Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / All marketing is meant to perform, or it's just noise - ft. MilliporeSigma's Nick Figueiredo
Transcript
- 0:00Nick Figueiredo: All marketing, or all advertising, is meant to
- 0:02perform, right? So I don't feel pressured to have to assign
- 0:06every single click or an order back to the spend which drove
- 0:09it.
- 0:16Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie? Then defy is next
- 0:18is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:21combined with functional ingredients. Giving you as much
- 0:24as 26 grammes of protein per bag. So you can be both a little
- 0:27bit bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:31brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:34owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:38defy with an i snacks.com and follow us on social at
- 0:42defisnacks.
- 0:49Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:51My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of Automated Creative,
- 0:54the creative effectiveness ad tech platform, and this is a
- 0:57weekly podcast about the future of data driven marketing every
- 1:00week or so I have the pleasure and the privilege of
- 1:02interviewing one of our industry's leaders, and this
- 1:05week is no different. I'm on a call with Nick Figueiredo.
- 1:08Sorry, Nick, your Portuguese name doesn't slip that easily
- 1:11off the tongue. Nick Figueiredo, and Nick is the head of
- 1:15performance marketing at MilliporeSigma. So Nick, for
- 1:18anyone who doesn't know who you are and what you do? Can you
- 1:21give the audience a bit of a background?
- 1:22Nick Figueiredo: Yeah, thanks so much. First of all, Tom for
- 1:24having me here today. So my name is Nick Figueiredo. I'm the head
- 1:27of performance marketing at MilliporeSigma. Currently, I've
- 1:30been in digital marketing for over 17 years. In my early days,
- 1:34I was cutting my teeth in SEO and SEM across B to B and B to C
- 1:38for a company named Vistaprint that's the old days of manual
- 1:41bidding and manual keyword mining in SEM, and then link
- 1:45building and chasing page rank and SEO. And now I'm working
- 1:48across all channels in SEM, display, video, social
- 1:51programmatic, television, influencers, audio, you name it.
- 1:55I'm doing it. We're trying it. And what I've loved the most
- 1:58about about digital marketing is, is being part of and helping
- 2:02build winning teams. I think for me, that's that's the stuff that
- 2:05makes me tick. I've been a lifelong athlete, and that's the
- 2:07stuff that that keeps me working in digital marketing and and
- 2:10building great teams for great brands.
- 2:12Tom Ollerton: So give me a bit on the lifelong athlete. If you
- 2:14had to be in the Olympics next time around, what would be your
- 2:17your choice?
- 2:17Nick Figueiredo: So your football, Tom my soccer, but
- 2:20we'll use the worldly term forward, so football. So I've
- 2:22been a lifelong footballer. Played all through college, up
- 2:25until about a year or so ago, I was playing very, very
- 2:28consistently in adult leagues around town, but injuries have
- 2:31kind of set me back a little bit recently.
- 2:34Tom Ollerton: But what position?
- 2:35Nick Figueiredo: Normally, striker, central midfield,
- 2:37outside midfield, the money man, that's it. The number 10.
- 2:40Tom Ollerton: I'm not, I'm not, I'm not. I'm not a huge football
- 2:43guy. So that's probably the extent of my knowledge. I see,
- 2:45all right, I try to the job of the host, but like, let's, let's
- 2:49get back to digital marketing. So, so you already shared a bit
- 2:52of you about your mindset and building being part of
- 2:54successful teams, but what new belief or behaviour has really
- 3:00changed your work life in the last five years or so?
- 3:03Nick Figueiredo: So I have a couple, right? So the first one
- 3:06is, is storytelling, and the second one is really leaning
- 3:09heavily on econometrics or statistics more broadly in my
- 3:12career, and so in the first one, right? So feedback is a gift,
- 3:16right? And one of the first, or one of the most critical pieces
- 3:18of feedback I received in my career was to become a better
- 3:22storyteller, right to state my impact more clearly. And so
- 3:25without getting too far into it, I had this big presentation in
- 3:28front of leadership, the C suite, where I really needed to
- 3:31state our impact for this, this awesome win that my team and I
- 3:35had. And unfortunately, it didn't go so well. I think I
- 3:38created all this... I put all this time into creating content,
- 3:41PowerPoint slides, etc, etc, but the story just didn't land, even
- 3:46though it was really clear that we drove a tonne of value,
- 3:48right, millions and millions of dollars in impact. And so coming
- 3:51out of that meeting, my manager had said, Hey, Nick, you really
- 3:54got to work on your storytelling, right? That's how
- 3:56you sell yourself. You sell your impact, you sell your team. And
- 3:58so what I really started to do over the years was to work on
- 4:01becoming more concise, right, making sure my I'm
- 4:04understanding, or excuse me, sharing with my audience why I'm
- 4:07taking their time, right? Why are you here with me today? Why
- 4:10am I stealing your time? This is what matters, more more concise,
- 4:15becoming more consistent. And then ultimately, I think a
- 4:18really critical part of this was turning up the frequency with
- 4:21which I referenced my stories or referenced anecdotes from my
- 4:24strategies, I think that was really critical in honing in on
- 4:27that for my audiences over time. The second part of that, as I
- 4:31said, was...
- 4:32Tom Ollerton: sorry, just before you move on, to move on,
- 4:34econometric and so on like so how do you map out a story?
- 4:37Right? So you've run I assume is a fairly data centric campaign.
- 4:41Right of dashboard, I have a spreadsheet. So how do you turn
- 4:44that into a story? What is Do you like, have an arc? Or do you
- 4:46have a start, middle and end? Like, how do you turn the cold,
- 4:49hard facts into a story?
- 4:50Nick Figueiredo: At some point you said, Start middle end... my
- 4:52father always jokes he won't watch a show or a series with my
- 4:55mom, or sometimes even movies, because, actually, largely for
- 4:59shows, he says, if it doesn't have a beginning, a middle and
- 5:01an end, I'm not going to watch it, right? And I think he's
- 5:04talking about series, because series go on for seasons and
- 5:06seasons, so truthfully, it's as simple as that, right? Why are
- 5:11you here today? Let me grab you immediately with that first
- 5:13slide. This is why I'm stealing your time. This is why what I'm
- 5:17talking about matters when it comes to the actual content of
- 5:21slides and selling the story. It's less about I need to
- 5:24create, cram all the information possible into this slide, and
- 5:28more about I need to just deliver the headline right,
- 5:32deliver the punchline, get to the next topic. So for me, I've
- 5:36moved away from cramming tonnes of... excuse me, text and
- 5:40content into slides and more about hero images, icons, one
- 5:45number, right? A very, very simple graph that makes it
- 5:49really clear what I'm trying to say. And then I use the backdrop
- 5:52for me as the storyteller to tell you about what's going on.
- 5:56So if you think about, right, I'm a new dad for the second
- 6:00time. And we have two under two. Actually, when I think about my
- 6:04kid, my kids and their development, right, I am reading
- 6:08to them, right? That's how they're learning, right? So if
- 6:12we think about our audience, how are they going to learn? They
- 6:15need to hear the story from me. I have to tell them what is
- 6:19going on, right? So that beginning, middle, end,
- 6:22obviously, is the simplest way of putting it. But since it, but
- 6:22selling the why, I think, and getting them hooked up front is
- 6:26how you get them into the story.
- 6:27Tom Ollerton: And this is how you speak to your kids, like
- 6:29guys, I know, stealing your time here. I know it's bad time, but
- 6:32by why? So I'm going to impart some serious life lessons on you
- 6:36right here. Here she is. Peppa Pig. Yeah, slide one.
- 6:39Nick Figueiredo: It's funny, right? Man. We've been reading a
- 6:41lot of Dr Seuss lately, Cat in the Hat, all these, all these
- 6:44characters.
- 6:45Tom Ollerton: Oh, it's fun. What the places we will go? Yeah, all
- 6:50the
- 6:50Nick Figueiredo: places you will go. Sorry, Green Eggs and Ham,
- 6:53all of them, all of them.
- 6:55Tom Ollerton: But brilliant. But let's I'm sure there's a strong,
- 6:57strong marketing analogy in Dr Seuss.
- 7:00Nick Figueiredo: It is, I think I think about it constantly when
- 7:02I'm reading to my kids, but, but I think the critical thing to
- 7:05remember is we all fall into this trap of like, I need to
- 7:08give them as much information as possible, right? Tell them
- 7:10everything. The reality of the situation is, if you put tonnes
- 7:14and tonnes of text onto a slide to support to help you as the
- 7:18presenter, you're getting it all wrong, right? People, your
- 7:22audience can read faster than you, so if you're going to sit
- 7:26there and read the words on your slide, you're doing everybody
- 7:29disservice, right? Send that ahead of time, and then when you
- 7:31get into the meeting, you can just have a 15 minute meeting.
- 7:34Everyone did the pre read, and then you're done and dusted. But
- 7:37the problem with today's today's world, is we're sending content,
- 7:41heavy slides and trying to read them to our audience. That's not
- 7:42Nick Figueiredo: to develop hypotheses from mmm, taking mmm
- 7:49going to
- 9:21and making it more predictive, which a lot of people don't
- 9:24realise, right? Mmm is actually predictive if you learn to use
- 9:28it in that way. And so this, this is another, I think, key
- 9:31tool for me in my career development more recently,
- 9:34Tom Ollerton: how are you coaching your teams to use mmm
- 9:37in a predictive way? What's that practically? How's that working
- 9:41Nick Figueiredo: So when, whenever we're getting readouts
- 9:41for you?
- 9:43right? Readout being like one, let's just say quarterly from
- 9:47the MMM, and then we're listening intently, we're
- 9:51observing, we're getting a lot of things read to us right? What
- 9:54I'm instilling in my team is to try to think differently, or
- 9:58think or ask yourself, what else, right? So you're getting
- 10:02these midpoint iroas readouts. You're getting these budget
- 10:05simulations, these models right that are saying a whole bunch of
- 10:08things that are looking backward. So I'm encouraging my
- 10:11team to take that and say, Okay, what if we tweaked this or that?
- 10:16What if we challenged what we were seeing from a return on ad
- 10:20spend perspective, on a marginal basis, instead of continuing the
- 10:24status quo, what if we heavy up with this tactic where we
- 10:27started to find some some marginal success? So for
- 10:30example, it could be a new channel, let's say, connected to
- 10:33television. What if we heavy up in that? What if we go way
- 10:36bigger in that, and really pressure test the assumptions
- 10:38coming out of the mmm, right? Maybe the mmm said our return
- 10:41was two, but if we have you up, we might see that that that
- 10:45holds or maybe even increases, if you couple that with better
- 10:47creative execution, better media planning and buying. So this,
- 10:51this idea of using the mmm as a baseline or a foundation, and
- 10:55then taking that and asking ourselves, what if we challenged
- 10:58it? What if we pressure test what the MMM said that's giving
- 11:02us the freedom within a framework to be more predictive.
- 11:04Tom Ollerton: I think that's what we we say a lot in
- 11:06automated creative is, don't look at just what the data is
- 11:09telling you, look at what it's hiding from me, right? We just
- 11:12released a book recently called using data and creativity and
- 11:15marketing, and I interviewed 40 people like 40 very senior,
- 11:18experienced marketers, performance, folk, CMOs, tech
- 11:20people, agency people, and that was the consistent messages.
- 11:24Like, you know, data is it's an indication of what something
- 11:27happening, but it's not the whole story. It's not a
- 11:29comprehensive record of the truth. Here's some things that
- 11:32happened, right? And so then you need to with your team. You're
- 11:35saying, Well, look, that was what happened over there in the
- 11:38past, but now we need to look over here. So what's, what is
- 11:41that data concealing from us? So it's really interesting to hear
- 11:44that that thought echoed again. So we're going to move on now to
- 11:48your shiny new object, which is breaking down the myth, the myth
- 11:51of performance marketing, which is a wild statement for what is
- 11:54essentially a performance marketing podcast. So, yeah,
- 11:57curious, what do you mean? Nick, pitch it to me.
- 11:59Nick Figueiredo: Yeah, listen. I'm not, I'm not the first to
- 12:01come up with this, right? But the reality of the situation is,
- 12:04all marketing, or all advertising, is meant to
- 12:06perform, right? So I don't feel pressured to have to assign
- 12:10every single click or an order back to the spend which drove
- 12:14it. And I think that's, that's the myth, right? It's like, it's
- 12:17like the new frontier of last click attribution, right? And
- 12:20sometimes I joke like it's this campaign by the media giants
- 12:23right to to say that there's this very niche set of
- 12:27marketers, or marketing and advertising that performs and
- 12:31all the other stuff doesn't perform. That, to me, just
- 12:33doesn't fly. That doesn't work. And if you think about the tools
- 12:37in front of us today, from a measurement perspective, we
- 12:40talked about statistics and econometrics. We talked about
- 12:43MMM, which is a form of those. We talked about, match, market
- 12:46testing, geo lift experiments, these types of tools are making
- 12:51it such that all your advertising can be measurable if
- 12:55you're doing it in the right way. And so this flywheel of
- 12:58buying stuff that performs right from a direct response
- 13:02perspective, put media out there that is generating demand right
- 13:06so away from the old school funnel of upper middle, lower
- 13:09funnel, and more towards this demand gen, demand capture, all
- 13:12of these things are performance marketing, even though we can't
- 13:16say from a last click attribution or even a multi
- 13:19touch, touch attribution perspective, This thing came
- 13:21from here and this thing came from here. So from my
- 13:24perspective, all marketing is meant to perform, and that's the
- 13:28end of it.
- 13:34Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 13:38brought to you in partnership with Madfest, whether it's live
- 13:41in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 13:44you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 13:47fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 13:50unconventional entertainment from Madfest events. You'll find
- 13:53me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 13:56podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 14:00people in marketing, check it out at www.madfestlondon.com.
- 14:11So what would be a better description, like direct
- 14:14response? Like so these, these ads were supposed to deliver a
- 14:17direct response, or an instant response, or a response within,
- 14:22like, an attribution window, like, is that? Is that more
- 14:24accurate?
- 14:25Nick Figueiredo: So think of it this way, right? If you're
- 14:27putting marketing out there that isn't meant to perform, why are
- 14:30you doing it? Or what are you doing, right? It's just noise.
- 14:32And so my belief is that we don't need a campaign to show
- 14:39direct response revenue from a last touch perspective, let's
- 14:42say just use a very simple form of attribution in a dashboard.
- 14:46Right we can use geo experiments, holdouts, growth
- 14:51studies, matched market testing, marketing mix modelling, to take
- 14:55that whole campaign and say, yes, it didn't drive last click
- 14:58attributed revenue, but it did drive on a model basis, or a
- 15:02probabilistic basis, than an estimated this amount of
- 15:05revenue. And so that that modern, that kind of, that
- 15:09modernised form of measurement, is what is allowing us to show
- 15:13that all of our marketing, or all of our advertising, is
- 15:16performing, not just the stuff that shows up in a direct
- 15:18response dashboard.
- 15:19Tom Ollerton: So you you're taking umbrage with the word
- 15:21performance, when we should be using the suite of tools that
- 15:25you're talking about to be judging our entire campaign as a
- 15:27performance campaign. Did it perform or not? Right? As
- 15:29opposed to slicing and dicing it and saying, Oh, this bit that
- 15:33required someone to click on the thing and go at the thing and
- 15:35buy the thing is what performed? Quote, unquote, right? So, so
- 15:40what would you prefer, what what's a what's a better
- 15:43terminology for it? Or is or should we just forget about
- 15:45that? What would your advice to a CMO be to avoid the trap of
- 15:48thinking with a performance mindset?
- 15:50Nick Figueiredo: I don't think there's a specific name for it,
- 15:52other than to just say we are, we are advertising to drive
- 15:57growth, right? So is it, is it growth marketing? Is it growth
- 16:01advertising? Right? You see a lot of that out there as well.
- 16:03I'm not to use the word tolerant, but I accept that term
- 16:08growth more than I accept the term or the phrase performance
- 16:11marketing, right?
- 16:12Tom Ollerton: But to your point, though, Surely all, all
- 16:14marketing, then, is designed to be growth, right? So, you know,
- 16:18I was having, I was having a debate with one of our team at
- 16:21automated creative, we were talking about tone of voice,
- 16:24right? And the discussion was, well, should the tone of voice
- 16:26be confident? And I'm like, No, not in a B to B area, like,
- 16:30because that's a given, right? Like, you can't have an
- 16:32unconfident B to B tone of voice, like, trustworthy,
- 16:35confident, liable, robust, all these things, like, you can't.
- 16:38You have to be something that someone else has not. It was an
- 16:44interesting debate, and I think I kind of feel a bit like that
- 16:45about growth and performance, right? Everything's got to
- 16:45perform.
- 16:46Nick Figueiredo: Everything's got, of course, growth, of
- 16:47course. I don't think you're wrong, right? And again, I'm
- 16:49like, I'm struggling to find a different word for it, other
- 16:51than to just call it what it is, right? We are marketers. We are
- 16:54advertisers. What is, what is the purpose of advertising or
- 16:57marketing? Right, to drive growth from a revenue
- 16:59perspective in the short and long term, to drive brand right,
- 17:03to grow the brand, to make the brand more reputable, to make it
- 17:09more salient, right? People remember it. People recall it
- 17:13when it's time to purchase.
- 17:14Tom Ollerton: So I wonder if it's maybe the performance
- 17:17growth isn't the issue. And more on the KPI. So I was fortunate
- 17:20enough to go on a book tour to talk about the book. I was in
- 17:22Amsterdam, and I was speaking to a large online retailer, and
- 17:25they were saying that they'd read the book and sort of been
- 17:27inspired by it, which is amazing. They were saying that
- 17:29the problem is, is that you have all these different teams with
- 17:32different KPIs. So you've got the E com team who were all
- 17:34about their basket size and conversion rate. Then you've got
- 17:36the media team, which all about impressions, breach, click
- 17:36through rates, little bounce rates. And then you had the
- 17:37brand team, which all about, like, long term brand health and
- 17:37metrics, right? Whereas, so the ecom team just want to cram as
- 17:43much use the basket as possible. The brand team are like, no, no,
- 17:48don't cheapen the brand. Don't, don't do anything. Don't, don't
- 17:51stick around all on anything, you know, like, make it a
- 17:53beautiful brand building thing. So, and really, what that
- 17:56organisation was trying to do was just, is to make everyone
- 18:00responsible for everyone else's KPIs. So, yes, yeah, you've got
- 18:01to increase basket size, but that basket size will go up if
- 18:04the brand team's long term health metrics got and vice
- 18:07versa, right? You know, if you've got great products, that
- 18:09was a an aha moment for me, really, is that you kind of need
- 18:12a rosy ag upstairs as like, a basket of data. You know, you
- 18:15all have the same basket of data, so the performance team
- 18:18can't do well if the brand team aren't doing well, and so on and
- 18:23so on and so forth. It's a really interesting way of
- 18:23looking at it.
- 18:23Nick Figueiredo: They all need each other, right? Like, at the
- 18:23end of the day, I think there still needs to be some, you
- 18:26know, we, I was talking earlier, about team and this, this
- 18:29mobilisation of the collective toward a shared outcome. Like, I
- 18:32still believe that in the uppermost way, there's some
- 18:36shared outcome that we all want as a team, right? But you're
- 18:39right, there is some underlying pond of data that we all pull
- 18:44from and we all understand, right? And different teams need
- 18:47different subsets of that data in order to succeed and drive
- 18:50toward that shared outcome. So the brand team might need
- 18:53awareness or salience. The you know, the digital marketing team
- 18:57might need revenue, right? But all of those things eventually
- 19:00ladder up to some shared outcome, which could be earnings
- 19:04per share or something like that. That's, that's not my
- 19:06favourite metric.
- 19:07Tom Ollerton: So Nick, I'm gonna, I'm gonna put you in a
- 19:14horrible position here. Ask for a football slash soccer analysis
- 19:19here, right? Yeah. So performance would be the
- 19:21striker, centre forward, and you can't just buying. You can't
- 19:25just have 11 strikers on the pitch, right? Yep, yeah. You
- 19:27might get one or two away. Do you know what I mean? And then
- 19:30how does it like? I'm just trying to work out what is the
- 19:32analogy there between. It is all about sticking the ball in the
- 19:35back of the net, but the keeper also can't let any, can't let
- 19:38any, but that's a very different metric to the front. 123, lose
- 19:42the ball. That puts stress on the keeper, doesn't I don't
- 19:45know, Nick, have I gone too far here?
- 19:46Nick Figueiredo: No. I mean, listen, like in certain
- 19:47circumstances, the keeper may have been the one to start the
- 19:51process of what eventually became a goal, right? If you
- 19:54think about some of the best teams in the world today,
- 19:56sometimes the keepers are outstanding with their feet. Or
- 20:00they make a great save that leads to a distribution to their
- 20:03outside fullback, who passes into this guy, who passes the
- 20:05next guy and leads to a goal, right? So six, 7, 10, guys could
- 20:08have touched the ball before the ball went in, right?
- 20:11Tom Ollerton: Nick I can see, I can see a LinkedIn post for you,
- 20:13right, which has got all of the that's got all the the 11 laid
- 20:16out on the pitch. All right, share it with me, man. I'd love
- 20:19to see it.
- 20:20Nick Figueiredo: It's already been done. It's not my my
- 20:24analogy, but it is there.
- 20:25Tom Ollerton: Unfortunately, we're at the end
- 20:32where's a good place to do that? And crucially, what makes a
- 20:34message that you will actually respond to?
- 20:36Yeah, find me on LinkedIn under Nick Figueiredo, keep it simple
- 20:40concise, right? If you think about what matters to me, it's
- 20:43It's why you need me, or why you're trying to steal my
- 20:45attention. So, so don't give me the average uplift or from all
- 20:50your case studies, right? I'm not the average, not, not many
- 20:52of us are. So just keep it short and sweet. Hit me with the why?
- 21:45Beautiful Nick, thanks so much for your time.
- 21:49Nick Figueiredo: Tom, thank you so much. I appreciate it. Thank
- 21:56you for having me today.