketplace and you sell your own products on it, and you
- 6:46compete with the third party sellers using your platform,
- 6:50regulators worry you might be unfairly tilting the playing
- 6:53field in your own favor. Right, using seller data to
- 6:56launch competing products, things like that.
- 6:58Exactly. It's a fundamental threat to how
- 7:00their marketplace operates, not just a cost but potentially
- 7:03model altering. OK, that's a big one.
- 7:05What about competition? Still fierce in the cloud, AWS
- 7:09faces relentless pressure from Microsoft Azure and Google
- 7:12Cloud. They're gaining ground, forcing
- 7:15AWS to keep innovating and potentially squeezing margins
- 7:18over time. And in their core e-commerce
- 7:20business? Traditional rivals like Walmart
- 7:22are fighting hard online and then you have newer deep
- 7:25discount players putting pressure on price and delivery
- 7:27speed. They can't stand still.
- 7:29OK. So we have this picture, an
- 7:31incredibly efficient, high growth dominant company, but
- 7:35facing real headwinds. Now the moment of truth.
- 7:39Right, the checklist. We take this amazing company and
- 7:42subject it to the cold hard logic of a deep value investor.
- 7:46Does it pass the test? This feels like where the story
- 7:49gets really interesting. And this is precisely where the
- 7:51narrative flips. The market clearly loves Amazon.
- 7:54It prices it for growth, for dominance, but the strict value
- 7:57investor using metrics designed primarily to avoid losing money.
- 8:02Finds it lacking. Finds it significantly lacking
- 8:05the short answer. Based on this strict checklist,
- 8:07Amazon fails. It fails several key tests right
- 8:10out of the gate. Wow.
- 8:11OK, let's break that down. Where does it fail first
- 8:13valuation? Immediately valuation.
- 8:15The most common metric is the price to earnings, or PE ratio,
- 8:19Report notes. Amazon's has recently been
- 8:21hovering around 45 times earnings. 45 X Now for a tech
- 8:24growth stocks, some might say that's not outrageous.
- 8:27Some might, but a traditional value investor like the model
- 8:30used in this checklist is looking for a margin of safety.
- 8:33They typically want APE ratio of 15X or less. 15 so. 45 X is 3
- 8:39times higher than the threshold. Why such a low bar 15X?
- 8:44It's about protecting your capital.
- 8:46A low PE suggests you're not overpaying for current earnings,
- 8:49and it provides A buffer if future growth doesn't meet
- 8:51expectations. AT45X Amazon is priced for
- 8:55continued high growth, if that falters even a bit.
- 8:58The stock has a long way to fall.
- 9:00The price assumes perfection. Essentially, yes, There's very
- 9:04little margin of safety baked in at that price from a value
- 9:07perspective. So big veil on valuation.
- 9:09OK. Valuation fail.
- 9:11What about cash generation? We talked about that huge $97
- 9:14billion operating cash flow figure.
- 9:16Surely that's a pass? This is where it gets tricky.
- 9:20We need to look at free cash flow or FCF.
- 9:23That's the cash left after operations and after reinvesting
- 9:26back into the business capital expenditures.
- 9:28So the truly discretionary cash the business generates.
- 9:31Exactly. And while Amazon's FCF was
- 9:33positive in 2023, about $9 billion, the margin is the
- 9:38issue. The FCF margin that's FCF
- 9:40divided by total sales was only about 1.6%. 1.6% That sounds
- 9:44incredibly low for a company this profitable on other
- 9:47measures. Why?
- 9:48Because they plow almost everything back into growth,
- 9:51building more warehouses, investing in AWS infrastructure,
- 9:55R&D, they prioritize reinvestment over generating
- 9:58piles of free cash today. And the value checklist demands.
- 10:02Typically, a value investor wants to see an FCF margin
- 10:05greater than 5%. They want businesses that
- 10:08effortlessly throw off cash, not one's constantly consuming it
- 10:12for growth, even if that growth is successful.
- 10:14So another fail based on that reinvestment strategy.
- 10:18That also explains the point about share buybacks, right?
- 10:21The report mentioned they didn't spend much on them in 2023.
- 10:24Precisely. They authorized a $10 billion
- 10:26program in 2022, which is small relative to their size, but they
- 10:30barely used it in 23. Growth investment comes first.
- 10:33Returning cash to shareholders is secondary.
- 10:35That's a growth stock mindset, not a value 1.
- 10:37OK, valuation fail, FCF margin fail.
- 10:41What else does the checklist look for?
- 10:42Predictability. Yes.
- 10:43Steady, predictable earnings growth over long periods,
- 10:46decades ideally. And Amazon had that stumble
- 10:48recently, didn't they? They did.
- 10:51The checklist flags the miss here because of that one year
- 10:54contraction back in 2022. They actually reported a net
- 10:57loss of $2.7 billion that year. A loss for Amazon?
- 11:01Yep, primarily due to write downs related to their
- 11:04investment in Rivian, but also some operational pressures.
- 11:07For a strict value checklist demanding unwavering, consistent
- 11:11profitability year after year, even one annual loss is a
- 11:14failure. It breaks the pattern of
- 11:16predictability. OK, this is brutal.
- 11:18Let's move to the balance sheet, the company's financial
- 11:20foundation. Surely it's strong there.
- 11:23This is where it's mixed and frankly quite fascinating.
- 11:25On traditional solvency measures, rock solid.
- 11:29The debt to equity ratio is very low, around .18.
- 11:31So not much debt relative to their equity base safe.
- 11:34Extremely safe from a long term debt perspective.
- 11:37Yeah, and their interest coverage, how easily earnings
- 11:39cover interest payments is huge. Around 28X.
- 11:42No risk of defaulting on debt. OK, sounds great.
- 11:44But you said mixed. Yes, but when you look at short
- 11:47term liquidity it's a different story.
- 11:49The key metric here is the current ratio.
- 11:52Current assets divided by current liabilities.
- 11:54Right. It measures if you have enough
- 11:56easily accessible assets like cash, receivables to cover your
- 11:59immediate bills, payables, short term debt value investors demand
- 12:04a cushion here. They want a current ratio
- 12:06comfortably above 1.5. And Amazon's.
- 12:09According to the report, it's only about 1.06.
- 12:12One point O 6 that's barely above 1.
- 12:15It means their current assets just barely cover their current
- 12:17liabilities. They're running really lean on
- 12:20short term cash. Extremely lean.
- 12:22It's like they operate with just enough cash to cover the next
- 12:25cycle of payments and inventory turnover.
- 12:27Why would such a massive profitable company choose to
- 12:31operate with such a thin short term buffer?
- 12:34It feels risky. It's a strategic choice, really.
- 12:36It reflects their obsession with operational efficiency and
- 12:39speed. They don't want cash sitting
- 12:41idle. They want it constantly moving,
- 12:43turning inventory over as fast as humanly possible.
- 12:46It's weaponizing working capital.
- 12:47But for the value investor? It's a major red flag.
- 12:50It leaves very little room for error.
- 12:52If there's a sudden shock, a supply chain disruption, a dip
- 12:55in demand, they don't have that traditional safety cushion.
- 12:58So strong solvency, yes, but weak liquidity by value
- 13:02standards. Fascinating trade off.
- 13:04OK. Last, check profitability
- 13:06metrics beyond just the net loss issue.
- 13:08Also mixed here, 1 positive. The gross margin has been
- 13:12improving significantly. It's now near 49%.
- 13:15Almost $0.50 of every sales dollar left after paying for the
- 13:18goods themselves. That's strong.
- 13:20Very strong. It easily clears the typical
- 13:23value threshold of around 40%. Shows pricing power efficiency
- 13:26gains, however. There's always a however, with
- 13:29this checklist it seems. Seems so, yeah.
- 13:31The net profit margin, what's left after for all expenses,
- 13:34taxes, et cetera, was around 5.3% in 2020. 5.3% That sounds
- 13:38okay. It's okay, but the really
- 13:40stringent value checklists often look for net margins closer to
- 13:4320%. 20%, That seems incredibly high.
- 13:46It is. It's typically found in dominant
- 13:48software companies or unique brands.
- 13:50Amazons 5.3% reflects those huge investments we talked about
- 13:54fulfillment, tech, R&D, they spend massively to fuel growth,
- 13:58which keeps the final Net margin down compared to less capital
- 14:02intensive businesses. So gross margin pass, Net margin
- 14:05fail, correct. So putting it all together, the
- 14:09rigorous unemotional verdict from this value checklist is
- 14:13pretty clear then. It is.
- 14:15Amazon is undeniably a high quality, incredibly successful
- 14:18growth company, but judge purely against the criteria designed to
- 14:22find deeply undervalued defensive investments with large
- 14:26margins of safety, it does not qualify.
- 14:28It's priced richly for its quality and growth prospects.
- 14:31It's a different kind of investment entirely.
- 14:32High grade growth, not deep value.
- 14:34Exactly. Now, very quickly, let's touch
- 14:36on management governance. Andy Jassi has been CEO since
- 14:39Jeff Bezos stepped back in 2021. Though Bezos is still involved
- 14:42as executive chair, right? And owns a big chunk of stock.
- 14:45Yep. He retains about 9% of the
- 14:47shares, so it's still significant influence.
- 14:50The report did praise management for transparency though.
- 14:52Yeah. I noted that they didn't try to
- 14:54hide that big Q 4/20/22 net loss.
- 14:57For instance, they explained the $3.9 billion hit from inventory
- 15:02write downs. Right, and instead of seeing
- 15:04pretty well aligned, Jassy and other execs have large stock
- 15:07packages, but they only vest if specific long term performance
- 15:11targets are actually met. So they're motivated for a long
- 15:14term shareholder returns, not just short term bumps.
- 15:17That's generally seen as good governance.
- 15:19Definitely a positive, positive mark.
- 15:20We also saw a glimpse of shareholder power dynamics.
- 15:23The institutional investors Vanguard.
- 15:27BlackRock. Yes, they hold huge stakes.
- 15:30And in the 2024 annual general meeting, shareholders voted down
- 15:33all 14 activist proposals, mostly on environmental and
- 15:37social topics. They cited overwhelmingly with
- 15:39the board's recommendations. Shows that the big institutions
- 15:42are currently pretty aligned with management strategy.
- 15:44Seems that way. OK.
- 15:46Finally, let's circle back to that valuation question with
- 15:48different tool, discounted cash flow or DCF.
- 15:51Right, this tries to estimate intrinsic value by projecting
- 15:54future cash flows. What does the DCF model in the
- 15:57report suggests? Well, even using what the report
- 15:59calls optimistic assumptions, projecting free cash flow growth
- 16:04at a very strong 30% rate for years into the future.
- 16:07Which sounds quite bullish. Extremely bullish.
- 16:10Even with that, the calculated intrinsic value lands somewhere
- 16:14around $260 per share. $260 and comparing that to where Amazon's
- 16:19stock typically trades. It reinforces the checklist
- 16:23findings. Even under very favorable growth
- 16:26projections, it's really hard to argue there's a significant
- 16:29margin of safety that buffer between intrinsic value and
- 16:32market price at recent levels. You're paying for that
- 16:35optimistic future already. Confirms the conclusion.
- 16:38You're buying expected future growth, not current undervalued
- 16:42assets. Precisely.
- 16:43So to kind of synthesize this whole deep dive, Amazon is
- 16:46phenomenal, an incredible ecosystem, stunning operational
- 16:49efficiency. That 45% cost reduction per unit
- 16:52is just one example, but it's strategic commitment to
- 16:55relentless reinvestment and the resulting high market valuation
- 16:59mean it fundamentally doesn't fit the mold of a traditional
- 17:01value investment. So the big take away for you
- 17:03listening might be this. You can have incredible
- 17:07operational strength like that, nearly 49% gross margin and
- 17:10still not be undervalued in the classic sense.
- 17:14High quality often commands a high price.
- 17:16Exactly. And that brings us to the final
- 17:18thought. Something for you to chew on.
- 17:20We saw Amazon's long term debt situation is incredibly safe.
- 17:24Detequity just .18 rock solid. But the glaring outlier on that
- 17:29balance sheet was the liquidity. That current ratio hovering near
- 17:33one point O 6. Running on fumes almost in terms
- 17:36of readily available cash versus immediate bills.
- 17:38Right. So the question to ponder is
- 17:40this. Is Amazon's choice to operate
- 17:42with such low liquidity, prioritizing vilimity, inventory
- 17:45turnover, capital efficiency over a traditional cash cushion?
- 17:48Is that the smart strategic future for large tech driven
- 17:52companies? Or is it a hidden vulnerability,
- 17:54a potential Achilles heel that conservative financial analysis
- 17:57is right to be wary of? What are the real trade-offs
- 17:59there? Something for you to think
- 18:00about.