Latest / Bloomberg Law / SCOTUS Down to the Wire & Tax on Foreign Income
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio. Today,
- 0:10Speaker 1: the Supreme Court upheld a twenty seventeen tax on American
- 0:14Speaker 1: owned businesses foreign profits, rejecting an appeal that could have
- 0:18Speaker 1: saved companies hundreds of billions of dollars. The vote was
- 0:22Speaker 1: seven to two, with the justices saying that Congress has
- 0:25Speaker 1: the constitutional power to tax people and companies on their
- 0:30Speaker 1: share of undistributed corporate income. It's a case that was
- 0:34Speaker 1: being watched because of its potential implications for Democratic proposals
- 0:39Speaker 1: to impose a wealth tax, but the Court skipped that question.
- 0:43Speaker 1: Joining me is leading tax scholar David Shizer, a professor
- 0:46Speaker 1: Columbia Law School and former dean of the school. This
- 0:49Speaker 1: hasn't been one of the most closely watched cases of
- 0:52Speaker 1: the term. Just how important is this decision?
- 0:56Speaker 2: This decision is very important for what it says and
- 1:00Speaker 2: also for what it doesn't say. What it says is
- 1:03Speaker 2: that many of the international tax provisions that the US
- 1:09Speaker 2: government has used to tax income from foreign corporations are constitutional,
- 1:14Speaker 2: and that's a very important holding. And at the same time,
- 1:17Speaker 2: what it doesn't say is whether something like President Biden's
- 1:22Speaker 2: marked to market income tax is okay, they haven't told
- 1:26Speaker 2: us whether Congress can tax people on appreciated stock when
- 1:30Speaker 2: they haven't sold the stock.
- 1:32Speaker 1: Tell us about the facts of this case.
- 1:34Speaker 2: So the Moors are US citizens who bought stock in
- 1:38Speaker 2: an Indian company. They have not sold the stock, they
- 1:41Speaker 2: have not received a dividend, and so ordinarily under US law,
- 1:46Speaker 2: you don't pay tax until you sell or until you
- 1:49Speaker 2: get a dividend. Here, they received a tax bill based
- 1:53Speaker 2: on what the foreign company was earning. And this was
- 1:57Speaker 2: part of a major US reform effort for corporate tax
- 2:01Speaker 2: in twenty seventeen. So the more said, hey, wait a minute,
- 2:04Speaker 2: you can't tax us because we haven't sold and we
- 2:07Speaker 2: haven't gotten a dividend. And the court said, actually, you
- 2:11Speaker 2: can be taxed. And initially the court sought they were
- 2:15Speaker 2: taking the question of can someone be taxed without a sale,
- 2:19Speaker 2: but it's actually not the issue that the case presented,
- 2:22Speaker 2: and the reason is that the corporation, the Indian company,
- 2:25Speaker 2: was realizing income. And so the court said, well, as
- 2:30Speaker 2: long as the company had these sales and was realizing income,
- 2:34Speaker 2: Congress could attribute those sales to you. And so basically
- 2:39Speaker 2: this became a case about the relationship between an owner
- 2:45Speaker 2: and the business entity the corporation, instead of a case
- 2:49Speaker 2: about whether you could tack an owner without a sale.
- 2:52Speaker 3: Was it an.
- 2:53Speaker 1: Unusual lineup of justices the seven to two Thomas and
- 2:57Speaker 1: Gore such in descent.
- 2:58Speaker 2: So I think what you have is a division of
- 3:01Speaker 2: views about things Congress could do. There is a seven
- 3:06Speaker 2: to two majority for the idea that Congress can treat
- 3:11Speaker 2: an owner as the entity for purposes of taxing the owner.
- 3:17Speaker 2: You can say, hey, owner, we're going to treat you
- 3:19Speaker 2: as earning the income of your entity. And there are
- 3:22Speaker 2: five justices that say that can be done pretty easily.
- 3:27Speaker 2: And there are two that say we think it can
- 3:29Speaker 2: be done, but only when there's an abusive situation, and
- 3:33Speaker 2: then two who say they don't think it can be done.
- 3:35Speaker 2: But on this other question of can you tax someone
- 3:39Speaker 2: for appreciation when they have it sold, there you have
- 3:42Speaker 2: four justices who come out saying the answer to that
- 3:45Speaker 2: is no, would be unconstitutional. You have five who said
- 3:49Speaker 2: we don't reach that question. One of those five, Jackson
- 3:53Speaker 2: wrote a concurrence saying and effect, she'd be fine with it.
- 3:56Speaker 2: But as to the other four, we don't yet know
- 3:58Speaker 2: where they are and that'll be another case.
- 4:01Speaker 1: So Paul Ryan, the former House Speaker who helped write
- 4:04Speaker 1: the legislation, said upending the tax could endanger a third
- 4:09Speaker 1: of the US tax code. Do you agree with that number?
- 4:13Speaker 2: The broadest holding here could have cost trillions of dollars
- 4:19Speaker 2: to the treasury, So I do agree. Really, the way
- 4:22Speaker 2: the court came out, you know, blesses most of what
- 4:27Speaker 2: Congress is already doing, and the questions are much more
- 4:30Speaker 2: about what in theories Congress might want to do, but
- 4:35Speaker 2: they haven't done it yet. So again, the big dollar
- 4:38Speaker 2: amounts that Congressman Ryan was probably thinking about were the
- 4:42Speaker 2: international tax provisions where US multinationals are taxed based on
- 4:46Speaker 2: the income of their foreign subsidiaries. And I think the
- 4:49Speaker 2: court today is saying that those rules are constitutional. What
- 4:54Speaker 2: Congress has not tried to do, but the President proposed
- 4:58Speaker 2: it a few months ago, is to say, hey, you
- 5:01Speaker 2: founded this company, your stake is now worth a billion dollars,
- 5:05Speaker 2: and we're going to tax that income on your stock
- 5:09Speaker 2: the fact that it's gone from zero to a billion.
- 5:11Speaker 2: We're going to tax you under the income tax even
- 5:14Speaker 2: though you haven't sold. And Congress has not done much
- 5:18Speaker 2: of that. And as for what it's done, there's still
- 5:21Speaker 2: a question whether it can, and if it decides to
- 5:24Speaker 2: do that, that's still an open question about whether the
- 5:27Speaker 2: Court would bless it.
- 5:28Speaker 1: Did Justice Cavanaugh, who wrote the majority, did he specifically
- 5:32Speaker 1: say we're not ruling on any other hypothetical taxes, we're
- 5:37Speaker 1: just resolving the issue before us today.
- 5:40Speaker 2: Yes, he did, And he also made another point. There's
- 5:44Speaker 2: another kind of tax, which is, hey, you're rich, and
- 5:48Speaker 2: it's not that we're going to tax your gains, we're
- 5:50Speaker 2: just going to tax your net worth. That would be
- 5:53Speaker 2: a wealth tax. That's the tax that Bernie Sanders and
- 5:56Speaker 2: Elizabeth Warrens have proposed. And interestingly, just as Kavanaugh said,
- 6:01Speaker 2: we're not deciding that, but he also added there that
- 6:05Speaker 2: the governments during oral argument had conceded that a wealth
- 6:10Speaker 2: tax would be unconstitutional. So I think he didn't just
- 6:14Speaker 2: note it. I think he sent a signal that he thinks,
- 6:18Speaker 2: like the government, that that would be unconstitutional. But the
- 6:21Speaker 2: Majority is very careful to say, this is a narrow decision,
- 6:25Speaker 2: and there are a lot of things we specifically.
- 6:27Speaker 4: Are not decided.
- 6:29Speaker 1: And did the government really concede that a wealth tax
- 6:32Speaker 1: would be unconstitutional? In the oral arguments.
- 6:36Speaker 2: Arguments, Yes, yes they did. There's this idea in the
- 6:40Speaker 2: Constitution of a so called direct tax, and a direct
- 6:45Speaker 2: tax is subject to a very unappealing requirement called apportionment,
- 6:51Speaker 2: which basically means that the amount of revenue collected from
- 6:54Speaker 2: the state has to be the same as its percentage
- 6:57Speaker 2: of the population. And if you had to abhor a
- 7:00Speaker 2: wealth tax, Bernie Sanders and Elizabeth Warren would have no
- 7:03Speaker 2: interest in it. The net effect of that is that
- 7:06Speaker 2: the wealth tax rate would be higher in poorer states. So,
- 7:11Speaker 2: when asked an oral argument, does the constitutional amendments for
- 7:16Speaker 2: income taxes cover a wealth tax or would a wealth
- 7:20Speaker 2: tax be a direct tax? The representative for the US
- 7:23Speaker 2: government said that would be a direct tax. So the
- 7:25Speaker 2: government did concede that a wealth tax would be unconstitutional
- 7:29Speaker 2: unless it was apportioned.
- 7:30Speaker 1: How often does the Constitution's sixteenth Amendment become a subject
- 7:36Speaker 1: of a Supreme Court case?
- 7:38Speaker 2: Extremely rarely. Part of the reason it came up now
- 7:43Speaker 2: is because of the conversation in the country about wealth
- 7:46Speaker 2: taxes or about an income tax that doesn't wait for
- 7:50Speaker 2: you to sell, and because Congress has been considering those steps.
- 7:56Speaker 2: I think the tax payers here brought this case in
- 7:58Speaker 2: an effort to who gives the court the chance to
- 8:02Speaker 2: say that those new rules would be unconstitutional. As it
- 8:06Speaker 2: turns out, they did not pick their vehicle. Wisely, they
- 8:11Speaker 2: did not pick the right case, because this case really
- 8:13Speaker 2: presents a different issue. It's much more about whether you
- 8:16Speaker 2: can tax an owner for what the business is doing
- 8:19Speaker 2: instead of the business. And that's the narrow basis in
- 8:22Speaker 2: which the Court resolved the issue.
- 8:24Speaker 1: So who were the winners here? The government the irs.
- 8:29Speaker 2: I think it's a win for Congress and the Internal
- 8:34Speaker 2: Revenue Service in the sense that a very important, longstanding
- 8:38Speaker 2: body of rules that are designed to protect the US
- 8:42Speaker 2: tax base against efforts to move income overseas. I think
- 8:46Speaker 2: those rules were blessed as authorized. But on the other hand,
- 8:51Speaker 2: there's still a big open question and in a sense
- 8:54Speaker 2: a mini win for opponents of these other tax reforms,
- 8:59Speaker 2: because the or It certainly did not bless them, and
- 9:02Speaker 2: we have four ninths of the Court explicitly coming out
- 9:06Speaker 2: against them, and heavy hinting from the majority that it
- 9:11Speaker 2: would be a different analysis than no one should assume
- 9:13Speaker 2: that they're constitutional.
- 9:15Speaker 1: I know you wrote an amicus brief in this case.
- 9:18Speaker 2: We actually said, we thought the issue that the court
- 9:22Speaker 2: said it was taking wasn't presented, and then instead, this
- 9:27Speaker 2: was a case not about whether realization was constitutionally required,
- 9:32Speaker 2: but about whether an owner could be taxed to what
- 9:34Speaker 2: its business is doing. And our theory is exactly the
- 9:37Speaker 2: theory that the court adopted.
- 9:39Speaker 1: Congratulations on that, Thank you. So does this mean then
- 9:42Speaker 1: that two hundred and seventy one odd billion dollars in
- 9:47Speaker 1: tax goes into the US treasury?
- 9:51Speaker 2: Yes, so the government doesn't have to give that back.
- 9:54Speaker 2: But the stakes were much broader because this was a
- 9:57Speaker 2: case about whether, on a one time basic, Congress could
- 10:02Speaker 2: tax earning and overseas companies. So the one time basis
- 10:07Speaker 2: was approved, but the reasoning the court gave and improving
- 10:12Speaker 2: it was this is just like a different rule where
- 10:17Speaker 2: there's other overseas income that we've been taxing all the time,
- 10:20Speaker 2: and we think that's constitutional as well.
- 10:23Speaker 1: With this decision, is a wealth check no longer a
- 10:27Speaker 1: concern since the government conceded that it was unconstitutional in
- 10:31Speaker 1: the oral arguments.
- 10:33Speaker 2: The government can change its psision in a future case.
- 10:38Speaker 2: So the fact that the government made that procession is
- 10:42Speaker 2: not finding. But I think the fact that the Court
- 10:47Speaker 2: shows to memorialize the concession is a signal of what
- 10:51Speaker 2: the current court thinks about the issue.
- 10:54Speaker 1: Thanks so much for joining us today and making tax
- 10:57Speaker 1: law understandable. That's Professor David's of Columbia Law School coming
- 11:02Speaker 1: up next on the Bloomberg Lawn Show. The Supreme Court
- 11:05Speaker 1: has about nineteen cases left to be decided within a
- 11:09Speaker 1: week that normally ends the term. The vast majority of
- 11:13Speaker 1: those cases are on controversial issues like presidential immunity, abortion, guns,
- 11:20Speaker 1: social media, and homelessness. Why are some of the most
- 11:23Speaker 1: controversial cases of the term being left to the last minute.
- 11:27Speaker 1: I'm June Grosso and you're listening to Bloomberg. The Supreme
- 11:32Speaker 1: Court handed down four decisions today, leaving nineteen more cases
- 11:37Speaker 1: to be decided before the end of the term next Friday.
- 11:41Speaker 1: Those include at least fourteen involving controversial issues from presidential
- 11:46Speaker 1: immunity and abortion to guns and homelessness. Joining me is
- 11:50Speaker 1: constitutional law expert Harold Krant, a professor at the Chicago
- 11:54Speaker 1: Kent College of Law, to answer the question that everyone,
- 11:58Speaker 1: well at least Supreme Court watchers are asking, what's the
- 12:01Speaker 1: hold up? First out, they issued three decisions. In addition
- 12:05Speaker 1: to the tax case today, and I have to say
- 12:08Speaker 1: they were not high profile cases that we were tracking.
- 12:12Speaker 4: All three cases were criminal law decisions and there were
- 12:16Speaker 4: relatively discrete issues which had divided the lower courts. So
- 12:21Speaker 4: the Supreme Court in those three cases acted as a
- 12:23Speaker 4: traditional Supreme court would in trying to clarify standards for
- 12:28Speaker 4: the lower court. So, for instance, in one case, it
- 12:30Speaker 4: had to do with the question of when you can
- 12:32Speaker 4: bring a retaliatory arrest claim, which doesn't happen very much
- 12:37Speaker 4: even if there's no probable cause, and the court held
- 12:41Speaker 4: that as long as you can show that even in
- 12:44Speaker 4: though probable cause existed, if no one else has ever
- 12:47Speaker 4: been convicted of that offense, then you can bring a
- 12:50Speaker 4: retaliatory arrest. So it's a relatively straightforward traditional decision which
- 12:55Speaker 4: commanded agreement of all the entire court. In the to
- 13:00Speaker 4: Marini case, there's a question about whether or not a
- 13:03Speaker 4: probable cause exists for one offense for which you have
- 13:08Speaker 4: been arrested, can you nonetheless bring a malicious prosecution charge
- 13:13Speaker 4: if you were charged with other offenses for which it
- 13:16Speaker 4: was no probable cause, And again relatively straightforward, the majority
- 13:22Speaker 4: of the court decided that a Moust's prosecution claim can
- 13:27Speaker 4: be brought even if there was probable cause for one charge,
- 13:32Speaker 4: but not for the rest. And in an interesting alignment
- 13:36Speaker 4: of the court in the Diaz case, it had to
- 13:38Speaker 4: do with the criminal rule of procedure, which says that
- 13:42Speaker 4: nobody can comment on an expert opinion on whether a
- 13:47Speaker 4: defendant had to requisite mental intent for an offense. In
- 13:51Speaker 4: this case, it was someone bringing over to clandestine drugs,
- 13:55Speaker 4: and the issue was she claimed she was innocent, didn't
- 13:58Speaker 4: have knowledge of it, and a FBI official testified that
- 14:02Speaker 4: most drug dealers in that situation would not give that
- 14:06Speaker 4: quantity of drugs to an unknowing mule to trying to
- 14:12Speaker 4: bring over the drugs. And the question at stake was
- 14:16Speaker 4: whether that testimony by the FBI has to do with whether,
- 14:21Speaker 4: in general, most people would know what they're hauling, or
- 14:26Speaker 4: is it too close to saying that in the FBI
- 14:29Speaker 4: experts mind, that person must have known that they were
- 14:33Speaker 4: bringing illegal drugs. So the court held that that testimony
- 14:37Speaker 4: was allowed, and that produced a bit of a split
- 14:40Speaker 4: in the court because of the fact that it wasn't
- 14:43Speaker 4: saying that that individual didn't know that they were bringing
- 14:47Speaker 4: over illegal drugs. It just said that most people in
- 14:50Speaker 4: that situation would know that they were bringing over a drugs.
- 14:53Speaker 4: So the Court allowed that to come in. And I
- 14:56Speaker 4: would make it interesting was that Justice Scorsich joined the
- 15:00Speaker 4: descent while Justice Jackson joined the majority. So in all
- 15:04Speaker 4: three cases criminal cases, the Court again performed its traditional
- 15:09Speaker 4: role of giving guidance to the lower courts in case
- 15:12Speaker 4: such cases percolated up. Again, they don't often, but they
- 15:16Speaker 4: do on occasion, and so the Court served that role.
- 15:19Speaker 4: And meanwhile, we're waiting for the more blockbuster cases that
- 15:23Speaker 4: the Court has yet to announce.
- 15:25Speaker 1: Every opinion day continue to be surprised that the blockbuster
- 15:29Speaker 1: cases are not coming out. I mean, here you have
- 15:32Speaker 1: the Raheemi case, the ban on guns for domestic bolence
- 15:38Speaker 1: abusers that was argued in November. Even if they have
- 15:42Speaker 1: descents and concurrences, should it take this long.
- 15:46Speaker 4: It shouldn't take this long. There may be a strategy.
- 15:49Speaker 4: I'm afraid of releasing many controversial decisions at once. So
- 15:55Speaker 4: it's sort of like mutes the overall reaction because nobody
- 16:00Speaker 4: knows where to start. And so the Presidential Community case,
- 16:04Speaker 4: the Raheemi case that you mentioned, the sleeping in the
- 16:08Speaker 4: parks case grants pass may be the same way. And
- 16:12Speaker 4: of course all the very sundry administry of law decisions
- 16:16Speaker 4: that have yet the be released. You know, you just
- 16:18Speaker 4: release them all together and nobody knows where to start
- 16:21Speaker 4: because they're also important and also controversial. That may be
- 16:26Speaker 4: a strategy or perhaps you know, a justice or two
- 16:30Speaker 4: can't finish a key concurrence or dissent and that's what's
- 16:34Speaker 4: holding up the court.
- 16:35Speaker 1: Who decides when the opinions come out? Would that be
- 16:37Speaker 1: the Chief Justice deciding that?
- 16:40Speaker 4: Chief Justice does decide that, and so that is a
- 16:43Speaker 4: strategy that Chief Justice Roberts oversees. But the question is
- 16:48Speaker 4: will he give a deadline to a fellow justice that
- 16:51Speaker 4: an opinion's going out whether or not the concurrence is ready.
- 16:55Speaker 4: That's not generally the case. But obviously the court doesn't
- 16:59Speaker 4: want to stay past July fourth. The Court may even
- 17:02Speaker 4: want to finish by the end of June. So it's
- 17:05Speaker 4: gettn close where the Chief just may say it was
- 17:08Speaker 4: not in by a certain day. We're releasing the opinion
- 17:10Speaker 4: the way it is. That's the leverage that the chief
- 17:13Speaker 4: can hold over the PEBO justices.
- 17:16Speaker 1: Do you think then that, for example, the Trump immunity case,
- 17:20Speaker 1: it's already written, concurrences, dissents, et cetera, and the Chief
- 17:25Speaker 1: is just holding it.
- 17:26Speaker 4: My guess is that other remaining twenty cases, they're likely
- 17:30Speaker 4: to be several that are all completed, and that for
- 17:33Speaker 4: strategic reasons, the Chief hasn't agreed to release the decision
- 17:37Speaker 4: yet wants to sort of stack them out in particular
- 17:40Speaker 4: orders over the last couple of opinions days. Not for sure,
- 17:43Speaker 4: of course, this is just speculation, but it's given so
- 17:46Speaker 4: much time that one would think that there are some
- 17:49Speaker 4: of these decisions would have been completed by now.
- 17:53Speaker 1: I've always suspected that, you know, because it's more than
- 17:56Speaker 1: strange that the last couple of days of the term
- 18:00Speaker 1: at all these controversial cases at once. And everyone says, well,
- 18:05Speaker 1: it's because there are so many concurrences and dissents and
- 18:10Speaker 1: you know, they have to circulate those. But still it
- 18:14Speaker 1: seems like there's got to be something else going on.
- 18:17Speaker 1: So right now, they have an opinion day schedule for tomorrow,
- 18:21Speaker 1: and they just scheduled another one for Wednesday of next week,
- 18:24Speaker 1: and they seem to be doing three to four cases
- 18:27Speaker 1: each opinion day.
- 18:28Speaker 4: Yeah, they've been averaging about three to four day. And
- 18:32Speaker 4: it's interesting, right because today three opinions were all in
- 18:35Speaker 4: the criminal procedure context. So is that an accident or
- 18:40Speaker 4: did the chief decide to group them together because it
- 18:42Speaker 4: made sense thematically? We simply don't know. And obviously, if
- 18:46Speaker 4: the court wanted to finish next week, it would have
- 18:50Speaker 4: to release far more opinions on day than it has previously,
- 18:54Speaker 4: which would lead one to think that they'll probably announce
- 18:57Speaker 4: some opinion days for the week thereafter, just otherwise they
- 19:01Speaker 4: would be releasing at least six opinions on a particular day,
- 19:07Speaker 4: you know, which is hard to believe.
- 19:09Speaker 1: The justices read from the bench excerpts from their opinion,
- 19:14Speaker 1: and then the dissent may read, is that why it
- 19:17Speaker 1: takes so long? Because why couldn't they come out with
- 19:19Speaker 1: five or so a day.
- 19:21Speaker 4: No, they could, They certainly could. It's just it's just
- 19:23Speaker 4: a tradition to try to limit the number of cases released.
- 19:27Speaker 4: It once, but there's no rule about it. And the
- 19:29Speaker 4: quote could decide to release ten decisions, you know, on
- 19:34Speaker 4: one day, and it would get everybody scrambling. I don't
- 19:38Speaker 4: think that will be the case, because that would be
- 19:41Speaker 4: a departure from tradition, but it's certainly in the relst possibility.
- 19:45Speaker 1: All the cases outstanding, many of which are controversial, it
- 19:49Speaker 1: leads me to think that these decisions are going to
- 19:54Speaker 1: be splintered, and that you're going to find a lot
- 19:56Speaker 1: of maybe six to three down ideological the lines. Yeah.
- 20:01Speaker 4: I mean, today, again, the cases were relatively discreet. We
- 20:04Speaker 4: did not see those kind of traditional six ' three split,
- 20:08Speaker 4: But it is certainly likely that in a lot of
- 20:12Speaker 4: these cases, whether it's the Second Amendment case or the
- 20:15Speaker 4: First Amendment, social media cases or the administry of law cases,
- 20:20Speaker 4: not to mention presidential community, there may be a traditional
- 20:23Speaker 4: split along the conservative liberal fronts. But there remains to
- 20:28Speaker 4: be seen. I mean, there may be broader areas of agreement,
- 20:32Speaker 4: for instance, on the presidential immunity case. At least that
- 20:35Speaker 4: will be my guests from listening to oral arguments, but
- 20:39Speaker 4: we'll just have to see.
- 20:40Speaker 1: Yeah, And I have to say I'm surprised about the
- 20:43Speaker 1: Raheemi case because I thought during oral arguments that there
- 20:47Speaker 1: seemed to be enough justices who thought that, you know,
- 20:51Speaker 1: someone with a domestic violence temporary restraining order was the
- 20:56Speaker 1: kind of person who shouldn't have a gun. Yeah, you know.
- 20:59Speaker 4: Again, to me, the case seems straightforward. If you have
- 21:02Speaker 4: a protective order against you because you've engaged in violence
- 21:06Speaker 4: in the past, that would be a person to whom
- 21:08Speaker 4: we would think, even under the traditions that the court
- 21:12Speaker 4: looks to in the Broin case, that that would be
- 21:14Speaker 4: somebody who would not be eligible for a GA license
- 21:18Speaker 4: depending upon the jurisdiction. But who knows, and that will
- 21:22Speaker 4: find out very short.
- 21:24Speaker 1: Okay. So of the cases that are left, besides presidential immunity,
- 21:28Speaker 1: which I think is the one that most people are
- 21:31Speaker 1: sort of looking for, which do you think is the
- 21:34Speaker 1: most controversial.
- 21:36Speaker 4: I think the question of the emergency medicine, whether it
- 21:41Speaker 4: can extend to under the federal guidelines, extend to having
- 21:47Speaker 4: an abortion in Idaho is going to be extremely controversial.
- 21:51Speaker 4: It's in essence of preemption case about whether this statute
- 21:55Speaker 4: over rides Idaho's decision to ban abortions. A lot of
- 22:00Speaker 4: eyes will be attuned to that. Obviously. There's also the
- 22:04Speaker 4: Fisher the United States case, which has to do with
- 22:07Speaker 4: charges stemming out of January sixth, because it's trying to
- 22:11Speaker 4: define what its impeding, and the official proceeding is and
- 22:15Speaker 4: whether the rush to the capital so qualifies. I think
- 22:20Speaker 4: that'll be ones that are focused on. And there's really
- 22:24Speaker 4: three major initstrative law cases up for grabs, and they
- 22:28Speaker 4: have the potential of not tearing down the administrative state,
- 22:32Speaker 4: but pairing it back quite substantially, so I think those
- 22:36Speaker 4: will be very controversial as well. Just to add is
- 22:38Speaker 4: the whole question about whether the Sacklers were able to
- 22:43Speaker 4: settle all the claims stemming from the lawsuits against Purdue
- 22:48Speaker 4: Pharma for the oipriodes. That has a very practical impact on,
- 22:54Speaker 4: you know, many people to whom otherwise might even be
- 22:57Speaker 4: able to get more money back for the injuries that
- 23:00Speaker 4: they've suffered. So as a practical matter, that's going to
- 23:03Speaker 4: attract a lot of attention as well.
- 23:05Speaker 1: Thanks so much, Hal for being on Supreme Court watch
- 23:07Speaker 1: with us. That's Professor Harold Krent of the Chicago Kent
- 23:10Speaker 1: College of Law. So some of the cases that the
- 23:14Speaker 1: Court could decide tomorrow involve Donald Trump's claim of presidential immunity,
- 23:19Speaker 1: guns for domestic violence abusers, one of the country's strictest
- 23:24Speaker 1: abortion laws, fines for homelessness, the regulation of social media,
- 23:29Speaker 1: air pollution, and agency power coming up next on the
- 23:33Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law Show. In Video will get a Supreme Court
- 23:36Speaker 1: review on a shareholder crypto suit next term. It's the
- 23:40Speaker 1: second case involving shareholder lawsuits that the Court is teeing
- 23:44Speaker 1: up for next term. I'm June Grosso and this is Bloomberg.
- 23:49Speaker 1: The Supreme Court is teeing up cases for next term.
- 23:53Speaker 1: It's agreed to use a case over in Vidia's crypto
- 23:56Speaker 1: mining revenue to consider making it harder for share holders
- 24:00Speaker 1: to press securities fraud lawsuits. In Nvidia is seeking to
- 24:04Speaker 1: stop an investors suit that accuses the company of being
- 24:08Speaker 1: deceptive about how dependent it was on revenue from crypto
- 24:12Speaker 1: mining before a twenty eighteen market turndown. Joining me is
- 24:16Speaker 1: Seth Gertz, a partner at Dorsey and Whitney and a
- 24:19Speaker 1: former federal prosecutor specializing in crypto related scams. So, Seth,
- 24:24Speaker 1: you have cryptocurrency, crypto mining, computer chips. Tell us what
- 24:29Speaker 1: this case is all about.
- 24:30Speaker 3: It's a really interesting case. I mean, not least because
- 24:33Speaker 3: in videos just became their most valuable company in the world,
- 24:36Speaker 3: I believe this week. On one hand, it's a very
- 24:39Speaker 3: technical question regarding the fleeting standards and private securities location cases,
- 24:45Speaker 3: and so deals squarely with what a plaintiff needs to
- 24:49Speaker 3: prove regarding fraud the enter to get past emotion to
- 24:53Speaker 3: this misstage in a security fraud case, and that is
- 24:58Speaker 3: the meat of the legal arguments there in videos is
- 25:02Speaker 3: saying is arguing that you have to specifically allege the
- 25:06Speaker 3: content of internal documents that indicated the CEO would have
- 25:10Speaker 3: seen that were contrary to public statements that were being made.
- 25:14Speaker 3: The plaintiffs in the case are saying, no, no, no, not
- 25:16Speaker 3: so fast, because enough that we can infer based upon
- 25:19Speaker 3: information to CEO would have known other things insiders were
- 25:22Speaker 3: saying about information, The CEO had to give us a
- 25:26Speaker 3: strong enough inference of particularity that you should have known
- 25:29Speaker 3: and was making false statements, those false statements to cruxt
- 25:33Speaker 3: them sort of. The facts of the case relates to
- 25:36Speaker 3: how much of Videous profit was coming from sales of
- 25:40Speaker 3: its GPU's graphic processing units to cryptocurrency miners. The concern
- 25:45Speaker 3: is that that amount of profit was not being fully
- 25:49Speaker 3: disclosed and instead in video was from the plaintiff's perspective,
- 25:53Speaker 3: hiding the amount of profit they were making from cryptocurrency
- 25:56Speaker 3: miners and just putting it under a catch all category
- 26:00Speaker 3: or gamers.
- 26:01Speaker 1: Please explain what cryptocurrency miners are.
- 26:04Speaker 3: Sure and so crystocurrency miners Clinston's bitcoin, which is bitcoin.
- 26:08Speaker 3: Anytime there is a bitcoin transaction, there are miners, people
- 26:12Speaker 3: who use a computer to validate that transaction, to confirm
- 26:16Speaker 3: that it's a legitimate transaction, and process the transaction. In
- 26:19Speaker 3: return for doing this work, the cryptocurrency minors have historically
- 26:23Speaker 3: been paid or to via bitcoin in order to do this.
- 26:26Speaker 3: Cryptocurrency mining is a very computer intensive work. It uses
- 26:31Speaker 3: an incredible amount of energy and it's actually terrible for
- 26:34Speaker 3: the environment because of how much energy that it uses
- 26:37Speaker 3: and how heavy and extent of the computer processing is
- 26:40Speaker 3: that's required to allow crystocurrency mining. But also from the
- 26:44Speaker 3: SEC's perspective, as an added wrinkle in this case, cryptocurrency
- 26:48Speaker 3: mining is problematic because from the SEC's perspective, the extent
- 26:53Speaker 3: to which mining because occurring mirrors the fluctuations in the
- 26:58Speaker 3: overall market cryptocurrency. So if we're taking bitcoins, the SEC
- 27:03Speaker 3: is concerned that if your processor tied to cryptocurrency mining,
- 27:07Speaker 3: then your profits are going to follow the sort of undulations,
- 27:10Speaker 3: the ups and downs of the bitcoin market, and that
- 27:13Speaker 3: is sort of what happened a little bit in Video's
- 27:15Speaker 3: case and why got hot water with the SEC, and
- 27:17Speaker 3: then why his case ultimately arose because at its core,
- 27:21Speaker 3: in Video, because they're just cryptocurrency adjacent. This isn't coin based,
- 27:24Speaker 3: they're not an cryptocurrency investment firm. They make computer shifts,
- 27:27Speaker 3: and they made these GPUs, a computer chip that was
- 27:30Speaker 3: initially meant for gamers, but because it is so powerful
- 27:34Speaker 3: and because a lot of the computing power that's required
- 27:37Speaker 3: for mining is somewhat transferable to the computing power required
- 27:41Speaker 3: for high level gaming, it became very popular among cryptocurrency miners,
- 27:45Speaker 3: and so cryptocurrency miners were buying huge amounts of these
- 27:48Speaker 3: processing units. And what is the crux factually of the
- 27:52Speaker 3: case is whether In Video CEO knew to what extent
- 27:57Speaker 3: a large portion of the profits the planet is alleged
- 27:59Speaker 3: that like nearly seventy percent almost of the gaming related
- 28:05Speaker 3: profit that in Video was claiming was actually due to
- 28:08Speaker 3: cryptocurrency minors. And from the SEC's perspective, that's the material
- 28:13Speaker 3: non disclosure, and certainly from the plaintiffs's that they're claiming
- 28:15Speaker 3: is a non disclosure because if over a billion dollars
- 28:18Speaker 3: of your profit is related to and tied up with
- 28:22Speaker 3: the cryptocurrency market and stakes bitcoin, that could give investors
- 28:27Speaker 3: cause for concern given the fluctuations inherent in the bitcoin market.
- 28:31Speaker 1: So the company said November twenty eighteen had missed its
- 28:34Speaker 1: revenue projections, and shares tumbled more than twenty eight percent
- 28:38Speaker 1: over two days. Innvidia's chief executives said, quote, a crypto
- 28:42Speaker 1: hangover was to blame. What did he mean by that?
- 28:46Speaker 1: And is it believable?
- 28:47Speaker 3: Well, it's certainly believable, you know. That's the statement that
- 28:49Speaker 3: I think certainly was part and parcel among why the
- 28:53Speaker 3: SEC has been involved. I mean, in Vidia has settled
- 28:55Speaker 3: an SDC regulatory enforcement action specifically related to this issue
- 29:00Speaker 3: five million dollars for that, and the plaintiffs are clinging
- 29:03Speaker 3: two statements like that to show that he knew essentially
- 29:07Speaker 3: what the plaintiffs were saying. Is the CEO, by saying
- 29:09Speaker 3: that knew that the fluctuation the wilds drop and bitcoin
- 29:14Speaker 3: around that same time, proved that Nvidia knew that these
- 29:18Speaker 3: processing units were being sold to and used heavily by
- 29:20Speaker 3: bitcoin miners because the reason that their profits dropped so
- 29:24Speaker 3: precipitously was because when bitcoin plummeted, so did the need
- 29:28Speaker 3: for minors and all of that work. And so the
- 29:30Speaker 3: fact that that those sales are so strongly linked, and
- 29:33Speaker 3: then you have the CEO statement to the same effect.
- 29:36Speaker 3: From the plaintiff's perspective, evidence is their knowledge, CEO's knowledge
- 29:41Speaker 3: certainly that a large portion of these GPUs graphic processing
- 29:46Speaker 3: units were heavily marketed, sold to, and utilized by the crisis.
- 29:50Speaker 1: Nvidia argued in its appeal that quote nothing plaintiffs have
- 29:54Speaker 1: sided describes the contents of a single internal communication involving
- 29:59Speaker 1: in vidious CEO that in fact addressed the portion of
- 30:02Speaker 1: GPU sold to cryptocurrency minors. Well, they don't need a
- 30:06Speaker 1: single internal document, do they.
- 30:09Speaker 3: No, they don't. I mean, I think that's a little overplayed,
- 30:12Speaker 3: and on some level it's difficult to contemplate how they
- 30:15Speaker 3: could get that right now. I mean, they have an
- 30:17Speaker 3: entry into discovery. They don't have access to any of
- 30:19Speaker 3: those documents that she would have in discovery. I mean,
- 30:22Speaker 3: it's a nice tagline, it's nice in hyperbolic, but it
- 30:25Speaker 3: really does I think overplay their argument a little bit
- 30:28Speaker 3: in that, of course they don't have documents, and they're
- 30:31Speaker 3: not required to state the specificity the actual contents of
- 30:34Speaker 3: a document, but they're required to say, and this is
- 30:37Speaker 3: one theory of pleading security fraud, is that there were
- 30:41Speaker 3: or there exists internal documents that would have put the
- 30:44Speaker 3: CEO unnoticed, as specifically the amount of proceeds coming from
- 30:48Speaker 3: sales to cryptocurrency miners, and the CEO knowingly and intentionally
- 30:52Speaker 3: may statements the contrary saying that you know, this profit
- 30:56Speaker 3: is more heavily tied to gaining and so you know,
- 30:59Speaker 3: the theory of their case, the plaintiffs case, is that
- 31:01Speaker 3: there were internal documents, internal information that would have put
- 31:04Speaker 3: the CEO unnoticed, and they do need to provide some
- 31:07Speaker 3: specificity as to what those documents would have been and
- 31:09Speaker 3: what they would have looked like, how much access we
- 31:12Speaker 3: would have had to them. But you know, word for word,
- 31:15Speaker 3: quoting a document for my read is hard beyond what's necessary.
- 31:19Speaker 3: But that is something that different court is going to
- 31:21Speaker 3: have to tease out here.
- 31:22Speaker 1: And why do you think the court took this case.
- 31:25Speaker 3: There's a number of different reasons. I think one of
- 31:27Speaker 3: them is that you now on a couple of issues
- 31:29Speaker 3: related to spleting standard like this for instance, this issue
- 31:33Speaker 3: on what needs to be pled about the contents of documents,
- 31:36Speaker 3: what's required for frauds. The answer you are having some
- 31:40Speaker 3: of these big circuits, like the Ninth and the Second
- 31:42Speaker 3: coming to diverging opinions. And there was a compelling argument
- 31:46Speaker 3: that Nvidia has here in that the Ninth Circuit and
- 31:49Speaker 3: the Second Circuit, if they are in fact approaching these differently.
- 31:53Speaker 3: Those two circuits, I mean, handle more than half of
- 31:56Speaker 3: the securities fraud cases in the country is an enormous number.
- 31:59Speaker 3: We have a circuit which is as California, since you
- 32:02Speaker 3: have San Francisco, to all any of the second circuit
- 32:04Speaker 3: which has New York. I mean, that is a tremendous
- 32:06Speaker 3: amount of security obligation should being handled by those two circuits.
- 32:09Speaker 3: And it is important that they are on the same page.
- 32:12Speaker 3: That's the strong spaces we're doing. So I think it
- 32:15Speaker 3: will be interesting to see which way the Court goes
- 32:18Speaker 3: on this as.
- 32:19Speaker 1: Far as shareholder actions, Does the Supreme Court have a
- 32:22Speaker 1: pattern of how it's ruled in the past or not.
- 32:26Speaker 3: I think that the knee jerk reaction would be to
- 32:29Speaker 3: say that they are going to make it harder to
- 32:31Speaker 3: bring these cases. But they haven't necessarily been issuing rulings
- 32:34Speaker 3: that just sort of fall in mind what you would assume. First,
- 32:38Speaker 3: They haven't been issuing sort of down the road conservative
- 32:41Speaker 3: super majority type of ruling.
- 32:43Speaker 1: I don't recall a lot of cases that they've taken
- 32:46Speaker 1: on cryptocurrency.
- 32:48Speaker 3: No, they really haven't. And this is sort of a
- 32:50Speaker 3: broader area in which, you know, cryptocurrency in the role
- 32:54Speaker 3: of the court in really kind of legislating cryptocurrency, it
- 32:58Speaker 3: has fallen to the Court to do so because cryptocurrency
- 33:01Speaker 3: is just far outpacing regulation. Congress is not moving fast
- 33:06Speaker 3: at all or even sort of at all to do
- 33:08Speaker 3: anything about cryptocurrency, and so you're seeing, for instance, like
- 33:11Speaker 3: the SEC getting very involved in attempting to regulate cryptocurrency,
- 33:16Speaker 3: in declaring it a security and therefore needs to be
- 33:19Speaker 3: regulated like any other investment. And you know, like they're
- 33:22Speaker 3: in orld and very aggressive litigation with coinbase right now,
- 33:26Speaker 3: I don't know that the three courts case here will
- 33:29Speaker 3: have any huge ramifications related to crypto currency, unless unless
- 33:34Speaker 3: the Court is notice to day we're denying it they
- 33:37Speaker 3: did complete enough the plant just have plt enough, in
- 33:40Speaker 3: which case I could see the court potentially going into Well,
- 33:43Speaker 3: here's why they've plat enough because you know, cryptocurrency mining,
- 33:47Speaker 3: the volatility the cryptal currency market is a huge issue,
- 33:50Speaker 3: and failure to disclose that information would obviously have an
- 33:53Speaker 3: impact on investor concerns, investor confidence in the company. And
- 33:57Speaker 3: if they choose to affirm, then I circuit I could
- 34:01Speaker 3: see a situation which they will have to delve into
- 34:04Speaker 3: some extent the facts and what's been pledged here. And
- 34:08Speaker 3: the crux of that really is like, how concerning is
- 34:11Speaker 3: like cryptocurrency might to an investor, and if the CEO
- 34:16Speaker 3: has some knowledge of that with holding it or masking
- 34:19Speaker 3: it under another profitability metric, how problematic is that? So
- 34:23Speaker 3: all that to say, I don't know that this case
- 34:26Speaker 3: will have sweeping ramifications for cryptocurrency like sec the coinbase
- 34:33Speaker 3: right now, but it's certainly possible. And I think this
- 34:35Speaker 3: represents a trend that we're going to start seeing more
- 34:38Speaker 3: and more up in which as cryptocurrency becomes more mainstream,
- 34:42Speaker 3: we are going to see the courts have to weigh
- 34:45Speaker 3: in and effectively legislate to roll cryptocurrency in our market economy.
- 34:50Speaker 1: What about the effect this would have on shareholder litigation
- 34:53Speaker 1: because the Court is also going to take a case
- 34:57Speaker 1: of a shareholder lawsuit against Meta over the data harvesting
- 35:02Speaker 1: scandal involving Cambridge Analytics. So with these two cases, could
- 35:07Speaker 1: the court give companies new leverage to win early dismissal
- 35:12Speaker 1: of shareholder lawsuits or the opposite if they rule for
- 35:16Speaker 1: the shareholders.
- 35:17Speaker 3: Absolutely absolutely, I mean I think that has been a
- 35:20Speaker 3: lot of the talk this week when service granted and
- 35:24Speaker 3: yet you know, rarely or the Supreme Court handle azing
- 35:26Speaker 3: really a security debligation and other next dockets, They're going
- 35:29Speaker 3: to have two cases related to this, and certainly there
- 35:32Speaker 3: is the potential for them to change the landscape entirely.
- 35:36Speaker 3: And I think you saw that in the AMIKI briefs
- 35:39Speaker 3: from the former sec chairs. We're asking the Supreme Court
- 35:41Speaker 3: to reverse the knife and uphold the District Court's denial.
- 35:45Speaker 3: Here is that there wasn't enough plas please, standard is
- 35:49Speaker 3: quite rigorous, and if the Supreme Court does sort of
- 35:52Speaker 3: follow that line of argument, it would certainly change the landscape.
- 35:57Speaker 3: In tandem with the met in Cambridge Analytic case, there
- 36:00Speaker 3: is joining the potential for surplaintive securious broadcases dramatically change next.
- 36:05Speaker 1: Term seems far away right now. Thanks for joining us. Seth.
- 36:10Speaker 1: That's Seth Gertz, a partner at Dorsey and Whitney. And
- 36:13Speaker 1: that's it for this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast.
- 36:16Speaker 1: Remember you can always get the latest legal news by
- 36:18Speaker 1: subscribing and listening to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
- 36:22Speaker 1: and at Bloomberg dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm
- 36:26Speaker 1: June Grosso and this is Bloomberg