Latest / First Encounter—A Historical Romance Podcast / S1 E21—Non-toxic Masculinity in Historical Romance with Eliza MacArthur
Transcript
- Andie James: Hello everyone, and welcome to First Encounter. My name is Andie James. I am a historical romance enthusiast and author. And I'm really excited to be joined today by Eliza MacArthur, who has written a Fabulous historical romance that I hope you've all read called Hold Fast and the sequel's coming soon. We're gonna talk about it. I'm so excited about that. Yay. So Eliza, thank you for joining me today and being willing to chat historical romance and all the goodness. Eliza: Thank you for having me, Andie. I scream at it, scream about it at every opportunity. So it's nice to have another platform to do that screaming. 'cause my family is tired of it. Andie James: yes. No. It's it's the best. I mean, mainstream Eliza: It's the best. Andie James: doesn't love us at the moment, but we know we're great. So Mainstream is wrong. Eliza: Mainstream's wrong. As I always say, you're entitled to your wrong opinion. I say it all the time. I'm like, you're allowed to have it. You're not right though. So Andie James: Yeah, yeah. I there I'm gonna get the podcast name wrong and I'm gonna feel bad about it. but there's another romance podcast that just this week released an episode with Elizabeth Everett and I can't remember exactly the title is something about like historical romance isn't dead, publishing just isn't finding their audience or something like that. And I was like, Yes, thank you. Thank you. Yeah, Elizabeth's great. Eliza: yeah, it's like it's not looking at it or something. I saw this. Yeah, I saw this. Yeah. No. It is not dead. It's not dead. Andie James: It is not dead. It's okay. I don't know. Eliza: Given the fact proof of this is the fact that the last three big events I've been to, I write paranormal, like contemporary paranormal, and I write historical. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: I have sold out of my of Hold Fast at every single event that I have been at. Andie James: Yeah, that makes me happy Eliza: And I haven't sold out Andie James: to hear. Eliza: every time of my contemporaries. So it's like, no, no, no. But it's like, right, right. And I always tell people, Andie James: that makes me sad that you didn't sell out your contemporaries, but it makes me happy of what that means for Eliza: I'm like, your budget is your budget. the economy is the economy. If you can only buy one book, that's great. I'm glad you chose to spend your one book money on my books. But I I think that's really an interesting. I think it's the mark, when I first started publishing. Holdfast was a much harder sell and the paranormals Andie James: Hm. Eliza: went. And Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: then I think since then, since publishing has completely divested from historical, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: what's been really interesting to me is that like readers have not, because Holdfast is consistently my top seller. so publishers, you're Andie James: Well, that's fantastic. So there you go. Eliza: wrong. You're wrong. Andie James: Yeah, they'll come back to us at some point. Eliza: They will Andie James: I think there's I mean, I'm certainly not the first person to say this, and I've probably even said this on the podcast before. But like, I think people that like romantasy there's something obviously to find in historical. 'cause so many of the romantasy like, yes, it's like a made up world, but it's a made up world that resembles a lot Eliza: Right, for sure. Andie James: of the older school and castles and the whole thing. I don't know. Eliza: For sure, for sure. Andie James: and then I I'm like people who love dark romance, I'm like, read an old school historical. Like, yeah. Eliza: my god, Joanna Lindsay, what's the you know the one the that everyone's been talking about lately? The I just downloaded it, what is it? Andie James: Yes. yeah, I can't think of it right now, but I know exactly what you're talking about. Eliza: Girl, it's the darkest thing prisoner of my desire. That's the one. Darkest Andie James: Yeah, yeah. Eliza: darkest thing I read in the really Andie James: Yeah. I'm just like, it's it exists for you. So yes, yes. Eliza: Correct. Correct. I think, yeah, I I read a lot of mafia. Andie James: Okay. Eliza: I well, 'cause okay, so I have I have ADHD for those who haven't heard me scream about it, which but I also am a big believer in my MFA I had a mentor who talked to me about raccoon brain, where she was like, You have to be really careful when you're writing about what you're reading. Andie James: Yes, yes. Eliza: Because there's this paradox where you wanna be reading what you write because it makes you a better writer. Andie James: Right. Right. Eliza: Right? Makes sense. You don't want to be reading what you write while you write because it's real Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: hard for your brain to distinguish a good idea from your good idea. And so, like, I am Andie James: Right. Yeah. Eliza: paranoid of it. I like overcorrect. I'm like, no, I can't read anything while I'm drafting. So I'm like, I'm gonna read Mafia. Andie James: Can't read any of it. Yeah. Eliza: and one of the things that I love about mafia is how it's like dark romance but bonkers. You know what I mean? Like, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: and I think that one of the things I love about historical romance is there is a certain level of bonkers in a lot of them that we Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: just just kind of like like I always think Virginia Henley's A Year and a Day when Waren is gravely injured and his wife breastfeeds him back to health and we're all just like, yeah, no, sure. That would yep, mm-hmm. And Andie James: Sure. Eliza: then like Tessa Dare When a Scott Ties the Knot, just like the lobsters. There's just lobs, like, just the lobsters. They've escaped. We have to leave a party Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yep. Yeah. when Eliza: because the lobsters got out. Like, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: I just I I don't know. I love. There's just this contract with reader that like in historical that you don't always get in contemporary. Like contempt in contemporary, I feel like you have to Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: explain everything away. Whereas historical, because it's the OG, every like reader is just kind of like, okay, I'll play ball. Like, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: I'll play ball. Like, you're gonna have to land this plane, but like, I'll get on, you know, and I I love that. And I think romantasy readers. Andie James: Hey. Eliza: They're missing out 'cause I don't know. I feel like historical romance walked so that romantasy could run, you know. Andie James: It's true, it's true. And now they're they're doing a marathon. and Eliza: I know. Andie James: but you know, the thing is, I do have faith. I do feel like and I mean part of this is probably just because, you know, your algorithm reinforces what you like and shows you those things. Eliza: Right. Right. Andie James: But I do feel like I'm seeing more people being chatty about historicals. Eliza: Mm mm. Yes. Andie James: on threads. And again it could be just 'cause it's feeding me that. But Eliza: Yes. Andie James: I don't know. I I feel like a revival is like on the way. It's on the way. I'd I yeah. Eliza: It's coming. It's coming. Yeah, I just like I Again, I learned a lot in my MFA program. Are they necessary? No. No. But I had another mentor who told me she was like, you need to write what you love. Don't worry about the market. Don't worry about Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yes. Eliza: it. Don't worry about the court of public opinion. Write what you love because people will be able to tell the difference between something you wrote because you love it and something you wrote because you're like, this is gonna sell. And I Andie James: Yeah, I believe that. Eliza: I I think I believe that, but I also think that like If I love to write it, invariably Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: someone's gonna love to read it. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: And I think that it is gonna have a comeback because I think people are gonna realize that it's like, wow, like I haven't read a historical in forever, but I cut my teeth on all my mom's old Julie Garwood books, you know, in the 90s and early aughts. And it's like that was a romp. I would love a romp. I feel like we're Andie James: It was it was, yeah. Eliza: we're like we're getting there. We're gonna go someplace. Andie James: We're getting there. Well, and I have more hope after this week. So we're we're recording this on Saturday the seventh. And you guys, Eliza: It has been such a big week. Andie James: I, you know, I try not to curse a lot on here. I don't care if people do, but I just gotta say, it's been a good fucking week. Okay. Like, it Eliza: It's been a great fucking week. Andie James: has been a good week. And I like I'm still reeling. Like, I don't know what this feeling is. Feeling like there's good news. What? Eliza: God. No, I know. I know. I know. It's like the opposite of loathing from wicked. You know, like, what is this feeling so sudden and new? It's like, I think for our battered little millennial hearts, it's everybody's just like, wait, what? Is this hope? I what? Andie James: But I know. What is this feeling? I know. Yeah. I know. We're just like I know. I know. I saw like a I don't I don't know what you call a thread, like a thread, I guess, but like I also would say it's a tweet, but it's not. I know. So I'm like, I saw this tweet, but I saw Eliza: Always do the same thing. Thank you. I'm always like, I read this tweet and Carter's my husband's like, You're not on Twitter. Andie James: it on threads, because I'm definitely not on X. And I hate even calling it that. I know. Yeah. Eliza: I'm not on that no. I don't even call it that. I still call it Twitter. It's like my civil disobedience. I'm like Andie James: but one was exactly what you just sang. They it said, what is this feeling so sudden and blue? And I was like, yes. but I Eliza: Mm. Andie James: saw this other one where they're like, I don't know how to be a millennial and an unprecedented event is a good thing. And I was like, yes, yeah, yeah, yeah. Eliza: I know, right. It's like did we finally get a good one? Andie James: But I feel like sorry, it's rein it back into my point. Eliza: I'm here for it. I'm here. Andie James: you know, again, going back to this podcast that I just listened to with Elizabeth Everett, I will link that in the show notes because I don't remember the name Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: of the podcast right now and I feel bad. I want to credit them. but they were talking about how you know Elizabeth was positing that some of the reason people younger people are saying they're not reading historicals. They're like, I don't want to learn anything. I don't you know, it's like too much effort, right? And I just I'm hoping that this week is the start of kind of a pushback against the anti intellectualism. And maybe we'll want to re embrace again, Eliza: Girl. Andie James: you know, some of like, actually reading about things that matter. Like Eliza: Right. I also think too though that there's as with everything, there's a spectrum. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: if you're gonna read a Beverly Jenkins, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: you best have your notebook. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: Because you're going to school. you're Andie James: Yes. Eliza: gonna read a book, it's gonna sweep you up, but you are going to learn things, you are going to confront things. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: You're probably gonna find a random historical rabbit hole that you're like, wow, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: I didn't know about that. Beverly Jenkins, I I f you know, like we worship Bev. Like Queen Bev. But a Andie James: Yes. Yes. And I just gotta say, we get to meet her in January. And I cannot Yeah, we're both going to Swoons Eliza: I know I Andie James: Fest, everyone. And Beverly Jenkins is gonna be there. Eliza: but I think there's other historicals that Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: are not as labor intensive. And then there's everyone in the middle, and it's like I think Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Eliza: but I also think too th this is now gonna be a rant about generative AI. Sorry. Andie James: God, please, please rant away. Eliza: I think when we say like I don't want to work that hard. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: They're working hard, using your brain, is a good thing. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: To your point about kind of this like anti-intellectualism, like I I'm not saying the you know, like I read read your read your fluffy things that are fun and they don't require brain work, but also like it's like not everything Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: has to be kale. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: But you also can't just eat nerds your whole life. You know what I mean? Like you you gotta eat a vegetable. Andie James: Yeah. Right. Eliza: Like you gotta do it. and I think that like like Queen Bev is kale. She is fibrous and so nutritious. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: you gotta work. And I think that she knows that and it's like you should work. Like you should. Andie James: You should. Yeah. Eliza: And I like I'm reading Alice Coldbreath right now. I don't know if you've read Andie James: I've not read her yet, but everyone, I need to. I feel like I'm like saving things for the podcast now because there's all these people. I I know. I know. Eliza: If you ever want me to come and just scream about Alice Coldbreath, I will. It'll be unintelligible. It'll just be me screeching for an hour. Andie James: Okay. We'll have you back for one of our book deep dives and we'll talk out. Okay. Okay. Eliza: Start with her prize fighter series. but she also has a series that I'm in right now called The Brides of Karadoc, which to your point about romantasy, Karadoc does not exist. It's loosely based, very clearly, it's medieval England. You know what I mean? Andie James: Yes. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: very clearly. But because it doesn't exist as a place, she's able to be like, hmm. I don't have to worry about the church. I don't have to worry about ecclesiastical involvement. I don't have to worry about any of this. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Like, and I love that. 'Cause neither I Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: I don't have to worry about it either then. reader doesn't have to worry about it. And so Andie James: Yeah, it's great. It's great. Eliza: I don't know. Anyways, yeah, to your point, I think you should work. It's good to learn Andie James: You should. Eliza: things. Andie James: You should. I love it. I love it. And I do think there is there is a spectrum. I I would say my own books the the s it it's more setting for me and obviously informs plot. because how can it not? yeah, Eliza: the setting is a character in historicals. Andie James: it is. It is. It is. But like, you know, I I'm not necessarily writing at the level of like My friend Louise Mayberry, who, you know, writes these very like detailed historical like I'm not doing that necessarily. Eliza: Yeah. Right. Andie James: There's a spectrum, like you said. So I think and there's Eliza: For sure. Andie James: something for everyone. But the thing that I always can't get over, I guess maybe is it is a romance. You know it's gonna have a happy ending. So you know you're gonna enjoy the ride. So Eliza: Yes. Yeah. Andie James: just dive in and enjoy it. And if you have to look up a word or two, like it's okay. Eliza: No knows. yeah. Andie James: dear. Yeah. Expand. Yes. I know. but I'm going way off here. Sorry. So you mentioned that you started reading like your mom's Julie Garwood's back in the day. So is this kind of something Eliza: Yes. Andie James: you've always been reading along the way? Eliza: Well, so I was that very curious 14-year-old who should probably not have been reading them, but my mom would go to the grocery store and leave me home alone, and I would like sneak into her bathroom and then look for all the dirty words and then read those changes and be like, what is that? Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: and this was back when everyone was just mounting things. Everything was mounting. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: no four-letter words except for mons. You know what I mean? Like these are like the Andie James: Yes. Yes. Eliza: oldies. and then I went to college, I was an English major. I went and got an MFA, which made me a dickhead. I got real pretentious in that MFA. I was like, you're reading literary fiction, I am writing a novel and stories. It's it's this really gritty Vietnam War story. People are dying, things are rough, there's existential dread. and I did an enrichment semester. because of the economy and everything else, I was like, Well, what the hell else am I gonna do? I guess I'll do another semester. And I had Andie James: What are you gonna do with your life? Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: this mentor who read my thesis. Because I was like, I'm gonna workshop this in this enrichment semester, and then I'm gonna go, I'm gonna query. I'm gonna be a serious author. And he read it. We had our meeting, and he was like, This is a love story. And I was like, No, it's not. You dumb dumb. This is a war story. This is a war story. And he was like, No, you dumb dumb. This is a love story. And he was like, because, and I've I've said this in like probably 20 different workshops now. Everything is a love story. Everything. Because Andie James: Yes. Eliza: everyone loves something. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: So maybe it's revenge, maybe it's another person, maybe it's your mom, maybe it's your cat. Everyone loves something. And the meat of your story is what they will do to get it, to protect it, and to keep it. And blew my mind. But of course I didn't listen to them. I was like, no, like it's a war story. Still, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: still. Cause you know, I like I had my head all the way up my own ass. So then I shelved it for a while, plonked around, got real into blogging, wrote a lot of humor, published some of that, and then my dad died. And after like a five year illness, but died really suddenly. Like wasn't supposed to go so soon. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And I was still reading Lit Fic, which this is not a shit on Lit Fic. Like I no no no no no no. But at the same time Andie James: No, no, no, no. Yes, no, I hear you. Eliza: We can have Lit Fic and, and Andie James: Yes. Yes. Eliza: I read Alice Hoffman's The Dove Keepers. Cause that's what everybody was reading. You know my go brief. I if you've read it. It's about the Roman siege at Masada. Fucking devastating. I think it's Andie James: not. I know her name. I know Alice Hoffman. I'm but I've yeah. Eliza: Alice Hoffman. Don't quote me on that. The Dove Keepers is the name of the book. I do know that. And I Got to the end of it and I cried for five hours and then I went to sleep. And I woke up the next morning and I cried for like another two hours. And I was like, life is really hard right now. And Andie James: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Eliza: I can't read because all the books that I read end with someone standing ankle deep in the ocean, staring out into the vast abyss, being like, Well, maybe there's no point to any of it. Andie James: Okay. Eliza: And my mom, who has been a voracious lifelong romance reader, handed me Julie Garwood's Ransom and was like, you should read this. And I, with my head still up my own ass, was like, No, I don't read romance. And she was like, You should read this because you know it's gonna have a happy ending. That's the whole deal. That's the whole deal. Andie James: Mm-hmm. That's that's the that is the bargain. Yeah. Eliza: And I read it, and then I literally, because she still has them all under her bathroom cabinet, all good Midwestern moms. you gotta hide them, can't have them on the shelf, you know. and Andie James: I love that. I love that. Cause I know exactly what you're talking about. I can picture. Yeah. Eliza: I read literally every single thing she had. And it was like Julie Garwood's, she has the entire Sinster series from Stephanie Lawrence. Like, I read, I ripped through them. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And there was just something about it that like my grief for my dad was so. encompassing and life feels so dark and hopeless when you're in those when Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: you're in the throes of that early grief that Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: reading was able to be an escape because I was like, this is all shit. This is all real bad and real depressing Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: and sad and awful. And I don't know, I know for a fact I will never be the person that I was before he died. Ever again. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: But then over here, I had this escape Andie James: Yes. Eliza: into something that even though all of these authors put their characters and therefore reader through hell. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: in the back of your brain that you're like, this is all gonna be okay. And I think that there's something about humanity and why Andie James: Mm. Eliza: we create romance and why we are drawn to romance, which romance as an archetype is as old as humanity itself. Andie James: yeah. Eliza: And I think that there is something about the knowledge and the belief that everything is gonna work out okay. That Andie James: Mm. Eliza: is frankly the reason we get out of bed in the morning. You know, and Andie James: Yeah, and that's why this week's been so great. Eliza: I know, I No no no no no no no no I Andie James: Sorry, I keep bringing it back, but I just like Yeah. Eliza: just just Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: hoticus Finch just I'm certainly the ultimate like Sir the audacity Andie James: Bench. my god, yes. That picture. I so my friend, I know, my friend Celine Oliver. she her debut is coming out in February, and I'm so excited about it. she just this week released, she did her cover reveal, and I love her cover. It's gorgeous. It was this illustrated by Palesile. It's it's gorgeous. but like her main character, first of all. He's he's wearing spectacles, which we love. But it's like just Eliza: my god. Andie James: like the pose and like his he's got a little curl of hair over the forehead and like the illustration, like the whole thing. Yeah. And so I know. So Celine just put up probably well, Eliza: Just the slutty little forelock. And the slutty little glasses. And I bet he's real uptight too, which like Andie James: he is, I know. I've read part of this book. It's amazing. so Peter Beckwith people, yeah. I know. Eliza: She's just gonna rumple that that little dress shirt, rumple that cravat. Andie James: But she did a side by side that she posted today of a close up of him on the cover next to that John Ossoff, the Hotticus Finch picture, and it's like uncanny. It's just like this is amazing. Eliza: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. that when she sent it to her cover illustrator, it was just that picture. She was like, give me this. Andie James: She actually didn't, but it just worked so perfect. I love it. I love it. Eliza: That's a well then you gu I guarantee her illustrator was like this god Andie James: There you go, here we go. Yeah. No, I love it. But anyways, I digress again. But so if that is what got you back into I'm wondering if since you started with this, is this what inspired you to write the time period in Scotland and Eliza: So again I was I had my head real far up my ass differently. I was Andie James: Okay. Yeah. Eliza: like, I love romance, I love romance but then Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: I was like, Well I have an MFA, I could do this, anyone can do this. Reader, not everyone can do it. Andie James: Yeah. So funny. Eliza: and so I wrote Hold Fast in like the throes of postpartum. So my dad died in August 2016. My daughter was born July of 2017. Like crazy time to be alive. And Andie James: Okay. Big time. Big time. Yeah. Eliza: I felt like going from grief And then still grieving, and then into postpartum, I very much lost myself. And I was breastfeeding, and she had a tongue tie, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: and no one is sleeping. And you know what I mean? Andie James: No yeah. Eliza: and I wanted something that was just me, just mine, even if nothing came of it. And I was writing in 10-minute chunks, and I was right, you know what I mean? Just like Andie James: Mm. Eliza: that book came together in a million. Little stolen chunks of time. And the first draft showed it because it was a hot mess. and the second draft and the third draft also showed it because they were that book's been rewritten, I think, four times. Four times. thank you. thank you. That means a lot. I mean, Andie James: Well you did a good job, 'cause it's excellent. Eliza: I learned a lot. I learned a lot. Like, everybody always asks, like. What's the book you're most proud of? Soft Flannel Hank was my first book that I published. That was my d my debut. but Andie James: Hmm. Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: the book I'm the most proud of is Hold Fast, because I did write it the first draft in that first year post baby, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: and I worked my ass off. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: re four rewrites. You know how long it takes to write a book, let alone to edit a book, and then to write the whole Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: book four times. but I wanted it. and I hadn't Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: wanted anything in a really long time Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And I think that some of this goes back to having been a caregiver for so long that Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: and I was in grad school, I want, you have desires and ambitions and things, but I was Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: caregiving for my dad and helping with my grandma. And so I was bartending, Andie James: Mm. Eliza: I was teaching yoga, I was doing all of these little side hustles that I could cobble around the caregiving, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: you know, and I feel like so many of us do that. And then having a baby where it's just like, God and I Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: I didn't quit on it because I wanted it so badly. and I hadn't like I said, I hadn't wanted anything for myself in a really long Andie James: Yeah, that's great. Mm hmm. Mm-hmm. Eliza: time. and I love the time period. Like I I did I do love like Brodack Buchanan in Ransom is one of the most problematic Here. he is terrible. But Andie James: Ha ha ha. Eliza: I would let him hit me with a car, anyways. So, the heart wants what it wants. I like them brooding and barely verbal, apparently. That's my that's my my husband always Andie James: Mm. Eliza: says my type. He's like, no, you don't like tall, dark, and handsome. You like cranky but competent. And I'm like, that is my type. That is my type. Andie James: competency is yeah, attack. Eliza: Spoiler alert, he is the crankiest and also the most competent. So but I do love the time. I love medieval and I feel like there's so Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: much regency and I I love Regency. And I love like, you know, I feel like Victorian is having kind of like a, you know, which Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: is fun. So much fun. but I like the medieval books were the ones that raised me. And I I think Andie James: There Yeah. And it's Eliza: they're just bonkers. Because there's so little technology. Andie James: Do you like medieval? I was gonna say, it's almost like you ca you can have more creative license because we don't know as much, you know? Like Eliza: Yeah. Well, and it's also like I think so I don't really talk about this a Andie James: Ha ha. Eliza: lot in Hold Fast. I don't really talk about the church at all. Andie James: No. Eliza: in the serial that I'm doing, which is also medieval on Substack, a huge component is like in the 1300s, the Scottish interdict, how the church basically excommunicated all of Scotland and priests were not Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: allowed to perform any sacraments at all. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Which causes big problems when you're trying to marriage of convenience. you know what I mean. Andie James: Yes. Yeah. Eliza: so I don't really talk about that in Hold Fast, but I think that like like we talked about like segueing into reproductive health, for example. Like Andie James: Yes, yes, which I don't know if you guys have read Hold Fast, but it's wonderful and very much issue n ish not issues, but themes, I guess, Eliza: Yeah. Andie James: of reproductive health in that because our main protagonist, Una, is a healer and so we see her working with people through their pregnancies, other, you know, healing issues too. she sews a lot of people up, including the laird. But so many broken men. I know. It's okay, they just keep getting Yeah. That's kind of like, yeah. Yeah, like when he brings her to the Eliza: So many broken men in the McDonald clan are just always it's been zero days since our last accident. That's just like the billboard, always just like a little whiteboard. Every morning Una wakes up and just erases it like Andie James: clan to work for them, it's like, someone's always getting injured. It's fine. You can Yeah. Lots to do. Eliza: They're like, Don't worry, you have plenty of work. Job security is ten out of ten. Andie James: but we do see her in the book help with births and and one in particular, I guess. but then she experiences her own pregnancy. But also, I think a strong theme though is agency and choice. And so I mean the book starts with her talking about using her knowledge of and using that knowledge to prevent herself from getting pregnant because she's in a not so great situation. She does not want to get pregnant. It's a whole I I won't spoil, but I j it's such a strong theme in the book, and I love it. and I d sorry, I just went off. You had a point though where you were going to it. Yeah. Eliza: No. No, thank you. Thank you for gushing about my book. I didn't set out to write that so thematically. The first draft does not really have In the first draft, she does not get pregnant because of the first bad guys just inability to do it. but as we went through rewrites, I was like, particularly, particularly in the current climate. Andie James: Yes. Mm-hmm. Eliza: It became very important to me to give her agency Andie James: Yes. Eliza: and to give her accomplices to her agency. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: because reproductive health and choice about birth and contraception, I think people like they don't like to. I think people frequently think of these concepts as being modern Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Concepts. but it's like I found this statistic. So giant fennel, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: which Sylphium. If you've ever read Finley Fenn's Orc Mountain series, there's a whole lot of Sylphium in those books. and Andie James: Ha ha ha. Eliza: it went extinct somewhere around the first century because it was so effective as Andie James: Mm. Eliza: both a contraceptive but also as like A food flavor and all it was literally this Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: miracle plant that I wanna Julius Caesar directly registered it as worth like 1500 like he like hoarded it and it was like 1500 pounds of it and it was like worth more than gold at one point. and it's just like not just for food. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: But also and I think that Particularly when you get into the medieval era and the church becomes a lot bigger actor. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: but even still, when you look at like medieval history, the church was really only concerned about abortion after the quickening, which is like when you could like feel kicks, etc., etc. But even then, Andie James: Yes. Yes. viable life. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Eliza: It was not a capital crime. Andie James: Right. Eliza: and they were far more concerned about malicious action from external factors. Like if a woman terminated a pregnancy, they were like, no, that's bad. But you would get like a one-year slap on the wrist, like one year of penance, basically. Whereas Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: if someone poisoned you or attempted to terminate the pregnancy. Against you, they would receive three years of penance. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: the they took it much more seriously. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: But it it it I mean, I'm trying to organize my thoughts because like I have a lot of them on this. Not to speak on the binary, like I don't want to speak on the binary, but like Andie James: Yeah. Right. Eliza: there was also this kind of like acknowledged culture that Andie James: Mm. Eliza: like birth was the sphere. Of women. And therefore matters of women's gynecological health were also the sphere of women. And then when you're looking at like medieval like pardon? Andie James: What a concept. I said, what a concept. You could pee in charge of your own. Exactly. Yeah. Eliza: I know, imagine. Don't have no uterus, don't be talking about no uterus. You know what mean? but I the other thing about it is like you start talking about like medieval medicine, like with humors, and how like, it's the bilious humor of the liver. It's this humor. There was this belief that women needed to menstruate every month to purge evil humors, that that was important. And so they were giving women basically abortifactants to treat like amenorrhea, people who were not having regular menses and so then there's kind of this like subculture that develops, and it just makes you wonder who like pitched the evil humours chat to the boys. because I guarantee it was a woman. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Because then you have this network for being like, no, I haven't purged my evil humours this month. Must I I need to. And the you know, the men are like, God, yes, you're brimming with evil. My God. and it was Andie James: Please too, yeah Eliza: you create kind of this I mean, and I think like women have always done this, kind of created this not all women, but this space Andie James: Mm. Eliza: in which you can get help and there Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: will be help. And maybe there's a code word. It's like what's her face just poisoning all the men in Italy? Like, you have a code word? Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Like, we'll just here you go. and I think that like particularly with some of these herbal remedies and like midwifery manual manuals, like one of the most popular like midwifery manuals is was written by a nun. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: Like a Catholic nun in Germany named Hildegard von Bingen. And von Bingen. yeah. And it's just like, Andie James: I've heard of this. I have heard of this, yeah. Eliza: I mean it's it's I don't know. Like I I got to do so much very cool research. But also you realize that so much of the social furor around reproductive Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: rights. Reproductive action is not modern. The frenzy about reproductive Andie James: No. Yeah. Eliza: action is. You know Andie James: Yes. Eliza: what I mean? Like. I it's just I don't know. It was just a Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: it's it's very interesting like 'cause all of these herbs that we used as abortivefacients and as contraceptives, you also used in cooking and medicine and it was just this Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: very like the the scholarship is that even though the church was like, no, no, no, bad lady, don't do it, the ability to prove it Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: was nigh onto impossible. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: 'Cause how are you gonna do that? that didn't Andie James: I yeah. I don't know. Eliza: stop them from burning witches at the stake for four hundred years, but yeah. That's a different story. Andie James: Well, yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, I mean, part of what is in the book too, which I appreciated, because I mean it's obviously you're very centered on you know, Una's perspective and some of it is trauma Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: from the the bad situation we talked about. massive trauma from that. Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: But Ewan, our hero, he Eliza: My sweet anxious bean. Andie James: He's so I know. he's like the most overprotective because he has his own childbirth trauma because he saw his mother die after delivering his brother and sister. Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: and it has like massively scarred him, impacted his life Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: not having his mother anymore, you know. And so he's like petrified, right, when she's pregnant and just can't, Eliza: Yeah. Yeah. Andie James: you know. Part of it is I can't lose someone else I love. Part of it's being scared of the childbirth, part of it's, all of it and just being the protective laird and you know, whatever. But I I mean, a lot of responsibility. but I Eliza: Yeah, blast is hard. I don't wanna be in administration either. I don't I don't wanna I don't wanna do that. I don't wanna be in charge. Andie James: No. No. Yeah. Mm-hmm. But yeah, but I appreciated that like there was kind of this other layer to it because I mean, well, obviously childbirth is still dangerous. We just have different ways of Eliza: A hundred percent. Andie James: very, very much so. We just have different ways of dealing with it now. But, you know, I mean, Eliza: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Andie James: could very easily die from it back in the day. I mean, and so yeah. Mm-hmm. Eliza: Truly, truly. And I I mean think Ewan's trauma is also like yes, he watched his mother die. Yes, he has decided that like the only safe way is to just not do it at all. You know. Andie James: Mm. Yeah. he wasn't gonna marry, he wasn't gonna Yeah. Uhhuh. Eliza: No, he was like, I've got five br four brothers. I'm good. We've got an heir and three spares. And you know what? If Andie James: They'll be fine. Eliza: we run through all the spares, there's probably been something cataclysmic anyways, and it doesn't really matter. So Andie James: Ha ha ha. Eliza: we good. which is why I had to give him so many siblings, which is now kind of a pain in my butt, but it's just from like a sequeling standpoint. I was like, This is great, I'll have books for days. And now I'm like, There's so many people. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Why? Why did I do this? but he also saw his father become like this shell of a man and die of a broken heart, like Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: three years later, because his father like did that to his mom. I think his father always felt personally responsible Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: for that. Which is a really interesting question about I it's a it's a joke, but like I saw one comedian joke that like penises are the world's largest weapon of mass destruction. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: and everybody was like, tee hee, but also like Andie James: Kinda. You might have a point. Yeah. Eliza: write a dissertation on it. I don't think it's that strong Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: a leg to stand on. But, And I think that I think it's just such a like I I write a lot about trauma in my books. And I used to be a social worker and I also have PTSD and you know, and I I think that I love Ewan as a character. I really do Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: because he makes a lot of mistakes because he's terrified. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: But the reason he's terrified is very relatable and justifiable. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Eliza: and I think to your point, he understands the stakes. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Like, like I this isn't this is a hundred years later, but like my husband and I just rewatched The Tutors, which then of course led me to like Andie James: mm-hmm. Eliza: 38 rabbit holes. one of which was about Jane Seymour, Andie James: Ha ha Eliza: who died of, you know, septicemia, the childbed fever after birth and it's like the the She was treated by both medwives and university physicians. Nobody knew about hand washing, all of these things. But it's just like, even as a queen with access to I mean, in some ways, so the the the interesting scholarship about Jane Seymour, because now we're gonna get 78 tangents, is that there's people Andie James: Ha ha ha. Eliza: who say that you're actually better off in that time being poor. You're more likely to survive childbirth. Because you're gonna be treated by a midwife who only does midwives, she's not up to Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: her elbows in septic gangrenous wounds all the time. She does babies, that's my whole deal. I do babies. Andie James: Right. Right. Yeah. Eliza: and just the the density of the population. If you were a midwife for the small folk, the volume of births you would be attending would be ten times higher. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: So you're gonna learn a whole lot. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: But those midwives were not the midwives brought in to treat the queen. No, Andie James: heavens now. Of course not. Eliza: we're not gonna let one of those filthy peasants touch the queen. and so it's like this interesting dichotomy and Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: paradox between like education Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: not being a substitute for experience always, and Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: you know how they were like like the the The theory is Edward was breached. They had to manually turn the baby. She was in labor for over 30 some odd hours that her uterus Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: had so exhausted itself from the delivery that it did not contract to expel the placenta. And that is what became septic. And ma ma ma like all of these things. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: but again, it's like this even a queen Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: and I think that Ewan having seen it happen to his mother, who is the Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: lady in charge, the lady of the domain, he's just terrified. And there's Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: and I think the thing too is he there's nothing he can do which terrifies him more because he's Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: like a problem solver. Like we got a problem and we'll fix it. We got a problem and we'll solve it. And he can't solve that. He can't there's Andie James: Mm mm. No. Yeah. Eliza: nothing he can do. Whereas Una's like, yeah, there's nothing you can do. Chill out. Like I've got this. I've delivered how many babies? I'm on top of it. Like we're fine. And he's Andie James: Yeah. She's like, I know what's going on. Yeah. Eliza: just like Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: breathing into a paper bag. and I that dichotomy kind of developed through the the rewrites. Her Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: and in some ways I think his Concern, though it drives her nuts. In some ways, it's very healing of her own Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: trauma because, as you said, she is angry and traumatized Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: to the max when she meets him. Andie James: yeah. Yes. Eliza: And then he wins her over purely by accident. He does not, he's like, I'm never getting married. I know. He's like, but I love you, but I don't. I know. He's like, what a nice. Andie James: She's just a good guy. And that's such a novelty to her. A good guy, what? Yeah. Eliza: Person? What? A family man? Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: And I think that the fact that he would rather her never give him an heir and live for them to be old. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: That is his ideal situation. I think that that is somewhat healing for her because she has been treated before as a commodity, as a brood mare, as a like her Andie James: Yes. Yes. Eliza: body existed to serve a purpose that was not her own. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: And I think the fact that he is like, I will never touch you again if it means you live and you stay with me because I love you so much that I the thought of something happening to you makes me physically incapacitated. Like I cannot. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: And I just think there's something about that level of devotion Andie James: Mm. Eliza: that is healing for her. It doesn't fix it. It doesn't, it's not like, Andie James: No. Eliza: it's not like, you know, like the magic dicking that all of a sudden, like, no, I'm not depressed anymore. Andie James: Yeah. Right. Right. Eliza: Like, but it goes a long way, I think, to like soften, to like blunt the edge of some of that trauma for her because she's like, not this one. A lot of them. But not this one. And Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: yeah. Birth, what a scary thing. Andie James: Yeah. And it's yeah. And he's yeah, he's great. I I mean he's Eliza: What a Muppet. Andie James: there are there are moments where I just wanted to like throttle him. I mean, she knows why Yeah, she Eliza: Don't you just want to swaddle literally, Andie James: knows she understands why he's overreacting so much, but it's like he just can't help himself. And it's like, I don't is it Eliza: Yeah. No, he can't. He cannot. Andie James: but I'm reading something else right now, and so I don't know if it's what I read or if it's your book, but it's basically like Eliza: You're raccooning. Andie James: Yeah. The idea of like I k doing the wrong thing for the right reason doesn't make it the right. Yeah. Like I understand your motivation here, but you're still doing the wrong thing. Like, yeah. Eliza: The right reasons. No, it's yeah. Yeah. We talk to my kids about this all the time. How you can have really good intentions. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Doesn't negate your impact. But Andie James: Right. Eliza: also sometimes you do a bad. Like Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: it is not the the the lawful thing, but you're doing it in service of the greater good. And Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: like I ethics are weird, like they're hard. Andie James: Ethics are weird. Yeah. Eliza: And I think the thing with him, he was a lot flatter in the first draft. He was just gr again, cranky, barely verbal. Andie James: Well that's the first draft. Yeah. Eliza: but the more I rewrote her having agency, the more her agency made him anxious. Andie James: And she does have agency because I will say as much as he like his she feels safe with him, which is a like such a blessing. She feels so safe with him, but she still saves herself. Yeah. Eliza: She does. she does. She's not afraid to literally step on his toes and tell him he's fucking up. Like she is not. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: and I like and and when they first meet, she's like flinching anytime he comes near her and Andie James: yeah. Yeah. Eliza: like will not look him in the eye. But Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: then once she realizes, like, no, like I'm safe with this one, then I think she is able to really kind of step into herself and be like Andie James: Mm. Yeah. Yes. Yes. Eliza: No, I am angry. I'm allowed to be angry. I'm I'm I'm justified. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. No, it's great. Eliza: And his anxiety is it's so funny because like in my family we lovingly refer to it as my Menti B. But it's when my anxiety just reached full tilt. I had been taking care of loved ones for years and then We I had a miscarriage and then we had a baby and then there was the pandemic and then my daughter had a brain tumor and and and and and and and and and all of these things and I had just been like chugging along, just do do Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: do we've got this, and then all of a sudden it was like my nervous system was like, No girl, we don't got it, we don't. And I was having like Andie James: We don't got this. We don't got this anymore. Eliza: panic attacks every day. I was waking up at three in the morning, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: having in the middle of a panic attack, which if you've never woken up, In the middle of a panic attack, it is a wild experience. and like Lexapro saved my life. Like it it literally did. But it's like writing Ewan and like reading him, it's like somebody please invent SRIs in 1420. It's like my dude, my dude needs one. because he just like Andie James: He needs some, yeah. Mm-hmm. Eliza: I think he even knows, which is like this is the this is the brutal paradox of anxiety. You know it's not real. Like you Andie James: Mm. he knows. Yeah, yeah. Eliza: know that you're like, this is not something to be worried about. It's like when they the joke, like, I my nervous system unfortunately can't tell the difference between like me ordering coffee for a friend or being lowered into the Coliseum wearing a meat suit. Like You're you're Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: you know in like a rational part of your brain that you're like, you're fine, girl, you're gonna be just fine. But like the loud shrieking anxiety is like, we're dying, this is it. And I think Ewan really struggles with that. And in the next book in the series, it's not any better. Like, I hate to say it, poor Ewan. He's just Andie James: Ewan. It's okay. Eliza: but there aren't SSRIs. So he's this is just his lot in life is to just raw dog his anxiety in fourteen twenty. Andie James: Yeah. Well, you brought up the next book. So I have to talk about it. So it comes out in January. That is so exciting. Eliza: I did. Mm-hmm. Andie James: tell us what you can about. Eliza: So it's Joan and Blair. I kinda that's kinda that's not really a spoiler. I kind of like set it up at the end. Andie James: Yay. Yay! I was hoping. You did. You did. Eliza: it's childhood, best friends, two lovers, but not easily. they are separated for 10 years, which you kind of you know, you Andie James: Mm-hmm. You Eliza: I I allude to that at the end. Andie James: see in this book, yeah. And hold fast. Eliza: and he after he has the lairdship thrust upon him in a way Andie James: Yes he does. Eliza: that he was never prepared for and didn't really want. because his heart's only desire his entire life is Joan. That's the only thing he's ever wanted in his entire life, is to be with her. And he was never allowed to have ambitions. And I think that's why that Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: he has life, he has two lives. He has his life in the keep with his father and his brother. And that's a very abusive relationship. And then he has his life when he escapes the keep. Because Joan is a weaver's daughter. She lives in the village. She's a crofter. Like, like among the small folk. But she's Kind and she's gentle, and she's this Andie James: Mm. Eliza: funny, vibrant, soft place to land. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And so because he's been told since birth that he's too stupid to be the laird, he's too big to be good for anything but swinging a sword, he's Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: to all of these things, like he has no self-esteem, that he's never had any Andie James: No. Eliza: ambition for himself, because he's never been allowed to. And so the only thing he Andie James: Yeah. He's not yeah. Eliza: wants. Is that safe space? So then the only thing he's ever wanted is her. And she believes Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: him capable of so much more. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: Not believe she knows he is capable Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: of so much more. And she wants him to want things. and then you know, he like there's a road trip and someone's gravely injured, and the McDonald's are mucking shit up again. And I as they are wont to do, we I like midway through the book. Ewan and Una show up and I just I'd really missed them 'cause Andie James: Ha ha ha Eliza: You like when we last leave them in Hold Fast, they've just had the baby, like, you know, there's the epilogue, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: but you know what I mean. and she has like a three week old baby because the timeline, they are like right next to each other. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: and she's like very in her element, even more so than she is. Like there's something about I think motherhood that for her it's not healing all the trauma. I'm not saying that, but it has empowered her in a way. Andie James: Yeah, yeah. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Eliza: Like she has done this incredible thing Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: that she chose. And Ewan now has two people to be terrified about losing. so he's not handling it well. he's just Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: kind of mother henning her around and she finally like whips around and she's I swear to God, if you don't sit down, I'm going to drug you. Like I will, I will slip something in that ale cup and I will drug you. And then he's Andie James: Whoa. Eliza: like, you wouldn't. And she's like, babe, I would. she's like, I'm done. But then, but Andie James: Yeah. Do not test me. Eliza: then she kisses his forehead and is like, I love you. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: It's all okay. You know what I mean? Like, she sees him. She Andie James: Mm. Mm-hmm. Eliza: doesn't enable it, but she sees him. And, you know, and it's been really nice to revisit them. But like Blair Andie James: Beautiful. Eliza: learns through the course of this book. He kind of is forced to learn it. Cause Everyone else is like, nah, my dude, you've got this. and it really isn't until there's no one else. And he realizes, like, well, I don't really have a choice. but he does step into his own agency and watching him Andie James: Step it up, yeah. Eliza: kind of learn that Joan is Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: still the the thing he wants most in the world is to be with Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: her, but that it's okay to want other things too, because she does. Andie James: Other things. Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: And you know, he's he's so broken. Just Andie James: Yeah. I he's not in a lot of the first book, but he's so memorable. So I'm so glad. Very beginning and the very end. Yeah. But yeah. Eliza: No. He's at the very beginning and he's at the very end. there was a scene with him in the middle, but we cut it because it was just it wasn't doing enough work. he was just being a sad sack. which is what he's best at. yeah, and he's he is Like I know we talked about maybe talking about like non-toxic masculinity. Like I think Bl I Blair Andie James: Yes, 'cause you're known for that too. Eliza: is gigantic. He is huge. And if you've read Soft Flannel Hank, Blair is medieval Hank. Like I mean they're different, but you know what I mean? Like they are these big burly, like strong fat. Did you watch during the Olympics? There was it was like during or the World Cup. I think he was from Brazil. It was like a picture that was all over the internet of this guy who's huge, big, strong, but the big belly. And everybody was like, Andie James: yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. Eliza: that, that one. and he is just such a protector, like lethal, lethal person. and so big that he could be lethal with his own hands. Like Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: But is like sneaking into the woods to pick Una's contraceptive herbs because he's the only one who no one tracks because no one cares about him. So no one pays attention to where he's going. And teaches her archery and teaches her to use a dagger because Andie James: Yes, I know. Eliza: he's like, My brother's a shitbird. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And I want you to know how to protect yourself. And then and he's just like he I think that when I think of masculinity, I think the the men love to talk about this concept of like the alpha male. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: just all the eye roll around right. But it's like an Andie James: Not for me. Yeah. Eliza: actual alpha. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: It's not a self-serving. It's not. You are looking out for your entire assemblage Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: for whom you are responsible. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: And it sounds exhausting, honestly. But like I think Andie James: yeah. Eliza: the funny thing is, like the men who are all over the internet screaming that they're alpha males are frankly the least alpha. Period. Because it's like my Andie James: yeah. Eliza: husband always says this quote that I love, which is like humility isn't thinking less of yourself, it's thinking of yourself less. Andie James: Yeah, yes. Mm-hmm. Eliza: And I think, right? I know he says this all the time. And I think that when you look at someone like Blair and Ewan, who Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: is also a burly, lethally swarthy man, like he could do a stab. He could do a murder, you know. and they wouldn't hesitate to, but they wouldn't hesitate to in the service of protecting someone. You know, like it's this Andie James: Protecting others. Mm-hmm. Eliza: like And Ewan cries all the time, he cries constantly, Andie James: I love that. Like he I mean, the reason we meet or not meet him, but like the reason he and Una kind of come together in the beginning is his brother has been gravely injured. And there's just like this beautiful it's just this little moment and it so stands out to me though, because it stands out to Una when like he comes in and he's just so tender with his brother, you know? Eliza: Mm. Andie James: And he's so upset Eliza: Yeah. Andie James: and he's crying because they don't know if he's gonna survive. And it's just, I love that. Eliza: Yeah. Yeah. That moment, That was one moment that was in the first draft that stuck around because that Andie James: Hmm. Yeah. Eliza: he basically tells Una that if she doesn't come with him, he's gonna kidnap her. basically is like I we don't have a healer. Old guy Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. He's like, I need you. Period. Yeah. Eliza: died. I am dead, I will do anything to save my brother. It's like you're doing a bad thing for the right reasons. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And she's like, Well, I'll be damned if I'm kidnapped. you're not gonna do that. Fine, fine, I'll go with you. And I will look at him, and then you're gonna return me home. You know what I mean? She's really resentful of the whole thing. And then when she sees him like fall to his knees at the bedside, it it's like I think that it gives reader really good insight into his character too, in that it's like his Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: brother very easily could still die. And I think Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: no one is more aware of that than him. But he's like, I have to try. And I'm gonna try Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: my hardest. And he does, and he gets her and he brings her back. And he it's so out of character for him to even threaten to kidnap someone, let alone actually do it. he's he's not that man. He would never do that. And yet, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. It's the desperation. Yeah. Eliza: he is so consumed by this desperation to save his family that he's like, I would do terrible things. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: and I think when she first meets him, all she sees is like, you're just like everyone else. You're a terrible man who does terrible things to get what you want. And it doesn't matter about anybody else. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: And then when she sees him in this very time and sees him weep. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: And then when she's done fixing Connor up and doing the best that she can, he literally crawls in bed with Connor and like lays next to him. Andie James: Yes, that's the part that I was just like, my god, I know so sweet. And he like kisses them on the forehead and like yeah, it's just the epitome, I know. Eliza: It kisses a forehead kiss for me is like I I can't. and I think that the reason that state, that scene of all Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: the scenes in the book, that is one of the most like visceral Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: scenes for me. I think it's because my grief was so fresh that there's Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: something about like being next to the bedside, knowing that you have done everything you can and it might not. Mean anything. And there Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: is this desperation in that Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: moment. And I think that it humanizes him so much for Una, and that she's like, Andie James: So much, yeah. Eliza: You're not a bad man who did a bad Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: thing for himself. You are Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: a good man who did a bad thing for someone you loved. Andie James: Bad thing. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Eliza: And that makes all the difference because Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: she's only been hurt by bad man. Who do bad Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: things for themselves. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And I think that that is the what makes him non-toxic. Does he do bad things? Sure. Do they make bad choices? Is he a dick about his anxiety sometimes? Yes. You know what I mean? Like, Andie James: Yes. yeah. Yeah. We all make bad choices. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Mm-hmm. Eliza: but it's the I your motive doesn't absolve you. But I do think your motive matters. And I think. Andie James: Yeah. Right. Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: What she sees in him is that his his drive everything that drives him is Andie James: Mm. Eliza: this just Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: unstoppable desire to protect the people Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: around him. and you see that with Blair too. Andie James: Well and with that yes, yes. I'm so excited for that book now. Like I mean I was anyways, but yeah. That's okay. Eliza: I hope I hope people like it. It's it's grittier for sure, which I did not expect. But also, I sidebar, I went into that one expecting it to be a super slow burn because you he's like a big shy virgin. and then it ends up being like the horniest Boinkfest I've literally ever written in my life. So I don't know how that happened. You know, they just take control. I have no control. I've I Andie James: There we go. Well, sometimes it just has a mind of its own and it goes where it goes. Yeah. Eliza: I never have. Andie James: Yeah. there's this small moment before we even get to that part with Connor, Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: which kind of like has primed Una, I think, to receive that one with Connor Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: a little more because when they first get to the castle or the keep and they Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: they get there, like His other brother, Rabbie, is like outside the room and he's crying. He's exhausted. He's upset. He's he is a little baby angel. I'm just saying. Yes. I'm so excited. Yeah. Eliza: Rabbie is an angel. He's a baby. Protect him at all costs. I can't wait for his book. It's really it's really gonna be fun. I'm really excited. Andie James: but the fact that like like she's just conditioned in a way that she's like crying is not masculine. And she's expecting Ewan to chastise him and he doesn't. Eliza: Mm-hmm. Andie James: He goes and he hugs him and she's like, What the what? Like, you know. And so I just yeah. So you're really good at those. I Eliza: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think Andie James: yeah. Eliza: I think there's this, and this goes back to like historical context. I think there Andie James: Mm hmm. Eliza: is this like tendency to say, like, well, that's unrealistic. the patriarchy, blah, blah, blah, blah. And I'm like, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: there have been assholes throughout all of human history. No doubt. No doubt. but like, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: people have always loved their children. People have always Andie James: Uh-huh. Eliza: loved their siblings, their parents, their partners, their Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: friends, their dogs, their horses. They they have always loved. And just as people sometimes do not behave appropriately with that love, and they let that love make them do really hurtful things to the people that they love. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: That has always happened as well. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: But so too has this tender acceptance and caretaking as well. That has also I Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: refuse to believe that no man throughout history ever cried and was comforted by another man. Like I refuse to believe that that is like a post nineteen ninety four con like I refuse. I refuse to believe it. Like Andie James: Right. Mm. Yeah. Right. Eliza: because of course. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: And I think that the the patriarchy rides people. That is true. And I don't know. Andie James: yeah. Eliza: Ewan would never have chastised Rabbie. Period. Because that's Andie James: No. No. Eliza: that's not what he would have done. If they had been out in front of the entire village, I think it might have been more of a hand on a shoulder, probably, kind of thing. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: You know, like I'm here. Andie James: Mm. Eliza: You're losing it, but I'm here. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And that's the patriarchy. But because, like, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: but when they're alone and he doesn't have to be like, I'm the big laird, I'm in charge, you know what I mean? Like, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: he embraces him and he's like, of course you're crying. Like, of course you are. And Robbie's crying, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: not just because he's devastated, but he's relieved because like he sees Una and he's like, You did it. Like, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: hot damn, you did it. And Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: I think that like I don't know. I love Rabbie. I love him so much. But I also love that Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Ewan gives Rabbie space to be Rabbie. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: And everyone else does too. nobody really understands Rabbie. because he's his own sweet jet like he doesn't want to do the swords. He doesn't wanna do Andie James: No. Eliza: the, you know, the things that little boys are raised to wanna do in this time. he wants to pet kittens and help with the baby lambs, and he's just this gentle soul, and it was very important to me. that nobody ever Try to change him. And in his book, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: that gets commented upon, and all the McDonald's shut it right down. because they're like, you will not talk to him that way. You will not. Andie James: Ugh. Very looking forward to that. Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: because he's ten times the person that you are, because Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: he would never even think such an uncharitable thing about someone, let alone speak it to them. So, Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: Which I guess is another it's it's that is that is more alpha male behavior, frankly, in an actual Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: sense, which is like I am not gonna let you come in here and hurt someone else. Like, no, I'm not going to allow that. Like, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Yeah. Eliza: shut it down. instead of just you know like flexing in the mirror and being like alpha. Alpha. Alpha male. Andie James: Yeah. I'm in charge. And you serve me. And do you yeah. Eliza: You can you could never keep up with alphas like me. I'm like Andie James: But Eliza: I hate it. I hate it. Andie James: We'll see how it goes. But I, I've I've got Eliza: We'll see. We'll see. I just Andie James: I've got more hope. I we're just talking about Eliza: I do. Andie James: John Ossoff and, you know, Mr. Hotticus Finch and we just Eliza: Potticus finch, man. Andie James: I I feel so hopeful by some of the men that we've just elected and that they will be able to be seen and yeah. So Eliza: Yes. Yes. Well, I think that that is I think one of the things that is such a common theme with a lot of these men. And Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: I'm not a lot of these are white men, which Andie James: Yes. Eliza: means they participate at the top of the food chain. Andie James: Yes. Eliza: But if we speak of non-toxic masculinity, to use non-toxic, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: the terms of the day, I think that you see a lot of this caregiving, this being a caring person, but also being like I will not stand for you saying things like that, but I am not. Going to tear you down in the process of, you know what I mean? Like, Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: I think the really good example of that was like that town hall with Abdul al-Sayed, where the the like this went viral. The one guy was like, Do you renounce the Muslim Brotherhood? Blah blah blah. And he Andie James: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Eliza: just like so kindly, but also so irrefutably shut Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: that down. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And I think that that that's it. Like you can be strong and you can have principles and be very firm in those principles and take no shit. Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: But you don't have to be a dick about it. You know what I mean? Like you can because ultimately it's like another person's choices do not mean that you have to join them. someone slinging mud at you, you do not have to sling it back to make your point. And to make your point better, frankly. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: and I think that but also there's like a sense of humor about it and a levity and Andie James: Mm, mm. Eliza: A gentleness, but also it's a gentleness that has a steel backbone too at the same time, Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And I like I think that's why, but I and I think in pop culture, I think Pedro Pascal scratches Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: very similar itches. There's a reason why people are feral for him. And it's like he is the silliest Andie James: Yes Yes. Eliza: little sausage. He is. He's just like a a very silly goose. Does not take himself too seriously at all, not afraid to be Andie James: Mm. Eliza: soft and funny and irreverent and wear shorty tuxedos to the Met Gala and do all of these things. But Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: at the same time, we've all seen The Last of Us. I have zero doubts that if it actually came down to it, that Pedro Pascal would throw down. Correct. Like it would be like, there you are. Like I have zero doubts Andie James: He would turn into that person. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: of that. And I think that's why we love them because there is a certain inherent safety that we just Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: pick up on. That it's like, it's like Obama. if there's a baby in the crowd, Obama's gonna find the baby. he will find the baby. Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: And there's just something about like he's funny and he's jazzy and he's a serious he was a president Andie James: Mm-hmm. Eliza: and all of this, but he's like bouncing in the baby, and he's like, I'll be back, I'm gonna steal this for a little while. And just but again. Andie James: I know, it's like, ooh, give me. Yeah. Eliza: They let him take the baby because if there Andie James: Hmm. Eliza: was ever a threat, that that man is gonna put himself in between the threat and that baby. And I think Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: that like I think that we recognize it. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: Like you recognize a threat when you feel one. Even if they're not Andie James: Mm. Eliza: doing threatening things, you know, your little spiny senses start tingling and you're like, that is not a safe person. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: And I think one of the reasons that some of these men in politics lately have really captured us is because those spidey senses tingle in the other way where it's like you're a safe person. I don't know Andie James: Yeah. Yeah. Eliza: why, but you're a safe person. Andie James: Yeah. It's kinda like I can't tell you why s I know something's AI, but I know it is. It's like that just gut feeling. Like, yeah. Eliza: it is. You're like, the fingers are all correct. There are ten fingers. There's no obvious tells. Andie James: But yeah. I digress again. So yeah, so for those of you, I just did a s a special episode about Swoon's Fest where I chatted with Miss Valentina. So yeah, it's gonna Eliza: I'm Andie James: be great. I know. So Eliza and I are both gonna be there. So again, Eliza: I love Valentina. Andie James: if you can make your way to Orlando, which I know is not the easiest. Like I'm looking at plant tickets right now and dying a little bit inside, but Eliza: There's more in Orlando than just Disney. There's all of us. So Andie James: There is, there's us, yeah. but it's gonna be great. I'm so excited. and so other housekeeping, because I'm terrible about this. I mean, you know, if you guys listen and you haven't like just liked it online, that would be really helpful. You know, algorithms, all that stuff, like and share, all that would be fabulous. Eliza: Like and share. Sharing is caring. Andie James: Yeah, whatever platform you're listening to this on YouTube, Apple, Spotify, whatever. and also, this is releasing a couple days after I've already announced that I am kind of relaunching, I guess, trying to make Besotted Books happen. So we'll be running a new Kickstarter for that in January, much smaller scale this time, because you know, I dreamed I I I dreamed a little big. I dreamed a little big and we're trying to rein it in. I mean Eliza: You should though. I think the I think the dream has to be big. Andie James: Yeah. Eliza: The dream is still big. You can adjust the scope. Andie James: Yes. So we're just we're just we're starting a little smaller. Does it make me nervous because there's no long-term security? Yes. But is it more reachable? Yes. So anyways, all that to say, there'll be a lot more information coming over the next few months about that. but we hope you will consider supporting the genre that we know and love, historical romance, by considering it's not dead. So we hope you'll Eliza: Because it's not dead. It's not dead. Andie James: consider looking into that Kickstarter coming in January. and Hold Strong is coming yes, hold strong is coming in January. Yeah, hold fast, yeah. Eliza: Hold strong. I really wrote myself into a corner on that, 'cause I'm gonna get to book two and be like, Hold me and then like Andie James: Yeah. Well that's how I feel when I'm writing You're talking about a large family. I'm currently writing a series of seven. It's total. And I'm only on book three and I'm like, my god. Eliza: I don't know how Stephanie Lawrence did it with forty-seven sinster siblings. I don't know. She was just pulling Andie James: Yeah, I don't Eliza: like by blows out of the woodwork, like, the Andie James: Yeah. I know. Eliza: old Duke really got around. Like, I don't know how we did it. Andie James: I know. I just well, I did cousins so I could include more and then I like, Why did I do that? But it's okay, it's okay. Eliza: Too many people, too many legs. Andie James: It's fine, we we love our Beaumonts. but anyways, Eliza: You can do it. You can do it. Andie James: sorry, I'm rambling again. this is what I do. But anyways, thank you all so much for being here. Thank you for loving historical romance the way that we do. and I know I need to go read Soft Flannel Hank. Everyone tells me it's like the best in terms of like the I just yeah. Eliza: He's the saddest saddest boy in the world. Andie James: I just Eliza: but they bang in chapter three. That's my elevator pitch. So Andie James: Well, there you go. Yeah. Yeah. So Eliza MacArthur writing our lovely non toxic men for us because we need that in our world. and now I have a little more hope this week. so happy listening, happy reading, and we will see you guys all next time. Thanks so much. Bye.