Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Handle an Employee Who Always Says I Need a Promotion
Transcript
- Lucas: So it's Monday morning, and a senior analyst named Priya sits down across from you. She's had three straight strong performance reviews, and she opens with, 'I think I'm ready for the next level.' What do you say back? Luna: Honestly, my first instinct used to be, 'Let's talk about it next quarter.' That never ends well. Lucas: Right. And that's the trap. The 'we'll revisit later' response just defers the anxiety and makes the employee feel unheard. Today we're going to drill into the promotion request — how to handle it when it's deserved, when it's premature, and everything in between. Luna: We've covered a lot of 'employee says X' situations on this show, but promotion talk is different. It's loaded with identity and money. Lucas: It's one of the few conversations where both sides are scared. The employee fears rejection, and the manager fears losing a good person or making a promise they can't keep. So the first rule is: separate the request from the person. You can say no to a promotion without saying no to the employee. Luna: How do you actually do that in the moment? Because the employee is usually emotional. Lucas: You acknowledge the ambition first. Something like, 'I'm glad you're thinking about your growth here. That's exactly what we want.' Then you move to specifics. The key is to avoid a yes or no on the spot. You buy yourself time to evaluate, and you set a clear follow-up date. Luna: So you're not making a decision on the spot, but you're also not stalling forever. Lucas: Exactly. You say, 'I need to think through this properly. Let's meet again in a week, and I'll come with concrete feedback.' That's honest, and it gives you time to gather evidence. Luna: But what if the employee is clearly not ready? I had a guy once who asked for a senior title after barely meeting his goals for six months. Lucas: That's where you need to be direct, but not punishing. The number one mistake managers make is softening the feedback to the point where the employee walks away thinking they're on track. You have to be clear about the gap between where they are and where they need to be. Luna: So you're saying we should actually name the gap. Like, 'You've hit your targets, but a senior role requires leading projects, not just executing them.' Lucas: Precisely. And you need to give them a path. That's the second rule: never say 'not yet' without a roadmap. Otherwise you're just demoralizing them. A roadmap includes specific skills, behaviors, and maybe a timeline. Luna: I'm thinking of something you once mentioned — a promotion checklist. Can you walk us through that? Lucas: Sure. A promotion checklist is a simple document listing the competencies and contributions required for the next level. It's not your secret HR file — you share it with the employee. So when they ask, you can say, 'Here's what the senior role looks like in our team. Let's check your work against these six points.' Luna: That takes the emotion out of it. It becomes a checklist, not a personality contest. Lucas: Right. And it forces you, the manager, to be explicit about what matters. A lot of promotion decisions are vague because managers have never written down what actually differentiates a level two from a level three. Luna: So the checklist is both a tool for the employee and a discipline for the manager. I love that. Lucas: And here's a subtle thing: the checklist should be based on demonstrated behavior, not time served. 'You've been here two years so you deserve a bump' is how you end up with a team full of entitled mid-performers. Luna: Yeah, we've all seen that. But what about the flip side — the employee who is clearly ready, and you've been holding them back because you need them in their current role? Lucas: That's a real tension. If someone is operating at the next level already, the worst thing you can do is pretend they're not. You risk losing them to another team or another company. So you make the case to HR and your leadership, and if the promotion isn't possible right now, you get creative. Luna: Creative like what? Lucas: Stretch assignments, mentee pairings, a temporary lead role on a project. You show them you're investing in their trajectory, even if the title change has to wait for budget season. Luna: But isn't there a risk that they see through that? 'Oh, you're just giving me more work without a title.' Lucas: There is, if you're not transparent. Say: 'I want you to have the title; the timing isn't there yet. Here's what we can do now to get you closer.' If you're honest, most people accept that. The ones who don't may be more interested in the title than the work, which tells you something. Luna: That's a good point. So we've covered the dialogue, the checklist, and the creative alternatives. But what about documentation? I feel like a lot of managers skip that. Lucas: Documentation is your friend. After the conversation, send a summary email to the employee: 'As we discussed, here's the feedback, here's the plan, here's our next check-in.' That protects you both and gives them a reference point. If they ask again in three months, you can point to the plan and honestly assess progress. Luna: And if they don't make progress, you have a clear record of the conversation. That's especially important if you eventually have to deny a promotion again or even consider performance management. Lucas: Exactly. It's not about covering yourself; it's about being fair. A promotion decision shouldn't be a surprise. If the employee is surprised, that's a failure of regular feedback throughout the year. Luna: So one-off promotion talks should never be the first time they hear about a gap. That means we need to be giving feedback constantly, not just at review time. Lucas: And that's the underlying truth. The promotion conversation is really a test of how well you've been managing all along. If you've been clear about expectations and development, the promotion talk is just a formalization of what you both already know. Luna: Before we go deeper into how to handle the 'not ready' employee, I want to pause here — if today's rundown is useful for you, the way we keep these episodes ad-free is through listener support. If you've gotten value from Manager Mondays, consider buying us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It genuinely helps us keep making the show. Lucas: And every little bit goes toward keeping this podcast free and focused, not padded with ad reads. So if you're able, we appreciate it. Now, back to that not-ready employee — I think the hardest part for a manager is avoiding the 'let's just wait six months' default. Luna: Yeah, because that just creates a countdown, and then you have to have the same conversation again with more resentment. Lucas: Exactly. Instead, you set a specific check-in date — say, ninety days out — and you define what success looks like. 'In three months, if you've led the client migration and mentored a junior analyst, we'll revisit.' That's concrete. Luna: And if they hit those goals, do you have to promote them? Because sometimes the goals get met but the business case isn't there. Lucas: You have to be honest about that too. You can say, 'You've done exactly what we asked, and I'm proud of that. The business doesn't have a senior opening right now, but here's what I'm doing to advocate for you.' And then actually advocate. Don't just say it. Luna: So the worst case is you lose a great employee because you couldn't create a role. Is there anything you can do to prevent that? Lucas: Sometimes you have to be willing to lose them. If you've genuinely tried and the organization won't budge, the kindest thing is to support their search. Say, 'I know you're ready, and I'll be a reference for you.' That preserves trust and your relationship, even if they leave. Luna: That's counterintuitive, but it makes sense. A manager who helps you leave even when it hurts is rare. Lucas: And it often pays off in the long run. People remember managers who were straight with them. They might come back, or they might refer someone great to you. Luna: So to wrap our heads around this: the promotion conversation is about aligning on the gap, giving a roadmap, documenting, and being genuinely supportive — whether the answer is yes or not yet. Lucas: And the manager's job is to make sure the employee never has to wonder where they stand. That's the real takeaway. If you're doing your job all year, the promotion talk is just a formality. Luna: I think we've given managers a lot of concrete language today. Maybe the most important is having that checklist ready before someone asks. Lucas: Go build it now. Before the next one-on-one. It'll change how you think about your team's growth.