Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Getting Your Exam Timely? NCUA Board Talks About this & More
Transcript
- 0:35Mark Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark Teichel with another
- 0:38episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:40Today I'm going to be chatting about my takeaways from the NCUA board meeting
- 0:44last week, the first meeting for 2024, and also a historic meeting in that it was the
- 0:51first board meeting for Tonya, for Tanya.
- 0:54Otsuka, the new Democrat board member on the NCUA board.
- 1:00So I'll have some thoughts on what board member Otsuka had to say, of
- 1:04course, chairman Harper, and of course, vice chairman Al Houtman we'll talk
- 1:08a little bit about what it means for fair lending, what it means for
- 1:11consumer compliance, what the hat tip was to what the priorities might
- 1:16be for NCUA in their priority letter that's coming out, a little discussion
- 1:20on recording exam exit meetings.
- 1:23And the renewed focus on credit unions getting their exam reports in
- 1:29a timely fashion, a reference to the equal footing that they're striving
- 1:34to achieve between consumer compliance and fair lending, excuse me, consumer
- 1:38compliance and safety and soundness.
- 1:40And next steps is that the priority letter will come out, and I'll
- 1:43say what I think that might mean.
- 1:45It's a little bit of a simplified plan, which is a good thing, and
- 1:49then also a discussion of NCUA's vacancy rates, which were brought up.
- 1:53All right I think one way to get a flavor of how this board meeting went is to go
- 2:01to the press releases that followed from NCUA, and I'm going to pull them up here
- 2:09and give you a little bit of a soundbite from each of the three board members.
- 2:13The summary that NCOA issued for Chairman Harper had this quote, and this is
- 2:18a direct quote from Chairman Harper.
- 2:21The NCOA in 2024 will continue to address consumer financial protection on equal
- 2:27footing with safety and soundness.
- 2:29In support of this goal, the NCOA will increase the target for fair lending
- 2:33exams by 10, moving from 50 to 60, to ensure credit unions are complying
- 2:39with the laws established to protect consumers against discrimination.
- 2:43Also, the NCOA will continue to focus on rising and continuing challenges
- 2:48within the credit union system.
- 2:50Those risks include liquidity, interest rate, credit, and compliance risk, as well
- 2:54as the omnipresent cyber security risk.
- 2:58Alright that's in a nutshell, Todd had much more to say, but that's
- 3:01what they highlighted in his press release that caught my attention.
- 3:04My ear caught my eye.
- 3:06So relative to the priorities on last week, I did a podcast on what
- 3:11I think will be in the priorities letter and all of those are there.
- 3:14I think I thought they might also add concentration risk.
- 3:18Normally, that letter would have come out.
- 3:20Last week the last two or three years at NCOA, that was the
- 3:23week that it would come out.
- 3:24I think chairman Harper was cognizant of the fact that with it being board member
- 3:29Otsuka's first board meeting, that he didn't want to bury the lead, which was
- 3:33her arriving and he also didn't want to bury the lead of the priority letter.
- 3:37So you can expect, in my opinion, to see the priority letter this week.
- 3:41I'll do a podcast on it coming up, but he referenced what his concerns
- 3:46were, which to me means that he's seen the letter and those things.
- 3:49are in the letter.
- 3:50Now, perhaps there's more, but he highlighted those.
- 3:52As far as the increase from 50 to 60 fair lending exams.
- 3:58Now, last year, they only achieved about half of that.
- 4:01Their goals and their achievements over the last three years
- 4:04range from in the 20s to 35.
- 4:06They're going up to 60.
- 4:07He asked staff about in a Q and A what qualified is counting towards that number.
- 4:16And the answer was that it could be a standalone fair lending exam.
- 4:20But also they were going to be counting an expanded scope that they are developing
- 4:25for those credit unions that NCUA is responsible for fair lending and consumer
- 4:30compliance, the biggest ones, and he specifically referenced 5 billion to 10
- 4:35billion, so they'll have their random sample that they come up with for the
- 4:40direct focused fair lending exams which will count towards the 60 and they will
- 4:45have those exams over of credit unions over 5 billion Between five and 10 billion
- 4:51that will have an expanded scope and those will count so that's how they're going
- 4:54to drag their numbers up by expanding the scope on the biggest credit unions,
- 4:57by the way, that's something that Todd's wanted to do since he was the he was
- 5:01the champion of a project when I was there of developing a transition for big
- 5:06credit unions into the world of CFPB.
- 5:09There's also just continued reference by Chairman Harper.
- 5:13The quote that I read.
- 5:14Didn't have the equal footing quote or did it?
- 5:17No, it did.
- 5:18The financial protection on equal footing with safety and soundness.
- 5:21So to me, equal footing means we'll spend as many resources on it.
- 5:24So 60 fair lending exams compared to thousands and thousands of
- 5:28safety and soundness exams.
- 5:30That's not equal footing, nor should there be equal footing.
- 5:33I think but he's raising it into the spotlight that he
- 5:36wants more resources here.
- 5:37I think we'll continue to see.
- 5:39In the mid year budget, and in the 2025 budget, particularly when you hear
- 5:44what board member Otsuka had to say on this topic this is not going away.
- 5:48The.
- 5:49The importance of consumer compliance at NCUA is going to continue to go
- 5:54up while Chairman Harper is chairman.
- 5:57All right board member Kyle Hauptman's statement was overall,
- 6:00I'm pleased to see the 2024 plan continues to put greater focus on
- 6:04output and outcome oriented results.
- 6:07I am grateful for the inclusion of Performance Indicator 1.
- 6:1222 regarding the post examination survey.
- 6:14Safety and soundness is improved by open and transparent
- 6:18communication with credit unions.
- 6:21By further anonymizing the post exam survey responses in 2023.
- 6:26The NCUA continued to normalize the use of the post exam survey.
- 6:31The hope was simply to improve the survey response rate,
- 6:35but Performance Indicator 1.
- 6:3722 takes it a step further.
- 6:39It sets the standard for outcome of 90 percent or greater on
- 6:43collaboration, narrative, and timely delivery of the exam report.
- 6:48What gets measured gets done.
- 6:50I continue to urge federal credit unions to record their exit
- 6:53meetings and joint exam conferences.
- 6:55The recordings are beneficial for the credit unions and the agency as they
- 6:59provide a resource for new examiners, credit union staff, and boards.
- 7:04By not having a To determine what was said, examiners and credit unions can
- 7:08save time and focus on moving forward.
- 7:11So there's themes here that chairman, vice chairman Hauptman
- 7:14has been pushing all along.
- 7:16The survey, he was big on getting the survey out there.
- 7:19He talks about it a lot.
- 7:21But the fact that the survey establishes measuring in part
- 7:25timely delivery of exam reports.
- 7:27He made reference to them constantly getting paraphrasing here, constantly
- 7:31getting hearing from credit unions that they were in here last year.
- 7:35I still don't have my report and they're coming in a few months and
- 7:37that's consistent with what I'm seeing that I don't know if it was
- 7:41the pandemic that elongated exams getting done more work being off site
- 7:45that elongated getting exams done.
- 7:48Of course, there's the exam review process which impacts that, but more
- 7:53often than not I'm hearing that credit unions are displeased with the timeline
- 7:59for getting their exam report finalized, and perhaps in that this is a whole
- 8:03nother topic not getting the opportunity to comment on the report the way that
- 8:08NSUA is falling behind, they sometimes Give it to you without an offer.
- 8:12Give it to credit unions without the opportunity to for them to have an
- 8:16influence on the report, which is part and parcel and integral to the exam process.
- 8:20So again, Chairman, chairman, vice chairman, focusing on the survey,
- 8:25focusing on recording meetings, which he's encouraging everybody to do.
- 8:30He mentions that in merit, they actually have to check whether or
- 8:32not the credit universe recorded it.
- 8:34He wants all federal credit unions to do that because it improves
- 8:38the administrative record.
- 8:39And yeah.
- 8:40I think his encouragement is a good reason for you to know that
- 8:44NCWA will accept that you do that.
- 8:47All right.
- 8:47And then new board member Otsuka what she indicated was finally the
- 8:52performance plan has set a target of 60 fair lending exams in 2024.
- 8:58Fair lending exams help ensure credit unions are fairly and
- 9:01equitably reaching all their members.
- 9:04Unfortunately, we've seen that red lining and lending discrimination.
- 9:08continue to be a problem today.
- 9:10This will be an area of focus for me.
- 9:13That's probably the biggest takeaway.
- 9:15This is consistent by the way.
- 9:16And now I've gone off the quote.
- 9:18This is consistent with what I anticipated would be coming from board member Oscar
- 9:22and a Democrat led board member, excuse me, a democratic led into a board.
- 9:27But this will be an area of focus for me.
- 9:29I support a stronger consumer compliance program, and I'd like to work with the
- 9:33board to continue to strengthen our fair lending and consumer protection efforts.
- 9:38So that's pretty direct, pretty clear.
- 9:41First time she speaks, she says it's about fair lending.
- 9:44It's about consumer protection, which no surprise.
- 9:47She is a Democrat coming from.
- 9:50Sherrod Brown's camp and not surprised here predicted it, but what will
- 9:54that mean in 2024, more fair lending exams, probably more items in the
- 10:00priority letter on consumer compliance.
- 10:02And then I'm really interested to see what they do in the budget
- 10:06in 2025, which of course doesn't come out till later this year.
- 10:11Draft in October approved in December, but there's going to be more resources
- 10:17spent on this, particularly again, when chairman Harper says we're going
- 10:21to put consumer compliance on equal footing with safety and soundness 90.
- 10:265 percent of NCOA staff are safety and soundness staff and they're different
- 10:31types of people than the people who want consumer who pursue consumer compliance.
- 10:35They're different breeds, they're different personalities, and it's
- 10:38going to be obvious that they're going to have to hire new people
- 10:42to do this, which is all great.
- 10:44But the pivot is going to be a little bit harder to achieve equal footing or
- 10:48how, I guess it depends how you define.
- 10:50Equal footing.
- 10:52Chairman Harper talked about vacancy rates that they put a goal
- 10:55of achieving vacancy rates at N.
- 10:56C.
- 10:57Way of 5%.
- 10:58He talked about how they I heard more than a hundred examiners last year to
- 11:02try and improve their staffing levels.
- 11:04He talked about the retirement of the baby boomers, by the way, when
- 11:08some NCUA baby boomers retired at the end of last year last couple of
- 11:12years, they've been added to my team at NCUA of subject matter experts.
- 11:16I anticipate adding one or two of those here in the first half of 2024.
- 11:21So stay tuned on that.
- 11:22You may hear them on the podcast.
- 11:25But it's great that they start measuring that I will tell you that when I was at N.
- 11:30C.
- 11:30U.
- 11:30A.
- 11:31Chairman W.
- 11:32Matt's watched that closely.
- 11:34But what I'm also seeing pivoting to credit unions, I'm seeing credit
- 11:37unions being criticized for having vacancies at their credit union,
- 11:42and I've never seen that addressed.
- 11:45In an exam report when I was at NCUA, and I've heard about it a handful of
- 11:49times over the last year, which means NCUA is talking about it internally,
- 11:52and they're being critical of credit unions while at the same time they're
- 11:56having challenges with with hiring at NCUA, and, of the handful of times that
- 12:03I saw it mentioned in credit unions, only one of them really seemed to be a
- 12:07reasonable issue that NCUA was bringing up, so I find that a little bit ironic.
- 12:12Let's see.
- 12:12What else do we have here?
- 12:13We talked about vacancy rates.
- 12:15We simplified plan.
- 12:16Chairman Harper.
- 12:18I think this is good that they're simplifying the plan.
- 12:21Vice chairman Huffman talked about if everything's a priority, nothing's
- 12:24a priority, which is something I say here a lot on the podcast.
- 12:28Maybe he's listening.
- 12:29Maybe he believes the same thing as I do, but in any event, I'm glad to hear
- 12:33him say that because if everything is a priority, indeed, nothing is a
- 12:37priority talked about equal footing.
- 12:39Talked about the exam reports timeliness.
- 12:41They want to, by the way, they want to have 90 percent of them timely.
- 12:45And from this, from what I've seen, it's definitely not near that.
- 12:50And the, so the priority letter should be coming out probably this week.
- 12:54That will become a focus of what Chairman Harper talks about at America's
- 12:58Credit Union slash CUNA slash GAC.
- 13:01He typically builds his speech off that priority letter.
- 13:05Consumer compliance buckle up.
- 13:07They're going to have an expanded footprint.
- 13:09They're also unfair lending, and it's clear that board member Otsuka
- 13:15is big on consumer compliance and big on fair lending and will give
- 13:19Chairman Harper the second vote.
- 13:21He hasn't had since becoming chairman.
- 13:24So it's going to be interesting to see.
- 13:27where NCWA goes in 2024, but they've hinted very strongly
- 13:30on where that will be.
- 13:32And as I've discussed here consumer compliance, fair lending, and improving
- 13:37the timeliness of examinations.
- 13:38All right, that's it.
- 13:39This is Mark Treichel signing off with Flying Colors.
- 13:42I appreciate you listening as always, and I hope you'll listen again soon.