Latest / Newcomer Pod / OpenAI: A $300 Billion Non-Profit?
Transcript
- 0:00Exciting week here at Newcomer. We just announced our Cerebral
- 0:02Valley London AI summit. We are going across the pond.
- 0:06How are you feeling about that? Daunting.
- 0:09No, I, I think we're ready. We've got the venue, we've got a
- 0:11great speaker line up. Very excited to have, you know,
- 0:14dark Hazra Shahi, the CEO of Uber.
- 0:17Oh my gosh. Wait, you're, you're the Uber
- 0:19guy. What's it like, you know,
- 0:20booking him into your own event? It's flashbacks, you know, I
- 0:24covered to the insurance and outs of Uber, including the CEO
- 0:27search. You know, when it was a what it
- 0:29was going to be Jeffrey Immelt, it was going to be Meg Whitman.
- 0:31And then out of nowhere, it was sort of the dark horse, dark
- 0:34Hazra Shahi. And, you know, I've met with him
- 0:36a number of times. When Uber went public, I was
- 0:39there on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange when
- 0:42newcomer launched, Dara was kind enough to give me an interview.
- 0:46They've been pretty savvy, honestly, about independent
- 0:48media. I, I, I'm sure you saw that they
- 0:50did what one of the inauguration parties with Barry Weiss at the
- 0:54Free Press. So they're, they're definitely
- 0:57up on this sort of indie media. I've known them for a long time.
- 1:01It helps that they have a partnership and investment with
- 1:03Wave, the great self driving car company of Europe.
- 1:06Alex Kendall is going to speak with Dara and Uber, of course,
- 1:11needs to show how it's relevant in a sort of self driving future
- 1:15with Tesla beating Instrum very loudly and Waymo partnering with
- 1:19Uber but showing, hey, we can do our own thing.
- 1:22So yeah, I'm definitely excited about that one.
- 1:25Yeah, that'll be a great hit. Also, I mean, I'm super pumped
- 1:28about all the, you know, like spicy hot early stage startups
- 1:32that everyone's talking about going to be on the lineup.
- 1:34We got the CEO of Granola coming, the hottest AI note
- 1:37taker. I know I've started using it
- 1:39though. I'm like not good at being chill
- 1:41about it. You know, I feel like part of
- 1:43the sales pitch with granola is that you just like let it run
- 1:46and don't bother everybody. But I'm like, oh, I need to tell
- 1:49everybody I'm using that, which sort of complicates everything.
- 1:52And obviously, we have Dylan Field at Figma, which we're
- 1:55equally excited about. Yeah.
- 1:58June 25th, Cerebral Valley summit.com.
- 2:00Check it out. It's, you know, we want founders
- 2:02to apply. Basically, if you're a real
- 2:04insider, you should join us and apply or shoot us an e-mail.
- 2:08This episode is presented by Brex, the financial stack
- 2:11founders can bank on. Brex knows cash is king for
- 2:14startups, so they build a banking experience that takes
- 2:17every dollar further. Unlike traditional business
- 2:21banking solutions, Brex has no minimums and no transaction
- 2:24fees, and you can get 20X the standard FDIC protection.
- 2:28Even better, you can earn industry leading yield from your
- 2:32first dollar while still being able to access your funds
- 2:35anytime. Get the business account trusted
- 2:37by one in three US startups at brex.com
- 2:40forwardslashbanking-solutionsthatsbrex.com/banking Dash solutions.
- 2:51Jumping into our main story of the week, spoiler alert, it's
- 2:53not tariffs. We're probably the only podcast
- 2:56not talking about the tariffs right now.
- 2:58We cover private companies, not public stocks that are tanking
- 3:03across the country. I know of anything that's one of
- 3:05the great privileges of being a private company.
- 3:08You're like we raised the money before we think on longer time
- 3:11horizons, we don't have to sort of have the ebb and flow.
- 3:14Obviously, private markets will not be insulated, given that
- 3:17this is likely to be an ongoing problem.
- 3:20Of course, but for an now it's, it's we're in that's over in
- 3:23public markets and over in private markets.
- 3:25They're having an awesome week. Open AI raised the largest
- 3:29venture backed round of all time at $40 billion.
- 3:34Wow. We've grown so numb to it.
- 3:35I I've, it's always like, wait, this is the largest, you know,
- 3:38we, we did make a big deal of Wiz when that was like what like
- 3:41the biggest M&A and now we have the largest round for.
- 3:44All the downturn naysayers right now.
- 3:47This quarter has been ridiculous.
- 3:49Just to catch everyone up on the Bulls points of the round, I
- 3:52know it's been out in the ether for a while, but it open AI
- 3:55finally announced it this week here.
- 3:57Kind of the rundown of the main stats you should know it was a
- 3:5940 billion total dollar round, but it's kind of tranche.
- 4:03So it's a little funky, but that raises the company's valuation
- 4:05to 300 billion, which is wild for a private tech company
- 4:09that's like one of the most valuable companies ever.
- 4:11We have SoftBank leading initially with a $7.5 billion
- 4:16investment and then 2.5 billion from an investor syndicate that
- 4:19includes Microsoft, CO2, Altima, Thrive.
- 4:22People have backed them before and then the round is tranched.
- 4:25So the remaining 30 billion of capital, which is again divided
- 4:29between SoftBank and those investors will come at the end
- 4:32of 2025 as long as Open AI converts to a for profit
- 4:35company. So it is dependent on that
- 4:37transition happening before the end of the year.
- 4:39Yeah, that's kind of staked, you know, funding there, but it's
- 4:43still a huge raise. And just for some reported stats
- 4:48behind how Open AI has been performing to justify this crazy
- 4:52valuation. They have projected 3.4 billion
- 4:55in revenue arr around 4.4 billion.
- 4:58So the implied valuation multiple is around 68 X, which
- 5:02is high but not the craziest we've ever seen.
- 5:05They they just have to do this one little challenging thing of
- 5:08figure out how to go from being a non profit to a for profit
- 5:11company. They don't figure that out.
- 5:13They don't get all the money. Hard to see how investors return
- 5:17all this money if they're investing investing in a non
- 5:21profit. So there's there's a big.
- 5:23Flip the big question on everyone's minds, of course, is,
- 5:27is open AI worth this? Is this just in La La land right
- 5:32now or is it actually the most valuable private company of all
- 5:35time? Eric, you made the bear case a
- 5:38few months ago at the 157 billion valuation.
- 5:41Now we've basically doubled that.
- 5:43I, I know I've been searching through the piece because I was
- 5:46like, I definitely caveated it. I said there's inevitably going
- 5:49to be more momentum investing in Open AI to come.
- 5:52Open AI is probably going to have to raise money again next
- 5:55year, even with its 4 billion revolving credit line.
- 5:58Open AI could very well raise an up round based on the same vibes
- 6:01it raised money on this time, especially if investors continue
- 6:05to prioritize revenue growth over cash flows.
- 6:07So I'm prepared for people to mock this story in a year or
- 6:11less when Open AI raises an up round.
- 6:13I should have foreseen SoftBank specifically.
- 6:16I should have been. Yeah, this is October 24.
- 6:18I, I should have said and you know, SoftBank hasn't even
- 6:22sufficiently marked it up and obviously until they top ticket,
- 6:25the bears are not safe. I'm still holding on to bear
- 6:29case at 1:57. I mean, obviously it's easier to
- 6:33transact private market stocks. So there's an argument that I
- 6:36was just wrong because should have invested, pulled a thrive
- 6:39invested 157. I don't know that they're
- 6:41selling, but you know, you could exit the position potentially in
- 6:45the next round. And so there's certainly people
- 6:47who are riding a momentum stock and there's plenty of money to
- 6:50be made there. But if we're talking on a sort
- 6:52of four year time horizon or a sort of long term settled out
- 6:56public market price, yeah, yeah, I I still I think I'm in the
- 7:00bare case. I mean, if you review what I
- 7:03said here are the bullets money losing machine.
- 7:05It's a company that loses a lot of money.
- 7:07Tenuous and expensive intelligence pole position.
- 7:10Man, we've talked about that a lot.
- 7:11We had the DeepSeek moment this year.
- 7:13Anthropic keeps getting better, there's serious competition,
- 7:16Google has one of the top models at the moment.
- 7:18It is a tenuous and expensive intelligence, pole position,
- 7:21talent exodus, Altmans limitations and Open AI's weak
- 7:25alliances. I mean I do think the Microsoft
- 7:28relationship continues to be a little muddled.
- 7:30I mean, Sam is depending more and more on Brad, the Chief
- 7:34Operating Officer and Sarah Fryer.
- 7:36It'll be interesting to see. I don't, I don't know as much
- 7:38about them. So I'm excited to see.
- 7:40I mean, I know Sarah Fryer. I don't know Brad.
- 7:42Brad Lightcap, he was running the investment fund out of Open
- 7:46AI that was backing some early stage AI companies.
- 7:49I talked to him briefly about that one time.
- 7:51He seemed, yeah, he seems legit. In that, yeah, he's the chief
- 7:54operating officer, clearly important guy.
- 7:56On top of all of that, they are a non profit company being sued
- 8:00by Elon Musk that has not made the transition to being a for
- 8:04profit and it's an insane risk factor.
- 8:08And also Elon is now one of the most politically powerful people
- 8:10in the world. Obviously Altman's, you know,
- 8:12work in his own relationship with the Trump people, but.
- 8:16I'm going to come in and make the bull case for this round.
- 8:19Yes, the price is crazy, I won't deny you there, but they have
- 8:23really, really upped their sales game.
- 8:25I mean just the demand there's already I think they saw reports
- 8:28that they people have already generated 700 million images
- 8:32just since they launched within the last few days the image
- 8:35generator tool, right people are clearly.
- 8:37Madeline usage means they spend more money.
- 8:42Yes, it's good to have customers want something you wanna do, but
- 8:47you give something if it costs more to deliver it.
- 8:50Obviously they will have to find some way to financialize and
- 8:54make some money off of all of their demand.
- 8:57But in the classic Silicon Valley form, you get the users
- 9:001st and then figure out how to make money later, right?
- 9:03Like that's how this always goes and I think they've captured the
- 9:07market in especially in consumer like there is no Chapel hot that
- 9:10comes close to them. Enterprise is a little bit
- 9:12rougher. Like obviously there's like, you
- 9:14know, more competition there. Anthropic is really popular, has
- 9:17a really popular API. It's a little bit more varied
- 9:19DeepSeek. Obviously we've talked to death,
- 9:21but I do think in the consumer market, people love Chachi PT
- 9:26that is the killer AI app. There really has not been
- 9:28anything that's come close to it.
- 9:30And so I think they have kind of like lightning in a bottle with
- 9:34their product and they're like the main productizers.
- 9:36So I could see this being worth it at some point.
- 9:40Yeah, I mean, I agree with everything you're saying.
- 9:43You know, I've personally probably spent 300 bucks on Open
- 9:45AI, you know, because I paid $200 for their ultra premium
- 9:50version and then subscribe to the Plus version.
- 9:54So they're clearly making money. I mean, they deliver value and I
- 9:58do think, you know, there's no question.
- 10:00It's not like sort of Uber, you know, they never really proved
- 10:03out like pool for example, feels like for sure they're going to
- 10:07be able to figure out a way to make Studio Ghibli photos in
- 10:10profitable way. To me it's more of the is that
- 10:14commoditized do sort of specialized apps when and the
- 10:18final creative bear case that I will make if open AI does too
- 10:23well that like say we are an AGI and it still this sort of
- 10:28nonprofit like are they really going to be able to like harvest
- 10:32everything or is it going to be like you were set up to be for
- 10:34the benefit of the world. Now you have the world
- 10:37controlling technology. Are they really going to be
- 10:39allowed to be the $2 trillion company that runs the only sort
- 10:44of non human competitive intelligence?
- 10:46That being said, opening I I think is really going to work to
- 10:49make this for profit conversion work.
- 10:51They'll lose half of this funding round if they don't,
- 10:53right? So they're working around the
- 10:55block. They want it, definitely, yeah,
- 10:58there's no question about that. From the biggest funding round
- 11:01of the year to the juiciest espionage spy drama of the year.
- 11:06So I had a fun story this week. I'm going to give you the brief
- 11:09facts so that you remember where this all started with a rippling
- 11:13lawsuit, right? So it's like Rippling, the
- 11:15company run by Parker Conrad, the sexiest, you know, payroll
- 11:19and company information, you know, like internal corporate
- 11:22management company you could have It's so.
- 11:23Funny that this all like came down over just like specifically
- 11:27payroll. Well, that's what's funny about
- 11:28it. It's a very boring sector.
- 11:30You know, you got Rippling and Deal competing with each other.
- 11:33Deal is the company backed by Entries and Horowitz.
- 11:36The firm that screwed over Parker Conrad is Old Companies,
- 11:39these benefits. So you have all sorts of
- 11:41competing alliances and Deal and Rippling, they hate each other,
- 11:44clearly. So Rippling then drops this
- 11:45lawsuit and says Deal has been spying on us.
- 11:48We had this employee, it was working for us and feeding
- 11:51information to Deal, which was like a pretty crazy explosive
- 11:56allegation. And then even crazier is
- 12:00basically Rippling says, we know this for sure because we set up
- 12:04a trap and we suggested the idea.
- 12:08We sent a letter to three deal executives and like, I think
- 12:11they're outside counsel and mentioned a particular term that
- 12:15we hadn't sort of mentioned anywhere else, a fake Slack
- 12:17channel. And then that mole, though, the
- 12:20spy searched frantically for it in our Slack channels.
- 12:24And, you know, obviously was like totally made-up, but he
- 12:26wouldn't have been able to hear about it if not for sending this
- 12:30to the executives. And then we went to confront the
- 12:33guy. He's in the bathroom and they're
- 12:36like, hey, we've got like a court order and like a court
- 12:38representative here that says you need to hand over your cell
- 12:41phone. And the guys basically like,
- 12:43I'm, you know, there was some interplay, like, I can't find
- 12:47it. But eventually it's like I'm
- 12:48willing to take the risk and sort of fled the scene.
- 12:50It is wild that like, this is maybe the first case of like a
- 12:53Slack orchestrated sting operation I've ever heard of.
- 12:57Like, Oh my God, the honeypot trap.
- 12:59The Slack Channel, their sexiest spy thriller breaking down on
- 13:03Slack. And so, you know, this was
- 13:05already like a great story. We'd gotten far more than we
- 13:08ever deserve in the boring world of, you know, writing about sort
- 13:12of payroll startups. And then this week this is all
- 13:16playing out, by the way, in Ireland like this employees, I
- 13:19think in Ireland. So the guy's name is Keith
- 13:21O'Brien. He is the alleged spy mole sort
- 13:25of whatever we're calling him. And according to sworn
- 13:29affidavit, he confessed like in court, basically he was like,
- 13:34yes, this is all true. And not just is this true, but I
- 13:38was coordinating with the CEO of deal.
- 13:42Like, like literally we were like going back and forth.
- 13:44And also, he was only getting paid $5000 a month for this.
- 13:50So it's like $60,000 a year to, like, do what seems clearly like
- 13:56criminal, you know, just for like, some small amount of
- 13:58money. The CEO of Deal, Alex Bozes,
- 14:02likened what Keith was doing to mean like, James Bond.
- 14:06And again, like if you're James Bond, you need more than $5000 a
- 14:10month. Anything else stand out to you?
- 14:12I mean, I feel like first of all, just glossing over that in
- 14:16the chat with Boise is there's also his father, Philippe deals
- 14:20CFO and this mysterious figure named the watchman not explained
- 14:25what's going on there. This is just like like Deep
- 14:28Throat, but like boring. I don't know.
- 14:30Do you watch Billions? You're watching Billions.
- 14:34There's a there's a character in Billions who's like this sort of
- 14:36like hatchet man basically for. Is he the watchman?
- 14:40Yeah, I feel it feels like that sort of role.
- 14:43Yeah. You have to imagine all these
- 14:45like, by the way, all these executives like watching like
- 14:48the villains on TV being like, oh, I guess that's how business
- 14:50is done. We need our like corporate spy.
- 14:53You know, it's like it's very like, are we the baddies or more
- 14:56like that's the model for. Sure.
- 14:58And I'm it's just still not over the fact that Deal's lawyer
- 15:01allegedly told O'Brien to destroy evidence where he
- 15:04smashed his phone with an axe and flushed down the toilet.
- 15:06Allegedly whenever you make allegations like that against a
- 15:10lawyer, you got this shout like allegedly a billion times.
- 15:13But yeah, it is a pretty strong allegation to say their lawyer
- 15:17was in any way involved because that's that's not good.
- 15:20You know, absolutely not. And of course, you know,
- 15:23allegedly Keith O'Brien has claimed in his confession that,
- 15:27you know, he was coached by Deals legal team to shift the
- 15:30narrative here. And they were they were like
- 15:32suggesting he like potentially like flee to the Middle East.
- 15:35I'm sincerely excited to see deals response like.
- 15:38I know deals been quiet this whole time.
- 15:40This is a wild case of accusations that they have not
- 15:43yet commented on. Most of this, again, of course,
- 15:45is coming from this confessional and the rippling lawsuit, right?
- 15:48So what are they going to say about this?
- 15:50But also, how do you come back from this?
- 15:52Like even if like this is some degree, if it's proven untrue,
- 15:55like where did you land in the court of public opinion after
- 15:58all of this as a. Company I can't claim to totally
- 16:00understand. Keith O'Brien and all this.
- 16:03I'm sure they'll be reporting at some point being like, how does
- 16:06this guy totally flip? Fascinating.
- 16:09Also this week, Politico reported that Elon is exiting
- 16:13the Trump White House in the coming weeks.
- 16:16Oh my gosh, the number two guy moving on out.
- 16:19Define coming weeks. Nobody else is saying this is
- 16:23the coming weeks sooner than late May or early June when
- 16:27Elon's special advisor status is supposed to end and he sort of
- 16:31signaled that. Maybe I'll wrap it up by then.
- 16:33The administration is not flat out denying the story, but
- 16:36they've reported back to that, you know, signifier initially
- 16:39that was like, this is always going to end.
- 16:41So it's not like a full denial, but that's kind of the thing.
- 16:44So maybe it's just like they're saying he's not extending upon
- 16:47this. But I guess the main thing was
- 16:48there was like ruffles around, you know, how well Elon and
- 16:52Trump are really getting along, which was sort of the intrigue
- 16:54they're going for. I almost wonder if tariffs like
- 16:57are good for Elon because it's like this, this one isn't his
- 17:00problem. And like, he was generating a
- 17:03ton of negative press with like, Doge.
- 17:06And just like, you know, they're destroying random things.
- 17:08You could also make the case that he, like, lost that
- 17:10Wisconsin race. Right.
- 17:12Oh, my God. Exactly.
- 17:13Right. Yeah, exactly.
- 17:14He not only did he lose it like, fine, they were going to lose
- 17:17it. It's classic politics that you
- 17:18don't say I'm staking my whole reputation and the whole world
- 17:23hangs on this race if you can't probably pull it out, you know
- 17:27what I mean? It's just like, why?
- 17:28Why raise the stakes of some random Wisconsin Supreme Court
- 17:32case? Like, I understand it has
- 17:34implications for like, members of Congress and like, it's
- 17:36important, but why put your whole reputation behind it if
- 17:40you know anything about politics?
- 17:41It was a little bizarre. For sure.
- 17:43So anyway, that's not looking so hot for him.
- 17:46And they're saying he could, you know, stay on as some kind of
- 17:49advisor in some capacity. Still, it's not like he's going
- 17:51completely away and leaving DC. I can't imagine that's going to
- 17:55happen unless he has like a major Trump ego clash.
- 17:58But that hasn't happened yet. I'm not sure that that's going
- 18:01to happen given that they've done so well together.
- 18:03This as far well-being a very relative term given everything
- 18:07we just discussed. But in terms of the rumors
- 18:10about, you know, the big personality billionaires
- 18:12eventually just going to flame out like that has not borne out
- 18:15yet. So I wanted to bring up what
- 18:17Elon's doing here is what he did at Twitter, right?
- 18:20People talk about it. He's like running the Twitter
- 18:22playbook in government. And so the Twitter playbook, the
- 18:26similarities are you come in, you RIP everything out and some
- 18:31things break and then you put those back in.
- 18:34But if nothing really breaks, you're like, oh, that wasn't
- 18:36that important. We just saved a whole lot of
- 18:38money. We got rid of it.
- 18:40And it's at least a way to cut costs.
- 18:41It doesn't necessarily drive revenue.
- 18:44And I don't think the federal government is going to have a
- 18:48hypey foundation model company that we can merge with to save
- 18:52everything. But putting putting even that
- 18:54aside, if we're just running the Twitter cost cutting playbook, a
- 18:58key part of it is that you sort of like get the feedback from
- 19:02the world and you feel like, oh, we we cut Social Security.
- 19:05Did that. Do people get really upset?
- 19:07You know, and I feel like government and society is slower
- 19:10and bigger than Twitter, right? It's not like looking at code,
- 19:14did the app break or like waiting till Disney like calls
- 19:17you shouting about something. And so, like, I don't see how
- 19:21Elon can expect to run even in the most charitable sense, this
- 19:26Twitter playbook, an exit by late May or early June because
- 19:31there's no way he's going to have the feedback to know like,
- 19:33oh, we should put back the pieces and he hasn't cut the
- 19:37budget, you know, as the other besides.
- 19:38Besides, he doesn't know if he should put anything back, and he
- 19:40hasn't even achieved the savings he's supposed to.
- 19:44We should remember the Doge, you know, savings website
- 19:47continually being debunked. So the savings aren't even what
- 19:49they're saying they're doing. Are you making the point, Eric
- 19:51here, that government and businesses are run differently
- 19:55and you don't actually run the government like a business?
- 19:58They're they're different, right?
- 20:00The, the, the metaphor isn't very good.
- 20:03Perhaps yes, it it does feel like that whole argument is
- 20:06basically like if USAD was so important, Elon and Trump
- 20:10personally would hear people psychologically like, you know,
- 20:13making would be so upset. It's like, oh, I'm, I'm such an
- 20:17elite disconnected from people who are hurt by my decisions
- 20:20that I don't feel it. And therefore that is proof that
- 20:22it has no impact. Is like exactly the problem at
- 20:26the end of the day. We are going to be able to judge
- 20:28their success because they're not very transparent about all
- 20:31the details on just like did the deficit go up or did it go down?
- 20:35And I think it's clear that the deficit is going to go up.
- 20:39Yeah, if you're combining this with tax cuts, yeah.
- 20:41And if you're combining it with cutting revenue, you know, like
- 20:47IRS agents and like other ways to make things in.
- 20:49And if you're sort of hurting the economy by putting a bunch
- 20:52of people out of jobs, like it's, it's not if tax cuts are
- 20:55part of it, but it's also like the things that they're doing
- 20:58with Dodge are going to hurt our ability to collect revenue, Have
- 21:03people employed, have a strong economy that produces taxes.
- 21:07I, I want Elon to stick around because I think he should finish
- 21:10the job, like prove that it can do it, not just say, oh, I, I
- 21:14tried, I hit the deadline. I got to get out of here.
- 21:16You know, it's like, do the thing you said you're going to
- 21:18do if you're, if it's so great, you know, I mean, I'm still in
- 21:21the like, run, run the country your way.
- 21:23I mean, we're getting it right now with tariffs.
- 21:24Notably, a lot of the VCs that are, you know, also involved in
- 21:28these efforts are not part of this exiting plan.
- 21:31So I can assume right like Sriram and some other people may
- 21:33stick around The A16Z people doesn't seem like they're
- 21:36leaving anytime soon. Scott Cooper, you know who is a
- 21:39top guy to Andrews and Horowitz? I still think he hasn't even
- 21:41been confirmed yet. I like him.
- 21:43We can we can bring this episode full circle, honestly.
- 21:46So Parker Conrad, the CEO of Rippling, the one going after a
- 21:49deal, was also in my piece after the election saying like, this
- 21:55seems like a disaster, but like a godspeed.
- 21:58I wish you the best for the country.
- 22:00But Parker to me was like, you know, they're probably going to
- 22:02get their faces ripped off like everybody does with Trump.
- 22:04And he specifically made the point everybody thinks Trump is
- 22:07going to do their crazy thing, but then he does, you know, some
- 22:10other crazy thing instead. So anyway, Parker tweeted today,
- 22:14I hope we don't forget Marc Andreessen's grand proclamation
- 22:16about the economic coiled spring that would be unleashed with the
- 22:20Trump presidency. It's like, yeah, exactly where
- 22:24is it? That's our episode.
- 22:25Stick around. I'm I have a conversation with
- 22:28the CEO of Clay, the top company on our mid stage enterprise 30
- 22:34list with Wing and a fun conversation digging into his go
- 22:38to market AI company. Give it a listen.
- 22:41I'm here with Kareem Amin, the CEO of clay #1 mid stage company
- 22:47on the enterprise 30 list that we did with Wing.
- 22:51And so this is our second video after talking to Paul Klein, the
- 22:55browser based CEO digging into companies that you know are now
- 23:00thrust on my radar that where I'm like, oh, I want to know
- 23:03everything about what you guys are doing.
- 23:06Kareem and I were on a panel the other day at NASDAQ celebrating
- 23:11the Wing 30 list and happy to have you on the podcast.
- 23:14Hey, hey, Kareem. Yeah.
- 23:16Thanks for having me, Eric. Great.
- 23:17Well, yeah, so I think, you know, we sort of want to get to
- 23:19like how did, how did you get to #1 on the mid stage list?
- 23:23And then where you're going, you know, the best place to start is
- 23:27how, how is Clay founded? And I think, you know, you, you
- 23:30guys have been at this a while. Yeah.
- 23:32Tell me about the the early days.
- 23:34Yeah. So we started a over maybe just
- 23:38seven years ago and the motivating idea was how do we
- 23:41give the power of programming to an order of magnitude more
- 23:44people? So we were very much in this
- 23:48continuation of the idea of how do you make programming
- 23:51accessible. And the reason we wanted to do
- 23:53that is that we knew that if you could essentially have that
- 23:57power, you would be able to level up kind of like the work,
- 24:00the type of work that you're doing and just have access to
- 24:02capturing a lot of more of that value.
- 24:04And we were anticipating that there will be more and more kind
- 24:10of like AI set of features that would automate work.
- 24:14Obviously we were not kind of like seeing that LMS would be.
- 24:18What year the way to do that was clay from?
- 24:212017. Yeah.
- 24:23And who is this first customer type?
- 24:27Great question. I think when you look back at
- 24:29it, yeah, you do need to have a clear customer and you need to
- 24:33have all of like, like who's your Tam and all of that stuff.
- 24:36But I don't think that most people, I think that's just one
- 24:39way of like articulating your idea.
- 24:41Like we started it off from what is it that we want to have in
- 24:44the world? And then we thought, OK, well,
- 24:46if we want to give the power of programming to more people, do
- 24:49we want to give it to engineers and make them a lot faster?
- 24:52Or do we want to give it to non engineers?
- 24:53And we started kind of exploring to see like what is possible at
- 24:57that time time, there was already things called
- 24:59programming by example. So in Excel, and I haven't
- 25:02talked about this actually before, but you could go in and
- 25:05let's say that you had like a phone number and some of it was
- 25:08missing the brackets around the first 3 digits.
- 25:10You could add it and you show kind of Excel like, OK, you add
- 25:14it once and it can add it to all of them.
- 25:16But sometimes it would add a double bracket.
- 25:17So you go delete that one. And now it learns, OK, if
- 25:19there's a double bracket, don't do that.
- 25:21And so we started to say, OK, there's going to be more and
- 25:24more ways to program by example, to program by showing the
- 25:28machine what you want. And we were kind of exploring
- 25:31like, what is it? What's possible today?
- 25:33We eventually decided that actually it's much, much more
- 25:37powerful to give it to non engineers.
- 25:39And we started thinking about like, what are the metaphors
- 25:41that people understand? And decided, OK, the
- 25:44spreadsheet's the world's most popular programming environment.
- 25:46And Google made it collaborative.
- 25:49So many people could work on it at the same time.
- 25:51But the next step was to make it connected to all of the
- 25:53internet's data. And so that's kind of like how
- 25:56we came to Clay because once once we did that, we were like,
- 25:59well, who is going to use this And there could be financial
- 26:02analysts or there could be people building lists.
- 26:05When we looked at people building lists, it was
- 26:07recruiters, salespeople, marketers, customer success
- 26:11people. And so we decided to focus it on
- 26:13a go to market teams. So I, I think at the end of the
- 26:16day, you need to focus it on who you're selling it to, to get the
- 26:19product going to build the business, but it's ultimately in
- 26:23service of this bigger. Goal and so just the core
- 26:25customer action so that people just understand yeah, are we
- 26:28going to use the product the way that most people use it First
- 26:31off is what. The core customer action is you
- 26:35want to grow your business, right?
- 26:38And to grow your business, you need to build a list of
- 26:40potential new customers or existing customers that you want
- 26:43to reach out to. And you need to figure out what
- 26:46properties predict that someone's going to be a good
- 26:49customer. So Clay allows you to aggregate
- 26:53all the data sources on the Internet to build the list of
- 26:56potential customers that you want a message.
- 26:58Using those data points, you can figure out what you're going to
- 27:00say to them. So let's say you find all the
- 27:03people on the Internet who don't have SoC 2 compliance, but are
- 27:06SAS companies that have been built and you sell a SoC 2
- 27:09compliance product. And that's a perfect moment for
- 27:12you to reach out to them. So was that possible pre LLM or
- 27:14how much? How much of the product really
- 27:16existed before through the model explosion?
- 27:19Yeah, it was totally possible. Pre LMS, there were all these
- 27:22different data providers that scrape data from the web and
- 27:25packaged what was difficult. So that's what we did first was
- 27:28say OK, like why use one data provider when you can use all of
- 27:32them? And it depends on what you're
- 27:33looking for, which data you need and make it makes it easier for
- 27:37you to work with that data to build the list.
- 27:39What LMS made it possible to do was to then also get unique data
- 27:44properties that no data provider kind of had.
- 27:46So let's say you want to say I want to find all companies that
- 27:50have remote offices in South America, right?
- 27:53And maybe that information you could kind of extract from
- 27:57existing data providers, but it would take a lot of work.
- 27:59You would have to say, okay, do they have an office in South
- 28:01America and an office outside? And where's the headquarters?
- 28:04And that means that they have a remote office in South America.
- 28:06So it extracted a lot more value out of these data sets that
- 28:09you'd gotten together because there's exactly logic and sort
- 28:12of pulling out pieces. Yeah.
- 28:14And you could do more real time things, right?
- 28:16So you could say check if this company has the logos of some of
- 28:21our current existing customers, right.
- 28:23So you can do things that maybe you'd have humans SDR's normally
- 28:26do. Do customers pay to use all the
- 28:29different data sources or you just license it yourself and
- 28:31they it's subtracted away from them?
- 28:33Or how much interaction do they have with?
- 28:35Yeah, we have an interesting model here.
- 28:37So basically you can use most of the data sources using clay
- 28:40credits, right? Because we have licenses with
- 28:42them. If you already have the contract
- 28:45or agreement to the data provider, you could just use
- 28:47your API key and click and it's free to do so.
- 28:50So our idea is very much a collaboration with data
- 28:54providers. We focus on a segment of the
- 28:56market that they don't normally have the resources to sell to.
- 28:59And some of the data providers are smaller and they have really
- 29:02high quality data, but they just don't have the full UI or go to
- 29:04market team to sell it. So and the other thing is once a
- 29:08customer grows big enough, we prefer that they actually have a
- 29:10connection to the data provider and they have a direct kind of
- 29:13like contract and API Q with them.
- 29:15Our belief is that, yeah, we don't sell, We don't necessarily
- 29:18make the money off of selling the data.
- 29:20It's how you make use of the data to create a campaign that
- 29:23we think is like where we provide value.
- 29:25Yeah. And then on sort of the content
- 29:27generation side and sort of the outreach scheduling, how much
- 29:31are humans in the loop or like how much is it sort of still a
- 29:34human firing off emails versus setting all these triggers or
- 29:38how do you think about that? The way we think about it as
- 29:41humans are there to come up with the ideas like which triggers
- 29:44when, how often, to whom, we just facilitate doing all of
- 29:48that work. So the way to think about clay
- 29:50is like if Figma is for designers, clay is for go to
- 29:53market teams. You're still involved, but it's
- 29:56a creative tool that allows you to express your idea quickly.
- 29:59We don't necessarily believe that there is one solution that
- 30:02fits all or that there's like one magic button that you should
- 30:05turn on and let it go. You have to constantly be
- 30:08iterating on who are you? What are the guesses that you
- 30:11think makes a good customer and what predicts that?
- 30:14What should you be saying to them?
- 30:16Your products are changing, their products and their needs
- 30:19are changing. So you need to stay up to date
- 30:21and you also need to stand out from the crowd.
- 30:22Does. This only work if it's like, oh,
- 30:24I can sort of AB test my customers and there's a huge
- 30:27universe like if I have a business where I'm sort of like
- 30:30whale hunting is AI is useful where it makes sense to focus a
- 30:34lot of total energy in particular.
- 30:36Right, because it's not just for outbound, right?
- 30:38Clay is letting you build, let's say, a deep research dossier
- 30:42about this customer, right? You might want to figure out,
- 30:46you know, who are all the how many people have they hired in a
- 30:49particular department? What is their organizational
- 30:51structure? What have they been publishing
- 30:53lately? Right?
- 30:54You can look at their financial statements that are public.
- 30:57So what are their actions online?
- 30:59What are they doing on social? You can like do social listening
- 31:02and you don't have to send them a message.
- 31:03You could send all of that information to your own team.
- 31:06The other the other thing is that, you know, I think of
- 31:08outbound as similar to advertising.
- 31:10So Coca-Cola still advertises you need to have it on your
- 31:13mind. So just you need multiple touch
- 31:15points for someone to know who you are right and why you
- 31:18matter. So and even example in clay
- 31:21isn't just to be used to find new customers.
- 31:24It's also to expand your existing customers.
- 31:26So imagine that your Figma, you release this new product dev
- 31:30mode and maybe you reach out to all of your customers who have a
- 31:34lot of designers, but you know they none of the engineers have
- 31:38onboarded. And you figure out who their
- 31:39head of engineering is. And you message them and say,
- 31:41hey, your designers are building a lot in Figma.
- 31:43Should your developers be using it too?
- 31:45Do you send the actual e-mail through Clay?
- 31:47And so we basically connect to a bunch of third parties to send
- 31:50the e-mail, but we have an interface that allows you to
- 31:53draft it and figure out what you're doing.
- 31:55And the reason we we stay kind of separated from the channels
- 31:58is that people do all kinds of things with Clay.
- 32:00So there are companies that send physical mail with Clay, that
- 32:04send gifts, personalized gifts that have created personalized
- 32:08websites so you can people have created personalized ads.
- 32:11So we're kind of agnostic about where the end channel is.
- 32:16You've obviously been intentional about the product
- 32:19besides sort of coming up with a great feature set like what's
- 32:22what explains your like explosive growth at the moment
- 32:25or what, what would you point to that sort of like really
- 32:27clicking for clay and why you're having this moment where
- 32:31investors are so excited about what you're doing?
- 32:33I think investors are excited because they see kind of the
- 32:36potential that is made possible through Clay.
- 32:40So if you're every company needs to grow, right and there are
- 32:46only three ways to grow, you either find new customers, you
- 32:49convert existing ones or you expand existing ones.
- 32:52Clay helps with all three, right?
- 32:54But we found a particular kind of gap in the market, which is
- 32:59that most schools in go to market want to sell you a
- 33:03solution that helps you automatically grow your company.
- 33:06It's sold to reps or people who are on the front line and lets
- 33:12them kind of pull a list quickly and send some messages.
- 33:15Whereas what Clay does is it assumes that there is a new type
- 33:18of role, Rev OPS, growth marketing, we call them go to
- 33:21market engineers. And we think that AI has
- 33:24actually enabled this new role that's going to be be really
- 33:27well paid and really expensive. That is a more technical person
- 33:31that can take on that job and can 10X the whole team and that
- 33:35and you don't need to AB test things, right?
- 33:38It doesn't have to be that scientific.
- 33:40It's mostly like you have an idea, we can turn it into
- 33:42reality quickly. And so we're a very, I think
- 33:45we're the first creative tool in the go to market space that
- 33:48actually allows you to speed up any idea to reality.
- 33:52And you can apply that for sales or for marketing or customer
- 33:55success. So the Tam is huge and people
- 33:57are making a lot of money using clay and also getting promoted
- 34:01using clay. So that's why customers like it.
- 34:06If you get this tool, you're gonna, yeah, get a promotion.
- 34:09On the flip side, is it hard to get a company to embrace a new
- 34:14tool when you say you need really to rethink what employees
- 34:18you have, if you have clay or like that's normally it's like
- 34:21we want to meet, meet you where you are so that you're excited.
- 34:24We meet you where you are right, like the the role already
- 34:27exists. It's it's called Rev OPS.
- 34:29I think it's just evolving. Also advanced AES or SDR's can
- 34:33pick it up. So it's basically you start off
- 34:36where you are and then you can essentially parlay it into this
- 34:41job once you prove that it's working.
- 34:43So we tend to kind of meet people where they are and then
- 34:45they quickly find that they're getting results.
- 34:47And then it transforms into, and don't forget that this is the
- 34:50particular moment where people are willing to experiment
- 34:53because they're like, what is our go to market strategy with
- 34:57AI? And the answer is you should be
- 34:59using clay. What can you say about number of
- 35:01customers, size, the business employees, whatever snapshot you
- 35:04can give? Right.
- 35:05So the last public numbers that we gave out was were in the
- 35:10forums article and we announced our raise at 1.25 billion and we
- 35:15had 5000 customers and over 30 million ARR and we've grown
- 35:20substantially since then. The jobs question, I mean, do
- 35:24you, do you have an intuition on whether AI is going to reduce
- 35:28the number of jobs or from your sector?
- 35:30Like how I mean if you sort of, you know, 10 Xing or more the
- 35:33capacity of an employee, does that sort of imply fewer
- 35:36employees or how do you think about that?
- 35:39My current sense is very much embodied in like things that are
- 35:44like previous technologies that we've encountered.
- 35:47So, you know, when you build more roads, you just get more
- 35:50cars. I think that our system is set
- 35:52up to, regardless of the efficiency gains, to do more.
- 35:55And so let's say we get more efficiency games.
- 35:57Well, we're just going to want to try to grow faster.
- 35:59We're not going to say, OK, great, now we can grow as fast
- 36:02as we did with fewer people. I think some people will do
- 36:05that. And hence you have a lot of
- 36:07people coming out saying, oh, we're going to build like, you
- 36:09know, 10% company with like 10 million per employee.
- 36:13And maybe you're satisfied with that.
- 36:15But I think there's going to always be competition at the top
- 36:18for markets where a winner takes all, where you will try to do
- 36:21more. So I don't think that you will
- 36:24have fewer people. I think you will have more
- 36:27productive people in certain elements of the business and you
- 36:30will find new areas where you want where things weren't doable
- 36:33before, it weren't worthwhile. The other thing is I think a lot
- 36:37of the current predictions are predicated on LLM's becoming one
- 36:41to two orders of magnitude better.
- 36:44And I think that that is different, right?
- 36:46If it becomes 2 orders of magnitude better, I do think
- 36:50many of the jobs will become less needed, but I'm not totally
- 36:54sure. I don't have an intuition on
- 36:56where we are towards that. Do you spend a lot of time as
- 36:58the CEO of a very forward thinking AI application company
- 37:03gaming out like AGI strategy or so much of the business is like
- 37:07new model comes out, figure out how to make use of it and we
- 37:10react when they come or like how much is there sort of like war
- 37:13gaming going on inside clay about what the capacity is going
- 37:16to be. I think you know what I've told
- 37:18the team in general is 90% of your time should be executing
- 37:2210% meta reflecting on anything, otherwise you're wasting your
- 37:25time. And so we're focused on
- 37:28delivering with what we have now.
- 37:30There's already a lot and 10% of the time we think about the
- 37:34future and what are the possible kind of options.
- 37:37But regardless of what the options are, we will be in a
- 37:40better place the more successful we are right now.
- 37:43Right, Yeah, to make a decision the what how do you think about,
- 37:46you know, I, so I use Superhuman a lot.
- 37:49Yeah, different, different products interested in using
- 37:52clay. I every, every sales product or,
- 37:54you know, could be a reporter tool.
- 37:56And obviously, you know, we, we have customers too now.
- 37:59But, you know, Superhuman or e-mail providers that can feel a
- 38:02little bit like you're fueling a war on both sides where it's
- 38:06like you're making it easier to e-mail people, but you're also
- 38:09making it easier to like then filter out sort of the emails.
- 38:13How do you think about it with your product?
- 38:14I mean, you're sort of you're more focused on arming sort of
- 38:17one side of the equation. But do you think, oh, there's
- 38:19just going to be another AI company on the other end that's
- 38:22making out filtering out all this like emails estimate that
- 38:25I'm going to receive? Yeah, yeah.
- 38:26But I think we're so, yeah. I mean, I love Superhuman and
- 38:30Raoul. I think they've done a great
- 38:32job. I think that you know that.
- 38:33Have you ever heard of the idea of the Red Queen?
- 38:36I think there's a yeah. It's been a while, I feel like
- 38:38it came up with Uber context. Right.
- 38:40I think, I think the author was met rightly.
- 38:42The idea is that, you know, the Red Queen keeps running and
- 38:45stays in the same place, right? So, and I think it was about the
- 38:48viruses and like human genomes and like you're constantly
- 38:52changing and and meeting it. So there's always this cat and
- 38:56mouse game. I think it just depends on how
- 38:58you approach it, right. So we are not thinking about how
- 39:01do we give people the power to send more messages.
- 39:04Quite the opposite. We think that you should be
- 39:07doing deeper research ahead of time, send fewer messages, do it
- 39:11over time, right? You don't want to blast your
- 39:13whole tan or all of your customers.
- 39:15You don't even know if it's going to work.
- 39:17So you should pick smaller segments that are deeply
- 39:20researched, spend the time deeply researching them, and
- 39:23then send a more worthwhile message.
- 39:26We just help you do that at a scale where it becomes feasible.
- 39:29And we give you the tools to do that if you, that's why we, we
- 39:33don't own kind of like the messaging channel because we
- 39:35don't know what you're going to send and we're not responsible
- 39:38for that. If your product sucks, your
- 39:40message won't work regardless of who you target and what you say.
- 39:44So that's also information, right?
- 39:46And that information is helpful. I think it doesn't make sense to
- 39:49claim that we will help you grow regardless, because what you're
- 39:52selling might not be worth growing.
- 39:54There are good customers out there that fit.
- 39:56We'll help you find them, but we can't.
- 39:58Promise, Right. Yeah, We'll help you figure out
- 40:01how to go about doing that. And so I think we're much more
- 40:05aligned, actually, with customers and people sending
- 40:09messages that are worthwhile. And we try to guide people to
- 40:12use this in this way. Because by the way, if you don't
- 40:14use this correctly, you're the one who's going to get banned,
- 40:17not us. Get banned just by like e-mail
- 40:19providers if you're sending too many.
- 40:20E-mail providers. Yeah, exactly.
- 40:22Or like by having, you know, add messages or you're the one who's
- 40:25not going to get the results. And so, yeah, I think that's a
- 40:28key element of it. Can you walk me through just
- 40:31like one of the most interesting customer case studies?
- 40:35Yeah, for sure. There's a couple.
- 40:37I won't name the names right now, but some of the case
- 40:40studies are on our website. But I want to tell you a couple
- 40:43of them that we don't have on the website that I think are
- 40:45great. One company actually sent us a
- 40:48message where they started looking at our status page and
- 40:52seeing whenever our product was down or had issues.
- 40:55And then they were a dev OPS tool and they would see what we
- 40:59said was the issue and they'd be like, well, if you were using
- 41:02US, you wouldn't be down. And here's why.
- 41:03And it was very effective. I read it.
- 41:06And so I thought that was a pretty creative way of lately
- 41:10there are no data sets that look at status pages, but they used
- 41:13our AI agent to monitor us. There's another company that is
- 41:19looking at to. Double click on that like they
- 41:21built a tool or like how no. So they used Clay as AI agent to
- 41:26look at our own status page and monitor it to see whenever we
- 41:31said that we were down, looked at the reason that we were down,
- 41:33matched it to one of the products that they could sell to
- 41:36us and then sent us a message. There's a tool that sort of
- 41:39triggers when websites are down in real time or.
- 41:42No, that's the beautiful thing. We have an AI agent that you can
- 41:45program to do whatever you want, including look at our status
- 41:48page. Interesting, right?
- 41:51So what's great is that we don't need to have a tool for every
- 41:53possible use case. Actually, customers discovered
- 41:56new use cases. But are they?
- 41:58Then they're hosting a tool they built on or that becomes a tool
- 42:02that all Clay customers can use. Or no, no, no, no.
- 42:05It's just they told the AI agent to go look at our status page
- 42:10and then message us when there's an issue and high it to their
- 42:13products. We can then take that use case
- 42:15and make it more templated for everybody else.
- 42:18Yeah. And that's something that we can
- 42:22choose to do, but we don't have a marketplace where you can then
- 42:24sell that strategy. Yeah, I see.
- 42:26Yeah, yeah. Got it.
- 42:28That's the Super interesting one.
- 42:29Yeah. There's another one that I think
- 42:33is pretty cool where company has a way of kind of doing brand
- 42:40normalization. So it's just like, is your brand
- 42:42the same in every channel that you're using it?
- 42:44So they use clay to look at like a company's brand identity.
- 42:50Then they look at all the social channels that they send messages
- 42:54through and whenever they see a discrepancy, they message the
- 42:58company and say, hey, you just tweeted out something that
- 43:00doesn't match your brand identity.
- 43:02You could have been using our tool to have brand consistency.
- 43:05Interesting. So these are very unique go to
- 43:08market strategies. And what's amazing about this is
- 43:10a very custom to your company. But the tools that you need to
- 43:14do that are not custom. They're the, you know, clay
- 43:17primitives. And that's obviously why we're
- 43:19called clay because you can build different things with it,
- 43:21right? The same way that every website
- 43:24you know could look completely different, but you can still
- 43:27build it in Figma. Do you allow customers like how
- 43:30much this is, this is going to reveal how non-technical I am,
- 43:34but like direct like API access or like, you know, I feel like 1
- 43:38trend in the AI world is like we're only an API business and
- 43:42you could sort of flow, flow through US without really
- 43:45interacting with our interface. It sounds like what you're
- 43:48describing though, is the opposite where it's like we have
- 43:50a great interface, you'd want to go through clay.
- 43:52Or how do you think about the rise of, you know, these sort of
- 43:55API first businesses? Right now we don't have a public
- 44:00API for you to do that. Sometimes we work with companies
- 44:03to enable that, but I think it depends who the customer is,
- 44:07right? Is the customer an engineer or
- 44:09is a customer a non engineer? And so we believe that the more
- 44:13features we make in our UI, the faster you can build some of
- 44:17these things without me being an engineer.
- 44:21And then there's obviously also room for engineers to use some
- 44:24of the capabilities that Clay has by API to build things
- 44:27themselves. That's something that we'll be
- 44:29looking at in the future. I want to ask you a couple
- 44:33questions about sort of AI applications broadly and where
- 44:35things are headed. Any I guess last words on clay
- 44:38or like you know where, where you'd like to be in sort of two
- 44:42years. Are there any other reflections
- 44:44that I haven't covered on your business before?
- 44:46I ask you to play pundit for a second, I think.
- 44:49That the thing that's so exciting about Clay is that we
- 44:54have this really large community, so there's over
- 44:5720,000 people in our Slack channel, there's clubs in over
- 45:0140 cities. We just opened out funding
- 45:05round, the community funding round that was basically allowed
- 45:11our own community to invest cuz we're getting ideas from the
- 45:14community so that they should share our ability to grow.
- 45:17But I think we've created this new go to market engineer role
- 45:21that isn't a really like powerful persona where you're
- 45:26able to kind of control all of like the third party data that
- 45:31you can find on the Internet about a company and then your
- 45:33own first party data. So like, let's say someone's
- 45:36been using your product lot, but stopped using it recently, but
- 45:40would use it if you released a new AI feature, you should
- 45:43message them or has been complaining in gong calls about
- 45:47your support and now you've improved your support.
- 45:49So this go to market engineer can turn all of these ideas for
- 45:52growth into reality. And I think those people are
- 45:55getting promoted really quickly, starting agencies as well to
- 45:58help other companies making a lot of money.
- 46:00And so in two years, we want this to be a role that's in
- 46:03every company. Each one of these companies is
- 46:06using clay to grow. The idea of, like, a service
- 46:10provider who's using your tool to then sell it to other
- 46:13companies. I mean, it's funny because
- 46:15you're also seeing AI businesses, you know, in the
- 46:18legal space. There's sort of an ongoing
- 46:20debate of whether you should be the service business that uses
- 46:23your secret AI tools or sell the AI tool.
- 46:26Yeah. I don't know.
- 46:26Do you worry at all? Like, oh, again, if you can
- 46:29build a company up to sort of consult just using clay, we
- 46:32should be sort of selling those consulting services or how do
- 46:35you think about that ecos? No, we're very much wanting to
- 46:39partner with that ecosystem and we have a very large number of
- 46:42people making a lot of money building on top of clay.
- 46:45It's a small percentage of our revenue.
- 46:48Most of our companies use it directly.
- 46:50But if you look at HubSpot, for example, about half of their ARR
- 46:54comes from basically revenue that that a consultant has
- 46:58touched. And so you can build a very big
- 47:00business doing that. Right, Yeah, We almost signed up
- 47:02for HubSpot, and it's like, we'll give you this person
- 47:05architect at all. It's like, my God, I'm gonna be
- 47:07spending this money forever. I'm never gonna get out of it.
- 47:09That's exactly what they want. Right.
- 47:11I walked away at the last second, but I know I said I was
- 47:15going to move on from Clay, but it's super interesting.
- 47:17I mean, how much are you learning from Figma?
- 47:19I mean, I hear like community centric.
- 47:22Are you allowing employees to start using Clay before the
- 47:25company starts paying for it? Or what is sort of the adoption
- 47:29sort of journey for most companies?
- 47:31No, we have a, we have a reverse trial.
- 47:33So you get all the features for two weeks and then you have to
- 47:35pay, right? Yeah.
- 47:37And so we have a free tier, but we are really selling to people
- 47:40who have a product that they want to grow.
- 47:43So our profile is a little bit different than like it's not.
- 47:46The rogue employee, it's sort of like, oh, no, this company is
- 47:48sort of deciding to consider using it.
- 47:51Yes, Yeah, yeah, yeah. And that's a better fit for us.
- 47:54Yeah, because it's how come just more intense or it's like.
- 47:58Well, it's just more that you need to have something to grow
- 48:01before you can grow it, right? Whereas some other products,
- 48:05like if you're in Figma, you might Draw Something, it doesn't
- 48:07really matter if the thing exists or not and you would
- 48:09still be playing around there. So it makes a bit more sense.
- 48:13We're closer, we are more closely tied to revenue.
- 48:16Once you start making revenue, we can help you grow that in.
- 48:18Right. Yeah, which is why investors are
- 48:20excited. It's like we're close to the
- 48:22money you can see that you're making.
- 48:24You can see the fact, yeah, yes, for sure.
- 48:27And don't forget that the biggest SAS company in the
- 48:29world, Salesforce, is basically a go to market kind of like
- 48:33toolkit. Like it's ostensibly a CRM, but
- 48:36really it's everything that you need to have the information so
- 48:39that you can grow your company. Do you have the CRM piece?
- 48:42Is it too or no? I don't think that that's kind
- 48:45of where we want to be. We are a system of action, not a
- 48:48system of record. I like that, yeah, yeah.
- 48:51What, what lessons do you think you know, other startup founders
- 48:54can learn from Clay in terms of building applications like
- 48:58whether it's the relationship with model companies that you've
- 49:01taken or, or sort of anything else that you you think is sort
- 49:05of more broadly applicable that you can give away in other
- 49:07categories? I think that the key thing
- 49:10without knowing a specific situation, the core ideas I
- 49:14think are you have to have alignment between the various
- 49:17parts of your business. So like what is your product,
- 49:21right? And how does that align with
- 49:23your go to market motion? How do they feed into one
- 49:26another, right? So where do you start?
- 49:28And then how do you take it to the next step?
- 49:30Those things need to make sense, right?
- 49:32So if you are, I'll give you an example, right?
- 49:35We knew that we wanted to have a PLG driven business.
- 49:39So like people can come and sign up for the product, product,
- 49:42they don't need to have a demo. So we built the product so that
- 49:45you can use it without needing a demo.
- 49:47And then we figured out who has the most acute problem that is
- 49:51similar to the one we want to solve.
- 49:53And it turns out that there's all these B2B agencies that are
- 49:56helping people grow their companies, but they are at the
- 49:59forefront actually because they're helping so many
- 50:01different companies. So they have the most
- 50:03complicated set of problems. And if we solve theirs, they
- 50:07would go and talk to other people about us.
- 50:09And so we knew that we could help them.
- 50:11And then we you can also do the same thing and go directly to
- 50:15companies. The use case is not different.
- 50:17The functionality isn't different, The feature set isn't
- 50:19different. If you're gonna help someone and
- 50:21then jump to another set of customers and the functionality
- 50:24is different, that's too far of a leap.
- 50:25It needs to be kind of concentric circles that are
- 50:28overlapping. Your success is to sell your
- 50:33product to somebody else without having to build something
- 50:36totally new. Exactly.
- 50:38And then you need to have the sales motion to be aligned.
- 50:41You can't start PLG and then suddenly be like, well,
- 50:43everything needs to be sales based in the future because you
- 50:46built a different culture. And you also have to have a
- 50:48unique insight, usually by turning something on its head.
- 50:52So you could build the simplest tool in the world or you could
- 50:55build a more complicated tool. You need to figure out what
- 50:58where are you on that spectrum? And you could build a tool.
- 51:01Tool for everyone to use, right? Or one person to use and those
- 51:05end up 'cause those assumptions change what you build.
- 51:08What do you make of this idea that, you know, sort of, I don't
- 51:13know, software companies are screwed Or it's like, if I'm
- 51:15gonna build, I mean, you talk about Salesforce.
- 51:17That was sort of the situation with Klarna.
- 51:19It's like I'm gonna build my own Salesforce so I won't have to
- 51:22pay them. Like is it just you have to sort
- 51:25of outrun the capacity of somebody to build it internally,
- 51:28or you think that's sort of overhyped?
- 51:30Or what do you think about this idea that every enterprise just
- 51:33builds any application that becomes core to what it's doing?
- 51:36Yeah, I mean that that was already happening, right.
- 51:39And just dependent how much how willing you were to spend money
- 51:42on this and how willing you are to kind of set up a team to do
- 51:45this. So a lot of people had clay like
- 51:47things internally the same way that people had built CRMS
- 51:50internally before Salesforce. So there's always a build versus
- 51:53buy conversation in in software, whether it's skews more to build
- 51:57now because it's cheaper. I think the question is, who is?
- 52:01It's not about building most of the time, it's about
- 52:03maintaining. Everybody knows this, right?
- 52:05That's the total cost of ownership, right?
- 52:08Who is going to maintain this? Who understands how this thing
- 52:11works? Who already is, you know,
- 52:14knowledgeable? Does this look like something
- 52:16else they've seen in the future? Are they starting from scratch?
- 52:18And I personally like the idea of personalized software, right,
- 52:22that you can build something quickly, you know, some internal
- 52:25tool that you need. I do think that for tasks that
- 52:29you're regularly doing and that look similar across every
- 52:33business, that you will still have software off the shelf that
- 52:36is just built to be very configurable very quickly.
- 52:39So that has tons of integrations that is easy to manipulate or
- 52:43mold right into whatever you want.
- 52:45So I think that software that is very easy to customize will
- 52:50still be in high demand. Yeah.
- 52:52And I, no. And I, I, yeah, I think that
- 52:54you're not going to build from scratch.
- 52:58Even if you can build it, the requirements gathering, knowing
- 53:01what to build is still a lot of the work.
- 53:04It's most of the work, by the way.
- 53:05Right. Yeah.
- 53:06And so imagine you're gonna have to figure that out.
- 53:08Your data relationships give you sort of a pretty big mode if a
- 53:12customer is using a lot of them and wants this sort of sense
- 53:17that I can pull from a lot of. Different sets, even if they're
- 53:20not. Using a lot of, mostly just
- 53:21using like one of them all the time.
- 53:23Like. Do you worry about that?
- 53:24That's not possible, right? Yeah, I'm not super worried
- 53:27about that because everybody has tried to build the one data set
- 53:30that rules them all. But you're working with living
- 53:33entities, people in companies, and there's so many different
- 53:35ways to view that. So there were so many different
- 53:37properties and you can't have them all.
- 53:39And it's also very different, right?
- 53:41Like you might have data about company than North America
- 53:43versus companies in Europe. So that hasn't turned out to be
- 53:47the case. There's definitely a mode in all
- 53:49of the data provider relationships and data cleaning
- 53:52and all that. But I think a lot of the motives
- 53:54in the workflows, right? Enabling you to build any kind
- 53:57of workflow quickly no matter what it is, and then also seeing
- 54:00what are the most interesting workflows and enabling that for
- 54:03everybody else, right? How much do you adjudicate which
- 54:07data source is more accurate or score it or you're like, oh, if
- 54:11you're, if you're depending on phone numbers, like we think
- 54:13this is the best source versus leaving it up to the customer to
- 54:17sort of pick between multiple. Lists, we do a lot of due
- 54:20diligence before kind of working with a data provider and we have
- 54:24a team that looks into that and compares kind of like, you know,
- 54:27whatever the data is in a particular, you know, set of of
- 54:32functionality like technographics or demographics.
- 54:36But we leave the choice to the customers.
- 54:38In the end, we'll be doing more and more of that as we figure
- 54:42out ways for us to be really accurate so that we can actually
- 54:45give really high quality information here, right?
- 54:49You know, I love the idea of like truth and AI and obviously
- 54:52with sort of existing companies, there are actual facts and so
- 54:56you can sort of decide overtime like what what's real and what's
- 55:00translating into yeah, the world does exist.
- 55:03Do do you use coding apps internally or I'm curious what
- 55:07you guys are obviously super sophisticated.
- 55:10There are lots of them running at each other right now, like
- 55:13Codium cursor, Lovable, you know, there's Replit, there's
- 55:17obviously Claude code. It's go straight to the source.
- 55:20Like what are you guys using and what's your read on how much
- 55:24that's helping Clay build quickly?
- 55:26A. Mixture of all of the above.
- 55:27I mean, I think people internally use cursor, some
- 55:30people use Windsor if we don't have a unified kind of ideology.
- 55:34Go forth and use what you want. I think it's too early to kind
- 55:37of decide and I think actually letting engineers decide what is
- 55:41best for them. You know, if you're using Bolt
- 55:43or Replit to like whip out product managers could use this
- 55:46to show like a quick prototype versus if you're using cursor as
- 55:50your IDE, that's a very different thing.
- 55:52Or some people use GitHub Copilot.
- 55:54We're still finding that a lot of like AI codes requires, you
- 55:59know, heavy human review and you also need to know what you're
- 56:02doing and so that you understand what you actually implemented.
- 56:05Otherwise we'll have there are like very subtle bugs that you
- 56:08can introduce. You know my friend Meryl runs a
- 56:10company graphite dot dev that does AI agent like code review.
- 56:18Yeah. So there'll be AI agents doing
- 56:20the review and then you'll review it.
- 56:21It is moving helping us to move faster for sure, especially if
- 56:26you're writing a lot of boilerplate.
- 56:27I do think that the the barrier is still the ideas what your how
- 56:32they all work together, coordinating all of these things
- 56:35and then being able to bring them to market through a unique
- 56:39kind of go to market channel. So we use clay internally as
- 56:42well to figure out like what are the tactics we're using to sell
- 56:44clay. And I think that you don't wanna
- 56:48just build a bunch of low quality things.
- 56:50Congrats, you know a mid stage winner and we'll be following
- 56:55everything you're doing and thanks for coming on the
- 56:57podcast. Appreciate it, Eric.
- 56:58Thank you. Cool.