Latest / This is Oregon / S2E10: A New Climate Blueprint: Building A Legal Framework for Atmospheric Recovery
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to This Is Oregon, the podcast where we take you inside research
- 0:05happening
- 0:05at the University of Oregon and show you how it applies to your daily life.
- 0:09I'm Ed Dorsch, your host for this episode.
- 0:12Today I'm talking with Mary Christina Wood, the Philip H.
- 0:15Knight Professor of Law.
- 0:16Mary is the founding director of the law school's Environment and Natural Resources
- 0:20Law Center.
- 0:21Her groundbreaking legal strategy, called Atmospheric Trust Litigation,
- 0:25was put into practice in 2010 on 21 youth plaintiffs represented by the nonprofit
- 0:30Our Children's Trust, filed a landmark climate lawsuit.
- 0:34Last March, the Supreme Court declined an appeal for Juliana v United States,
- 0:38but the lawsuit and Mary's bold assertion that the public trust doctrine
- 0:42applies to fossil fuel policies inspired a global groundswell of litigation.
- 0:48That includes successful lawsuits in Montana and South Korea,
- 0:51as well as a groundbreaking settlement in Hawaii.
- 0:54And dozens of
- 0:55similar cases are working their way through the courts around the world.
- 0:59In recent years, Wood has been breaking trail again.
- 1:02We're going to talk about her latest work at the vanguard of legal scholarship.
- 1:06Welcome, Mary. Thank you.
- 1:09You and I are both lifelong
- 1:12Oregonians, but in fact, you're a fifth generation Oregonian.
- 1:15Tell me a little bit about what it was like growing up;
- 1:18I know you explored the natural wonders of the state that both of us love,
- 1:22but you also witnessed the loss of farms, forests and wetlands.
- 1:26How did this experience help spur your environmental work?
- 1:30Well, I grew up on the banks of the Columbia River,
- 1:33and as a child, I played in the forests and biked through endless farmlands.
- 1:38But in just the few years that I was in high school,
- 1:41developers got hold of that area and really started ravaging it,
- 1:46and they turned all of these forests and farmlands
- 1:49into pop-up malls and endless subdivisions with McMansions.
- 1:54And for me, it was personally devastating to watch something so rich
- 1:58with natural beauty and function just disappear in a matter of a few years.
- 2:04And I thought to myself, then in high school, you know,
- 2:07I want to devote my career to protecting these natural systems.
- 2:12And I knew even then, before I went to law school, that
- 2:15the law wasn't working because there were plenty of environmental laws,
- 2:18but the agencies were just dishing out permits to destroy these forests, rivers
- 2:22and wetlands with little regard for any of the consequences.
- 2:27And so I knew even back then that real change would have to come
- 2:30from outside that narrow box of statutory law.
- 2:35And you've you've built a career, at the vanguard of legal scholarship,
- 2:39leading the way and most recently around the issue of climate change.
- 2:43And I have kind of a good news, bad news question for you next.
- 2:48First of all,
- 2:49why should we be concerned about climate change?
- 2:52And on the flip side, why should we still have hope?
- 2:55Well, nature has its own laws, and those laws are supreme,
- 2:59and you can consider climate balance as one of those laws.
- 3:03If we spew fossil fuel emissions
- 3:06and drive up the planet's average temperature,
- 3:10the climate system becomes disrupted and we pay the price
- 3:13in loss of life and property loss and economic collapse.
- 3:16And there's just no negotiating our way out of those laws,
- 3:20and we see this kind of disruption all over the planet
- 3:23now in the form of huge wildfires and mega storms and unprecedented
- 3:27floods and collapsing ice sheets and sea level rise.
- 3:31The very scary aspect to this is the nature does have a point of no return,
- 3:37and if we pass that, we can't come back to a safe place in terms of climate.
- 3:42We are now precariously near that threshold, and our federal government
- 3:46is pushing down on the accelerator of fossil fuels,
- 3:50driving us towards that climate cliff, as if there's no tomorrow.
- 3:54And so it's really, you know, we're faced with an appalling disregard
- 3:58for human life and property and economic stability.
- 4:01So that is the bad news.
- 4:04And there's a ticking time clock to this.
- 4:06The good news, though, is associated with the bad news.
- 4:10And that is the climate disruption is just so bad with people all over the world
- 4:15facing these unprecedented disasters
- 4:18that there's just no denying the obvious.
- 4:21And people are demanding solutions and policy changes from government.
- 4:26People from all corners and walks of life are stepping up
- 4:29with this understanding that, you know, we're all part of the problem
- 4:33in that we all participate in this fossil fuel economy, but that also means
- 4:38can all be and actually, we all must be part of the solution.
- 4:42Absolutely, and as you said, that clock is ticking.
- 4:442024 was the warmest year by a wide margin
- 4:48since we began recording it in around 1850.
- 4:52And we're seeing a lot of the results of this in Oregon
- 4:55with wildfires and droughts and low snowpack.
- 4:58So it's both a global problem and a very local problem.
- 5:02Now, most people think of, lawyers
- 5:06as, taking cases to court or filing lawsuits.
- 5:10But you don't do that.
- 5:11You create the strategies and the legal frameworks,
- 5:14that allow attorneys and organizations to take action on climate change.
- 5:19And I'd like to start with a strategy you developed years ago
- 5:22that has been and continues to be, quite successful.
- 5:26Tell me a little bit about atmospheric trust litigation.
- 5:30Well, atmospheric trust litigation came about in my mind
- 5:34when I realized that there was just no way the Clean Air Act would solve this
- 5:38climate crisis in time, because the agencies were just
- 5:42too politicized and too much in the hands of these powerful
- 5:46fossil fuel interests to really force with the statutory law,
- 5:51authorize them to do, and that is control fossil fuel pollution.
- 5:55The Clean Air Act had been around for years, 50 years,
- 5:58and it's always contained ample authority to regulate carbon emissions.
- 6:02But still today, there's no comprehensive regulation.
- 6:05And so I stepped back and outside of that box and I applied
- 6:09what's known as the public trust principle,
- 6:11which I'd been writing about for some time,
- 6:14to the climate crisis.
- 6:15And that is a principle
- 6:16outside of statutory law that is just really simple to understand.
- 6:21And that is government is a trustee of our crucial resources
- 6:25and as a trustee, must protect them
- 6:28not only for the present generation but also future generations, as well.
- 6:33And this principle have been applied many, many times with success
- 6:37in the water context and as logic certainly applied to the atmosphere
- 6:41as well, which supports all of human civilization.
- 6:45So I began making speeches and doing press interviews,
- 6:49and a lawyer named Julia Olson attended one of those presentations
- 6:54and decided to take this, this theory to court.
- 6:58And she formed Our Children's Trust, a nonprofit organization, and began
- 7:01to bring cases on behalf of youth against government agencies demanding
- 7:06emissions reduction, and one of those was a federal case, Juliana v United States,
- 7:12tried here in Eugene, which has been called,
- 7:15the biggest case on the planet because it was an effort to sue
- 7:19the federal government to force emissions reduction on that level.
- 7:23And while it was ultimately dismissed after a decade of litigation, it did lead
- 7:29to the declaration of a constitutional right to a stable climate system.
- 7:35And now youth have taken that right to court in cases around the country
- 7:38and, as you say, have, met with some some great success.
- 7:43So I'm sure, back then, when you first came up with the idea,
- 7:45it seemed a bit out there., but we've seen that in time
- 7:50that can come to fruition.
- 7:52You plant a seed and a tree grows.
- 7:55So I'd like to talk about a new seed that you're planting, some new trail
- 7:58that you're breaking. Let's talk about your latest idea.
- 8:01The Pacific Northwest framework for atmospheric recovery.
- 8:05What's the problem that you're working on?
- 8:07Well, this is, the other side of the climate equation.
- 8:12So we often just think of climate crisis as a problem of emissions or pollution.
- 8:16Too much fossil fuel use, sending those pollutants into the sky.
- 8:21But we could halt all fossil fuel use tomorrow,
- 8:24and we would still be sliding towards a climate cliff.
- 8:28And that's because we have exceeded the highest safe
- 8:31level of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere by a long shot.
- 8:34Scientists estimate the 350 parts
- 8:37per million of atmospheric CO2 is really the highest safe level.
- 8:41And now we've careened past that.
- 8:43We're beyond 420 parts per million and still climbing fast.
- 8:49So is that carbon pollution already
- 8:52in the sky that is causing havoc around the world?
- 8:55Its not tomorrow's pollution, actually, but yesterday's.
- 8:58So we have to engage in this massive sky cleanup, so to speak,
- 9:03in order to get levels back down around 350 parts per million.
- 9:07And you can think of it as analogous to a marine oil spill.
- 9:11If a big tanker spills, you know, millions of gallons of oil into the bay,
- 9:16there'd be no question that there would be a cleanup plan developed immediately,
- 9:21because everyone knows oil will destroy the function
- 9:24of that marine ecosystem that people and species rely on.
- 9:27Well, we can think of climate disruption is caused by a huge carbon
- 9:31spill in the sky, and it needs cleaning up so that we can achieve climate balance
- 9:36once again.
- 9:37You can kind of, think of this as an overflowing bathtub.
- 9:42Scientists use this analogy all the time where there's,
- 9:46a spout running water into the already full bathtub.
- 9:50Those would be the emissions.
- 9:52You've got to close the spout, but imagine that the drain is also plugged.
- 9:57You've got to to correct the problem, unplug the drain.
- 10:01Take to return equilibrium to the bathtub, and thus, basically what you have to do
- 10:05with the atmospheric pollution that we've got stop emissions, that is the spout.
- 10:10But also we've got to drain the atmosphere
- 10:13of the excess legacy carbon that's already there.
- 10:16And if we don't do that, we still plunge into, climate tipping points.
- 10:22So we have this overflowing bathtub making a big mess.
- 10:25And first we need to turn off the spigot, but then we need to pull that plug
- 10:29and let the bathtub drain.
- 10:30How do we do that?
- 10:32How do we clean up that proverbial oil
- 10:34spill and scrub all that carbon out of the sky that's there right now?
- 10:38Well, unfortunately, there's no magic vacuum cleaner to suck carbon
- 10:42out of the sky.
- 10:43But fortunately, nature has its own engines
- 10:47to draw down and sequester carbon through vegetation and soils.
- 10:51It's called the carbon cycle.
- 10:52Basically, nature absorbs carbon
- 10:55through plants and soils and also the ocean.
- 10:59And these are found across four eco types basically:
- 11:02forests, farmlands, grasslands and blue carbon areas.
- 11:06The problem is that we've gummed up these engines
- 11:10by destroying these ecosystems, so they don't function to absorb as much
- 11:13carbon as they should.
- 11:15We've clearcut the forest, we’ve damaged soils through industrial agriculture.
- 11:19We've destroyed wetlands.
- 11:20We've overgrazed grasslands.
- 11:22Scientists have delineated, what are called
- 11:26natural climate solutions to restore these ecosystems.
- 11:30And when you restore them, you boost their natural capacity to clean up the sky.
- 11:36Well, there are many, many pilot projects, around this region and elsewhere
- 11:41that show the effectiveness of these natural climate solutions.
- 11:45But they are few and far between.
- 11:47And so what's needed is a global effort to accelerate and scale up
- 11:53natural climate solutions across really the broadest territory possible worldwide.
- 11:59Now, I think most of us know what a farm is,
- 12:02as well as a forest or a rangeland, but what is a blue carbon area?
- 12:06Blue carbon areas are those areas in the tidal zones.
- 12:10Basically, they hold estuaries
- 12:12that have great potential to store carbon,
- 12:16and many of these have been effectively
- 12:18watered by levees and such to achieve flood control.
- 12:22But the reasons for these water impediments sometimes no longer exist,
- 12:28so some can be removed to re-water the blue carbon area
- 12:32and jumpstart is carbon sequestration abilities once again.
- 12:36I think those of us in Oregon probably all have our own favorite blue
- 12:40carbon areas along along the coast and, these solutions
- 12:44that you're proposing, offer additional benefits to communities, right?
- 12:47Like fish habitat, mitigation,
- 12:51from flooding or big waves and that kind of thing.
- 12:53Is that right?
- 12:54Oh, by all means, flood control, pure water
- 12:58species, fisheries protection, all of that recreational opportunities.
- 13:03So they are filled with co-benefits.
- 13:06So tell me about your plan for a solution.
- 13:08Well, one has to really think on a global level here.
- 13:11And because it's a planetary effort to to sequester and store
- 13:16the amount of carbon necessary, and it must fall,
- 13:19although as a planetary effort to regions around the world, regions
- 13:24that hold the eco types with potential for this major carbon drawdown.
- 13:29So really, the world needs something of a marshall plan,
- 13:32if you will, that kind of rebuilds ecology
- 13:35that can sequester carbon.
- 13:38But regions worldwide are still operating according to the way they have
- 13:41for decades.
- 13:42And the status quo is not going to restore the ecosystems
- 13:46necessary to draw down carbon.
- 13:48So we conceived of an organization framework on a regional level
- 13:53that details the components necessary
- 13:56to any regional sky carbon cleanup.
- 13:59And these components are pretty basic.
- 14:01We start with the natural climate solutions.
- 14:05Those are the protocols that can boost sequestration,
- 14:08things like restoring estuaries and protecting forests from clearcutting.
- 14:12And for every prescription, we also addressed,
- 14:16you know, how do you implement those and what barriers stand in the way,
- 14:19what are their costs?
- 14:21How would you monitor these to make sure that carbon
- 14:24really is, in effect, being sequestered and stored?
- 14:27And then, of course, we also focus on those vast co-benefits
- 14:31associated with these techniques, like flood control, water
- 14:34purification, storm buffers, and recreational opportunities,
- 14:38so the communities can see that this isn't just about carbon sequestration.
- 14:43And then finally, it's protocol needs some durability
- 14:47so that the next farmer or the next forester
- 14:50doesn't just undo all of the efforts by, say, cutting the forest
- 14:54that was seeking out carbon or returning land
- 14:57to industrial agriculture and releasing the stored carbon.
- 15:01This all sounds like it will cost a lot of money.
- 15:03Who pays for it?
- 15:05It will cost a
- 15:06lot of money because it's a huge global endeavor.
- 15:09If you think about who should pay for it, well,
- 15:12my analogy is a marine oil spill.
- 15:15Let's say a company had a tanker that spilled millions
- 15:18of gallons of oil into the bay.
- 15:22There would be absolutely no question that the company that owned
- 15:24the tanker or the petroleum would pay for the cleanup.
- 15:28And so really, the fossil fuel companies should pay for this cleanup,
- 15:32and there are lawsuits against fossil fuel companies around this country,
- 15:37but basically,
- 15:38they're asking the lawsuits are asking for a different form of damages.
- 15:42They're asking for adaptation damages.
- 15:45So many to build seawalls and provide more
- 15:49cooling centers and fire protection and so forth.
- 15:52And there's just no adaptation
- 15:55possible in a climate system that's out of control.
- 15:58So none of that money would go towards solving the problem.
- 16:02Whereas what's really needed is to have the fossil fuel companies
- 16:05pay for a cleanup of the pollution problem that they've cost.
- 16:10Another thing that you've brought up is that the first cities that win
- 16:14those sorts of lawsuits
- 16:16will get the seawalls and the cooling centers,
- 16:19but the rest of us would kind of be out of luck.
- 16:20So it's really not a viable solution.
- 16:22That's right.
- 16:23There's a real environmental justice component to this because,
- 16:26most places on Earth won't won't get a penny
- 16:29because the coffers will be drained in the first couple of lawsuits.
- 16:33And this might seem a little far fetched, but there have actually been
- 16:36similar examples, albeit, smaller in scope, that have worked.
- 16:40I know you've talked about, paint manufacturers, for example,
- 16:43in California, who paid for lead abatement in homes.
- 16:47It's analogous to that, but a lot grander in scale, right?
- 16:51Right.
- 16:52And even more recently, there's been settlements of lawsuits
- 16:57against manufacturers of PCBs and those settlements have been huge.
- 17:02And they occurred in the state of Oregon, in Seattle.
- 17:05And these, actually bring money
- 17:08damages to the state agencies
- 17:11in Oregon to clean up PCBs across all sorts of environmental media,
- 17:16like waters and species and soils and so forth.
- 17:19So that's a really great analogy.
- 17:21And the legal theory is exactly the same as the theory that would be used to hold
- 17:25fossil fuel companies accountable, and that is they're accountable
- 17:29for natural resource damages to a public trust resource.
- 17:34So let's get down to brass tacks.
- 17:36What's a specific example of of how that kind of money from a settlement
- 17:40that's recovered for carbon pollution, could be put to work
- 17:44right here in the northwest.
- 17:46Oh, well, it could pay for,
- 17:48could pay farmers to, change their practices on their lands.
- 17:53They might, change their practices to plant cover crops or row cropping.
- 17:58It could pay ranchers for transitioning to what we might call
- 18:02regenerative grazing, where they have more hired hands,
- 18:07but they bunch their cattle in ways and move their cattle
- 18:10through grasslands in ways, that are more concentrated.
- 18:14And so they don't destroy the roots of the vegetation.
- 18:17It could pay for conservation easements on forests that you want to keep standing.
- 18:22So they absorb carbon dioxide.
- 18:24It could pay for huge restoration projects along the coast to re
- 18:28water estuaries that have been drained from levees and so forth.
- 18:32So there's really no end to what you can do.
- 18:34The land is is overall in a very different condition than it was 200 years ago.
- 18:40And nature had its own processes of carbon sequestration.
- 18:44We've we've basically just thrown a wrench into most of those.
- 18:48Now, first of all,
- 18:49I think it's important to understand that all of this would be voluntary, right?
- 18:53And then, the Pacific Northwest would really be your your blueprint
- 18:59for other regions to emulate in this spinning up
- 19:02of natural carbon sequestration systems that that we already have in place.
- 19:09And then tell me a little bit about how,
- 19:11other regions could emulate what we're doing here in the Pacific Northwest.
- 19:15Well, we focused on the Pacific Northwest
- 19:17first as the lead region in this global effort,
- 19:21because if you think about it, we have a very unique region here.
- 19:25We have all four ecotypes.
- 19:27We have some of the most massive carbon sequestering forests on planet
- 19:31Earth in our west side, mature dug fir forests less what is left of them.
- 19:36And we have vast farmlands, grasslands, and also the estuaries at the ocean.
- 19:41We also have a league of scientists
- 19:44and land managers and tribes and groups all over the region
- 19:47interested in scaling up these natural climate solutions.
- 19:51So I think the Pacific Northwest is an ideal region to lead the way
- 19:55and also to inspire other regions across Earth to do the same.
- 20:00And this really is a grassroots strategy, and I think
- 20:03part of the strength of your new legal blueprint is that you have
- 20:07and will involve many different people at the local level, right?
- 20:12Yes. This framework, as you mentioned, is not a regulatory framework.
- 20:16It's an organizational framework.
- 20:18So it maps the way to implement natural climate solutions,
- 20:22but it depends on communities to take it forward if they so choose.
- 20:26And because land is managed by so many different people and agencies,
- 20:31this region wide effort would involve tribes and farmers and foresters
- 20:35and ranchers and restoration professionals and many, many others.
- 20:39You can really think of this.
- 20:41I like to think of it as a movement, an absolutely necessary one
- 20:46if we are to restore our climate system and secure a safe future for our children.
- 20:53And what you're talking about is, is not hypothetical.
- 20:56All those constituents you've mentioned, as I understand it, are groups that you've
- 21:00already been working with for this first plan that you're developing.
- 21:03So this is this is really happening?
- 21:04Right, we did tremendous outreach over the course of 3 or 4 months.
- 21:08And then, the idea is that our region, the Pacific Northwest,
- 21:13could be a prototype for other law schools around the country
- 21:16and around the world, they can create their own regional frameworks.
- 21:19Yeah.
- 21:20And in the stage we're at right now is,
- 21:23we are nearly, done with completing the framework.
- 21:27So the research is done and the writing is nearly done.
- 21:30So we are ready now to hand it off to basically an implementer
- 21:34who can take it forward in this region, and I envision at Northwest
- 21:39Atmospheric Recovery Institute, there would be a consortium of top flight
- 21:44research universities in Oregon, Washington and Idaho,
- 21:48and that institute could do the outreach necessary
- 21:51to get this off the ground in rural areas across the three states.
- 21:55And it could monitor the successes and failures
- 21:59and revise the framework, drawing upon this massive collective experience.
- 22:04And the really great thing for universities is by sending
- 22:08students and professors out to areas to monitor and study
- 22:12these natural climate solutions as they are being implemented,
- 22:16and engaging with the the actual land managers.
- 22:19Universities can train and grow new professional pathways for their students,
- 22:25and then once it is off the ground, I also envision other law schools
- 22:29as performing the same function we did in the Pacific Northwest
- 22:33in their own regions as well.
- 22:34This would be a fantastic project for law schools around the country
- 22:38to really jump start a framework for their regions.
- 22:42Frankly, it all seems really ambitious.
- 22:44But I know that new and bold is kind of what you do.
- 22:48Do you think it could really happen?
- 22:50Yeah. Well, I have a simple answer to that.
- 22:52It must happen.
- 22:54It may take a century, but this effort must happen.
- 22:58and it's going to take participation from around the world.
- 23:00And the reason must happen is because nature has its own laws,
- 23:04and we've really violated them by putting so much carbon
- 23:07dioxide into the atmosphere.
- 23:09If we don't clean up that carbon dioxide,
- 23:12we face, kind of a hellish world of,
- 23:15floods and fires and, more sea level rise and so forth.
- 23:19So if we want a habitable planet, this must happen.
- 23:22It's kind of an overwhelming problem.
- 23:24I think the magnitude of it, can often cause folks to kind of shut
- 23:28down, and I'm curious, what gives you hope?
- 23:32Well, what gives me hope is just encountering
- 23:35so many people that are enthusiastic about this idea.
- 23:38And when they first learn of it, they just think that makes sense.
- 23:43What gives me hope, too, is encountering so many different people.
- 23:47Inevitably people think, oh, I can, meaningfully
- 23:51participate in this small way.
- 23:54And I always say, you know, you can't save the world alone,
- 23:58but the world can't be saved without you.
- 24:02Well, I think it does make sense, and your words give me hope.
- 24:05And so thank you, Mary, I appreciate your time today
- 24:09and all the important work that you're doing.
- 24:11Thank you.
- 24:13Thank you for listening to my conversation with Mary Christina Wood
- 24:16about regional frameworks, a legal solution to the problem of climate change.
- 24:20If you're interested in learning more, check out the links
- 24:23in the episode description, and don't forget to follow This Is Oregon.
- 24:26For more stories from the University of Oregon.
- 24:28See you next time!
- 24:31This is Oregon is produced by the Division of University Communications.
- 24:34For more on the latest University of Oregon
- 24:36research and news, visit news.oregon.edu
- 24:40or find us on your favorite social media platform
- 24:43using the handle @uoregon.
- 24:45Thanks for listening and Go Ducks!