Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Negotiating Class/PAGA Settlement Releases: Maximizing the “Benefit of Your Bargain” and Other Tips for Successful Wage and Hour Settlements
Transcript
- 0:03I'm Andy Fields. I'm an attorney at the Jeannie
- 0:05Harrison Law Firm and chair of the BHBA's employment
- 0:08law section. I am delighted to introduce our
- 0:12speakers, Justin Marquez and Allison Ekstrom.
- 0:16Allison Ekstrom is a mediator with signature
- 0:18resolution. Allison brings over two decades of
- 0:21experience in employment and wage and hour litigation.
- 0:24With a proven track record of resolving complex
- 0:27disputes, she has represented clients across
- 0:29the retail, financial services, technology, transportation,
- 0:33aerospace, pharmaceuticals, property management,
- 0:37and hospitality industries. Allison has litigated
- 0:40more than 250 class and representative actions
- 0:43in federal and state courts, skillfully navigating
- 0:46claims involving mail -in rest breaks, regular
- 0:49rate of pay, wage statement compliance, rounding,
- 0:53off -the -clock work, expense reimbursements,
- 0:55and employee misclassification, among others.
- 0:58Justin Marquez brings over 15 years of distinguished
- 1:02experience in complex litigation to signature
- 1:04resolution. He has successfully litigated class
- 1:07actions and individual employment cases at the
- 1:10highest levels, including the Ninth Circuit Court
- 1:13of Appeals, the California Court of Appeals,
- 1:15and the federal district courts nationwide. a
- 1:18recognized leader in class action litigation.
- 1:21Justin is a proven track record of securing landmark
- 1:24victories in wage and hour, consumer protection,
- 1:26and data breach cases. And now let's get started.
- 1:34Thank you, Andy. And thank you, everyone, for
- 1:37joining us today. I hope that our presentation
- 1:41and our diverse backgrounds in the wage and hour
- 1:43space offers you some helpful tips in mediating
- 1:47your next class or Paga case. Justin is going
- 1:51to start off today's presentation talking about
- 1:55the best time to mediate a class and Paga lawsuit,
- 1:59the factors to consider in selecting a class
- 2:02Paga mediator, and how to best prepare for mediation.
- 2:06Then I'm going to spend some time talking about
- 2:08the scope of class and Paga mediations and in
- 2:11particular, how to ensure that the release that
- 2:13you negotiate as part of your settlement effectively.
- 2:18bars future litigation of the same claims and
- 2:21accurately reflects the party's agreement. Finally,
- 2:24we'll conclude with some post -mediation considerations
- 2:27and take your questions. And of course, if you
- 2:29have any questions along the way, feel free to
- 2:32drop them in the Q &A box and we can engage a
- 2:35discussion. Now I'd like to turn it over to Justin.
- 2:40Thank you, Alison. Hi, everyone. Thank you for
- 2:43joining us today. I'm going to get started by
- 2:47talking about when are the parties ready to mediate.
- 2:51A case can be ripe for mediation at three different
- 2:54stages. Early litigation, and what I mean by
- 2:58that is shortly after a complaint is filed and
- 3:00the parties complete an initial status conference,
- 3:03it makes sense because it's cost efficient for
- 3:06both sides. Let's face it, not every case is
- 3:09worth litigating towards class certification.
- 3:12Even if the plaintiff wins class hurt, it's not
- 3:14clear that a defendant can afford to pay full
- 3:17liability Especially when we're you know talking
- 3:19about millions of dollars at stake Defendant
- 3:24might also want to get rid of a case early if
- 3:26liabilities clear such as a rounding or a facially
- 3:31unlawful meal or rust break policy and Money
- 3:35saved in litigation can be spent for a settlement
- 3:38in order for early litigation to be Early mediation
- 3:43to be effective requires the willingness to exchange
- 3:46data and documents, even the bad stuff. So we're
- 3:50talking about time and payroll data, policies
- 3:53and practices during the relevant statutory period.
- 3:58In my experience, the biggest hurdle towards
- 4:01early mediation is the presence of an arbitration
- 4:04clause. Most defendants assume that an arbitration
- 4:08clause will be upheld. For you plaintiffs attorneys
- 4:11out there. Have you ever met a defense counsel
- 4:13that didn't like the arbitration agreement? Of
- 4:16course not. They probably drafted it So but we
- 4:20did fight those and when I was litigating I've
- 4:22had cases resolved on a class basis after we
- 4:25successfully challenge contract formation Such
- 4:29as the authenticity of an e -signature The upside
- 4:32is obviously huge because it opens up a class
- 4:35settlement instead of an individual or pocket
- 4:37only settlement The next stage is where there's
- 4:42been some written discovery, some depositions,
- 4:45and maybe even a fully briefed class certification
- 4:47motion. In these cases, you have to develop the
- 4:51evidence to see what are the real risk and value
- 4:53of the case. If the employer's not going to pony
- 4:57up big dollars early, it's worth it to do the
- 4:59work. And when you have cases that are more fully
- 5:02litigated, you have a better sense of the strengths
- 5:05and weaknesses of the case. You're likely to
- 5:08have taken depositions, HR depots, PMKs, written
- 5:13discovery. You know, you have an expert report
- 5:16ready typically. You know, some dispositive motions
- 5:19or rulings might have narrowed the scope of the
- 5:22claims. And, you know, after the litigation work
- 5:30has been completed and you're facing a class
- 5:33certification motion or you've filed one, Clause
- 5:36certification is not a slam dunk for either side.
- 5:40So the parties want to immediately avoid the
- 5:42risk of an adverse ruling. In my experience,
- 5:47litigation doesn't really help in driving the
- 5:49settlement value down. Usually, plaintiffs want
- 5:53more out of the case in order to get a return
- 5:57for the work they put in. And once a certain
- 6:01motion has been filed, you're already in the
- 6:03mindset of, being willing to roll the dice. So,
- 6:08you know, my preference is early mediation, especially
- 6:11because it makes sense, you know, cost -wise.
- 6:14Now, the final stage is where there's been a
- 6:17ruling on class certification or a trial on the
- 6:21merits. You know, at this point, the court has
- 6:23already made a decision and picked a winner and
- 6:26a loser. You know, one side is up against the
- 6:29wall, but even then, it makes sense to mediate
- 6:32a case. There's always the risk of De -certification
- 6:37it could happen anytime. I had a case against
- 6:40Bank of America that was litigated for five years.
- 6:43We Did summary judgment? I have one class certification.
- 6:49I beat a 23f Petition for permission to appeal
- 6:53and the Ninth Circuit yet elite a year later
- 6:56The case was de -certified. So when that does
- 7:00happen It's the worst feeling in the world for
- 7:02a plaintiff attorney, but in contrast, you know
- 7:05defense is jumping up and down because they have
- 7:08snatched victory from the jaws of defeat and
- 7:11You know appeals can take forever. I've worked
- 7:14on cases where the that were in appeals for ten
- 7:18years Harris versus Liberty mutual I worked on
- 7:21that that was in the Supreme Court in California
- 7:23Court of Appeals for ten years ABM Industries
- 7:27overtime cases that was in the Court of Appeal
- 7:29for five years. So you know, that is a big risk,
- 7:34you know, that consumes a lot of time, you know,
- 7:38you might be better off selling the case. So,
- 7:44Allison, do you have any take on this slide?
- 7:50No, I think you covered most of it. Okay. Let's
- 7:54move on. Do I see any questions? No, no questions.
- 7:58Okay. Okay, so you've decided to mediate. How
- 8:04do you choose the right mediator? Every mediator
- 8:07has a different style, you know, some are more
- 8:11evaluated by, you know, what I mean by evaluative
- 8:14is that they're opinionated. They're going to
- 8:16tell you what they think about your case and
- 8:19the likely outcomes if the case proceeds towards
- 8:21litigation. I think in order for this approach
- 8:24to be effective, the mediator has to be wage
- 8:28and hour savvy. It's got to be credible. On the
- 8:33other hand, you have facilitative mediators who
- 8:36are less opinionated, more neutral. You know,
- 8:40the approach is to help the parties find a path
- 8:41to resolution more organically. You know, that
- 8:44could be helpful when creative solutions will
- 8:47be needed for settlements, you know, and when
- 8:49counsel for the parties drive the negotiations.
- 8:54I don't think it's the best approach for these
- 8:58cases. I typically prefer someone who's evaluative
- 9:01and, you know, gets to the point and, you know,
- 9:04tells me the strengths and weaknesses of the
- 9:06case. And there's also the data -driven mediator
- 9:12who's very comfortable with the numbers. That
- 9:15person is good with claims that can be proven
- 9:17based on the record, such as meal period claims,
- 9:20regular rates. But usually that type is less
- 9:23effective with claims that rely on anecdotal
- 9:26evidence like off the clock and rest breaks.
- 9:29I wouldn't necessarily bring a bag check case
- 9:33before a mediator that prefers having data, having
- 9:36records to really hammer home liability. And
- 9:44there's also the corporate savvy mediator, someone
- 9:47who's good at communicating risk to a corporate
- 9:49representative. who's able to get them to come
- 9:52to terms with liability. That's useful when an
- 9:56employer is not based in California, who's unfamiliar
- 10:00with how it's done here, especially with these
- 10:02complex wage and hour laws, and the high penalties
- 10:05involved with Paga. So having someone who's more
- 10:09corporate savvy can really carry weight as far
- 10:14as messaging goes, if it's being delivered with
- 10:18someone who has you know, proven track record
- 10:23in this area and can get through with difficult
- 10:26clients on the defense side. Let's move on to
- 10:35the next slide. Let's talk about mediation preparedness.
- 10:47You know, overall it's important for everyone
- 10:49to be on the same page about the scope of the
- 10:52claims. Ask yourself, is the complaint specific
- 10:56enough to put the employer on notice about the
- 10:58claims in dispute? You know, most complaints
- 11:02are pretty generic. Same with the Paga letter.
- 11:08So, you know, you want to avoid surprises in
- 11:13a mediation. If you're a plaintiff attorney who
- 11:16spotted a new claim that's not specifically spelled
- 11:19out in the complaint, you might want to pick
- 11:21up the phone and tell defense counsel about it
- 11:25before the mediation. And another thing to consider
- 11:29is the impact of other pending, overlapping lawsuits.
- 11:35It's important for both sides to do their due
- 11:37diligence and understand whether other lawsuits
- 11:40have an effect on the mediation. Because the
- 11:43goal of mediation should be finality. You might
- 11:46not get that if there are other plaintiff firms
- 11:48involved in the case that might cause trouble
- 11:51with an objection down the line. So sometimes
- 11:55the global mediation might make sense. And as
- 12:01far as preparedness goes, these cases are typically
- 12:04data -driven. Timekeeping and payroll records
- 12:08are key. Getting them is important. and getting
- 12:12them on time is extremely important. In my experience,
- 12:16the number one reason why mediations get delayed
- 12:18or rescheduled is because of issues with getting
- 12:21the data on time so your expert can analyze it.
- 12:26It already takes several months to book a good
- 12:28mediator, so rescheduling means additional delay
- 12:31that you want to avoid typically. So to avoid
- 12:35this issue, the best practice is to have an early
- 12:39conversation about what type of format the data
- 12:42is in, paper or electronic. It's going to be
- 12:47more time consuming to pull paper records, which
- 12:49means you have to also talk about sampling. And
- 12:54in my experience, it's also hard to get the electronic
- 12:57records on time. Typically, I ask that they be
- 13:01produced a month before mediation, but more often
- 13:03than not, they're usually produced a week before.
- 13:06And that doesn't help anyone when that happens.
- 13:10You should consider scheduling regular calls
- 13:13to discuss the progress of the data. You know,
- 13:16have like, I don't know, calls every two weeks
- 13:19with counsel to discuss what's going on. You
- 13:21know, are you going to get this to me on time?
- 13:24That also helps build rapport with opposing counsel.
- 13:27So I found that approach, you know, pretty effective
- 13:30in my cases. But still, I still get it pretty
- 13:34late. But, you know, it's worth trying. But if
- 13:38you exchange data the last minute, it's easier
- 13:41to be vulnerable to surprises. For example, plaintiff
- 13:47might spot a regular rate claim by looking at
- 13:49the data, but it's not in the complaint. There's
- 13:52one case I resolved where there's like this big
- 13:55makeup pay claim. It was a seven figure claim
- 13:58that we only discovered after looking at the
- 14:00data. So there's more to the data than just work
- 14:04weeks. You have to really... Analyze it carefully,
- 14:07hire an expert. Make sure you have time with
- 14:10it to go through the different permutations.
- 14:15Another question is whether you're getting a
- 14:19full data set or a sample. I recommend producing
- 14:22the full data set if it's all electronic. Of
- 14:25course, it's not going to be realistic if it's
- 14:27paper, but electronics should be fine. I mean,
- 14:30it often takes longer to get a sample because
- 14:33there's usually some back and forth. about the
- 14:36appropriate sample size and the data has to be
- 14:39filtered. All that takes time. You know, a sample
- 14:42can also cause issues down the line. I've had
- 14:45cases where the defendant overestimated the work
- 14:49we count by 30%. You know, when that happens,
- 14:53defendants are just giving money away. You know,
- 14:56it's a different case if the work we count is
- 15:0030 % lower. I've also had cases where the workweek
- 15:03count was underestimated and resulting in the
- 15:06escalator clause kicking in. I mean, these problems
- 15:10can all be avoided if the full data set is provided.
- 15:15And it's also important to note that courts are
- 15:17also scrutinizing the sample size and whether
- 15:20it supports a Coolar analysis. If the sample
- 15:24is too small, your settlement might not get approved.
- 15:27This is a big issue in San Francisco. I've seen
- 15:29this happen in Orange County, LA. Another topic
- 15:37to talk about in preparing for ammunition is
- 15:40whether you should exchange briefs. I wonder
- 15:44if this is controversial and how many people
- 15:46actually do it. When I was litigating these cases,
- 15:50I didn't like exchanging briefs. I thought that
- 15:53I didn't learn anything from defendant's brief.
- 15:56And I was worried that if the case didn't settle,
- 15:59defendant might use my brief to prepare for a
- 16:02deposition. So I didn't really see that much
- 16:05upside when I was litigating these cases. But
- 16:08now as a mediator, I see the value in sharing
- 16:11briefs because it helps educate the other side
- 16:14on how you see the claims and it's a way to demonstrate
- 16:17your competency. All that is helpful towards
- 16:20settlement, I feel. Let's also talk about What
- 16:27should you put in your mediation brief? As a
- 16:30mediator, I like to see the expert report. I've
- 16:33been doing this a long time. I'm very comfortable
- 16:36with numbers and spreadsheets. I want to see
- 16:38the actual report because it usually has more
- 16:42details than a summary of findings in a mediation
- 16:44brief. I also want to see corroborating payroll
- 16:48and time records that back up your arguments.
- 16:50If you have a regular rate claim, Show me the
- 16:53records that back it up. Usually if, you know,
- 16:56defendant insists that they're doing a true up
- 16:58on a regular rate claim, you know, show me instances
- 17:01where they're wrong because it's hard to explain
- 17:03away something when there's an actual paper record
- 17:06of the problem. So, you know, exhibits with actual
- 17:10examples are very helpful. I also want to know
- 17:14about the judge in your case. I've litigated
- 17:16over a thousand of these cases all across California,
- 17:20most likely. I've been before your judge and
- 17:23I know how that judge is going to rule. You know,
- 17:25there are even some judges I've litigated class
- 17:28certification against. So I find that that helpful
- 17:32as well. But sometimes I don't see the judge's
- 17:35name being mentioned, the venue even. So that's
- 17:38frustrating. Allison, what's your what's your
- 17:42take on, you know, tips for mediation preparedness?
- 17:48I think hiring an expert is critical. I'm going
- 17:51to touch on this a little bit. But you can often
- 17:54find on both sides, the plaintiff identifies
- 17:57claims that they didn't know they had. Employers
- 18:00may identify claims that they don't necessarily
- 18:04want to bring to light, but want to release for
- 18:07it. So I definitely think there's value, even
- 18:11though there's expense associated with getting
- 18:13an expert. I tend to agree there are benefit
- 18:18pluses and minuses to sharing briefs. I think
- 18:22once there's been a lot of litigation, if you're
- 18:24doing a mediation, maybe post -certification
- 18:28or right before certification, there may be more
- 18:33value to exchanging the briefs, whereas if you're
- 18:35doing an early mediation where there's been a
- 18:37stay of the litigation and the parties are going
- 18:41to see if it's a possible there's a path to settlement,
- 18:44but there may be miles apart in terms of settlement
- 18:48value that they may want to keep the briefs confidential
- 18:51so they're not tipping their hat too much on
- 18:54what their defense is or their strong claims
- 18:56are. Yeah, great points. Great points. We want
- 19:04to try to keep this collaborative and interactive.
- 19:09Looking at questions, there aren't any. Let's
- 19:13move on to the next slide then. Hopefully there'll
- 19:15be more questions at the end as we talk about
- 19:19these issues that we all face, you know, very
- 19:23commonly. Okay, moving on. Financial disclosures
- 19:30and considerations. So many mediations stalled
- 19:33out because of financial inability to pay. You
- 19:37know, it's very frustrating to see that. Especially
- 19:40if you waited several months to get to mediation
- 19:42and you know The thinking is when when I experienced
- 19:47that is why didn't they tell me before you know,
- 19:50why? Maybe this meet mediation could have even
- 19:53be avoided if we if there are serious financial
- 19:57issues that they disclosed before And you know
- 20:02when you're put in that situation often you have
- 20:05to schedule another mediation just to get the
- 20:09financials. You know, when that happens, it feels
- 20:12like mediation is a waste of time. So bringing
- 20:18up financial issues at the last minute on the
- 20:21day of mediation is for sure going to kill any
- 20:24prospect of settling that day. So the best practice,
- 20:28I believe, is to bring up financial issues early
- 20:32so a party doesn't get blindsided. You know,
- 20:36I get it though. Sometimes it's a surprise to
- 20:39defense as well. You know, and by the time they
- 20:42find out it's too late to reschedule without
- 20:45losing on the mediation fee, it's also a tough
- 20:48spot to be in. But at the very least, you know,
- 20:51I ask you defense counsel to, you know, bring
- 20:54some documents at the mediation that helps with
- 20:57transparency. I'm talking about tax records.
- 21:01Profit and loss statements lines of credit, etc.
- 21:04You know the more You're willing to disclose
- 21:08at the mediation It adds to credibility like,
- 21:12you know, okay. Okay, your client is really broke.
- 21:15I get it. Okay, you're you're showing me the
- 21:17documents This this has happened to me so much
- 21:21that I've had a forensic accountant on call I
- 21:25You know, she's avail. I don't even have to Didn't
- 21:28even have to tell her that I'm meeting that day,
- 21:30but she's the type to to you know If I had a
- 21:35meeting in case and there's like financial issue,
- 21:38I just sent her an email. She's going to work
- 21:39on it and give me an answer that day. If you
- 21:43want her name, I could give it to you. Just shoot
- 21:45me an email. That's fine. She's worked with defendants
- 21:48as well. She's great. I've worked with her for
- 21:51a number of years now. So it happens so much
- 21:54that I have that person on call and it's worked
- 21:58out for me. I've been able to get cases resolved
- 22:01that way because I don't really I can't really
- 22:04understand these financial records. Usually it's
- 22:07over my head. Let's see. What's the next? I think
- 22:13I'm going to kick it over to Allison next to
- 22:16discuss the scope of mediation. But do you have
- 22:18any thoughts on that slide before we turn it
- 22:21over to you, Allison? No, I think you covered
- 22:24it. So let's talk. Now everybody's agreed to
- 22:29go to a mediation. And the question is, what's
- 22:32the mediation going to really be about? It sounds
- 22:34like an easy question. Let me get to the slide.
- 22:40But oftentimes, the mediation can morph into
- 22:43a completely different day than the parties otherwise
- 22:45would have expected. And we've touched on some
- 22:47of this. But I want to emphasize that you can
- 22:51come to mediation. And of course, everybody's
- 22:54prepared for the claims that are alleged in the
- 22:56complaint or in the Paga letter. It's not uncommon
- 23:00for claims to be raised for the first time at
- 23:03mediation by the plaintiff, right? As we mentioned,
- 23:05they look at the time records, they identify
- 23:07a rounding claim that they otherwise didn't see
- 23:10when they were preparing the complaint, and that
- 23:12becomes the center of the day. And conversely,
- 23:16the employers can come up with issues that they
- 23:19identify to. It might be a wage statement that's
- 23:22noncompliant that they didn't realize during
- 23:25the statutory period that maybe it's corrected.
- 23:28now, but they know that there's some vulnerability
- 23:31there. So they want that to be part of the day.
- 23:35And as the mediator, I try to do pre -mediation
- 23:39calls with both sides. And I really encourage
- 23:43the parties to, at a minimum, give the mediator
- 23:46a heads up that there are going to be some additional
- 23:50claims, theories of liability that they want
- 23:53to address during the mediation. So at least
- 23:56we have a heads up. to that. Also, the effect
- 24:01of a prior, this is a very common one. We go
- 24:05to mediation and then the employer raises the
- 24:09fact that there's a prior class or Paga settlement
- 24:11that either cuts off the timeframe, could potentially
- 24:15bar the litigation entirely. And so that's, the
- 24:19parties need to be on the same page in terms
- 24:21of what the mediation is about. And so, The last
- 24:27topic about the effective prior agreements raises
- 24:31a larger issue that I'm going to spend quite
- 24:33a bit of time on today, because hopefully you
- 24:36go to mediation and you reach an agreement to
- 24:39settle the case. And obviously, there's a release
- 24:42of claims that's going to be the main result
- 24:45of the case in exchange for the monetary settlement.
- 24:49And so understanding the breadth of a class and
- 24:51a PAGA release is critical. to making sure that
- 24:58both sides are getting the benefit of their bargain,
- 25:00I'd like to say. And as many of you know that
- 25:04do these types of cases, there's limits on what
- 25:07you can release as part of a class or PAGA settlement.
- 25:12Obviously, for example, you can't have settlement
- 25:14class members or aggrieved employees be bound
- 25:17by a 1542 release. There's limitations. and the
- 25:21case law has evolved over the years in terms
- 25:25of what they're really bound to and what they're
- 25:28really releasing. One of the seminal cases that
- 25:31talked about the limitations on settlement releases
- 25:34was the Vellakers versus ABM case. In that case,
- 25:38the plaintiff was a settlement class member in
- 25:42a prior overtime class action, didn't opt out,
- 25:46the case was dismissed, the plaintiff was bound
- 25:50by that release, but nevertheless brought a Paga
- 25:54-only case alleging the same overtime claim plus
- 25:58some new claims. And I think that that's the
- 26:00important emphasis in Lakers is there were some
- 26:02new meal and respirate claims and other derivative
- 26:05claims that were not at issue in the prior case.
- 26:09And so the court in the Lakers analyzed whether
- 26:12there was the effect of raised judicata from
- 26:14the prior settlement on the subsequent litigation.
- 26:18Ultimately, the court decided that even though
- 26:21the meal and respirate claims and some of the
- 26:24other claims were not part of the prior case,
- 26:27that the plaintiff nevertheless was barred from
- 26:31pursuing the subsequent litigation. It's noteworthy
- 26:34that the court's rationale in the Lakers, I think,
- 26:39was driven pretty heavily by California adopting
- 26:43the primary rights theory in terms of how they
- 26:45define causes of action. It's a pretty broad
- 26:48definition, which basically that a law a lawsuit
- 26:51that alleges illegal harm effectively includes
- 26:54all legal theories or different revenues available
- 26:57on that particular injury. So it's a little bit
- 26:59broader. And that was one of the drivers behind
- 27:03the Lakers decision. And so as a result of the
- 27:09Lakers, it's very common that, particularly on
- 27:12the defense side, will want express language
- 27:15in the settlement agreement that the release
- 27:18has raised Yudekata effect and that the release.
- 27:25Oftentimes, it will state that it releases claims
- 27:28that are alleged expressly in the complaint and
- 27:31claims that could have been brought based on
- 27:35the operative facts in the complaint. I guess
- 27:38the question then becomes, well, how much broader
- 27:41do you get in terms of claims that are not expressly
- 27:44alleged? And that's where we get into what's
- 27:47referred to as the identical factual predicate
- 27:50doctrine. it's a very fancy term, where the courts
- 27:54basically look at the scope of a release. And
- 27:59the courts will analyze the scope of a release
- 28:03in a variety of contexts. They can analyze it,
- 28:06as we've discussed, whether a prior case bars
- 28:10subsequent litigation. But many cases are also
- 28:13doing an identical factual predicate analysis
- 28:15in the settlement approval contexts. the identical
- 28:22factual predicate doctrine means is that a settlement
- 28:27may preclude a party from bringing a related
- 28:30claim in the future, even if that claim was not
- 28:32presented and might not have been presentable
- 28:34in the class action, but only where the release
- 28:37claim is based on the identical factual predicate
- 28:39as that underlying the claims in the settlement
- 28:42class action. Let me switch slides. The majority
- 28:53of the federal courts and the California state
- 28:55courts have adopted this doctrine, but it's a
- 28:58little hard to understand what the courts mean
- 29:00unless you get into the weeds of the cases. But
- 29:03basically, the majority of the courts define
- 29:06the identical factual predicate as a common nucleus
- 29:09of operative facts with the earlier class action.
- 29:13Same facts are at the core of both the unpleaded
- 29:16and pleaded claims. What the courts mean by that
- 29:20is had a judgment been based on an adjudication
- 29:22in the prior proceeding rather than a settlement
- 29:24that the unpleaded claims would have been issue
- 29:26precluded because they turned on the same facts.
- 29:31The Ninth Circuit, however, has obviously the
- 29:35Ninth Circuit, California always has to do something
- 29:36a little different. So there's like some nuances
- 29:38in the Ninth Circuit where. One Ninth Circuit
- 29:42decision distinguished the identical factual
- 29:45predicate analysis from the same transaction
- 29:48test that's used for collateral estoppel purposes,
- 29:52explaining that a claim can arise out of the
- 29:55same transaction, but not necessarily involve
- 29:57the same underlying facts. I do think that this
- 30:03nuance is important because particularly in the
- 30:06federal courts, the federal courts seem to be
- 30:08much stricter in in how they analyze the scope
- 30:14of a release under the identical factual predicate
- 30:18doctrine. The state courts, I believe because
- 30:24of the primary rights theory, tend to find broader
- 30:29releases than the federal courts. How close must
- 30:38the facts align? There, I think that the big
- 30:42takeaway from this is that there's no bright
- 30:43line rule, but I thought I would share some examples
- 30:46of some recent cases and how the courts in different
- 30:49procedural contexts apply the identical factual
- 30:53predicate analysis. And the reason why this discussion
- 30:57is important is, right, the parties want to make
- 31:00sure that the release that they ultimately can
- 31:03get approved by the court, you know. holds up
- 31:06particularly from the employer side that the
- 31:09release that they're getting what they paid for.
- 31:13The first example is this decision in Shine versus
- 31:16Williams -Sonoma. In that case, there was an
- 31:20earlier class action, I think it was called Morales
- 31:23versus Williams -Sonoma, involved a bunch of
- 31:26different meal and rest break canes, unpaid overtime
- 31:29and minimum wage claims. There was a later case
- 31:33that was filed, Shine, where a settlement class
- 31:38member from the first case brought a reporting
- 31:41time claim, same putative class, overlapping
- 31:44time frame. And the court concluded that because
- 31:47reporting time pay is a form of wages, a claim
- 31:50for reporting time pay could have been raised
- 31:52in the prior settled lawsuit and therefore was
- 31:54precluded in the Schein case. The court definitely,
- 31:57the analysis was rooted in the Vellaker's decision.
- 32:01And they reason that the fact that no claim for
- 32:04reporting time pay was alleged in the Morales
- 32:06case doesn't alter the determination that the
- 32:09same primary right, i .e. the seeking payment
- 32:13for unpaid wages was involved in both cases.
- 32:19Another decision, the Amaro versus Anaheim Arena
- 32:23Management LLC case, that was in a different
- 32:26procedural context in that it was a direct challenge
- 32:30to the scope of the release during the approval
- 32:32process. There were several pending overlapping
- 32:35class actions that were at issue and the court
- 32:38held in that case that the language that was
- 32:41used in the proposed release was far too broad.
- 32:46And in that case, the release was framed basically
- 32:49to say that it released claims alleged in the
- 32:51complaint, but also any claim that quote in any
- 32:54way related to the allegations in the complaint.
- 32:57So in that, in the court basically says, you
- 33:00know, that could extend, you know, they gave
- 33:02an example in that case that it could conceivably
- 33:04extend to a retaliation, like a retaliation case.
- 33:08by a plaintiff who complained about meal and
- 33:11rest break violations. And that obviously was
- 33:15not contemplated. That wasn't based on the factual
- 33:17predicate in the class action complaint. So I
- 33:21think the big takeaway from that is using language
- 33:24where you try to get the claims released and
- 33:29any claims that are related in any way to the
- 33:31complaint, that would be a no -no. Another recent
- 33:36case that came out this year, actually, Toronto
- 33:38versus Victoria Secret. This was a case where
- 33:42the employer moved for a judgment on the pleadings
- 33:46to bar a class action based on a prior settlement.
- 33:52This is an interesting case because it deals
- 33:56with off the clock. definitely an area of the
- 33:59law where you really want to be intentional on
- 34:01the scope of your release. But in that case,
- 34:03the first class action that was settled involved
- 34:07just general pre shift off the clockwork. And
- 34:11then the second case came. and had very specific
- 34:14allegations of unpaid wages for mandatory pre
- 34:17-shift COVID -19 screenings. And the court basically
- 34:21said, even though the release in the prior case
- 34:24didn't specifically reference COVID temperature
- 34:26checks, that the court said that it met the requirements
- 34:29for the identical factual predicate doctrine.
- 34:33So those are just a few. There was a couple of
- 34:35other ones that I had read. written an article
- 34:38about this recently on the preclusive effect
- 34:41of class releases. And there's a lot out there.
- 34:44As I said, there's no bright line rule. But I
- 34:47even found a case, I believe it was Chavez versus
- 34:50PVH Corp, interesting case in my 20 plus years
- 34:54of litigating class and Paga litigation. I think
- 35:00most lawyers on both sides would agree that when
- 35:03you get a release under labor code section 203
- 35:06for waiting time penalties or 226 for derivative
- 35:09claims, that those would encompass any factual
- 35:14predicate. Like once you have a class action
- 35:16that releases 203, you're sort of good to go.
- 35:19Well, this case actually, they denied final approval
- 35:22after the parties had confirmed that their intention
- 35:25was that the waiting time penalty extend not
- 35:28only to the very discreet payroll debit card
- 35:31claim in that case, but also all of the various
- 35:35claims that were in other pending class actions
- 35:38against the same employer for a meal and rest
- 35:40and unpaid wages and the court did not allow
- 35:43that. Again, the importance of understanding
- 35:49what your release is buying you. There was another
- 35:52one, for example, Nangle versus Penske logistics.
- 35:58In that case, I think it was also at the approval
- 36:01stage where there were prior claims for unpaid
- 36:06vacation wages, and the court held that there
- 36:11was not an identical factual predicate for purposes
- 36:14of a current unpaid wage claim. Again, no Brightline
- 36:21rule on this. Alison, I think we have a question.
- 36:25Oh, sure. Any dispute arising out of or in connection
- 36:29with? You see that by Cher Chia Wong? Let me
- 36:36see. The question is, is there a concern by only
- 36:38using the language, any dispute arising out of
- 36:40or in connection with? Any disputes or claims
- 36:44arising? I guess one could argue that this is
- 36:49maybe similar in any way, which is what the court
- 36:53took issue with in the Amaro. I think also it
- 36:58will matter whether you're in federal or state
- 37:00court. But I would say that that could potentially,
- 37:05I think your safest bet, it seems to be, right,
- 37:07if you say that it's limited to the operative
- 37:10pleading or claims that could have been based
- 37:13on the same operative facts in the complaint.
- 37:17So that one's an interesting one. I think that
- 37:19there could be some risk in that one. There's
- 37:25another one too about amending the complaint.
- 37:28Ah, yes, we are going to get to amending the
- 37:30complaint. And then if I didn't answer your question,
- 37:32I'm happy to do it. So some practical tips for
- 37:36drafting release language. As a mediator, I don't
- 37:39like to get involved in in drafting any of your
- 37:43settlement documents. But I do think that it
- 37:47does come into play at the mediations. And so
- 37:50obviously, you want to avoid over broad release
- 37:52language, like we discussed the Amaro case, that
- 37:55it really should be limited to the operative
- 37:57pleadings and claims that are based on the facts
- 37:59in the complaint. And be intentional when you're
- 38:03releasing under labor code statutes that can
- 38:07encompass a variety of factual predicates. I
- 38:09mean, the three that came to my mind immediately
- 38:11were expense reimbursement cases, wage statement
- 38:14cases, and then the sort of like kitchen sink
- 38:18unpaid wage claims. There were two decisions.
- 38:22I think they were federal court decisions recently
- 38:25that denied approval in a 2802 expense reimbursement
- 38:29case because the release purported to extend
- 38:34types of expenses that were not alleged, right?
- 38:37And so obviously the employer wants to get everything
- 38:40under the sun released under 2802. And at least
- 38:43in two courts, they said no. Like if it's a uniform
- 38:47case, you're releasing 2802 based on uniforms.
- 38:50That doesn't extend to mileage or cell phone.
- 38:54And so being intentional in what you're, you
- 38:58know, What you're trying to, if you want the
- 39:02broadest release under 2002, you need to craft
- 39:05language that makes it clear that it does involve
- 39:08any and all expense reimbursements and you may
- 39:11get that approved. You may not. So, and then
- 39:16obviously with off the clock, there's just so
- 39:19many different theories of off the clock. And
- 39:21so I think it will be important to make it clear.
- 39:25How broad can you go? Or are you really limiting
- 39:29it to a certain off -the -clock theory? Maybe
- 39:32the employer, for financial reasons, is paying
- 39:37a smaller amount, taking a bigger discount, but
- 39:41in exchange that they've agreed to just limit
- 39:43it to a certain specific type of off -the -clock
- 39:45theory of liability. The takeaway is to really
- 39:49be mindful of what's in the language in your
- 39:53releases. And then I'll get this is where we
- 39:59were going to talk a little bit about the amended
- 40:01pleading and I welcome Justin's thoughts on this
- 40:03too. So post mediation considerations, right?
- 40:07So you've reached a deal. Maybe you accepted
- 40:10a mediator's proposal or you have some agreement
- 40:13in principle term sheet and. Things to keep in
- 40:18mind when you're doing a more formal, long -form
- 40:21settlement agreement. Oftentimes, if new claims
- 40:24arise, which happens more times than not in my
- 40:26experience as a mediator, you're going to have
- 40:29to amend the pleading. My recommendation is to
- 40:33make that clear. I try to make that clear in
- 40:36my proposals if the mediation is going to end
- 40:39by way of a proposal that the parties are agreeing
- 40:42as part of the proposal that they will amend.
- 40:44The complaint and if necessary, send a Paga notice
- 40:47or amend an existing Paga notice to the LWDA
- 40:50to ensure that they're effectuating a full release
- 40:54of the claims. Other considerations. Many of
- 40:59the the courts in the state courts in California
- 41:02now have settlement checklists, so it's a good
- 41:05idea when you're putting together your long form
- 41:07or even an MOU. If you're in LA Superior Court,
- 41:12you know what's required. from the judges in
- 41:15CCW and making sure that your MOU or maybe your
- 41:18long form agreement follows, I think even some
- 41:21of the courts even have template agreements now.
- 41:24And so obviously keeping those in mind when you're
- 41:27trying to get your, that's gonna help you get
- 41:29things approved a lot quicker. And then confirmatory
- 41:34discovery, Justin was talking about the COOL
- 41:37-R obligations as part of preparing for mediation.
- 41:43Sometimes, again, issues, claims come up during
- 41:46the course of the day, and the employer wants
- 41:52a release for a certain claim. Plaintiff's side
- 41:54doesn't have all the information, but they don't
- 41:57want to stop the day. They want to keep going
- 41:59and hopefully reach a deal subject to some kind
- 42:02of confirmatory discovery. It may be, let's say,
- 42:05the employer only gave a certain amount of data
- 42:10through a certain time period. So they want confirmatory
- 42:12discovery about work weeks, pay periods through
- 42:16the class period or Paga period end date. That's
- 42:20very common. Sometimes you may need shift data
- 42:24confirmed. So bearing in mind that sometimes
- 42:28confirmatory discovery is something that needs
- 42:30to take place after the mediation in order to
- 42:32get the case approved. I don't know if Justin,
- 42:35you have any insights on that. Yeah, I'm ending
- 42:38the pleading or the or the pocket letter is usually
- 42:40not a big ask for the for the plaintiffs, you
- 42:43know, they're typically willing to do that. The
- 42:46only exception is where when when when an amendment
- 42:50can knock out a case that you weren't even thinking
- 42:54about at the mediation or you didn't even know
- 42:56about. And most plaintiffs want to avoid that
- 42:59because we all work in the same ecosystem. We
- 43:03see each other often. So it's usually bad practice
- 43:06to amend the complaint to kill a case you didn't
- 43:10know about until after you settled the case.
- 43:14most plaintiffs' attorneys want to avoid that.
- 43:17And it all goes back to having a discussion beforehand
- 43:20about the scope of the mediation, what claims
- 43:25are going to be released, and avoiding surprises.
- 43:31So I see a couple of questions. Justin, we can
- 43:34take one. Let's see. The first one said, how
- 43:37do you handle situations where a defendant says
- 43:40it has no money but refuses to share documents?
- 43:43So I would say, as a mediator, yeah, in my experience,
- 43:51play -to -flers don't just rest on a representation
- 43:54from the in -house council that they don't have
- 43:57the money to pay, right? I think that they definitely
- 44:01have to produce some documents. There's a variety
- 44:03of ways to do that, in my experience. Obviously,
- 44:07as a mediator, I'm not an expert per se in looking
- 44:10at profits and loss or audited financials. But
- 44:15Justin obviously has an expert. I know some employers
- 44:20are very sensitive about turning over their data.
- 44:24I remember years ago, I had a situation where
- 44:27the client gave me the financial information,
- 44:32I drove it over to plaintiff's counsel's office.
- 44:34This is obviously way back in the day before
- 44:36we did everything via Zoom. And I sat in the
- 44:39room with the expert retained by the plaintiff
- 44:43who looked at the documents, and then I took
- 44:45those documents back. So it just depends on...
- 44:50But I don't see how you get and how you... um
- 44:55meet your cool our obligations as a plaintiff's
- 44:57counsel without looking at some documents i don't
- 45:00know justin your thoughts on that yeah i agree
- 45:02i mean if you're not willing to show documents
- 45:04uh thinking as you must be hiding something so
- 45:08you know again the best practice is transparency
- 45:11be a straight shooter if you want to get a deal
- 45:14done Yeah, and then there's another question
- 45:18that I think sort of dovetails on that about
- 45:20how you would deal with Section 558 .1 issues
- 45:23where a company is asserting an inability to
- 45:25pay 558 .1 in terms of whether individual officers
- 45:29or directors could be also held liable. I think,
- 45:34and Justin, welcome your thoughts on this. I
- 45:37think it, one, depends on whether the individuals
- 45:40are named in the lawsuit. I think if they are,
- 45:44then and they could potentially be on the hook,
- 45:46they may need to demonstrate their inability
- 45:50to pay just like the corporation would. Yeah,
- 45:54I mean, when I was doing this case is typically
- 45:56I didn't name the owner. So, you know, five,
- 46:01five, eight point one, you know, bringing that
- 46:03up is kind of like the nuclear option that you
- 46:06don't want to usually try to avoid because it's
- 46:09going to piss off the other side, you know, being
- 46:12sued personally. As opposed to just a company,
- 46:16but you know, you got it. You got to deal with
- 46:19it You got to take the initiative on that. You
- 46:21got to look at the assets before the mediation
- 46:24happens Yeah, if you have any inkling that there
- 46:27could be financial inability to pay issues, you
- 46:30know, typically the owner is not gonna You know
- 46:33give give that voluntarily, but there are ways
- 46:36to look at it. You could you know, do a property
- 46:38search you can investigate The company and look
- 46:42up who owns the company and search if that person
- 46:45owns other companies. So that's one way to tackle
- 46:48it You know, typically I I did ask to see personal
- 46:53tax returns as well If they brought that up and
- 46:57you know, sometimes they provided and you know,
- 47:00typically when they did provide it that person
- 47:02is broke, you know usually Also, in my experience,
- 47:09when that happens, you're talking about like
- 47:12a small business, family owned, the company,
- 47:15you know, probably wants to keep it alive so
- 47:18their children can work there. So it's another
- 47:21pressure point to emphasize when you're faced
- 47:24with that situation, I think. OK, there's another
- 47:31question. Do you recommend that the settlement
- 47:33ever include a requirement that the plaintiff
- 47:36amend the complaint to include all the claims,
- 47:38or is this doctrine enough? So I would not rest
- 47:43on the doctrine, especially because the case
- 47:47law is sort of all over the place. And I think
- 47:51it depends, as I said, if you're in federal court
- 47:53or state court or who your judge is. And so I
- 47:57think. I think it is important that if you have
- 48:04a new off -the -clock theory that's different
- 48:07from the off -the -clock theory that was raising
- 48:11the complaint, and you want to make sure that
- 48:13that theory is part of the release, I would not
- 48:16rest on just pre -shift off -the -clock work.
- 48:20I think that that case, the Toronto case in the
- 48:24Eastern District, easily could have gone differently.
- 48:27in the northern district, for example. So I think
- 48:33you're best served to amend the complaint as
- 48:38agreed to by the parties. I would think that
- 48:39the defendant in particular would want the complaint
- 48:42amended to make sure that the labor code sections
- 48:45are identified and there's no question about
- 48:48what's part of the release. Let's see. OK. Another
- 48:55one. While not drafting releases for obvious
- 48:58reasons, do you manage the drafting of the releases?
- 49:00And if so, does this occur generally after the
- 49:03mediation or before it concludes on the day of
- 49:05the mediation? So this is a great question. I
- 49:09have definitely been involved the day of the
- 49:13mediation. If the parties are working on an MOU,
- 49:17for example, you know. I will definitely participate
- 49:21in those discussions. I've done it where I'm
- 49:24in the same room with the two lawyers for both
- 49:27sides, and we hammer out just to make sure that
- 49:30we're all on the same page. I don't typically,
- 49:32I have never and probably would not want to get
- 49:37involved, for example, with the parties sending
- 49:39me a draft of the release after mediation and
- 49:42asking, I feel like that's... getting out of
- 49:46my role as a mediator and getting back into my
- 49:48role as a lawyer. So I don't know, Justin, your
- 49:51thoughts on that. I feel like the release is
- 49:55less of an issue now because of the model settlement
- 49:58agreement in L .A. Superior Court. And a lot
- 50:01of people just default to that. And, you know,
- 50:04prior to that, we each had our own settlement
- 50:07agreements that we preferred. And some were more
- 50:11specific than others. So. I wonder if it's going
- 50:17to be a problem if people rely on the model settlement
- 50:21agreement in LA Superior Court, but it's not
- 50:24as tight as the ones I've seen in the past where
- 50:27the attorneys have drafted it before. That could
- 50:31be an issue down the line. Typically, I didn't
- 50:41push back that hard on the release unless they're
- 50:47trying to include a new claim that wasn't even
- 50:51in the complaint or part of the conversation
- 50:53during mediation. I get that employers want to
- 50:58have finality, especially with mail period claims
- 51:00off the clock, 2802. Um, my approach was more
- 51:04pragmatic, but you know, not everyone is like
- 51:07that. And if you're dealing with someone who's
- 51:09more strict about that, you know, better to have
- 51:12that, have an upfront conversation about that,
- 51:14or else you're going to be bogged down during
- 51:17the whole mediation, just fighting over that.
- 51:19And, you know, that's, that's not conducive towards
- 51:21settlement in my mind. Yeah, I would agree. Um,
- 51:28another Actually, before we go into this other
- 51:32question, another point that I didn't have in
- 51:34the bullet for post -mediation consideration
- 51:37is not just amending the complaint or Paga letter
- 51:43to add a claim, but there will be times, and
- 51:45this often happens, where you have a plaintiff
- 51:50who um, worked for a temporary staffing agency.
- 51:53So you have a client employer and a temporary
- 51:55staffing agency, um, involved in the class or
- 51:58product case. Um, sometimes they worked for multiple
- 52:02staffing agencies, um, and some are, none of
- 52:06them might be actually named in the, in the complaint.
- 52:09Um, but you learn during the course of either
- 52:11discovery or, you know, um, informal discovery
- 52:14for an early mediation that the plaintiff either
- 52:18work for the entire period of time for a staffing
- 52:20company or a portion of the time. And so it's
- 52:25imperative that the parties are on the same page
- 52:28about whether and which additional defendants
- 52:32need to be added. I would not recommend just
- 52:36resting on language that includes the defendant
- 52:40and any of their joint employers, et cetera.
- 52:44And I would think the staffing agencies would
- 52:45want want them to either be expressly named or
- 52:49in added as a defendant. So there's not just
- 52:52considerations for amending the pleadings for
- 52:54claims or causes of action, but also parties.
- 53:03OK. We missed one. How often do alter ego piercing
- 53:09the veil issues become primary issues in the
- 53:11mediation at collectibility? I think you probably
- 53:18need to litigate that issue. If the employer
- 53:21is bringing up alter ego or piercing the corporate
- 53:24veil, then they typically want to limit the class.
- 53:28So it's an issue that you have to get in front
- 53:30of before the mediation or else the scope of
- 53:35the class is not going to be to your liking on
- 53:39the plaintiff's side. So when I've been put in
- 53:43that situation, typically, I had a beat emotion
- 53:47to dismiss in order to get those other entities
- 53:50involved. You have to do that in order for the
- 53:56parties to get serious about encompassing all
- 53:58corporate entities. So usually there is litigation
- 54:01involved. But on the other hand, you could have
- 54:06an employer who's very flexible and just wants
- 54:08to get the biggest release possible. But in my
- 54:13experience, they typically want a discount if
- 54:16there are like some serious, you know, alter
- 54:20ego issues and piercing corporate bail. So it's
- 54:23probably something that you should litigate or,
- 54:25you know, hammer home before the mediation starts
- 54:29that, hey, look, you know, I got some great ways
- 54:32to pierce corporate bail or argue, join employer,
- 54:35whatever, you know, you got to include everything
- 54:38for this mediation to be successful. OK. Let's
- 54:47see. What do you recommend defense counsel do
- 54:51when plaintiff's counsel refuses to share data
- 54:53supporting the claims, but merely gives summary
- 54:56of pay periods, percent violations, et cetera?
- 55:01I hope I understand this question correctly.
- 55:03And if I don't, happy to chat offline about this.
- 55:08I usually see the issue more when defend. is
- 55:12the defendants are not giving the plaintiffs
- 55:13the data that they need. But yeah, I mean, so
- 55:21if you both have data, like you have an exchange
- 55:24of data, I think that there should be, I wanna
- 55:31make sure, given summary of pay periods, I would
- 55:33think that the defendant would know the pay periods
- 55:38based on their own analysis because they have,
- 55:41they have access to that information. If your
- 55:44question is, how did the plaintiffs arrive at
- 55:47their figures? I think that that is absolutely
- 55:49a valid question that needs to be like, for example,
- 55:54if you guys have a different work week count
- 55:56or a different pay period count, you definitely
- 56:01need to again, I encourage. talking both sides,
- 56:06even before the mediation, at the mediation,
- 56:09as a mediator, I often will get the lawyers in
- 56:13a room to hammer it out, because it is not uncommon,
- 56:16for example, where the defendant gives a sampling
- 56:19of time and payroll data, and maybe they give
- 56:2310%, right, to the plaintiff. So the plaintiff
- 56:26hires an expert, they analyze 10%. The client,
- 56:30the employer, however, looks at 100%. right?
- 56:33So they're just by virtue of the plaintiff having
- 56:36to extrapolate, right? They're going to have
- 56:38different workweek pay period, you know, violation
- 56:41rate numbers. So sometimes That can be clarified
- 56:45through, you know, as a mediator, I often will
- 56:48see both sides numbers. And so I can get information.
- 56:53And of course, with approval to share that with
- 56:55the other side, get an understanding of where's
- 56:57the disconnect. Sometimes the disconnect in terms
- 57:00of violation rates is rooted in the party's respective
- 57:04theories of liability. A very, very common one,
- 57:07for example, is in meal break cases. The employer
- 57:12will often analyze the data, excluding meals
- 57:17that start at 5 .0 as violations, where the plaintiff
- 57:23side will deem those violations. And so you will
- 57:26see violation rates that are drastically different.
- 57:28You'll see one side shows 15 % violation rate
- 57:31and the other side shows 55 % violation rate.
- 57:34And you start to figure out during the course
- 57:36of the day that that's because of how they're
- 57:38defining what constitutes a meal break violation.
- 57:44So I hope I answered your question. One, you
- 57:47definitely have to make sure that both sides
- 57:48have the information they need to analyze data.
- 57:53And if you have a difference in how the data
- 57:57was analyzed or the results, again, I think you're
- 58:01going to need to have that understanding. And
- 58:03if you need to use the mediator to help, I'm
- 58:07always happy to get involved in making sure everybody's
- 58:09on the same page. Yeah, usually you're not going
- 58:14to have issues working off the same data set,
- 58:17but usually the issues evolve from different
- 58:21interpretations of what's in a violation. Like
- 58:24Allison brought up that meal period example where
- 58:27plaintiff's attorneys push for five hours being
- 58:31a violation, whereas defense does 459. That's
- 58:36common. I've also seen issues where plaintiffs'
- 58:41attorneys had a different way of calculating
- 58:43the regular rate of pay, you know, that causing
- 58:46a problem. So, you know, you really have to drill
- 58:48that down and what's causing the discrepancy
- 58:50and talk about it in order to have an effective
- 58:53negotiation. And, you know, sometimes plaintiffs'
- 58:57attorneys, they only analyze a fraction of the
- 59:01sample as opposed to the whole sample that they
- 59:03were provided. So that's another good thing to
- 59:05flag if you're a defense, you know, if they're
- 59:08doing that. That's another reason why the numbers
- 59:11could be different. And there's actually a question,
- 59:14Justin, on that. There's two more questions.
- 59:16One of them is about sampling. And what percentage
- 59:19of sampling do you see that the courts don't
- 59:21feel is sufficient? I'll answer from my viewpoint,
- 59:27Justin. I welcome your thoughts, too. I mean,
- 59:29I'm by no means an expert. I can't necessarily
- 59:32state what's statistically significant. But in
- 59:34my experience, the larger the class, thousand
- 59:39plus, you can get away with a smaller sampling.
- 59:43If you have a 5 ,000 member class, giving a 10
- 59:47% sampling oftentimes is considered statistically
- 59:51significant. If you have a 100 % class, again,
- 59:55I'm not a damages expert, but you may have a
- 59:59tougher time with only a 10 % sampling. You may
- 1:00:03need a 50 % sampling. And some judges are more
- 1:00:08finicky about that than others. I don't know,
- 1:00:12Justin, in your experience, when you were - Yeah,
- 1:00:15I agree with that. Generally, the bigger the
- 1:00:17population, the smaller the sample you need to
- 1:00:21get a representative sample. And what I've done
- 1:00:24when confronted with this issue is give the judge
- 1:00:28a number as far as - the margin of error for
- 1:00:32the sample we use. And usually that's enough.
- 1:00:36Usually the error rate is small in the cases
- 1:00:38I've worked on. OK, the last question. There's
- 1:00:50two more questions. I'm happy to stay longer
- 1:00:52too, by the way. How do you approach mediations
- 1:00:54for cases in which there are interveners and
- 1:00:56or related or consolidated cases? Do you invite
- 1:00:59everybody to the mediation and attempt to reach
- 1:01:01a global? Do you exclude them? So this is a challenging
- 1:01:08area to answer the question. I would say my role
- 1:01:11as a mediator is not to get involved in that.
- 1:01:14My recommendations is I always think global mediations
- 1:01:18make the most sense. And I do think that there
- 1:01:24should be full transparency and even the procedural
- 1:01:29rules in the courts, both federal and state court,
- 1:01:32have requirements in terms of notices of related
- 1:01:34cases in state court, notice of penance of actions
- 1:01:37in federal court. make sure that everybody is
- 1:01:42on the same page about what's out there in terms
- 1:01:45of the pending cases. So this gets really nuanced,
- 1:01:50and there may be reasons why or not to invite
- 1:01:52people. So generally, as a mediator, I stay out
- 1:01:55of that and let counsel decide which makes most
- 1:02:02sense. But obviously, global peace for everybody
- 1:02:06is the way to go. And then there's one more.
- 1:02:12OK. Apologies in advance for the basic question,
- 1:02:15new to this field. Welcome to this field. What
- 1:02:17if you have a frivolous suit that was settled
- 1:02:20before extensive litigation and even before reaching
- 1:02:23mediation, but the complaint was broad and ambiguous,
- 1:02:25obviously including causes of action under PAGA?
- 1:02:28What are best practices for negotiating that
- 1:02:31type of release? Let me let. Justin, what are
- 1:02:38your... I need to review this fact pattern a
- 1:02:41little closer. Okay. I guess my first question
- 1:02:47is why was the original suit that was settled
- 1:02:51frivolous? And I guess we might have to take
- 1:02:58this offline because I might need a little bit
- 1:03:00more information, but I would need to have an
- 1:03:01understanding of whether the prior suit was settled
- 1:03:03on a class or a... Paga basis, what was the,
- 1:03:10I'm not sure I can answer this question without
- 1:03:11more information. Well, if you settle the case
- 1:03:14just on an individual basis, the Paga could still
- 1:03:17survive, but the class won't. So if you want
- 1:03:21to get rid of the Paga, you probably have to
- 1:03:27devote some money towards the Paga release. you
- 1:03:32got to involve the lwda as well because those
- 1:03:35have to be approved right or disclosed yeah so
- 1:03:41if it was a class or paga i would and if it was
- 1:03:46truly frivolous or there were problems with that
- 1:03:48i would think that the court wouldn't approve
- 1:03:52it but if it was you know approved for some reason
- 1:03:55um yeah Why don't you email me and Justin and
- 1:04:02we can address that one. I don't want to misinterpret
- 1:04:06the... Oh, I think we're... Are we done? All
- 1:04:15right. Allison and Justin, thank you. Oh, last
- 1:04:18question? Feel free to email us questions. We're
- 1:04:23willing to help out. Allison and Justin, thank
- 1:04:28you both so much for your time today. We appreciate
- 1:04:30you speaking on this topic and I hope our members
- 1:04:32enjoy the rest of their afternoon. Thank you.
- 1:04:36Thank you.