Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / XPeng P7 Debut at Munich Auto Show
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep Dive. OK.
- 0:12Today we are strapping ourselves into probably the fastest moving
- 0:17sector out there right now, the electric vehicle market.
- 0:21It's incredible, isn't it? The pace is just relentless.
- 0:24Absolutely. And we've got a real heavyweight
- 0:26bout lined up. We're pitting the well, the
- 0:29established icon, sometimes controversial, the Tesla Model
- 0:323, against a really sleek high tech contender from China, the X
- 0:37Ping P7. Yeah, fascinating matchup.
- 0:40This really feels like more than just comparing 2 cars.
- 0:43It does. It feels like comparing
- 0:44philosophies almost, you know, are you leaning towards that raw
- 0:48kind of minimalist efficiency that Silicon Valley champions?
- 0:51Right the Tesla way. Or are you more drawn to the
- 0:56high end intelligent tech luxury vibe that this new wave of
- 1:01Chinese electric sports salons like the P7 really embodies?
- 1:04Exactly. So if you're listening and you
- 1:06need to cut through all the marketing fluff, get straight to
- 1:08the hard numbers that affect, you know, your wallet and how
- 1:10the car actually feels to drive. Then you're in the right place.
- 1:13You're doing that homework for you today.
- 1:14Our mission, yeah, it's pretty straightforward.
- 1:16We're unpacking a really detailed head to head
- 1:19comparison. We're going beyond the shiny
- 1:21pictures. We're digging into horsepower
- 1:25zero to 100 times the really crucial battery consumption
- 1:29figures. And yes, that all important boot
- 1:31space. And forget the boot space.
- 1:33Never. We're aiming for those specific
- 1:36little Nuggets of info that really set these two, both very
- 1:40capable vehicles apart. OK, let's get into it then, this
- 1:43battle of the Titans. But before we even talk speed
- 1:47and power, we need to talk, well, basics, the entry fee and
- 1:51the actual shape of these cars, because those are fundamental
- 1:54differences right from the start.
- 1:55Absolutely foundational. Let's kick off with the the
- 1:58physical structure. The Model 3.
- 2:00People often call it a sedan, but technically, officially,
- 2:03it's a hatchback. Right, that sweeping fastback
- 2:05roof line, 5 doors. Exactly, and we'll see later how
- 2:07that gives it a massive advantage in practicality.
- 2:10The X Peng P7 on the other hand is strictly a traditional 4 door
- 2:14saloon. OK, simple enough.
- 2:16Now the money and this isn't a small gap, is it, Especially
- 2:19when we look at the entry level models using UK and EU figures.
- 2:23No, it's quite significant. The Model 3 really positions
- 2:26itself as the Gateway EV here it starts notably lower.
- 2:30You're looking at around 34,300 lbs or 42,400 and 9000.
- 2:36OK. And the P7 the.
- 2:38P 7 steps onto the stage asking for a premium right away.
- 2:41It's entry prices quite a jump starting at 42,500 lbs or 49,600
- 2:46back. Wow.
- 2:47OK. So for anyone just starting
- 2:49their comparison, the Model 3 clearly offers a well a much
- 2:51easier financial entry point. It's a substantial advantage,
- 2:54yeah, right out of the. Gate.
- 2:55So if the P7 is asking for roughly 8000 lbs or what, €7000
- 2:59more to start, it really has to bring something extra to the
- 3:03table, doesn't it? Something tangible to justify
- 3:06that leap. It absolutely has to earn that
- 3:07premium. You know, the M3 seems to be
- 3:09betting on its efficiency, its software ecosystem and that
- 3:11lower entry price. Yeah, the P7 is signaling
- 3:14luxury, maybe a sense of scale, more traditional comfort
- 3:17perhaps. And the big question becomes,
- 3:20does the performance or the size or the tech actually justify
- 3:24that significantly higher starting cost?
- 3:26OK, now for the fun part. Let's get into the raw numbers
- 3:29for the driver whose first thought is always who wins the
- 3:32Drag Race. Right.
- 3:34Well, if your absolute priority is raw, blistering peak
- 3:38horsepower and the highest possible top speed, then the
- 3:41Model 3 is the clear winner in this particular fight.
- 3:43No contest. In its top specs, no.
- 3:45We're talking up to 627 horsepower.
- 3:48That allows for a top speed of 262 kilometers per hour.
- 3:51And the 0100 kilometer acceleration, it's just
- 3:55staggering 3.1 seconds. That's insane.
- 3:57Proper electric punch. It's pure unadulterated electric
- 4:00violence, as you say. Now the XP-7 is quick, don't get
- 4:03me wrong, very quick for a saloon, but it objectively
- 4:06trails behind those top tier Tesla numbers.
- 4:08The P7 maxes out a 473 horsepower, It's top speed is
- 4:12limited to 200 kilometers and it's fastest 0100 kilometer a
- 4:15time is 4.1 seconds. Still very rapid obviously, but
- 4:19yeah, a clear step behind the Model 3 is Ultimate Performance
- 4:21variant. Correct.
- 4:22However, there's a really interesting twist when we look
- 4:26beyond just horsepower and focus on torque.
- 4:30Torque, the twisty force. Exactly that rotational force,
- 4:34the shove that pushes you back in your seat when you accelerate
- 4:37from a standstill. So wait, are you saying that
- 4:39even though it has less total horsepower, the P7 might
- 4:41actually feel punchier off the line in like normal driving?
- 4:45That's precisely it. While the Model 3 leads
- 4:48decisively in peak HP, the X Peng P7 offers a substantially
- 4:52higher peak torque figure. The Model 3's torque range goes
- 4:56up to about 660 Newton meters OK.
- 4:58The P7 range, though, climbs all the way to 757 Newton meters.
- 5:03Wow, that's a big difference. So what does that mean in
- 5:05practice? Well, it means the P7 with that
- 5:07higher maximum pork likely delivers a more robust immediate
- 5:11shove right from low speeds. It gives you a different kind of
- 5:14fun driving experience. Right, that instant effortless
- 5:16surge you feel when the traffic light goes green.
- 5:18Exactly, even if you know it might run out of steam earlier
- 5:22than the top spec Tesla at much higher speeds, it suggests the
- 5:26P7 might be tuned more for that immediate real world Rd.
- 5:30excitement rather than setting ultimate track lap times.
- 5:33That's a critical point. HP wins the bragging rights for
- 5:36top speed, maybe, but high torque often feels more
- 5:39relevant, more satisfying in everyday driving.
- 5:42It really does that traffic light Sprint, that feeling of
- 5:44instant readiness when you're commuting.
- 5:47Higher peak torque delivers that.
- 5:48OK, performance is thrilling, but let's talk about the EV
- 5:52reality check efficiency. This is where things get really
- 5:56critical for long term ownership.
- 5:58Running costs the whole experience.
- 6:00Absolutely. And when we look at energy
- 6:01consumption, how much energy these cars use per 100
- 6:04kilometers, the Model 3's engineering efficiency really
- 6:07comes to the. Forefront, it's noticeably
- 6:09better. Oh yes, the M3 is significantly
- 6:11more efficient. Its consumption starts at a
- 6:13really impressive 13.2 kilowaters per 100 kilometers,
- 6:17according to the specs. 13.2 OK and AP7.
- 6:20The P7, well, it uses quite a bit more energy.
- 6:23Its consumption starts at 16.8 kilowaters per 100 kilometers
- 6:28and that can climb up over 19 kilowaters for some versions.
- 6:30So right at the baseline, that's a 3.6 kilowatt order difference
- 6:35per 100 kilometers. That's that's actually quite a
- 6:37tangible gap over the life of the car, isn't it?
- 6:39It absolutely is. It directly impacts your running
- 6:41costs and this leads us into a sort of efficiency paradox when
- 6:45we look at the range figures. Well, the Model 3 uses various
- 6:48battery pack sizes, right, ranging from about 62 up to 79
- 6:52kilowaters. And with those, it achieves a
- 6:54maximum WLTP range that's just eye watering up to 702
- 6:59kilometers. 702 kilometers, that's huge range.
- 7:01It really is class leading. Now compare that to the P7X.
- 7:04Peng doesn't offer different battery sizes for the P7.
- 7:06It comes with one single quite large battery, 82.70 kilowaters.
- 7:10OK, bigger battery than the Tesla's largest option.
- 7:13Correct, but despite having this significantly larger single
- 7:16battery capacity, its maximum WLTP range is only 576
- 7:21kilometers. Hang on, that doesn't
- 7:23immediately make sense. How can the Model 3, potentially
- 7:26running on a smaller 62 kilowatt battery, achieve so much more
- 7:30range and better efficiency than the P7 with its big 82.7
- 7:34kilowatt pack? It really boils down to the
- 7:37Model 3's mastery of, well, basic physics and overall
- 7:40engineering efficiency. The M3 is simply a smaller,
- 7:43lighter car. It's shorter, about 4720mm long,
- 7:48and it's curb weight starts down around 18122 kilograms.
- 7:52Less mass to move, potentially better energy regeneration, and
- 7:56crucially, very optimized aerodynamics.
- 7:58So the P7 is just fighting against its own size and weight.
- 8:01Essentially, yes. The P7 is the physically bigger
- 8:05vehicle overall. It's nearly four inches longer,
- 8:074888mm it's wider and consequently it's heavier, often
- 8:12tipping the scales over 2000 kilograms.
- 8:14That extra mass combined with the aerodynamic profile of a
- 8:17more traditional saloon compared to the M3 slippery fastback
- 8:20shape, it just means the P7 is that massive 82.7 kilowatt
- 8:24battery just to get a respectable range figure.
- 8:26It's burning more energy, just moving itself through the.
- 8:28UR precisely that really highlights the M3's advantage in
- 8:31fundamental design efficiency. OK, we've hammered the technical
- 8:34stuff. Let's switch gears a bit to more
- 8:36lifestyle factors. Practicality, you know.
- 8:40What about checking the weekly shop in the back or packing for
- 8:43a weekend away? Ah, yes, the practicality
- 8:45question. And this is where that hatchback
- 8:47design for the Model 3, the one we mentioned right at the start,
- 8:49pays off massively. How big a difference are we
- 8:52talking? Huge.
- 8:53When you compare the boot space, the Model 3 has a massive,
- 8:56really usable 594 liters. 594 OK, and the P7 being a saloon.
- 9:02It offers a perfectly decent saloon boot, but it's much
- 9:05smaller, 440 liters. So it's 154 liters difference.
- 9:09That's not trivial. Not at all. 154 liters is the
- 9:11difference between easily fitting say a bulky travel
- 9:15stroller plus luggage, or having to make tough choices about what
- 9:18you leave behind. For sheer real world utility
- 9:21getting stuff in and out, the Model 3 is just superior purely
- 9:25because of that body style and the huge opening.
- 9:27It's funny though, because a P7 is the physically bigger car
- 9:31overall. It's longer, it's wider, 1896mm
- 9:34width. So you might actually feel like
- 9:35you have more space inside the cabin, right?
- 9:37More shoulder room or leg room? That's likely the trade off.
- 9:40Yes, the P7 probably prioritizes passenger space and maybe a more
- 9:45traditional sense of interior roominess by being physically
- 9:48larger and heavier. But the Model 3's clever design
- 9:52just maximizes the cargo space within its footprint.
- 9:55So as a buyer, you have to decide, do you prioritize
- 9:58carrying more people and slightly more comfort or
- 10:01carrying significantly more stuff?
- 10:03A classic car buying dilemma. OK, we've crunched the cold hard
- 10:07numbers. Now let's talk about the less
- 10:09tangible stuff. The vibe.
- 10:11What's the feeling when you actually climb inside these
- 10:13cars? Right.
- 10:14The subjective experience, Well, the Tesla Model 3 vibe is it's
- 10:18purely futuristic. It's uncompromisingly tech
- 10:20first. That big screen dominates
- 10:22everything. Completely.
- 10:23You step into this cabin defined by its minimalism.
- 10:26There's no traditional instrument cluster behind the
- 10:28wheel, very few physical buttons.
- 10:30Everything relies on that massive central touch screen.
- 10:33Yeah, it's all about the software experience, those
- 10:35constant over the year, updates, improving things and the
- 10:38state-of-the-art autopilot system.
- 10:40It really feels like you're driving a very capable large
- 10:42gadget. OK, so pure tech focus, what
- 10:45about the X Peng P7 given its higher price?
- 10:48What's the experience like there?
- 10:50The P7 feels like it's trying to strike more of a balance.
- 10:53It blends advanced technology with a more traditional luxury
- 10:56cabin feel. So less stark minimalism.
- 10:59Definitely. Instead of absolute minimalism,
- 11:02the P7 seems to aim for a sense of serenity, maybe luxury.
- 11:07You're greeted with premium feeling materials, softer touch
- 11:10surfaces, generally a more conventionally designed
- 11:13dashboard layout. But still techie.
- 11:15Oh yes, it features an intelligent cockpit, advanced
- 11:18AI, voice interaction systems, sophisticated driver assist,
- 11:22features ADS. But it delivers all that tech
- 11:25within a framework that feels more familiar, perhaps more
- 11:28upscale and conventionally sophisticated, like a premium
- 11:31European saloon. That's a really neat way to put
- 11:33it. So the M3 is basically saying
- 11:35trust the screen, trust the software, this is the future.
- 11:39Whereas the P7 is saying, here's all our cutting edge tech, but
- 11:42we've wrapped it in the kind of comfort and materials you'd
- 11:44expect at this price point. Exactly that, and it's worth
- 11:47noting both cars achieve the highest CO2 efficiency Class A
- 11:50rating, which is excellent for the environment.
- 11:53But yeah, the M3 offers that functional, almost Spartan
- 11:57digital future, while the P7 offers a more cushioned, perhaps
- 12:02more traditionally luxurious technological future.
- 12:05That was a fantastic breakdown. OK, so for you listening, trying
- 12:08to maybe make that final decision, let's try and
- 12:10summarize this quickly. Good idea.
- 12:12If your top priorities are the entry level price point, getting
- 12:16the absolute maximum peak performance figures, that crazy
- 12:19HP and acceleration, incredible energy efficiency, and just
- 12:22massive versus storage space. Well, the Tesla Model 3 seems to
- 12:26hold the clear edge doesn't. It it really does on those
- 12:29specific metrics. However, if you're perhaps
- 12:32looking for a physically larger car, maybe one that prioritizes
- 12:35that higher peak low end torque for punchy daily driving.
- 12:38Yeah, that traffic light Grand Prix feel.
- 12:40Exactly. And if you want a car that
- 12:43balances the advanced tech with more premium interior finishes,
- 12:47focusing on a luxurious, comfortable cockpit experience,
- 12:51then the Xping P7 is a seriously compelling alternative.
- 12:54And you can see how it justifies that higher price tag for
- 12:57certain buyers. Makes sense.
- 12:59Now for that final provocative thought we'd like to leave you
- 13:01with. We noticed something interesting
- 13:03about the batteries. The X Ping P7 uses just one
- 13:07single substantial battery size across its range, that 82.70
- 13:12dollar unit. Right.
- 13:13One-size-fits-all, basically. Whereas the Tesla Model 3 offers
- 13:16a range of battery capacities from that smaller 62 kilowatt
- 13:19Watt pack up to the 79 kilowatt Watt.
- 13:22This allows Tesla to segment their pricing and performance
- 13:24levels very finely. Doesn't.
- 13:26It it absolutely does. So thinking about things like
- 13:30supply chain management, manufacturing complexity,
- 13:32overall market strategy, what does this difference tell you?
- 13:35Yeah. What does it suggest about how?
- 13:36These one strategy emphasizes flexibility, using different
- 13:40batteries to hit various price points and performance tiers.
- 13:43The other focuses on standardizing with a single high
- 13:46capacity battery. It's quite a fascinating
- 13:48reflection of their broader business philosophies, isn't it?
- 13:51It really is something to definitely Mull over as you
- 13:54compare your next set of EV specs.
- 13:57OK, that wraps up our deep dive today.
- 13:59Thank you so much for joining us for this electric.
- 14:01Showdown a pleasure. And if you enjoyed unpacking
- 14:04these comparisons with us digging into those crucial
- 14:07details, please make sure you follow the channel so you don't
- 14:10miss our next explorations.