Latest / Jew York Times / Zohran Mamdani's October 7th Was A Garbage Fire
Transcript
- Eitan: Welcome to the Jew York Times, a special midweek episode. We're gonna be talking about Zoromam Dani's awful, comically bad October seventh. today I'm joined by Chelsea Jacobson. Chelsea Jacobson, how's it going? in New Chelsea: Hello. Eitan: York. Where are you right now? Chelsea: I'm in New York. I'm in Mom Donnie's New York. Eitan: Montanistan. That's Me and Chelsea, our jobs, aside from in media, is that we are the ones that get Israel its weapons. Okay? We are the two in charge. Chelsea: Yeah, yeah, we're arms dealers. Eitan: That's us. And then also we both had a a small stint as lab technicians in Siberia that ended about a week ago, unfortunately. That was me. You know Chelsea: Yeah, when the plague broke out. no, I've said too much. we weren't supposed to talk about it. Eitan: At the end of the day, this whole Israel thing, I don't know why we're all obsessing over it. The whole region is gonna get wiped out by a Siberian measles at any day now because of the Russian League. Anyways, okay, let's talk about what happened yesterday. Yesterday was the third anniversary of October 7th. and this is gonna be a quicker episode because we're just talking about one thing, and that is how Zoran Mamdani spent his first October 7th as the mayor of New York. New York, by the way, Chelsea, I don't know if you know this, has a lot of Jews. Chelsea: Very Jewy. Very Jewy. The most Jews I've heard, besides the Jewish country. Eitan: Very, very, very Jewy. It's basically it's the most Jews. It's essentially late night writers' rooms in the 90s. That's what I would consider New York. The same demographic of Jewish Chelsea: Mm-hmm. Eitan: involvement. but basically, okay, so Zor Mandani, he starts off the day by putting out what I would describe as one of the worst all time tone deaf political statements on a day of anything. And it was a it was a post, and I say that I'm not it feels like I'm being like hyperbolic about this. And like I celebrate him when he does the good stuff. I definitely call him out when he does the bad stuff. This was terrible. And basically, it Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: was an October 7th post where the first paragraph, about four sentences, was about the massacre that happened in Israel with the 1200 people that were killed and those that were taken hostage. And then he proceeds to spend about three quarters of the Calling out Israel for the genocide, you know what he calls it, you know, debating the word and anything like that, but like the whole Israel's wrong. Basically guilting the Jews in their hollow, sorry, guilting the Jews in their October 7th post over support of Israel. and that is how it started. It's actually like pretty crazy. I what was your opinion of it when you first saw it? Because when I was reading it, I actually was blown away. I thought it was AI for like a second. Because of how tone deaf it was. Chelsea: No, I wasn't shocked at all. I thought somebody told me he said something crazy on X, and I was like, did he all lives matter it? And say one sentence about October 7th, and the rest of it was just demonizing Israel. And they were like, Yeah, that's actually on the nose. That's exactly Eitan: A hundred percent all lives mat yeah. Chelsea: what he did and exactly what I expected him to do. Even so though, you're right, the tone was pretty the just that you can look that it's like one sentence on October 7th and then like paragraphs and paragraphs and paragraphs and paragraphs about how awful Israel is. It's like Eitan: Yeah. This is what Claude is for. Chad GPT Chelsea: Even for him, pretty severe. Eitan: Claude could have easily just made the percentages and ratios of the Palestine to Gaza to Israel ratio in that post completely different. I you know, I Chelsea: Also, Aitan, my favorite thing about it, sorry, my favorite thing about it is that he rounded down to eleven hundred people killed. Did you did you notice that? Eitan: Yeah. that's kinda nice about him. Yeah, he keeps on it's eleven it's all it's like eleven fifty two if I'm not mistaken. It goes up to twelve hundred. Give us that at least. Yeah. Chelsea: Yeah, it's like people generally say around twelve hundred. He's the only person I've ever seen round down and say more than eleven hundred. Eitan: I think there's also another issue with it. When he talks about the 74,000 Palestinians that had died, I am totally fine with him saying the massive, massive, massive number of people. At some point, there does need to be a conversation about Hamas operatives within Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: the 74. And I don't understand why that is not brought up more. How it's not 74, it's a lot. This is not to say that it isn't a lot. It's not to say that being a kid in Gaza fucking sucks right now. But 74,000 is just, it's just not accurate. At all. And it's like if he spends Chelsea: Right. Eitan: the entire thing over exaggerating and like botching the messaging and botching the day to begin with, we can't even have like the basic conversation of factually this does not make any sense. And I'm going beyond the genocide thing. I'm not gonna argue about whether it's a genocide or whether the the wording is correct or not. But if there's factual issues within your October seventh post about October seventh, then that's a fucking problem. Chelsea: The horse is so far out of the barn on that. It's like every time I'm at one of those protests, they make up a different number. I think they were screaming seven hundred thousand dead at him last night. Which they just make up a Eitan: yeah, I did see that. They said seven hundred thousand dead. Seven hundred yeah. Chelsea: new number all the time. And so, yes, you're right. We can't have a serious conversation about any of this when when people are throwing around numbers willy nilly. yeah. Eitan: We gotta start making up numbers. Did you actually know that seven hundred and fifty thousand people died in Israel on October seventh, Chelsea? Did you know that? Every day, seven hundred and fifty thousand die. Huh? Fight that. Ha, where are you a sodpiker on that? Chelsea: Just yesterday, actually. Every day seven hundred and fifty thousand people are dying. Yeah. Eitan: But I think what what really annoys me about the about this post is that realistically, you got three hundred and sixty four days a year when it is totally fine to bring up, you know, what is happening in Gaza. It's obviously complicated. It's obviously complex. Everyone has their own opinions about what happened on that day. 364 days a year to talk about it. And it's not an issue. October 7th is the one day where it is, you don't talk about it. It is the largest massacre Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: of Jews since the Holocaust. It's 1200, it's 1,200 people that had died on that day. And he knows when he's going out there and when he's centering the aftermath of what happened afterwards. He knows that it takes away from the space that Jews and Israelis should have in order to mourn this stuff. And to be honest, the whole fucking progressive left, their entire thing is identity politics. Their entire thing is creating safe spaces. It's being able, it's giving people room to explore their culture and to mourn their heritage and to talk about this stuff. And it's like, unless it's fucking Jews and Israelis, at which point they don't get to do their own thing. They have to have their thing smushed up with a war that happened afterwards. And then also, no Palestinians died on October 7th. It's just not the day to talk about this stuff. If he wants to talk about it on October 8th, totally fine with it. It makes complete sense to go talk about October 8th. Sixth, well, Chelsea: Or sixth Eitan: I wouldn't sixth would be an issue 'cause it would undercut. Yeah. Yeah. Chelsea: No, October sixth. Eitan: October sixth, he can talk about it. October Any of them. Chelsea: Yeah. Fifth, fourth, third, second, first. Eighth, nine, tenth, eleventh, twelfth, just one day. Just the seventh you can Seven, eight, nine six, seven. my God. Yeah. Eitan: Why was October 6th afraid of October 7th? No, I'm joking. That's the stupid hey. but that was how the day started. It was like that was like the first thing that happened in the morning. And I also want to put out this context. A week ago, he put out his anti-Semitism plan, where he put out that big like, this is my this is my my my olive branch Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: to cover his. Yeah. Chelsea: Yeah. Close. Olibrands. Olibrands. Which everyone hated, by the way. On both sides. He's he's done a really Eitan: But this was my olive branch of the Jewish community. Yeah. This was his original thing was like What completely. Chelsea: good job the last couple weeks of just upsetting everyone equally everywhere. Which I guess he wants to treat everyone equally, so good for him. But like Eitan: I do actually think that that is pretty funny that the that Zoran Mamdani's first October 7th as mayor of New York was such a goddamn disaster that he somehow got both Israelis, Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: Jews, and Palestinians to all hate him at the same time. And to be honest, the only thing that Israelis, Jews, and Palestinians all agree on is one. They don't like flavored chocolate chumous from Trader Joe's. And two, for some reason, Chelsea: So true. Eitan: the decision was made that if you're not gonna live in the Middle East, you're gonna live in northern New Jersey. Those are the two things, the only two things that the Jews, Israelis, and the Arabs, Middle Eastern, whoever agreed on until Zora Mamdani came and botched October seventh. Because the second thing happened was he releases a statement. The statement is like across the board, torn up by every single Jewish group. I don't know, actually, can I answer a question on you? This was the first time that I'd seen a lot of people who were like pro Mom Donnie or people who were like they liked him or whatever. It was the first time that I really saw people in that universe raise their eyebrows at it and see how the statement wasn't the best statement to be making on that day. Chelsea: Yeah, I do think it was so egregious. You're right. It was so egregious that that people were kinda like, This is just like again, I think it's Eitan: Yeah, I'm like, what are you doing, bro? Chelsea: just that you could look at it. It's like looking at the tweet. There were like ten words about Israel and then a hundred thousand about Gaza. And it's you know, you can't argue with math. These people try to, but you can't argue with math. So math is stuff. No, I yeah. Eitan: mean math is math is tough. But it was like it was like I'm telling there were people I'm not gonna say who, but actually no, there was someone, I had personal people in my life who I know who I know are Zaron fans. they've they text me and they're like, Chelsea: Hmm. Eitan: they're they're into his stuff. There was a guy, Jeff Perlman, who is like a really lib sports journalist, used to write for Sports Illustrated. Even he put up something that was like, I like Zaramam Dani, but this statement is just it ain't it. And it was really across the board, it seemed like it had It seemed like people who were just casual viewers of the situation looked at it and were like, okay, that's not whatever. So that was how he spent his morning, the October 7th morning. The night was then spent by going to a rally in in Union Square. Now here's the thing about the rally. The rally was thrown by Israelis for Peace. Israelis for Peace was created after October 7th as one of the only spaces in New York where people, Israelis and Palestinians, it was based, it was based on bridge building. These are hippie libs. Israelis. These are the kind of Israelis that their entire thing Chelsea: Yes, I read the vigil was also for Palestinians too. The vigil was for October Eitan: Yes. Chelsea: seventh victims and also people who died in the subsequent subsequent war. So very, very lefty vigil, which is fine. Eitan: Complete lefty. And I will say, like, you know, in the Jewish community, in the Israeli community, I would even say that they're not like liked by Jews and by some Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: Jews and some Israelis because they are so lefty. Now, let me just say I like them. You know, I like some of some of the stuff I don't like, some of the stuff I do like, you know, but I will say that in the Jewish community, they are viewed as like l hyper lefty, like almost as lefty as you can go before going into the SJP, JVP. universe. So when we're talking about the people that are running this, protest yesterday, this is really a group of people who their entire thing is Palestinian bridges and you and and unity. The fact that they had invited Zoran Mamdani to their vigil, I gotta imagine they're one of the only places, one of the only Jewish groups in New York where Zoran's invited to this stuff. Like so this is it was it was Chelsea: Yeah. A hundred thousand percent. The only place. Eitan: the only place it was him, it was Jamani Williams, and it like Brad Lander who boy howdy, I God damn do people hate this guy. He is gonna something Chelsea: I know, it was Lander. Eitan: This is gonna he's gonna have a very bad ending to his political career. I'm calling it right now. So they're gonna eat him up and chew him spit him out at some point. But anyways. Chelsea: God, I hope so. He does just look like an idiot all the time. Eitan: is idiot the right word? Let's debate. Is idiot the right word or is he cowardly and opportunistic? Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: Like I think that he knows what he is doing. Chelsea: I think they're they go hand in hand. I don't think he's I don't Eitan: The cat were yeah. Chelsea: think he understands how much he's gonna be like cannibalized by by the movement. Eitan: Yeah. Chelsea: I don't think he understands still, he's already been yelled at by the left like a hundred times. And he still doesn't really internalize, I think, that he's gonna keep going to events like this vigil and the far lefty people are going to keep villainizing him and yelling at him and there's nothing he can do. I still think it has set in for him. Eitan: Yeah. I he's been kicked he's been shouted out of events before. I forgot there was like some Chelsea: Right. Eitan: event at MSG a couple weeks ago where he was kind of shouted out. And it's funny because during the election, you know, they loved it. You know, his side l really loved him. They looked at him as like a sympathetic Jew that they were kind of like propping up without saying the word Zionist, when realistically, Brad Lander, by his own admission, just brings up all the time that he's a liberal Zion Zionist. His entire Selling point as who he is is that I am a liberal sign, you hate Israel, I am your ally here. And what he's finding out in real time, and it's very funny, there's a lot of shot in Freud with this, is that he Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: is they hate him and they're starting to like chew him up and spin him out. I think it's the fourth time I said that in this, you know, in this thing. But you know, if he's Chelsea: Mm. Eitan: going, but he's like Lib, he's you know, he's on the left. So if he's going to the Israelis for peace event, that is the genre of event that this that this was, right? Israelis for peace. Chelsea: It wasn't put on by the IDF, Eitan: It was not put on by the IDF. It was it was put on by a Mossad sleeper agent cell, though. Chelsea: Right, right. Eitan: Completely different. Completely different stuff. But this Chelsea: Completely different. Eitan: protest, which is once again pro-Israel and talking about the Gazans that had been, that had been what it's like to be a Gazan right now and how the Gazans are getting fucked over. This protest, which is showing sympathy to both sides, gets immediately protested by literally every single Pro-Palestinian, anti-Israel group in New York. I've heard that JVP was the only one that wasn't involved in these protests, but they show this is Chelsea: wow, that's shocking. Eitan: what I've heard. This is what it was based Tamark Leserman's thing, who I think I I think I read that right. but Tamar Gleserman, Tamar Gleserman runs this this this this organization. Her aunt was killed on October 7th, yet she has spent the past two, three years at this point. Doing everything she can to build unity. So, this is once again the kind of organization that Israeli Sherpeace are. It starts to get protested by every single pro-Palestinian group in New York in ways that were terrifying. People showed up in Hezbollah outfits, Hamas outfits. There were posters of Yahya Sinwar who I think who I Chelsea: It's cartoonish. It's cartoonage. it wasn't it wasn't even masquerading behind this ceasefire now. Like peace. Like no no, there was no masquerading at this thing. They were they were flying a moss flags. Eitan: Cease fire now. No. You know what is kind of funny? You can't buy a Hamas outfit. You gotta make that. So I do think that there is a kind Chelsea: Hmm. Eitan: of fun like artsy craft like meetup behind these protest groups. Chelsea: Not so nice for them. It's an added layer of the community bonding. Eitan: Listen, they all have MFAs in art, you know, in acrylics and and theater design. Chelsea: That's true. Eitan: Broadway's in the shit. They all have Theater design degrees and the only thing they're doing is creating Hezbollah uniforms to show up to protest at this point. God, this is the problem with Broadway. Chelsea: You know, anything to support craft. Like human craft. Eitan: But anyways, okay, so they dress up in like Hezbollah Hamas. You they did the we, you know, hey, something, something we want Hamas here, chance. and then something fascinating happens. Zoran Mamdani shows up and they start to boo him. And they start yelling at him. They're calling him traitor, Chelsea: Gorgeous. Eitan: they're calling him a bootlicker, they're calling him a Zionist. And they're just like evisc, they're literally. Yelling so loud, and it's a moment of silence. So the protesters are taking advantage of this moment of silence to yell at him, and he's standing there stonefaced while they're just yelling, traitor, traitor, traitor at him. And it's not Schottenfreud because I'm I'm at the end of the day, I'm rooting for him because like I do want him to to like succeed. And it's it's not Schadenfreud because it's more complicated than that. But like it wasn't not not Schottenfreud, is what I would say. Chelsea: I'll call it Schadenfreude because it's amazing. It's poetic justice, really, is what it is. Because it's like they were using all these chants that Mamdani himself has chanted before, you can't run, you can't hide, we charge you with genocide. all these ridiculous chants that Mamdani himself has shouted at civil servants in New York, blaming them Eitan: Mm-hmm. Chelsea: for a war on the other side of the world. It's really beautiful poetic justice that he found himself in their shoes and he was like, I'm just a civil servant on the other side of the world. Why are these people screaming Eitan: What about I'm just Chelsea: genocide at me? Eitan: but he also built this up. The thing is that he like he built this up that he would be able to do something. This is the impossible corner that Zoran has painted himself into. And it is that Chelsea: it's amazing. Eitan: his entire campaign was built around this idea that he would be able to affect what happens in the Middle East as the mayor of New York. That is not something that can happen. As mayor of New York, he can't arrest BB, he can't affect. Defunding weapon sales. He has no votes in the Senate, he has no votes in the Congress. At most, he can maybe get Letitia James to look at the financial backings of Batar or whatever. But realistically, that is the full extent of what he can do. And the problem is that he keeps on pushing himself as some sort of game changer in this universe when he literally cannot do it. And what that has equaled is leaving this open, festering wound about him not being able to do this is that his is his community that he came up for is starting to get angry at him for not accomplishing these impossible fucking things that he told them that he would be able to do that he knew he would never be able to do. It's the funniest thing of all time. And then I will say another thing with this. there are two huge issues. That Zoran is running up against. There's two unavoidable, unfixable problems that Zoran is running up against. The first one is that Israel isn't going anywhere. And I don't say that as a declarative statement. I say that as a fact. China's not going anywhere. Russia's not going anywhere. Ukraine isn't going anywhere. Michigan isn't going Chelsea: Today. Eitan: anywhere. Florida isn't going anywhere. Canada isn't going anywhere. Israel isn't going anywhere. It just is what it is. No matter You can call it a settler colonial apartheid project, whatever. It just it's not going away. So treating it like there's any conclusion to this where Israel just ceases to exist is just not a workable thing that adults can even push. El Sayed isn't even pushing this shit. That's number one. Number two, Jews have a connection to Israel. you can disagree with the connection, but it will always be in there in a way that you can't ignore. and I'm not saying that, it's isn't saying that stuff is right or, or that there aren't other arguments or other sides to this, but the Jews do have a connection to Israel, and that's just always gonna be there. It's in too much of our texts. It's just it is what it is. So as long as Israel is there, the Jews are gonna have this connection to Israel. Israel's not going anywhere. Mamdani attacking Israel and not having not having like a more nuanced approach to how to deal with this is causing him problems over and over and over because he's not getting rid of Israel. He's taking this wishy-washy stance on Jews and their connection to Israel. And what that has led to is releasing bullshit, crazy stent say statements on October 7th, and then getting it followed up by getting protested at pr by pro-Palestinian protesters that, like you said, are from the same place that he came from. So there's this impossible equation that I don't know if he has an ability to like back himself out of. Chelsea: No, he doesn't. He he can't he built his own gallows. He's like in a prison of his own making. And it's beautiful. Eitan: That's so funny. Chelsea: It's beautiful. Cause yeah, for all the reasons you're just it's like this fantasy world that he's built is now like coming crashing down around him. And the lies are coming crashing down around him because he talks out of two sides of his mouth and he tries to please everybody. And he has I think I know what his real convictions are, but at least consistently in terms of what He tries to do, he doesn't have real convictions because he flip-flops so much, depending on the situation. And it's like it's all coming to a head at this one vigil where Eitan: Yeah yeah. Chelsea: no one's happy. Everyone's like, you're full of shit. Cause everyone's like, you know, the pro-Palestine people are like, A year ago, you were standing over here with us. And the Jewish people are like, A year ago, you were standing over there with them. Like, we're all aware Eitan: Yeah. Chelsea: of what's going on. And his hands were tied. There was nothing he could do but sit there and fume. His face, Eitan: Yeah. Chelsea: he was just fuming. Just fuming. So funny. Eitan: It was so funny. It was the epitome of the like of you're probably wondering how I got here. Like that that movie Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: trope of just him staring out there. That is a very good point where it's like you have two groups that he's he's from the start alienated him from one side, and then as he's continued, he's alienated himself from the other side. the disassembly of the Zionist entity of Israel as a staple of your running platform in DSA meeting halls. I Chelsea: Right. Eitan: I understand the universe he came from where he goes the DSA meetings, we've all seen them. We've all seen how insufferable and fucking crazy they are. So I he that's where he came from. Chelsea: They're incredible. Eitan: There and if you haven't by the way, at home, just Google DSA meetings and I it's a laugh riot. You it's Portlandia but ten times better if it was it's like if it was a documentary. On port Portlandia, the documentary is what I would describe those DSA meetings. Chelsea: And if it were so extreme that even if you were on Portlandia's set, you'd like, Are you sure? Like Eitan: Yeah, I'd be like, I they wouldn't stop the meeting as frequently as possible to address everyone's Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: pronouns in the room, right? but Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: you know, so he's he's leading these like these DSA meetings, they are psychotic imagination land, like whatever. So he's good at leading those meetings, I guess. But those meetings don't exist in real life. What he's finding out is that if you are the mayor of New York, you know the two groups that you gotta deal with a lot? Jews and Zionists, Wall Street, Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: Broadway, real estate. it's all Jews who frequently travel to Israel. So it's like he can't operate in the universe that he was in because he's finding out slowly over time just how unavoidable the idea of Jews and Israel is. And it's very funny because I do think that he I think that there was an original tactic that he is now seeing that is completely unpassable at remote at separating Jews and Israel. When like I think that he thought that he can just handle the Chelsea: Right. Of course. Yeah. Eitan: anti Semitism side. without talking about the Israel side and w he is finding out like that that is fucking impossible. Chelsea: But no, it's October 7th and the Jews care about the thing that has to do with Israel. What am I supposed to do? Yeah. Yeah. Eitan: Crazy. If yeah, I put this on Instagram yesterday, but if you were a politician who was trying to figure out what to post about October seventh and you don't like the Israeli government or whatever, yard site candle and the date. It. Let everyone take let everyone take whatever they want from it. I it that's what I would say. I that's all you gotta do. Yardsite candle I really don't give a shit. Like you're or maybe Chelsea: Yeah, even as a private citizen, that's kinda how I felt like it was best to handle. It's like just remember the day, it's horrible. It's about remembering the people who died and that's it. we don't need like that's it. That's it. Eitan: I I think also there's another element to him where I early on it felt like ev the reason why he shouldn't keep on screwing this up is because every time he screws up like this, it takes up a lot of political space. It takes up like the rest of his Chelsea: my god, everything. Eitan: week is gonna be dominated by this. Into next week, it's gonna be dominated by this. The grocery stores, the buses, he's doing a good job of the potholes, although apparently de Blasio had a better pothole rate than he had. But over time, He's not doing anything. We talk about Israel in ways where we're not even bringing it up. this was Chelsea: Right. Eitan: an unforced conversation about Israel that he decided to bring up and have it dominate his week. Like there was a way Chelsea: Yeah. Again, he's like just constantly being hoisted by his own petard. it's like he's just constantly setting himself up for failure by harping on this thing, like you said, that he inherently has no control over. And he's focusing the conversation back on how he fails to control this thing that he has no control over instead of just quietly doing his job. And maybe it actu maybe it would actually work. And maybe people would actually like him. But he can't help himself. Eitan: Can I ask you a question? Chelsea: It's a compulsion. Eitan: Qui que role play here? Can I ask you a question? Let's play, let's pretend like you are Zoran's like PR person or whatever. Like you're on you're Zoran's Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: calm strategy person. Chelsea: I look like I would be, by the way. Eitan: hundred percent. Listen. You literally you also talk like like you you would. You would give a good statement. Chelsea: Yeah, I'm like right I'm like the Gen Z millennial, on the edge. Like Eitan: Mm-hmm. Chelsea: I have that I have that look. In another life. I'm very short. Yeah. Yeah. Eitan: You're also very short, very unintimidating. Very short, very unintimidating, which I think is very important for a press for a press lead, for a comms director. Chelsea: Yeah, I just need a nose piercing and I'm good to go. So yeah, imagine I have a nose piercing. Eitan: That's actually one purple streak and a nose piercing? That you're Zoran's press secretary. You get Chelsea: Ha ha ha. Eitan: brought, you know, you're brought in. Zoran says, like, all right, like, I gotta handle this way better. What is the thing that you are telling him to do that doesn't alienate his old universe? Do you tell him to alienate the old universe? Do you tell him to forge a new universe? Like, how do you even tell him to like go forward on this? Chelsea: That's a great question because I don't think he can alienate the base. I think they'll go crazy, like we saw. He can't alienate the Eitan: Th but Chelsea: base. Eitan: but over time they're they are they're gonna go crazy over time. Like, are we not seeing how Chelsea: Yeah. I would tell him to walk the line more. It's like that statement, if it were one sentence about Israel, or I'm sorry, one sentence about October seventh and then one sentence condemning Israel, it would be like yikes, but people wouldn't go completely fucking nuts. he just needs to walk it back play both sides and walk it back eighty percent, know? Give a little to Eitan: Yeah. I Chelsea: each group, but not so much that the opposite side notices what you're saying. Like that's what I would tell him to do. Eitan: Do you even but why even I guess my question is like, do you even instruct him to try to like appeal to that original base still? Or is there a group of extremists on that side that are never gonna come over to him? And if I'm him, I try to expand my base kind of like right rather than left. Not that it's right, but like I exp I try to expand my base into the Israel side versus trying to get into the d deeper into the Palestinian side. Cause I feel like there is a left wing group of Palestinian protesters that have decided we're not fucking with you anymore and we're gonna make your life a living hell. We're make your political life a living hell. And there are already people that but this is a new group. And and the Jews there it was already very clear who likes him and who doesn't like him. In my mind, it's it's he tries to go more Israel than Palestine over time. He starts to go more Brad Lander than than Hassan. Chelsea: Maybe, but honestly, Aton, I don't think his heart's in it. I don't think he can handle it. I we saw last night, his heart's not in it. He tried it. Everyone yelled at him. He couldn't handle it. It was on his face that I do think politically that would be the best thing for him to do to mellow out a little bit, moderate, but but you know, his heart's simply not in it. He can't do it. I don't think he can do it. Eitan: He can't do it. His heart isn't there. I also tell him I also if I'm a comms person, I say, Don't talk about it anymore. I'm like, Stop, just don't stop it. Like Chelsea: Yeah. Well, that'll never happen either. I think truly in his heart of hearts, I don't think he came to this issue because it's it happened to be politically advantageous, but I don't I think truly in his heart of hearts he really, really viscerally hates Israel. He's not just hopping on the bandwagon. Eitan: Not it. Chelsea: And so his his spirit is is too consumed by thinking about Israel. Like he's just not able to let it go, even for politics. Eitan: I think that that's I think I think that that is very, very acting. I think that he's been very clear about the hatred of Israel. I also think that he doesn't view himself as anti-Semitic. I think that he has Chelsea: Yeah. Right. Eitan: a you know, he went to Bronx Science. Like, you know, he had a bunch of Jewish friends, I assume. I assume that Israel was a thing that was in his universe but not talked about that much. So he his views on it didn't really have to come out. Most people's views on Israel didn't wasn't really a thing that was important until like four years ago. but yeah, I don't I I don't see him I see him honestly one terming and then continuing to make his thing about Israel, he's not gonna do a second term as a mayor in this current thing. I think that that's honestly the other part to this is that he's starting to realize that there's no way for him to stay in this position and to do the things that he wants to do without getting eaten up. He needs to go into a position where he's able to affect what he should he wants it to fund Israel. He should go and try to do that if he really wants to do that, because right now it just it's gonna eat him up once again over time. Chelsea: Yeah. And being a politician's heart or being mayor's heart. I also think he's maybe contending with that because he's never had a job in his entire life. It's like, this is hard. Eitan: Ha. Yeah. Chelsea: This is stressful. This is like a lot of work. And it's a dealing with like sewage in potholes. And it's not speaking to crowds all day, every day about how much you hate Israel and and getting off on that. And so there also might be some he might have to reckon with that and decide to be like a media, like maybe a reality TV show. I don't know. Eitan: That's coming next. Do you think Chelsea: I don't see him being a public servant, a dutiful public servant for the rest of his life. Eitan: Do you think any of his chat GPT searches are just how does housing work? Or or like, or like, what is a comp troller? I want to know when the Chelsea: I think all of them. All of them are like Yeah, literally. All of them. Eitan: last time he googled what is a comp troller. Dead serious. That should be a that should be a question in every mayoral debate. When is the last time that you go that you Googled what is a comp troller? That should be first question. I can't even tell you. Chelsea: Yeah, I think his Google searches are also just like, How many hours normal work? Question mark. He's just like, wait, what's happening to me? Why do people want things for me all day long? my God. Eitan: Yeah. PT yeah. Yeah, PTO question mark. Yeah. Yeah. When they say nine to five, they literally mean nine to five? That wasn't just a turn of phrase. Chelsea: It's like is that banking hours? Cause only banking people do like what what Eitan: Yeah. Chelsea: what is this? But yeah, I just don't see him ever giving it up. Well what? Eitan: Also I'm doubling down and going No. No, he's gonna he's gonna be Congress. I think that he's gonna he's gonna try to go the AOC path, but AOC is more like mainstream. He's gonna try to become what? Chelsea: But she might quit too. But she might quit too and just be like a media person. I think all these people are gaming Eitan: Yeah. Chelsea: out like, wow, I have 10 million Instagram followers. What if I just did something with that instead of sat through these boring like Congress votes all day, congressional hearings all day? Eitan: You don't think AOC you don't think AOC is gearing up for she's clearly going up gearing up for presidency. you don't think that she's gonna kinda stick in the long haul? Chelsea: Maybe if she wins, but I think they're I think they're gonna kinda reach a crossroads where it's like it's like a w winner takes all situation. I think it's zero sum. It's like they are gonna be president or then they're just gonna start their own media company. And there's the interim of like I'm just gonna be again like a civil servant in the meantime and work towards this thing is not gonna happen. So we'll we'll see. But I do think it'll go either way. Eitan: Yeah. I think she I I think that the issue she's gonna face is the same issue that Bernie Sanders had, where like they're just the centrists are gonna railroad her and then it's gonna take a few what's gonna happen is gonna take a few of her runs, like two or three runs of hers, in order to figure out in order to become centrist, to be completely honest, in order for society to move closer to her. I I do think I I but I don't know. I I think she's gonna be more in the politicians sphere for a long time. I can see Zoran leaving before she does, to be honest. I Chelsea: That's fair. That's fair. I see him leaving before her too. Yeah. Eitan: I don't think he does a second mayoralship. I just I don't think he wants it. I don't I think he's bored. No. Chelsea: No, again, you know, it's like nobody expected him to win, like least of all him. He's like it's like, Why am I here? This was just Eitan: Yeah. Hundred percent. I think Chelsea: this was a publicity stunt gone wrong and now I have to govern. Eitan: I think the only person more surprised the only person more surprised is Rama. She's the most Chelsea: Yeah, truly. Eitan: like I think she hates this. Anyways, we'll talk about that some other time. Chelsea: yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Eitan: Chelsea, any last thoughts about you know, the Zionist occupation of Mamdanistan that we currently live in? Chelsea: I just I can't wait to see how he handles this now. It's like, Eitan: Yeah. Chelsea: what is the next step for Mamdani after a bunch of, you know, his his people went feral and called him a genocidal maniac? Like, does he go to a public event? Does when what's the next protest look like? Does he release Eitan: This Chelsea: a statement saying I I I'm not responsible? Like Eitan: So he so he did I will say that he did give a press conference today and was asked about the booing and stuff like that and gave a very Chelsea: Okay, I didn't see Eitan: milk toast, I respect everyone booing me, all that stuff. But then he says something about there has to be space for Gaza and for the Israelis and all that stuff and just to mourn what happened in Israel and for Gaza. And again, that brings back to the initial point of like, yeah, there was supposed to be a space to mourn both. Unfortunately, you decided to take the Israeli side and fill it three quarters of the way with the Israel with the the Palestinian narrative. So we passed that. But also he knows that. Sometime how old is he? Thirty five? What's what's his age? You older? You younger? God. Chelsea: God, he's old enough to be president, thirty five. Eitan: Yeah, but he's too Senegalese. No, where's he from? Where is he from? Yeah, where is he from again? Chelsea: Watch out. wait, but he wasn't born here. he's from he was born in Africa, which is he's ethnically Pakistani, Eitan: Not Senegal. Was it Senegal? Chelsea: but he was born in Africa and that's why he put that he was African American on his Columbia application. Remember this? Eitan: You that is such that's also DSA bullshit. That is weirdly that's so funny. That is so funny. All right, Chelsea th Chelsea: Yeah, he really did that. That's a fact. He really did that, so anyway, cheers to proud African American Zoramamdani and I hope he Eitan: Look, I am Chelsea: doesn't get screamed at like that again. Eitan: I'm actually starting to identify as a Pakistani American personally, but you know, just to see. I'm planning on mayoral run. Yeah. Chelsea: Yeah, proud. You're Swana, that's what they called it. Southwestern Asian Eitan: As we all know, the New York New York magazine made it very clear there are no Jews in that region at all. Definitely, definitely no Jews at all in that region. All right. Chelsea, thank you so much. Chelsea: Right, right, right. So we probably identify as Swana. Eitan: Thank you so much for hopping on for this quick session. this is been the Jew York Times. First of all, we have a Patreon. Definitely go and donate to the Patreon. October twenty second, 92nd Street. Why? It's gonna be a ton of fun. Chelsea, you got anything you wanna push on on here? You got anything you want to say? Chelsea: just follow me my handles at Chelsea Jacobson. Two N's. 'Cause some bitch has the one N. And won't give it to me. Yeah, yeah. I can't get my actual name. Eitan: Yeah. There. You have two ends at the end of it? Got it, got it. Not in real life. Chelsea: Yeah. Eitan: Not in real life. Chelsea: No, no. Eitan: and for that. we'll see you later in honor of my roommate who ends the show. We're gonna yell the thing that you actually don't know where we're gonna yell, but the end of the show, we end every show by going, Barstool.