Latest / Bloomberg Law / Ex-Banker's Fate Sealed by Best Friend's Testimony
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: So, how long have you.
- 0:10Speaker 3: Known mister Depp?
- 0:11Speaker 4: How many years it's gotta be over forty and from eighty.
- 0:15Speaker 3: Two to now? And before four years ago, were you
- 0:18Speaker 3: close friends?
- 0:20Speaker 4: Yeah? It was a zero my best friend.
- 0:22Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 0:23Speaker 3: Was he like a brother to you before four years ago?
- 0:25Speaker 2: I mean, yeah, we were brothers.
- 0:27Speaker 5: You would call me a brother, I'd call him a brother.
- 0:29Speaker 2: Yeah.
- 0:29Speaker 1: You might remember when Johnny Depp's former best friend Bruce
- 0:33Speaker 1: Whitkin testified against him. That was a defamation case where
- 0:38Speaker 1: the verdict meant money damages. But what about a case
- 0:41Speaker 1: where a former best friend's testimony leads to prison time.
- 0:45Speaker 1: That's exactly what happened when former Barclay's trader Okshane Naran
- 0:50Speaker 1: John testified against former Goldman banker Brigesh Goyle, who was
- 0:54Speaker 1: once his best friend, his classmate, his groomsman, his squash
- 0:58Speaker 1: partner and wingman, and the author of an insider trading
- 1:02Speaker 1: scheme that's upended both of their lives. Neuron John's testimony
- 1:07Speaker 1: basically sealed Goyle's fate. After just three hours of deliberations,
- 1:12Speaker 1: a New York jury returned a verdict against Goyle guilty
- 1:16Speaker 1: on all charges. Joining me is Greg Farrell, Bloomberg Legal reporter,
- 1:21Speaker 1: tell us about this case, what it was about.
- 1:23Speaker 3: It's an insider trading case and it was charged a
- 1:25Speaker 3: year ago by prosecutors here in Manhattan, and a few
- 1:28Speaker 3: things struck me as unusual about it. First of all,
- 1:31Speaker 3: the evidence that was in the indictment. I think it
- 1:33Speaker 3: was July of last year when this indictment came down,
- 1:35Speaker 3: had evidence like as recently as early June, May and June,
- 1:39Speaker 3: so obviously they'd gotten evidence and then charged it within weeks,
- 1:42Speaker 3: which is highly unusual. Secondly, it's an insider trading case,
- 1:46Speaker 3: and the cooperator, the guy who actually did the trading
- 1:49Speaker 3: and kept the profits for the most part, wasn't charged,
- 1:53Speaker 3: which is unusual. And then thirdly, I did a little
- 1:55Speaker 3: feature on them a year ago because they played squash together.
- 1:57Speaker 3: They were best buddies, their wife's social eye, you know,
- 2:00Speaker 3: they traveled together, they went to concerts, you know, in
- 2:03Speaker 3: Belgium that famously, and one of them was a groomsman
- 2:06Speaker 3: of the other at his wedding. So these guys were
- 2:08Speaker 3: very tight. They're from India and they met at the
- 2:11Speaker 3: high school of Business at UC Berkeley, and they both
- 2:14Speaker 3: came to New York and they were strivers. The sad
- 2:17Speaker 3: thing is they made it they were here. One of
- 2:19Speaker 3: them was a VP at Goldman Sachs and then he
- 2:21Speaker 3: went became a principal at Apollo, and the other one
- 2:24Speaker 3: was an FX trader at Barclay's. People come from all
- 2:27Speaker 3: over the world to work on Wall Street, and you know,
- 2:29Speaker 3: these guys did everything by the book. They went to
- 2:30Speaker 3: the best university in India, they went to Berkeley, and
- 2:33Speaker 3: then they got to Wall Street and then it was
- 2:36Speaker 3: like the gang that couldn't shoot straight. You know. They
- 2:38Speaker 3: had a few trades that you know, the first one
- 2:41Speaker 3: that was charged inside of trading, they made two thousand
- 2:44Speaker 3: dollars on it, and then the second one was over thirty. Okay,
- 2:47Speaker 3: that's better. It was the one that made two hundred
- 2:49Speaker 3: and forty five thousand that caught the attention of the
- 2:52Speaker 3: sec and eventually led to this.
- 2:54Speaker 1: Did Nurajah maintain that he didn't know at first that
- 2:58Speaker 1: Goyle was using insight in from.
- 3:00Speaker 3: So that's what I was looking forward to learning in
- 3:03Speaker 3: the trial is how did this come about? Why did
- 3:06Speaker 3: prosecutors in Manhattan who were very tough and rigid on
- 3:08Speaker 3: inside of trading. How did they let this guy go?
- 3:11Speaker 3: And the story that Akshay told on the stand was
- 3:14Speaker 3: this that he had breached. Both these guys breached their
- 3:18Speaker 3: own rules like the venial sin, not the capital crime.
- 3:22Speaker 3: Akhay was an FX trader at Barclay's and he wanted
- 3:26Speaker 3: to trade in options and he was not allowed to
- 3:28Speaker 3: because he was involved with options at Barclay's. But he
- 3:30Speaker 3: set up an account in the name of his brother
- 3:32Speaker 3: who was in the UK and traded there. And when
- 3:35Speaker 3: his friend Goyle heard about this, he thought that was
- 3:38Speaker 3: very interesting. He was intrigued like that, you know, his
- 3:41Speaker 3: friend had figured out a way to do some trading
- 3:44Speaker 3: and what Okhay was trading on was not inside information.
- 3:47Speaker 3: He came up with an algorithm that would chase market
- 3:49Speaker 3: trends and try to beat the market, and of course
- 3:51Speaker 3: it didn't. And according to his testimony, when Goyle found
- 3:54Speaker 3: out about this, he said, forget the algorithm. That's like,
- 3:57Speaker 3: you know, trying to find a needle in a haystack.
- 3:58Speaker 3: And according to Naranja and the cooperator, Goyle said, I
- 4:02Speaker 3: have good insights on the market and I'll help you
- 4:05Speaker 3: I'll give you some advice on things to buy, et cetera.
- 4:07Speaker 3: And then there came in the year twenty seventeen a
- 4:10Speaker 3: series of suggestions, why don't you buy some options in Loomos.
- 4:15Speaker 3: You know, it's looking good to me, And sure enough,
- 4:18Speaker 3: a month later Loumos was acquired and there was a gain,
- 4:21Speaker 3: a modest gain of two thousand. But then a series
- 4:24Speaker 3: of other tips came in, and on the stand, Naranjan
- 4:28Speaker 3: talked about how he really felt something wrong here. This
- 4:31Speaker 3: guy's getting this two exact too many times, and he'd
- 4:36Speaker 3: pester Goyle like we insider trading, do you know something?
- 4:39Speaker 3: And no, no, not at all, not at all, and
- 4:42Speaker 3: would again keep to his story that this is just
- 4:44Speaker 3: stuff he's picking up. But in fact, prosecutors showed he
- 4:48Speaker 3: was still getting emails from the firm wide capital Committee,
- 4:50Speaker 3: which is highly confidential stuff at Goldman, about what deals
- 4:53Speaker 3: are coming in the pipeline and things that are restricted,
- 4:56Speaker 3: and so he'd get a good heads up, you know,
- 4:58Speaker 3: weeks or sometimes days in advance chants of companies that
- 5:01Speaker 3: were going to be acquired. So there was a series
- 5:03Speaker 3: of six of these trades that were charged, and then
- 5:06Speaker 3: every one of them, you know. The prosecutors demonstrated that
- 5:08Speaker 3: the memo arrived on let's say, the first of the month,
- 5:12Speaker 3: saying that there'd be a deal within the next few weeks,
- 5:14Speaker 3: and then shortly thereafter Goyle would get in touch with
- 5:17Speaker 3: his friend and say, you know, let's talk, Let's have
- 5:19Speaker 3: a drink tonight. Goyle was very careful not to spell
- 5:22Speaker 3: anything out in texts or in email, so it was
- 5:24Speaker 3: only person to person. He never texted and said buy
- 5:28Speaker 3: some options in Loumos or buy some options in Thermo
- 5:31Speaker 3: King or whatever. It was always face to face meetings
- 5:34Speaker 3: and akshay Niron John that the Barkley's trader was accumulating profits,
- 5:38Speaker 3: but there was no splitting it. They had agreed at
- 5:40Speaker 3: first they would split whatever came out of this joint venture,
- 5:43Speaker 3: but it wasn't until twenty twenty one Nearrojen had moved
- 5:46Speaker 3: to London and then come back change jobs, and finally
- 5:50Speaker 3: Goyle asked him for a loan of eighty five thousand dollars,
- 5:53Speaker 3: carefully phrased in one of those text messages so you
- 5:56Speaker 3: couldn't quite tell or in his email what the loan
- 5:59Speaker 3: was for. And the government charged that this was basically
- 6:02Speaker 3: the payback for his half of the spoils. They made
- 6:05Speaker 3: about two hundred and eighty thousand dollars in illicit profits,
- 6:08Speaker 3: but they also blew some money still with the algorithm
- 6:11Speaker 3: other stuff, so that wasn't the total, it wasn't half
- 6:14Speaker 3: of that.
- 6:14Speaker 1: So without Neurangen, would there have been a case against Goyle.
- 6:19Speaker 3: No, And this is the thing about this, and if
- 6:21Speaker 3: it weren't for what Nourangen did and the way he testified,
- 6:26Speaker 3: I suspect his wife was all over him and said,
- 6:28Speaker 3: you've got to make this right. And by the time
- 6:31Speaker 3: the FBI came calling on Goyle and Neurangen early last year,
- 6:35Speaker 3: in like May of twenty twenty two, by the time
- 6:38Speaker 3: it came around, Nouranngen decided he was going to record
- 6:42Speaker 3: one of the conversations. This was actually dramatic testimony. The
- 6:45Speaker 3: first time they spoke, they were talking about like, are
- 6:47Speaker 3: there any incriminating messages or what's going on here? What
- 6:50Speaker 3: can we get rid of? And Goyle had deleted most
- 6:52Speaker 3: everything any switch jobs, so he didn't have his text
- 6:55Speaker 3: from a few years before, but Nouranngen did. And the
- 6:58Speaker 3: second time they met, Goyle was very careful not to
- 7:01Speaker 3: reach out to him directly, but to have the receptionist
- 7:03Speaker 3: at the health club in the building where they both
- 7:06Speaker 3: lived call up and relay a message please bring down
- 7:09Speaker 3: my swim goggles. I left them there, something innocuous that
- 7:11Speaker 3: could not be traced, and a phone call that wouldn't
- 7:13Speaker 3: be from him. He spent a lot of time making
- 7:15Speaker 3: sure there are no fingerprints on the contacts like that.
- 7:17Speaker 3: They would only meet face to face. So at some
- 7:20Speaker 3: point when the rangine didn't respond, Goyle sent his wife
- 7:22Speaker 3: to knock on the door, and so they finally had
- 7:24Speaker 3: to meet. Goyle brings him into a stairwell because there's
- 7:26Speaker 3: no cameras in the stairwell, and we saw evidence of
- 7:29Speaker 3: photos from the elevator and common spaces, but he wanted
- 7:32Speaker 3: to be out of side of a camera. He made
- 7:33Speaker 3: an Aranchin put his own phone, shut it off and
- 7:35Speaker 3: put it on the stairwell behind a cement block so
- 7:38Speaker 3: they couldn't be traced. And then they started talking in
- 7:40Speaker 3: specific details about messages, and Naranjen had his wife's cell
- 7:44Speaker 3: phone and was recording, and Arranchin testified it started like
- 7:48Speaker 3: vibrating while he was there, like his wife was getting
- 7:50Speaker 3: a call and he didn't know how to do it,
- 7:52Speaker 3: so he somehow turned it off, so we only got
- 7:55Speaker 3: a partial recording. So having gone that far, he went
- 7:58Speaker 3: to the FBI, and the FBI I wired him up
- 8:01Speaker 3: properly for the next meeting a week later, and that's
- 8:03Speaker 3: where Goyle started saying, Oh, these messages are terrible. We
- 8:06Speaker 3: got to delete this, delete that, and Goyle himself started
- 8:08Speaker 3: deleting messages.
- 8:10Speaker 1: Was their tension in the courtroom when he was on
- 8:12Speaker 1: the stand. Was Goyle glaring.
- 8:14Speaker 3: Was he was glaring at him and at one point
- 8:16Speaker 3: I'm just giving him. I'm not sure it'd be a
- 8:18Speaker 3: death stare because the jury could see that. But I'm
- 8:20Speaker 3: behind the defendant. You know where the reporters sit, so
- 8:23Speaker 3: I couldn't doubt. But clearly he was locked in on it.
- 8:25Speaker 3: And clearly his decision to testify in his own behalf,
- 8:28Speaker 3: which is very risky, was a sign that they thought
- 8:31Speaker 3: they had to get him out there, and it was
- 8:33Speaker 3: largely his decision. I'm told that he wanted it. It
- 8:35Speaker 3: could have gone either way. You know, defense lawyer's offering counsel,
- 8:38Speaker 3: be careful unless you really want to go, and I
- 8:40Speaker 3: think he said, yeah, I really want to go testify,
- 8:42Speaker 3: and he comported himself really well, here's the thing. The
- 8:45Speaker 3: main lawyer for Goyle, Read Brodsky of Gibson Dunn, used
- 8:49Speaker 3: to be a prosecutor in that office and he won
- 8:51Speaker 3: some of the famous insider trading cases brought on Great
- 8:53Speaker 3: Baher a decade ago. So he was the right guy
- 8:56Speaker 3: for something like this, and he presented circumstantial evidence showing
- 9:01Speaker 3: that Nourangen, the other guy, could actually have overheard. These
- 9:04Speaker 3: guys were so close that he could have overheard Goldman conversations.
- 9:07Speaker 3: He could have, you know, because they knew each other's
- 9:09Speaker 3: passwords to the phones when they're playing Spotify or whatever.
- 9:12Speaker 3: Could have There was reasonable doubt baked into it. The
- 9:15Speaker 3: problem was, even though it's possible that several of the
- 9:19Speaker 3: trades could have been explained by that, you can't explain
- 9:21Speaker 3: the deleting of the texts. You can't explain the obstruction.
- 9:24Speaker 3: There's no story you can concoct that will reasonably explain
- 9:29Speaker 3: why a guy is being invested by the FBI. Start saying, Okay,
- 9:31Speaker 3: we're going to delete some of these messages. This is
- 9:33Speaker 3: really bad exploitive, exploitive exploit It's just clear and once
- 9:37Speaker 3: you see that, all the rest of the inside of
- 9:38Speaker 3: trading falls into place, like, yeah, he had to have
- 9:41Speaker 3: done it because the obstruction tells the story.
- 9:44Speaker 1: Did he explain why he was there testifying again to yes.
- 9:48Speaker 3: So that's a big part of it is the introduction
- 9:50Speaker 3: he talks about and said, you know, we were close friends.
- 9:54Speaker 3: I looked up to him. He was my mentor. Because
- 9:56Speaker 3: Goyle was a few years older he was he seemed
- 9:59Speaker 3: more mature. I spent some time last year looking through
- 10:01Speaker 3: all the social media postings, particularly Neuragen had a lot
- 10:04Speaker 3: of them, and his wife had a lot of them,
- 10:05Speaker 3: so I got to know them virtually, including photos from
- 10:08Speaker 3: their wedding, based on how publicly they were sharing in
- 10:11Speaker 3: their lives, unlike Goyle and his wife, who would very
- 10:14Speaker 3: few outside of a photo from the Tomorrowland concert in Belgium.
- 10:17Speaker 3: I don't think Goyle had much on his social media
- 10:19Speaker 3: sites before they shut them all down. So Naranjin talked
- 10:22Speaker 3: about this, and the way he talked about it was
- 10:25Speaker 3: it was definitely a big brother, little brother relationship, and
- 10:27Speaker 3: clearly the FBI and the federal prosecutors in Manhattan agreed.
- 10:31Speaker 3: They thought, you know, he doesn't deserve to get charged.
- 10:33Speaker 3: He made the case by bringing in the original tape
- 10:35Speaker 3: and then sending it, so the case would not have
- 10:38Speaker 3: occurred without Nourangen cooperating or coming in like that, or
- 10:42Speaker 3: if it did, the FBI would have really put them
- 10:44Speaker 3: both through the ringer and would have spent much more time.
- 10:46Speaker 1: I mean, how did he explain why he did that?
- 10:49Speaker 1: Was he afraid?
- 10:50Speaker 3: Yes, he was afraid, and he'd suspecting it was insider
- 10:53Speaker 3: trading all along, according to his testimony, and it was
- 10:55Speaker 3: just dirty, stinky his words, something like that, insider trading.
- 11:00Speaker 3: And I kept gnawing at him, and he couldn't share
- 11:03Speaker 3: it with his wife because he knew that she would
- 11:05Speaker 3: be down on him for this. So that was interesting.
- 11:07Speaker 3: The portrait of the cooperator is, if not a broken man,
- 11:11Speaker 3: a guy was you know, he knows his career and
- 11:13Speaker 3: finance is over. And he spoke softly and there was contrition,
- 11:17Speaker 3: and you couldn't detect any animosity on the Branchin's part
- 11:20Speaker 3: towards his former best friend. It was just it was sad.
- 11:23Speaker 1: And basically Goyle just denied everything.
- 11:25Speaker 3: Yes, And he struck me as sort of like, Okay,
- 11:28Speaker 3: this guy, you know, has succeeded he's at Goldman, he
- 11:30Speaker 3: knows how to manage himself, and he's on the stand
- 11:33Speaker 3: and he's saying absolutely, not that never happened, etc. No,
- 11:36Speaker 3: not at all, And he kept having plausible excuses for
- 11:40Speaker 3: things that happened, except for the obstruction, where it was
- 11:43Speaker 3: less plausible. It's just why panic, that's all. I just panicked.
- 11:46Speaker 3: And the prosecutors cross examined him and put him through
- 11:49Speaker 3: the ringer and said, you know, you've been lying here,
- 11:51Speaker 3: not really. And maybe the moment that really turned this
- 11:54Speaker 3: from being something where it would have taken maybe a
- 11:56Speaker 3: couple of days of deliberations before Friday verdict or a
- 12:00Speaker 3: possible hung jury was the government's rebuttal after a great
- 12:03Speaker 3: closing argument by Ribrodsky, the former insider trading prosecutor turned
- 12:07Speaker 3: defense lawyer, raising all sorts of reasonable doubt possibilities. After that,
- 12:12Speaker 3: one of the government's prosecutors, and Sam Rothschild did an
- 12:15Speaker 3: excellent job with the rebuttal, just saying, you know, come on,
- 12:18Speaker 3: the simplest explanation is what controls here? And what's the
- 12:21Speaker 3: simplest explanation. How does this all fit? And he said,
- 12:24Speaker 3: these lawyers you've heardgested they're great, you know, I think
- 12:26Speaker 3: they're terrific too, but they can't perform magic. They can't
- 12:29Speaker 3: make these facts go away. You know, he clearly connected
- 12:32Speaker 3: with them for them to turn around and give him
- 12:34Speaker 3: a verdict.
- 12:35Speaker 1: How long was the jury out?
- 12:37Speaker 3: Oh? Three hours. I'm glad I didn't place a wager
- 12:39Speaker 3: on this because they went in midday on Wednesday, like
- 12:42Speaker 3: a twelve thirty, and I thought, okay, there reasonable doubt here.
- 12:45Speaker 3: It's at least going to go to Thursday. You got
- 12:46Speaker 3: to give the guy like the respect of thinking about
- 12:49Speaker 3: it for a few hours. And a note came out
- 12:51Speaker 3: around three forty five, so several of us went up
- 12:53Speaker 3: to the courtroom and instead of asking for testimony, it said,
- 12:56Speaker 3: but you have a verdict, and it's like, you know,
- 12:57Speaker 3: he's dead. Three hours and the jury they got along
- 13:01Speaker 3: very well. You could tell just the chemistry. They're all
- 13:02Speaker 3: sort of laughing and joking with each other. There wasn't
- 13:04Speaker 3: any evidence of what you need to get a hung jury,
- 13:07Speaker 3: which at a certain point I'm sure the defense wanted
- 13:09Speaker 3: is someone who can be obstinate, someone who can dig in,
- 13:12Speaker 3: someone who doesn't really fit in. Well, that sometimes helps.
- 13:15Speaker 3: There didn't seem to be any evidence of that. Yeah,
- 13:17Speaker 3: they all got along well. But when the verdict came in,
- 13:20Speaker 3: the jury foreman got up and said, we've reached verdict.
- 13:23Speaker 3: Youre on. I'm guilty on all six counts. And then
- 13:25Speaker 3: the judge makes sure he pulls each of the twelve jurors,
- 13:28Speaker 3: and one after the I said yes guilty. They got
- 13:30Speaker 3: to number eleven, and this woman like, paused, I need
- 13:34Speaker 3: a moment, and she was almost tearing up, and she said, like,
- 13:38Speaker 3: I had trouble hearing it, but please give me a second.
- 13:41Speaker 3: And then after like almost a full minute, she said,
- 13:45Speaker 3: yes guilty. You could tell she was having trouble with this,
- 13:48Speaker 3: and I thought, that's kind of weird, and yet not
- 13:51Speaker 3: because this is a sad story, and you develop empathy
- 13:53Speaker 3: for a defendant. You know he's there every day, and
- 13:56Speaker 3: even though the evidence is there, I could understand after
- 13:58Speaker 3: the fact what probably happened. If they're in the jury
- 14:01Speaker 3: room and eleven of the twelve are clearly like, yeah,
- 14:04Speaker 3: this is clear, and she agrees intellectually she knows it,
- 14:08Speaker 3: but it's just tough emotionally because even though the judge
- 14:11Speaker 3: says you're not to think of the punishment at all,
- 14:13Speaker 3: you're just here to judge the facts and whether or
- 14:15Speaker 3: not the defend communities crimes. It's clear what's going to
- 14:17Speaker 3: happen to this guy. You know, he's going to go
- 14:19Speaker 3: to jail, and I think she probably had trouble with that.
- 14:21Speaker 1: So how much time is he facing.
- 14:23Speaker 3: Well, the maximum prison term for some of these insative
- 14:25Speaker 3: trading and securities fraud cases is twenty years. There's no
- 14:28Speaker 3: way he'll get that. I suspect a few years. However,
- 14:31Speaker 3: he testified and it's clear the jury, you know, agreed
- 14:35Speaker 3: with the government that he was lying. So the judge
- 14:37Speaker 3: won't like that that you're in my courtroom and you lied.
- 14:40Speaker 3: You know, judges don't like that. So that's a negative.
- 14:42Speaker 3: That will add something to it, a lack of contrition
- 14:45Speaker 3: unless he somehow comes around now and prays for mercy,
- 14:48Speaker 3: which is tough to do after you've just testified. You know.
- 14:51Speaker 3: In some ways, Goyle struck me a bit like to
- 14:54Speaker 3: go back. I know you and I've talked about en
- 14:55Speaker 3: round before. Jeff Skilling a very bright guy who was
- 14:58Speaker 3: sort of cornered by some facts and tried, you know,
- 15:02Speaker 3: and was bred enough to argue his way out or
- 15:04Speaker 3: try to argue his way out of some of them,
- 15:06Speaker 3: but it just didn't work. And at the end, you know,
- 15:09Speaker 3: you lose that when you're a judge at sentencing time,
- 15:12Speaker 3: you don't have sympathy for a guy who clearly was
- 15:14Speaker 3: not truthful in your court.
- 15:16Speaker 1: It is such a sad case, friends turning against each other.
- 15:20Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Greg, That's Bloomberg Legal reporter Greg Farrell.
- 15:25Speaker 4: This case has been extremely complex, involving a coordinated international,
- 15:30Speaker 4: interagency and private sector response and an unforgiving and difficult
- 15:36Speaker 4: to access region of the ocean.
- 15:39Speaker 1: The Coastguard has officially convened a Marine Board of Investigation,
- 15:43Speaker 1: or MBI, into the cause of the deadly implosion of
- 15:46Speaker 1: a titan submersible on its way down to the Titanic.
- 15:50Speaker 1: All five people on board died, including the CEO of
- 15:53Speaker 1: the subcompany, Stockton Rush. Captain Jason Neubauer is the Coastguard's
- 15:58Speaker 1: chief investigator.
- 16:00Speaker 5: The NBI is also responsible for accountability aspects of the incident,
- 16:05Speaker 5: and it can make recommendations to the proper authorities to
- 16:08Speaker 5: pursue civil or criminal sanctions.
- 16:11Speaker 1: Carl Stanley, a sub expert who took a trip on
- 16:13Speaker 1: the same sub back in twenty nineteen says he warned
- 16:17Speaker 1: Rush about safety flaws in the vessel after the trip,
- 16:20Speaker 1: but his concerns were dismissed in an email exchange.
- 16:24Speaker 3: I think the more this picture shapes up, we're going
- 16:27Speaker 3: to see that he was not only a terrible engineer,
- 16:31Speaker 3: but something of a con man.
- 16:33Speaker 1: And Charlottean joining me is Bloomberg legal reporter Joel Rosenblatt,
- 16:38Speaker 1: who's looked into the possible legal ramifications of the implosion.
- 16:43Speaker 1: Is the US or is Canada taking the lead here?
- 16:47Speaker 1: Who's doing investigating.
- 16:49Speaker 2: In the US? Coast Guard is announced in an investigation,
- 16:54Speaker 2: so has Canada's Transportation Safety Board, as well as the
- 16:59Speaker 2: Royal can Mounted Police. British investigators and French investigators are
- 17:03Speaker 2: also looking at what happened. So it's a real combination
- 17:07Speaker 2: and according to the Coast Guard, they're all working together.
- 17:12Speaker 1: So are criminal charges of possibility here.
- 17:16Speaker 2: There is the possibility of criminal charges. It would be tricky,
- 17:21Speaker 2: It's going to be difficult, but we'll have to kind
- 17:23Speaker 2: of see what the investigations produce. In the United States,
- 17:27Speaker 2: under US law, criminal charges would be brought under what's
- 17:30Speaker 2: called the Stemens Manslaughter Statute, which dates to the eighteen hundreds.
- 17:35Speaker 2: You can imagine how in earlier periods of you guys
- 17:38Speaker 2: Say's history, there are many more different types of accidents
- 17:42Speaker 2: and deaths on the high seat. And the law has
- 17:46Speaker 2: actually a relatively low bar for establishing criminal responsibility. But
- 17:52Speaker 2: there are, of course, as required under any kind of
- 17:54Speaker 2: ob but especially criminal others, certain hurdles you have to
- 17:57Speaker 2: get over, one of which is just right. I mean,
- 18:01Speaker 2: that's just kind of basic to any lawsuit, but especially here.
- 18:04Speaker 2: And that's what makes it especially tricky is just given
- 18:08Speaker 2: all the different locations involved. The company was based in Everett, Washington,
- 18:13Speaker 2: in Washington State. It had a unit registered in the
- 18:16Speaker 2: Bahamas under which I think the Titan submersible was kind
- 18:20Speaker 2: of operating. The submersible is what the Titan was called,
- 18:24Speaker 2: was deployed by a Canadian ship called the Polar Prince,
- 18:27Speaker 2: which left from Saint John's in Newfoundland to international waters
- 18:31Speaker 2: in the Atlantic over the Titanic, which it was exploring,
- 18:35Speaker 2: you know. And then I mentioned the different countries involved.
- 18:38Speaker 2: The passengers were American, Pakistani, French, and British. And so
- 18:42Speaker 2: you take all this together and it's going to be
- 18:46Speaker 2: a big question of where a criminal case would be brought.
- 18:49Speaker 2: Who has jurisdiction. It's one hurdle under the seamen's manslaughter statue.
- 18:54Speaker 1: You mentioned it's a submersible under the semens statute. Is
- 18:58Speaker 1: it also a question of whether it is actually a vessel?
- 19:02Speaker 2: Well, Junior, really seem to know your maritime law because
- 19:05Speaker 2: that's the other hurdle, right, So there's a kind of
- 19:09Speaker 2: definition of what is a vessel under that statute, and
- 19:13Speaker 2: there's big questions to what not the subversible was a
- 19:16Speaker 2: vesselble In fact, most leglfes were doov spoken to. I
- 19:19Speaker 2: think it wasn't. It just wasn't designed to carry people
- 19:23Speaker 2: across on top of the surface of the ocean. And
- 19:27Speaker 2: you know, it had very limited capability in terms of
- 19:30Speaker 2: how it can move. So probably prosecutors US prosecutors would
- 19:34Speaker 2: be I think it's going to be hard pressed to
- 19:35Speaker 2: fit the submersible into the definition of a vessel under
- 19:40Speaker 2: that act.
- 19:41Speaker 1: And Joe, who would they possibly prosecute here?
- 19:45Speaker 2: That's a good question because the captain, the pilot of
- 19:49Speaker 2: the submersible, his name was Stockton Rush. He's also the
- 19:52Speaker 2: CEO of the company ocean Gate that operated it, is dead.
- 19:56Speaker 2: He was piloting dismersible when it imploded. So so the
- 20:00Speaker 2: question is, well, on the civil side, you know, who
- 20:03Speaker 2: else could you go after? You know, can you go
- 20:05Speaker 2: after the company itself or what's left of it, or
- 20:08Speaker 2: any possible affiliates of the company. On the criminal side, though,
- 20:12Speaker 2: that's what the semen's manslaughter statute actually benefits prosecutors because
- 20:17Speaker 2: you can go after a kind of wide range of
- 20:19Speaker 2: people and you know, not only it's operators, but engineers
- 20:23Speaker 2: and managers, are even inspectors who gave it a pass
- 20:26Speaker 2: maybe and when they shouldn't have. So it actually captures
- 20:30Speaker 2: potentially a white net that can be cast in terms
- 20:33Speaker 2: of a criminal prosecution.
- 20:34Speaker 1: Whenever there is a disaster like this, civil lawsuits are
- 20:38Speaker 1: almost certain to follow. The passenger assigned waivers agreeing the
- 20:44Speaker 1: trip to the bottom of the Atlantic might result in
- 20:46Speaker 1: injure your debt. But a lot of time those waivers
- 20:50Speaker 1: aren't worth the paper they're written on. What about the
- 20:53Speaker 1: waivers here?
- 20:55Speaker 2: Yeah, Well, so that's another question that comes up, in
- 20:58Speaker 2: particular on the civil side that the maritime law there
- 21:02Speaker 2: is the Death on the High Seas Act and the
- 21:04Speaker 2: waivers as I understand it, mentioned the possibility of death
- 21:08Speaker 2: numerous times. If you actually read the waiver, there's lots
- 21:12Speaker 2: that can go wrong, Ocean Gates said, and it's not
- 21:15Speaker 2: liable for any of it, including you know, you dying.
- 21:19Speaker 2: So that would seem on the face of it to
- 21:22Speaker 2: be a big problem for any civil suit. But under
- 21:25Speaker 2: the law, under really any law, a waiver can protect
- 21:29Speaker 2: a company for negligence, but not it's the negligence as
- 21:32Speaker 2: gross in other words, want in our reckless conduct affecting
- 21:36Speaker 2: the life of another person. And so here there were
- 21:39Speaker 2: plenty of warnings. That's kind of the most interesting part
- 21:42Speaker 2: of this, and in some ways the most tragic part
- 21:45Speaker 2: is that Stockton Rush, the CEO and pilot, had many
- 21:50Speaker 2: warnings of problems with the Titan sub and disregarded them.
- 21:55Speaker 2: You know, all these warnings that Stockton Rush god could
- 21:59Speaker 2: be evidence of gross negligence, right if he just got
- 22:03Speaker 2: all these warnings from different sources, and I'm talking about
- 22:06Speaker 2: very explicit, technical and well considered complaints about the problems
- 22:12Speaker 2: that the Titan faced and the risks, So then the
- 22:15Speaker 2: question would be, well, how much of that did he ignore?
- 22:18Speaker 2: But also then you know, if you're signing these waivers
- 22:21Speaker 2: but you're not disclosing. For example, it's hard to imagine
- 22:23Speaker 2: he disclosed all this information that he got to a
- 22:27Speaker 2: warning of the possibilities of fatality from your story.
- 22:30Speaker 1: It seemed to me that one of the most relevant
- 22:33Speaker 1: pieces of evidence was a letter from the Marine Technology
- 22:37Speaker 1: Society tell us about that.
- 22:40Speaker 2: That to me is the most damning piece of evidence.
- 22:43Speaker 2: I mean, there's another piece from a whistleblower lawsuit, but
- 22:47Speaker 2: the letter from the Marine Technology Society dated in March
- 22:51Speaker 2: of twenty eighteen, right, so this is quite a while
- 22:53Speaker 2: ago in terms of, you know, its relationship to what
- 22:56Speaker 2: happened here five years later is it wasn't. And there's
- 23:00Speaker 2: some controversy or questions about the letter, but there's no
- 23:03Speaker 2: question that Stockton Rush received it. And I spoke to
- 23:07Speaker 2: William Conan, who's the chairman of the Marine Technology Society's
- 23:11Speaker 2: Manned Submersibles Committee, which is quite a title. But the
- 23:15Speaker 2: letter is very concise. It's one page long, but it
- 23:18Speaker 2: describes warnings about negative outcomes, including catastrophic events, and how
- 23:24Speaker 2: a single they call it a negative event, could totally
- 23:28Speaker 2: kind of destroy the reputation that the Marine Technology Society
- 23:32Speaker 2: has by getting its members and all the kind of
- 23:35Speaker 2: people who are doing this type of deep sea diving
- 23:37Speaker 2: in submersibles to adhere to industry standards and testing. And
- 23:43Speaker 2: the letter says that Stockton Rush's marketing material advertises that
- 23:48Speaker 2: the Titan had met or exceeded safety standards, but there's
- 23:51Speaker 2: no evidence that it has actually been followed or tested,
- 23:55Speaker 2: and that he was misleading the public and urged him
- 23:58Speaker 2: to stop thesions until he got his Titan submersible tested
- 24:04Speaker 2: and up to standards. The letter is if you read it,
- 24:07Speaker 2: it's just a quick, really well written read of saying,
- 24:10Speaker 2: you know, please stop this before you kill somebody. That's
- 24:13Speaker 2: the upshot of it.
- 24:14Speaker 1: And what about the whistleblower.
- 24:16Speaker 2: The whistleblower is named David Lockridge, and at about the
- 24:19Speaker 2: same time, I'm suspecting that there's some overlap between David
- 24:23Speaker 2: Lockridge's firing and subsequent litigation and the letter from the
- 24:28Speaker 2: Marine Technology Society. Though I don't know that David Lockridge
- 24:31Speaker 2: was a high level person, then probably I think an
- 24:34Speaker 2: engineer would describe his work who objected to the design
- 24:39Speaker 2: of the Titan submersible and said so and was fired
- 24:43Speaker 2: for it, and the litigation that ensued it produced enough
- 24:47Speaker 2: documentation to indicate that this is another example of how
- 24:51Speaker 2: doctor Rush was really well aware, this time from a
- 24:55Speaker 2: high level employee who ultimately refused to go forward and
- 24:59Speaker 2: stay at the company unless he did something to address
- 25:03Speaker 2: the design flaws that Lockledge was calling his attention to.
- 25:07Speaker 1: A lot of the people on board were very wealthy.
- 25:11Speaker 1: There was a billionaire father and son in one of
- 25:14Speaker 1: Pakistan's wealthiest families, and the question is whether their family
- 25:19Speaker 1: would even want to pursue a lawsuit.
- 25:23Speaker 3: You know.
- 25:23Speaker 2: I talked to a lawyer whose response to that question
- 25:26Speaker 2: was probably not, like why, really, we kind of know
- 25:30Speaker 2: what happened physically, right, the submersible imploded and these people were,
- 25:36Speaker 2: as you mentioned, wealthy, and they signed these waivers, so
- 25:39Speaker 2: they knew the risk, So what's to learn? However, another
- 25:43Speaker 2: lawyer that I spoke to pointed out that, you know,
- 25:47Speaker 2: money isn't the only objective of a lawsuit. A lawsuit
- 25:50Speaker 2: could be filed by these people in part because they're
- 25:53Speaker 2: wealthy and can can afford it to figure out more
- 25:56Speaker 2: deeply what happened. For example, you know, all the stuff
- 25:58Speaker 2: that we're talking about, the letter from the Ring Technology
- 26:01Speaker 2: Society and David Lockleuch's lawsuits you know, how much more
- 26:04Speaker 2: of that is there? And were they duped despite the
- 26:07Speaker 2: fact that beside these waivers renewed the risks. Maybe they didn't,
- 26:10Speaker 2: right as we're discussing here, Maybe they didn't know the
- 26:12Speaker 2: extent of the risks or Stocking Rush should have told
- 26:15Speaker 2: them more, and they want to kind of publicize that
- 26:17Speaker 2: or prove that and find out the truth. Or you know,
- 26:21Speaker 2: maybe the lawsuit is filed simply because they're angry. Right.
- 26:25Speaker 2: Sometimes that's the reason lawsuits are filed. It's not necessarily
- 26:28Speaker 2: a rational decision. I haven't seen any indication of filing yet.
- 26:33Speaker 2: But these people, as you mentioned, were extraordinarily wealthy. You
- 26:36Speaker 2: had to pay two hundred and fifty thousand dollars for
- 26:38Speaker 2: the privilege of taking this trip, so they were all wealthy.
- 26:41Speaker 2: It's not clear to me that all of them paid
- 26:43Speaker 2: that much. One of them who died. His name was
- 26:45Speaker 2: Paul Henri Nargioles is how I would pronounce it. He's
- 26:49Speaker 2: a French diver and had been down to the Titanic
- 26:54Speaker 2: thirty seven times in submersibles and as a diver, he's
- 26:58Speaker 2: a renowned diver. You know, somebody like that is obviously
- 27:02Speaker 2: really well aware of the risks and what's going on.
- 27:05Speaker 2: And it's one of those kind of I think perplexing
- 27:08Speaker 2: pieces of this story is why would somebody like that
- 27:12Speaker 2: in particular, you know, you're so well aware of what's
- 27:16Speaker 2: going on in terms of the pressure that the submersible
- 27:20Speaker 2: is under. Why would he get on board that submercible?
- 27:23Speaker 1: There are a lot of questions and too few answers here.
- 27:26Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Joel. That's Bloomberg Legal reporter Joel Rosenblatt,
- 27:31Speaker 1: and that's it for this edition of The Bloomberg Law Show.
- 27:34Speaker 1: Remember you can always get the latest legal news on
- 27:36Speaker 1: our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 27:41Speaker 1: and at www dot Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast slash Law,
- 27:46Speaker 1: and remember to tune into The Bloomberg Law Show every
- 27:49Speaker 1: weeknight at ten pm Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso,
- 27:53Speaker 1: and you're listening to Bloomberg