Latest / Crimes and Consequences / EP205: The Crimes of Joseph Edward Duncan
Transcript
- 0:00This episode may contain content of a graphic nature, including descriptions of physical and
- 0:05sexual violence against adults, children, and animals. Listener discretion is advised.
- 0:12Hi everyone, I'm Teleia and I'm Tanya, and together we are Crimes and
- 0:17Consequences, a true crime podcast. Welcome back everyone to another episode of Crimes
- 0:38and Consequences. I'm Tanya and I'm Teleia, and we are going to present
- 0:43today another exciting true crime story. Yes, thank you. But before we
- 0:49start, I would just like to remind everyone to hit the like or subscribe
- 0:52a button. And we are going to start our podcast today a little bit
- 0:56differently. We usually do this at the end, but today we're going to
- 1:00make a special special time. This is something that needs to be done year
- 1:06early. We're gonna do a little bit in the beginning and then we'll do
- 1:08more at the end. It's what we It's a segment we call review the
- 1:11reviewer, Yes, where we go over the reviews. But because we are
- 1:15they're not necessarily reviews their comments. So it's commenting on the commentary, commenting
- 1:22on the comment and then we rate them from a zero to five with what
- 1:26we think their star should be. They're rating exactly. So the first one
- 1:30is from someone that absolutely just I don't I don't know if she's watching every
- 1:34episode, but boy, she can't stand us. She hates us, she
- 1:38hates us. So I'm going to give a special shout out to at glam
- 1:41Dolly thirty. Hey, glam Dolly thirty. She has commented on all three
- 1:46of our videos that are on True Crime Daily right now. She says they
- 1:49are beyond amateurish, like a couple of schoolgirls. Oh yeah, who marks
- 1:53the gruesomeness of a murder out of ten? Well we did that as a
- 1:57warning? Yes, and who drops that f I'm during a podcast? I
- 2:00do sometimes I do too? Yeah you do? Yeah? So so childish
- 2:06that's how people talk. Yeah. And the next one she said, this
- 2:08was shockingly bad. Oh, I'm professional amateurist and disrespectful to tragic victims of
- 2:15crime. In fact, it's the best example I've ever seen of how not
- 2:19to do true crime. So my question is why if she watched on the
- 2:22second one or the third one. Oh, she's the third one. She
- 2:25watched all of them. Why are you watching us? Yeah? Or are
- 2:29you just commenting to just be a dick. I'm just asking her because you
- 2:32know, I'm gonna have to give her zero stars. I'm gonna give her
- 2:36zero stars zero stars as well, because she's an asshole. Yeah, I
- 2:40mean, move on, girl, it's not for you. If you don't
- 2:44like us, move on, Why are you watching us? I know,
- 2:46why are you watching? And please I get it. Maybe if you're new
- 2:50and you get into five minutes and you don't like it, just move on.
- 2:53It's okay, Yeah, it's okay with it. I'm okay with it.
- 2:55She's got to get a zero star, absolutely zero. So we'll cover
- 3:00some more. Move on though, move on? Where is it? Glam
- 3:02Dolly, glam Dolly thirty? You know I have two words for you,
- 3:08okay, start with enough a man with you? Thank you, thank you,
- 3:15thank you, thank you, thank you for caring. Yes, move
- 3:19on. So okay, let's go on. I'll just side. Let's yeah,
- 3:22yeah, let's go on. Now we're gonna get serious. And again,
- 3:24I'm just gonna tell everyone I laugh and if it's inappropriate to you,
- 3:28it's inappropriate. But it's a nervous giggle. Yeah, it's a nervous giggle.
- 3:30And I never am disrespectful to victims or they're families and I like to
- 3:36make fun of killers and how stupid they are. So anyway, and I
- 3:40like to swear. Yeah, so it makes me express myself better. It's
- 3:46like an art. Yeah. You wouldn't believe what I could do with the
- 3:47F word, verbs, nouns, adjectives. Absolutely, it's it's a wonderful
- 3:53word. And if you don't like it, just clutch your pearls and move
- 3:58on. Yeah, just chill out. So just chill out. We're just
- 4:00being real. Yeah, just being real. So let's go, all right,
- 4:03what do you got? Serial killer and gross child molester Joseph Edward Duncan.
- 4:10Oh, I know this one. Well. He may not be known
- 4:12to someone, you know, his name might not ring a bell, but
- 4:15you maybe you maybe remember the case which brought him to justice. In May
- 4:20two thousand and five, Joseph was driving through Cordeline, Idaho, when he
- 4:27noticed two children, siblings, eight year old Shasta Gronie and nine year old
- 4:32Dylan Grony. This was all over the news, Oh, it was nationwide.
- 4:36They were playing in the front yard. And what Joseph would do.
- 4:40He would drive through neighborhoods until he spotted some children who maybe would make a
- 4:44perfect target. For him, and so he didn't snatch up Shasta and Dylan
- 4:49right away. He waited until the evening to strike. So he's kind of
- 4:54like stalking them. Yeah, he was stalking them, Yeah, scoping it
- 4:57out. Mm hmm. He forced his w and to the Grony house where
- 5:00he knew that there were parents and an older sibling. Yeah, he pretended
- 5:08he was just in the house to steal valuables initially, but what he really
- 5:13wanted, like I told you, were the children. That's what he valued
- 5:16most. Oh, I know from this home invasion, the children's mother,
- 5:20Brenda. So when when Joseph went in the house, mother Brenda, she
- 5:25was crying and she woke the children up and she told Shasta, you need
- 5:29to wake up. Someone's in the house. And she told her kids through
- 5:31tears, that they needed to come into the living room. And by the
- 5:34time Brenda entered the room with her two small children, their older brother Slaid
- 5:41and Brenda's longtime boyfriend slash fiance Mark were already faced down, bound with zip
- 5:46ties and gagged with duct tape across their mouth. So you can imagine this
- 5:50scene right, Oh, it's horrible. I'm sure it was terrifying. Joseph
- 5:57pointed a shotgun of Brenda and told her to get on the ground so that
- 5:59he could do the same to her. He tied up Shasta and Dylan and
- 6:02took them outside and told them to wait on the grass. He then went
- 6:08back inside the house and he killed Brenda, Mark and Slade. Yeah,
- 6:13and Slade. How did Slade? How did he do it? She killed
- 6:16them? No, he killed them with a hammer. He beat them to
- 6:19die. Oh my, yeah, it was. It was horrible. And
- 6:25the children were waiting outside while this was all happening. Thank god they were
- 6:29outside. Yeah, but I'm sure they could hear everything that was going on.
- 6:33And at one point Slade even made his way outside, kind of like
- 6:38stumbling outside, and when Joseph saw him, he went back and hit him
- 6:43some more, and Slade was on the I guess maybe the porch area the
- 6:46threshold, and he fell and police say he ended up making his way back
- 6:54into the house and he died next to his mom. That is so I
- 6:58know, damn sad, I know, it's terrible, Like I I can't
- 7:01even imagine the horror. Joseph kidnaps Shasta and her brother, Dylan and Chessa's
- 7:08eight and Dylan's nine just in I did yeah, my head. Yeah.
- 7:13And the following day he takes off, so Joseph takes off with them.
- 7:16But the following day, a neighbor saw some blood on the front door of
- 7:20the Groanie house and he contacted police right away. When they arrived, they
- 7:26found forty year old Brenda Gronie, thirty seven year old Mark Mackenzie, and
- 7:30Brenda's oldest son, thirteen year old Slade Bronie, all dead. Yeah,
- 7:35all dead. Blood was everywhere. I mean, the officers were just yeah,
- 7:40he's a hammer. Yeah. The officers was just shocked. They it
- 7:46was hate him, I know it was. It was a horrific scene.
- 7:51I mentioned that he drove off with Shasta Dylan. What he did was once
- 7:57he got the kids in the car, he tied them to the floor of
- 8:00his red jeep Cherokey, and he drove them to a cabin that was located
- 8:03in a secluded area in Montana. M This is all bringing back the memories
- 8:09of his case. This is just terrible and this would be a house of
- 8:11horrors. Yeah, these poor children, they were there, yeah for a
- 8:15while. When the police arrived to the scene. Like, like I mentioned,
- 8:20there's blood everywhere, and they searched the rest of the house. They
- 8:24found blood in every single room of this house. And they weren't sure if
- 8:28some of the blood was Shasta's or Dylan's since they weren't in the home when
- 8:33the police arrived, you know, so where are they? They brought in
- 8:37a forensic analysis and analyst, and it was determined that most of the blood
- 8:41was slaves because like I told you, he was able to walk. Yeah,
- 8:46but there wasn't a single trace of blood or anything from Shasta or Dylan's
- 8:52horrible Oh my god. Steve Groeney, Shasta and Dylan's and Slade's biological father
- 8:58was called and he was just absolute crushed when he got this news of the
- 9:01murders of Brenda, Mark and Slade and then where are my kids? Right?
- 9:07My kids? Yeah, But police didn't rule him out initially as a
- 9:11suspect because there was some history between he and Brenda, and he admitted to
- 9:16police that he and Brenda had argued the day before and you know, they
- 9:22sometimes had a rough time getting along, like a lot of divorced parents do.
- 9:26But he was eventually cleared after investigators couldn't find anything to link him to
- 9:31the crimes. The day prior to the murder and kidnappings, the family had
- 9:37a barbecue, so police had their handsful with interviewing every single person that was
- 9:43in attendance at that barbecue. But again, law enforcement couldn't find anything to
- 9:48tie the crimes to the attendees, so the next step in the investigation was
- 9:54to issue an amber alert. However, weeks passed with no really movement in
- 10:01the case. Yeah. I remember all of this, Yeah, I remember.
- 10:05It was all over the news. Oh man, the cabin where Shasta
- 10:09and Dylan were being held captive, I mentioned, was in Montana. Oh
- 10:13yeah, so it's a remote cabin in Montana. Good luck finding him.
- 10:16Yeah, out in the woods somewhere right was his It was like at a
- 10:22campsite. So maybe I don't I don't. Ever, I did not read
- 10:26anything that said he owned the cabin. So maybe it's something you can rent
- 10:31or break into, Yeah, or break in. It made me broke into.
- 10:35Yeah, I probably didn't want to leave a trail once I got to
- 10:37the cabin. Joseph said there was a rule that the kids needed to call
- 10:41him daddy. Oh, stop it fucking gross. Yeah, big time dude,
- 10:48And he said if they tried to run, he was going to shoot
- 10:50them. At one point, he held up a clawhammer and told the children,
- 10:58this is what I killed your parents. Oh, I said, I'm
- 11:03going to kill you the same way. Of course, Shastaan Dylan were absolutely
- 11:07terrified. This is just evil. This is evil, I know, and
- 11:11these are just little kids. I mean, this is Yeah. I can't
- 11:15imagine the terror that they felt. Joe was a rollercoaster of emotions because after
- 11:20he threatened to kill the kids with the hammer, he was overwhelmed by a
- 11:24sense of regret for killing the family in the first place. Yeah, okay,
- 11:28he apologized, Yeah enough to release the kids. I know, right,
- 11:33No, because he's a gross child molester. Yeah, he apologized to
- 11:39Shaston Dylan for killing their family. I'm so sorry I killed your family.
- 11:41Yeah, I'm so sorry. He would sometimes touch on religion, blaming God
- 11:50for the things he did. That's God's fault. It's God's fault, he
- 11:52said, no responsibility. Yeah, no, no, it's all God's fault
- 11:56for making him, you know, make him rape and kill chill and people.
- 12:01I guess. He would also just say weird shit to Shasta, like
- 12:03how she was the one that taught him how to love. It's just Grosst
- 12:07like, I just can't get over it. Yeah, and despite having these
- 12:15moments where he's like, I'm so sorry that this happened, he was incredibly
- 12:18cruel. Yeah, I remember Shasta and Dylan very cruel. He Yeah,
- 12:26he took his He took his evilness though to another level when it came to
- 12:31Dylan at one. One time he killed or he tied Dylan to a log
- 12:37and proceeded to beat him with a stick and he didn't stop until the stick
- 12:41broke. And where was Shasta? I'm sure she was watching it all.
- 12:46Dylan was scared of the dark, and Joseph took advantage of that fear.
- 12:50He often made him cry by calling him names like a coward and it is
- 12:56what nine, Yeah, he's nine. And because I'm sure he was crying,
- 13:01and I would be crying the entire time, So I mean, I
- 13:05don't blame him at all. I would be terrified and crying every single minute
- 13:09I was there. And didn't he He did sexual assault? Oh yeah,
- 13:11he raped these children and not just ones, however, so they're with Joseph
- 13:18and it's like weeks of Goune. Yeah, one day during yeah, exactly
- 13:24one day during their captivity, she has to heard a gun shot and saw
- 13:28Dylan dropped to the floor, screaming out in pain from a shot to his
- 13:33stomach. Joseph claimed it was an accident, like I was moving the gun,
- 13:39playing with the gun. I don't know what he was doing, but
- 13:41ooh, I accidentally shot Dylan in the stomach. But the next thing he
- 13:46did was he put the muzzle of the gun to Dylan's head, oh,
- 13:50man, and he pulled the trigger but nothing happened. The gun was out
- 13:54of bullets, but this didn't deter him. He reloaded it, pointed it
- 14:00Dylan once again, and Dylan pleaded and pleaded for his life and told Joseph,
- 14:05don't shoot me, Please, don't shoot me. But he did anyway.
- 14:09Oh, a friend of Shasta just saw this. All I remember hearing
- 14:15something about him like tying to rafters. Maybe that's what you meant when you
- 14:18said log like you tie maybe yeah, to rafters or oh he was just
- 14:24he did multiple things. That's a multiple things. Cruel, just horrible,
- 14:28I mean, just stopping. Yeah, yeah, And he tried to tell
- 14:37Shasta that he killed Dylan with the shot to the head to put him out
- 14:43of his misery because he had shot him in the mercy killing. Yeah,
- 14:46a mercy killing. But he can fuck right off. Yeah, he can
- 14:50totally fuck right off. And according to Shasta, after Dylan was killed,
- 14:54Joseph set a fire and burned Dylan's body along with any bloodstained clothing. He
- 15:03then dumped Dylan's ashes into a drain pipe that led into a river. And
- 15:07where was she? She was there, Tanya. I can't now she's all
- 15:13alone and she's in her burned. I know, I why, I know.
- 15:20I just this is very painful. I can't imagine. I hate him
- 15:26so much. He is such a fucker. I just, yeah, God,
- 15:30there's no redeeming qualities in someone like that. Yeah, I know.
- 15:35Okay. Joseph was really scared of getting caught, so he would travel along
- 15:39the back roads that led into Cordeline. He promised, that's an Idaho,
- 15:46that's where Shasta. Shasta's family was from. Okay. He promised Shasta that
- 15:50he would drop her off at the police station, but only after they watched
- 15:54Star Wars. What is this? He said he wanted to see it one
- 15:58last time before he went to prey in and but he thought he would also,
- 16:02you know, take Chessta's mind off of this horrible ordeal. She's going,
- 16:04She's going to distract her from the pain by with a movie and can't
- 16:08you watch it? Don't you get YouTube in prison? Now? I don't
- 16:11know. It sounds like you get there. I don't know the iPads and
- 16:15things. Yeah, I don't know. Don't they have a movie night?
- 16:18I don't know. I've never been to prison. I don't either, but
- 16:21okay, yeah, just an excuse to keep her longer, Yeah, exactly.
- 16:26He took her to a restaurant to get her some food. Denny's,
- 16:29Yes, Denny's, And at this point she had been Joseph's prisoner for seven
- 16:36seven weeks. Leading up this trip into town, he had tried to strangle
- 16:41her but only stopped when she said, please stop, and so he did.
- 16:45I don't know why he stopped. And she did tell the police eventually
- 16:48that he threatened to kill her multiple times a day over that seven week period,
- 16:53but she has to kept hope alive. She had a strong feeling that
- 16:56she was going to get rescued and that he was going to get caught before
- 17:00he actually killed her, and she was right. While in the restaurant.
- 17:06One of the employees recognized her from the news. I remember this. It
- 17:11was like a miracle, yes, And I remember hearing the call. I've
- 17:15heard it on the internet, and it was a woman and she said,
- 17:18you know, there's a little girl in here, and she looks just like
- 17:22that little girl that's been all over the news, Shasta. And you know,
- 17:26maybe I maybe I'm wrong, but she looks exactly like Shasta was.
- 17:32Yeah. So the police show up and obviously they arrest Joseph, and she
- 17:40has to help the police with filling any blanks in his story, maybe that
- 17:42he had told the police about what happened to her brother and about where they
- 17:47were being held. She took law enforcement out to the cabin so they could
- 17:51collect physical evidence that would assist in back to that cabin. Brave, I
- 17:59remember, so brave. She was just so strong, and having to relive
- 18:03everything to help in the investigation just must have been I can't imagine. After
- 18:10Joseph was arrested, and while he was in custody, he confessed to other
- 18:15abductions and murders, And this part of the story I didn't know about,
- 18:18because I do remember, I don't know the details. I just don't he
- 18:21had. This wasn't his first time, because I remember when he killed the
- 18:23Groni family, and you know, when this all happened to her, I
- 18:27just didn't know there were other crimes, wasn't it in California? Oh,
- 18:32he was all over the place. Yes, Those first recorded murder victims were
- 18:36Sammy Joe White and Carmen Joy Kubias. Okay, these two girls were inseparable.
- 18:41Sammy Joe was eleven and Carmen was nine at the time of their murders.
- 18:48These two girls were half sisters. Then they were best friends. Where
- 18:51did they live? I'll get to that. I was sorry. They were
- 18:56the boss friends who did everything together and and they they were just two little
- 19:02girls that were fun loving. You know. They loved Disney movies and drawing
- 19:07pictures and listening to their favorite music, which was R and B. They
- 19:11loved going to seven eleven and get nacks and oh me too. Seven eleven
- 19:15is the place, right. They lived with their mother, Margaret Delaney,
- 19:21in a motel where in a motel, they lived in a motel, and
- 19:26they they lived in a motel. Their mother moved around a lot, and
- 19:30they weren't enrolled in school. So really these two a stable right going on?
- 19:37Right? They and so these two little girls were all they had,
- 19:40right, They didn't have any fan of each other. Yeah, they had
- 19:42each other exactly. On July sixth, nineteen ninety six, both Sammy,
- 19:48both Sammy, Joe and Carmen disappeared while leaving the Crest Motel, which was
- 19:53in Seattle. Okay, so there we are. They're in Seattle, and
- 19:57that motel was located on a Avenue North and this was a little bit before
- 20:03eleven pm. The street that they had taken, or that they were on,
- 20:08was known for its drug dealing and sex workers worked off the street.
- 20:14So it's not exactly the safest neighborhood for these two little kids. What's the
- 20:18mom doing? I don't know what she was doing, but we're not judging.
- 20:21I'm not judging. I'm just saying, yeah, I know, and
- 20:23it's eleven I mean, it's late. These little girls should not be out,
- 20:26but they were. They went to a nearby restaurant called Tacko Time Oh
- 20:30to get cigarettes for their older brother, and this is where they were last
- 20:34seen. When their mother, Margaret got home, she was at work,
- 20:37I believe, Okay, and the girls had not returned she reported them missing.
- 20:44The police initially thought, like in a lot of cases that we've covered
- 20:48that the girls had run away, but their families, you know, their
- 20:51family members, so they would never they would never run away. And like
- 20:56how old are they? Wait, they're nine to eleven. Where they're gonna
- 20:57go? You know the last Maybe I can understand you think that about maybe
- 21:02ifteen year grade you get on your own, right, No, but I'm
- 21:06sure, I mean they had their reasons. Sadly, on February tenth,
- 21:11nineteen ninety eight, the remains of Sammy, Joe, and Carmen were found
- 21:15by a homeless person who was residing in an abandoned barn in the North Creek
- 21:21area of Bethel, Washington. So he got both of them, Yep,
- 21:26he got both of them. Illallly used one to you know, control the
- 21:30other. I would think so because they loved each other so much, inseparable,
- 21:34I'm sure they would have never left each other to run away. He
- 21:38just gets worse. Yeah. The King County Medical Examiner determined that the two
- 21:42girls had been killed shortly after they disappeared. The skeletal remains were found in
- 21:48a field and not much was skeletal. Yeah, So how long was it?
- 21:52It was? It was almost two years. They just years. Yeah.
- 21:57They disappeared July nineteen ninety six and they were found February nineteen ninety eight.
- 22:03So was that maybe a year and a half. Oh, ish a
- 22:06poor mom that whole time. We're my kids, I know. And that
- 22:11much else is known about how they died, other than they were a skeletal
- 22:15remain, yeah, other they were killed in a violent way. Well,
- 22:18how do they know they died? Right away? That's a good question if
- 22:22it's their skeletal remains, You're right, how did they know? I don't
- 22:26know, You're you're the answer. I'm not a medical examiner, okay,
- 22:30which not a trained professional, not a trained professional, just a lawyer.
- 22:33We're just lawyers, right, you know. Well they have ways. I
- 22:37don't know. I don't know, but dater's right away. Mean, I
- 22:40don't know. I know if they're just skeletal, I don't know. I'm
- 22:42I'm gonna be thinking about this forever. After the remains were found, roughly
- 22:48about one hundred people gathered at Our Lady of Mount Virgin Church to remember their
- 22:53beautiful souls. Sammy Joe's father whose name was Sam was of the Gross Venture
- 23:00tribe in North Dakota, so he was a Native American, so he said
- 23:04a few traditional Native American prayers during the service. Sam was staying at the
- 23:10Harbor View Medical Center for complications. He was suffering from diabetes, and he
- 23:15was released just so he could attend his daughter's funeral. He trembled while he
- 23:22was reciting the prayers and while family members hugged him. Friends and family members
- 23:26passed around pictures of the two girls as they told their own stories about how
- 23:30Sammy, Jo and Carmen lit up their lives in such an enormous way.
- 23:34I mean, they were just fun loving. Did they have any clues?
- 23:37No, in that year and a half, No, no, No.
- 23:41The last time their family was together like this was just two days before they
- 23:45disappeared on the fourth of July in nineteen ninety six. During his confession,
- 23:52Joseph described what happened. So that's how we know he did it, is
- 23:56he confessed? Yeah, he confessed. I don't want to know what he
- 24:00is. I don't Yeah, I don't have a lot of details, but
- 24:03he said he took the two girls while they were walking out of the taco
- 24:06time and he hit them with a crowbar? What and he called them he
- 24:10said they looked like horrors and gang bangers, little girls. Yeah, and
- 24:14how is he hitting them with the crowbar outside of taco time and nobody sees
- 24:18it? Nobody? Maybe people saw him, didn't care. Maybe people don't
- 24:22like to get involved. Yeah, they don't want to call the police either.
- 24:26Probably it's the neighborhood. I don't think they'd want the police in.
- 24:30Next, in his convention confession, Joseph told law enforcement about how he abducted
- 24:34and murdered ten year old Anthony Martinez. Anthony was kidnapped on April fourth,
- 24:41nineteen ninety seven, in Beaumont, California. He was taking a knife point
- 24:45from his family as they stood about twenty feet from the front door of his
- 24:48house. And I'm not sure exactly how he did it. He was taking
- 24:51a broad daylight right in front of his younger brother and cousin and they were
- 24:56also neighborhood kids there. He just didn't give a fuck, He raisen,
- 25:00Yeah, he in front of a bunch of kids. He takes this child
- 25:04and what years this ninety seven, Anthony had been outside playing behind their house
- 25:10when Joseph pulled up in a car, and he was able to lure Anthony
- 25:15away by offering the group of kids a dollar to help him find his lost
- 25:21cat. So everyone warn your children. I do. I know I do
- 25:23too. If they have a kitten, a puppy, I don't care.
- 25:27They're there, their baby is hurt. Do not warn your kids. Please,
- 25:32Oh my gosh, I always I've told you before. I would pull
- 25:36up when my kids are like walking, Hey, I've got some candy.
- 25:40I lost my poppy, and I'm like, don't get in my car.
- 25:42Yeah, exactly. I just bought your children because tom molesters are sneaky and
- 25:48that's how they get away. They're aware. I don't think they're not.
- 25:52Yeah. He held up this photo of a kitten and he held up the
- 25:56dollar, and some of the kids ran away, but Anthony, he held
- 26:00up a photo of a fucking kitten. Yeah, not like yeah oh this
- 26:03Yeah. He was like, this is my kitten. Yeah, okay,
- 26:07all right, this is what my kitten looks like. Fucker. Anthony wasn't
- 26:11his original target. He actually lunged at Anthony's younger brother and missed. Then
- 26:18he decided that Anthony was going to be his next victim. After Anthony disappeared,
- 26:26a sketch artist was immediately brought in and the sketch artists worked with the
- 26:30children that were there. He worked with the children for hours. These kids
- 26:34were traumatized. To help get a picture of what Anthony's abductor looked like,
- 26:41and they published it on the news, and fifteen thousand leads were called in
- 26:45holy shit, and the police followed up on every single one of them,
- 26:49but nothing panned out. Fifteen fifteen, I know, and none of them
- 26:56panned out. The media released that the kidnapper was a skin white guy with
- 27:00blue eyes and a mustache, and when he took Anthony, he was wearing
- 27:03a red and black plaid button down shirt and blue jeans, which you probably
- 27:08ditched right away, right. Did they know? Did they describe his car?
- 27:12Yeah, the kids told the police that his car was a white car.
- 27:17I don't think they would know enough to know what kind of make it
- 27:18was, but they said it was a white car. The Riverside County Deputy
- 27:22District Attorney said that he thought the kidnapper was someone who was familiar with the
- 27:27area, since, you know, he said the abduction didn't seem like it
- 27:32was like spur of the moment, like I just you know, I'm in
- 27:34a weird area and I'm just going to kidnap a child, like he knew
- 27:38what he was doing. Sixteen days after he was abducted, Oh, what
- 27:47are you gonna tell me? The nude body of Anthony Martinez was found in
- 27:52a remote area of the desert with his feet and his hands taped together and
- 27:59most of us by. He was buried under some stones, but his face
- 28:02and hands were exposed, and due to the exposure to the elements and to
- 28:06animals, that's where his body suffered the most decomposition. So he tried to
- 28:11bury them somewhat. Yeah, put him up with stones maybe, Like the
- 28:17police couldn't decide whether he did. He covered him with stones on purpose or
- 28:21if the stones fell from higher elevation, you know, and landed there.
- 28:23So it could have been either or I mean, he could have just dumped
- 28:29his body out in the desert and who knows. His body was found by
- 28:33a Bureau of Land Management ranger who noticed vultures circling in the sky above Anthony's
- 28:41body. Since his body was found in such a remote area, which was
- 28:45about one hundred and thirty miles from Los Angeles. This was another factor in
- 28:49the police thinking that the person who did this was familiar but the area.
- 28:55There wasn't much evidence left on Anthony's body, Yeah, because he was nude
- 28:59too. Yeah, except there was a partial thumb print that was left on
- 29:03duct tape that was around his feet and hands. I'm not sure if it
- 29:06was on the one on his feeter his hands. It doesn't matter. I
- 29:08hate stories with kids. Oh, these are the worst. I just nah,
- 29:14okay, it's so not that you know, an adult, but innocence.
- 29:19Yeah, it's the innocence involved for sure, since his family, since
- 29:25his face was heavily decomposed, the police had no idea who this child was.
- 29:30And he's far away, right, Yeah. He was from Beaumont,
- 29:34Yeah, which is a suburb of Los Angeles. So I think, yeah,
- 29:37you think he's probably at least I mean, it was one hundred and
- 29:40thirty miles from Las Yeah, so's he's far yeah. Yeah. But they
- 29:44were able to use donald records and they determined it was Anthony, and with
- 29:48that id, the nationwide search ended for him. When the news broke about
- 29:52the discovery of his body, the LAPD was very careful with the information they
- 29:57divulged. The only thing that they would say was that his cause of death
- 30:03was pretty obvious when looking at the body after it had been uncovered by the
- 30:07rocks in the ravine. What did he do? The details about Anthony being
- 30:12molested was also kept hidden, but they did say that this crime was the
- 30:17work of a quote practiced sexual predator mmmmm end quote. Anthony had been raped
- 30:25at least once, but probably more because Joseph Netever let a child go after
- 30:30only raping them one time. Yeah, that's why I wonder what he did
- 30:33with this girl. I know, I know. Police estimated the predator was
- 30:38twenty five to thirty five years old. He was about five eight. The
- 30:42FBI got involved in the search for this mystery man, and they even brought
- 30:48in an archaeologist and hopefully getting a different perspective on the crimes. An archaeologist,
- 30:52I know, I mean, I didn't see that if it had been
- 30:55longer than sixteen days. Yeah, but they brought one in. Okay,
- 31:00kind of intrigued me. I was like, why are they getting an archaeologist?
- 31:02I wanted to be an archaeologist. I know you did. I wish
- 31:04I would have said you became a lawyer, I know, and every day,
- 31:07every day, I kicked myself every single day. Choice I could be
- 31:12somewhere just dusting you know, dinosaur bones exactly, or you know, wonderful
- 31:18artifacts from the past, but instead I'm here lawyering. So I'm podcasting too,
- 31:23been podcasting, yes, but you know, life's funny that way.
- 31:29Anyway, investigators, along with some FBI agents, made their way through the
- 31:33Joshua Tree National Park as gunshots could be heard. There was an open gun
- 31:38range nearby, which I'm sure was kind of unnerving. They gathered shellcasings and
- 31:45took pictures of everything that could possibly be relevant to Anthony's case, and then
- 31:51they made their way to the makeshift grave once they got back from where his
- 31:55body was discovered, which was about one hundred feet from the closest road.
- 32:00The authorities were unable to determine one hundred feet from the closest road, so
- 32:04how to get him out there naked? He carried him. He's a little
- 32:08boy, he's ten, I mean, even if he's a large ten year
- 32:13old. I'm just wondering, like Buzzy forced to walk and then oh god,
- 32:16maybe I don't know. Oh no, I don't know either. Since
- 32:22his body was so badly decomposed, the medical examiner could only say that he
- 32:27could have been dead for as little as two days or for as long as
- 32:30two weeks. Joseph told police it was sixteen days yeah, after he disappeared,
- 32:37so he was maybe held for at least couple days at least man,
- 32:42if not two weeks. Anthony told police the way he killed Anthony was by
- 32:46repeatedly hitting him in the head with a rock, and so I think he
- 32:50killed him right there in the desk, That's what I'm thinking, Yeah,
- 32:52before he left him for dead. Mmmmm. During the time between the murders
- 33:00of Anthony, Sammy, Joe, and Carmen, their murder cases went cold.
- 33:05Joseph was sent back to prison for violating his parole for I'm not sure,
- 33:09I'm sure has something to do with sure had something to do with wasn't
- 33:14supposed to be, you know, one hundred feet and in front of a
- 33:16school or something. Yeah, But then he was released yet again and what
- 33:21they deemed is good behavior. At this point, he was classified as a
- 33:25Level three sex offender, a level three sex offender, and it meant that
- 33:30even though he was being released he was more than likely going to commit another
- 33:34sexual crime against another child, So we're going to release him. Yeah,
- 33:37even though more than fifty more you know, more than fifty percent likely.
- 33:44Yeah, it's going to do it again. Let's get him out. Yeah,
- 33:45let's let him out. I but we'll put safety precautions in place.
- 33:50He's not allowed by a school, right, yeah, things like that.
- 33:52Yeah, like, no kind of other monitoring, no ankle bracelettering. No,
- 33:57we're just gonna let him out. In two thousand, before he attacked
- 34:00and raped two young boys that were playing at a local playground in Fargo,
- 34:05Minnesota. What Yeah, and did he he how do we know? Did
- 34:09he admit this? Yeah? He admitted it. It's actually shocking that he
- 34:14went four years without raping another I know, but he more than likely did
- 34:20I mean, what does he just hand? Oh you know, I cleaned
- 34:22up my actor for No, he didn't. No, you didn't. Really.
- 34:24He's a liar, he's a sick fuck he's no, he can't stop
- 34:29himself. No, no, no. When he was arrested for these crimes
- 34:34the two boys in Minnesota, he was quickly released on fifteen thousand dollars bail.
- 34:39Rave than two boys and then he skipped down. I can't even get
- 34:44away with a parking you know, what is this? I know, it's
- 34:46ridiculous. And he left town and committed even more horrific cbsconded. Yeah,
- 34:52he absconded. Because then in two thousand and five is when he picked up
- 34:57Dylan and chest On murdered their family. Joseph was on the run and the
- 35:01cops were looking for him, but he felt like he needed to get revenge
- 35:06on the judicial system, even though I think the judicial systems treating him pretty
- 35:09fucking good. They're pretty yeah, I mean real nice, yeah, considering
- 35:15you're touching and blessing and he's allowed into society, right, you know,
- 35:21he was locked up so many times, so now he's pissed at the judicial
- 35:23system. Damn them. Yeah, and that's when he found him side damn
- 35:28and God who made him do all these things. Not the victims. He's
- 35:32a victim. He's a victim, victim of the system. And that's when
- 35:36he found himself right outside of Cordelaine, Idaho, and went on to target
- 35:40Like I mentioned, the prony. So he's going to take his revenge out
- 35:44on kids and family to get to the judicial system. Right. He After
- 35:50his arrest, he told police about how much he wanted to get revenge on
- 35:53society and said, quote, my intent is to harm society as much as
- 35:58I can then die end quote. Well, how about he just kill himself.
- 36:00I'm not not suggesting anybody kill themselves, but I'm just saying, I
- 36:04mean, no, he's just going to hurt children. You said that he
- 36:10was going to get revenge and then he was going to kill him? Yes,
- 36:13what would you just skip over the road. We didn't even say he's
- 36:15gonna kill him. He said I was going to die. Oh So I
- 36:16don't even know if he had that intent, but maybe he thought, you
- 36:21know, he just dying a shootout. I have no idea. I'm making
- 36:23things up at this howling I am. That'd be pretty awesome though, if
- 36:28it was a shootout. I'm sorry. Well, I've got another case coming
- 36:31up. Oh I can't wait to hear that one. Okay. When he
- 36:37was arrested, they looked through his car and they found a GPS system which
- 36:43showed he pretty much just went to schools or playgrounds, like he just spent
- 36:47his days stalking children. So gross. Yeah. Before striking the Grony family,
- 36:54he had kidnapped a child in Montana, and he stocked their house,
- 36:59the grown family's house for a few days before Yeah, he swooped in,
- 37:02like I mentioned in twenty in two thousand and six, I always do that,
- 37:08I'm gonna say twenty six, Joseph pled guilty to murdering Brenda and Mark
- 37:15and Slade. In two thousand and seven. He pled guilty to kidnapping,
- 37:20physically harming and raping shafta In Dylan, and to murdering Dylan for Dylan.
- 37:25It took him for more years to plead guilty in court to killing Anthony Martinez
- 37:30in nineteen ninety seven, and he was given too life sentences. He wasn't
- 37:34prosecuted for the murders of Sammy, Joe and Carmen in nineteen ninety six evidence
- 37:39just because he confessed doesn't mean he actually did it, but yeah, Allegedly.
- 37:46Following the sentencing hearings in November of two thousand and eight, Joseph waived
- 37:52his right to an appeal, and he told the judge quote, if any
- 37:54appeal is initiated on my behalf, it is done against my wishes end quote.
- 38:00The judge found Joseph to be competent as he waved his own rights,
- 38:04but his attorneys appealed to the Ninth Circuit and they claim that he wasn't competent
- 38:08enough to waive his rights. The Ninth Circuit said the judge should have a
- 38:14competency hearing. This is just we say, the court's time, but everyone
- 38:19has the rights. Yeah, but the competence that that hearing should have been
- 38:22done way back and the original trial. You're not an appeal they had,
- 38:29they had a right to request a competency hearing that you're right, you're right.
- 38:34But in early twenty the judge held a twenty three day long retrospective competency
- 38:42hearing. Andy Somber of that same year, the judge issued a detailed order
- 38:45finding him to be completely competent because he's not insane, he's crazy, that
- 38:51he's not mentally it's not only ill. Well, well, I don't know,
- 38:53I don't know. I don't know. Being a child molester I think
- 38:57is probably a mental illness. I don't know. I think that's sexual proper
- 39:00ference. But that's a whole nother story. Yeah, that's a whole other
- 39:01topic. After receiving several life sentences in multiple death sentences. He was sentence
- 39:08to death. I'm sorry by Lada. He was sent to death row,
- 39:13but while on death row, he was diagnosed with stage four brain cancer.
- 39:17He had brain surgery in twenty twenty, but later refused radiation and chemotherapy due
- 39:23to how advanced the cancer was. His doctor didn't even think he had even
- 39:27a year left life. He died on death row on March twenty eighth,
- 39:31twenty twenty one, at the age of fifty eight. Politics. Yeah,
- 39:37The family of Anthony Martinez told reporters of how they wished to see him be
- 39:40executed. His father, Ernesto said, quote, knowing that he is now
- 39:45standing before God being held accountable for what he has done, what he did
- 39:50to my son in the horrible crimes he committed to others, That's the real
- 39:53justice end quote. Anthony's brother Marcos said that there was less evil in the
- 39:59world now that Joseph was dead. Even though he knew that his death wouldn't
- 40:02bring Anthony back, he found relief. Yeah, just knowing that nobody else
- 40:07is going to get hurt in this guy just no longer. He no longer
- 40:09exists because of what happened to his brother. Marco said, that he will
- 40:15spend the rest of his life fighting against the evil that is still left in
- 40:17the world. Well that's a big fight. Yeah, there's a lot of
- 40:21evil. And I could go into more about Joseph's life, childhood and upbringing,
- 40:28but I don't think any of us cares. I'm sure what his mom
- 40:31would be nice. He was amused atually abused. Well, he said choices,
- 40:36Yeah, he said choices he could make, and he made really bad
- 40:38ones. Yeah. I mean he made a conscious decision to do everything he
- 40:44did and instead of getting therapy or you know, dealing with his own isspeaking
- 40:47Hell yep. So everybody can make a list about all the crimes your mom
- 40:53did you and how you know life was hard, and I'm sure maybe his
- 40:58was extra hard, but it's still not excuse to be heavy. But I'm
- 41:00not gonna get into it because I really don't care about him. He's dead,
- 41:04he's gone. He's not gonna molest any more children. That's all I
- 41:06care about. You can funk off, mm hmm. He's on our hate
- 41:07list very much. Our hate list is long, but only for the people
- 41:13that deserve to be on the hate list. Absolutely, we love all you
- 41:15guys. Even the ones that leave us back. We do. We're gonna
- 41:19kill them with kindness? Are we gonna kill it with except for whatever?
- 41:27Dolly Glamour shot glam Dolly, I think that was her name. I was.
- 41:31I'm very kind Dolly. So do you want to hear a few more
- 41:35reviews? Sure? Comments are gonna be nasty. Yeah, we're gonna I'm
- 41:37gonna tell you a few nasty ones here. This is a general consensus of
- 41:40some of the nasty. Oh god, I can't wait. At Ziptoid said,
- 41:45great info, but terrible storytelling. I feel like you guys have no
- 41:50chemistry, which I find kind of ironic, locked up because we're like,
- 41:52f us, yeah and we this is like episode two hundred and something.
- 41:57Maybe it was just a little nervous like in the beginning. Maybe I think
- 42:00it's easier every episode we video record. For sure, we have a lot
- 42:05of chemistry. Yeah, you're like yeah, yeah, then and we finished
- 42:09each other's sentences at Dan Daniel, it's d A and I E. That's
- 42:16okay, I E. On eleven ninety, she said, I can't believe
- 42:21they let them back on. Did they not read the comments the first time
- 42:24off? Can we get to some nice ones. Yeah, I'm getting mad.
- 42:30That's that's those are all zero stars. I don't know, you got
- 42:34nothing better do than insult somebody. Let me see your true crime podcast.
- 42:38Let's see you coming all of a sudden be on TV. And I'm not
- 42:43a robot, and I don't I'm not a newscaster, and neither are you.
- 42:45We're last time I checked, and I don't want to tell a story
- 42:49that way. And we just are not you saw the camera stock, Yeah,
- 42:52and we're people nervous, we're people. Yeah, I'm giving you my
- 42:55honest reaction to some of these crimes. And she's great, and she's great,
- 43:00Yeah, she's great. You're missing out if you're not watching or listening.
- 43:04Yeah, oh fuck them. I don't care. It's fine. Here's
- 43:06some nice ones, okay at Pam none nine zero nine nine, she said,
- 43:10jeesh, no one's forcing anyone to watch. Don't like these episodes,
- 43:15just skip them. I don't feel they laugh at or disrespect or disrespectful of
- 43:20the victims. They laugh at themselves and scientopics, not the girl or what
- 43:24happened to her. I mean, you are never going to be everyone's cup
- 43:29of And that's okay. And exactly, Pam, thank you? Was that
- 43:31my mom? No. And there was one woman in one comment that I
- 43:37saw, and she defended us pretty vigorously in the comments, and I couldn't
- 43:43find it today to talk about it. But her name was Tanya, and
- 43:45there were some numbers, and it wasn't me. I thought it was funny
- 43:47because I was like, and she was a blond woman, and I was
- 43:50like, it's not me. But thank you girl, thank you for all
- 43:52the defense. Well here's the thing. You don't like us, move on,
- 43:57I mean I don't. It's a different right, Like I have better
- 43:59things to do. The right negative thing ye about people, I just don't
- 44:02watch again. If I don't like it. I assume nobody cares what I
- 44:06think. Anyway. Why am I gonna leave a review? I mean,
- 44:09I mean, I don't even do it when I have a bad meal or
- 44:12I go somewhere and I have bad sir, because we're nice. Yes,
- 44:15I don't do that. You guys try to do all this not as easy
- 44:17as you think. But we've loved the people that want to just let do
- 44:22it. Someone said I were here. It was at gun g n I
- 44:27R for twenty I love these women the type you want to have a coffee
- 44:30cup with Yeah, thank you or a drink yes, and I'm gonna leave.
- 44:36I'm gonna say another nice one, because please, can you build up
- 44:38my self esteem? Feeling pretty lost at Brian and A R I E.
- 44:46I D. Sorry five twenty two nine and Telia are by far my favorite
- 44:52true crime to listen to. In fact, they are the only ones I
- 44:57listened to these days. I particularly love how they get right to the point.
- 45:00One hundred out of ten recommend I give five stars for the qu for
- 45:06that comment and a commenting on the commentary or whatever, we have five stars
- 45:12exactly, So thank you all for your lovely comments. Yeah, and there's
- 45:17so many haters out there in general. We learned that like sixty percent of
- 45:23everything is going to be people at least that hate you. And it's like
- 45:27they don't like our swearing, they don't like our laughing, they don't not
- 45:30swear. Apparently not. So are we the only wants to say fuck?
- 45:34I can't believe that because I know plenty of people. Everybody, Yeah,
- 45:37everyone, the court, I mean, the chambers, the judges. Come
- 45:43on, we're all your dentist, does your doctors do Yeah? I mean,
- 45:46just on you. Do you swear too? You know it? My
- 45:52mother always said she never said the F word in her entire life. Now
- 45:54she's missing out. Yeah, well maybe she's a better person than me.
- 45:58I don't know, because sometimes the word is sometimes yeah, like what the
- 46:04fuck? That's a favorite of mine. Yeah. But anyway, Well,
- 46:07thank you all for watching and listening, and don't forget to hit the subscribe
- 46:12or follow button. Thank you True Crime Daily absolutely, thank you. Yeah,
- 46:15so names at least, well, if you would like more episodes of
- 46:30our podcast, we don't have additional video episodes, but if you'd like additional
- 46:35podcast episodes, you can hit our Patreon. It is t NT Crimes,
- 46:39slash t T Wait, I'm sorry patrion. Oh my god, I'm messing
- 46:45it all up. Patreon dot com, slash t and t crime. You
- 46:46can also get them on any podcast app. Yeah, but I'm talking about
- 46:52our extra episodes, our extra but you can listen to us too. We're
- 46:55on any podcast. We don't want we want you to. We want you
- 46:58to watch. Yeah, and you can go to your Apple app and you
- 47:02subscribe there. Yeah, you get extra episodes. We release a regular episode
- 47:06a week, and we release a Patreon or members only episode a week,
- 47:09so check us out there ab free, free up. There's a lot of
- 47:12goodies. Just check it out. Just check it out. If you're interested,
- 47:15go to Crimes Andconsequences dot com and see more. And we have merched
- 47:17there too. Wo I feel like something very cool because I hate Christmas is
- 47:22coming. Get it for your favorite fan and all proceeds go to the charity
- 47:28called Crimes and Consequences. So thank you all again for watching and listening,
- 47:34and until our next episode, don't kill each other. Bye bye