Latest / The New Humanitarian / In the Taliban's Islamic Emirate, 'everything seems fine, until it's not' | First Person
Transcript
- 0:02Ali Latifi: The New Humanitarian aims to amplify the voices of
- 0:05humanitarian workers, refugees, asylum seekers and people
- 0:10affected by conflicts and disasters. Today, I'm going to
- 0:13tell my story, part of a series of First Person narratives that
- 0:17dig into the humanity of humanitarian challenges. My name
- 0:21is Ali Latifi. I'm The New Humanitarian's Asia Editor and
- 0:26co-host of the What's Unsaid podcast. I grew up in the US,
- 0:31but I've been based in Afghanistan, where I was born,
- 0:34for more than 10 years now. Today marks three years since
- 0:38the creation of the Islamic Emirate. August 15, 2021. It's a
- 0:43moment to reflect.
- 0:54I've lived in the same building in Kabul since 2017. Over the
- 0:59years, I've often found myself staring out at the large, wide
- 1:03windows that look directly out onto the edifices of the new
- 1:06high rises that were just starting to pop up in the city
- 1:10skyline, and I think about the state of my country. I was
- 1:18gazing out of these windows when my cousin and I were deciding
- 1:21whether I should risk getting caught in the crossfire of an
- 1:24hours-long fight between the police and the son of a former
- 1:28defense minister. 'I really think it's dangerous, Ali.' My
- 1:31goal was to meet my friends at a birthday party they had planned
- 1:34for me at a Lebanese restaurant. 'Okay, what it's gonna say on
- 1:37our tombstone? Death by going to birthday party?' After a series
- 1:42of high-magnitude earthquakes struck the city in a single
- 1:4524-hour period in 2018, I would stare out these same windows for
- 1:49several nights after being awakened by the sensation of
- 1:53phantom tremors. On August 13th 2021, when the Taliban had taken
- 2:00over the provinces of Herat and Kandahar, I stared out those
- 2:03same windows, fearing what was to come, but vowing to try and
- 2:08stand by my people. 'A lot of people keep asking, what's going
- 2:12to happen, and the truth is nobody knows.' Two days later,
- 2:17when the Taliban finally did arrive in Kabul, I was too
- 2:21scared to look out those windows. 'That we still, as the
- 2:24Afghan people have to fear the Taliban.' I was driven by some
- 2:28lingering irrational fear that even high above the ground, I
- 2:32would somehow be recognized as a journalist who had spent the
- 2:35prior weeks speaking to what seemed like every TV station on
- 2:39Earth in a dumb California-boy accent. 'The last few weeks have
- 2:43been so up-and-down, what's going to happen, and the truth
- 2:46is nobody knows.' At the time, I couldn't imagine what life under
- 2:51an Islamic Emirate would be like, not only because I'd never
- 2:55experienced it before, but also because in those moments on
- 2:59August 15th, I couldn't think of anything other than what each
- 3:02succeeding minute would bring. 'That's the legacy of this war.
- 3:06I'm Ali Latifi, the online correspondent in Kabul for Al
- 3:09Jazeera.' Now, three years later, I've seen something
- 3:14strange. Something not even I could imagine possible. Tens of
- 3:19millions of Afghans who have lived through so many cultural
- 3:23and political upheavals since an absolute monarchy turned into a
- 3:26constitutional one in 1966, have somehow found ways to adjust to
- 3:31life under Taliban rule. 'Salaam, I am your host.' By
- 3:40many accounts, today's Islamic Emirate is not the same as the
- 3:44one in the 1990s. Televisions remain on. The cities are full
- 3:49of amateur YouTubers, aspiring Instagram influencers and
- 3:52TikTokers, including a little boy whose father swears is a
- 3:56genius and a Taliban-allied general who famously made a
- 4:01video offering Iran a pitcher of water from his native Logar
- 4:05province. But some things still remain very much the same. Girls
- 4:12are still not allowed to study beyond the sixth grade. Women
- 4:15are still barred from most employment opportunities.
- 4:18Afghanistan is still considered to be in the throes of a
- 4:20humanitarian crisis, with 23.7 million people in need of
- 4:25assistance. At least 700,000 people have been rendered
- 4:30jobless since 2021, while some Taliban officials may insist
- 4:34these are minor domestic issues, the truth is that to many
- 4:38Afghans, inside and outside the country, these are the issues
- 4:42that stand between them and a more wholehearted embrace of the
- 4:45Islamic Emirate. We've now found ourselves in a strange place
- 4:53where, like George Bush after 9/11, the Taliban insists the
- 4:58Islamic Emirate is open for business, and in many ways it
- 5:02is, but in just as many ways, it's not. Almost every week,
- 5:08there are media reports of investments, trade projects and
- 5:12contracts with foreign countries and investors. The evidence of
- 5:17these developments can be seen on city streets. Foreigners sit
- 5:20with Afghans at higher end eateries to discuss potential
- 5:23business ventures in English, German, Russian and mostly
- 5:26Mandarin. It's even found its way into the village, though.
- 5:31When a wild pig was discovered in Mussahi district of Kabul
- 5:34earlier this summer, a local farmer told me he would kill it
- 5:38and give it to the Chinese who are here every day to eat. It's
- 5:45not just would-be investors coming to Afghanistan though,
- 5:48the nation's urban centers are increasingly being inundated
- 5:51with foreign visitors. Afghans returning to their homeland for
- 5:55the first time in years, or maybe even decades, and foreign
- 5:59nationals eager to visit a country where the group that's
- 6:03now in power was the greatest threat to their safety for 20
- 6:07years. 'You
- 6:07Unknown: want to visit Taliban-controlled Afghanistan.
- 6:09I am super excited to be here'. While
- 6:12Ali Latifi: foreign nationals are busy posting about their
- 6:15adventures on Instagram, TikTok and YouTube, for Afghan's
- 6:19visiting their country, their fun will always be interrupted
- 6:23by the undeniable reality. Over the last two years, the Kabul
- 6:27municipality has worked on restoring and greening the
- 6:30Shahr-e Naw park, which was once the domain of strung-out drug
- 6:35addicts, snake oil salesmen, and young men lighting up joints.
- 6:39Since the renovation, though, men and boys are gathering at
- 6:43the restored park to read, pray, play cricket and football, or
- 6:47just lounge around. But women and girls are not legally
- 6:51allowed to enter the park. People have found a way to work
- 6:54around these restrictions. Girls and women are attending
- 6:58unofficial or home schools, or religious madrassas, or private
- 7:02language and computer courses. Female NGO leaders are securing
- 7:06permission for their female staff to continue to work. The
- 7:10owners of private businesses are still hiring women as call
- 7:14center operators, waitresses, sales girls, stewardesses,
- 7:18receptionists, and any number of other jobs. But the truth is
- 7:22that for the people and the international community, this is
- 7:26simply not enough. Last autumn, I had brought up these very
- 7:30workarounds to a Western diplomat in Doha. What I wanted
- 7:34to show her was that there was a semblance of difference or hope
- 7:38for this version of the Islamic Emirate. But her response was
- 7:42simple and blunt. We go by the law, not the workarounds. Last
- 7:46month, the 12-year-old daughter of a relative in Kabul was
- 7:50inconsolable after a worker of the Ministry of the Propagation
- 7:55of Virtue and the Prevention of Vice accosted her because a few
- 7:59wisps of her hair were protruding after the wind caused
- 8:02the scarf of her black abaya to slip. Though that marked the
- 8:06first run in any female member of her family had with the Vice
- 8:11and Virtue, it did a lot to shatter their illusion of
- 8:14normalcy. And that's just it. In the Islamic Emirate, everything
- 8:18seems fine until it's not. A relative of ours put it all
- 8:22pretty simply. There is safety, there is security. You can go
- 8:26anywhere you want. But there's still tension in the air. Deep
- 8:30down, people are still afraid of that one time when they cross
- 8:35the wrong one. Even with this underlying tension though,
- 8:38people, men and women, are still trying to live their lives, but
- 8:43as in the past, those on the margins of the map remain poor
- 8:47and underserved. Many of their fears may have dissipated with
- 8:51the end of the occupation, but the hunger and lack of services
- 8:55has not abated, especially as NGOs have had to cut their
- 8:59global budgets over the last two years, so now we're in a
- 9:02situation full of paradoxes. Much has changed, but much has
- 9:06also stayed the same. Many fears have been allayed, but other new
- 9:11ones have taken their places. The roads have opened, but the
- 9:15doors of many institutions have been shut. There is an
- 9:18acknowledgement that many issues must be resolved domestically by
- 9:23Afghans themselves, but from way up here, staring out of these
- 9:27big windows again, there's also little proof that people's cries
- 9:31are being heard.
- 9:38The New Humanitarian aims to amplify the voices of refugees,
- 9:41asylum seekers and people affected by conflict and
- 9:44disaster, placing them at the center of the conversation about
- 9:48the policies and events that shape their lives. Subscribe to
- 9:52our podcast feed to hear more stories from people affected by
- 9:55humanitarian issues. This episode was produced and edited
- 9:59by Freddie Boswell. Sound engineering by Alex Higgins and
- 10:02Original Music by Whitney Patterson. I'm Ali Latifi.
- 10:06Thanks for listening.