Latest / Deep Dive / When Housing Becomes a Health Issue: How Poor Housing, Financial Strain and Mental Health Interact
Transcript
- 0:00Usually when we talk about a medical diagnosis, there's this
- 0:03expectation of precision, right? Like it feels kind of like
- 0:06engineering. Right.
- 0:07Yeah, exactly. You break your arm, the X-ray
- 0:09shows a jagged white line, and the doctor just points at it and
- 0:12says you know, there it is. That's the problem.
- 0:14It's a very comforting binary. Yes, like it.
- 0:16It's either broken or it's not. Yeah, we want all our problems
- 0:19to be visible and easily categorized like that.
- 0:23We really do. But step into the world of like,
- 0:26neurodevelopment or trauma, or in, in the case of what we're
- 0:29unpacking today, the intersection of housing,
- 0:31financial strain and mental health, and suddenly that X-ray
- 0:33machine is just totally useless. It's completely useless, Yeah,
- 0:37because we're dealing with systems that overlap and
- 0:42compound, and honestly, they disguise themselves right?
- 0:46Like housing is almost always treated purely as an economic
- 0:49indicator on the no. For sure interest rates, market
- 0:52values. Exactly.
- 0:53But the data we're looking at today proves it's actually this
- 0:57massive, glaring public health blind spot.
- 0:59And that is exactly what we're diving into.
- 1:02So for everyone listening, welcome to today's deep dive.
- 1:05We know you're curious and you want to get past those surface
- 1:08level news stats, so today our mission is to explore a massive
- 1:12blind spot in global housing data.
- 1:15It really is huge. It is.
- 1:16We're focusing on a fascinating 2020 study from Habitat
- 1:20International. It's by Viljohn, Loews,
- 1:23Lushington and Mcgreal, and it's titled Female Perspectives on
- 1:28Housing Quality and Household Characteristics, Perceptions and
- 1:31Challenges. Evidence from Australia.
- 1:33Which is a mouthful, but the actual content is.
- 1:37I mean, it's paradigm shifting. Right.
- 1:39We're going to break down surprising generational divides
- 1:41between women under and over 65. And later we're going to unpack
- 1:45this thing called a logistic regression model.
- 1:47Yes, which sounds super math heavy, but it basically predicts
- 1:50exactly what triggers financial strain in a household.
- 1:53Because housing isn't just, you know, bricks and mortar.
- 1:55It's a bio ecological pressure cooker.
- 1:58That's a great way to put it, a pressure cooker.
- 2:00Yeah, so by the end of this deep dive, you are going to look at
- 2:04leaky roof or like an expensive winter utility bill, not just as
- 2:09an annoyance, but as a literal predictor of mental health and
- 2:12systemic inequality. And to really grasp the gravity
- 2:15of this study, we first have to realize that the baseline data
- 2:19governments used to build cities and design policies, it's
- 2:23fundamentally. Right, the invisible women
- 2:25problem. Exactly.
- 2:26The literature introduces this concept of gender housing, and
- 2:31this goes way deeper than just marketing or aesthetics.
- 2:33It's not about like painting the walls pink.
- 2:36No, no, the researchers point to this Really Seminole 2008 paper
- 2:39by Foxo Mahoney, which lays out how historically and frankly,
- 2:43globally, the physical components of a house.
- 2:45The bricks, the land, all. That take the financial asset
- 2:48side of it that is legally and culturally viewed as a male
- 2:52preserve. Wow.
- 2:53OK, so the hard assets are male, while the softer elements like
- 2:56the sentimentality, the comfort, the actual creation of a home
- 2:59environment that is treated as a female preserve.
- 3:02Exactly. And this bias, it's not just
- 3:05historical, it's actively coded into our modern financial
- 3:08systems. Right now, the house as a
- 3:11tradable commodity, as a wealth generating asset, has been
- 3:15structured almost entirely around male earnings and male
- 3:18ownership. And you see this in the global
- 3:19data, right? Oh.
- 3:20Absolutely, yeah. The study sites a survey
- 3:23OF22OECD countries demonstrating that female home ownership
- 3:27remains stubbornly uncommon across the entire developed
- 3:30world. 22 countries, that's, I mean that's not a localized
- 3:34issue. No, it's systemic, Yeah.
- 3:35And they also look at specific cultural structures.
- 3:38Like in China, patrilineal family traditions basically
- 3:41dictate that both the local community and the local
- 3:43authorities automatically recognize the male as the head
- 3:47of the household, right? And therefore he's the default
- 3:49owner of the family home completely regardless of the
- 3:52internal financial dynamics of that actual family.
- 3:54Wait, so even if the woman makes all money?
- 3:57Yes, it defaults to the male. And it's not just a matter of
- 4:01income in other places either. The paper mentions Latin
- 4:04America, where researchers found that even when female headed
- 4:06households have higher incomes, they still have substantially
- 4:10lower homeownership rates than male headed households.
- 4:13OK. So that totally breaks the
- 4:15standard economic equation, right?
- 4:16The idea that higher income automatically equals higher
- 4:19asset ownership. Exactly.
- 4:21When you factor in gender, that equation just falls apart.
- 4:24There are these complex structural, cultural and
- 4:28systemic barriers preventing women from converting their
- 4:31income into the physical asset of housing.
- 4:34But wait, if we look at modern data collection, like if a
- 4:37family is married and the money goes into the exact same joint
- 4:40bank account, why does it matter who the what do they call it the
- 4:45reference person? Reference person, Yeah.
- 4:47Why does it matter who the reference person on a government
- 4:50survey is? Like the household owns the
- 4:52house, right? It matters deeply because of how
- 4:55financial control and psychological stress are
- 4:57actually distributed inside that household.
- 4:59OK, unpack that for me. So let's look at Australia,
- 5:02which is where this specific data set is from.
- 5:05Australia is a highly developed, wealthy nation with, you know,
- 5:09very robust statistical gathering.
- 5:11But the Australian Bureau of Statistics, the ABS, they report
- 5:15on national home ownership rates based on the age and status of
- 5:18this reference person, and in their methodology, the default
- 5:23reference person is male. Are you serious?
- 5:25So when the government sends out a survey to figure out how
- 5:28Australians are experiencing their housing and the data just
- 5:31defaults to the guy's perspective.
- 5:33Yes, it completely obscures the female voice.
- 5:36It misses her perception of the housing quality, her specific
- 5:40financial strain and her psychological experience of
- 5:44navigating that living. Space.
- 5:45That's crazy. It's the 21st century.
- 5:47Are urban planners and data scientists really still
- 5:50operating with this level of gender blindness?
- 5:52Unfortunately, yes. The researchers bring in a 2019
- 5:56review by Moga Diamond Raffian, and they observed that urban
- 5:59planners still have a remarkably limited knowledge about gender
- 6:02complexity. Wow.
- 6:03Precisely because of methodologies like this.
- 6:05So planners are out there zoning neighborhoods and designing
- 6:08multibillion dollar housing policies based on data that
- 6:11effectively erases half the population's lived experience.
- 6:14It's like, OK, it's like trying to understand how a car drives,
- 6:16right? The suspension, the handling,
- 6:18the braking. But you only ever survey the
- 6:21passenger. That is a perfect analogy.
- 6:23You never ask the person who's actually steering the household
- 6:26budget and dealing with the mechanical failure.
- 6:28Right. And if the foundational data
- 6:30doesn't measure the driver's experience, any policy built on
- 6:33that data is going to fail the driver makes.
- 6:35Total sense. Which is exactly why Will Joan
- 6:38and her team had to bypass the standard government data
- 6:41entirely for this study. Right, they had to go find the
- 6:44drivers. Yes, they utilize the Australian
- 6:47Housing Conditions data set. This is funded by the Australian
- 6:50Research Council and it involved over 4500 in depth interviews
- 6:55across SA, Victoria and NSW. That's a huge sample size.
- 7:00It is, and for this specific paper they isolated 25181 female
- 7:06responses. So they finally just asked the
- 7:09driver. And the moment you isolate those
- 7:112500 women, this massive generational divide just
- 7:14fractures the data right now. Completely splits it open.
- 7:17Let's look at the household structures first because this
- 7:19blew my mind. 31% of these women are in a couple with kids. 29%
- 7:25are in a couple without kids, but a crucial 34% are living in
- 7:29exclusively female headed households.
- 7:31Right over a third, yeah. And that breaks down into 27%
- 7:35living as a lone person and 7% operating as one parent
- 7:39families. And that 34% represents a
- 7:42massive demographic that is navigating the housing market
- 7:46and all its associated costs entirely on their own.
- 7:49Without a safety. Net without the buffer of a
- 7:51second and historically higher male income, right?
- 7:54So to understand this dynamic, the research basically split the
- 7:58database on age. You have the over 65 cohort
- 8:02representing the retirement phase, so the silent generation
- 8:04and older boomers and then the under 65 cohort representing the
- 8:09active working age population. So let's examine what they call
- 8:12the 10 year divide, because across the entire sample, 63% of
- 8:16the women own their homes outright.
- 8:19Right. No mortgage at all.
- 8:20Zero mortgage, which sounds great right?
- 8:23But when you apply that age filter you just mentioned, the
- 8:26reality shifts drastically because of the over 65 cohort,
- 8:3083% own their homes outright. That's a huge majority.
- 8:34It is, but for the women under 65 five, that number plummets to
- 8:3847%. And if we look at who is
- 8:40carrying a mortgage, 41% of the under 60 fives are strapped with
- 8:45mortgage debt, compared to just 5% of the over 60 fives.
- 8:49We are essentially looking at 2 completely different economic
- 8:52universes occupying the exact same cities.
- 8:55Yeah, the older generation has secured the foundational asset
- 8:58of modern wealth, right the house.
- 9:01Outright. Outright, while the younger
- 9:03generation is actively and heavily indebted, just trying to
- 9:06acquire it. Interestingly, though, both
- 9:09groups rent at roughly the same rate, right around 10 to 11%.
- 9:13OK, I have a question about this because if someone is over 65
- 9:17and owns their home outright, meaning they have zero mortgage
- 9:19payments, how can they possibly be experiencing housing stress
- 9:24like their single biggest monthly expenses eliminated?
- 9:28Haven't they essentially won the housing game?
- 9:31On a macroeconomic spreadsheet, outright home ownership looks
- 9:34like absolute security. It looks like you've won, right?
- 9:37But the researchers pull from some really vital background
- 9:40literature here, specifically work by Dareb and Hartman and
- 9:44Baker and Thule, to reveal the extreme vulnerability hiding
- 9:48beneath that 83% figure, and particularly within the 10% of
- 9:51older women who are renters. Oh, let's start with the
- 9:53renters. That sounds precarious.
- 9:55It is beyond precarious. The private rental market in
- 9:57Austria, Australia, and this applies to the US or the UK as
- 10:00well, is incredibly volatile. Sure, if you are an older single
- 10:03woman relying on a fixed government pension and you're
- 10:07trying to survive at a private market where landlords can just
- 10:10increase rents arbitrarily or terminate leases, you are facing
- 10:14severe chronic economic disadvantage.
- 10:17Your income is totally flat. Exactly.
- 10:19You haven't accumulated wealth in the form of housing equity
- 10:22and your fixed pension simply cannot absorb market rent
- 10:26inflation. So that minority who missed out
- 10:29on home ownership are arguably the most vulnerable demographic
- 10:33in the entire country. Wow.
- 10:35They're constantly teetering on the edge of homelessness.
- 10:37It paints a really bleak picture, like if you didn't
- 10:40secure your spot on the home ownership boat decades ago,
- 10:44you're just left treading water in a stormy sea at an age when
- 10:48your physical capacity to work is diminishing.
- 10:52It's a brutal reality. And The thing is, even for the
- 10:5483% who do own their homes outright, the physical reality
- 10:58of maintaining that asset introduces an entirely different
- 11:01kind of stress. OK, so the house itself becomes
- 11:04the stressor, yes? This brings us to the physical
- 11:06structures. The vast majority of the women
- 11:09in this study of about 83% live in detached houses, though the
- 11:14older women are slightly more likely to live in semi detached
- 11:17homes or flats. But the average age of these
- 11:19dwellings across the board is 39 years.
- 11:22So these are older properties are going to need maintenance.
- 11:24Absolutely. Yet the baseline satisfaction
- 11:27reported in the survey is very high. 85% of the women rate the
- 11:33physical quality of their housing as excellent or good.
- 11:36And unsurprisingly, people who own their homes consistently
- 11:40rate them higher than renters do.
- 11:41Oh wait, the data reveals this thing.
- 11:43We should probably call the repair paradox, right?
- 11:45Yes, the repair paradox. This is fascinating.
- 11:48Because only 13% of the total sample reported that their home
- 11:52had major building problems. We're talking structural issues
- 11:56like rising damp, mold, cracks in the walls, sinking
- 11:59foundations. Right, the big stuff.
- 12:01But when the survey asked about the need for repairs, this
- 12:04enormous gap opened up between a generation.
- 12:07A massive. Yeah.
- 12:08Of the 3% of women who stated that repairs to their home were
- 12:11essential, 66% of them were in the under 65 cohort.
- 12:16And of the 1% who said repairs were essential and urgent, 74%
- 12:20were under 65. So the younger demographic is
- 12:24vastly more likely to perceive their housing flaws as like
- 12:27immediate, urgent crises. Which creates a really
- 12:30fascinating interpretive challenge for the data
- 12:33scientists. Right.
- 12:34Like, are the houses of younger women objectively deteriorating
- 12:38at a faster rate, or is there some psychological mechanism
- 12:42altering how these two groups report the exact same structural
- 12:46flaws? Like, is a younger woman just
- 12:49more stressed out by a cracked tile than an older woman?
- 12:51I love how you phrase that. How do you see it?
- 12:53Well, I think about this like the check engine light on a
- 12:55dashboard. Okay, if you're a younger driver
- 12:58and maybe you're stretched thin on your car payments and that
- 13:01little orange light comes on, you immediately panic.
- 13:05Oh, absolutely. You perceive it as an essential,
- 13:08urgent crisis because you fear the engine is about to explode
- 13:11and leave you stranded. You literally can't afford for
- 13:14the part to die, right? But if you've been driving that
- 13:16exact same car for 26 years and the check engine light has been,
- 13:19you know, flittering on and off since 2012, you know the quirks
- 13:25of the engine. You might just put a piece of
- 13:26black tape over the light. Exactly.
- 13:28You ignore it because you know the car will still get you to
- 13:30the grocery store. It's fine.
- 13:32That dashboard analogy maps perfectly onto the psychological
- 13:35literature the researchers used to decode this data.
- 13:38They pull from a 2016 study by Coleman ET al.
- 13:41Which investigated this concept of aging in place.
- 13:45Aging in place? What does that mean exactly in
- 13:47this context? It's the widely held desire
- 13:50among older adults to remain in their own homes for as long as
- 13:54possible, rather than transitioning into residential
- 13:56care facilities or nursing homes.
- 13:58Which makes sense, but that requires the home to actually
- 14:01remain safe and functional. Yes, it does.
- 14:04But Coleman found that for older adults, and particularly older
- 14:06women facing financial constraints, home maintenance is
- 14:10a source of intense psychological distress.
- 14:12Really. Yes.
- 14:14They often lack the physical capacity to do the repairs
- 14:17themselves. They don't know which
- 14:18contractors to trust not to scam them, and they are terrified of
- 14:22the financial cost. So what's their coping
- 14:24mechanism? Just ignoring it.
- 14:26They deliberately avoid asking for help or reporting the issue.
- 14:29Wow, because admitting the house is failing is essentially
- 14:32admitting they are failing to manage it.
- 14:35Precisely if an older woman admits she has major structural
- 14:38problems she cannot fix, she fears it's going to signal to
- 14:41her family members or social workers or medical professionals
- 14:45that she no longer has the competency to live
- 14:47independently. Oh wow, it triggers the dreaded
- 14:50conversation about moving into a care home.
- 14:52Exactly. So the data showing older women
- 14:55reporting fewer urgent repairs might not reflect reality at
- 14:59all. It likely reflects a survival
- 15:02strategy that's. Heartbreaking.
- 15:03It really is. They're under reporting the
- 15:06issues out of a deep seated fear of losing their autonomy.
- 15:10The under 60 fives report the check engine light because
- 15:13they're trying to maintain the assets value.
- 15:15Right, They want to protect their investment.
- 15:17But the over 60 fives ignore the check engine light because
- 15:20acknowledging it might mean someone takes the keys away
- 15:23entirely. That entirely shifts how we read
- 15:25the numbers. It transforms a simple housing
- 15:28statistic into a literal measurement of psychological
- 15:31safety. It really does.
- 15:32And this underlying anxiety over maintenance costs leads us
- 15:36directly into the core thesis of the paper Financial Strain,
- 15:41because this is where the structural inequities of gender
- 15:44become painfully mathematical. Yes, let's get into the numbers
- 15:47on strain. Yeah, the baseline metric here
- 15:50is that 13% of all the women surveyed reported their
- 15:54household experience financial strain in the previous 12
- 15:57months. But again, the age split changes
- 16:00everything. It is 20% for the under 60 fives
- 16:03versus only 5% for the over 65. Which is a massive difference.
- 16:07One in five younger women are in active financial distress and
- 16:11when you look at lone parents, the single mothers, the number
- 16:14is just staggering. 49% of lone parents experience financial
- 16:17strength. Wait, nearly half?
- 16:19Literally half of all single mothers are operating in a state
- 16:22of financial crisis. That is, I mean, that's a
- 16:24systemic failure. So the researchers naturally dug
- 16:26deeper to find the catalyst, right?
- 16:28Like what specific expenditure is pushing these households over
- 16:32the edge? Right.
- 16:33And you would assume the primary culprit is the mortgage or the
- 16:36rent. Like, it's the largest line item
- 16:38in any budget, of course, but the data shows only 11% of the
- 16:42people in financial strain attributed it to their mortgage
- 16:45or rent. Really only 11%?
- 16:47Yeah, it seems people will severely compromise every other
- 16:51aspect of their lives to ensure they don't lose their physical
- 16:54shelter. Because shelter is the non
- 16:56negotiable baseline, you will skip meals before you skip rent.
- 17:00Exactly. So the breaking points are
- 17:02actually the secondary highly volatile costs of living. 27% of
- 17:06the respondents stated the primary cause of their financial
- 17:09strain was utility bills keeping the lights on and the house
- 17:12heated, and another 16% identified car registration and
- 17:17vehicle insurance as the trigger.
- 17:19It's the unpredictable chunky expenses.
- 17:22Right. I sort of like in the household
- 17:23budget to a game of financial Jenga.
- 17:26OK, I like. That the mortgage or the rent is
- 17:28that massive foundational block at the very bottom.
- 17:32You never touch it because pulling it out brings the entire
- 17:35tower down immediately. You lose your home, but the game
- 17:38of life forces you to keep pulling blocks just to survive
- 17:41the month. So you pull the entertainment
- 17:43block. You pull a new clothes block.
- 17:44You pull the premium groceries block.
- 17:46You're fitting out the tower. Exactly.
- 17:48But suddenly winter hits and you are forced to pull a massive
- 17:51utility bill block out of the middle of the stack or the car
- 17:55registration comes due. Pulling those specific blocks is
- 17:58what actually destabilizes the entire tower and makes it
- 18:01collapse. That is a brilliant way to
- 18:03visualize it, and this introduces a really critical
- 18:06concept that the researchers highlight, which is energy
- 18:10poverty. Energy poverty, yes.
- 18:12Overall, 6% of the women in the study struggle to keep their
- 18:15house comfortably warm in the winter or cool in the summer.
- 18:18Which in Australia can be extreme.
- 18:20Very extreme and predictably, this incidence of energy poverty
- 18:24is significantly higher for the under 65 cohort because they
- 18:28cannot afford to pull that utility bill Jenga block.
- 18:31They are literally enduring freezing conditions inside their
- 18:35own homes. And the study also maps out how
- 18:37repair costs act as the sudden shocks to the Jenga tower too,
- 18:41right? Oh, absolutely.
- 18:43They mathematically demonstrate that even a relatively modest
- 18:46repair cost of under $2500 is a highly significant trigger for
- 18:51financial strength. 2 1/2 grand, right?
- 18:53A broken water heater or a leaking roof isn't just an
- 18:57inconvenience, it can throw a single parent household into a
- 19:01cycle of debt that lasts for years.
- 19:03Which forces us to ask why the financial architecture of these
- 19:06households is so fragile to begin with.
- 19:09Why does a $2000 unexpected expense trigger a catastrophic
- 19:13structural failure? And that's where the paper
- 19:16points to intersecting macroeconomic inequality.
- 19:18The bigger picture. Exactly.
- 19:20Women face a persistent gender pay gap, and due to
- 19:23disproportionate caregiving responsibilities, whether that's
- 19:26for children or aging parents, women have a much greater
- 19:29reliance on part time work or less secure employment.
- 19:32Right, they have to be flexible. And in Australia, this directly
- 19:34translates to drastically lower superannuation.
- 19:37Which is their mandatory retirement savings system for
- 19:40anyone unfamiliar. Right, because superannuation is
- 19:44tied directly to your wages. If you spend a decade working
- 19:47part time to manage school drop offs, or you step out of the
- 19:51workforce entirely for early childcare, you aren't paying
- 19:55into your retirement. While your male counterpart is
- 19:58compounding his investment wealth uninterrupted.
- 20:00Uninterrupted exactly while you are effectively economically
- 20:04penalized for performing unpaid domestic labor.
- 20:07And this macro level disparity leaves women under 65 uniquely
- 20:12exposed, doesn't it? It does.
- 20:14The researchers explicitly note that this younger demographic
- 20:17has borne the brunt of the debt funded economic crises over the
- 20:20last two decades. They purchased homes during
- 20:23periods of wildly escalating housing costs, meaning they
- 20:26carry massive mortgages, they have less liquid savings, and
- 20:29they're navigating a gig heavy, precarious job market.
- 20:33Their Jenga tower just starts with fewer blocks and a much
- 20:36less stable base. And when that tower wobbles, the
- 20:38impact isn't just confined to like a bank Ledger, it acts
- 20:41directly on the human body. Which brings us to arguably the
- 20:45most complex and revealing part of this entire study, the
- 20:48logistic regression model, because the researchers wanted
- 20:52to mathematically prove the connection between the physical
- 20:54home and the physiological health of the occupant.
- 20:57Let's establish the physical health baseline first, just to
- 21:00give a context. Across the board, 86% of the
- 21:04women rated their physical health as good to excellent.
- 21:08OK, pretty high. And naturally, the over 65
- 21:11cohort reports higher incidences of physical ailments, things
- 21:15like hypertension or long term disabilities that might restrict
- 21:19daily activity. That's just the reality of
- 21:21aging. But when we pivot to mental
- 21:23health, the trend reverses completely. 18% of the women
- 21:27reported experiencing mental health issues in the last 12
- 21:30months and those issues, clinical anxiety, depression,
- 21:33chronic stress are heavily, heavily concentrated in the
- 21:36under 65 cohort. So to understand how all these
- 21:39variables age, housing, income, mental health, actually
- 21:43interact, the researchers utilized a logistic regression
- 21:46model. OK, before we get to the actual
- 21:48results, can we just unpack what a logistic regression model
- 21:51actually does? Like if you're listening to this
- 21:53and you haven't taken a statistics class in 20 years,
- 21:56how does this work? Sure, Yeah, Think of a logistic
- 21:59regression model as an advanced filtering system used to predict
- 22:04a binary outcome. In this case, the outcome is
- 22:07whether a household will or will not experience financial strain.
- 22:12OK, so imagine you're trying to figure out what makes a car
- 22:15fast. I like car analogies.
- 22:17You have all these variables, right?
- 22:18The engine size, the weight of the car, the aerodynamics, even
- 22:21the color of the paint. A regression model looks at all
- 22:24the data and isolates each individual variable by
- 22:28mathematically holding all the other variables constant.
- 22:31It basically says if we have two cars that weigh the exact same,
- 22:35have the exact same aerodynamics and the same paint color, but
- 22:38one has a bigger engine, how much faster does it go?
- 22:40OK, so it strips away the noise. Exactly.
- 22:43It strips away the noise to find the true mathematical drivers of
- 22:46an outcome. It allows us to pinpoint the
- 22:50exact influence of a single factor without it being muddied
- 22:53by everything else. That's brilliant.
- 22:55So it finds the true mathematical drivers of
- 22:58financial strain, and the results they got are incredibly
- 23:01revealing. They really are.
- 23:03The model shows that age is actually a protective factor.
- 23:06Being over 75 actually reduces your likelihood of experiencing
- 23:10financial strain. Which makes sense based on what
- 23:13we talked about earlier, primarily because of the high
- 23:15rate of outright homeownership in that group.
- 23:17Right, but then the model identifies the risk multipliers.
- 23:21OK, hit me. Being a lone parent increases a
- 23:23household's odds of financial strain by 1.85 times.
- 23:27Almost double. Having poor physical health
- 23:29increases the odds by 1.79 times.
- 23:32Experiencing poor thermal comfort, that energy poverty
- 23:35where you were freezing in your living room, that increases the
- 23:38odds by 1.72 times. OK.
- 23:40So those are all major, major stressors.
- 23:42They are, but there was 1 predictor that completely dwarfs
- 23:46all the others. The monitor proves that
- 23:48experiencing mental health issues in the last 12 months
- 23:51increases the odds of a household experiencing financial
- 23:54strain by a staggering factor of 2.619.
- 23:57Wait. 2.6 times more likely. Over 2 1/2 times more likely.
- 24:01But OK, doesn't this present a massive chicken and egg dilemma?
- 24:05Like does the financial strain of the leaking roof in the
- 24:08unpaid electricity bill cause the clinical depression and
- 24:11anxiety? Or does a pre-existing mental
- 24:13health struggle make it exponentially harder to maintain
- 24:16employment and manage a strict budget, thereby causing the
- 24:20financial strain? That is the central tension of
- 24:22the entire research field right there.
- 24:24Based on the extensive psychological literature the
- 24:26authors incorporate into the paper, the answer is that the
- 24:29relationship is deeply bidirectional.
- 24:31It feeds itself, yes. Yes.
- 24:33It operates as a self reinforcing downward spiral.
- 24:35However, there is powerful evidence demonstrating that
- 24:37housing quality is a primary initiator of mental health
- 24:40decline. Really.
- 24:41The house starts, Yes. The paper cites a really pivotal
- 24:44year 2000 study by Evans, Wells and Marsh.
- 24:47How did Evans isolate the housing from the income though?
- 24:51Because usually bad housing just means low income, right?
- 24:55That's the genius of the study. Evans and his team studied low
- 24:59income women and their young children who are living in urban
- 25:02high rise buildings. They systematically measured the
- 25:05physical environment, the cleanliness, the indoor climate,
- 25:08crowding hazards, structural quality, but crucially, they
- 25:13controlled for income, meaning they were mathematically
- 25:17comparing women who made the exact same amount of money.
- 25:20Oh wow, so they eliminated the income variable completely?
- 25:23Exactly. And they discovered that the
- 25:24women who were forced to live in poor quality housing exhibited
- 25:28significantly higher levels of psychological distress than
- 25:31those in high quality housing. Even with the same amount of
- 25:34money in the bank. Exactly.
- 25:35The physical environment acts directly on the nervous system.
- 25:38The ambient stress of living in a dilapidated space biologically
- 25:42alters you. So the house itself becomes a
- 25:44pathogen. That's a strong word, but yes.
- 25:47It is either a healing environment that buffers you
- 25:49against the stress of the outside world, or it's a toxic
- 25:52environment that actively degrades your mental resilience
- 25:55every time you walk through the door.
- 25:56And the collateral damage of that toxic environment extends
- 25:59directly to the next generation. The kids.
- 26:02Yes, the researchers bring in a 2012 study by Coley and
- 26:06Leventhal, which viewed housing through a bio ecological lens.
- 26:11They demonstrated that low quality housing induces severe
- 26:14chronic stress in mothers. Which elevates cortisol.
- 26:18Elevates cortisol causes emotional exhaustion, and that
- 26:21exhaustion limits the mother's capacity to regulate family
- 26:24routines and provide emotional buffering for her kids.
- 26:28Consequently, this directly damages the children's socio
- 26:31emotional functioning. The children in these
- 26:34deteriorating homes showed far greater emotional and behavioral
- 26:37problems than their peers in better housing.
- 26:40So a cracked foundation or a freezing living room doesn't
- 26:43just impact a mother's bank account, it chemically alters
- 26:46her stress response which in turn alters the socio emotional
- 26:50development of her child. We are looking at a multi
- 26:53generational cycle here. Like financial strain prevents a
- 26:56woman from fixing her house or heating it properly.
- 26:59The freezing deteriorating house destroys her mental health.
- 27:03The degraded mental health makes it 2.6 times more likely she
- 27:06will face even deeper financial strain while simultaneously
- 27:10impact her children's development.
- 27:12And this entire cycle is disproportionately trapping
- 27:15younger single women. It is a profound systemic
- 27:19failure, truly. Heavy.
- 27:21It is, but the researchers, to their credit, do not stop at
- 27:25just diagnosing the problem. The final section of the paper
- 27:28pivots to macro level policy implications and proposes very
- 27:32concrete interventions to break this cycle.
- 27:35We have to look at how government policies actively
- 27:38manipulate this Jenga tower. Essentially, yes, because the
- 27:40study highlights a major, highly consequential policy shift in
- 27:44Australia regarding the retirement safety net.
- 27:46Back in 1994, the Australian government raised the pension
- 27:49eligibility age for women from 60 to 65, basically aligning it
- 27:53with men, and more recently, they initiated a progressive
- 27:56time to push the eligibility age all the way to 67 by 2023.
- 28:03Now, if you view the population purely as data on a
- 28:05macroeconomic spreadsheet, raising the retirement age seems
- 28:09logical. Governments are managing aging
- 28:11populations and shrinking tax bases, right?
- 28:13They need people working longer. Sure, on paper it makes sense.
- 28:17But Villjohn and her team point out that this blanket reform
- 28:20disproportionately punishes the most vulnerable demographics,
- 28:24the poorer households, the single women and the lifelong
- 28:27renters. Because the policy just blindly
- 28:29assumes everyone arrives at age 65 with the exact same level of
- 28:33resources and physical health. Exactly.
- 28:36If you are a high income earner who owns your home outright and
- 28:39works a, you know, low impact desk job, working until 67 might
- 28:43be entirely manageable. It might even be preferable.
- 28:46But what if you were a 62 year old woman who never managed to
- 28:48buy a home? You're navigating A ruthless
- 28:50private rental market. Your body is literally breaking
- 28:54down from decades of physical labor in retail or caregiving,
- 28:58and your mental health is severely compromised.
- 29:01The government is essentially telling you that your safety net
- 29:03has been moved further away and you have to somehow survive five
- 29:07more years of manual labor just to access basic survival funds.
- 29:11It's cruel. For women trapped in the cycle
- 29:13of financial strain and poor health, adding years to the
- 29:16finish line is catastrophic. The physical and mental toll of
- 29:20precarious employment and housing insecurity just
- 29:22accelerates as they age. And we really have to view this
- 29:25vulnerability through the lens of recent macroeconomic shocks
- 29:28to like. This paper was finalized in the
- 29:31shadow of the COVID-19 pandemic. Oh absolutely.
- 29:33The pandemic acted as a massive accelerant to these exact
- 29:37inequalities. It perfectly targeted the fault
- 29:39lines this study identified. The researchers cite data
- 29:43confirming that globally, more women lost their jobs than men
- 29:46during the initial economic lockdowns.
- 29:47Primarily because women are vastly overrepresented in the
- 29:50hardest hit sectors. Right.
- 29:52Hospitality, retail and caregiving, Those were wiped
- 29:54out. Exactly.
- 29:56But the economic blow was also coupled with a massive
- 29:58psychological blow. The authors reference a 2020
- 30:02study by Liu that examined populations in China during the
- 30:05most severe early outbreaks. They found that women reported
- 30:09significantly higher levels of post traumatic stress symptoms,
- 30:12PTSS than men did. So just think about how that
- 30:15interacts with the logistic regression model we just talked
- 30:18about. We know that experiencing mental
- 30:20health issues makes a woman 2.6 times more likely to suffer
- 30:23financial strain, right? Then a global pandemic hits,
- 30:26simultaneously destroying female dominated job sectors and
- 30:30inflicting mass psychological trauma on that exact same
- 30:33demographic. It is a compounding disaster.
- 30:36It is. So how do the researchers
- 30:38suggest we intervene? Like how do we actually stop the
- 30:40bleeding here? The picker proposes solutions on
- 30:432 distinct fronts, enhancing individual capability and
- 30:47executing structural systemic reform.
- 30:49OK, let's start with the individual.
- 30:50On the individual level, they point to research by White at
- 30:54from 2018. This study demonstrated that
- 30:57providing targeted financial education programs specifically
- 31:01designed for single low income women yielded measurable
- 31:04improvements in their overall well-being and health.
- 31:07Which I can see equipping someone with the tools to
- 31:10navigate complex debt structures or understand interest rates and
- 31:14manage budgeting. It gives them a sense of agency.
- 31:16Exactly. It transitions them from feeling
- 31:18like a passive victim of a massive financial system to an
- 31:21active participant. And that transition in itself
- 31:24reduces psychological distress. Knowledge provides armor.
- 31:28It does very, very clear that financial education alone cannot
- 31:31solve a fundamentally broken structural market, right?
- 31:34You cannot. Budget your way out of a housing
- 31:36crisis. If basic rent consumes 60% of
- 31:39your take home pay, you just can't.
- 31:40No amount of budgeting apps will.
- 31:42Fits that the primary focus must be on macro level intervention
- 31:45and the paper argues. Vehemently for massively
- 31:48increasing the availability of affordable, secure housing.
- 31:52But what I found revolutionary here is the framing.
- 31:55They aren't just arguing for affordable housing as a standard
- 31:59welfare policy, right? Like they're demanding it be
- 32:02viewed as a critical mental health intervention.
- 32:04This is the key take away. If the empirical data proves
- 32:07that deteriorating, insecure housing actively drives mental
- 32:11illness, and that mental illness destroys a household's financial
- 32:15viability, then building affordable, secure housing is
- 32:19literally preventative healthcare.
- 32:21It's medicine. It is.
- 32:23The upfront. Societal investment in building
- 32:25affordable housing directly reduces the massive downstream
- 32:28costs on the emergency medical system, psychiatric services,
- 32:32and child welfare programs, and the researchers also.
- 32:34Challenged the ideological rigidity of how we view housing
- 32:37in general. Right?
- 32:38Like in countries like Australia, and similarly here in
- 32:41the United States, there's this deeply entrenched dream of the
- 32:44detached single family home, the suburban castle.
- 32:47Exactly. It is the ultimate.
- 32:48Marker of success but as this data shows, that very rigidity,
- 32:52the societal expectation that everyone must acquire and
- 32:56independently maintain their own suburban castle, is exactly what
- 32:59traps so many single women in relentless financial strain they
- 33:03cannot afford the. Castle on a single income right
- 33:06so they. Are pushed to the absolute
- 33:09precarious margins of the private rental market instead,
- 33:12so the authors rely on. Literature from Darab ET al.
- 33:15And Devlin ET al. To propose that ARC
- 33:17architectural and financial flexibility is the key to
- 33:19protecting this demographic, we need to actively design and
- 33:23incentivize alternative models. Like what?
- 33:27Well, they suggest. Expanding Co housing models for
- 33:29one where residents have independent private living
- 33:32units. So you still have your own
- 33:33space, but you share extensive communal spaces, kitchens,
- 33:37gardens, maintenance resources. Oh I see.
- 33:40This drastically reduces both the financial burden of upkeep
- 33:43and the psychological burden of isolation.
- 33:45And they also discuss. Structural Co ownership schemes,
- 33:48right? Those are fascinating.
- 33:50Models where a low. Income earner might own, say,
- 33:5350% of a property's equity, while a government entity or a
- 33:57nonprofit Community Housing provider holds the other 50%
- 34:00right. It bridges the gap.
- 34:02The strict binary of either owning your home outright or
- 34:06being completely at the mercy of a private landlord is
- 34:09mathematically failing an enormous percentage of the
- 34:12population. We have to create more.
- 34:13Diverse options on the menu of human shelter.
- 34:16We really do. It requires a total paradigm
- 34:19shift in urban planning and economic policy, one that
- 34:22finally incorporates the specific, measured needs of the
- 34:26women who are actually steering these households.
- 34:28Let's pull all these threads. Together, because we have
- 34:30covered a lot of ground today, a huge amount.
- 34:32Began by uncovering. A massive blind spot in global
- 34:35data collection realizing that by defaulting to a male
- 34:38reference person, governments have essentially been flying
- 34:41blind they've been ignoring the operational reality of female
- 34:45headed households we examine the stark.
- 34:47Generational divide Within the female population itself, we saw
- 34:51a relatively secure over 65 cohort that is protected by
- 34:55historic outright homeownership standing in sharp contrast to a
- 34:59highly stressed under 65 cohort, a cohort that is drowning in
- 35:03mortgages, volatile utility bills and urgent repair costs.
- 35:07And then we looked under the. Hood of a logistic regression
- 35:09model to map the exact mathematical relationship
- 35:13between a home's physical state and a woman's psychological
- 35:16survival. Right.
- 35:17We established that energy poverty and structural flaws act
- 35:20as biological stressors and that declining mental health is the
- 35:24single most powerful predictor of catastrophic financial
- 35:27strain. Housing is not just an asset
- 35:29class, it is the bio ecological foundation of public health.
- 35:33Yes, if you are looking at your own utility bill or a crack in
- 35:36your ceiling, you are looking at an active variable in your
- 35:40physiological well-being, and that fundamentally.
- 35:42Alters how we should evaluate our own living spaces and the
- 35:46policies that govern them exactly the next.
- 35:48Time you see a news segment touting national homeownership
- 35:51rates or housing market resilience, the very first
- 35:53question you need to ask is who is actually being counted in
- 35:57that data and whose perspective was entirely erased to make the
- 36:01numbers look that clean. It's a crucial question.
- 36:03But before we wrap up. There is one final, overarching
- 36:07thought we really need to explore.
- 36:10It isn't a stated conclusion in the paper, but it is the
- 36:13terrifying, inevitable destination of all the data
- 36:16we've analyzed today. OK, I know where you're going
- 36:17with this. We saw clearly.
- 36:19That the current over 65 cohort, the older boomers and the silent
- 36:23generation, they are relatively stable today because they
- 36:27secured outright home ownership 30 or 40 years ago, right?
- 36:31That physical equity acts as their armor against the
- 36:34vulnerabilities of aging and the volatility of fixed pensions.
- 36:37Yes, but what happens in 20 years?
- 36:40Look at the current under 65 cohort we spent this entire time
- 36:43discussing. These are women currently
- 36:45carrying massive mortgages, battling clinically measured
- 36:48mental health stress, enduring energy poverty in the winter,
- 36:52navigating a gig economy that limits their retirement savings,
- 36:55and trying to manage households on single incomes.
- 36:58It's perfect storm. What happens when that?
- 37:00Demographic reaches the age of 67.
- 37:02What happens when their bodies can no longer perform manual
- 37:05labor, but they do not have the safety net of owning their homes
- 37:08outright? When the financial Jenga tower
- 37:11they have been desperately managing for decades finally
- 37:13gets too tall and there are simply no more blocks left to
- 37:16pull? It's chilling.
- 37:18Are we? Currently mathematically.
- 37:20Sleepwalking into an unprecedented future crisis of
- 37:23elderly female homelessness, It is something to seriously Mull
- 37:27over the next time you turn the key in your front door.
- 37:30Until next time, keep diving deep.